Latest / Film And Whiskey / Brief Encounter / Rich & Rare Reserve
Transcript
- 0:00Some whiskey Nation. Do you ever think about Awards
- 0:03course he do you drink whiskey and watch movies which means
- 0:06that, you know, that nothing is validated until a group of
- 0:08random people say hey we love what you're doing.
- 0:11The awesome thing about doc Swensons, whiskey is that it
- 0:14isn't just some group of schlubs that are given them Awards.
- 0:17They have been winning attention from some of the most important
- 0:20whiskey experts that you can imagine.
- 0:22They've been voted best distillery in Washington state
- 0:25by the New York International Spirits competition.
- 0:28They've been voted the best independent Pendant bottler by
- 0:30the Ascot Awards as well as the best finished bourbon from the
- 0:33Ascot awards for their La. Mente exploratory Cask their
- 0:38exploratory Cask series is where they release some of the most
- 0:40fascinating and adventurous experiments.
- 0:43If you're ever checking out, docks line up and see a white
- 0:45label is a really good chance that that's the only time you'll
- 0:48see that bottle. So, make sure you snatch it up.
- 0:51Doc Swensons has been offering just phenomenal finished and
- 0:54Blended whiskies for quite some time.
- 0:56Now, you can find them online at Doc's, whisky.com.
- 1:00Mom. That's doccs whisky.com.
- 1:04And 1945 director David lean and star.
- 1:07Celia Johnson gave the world. A quietly sorrowful picture
- 1:11about the dangers of falling in love.
- 1:13After one is married in 2022. We try a blended whiskey.
- 1:18That may or may not be what it claims to be the film is brief
- 1:22encounter. The whiskey is Rich and rare
- 1:25reserve and we'll review them both.
- 1:28This is the film and whiskey podcast.
- 1:50Welcome to the film and whiskey podcast, where each week, we
- 1:52review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 1:56I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G. And this week, we are finishing
- 2:00up our mini series of films by the director David lean.
- 2:03We went and reverse chronological order, starting
- 2:06with 1962, S Lawrence of Arabia, we threw it back, five years
- 2:10from there to Bridge on the River Kwai and now we're going
- 2:12all the way back to 1945 in Great Britain.
- 2:16And we are watching brief encounter a movie that lots of
- 2:21movie critics and film people know and love.
- 2:25It's very appreciated. It's still considered like an
- 2:27all-time classic in Britain, but Americans don't know it to the
- 2:32extent that they know. No, you know, David lean's,
- 2:34Hollywood movies. I saw this movie for the first
- 2:36time, just about a year ago, Brad and I can't stop thinking
- 2:40about it. I haven't been able to stop
- 2:41thinking about this movie ever since and I gave it like an 8
- 2:44out of 10 the first time I saw it, but it has haunted me since
- 2:48then and upon this re-watch, I can already tell you that score
- 2:51is coming up but I was so excited to have the opportunity
- 2:55to kind of squeeze it in here by sandwiching it with other,
- 2:59David, lean movies and I don't know, man.
- 3:02I'm really really. Excited to talk about this
- 3:04movie. I have a feeling, this might be
- 3:06the least seen of all 32 movies that we have on this season's
- 3:11list. And I don't care because I think
- 3:13it's a movie people should see. Yeah, I came into this mostly
- 3:17blind. You had just told me it's a
- 3:20really quiet British movie about people who kind of fall in love
- 3:25and they shouldn't have and that was like about all I knew man, I
- 3:31really enjoyed. Add this movie.
- 3:34Yeah. And not in like, like it was fun
- 3:39but in like Man, that's like brutally honest.
- 3:45And we need movies like this in the world.
- 3:48Yeah, we were talking just a little bit before we press
- 3:50record and we kind of stopped ourselves because we wanted to
- 3:52get it all in the Pod. But we were saying that, you
- 3:55know, this movie doesn't talk down to its audience, and it
- 3:59doesn't talk down to its characters.
- 4:00It treats, everybody as an adult and as an adult with agency and,
- 4:08you know, it's a story about two married, people who fall in
- 4:11love. For no apparent reason almost.
- 4:14Like there's no Rhyme or Reason to it.
- 4:16It's something that just happens to them almost passively and I
- 4:20love that this movie doesn't really judge its characters.
- 4:25Especially its lead character played by Celia Johnson.
- 4:27It's you know, she's a smart woman, she's not trapped in some
- 4:31sort of loveless marriage. It's not as if her husband is at
- 4:34home beating her something. It's just like, hey, what would
- 4:37happen if you the audience found yourself in a Situation like
- 4:42this. And how do you deal with that in
- 4:44a mature way? And I love that it.
- 4:47I mean, just treats everybody, including the audience like a
- 4:50grown-up and it is very very rare to see subject matter like
- 4:54this portrayed. That way also 1945 with a female
- 4:59lead. Yeah.
- 5:00Told a female perspective told from a female perspective like
- 5:04that's pretty Progressive for its time.
- 5:06Absolutely good job David lean. There you go David.
- 5:10So this was written by Noel Howard, who is again, a very
- 5:14famous British person. If you've never heard of him, I
- 5:16understand. But at one point, he was the
- 5:19highest grossing author in the world because he was so popular
- 5:22in Britain. He was kind of a wunderkind.
- 5:26Like he came up in the theater and wrote a bunch of plays and
- 5:28then came to New York at a young age and kind of figured out the
- 5:32rhythm of Broadway shows and took that back to Britain and
- 5:35started writing his plays with a very particular pace and
- 5:39dialogue style that people came to mimic.
- 5:42And he had such an influence on British culture.
- 5:45That like I said he became like the most popular author in
- 5:49Britain for a period of time. He ended up being in movies, he
- 5:52kind of reminds me in some ways of like a more a more refined
- 5:56Orson Welles like I was literally just about to say.
- 5:59Yeah, he had that sort of a trajectory to his life and so
- 6:04you know this is based on one of his plays he helped adapt the
- 6:06screenplay and I really love Now I don't even just say like the
- 6:12pace or the rhythm of the dialogue here Brad but they're
- 6:15just so many lines in this movie that you hear them and you're
- 6:19like oh that's an effective line.
- 6:21And then when you see it written on the page I feel like you
- 6:23could take this script and put it in book form and it would be
- 6:27even more profound because when you see the text spelled out in
- 6:30front of you, like, there's just so many quotes that I wrote down
- 6:33from this movie. Well, and it's such an
- 6:36incredible script in the fact that it gives you characters.
- 6:40We've all seen and yet they don't feel like tired or overuse
- 6:46tropes. Like, you know, I'm thinking of
- 6:49the very opening scene when the character named Dolly mesoderm
- 6:52sits down and starts gossiping and chitter chattering.
- 6:55And every single one of us, has a friend like that, right?
- 7:01That like no matter where you see them, you just kind of PSI 0
- 7:04a little bit on the inside and, like, brace yourself for the
- 7:07next seven minutes of a barrage of Of verbose just you know what
- 7:13I'm saying? Oh, yeah.
- 7:15And like, every single character in this movie is somebody that
- 7:19we all know, and it makes the movie incredibly intimate.
- 7:24They it makes it something that feels lived-in something that
- 7:28any of us could experience. And I think that's what makes
- 7:31the, the main thrust of the plot.
- 7:32So effective, is the fact that it feels like any of us could
- 7:36live out this story. Yeah.
- 7:38All right, before we get any further, it's almost It's time
- 7:40for us to throw over to Brad explains, which is America's
- 7:43favorite segments of this podcast.
- 7:45But before we get there, whether you're a first-time listener or
- 7:48a long time listener, we want to encourage you to check out our
- 7:51patreon patreon.com film whiskey.
- 7:55Look guys, we do this for pretty much free and we spend a lot of
- 7:58money on whisky and it's a lot of time to edit this series.
- 8:01And so if we have offered any value to your life, consider
- 8:05becoming a member you can join at three different tiers, $3 $5,
- 8:10$7 Dollars a month at all three tiers.
- 8:12You get a ton of bonus perks, including access to a special
- 8:15discounted server that Brad. And I are on like every single
- 8:18day talking with members of film and whiskey Nation at the seven
- 8:22dollar a month tear, you get specific episodes that are just
- 8:25for patrons at that tear, you get unedited episodes.
- 8:28All of our patrons get early access to everything and they're
- 8:31all ad-free. So if you'd like to consider
- 8:34joining you can find us at patreon.com film whiskey.
- 8:40Brad, it's time for Brad explains.
