Latest / Wheel Takes / WoT on Prime (S2E1 "A Taste of Solitude"): Obstacles and Inciting Events
Transcript
- 0:17Hello, Hi, and welcome to Wheel Takes, a podcast that is normally
- 0:22about the Wheel of Time and sometimes also about other things like the Hunger Games,
- 0:26but right now it's definitely about the Wheel of Time TV show. Yes,
- 0:30I am Ali, and i am a first time reader of the Wheel
- 0:34of Time. I'm on book ten. Yes, and I am Gus and
- 0:38I have read all of the Wheel of Time and I'm on my second time
- 0:43through it on book ten. And you're thinking, what sets this show analysis
- 0:48apart from any other show analysis that I could go get. Well, first
- 0:52of all, it's longer. It's probably longer. Historically these have been really
- 0:56really long. Yes, but from what I hear, worth it because why
- 1:02they are both we hope in the entertainment industry. I am formerly a creative
- 1:07executive and now a screenwriter, most recently of rug Rats, my first episode
- 1:14of which will be on Paramount Plus soon, which she can talk about because
- 1:19it's it's the animation guild. Well, yeah, yeah, I can talk
- 1:23about that because animation and animation writing is a different guild than the WGA.
- 1:27It's tag which is under AATSI and I am an actor, and I can't
- 1:33talk about that. It's irrelevant to this current conversation because, as you may
- 1:38or may not know or recall depending on when you're listening to this, As
- 1:42we are recording this, we are in the midst of the Writers Guild of
- 1:46America and sag AFTRA strikes, so we don't know when we are going to
- 1:51be able to upload these critical analyzes of the show. We are waiting until
- 1:57we can get the guild's blessings. I assume that we put something at the
- 2:00beginning of this episode outlining that, yeah, but for those of you just
- 2:06finding us for the first time, essentially what we do, we welcome all
- 2:09of your feelings. I'm sure that you are watching The Wheel of Time right
- 2:12now, whether you're approaching it from being a first time reader. We have
- 2:16spoiler tags that are very clear about where you need to stop listening if you're
- 2:22coming to us as a first time reader encountering the stuff for the first time.
- 2:28We also welcome people who have read the books a thousand times and are
- 2:32feeling feelings about the adaptation and want to understand a little bit from our perspective.
- 2:38Having worked in the entertainment industry for a long time in various capacities,
- 2:43why we think they made the decisions that they made and just kind of like
- 2:46make it so that you can understand the process of that adapting and screenwriting and
- 2:52acting as well. These are pretty specifically about how the sausage is made essentially
- 3:00and why why choices may have been made in converting from one medium to another.
- 3:05Yeah, but that being said, these are not to tell you that
- 3:07your feelings unless they are like racist, homophobic, or misogynistic, those aside
- 3:13are wrong, right. These are just to present like this is kind of
- 3:16why in adapting from page to screen, certain things need to become more visual,
- 3:22certain things need to become more overt, more covert, you know,
- 3:28longer, shorter, just depending on what the issue is at hand. And
- 3:32we also try as best as we can to answer any questions that people reach
- 3:37out to us with about the industry. The industry is big and has a
- 3:43lot of different jobs, So answer every answer every question. What I can
- 3:47promise, try to reach out to people I think will know the answer and
- 3:52see if I can come back to with something more solid. Also, of
- 3:55course, my opinions and Gus's opinions about why things might have happened and how
- 4:00the entertainment industry works. You talk to another entertainment industry, they'll tell you
- 4:05something. I'll tell you something else. This is our perspective. This is
- 4:10not gotful. This is our take on why adaptational choices may have been made.
- 4:15Yes, and to give you a general feeling of kind of how we
- 4:20feel towards the show. We're mostly very positive towards it. So if you
- 4:25are here to hear two people rant and rave about the show being you know,
- 4:30woke crash and Robert Jordan is spinning in his grave, then you will
- 4:32not enjoy this. Yeah, this may not be the thing for you.
- 4:35I will be honest with you. If you are open to having that opinion
- 4:40changed, like genuinely open to it, then maybe you will. Well,
- 4:43I mean not even changed, but just our perspective of like why things happen
- 4:48explained. You don't have to like. You don't have to like it.
- 4:51You don't, you don't have to just you know, come in with an
- 4:55open mind. But the other thing is is that just as kind of a
- 4:59spoiler into mind personality, if you're not familiar with me, I don't tend
- 5:04to bash the hard work of other people. Yeah, generally speaking, we
- 5:09we will avoid that because we have made media before, and it's really fucking
- 5:17hard and hard, so we're mostly gonna celebrate what has been made. Yeah,
- 5:24to be just look at why they did the things that they did.
- 5:27Whether or not we thought that they were successful is kind of not really relevant.
- 5:32I mean, we'll talk about our feelings about it. But yeah,
- 5:35I don't. I don't. I'm just a person that believes that the things
- 5:41you put out into the world should be as kind as possible and as positive
- 5:46as possible. So and yeah, just to be explicit about it, No,
- 5:49we're not being paid by Amazon, we're not under contract with Amazon.
- 5:56If we're really effusively positive about the show, it's just because we like it.
- 6:00It's just because we like it. But yeah, and my thing too
- 6:02is I just don't. I also don't believe that anything is objectively bad or
- 6:08good. Yes, it's all media and art have what three three components generally,
- 6:14right, there's the creator of the media, there's the medium, and
- 6:16then there's the receiver of the media. And it's any combination of those three
- 6:21is going to change the ultimate product. Yeah, right, the wheel of
- 6:26time that I watch, the experience that I have is going to be different
- 6:30from the experience that Ali has is going to be different from the experience that
- 6:34you listener, who has read the books fifteen times and has a very specific
- 6:39idea will have, is going to be different from my buddy Zach, who
- 6:43has never read the books and is kind of doesn't really have a huge amount
- 6:47of interest in the goings on of the show, but he wants to watch
- 6:50it anyway. Yeah. So, I guess my thing is, I don't
- 6:53really care to examine whether something is good or bad, because I don't think
- 6:57that's an objective thing. I'm here to be, like, here's an intellect
- 7:00exercise. We're talking about the intellectual exercise of adapting and what decisions they made
- 7:04that I find interesting from an intellectual perspective of, like how do we get
- 7:10this chonky book series into a streamlined television show? Yes? So, yeah,
- 7:15so that's what we're here to talk about, and like why it happened
- 7:18that way? Probably we don't know in full because we're using our educated guesses.
- 7:25Okay, cool, all that being said, all that disclaimer aside,
- 7:29let's dive in, shall we. Yes, So, first, let me
- 7:31get the dog. Yes, he's barking. So while Allie gets the dog,
- 7:35let me run you through how these episodes are structured. The first thing
- 7:41and the longest part by far, is going to be the spoiler free up
- 7:46to the show section. So what that means is any information that is not
- 7:53revealed in the show we are not going to cover. We're not going to
- 7:57tell you in this section. Oh and this is up for this thing that
- 8:01happens later. This is definitely meant to be explicitly foreshadowing this. Yeah.
- 8:07What might happen in this section is if there is a portion of the episode
- 8:13that is adapted from a scene that is in Book three that happens chronologically later
- 8:18than in the books than the rest of the episode. We might discuss that
- 8:24because that has been covered by the show. But we're going to do our
- 8:26darness to avoid talking about anything that is not right in the show. We
- 8:31may also the dog has a squeaky toy. You may hear that we have
- 8:33a dog. His name is Petie, and he hangs out in the studio
- 8:35with us when we record, so so you are all very welcome for the
- 8:41dog sounds. I've been told to stop apologizing for the dog sounds, so
- 8:46there you go. We may also touch on certain changes that is to say
- 8:50this was not like this in the show. This is different. This is
- 8:54a plotline that appears to be new. We also might not because we don't
- 9:00don't always want to. We don't want to give anybody who has not read
- 9:03the books but has seen the show too many preconceived notions about, Oh,
- 9:07therefore this doesn't matter because it's not in the books. We don't know what
- 9:11does or does not matter. That's the fun part. Yeah, Honestly to
- 9:15take a quick side sojourn thing. As somebody who's read these books and knows
- 9:20them pretty well, I am continuously surprised by the show, and it makes
- 9:24me feel as though I am experiencing the story for the first time. In
- 9:30a lot of ways, even though I know the arc of the story,
- 9:33the plot of these episodes is markedly different. And yes, you can have
- 9:37the same story but a different plot in much the same way that, for
- 9:41instance, Lord of the Rings and Star Wars are in a lot of ways
- 9:43the same story, right, Ali, Yes, they are very different in
- 9:46their plotting and characters and everything else. And that is not to say that
- 9:50I think that the books in the show are as different as Star Wars and
- 9:54Lord of the Rings the second section, which will happen after you hear this
- 9:58siren. So a spoiler, babies, spoilers, spoilers, spoilers, spoilers,
- 10:05spoilerts, spoilers, spoiler is, spoilers. Up through what Alley's read
- 10:11right now, that's Crossroads of Twilight. Well like chapter nine. I want
- 10:16to say, al yeah about chapter nine, although frankly it's unlikely we're going
- 10:22to talk about Crossroads of Twilight at all. So what through Let's just say
- 10:26through the end of Winter's Heart, give or take. We'll have specifics when
- 10:30we get there, we will delineate it. There will be a chapter marker,
- 10:33there will be a time stamp. If you have not read the books,
- 10:35you should leave at that point. And then the third section, and
- 10:39that is going to be by far the shortest section almost every time. Every
- 10:43time is full book spoilers, where I may or may not actually have a
- 10:48third section where our good buddy Bree, who is half of the author duo
- 10:54kit Rosha, joins me and discusses some things that Ali doesn't know yet that
- 11:01happen in the books that are being foreshadowed in the show. Last Day,
- 11:05I too, will be part of that discussion. Last season, we had
- 11:09significantly more to discuss in those sections because Allie was on Book six, chapter
- 11:15like five, and she has since read you know, books six, seven,
- 11:18eight, and nine, so she's got a lot more context. A
- 11:22lot of the major events that we're being foreshadowed in book one have since happened,
- 11:26so yeah, a little different. So I just got a text from
- 11:31my non reader friend. Oh yeah, yes, Oh, we may or
- 11:35may not discuss also things that happen in episodes one, two, and three.
- 11:39We're gonna try not to. We're gonna try really hard to keep this
- 11:43to season one. Season two episode one. Okay, well quick like not
- 11:46even spoiler, but just emotional reaction to something my friend Nathan, So skip
- 11:52ahead a little bit if you're worried about that. But my friend Nathan just
- 11:56text me, y'all that what episode three was a fucking emotional roller, Yes,
- 12:00everybody, So we look forward to hearing about that in fifteen or so
- 12:03hours of podcast depending. I don't know, do you think these they know
- 12:07already they can see the time stamps. Do you think these will be shorter
- 12:09than our season one talking No? No, not. Based on my notes,
- 12:13there's so much more to unpack that's there is a lot, though I
- 12:18do think they might be shorter in that I won't feel the need to explain
- 12:22in as much detail the screenwriting terms because I'm already this is giving me so
- 12:26much life. I am seeing so much critical well not that there wasn't critical
- 12:31analysis before, but just like the proliferation of certain terms and you know,
- 12:39certain knowledge that I'm not going to say like that was me, but I've
- 12:43just noticed it in the community a little bit more this time around, this
- 12:48like feeling of like, oh, I see why they did this. It
- 12:52goes back to x Y or Z or people messaging me or even some of
- 12:56our content creator friends like this is the A plot, this is a B
- 13:00plot. Things like that where I discuss terminology that we established last season's analyses,
- 13:05which we will probably be less explicit in redefining. Yeah, I mean
- 13:09we still will a little bit, but not to the except so I think
- 13:13that part will be short any explanation. It's also worth noting if you are
- 13:16joining us for the first time, we're going to be examining these episodes from
- 13:22a fairly boiler plate structural standpoint. As our framework. We're going to be
- 13:28using terms like a plot, B plot, C plot. We're going to
- 13:33be looking at an eight episode season structure as what it is in the textbook,
- 13:39as it were. That Again, as we've said before, that is
- 13:41not to say that all pieces of media as we're going to examine today in
- 13:46episode one, must strictly follow these rules or they're bad. That's not what
- 13:52we're saying. We are using this as a basis point to jump off of
- 13:54because, as Shakespearean actors like to say, you have to know the rules
- 13:58before you can decide when you're going to break them. Yeah, it's super
- 14:01important. So cool, let's talk about the rules. So we're doing episode
- 14:05one right, just for now, it's episode one. Can I ask you
- 14:09a question before we get started? Yes, of course. First initial reactions
- 14:13to season two versus season one. I really loved season one. Yeah,
- 14:18me too. Let me put that out there. This season already three episodes
- 14:22in, blowing it out of the world. It's it's I think it's a
- 14:24lot, and I loved loved season one and this isn't a knock on season
- 14:28one. Yeah, it's really strong. It's really strong to really strong,
- 14:33so really really strong. And I think it's because they have the luxury of
- 14:37taking a little more time. Yeah, not just in the like we have
- 14:41longer episodes. We've cut the intro for time which we can get into I
- 14:48do. I loved the intro. I agree with the decision if it means
- 14:52that we get longer episodes, but I think, you know, we're still
- 14:56really following within that sixty minute structure where just like letting a couple character moments
- 15:01breathe a little bit longer, and I think we desperately needed that. I
- 15:05think season one was very plot heavy, not a bad way, but I
- 15:09think in order for us to like really connect with these characters, those character
- 15:13moments are really helpful. Like I was talking to a first time reader or
- 15:18first time watcher friend of mine who said, I just feel so much more
- 15:22in it, and I feel so much more like interested in the characters than
- 15:26I like they like season one. But they were like, I just feel
- 15:28like I get them now. And I think part of that is just like
- 15:33we have the luxury of that time plot wise. Also, we're not running
- 15:35away from fades right now, you know what I mean. We have this
- 15:39time to really do some setup. And what's nice in season two is you
- 15:45have a fan base already so you're not trying to suck people in as much
- 15:48anymore. It's a little bit less of that go go, go, go
- 15:50go. You're trying to kind of like expand what you already have. Yes,
- 15:54so you have that breathing room in time that you don't have in season
- 15:56one. Set Up with season one is always the hardest thing to do,
- 16:00and so season two is always, in my mind a lot of the time,
- 16:04a better season. I think there's so many reasons why, Like you'll
- 16:07hear of shows that don't quite stick the landing on their first season, you
- 16:14know. I think Parks and Recreation is a pretty famous example of that that
- 16:18people refer back to. Whether or not you agree with that, always Sonny,
- 16:22there's a lot of people that say, like always Sunny Parks and Recreation,
- 16:25those shows didn't quite stick the landing their first season and still had to
- 16:29kind of like figure out the bones. And I think that that, yeah,
- 16:32that tends the comfortability of like this is what the show is and this
- 16:37is who we are and why we're here tends to make for a better season
- 16:40two. That being said, let's talk about well, I think I think
- 16:42there is more to talk about within that though. If you don't mind,
- 16:45we're going no within within run time. And because last season we talked a
- 16:52lot about how if you push over sixty minutes, it's you're going to feel
- 16:56it. You do feel it, and we do feel it. Yeah,
- 16:59I do think we've now pushed it about as far as we realistically can.
- 17:03Yeah, with about seven extra minutes. I think it's a good amount.
- 17:07I do. Because there's such a thing as letting too much air in to
- 17:11your show. It's a really delicate balance because we as a culture have become
- 17:15used to thirty or sixty minute episodes. When you screw with that formula too
- 17:21much, it tends to actually be antithetical to the success of the thing.
- 17:26So like, for instance, it's interesting I have a learning disability, right,
- 17:32I was given an extended time on my test. Yes, And all
- 17:34these people be like, oh gosh, that's not fair, Like I should
- 17:37get extended time on my test. Well, the studies show that that's actually
- 17:41antithetical to kids doing well on their tests if they are neurotypical. Sure,
- 17:45so, like it's not an advantage, it's it's creating equity in the classroom.
- 17:49Sure So, Like that's that's an example. So when a show when
- 17:53you're like, oh, I wish we had four hour episodes or whatever.
- 17:56It is a lot of the time, what's then happening is if you're creating
- 18:00longer and longer episodes, we're really doing is kind of creating a film,
- 18:03and then you're just creating a series of films, which can work, but
- 18:07it's a different can work, but it's a it's not. It doesn't tend
- 18:11to be my favorite thing, sure, because I think that there's a reason
- 18:15why the formula exists. And when you screw that formula too much, I
- 18:19think you start to make people like weirdly mad, Like I think our brains
- 18:23start to get mad when the patterns that we are used to get broken too
- 18:26much. Yeah, we're just like, ah, we've been telling stories the
- 18:30same way since time immemorial. Why are we screwing with that now? Yeah,
- 18:33which again is say it can't work. And I made that point last
- 18:37season, and then I had somebody message being go I didn't really like latch
- 18:42onto that as a concept until I saw a show break that formula and I
- 18:47kept thinking, God, how long is this? Yes, yeah, so
- 18:52big thing. We have our big thematic dichotomy that's coming back into play,
- 18:56right, what is good? What is evil? When we talk talk about
- 19:00a thematic dichotomy, guess what am I talking about? The thematic dichotomy is
- 19:03two opposing or non complimentary perspectives or topics or or modes of being that are
- 19:14kind of locked in an eternal struggle that the show is there is examining as
- 19:18its thesis right, and the protagonist is stuck between those two polls right,
- 19:22and neither side can really fully win. So when we talk about good versus
- 19:27Evil as an example, and this is what classic dichotomy creates the longevity of
- 19:32the show. We want a show that's going to last multiple seasons, unless
- 19:34you're writing a mini series and that's like a whole other fucking can of worms.
- 19:37But ideally with the show, like the wheel of time, we want
- 19:40a show that's ongoing and continuous, especially because shows don't make money until at
- 19:44least season two for the most part. So when we're talking about thematic dichotomy
- 19:48and we're saying good versus evil, Rand and his friends by extension as sort
- 19:53of mini protagonists, right, we're all protected. I would argue they're all
- 19:59protacon but I would say Rand is kind of the dragon, right, So
- 20:04he's the person we would think of as the protagonist, but they're stuck in
- 20:07the middle between good versus evil. Now, wouldn't evil be something you would
- 20:11naturally go away from and go to the good side? I mean theoretically,
- 20:18right if we have these mustache twirling, ridiculous villains who are like eating babies
- 20:23in front of us, right, yeah, but that's not what the show
- 20:26is doing, and that ultimately also is not Robert Jordan's thesis is that like,
- 20:30oh, you should just be good, that evil is easy to oppose
- 20:33and simple to notice. Right, It's really an examination of like the layers
- 20:38and levels of what good is and what evil is and balance, and we
- 20:45think of what that is. It's like we're also presenting two camps, right.
- 20:48The characters that populate this world all have to fall somewhere along the spectrum
- 20:52and are pulling the protagonists in different directions. So when you're talking about evil,
- 20:57obviously on one end, we have a Shameel, right, who we
- 21:02now can say is the sha Maye because the show has made that explicit now,
- 21:07and of course the dark one obviously not appealing, but a Shamel has
- 21:10some pretty good points, right, about I mean, they've got child care.
- 21:15The first the first scene of the season is a shameel effectively delivering a
- 21:22monologue about how evil. Isn't that simple? Exactly right? And that is
- 21:26the thesis of the show, right, And like, what is a monster?
- 21:32What does a monster look like? Can we really know? It's just
- 21:34based on our own implicit biases? Right? And then on the good side,
- 21:40it's not all sunshine and roses over there. We've got white cloaks who
- 21:44think they're the good guys. Do we agree on your perspective? Right?
- 21:51So we have the protagonist in the middle of these dueling, opposing parties and
- 21:56where do they fall? They have to fall in the middle somewhere. But
- 21:59our distantly pulled in different directions because that creates consistent and lasting conflict, and
- 22:03conflict in shows is king slash queen slash non binary ruler? Now, allie
- 22:11h. In the past, we have discussed episodes as part of an eight
- 22:17episode structure, and you have mentioned that seasons, because this show is intended
- 22:21to be eight seasons, follow a very similar kind of macrocosm form of that
- 22:27eight episode structure. Right, Can you remind us for the season two episode
- 22:33one, what is season two? And then also what is episode one?
