Latest / Bloomberg Law / Special Counsel Wants to Bar Politics From Trump Trial
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: They want to silence me, because I will never let
- 0:13Speaker 2: them silence you. And in the end, they're not after me,
- 0:16Speaker 2: They're after you. I just happened to be standing in
- 0:19Speaker 2: their way, and I always will say it in their way.
- 0:22Speaker 1: Donald Trump's presidential campaign seems to be driven by grievance
- 0:27Speaker 1: over the four criminal cases against him. It's a campaign
- 0:31Speaker 1: narrative where Trump is the victim of an unfair justice system,
- 0:35Speaker 1: the target of a witch hunt, and somehow he comes
- 0:38Speaker 1: to the conclusion that he's just standing in for his supporters.
- 0:42Speaker 1: Trump often vilifies the prosecutors bringing the cases, in particular
- 0:47Speaker 1: Special counsel Jack Smith.
- 0:50Speaker 2: And did you see today that deranged Jack Smith. He's
- 0:53Speaker 2: the prosecutor, He's a deranged person, wants to take away
- 0:57Speaker 2: my rights under the First Amendment.
- 1:00Speaker 1: But Smith is attempting to stop Trump from bringing his
- 1:03Speaker 1: politics and misinformation into the courtroom during his criminal trial
- 1:08Speaker 1: for election interference. He's filed emotion asking Judge Tanya Chutkin
- 1:14Speaker 1: to bar Trump from introducing certain potential defenses. Joining me
- 1:19Speaker 1: is former federal prosecutor Robert Mintz, a partner at Macarter
- 1:23Speaker 1: and English. So Special Counsel Jack Smith filed the motion
- 1:27Speaker 1: last Wednesday to prevent Trump and his defense lawyers from
- 1:31Speaker 1: turning quote, the courtroom into a forum in which he
- 1:34Speaker 1: propagates irrelevant disinformation. Is this basically emotion designed to stop
- 1:41Speaker 1: the expected circus that comes with Trump. I mean, we
- 1:45Speaker 1: saw it in the New York civil case by the
- 1:48Speaker 1: Attorney General.
- 1:50Speaker 3: Sure, these are critical motions that were filed by the
- 1:54Speaker 3: special counsel in order to limit the scope of where
- 1:58Speaker 3: the defense can actually go during this trial. So what
- 2:02Speaker 3: mister Smith did was to file with the judge a
- 2:05Speaker 3: motion barring ten different forms of evidence that he anticipates
- 2:10Speaker 3: that the Trump defense may raise a trial. These are
- 2:13Speaker 3: what's called pre trial evidentiary rulings or inlimit emotions, where
- 2:18Speaker 3: a judge is asked before a trial to make a
- 2:21Speaker 3: ruling as to what evidence can be permitted and what
- 2:24Speaker 3: evidence has to be excluded from the trial. And they
- 2:27Speaker 3: could be filed by both sides. The defense can file
- 2:29Speaker 3: it in an liimity motion, so can the prosecution. But
- 2:32Speaker 3: what we're seeing here is an attempt by the prosecutor
- 2:34Speaker 3: to rein in what could be a very far flung
- 2:38Speaker 3: defense and in the eyes of prosecutors, an attempt to
- 2:41Speaker 3: distract the jury and to politicize this case on a
- 2:45Speaker 3: whole series of issues that do not go directly to
- 2:48Speaker 3: the evidence that will ultimately convict or ecquit former President
- 2:53Speaker 3: Trump at trial.
- 2:54Speaker 1: So this kind of motion called emotion and leimonae, as
- 2:57Speaker 1: you mentioned, is common, isn't it.
- 3:00Speaker 3: It's quite calm, and it's filed in many criminal cases.
- 3:03Speaker 3: And again, what you try to a voice here is
- 3:06Speaker 3: a issue coming up in the middle of the trial.
- 3:09Speaker 3: You've got jurors and paneled, they're sitting there, they've been
- 3:12Speaker 3: hearing a case for a while. What the judge doesn't
- 3:14Speaker 3: want and what the prosecution doesn't want, is to go
- 3:17Speaker 3: into a big argument about some issue as to what
- 3:21Speaker 3: can be admitted to trial, what can't be admitted in trial.
- 3:24Speaker 3: And in order to give both sides a fair opportunity
- 3:26Speaker 3: to prepare adequately for the trial, prosecutors will often ask
- 3:30Speaker 3: a judge before a trial begins to limit in some
- 3:34Speaker 3: way the evidence that the defense is allowed to present
- 3:37Speaker 3: to the jury during the trial.
- 3:39Speaker 1: Tump has repeatedly said this is a vindictive prosecution directed
- 3:43Speaker 1: by Joe Biden and constitutes election interference. Smith wants to
- 3:49Speaker 1: prevent him from raising selective prosecution during the trial. What
- 3:54Speaker 1: are the standards the judge will use? I mean, is
- 3:57Speaker 1: it relevance, prejudicial? What kind of standards?
- 4:01Speaker 3: Well, that's a great question. I think the two themes
- 4:04Speaker 3: that we are going to see the defense try to
- 4:06Speaker 3: go after here are selective prosecution, as you say, and
- 4:09Speaker 3: also the concept of election interference. The selective prosecution argument
- 4:15Speaker 3: is basically trying to argue that similarly situated defendants have
- 4:18Speaker 3: been treated differently by prosecutors, and that the defendant in
- 4:23Speaker 3: this case is being singled out for some improper motive.