- 8:42This is the part of the podcast where my wonderful co-host
- 8:45breaks down the plot of the movie that he has just seen
- 8:48often for the first time now. Back in season one, Brad used to
- 8:52take these things for for 56 minutes at a time and do just a
- 8:55really great detailed job of breaking down the plot.
- 8:58But what we have found is that it's much more fun to just put
- 9:0160 seconds on the clock and see if he can fit the plot of the
- 9:04movie into just one minute. Brad.
- 9:07You think you can do it today? I think this might be the
- 9:10easiest one I've ever done. All right, you have 60 seconds
- 9:14on the clock and go a Suburban British woman finds herself
- 9:20falling in love with a stranger that she meets at the railway
- 9:23station and the movie tells the story of their falling in love
- 9:27and realizing that they can never be together since they're
- 9:30both married. Hmm, it's about it.
- 9:33That's pretty much it. Yeah, so I guess what I want to
- 9:37start with today is the plot of this movie and I mean pretty
- 9:41much everything about the movie would indicate that this is like
- 9:44an overly sappy overwrought. Melodrama that you know, people
- 9:50are going to be running up and down stairs and screaming, after
- 9:52Rhett Butler and the violin strings will swell, you know
- 9:56what I mean? It just has that.
- 9:57Yeah, it seems like it's gonna be one of those movies and it's
- 10:00not There is a, there's a sense of melodrama to it like there's
- 10:04this classical Rachmaninoff, the place through the whole movie,
- 10:07but everything about it is so grounded like the people in it
- 10:11are Ordinary People, David lean. I mean, very famously did not
- 10:15hire the most glamorous movie stars to play his leads.
- 10:19It's just like the emphasis in everything about this movie is,
- 10:23this could happen to you. And this is a story of ordinary
- 10:27people who live ordinary lives and what if, and I feel like
- 10:32this is an indie film before. Indie films were thing.
- 10:36What do you mean by that? Well, it just has that Vibe of a
- 10:40director wanting to do something artistic and just having a
- 10:44really small budget and a small amount of time to film the
- 10:48project and just knocking it out of the park.
- 10:52Yeah, for sure. Yeah.
- 10:54And to your point brat, like I want to talk about this idea of
- 10:58melodrama versus realism because this movies, I mean, It's
- 11:01obviously not a documentary but there is something about the
- 11:05decisions that David lean makes as a director that pulls this
- 11:10out of being an overwrought. Melodrama into something that's
- 11:14much more emotionally affecting. Yeah.
- 11:16There there's a I like that you use the word realism.
- 11:21There's just a lived-in feeling about this movie where anybody
- 11:26can imagine themselves having a chance encounter.
- 11:31With another human being and that chance encounter turning
- 11:35into something more and like almost not even realizing that
- 11:40it turned into something more until you reflect on and you
- 11:43know what I mean. Yeah I think that's one of the
- 11:45most powerful parts of the movie.
- 11:47It's honestly this is one of the few movies where I'd say that
- 11:50the constant narration never gets old.
- 11:54And it always feels like it adds to the movie and the the way
- 11:59you're able to get into To you know Laura's mind the main
- 12:03character really helps flesh out who she is as a person and I
- 12:09think it's it's paired with her physical acting like you hear
- 12:14her inner thoughts but you see what she is looking like.
- 12:17And it's almost a reminder that every single person we ever
- 12:21interact with has a very rich and intense inner thought life
- 12:26that we are never privy to, and I man there.
- 12:30Yeah. It's amazing how he was able to
- 12:33capture the essence of any humans experience of
- 12:40accidentally falling in love, after you've already been
- 12:43married. So, let's talk a little bit
- 12:45about the way this movie is set up.
- 12:47When Noel coward, wrote, the play that the script is based
- 12:51on. It was a very short, one act
- 12:52play and David, lean felt, it didn't really have a lot of
- 12:55dramatic, like tension in it. There was no thrust to it and it
- 12:59told the bones of this story, but He basically said, look you
- 13:03got to do something to hook the audience and he basically
- 13:06pitched Noel coward on the idea of starting with the last scene
- 13:11in mind. And so you see this scene play
- 13:13out where these two people look very distraught and they're
- 13:16sitting in like a refreshment stand waiting on trains to come
- 13:20and they are very clearly have something going on between them
- 13:23and there's a longing there and that it's interrupted by.
- 13:26Somebody else coming to sit down and something feels very
- 13:29unfinished about it. And then you follow All this
- 13:31woman home. And she's very obviously, like
- 13:35zoning out and her husband can't really connect with her, and she
- 13:38starts crying and they sit down, and they turn on some music, and
- 13:41then she goes into this reverie. And that's where the movie kicks
- 13:45into gear. She starts narrating as a
- 13:48confessional to her husband. Basically, she's like, hey, I
- 13:51will never be able to tell you this out loud, but this is what
- 13:53I would want to tell you, and she goes all the way back
- 13:56through this relationship, that she's had with this man, for the
- 13:58last seven weeks. And I love the The way this
- 14:02movie is structured Brad because David lean, hit the nail on the
- 14:05head, like it is a, it's a slower-moving film.
- 14:08I don't even call it slow moving.
- 14:10It's a quiet movie and if he didn't like kind of employed the
- 14:14bag of tricks that he does to keep the narrative as fresh as
- 14:18possible and to use those and welcome gimmicks.
- 14:21But like those devices like the narration and like the
- 14:25cross-cutting between the present and the past, I think
- 14:28this would be like a very inert Movie.
- 14:32And so, he does a lot to keep it flowing and using the, like, the
- 14:36final sequence at the beginning. So that you can come around full
- 14:40circle to it at the end, and it has that much more meaning
- 14:43really is a brilliant touch. Yeah.
- 14:45The, the more I think about that final scene, where they're
- 14:49sitting, you know, in the, in the tea and the refreshment shop
- 14:54and that, you know, the stupid lady starts coming and talking
- 14:57to them, like you at the start of the movie, you're like, Oh
- 15:02this is an annoying woman who's interrupting something and at
- 15:05the end of it you find in your own heart.
- 15:08You're like damn it like you are ruining this.
- 15:11You suck you're the worst like this is their final time they'll
- 15:16ever see one another and it's just ruined.
- 15:19But then like the reality is when you sit with that for a
- 15:24while you're like that's real life like yes there's no there's
- 15:28no opportune time to have an affair.
- 15:31Well, yeah. And and so, I mean, I mean, not
- 15:34even just that but like, you know, he builds such dramatic
- 15:38tension and I don't know what the word is, but he magnifies
- 15:42the ordinary to the point where it becomes like, no, don't you
- 15:45understand you stupid woman. This is the greatest love story
- 15:48ever told and you're ruining it right now.
- 15:50And what it really is, is this seven week and I want to call it
- 15:54a fling, but kind of a fling between two ordinary people and
- 15:58they have an ordinary goodbye and they never see each other
- 16:00again, and it really Ali makes you think about like, how often
- 16:03are these sorts of comings and goings going on in the world
- 16:08around us at all times? And you hit the nail on the head
- 16:11earlier. Man, when you were talking about
- 16:13the interior life of everybody around you and how these many
- 16:19tragedies are playing out and how, you know, they seem so
- 16:23small in the grand scheme of things but to the people in
- 16:25them, it's the greatest story that they could.
- 16:28Right. You know what I mean?
- 16:30Yeah, man, that movie. Gets me thinking about these
- 16:32things. Yeah, and that's really what
- 16:36gets me about this film is that it tells the the emotional
- 16:42rollercoaster of a few weeks of This Woman's life.
- 16:46And yet, you know, like she talks about the, the before, and
- 16:51the after of her life are going to be full.
- 16:54Like, she has people around her that she loves and cares for,
- 16:57and that support her. And her husband is a good
- 17:00husband. You know, not perfect, as no
- 17:03husband is, you know, perfect. But he like, he genuinely loves
- 17:07and cares. For, I love the performance of
- 17:09her husband. He like he plays the loving and
- 17:14supportive yet slightly witless husband just perfectly, and you
- 17:20see how devastating it can be when we allow our inner emotions
- 17:30to overrule. All our good judgment and our
- 17:33commitment, to something that we promised ourselves to, you know
- 17:39what I mean? Let's talk about these
- 17:40performances because there's really only two big ones in the
- 17:43film to talk about. And let's start with Celia
- 17:46Johnson. She is the star of this movie.
- 17:48She didn't make a lot of movies. You know, she gets nominated for
- 17:52an Oscar for this film and she was an actress of, I would say,
- 17:56moderate success in film, but she just didn't appear in a ton
- 17:59of them. And so she's not Not somebody
- 18:02that you might necessarily recognize.