- 22:38Sure, as a quick explanation, every episode of a TV show has its
- 22:45own arc, right, you get the you saw it when you first were
- 22:48in school. There's it's a little more complicated when you get dive into it
- 22:52a little bit deeper. But you've got, you know, the inciting incident,
- 22:55which is the why we're here, what's causing us to start out,
- 22:57why today, the climb, which is the big moment of answering the question
- 23:03of like, will they accomplish their goal or not? And the resolution,
- 23:06which is we are finished with that, and then of course with TV and
- 23:10we'll talk about this a little bit further, a hook that leads us to
- 23:12the next episode so that you want to keep watching, especially with this binge
- 23:17model that we've created. So there's that. Then there is a larger arc
- 23:22within that whole thing that is the season arc, right, and that also
- 23:27has the same beats that an episode would have just over a longer period of
- 23:32time. Right, Each episode encompasses a beat of that season. Then you
- 23:37have the series. Each season encompasses one of those beats that make up the
- 23:44larger season arc of the entire show. The series arc said season series.
- 23:48Sorry. Yeah, So in terms of the season to you know kind of
- 23:56what we can expect. This is the Obstacles season. So we're going to
- 24:02start to see increased obstacles, more and more batties. The batties are going
- 24:08to be leveling up. Our characters will also be leveling up in response to
- 24:14those obstacles. They're going to be learning new things about their world and their
- 24:17environment. Things are going to be more difficult than they initially thought. And
- 24:19then we're also going to have a point of no return. This is going
- 24:22to be the ah crap, we can't go back. I have some advanced
- 24:27theories based on the books of what those will be. We'll talk about that
- 24:30in the spoiler section, but I'm like very certain I know exactly what the
- 24:34point of the return is going to be. Cool. So in addition to
- 24:41that, we're also going to have a season question. Yeah, so just
- 24:45just to loop back on obstacles. Yeah, this is essentially oh, this
- 24:51is harder than we thought. This is the other this is harder than we
- 24:53thought. Season great, right, So I think that's why we're getting introductions
- 24:59to well, I can't say who the batties are that we're getting introduced to
- 25:04yet, but know that there's a reason why we were fighting three fades instead
- 25:10of one this episode. Right, we're leveling up. It's more dangerous.
- 25:14It's more dangerous, it's more threatening. We are growing up, and we
- 25:18got to grow up fast. So in the terms of the season question,
- 25:22this is kind of like the plot question of the season that's gonna keep us
- 25:25watching from episode to episode. So last season it was who is the dragon
- 25:27reborn? Right, that's gotta be a really strong season question to suck those
- 25:33new fans in. This season, I think it's gonna be a little bit
- 25:37lighter as a season question. Sure, I think it's gonna be a little
- 25:41bit lighter because we have so many different moving pieces that in order to unite
- 25:47all of them together under one banner question, it's a little complicated. That
- 25:52is certainly true. The party has been split. Yes, So my season
- 25:55question is can these kids stay safe long enough to learn to control or master
- 25:59their abilities to deal with the battles to come and find their way back to
- 26:03one another. I think that's the most important thing is are they going to
- 26:06find their way back to one another? Can we? Yeah, can we
- 26:10get the gang back together. Well, the gang get back together, and
- 26:11I think that's that. The stakes of that is highlighted in Paren's letter,
- 26:17which we'll talk about, where he says, I feel like alone, we
- 26:21are more vulnerable. The world is more dangerous. Obstacles obstacles. I'm just
- 26:26going to point it out every time we need more obstacles, that we feel
- 26:32exposed when we're not all together, which means we're in danger. When we're
- 26:37not all together, we need to come back together so that we're safe.
- 26:40Does that make sense? Makes sense to me? Cool? And we notably
- 26:44we see a lot of people, not all of them, but many of
- 26:45our friends in danger this episode. Yes, so without without being too specific,
- 26:52well, getting specifics later, Alley, with that being too specific.
- 26:56Uh. Do are the obstacles usually overcome in the Obstacles season? Some of
- 27:02them or all of them? I mean yes? And no? Sure?
- 27:07I mean I think it depends a lot of the time. No sure,
- 27:12because here's the thing with TV. You need to oscillate between hope and fear.
- 27:18Right. If there's too much hope, right, if too many obstacles
- 27:21are defeated, we have we kind of run out of steam. The stakes
- 27:25are too low. We get bored. Sure, if there's too much fear
- 27:29and no obstacles get overcome, then at this point you're depressing. We're like,
- 27:33there's no way that this protagonist could actually win, so we lose interest.
- 27:37Sure, because it's boring to watch people suffer with no skills. That
- 27:41is true, you don't no one wants to see hot people doing well and
- 27:45no one That's something a mentor of mine said. They're like, no one
- 27:49wants to see hot people doing well. That's funny, so too much hope,
- 27:52get rid of it. But also no one wants to see depressing McGhee.
- 27:56So when we think of the obstacles that are before us, that have
- 27:59been set out before us at the end of last season, we've got powerless
- 28:03Moraine. Yeah right, I think that's probably something that will be overcome,
- 28:07just because just because I think that people want to see magic on the show.
- 28:14I think from a producer perspective, roswind Pike even talked in the like
- 28:18X Ray about missing doing magic. I think there's just no way we have
- 28:22not the Magic Lady, not we have Gandolf for like six seasons, not
- 28:27Channel Sure. I just don't. I just don't think that's possible. We've
- 28:30got the band has been is not together were all. There's a diaspora that,
- 28:37to me is probably going to be resolved in some way. I think
- 28:38they will come back together. I think it will likely be temporary because from
- 28:42a screenwriting perspective, it's just very hard to have that many people in one
- 28:45space and create compelling conflict. And none of this is based on what does
- 28:48or doesn't happen in the books, because again they're playing fast and loose with
- 28:52specific pacing, which works for me right well. It also comes from knowing
- 28:57that next season is the story in season yeah, which is basically the like
- 29:02ramp up to the midpoint, which is like the mini climax in the middle
- 29:06of everything. So it's the point at which like everything kind of shakes up.
- 29:10Sure, so all the like stuff we thought we knew and the gains
- 29:15we thought we were making, all that gets shaken up because new plans get
- 29:18introduced. We've got Rand lost and Matt in captivity. Yeah, I mean,
- 29:23I think we're already seeing with Matt that he's looking for a way out
- 29:27of that problem. Rand. We're not really sure what's going on with Rand
- 29:32at this point, so we can put him kind of on ice. Yeah,
- 29:36for now, just put him in the box, put him on the
- 29:37shelf. I mean, I think there's a reason why I did see some
- 29:44complaints about rand not showing up until the middle of the episode. Really the
- 29:48end. I mean we time this eight minutes from the end. There's a
- 29:51reason for that. Yeah, we'll get into it, but it has to
- 29:53do with the question of the episode, which I think I can get into
- 29:57now. Right, Oh, do you mind if I more obstacle please?
- 30:00There were these weird fuckers on boats at the end of episode eight that seemed
- 30:04to be there to presage something bad. Yeah, I mean exactly if you
- 30:08title wave a city and a small girl, and they were not aiming the
- 30:11title wave at the small girls, oh my gosh, I cannot see her
- 30:15teeth. They're clearly aiming for the city. She just happened to be on
- 30:18the beach. They probably at the beach you anyway. But so my big
- 30:25thing was with that. I think that the reason why they were the hook
- 30:32of the episode, right, is because that is going to propel us into
- 30:37the obstacle season. We have introduced a tiny glimpse at what that new obstacle
- 30:41could be. One of the new obstacles, right. Obviously, a Shamael
- 30:47is also another big, one, big obstacle. As the trailers told us,
- 30:51we set his strong, strongest left tenant tree lieutenant as they say,
- 30:56she's very British. Uh, now we can jump in if you're ready to
- 31:03jump into the question of episode one. Yes, we can do that right
- 31:07after these ads welcome back, we ate dinner, dinner time because these are
- 31:26long. So Also, I'm texting with a friend who is also another first
- 31:33time watcher who is obsessed with issue. For us, fres really has crushed
- 31:41it. Yeah, pay your actors and your writers. Pay your actors and
- 31:45your writers. Holy shit, why is that hard? Anyway, the plot
- 31:48question of the episode, right, the thing that's going to be keeping us
- 31:52watching is very simply I went back and forth with you about this at all.
- 31:56Yes, we talked about this extensively. And this is why we say
- 32:00that this is a great episode for us to look at in terms of formula
- 32:05not formulaic. It's because it's it's difficult for us to really distill this down.
- 32:10Well yeah, I mean, there are so many moving parts now to
- 32:14these episodes, but they still manage to keep those arcs yes, present throughout
- 32:20and they don't forget about anybody or like let anything drop, which I think
- 32:22makes this even more impressive. But the blot question I think we determined was
- 32:27where is everyone? Where are we? Where is everybody? If you think
- 32:30about it, the where is everyone question for random Matt is obvious. Where
- 32:36are they are? Where are they? We start the episode with a shamo
- 32:43being like where is rand Boom? Usually with a plot question, it's asked
- 32:46pretty quickly yeah. And a plot question, by the way, needs to
- 32:51be answerable within the bounds of the episode correct, yes, yes, at
- 32:55least in some way. It doesn't have to be like definitive yes or no,
- 33:00but it has to be like, there's progress made, here's a p
- 33:02Yeah, here's progress. Movie for it. Otherwise we get mad. We
- 33:05don't know why we get mad, but we do, and then everyone floods
- 33:07to Twitter. Why are we here? About that episode? What? Right?
- 33:10So? Where's everyone? So we got paren hunting for Pad and Fane
- 33:15and the horn? Where is everyone? Where's Pad and Fane? Where's Pad
- 33:16and Faine? We've got the fades with Moraine, Yes, where and not
- 33:22only that, but with it's clear that she's hunting somebody in this episode,
- 33:30right, she's looking for some information to get more more detail, but she's
- 33:34not being very clear about it. I think this also extends metaphorically out to
- 33:37like where where are we now? Where do we stand? We've got we've
- 33:43got nine, even a Gwain in the tower, like, well, fucking
- 33:45what now we're here, We've done the thing and now we're stuck. Where
- 33:49are we now? Right? But I mean in that plot line though?
- 33:52Where though? I mean in that plot line even more the where is mac?
- 33:55Where's Maval? Where Moraine? And where do we stand with one another?
- 34:01Which is why we don't see Matt or Rand until pretty late in the
- 34:05episode. Because the climax is when those questions get answered, right, and
- 34:09we have definitive answers for all of these things by the end, Yeah,
- 34:15pretty much by the climax, and in the climax we have the very definitive
- 34:21Okay, we understand, we have answered the question. The answer is we
- 34:23know where all of them are. We don't know where Pat and Fain is,
- 34:27but yeah we do. He's present in the dark Friends Social at the
- 34:30beginning. Yeah okay, sure, but yeah, all right, so we
- 34:34know he's around. We've had to check it. Sure. Yeah. Oh,
- 34:38and a Taste from Solitude as a title's kind of the hint of the
- 34:43need for them to come back together. They're alone, They're starting off in
- 34:45the stasis of being alone, and we'll need to come back together because alone,
- 34:49as parents says, they're vulnerable. Yes, trouble is, we don't
- 34:52know where they are. So how can we come back together if we don't
- 34:54know where they are? So the a plot, it's going to be the
- 34:58plot typically that takes up the most screen time. It's also usually going to
- 35:01be the plot forwarding plot. Right, How can a plot not be plot
- 35:06forwarding alley when it's more emotional? Ah, yeah, more character driven than
- 35:10you know, ploty. I mean that's not to say that the other plots
- 35:14can't be plotty, it's just that this is the plottiest plot. We went
- 35:16back and forth on a plot B plot, so this one was hard.
- 35:21C plot was pretty clear. There's usual with three very clear. Sometimes there's
- 35:23a secret D plot. Sometimes there's even an easy we'll get to another episode's
- 35:29a secret E plot. The dreaded E plot. I wouldn't call it dreaded.
- 35:34I would only say it would be dreaded as a writer because it's like,
- 35:37that's a lot to fucking juggle. But I would say usually people stick
- 35:42to ABC. I mean, you could even argue there was a D plot
- 35:45in this because we got a ten second shot of Rand, which I did
- 35:49at one point kind of argue, and then I was like, it's more
- 35:52of a like cameo. Yeah, it's more of like I hit there he
- 35:57is and then we go away, which, by the way, is in
- 36:00my opinion, felt like a fun nod to one of the early books in
- 36:04the series that Rand is almost entirely absent from. Yeah, I did think
- 36:07that was fun. Yeah. So the A plot I decided and you decided
- 36:10with me was more rain and land. We timed it. It doesn't always
- 36:15come down to which one has more screen time. It often leans that way,
- 36:20but they both felt very emotional. Both the A and the B plot
- 36:23felt very emotional and very plot for already at the same time. Yeah,
- 36:28so it's hard to pick. So when it came down to brass tacks,
- 36:31there were two things that made me decide this was the A plot. One.
- 36:34It's the first thing we say, yes. That's often a good indicator,
- 36:37often a really good indo counting the cold open now, which, by
- 36:39the way, without giving it away, all three episodes, yes, they
- 36:44have all had cold opens. Yes, there is a different definition from cold
- 36:47open from what you might expect. Oh yeah, I did see people going
- 36:51there's no cold opens anymore. There are no flashback cold opens anymore. But
- 36:55a cold open is anything that happens before the opening credits. It is that
- 37:00simple. Yeah, because we open coldly, which is sort of a hangover
- 37:06from TV time, when you know, you'd be watching network television that is
- 37:10airing, and your show would end, and there might be a commercial,
- 37:15and then the credits would start rolling, and you would be getting up and
- 37:19you'd be putting your chips and salsa away, and then the opening titles to
- 37:24the next show would start playing, at which point you would go, I
- 37:28don't care, and you would turn it off. Whereas instead, if suddenly
- 37:31The Dark Friends Social started playing, you might care. You might go,
- 37:36what the fuck is this cold open? Because it's before the credits. Cold
- 37:39apparently goes back to like when they would shoot them on sound stages with like
- 37:44very little effects or crew. I guess I was reading about this on Wikipedia.
- 37:47Yeah, but it's anything that happens before the title sequence, And even
- 37:52though we got rid of most of the title sequence for this season, there's
- 37:54still the aurboris and it still says wheel of Time yeah, which will take
- 37:58as the title sequence. So the A plot sorry, the A plot by
- 38:04two minutes Lanna warrain, Yes, And it's also the first thing we see.
- 38:07So those are the two points in its favor. But you could make
- 38:09an argument for both the A and B plots being the A plot we went
- 38:14with Lanna mo Rain because it felt more correct, which again is a great
- 38:17I'd love that this happened on the first episode of the second season because this
- 38:22gives us a great thing to point to to go. The rules are not
- 38:24always specifically set in stone, right right, We have some legal room,
- 38:30you know. Sometimes we have to really break it down. It's kind of
- 38:32my favorite thing when people will message me trying to guess what the A plot
- 38:37is of a certain episode. It's so fun. It's really my favorite thing.
- 38:39And I'm like, oh, they're true, They're doing the thing,
- 38:42and even if you're wrong, it's okay. This is this is again not
- 38:45set in stone. These are our opinions. Yeah, B plot. The
- 38:50writers may not even be thinking with these specific terms. Yeah, they may
- 38:53be, but they might not be probably in the back of their mind.
- 38:55Yes, this is just kind of like since Aristotle, oftentime stories will go
- 39:00this way. Yeah, B plot that's usually the more emotionally driven plot,
- 39:05you know, very character momente. By the way, sometimes also a plot
- 39:08B plot, Like it can be the same characters. There's just like different
- 39:12things happening. That can also be a thing. But so B plot is
- 39:15nineyve a gwayn Leandron and little parentheticals and Matt the tower Yeah, the tower
- 39:22group. Uh, sea plot is parent in the Hunt for the Horn.
- 39:24The sea plot is usually kind of like a runner. It's not necessarily something
- 39:28plot forwarding. What's a runner out? I was just about okay, sorry
- 39:32you kept talking. I said, it's kind of like a runner where Like,
- 39:37I mean, if you look at it from a comedy perspective, it's
- 39:39usually going to be like a running gag, right, something you know that's
- 39:44not necessarily plot forwarding, not necessarily super emotional. It's a like third check
- 39:50in that occasionally will happen with a different subplot. Sure, and then you
- 39:54have D plot. I determined there was no D plot this episode because I
- 39:59decided Rand didn't count. It's not enough. Yeah, I'm sorry, it
- 40:01was not enough. It was well, we just got he's okay. Yeah,
- 40:06and he has a lantern and he still wants to feel connected. Something
- 40:09I thought was really clever continuing to talk about the lantern is the connecting thread,
- 40:15because something that you want to do a lot of the time is somehow
- 40:20weave these plots together. Right, That's why we have the plot question.
- 40:22It's like the thing that's kind of weave these plots together and have like kind
- 40:25of a touch base for everything so it doesn't feel like a bunch of random
- 40:29moving parts that don't interact, so you know, the where are they of
- 40:32it all? But also Bell timee s Yes, I love that. Loved
- 40:37that choice. When I was doing my time breakdown, I have you know,
- 40:42scene one is this character, seen two is this character, See three
- 40:45is this character? And then the end of sa Bell Time is like three
- 40:47minutes long because it's all of them. It's great, well maybe not more
- 40:51rain, but it's all the two rivers kids. Yeah, and it's kind
- 40:53of montage. Ask it's a little too long scene wise to be a montage,
- 40:59but like you know, it's montage esque. So yeah, we've got
- 41:05We've got bell Tine as a connecting thread. Freaking loved that decision because it
- 41:08just made everything feel a little tighter in terms of connecting threads, connecting tissue,
- 41:15which is just important for us to feel like there's a point to all
- 41:17of these different components being mushed together. Some people also ask, how is
- 41:22it possible that it's been a full year since season one? I don't know.
- 41:27I honestly don't really care. I know it's been six months. I'm
- 41:30not going to get into the nitty gritty the calendar just because that doesn't well,
- 41:34not it's been six months. But then there was also a month or
- 41:37two in between them going from Karini's death to the White Tower, Right,
- 41:40yeah, there were times. It's we can assume that there were like big
- 41:46swaths of time. Plus it's been six months since they got to the tower.
- 41:52That doesn't necessarily like the travel time would have also been a thing.
- 41:55Sure. The long and the short of it is, when we get to
- 41:59what I'm going to call cinema sinsh like specifics, usually the answer is gonna
- 42:06be I don't really care. It worked for me, it worked for me,
- 42:08and if if, if it didn't for you, I'm sorry, that's
- 42:12okay, especially when it comes to when they're all separate, because the last
- 42:16time they were all really really together was Bell time. Yes, so it
- 42:21being the one year anniversary of when they were all separated has just so much
- 42:24emotional impact that I was like, I don't care about the practicalities because really,
- 42:30to me, the emotions of it were more important than the nitty gritty.
- 42:36All right, Rafe, I want a timeline, yeah, which isn't
- 42:37say you can't have fun constructing that timeline. You can. I just don't
- 42:40know why, you know whatever, I'm just Brandon Sanderson has this thing Reese's
- 42:44Air on the side of Awesome. Yes, I'm I'm going on Era in
- 42:46the side of awesome for this. I you know, yeah, but you
- 42:50know, Brandon Sanderson, you bother to you. Famously. Also, when
- 42:53he started writing the last few Wheel of Time books, the person who was
- 42:57keeping the chronological calendar, the fan calend under gave up because it's impossible to
- 43:02keep track of when things kind of gonna be honest, calendars suck on no
- 43:08one. You know what, if you have a shitty story but a great
- 43:12calendar. No one fucking cares. A couple people might couple people, most
- 43:16people don't. Yeah, but how many times have you talked to a friend
- 43:20about a book and gone, God, the calendar of it all really well
- 43:24done anyway? Anyway, So all right, that brings us to almost an
- 43:29hour in the dark friend's social cold open. This is an opportunity to introduce
- 43:34one of our new obstacles, the forsaken, particularly a shamao, and that
- 43:38this enemy is organized oof so important. When crafting a compelling enemy, we
- 43:45always want to see their strengths. They have to be what we call professionally
- 43:49bad in order for us to buy that they are a palpable threat. Mustache
- 43:53twirling incompetence is not a compelling villain. It just isn't. Not usually,
- 44:00unlike unless it's a comedy, unless it's a comedy or if it's like a
- 44:04swashbuckler film from if it's a Ray Harry Haws a movie. I'm okay with
- 44:08a monster like that. I'm not going to be intrigued by them as much.
