Latest / The Vegan Report / What If the World’s Religions Stood Up for Animals? With Joyce D'Silva | Ep. 110
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening
- 0:03to The Vegan Report. Have you ever considered
- 0:07what it would mean if global religions echoed
- 0:11and supported our fight for animals? To explore
- 0:15this question, I have the honor of welcoming
- 0:17a true hero of this movement, Joyce De Silva.
- 0:23Joyce has been vegan for 52 years. longer than
- 0:27I've been alive, and her contributions to animals
- 0:30are extraordinary. She wrote one of the first
- 0:34ever vegan cookbooks, led the adoption of major
- 0:38animal welfare legislation in the UK and Europe,
- 0:43and continues her work to this day as Ambassador
- 0:46Emeritus for Compassion in World Farming and
- 0:50patron of the Animal Interfaith Alliance. She
- 0:54is also the author of Animal Welfare in World
- 0:57Religion, Teaching and Practice. I highly recommend
- 1:01getting multiple copies of this book, one for
- 1:05yourself and your enjoyment, and others to share
- 1:09with the religious leaders of your town. Beyond
- 1:12religion, Joyce and I discussed The Nature of
- 1:16Evil, the idea of publicly naming and shaming
- 1:22wealthy factory farm and slaughterhouse owners,
- 1:26the most surreal moment of her life, and much
- 1:30more. To explore more challenging questions and
- 1:34critically examine the world of animal rights
- 1:37activism, follow or subscribe to the show, leave
- 1:41a nice review, but more importantly, share the
- 1:45episode with the vegans you know. Every gesture
- 1:48of support counts. Thank you. So Joyce, welcome
- 1:53to The Vegan Report. It's such a pleasure to
- 1:55have you on. Thank you for having me. I'm delighted
- 1:58to be here. As listeners of this podcast know,
- 2:03I am truly passionate about the intersection
- 2:06of religion and animal rights. As I started this
- 2:10podcast and hosted countless conversations with
- 2:15different animal rights activists, I became more
- 2:19and more convinced that the key to making progress
- 2:22with the animal cause was to basically convert
- 2:27religious institutions to veganism and the animal
- 2:34rights message of compassion. Do you agree with
- 2:39that? Did you also develop that instinct? religion
- 2:45was a key aspect to making progress. I'm just
- 2:51trying to think of a good answer to that. It's
- 2:54kind of yes and no, because when I was researching
- 2:58my book and I looked at all the major faiths
- 3:01and some not so major, and I could find in virtually
- 3:06all of them some really good teaching about animals
- 3:10are God's creatures or In some faiths, like Islam,
- 3:16animals praise God, even the suggestion that
- 3:20animals go to heaven. So there are going to be
- 3:23a lot of chickens there. And you know, we should
- 3:29be kind to animals. We are looking after the
- 3:32earth on God's behalf. all sorts of things, or
- 3:36the reincarnation side, live a good life as an
- 3:39animal, you may be born as a human. Not sure
- 3:42that's a very good deal, but never mind. But
- 3:47then I looked at what actually happens. So I
- 3:49looked at some countries where there's a huge
- 3:52majority of a particular faith, say Thailand,
- 3:5687 % Buddhist, I think, and you would think that
- 4:01the faith would have a huge impact. on what happens
- 4:05in Thailand with animals. I'm sure there's some
- 4:08wonderful Thai people who are running refuges
- 4:11and looking after their animals really well.
- 4:14But then I found the national sport in Thailand
- 4:17is cock fighting. I thought, oh, that's a horrible
- 4:22sport. These poor little cockerels are made to
- 4:26fight each other. It can go on for hours and
- 4:30they get exhausted, they get wounded. And, you
- 4:34know, God knows what the life is like in between
- 4:37fights. And then I realized that there's a lot
- 4:40of broiler chicken, meat chicken production in
- 4:43Thailand. I mean, we import some of it here in
- 4:46the UK. And, you know, it's the same old broiler
- 4:50chicken farms that you find all over the world.
- 4:53Fast -growing chickens, growing too fast for
- 4:56their own good, lots of them going lame, and
- 5:00most of them getting too slaughtered. couple
- 5:03of kilograms, let's say four pounds, at about
- 5:07five or six weeks old, which is completely unnatural.
- 5:12And so a lot of them go lame. So the last few
- 5:15days of their lives are spent in pain. And I
- 5:18thought, hang on, this is a Buddhist country.
- 5:21And I found that sort of almost shocking, really.
- 5:26And then you could say, look at Europe and North
- 5:31America. countries where factory farming has
- 5:35really taken a hold. These are supposedly Christian
- 5:39countries. I think that's pretty shocking too,
- 5:45actually. I think there are people who are inspired
- 5:49by their faith to really care for animals and
- 5:53to campaign for animals to be kept in decent
- 5:58conditions or not to be used at all. But yeah,
- 6:03it's a very kind of mixed picture. I would love
- 6:07to think that the fates inspire people to do
- 6:09good things for animals. And sometimes they can,
- 6:13but they're not thinking very well, if you ask
- 6:15me. Well, you know, how do you explain that disparity
- 6:20between the teachings that promote compassion
- 6:24for animals and the practice of the people? Well,
- 6:29I mean you could say, you know, look Christians
- 6:31are meant to love each other and look at the
- 6:34state of the world and what Christians are doing
- 6:39to each other and to other people not of Christian
- 6:43faith. It just seems people are very picky about
- 6:48which bits of religion they like and some people
- 6:51like the rules, you know, you can't do this and
- 6:53you can't do that and you can only eat this and
- 6:55you can't eat that. But sometimes the big messages
- 7:01are getting lost and the little picket rules
- 7:04are winning through. Oh, you can't marry that
- 7:08person. They're not a member of our faith or
- 7:11something. Unfortunately, things like that, which
- 7:16cause much unhappiness to people. The big picture
- 7:21of caring for creation If you believe it is creation,
- 7:27that just seems to get put to one side. It's
- 7:34not a sort of day to day thing for most people,
- 7:38but just really sad. And if you ask me, it's
- 7:41a huge challenge to the faiths to get that message
- 7:45out there. And, you know, obviously religious
- 7:49leaders have a lot to answer for and a lot they
- 7:52could do, but so the You know the faithful the
- 7:56people who go to church or mosque or temple,
- 7:59you know, are they? Enduring the religious leaders
- 8:04to the cause of they landed them the right books
- 8:07having conversations with them Even maybe having
- 8:11a little bit of a campaign if they're not getting
- 8:13an answer There's there's a lot to do Well, let's
- 8:17talk about the religious leaders Let's spend
- 8:20some time on that because you know in my mind
- 8:24I think of them as the ones that gave the moral
- 8:29stamp of approval for our cruelty to animals.