- 18:03Even if you're very familiar with British Cinema, you know,
- 18:06Again, Brad, we always take great effort to not talk about
- 18:11people's looks in a movie, unless it's integral to the
- 18:15plot, or there's a very obvious reason to and my no means.
- 18:19Am I saying that? She is like an unattractive
- 18:22woman or anything like that. But is it was a very deliberate
- 18:26Choice by David lean to cast, Trevor, Howard and Celia Johnson
- 18:30in this movie because They don't look like your standard movie
- 18:33stars and they look like Ordinary People.
- 18:36They're a little bit older than what you might expect for
- 18:38leading people in a movie like this.
- 18:40And I think the fact that this movie is filmed in 1945, you
- 18:44know, right as the war is wrapping up and British people
- 18:47have been through this hellscape for the last decade.
- 18:50You know, when I look at Celia Johnson on screen even compared
- 18:53to pictures of her in other films, she looks like she's
- 18:55about 15 pounds underweight. You know what I mean?
- 18:57And there's just a tiredness about her and it may just Just
- 19:01be the fact that she's been living in Britain during the war
- 19:05and yet, like, it is such a great reflection of the people
- 19:08whose butts are in the seats. Watching this movie, it like
- 19:12every decision, even the fact that she hardly wears any makeup
- 19:15throughout the movie and you can see the creases in her forehead
- 19:17and it's just, you know, I'm not trying to describe her as like a
- 19:21Haggard looking woman. She's not, she just looks like a
- 19:24regular person and it is so rare to see that especially in films
- 19:28of the 1940s Well, and you really, for me, at least, I
- 19:33found myself being more attracted to her as the movie
- 19:36went on. Like there's almost a reality
- 19:39where as you learn more about her inner life and the struggle
- 19:44that she's going through, you appreciate, who she is and the
- 19:48life that she's lived. And I don't know about you, man.
- 19:52But for me, I was like, oh, she's not just a, you know,
- 19:56average middle-aged woman. I'm like, oh, like she has
- 20:00Attractive qualities about her. And I think what I'm saying is
- 20:03you can understand how, you know dr.
- 20:05Harvey would also fall in love with her.
- 20:08Hmm. All right, and that's a great
- 20:10segue into talking about Trevor Howard as dr.
- 20:12Harvey. Now, Trevor Howard was a much
- 20:14more well-known actor. Especially after this movie, he
- 20:17made a ton of movies in America and he is, you know, he plays a
- 20:21doctor. So, he's a man, of some means in
- 20:23this movie and he seems very Dapper compared to, you know,
- 20:28the rest of the middle. Less people in this movie.
- 20:31And yet, when you stand him up next to somebody like I don't
- 20:34know what's another British actor of the time?
- 20:35Like a David Niven, you know, like even David Niven was seen
- 20:39with seem much more sophisticated.
- 20:42You know this role couldn't have been played by Cary Grant, you
- 20:44know him saying like yeah there's a sense of like he is
- 20:48the best-looking ordinary person in this small village and again
- 20:53like it works. So so well for this movie.
- 20:57Yeah, I think what I really appreciated about him is that
- 21:02you don't really get I'm trying to member.
- 21:03Does he have one little moment where he gets a inner monologue
- 21:08narration? I just I don't believe so.
- 21:09I think the whole thing is from her perspective, okay?
- 21:12So I think that he does an incredible job at portraying his
- 21:18inner life, without the opportunity to have a narrative
- 21:22bit, the way that Celia Johnson does, does that make sense like,
- 21:27throughout the Only you can feel his energy of I want this woman,
- 21:32but I know it's wrong and I'm not sure how to handle this
- 21:37situation and I think that he just does an incredible job with
- 21:41his physicality of conveying his desires and trying to reconcile
- 21:49them with the reality of his and her situation.
- 21:53Well, before we go to break, let's let's dive a little bit
- 21:56deeper on the sort. Of dramatic Stakes here on that
- 21:59situation that you're referring to.
- 22:01Because again, there's something to be said, here, about the fact
- 22:05that this movie is not judging its characters, it's not looking
- 22:08down on its characters, and it's portraying the fact that, you
- 22:12know, Laura is not in an unhappy marriage.
- 22:15Like her husband might be to your point like a little aloof
- 22:19and, you know, there's times where he comes up and he's like,
- 22:22ah, fix me my dinner, you know what I mean?
- 22:24It's like I didn't age well and yet it's Very clear that he
- 22:28loves her and she loves him. And the whole reason that she
- 22:31meets Trevor Howards character is because she goes into the
- 22:34city to buy her husband. A birthday present, because she
- 22:37loves him and it's like, it doesn't really good job of
- 22:40depicting a marriage that maybe it's a little bit stale, but
- 22:44it's certainly not an unhappy marriage.
- 22:47And I think that that level of nuance adds even more to the
- 22:51movie, it adds more to her guilt and it adds more to, I guess the
- 22:56dramatic Stakes of like Like this thing over here is much
- 22:59more exciting and shiny and new and romantic and maybe even
- 23:02deeper than what she has with her husband.
- 23:04But it's also not like there's something driving her to him.
- 23:09That's a negative about her home life.
- 23:12Yeah, it's literally just the fantasy of it all.
- 23:17Hmm. Like it came out of nowhere, it
- 23:20hit, both of them, you know, just broadsided them
- 23:23unexpectedly and they're left. Trying to No shake their heads.
- 23:28Clear of this fog, that has enveloped their souls and it
- 23:33leaned just does such an incredible job.
- 23:36I think of portraying the roller coaster that it is to try and
- 23:41have an affair like to, to try to display the difficulty of
- 23:49hiding it, and the difficulty of managing your own emotions.
- 23:53And you know, when, when Trevor Howard delivers the line talk,
- 23:57About like, did you spend the last week, promising yourselves
- 24:00seven times a day that you wouldn't come here today.
- 24:03Because I know I did that as well and you know, she like nods
- 24:06her head to it and it's like he gives voice to all of the
- 24:12emotive realities that would go on in a person's heart and in
- 24:17their mind as they're trying to figure out this thing that's
- 24:20happening to them. Yeah.
- 24:22And I think what I love so much about it is, you know,
- 24:24especially like an American Media.
- 24:26There's Is a scene in every movie where character says the
- 24:31line like I've met someone else. And, you know, that what's going
- 24:34to happen after that is, there's a confessional and then the
- 24:37marriage falls apart and you get the dramatic divorce story,
- 24:40right? Like this, you know, the way
- 24:42that this could go is Kramer vs Kramer or marriage story or
- 24:45whatever and there's something so much more.
- 24:49I don't know compelling, almost or like Rich about the idea
- 24:54where the line I've met someone. Elsa's never delivered out loud
- 24:59and it's only delivered in someone's head towards their
- 25:02spouse and even though, you know, there's a there's a but
- 25:06after it I've met someone else but it's over and you don't to
- 25:11worry about that anymore. It's still unspoken and it's
- 25:14still something that gets locked up in her heart forever and man,
- 25:18there's just something so compelling and so heartbreaking.
- 25:20And, you know, I don't want to call it more romantic.
- 25:23It's not more romantic but it's more.
- 25:26I don't know what the word is, man.
- 25:29I mean, it's kind of like a Casablanca ending.
- 25:31Yeah, right. Like, like, she chooses Duty and
- 25:35honor and she chooses the commitment that she committed to
- 25:40all those years ago. And I think that's what I love
- 25:43about this movie, is that, in the end, the like she doesn't
- 25:46choose her heart, she chooses, her Duty, and she chooses the
- 25:51Covenant that she made with her husband, all those years ago,
- 25:54not did. She was there a doubt?
- 25:56Vince was there, you know, cheating.
- 25:59Yes, like she very clearly emotionally and physically
- 26:03cheated on her husband, but that was not her ultimate end.
- 26:07Her ultimate end was returning to her husband.
- 26:10And that final line of the movie that you texted me is just
- 26:14heart-wrenching beautiful because, you know, that the
- 26:18emotions of her life are in The Dread, like just in the dumps,
- 26:24but the honor and dignity that she brings to the Relationship
- 26:27by not straying from it you know long not breaking.
- 26:31It asunder tearing it apart. I it's honorable yeah.
- 26:36And it's it's just it's a it's a study in contrasts that you
- 26:41don't often see in a rented movies.