- 4:27Speaker 3: So to give a very simple example of selective prosecution,
- 4:30Speaker 3: if you're driving down the New Jersey turnpipe and there's
- 4:32Speaker 3: ten people speeding and they pull only you over and
- 4:35Speaker 3: the other nine people are not pulled over, even though
- 4:38Speaker 3: everybody is perhaps speeding, and you're the only one who
- 4:40Speaker 3: gets a ticket, you can't really raise selective prosecution there
- 4:44Speaker 3: to say that it's unfair that you were ticketed and
- 4:47Speaker 3: they were not. You have to go beyond that and
- 4:49Speaker 3: to show that you were singled out for some kind
- 4:51Speaker 3: of improper motive, that you were targeted for some reason
- 4:55Speaker 3: that is constitutionally impermissible. So in this case, to raise
- 4:58Speaker 3: selective prosecution is going be extremely difficult, just because there's
- 5:02Speaker 3: really nothing to compare this case too. It's so unique,
- 5:05Speaker 3: it's so unprecedented that to say that former President Trump
- 5:08Speaker 3: is being singled out here, what other similar situated defendants
- 5:12Speaker 3: may have been treated differently is going to be a
- 5:14Speaker 3: very tall mountain decline here and unlikely to be successful.
- 5:17Speaker 1: Smith also wants Trump to be prevented from blaming the
- 5:21Speaker 1: events of January sixth on the Capitol Police, the National Guard,
- 5:24Speaker 1: or the DC mayor, in other words, law enforcement's failure.
- 5:29Speaker 1: And he said, a bank Robert cannot defend himself by
- 5:32Speaker 1: blaming the bank security guard for failing to stop him.
- 5:36Speaker 1: I'm just wondering because a lot of times at trial,
- 5:39Speaker 1: the defendants will point to other people. You know, I
- 5:43Speaker 1: didn't do anything wrong, but he did, she did. Is
- 5:46Speaker 1: the special counsel trying to prevent Trump from doing that?
- 5:50Speaker 3: Yeah, That's exactly what's going on here. Judges are often
- 5:53Speaker 3: placed in the very difficult position in criminal trials to
- 5:56Speaker 3: decide what defenses are permissible and what defense is there
- 6:00Speaker 3: are going to exclude a trial, And the one hand,
- 6:03Speaker 3: a judge is always trying to give a defendant a
- 6:06Speaker 3: fair trial, to allow them to try their case, to
- 6:09Speaker 3: present their defenses, to force the government to meet the
- 6:12Speaker 3: burden of proof, because as always in a criminal case,
- 6:15Speaker 3: the burden is always with the prosecution, it never shifts
- 6:18Speaker 3: to the defense, and the government has to prove its
- 6:20Speaker 3: case beyond a reasonable doubt. So a judge is going
- 6:23Speaker 3: to be very careful not to unfairly tie the defense's
- 6:27Speaker 3: hands and let them avail themselves of any reasonable defense.
- 6:31Speaker 3: But on the other hand, what a judge cannot let
- 6:34Speaker 3: happen is a trial gets completely out of control, where
- 6:37Speaker 3: the defense tries to go down rabbit holes of issues
- 6:40Speaker 3: that are not really relevant, that don't go directly to
- 6:43Speaker 3: the guilt or innocence or the burden of proof that
- 6:45Speaker 3: the government has to meet in order to get a
- 6:47Speaker 3: conviction at the end of trial. And in this case,
- 6:50Speaker 3: because it's been so highly politicized, it is extremely important
- 6:54Speaker 3: here that the judge reigns in the defense and only
- 6:57Speaker 3: allows them to present defenses for which there is a
- 7:01Speaker 3: reasonable basis. In other words, as a defense player, you
- 7:04Speaker 3: can't just present any fanciful defense. You dream up. There's
- 7:08Speaker 3: got to be some evidential basis to support that defense,
- 7:12Speaker 3: and that is what the jail you will have to
- 7:13Speaker 3: decide here. So in this case, the argument about that
- 7:17Speaker 3: it's the fault of the Capitol Police or the National
- 7:19Speaker 3: Guard or the mayor for not preventing January sixth is
- 7:23Speaker 3: really beside the point from the prosecution standpoint. For the
- 7:27Speaker 3: reason you just stated that you can't commit a crime
- 7:30Speaker 3: and then blame it on law enforcement for failing to
- 7:33Speaker 3: prevent it from happening, and that is what prosecutors are saying.
- 7:36Speaker 3: The Trump team is trying to argue here.
- 7:39Speaker 1: There's a lot that they want to prevent evidence from
- 7:41Speaker 1: coming in on. They want to prevent evidence of alleged
- 7:44Speaker 1: to foreign influence in the twenty twenty presidential election. They
- 7:48Speaker 1: argue that Trump should be prohibited from arguing he was
- 7:51Speaker 1: personally tricked by foreign disinformation about the election, or that
- 7:55Speaker 1: foreign disinformation campaigns led to the January sixth riot. And
- 8:01Speaker 1: it just comes to mind cases where it seems like
- 8:05Speaker 1: defense attorneys throw everything at the wall just to see
- 8:09Speaker 1: what sticks, and is a special counsel trying to prevent
- 8:14Speaker 1: Trump from doing that?
- 8:15Speaker 3: Yeah, that's exactly what's going on, and that is exactly
- 8:19Speaker 3: the tension between the prosecutor and the defense. When you're
- 8:22Speaker 3: the prosecutor, you want this case to go in very focused,
- 8:27Speaker 3: very streamlined. You want everything during the case to be
- 8:31Speaker 3: presented to be focused directly on the evidence and whether
- 8:34Speaker 3: or not you've met your burden of proof. When you're
- 8:36Speaker 3: on the defense side, it's a completely different role that
- 8:39Speaker 3: you're playing. You're trying to raise every issue under the sun.
- 8:42Speaker 3: You're trying to bring in all kinds of extraneous and
- 8:46Speaker 3: perhaps irrelevant information, because at the end of the day,
- 8:49Speaker 3: if even one juror is confused by the evidence and
- 8:52Speaker 3: unable to vote to convict, then you have a victory.