- 8:34Most people don't look for Peter Singer as a
- 8:39guide for their morality, as a moral compass.
- 8:42They look at their rabbi, they look at their
- 8:45imam, they look at their local priest. That's
- 8:49the person they go to for moral guidance. And
- 8:53that person tells them, yeah, it's okay to eat
- 8:56animals, it's okay to exploit them. There's nothing
- 8:59that goes against our fate. You know, doing all
- 9:04of that. How do we approach those religious leaders
- 9:09and kind of gain them to our cause? Well, I think
- 9:14you'd give them a copy of my book to start with.
- 9:18No, I mean, seriously, because It's just that
- 9:21when they've done their studies to become a priest
- 9:24or a rabbi or an imam or whatever, the subject
- 9:27hasn't come up. It's just kind of in the background,
- 9:32oh yeah, be kind to animals. In other words,
- 9:35look after your pet dog or cat. And maybe, maybe
- 9:42not about wildlife. Should people go out and
- 9:47shoot? wild birds and deer and other animals,
- 9:53the big cats in Africa and so on. You don't often
- 9:58hear religious leaders making moral statements
- 10:02about these things. I mean, it's such a good
- 10:04opportunity for them. When the focus is on, say,
- 10:10a Canadian dentist who went to Africa and got
- 10:14in trouble because he shot a lion or something
- 10:18made a big thing about it. These are opportunities
- 10:22that could be used, but very rarely are by any
- 10:26religious leaders. I would say in terms of knowledge
- 10:31and understanding of the teaching of their particular
- 10:34faith, the leaders are no different from the
- 10:37non -leaders, the ordinary, the faithful, if
- 10:40you like. Really, if you're a member of a church
- 10:44or whatever religious group, you have an opportunity,
- 10:49almost an obligation, to try and get your religious
- 10:54leader on side. Or at least they may not become
- 10:58an animal rights campaigner, but at least they
- 11:00will understand what you're on about and why
- 11:03their fate has said the things it has. That's
- 11:07reassuring to hear that the cause of that could
- 11:11be just ignorance. You know, it's easier to think
- 11:14about it that way because then we can resolve
- 11:17this issue. Like you said, by distributing your
- 11:20book, by talking about the religious argument
- 11:24for being kind to animals. Now, you know, many
- 11:29of those religious leaders have chosen to advocate
- 11:35for compassion for animals. But what I've noticed
- 11:39is that They present it as a plus to one's spirituality
- 11:44and religiosity, but they never talk about abusing
- 11:51animals as something that could send you to hell.
- 11:56They talk about being kind to animals as a plus.
- 12:00It adds something to your faith, but not being
- 12:04kind won't take something away. Have you also
- 12:08noticed that positioning? I think I have to say
- 12:15that there are so few religious leaders who speak
- 12:19about the subject at all in any terms that I
- 12:23wouldn't like to say, but I think that's quite
- 12:26likely the way it is. And, you know, you have
- 12:32a few people like someone, you know, Bhikkhu
- 12:35Bodhi. North America who's, you know, happy to
- 12:41speak out for animals and does so. And, you know,
- 12:45that's wonderful. But I'm thinking about, you
- 12:47know, there are lots of religious leaders in
- 12:50the UK where I live. There are Church of England
- 12:53bishops and Catholic bishops. I know one Catholic
- 12:56bishop, but about two in the Church of England
- 12:58who speak up for animals. But, you know, they're
- 13:02a tiny minority, tiny minority. It's really sad,
- 13:07and I do know, you know, I've known a very quite
- 13:14well -known Muslim leader, sadly no longer with
- 13:19us, who wrote a book called Animals in Islam,
- 13:22Mr. Masri, a beautiful, lovely, gentle man. And,
- 13:27you know, he spoke out and wrote his book and
- 13:31so on. you know, that's really rewarding. And
- 13:36yeah, when he wrote his book and published it,
- 13:40he did get asked to speak at various mosques
- 13:43and so on. And so that's what you need, someone
- 13:46like that who kind of said, no, I'm going out,
- 13:48I'm going to say this is what I believe. And
- 13:51it's substantiated by the teaching of the holy
- 13:53books. And that's great when you find someone
- 13:57doing that. Well, now you mentioned a few times,
- 14:00you know, how it is important for advocates to
- 14:05approach their religious leaders and make the
- 14:08case for animals. Now, how do we go about interesting
- 14:14vegans animal rights activists to give more attention
- 14:20to this issue? Because, you know, most of them
- 14:25are not religious. I think I've seen one study
- 14:30saying that 73 % of the movement is non -religious.
- 14:36And so often when I present the idea, people
- 14:41don't take it seriously. Sue, what do you say
- 14:45to the movement at large? They're kind of missing
- 14:49a trick because there are so many people who
- 14:53do belong to a faith. I mean, figures go like
- 14:5770 to 80 % of the world's population say they
- 15:01adhere to a particular faith. So, you know, there's
- 15:05an opportunity there, even if that's an optimistic
- 15:08statistic. So people are quite happy to go to
- 15:12the politicians and lobby the politicians, but
- 15:16actually, you know, someone who's a priest or
- 15:19a bishop or rabbi or an imam may actually have
- 15:22more clout than the average member of a parliament.