- 44:13Right, Okay, here's the thing though, that's a movie. True,
- 44:15it is a two hour thing. True, We're talking about longevity here,
- 44:19we're talking about something that's gonna have to sustain multiple seasons of television.
- 44:22That is compelling. Yes, in a TV show, we have to think
- 44:27about like will this be interesting for three years? That's true. That is
- 44:31a different thing, different thing entirely as opposed to two hours. So yeah,
- 44:37the Little Girl is an opportunity to showcase the indoctrination that goes on that
- 44:42makes us understand why someone would join the bad side so as to humanize them
- 44:45m hm. Thus going back into our good versus evil, Perhaps the evil
- 44:50isn't actually that evil. Perhaps they are humans. Perhaps they are humans making
- 44:53choices. Now we may or may not get definitive answers one way or the
- 44:58other later on. But this guy who calls himself the Father of Lies is
- 45:04certainly making a lot of compelling arguments well, and Dana last season made a
- 45:07lot of compelling arguments as well. She did about how she watches people just
- 45:12continuously suffer all the time. But maybe there's an end to that. You'll
- 45:15remember, we also have the I forget exactly what the term is for it.
- 45:22But Dana effectively betrayed her own ideology because her whole thing was about the
- 45:25good of the many, the good of the many, and then she is
- 45:28so proud of herself for being the one who called the fade. Well,
- 45:30yeah, because at the end of the day, right, the evil's logic
- 45:35still has to be a little flawed. Otherwise we're like, sign me up
- 45:38for the Dark Friends. Yeah, it's there, God free daycare. More
- 45:43than a few pieces of media I've watched where I went like, oh,
- 45:45they had to really kind of stuff something in there at the end. That's
- 45:49like, but also they want a nuke you. Yeah, now they because
- 45:53you can't like them too much, like they support working mothers, sign me
- 45:57up? I think I tweeted out, do they have the why do the
- 46:01Dark Friends have better childcare than the US? And I think I got a
- 46:07lot of how for that? Was I wrong? Did I stutter? So
- 46:10it showcases, though there why the Dark Friends are effective to people like Dana,
- 46:15who doesn't seem like an idiot. Right. Yes, It also serves
- 46:20to show us that there are probably more Dark Friends than we thought, right,
- 46:24and is that where you're going to it might look different than we might
- 46:28look different from how we thought they would look. So by extension, it
- 46:30makes them even scarier. They could be anyone, even people we as a
- 46:36society hold as the most precious mothers and children, especially little girls. Mm
- 46:42hmmm. Also, did we see that this scene takes place in the dream
- 46:45world. Yes, so if you paused and looked at the x ray,
- 46:49which is why this isn't a spoiler. The location is listed as to Lyra
- 46:53and Riod, which if you click on that, it describes as a world
- 46:59of dreams, not necessarily a world that is your dream, but a world
- 47:05that exists of dreams. When you dream, you can touch it, you
- 47:09can enter it, and what happens to you there happens to you in real
- 47:13life, according to the X ray, A dangerous world of dreams. So
- 47:17the first question that we get presented is a shamayel, essentially asking where Rand
- 47:23is and where he might be hiding. They also talk about whether they can
- 47:28turn him. Yeah, I watched with the sub the subtitles on because I
- 47:31always do, and they talk about whether they can turn him to their side.
- 47:37Again, we're showcasing Rand is in the middle and both sides are going
- 47:40to be fighting to keep him. He's the football. He's the football.
- 47:45We see when the little girl crawls under the table, we see a tinker
- 47:47mother and daughter. Of course, a white cloak a chinarn who, theoretically,
- 47:53in this episode eventually dies, could very well be Yeah. Probably that's
- 47:58that's that's a reasonable take it. It's what we are to assume based on
- 48:00the focus on the Yeah, the bird on his outfit. Yea, the
- 48:06bird on his outfit when he's dead. At least one person in armor Pad
- 48:10and Fane of course, Yes, somebody who looks like they're wearing white cloak
- 48:15armor. I said that, Oh, I thought there was a different armored
- 48:16person. No, a person with an isid ee ring. But the ring
- 48:22appears to be black. It's black. Yes, the jewel is not colored
- 48:27per a colorful agi. It is black. Interesting. Someone with wildly long
- 48:31nails, extraordinarily distinct lengthy nails. Yeah, it seems wildly impractical. But
- 48:37go off. A little person m or a child? But I think a
- 48:42child. Yeah, but it seems like the children were under the table.
- 48:45Yes, so either a very mature child or a little person. A woman
- 48:51in red who appears to be upper class. The outfit looks silk as side
- 48:54silk gown. Yeah. I was like, mmm, my one's walking around
- 49:00in the mud. We're in that someone with white gloves and someone with black
- 49:04gloves. I think this is important to pay attention to because and cuffs.
- 49:07The black clove guy had really nice cuffs. Yeah, I think, I
- 49:10woman, I don't know. I think it's important to pay attention to because
- 49:14in the X ray one of the executive producers said, these could be new
- 49:20enemies or enemies we've or like people we've already encountered. So might be important
- 49:24to just keep an eye out for some of these markers and see if maybe
- 49:30we might be able to deduce who some of these other people are. That
- 49:32would be really fun. Cold opens about the standard length of a cold open.
- 49:38We have the opening sequences we've talked about getting cut for time and then
- 49:44I do miss it. I miss it, but I also understand the cut,
- 49:47like if something's gotta go h from this episode, it's the opening sequence.
- 49:52I love the opening titles. Think because we've got a lot of talk
- 49:55abuzz online, I think we need to address it a little bit. It
- 50:00removing them, while I miss them and love them very much, it does
- 50:05keep the flow going directly from the cold open into the episode, and it
- 50:09lets us hold onto that a little more strongly. I think a lot of
- 50:13people also now just hit skip intro by default. I never did on wheeled
- 50:16time, but I would, you know, get up, make popcorn,
- 50:20you go to the bathroom, take the time to pause, whereas I am
- 50:23no longer really doing that during the spinning oroboris. So maybe they'll bring it
- 50:29back. I would be happy either way. I understand why it's gone.
- 50:31So we go to Morain taking her bath. So baths were kind of like
- 50:37a luxury item that Morain really appreciated. An episode in season one we had
- 50:43her at least twice, Yeah, mention or be in a bath. Yeah,
- 50:47I think it was actually three times. I can think of two off
- 50:50the top of my head. Two times she took a bath, one time
- 50:52in episode one and then one when she got to the tower. Two times
- 50:55she took a bath, but one time of belief she mentioned taking a bath.
- 50:58That sounds as a luxury that she enjoys. Yes, and she's in
- 51:01clothes that are literally devoid of her characteristic blue and any color. I hadn't
- 51:07noticed that she blends into with her background. Now that's a great point.
- 51:13She's been sapped of color and by extension, her identity. The labor she
- 51:16now has to endure is super important, right to get that one shot at
- 51:21luxury that she has. It's a callback to how she could easily make the
- 51:24bath in season one warmer and a preempty show of what will be a discussion
- 51:29about Moraine's strength in losing access to her powers, which is going to be
- 51:32like, what are her strengths now? She's going to be important for understanding
- 51:37the stakes of why keeping those powers are important and why it's devastating and maddening
- 51:40for people like low Gain from last season to lose them. Yes, she
- 51:47also, during this luxury this time that she usually spends in luxury, has
- 51:51to also wash her clothes at the same time. Yes, I think that's
- 51:54super important, it's likely to say on all of the works she has to
- 51:58do. Yes, exactly to do both activities now, so something she once
- 52:01luxuriated and has become a chore, further emphasizing what she's lost. The shot
- 52:07in which she puts her hand and the water is identical to the one in
- 52:08the pilot episode of last season, showcasing her loss further. The garment she
- 52:14scrubs is also blue. Oh, so she's laboring to bring that color back
- 52:19that has been stolen fide that's really good as someone that isn't a body that
- 52:22is frequently unwell. This scene really spoke to me. I like that,
- 52:25that's a g I hadn't noticed the clothing. I have watched this episode like
- 52:30five times, Like I'm at a point where I'm like watching what colors they're
- 52:36wearing, I'm watching what the patterns are. I'm watching like are they in
- 52:39a corner that's important? Are they under like an oppressive archway? Like it's
- 52:45a lot. All right. Then we moved to Land doing his sword practice,
- 52:49but not nearly importantly with the same gusto as he had in the previous
- 52:52season with Steppid. Yes, he seems distracted, he seems uh devastating,
- 53:00he seems very upset. He's like near tears, you can't focus. Yeah,
- 53:04he's lost a connection he values, and that loss also results in the
- 53:07mental loss of some of his ability. I think, I think that's very
- 53:12possible. There is, and this is a book parallel we can mention.
- 53:15It's not explicitly been stated, but it's relevant in the books. Warders get
- 53:22bonus stamina, bonus awareness, a little extrajuice, a little extra strength from
- 53:27the bond it's possible that's missing. It's possible he's just despondent, I think
- 53:32regardless. When you saw the connection that those two had in that initial battle,
- 53:40yeah, that battle, when you saw those two together, they were
- 53:44like flowing together. It's a dance. They even specifically, Rosamond and Daniel
- 53:50choreographed it so that, like when he was moving, she was moving,
- 53:53they could do things in tandem. Yeah, and then you compare that too,
- 54:00the kind of discombobulated fight at the end of this episode where people were
- 54:07like, Land's supposed to be this great swordsman. What the heck? What
- 54:10happened? I have things to say about that in the spoiler section. I
- 54:15do it because, without giving too much away, Fades don't fuck around,
- 54:21Well, fads don't fuck around. I think that was important here because again
- 54:23they are professionally bad. Yes, right, we have to have those stakes
- 54:28of how bad these creatures are. Second, fighting trollocks versus fighting face extremely
- 54:32different, extremely different. Also, not only that, but he has lost
- 54:39this connection that like makes him more connected to his fighting partner, Like he's
- 54:45lost it and he's fighting three fades, well two, well he beheads one,
- 54:52but still that's two on one that's pretty impressive. But another thing that's
- 54:59been mentioned I believe by the actors as well, and this this is slightly
- 55:04upsetting parallel is a lot of the emotional beats in landin Warain's storyline so far
- 55:13can be compared to the emotional beats in a story about parents losing a child,
- 55:16which is significant considering that Land thinks they lost Rand, yes, and
- 55:22that their whole mission lost their missions splash their power. Well, and we'll
- 55:25get into the mission of it all when we talk about the color transformation of
- 55:30Morain's outfits. Yes, but Land is also shirtless, which I think is
- 55:36more than just fan service. Yeah, I think it's also to showcase his
- 55:38newfound vulnerability. There are emotional stakes here that will be further explored down the
- 55:43line. Not to mention, how is Morain supposed to help the world being
- 55:45deprived of her power? Can she find other kinds of power? We'll get
- 55:51into that because it's not interesting again watching depressing McGee. Right, if she
- 55:55just sat there and cried about how she's lost her powers, that's not more
- 56:00rain, we know, No, Okay, we get the introduction of Adalias
- 56:04is what they call her in the show, So I'm going to go with
- 56:06that slightly different from how we pronounce it. Whatever and her sister Varin.
- 56:12Have I not been saying all year that I think they might make Varon and
- 56:15Adelia's sisters, Yes, you have, I said it, Okay. Varion
- 56:22is clearly the practical one in muted colors and practical fabrics. Adalius is more
- 56:27lavish in florals and what looks to be silk. Adalius. Oh, Atlius's
- 56:31moved to the left makes us instantly lover. We have to remember how a
- 56:35character, and this is going to be so important a character making us laugh
- 56:39instantly endears them in similar ways to them showing their kindness, yes, or
- 56:44vulnerability. That is true of a couple characters this season, this episode.
- 56:49I mean, I think Adalius and Uno both the writers have gone out of
- 56:53the way to make them funny. I think the writers have gone This is
- 56:59my thing about dramas. I do think they need to have some dose of
- 57:04humor because otherwise again it's depressing McGee. Yeah. Like, I have a
- 57:07hard time with dramas that are just that I need. I need a little
- 57:15a little ha ha in my And that goes back to like Hitchcock, would
- 57:22put laughter before his scares because it made the punch of that scare more compelling.
- 57:28Yeah. You know, our emotions are all very closely tied to one
- 57:31another, and that brings us to the inciting incident, and if you want
- 57:37to find out what that is, you'll have to find out after our ads.
- 57:55Welcome back, Okay, So the inciting incident is now we're in the
- 57:59inciting into it in bail Domon's Arrival. Oh we're back baby, Oh hell
- 58:04yeah, an our end the insetting incident. This is what I'm talking about.
- 58:07Yeah, I so miss this. This is because we're fucking nerds and
- 58:09we want to just nerd out about structure and storytelling. Yeah, give us
- 58:15a microphone and suddenly you'll never hear a shut up. That's true, all
- 58:17right? Since seven hours of that episode eight bail Domon's arrival with a broken
- 58:22quindyard that applies maybe there's more than just a shaw Mael on the loose,
- 58:25some beds going on, something bad's going on. And the poem which introduces
- 58:30an additional question that propels the episode. The fucks in that poem? And
- 58:35what's Marian hiding from land, which is notably again the last thing. He
- 58:38asks her, what are you hiding for me? We're keeping for me whatever
- 58:43it is. I'm going to paraphrase now, I don't remember if he gives
- 58:45I think he just shows her the quendyyar this scene. He talks about it
- 58:49a little bit more later, but we come to learn that this is an
- 58:52unbreakable material that has broken. It's the same thing that that seal was made
- 58:58out of. But this is important because up until now, this inciting incident
- 59:02is also kind of the stasis break. Right, we have a stasis going
- 59:07Moraine and these muted colors. Everything's depressing. She is bummed out. Funny
- 59:10funny at etalias and somber varin right, and then all of a sudden we
- 59:16have a break in that stasis. Suddenly Morain has a mission again. Yes,
- 59:22she's no longer the sad sack in the bath. Yes, this is
- 59:24uh. She's had twenty visitors fifty variance has a large number of visitors right,
- 59:30Land has been kept in the dark about them. And then this guy
- 59:34seemingly brings something that is actually of use. Yes, this has given her
- 59:38a direction to go in. It's bail domon. This is important so and
- 59:44that reflects in the fact that oh, that's our dog, we belwobbling,
- 59:50and that reflects and the fact that after that Morain gets blue again. Oh
- 59:53she does, doesn't she. Yeah, she starts to slowly get more and
- 59:58more blue. She's brush to Lan. A lot of people brought this up.
- 1:00:01She's trying to push him away. Yeah, likely, And they say
- 1:00:06this in the X Rays Well, likely because she can't protect him anymore the
- 1:00:08way she needs to, and so she's trying to save his life. And
- 1:00:12I want to point out this is a very close parallel to the way that
- 1:00:16Rand is behaving at this point in Book two. The first maybe hundred pages
- 1:00:22of The Great Hunt. Things have were markedly different at the end of season
- 1:00:27one from the end of book one for a lot of reasons that you can
- 1:00:30listen back to about our old episodes about. But essentially Book two kind of
- 1:00:35starts with a lot of Rand pushing people away. Well, he's doing it
- 1:00:37still, he's pretending he's dead. That's the ultimate push you. Yes,
- 1:00:42I'm gonna say, And in season two he has succeeded. Yeah, but
- 1:00:45he's pushing people away to keep them safe. And I think you are right,
- 1:00:50and I want to echo this that Mauurain is pushing Land away in no
- 1:00:54small part to keep him safe and also because she feels like she has failed
- 1:01:00she is probably not worthy of him right, beating herself up for sure.
- 1:01:05Yeah. Yeah, she's trying to save them, and I think it's a
- 1:01:07fun reversal, and the whole man wants to protect woman, so he pushes
- 1:01:10her away. Troe. Yes, I also love that they're exploring how hard
- 1:01:15this is on both of them, giving us a great look at how a
- 1:01:19traumatic event affects more than just the person going through it. It affects the
- 1:01:22people they love. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, because you know, Land
- 1:01:25is now in a position where he cannot help her with this thing. No,
- 1:01:29he just has to bear witness to her suffering, which is which you
- 1:01:31know, obviously the suffering is harder, but that is in and of itself
- 1:01:37really hard. Which also I ask the people around when you are suffering,
- 1:01:42how often do you also push away the people you love the most? Tends
- 1:01:46to happen, or try to isolate yourself from those people to spare them your
- 1:01:51suffering. It happens a lot. To me. This is very realistic of
- 1:01:54someone who is as hyper independent as Morain. Yeah, but that doesn't mean
- 1:01:59she's just sitting around feeling sorry for herself and just being mean to Land for
- 1:02:01no reason. It's motivated. She's trying to get him to leave her because
- 1:02:06she wants to protect him and keep him safe, and she just she's not
- 1:02:09going to be able to boom pow zap things the way she used to be.
- 1:02:14Right. So then we get to Agwayne at the Tower. She's working
- 1:02:16hard but hardly working. No, she's working hard and ninety is hardly working,
- 1:02:21but she's being treated like a nobody, setting her up for a very
- 1:02:22relatable conflict with nine Eve that was already starting to get set up in season
- 1:02:27one when she hears nine Eve is the most powerful channel earned a thousand years
- 1:02:30in Swan's office and stares at nine Eve. Right, yes, that's the
- 1:02:34initial seed. Agwayne is not a nobody at the Two Rivers. She is
- 1:02:38the daughter the innkeeper, right like we see her in the beginning. She
- 1:02:44goes through this you know, womanhood ceremony and everyone's congratulating her. It's like
- 1:02:49she has the sweet sixteen that everyone goes to. Yes, right, she
- 1:02:52is. She's well known and the love in the community whose parents can afford
- 1:02:57to throw a hell of a sweet sixteen. Yes, so being treated like
- 1:03:01nobody at the and she was not only that, not only that, she
- 1:03:05was going to be the wis stuff at some village eventually. Right, So
- 1:03:08she's not nobody back home. She has a smaller fish in a much bigger
- 1:03:14pond. Now, yes, right, but nine Eve is not nine Eve
- 1:03:17is big deal. Nine Eve is huge deal. So this is as rough
- 1:03:22a transition for a Gwaine as it is for nine Eves. Agwayne's whole thing
- 1:03:25in the books is that she's someone who tries very hard and occasionally gets overlooked
- 1:03:29or overtaken despite working hard. It's a very relatable issue for a lot of
- 1:03:32people and starts to ground her ambition in emotional stakes. Extreme uh extreme,
- 1:03:38they're extreme close up. So that's when the camera's super close to something.
- 1:03:43Yeah, there's really big close ups on her tasks, like the bucket,
- 1:03:46Yeah, which showcases the oppressive nature of the tasks. Right, it's so
- 1:03:52there, Right, it's a but then when you focus on a GWayne,
- 1:03:59it's like these eider frame shots and these big hallways, vaunted towers, vaunted
- 1:04:03hallways. Yeah, to establish how small Agwaine feels in her surroundings. Yes,
- 1:04:09a real emphasis on how big the tower is and how small Agwaine is
- 1:04:12within it. That is furthered by Madeline Patten's incredible acting and use of posture.
- 1:04:16Yes. And this is also when we get the scene where she walks
- 1:04:21in on Alana and her warders right, yeah, I was just about to
- 1:04:26get there. Yeah, what do you have to say about Well? I
- 1:04:28think it showcases again that she is essentially that. And the scene where Leana
- 1:04:31just throws a cup in her Leana, if I said, Alania, she
- 1:04:38really is a keeper. These both serve to showcase how she's essentially furniture.