- 8:55Speaker 3: There a hung jury, even one juror not voting for
- 9:00Speaker 3: viction means that the prosecution has to retry the case
- 9:03Speaker 3: all over again. So the defense is going to try
- 9:05Speaker 3: to raise a number of issues which they claim are relevant,
- 9:09Speaker 3: and here the foreign interference defense is something that they're
- 9:12Speaker 3: going to pursue, I think quite vigorously, and that defense
- 9:15Speaker 3: is basically asking for the government to give them access
- 9:19Speaker 3: the more government documents, including classified information from former President
- 9:24Speaker 3: Trump's administration, that he believes will back up his arguments
- 9:28Speaker 3: that the election result couldn't be trusted. In other words,
- 9:31Speaker 3: that they were outside on foreign influences that were providing
- 9:35Speaker 3: disinformation about the campaign. They're seeking access to intelligence about
- 9:39Speaker 3: Iran and China, for example, about interfering with the US politics.
- 9:44Speaker 3: All of this is trying to support the Trump defense
- 9:48Speaker 3: that his belief that the election was not there and
- 9:51Speaker 3: was not accurate was something that he believed in good faith,
- 9:55Speaker 3: and by raising proof of foreign interference, it's apports the
- 10:00Speaker 3: argument that his belief that the election was not properly managed,
- 10:05Speaker 3: it was not a fair result, was at least a
- 10:08Speaker 3: good faced belief, if not in fact true.
- 10:10Speaker 1: Coming up, can any trial judge rein in Donald Trump,
- 10:14Speaker 1: I'm June Gross. When you're listening to Bloomberg, I've been
- 10:17Speaker 1: talking to former federal prosecutor Robert Mints of McCarter and
- 10:20Speaker 1: English about Special counsel Jack Smith filing a motion to
- 10:24Speaker 1: stop Trump from injecting politics and misinformation into his criminal
- 10:29Speaker 1: trial for election interference. Bob Trump continues to repeat allegations
- 10:34Speaker 1: of election fraud. It's part of his campaign spiel, but
- 10:38Speaker 1: those claims have been nearly unanimously rejected by the courts
- 10:43Speaker 1: state and federal. So can Judge Judkins say no, this
- 10:48Speaker 1: can't come in, It's already been decided in other courts.
- 10:51Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 10:52Speaker 3: Absolutely, the judge can say that there is not a
- 10:55Speaker 3: credible basis to mount this defense. In other words, there
- 10:59Speaker 3: is not credible evidence that the election was not fair,
- 11:02Speaker 3: and the judge count point to the many decisions around
- 11:05Speaker 3: the country which found that there was no material interference
- 11:09Speaker 3: with the election to make the results unfair, and that
- 11:13Speaker 3: therefore there is not a bassist for the defense to
- 11:16Speaker 3: argue that there was some foreign interference that tampered with
- 11:19Speaker 3: the election results and allowed President Trump to have a
- 11:23Speaker 3: good faith belief that those results were unfair. And one
- 11:26Speaker 3: thing that the prosecution will prove to support that is
- 11:28Speaker 3: that I think we can expect to see them call
- 11:31Speaker 3: a series of former Trump officials, including former Attorney General
- 11:35Speaker 3: Bill Barr, vice President Mike Tence, for example, on others,
- 11:40Speaker 3: who would testify that not only do they believe the
- 11:43Speaker 3: election was fair, but that they told former President Trump
- 11:47Speaker 3: that they believed the election was fair, and therefore, the
- 11:50Speaker 3: prosecutors will argue that he had no good faith belief
- 11:53Speaker 3: that the election had been tampered with and in fact,
- 11:56Speaker 3: his actions in order to gin up the activities of
- 11:59Speaker 3: January six. We're done for the purpose of interfering with
- 12:03Speaker 3: the election, and not because he truly believed that the
- 12:06Speaker 3: election was unfair.
- 12:07Speaker 1: Now my question is this, will the judge look at
- 12:10Speaker 1: these and look at each one individually, make her decision
- 12:14Speaker 1: on each one individually, or will she try to balance
- 12:16Speaker 1: it out, you know, giving some to Trump so that
- 12:19Speaker 1: he has a means of defending himself and giving others
- 12:23Speaker 1: to the Special Council.
- 12:25Speaker 3: Well, I think the judge will look at each of
- 12:27Speaker 3: these defenses individually. Certainly, she'll look at the basis that
- 12:31Speaker 3: the defense has to raise them and weigh that against
- 12:35Speaker 3: the prosecution's argument that it's irrelevant or somehow prejudicial. And
- 12:39Speaker 3: that's the balancing actor she's going to have to engage in.
- 12:42Speaker 3: And I think we could expect her to bar outright
- 12:45Speaker 3: some of these defenses and for others to allow them in.
- 12:48Speaker 3: But perhaps up to a point. I do not think
- 12:51Speaker 3: they're going to see the judges barring all of these defenses.
- 12:54Speaker 3: But she's going to go through them one by one
- 12:57Speaker 3: and decide just which one is the defense can raise
- 13:00Speaker 3: and how far they can go in order to mount
- 13:04Speaker 3: that defense.
- 13:05Speaker 1: Smith is making this motion now, but the case has
- 13:08Speaker 1: been put on hold by the trial judge while Trump's
- 13:11Speaker 1: claims of presidential immunity work their way through the appellate
- 13:15Speaker 1: court and perhaps the Supreme Court. Why is Smith doing
- 13:18Speaker 1: this now? Is he trying to get ahead of the game,
- 13:22Speaker 1: or is this the right time for a trial that
- 13:26Speaker 1: was supposed to start on March fifth.