- 15:28So why are you ignoring them? Don't ignore them.
- 15:31get them on site and they have an opportunity
- 15:34every sunday or friday or saturday whatever the
- 15:38only day is to stand up and speak out and so
- 15:43you know where is an ordinary member of the parliament
- 15:45kind of gets lost or has to tell the party line
- 15:49or whatever it may be and you know can occasionally
- 15:53do something perhaps introduce a bill or something
- 15:57like that and of course that's important and
- 15:59it's great But I would say really, really don't
- 16:02neglect the religious leaders. And you don't
- 16:05have to be a member of their particular faith.
- 16:08I mean, most of them will speak to you whatever
- 16:11faith or no faith at all. So I think it's definitely
- 16:16worth plotting how you can do that. And if you
- 16:23belong to a group, there may be people of different
- 16:26faiths or who grew up in a different faiths,
- 16:29even if they don't still have it, and they can
- 16:32find out who the important people are to talk
- 16:36to in their faith. It's funny, I remember I was
- 16:39at an animal rights conference in San Francisco,
- 16:45it was probably about 15 years ago, and in the
- 16:48evening there were eight of us sitting around
- 16:50having coffees and chatting, and we discovered
- 16:53that seven of the eight had been brought up as
- 16:56Catholics. I don't think anyone was practicing
- 16:59still, but they'd all been brought up as Catholics.
- 17:04But it was interesting and I thought, why so
- 17:06many Catholics? And I think there are a larger
- 17:11number of Jewish people involved in animal rights
- 17:13in the States as well. And that's great. And
- 17:19I think what is it about those faiths that sort
- 17:21of sends people towards animal rights? And I
- 17:24haven't answered that one yet. Is it guilt? because
- 17:28Catholics can carry quite a lot of guilt. So
- 17:33it was just an interesting observation. LR. You
- 17:37know, I have a bit of a polemic stance on the
- 17:43whole religious discussion, which is you can
- 17:46never become fully an atheist, you know, you
- 17:50can, you know, stop believing in God, but you've
- 17:52been brought up with certain teachings and certain
- 17:56values and that has been instilled in you and
- 18:00you're, you know, in a culture, in a civilization
- 18:02that promotes those values and culture. So you're
- 18:08always, you know, even if you're an atheist,
- 18:10you're a Christian atheist or maybe a Muslim
- 18:13atheist. Like there are many flavors of atheism
- 18:16out there. It's funny you use that term because
- 18:20before I worked in animal welfare, I did for
- 18:25a few years teach religious education in a secondary
- 18:29school. And one of my advisors was a lovely Scottish
- 18:33gentleman who belonged to the Presbyterian Church
- 18:37in Scotland. And he said to me, actually, he
- 18:41said, Joyce, I'm really a Christian atheist.
- 18:47So that was interesting. And he was there to
- 18:51advise religious education teachers. Well, it
- 18:56sounds weird, but I completely see that. It's,
- 19:00it makes sense. Um, okay. So, uh, Joyce, you're,
- 19:05you're at the head of an enter fit, um, initiative
- 19:09and you know, I've, I've seen that. the effort
- 19:14of multiple religions, you know, uniting in order
- 19:19to put more weight behind a certain cause. Now,
- 19:25I've tried organizing an interfaith conversation
- 19:29on this podcast. And whoa, was it hard? Yeah,
- 19:34getting people to agree to talk with each other
- 19:39from different, you know, religious views. And
- 19:44I think, you know, it has to do with how this
- 19:48world has become more and more divided. So I
- 19:54guess the question related to that is, how do
- 19:58you go about building coalitions in this world
- 20:02that is so divided? I don't think I've actually
- 20:06been able to do that. I mean, yes, coalitions
- 20:10of animal groups working for the same thing and
- 20:14trying to get a particular law passed or some
- 20:18horrible practice banned and, you know, Compassionate
- 20:21World Farming, the organization I've worked with,
- 20:24we've been very good at that. And I'm a patron
- 20:28of something called the Animal Interfaith Alliance,
- 20:32which is not a huge thing and it's based primarily
- 20:35in the UK, but it does contain people of every
- 20:40major fake, which is great. And, you know, when
- 20:43they have the annual meeting, nobody's arguing
- 20:45with anybody else. They're all just there to
- 20:48help the animals, which is lovely. Yeah, I mean,
- 20:56Compassion Well Farming, we were trying to get
- 21:00a law passed in the European Union to ban the
- 21:03use of cages, not just for laying hens, but for
- 21:06quail and all sorts of other. animals, and we
- 21:09would include just Asian crates for size as well.
- 21:15And the European Union has a specific kind of
- 21:19way you have to do a petition. You can't just
- 21:21get some signatures. You have to get over a million
- 21:24signatures within one year. And if you get a
- 21:28signature from Germany, all the German signatures
- 21:32have to be looked at by the German government
- 21:35to say, yes, these are genuine German people
- 21:37who are citizens of Germany. So it's a huge undertaking.
- 21:42And we did this about five years ago, and we
- 21:47managed to get 1 .4 million signatures from citizens
- 21:51of the European Union. And because we got that
- 21:55all within a year and handed it in, European
- 21:59Commission, which is like a sort of civil service
- 22:02of the European Union, they have to make a response.
