Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Mastermind] 1959 Warren Buffett to Partnership Letter
Transcript
- 0:001959 Letter Warren E Buffett 52O2 Underwood Ave.
- 0:05Omaha, NE The general stock market in 1959, the Dow Jones
- 0:10industrial average, undoubtedly the most widely used index of
- 0:14stock market behavior, presented A somewhat faulty picture in
- 0:181959. This index recorded an advance
- 0:21from 583 to 679, or 16.4%, for the year when the dividends
- 0:28which would have been received through ownership of the average
- 0:31are added, an overall gain of 19.9% indicated for 1959.
- 0:37Despite this indication of a robust market, more stocks
- 0:40declined than advanced on the New York Stock Exchange during
- 0:44the year. By a margin of 710 to 628.
- 0:48Both the Dow Jones Railroad average and utility average
- 0:52registered declines. Most investment trusts had a
- 0:55difficult time in comparison with the Industrial average.
- 0:58Tri Continental Corporation, nation's largest closed end
- 1:02investment company, total asset $400 million, had an overall
- 1:06gain of about 5.7% for the year. Fred Brown, its president, had
- 1:12this to say about the 1959 marked in a recent speech to the
- 1:16Analysts Society. But even though we like the
- 1:20portfolio, the market performance of Tricontinentals
- 1:23Holdings in 1959 was disappointing to US.
- 1:26Markets in which investor sentiment and enthusiasm play so
- 1:30large a part as those of 1959 are difficult for investment
- 1:35managers trained in values and tuned to investing for the long
- 1:39term. Perhaps we haven't had our space
- 1:41boots adjusted properly. However, we believe that there
- 1:44is a limit to risks that an investing institution such as
- 1:47Tricontinental should take with its stockholders money and we
- 1:51believe that the portfolio is in shape for the year ahead.
- 1:55Massachusetts Investors Trust, the country's largest mutual
- 1:58fund with assets of $1.5 billion showed an overall gain of about
- 2:039% for the year. Most of you know I have been
- 2:06very apprehensive about general stock market levels for several
- 2:10years. To date, this caution has been
- 2:12unnecessary. By previous standards, the
- 2:15present level of blue chip security prices contains A
- 2:19substantial speculative component with a corresponding
- 2:22risk of loss. Perhaps other standards of
- 2:25valuation are evolving which will permanently replace the old
- 2:28standard. I don't think so.
- 2:30I may very well be wrong, however I would rather sustain
- 2:34the penalties resulting from over conservatism than face the
- 2:38consequences of error, perhaps with permanent capital loss
- 2:42resulting from the adoption of a new era philosophy where trees
- 2:46really do grow to the sky. Results in 1959.
- 2:50There has been emphasis in previous letters on a suggested
- 2:53standard of performance involving relatively good
- 2:56results compared to the general market indices and leading
- 2:59investment trusts in periods of declining or level prices.
- 3:03Relatively unimpressive results in rapidly rising markets.
- 3:08We were fortunate to achieve reasonably good results in 1959.
- 3:12The six partnerships that operated throughout the year
- 3:15achieved overall net gains ranging from 22.3% to 30% and
- 3:20averaging about 25.9%. Portfolios of these partnerships
- 3:25are now about 80% comparable, but there is some difference due
- 3:29to securities and cash becoming available at varying times,
- 3:33payments made to partners, etcetera.
- 3:36Over the past few years, there hasn't been any partnership
- 3:39which has consistently been at the top or bottom of performance
- 3:43from year to year and the variance is narrowing as the
- 3:46portfolios tend to become comparable. 7 The overall net
- 3:50gain is determined on the basis of market values at the
- 3:53beginning and end of the year, adjusted for payments made to
- 3:56partners or contributions received from them.
- 3:59It is not based on actual realized profits during the
- 4:02year, but is intended to measure the change in liquidating value
- 4:06for the year. It is before interest allowed to
- 4:09partners, where that is specified in the partnership
- 4:11agreement, and before any division of profit to the
- 4:15general partner, but after operating expenses.
- 4:18The principal operating expense is the Nebraska intangibles tax,
- 4:22which amounts to .4% of market value on practically all
- 4:26securities. Last year represented the first
- 4:29time that this tax had been effectively enforced and of
- 4:33course penalized our results to the extent of .4% the present
- 4:37portfolio. Last year, I mentioned a new
- 4:40commitment which involved about 25% of assets of the various
- 4:44partnerships. Presently, this investment is
- 4:46about 35% of assets. This is an unusually large
- 4:50percentage but has been made for strong reasons.
- 4:54In effect, this company is partially an investment trust
- 4:57owing some 30 or 40 other securities of high quality.
- 5:01Our investment was made and is carried at a substantial
- 5:05discount from asset value based on market value of their
- 5:08securities and a conservative appraisal of the operating
- 5:11business. We are the company's largest
- 5:14stockholder by a considerable margin and the two other large
- 5:17holders agree with our ideas. The probability is extremely
- 5:21high that the performance of this investment will be superior
- 5:24to that of the general market until its disposition, and I am
- 5:28hopeful that this will take place this year.
- 5:30The remaining 65% of the portfolio is in securities,
- 5:34which I consider undervalued, and workout operations. 2 The
- 5:38extent possible, I continue to attempt to invest in situations
- 5:42at least partially insulated from the behavior of the general
- 5:46market. This policy should lead to
- 5:48superior results in bear markets and average performance in bull
- 5:52markets. The first prediction may be
- 5:54subject to test this year since at this writing, the Dow Jones
- 5:58industrials have retraced over half of their 1959 advance.
- 6:03Should you have any questions or if I have not been clear in any
- 6:06respect, I would be very happy to hear from you.
- 6:10Warren E Buffett February 20th, 68.