- 26:43Yeah. Hold that thought for one second
- 26:45because I want to come back to that and I think that's a good
- 26:47place to end but I think that the word that I would use when
- 26:50I'm describing this whole thing is that it's it's more tragic in
- 26:54a way then the Common like divorce movie and it's, you
- 27:00know, it's the study in Gray areas, I guess or like there's
- 27:03grades to it, but are there other Shades of gray hairs,
- 27:07there's 50 Shades of them. You know, 50 of them.
- 27:09Wow, that's very specific. But I feel like it's one thing
- 27:13to see the tragedy play out in life.
- 27:16You know what I mean? Like somebody confesses
- 27:17infidelity and then a divorce happens.
- 27:19And a family is torn apart and there's a very tragic element to
- 27:21that but there's also something so rich and complex and
- 27:25compelling about watching. The many tragedy of somebody
- 27:28having to hold this Secret inside and it really speaks to
- 27:32this idea. And, you know, you talked about
- 27:34the idea of marriage being a covenant.
- 27:36I really think that this movie says a lot about the sacrifices
- 27:40that people make to remain in a steady marriage and I am not at
- 27:45all saying that. Like all marriages have secrets
- 27:48like this nor should they and I'm also not suggesting that
- 27:52like all marriages are beneath the surface, very unhappy and
- 27:56Looking elsewhere, that's not what I'm saying.
- 27:58But what I am saying is that the end of the day like this movie
- 28:01ends in a place where she has resolved herself to keep this
- 28:05thing a secret because it's over and because she is committed to
- 28:09her husband and she never really strayed from that.
- 28:11And you get this final image back to your point.
- 28:14Brad the whole movie, they've been returning to her just kind
- 28:18of sitting on this couch, zoning out remembering and every once
- 28:22in a while, they would show a shot from her point of view,
- 28:24where her husband is across the room.
- 28:26Doing a Crossword puzzle and not paying any attention to her.
- 28:28And at the end of the movie, they come back to her and they
- 28:32cut back to her husband and it's a much closer shot than her
- 28:36point of view. And he's staring directly at her
- 28:39and it is so jarring. Because for the first time he's
- 28:43noticed, what's going on with her and you just like in that
- 28:46moment, you're like, oh he knows like he he he knows and he walks
- 28:51over to her and they like in a very British way neither of them
- 28:55ever acknowledge. Happened.
- 28:57Right? And yet they both acknowledged
- 28:59what happened and he says to her.
- 29:02You've been so very far away and he just says, I'm so glad you
- 29:07came back to me and it's like, dude like It is not even the
- 29:12point of the movie that like, oh, their marriage can get back
- 29:14together, right. Like, it ends in a place where
- 29:16it's like, this is a really nice ending, but this wasn't the
- 29:18point of the movie and yet it gets me like, I was like,
- 29:22Weeping at that line and the way that she just collapses into his
- 29:26arms, at the end of this movie, is like, there is such a release
- 29:30and there is such a, I don't know, man.
- 29:32What do you want to call it? Like art.
- 29:34It's catharsis. It's catharsis and it's an
- 29:36honoring of their commitment. Yeah, you know, the But the
- 29:41reality is that the greatest tragedy of this film, is what
- 29:46you said that she will carry this secret with her.
- 29:48Her whole life human beings were not meant to live in darkness
- 29:55and whenever we keep things secret, whenever we keep things
- 29:59bottled up, it corrodes it. Degrades our soul.
- 30:05And I just, I think that this film shows both sides of it that
- 30:10she's keeping Secret, and it's tearing her apart but in the
- 30:14midst of that, her husband comes over holds her as she weeps.
- 30:20And, you know, whether or not he knows that she cheated on him or
- 30:25thought about cheating on him and leaving him.
- 30:29He accepts her for who she is and he offers her a community.
- 30:35He offers her what a marriage is supposed to be all about, which
- 30:39is unconditional, love and support.
- 30:40Art. And that like, that is such a
- 30:44beautiful thing. It's something that every single
- 30:46human needs. We need people to be witnesses
- 30:50to our lives, in order for them to have meaning.
- 30:54And I just, I think that this movie, Just hits the nail on the
- 30:58freaking head, at what it means to be a human in so many
- 31:03different ways. All right man.
- 31:06We are in a really good place to press pause and drink.
- 31:08This was a I hit this like forgets.
- 31:11Forget hidden pause. Like we pretty much just did it.
- 31:13Yeah. Like and yeah, the funny thing
- 31:16is in my notes I go so much deeper than this.
- 31:19I'm like, okay, we've talked about the surface level of this
- 31:21movie. Now let's talk about some more
- 31:22things under the surface and so, you know, it might seem like
- 31:26we're done at this point and I hope that like I hope that our
- 31:29enthusiasm for this movie is coming through, because I was
- 31:33really worried Brad. That you wouldn't like this
- 31:35movie. You know how I am when I'm
- 31:36worried that you don't like a movie.
- 31:38I text you and tell you like please don't watch it when
- 31:40you're busy, please. Make sure that you can't you're
- 31:42not distracted. Like please give it a chance.
- 31:44You always you always put like a lot of disclaimers when I know
- 31:49you're nervous that I'm not going to like the movie there.
- 31:51Well it's a very quiet British film so make sure you know
- 31:54you're in a quiet British kind of mood like I'm Pablo make a
- 31:57cup of tea it'll be alright it's alright man let's try this.
- 32:01Rich and rare Reserve. What do you say?
- 32:04I already tried. To Bob, I'm excited to talk
- 32:07about it. Alright, so today we are
- 32:18checking out rich and rare Reserve.
- 32:20This is a Canadian whiskey that honestly, I just kind of paired
- 32:24up with this movie because it sounded like something that
- 32:26would go with Brief Encounter. It sounded like something that
- 32:28was stately and would go with Society, its rich and rare, you
- 32:31know, I wish we haven't done a Canadian whiskey in a while, and
- 32:36I'm going to be real Frank with you there.
- 32:38That is on purpose because he was.
- 32:41He's not usually that good. And here's the crazy thing
- 32:45though. I feel like Every single not
- 32:49Distillery. But like all the places that are
- 32:52blent that are importing and blending Whiskey's.
- 32:55They're all doing it with Canadian whiskies, and they're
- 32:58all freaking amazing. Well, that's the thing is like,
- 33:01there are some Canadian Whiskey's, especially Whiskey's
- 33:03that are distilled in Canada. That are very, very good.
- 33:06But a lot of what we know as Canadian whiskey is kind of a,
- 33:10you know, to use a very crappy pun like bottom of the barrel
- 33:13type stuff here. So, It's real quick.
- 33:17Let's do a rundown, a reminder, a refresher on Canadian whiskey.
- 33:21In order to be called Canadian whiskey, it has to be distilled
- 33:24from grain from cereal and it has to be aged in wood barrels
- 33:30for 3 years. Now, it doesn't have to be
- 33:33distilled in Canada and it doesn't have to be aged in
- 33:36barrels that are first fill or fresh virgin barrels.
- 33:40So most Canadian whiskey is imported and aged in used
- 33:44barrels. So, like that's kind of why I
- 33:48would Canadian. Whiskey is always very light and
- 33:50color why it doesn't seem to have a lot of flavor.
- 33:52Why sometimes it kind of seems harsh is because it's just not
- 33:56really maturing to the level of something like, you know, well
- 33:59aged bourbon, there are typically like two ways that
- 34:04Canadian whiskey is Blended because it's almost all Blended
- 34:07and today's whiskey is no exception.
- 34:09So what you get is what they call Base Whiskey's which is
- 34:12whiskey that's actually distilled in Canada, it's some
- 34:14of their larger distilleries. And then that's usually put in
- 34:18used barrels and then they have what's called like flavoring
- 34:22Whiskey's, which are brought in, and they actually usually age
- 34:25those in new barrels and then they blend them together.
- 34:29It's because it kind of gives you like a nice Middle Ground,
- 34:31like aging, new stuff and used barrels and you know, older
- 34:36stuff in new barrels. I just wish that they would flip
- 34:39that process. It just seems like they can get
- 34:41so much more flavor taking the exact opposite approach but hey,
- 34:45I don't know man, they've been doing it for a long time in
- 34:47Canada. This is what we're drinking
- 34:50today, is kind of on par with like Crown Royal except way
- 34:53cheaper, it's Blended. I have no idea what's causing it
- 34:56to little more. It's a little more Misty, you
- 34:59know, whom were Canadian. Misty, 80 proof, I don't know
- 35:02what's in it. It's aged 43 years.