- 22:07And they actually said, yeah, we will get rid
- 22:10of cages in the European Union. And we'll do
- 22:14it, you know, by some ridiculously closed stage,
- 22:18you know, within five years or something. And
- 22:22then it all went silent. And we thought, why
- 22:25has it gone silent? It went silent because it
- 22:28had been a European Union election and it had
- 22:32moved to the right. The whole of Europe had moved
- 22:35to the right. And so the commission had gone
- 22:38silent. So what we just did, and actually just
- 22:41happened this week, we took the European Commission
- 22:45to the European Court of Justice and said, look,
- 22:49you promised you would do this and you haven't
- 22:51done it. So we're now waiting to see what the
- 22:55judges will think about our case. We took the
- 22:58case, but we took it with three or four other
- 23:02NGOs who are happy to join us in the case. I'm
- 23:05not sure we'll win, but at least we may get some
- 23:09kind of statement kind of encouraging the European
- 23:12Commission to get the right together and ban
- 23:15these dreadful cages. So that's probably easier
- 23:21than getting coalitions of religious leaders.
- 23:25I'd love to do it. And maybe I will. Maybe you
- 23:29will. Well, I'm thinking about it. I work for
- 23:37Dharma. I serve Dharma. I like to say I serve
- 23:39Dharma Voices for Animals and its cause. And
- 23:42I've been put in charge of developing their North
- 23:46American program and basically mobilizing religious
- 23:51leaders in Buddhism. from different traditions.
- 23:57And I guess that's an easier ask than an interfaith
- 24:02coalition with such varying views. At least we
- 24:10agree on the core principles. It's just different
- 24:13traditions of different flavors of the same thing.
- 24:19But the whole topic of how to find, I guess,
- 24:24unity in this current era is something that fascinates
- 24:30me. You mentioned how the European Union went
- 24:37right -wing a bit. That's also part of it. How
- 24:41do we get the conservative people on board with
- 24:47the animal rights movement? So how do we build
- 24:51those bridges with um, people with whom we don't
- 24:57have much agreement. Well, I think, you know,
- 25:02there are probably people to the very, very far
- 25:04right, who I, I just don't feel I would approach
- 25:08at all because I find some of them, they promote
- 25:11racism. So I'm so distasteful. I don't know that
- 25:15I could really have a good conversation with
- 25:18them, but you know, the more sort of One's a
- 25:22bit like your granddad, or something one would
- 25:24say, who might be a bit on the right. Then I
- 25:30think you can, and sometimes they're really helpful.
- 25:33I mean, in the UK years ago, there was a really
- 25:37lovely man, Sir Richard Boddy, who had been a
- 25:42free range pig farmer and loved pigs, and he
- 25:45was a conservative MP. There's a procedure within
- 25:51Westminster where MPs can put their names on
- 25:55a hat and get chosen to introduce a private member's
- 25:58bill. And his name came second in the ballot.
- 26:03And so then everyone approaches his MP and said,
- 26:06can you introduce a bill to ban smoking to do
- 26:09this, to stop that. And we knew him and asked
- 26:13him, please, please, please. where you introduce
- 26:16a bill to ban gestation crates for size. And
- 26:20after a lot of thought, he said, I will, I'll
- 26:25do size because I love pigs. And he introduced
- 26:29his bill and we wrote to every member of parliament
- 26:33and said, if you do one thing, please support
- 26:35this bill. And you know, there were members of
- 26:38parliament standing up during the debate and
- 26:40saying, I've had more letters on pigs than on
- 26:45the Gulf War, and this was the first Gulf War.
- 26:49I thought, well, that's good. Our members have
- 26:51been really great at this. And in the end, because
- 26:55it was a private members' bill, it can't actually
- 26:57become law. But if it gets huge support, and
- 27:00it did, only two MPs voted against it. And the
- 27:04government is kind of under an obligation to
- 27:06take it on. And it was a conservative government,
- 27:09but they took it on. And so since they gave an
- 27:13eight -year phase out, but since 1999, you cannot
- 27:17keep a pregnant pig in a side stall gestation
- 27:20crate, call them, in this country. And that was
- 27:24sort of triggered other countries to follow suit
- 27:26and European Union to almost fan the system,
- 27:30but not quite. So yeah, I mean, it's like the
- 27:36ballot initiatives that have been happening in
- 27:38the United States. You know, one triggers the
- 27:41next one and so on. And then of course, you know,
- 27:44the fight back comes because the industrial farmers
- 27:48want to keep what they're doing. Um, but you
- 27:52just have to do everything you possibly can and
- 27:56hope that your president doesn't change the law
- 27:58so that you can't. Yeah, this is something I
- 28:04always think, um, The animal cause should have
- 28:11this universal appeal. Everybody loves animals.
- 28:15There was a part of you that just loves animals.
- 28:19We should bet on that universal appeal when approaching
- 28:24people. Yeah, I mean, I think it's really difficult.
- 28:28If you said, do you love dogs? If I went down
- 28:31my street, I live in a little village, and I
- 28:34was 50 people who live near me. Do you love dogs?
- 28:37They say, oh yes, I love dogs. I've got one or
- 28:40my auntie's got one or whatever. If I went down
- 28:43the street and said, do you love pigs and chickens?
- 28:48They might say, yeah. And then they say, do you
- 28:51ever eat them? They say, yeah, bacon and eggs
- 28:54and breakfast. And I'm having chicken for my
- 28:57dinner. And it's just, no one's kind of making
- 29:02the sense out of it. That you know, yeah, you
- 29:05can love your dog So you patch a dome beside
- 29:09the table and eat your pig at the same time.
- 29:12It's crazy But people don't they don't tend to
- 29:17see that and if they do begin to see it they
- 29:20get quite uncomfortable Quite uncomfortable.
- 29:24So you have to do is in a gentle way and not
- 29:27a sort of accusatory way. I think Yeah, being
- 29:32the sort of aggressive It won't really usually
- 29:37help anything. I mean, I think it's fine to have
- 29:39a demonstration outside the parliament or if
- 29:42you want to church or whatever, but make it peaceful,
- 29:46make it non -aggressive and you know, maybe hand
- 29:51in a letter saying we'd love to talk to you.