- 13:28Speaker 3: Well, as you say, the judge who has the trial
- 13:31Speaker 3: and the District of Columbia has temporarily froze these criminal
- 13:34Speaker 3: proceedings pending the appeal by former President Trump on whether
- 13:39Speaker 3: his conduct was immune from prosecution. So at this point
- 13:42Speaker 3: the trial can't really proceed, but the judge can receive
- 13:47Speaker 3: motions and at least review them and think about them
- 13:50Speaker 3: while they are in this period where they're waiting for
- 13:52Speaker 3: the Court of Appeals to rule. So while she can't
- 13:55Speaker 3: issue any decisions, she can look at those issues. And
- 13:59Speaker 3: what the prosecution trying to do here is tee these
- 14:01Speaker 3: things up so that when the Court of Appeals rules
- 14:05Speaker 3: and the prosecution expects that the immunity defense will be rejected,
- 14:09Speaker 3: the judge will quickly move to these various inlimni motions
- 14:12Speaker 3: that be able to rule on them quickly. Another thing
- 14:15Speaker 3: that's going on here is that we're seeing here a
- 14:18Speaker 3: real battle between the defense and the prosecution over who
- 14:22Speaker 3: controls the narrative in this case. And so what Special
- 14:26Speaker 3: Counsel Jack Smith has done here is these raised all
- 14:29Speaker 3: of these issues to try to get out in front
- 14:31Speaker 3: of the Trump defenses in order to put them on
- 14:34Speaker 3: the radar not only of the court, but also on
- 14:36Speaker 3: the public, to project in some ways exactly where the
- 14:39Speaker 3: prosecution is going, and to try to debunk and de
- 14:43Speaker 3: legitimize these defenses which prosecutors are expecting the Trump team
- 14:48Speaker 3: to raise. It really is a battle here over the
- 14:51Speaker 3: legal versus political view of this case. Prosecutors are going
- 14:55Speaker 3: to make this case all about the truth versus disinformation,
- 15:00Speaker 3: about proof versus propaganda, about the difference between a court
- 15:04Speaker 3: of law and the court of public opinion. And the
- 15:07Speaker 3: Trump team, on the other hand, is going to try
- 15:10Speaker 3: to make this case as political as possible. The political
- 15:13Speaker 3: world is the world that former President Trump inhabits. It's
- 15:16Speaker 3: what he's used to dealing with, and they're going to
- 15:19Speaker 3: try to raise the same themes that we have seen
- 15:22Speaker 3: in the campaign, a world of grievance, blaming, trying to
- 15:26Speaker 3: message something over and over and over again in the
- 15:30Speaker 3: court of public opinion so that it ultimately sinks in
- 15:33Speaker 3: and becomes truth. That's what I think we're going to
- 15:35Speaker 3: see from the defense here leading up to the trial.
- 15:38Speaker 1: And Bob, we saw in the Sam Bankman Freed trial
- 15:42Speaker 1: how the judge there really limited the defense. These kinds
- 15:47Speaker 1: of motions excluding evidence, are they issues that appellate courts
- 15:52Speaker 1: usually reserve for the trial judge and are hesitant to reverse.
- 16:00Speaker 3: Yeah, those are decisions that usually are given wide discretion
- 16:05Speaker 3: to the trial judge, who hears all the evidence, listens
- 16:08Speaker 3: to the arguments, and tries to decide the balancing act.
- 16:12Speaker 3: As I said a moment ago, the balancing between giving
- 16:15Speaker 3: the defense latitude to raise legitimate defenses, to raise issues
- 16:19Speaker 3: for which there is some evidentiary basis, and on the
- 16:23Speaker 3: other hand, not allowing the defense lawyers to turn the
- 16:26Speaker 3: trial into a circus where there are a host of
- 16:29Speaker 3: irrelevant issues that are put in front of a jury.
- 16:32Speaker 3: The prosecutors will say is being done in order to
- 16:35Speaker 3: prejudice the jury, or even perhaps an attempt by the
- 16:38Speaker 3: defense to obtain what's called jury nullification, that is, to
- 16:43Speaker 3: try to convince at least one juror to block any
- 16:47Speaker 3: attempts by prosecutors to prove their case. And what jury
- 16:50Speaker 3: nullification is, thankfully means is that even when prosecutors have
- 16:54Speaker 3: proven their case by beyond a reasonable doubt, which is
- 16:56Speaker 3: their standard, that one or more jurors may still vote
- 17:00Speaker 3: to ac quit for reasons unrelated to the evidence presented
- 17:03Speaker 3: at trial. So you're going to see that issue perhaps raised,
- 17:06Speaker 3: not directly, certainly because it's improper, but indirectly to try
- 17:10Speaker 3: to appeal to the politics, to the unfairness, to some
- 17:14Speaker 3: sense that the deck has been unfairly stacked against former
- 17:18Speaker 3: President Trump and therefore curers should not believe what prosecutors
- 17:22Speaker 3: are presenting to them at trial.
- 17:24Speaker 1: Judge Chuckkin has been on the bench for about a decade.
- 17:28Speaker 1: Before that, she was a seasoned public defender. But we
- 17:32Speaker 1: saw what happened in the New York courtroom where his
- 17:36Speaker 1: civil case was heard. Can any judge really rein in
- 17:41Speaker 1: Trump and his defense team?
- 17:43Speaker 3: Well, I think the judge is going to try to
- 17:45Speaker 3: do that. I think she's going to control her courtroom
- 17:48Speaker 3: very carefully, because one thing you can't do as a
- 17:50Speaker 3: judge has ever let your courtroom get out of control.
- 17:54Speaker 3: The judge controls everything that goes on in that courtroom.
- 17:57Speaker 3: The judge tells people when they can speak, when they
- 17:59Speaker 3: can't speak, the topics they can address, when they can
- 18:02Speaker 3: address them, and when the judge will decide the various issues.