- 1:04:43Yeah, she's nobody. Why should they worry about her? She's essentially like
- 1:04:47a pledge and a sorority. Yeah, And she and Nineyve have this lovely
- 1:04:53conversation because nine Eve is not having it. Yes, so transition for all
- 1:04:59of them. And Wwayne is the one who says everybody had to do this,
- 1:05:01right, This is wayn who says that because all of the ice that
- 1:05:04I had to do this, even the omberlind seat in ninety's like I'm twenty
- 1:05:08five, I'm too old to go through some kind of pledge thing. My
- 1:05:11brain is fully developed. Okay. We also get that great scene where she's
- 1:05:15cleaning the Omberlin's room and she looks at her robes and it's like, that's
- 1:05:17so cool. What a cute little dorc. Yeah. Yeah, so Alana's
- 1:05:21in bed with Maxim and Ivan. First of all, gay positive depictions of
- 1:05:26polyamory. Yeah, they're very good. Second, lol, so funny bit
- 1:05:30off. Third, again setting up yep A Gwain's invisibility and feelings for nine,
- 1:05:34even also setting up her relationship with Alana and further establishing the relationship between
- 1:05:39Alana and her warders, which is going to be kind of important considering that
- 1:05:44the relationship between and isid Ee and her warder is really impacted in the A
- 1:05:49plot. Yeah. Relevant, but yeah, they're playful together. We love
- 1:05:55a romance that is playful. So we've got more and more obstacle. Yes,
- 1:06:00the Novices are in white, which people were worried about not being true,
- 1:06:04and they're watching the warder's spar just like in the books. So the
- 1:06:08novices being in white has not been changed, but we are adding the practicality
- 1:06:12of them not wanting to go through a tub of chlorox every day, which
- 1:06:15I think is really smart, because frankly, that would take me out.
- 1:06:19It'd be a lot all right in the kitchen, I potentially spy Elsie grinwell
- 1:06:25as a blonde. They named her Novice one. There's time. I know,
- 1:06:30Agwain and nine Eve talk about how frustrated nine Eve is and Awaine says,
- 1:06:33it's building character, and nine Eve says an incredible line, I have
- 1:06:38enough character, very clever, very very ninety thing to say a great explanation
- 1:06:43of how the magic system works. The show gave us a slow exposure to
- 1:06:45the magic system to make it easier on first timers. Ooh, I loved
- 1:06:49Agwayne's I didn't come here for easy. And I want to point out by
- 1:06:53the way that this was something that we discussed extensively, as probably gonna be
- 1:06:58when they're in the Tower in season two, that we get into the sub
- 1:07:01categorizations of the power, We get into what the threads are, we get
- 1:07:06the mechanics more in detail. There are still mechanics we haven't heard explicitly within
- 1:07:11the bounds of the show. Let it cook. I mean, I expect
- 1:07:14it will come out in time. I feel that they pick thanks will also
- 1:07:18change. I also said it's going to be in a lesson to the novices?
- 1:07:23Did I not say it? Did say that? Because you know why?
- 1:07:26I knew that? Why Because it is easiest to explain something new to
- 1:07:30an audience. This is just a trick. You always want someone who is
- 1:07:36as new to something as an audience member. That's why it's like someone's first
- 1:07:41day on the job and they're explaining how the rules work, or someone's first
- 1:07:44day in the oppression of regime. This is why iced Tea always asks the
- 1:07:47questions. Yes, in some shows, that's for you, that's for you.
- 1:07:51Oh yeah, we could talk about it. So yeah, we always
- 1:07:57need someone who's on the audience's level in terms of underst standing. Who better
- 1:08:01to be a novice in the situation than the novices themselves? Because yeah,
- 1:08:06it's it's literally called like you're supposed to have a novice. Yeah, so
- 1:08:12why not use the novice, the literal novices. It just makes it easier.
- 1:08:15It makes it easier when you have one dummy, not too dumb,
- 1:08:18because then the audience will get ahead of that character. But someone who will
- 1:08:21be at the audience's level. So yeah, agwain going, I didn't come
- 1:08:27here for easy again. We're getting at that hard working, ambitious character that
- 1:08:31is immediately juxtaposed by Ninive's attitude. Right. Alta's description of the power is
- 1:08:38straight out of the books and also very appropriately for her quite sexual Yeah,
- 1:08:44Nineive drinks the water rather than having to potentially channel. I freaking loved this.
- 1:08:48Now. Some people felt that this was really out of line of her
- 1:08:51character. I disagree. Really. Some people said she would never have given
- 1:08:55up, she would never have stopped trying, et cetera, et cetera.
- 1:08:58I don't know that I agree with that. I didn't consider it to be
- 1:09:00giving up. Here's my interpretation. Ninive is not someone who likes to fail
- 1:09:06in front of people that she shouldn't be failing in front of Yes, she's
- 1:09:10gonna look at a Gwaine especially, is someone that she is like I am
- 1:09:15her mentor so failing in front of a GWayne when a Gwayne's here, super
- 1:09:19channeler girl being like I didn't come here for easy, so I'm gonna channel
- 1:09:23without my hands. Right, Nine's not gonna want to fail in front of
- 1:09:27her. That's humiliating. She's twenty five years old, She's older than all
- 1:09:31these girls that would be so embarrassing for her. She's she was the big
- 1:09:34fish in the teen seat. That's she was the biggest fish. Anyone who's
- 1:09:40tried to learn something as an adult knows how much vulnerability that takes. Not
- 1:09:45to mention also, the last time she really got to channel, she almost
- 1:09:48died. Yes, and notably has not channeled sense and can only channel when
- 1:09:55she's angry or afraid. It seems like something like that. So when she's
- 1:09:58experiencing an extreme so to me, it's not that she gave up now,
- 1:10:03it's that she's a miasma of feelings right now, and she found she's still
- 1:10:08accomplished the specific task. The specific task was you're gonna drink the water?
- 1:10:14She said, Okay, fuck you, i'lo break the water, like if
- 1:10:15Sun Booi back home, right, using an example for the book from the
- 1:10:18books went up to nine Eve, it was like, this is what you're
- 1:10:21gonna do. Night Eve would be like, go fuck yourself, I'm going
- 1:10:25to break a broom over your head. Yeah. So, honestly, Alana's
- 1:10:28just lucky that Ninive didn't break that glass over her head attacking people. Yeah,
- 1:10:31yeah, I enjoyed it. I like it. But ninety was once
- 1:10:35someone people respected and came to for guidance, but now she's completely starting over
- 1:10:40and it's humiliating. And Alana is bringing extra special attention to her, and
- 1:10:45everyone is paying extra special attention to her, and she's fucking it up.
- 1:10:48That's a lot of pressure, a lot of stress. Alana also, during
- 1:10:53this, which might also be why ninety've had a bad reaction to her,
- 1:10:59brought up ninety five trauma in Faldara during the scene to provide us with an
- 1:11:02explanation on why she might be struggling so hard. Yes, and I really
- 1:11:08like that they did this, by the way, because I know we get
- 1:11:11hints that prior to Faldara, she's been having trouble channeling, right, we
- 1:11:15get the whole I haven't been able to listen to the wind, et cetera,
- 1:11:19et cetera, but it seems like seeing what can be done with the
- 1:11:24power, what Ama Lisa did using their power has really really scared her,
- 1:11:31really deeply deeply frightened her of using it at all. And that makes sense.
- 1:11:36I would be scared too. Listen, there was a spider. I'm
- 1:11:41I'm healing my relationship with spiders right now. But I was in the car
- 1:11:45today, and I guess a spider had somehow gotten into my car and made
- 1:11:51a web on my front seat that I didn't notice un till I sat down,
- 1:11:56and then I found it, the spider crawling all over over my legs,
- 1:12:00and I just panicked and slapped myself a billion times and ran out of
- 1:12:04the car screaming. So I'm still working on you know, when a spider
- 1:12:09touches me. But I can be like in a room with one and be
- 1:12:12like, look at you be in there, So that's you know, progress.
- 1:12:16I also couldn't help but feel like the scene was very reminiscent of a
- 1:12:19lot of like military training moments. Yeah, you mentioned where the drill sergeant
- 1:12:23states like, no one is leaving until you accomplish this huge task, right,
- 1:12:27and we see that like we're not going to give up. I think
- 1:12:29we've been conditioned to believe that the protagonists in that situation will be like you
- 1:12:33know, officer duty hops and Zootopia where she's like, I don't know how
- 1:12:38to quit. Let it is, I'm going to it. But it feels
- 1:12:41fitting both to Robert Jordan's military background and that Alana is part of the military
- 1:12:45branch of the iside, Oh my god. Yeah, we expect ninety,
- 1:12:47based on pasth stories, to do everything she can to meet the expectations,
- 1:12:50making it hysterical when she doesn't. Yes, right, because this is Rafe
- 1:12:55going, oh my, I have a download, Rafe, and of course
- 1:12:59the right going, I have a download in my head of like what our
- 1:13:02expectations would be for a scene like this. I'm going to subvert it.
- 1:13:05That's knowing the rules and breaking it. Yes, so we have the meeting
- 1:13:10of the teachers, the staff meeting after that, Yes, and we find
- 1:13:15out that like a Leandro immediately is like, oh, maybe she doesn't have
- 1:13:19a good enough teacher. If only there was a woman in red. She's
- 1:13:25so snirky, and and they're all like, you can't teach a novice because
- 1:13:31last time you did, a novice dieild one, which makes it so that
- 1:13:36raises the stakes for when she does ultimately win in this situation and gets to
- 1:13:42go talk to nine Eve and goes whoever died from a little talk? Look,
- 1:13:45I've seen the first episode of Battlestar Galactica. Talks can be very harmful.
- 1:13:51There's a discussion also of Logane and a channeler who may be even stronger.
- 1:13:59Another alls dragon, which is kind of alarming considering how distractive Logane was.
- 1:14:03Yes, so, and they talk about this in the vein of Hey,
- 1:14:06y'all, the last battle's fucking coming. We should probably make sure that
- 1:14:11Nuke Girl is ready, and so they decide for some reason to let Leandrin
- 1:14:16talk to her. They want to get Nuke Girl ready. I want to
- 1:14:18get Gerriam read the Mistress of Novices goes well is worth the try. Yeah,
- 1:14:24a lot of Leandre in this episode, really enjoying that. I love
- 1:14:27Kate Fleetwood, so I'm not complaining. Paren writes a letter to Agwayne and
- 1:14:30nine Eves, saying that they're all he has now, reminding us Rand is
- 1:14:33dead, Matt is m i a but even settler, reminding us that Leila
- 1:14:36is dead, very sad. Loyle mentions that Inktar hired something called a sniffer.
- 1:14:43Uno talks shit about the tracker's signal fires. Yeah, he also mentioned
- 1:14:47smelling pad and fine as parent is listening, setting up UNO's comedic relief in
- 1:14:53this moment. Yes is making him funny interact Yeah, super silly where he's
- 1:14:59like taking the press whatever it is. Remember when I said how comedic moments
- 1:15:04have a lot of power over an audience. We love someone who is funny
- 1:15:08because it makes them feel like they're are friends. Yes, now, you
- 1:15:12had a qualm with something that you felt could have been better addressed from the
- 1:15:17end of last season that I feel like this is the right time to bring
- 1:15:20it up. I did think, and I'm still thinking that we might have
- 1:15:26a discussion about this, just not yet, but loyal and loyal that's stabbed.
- 1:15:32Yes, I just feel like potentially we may have wanted to address that,
- 1:15:39But yes, I don't necessarily think that we won't. Yes, now,
- 1:15:43I will also pause it. It's been six months, right, so
- 1:15:46it hasn't come up. Yeah, there hasn't been an organic way to bring
- 1:15:49it up. Yeah, and I'll talk in the spoilers section about when I
- 1:15:54think we might be able to have a more organic discussion about it. Do
- 1:15:58we want to mention now now why we as book readers expected this to be
- 1:16:02more significant? No, it's book spoilers. Okay, we'll talk about that
- 1:16:05in the book section. And then we get to the point of no return.
- 1:16:09So this is a we can't go back from where we are right now.
- 1:16:13This is like a moment that sets everything kind of in motion. We
- 1:16:15meet a guy named Elias with golden eyes like paren. He reveals the signal
- 1:16:20fire isn't his and leads him to dead Tinkers who were attacked by Fane's men.
- 1:16:26Parent's relationship with violence is further explored as the people he was vibing with
- 1:16:29last season show him the consequences of sticking to pure nonviolence. Yes, probably
- 1:16:33death. Probably death. Although the girl got away right, yeah, because
- 1:16:39it kind of looked like everyone else fell on the sword. Yeah, for
- 1:16:42her, including a dog. You you went out of your way to check
- 1:16:45this is not the same girl. I slowed it down to make sure I
- 1:16:49double check, triple check. She's not the same kid from the cold open
- 1:16:53from the Cold Open, No different Tinker girl, which I kind of which
- 1:16:57I like because to me, it's showcases one like like what happens when you're
- 1:17:03on either side, Like, if you're on the good side, quote unquote,
- 1:17:09you get killed, your family gets killed, everyone dies. So perhaps
- 1:17:13there's a reason why a Tinker might want to be a dark friend. We
- 1:17:16also get a parent has this sort of like flash back thing where he watches
- 1:17:26there's a howl of a wolf and then he sees the attacks sort of happen.
- 1:17:30Yeah, and then when it closes, he's locked eyes with Elias,
- 1:17:33so, which I think goes back to your question really quickly, Eliza's introduced
- 1:17:39to someone potentially menacing. Yeah. Right, he's a little stoic, he's
- 1:17:45not funny, so he's not endearing himself to us. He's not vulnerable,
- 1:17:47so he's not endearing himself to us. And he shows no points of kindness,
- 1:17:51so he's not endearing himself to us. Those are the three big things
- 1:17:54we need to endure someone to us. So we're kind of like unsure of
- 1:17:58where. But he also hasn't like, you know, kicked to puppy,
- 1:18:00So we're not really sure where we stand with Elias. And I think that's
- 1:18:03on purpose because we're not really sure where we stand with Parents' powers. Either
- 1:18:06are they good or bad? We don't know. But this is the point,
- 1:18:11the point of no return right of this episode. We can't leave what
- 1:18:15we're doing and just get back together because if we abandon what we're doing,
- 1:18:18people will die, right, parents seeing that if he just lets Pat and
- 1:18:23Fane go, people will die. Yes, And that's going to be a
- 1:18:28thread that's true for every single person. If they let people go and go
- 1:18:31like, actually, I'm going to be selfish and get back with my friends,
- 1:18:34it could result in a lot of shit. Parent appears to be able
- 1:18:38to see into the past is the Tinker massacre, and Elias seems to have
- 1:18:42At the Tinker masaker, and Elia seems to have the same ability, they
- 1:18:45reveal that it looks like a child escaped the slaughter. I really like this
- 1:18:50Choices isn't quite how these skills manifest in the books. I don't think it's
- 1:18:55a spoiler to say. I think direct comparison, but like, we have
- 1:18:59not yet perfect the art of smell avision, and so I'm going to say
- 1:19:04that this is as good as because I was racking my brain. I was
- 1:19:09like, how are they going to accomplish that without it looking like pepe la
- 1:19:12pew. Yeah, because in the book, one of the things that Paren
- 1:19:16has going on is that he has an incredibly strong sense of smell, which
- 1:19:21they kind of get at. But I think here's my read on it.
- 1:19:26So like I have been reading and he can also like smell things that have
- 1:19:30happened. Yeah, I have been reading this book called An Immense World by
- 1:19:33Ed Young. Yes, Ed young, which is all about how animals perceive
- 1:19:39our world in and how kind of the sensory sciences have been really kind of
- 1:19:43blown up of late because we stopped looking at animals and their senses from a
- 1:19:49human lens and we started looking at them from a purely like place of study,
- 1:19:55not like how do we compare them to how humans can do things?
- 1:19:58It's like, how do animals just person see of our world in a way
- 1:20:00where we're not comparing or contrasting them to human beings? Yeah, which is
- 1:20:03looking at it as it is, And we're learning a lot of new shit
- 1:20:08from that, from just taking ourselves out of the equation, not worrying about
- 1:20:12us so much. So one of the things that they've learned about dogs is
- 1:20:16dogs and wolves by extension, have such a keen sense of smell. They
- 1:20:20can smell into the past. How do you mean? So they literally through
- 1:20:27their ability to smell the waves that their nostrils are made up, the way
- 1:20:32that they're kind of like apostrophe almost when they're breathing out, they're still breathing
- 1:20:38in. They're still smelling. Yeah, they can smell. That's why when
- 1:20:42they kind of go like like they're smelling both ways. And what they can
- 1:20:47do is they can understand what has happened there before, right, and they
- 1:20:53can tell time based on how much your scent has faded. Right. That's
- 1:20:59fucking crazy. So this is sort of a representation of what would happen if
- 1:21:03you took that degree of sensory awareness and combined it with the cognitive rational you
- 1:21:11know, puzzle solving brain of a human essentially. Yeah, And my thing
- 1:21:14is is it's different than men's ability because one, at the beginning, you
- 1:21:17always hear a wolf howling so far, yeah, that did happen, all
- 1:21:21right, And men's viewings from last season are super shiny, right have you
- 1:21:29noticed that they're like super shiny. Parents are kind of shiny, But parents
- 1:21:32are like moving faded sure, right, Like they're like kind of like like
- 1:21:38there's like a weird frame rate to them. Sure, almost, Yeah,
- 1:21:42does that make sense. They're all kind of choppy as it moves. They're
- 1:21:45also explicit things that have already happened, whereas men's are what is going like
- 1:21:49metaphors or explicit things that are going to happen. Right, So parent can
- 1:21:54smell the past essentially like a dog. Yeah, he sees it. Yeah,
- 1:21:58And his eyes get gold and as I get gold, and that doesn't
- 1:22:01happen to men. So they have different abilities essentially, Yes, we should
- 1:22:05probably take a quick second before we dive ahead. Speaking of abilities, here's
- 1:22:11your ability to listen to ed Welcome back, All right, let's die back
- 1:22:30in oh so oh. I also said the child is a different child than
- 1:22:35the one we saw earlier, but that serves to showcase the potential consequence of
- 1:22:39ending up on the wrong side of the dichotomy good and evil. We will
- 1:22:42instantly side against the Shinoran man who killed a dog and tried to go after
- 1:22:45a little girl. Yeah, that's those are all the shitty things to do.
- 1:22:48Both are big no nose in the villain canon. It's literally the two
- 1:22:53worst kick the dog moments you can do. It's bad. Yeah, we
- 1:22:57love our dogs, we love our children. Story tell So now we learn
- 1:23:01new things that kind of ramp shit up to the climax, Bail Dummon comes
- 1:23:05to talk to Moraine and shows her quendiar that's broken, just like in the
- 1:23:08eye of the world, indicating the other forsaken are loose in the world.
- 1:23:11And if you're looking for the specific instance of what gives us this piece of
- 1:23:15information is Shamael in the cold open says he let me out at the eye
- 1:23:19of the world. He released me from my prison. So it stands to
- 1:23:21reason that rand cracking that seal let issue out. Yeah, so if there's
- 1:23:27another seal somewhere that is broken, and we already know there are eight forsaken,
- 1:23:30at least at least from the stands to reason that maybe another one's out.
- 1:23:34We also really haven't talk about what a forsaken is. Is. She
- 1:23:38mentions Ishue we call him ishi colloquially is Shameel mentions that he is called forsaken.
- 1:23:45We will get more information about this as we go on. You can
- 1:23:48stand to assume right now, well, he's one, so it's probably bad,
- 1:23:53probably bad. Now this this what is this thing? He's got a
- 1:23:57piece of quendiar from a moon die moon? What is a moon dial?
- 1:24:01I assume it's like a sun dial, But like how you would a real
- 1:24:05time at night? I don't know, because now I'm just really curious.
- 1:24:09Would it be how you tell time at night? I mean I would assume
- 1:24:12that if it's yea, yeah, he would absolutely need a way to tell
- 1:24:15the time at night, right, mm hmm. Moon dial Holse, do
- 1:24:19you know when to put the kids to bed? At this first story turn,
- 1:24:25it's set up to look like repeat information since we know this about quendi
- 1:24:28Are, but we also have to remind the people who haven't watched in a
- 1:24:30season. But then the poem is presented, which is the new information propelling
- 1:24:35us to the midpoint. Land and Thomas talk about how the bond between himself
- 1:24:39and Moraine has impacted him. I loved Tomas's line, you don't seem like
- 1:24:44a man who minds silence to Land. Yeah, just they understand these characters,
- 1:24:50you know, they really do. Land mentions that Moraine wants him to
- 1:24:55leave, but he won't. Though he's technically free and encouraged to even be
- 1:24:58with dine Eve, his loyalty, loyalty to his oath is as strong as
- 1:25:02the bond itself. He's not someone who will turn his back on something just
- 1:25:06because it's difficult. Domon haggles with Morain over the quendiar and a poem written
- 1:25:11in blood, which is always a good sign, very dramatic. When something
- 1:25:15is written in blood, you can take that to the bank. Always good.