- 29:55So that you're not seen as the enemy. Yeah, enemies.
- 30:02That's not the place to be. And I should say,
- 30:08you know, I think if you're American and I have
- 30:11lots of American listeners, I think it's illegal
- 30:15to do demonstrations in churches. So just, you
- 30:18know, check the law outside. Can you demonstrate?
- 30:22I think outside. Yeah, outside. As long as it's
- 30:25public. You know, no, I don't think you should
- 30:27go in and interrupt a service because that's
- 30:30not very respectful to the other people who are
- 30:32there. So you don't want to antagonize people,
- 30:35but I think, you know, you've heard of nice little
- 30:37leaflet. You could hand out to people as they
- 30:39come into the service or leave the service or
- 30:42whatever. Um, and I would say, you know, a very
- 30:46polite letter to the religious leader and saying,
- 30:50you know, we'd love to discuss these issues with
- 30:52you. Um, Here's our email. Please get in touch.
- 30:57And you know, maybe if you will, it's worth a
- 31:00try. I agree. I completely agree. And you talked
- 31:05about how, you know, it's crazy, you know, how
- 31:08people pet their dog and eat, you know, pigs
- 31:11and eggs and all of that. Yeah, it feels crazy.
- 31:17And lots of animal rights activists have mental
- 31:21health issues because of this situation. I think
- 31:26someone coined the term for that, vistopia, the
- 31:31existential dread of being in a world where animals
- 31:36are exploited. But religion can be, and spirituality
- 31:43can be a solution to that, to addressing those
- 31:48mental health issues. I know that I'm a proponent
- 31:54of meditation practice. I always try to introduce
- 31:58it with animal rights activists who are struggling.
- 32:02Is it also your case, Joyce? Have you found some
- 32:06kind of foundation in spirituality to be able
- 32:12to continue doing this work despite the harshness
- 32:16of it? elapsed Catholic and I kind of lost my
- 32:23Catholic faith in my 20s and I find sort of beauty
- 32:27in many faiths and I do appreciate meditation
- 32:33and I teach Tai Chi in Qigong class where we
- 32:39do quite meditative stuff with some of the time
- 32:42and I think those things can help. I always remember
- 32:46another animal rights conference. I think this
- 32:50one was in DC, maybe. It was quite a long time
- 32:56ago. And a lady who was a very prominent campaigner,
- 33:00middle -aged lady, she's no longer with us, but
- 33:04she was well respected in the movement, and rightly
- 33:06so. But she stood up and said to all these young
- 33:09people, and they were mostly young, and she said,
- 33:12now what you've got to do, you've got to get
- 33:14posters showing the most terrible animal cruelty,
- 33:18put them around your bed, and last thing at night,
- 33:21you look at them, and I thought, no, that's the
- 33:26thing you shouldn't do. Don't do that. That's
- 33:31the last thing. Imagine you're disturbed with
- 33:34sleep and feeling helpless and so much suffering
- 33:38in the world, and no, no, don't do that, please.
- 33:45I would say the absolute opposite. I say, you
- 33:48know, if your life is devoted to animal rights,
- 33:51do something else, you know, play a sport, do
- 33:56Tai Chi, do yoga, do meditation. But for goodness
- 34:00sake, do something else, um, which gives you
- 34:04a space where you can just let all that activism
- 34:08just go for an hour or whatever. But you've got
- 34:13to look after yourself. If you don't look after
- 34:15yourself and your mental health, your physical
- 34:18health, then you're not going to be so much use
- 34:20for the animals. So look after everything and
- 34:24then you can be a stronger campaigner. So I think
- 34:28it's really important. I agree. They actually
- 34:32should find a picture of the happiest animal
- 34:36out there and put them, stick that on the wall.
- 34:41I became vegan because I love animals and I love
- 34:45seeing them happy and joyful. The footage of
- 34:54tortured animals, that's not so much what convinced
- 34:58me to go vegan and to commit to this lifestyle.
- 35:03Yeah, I'm trying to think back why I went vegan
- 35:06because I've been vegan for 51 years. It's quite
- 35:12a long time. And I'd gone vegetarian after reading
- 35:16Gandhi's autobiography, which is a very interesting
- 35:20book. If you haven't read it, I'd totally recommend
- 35:22it. And he wrote it himself, not towards the
- 35:25end of his life, but sort of in the middle of
- 35:27his life. And there was a lot in there about
- 35:30diet and he was trying to be vegetarian and it
- 35:33was difficult and where he was living. I went,
- 35:38oh, it keeps going on about food. And it gradually
- 35:41started getting to me. So I gave up meat and
- 35:46then sort of went to my first health food shop,
- 35:49picked up a magazine, got some veggie food, didn't
- 35:52know what to do with it. And after about four
- 35:57years, I suddenly realized the suffering of cows
- 36:01in the dairy industry and the calf being taken
- 36:06away. and, you know, hens in cages and all that
- 36:09stuff. And I thought, oh, I should be a vegan,
- 36:12but I love cheese. Ask any vegan, what's the
- 36:15hardest thing to give up? Cheese. And, you know,
- 36:17there are vegan cheeses, but let's be honest,
- 36:19they haven't quite got there yet. They're getting
- 36:22better, but not quite. You wouldn't serve them
- 36:26to your non -vegan friends. I mean, you can,
- 36:29but don't expect, oh, it's delicious answer because
- 36:32you won't get it. So I watched, there was a BBC
- 36:40Two, which is a kind of documentary channel.
- 36:43And in February, 1975, they showed a documentary
- 36:50on the life of a dairy cow. And they did very
- 36:53sort of, not like activists or campaigners, just
- 36:56sort of, this is what happens. And here's her
- 36:58calf being taken away. And you can see the calf
- 37:01in this little truck and he's bellowing his head
- 37:03off. And you can see the mother running up and
- 37:07down the hedge trying to get out to be with him.