- 35:04That's about all we know. So Brad, let's dive in here
- 35:08because this is real cheap and I got us two little 50 ml bottles
- 35:12to sample, they were like a dollar a piece, they both came
- 35:15in plastic. And when I pour this out, man,
- 35:18I'm trying this live on-air, you've had it already, this
- 35:22smells like plastic, it smells like someone is burning a
- 35:25plastic jug in a bonfire when they shouldn't be doing that.
- 35:28And that's kind of what I've been here.
- 35:31You know. It's a very thin nose.
- 35:34I had a friend come over and he was he was like arrived, right?
- 35:38As I was finishing writing my review for this and I gave him
- 35:43the glass and I was like, hey just give me your nose.
- 35:46A notes on this and he took it for about five minutes and tried
- 35:51to come up with anything and he's like, you know, it's a high
- 35:55ethanol nose. And I was like, yeah, that's a
- 36:00good note because I don't have any other notes on the nose.
- 36:04No, it smells like ethanol and plastic.
- 36:06That's pretty much all I get here.
- 36:08Yep, they sitting, I literally sat with it for probably 10 to
- 36:1115 minutes, trying to get any nosing notes.
- 36:15There's like a tiny Bit of generic sweetness, you might
- 36:19call it caramel that comes through.
- 36:22You might, you might, it's caramel adjacent obviously, like
- 36:29for how little there is on the nose.
- 36:31It's not actively bad the way that some noses are so I would
- 36:37rather take nothing over actively bad.
- 36:41So I, yeah, I give it a four and a half on the nose.
- 36:44Yeah, I'm gonna give it a three. This is actively bad.
- 36:46Add. This is like the only notes here
- 36:49are alcohol. It smells like, you know, if you
- 36:52opened up a thing of rubbing alcohol and then dumped all the
- 36:56actual alcohol out of it and just breathed in the inside of
- 37:00that plastic little squirt bottle, it comes in.
- 37:02It just smells like unable just alcohol.
- 37:06And and most ruthless note you've ever given this worried
- 37:10about what chemicals are going into our bodies here, but it
- 37:13just seems like this has been like, the BPA.
- 37:16In this crappy plastic bottle has just been leaching into this
- 37:19for two years while inside on our shelves.
- 37:21Bob, I've I'm already, I meant I've already drank it, you can
- 37:25hold off and just skip it if you want to, I'm I'm tasting it.
- 37:32Now. Give us your tasting notes real
- 37:34quick. Honestly, that little bit of
- 37:38hints of caramel adjacent kind of came through on the flavor.
- 37:42There's a little bit of vanilla. The most interesting thing I
- 37:46Could say about it is that there was like a tiny hint of
- 37:49nuttiness, the almost like a little bit of a peanut.
- 37:54It's okay, it's not bad. On the taste, I'll give it a six
- 37:58out of ten on the taste that like it's not actively bad.
- 38:03There's a few hints of things that could be good.
- 38:06So, yeah, well just stick there. Okay.
- 38:10I will say this, this is not what I would call like a very
- 38:13good whiskey. But when you take the nose as
- 38:17the Baseline, the flavor is shockingly, good?
- 38:21Yeah, okay. So, tip of my tongue is just
- 38:24water, like there's no initial burn at all and on the mid
- 38:28palate, it starts to develop some kind of almost like, like
- 38:31barley type notes for me and I'm a you get a little bit of
- 38:34vanilla sweetness that you're talking about on the back end
- 38:37the alcohol comes in and it turned into lots of melon for
- 38:40me. I got a lot of like cantaloupe
- 38:42on this. And it kind of reminds me of
- 38:46like, if you poured yourself a cheap Irish whiskey and put an
- 38:50ice cube in it, and then let the Ice Cube melt all the way forgot
- 38:54that it's at out on the table overnight and then drank it all
- 38:56lukewarm the next day, that's like what this is.
- 38:59Like it just feels very diluted and even the pallet of it feels
- 39:04diluted but it's not bad. Like I'm gonna give it a seven
- 39:09out of ten on The Taste because it's so pleasantly.
- 39:11Surprising compared to that knows.
- 39:13Oh yeah that's that's not trying to say like it it's not bad and
- 39:20that's that's good. As I got into the finish it
- 39:25definitely soured as it went as I would expect of a cheap
- 39:30whiskey, it finishes with a few peppery notes, but nothing
- 39:35really, very nice. I dislike the finish a lot and
- 39:40give it a 4 out of 10. Yeah, I don't think it's that
- 39:43quite Bad. It does turn peppery a little
- 39:45bit hokey and kind of like some graininess or some young like
- 39:49vegetal notes, almost a little bit bitter and so I'm going to
- 39:53give it a 5 and a half on the Finish.
- 39:55But again, like coming from the knows the taste in The Finnish
- 39:59are like a, like, world's different for me.
- 40:02So that brings us to balance and this is where things get
- 40:05interesting, because I don't think this is a well-balanced
- 40:08whiskey. I actually think that I might
- 40:10enjoy this whiskey more than the way that we Scored out would
- 40:14indicate, but this is only like a 5 out of 10 on ballots.
- 40:20Yeah, I give it a 5 as well and I don't think there's really
- 40:23anything else to say there. It's very thin throughout and
- 40:27doesn't have a very even experience.
- 40:30So 5 out of 10. Let's get onto value Bob.
- 40:33This bad boy in the state of Ohio.
- 40:36The wonderful beautiful state of Ohio will cost you for a fifth
- 40:40of this nine dollars and 49 cents.
- 40:42Yeah. Well Now, it is important to
- 40:45note that this is owned by the Sazerac company.
- 40:48They own the label, rich and rare.
- 40:50And there is there's two tiers of rich and rare.
- 40:53There's rich and rare, and then there's rich and rare Reserve.
- 40:57So we got the, we got the high-end stuff here, Brad, and
- 40:59it's still nine dollars a fifth. So like I think regular rich and
- 41:03rare is six something for her fifth.
- 41:07So here's the thing, when it comes to scoring this out, you
- 41:10cannot get many Whiskey's for less than $10.
- 41:13Ali whiskies that actually meet the threshold of being 80 proof,
- 41:16I guess the best comparison for this.
- 41:19You know, you can get like Benchmark for $12 or something
- 41:22in the world of bourbon but this isn't like that this is not,
- 41:26that's not single digits Bob. Yeah, this is much more similar
- 41:29to I guess. I'll say it like this, compare
- 41:32this to Cutty Sark, which we had.
- 41:34I don't know a couple months ago.
- 41:36Cutty Sark is better than this, and this feels like watered-down
- 41:40Cutty Sark. And so it's hard to recommend
- 41:44this over something like a Cutty Sark because even as a mixer, I
- 41:47don't know if this is Like if this stands out enough or if it
- 41:51would just get swallowed up by everything else in your drink.
- 41:55Yeah, they it wouldn't it wouldn't stand up if anything.
- 42:02It would remind me of using like, vodkas a mixer where
- 42:05you're like, oh, I know that there's alcohol in there, but
- 42:09the mixers is the only thing I taste.
- 42:11Yeah. Do you remember when we drank
- 42:13that Seagram's Seven? That had like it was part
- 42:15neutral grain spirit so it just tastes like.
- 42:18Yep. Vodka like whisky flavored
- 42:19vodka. This is better than that.
- 42:22This taste like whiskey and the more that I drink it.
- 42:24Like I'm on my third or fourth sip of this now.
- 42:26It's very pleasantly sweet up front in a way that it wasn't
- 42:29initially. If you can get past, that knows.
- 42:32This is not awful, it's just not really good either.
- 42:36And even at a ten dollar price point, I think there's a couple
- 42:39other options you could choose. So I'm going to give it a 5 out
- 42:42of 10 on value. Honestly, I gave it a 7 out of
- 42:4510 on value like for a sub 10 dollar whiskey.
- 42:49It's really not too bad. And I, I guess I feel like I was
- 42:55brutally. Honest enough about the nose and
- 42:58finish and balance to just say, yeah.
- 43:02Like I think this is a decent value and I would recommend it
- 43:05just on the fact that if you don't have ten dollars to spend
- 43:09on Whiskey, then I think you have other issues that you
- 43:13should focus on again, I get that.
- 43:15But also then you have to ask the question of like, who's this
- 43:18for, right? Because if you're making a ten
- 43:20dollar whiskey, you're not making a great whiskey, right?
- 43:24So you're probably just like, hey, this is for someone.