- 1:25:17You should definitely pursue it. We learned to haggle. He learned to
- 1:25:23haggle from someone called the sea folk, yes, some other culture. He
- 1:25:29also mentions that some cloaked men have been following him thinking that they're from Morain.
- 1:25:32Hilarious moment between himself and Morain where she takes the poem The sea Folk
- 1:25:38may be good at the game master Domon, but the Isidie invented it.
- 1:25:41Morain still has powers even if it's not magic. And she's wearing blue again,
- 1:25:45isn't she She's down but she's not defeated. Is part of the Could
- 1:25:48part of this be that she's keeping up appearances with Domon and the blue could
- 1:25:53be, But also the fact that she now has this new mission I think
- 1:25:58brings out this sassy spark that we haven't seen in a second. I'd buy
- 1:26:01that. But also just her powers of negotiation showcase that she has powers still
- 1:26:06at her disposal, even if they're not magic. Yeah, she's not like
- 1:26:12this useless waif now She's still got it. It's just not all of it.
- 1:26:16She's and like I said, she's down but not defeated. That's important.
- 1:26:19We need to believe Morain can still win and that she still got abilities.
- 1:26:24Otherwise it's too much despair and not enough hope. Yep. Balance.
- 1:26:29Then we have ninety sword fighting with the warders, answering that really big question
- 1:26:32from the Oh Yeah. There was much consternation about this ten second clip before
- 1:26:40the season came. People were worried that I don't even I'm not going to
- 1:26:43get into it. Essentially, I like this scene this without getting too specific,
- 1:26:48this parallels a lot of moments in the books where channelers discuss how it
- 1:26:54may or may not be useful to also no sword play, and we get
- 1:26:58a wonderful rebuttal in a moment from Leandrin where she says, who the fuck
- 1:27:01needs it? Look what I can do? Yeah. I also think that
- 1:27:04it makes sense that when Ninive is missing the person that she's kind of grown
- 1:27:12into, like she really likes Land, she's going to hang out with his
- 1:27:15friends. Yes, she doesn't have any friends at the White Tower. I'm
- 1:27:18assuming that if Agwayne resents nine Eve, Ninive hasn't necessarily endeared herself to anyone
- 1:27:24else with her antics. Probably not, I imagine she doesn't have a ton
- 1:27:28of friends, but it looks like she has a great rapport with Maximum Ivon,
- 1:27:31so why would she not go hang out with them. Yeah, makes
- 1:27:33a lot of sense. Also, sword fighting is a great way to get
- 1:27:38across power dynamics, yes, and verbal spa like externalizing verbal sparring, because
- 1:27:44having someone in a room and talking is a lot less interesting than having some
- 1:27:47people play with swords. Yeah, and that would of course be what the
- 1:27:50warders would want to do as a hangout activity. It's we've seen that from
- 1:27:55last season with Lan and Steppin. They hang out and play swords together.
- 1:27:59That's what they love, kind of their whole thing. They're just ken anyway.
- 1:28:03Their job is soored. But it showcases that she's still got a connection
- 1:28:08to Lane even when he's not there, and she feels that she can be
- 1:28:10vulnerable with his warder friends in a way that she can never be with her
- 1:28:14best friend, a GWayne, because she sees herself as a Gwayne's mentor,
- 1:28:17whereas with them she's more of an equal or even a pupil. She's even
- 1:28:20comfortable enough to let herself be taught. She's also not afraid to fail in
- 1:28:25front of them while sword fighting, because they've earned her trust in a way
- 1:28:27that the others haven't. When she fails in front of them, she laughs
- 1:28:30about it, She laughs it off. It doesn't matter to her, even
- 1:28:32though she's a healer. She puts herself in the vulnerable position of learning something
- 1:28:36new as an adult and potentially doing something that she might fear because of that.
- 1:28:40Dressed right like a healer who is picking up a weapon, that's a
- 1:28:45big deal, big time. This level of finding trust with someone and ultimately
- 1:28:48herself may be the key to breaking her block. Lane is uber present in
- 1:28:53this scene, even though he isn't mentioned, because the foundation of this friendship
- 1:28:56was formed through him and is likely why they're looking out for her so much.
- 1:29:00Maxim also displays his loyalty in connection with Alana that is above his friendship
- 1:29:02with nine Eve, even though they appear to be close, by correcting nine
- 1:29:05even demanding she show a lot of the proper respect. That's Alana Sadai to
- 1:29:10you loved that, giving even more context to the landa Morain relationship. It's
- 1:29:15above friendship, which they said last season. It's above friendship. It's above
- 1:29:19like parent child even Yeah, it's closer than husband and wife. Yeah yeah,
- 1:29:26but we get a little show not tell of that, all right,
- 1:29:29we got on that scene, I think. So it's a good scene,
- 1:29:32we is the next thing Leandren. No, it's a GWayne knocking on Alana.
- 1:29:38Oh yeah, let's talk about that. Okay. So GWayne knocks on
- 1:29:42Alana's door and says the best line. She says, are you decent?
- 1:29:46What she says, do you need a moment? Incorredible? Being funny and
- 1:29:51then by extension, as we know about people being funny, endearing us to
- 1:29:56her. Alana once again is sitting there eating a fruit associated with womanhood and
- 1:30:00sensuality. Loves her fruits, the pomegranate. It's always fruit that's sexy.
- 1:30:04It is always fruit that's sexy. It's pomegranates, figs. I'm just saying
- 1:30:10she's not She's never deep throating a banana. It's always like a woman fruit.
- 1:30:15She offers it to a GWayne, but Agwayne is not ready to receive
- 1:30:17that she's not on that she's not on that track. Also, it's gonna
- 1:30:20always call in like persephone, all kinds of shit. Yeah, even the
- 1:30:26fruit she's eating is purposely giving us insight into her character. Agwayne tries to
- 1:30:30mimic how Alana is sitting, which showcase how much she tries to be like
- 1:30:35the mentor she has which go ahead? Sorry, which what you first?
- 1:30:41I know you're gonna say go ahead? Making her lack of a braid really
- 1:30:44telling about her changing dynamic with ninety. Could that possibly raise the steaks for
- 1:30:49ninety failing in front of a GWayne a little bit? If she feels a
- 1:30:53Gwaine pulling away from her as a mentor. It is such a blaze,
- 1:30:56such a subtle detail that is a little it's less explicit than it is in
- 1:31:00the books. Is that her hair and braided. And we got that scene
- 1:31:04in episode one where and see in uh yeah in season one where nine Eve
- 1:31:11talks about the braid and talks about what the braid indicates and talks about what
- 1:31:15the braid represents and Agwayne left home and now she's like, eh, yeah,
- 1:31:20Alana misunderstands the what Agwaine is asking for and gives advice on handling multiple
- 1:31:26partners. Oh and can I also just just say that this is also going
- 1:31:30to make it make that tension between Agwaine and nine Eve even stronger. Yeah,
- 1:31:35that that tension about sort of, which is very I think in tune
- 1:31:40with Agwaine's character of sort of I am working my fucking ass off here you're
- 1:31:45not right. Can I have a little fucking recognition exactly? Alana gives a
- 1:31:49GWayne advice in handling multiple partners, though if you listen, the blooming metaphor
- 1:31:54isn't unlike what she tried to tell Nineve about channeling. No, it's it's
- 1:31:57really well constructed this bit, because for about two thirds of it you can
- 1:32:01go, um trama, which where are we going here? She don't know.
- 1:32:10Sense I also appreciated that Alana was not embarrassed at the misunderstanding sexuality isn't
- 1:32:15embarrassing to her because she's a grown ass woman. Yes, and nor should
- 1:32:18it be to an adult woman. But most comedies would have it be an
- 1:32:21embarrassing thing, right, Most things would have it be like, oh my
- 1:32:25god, I'm so sorry. Now. The one thing I will say is
- 1:32:30Alana is a little she disregards Agwayne's comfort level with the situation. Hmm,
- 1:32:36yeah right. I just think it is an important note to mention for her
- 1:32:42character that she is very comfortable where she is comfortable. She's also comfortable with
- 1:32:46others discomfort. Yes, yeah, interesting stuff. Yes, uh well,
- 1:32:53sorry my notes scrolled up for some reason. But I did just love her.
- 1:32:57Oh it was really fucking funny. I also really loved the line,
- 1:33:00remember things are messy before they are perfect. Nothing worthwhile is neat and tidy.
- 1:33:05Just snap that on a Gwayn's forehead, you know. Yeah, Then
- 1:33:08we gets the midpoint of the episode ninety of trying to practice alone, showcasing
- 1:33:13once again her fear of public failure. She doesn't give up, right,
- 1:33:17she does practice, She does try. She just doesn't want to humiliate herself
- 1:33:23by failing over and over again. But she does try. Yes, and
- 1:33:27then what There is a scene, there are a few scenes in one of
- 1:33:30the books where while while Nineve is trying to break through this block she has,
- 1:33:34she's doing these ridiculous tasks to try to break the block. She's getting
- 1:33:40drunk, she's staying up all night. But these things are done generally either
- 1:33:44one to one with a teacher or alone, which I think is the biggest
- 1:33:47differentiator there. Yeah, not in the kitchen, but doing it in front
- 1:33:51of everybody is way higher stakes, you know what I mean? Yes,
- 1:33:56yes, yes, because none of us want to be the one who pronounces
- 1:34:00bourgeois in class. No, I still think about it. That happened to
- 1:34:04you? Yeah, freshman year how'd you say it? Well, I'd never
- 1:34:09seen it written out burgoys burgios. Yeah, well that's what it looks like.
- 1:34:14That was a bad day. No one wants to be that person.
- 1:34:16It's it's to everybody. Someone's got to do it. We've all got to
- 1:34:18do it once. Yeah. But don't you always think to yourself, I
- 1:34:23think, fuck, it wasn't me. Yes, yeah, she's just trying
- 1:34:25to avoid her Burgios moment. So Leandron comes in and tells niney she's a
- 1:34:31disappointment. I think this is interesting. Niney've kind of laughs that off.
- 1:34:36Yeah, one, because I think Ninety will always present an outward tough face.
- 1:34:42But I think that would have cracked a GWayne like tissue paper. Absolutely.
- 1:34:45Oh well, I think that goes back to their respective feelings towards external
- 1:34:48authority. Yeah right, because GWayne loves authority. Agwayne desperately wants to please
- 1:34:54authority. Same it just like I am the authority. Yeah, Ninety only
- 1:34:59respects her own authority most of the time. Yeah, She's like, I
- 1:35:01am authority, what are you talking about? That's why she doesn't want to
- 1:35:04look like she doesn't know what she's doing. Yes, because Ninive is secure
- 1:35:09in her worth and you can't wound where they don't bleed. Leandron tells nine
- 1:35:13Eve that practicing with the sword is beneath her. Oh yeah, this is
- 1:35:16a cool scene. And she says, I don't want it to be a
- 1:35:18fair fight. I want to win. This scene is largely Swan in the
- 1:35:24books with nine Eve. Yes, Leandron uses Ninety's affection for I like that
- 1:35:29they change it to Leandred because I feel like you had a really good point
- 1:35:32about this. Yeah. So in the book, at this point, they're
- 1:35:38on the boat to Tarvaalin from Faldara, and Swan had the umbrelin seat,
- 1:35:46had gone to Faldara, and she is accompanying them back, and she is
- 1:35:51doing the occasional private lesson with these two. And I think that the more
- 1:36:00you put the magic Pope in banal situations that we can see, the less
- 1:36:08mysterious aloof and significant she feels. Swan. So far in the show,
- 1:36:18she she has shown up a couple of times, very much in a tight
- 1:36:25position that is bounded on both sides by razors. She's she's navigating a tightrope.
- 1:36:31Right of this, of this plot She's got with Waain, this secret
- 1:36:36romance she's had with Waurain. She she is essentially, for lack of a
- 1:36:44better term, a slave to her circumstance, which is a powerful circumstance.
- 1:36:48But she knows that, to paraphrase Galadrail, stray but a little and she
- 1:36:54will fall. And that is true in the books as well. But I
- 1:36:58think the more we keep her away from the brunt of the action in a
- 1:37:03lot of ways, the more significant her effect is when it does happen.
- 1:37:13That's not to say that you can't have her teaching novice lessons, that you
- 1:37:16can't have her have giving this demonstration to nine Eve. I think that for
- 1:37:26the way the show is painting these arcs, it makes a lot of sense
- 1:37:30for Leandron to do it for reasons I could get into in the spoiler section.
- 1:37:33And it also makes a lot of sense to keep Swan as a special
- 1:37:39treat I guess what do you think? Eli? I agree with you.
- 1:37:42I think that the less well, First of all, it just feels beneath
- 1:37:45her. But the second thing is is that the less we see somebody,
- 1:37:48the more powerful they feel. Yes, yeah, agreed. Leandron uses nineties
- 1:37:55affection for Land in order to break nine Eve's bond. Yeah, block my
- 1:37:59bad ye, or at least get her around it. But she also refers
- 1:38:02to it as a weakness, and Niniu doesn't truly get angry until Leandron says
- 1:38:06hurtful things about orders that nini herself once said to land She did, didn't
- 1:38:12she Her own words are used against her, but now she regrets I think
- 1:38:15saying those things to him. Yeah. When Ninive lets Leandron go right,
- 1:38:19Leandrin lands on her feet while Ninive is staggering. There's a clear power dynamic
- 1:38:25there. Leandron's been around the block for lack of a better term, yes,
- 1:38:30yeah, very very clever play on words there. Leandron informs ninety that
- 1:38:33she can use her anger to channel, because there's more than one way to
- 1:38:36channel. So you know, Alana presented the pink supple flower bullshit, Right,
- 1:38:44that's Lana's way, but Leandre's like, get fucking pissed. Who cares?
- 1:38:49That's a way to channel two. Does it seem like a healthy way
- 1:38:53to channel? Probably not. Now we can talk about metaphysics later. I
- 1:38:57don't think this is a significant change, because this is how this works in
- 1:39:00the book, is ninety off has to get mad to channel. Also,
- 1:39:02this harkens back to Leandron talking about what the world will do to little girls
- 1:39:06with a spark of being greater than they are. Yes, well, let's
- 1:39:11keep an eye on Leandren and her obsession with protecting little girls because I think
- 1:39:16there's an insight into her character there. What happened to Leandron to make her
- 1:39:21crave power like this, that's my big question. I think something traumatic happened
- 1:39:27to Leandron, and that's my opinion. I think that's very likely. I
- 1:39:30don't know, because I don't at this point where I'm at. Sincerely,
- 1:39:34I don't know about that for Leandron, but that's my assumption about where they're
- 1:39:40going with this character. The scene also fully explains what happened to Moraine,
- 1:39:45linking the plot lines. In my mind, I think everything that Leandron did
- 1:39:49look like what Vishamael did to Morain last book. So I think to me
- 1:39:54that answered the question of cut off versus just yeah, because it's from It's,
- 1:40:00it's it's It is not clear whether Waurin has been permanently cut off from
- 1:40:08the power or temporarily cut off from the power. We know that you can
- 1:40:11shield people. We know that you can also gentle or still people. I
- 1:40:15think the visual verb vocabulary that we see for for ripping the power out of
- 1:40:23somebody versus blocking it in not block like nineties block. This is more in
- 1:40:29key. That was more in keeping with a shield. And now what Leandron
- 1:40:31does to nine Eve is also very similar I think to uh to what happened
- 1:40:38to Warren. Speaking of being cut off, we're cutting you off from the
- 1:40:40episode to break for ads, Yes, welcome back, all right, we
- 1:41:00got the burial scene. Yes, a lot of funerals in this series.
- 1:41:04Can we pay attention to that star motif that keeps coming up? I think
- 1:41:10it spokes of a wheel, Yeah, I really do, because they keep
- 1:41:14burying people in a round essentially. Yeah, and I'm ninety nine percent sure
- 1:41:18it's meant to be spokes ofble. But then there's also the little girl playing
- 1:41:23on the thing and it's a star as well, playing on the stone stuff,
- 1:41:28the stone slabs, and she's like, and that's a star. And
- 1:41:32also the house that they're in is a star. Yeah, it's possible.
- 1:41:35I'm just putting it out there. It could be spokes on the wheel.
- 1:41:39Though Elias buries the dog he does, which is endearing and also seems significant
- 1:41:46based on what's going on with Paren. Yes, Ingtar insisted on burying the
- 1:41:50China and that betrayed him and gives some gorgeous thoughts about revenge to Paren.
- 1:41:56Really beautiful scene, gorgeous, which deepens the complexities one again of good and
- 1:42:00evil. If Schinarans sought revenge for every wrong done to them, there would
- 1:42:03be no Chinaran's left. Layla's influence on Parens continues as Parent reflects on how
- 1:42:09she waived at patent Fane, who is the reason for her death. I
- 1:42:12mean other than Paren, Paren is afraid of I mean ultimately, Paren is
- 1:42:16afraid of what his anger at that betrayal might make him do. And he's
- 1:42:20still torn between these two dicotomous sides of himself, the good and the evil.
- 1:42:25Well, I would say, but what is it? What is evil?
- 1:42:28For him? Yeah? Yeah, that's the thing. Is is it
- 1:42:30good an evil? Or is it pacifistic and belligerent? But see, we
- 1:42:33could easily link pacifistic to good, Yes we could, and we could easily,
- 1:42:40but like look at the two Tinkers who are pacifists who are also dark
- 1:42:44friends, yes, right, versus like look at you know Dana who theoretically
- 1:42:50went into being a dark friend for like humanity saving reasons. Well, you
- 1:42:57look at Volda, who I think is a hideous person who for all we
- 1:43:02know he's I mean, we know there's at least one white cloak dark friend.
- 1:43:05Could might not be that guy. That guy might very well be on
- 1:43:09the side of good while doing horrendous things. No, but yeah, so
- 1:43:13I think it's it's easy to want to link passive, but also pacifism in
- 1:43:17the face of like horrific oppression is actually also harmful. Yeah, right,
- 1:43:23Like there's a reason why people are like, no punch Nazis in the face.
- 1:43:28It's nuanced. It's a nuance, a nuanced conversation. But that's what
- 1:43:30I'm saying is like with parent, he's also exploring the nuances of this conversation.
- 1:43:34Like sometimes people people think pacifism means inaction, right, and that's like
- 1:43:43and being despondent or uh, non reactive and like yes and no, right,
- 1:43:51I mean there's a more complicated question like if someone's beating someone else up
- 1:43:56and you do nothing to intervene, then that's just bystander effect. Right.
- 1:44:00So his also UNO's rigidity in this scene is a big juxtaposition to ink Tar.
- 1:44:06Yeah, absolutely, he's he. He was pretty firm on fuck this
- 1:44:11guy, let him rot, right. He seems like he's got a pretty
- 1:44:14bit on him. Yeah, he's got a pretty strict moral code. He
- 1:44:16does. In addition to that, I thought Angktar asked a really interesting question
- 1:44:23where he's like, well, if you get an opportunity, maybe ask patent
- 1:44:26Fane why he did it. You might not like the answer, but you
- 1:44:29may want to know. Ink Tar really coming in with the hot nuance.
- 1:44:33Hot nuance, possibly too much hot nuance, depending on who us. Yeah,
- 1:44:38it's a bit of I mean, the creepy whistling kind of gives a
- 1:44:42little more mustache toyally than the rest of them, But there could be some
- 1:44:45nuance in evil. I do appreciate that they're the the the Dark Friends seem
- 1:44:53to be very three dimensional. I love that, right, talking about the
- 1:44:57talking about Patten Fain, talking about the the presumably mother of the Tinker Girl.
- 1:45:03Mm hmm. There's a lot a lot going on that I'm excited about.