- 37:10And it was heartbreaking. And I thought, that's
- 37:12it, soy milk tomorrow. And of course, in 1975,
- 37:16it was very difficult finding soy milk. It's
- 37:20not like now where you can go at any supermarket
- 37:22and you have about 50 different kinds of alternative
- 37:25milks available. It wasn't like that then, but
- 37:28you know, it could be done. I managed to do it.
- 37:33Being a vegan in terms of buying vegan food has
- 37:36become a lot easier, so much so that you can
- 37:41now buy absolutely crap vegan food if you want
- 37:44to, vegan burgers and things. Well, if you want
- 37:48to eat vegan burgers, that's fine, but you wouldn't
- 37:51want to live on them. No. But they're all helpful.
- 37:56They're helpful. Well, I'm so impressed by your
- 38:01long -standing commitment, truly, and I want
- 38:04to have your perspective on cultivated meat.
- 38:08That's the last episode I posted, an interview
- 38:11with Bruce Friedrich, who is basically leading
- 38:14the way for cultivated meat. What is your opinion
- 38:18on that? Well, I mean, I'm not going to eat it,
- 38:23but I think it's a very good thing for encouraging
- 38:28people who love that kind of food to eat it instead
- 38:33of eating dead animals because most of it at
- 38:38this stage will still have maybe an animal cell
- 38:40or two at the beginning of the process and that's
- 38:45the kind I won't be eating. And I don't pine
- 38:48for meat in any way. So I may not be a big purchaser
- 38:53of cultivated meat, but I think As an option
- 38:56to help get people off their devotion to dead
- 39:00animal eating. I think it's great. Fantastic.
- 39:04I'm might be braced on this one. Absolutely.
- 39:08Well, in his book, he also mentions how, you
- 39:12know, cultivated meat is actually the answer
- 39:14to the problem of animal exploitation and how,
- 39:19you know, our current activism, you know, has
- 39:22reached a certain ceiling. Um, I tried pushing
- 39:26back against that because the way I see it, we
- 39:28are underfunded and so many initiatives are completely
- 39:33unexplored like the religious lane. Um, what
- 39:37do you make of his assessment? Well, I haven't
- 39:41read his book yet. Um, but I think it's definitely
- 39:47one of the ways forward. I mean, I would be happy
- 39:50if everyone said, no, no, I'll go for lentils
- 39:52and beans, but they won't, at least not yet.
- 39:57So if cultivated meat helps them on the way to
- 40:01wean themselves off dead animal eating, then
- 40:05I think it's fantastic. I think it's fantastic.
- 40:10And you know, if you're talking to Christians,
- 40:13there's one thing I always think, Jesus had the
- 40:16last supper. What was it? Bread and wine, a vegan
- 40:21meal, you know? So people say, oh yeah, but he
- 40:24ate fish. And yeah, he probably did. And who
- 40:27knows, he probably had meat too. But the meal
- 40:31he set up as a memorial meal for him was a vegan
- 40:36meal. And people say, oh yeah, but there's fish
- 40:39blood, there's some wine these days. And there
- 40:41is in some, but I bet there wasn't back then.
- 40:44I bet it was, you know, absolutely vegan. So,
- 40:48yeah, I think it gave a good example to Christians.
- 40:52So they should be all having their vegan meals
- 40:55too. I love that image. It's a beautiful one.
- 41:00A topic I like to bring up when I discuss religion
- 41:06and animal rights is, you know, the question
- 41:08of evil and, you know, is it something real?
- 41:13Is it something real we're fighting or is just,
- 41:16you know, ignorance that we're fighting and human
- 41:20nature at its worst. Um, what do you make of
- 41:24that question? Oh, that's a tricky one. That's
- 41:28a tricky one. Um, I kind of, I'm a bit of a softy.
- 41:35I kind of think people, you know, end up being
- 41:38factory farmers or animal exploiters, one kind
- 41:41of all the other out of mainly out of ignorance.
- 41:48and just because they've never thought it through.
- 41:51I always remember when I was still a very religious
- 41:54Catholic, I was a student and I was worried about
- 41:58the concept of hell with people going to suffer
- 42:02for eternity. I remember asking a very distinguished
- 42:05priest, I said, Father, I can believe in the
- 42:09concept of hell, but I can't believe there's
- 42:12anybody there. He said, okay. He said, Yes, that's
- 42:16okay. You don't have to believe there's anyone
- 42:19there. And I always think, I mean, this may sound
- 42:23dreadful thing to say, but Hitler was a baby.
- 42:26You know, what happened? How did it become this
- 42:30gross sort of mass murderer? And, you know, the
- 42:34same with people who, you know, run factory farms
- 42:39or these big animal exploiting companies. They
- 42:45probably got into a perhaps it was a family business
- 42:48Maybe they just sort of like to make a good living
- 42:51out of this so we can live in the country and
- 42:54So on so I kind of excuse people really. I'm
- 42:58a real softy on this I find it very hard to think
- 43:02of the world as Full of evil. I think there's
- 43:06lots of evil things happening But maybe not evil
- 43:11people doing them but ignorant people all You
- 43:15know, people with various problems, some of them
- 43:19not so far from where you are, you know, creating
- 43:23wars and so on. Yeah, I think, you know, I would
- 43:31say the war that's happening now is an evil war.
- 43:34And somebody would say, yeah, yeah, but Iran
- 43:36is run by evil people and so on. I mean, how
- 43:41many people they've already killed in one week
- 43:43in this war? of all kinds, just people living
- 43:46their lives. So I'd say the war is evil. Certain
- 43:53people in positions of power are evil. They may
- 43:57do evil things, but are they fundamentally evil?