- 43:26Who's either just trying whiskey for the first time or it's a
- 43:30mixer. And I don't know if I'd
- 43:33recommend. Maybe I'd recommend this to
- 43:34somebody trying whiskey for the first time because it's really
- 43:36inoffensive and and pretty generically sweet.
- 43:40I wouldn't recommend it as a mixer so like one of its two
- 43:44intended uses. I think it kind of fails at
- 43:47before we reveal our final scores Brad.
- 43:49Like let's just say it like this.
- 43:50Would you recommend this whiskey to any particular group of
- 43:55people? Like, is there any group of
- 43:58people that you can think of that?
- 43:59You'd be like, oh, this would be good for people.
- 44:01That are blank man. Bob, I am racking my brain.
- 44:07I really don't think of any particular group of people that
- 44:11I would want to recommend this to.
- 44:13Yeah, that's like part part of me, would part of me, would want
- 44:17to drink it with some of my whiskey friends, just to like,
- 44:20get their thoughts on it. But not to just sit there and
- 44:24drink whiskey with them, right? Like I would be like, hey, like
- 44:28I had to try this for the podcast, try it with me.
- 44:31All right, so what do you coming out to you, man?
- 44:33I'm at a twenty six point five out of 50.
- 44:36Remember, 25.5 out of 50. So we're coming out to a 26 out
- 44:39of 50 or just a 52 out of 100, which I'm pretty sure we just
- 44:44gave that exact same score to something like a couple weeks
- 44:47ago. Am I wrong on that?
- 44:49No, we were very close, man. What was it?
- 44:54I'm looking through it, was it the Jameson cold brew?
- 44:57Yeah, maybe we just did last week, I think.
- 45:00Okay, listen, I'm going to say this, this is never been part of
- 45:02my nose and you're tasting notes before I, you know, like I'm I
- 45:06got my face pressed up against my windscreen here on my
- 45:09microphone. So my breath is just bouncing
- 45:11back into my nose and after drinking this, my breath smells
- 45:16like when you when you cut open a pumpkin, to make a
- 45:20Jack-o-lantern and you're like the inside of the guts of the
- 45:23pumpkin, Like this whiskey has made my breath, smell like
- 45:27pumpkin guts. So if that's your thing, run out
- 45:31and buy rich and rare Reserve League, get you some rich and
- 45:35rare Reserve. Treat yourself.
- 45:38All right man, let's get back into talking about a movie.
- 45:40That is significantly better than this.
- 45:42Whiskey was brief encounter. Let's get to it.
- 45:49All right, everybody, that was rich and rare.
- 45:51Reserve, the highest-end rich and Rare whiskey.
- 45:54We will ever drink on this podcast.
- 45:56I don't know if we're ever going to.
- 45:58Listen, if you see a stoop to the level of rich and rare,
- 46:02like, please subscribe to the patreon because we are
- 46:04encumbered dire check on. Yeah.
- 46:10Oh, man. Well, it is time for to fax in a
- 46:13falsehood to fax in a falsehood where Brad Tries to stump Me by
- 46:18presenting three items. As fact, one of which is a
- 46:21complete fabrication that Brad made up.
- 46:24Now in an Ideal World, we would be better at keeping score.
- 46:27I think that I'm still above 500 on the season but at this point
- 46:32of the year it's kind of just Vibes you know.
- 46:34Like it feels like I'm doing. Okay.
- 46:37And so I'm just gonna like, I'm gonna put that out into the
- 46:39universe, you know? I'm going to say, hey, you're
- 46:41like like nine and eight. Yeah, we'll say that.
- 46:45Yeah. All right Brad.
- 46:47Let's see if I can keep this incredible streak going with
- 46:50your two facts and a falsehood. Alrighty, fax number one sir.
- 46:54Anthony havelock-allen was convinced that the only place
- 46:58this movie would do while was France but the major French
- 47:02distributor turned it down, it only changed its mind when the
- 47:06movie won the grand prize at the Cannes Film Festival.
- 47:10Fact number two. Lean was so interested in the
- 47:13clock at the train station that he had a dummy face built for it
- 47:17so that it could be controlled as well as be more easily read
- 47:21from a distance. So interesting facts.
- 47:24Number 3, Celia Johnson was initially extremely nervous
- 47:28around the cast and crew and asked for the first week of
- 47:31production, if she could have a cup of her favorite tea to calm
- 47:36her nerves before her scenes. Huh.
- 47:40Interesting, I know that number three, at least parts of it are.
- 47:43True. Like she was very nervous about
- 47:46performing in this movie. And you said that because of
- 47:49that, she requested that he be made for her.
- 47:53Yeah. Her favorite tea.
- 47:54Okay. Number one sounds interesting
- 47:57because I know that this movie was in competition at the very
- 48:00first ever confirm Festival. So like which is really cool.
- 48:04Just a cool fact to learn it so I guess just based on Those two
- 48:09things I guess I'm gonna say number two is the falsehood,
- 48:12unless there's like, some little detail that I missed in one or
- 48:16three, but I'm going to say to the falsehood.
- 48:19Number two is not the. Oh my gosh.
- 48:21Brad, dude, you kind of give me a softball here, like just got a
- 48:29Lobby one, the next couple weeks.
- 48:30I feel like I feel like The Vibes are turning limes are very
- 48:34bad right now. Oh, man, yeah.
- 48:39It did win the grand prize. However, Celia Johnson, never
- 48:44asked for her. Favorite tea to be made before
- 48:47her scenes, cool. So yeah, but yeah, David leaned
- 48:51was vastly interested in the clock at the train station to
- 48:56the point where like it never was even mentioned in the script
- 49:00that there was like this clock at the train station, but he
- 49:03like made in a prominent part of the scenery of the film.
- 49:07His vision of walking into that station and being like, I must
- 49:10shoot. You talking to the clock.
- 49:12You must be a family. It's like a Family Guy scene.
- 49:18Alright, so speaking of that train station and moving very
- 49:21quickly away from the fact that I am probably below 500 at this
- 49:24point on the, on the season. So, this movie was filmed, you
- 49:28know, while the war is still going on and they the production
- 49:31kind of got moved out of main train stations in the London
- 49:35area, to like a more remote train station, where they kind
- 49:38of took over production, but they also weren't In Harm's Way,
- 49:41and they weren't impeding the war effort.
- 49:44And I think Brad that I want to talk for a little bit, about the
- 49:47fact that this movie is without really saying it set in the
- 49:52pre-war era and released During the war or at the very end of
- 49:57the war. And what those two things really
- 50:00mean for this movie because I think that there's a lot to
- 50:03glean from the historical context here and we don't really
- 50:07get a chance to often to talk about reading the historical
- 50:11context into the text of a movie.
- 50:13And this is the kind of stuff that like me and you the Bible
- 50:16and theology major is in us. Like I get very giddy about this
- 50:19because it's pretty rare to get a movie that comes across our
- 50:23plate, where the historical context is as like, As rich and
- 50:27adds so much to the story as a movie like this.
- 50:29So why is it important that this movie is set in the pre-war era?
- 50:36You know? So the the play is written in
- 50:37the mid-1930s, we can kind of estimate that this is set like
- 50:41sometime in the late 1930s. But again, they never really say
- 50:44it but when you stop to think about it for a minute, it I mean
- 50:47it has to be set before the war because people have pointed out
- 50:50things. Like people are just buying bars
- 50:53of chocolate. And there's no chocolate
- 50:54rationing and All of the men are still at home and not fighting
- 50:58overseas. And like it's very obviously not
- 51:01during wartime. And I think that it's important
- 51:05that this is set before the war, but release during it because
- 51:10you definitely couldn't have made this movie 10 Years prior.
- 51:14But I don't know if this movie gets released 10 years earlier,
- 51:17just based on the subject, matter alone.
- 51:20Like the fact that this is a movie that is fundamentally
- 51:22about an affair, is something that certainly would Not have
- 51:26flown in the US with like the, the Hays code coming into play,
- 51:30but even in Britain, like, I just don't know if British
- 51:32sensibilities were ready for this movie, 10 years earlier.
- 51:36And I think that, you know, I've been reading this really great
- 51:39breakdown of women in British film.
- 51:43By the professor, her name is Anna, tony'll aunt, and I got
- 51:46her book from the library just to read about this this movie,
- 51:49because she goes into like, such detail about women in film, in
- 51:54Britain. In the, in the The War years and
- 51:57there's a whole chapter about Brief Encounter.