- 1:45:06Yeah, me too, y Shamaya even he's very three dimensional. So
- 1:45:11Land comes into Moraine's little office and he's basically like, what was all that
- 1:45:15about with Belle Delmont? Yeah, and she doesn't tell him. She sh
- 1:45:18didn't tell him, And she eventually looks up and is like and smiles at
- 1:45:21him and says, is a nice that I not allowed to have secrets?
- 1:45:25But that's been the problem between them. Yes, Lane now knows nothing about
- 1:45:30her. Yeah. Before there weren't really secrets between them, and that's what
- 1:45:33sets him off, Like there were secrets but not but he still had access
- 1:45:38to her. She was still accessible to him. Yeah, but she's not
- 1:45:41anymore, and that sets him off. He's pissed now. And and to
- 1:45:45our read, this is to keep him safe. Yeah, but he doesn't
- 1:45:47know won't kill him, won't kill him? Since the bond between them is
- 1:45:51being further severed by her she he goes a step further by telling her to
- 1:45:56make dinner herself. Yeah. Lorraine looks at the broken bell tine, which
- 1:46:00ultimately is the thing that ties the plot lines together. It's interesting to me
- 1:46:03that her bell time lamp is broken, not giving off any light, whereas
- 1:46:09the other one's are whole. Yeah, and she notably would know. Well,
- 1:46:13they kind of seem we've made belltime maybe more of a global holiday in
- 1:46:17the books. It's pretty No, I don't remember. Actually there's a lot
- 1:46:20of regional holidays. But it's possible that she's cognizant of it as well.
- 1:46:24Yeah, Niny brings Paren's letter to Agwayne, though Agwayne has her hair down.
- 1:46:29Niney forgot bell time. Both of these girls have abandoned parts of their
- 1:46:32home, and Niney seems pretty pissed that she has forgotten. She's really upset.
- 1:46:38She can't believe it. She also hesitated before walking into Awayin's room.
- 1:46:42Yes, FELANX, Okay, this is a tortoise believe that. No,
- 1:46:50No, I believe that Raf Judkins did this for me. So if you
- 1:46:55listen to our book episodes, you already know about this. There is unning
- 1:47:00joke that we have, which is, anytime a military formation is described of
- 1:47:05of armored soldiers or unarmored soldiers in a formation, Ali, what is that
- 1:47:12formation likely called a failanx Inevitably, if it's an encircling enfalade, what's that
- 1:47:17a failing? If it's a bunch of guys with spears in a box,
- 1:47:20what's that? What if it is a line of men with muskets? Well,
- 1:47:25obviously a failing. So when Paren writes this beautiful letter, which by
- 1:47:30the way, shout out to communication in my wheel of time, Uh,
- 1:47:34where that we communicated about a FAILANX. This was done for wheeltakes, I
- 1:47:41believe it. Where he's describing soldiers covering one another with their shields, which
- 1:47:47is technically a tortoise, but it looks like a FAILANX. I yelled,
- 1:47:51I screamed FAILANX. She did. Anyway, Paren's letter talks about the dangers
- 1:47:57of them being scattered, hearkening back to the question of will will they ever
- 1:48:00be able to age FAILANX? So you know it's a FAILANX. We'll call
- 1:48:03it a FAILANX. Parents seems to think The parents seems to think that the
- 1:48:09closest they can be to get together is next year. I don't he said,
- 1:48:14next year, I'll come to the White Tower with Loyal and we'll celebrate
- 1:48:17bell time together. I think he was referring less to I won't see you
- 1:48:24until next year and at the latest, let's make sure that next belt.
- 1:48:28But that implies that he thinks that that could be the latest that he sees
- 1:48:31that. Sure, sure, that's a long time. Then we get to
- 1:48:34the story turn Boom, Matt is in the White Tower and is being held
- 1:48:39by Leandron. This is kind of late for the story turn, isn't it.
- 1:48:41Second story turn? Oh? The second What was the first one?
- 1:48:44First one was the poem? I think so. And a story turn is
- 1:48:47when new information is revealed. Second story turn. Yeah, no, there's
- 1:48:50a story turn after the midpoint. Okay, this is the second story turn.
- 1:48:55So the second story turn is Boom, Matt's in the White Tower being
- 1:48:57held by Leandred. We get an answer on where he is, even though
- 1:49:00we kind of already had hints of that. We didn't see it for sure.
- 1:49:02We didn't see it for sure, parent hasn't we got hints? Oh
- 1:49:08yeah, Paren has a moment with the lanterns where he considers putting his ring
- 1:49:12on the lantern and sending it out, but he takes it back at the
- 1:49:15last second. He's not ready to let go over yet. Oh, by
- 1:49:17the way, when we're at the but but the information that we have is
- 1:49:20that Leandron's keeping communications about him from Matt. Yeah, that's the big story
- 1:49:28turn moment where we're like, oh, Matt still thinks that they've abandoned him.
- 1:49:30Yes, she's selectively omitted or I guess not abandoned him, but like
- 1:49:34don't like him. Yeah, Agwayne talks, Yeah, she selectively omitted.
- 1:49:40That is some real twisting of words here, right, because she says not
- 1:49:45a single mention of Matt Coffin and all these letters, perhaps there have been
- 1:49:49several, that's not a single that's true. There are ways to get around
- 1:49:56the whole lying versus always telling the truth. Thing. Could also be the
- 1:50:00truth that she perceives it. Maybe she's not getting the full letter. Possible.
- 1:50:04My question is where where she's lying? Where's she getting the letter?
- 1:50:09I'm impressed he's able to intercept this truly, although I guess that makes sense.
- 1:50:15Would somebody be copying it and giving it to her? Yeah? The
- 1:50:16White Tower probably scans shit, Yeah, scans it. They have a magical
- 1:50:21scanner. Yeah, I mean, I mean when when letters come in they
- 1:50:25intercept them. I assume they always need magical it t to come fix it
- 1:50:29though. Yeah, agwayin talk, there's never any toner magical toner. No,
- 1:50:32well, magic it exists because of magic printers. Agwayne talks about how
- 1:50:38much she misses Randon niney uh rand A Ninieve assures her that she's always with
- 1:50:42Agwayne something that will potentially be a comfort, and answers the question post to
- 1:50:47her by the warders earlier, why are you here? She's here for Agwayne.
- 1:50:51They're also uh revamping the reincarnation aspect of the world and encouraging Rand's spirit
- 1:50:59to find its way back to them. They're revisiting that getting at the overall
- 1:51:03season arc plot question about whether they will master their abilities and reunite. Matt
- 1:51:09pulls the armor down to pull a shash ink. Oh yeah, that's cool.
- 1:51:13Rand reveals where he is the light illuminating him. No, is that
- 1:51:16the climax of the episode technically? No? No, even though okay,
- 1:51:21no, but it's kind of I think it's still encapsulated in the story turn
- 1:51:27sure. I think this whole bell time scene is the story turn sure?
- 1:51:31Personally? Did you want to go back and talk about parent in the Ring?
- 1:51:33Though? I feel like we kind of brushed over that. I really
- 1:51:38like that they're they're not writing her away, they're not writing her off.
- 1:51:43They're really giving that death consequence, yes, which is so necessary. Yes,
- 1:51:47an emotional weight, Yes, which is like if you're gonna do a
- 1:51:50fridging. Yeah, let's really emotional weight go through that not just plot weight,
- 1:51:56Yes, exactly. Yeah. Rand reveals where is the light illuminating him?
- 1:52:01Yeah? Pretty cool, bringing him out of the shadows and mirroring his
- 1:52:06last bell Tinmee scene, but this time he's alone, a taste of solitude.
- 1:52:13You might say, there, it is there, it is frienda br
- 1:52:15vrain okay. Land says he wants them to visit to wait for Moraine,
- 1:52:20and Adelias's face sends me oh at dinner. Oh, She's like, I
- 1:52:25just want to eat my fucking cauliflower, dude, which I feel that.
- 1:52:29Varren tells Land that what Moraine is going through would break anyone else, but
- 1:52:32not Morain. Again, we're getting at she's a strong bitty Yeah, she
- 1:52:38doesn't give a fuck. This softens Land to her obstacle. Obstacle. Hey,
- 1:52:43I think that's the first time anyone has ever told me to be quiet.
- 1:52:45What a great fucking line. Yes, he brings up her food,
- 1:52:50noticing she's gone and allowing him to save her life. All is lost moment
- 1:52:56Moraine alone with the fade. Land shows up, but it's all so bested.
- 1:53:01Maureen notably is in Dark Blue again. She's on her freakin' mission,
- 1:53:05but she's much more vulnerable than she was before. Do you want to say
- 1:53:09anything about this? But I the first time I watched this battle, I
- 1:53:13had a lot of trouble telling what was going on. Yeah, partially because
- 1:53:15I was looking at it on just because of the particular lighting I was watching
- 1:53:19it in. Then the second time I watched it and I saw the fades
- 1:53:23start shadow stepping, I screamed, because it's so goddamn cool. My one
- 1:53:29very small, little nitpicky criticism is I love this battle. I do think
- 1:53:33it suffers a little bit from just stab them. So that makes me wonder
- 1:53:36if that's a question we're going to get answered later, but doually, because
- 1:53:41they were multiple times where I felt like they could have just stabbed him.
- 1:53:45But by the way, you'll know how impressive this is. They shot that
- 1:53:48fight in two nights. You fucking kidding me? No, that's insane.
- 1:53:51Is not that wild? I saw that. Look here's any honey, was
- 1:53:56like, oh, we shot that in two nights. Here's the thing about
- 1:53:59night shoots are they're awful. Fight shoots are a nightmare themselves. Okay,
- 1:54:03explain why night shoots are awful, and explain why fight shoots when you're staying
- 1:54:08up. Well, first, let me just say, like I just simply
- 1:54:11had to say, I felt like they could have stepped but I know why
- 1:54:13they didn't, and I'm not actually upset about it because the battle was fucking
- 1:54:15cool and I'm happy that it was cool. So going back to night shoots
- 1:54:18and going back to uh fight scenes, night shots are a fucking nightmare because
- 1:54:25it was outside, right outside. Okay, great, so you're standing up
- 1:54:29all night. It's fucking free. You're staying up all night. It's probably
- 1:54:31cold. Lighting is as much of a pain in the ass as it ever
- 1:54:35is. Everyone's cranky, everyone's having a bad time because they've all been awake
- 1:54:40all night. And probably, by the way, usually have to like train
- 1:54:44yourself for a night shoot, so like you're also staying up until all night
- 1:54:48for like a week before so that you can handle it. You are,
- 1:54:51because you're not. Just night shoot does not mean okay, we filmed from
- 1:54:56noon until midnight this time, so we got a few hours of night.
- 1:55:00No night shoot means you got to set two hours before sundown to get into
- 1:55:03hair and makeup or however long. So they were filming until like the sun
- 1:55:09started to come up. Yeah, that's when they lost. Someone comes up,
- 1:55:12So it sucks, it's not fun. Notably, Helm's deep I think
- 1:55:17was like two months of night shoots. Oh and on top of that,
- 1:55:23stage combat and combat of this type is so precise. We talked about this
- 1:55:29in The Blood Snow how precise stage combat fight choreography, not stage combat,
- 1:55:35not a stage but you know, combat like that is uh. And to
- 1:55:43do that level of intense multiple person fight choreo in two days bananas. Absolutely
- 1:55:49fucking only at night time, yeah, where you can't see anything. Yeah.
- 1:55:55I again, I really like this fight. Even if I had a
- 1:55:57little bit of a I mean, you could have killed him, but again,
- 1:56:00that wouldn't be fun. If they were just dead, then the theater
- 1:56:02kids with a flair for the drum. Maybe maybe they had a reason.
- 1:56:06But yeah, Moraine left so that Land was not impacted by her vulnerability,
- 1:56:11and she's ambushed by a fade. The fades fading into the shadows was fucking
- 1:56:15amazing, so fucking cool. If you can't see it, turn your brightness
- 1:56:18up a little bit. Oh, it's so cool because they're like fully shadow
- 1:56:21stepping. Yeah, it's so cool, so cool. Moraine again proves that
- 1:56:27she hasn't lost all of her powers. When she's able to outsmart one of
- 1:56:30the face she did air quotes on powers. Yeah, powers, I mean
- 1:56:33she's got other abilities, but she also immediately gets reminded that she's still vulnerable
- 1:56:38and may still need help when she's injured by another fade and Land saves her.
- 1:56:42Yeah, he answered. But but what I love about it is she's
- 1:56:45not it's not a like damsel in distress, Like she's handling it okay,
- 1:56:49even though she's been hamstrung. He answers the question we were asking. We
- 1:56:55are asking during this fight. Where is land? Yes, right, the
- 1:56:59whole fight. You're like, where the bucket land? Where the fuck is
- 1:57:00land? Where the fuck is land? Now? Some people have also asked
- 1:57:03where was Mourrain going. I'm frankly not super concerned with it. I also
- 1:57:08think that there are a lot of possible places she could be going. She
- 1:57:12could be going to deliver a letter. She could be going to investigate bail
- 1:57:15Doman's thing. She could be going to see if she can spy on the
- 1:57:18fades. There's a number of places she could be going. She could be
- 1:57:23trying to run away and not have to have any kind of tough conversations with
- 1:57:27Lan about this. I have spoilery thoughts about this. Yeah, I think
- 1:57:30there are enough possible places she could be going that I'm not too unduly concerned
- 1:57:35with the specifics. I know where she was going, I think. But
- 1:57:40okay, it's notable. Oh yeah, somebody was like, how is Land
- 1:57:44fighting two fates the fade? Moraine injured, got back up, Yes,
- 1:57:46and then it became a two on one. It's notable that both Lan and
- 1:57:50Morain are significantly let's good at fighting without their bond, and the two of
- 1:57:55them made each other better. The fades move freaky fast, really really fast,
- 1:58:00and Land is injured. Uh yeah right, and I just can't believe
- 1:58:04they did it in two nights. I have specific book quotations about fade strength.
- 1:58:11I can't read all of them right now because of book spoilers. I'll
- 1:58:14read them in the spoiler section, but suffice to say, especially early on
- 1:58:17in the books, if a fade is there, you're probably you're probably not
- 1:58:23making it out unscathed. No, if two fades are there, you're pretty
- 1:58:27fucked. Yeah. So yeah, yeah, this yeah very yeah, yeah,
- 1:58:32but this is a good all his last moment, all is lost basically
- 1:58:34being like, we're fucked. Yeah, we're the farthest are away from our
- 1:58:39goal. Essentially, uh climax. Mauraene tries to channel to save them,
- 1:58:45addressing the biggest question of our powers, where are there her powers? Land
- 1:58:50reaches for her just as she reaches for Sidar, so like there's just let
- 1:58:55oh yeah this parallel. Yeah, for a split second, it seems like
- 1:58:58maybe her powers have returned to to both her and the viewer. I was
- 1:59:00like tricked for a second. I was like, what, this is my
- 1:59:04season, my episode seven, this is my episode seven. It's too soon.
- 1:59:08It's too soon, Raith, it's too soon. It's episode it's episode
- 1:59:12one, and this should be episode seven. And then they tricked me for
- 1:59:15a second because I was like, I'll never be able to show my face
- 1:59:16again. But yeah, but I was not wrong. We realized it was
- 1:59:24a Delius. However we want to say it and Varon. So then we
- 1:59:30get to the resolution, right Varon and Adelius and Elis save them, answering
- 1:59:35where they are at this time? Right? Where are they? There's another
- 1:59:40question we're asking during the fucking fight, We're like, where where are the
- 1:59:44other people involved in this? Too? And gives us a moment of reminding
- 1:59:47us all of that Moraine has, of all that Morain has lost in terms
- 1:59:51of power. In an episode Leandron had just harped on the importance of power.
- 1:59:56Yep, and then we get our hook Land looking at more and going,
- 2:00:00what are you telling me? What are you what aren't you telling me?
- 2:00:01Or what are you keeping? Is one of the other one of these
- 2:00:04we're paraphrasing, which is a nice button also to everything that's happening in the
- 2:00:09show is everyone is keeping something from one another, but especially mor Rain and
- 2:00:12Lands plot and if you want to find out what those things are, you're
- 2:00:16gonna have to keep watching. And that's the hook. Yeah, that's our
- 2:00:20episode. A lot of exciting incidents, that a lot of them. There's
- 2:00:25a lot of setup. It's it's which is good. We've got a lot
- 2:00:28of interesting plot lines coming set up review not even review, but sort of,
- 2:00:31hey, how did we get from there to hear? We skipped a
- 2:00:33lot of intervening time, which was fine with me. To me was the
- 2:00:36perfect decision. If you're going to skip time, I think the perfect time
- 2:00:42to do it is between seasons. But yeah, we get new insight and
- 2:00:45citing, exciting stuff from everybody. Right, we get more Leandren and ninety
- 2:00:49special relationship, we get Waurrain gets the quendiar, we get Parrin meets Elias,
- 2:00:58right right, I'm trying to think of or something else we get.
- 2:01:00We know where Matt is, we know where what kind of we're rand,
- 2:01:03we know he is a round, we know Ram's alive. Just inciting incidents
- 2:01:08stacked on top of inciting incidents, which is pretty fucking cool in my opinion,
- 2:01:14which is gonna set us up for a fuck load of obstacles, a
- 2:01:16lot of other obstacles, tough things coming down the line, resulting in what
- 2:01:20will happen in Caeson in episode seven to night, which will be our point
- 2:01:25of no return. Uh huh, cats out of the bag, babies,
- 2:01:29we can't go back. So do we have anything else to say? From
- 2:01:32a non spoiler perspective, I do know. I think we wrapped it up
- 2:01:38pretty well, all right, well two hours and ten minutes, I think,
- 2:01:43or nineteen minutes. I think we did a really good job. Pretty
- 2:01:45good. Let's take a quick ad break and then we'll come back and let's
- 2:01:50get some walk spoilers. It's a spoiler babies, spoilers, spoilers, spoilers,
- 2:01:59spoilers. Welcome to spoiler Oh god. I also I used to make
- 2:02:04jokes like this shit. The only thing that's coming to mind is spoiler rama,
- 2:02:09and I've done that before. So welcome to spoil unguard on, where
- 2:02:13we discuss things that are spoilers for everything through what Ali's read, which for
- 2:02:18all intents and purposes, today we're just gonna call it the end of Winter's
- 2:02:21Heart because Crossroads is fun. Uh, here we go. We're gonna talk
- 2:02:29about some shit. We're gonna talk about some shit with spoilers and some of
- 2:02:31the ramifications that that might have longer term down the line, and like you
- 2:02:36know, thought processes, et cetera. Okay, awesome, Wait I'm readjusting
- 2:02:41my mic and now everything has gone to shit? All right? Yeah okay.
- 2:02:44So to add to the by the end of the season, I expect,
- 2:02:47so I said all of them to reunit at Fom matt rejoined the party,
- 2:02:51Landon, moraen to come back together. Morain gets her powers back.
- 2:02:55Here are the spoiler ones a GWayne rescued from Sean Chan. Yeah yeah,
- 2:02:59magic Battle in the Sky. You think I think reveal Leandrin as black Aja
- 2:03:06likely deaf. Okay, oh, and I said, yeah, so the
- 2:03:12point of no return where I said, by the end of the season,
- 2:03:14I think we will likely have a whelp the cats out of the bag about
- 2:03:16Rand being the dragon reborn and now like kind of everyone knows the dragons around
- 2:03:20is the Magic Battle in the Sky. It seems like Magic Battle in the
- 2:03:26Sky will be happening and sees it in episodes either seven or eight. I
- 2:03:29think we can obliquely reference the first three episodes as a whole. They do
- 2:03:33talk about it. Yeah, so then the climax, a resolution episode we're
- 2:03:38get in the Magic Battle in the Sky. Come on, y'all. Oh.
- 2:03:45I posited that potentially the Chinarin that died over the tinker girl that he
- 2:03:53was trying to murder might have been like us thinking that that was the Shinarin
- 2:03:58at the Dark Friends Social, but that could be inc Tar. Also,
- 2:04:01uh, well, I think it's a bait and switch, right, Yeah,
- 2:04:03I think it's a total bait and switch. We're like, oh,
- 2:04:05okay, so we know that the Chinaran guy that was at though Darkford Social
- 2:04:09is dead, but no, I think it's Inktar. Yeah. Also,
- 2:04:13Leandrin I think was probably there, oh for sure, as the black Aja.