- 44:00I find that hard to believe. I think even the
- 44:06person doing the most evil deeds probably has
- 44:10a soft spot for the family or the dog or whatever
- 44:15it may be. So they're not 100 % evil all the
- 44:21time. They don't go home and beat their wives
- 44:24or, and I'm presuming their men mostly there,
- 44:28and beat their children and everything else.
- 44:33They might be quite lovely to them in a home
- 44:36setting. So they're not completely evil, but
- 44:39some of the things they do. Really, there's no
- 44:42other word for it here. I was thinking a few
- 44:49weeks ago about there was some kind of infighting
- 44:53in this movement and one activist was making
- 44:56the headline and I was thinking I know his name.
- 45:01I know the name of all, you know, the big people
- 45:05in this movement who cause a bit of trouble.
- 45:09But I don't know the name of the billionaires
- 45:12and owners of the slaughterhouses and, you know,
- 45:17you know, pising corporations and so on. And
- 45:20I started Googling those people and, you know,
- 45:24learning about their life and their hobbies.
- 45:28And, and I was wondering, why haven't we ever
- 45:32did some name calling? Why haven't we shamed
- 45:38those people and altered their names? Well, that's
- 45:43a good point. I mean, obviously, because of the
- 45:47way things are now, you can find out who owns
- 45:50just about anything. And you can find out a lot
- 45:54about their personal life. I don't think I would
- 46:01want to. Call out the names of somebody because
- 46:05I know what happens then they get bricks through
- 46:07the window The kids get beaten up at school.
- 46:11So I think you have to be very careful to distinguish
- 46:14the personal life the family person if you like
- 46:19From the job. I didn't go to their offices meet
- 46:22them demonstrate outside their offices, but don't
- 46:26go outside their homes and demonstrate outside
- 46:29their homes and vilify them at that kind of personal
- 46:33level, because I really think then you're inflicting
- 46:38a lot of suffering on them and you're saying,
- 46:40don't inflict suffering on animals, but I'm going
- 46:42to make you suffer. That doesn't seem very good
- 46:45to me. I agree. But at the same time, there was
- 46:49this big Netflix documentary about a very wealthy
- 46:54family behind a drug that was distributed across
- 46:59North America. internationally that created dependence
- 47:04in people. It was sold as a drug that doesn't
- 47:09cause any kind of addictive behaviors, but it
- 47:14was a lie. And those people, because of that
- 47:18documentary, were shamed out of polite society.
- 47:24Causes stopped welcoming them on their board.
- 47:28art galleries that had their name, you know,
- 47:31stopped having their name. And that family became,
- 47:35you know, in the margins of society. And I think
- 47:40it served as an example of, you know, if you
- 47:43do wrong in this world, here are the consequences.
- 47:48Do you think that should be an inspiration for
- 47:50us with the big wealthiest, you know, families
- 47:54owning Tyson and so on? Sorry, I don't think
- 48:00you're going to love animals. Sorry, you've got
- 48:03to love the guy who runs Tyson's. I presume it
- 48:06is a guy. If you love someone, you're not going
- 48:09to cause them suffering. What they do their job,
- 48:13you can attack that, demonstrate against it,
- 48:16write letters, line the road outside the factory
- 48:20or the office, whatever you like. But you don't
- 48:25hurt him by throwing bricks at him or knives.
- 48:28And you don't hurt him the other way by vilifying
- 48:32his whole family. And as I say, his kids or grandchildren
- 48:36getting beaten up at school. No, that's, that's
- 48:40just adding to the suffering in the world. We
- 48:42want to reduce the suffering in the world. So
- 48:47I told you I'm a softy. I don't think, you know,
- 48:51it's a softy thing. I agree with you actually.
- 48:54I would not be the one doing. that, but I guess,
- 48:58you know, I, I like the idea of it maybe from
- 49:03a strategic standpoint. Um, yeah. I mean, I think
- 49:08one thing I've done quite a few times, if I go
- 49:11to a conference, perhaps a veterinary conference,
- 49:15something like that, and someone is giving a
- 49:18paper all about how you did this experiment on
- 49:22sheep or whatever, and wasn't it interesting?
- 49:25Bloody blow. And then there's questions. And
- 49:29then I put my hand up and a great way to be chosen
- 49:34for asking questions is wear a colorful scarf.
- 49:36And you say, oh, the lady in the tukwa scarf.
- 49:40That's just a hint. And just ask a very simple
- 49:45question. What was your moral justification for
- 49:49doing that to sheep? And I tell you what, they
- 49:52usually go white. They've never even thought
- 49:55of a moral justification. Most of the time, they're
- 49:58doing it because it's interesting, and they're
- 50:00scientists, blah, blah, blah. So I always ask,
- 50:05what's your moral justification? And I've yet
- 50:08to find someone who could morally justify what
- 50:13they've been doing. They could justify it in
- 50:15terms of scientific progress, but not really
- 50:19in terms of ethics. Yeah. Yes, and I compared
- 50:24them to that family, that family with the drug
- 50:28company, but the drug company created the demand
- 50:31for a product that did not exist. This is different.
- 50:35The demand is present. You know, people want
- 50:38to consume animals and have been consuming them
- 50:41for thousands of years. So, you know, it's, it's
- 50:44different. I guess as a last question for you,
- 50:47Joyce, um, again, you know, From your perspective
- 50:52as a longtime vegan and activist What is your
- 50:57current? I guess diagnosis of our cause our movement
- 51:03Where are we? What are your hopes for the future?