- 18:05Speaker 3: So the judge has to always remain in control of
- 18:08Speaker 3: the courtroom. And I do think the judge is going
- 18:10Speaker 3: to have a difficult time reigning in former President Trump
- 18:14Speaker 3: and reigning in his defense lawyers, regardless of what these
- 18:17Speaker 3: rulings are. Because even if there are certain rulings about
- 18:21Speaker 3: certain defenses that the judge says in the pretrial motions
- 18:24Speaker 3: are inadmissible or inappropriate and that the defense can't raise,
- 18:28Speaker 3: you're going to see the defense trying to raise them anyway,
- 18:30Speaker 3: perhaps not directly, but at least indirectly. That's going to
- 18:34Speaker 3: be the theme of this trial. Is going to be
- 18:36Speaker 3: a battle between the law and the politics of how
- 18:39Speaker 3: January sixth unfolded.
- 18:40Speaker 1: I mentioned that this trial is on hold while that
- 18:43Speaker 1: issue of presidential immunity goes through the appellate process. Most
- 18:49Speaker 1: legal experts seem to think that Trump is not going
- 18:52Speaker 1: to win that that his claim of presidential immunity will
- 18:56Speaker 1: be rejected. What do you think.
- 18:59Speaker 3: I do think that the claim for presidential community will
- 19:02Speaker 3: be rejected, but it's now before the Court of Appeals.
- 19:05Speaker 3: As you said, Special Council of Jack Smith tried to
- 19:08Speaker 3: short search that process by taking it directly to the
- 19:11Speaker 3: United States Supreme Court bypassing the Court of Appeals. The
- 19:15Speaker 3: Supreme Court rejected that move, which is not to say
- 19:19Speaker 3: that the Supreme Court will not ultimately hear this issue,
- 19:21Speaker 3: but they wanted to allow the Court of Appeals to
- 19:24Speaker 3: decide the issue first. The DC Court of Appeals is
- 19:27Speaker 3: going to act very quickly. There's argument schedule for January
- 19:29Speaker 3: ninth on this issue, and I think we can expect
- 19:31Speaker 3: the decision fairly quickly, and then it will move to
- 19:34Speaker 3: the United States Supreme Court. But really this is a
- 19:37Speaker 3: race to the finish line for Special Counsel of Jack
- 19:39Speaker 3: Smith trying to get this case in before the elections,
- 19:43Speaker 3: and from the defense side, this is a slow and
- 19:45Speaker 3: deliberative process where they are trying to inject as many
- 19:49Speaker 3: issues into this case as possible because they have no
- 19:52Speaker 3: interest in seeing this case go to trial anytime soon.
- 19:55Speaker 1: Great Insights, as always Bob, thanks so much. That's Robert
- 19:58Speaker 1: Men's apartnerment CA or in English. Coming up next, Google
- 20:02Speaker 1: settles a five billion dollar privacy lawsuit. I'm June Gross.
- 20:07Speaker 1: When you're listening to Bloomberg, you may have used Google's
- 20:10Speaker 1: incognito mode in its Chrome browser, signified by a little
- 20:14Speaker 1: black hat in glasses. That's supposed to indicate that your
- 20:18Speaker 1: Internet browsing will be concealed or private. Well, Google has
- 20:22Speaker 1: agreed to settle a five billion dollar consumer class action
- 20:26Speaker 1: privacy lawsuit alleging that it essentially spied on people who
- 20:30Speaker 1: use the incognito mode, secretly tracking the Internet use of
- 20:34Speaker 1: millions of people who thought their browsing was private. The
- 20:38Speaker 1: terms of the settlement have not been disclosed. Joining me
- 20:41Speaker 1: is Austin Chambers, a partner at Dorsey and Whitney whose
- 20:44Speaker 1: practice focuses on data privacy and security compliance. Tell us
- 20:49Speaker 1: about this case against Google, what it's about in Google's defense, So.
- 20:54Speaker 4: This case of the Brown case was a case brought
- 20:56Speaker 4: against Google back in twenty twenty. This was a case
- 20:59Speaker 4: brought by several plaintiffs in California against Google, alleging that
- 21:02Speaker 4: Google collected information while users were using the Chrome browser
- 21:06Speaker 4: in what is called incognito mode, So that's the version
- 21:10Speaker 4: of the browser or higher box that's a similar one.
- 21:12Speaker 4: There are others across all the browsers that allegedly prevent
- 21:14Speaker 4: your data from being collected or track while you're on
- 21:16Speaker 4: the Internet. So these plaintiffs argue that Google, despite the
- 21:20Speaker 4: fact that you were using this incognito mode, Google was
- 21:22Speaker 4: in fact still collecting information about you, tracking you across
- 21:25Speaker 4: the Internet, collecting your browser history and so on and
- 21:28Speaker 4: so forth, basically continuing to spy on you, despite the
- 21:32Speaker 4: fact that they said that they wouldn't, And so they
- 21:34Speaker 4: brought this claim basically arguing that this was all valuable
- 21:37Speaker 4: data that if they thought they weren't giving to Google,
- 21:39Speaker 4: the Google's collecting anyway. And then they put that together
- 21:42Speaker 4: and I think this this came out to about five
- 21:43Speaker 4: billion dollars they alleged in unlawful, unauthorized data collection.
- 21:47Speaker 1: What was Google's defense or what was their response.