- 52:00And one of her main arguments is that like setting this movie in
- 52:04the past during the war allows for this kind of like Detachment
- 52:08from the audience where they can look at this movie that is about
- 52:12people who are not rich but certainly of some means who are
- 52:16doing bad things and yet they're able to kind of sympathize with
- 52:20them in a way that they wouldn't have been.
- 52:23If a, it had been set during the war, or Or be if it had come out
- 52:27before the war. So I think there's just a
- 52:29really, there's a lot of really interesting things going on here
- 52:32and I've got obviously if you know me, I have much more to
- 52:34say, but I wouldn't want to stop here and I want to hear your
- 52:38initial thoughts on this. Well, I was going to say.
- 52:40Why do you think it is that? The Warhead.
- 52:45Like, what do you think the war had changed about the British
- 52:48public that they were okay with hearing a story about an affair?
- 52:53That's a great question. And I will not take credit for
- 52:55this, and I will point back to that book.
- 52:57I was reading, but she kind of goes in on this.
- 52:58She says, like, you know, during the War British propaganda was
- 53:03all about unifying, the British people, which had been so
- 53:06divided for so long among class lines where now, it was like,
- 53:10people of all classes were bound together, by the fact that like
- 53:13we are, British and we were all sharing this experience
- 53:15together. And so you could go to the
- 53:17movies as like a poor person, a commoner, right?
- 53:21And watch this movie where, you know, whether this woman and
- 53:25this doctor are richer than you or poorer than you.
- 53:27You now identify with them as like, sharing in this British
- 53:32experience in a way that like, in the 1930s, you would look at
- 53:36that woman. And if you were richer than her,
- 53:37you would be dismissive of like this is this is the type of
- 53:41trash that, that exists in Britain.
- 53:43And if Rapport than her. You'd be like this is a movie
- 53:46about rich people. Dealing with these, you know,
- 53:49whims of Flights of Fancy that us commoners never have to worry
- 53:53about. And yet like in the context this
- 53:55was released in I think people were more receptive to it
- 53:59because they could see themselves in it in a way they
- 54:01couldn't before. Yeah.
- 54:03Well, and that comes back to what we have said, from the very
- 54:06start of this episode that this movie is incredibly intimate and
- 54:12not just with its subject matter.
- 54:13But It feels intimate to anyone who watches it, that it could be
- 54:18real for them. And yeah I wonder if I think
- 54:22that she probably has a point in saying that they might have been
- 54:28dismissive of the movie earlier but because of all that
- 54:31propaganda. Yeah, sure.
- 54:33This could be any British citizen struggling with this
- 54:36situation. Well and and then you get to the
- 54:39part that it's released during the war.
- 54:41And me think about all the The world war two movies, you've
- 54:45seen and the destruction that happened in Europe.
- 54:47And obviously, Britain is a little bit removed from what's
- 54:50happening on the continent, but you've got the bombing of
- 54:52Britain going on for however, long right.
- 54:54And hmm, the men are all at War and obviously like when war is
- 54:59happening, it is just, it's never talked about but it's
- 55:03always assumed that like the men are off fighting and then they
- 55:06go to a town in France somewhere and they all, you know, get
- 55:10their rocks off with a prostitute or some desperate
- 55:13townsperson And the women are at home and the men that remain at
- 55:16home. They're all cheating with the
- 55:17women because like everyone's doing what they have to do to
- 55:20survive during wartime. And then, you know, when we come
- 55:24back together at the end of the war, were never going to talk
- 55:26about this again. But it's obvious like infidelity
- 55:29is happening in Britain in a way that it wasn't before and it's
- 55:33not to say that it's accepted, but it's like it's just
- 55:35happening. And this is part of life right
- 55:37now because life is really fucked up because it's WWII
- 55:40right? Look like yeah and and you know,
- 55:42Lance in this, Look, she goes into a lot of detail talking
- 55:46about how even during this time, the idea of like what it means
- 55:49to be a responsible, housewife and mother is changing in
- 55:53Britain, similarly, to how it was changing in America.
- 55:56Like, women are coming out of the home and having to work and
- 55:59having to do things that they weren't expected to do before,
- 56:02and it got to the point with the infidelity and women being out
- 56:06in, you know, out of the home more than they were that like
- 56:09illegitimate children in Britain doubled between In 1945.
- 56:15So like this is something that a lot of people are sitting in the
- 56:19theater and able to empathize with what's going on on-screen.
- 56:22Because a lot of these people are harboring their own secrets
- 56:25and they've done things that they probably regret, but that
- 56:28like at the end of the day, I don't want to judge anybody for
- 56:32because I've never been in a situation like that, you know
- 56:34what I mean? Like, it's yeah, World War 2
- 56:37like yeah. And I think that all of those
- 56:40layers added onto this movie, really help you to understand
- 56:43why. Why it was a success in Britain
- 56:45and why it's so beloved because it speaks to these secrets and
- 56:48it speaks to these truths that a lot of people had at the time
- 56:52and it speaks to how the Brits will just never talk about it.
- 56:59Oh man, I mean, when I was doing my research for two facts in a
- 57:02falsehood, what one of the little bits of trivia I stumbled
- 57:05upon was that lien was taking a train somewhere in Britain and a
- 57:10man came up to him and like almost a cost.
- 57:13Had him and was like, why did you make that movie?
- 57:17Because now I realize that if that woman could think about
- 57:20cheating on her husband, my wife could think about cheating on me
- 57:25and he was like angry with lien for making this movie and
- 57:30bringing this awareness to his soul and I think it just speaks
- 57:34to what we're talking about that this movie.
- 57:39It is sincere and it feels like one of the most honest human
- 57:44experiences we've ever watched on this podcast.
- 57:49And again it treats everybody like an adult and it doesn't
- 57:53assume that because people are prone to make bad decisions that
- 57:57they are fundamentally bad people.
- 57:59And I think that, that is like a huge important distinction about
- 58:02this movie and then again, getting back to the wartime
- 58:05thing, like, there's a way of reading this movie.
- 58:08Are you read their relationship as a kind of a metaphor for
- 58:12Britain itself? Like these people's lives have
- 58:16been thrown into a period of disequilibrium, right of
- 58:21destabilization that they have been going.
- 58:23They're going through this thing that they don't really
- 58:24understand and it feels like a whirlwind and they kind of come
- 58:28to their senses and collect themselves, and they keep calm
- 58:30and carry on. And then at the end of it, they
- 58:34try to return to a sense of normalcy and that is exactly
- 58:37what the All nation is going through at the end of World War
- 58:41Two. And again, that's why I say that
- 58:44you can't really divorce this movie from the historical
- 58:46context. And I think that part of the
- 58:48sensitivity that Noel coward and David lean, give these
- 58:53characters is a result of this shared lived experience that
- 58:57everyone in Britain has been going through.
- 59:00Ma'am. This movie is so good.
- 59:03Bob I'm so freaking glad you liked it.
- 59:05I was so so worried that you're going to be like this was the
- 59:08most Boring movie I've ever watched.
- 59:10Oh, no, dude, I really really loved it.
- 59:13I'd be curious before we get into, let's make it a double.
- 59:16And our final scores is there, is there anything else that you
- 59:19want to talk about the music? The cinematography, the
- 59:22lighting? Like because I feel like there's
- 59:24a lot going on here that we haven't even started to touch
- 59:27on, you know, one thing that I will say, and we're wrapping up
- 59:30our David lean miniseries here is that for an for a director,
- 59:36who chose subject matter that On the surface always seemed like
- 59:40it could be very stuffy and like really stiff upper lip Britain
- 59:46kind of stuff. David lean was radically Modern
- 59:50about his approach to britishness but also like how he
- 59:53cut his movies together, watching Lawrence of Arabia and
- 59:57watching Bridge on the River Kwai, I was kind of shocked at
- 59:59how often there would be just like a smash cut to the next
- 1:00:02scene. And there was one moment I think
- 1:00:04in Bridge on the River Kwai where it cuts to a scene, where
- 1:00:07it's staring directly, Directly up at the Sun and then William
- 1:00:10Holden like staggers into view and you're looking at him from
- 1:00:13below and it looked like a shot from like a Sergio Leone
- 1:00:18spaghetti western. And there's a couple shots like
- 1:00:21that in Lawrence of Arabia to and obviously this movie is very
- 1:00:24different in terms of its Rhythm and its pacing.
- 1:00:26But there's a couple moments in this movie where it will just
- 1:00:30like smash cut to a shot of a train ripping through this
- 1:00:34station. And you know, at the end of the
- 1:00:37movie, when she's contemplating In suicide, it pushes in and it
- 1:00:40turns into this like Dutch angle.