- 51:07Have we met have we made Enough progress yet,
- 51:11you know if you look back and think um, so yeah,
- 51:16what is your analysis outlook on on the movement
- 51:20currently not very good at analyzing anything
- 51:23but I would say when I saw say 50 years ago it
- 51:29was there weren't that many activists around
- 51:32and some of them who were around were actually
- 51:38Breaking into places and stealing animals and
- 51:42I thought well, that's lovely for the animals
- 51:44But then they would do things like cutting the
- 51:47brakes on the trucks And I thought that is just
- 51:50not on is some guys gonna get in and drive that
- 51:54truck and probably kill himself Is that what
- 51:56you really want and if you burn down the shed
- 51:59after you've taken the chickens out? What about
- 52:01all the spiders that are going to die? Have you
- 52:04really thought that through on the mice? The
- 52:07rats no So I'm very in favor of activism, but
- 52:13not activism, which has an outcome which causes
- 52:16suffering, be it to humans or other animals.
- 52:22And I do think people need to think things through
- 52:25and ask themselves questions. But certainly,
- 52:29you know, 50 years ago, it was people would say,
- 52:33a vegan, what's that? but occasionally I still
- 52:38ask that, but not so often. The difference now
- 52:43regarding diet, I can go into any pizza place,
- 52:47let's say, and some of them will have a full
- 52:50vegan menu or they will have identified all the
- 52:53vegan items on the menu. So it's much easier
- 52:59to go out and have a vegan meal somewhere, which
- 53:03was really difficult when I started. I mean,
- 53:06it was baked potato with baked beans, and that
- 53:08was it, unless you had a few lettuce leaves on
- 53:11the side. So the whole food thing has completely
- 53:14changed. And there are, you know, I wrote a vegan
- 53:19cookery book which was published in 1980. It
- 53:24was only the second one in the UK. But now, you
- 53:27know, everywhere. There are hundreds of vegan
- 53:30cookery books and online so many vegan recipes.
- 53:33So it's all made it much easier for people than
- 53:36it used to be back then. And I think caring for
- 53:40animals and being an activist is now, people
- 53:45say, people who don't have sense, yeah, okay,
- 53:49I kind of understand that. People campaign for
- 53:52the environmental issues, yeah, okay, you can
- 53:54campaign for animal issues. Whereas 50 years
- 53:58ago, it was really sort of a bit outlandish,
- 54:02a bit beyond the pale, as they say. So I think
- 54:06things are changing in kind of subtle ways and
- 54:11sometimes very big ways when horrible practices
- 54:16are banned. And that's great. They're hard to
- 54:20come by. And boy, they do take time. The person
- 54:25who founded Compassion and Well Farming, Peter
- 54:29Roberts, had been a farmer himself. And his guy
- 54:34who provided animal feed for his dairy cows said,
- 54:37oh, look, why don't you do this intensive chicken
- 54:39farming? You make more money. And he and his
- 54:43wife sat down and they just thought, we can't
- 54:45do this. And the more they thought about animal
- 54:48welfare, the more it sort of hit them. So they
- 54:51gave up eating meat and they had to give up farming.
- 54:54And he found a compassionate world farming, which
- 54:56is a very good thing. But he always kind of understood
- 55:03where the other side was coming from because
- 55:06he'd almost been right in it himself and could
- 55:11understand how easy it would have been for him
- 55:13to say, yeah, I'll set up a shed and give me.
- 55:1720 ,000 chicks and we'll get going, but he didn't.
- 55:23I think people just don't get it. I'll tell you
- 55:26the most surreal moment of my life. About 20
- 55:30years ago, one of the big battery cage companies
- 55:34who owned thousands of hens had been in touch
- 55:39with me. He said, well, you can come and see
- 55:40our hens, see how happy they are. So off I went
- 55:44to the place. You know, this is all about the
- 55:47ward and they greet me and give me a pair of
- 55:49wellingtons. I dip my wellingtons in the disinfectant.
- 55:53We go into this shed with 65 ,000 hens in cages.
- 55:58And we walk down one of the rows and I'm looking
- 56:03at this hen. She's going for slaughter in about
- 56:06six weeks. So she's been there a long time. She's
- 56:09lost most of her feathers and our eyes just meet.
- 56:13She's looking at me. I'm looking at her. And
- 56:15I'm just saying to myself, oh my God, I will
- 56:18do my best to get you and your sisters out of
- 56:21this horrible system as soon as I can. I will
- 56:24really work hard. And behind me, I heard the
- 56:27manager say, we really do think this is the best
- 56:30way to keep pens. And I thought, wow, what I'm
- 56:33looking at, what I'm hearing are so far apart.
- 56:39I say it was the most surreal moment of my life.
- 56:42Yeah, it feels that way sometimes that we are
- 56:46moving in a alternate dimension like a parallel
- 56:51dimension Yes, yes, so we've got to get more
- 56:56people into that dimension But you know do it
- 57:00in a good way in a way that if that person be
- 57:04they the manager of a factory farmer Imagine
- 57:07that your brother or your sister or your uncle
- 57:10or your auntie What would you do to them? Would
- 57:15you really make life totally miserable for them?
- 57:18Or would you just try to persuade them and then
- 57:22maybe a little gentle activism to make them rethink
- 57:25what they're doing? So I think, yeah, see them
- 57:29as real people. Maybe see them as someone you
- 57:32actually love. And if you love them, then you'll
- 57:36do the right thing. That's beautiful. And I second
- 57:40that. I mean, yes, the the end does not justify
- 57:44the means I agree with that. That's wonderful.
- 57:51Joyce, did you want to add something before we
- 57:53stop the recording? No, I think that's really
- 57:56nice. I really enjoyed talking to you. Yes. Good
- 57:59luck. Me too. This was truly a pleasant conversation.
- 58:04I learned a lot and you stand on the shoulder
- 58:08of giants. Well, you're one of those giants.
- 58:11I'm truly honored to have met you and yeah, hopefully
- 58:16we stay in contact. Joyce, you're always welcome
- 58:19to come back on the show. That's for sure. Thank
- 58:22you. Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly
- 58:26invite you to share this podcast with the vegans
- 58:29you know. Let's encourage more people to take
- 58:32action. Again, thank you so much for caring and
- 58:36I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.