- 2:04:16I think that's highly likely. Siroth obviously represented and was obviously the other
- 2:04:20one that was there. I saw a white cloak, which makes me curious
- 2:04:25because we don't we didn't meet uh Carradin. Yeah, it's possible that we
- 2:04:33will meet. I mean, I'm I'm unless they combine Caroden with someone else.
- 2:04:36Call me crazy, but I don't think we've met all the characters in
- 2:04:40the Wheel of Time yet as of season two episode three. What so,
- 2:04:44is this a hint that Caraden is coming or are they combining Caroden with someone
- 2:04:47else? Well, I think I think that, Like, could they combine
- 2:04:50him with Volda? I thought it seems obvious. I do that because Valda's
- 2:04:54got his own jury. It's the same reason why I don't think they're going
- 2:04:57to combine Leandron with Alaia, not only because Rafe said that he's excited to
- 2:05:00see Alia come to screen eventually. Yeah, and I think, well,
- 2:05:06I think we also need him involveda to think he's a good guy. Yeah.
- 2:05:11Yeah, Well, it's the same thing as with Eli. Yeah,
- 2:05:14yeah, I think we have to show the spectrum of like what good guys
- 2:05:17quote unquote can be and what bad guys could also be in like a oh,
- 2:05:25actually, there's a lot of hot nuance in this situation. I think
- 2:05:28Rafe is really bringing the hot nuance into this show, and I think it's
- 2:05:32great. Alas, I actually think, sorry, really quick, I think
- 2:05:36that's Robert Jordan's thesis at the end of the day. And I think I've
- 2:05:40said that before, but I'll say it again because it bears repeating. Yeah,
- 2:05:45do we want to talk now or do we want to wait until we
- 2:05:47do episode three breakdowns to discuss I guess some of these plots that we are
- 2:05:56following are heavily divergent, which I'm fine with from the plots as they are
- 2:06:01written in The Great Hunt, and one that is getting probably the most buzz
- 2:06:06as being markedly changed is land and warring. I think it might be worth
- 2:06:13waiting until we have the full context of the first three episodes behind us.
- 2:06:16I would agree with that to discuss sort of what what's what we think the
- 2:06:21the the broader perspective and impetus outside of they wanted to give Rosamond something to
- 2:06:28do, which is a factor that is definitely a factor're not going to sideline
- 2:06:32her, and frankly, they really can't sideline the Gandolf character. She's a
- 2:06:38big draw. But I think the other thing is, like, you know,
- 2:06:43just magic women in general. They're not going to be like, here's
- 2:06:45magic women anyway, you know. But I think the other well, I
- 2:06:51do think the episode three is a better place for discussion. But I think
- 2:06:59that at in a book, you're kind of bouncing around between povs and like
- 2:07:05stuff happens off screen quote unquote that kind of can't happen off screen in a
- 2:07:12TV show. Can you elaborate? We kind of well, TV shows,
- 2:07:17by virtue of the fact that they're TV shows, take on a like third
- 2:07:21person. The camera takes on like a third person omniscient sure role in the
- 2:07:27series. So when you have a book that's a first person or I guess
- 2:07:33second person perspective, second person, it's third person, you know, Wait
- 2:07:38you mean, oh, you mean you mean a third person perspective, But
- 2:07:43I do mean third person limited, That's what I mean. I was I
- 2:07:45was like, yeah, because I said first person, I was like,
- 2:07:47that's not right, and I said second person that I was like, that's
- 2:07:49not right, thank you. Third person limited a third person limited perspective versus
- 2:07:55the third person omniscient perspective. You're by extension, going to like have to
- 2:07:59pull back and showcase more of the world at large in a TV show than
- 2:08:05you will in like a POV, right, because like the point of the
- 2:08:09POV is that we're getting like limited information. Yeah, right, and like
- 2:08:15we will obviously be playing we are obviously playing with that in the TV show,
- 2:08:20right when we're having the ice that I say things that are like incorrect,
- 2:08:22or people say things that are they they assume but are incorrect, and
- 2:08:26then all this like book fans go ah, and then we realize that they're
- 2:08:31saying the wrong thing on purpose, right to give us that sense of limited
- 2:08:35perspective, But in this place that necessitates a third person omniscient perspective. Yeah,
- 2:08:43does that make sense? So we're going to accept to pull back and
- 2:08:46evaluate the world as it is at large and the world building at large.
- 2:08:50Yeahes, that makes sense. It makes sense to me, and especially one
- 2:08:52of the kind of reasons. And then we'll get further as time goes on
- 2:08:56into like how this is going to be important for understanding the water bond,
- 2:09:01the importance of you know, being connected to the source, which is of
- 2:09:05course going to be a huge thing down the line for characters like Logain,
- 2:09:11swand Leanna, among others. And I also want to take a moment to
- 2:09:18hold space for folks who who may be missing other plotlines from the books that
- 2:09:26they would have preferred to see and are frustrated that there is new material.
- 2:09:30We're not saying by any means you you must love every choice, or that
- 2:09:37you said this, I think bears repeating that. We're not saying when when
- 2:09:41we when we discuss this choice, we think was made this way and we
- 2:09:46like it or don't because of X, Y and Z. Do not take
- 2:09:50that as if you don't like this, or if you didn't enjoy this,
- 2:09:54or if you would prefer something else, we hate you and you're wrong.
- 2:09:56It's not what that is. What I mean, Oh, I would never
- 2:10:01say that, and I would never think it either. I to zoom out
- 2:10:07a little bit and just sort of broadly discuss page to screen diversions and changes
- 2:10:15really in season one and in season two, thus far from what I can
- 2:10:18discuss here and now. I think there is a lot of effort to bring
- 2:10:26the tone and maturity of the story of the first three books, and the
- 2:10:33scope of the story in the first three books in line with the tone,
- 2:10:37maturity, and scope of the story from Shadow Rising on. That is very
- 2:10:43valid, and I'm glad you pointed that out because I think that when you
- 2:10:50are creating a TV series, you want from the beginning to give a very
- 2:10:54clear sense of the tone and where the story may be going, and who
- 2:10:58the important character are and what the maturity level is. Right. In part,
- 2:11:03that's because I don't want to start watching a TV show with my nephew
- 2:11:07and then realize the next season that this show that we really liked is way
- 2:11:11too mature for him. Yeah, right, same thing with and believe with
- 2:11:16like do my as well. So that's not gonna be a scene I'm gonna
- 2:11:18watch with my nephew, no, right, So we kind of have to
- 2:11:22accelerate some of that development and showcase like from the beginning, this is a
- 2:11:26show that's not going to fuck around. It's going to be a show where
- 2:11:30like hard stuff happens and the character is going to be dealing with some deep
- 2:11:33fucking emotional trauma and that's gonna be real. So, yeah, I agree
- 2:11:41with you. I think that they are accelerating the maturity and the tone in
- 2:11:46an effort to showcase where the story is going to go so that you know,
- 2:11:48like, who am I going to watch this with? And it is
- 2:11:52this show for me? Where am I going to get mad? Five seasons
- 2:11:56in that the show takes a different turn and becomes like about something that I
- 2:12:03was like, why was I invested in this show when it went in this
- 2:12:05other direction? It's like, well, it was always going to go in
- 2:12:07that direction. Yeah, when we just tricked you into liking it for five
- 2:12:11seasons and being loyal to it for it to go into a direction that you
- 2:12:15wouldn't want it to go in. Yeah, that doesn't make sense. So
- 2:12:18it's like we're trying to cultivate the fan base that is going to be a
- 2:12:22fan of where the story goes. Does that make sense? It makes Yeah,
- 2:12:26that's that's that's what I was getting that. Yeah. Oh the speech,
- 2:12:30I think, oh this speech, Oh that a Shameel gives a little
- 2:12:35girl about being a monster and Lada Da will be so poignant when we think
- 2:12:39about parents' plotline and his struggles with his wolf self Rand and his struggles with
- 2:12:45his like dragon reborny self. Matt and coming to terms with the fact that
- 2:12:50he left the group. Yep nine Eve and no one should have that much
- 2:12:54power, right, Yeah, I think that's that's pretty much encapsulated a lot
- 2:13:03of the characters journeys in one speech. Well, then this season is gonna
- 2:13:07have a lot of monster in it. Not the energy drink. Uh oh
- 2:13:11yeah. Moraine's Things seriously sets up Swan, Leanna, and Logan losing their
- 2:13:18powers for real and how awful that will that is and will be for them?
- 2:13:22Can you imagine? Also, well, different episode I'll talk about it
- 2:13:26later is Varon a dark Friend. Yeah, this has been on your mind
- 2:13:30NonStop since you what can you? Can you so? For people who do
- 2:13:33not listen to Ali's our book episodes, Ali has a theory. We're currently
- 2:13:41mid book ten, about a book and a half ago, and again there's
- 2:13:45gonna be spoilers through the end of book nine book about a book and a
- 2:13:48half ago, Adelius died. Can you imagine this ideally? Oh my god,
- 2:13:56I'm gonna be try very sad. Although I couldn't help but notice that
- 2:14:00so many of her outfits have like reddish flowers on the thorn. I couldn't
- 2:14:05help but notice that and I was like, they're doing this on purpose.
- 2:14:09So a couple of books ago, Yeah, I decided is go ahead.
- 2:14:13I decided that Van Deen killed her for a billion reasons and that I don't
- 2:14:20check the you can check the episode where that happens. It's it's the chapter
- 2:14:24where that happens. I don't remember which one it is. I'll check.
- 2:14:26Yeah, So I decided Van Den obviously killed Adelias because of the thesis of
- 2:14:35Robert Jordan and I have been struggling with whether or not Baron is a dark
- 2:14:39friend for a while because she's kind of shady, but I also fucking love
- 2:14:45her. But I'm like, maybe that's Robert Jordan going it truly could be
- 2:14:48anybody, even the people you like, which fits into where this show is
- 2:14:52going. Also, it could be anyone, even the people you like.
- 2:14:56Yeah, ing Tar's nice. I likeing Tar. I like him a lot.
- 2:15:00He's a great guy. You know, Ameanvalda sucks, but like,
- 2:15:05you know, he's like a normal guy probably, so yeah, I think
- 2:15:11and like a Jamaiel is a great babysitter apparently really good, really hands on
- 2:15:16with the kids. So you know, my thing is, I'm like,
- 2:15:20well, I think Van Deen did it because of all the reasons that I
- 2:15:24go into in the episode, and so there in being Vanden made me go
- 2:15:30h like a dog because I was like, well, if they had different
- 2:15:35allegiances and they were combined into the same character, Twitter would be flipping a
- 2:15:41baby right now, you know what I mean. They'd be losing their absolute
- 2:15:45goddamn skulls, and no one was over the combo and that was very measured
- 2:15:50for Twitter. So it was like, so they can't be functionally that fucking
- 2:15:56different in terms of allegiances and functionality in the story, right, or like
- 2:16:01Van Deen is kind of like a nothing or vandid It's kind of like a
- 2:16:03nothing character that Varren swallows, right. So like people were kind of like,
- 2:16:09this seems to make sense. I mean, I see a lot of
- 2:16:11people freaking out over this decision. Did you not a lot couple? Well,
- 2:16:16yeah, obviously there's going to be a couple. It's Twitter, But
- 2:16:18like you know, I mean, nobody there wasn't like a mass implosion.
- 2:16:22So I'm like, so they have to be the same same team, same
- 2:16:26tape. So I was like, okay, well, if Vanden is Adelius's
- 2:16:31killer and he is a dark friend, and I'm right about that, Then
- 2:16:33that means Varren has to be a dark friend. And if Varren is a
- 2:16:37good person, then Vanden has to be a good person, which means I'm
- 2:16:39wrong. And I refuse to believe that that's true, because then that means
- 2:16:43that Robert Jordan really whiffed, in my opinion, on an opportunity to prove
- 2:16:48his thesis. And kind of, yeah, so I refuse to believe that's
- 2:16:52true. And if it is true that I am wrong, then maya kulpa
- 2:16:56Robert. But like, I kind of think you might be whiffed on that.
- 2:16:58But yeah, so I think Theren might be a dark friend, then
- 2:17:05you're gonna have to what's that word. Well, I'm working on it.
- 2:17:09It's taking him minute. It's been three years anyway, And I wrote in
- 2:17:15all caps, Oh, I don't want to Delius to die a fucking lover.
- 2:17:18Oh. The fun reversal of Moraine on the Whole with Land on the
- 2:17:24Whole. Man wants to protect woman, so he pushes her away trope,
- 2:17:28which is setting Land up for doing the exact exactly that to niney, which
- 2:17:31he does in the books, and or reversing that bullshit but like you know,
- 2:17:35one of those Yeah, I'm I'm really what I will say, bullshit,
- 2:17:41I'm not insulting Robert. I'm just saying it annoys me that Land did
- 2:17:43that. What I will say, uh about this plot line is I'm actually
- 2:17:48really enjoying it a lot. Me too. I really like, uh the
- 2:17:54deepening of these characters that we're getting, uhh. And I like that it's
- 2:18:01feeling like these two people that we would normally feel like are in vulnerable right,
- 2:18:05Like we look at Gandoff and we're like, well, he's Gandalf,
- 2:18:09they can do anything, right, he's ganed Off. It's way scarier if
- 2:18:13they're more vulnerable than that. It's way scarier if they're just people doing their
- 2:18:16best who happen to have really badass magical abilities, but at the end of
- 2:18:20the day they're just lost as well, which you know from New Spring.
- 2:18:26We know that they're kind of very very low points in parts of New Spring.
- 2:18:33Yeah, and this is setting up for like Morain's death to mean even
- 2:18:37more because we know how close they are and how much Land cares about her.
- 2:18:41I think also something that has been said is that this I may have
- 2:18:48said this earlier, forgive me if I did. We took a pretty long
- 2:18:50break between recording these sections. Their plotline follows a lot of the same beats
- 2:18:56of a married couple that's lost a child and sort of where they find themselves.
- 2:19:01At the beginning of this series, I wrote like a whole dissertation about
- 2:19:05this that I will read later on probably run ups with three. But to
- 2:19:09be brief, they have had one guiding purpose and light for twenty years and
- 2:19:15it is now effectively they fucked it up, and she is no longer able
- 2:19:20to do the things that she thought she would be able to do to do
- 2:19:22the thing, and also, oh shit, we made it worse, So
- 2:19:26you know, should we even be doing this at all? Right? And
- 2:19:30I mean like, I mean, it's just present in her clothes right.
- 2:19:33By the end of the episode, she finally has a mission again, but
- 2:19:37at the beginning she doesn't. She's fucked up and like that the fact that
- 2:19:41that is possible for the leaders to do should terrify us, and it does.
- 2:19:48I think all makes everything worse. The more we discuss it, the
- 2:19:52more I firmly believe you are dead on the money. With the inciting incident
- 2:19:56being the moons, the quendiar the moon die, well, you know,
- 2:20:01him bringing the quendiar in because that and the poem poems. He says,
- 2:20:05launch is more a that launches kind of everything else. Right, And we're
- 2:20:09assuming, having seen three episodes. I'm not going to be specific, we're
- 2:20:13assuming we're going to see land fear right. And it was a moon dial,
- 2:20:18so like there's got to be land Feir. Yeah, I mean I
- 2:20:22think it's heavily implied to be land Fair. Yeah. I mean, and
- 2:20:24there's a poem, I mean, come on, Yeah, and also we
- 2:20:28know which poem is. It's blood calls blood. It's got to be blood
- 2:20:31calls blood. It's got I mean, it's God. And we'll talk more
- 2:20:33specifically when we can talk about episodes two and three. Okay, the scene
- 2:20:39when Agwayne is in Swan's office and is cleaning. I love this shit.
- 2:20:43One peep the box on Swan's desk. Yeah, they keep showing the box,
- 2:20:48keep showing the box, and I'm like, okay, so that's got
- 2:20:50to be a call to when Swan gets to post. That's gotta be Tower
- 2:20:56cou shit. They're alluding to it even now. And also of course a
- 2:21:00GWayne looking longingly at the stole setting that ship up right in season two.
- 2:21:05I like that all the scenes with Ilana and her warders are going to make
- 2:21:09it even more violating when she takes Land and Rand, and also will make
- 2:21:13maxim death even sadder. I'm positive it's Maxim that dies first of all,
- 2:21:18in the books, lives is the one who lives, so it is going
- 2:21:22to always be the other one. But also is that this episode what I
- 2:21:28will know. What I will say is I think, yes, it is.
- 2:21:31It is. Yes, it is where they sword fight. Okay,
- 2:21:33so and he says the thing about being it's always feeling like a third wheel.
- 2:21:37Yeah, that's this episode. And I also don't think that that's that
- 2:21:43to me is also a yeah, you're gonna die, buddy. I don't
- 2:21:46think Rafe is gonna choose to have the Black Order die so his boyfriend can
- 2:21:52stay on the show. Optically, that's gonna do that. Disappointed, super
- 2:21:58shit, that's not gonna have it. I would be disappointed. Yeah,
- 2:22:03I love I love Tailor Naked where he's so he's funny. That's the other
- 2:22:09reason I think he's gonna die. He's funny, and the funny one always
- 2:22:13dies. We have discussed humor is the best way to get you to like
- 2:22:16a character if they're funny, genuinely funny, you are you are fond of
- 2:22:22them? Yeah, the funny best friend always dies. Which Yeah, in
- 2:22:26this sort of medium, Alana's earrings look like chains, and her necklace looks
- 2:22:31like a collar, and so to her, and her braces look like cuffs,
- 2:22:35and her conflict with ninety, fear and her looming over ninety is all
- 2:22:39such foreshattering for their issues starving land. Yeah, I expect. So do
- 2:22:45we want to talk about the scene with I'm going in order? Okay,
- 2:22:52go ahead, unless you want to jump around? No, please, But
- 2:22:56this is just the last thought about this one. Also, we literally just
- 2:22:58got shown how they uns the tank. Yeah, and the fact that Ninie
- 2:23:01refuses to participate and has such a big moment in this scene is also pretty
- 2:23:05relevant, pretty cool, pretty pretty clever little things layered in there that I
- 2:23:11really enjoy. Some We talked about that in the first part. Never mind.
- 2:23:16Did we talk about how some people say it's out of character for ninety
- 2:23:18to drink the w We did talk about that. Yeah, we did talk
- 2:23:20about that, and I agree with that very much. Disagree. I'm speculating
- 2:23:24that they're switching the Alia backstory that Morain told rand about, which was a
- 2:23:28new spring about Alida, like beating them right to try and get them to
- 2:23:33channel when they had difficulty channeling, which by the way, is going to
- 2:23:35be super relevant when it comes to ninety. But they're giving that to Leandre,
- 2:23:37and I think I think that's very possible only because of what's going off,
- 2:23:43what we've seen established of Morraine's relationship, the dirty rushing and Leandre dirty
- 2:23:52rushing. Dirty rushing is in sorority terms, like before rush starts, you
- 2:23:58start trying to like get the girl roles that you want to be interested in
- 2:24:01your sorority. Rush being when you pick a sorority or try to get to
- 2:24:05like a court a sorority. Yeah, life is very confusing, Yeah it
- 2:24:09is. But so basically when like Rush at our school didn't happen until the
- 2:24:16wintertime, and you were not allowed as a freshman in the fall, I
- 2:24:22don't think you were allowed to go into sorority houses until you had until winter
- 2:24:28or something like that. You like weren't allowed to go until a certain point
- 2:24:31because they would be considered dirty rushing, and you also weren't supposed to accept
- 2:24:37any gifts, like when you went to like the pre rush, like where
- 2:24:41you got to finally go into the houses and look at pre rush being like
- 2:24:43a party sort of like a formula of wan to all the different places and
- 2:24:50just like talk to people. Yeah, Rush rush being when you court the
- 2:24:52sorority and the sorority courts you back. Yeah, you weren't allowed to take
- 2:24:58like a napkin or like any food or anything from the sorority because it was
- 2:25:03considered gifts, which would also be dirty rushing. Dirty rushing being starting that.