- 21:51Speaker 4: Google basically came back and defended saying that you know,
- 21:54Speaker 4: this is browsing data. It's not very valuable data. It's
- 21:56Speaker 4: just data about how you move around the Internet. Most
- 21:59Speaker 4: of it isn't data that actually relates to you specifically,
- 22:02Speaker 4: this is information about the sites that you visited, or
- 22:05Speaker 4: maybe the IP address from your device, which is just
- 22:08Speaker 4: basically a network idea string of numbers of sorts that
- 22:11Speaker 4: relates to your computer, but it doesn't identify you. And
- 22:14Speaker 4: they said that you know this isn't personal data, This
- 22:16Speaker 4: isn't data that subject to the wiretab acts or other
- 22:19Speaker 4: access plaintiffs alleged would be subject to those laws, you
- 22:22Speaker 4: can't collect unlawfully. And they also basically said, even if
- 22:25Speaker 4: that were the case, that you wouldn't have standing in court,
- 22:27Speaker 4: basically that you didn't have harms that would be sufficient
- 22:30Speaker 4: to confer standing in court. That you know the data
- 22:32Speaker 4: wasn't valuable or you weren't actually harmed. You can't prove
- 22:35Speaker 4: that you were financially or intangibly harmed in some way.
- 22:38Speaker 4: So therefore they try to get thrown out of court
- 22:40Speaker 4: multiple times.
- 22:40Speaker 1: Let's talk about In August, the trial judge rejected Google's
- 22:44Speaker 1: attempt to dismiss the lawsuit. She said it was an
- 22:48Speaker 1: open question whether Google had made a legally binding promise
- 22:52Speaker 1: not to collect users' data when they browsed in private mode.
- 22:56Speaker 1: Tell us a little bit about her decision.
- 23:00Speaker 4: Where this case was positioned leading up to August is
- 23:02Speaker 4: these plantists have brought these claims back in twenty twenty,
- 23:05Speaker 4: and they've been fighting in the interceding years as to
- 23:07Speaker 4: whether or not what they've alleged is actually a claim
- 23:10Speaker 4: under the law. And so Google had sought a motion
- 23:12Speaker 4: to dismiss saying is these aren't real claims. The law
- 23:15Speaker 4: doesn't recognize these claims as potential violations of the law.
- 23:18Speaker 4: So this is very early in the case and Google
- 23:20Speaker 4: was basically trying to say that these are not recognized claims.
- 23:25Speaker 4: And so what this decision meant in practice is that
- 23:27Speaker 4: these claims can proceed. This goes on to discovery, on
- 23:29Speaker 4: to trial, and we can actually see whether or not
- 23:32Speaker 4: Google actually violated the law. And so it's important because
- 23:36Speaker 4: for a long time historically, and why this case is
- 23:38Speaker 4: kind of a turning point, is that we're starting to
- 23:41Speaker 4: see the law recognize these types of claims, this type
- 23:43Speaker 4: of data collection, these types of behaviors really as something
- 23:46Speaker 4: that can form a cognizable claim. Historically, they had been
- 23:49Speaker 4: thrown out at these very early stages and not proceedings.
- 23:53Speaker 4: And I guess an interesting piece you mentioned that there
- 23:56Speaker 4: was a legally binding promise not to collect data, which
- 23:59Speaker 4: is an interesting issue onto its own in the sense
- 24:02Speaker 4: that oftentimes we view privacy policies as just a sort
- 24:05Speaker 4: of statement to practice. The way that Google had positioned
- 24:08Speaker 4: the product of the incognito mode within Chrome, the way
- 24:11Speaker 4: that their business operated, what they had told users, and
- 24:14Speaker 4: the way that they had set up their user agreements,
- 24:16Speaker 4: the planners were actually able to allege that Google did
- 24:18Speaker 4: actually make a contractual promise not to collect data, and
- 24:22Speaker 4: that their data collection practices in their privacy policy were
- 24:25Speaker 4: a contract between them and the user. At least that
- 24:27Speaker 4: was the allegation. So a very interesting sort of site
- 24:30Speaker 4: issue in the case tell.
- 24:31Speaker 1: Us about the trend of trying to rein in companies
- 24:35Speaker 1: use of dark patterns and deceptive conduct to get users
- 24:40Speaker 1: to agree to provide data. And if you could explain
- 24:42Speaker 1: that dark.
- 24:43Speaker 4: Patterns of course, So dark patterns are something I think
- 24:48Speaker 4: many people have probably heard, at least recently the last
- 24:50Speaker 4: couple of years. It's been a sort of trend and
- 24:52Speaker 4: we've seen this both from court cases and regulators from
- 24:56Speaker 4: the FTC. Dark patterns are sort of this notion that
- 25:00Speaker 4: companies will use some sort of interfaces that how or
- 25:03Speaker 4: how they interact with the consumer to try to get
- 25:05Speaker 4: them to consent or agree to provide data. And so
- 25:08Speaker 4: if you've ever gone to a website and they say like,
- 25:10Speaker 4: do you want to provide us this data? And they'll
- 25:12Speaker 4: give you two buttons. One says yes, one says no.
- 25:14Speaker 4: But yes isn't red, and no isn't green. This is
- 25:17Speaker 4: the sort of essential notion of a dark pattern, something
- 25:19Speaker 4: that would be confusing. You would expect green to beg
- 25:22Speaker 4: and say yes, and red to be no, and block
- 25:24Speaker 4: and stop. So this sort of you know, bait and switch.
- 25:26Speaker 4: This sort of deceptive conduct is sort of pervasive, especially
- 25:30Speaker 4: in cases where you're trying to collect data that people
- 25:33Speaker 4: may not want necessarily to give. And so we've seen
- 25:35Speaker 4: a lot of companies engaging in these types of behaviors
- 25:38Speaker 4: as the law has started to crack down on data
- 25:40Speaker 4: collection and consumers have become more sensitive the data collection
- 25:44Speaker 4: practices by companies, and so that's sort of the underlying issue.