- 1:00:42And so he's just always doing interesting things with the
- 1:00:45editing and the camera movements in a way that you might not
- 1:00:50expect if you were just reading like the synopsis of this movie
- 1:00:53on IMDb. Yeah, I mean, that, that Dutch
- 1:00:56angle that he uses at the end. Feels so incredibly out of place
- 1:01:02for, you know, for the cinematography of the rest of
- 1:01:04the film. And yet, I think it might be one
- 1:01:07of the best best uses of a Dutch angle that we have ever seen on
- 1:01:11this podcast because it truly communicates the horror and the,
- 1:01:19the darkness of the moment and the how dissonant it is with the
- 1:01:26rest of her life that she would consider committing suicide like
- 1:01:31that. Like, it truly is a dissonant
- 1:01:34thought for her and he uses the camera.
- 1:01:38To communicate that and you feel the eeriness and the gross sness
- 1:01:42of the moment as the camera slowly Zooms in and, and like
- 1:01:47turns to the right eye that liked was Haunting to me.
- 1:01:52And it was just a 3-second Dutch angle and I was just like broken
- 1:01:57by it. All right, so let's get into.
- 1:02:00Let's make it a double because we're we're right about at the
- 1:02:03hour mark I think now and this movie to it's you know, Eternal
- 1:02:07credit is an hour and 86 minutes long, which is just raised guys,
- 1:02:11chefs kiss. You know, for the yeah, this sub
- 1:02:1390-minute movie and I love on. All right, so we're getting to
- 1:02:17the point where our podcast episode could become a DVD
- 1:02:21commentary track. So we need to wrap things up
- 1:02:23here but let's make it a double man.
- 1:02:25What would you pair this movie up with to make the perfect
- 1:02:28double feature? Honestly I was thinking about
- 1:02:31two movies, the first of which being lala land.
- 1:02:35Oh interesting. But you know part Just because
- 1:02:39it's a story of two, you know, people who fall in love, and
- 1:02:42then don't end up together. Sure sure.
- 1:02:44But I think I'm going to do a movie you mentioned earlier.
- 1:02:47I'm going to pair it with marriage story.
- 1:02:49Oh, nice! I think that lala land is is the
- 1:02:53American version of of brief encounter where it's prettier
- 1:02:58people, doing prettier things. I think that marriage story is
- 1:03:03the it encapsulates, the rawness and the Lived-in feeling of
- 1:03:11people going through a divorce in such a way that I think it
- 1:03:15just a super. Well if Brief Encounter, even
- 1:03:18the way that the movie starts that marriage story starts with
- 1:03:22the narration of the letters that they wrote for their
- 1:03:25counselor, like has a very brief encounter ask feel to it so I
- 1:03:31yeah, I think I'm going to pair it with marriage story.
- 1:03:33I love that man. Alright so for mine I was
- 1:03:36thinking about this scene where They get caught in his friends
- 1:03:40flat and then they cut to a shot where she's outside and she's
- 1:03:44just like running through the streets and it reminded me and
- 1:03:47you thought of singing in the rain, it reminded me, it's a
- 1:03:52great. Very Bob, it reminded me of the
- 1:03:54very end of the movie the apartment with Jack Lemmon and
- 1:03:58Shirley MacLaine where she is like running through.
- 1:04:00She leaves Fred MacMurray and she's running through the street
- 1:04:03to get to Jack Clemons house. And I think there's a lot of
- 1:04:05that like Mel that's a Melancholy is in the Meant, but
- 1:04:09ultimately, I don't think I'm going to choose the apartment.
- 1:04:12I'm going to choose a movie that is just as much about a woman
- 1:04:18who explicitly at one point in the movie talks about how women
- 1:04:22keep things locked up in their heart.
- 1:04:24And it's a movie where a woman sits down and has a
- 1:04:27confessional. And at one point, she even says
- 1:04:30that she's been holding onto the secret of this brief encounter
- 1:04:34for 84 years and that movie is James Cameron's Titanic.
- 1:04:38Nick. Oh, look at you go.
- 1:04:41And that movie is very different from Brief Encounter because the
- 1:04:43love story ends up taking a backseat to the disaster element
- 1:04:46of it all. And this is like, what if that
- 1:04:48story played out in everyday life and nothing disastrous
- 1:04:52happened. So it's like two sides of the
- 1:04:55same coin in a lot of ways. But yeah, I love me some
- 1:04:58Titanic. I always happy to talk about it.
- 1:05:00I think I'd pair this up with Titanic.
- 1:05:03Well, did you know that the apartment only happened because
- 1:05:07of this movie? She did it really?
- 1:05:09Yeah. In man I'm trying to I'm
- 1:05:12literally looking through the IMDb.
- 1:05:14I read it while I was doing research for two facts in a
- 1:05:20falsehood, according to several Billy Wilder biographies the
- 1:05:24scene in the movie where alack Harvey tries to use a friend's
- 1:05:28apartment in order to be alone with Laura.
- 1:05:31Inspired him to write the apartment.
- 1:05:34How interesting? You know I've heard this story
- 1:05:36before because he walks away in wonder.
- 1:05:38Is like what's it like for the poor guy that has to get into
- 1:05:41the bed when it's still warm and like, oh my gosh, let this yeah,
- 1:05:46it's horrible. Yeah, I love that.
- 1:05:49All right, so maybe we should pair it up with the apartment.
- 1:05:51It sounds like they were. They were made for each other.
- 1:05:54Yeah, from from each other at the very least.
- 1:05:59All right, man. What what score would you give
- 1:06:01this movie out of 10? I'm really anxious to hear what
- 1:06:03your Squirtle I am really trying to think of why I shouldn't give
- 1:06:13it a 10 me too. Like, is this a 10?
- 1:06:18I think it's a 10, Bob, it doesn't fit.
- 1:06:20So I'll say this. It doesn't feel like a perfect
- 1:06:23movie. No.
- 1:06:24But it's one of those movies and I'm telling you, dude, you will
- 1:06:27think about this movie or like some, some emotion, some
- 1:06:32connection that you had with this movie, like every week for
- 1:06:34the next year, because it's been happening with me.
- 1:06:37Like I said, I gave it an eight when I first watched it but no
- 1:06:41movie has had this sort of like haunting effect on me since the
- 1:06:44last time you and I watched vertigo.
- 1:06:47Hmm. Yeah dude and I think the thing
- 1:06:50yeah go ahead. I think that with vertigo and
- 1:06:52with Brief Encounter this is like Capital C Cinema that.
- 1:06:58I'm pretty sure like 80% of the population could watch and
- 1:07:02enjoy. Yeah.
- 1:07:03And so I'm like I I think it's a ten out of ten Bob.
- 1:07:07Do it, man. I'm going to give it a 10,
- 1:07:08you're going to give it a 10 that which means that this is
- 1:07:11the highest ranked of our three David lean films.
- 1:07:16I could not be happier. This, this turned out better
- 1:07:20than I ever expected, just Stellar Stellar movie.
- 1:07:24All right. Show old chap.
- 1:07:26Well, guess what time it is Brad.
- 1:07:27It's time for us to turn the page from David lean to James
- 1:07:32Cameron. Oh, and not only are we turning
- 1:07:35the page to James Cameron. But this Friday, A Avatar 2
- 1:07:38comes out and I'm gonna go see it.
- 1:07:41Like, I'm very excited to see this movie because I need to
- 1:07:45verify whether Avatar one was any good and that means that
- 1:07:48next, it wasn't next Monday. Our movie for the week is
- 1:07:52Avatar. So we're going from Brief
- 1:07:54Encounter to the navi. The the quietest movie we've
- 1:07:59ever seen to one of the loudest movies we've ever seen.
- 1:08:03I'm really, really excited to do James Cameron because I feel
- 1:08:05like you have not Yet, come to terms with the fact that he is
- 1:08:10like a master filmmaker. I think you're still, I don't
- 1:08:13want edge with him, and I don't understand why.
- 1:08:16Well, it's because Avatar is not a good movie.
- 1:08:20Well, next week, in any case, we will be reviewing Avatar one and
- 1:08:24kicking off for movies with James Cameron.
- 1:08:26So we will see you for that next Monday.
- 1:08:28But until then I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and we'll see you next
- 1:08:33time. A Suburban.
- 1:09:03He's on my ass. You missed it right Dragon too
- 1:09:07much. A Suburban woman in Britain is
- 1:09:12on a rail train and she have me. Do you really you really screwed
- 1:09:19yourself with that prediction I did?