- 25:48Speaker 4: And then here the issue with Chrome is that when
- 25:52Speaker 4: users open incognitom of one of the things that they
- 25:54Speaker 4: expect is that they're not being tracked. Google, for its part,
- 25:58Speaker 4: you click this little masked eye account. It looks like
- 26:01Speaker 4: a little spy and you click on him and he
- 26:03Speaker 4: takes you to incognito mode. You get a screen that
- 26:06Speaker 4: says that your information won't be tracked. Google won't keep
- 26:08Speaker 4: your history. It does tell you that other people may
- 26:11Speaker 4: be able to see it, like your employer or whoever
- 26:13Speaker 4: operates your network can still see some of the traffic
- 26:16Speaker 4: that your device is engaging in. But it does give
- 26:19Speaker 4: you this impression that you're browsing privately. And there's been
- 26:21Speaker 4: statements in the Privacy policy and in the settings mid
- 26:24Speaker 4: us and things like that where Google has indicated or
- 26:27Speaker 4: at least suggested that this type of tracking would not
- 26:29Speaker 4: occur and that you're in control of how your data
- 26:32Speaker 4: is being collected if you want to browse privately. All
- 26:34Speaker 4: this again leading consumers to believe they're not being tracked.
- 26:38Speaker 1: You say, the court applied to holistic approach. Explain what
- 26:41Speaker 1: you mean by that.
- 26:42Speaker 4: So the court in this particular case, and I think
- 26:44Speaker 4: it's a trend that we've seen across some of the
- 26:47Speaker 4: recent cases, is that courts when they're looking at these
- 26:50Speaker 4: types of consumer privacy claims, and historically there's been this
- 26:54Speaker 4: notion of what's called noticing consent. The idea is that
- 26:57Speaker 4: the website puts a privacy policy. They put in that
- 27:00Speaker 4: privacy policy that they may engage in some kind of
- 27:03Speaker 4: data collection, and then by continuing to use the site,
- 27:06Speaker 4: you have implicitly consented to the conduct that they describe.
- 27:09Speaker 4: It's been a sort of simplistic sort of thing in
- 27:12Speaker 4: this case and in the other cases we've seen, we've
- 27:14Speaker 4: started to see courts really kind of applying a more
- 27:16Speaker 4: holistic approach in two ways. First, from the sort of
- 27:20Speaker 4: consumer perspective, they're looking at these apps. They're looking at
- 27:23Speaker 4: dark patterns. They're looking at how a service is presented
- 27:27Speaker 4: to a user, what representations the website operator makes or
- 27:31Speaker 4: even suggests about how their service works. They're not taking
- 27:34Speaker 4: this formalistic approach looking at the privacy policy, looking for
- 27:38Speaker 4: the magic words, and the privacy policy is moving on.
- 27:40Speaker 4: They're saying, Okay, maybe you did that, but you also
- 27:43Speaker 4: did this over here to suggests that this wasn't happening
- 27:46Speaker 4: or you presented it in such a way. And then
- 27:48Speaker 4: they apply a more holistic approach to the type of
- 27:50Speaker 4: data that's being collected. I mentioned that one of Google's
- 27:53Speaker 4: defenses to this was that the data wasn't valuable, It
- 27:57Speaker 4: even potentially didn't identify you at all. However, today are
- 28:01Speaker 4: looking at that data and saying it is valuable data.
- 28:03Speaker 4: They're looking at evidence that Google was profiting from this
- 28:06Speaker 4: type of data even if it wasn't directly related to
- 28:09Speaker 4: a person. They're still able to extrapolate trends from how
- 28:13Speaker 4: a device that sort of navigates them across the internet,
- 28:16Speaker 4: what sites they see, et cetera. And so we started
- 28:19Speaker 4: to see them sort of looking at that and saying, Okay, well, yes,
- 28:22Speaker 4: this one piece of data maybe doesn't identify you, but
- 28:24Speaker 4: if I put it together with this other piece of
- 28:26Speaker 4: data to time, the type of device, and so on
- 28:28Speaker 4: and so forth, we can extrapolate very valuable information about
- 28:32Speaker 4: how you and people like you use the Internet. And
- 28:35Speaker 4: not only is that valuable, that is a privacy harm.
- 28:37Speaker 4: That is still your activity, that's still your data, your
- 28:41Speaker 4: privacy that's been effective by this conduct.
- 28:43Speaker 1: What are the biggest takeaways from this case for other
- 28:48Speaker 1: consumer privacy lawsuits.
- 28:50Speaker 4: It's a part of a trend. It's really a milestone
- 28:52Speaker 4: in my mind, to all these sorts of different types.
- 28:55Speaker 4: There's ongoing litigation around similar data collection practices similar sorts
- 28:59Speaker 4: of claims under the wire Tap Act, both in California
- 29:01Speaker 4: and the federal wire Tap Act. We've seen a lot
- 29:04Speaker 4: of these claims really proliferating over say the last year
- 29:06Speaker 4: or so. In this case, I think is a milestone
- 29:08Speaker 4: in that line of cases, largely because the court does
- 29:11Speaker 4: recognize again that this is valuable data, the plaintiffs do
- 29:15Speaker 4: have standing. We're seeing consistent cases following the TransUnion Supreme
- 29:19Speaker 4: Court case a number of years ago, really starting to
- 29:21Speaker 4: interpret TransUnion, which recognized that there are privacy harms, that
- 29:24Speaker 4: these are intangible harms sufficiently confer standing. This has solidified
- 29:29Speaker 4: that notion. On the one hand. And then similarly, what
- 29:31Speaker 4: we've seen is that where companies engage in some kind
- 29:34Speaker 4: of conduct that at least is ostensibly in some way deceptive,
- 29:38Speaker 4: that if plaintiffs can allege some kind of deceptive conduct,
- 29:41Speaker 4: that they're going to have more success than these sorts
- 29:43Speaker 4: of claims. And that again that a website that just
- 29:46Speaker 4: puts up a privacy policy that's not sufficient anymore. And
- 29:50Speaker 4: often that's sort of what you see, that's how industry
- 29:52Speaker 4: is operating. That's sort of been the norm for a
- 29:55Speaker 4: number of years, and again, we're starting to see courts
- 29:57Speaker 4: recognize that that may not be sufficient. Started to see
- 30:00Speaker 4: these types of allegations popping up not just since this case,
- 30:03Speaker 4: but sort of alongside this case, and I think that's
- 30:06Speaker 4: why it represents a really significant moment. Frankly for these
- 30:10Speaker 4: types of cases.
- 30:11Speaker 1: How do you advise tech clients about how transparent they
- 30:15Speaker 1: have to be about their privacy policies going forward.
- 30:19Speaker 4: I think that this case really is it's something that
- 30:21Speaker 4: we can point to to tell clients that, again, historically,
- 30:24Speaker 4: what they've looked at is, you know, what does our
- 30:25Speaker 4: privacy policies say, and do we get users to read
- 30:28Speaker 4: the privacy policy or at least acknowledge that they've seen
- 30:31Speaker 4: it or had the ability to read it. Whereas today
- 30:33Speaker 4: I think what we're seeing is that maybe that's not sufficient.
- 30:35Speaker 4: That what we need to do is put a notice
- 30:37Speaker 4: that pops up like we've seen you've probably seen more
- 30:40Speaker 4: on the web these days, the little pop up banners
- 30:42Speaker 4: and things like that, telling people that their data is
- 30:45Speaker 4: being collected for say, social media or for advertising purposes,
- 30:49Speaker 4: and just letting people know immediately upon visiting a site
- 30:52Speaker 4: that this is happening, and then giving users a choice
- 30:54Speaker 4: around that. So I think what we've been looking at
- 30:57Speaker 4: kind of in light of a lot of these cases,
- 30:59Speaker 4: is it by and clients, you know, anybody with the
- 31:01Speaker 4: website frankly that engages in advertising or uses social media
- 31:05Speaker 4: type integrations to be more transparent, to give users that
- 31:08Speaker 4: sort of upfront notice about what's actually happening on the site,
- 31:11Speaker 4: what data is being collected in the background, and then
- 31:14Speaker 4: giving them some kind of choice like giving them the
- 31:16Speaker 4: ability to click that reject all button and say, you
- 31:19Speaker 4: know that they don't want to be tracked by these services.
- 31:23Speaker 1: The class action sought at least five billion dollars. Do
- 31:26Speaker 1: we know any of the terms of the settlement.
- 31:30Speaker 4: As of today, we don't know the terms of the settlement.
- 31:32Speaker 4: It's all still confidential at this point. That five billion
- 31:37Speaker 4: dollar number was that I think that came out of
- 31:41Speaker 4: the assessed damages for the class and so the class
- 31:44Speaker 4: was essentially everyone who had used incognito mode from I
- 31:48Speaker 4: believe it was June first, twenty sixteen, until the case
- 31:51Speaker 4: was filed in twenty twenty, and so I think they
- 31:54Speaker 4: were ledging somewhere between one hundred and one thousand dollars
- 31:57Speaker 4: in damages per affected class member, and so this number
- 32:01Speaker 4: came about based on sort of the claiman's assessment and
- 32:06Speaker 4: some evidence that they had uncovered around what Google was
- 32:10Speaker 4: selling browsing history data for and how they were monetizing
- 32:13Speaker 4: it as part of their business. But the actual terms
- 32:15Speaker 4: of the settlement we don't know, And.
- 32:17Speaker 1: I suspect that those of us who turned on the
- 32:20Speaker 1: incognito mode in that time period are going to get
- 32:24Speaker 1: a little card saying talking about the settlement and some
- 32:28Speaker 1: kind of pittance. That's what these class action lawsuits usually
- 32:32Speaker 1: end up being for consumers, that is correct.
- 32:34Speaker 4: I would be very interested to see how they find
- 32:38Speaker 4: out how to give you the card or how to
- 32:39Speaker 4: send it to you and who was actually inspected members.
- 32:41Speaker 4: So I think it'll be very interesting to see how
- 32:43Speaker 4: they actually do links that up.
- 32:46Speaker 1: Any final thoughts, The.
- 32:47Speaker 4: Big takeaway for me is again that you know, we
- 32:50Speaker 4: see these trends of you know, data collection around people's
- 32:52Speaker 4: browsing behavior and all of advertising and all of the
- 32:55Speaker 4: analysis that goes on about how people use the Internet,
- 32:58Speaker 4: how they they visit, all of this stuff that's been
- 33:01Speaker 4: happening in the background since I thought as long as
- 33:03Speaker 4: the internets existed. It's really becoming somewhat of a sensitive thing,
- 33:07Speaker 4: and the courts are responsive to that. And we're seeing
- 33:11Speaker 4: consumers really starting to take the initiative here, and you know,
- 33:14Speaker 4: clients just need to be aware of that. And you know,
- 33:16Speaker 4: anybody is sort of with a website sort of needs
- 33:18Speaker 4: to be aware of this activity and these potential claims.
- 33:21Speaker 1: This lawsuit may make people think twice before clicking on
- 33:25Speaker 1: that incognito mode. Thanks so much, Austin. That's Austin Chambers,
- 33:30Speaker 1: a partner at Dorsey and Whitney. And that's it for
- 33:33Speaker 1: this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can
- 33:36Speaker 1: always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 33:40Speaker 1: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 33:43Speaker 1: www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, Slash Law, and
- 33:48Speaker 1: remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight
- 33:51Speaker 1: at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and
- 33:55Speaker 1: you're listening to Bloomberg