- 2:25:09I'm just using the term courtship because it feels appropriate, starting the courtship
- 2:25:13process before you're allowed to trying to influence the outcome of someone else's decision with
- 2:25:18through like gifts or like approaching them to early like all that kind of stuff.
- 2:25:24Yeah, which is exactly what Leandron's dirty rushing. Nine Eve, she's
- 2:25:28not accepted yet, and she's like, here's why you should pick red.
- 2:25:31Here's why you should pick red here, or you know, probably eventually going
- 2:25:33to turn into here's why you should pick black. Yeah, but you know,
- 2:25:37yeah probably, But Maureen told Rand about that backstory at the end of
- 2:25:41season one with Leandron but I don't think that means no Alida. It's just
- 2:25:46it just grounds out relationship and more complexity and raises the stakes for Leandron's interest
- 2:25:50in nine Eve. I think they're combining Leandron and all vr in, which
- 2:25:54works for me because then Alida is still there to be the puppet. Yeah.
- 2:25:58And if you're going to pick another black Gadja character that needs presents,
- 2:26:03it's it's I think it's all vr and over Galina. Yeah, I do.
- 2:26:07I think Leandron doesn't read as the head of the red Osa to me,
- 2:26:13I know she's got her cabal I think is the word that they used.
- 2:26:18Yeah, she's got her cabal, but she to me, she doesn't
- 2:26:24read like like the head of the aja is because everyone else feels the head
- 2:26:28of that asa because everyone I think then she would have seniority over the mistress
- 2:26:33of Novices. No, no, well, I don't know. I don't
- 2:26:37know. She didn't read Gallina to me. I to me, it feels
- 2:26:39more al vr in because all VRN is the one that has the cabal that
- 2:26:45votes on eliminating Swan. So to me, that's just auguring that I love
- 2:26:54in general that they're making Leandre in a more complex character than she is in
- 2:26:56the books. Yeah, yeah, yeah, really, I think the only
- 2:27:01dark friend in the books with uh, well yeah, the only never mind.
- 2:27:07I'm liking that all of them are more complex than they are in the
- 2:27:11books because it more closely gets at Robert Jordan's thesis about how complex notions the
- 2:27:16notions of good and evil are and that no one is too far gone.
- 2:27:18Yeah uh squeal masrum Tayee mentioned in The White Tower that was fun Paren has
- 2:27:24a beard, likely getting at his growing connection with the wild and his maturation.
- 2:27:30He doesn't need fi Iel to necessarily start that transformation. Also points at
- 2:27:35the passage of time. Yes, yes, because time has passed and between
- 2:27:41seasons is a good time to do that. That's like the time to do
- 2:27:43the best time to do that, because otherwise it is a little jarring,
- 2:27:48you know, it's hard to it's hard to stick that landing. I like
- 2:27:52the combination of Elias and Hearin because to me, they're functionally the same.
- 2:27:54I love hearing he's funny, he's goofy. You know that apisode of Always
- 2:28:00Sonny where they talk about Mac and Charlie Wright a movie, and the movie
- 2:28:05is about Dolph Lungren playing a scientist who can smell crime. Yes, that's
- 2:28:11always kind of what I think about when I think about Hurin. That's very
- 2:28:16valid. I like Kieran, he's a nice guy. He's a cool character.
- 2:28:20What if they got inspired by reading by reading Robert Try it's not out
- 2:28:24of the question, that would be hilarious. Massima immediately says something religious upon
- 2:28:28finding the dead bodies. Yeah, I loved that detail. Ink Tar also
- 2:28:33insists on burying them, which is straight out of the direct the book,
- 2:28:37and also showcases his later traitors deeds because he identifies with the baddies. Oh.
- 2:28:43I like the focus of Lan and his commitment to his oaths to Moraine,
- 2:28:48whether or not like he's obligated to stick with them. It shows how
- 2:28:54in it he is, like that he's not needing to like go do his
- 2:28:58own thing now that like the bond's gone, because his oaths are what really
- 2:29:01matters to him as a person. Yeah, And I was like, potentially
- 2:29:05the only thing that can compete with that would be a different kind of oath,
- 2:29:11like a marriage vow. That's real. So something that I've noticed they
- 2:29:16haven't brought up as much on the show is the you know, suicidal drive
- 2:29:24to reclaim malk here or die trying. We have kind of talked about it
- 2:29:28a little bit. I here's my thing. I think that that is going
- 2:29:33to come up when it's relevant. And I don't think it's been relevant yet.
- 2:29:39Like I think that they have been because there's a lot of like,
- 2:29:43well, why haven't they talked about this yet? And I'm not being mean
- 2:29:46about it. I'm just saying there's been a lot of why haven't they talked
- 2:29:48about this yet? From myself included, why haven't they talked about this yet?
- 2:29:54This is really important information? Is it cut? And then this season
- 2:29:58has shown that, like, no, weaves aren't cut, Like the different
- 2:30:01kinds of the threats of the power aren't cut. It's just that it's a
- 2:30:07lot of information to get get across to a new audience in a visual way.
- 2:30:16It's a lot of exposition to get through. This season's already I think
- 2:30:20a lot more exposition heavy than season one, just in this first episode,
- 2:30:24right, And I think we can get away with that because the audience is
- 2:30:26on board at this point, right, and we've still peppered it with a
- 2:30:31fuck load of action. I mean that fade fight was was amazing. Oh
- 2:30:33god. Yeah, And the fact that they shot that over two days is
- 2:30:37I all can't get over that fucking bananas. Yeah, I can't get over
- 2:30:41it either. So to me, we haven't established O gear settings either.
- 2:30:48We haven't established a lot. We haven't established to lybry and Riod, we
- 2:30:52haven't established a ton of important stuff about the Yeah, the X ray did,
- 2:30:56but like those people are, Yeah, that's going to be something that
- 2:30:58people are they're going to know or they're not going to know, you know.
- 2:31:01But I feel like, you know, to Lyran Red, we're not
- 2:31:05going to bring that up until Land fears in the picture, because that's not
- 2:31:07going to be important until Land Feer's here, right, Yeah, probably that's
- 2:31:11the important time for that. I was surprised that they didn't bring up malk
- 2:31:18Heir more in toward the end of season one, but I think that they
- 2:31:24had a lot of other shit to do. Is it possible also that malk
- 2:31:31Heir will become more of a driving force when there is an iota of hope
- 2:31:35behind it, because because Land has his line in season one to Maurain before
- 2:31:41you, I had nothing to live for and nothing to die for, and
- 2:31:43I know the ubbed. A lot of people are the wrong way because because
- 2:31:46Land's thing kind of in the books as he's like, well, eventually I'm
- 2:31:50gonna go die in the Blake. Yeah, but I think in his mind
- 2:31:52he could interpret that as nothing right, because he's like, there is no
- 2:31:56city, there is no there are no people there, there's not like it
- 2:32:01is a hopeless cause that he will eventually try and do by himself. Yeah,
- 2:32:09but like I just I wonder if this but can I g please please
- 2:32:13let you're done? Sorry, But the thing that she gave him was something
- 2:32:16something more real to die for, which is like if he dies for saving
- 2:32:22the world versus useless question to the blight, right, that potentially is real
- 2:32:30slash. If they defeat the Dark, Malkire might get saved anyway, So
- 2:32:35she might have actually given him something real to die for. I wonder also
- 2:32:39if we're going to see down the line a situation where there becomes a more
- 2:32:46tangible goal for malk here and he is being drawn towards Malkir not because he
- 2:32:52has decided that it's time to you know, it's death time, but rather
- 2:32:58because by the way, again we're in book what nine and a half,
- 2:33:01he hasn't mentioned Milk here since I don't know book four. Well, I
- 2:33:07also think potentially his growing relationship and connection with nine Eve is another really good
- 2:33:13reason to bring it up. Yeah, yeah, as just as a thought,
- 2:33:16you know, I think that's the most relevant time potentially to bring that
- 2:33:22up. Is like, oh no, when I said when I like rejected
- 2:33:26you after we had sex, well, not really rejected you, just was
- 2:33:31like both of us have our causes and have things we need to do.
- 2:33:35Also, the additional thing is like I don't want to make you freaking widow.
- 2:33:39Yeah, which is most of what he says in the book. Yeah,
- 2:33:41but I think that like them just like doing it, and him going,
- 2:33:46well, I don't think we can really be more than this, Like
- 2:33:50that's one thing, but like it's it's at the point where like they might
- 2:33:54love each other, and I think that just one season is a little too
- 2:33:58fast for that to a conversation. That's when that really becomes relevant. Sure,
- 2:34:03and him kind of going like, yeah, but this can't this still
- 2:34:07can't happen even though like at this point we're in love. I mean that's
- 2:34:09the time, Yeah, uh do we talk about in tars I know this
- 2:34:15is probably the next time we see them. Oh, oh, actually,
- 2:34:18do we want to talk about because but I also just want to say,
- 2:34:22hey, we're getting c folk also Game of Houses? Yeah they named off
- 2:34:26that. Did they name drop Game of Houses? But I just thought like
- 2:34:31Morain was showcasing she said Game of Houses. Oh yeah, okay, yeah,
- 2:34:35we're getting that. I was going to say, do we want to
- 2:34:52talk about in tar the funeral scene now or later later because it's not in
- 2:34:58order yet. Okay, do we want to talk about I have Well,
- 2:35:01I think we passed this already if we're talking about parents. Oh yeah,
- 2:35:05Leandrin, Shiiam, the other Ice, Elana, the rest of them talking
- 2:35:11about nineve remind the people where you are in your journey with Shiiam in the
- 2:35:16books right now? Oh, she is definitely black Asia, But I think
- 2:35:22she's a triple agent. And to me, oh, to me, this
- 2:35:26makes sense because I think she is being set up as someone a little bit
- 2:35:30more complicated in her allegiances. To me, she is a lot more of
- 2:35:33a question mark in the series. In the TV series, sure, but
- 2:35:37like, maybe I'm wrong about that. I just also think that's another one
- 2:35:39where I'm like, Okay, but to me, all of the signs are
- 2:35:43there, do you have any thoughts on them? Choosing to have specifically Leandrin
- 2:35:50and Shiiam be the ones to discuss how we need to take good care of
- 2:35:54ninive Elmira. She's the best weapon we've had against the Dark in a long
- 2:35:58time, and that being the thing that ultimately gets Shiriam to agree to let
- 2:36:05Leandrin. Oh, yeah, oh, I can't believe I even forgot to
- 2:36:09write any Did I forget to write this all down? But yeah, that's
- 2:36:13definitely discuis it? What would you like to say about it? I've said
- 2:36:16everything I want to say because I want this to be make it. I
- 2:36:20don't want to inform your opinion one way or the other on Shirium because I
- 2:36:24know how much information you have which has led you to the conclusion that which
- 2:36:28I think is a reasonable conclusion. She is either black Auja or she is
- 2:36:31working for the Black Ogua. She's definitely working for it, considering she was
- 2:36:35shielded and beaten by almost definitely Helema. Well, she's definitely the first step
- 2:36:41which is black Auja for sure, like and so that conversation is loaded regardless
- 2:36:46of whether or not she is a triple agent. I really want to see
- 2:36:50her interact with either Swan or Moraine or Leanna. Like what, well,
- 2:36:56no, Leanna doesn't know, so either Swan or Maraine. I want to
- 2:36:58see her interact. No, I just want to see her interreck WITHSS one
- 2:37:01because I think, to me, that will tell me a lot or nothing.
- 2:37:05But like, I just I feel like Rave is doing a lot of
- 2:37:09really great layered foreshadowing in here. All I would agree with all of that.
- 2:37:13And I mean, what did they say. They say she's the best
- 2:37:18weapon that we have against the Dart obviously, then they share a look have
- 2:37:22to turn her to our side, And I mean I think that there is
- 2:37:26dirty rushing of nine Eve in part because it's like, well, she's one
- 2:37:30of the most powerful channelers ever, obviously we need her on our side,
- 2:37:33Slash. We need all of them potentially on our side, because Rand will
- 2:37:35buckle like a tissue paper if that's the case. The boy loves his friends,
- 2:37:41Slash. There was some leaked script a while ago that said that A
- 2:37:46Shamel was loose Sarren's best friend. Yeah, that was a Gwain audition script.
- 2:37:50Yeah, I'm thinking that they're going with all of the forsake and have
- 2:37:54some kind of friendship, love affairs, something connection to loose what's true in
- 2:38:00the books. It is true in the books, and I think they're going
- 2:38:03deeper with that, and I think it's going to have like bigger implications for
- 2:38:07Rand's friends, especially people like you know, especially when they're getting at the
- 2:38:11like who is a monster? And like could paren Matt ninive a GWayne make
- 2:38:18decisions that end up being in favor of the dark. I mean, Shamel
- 2:38:22is pretty fucking convincing. He's he's doing a good job this turn, and
- 2:38:26the White Cloaks are real bad, and like, so like who is good
- 2:38:30in this situation? Who's actually good? Who's actually bad? It's all very
- 2:38:35hot, nuanced, and so I feel like, I mean, if Rance
- 2:38:39passed, it's like I made all the wrong decisions when it came to my
- 2:38:45friends and loved ones except for el Yana, and that resulted in me and
- 2:38:48el Yana get Yana, me killing el Yana, I mean well, and
- 2:38:54not to mention that I was like Latriposi feels like a real stand in for
- 2:38:58a GWayne in that one scene, right, I think they are definitely definitely
- 2:39:03carrying the Latropossai is a GWayne stuff. I think they're playing around a fuck
- 2:39:09load with like loose Theren's past and how it equates to Rand's future slash presence.
- 2:39:13I think Latropossei being a character who's really only mentioned in the Strike at
- 2:39:18child Ghoul being in episode eight. We've talked about this last season some,
- 2:39:24but I absolutely do think they're going to pull through that through line of the
- 2:39:26gwayn Latropossei. I think it's all but certain to me that they're like expanding
- 2:39:31upon this idea of like these were once Louse Thearren's friends and like they fucked
- 2:39:37him over big time, big time, So like can we trust Rand's judgment
- 2:39:43and friends? Will these people actually get tempted by the dark because like we
- 2:39:48watch something like Harry Potter hashag trans Lives Matter. I mean we're like never
- 2:39:50concerned that Harmione or Ron are going to turn on Harry. No, but
- 2:39:54if we're at cerned, but the one time in book seven, well seconds
- 2:40:00with the whore Crux, well, and that was kind of freaking scary.
- 2:40:03Am I wrong? Like you're like, oh my god, what happened to
- 2:40:05Ron? But we're already playing around with like is Matt good guy? How
- 2:40:11do you feel about that? By the way, sorry, continue to continue.
- 2:40:13I do. I mean, obviously Matt is a good guy. We
- 2:40:16know this, but like, I like the idea of playing with I mean,
- 2:40:20if we're really blurring the boundaries and lines of like good guy versus bad
- 2:40:26guy, which again I really do think goes back to Robert Jordan's initial thesis.
- 2:40:31Oh yeah, a lot. I think it's just expanding upon it and
- 2:40:35adding to it. I think that playing with like, does Matt have the
- 2:40:41potential to be a bad guy? Does Paren have the potential to be a
- 2:40:45bad guy? Does nine Eve with being like pals with Leandron for a little
- 2:40:50while have the potential to be a bad guy and angry at the world?
- 2:40:54Yeah? I mean Leandron's arguments were compelling. Yeah right, She's like,
- 2:41:00Okay, I know you're miss healer girl and want to save the world.
- 2:41:03Well have you heard about our Lord and savior, mister Heelman, Who's going
- 2:41:09to break the wheel and make everything better because, like I make it so
- 2:41:13that little girls don't suffer anymore. Which, by the way, who hurt
- 2:41:16Leandron? Oh yes, somebody hurt Leandre. Somebody fucked with Leandren. So
- 2:41:20she is a real specific thing about like little girls getting hurt by men.
- 2:41:26Yes she does. Let's go back real quick to Matt, because I want
- 2:41:30to touch on something. I know he's barely in this episode. I know,
- 2:41:33I know, I know, I know. We'll talk about Matt when
- 2:41:35we get there. But that's all on purpose. Yeah, I think Matt
- 2:41:41specifically, they almost kind of fell into a complimentary growth thing for him with
- 2:41:50Barney Harris leaving the show, which is Matt starts the season. Obviously,
- 2:41:56he's come from a place of enormous hurt, et cetera, et cetera.
- 2:42:01He's doing good things and he kind of doesn't really want to, but he
- 2:42:05continues to do good things for the entire season, and then episode six happens
- 2:42:09and he bails because of you know, things outside of the control of the
- 2:42:15student, the things outside of everybody's control. And now we get to see
- 2:42:20him recover from that because now he has done something wrong, he has done
- 2:42:26a bad thing, and now he has that backing his actions as he makes
- 2:42:33efforts not to do bad things again. Yeah, which which I think is
- 2:42:39almost more compelling than a guy who doesn't want to do the right thing but
- 2:42:43always does. Is a guy who doesn't want to do the right thing,
- 2:42:48who doesn't always want to do the right thing, but he knows what will
- 2:42:50happen if he doesn't. Yeah, because he's been there, because he's experienced
- 2:42:54it. Yeah, I yeah, there's a lot. I'm just excited to
- 2:42:58see what I do. Anyway, I've taken you far afield from your notes.
- 2:43:01Well, and I had a thought about that too, and I'm trying
- 2:43:03to think. I'm just Oh. People complaining about Random Matt not being in
- 2:43:09the episode, it's for a large portion of it. It's because the plot
- 2:43:15question of the episode was where is everybody? And the two most important people
- 2:43:18to find and the two people were going to have the most questions about are
- 2:43:24Random Matt. Yeah, I mean Rand is essential to find. So if
- 2:43:28the question is like where are we? Where is everybody? We can't have
- 2:43:31Rand in a large portion of the episode because then we answered the question too
- 2:43:37soon. Yeah. Like Rand's location is the most compelling thing in the entire
- 2:43:43episode. And I'm not laughing at you, I'm just I'm just speaking,
- 2:43:50But it is the it is the climactic thing about this episode, and so
- 2:43:54to reveal him too soon would be to make the episode not interesting? Yeah,
- 2:43:58does that makes sense? Cool? Okay? Oh, so Ninety've kind
- 2:44:07of is like dealing with her block through playing swords with the warders right,
- 2:44:11with which Leandron takes issue with later. But part of that is kind of
- 2:44:16hinting at the key to breaking her block being through a warder, specifically Land.
- 2:44:22Also, let's clock how much Land being in danger helps her channels being
- 2:44:28threatened in some way? It does? Can I also say that I love
- 2:44:31what they're doing with the block. I love what they're doing with the block.
- 2:44:35I love what they're doing. I think it is it's kind of implied
- 2:44:39that it's been there from from the beginning, the first time she channels because
- 2:44:43she's not hearing wind anymore. But I think we said this last season.
- 2:44:46I think specifically tying this explicitly mentally connecting it to Amalisa again, as we
- 2:44:56said, using their power to do these things and letting that be what keeps
- 2:45:01ninety Eve from accessing her own abilities is such a great expansion on like what
- 2:45:09Jordan already put in there, because her you know, I think it's very
- 2:45:13much the same thing as in the books, is that her power, her
- 2:45:16block is because she's afraid of watching New Well, one of my big issues
- 2:45:20that I've taken with Robert Jordan is that I don't think he explores women's trauma
- 2:45:24enough when his whole thing is exploring like kind of the trauma of what war
- 2:45:30does to people. Yeah, the women endure traumatic events in those books.
- 2:45:33And this is with all the love and respect, but I think that he
- 2:45:39was a little bit limited in how he explored some of that trauma. Sure,
- 2:45:43right, And I think a lot of we've talked extensively about this on
- 2:45:48the podcast, right, that I wish that he had delved more into how
- 2:45:52these events affected the women in it, because I felt like the men got
- 2:45:58a lot of to explore what was happening to them, and a lot of
- 2:46:03grace in those moments too, that I don't necessarily think happened for the women
- 2:46:09the same In the same way, I don't think the same energy was given
- 2:46:13to like Ogwayne when she gets kidnapped by the shan Chan. She's there for
- 2:46:16about two months. Yeah, that's fucking traumatic, and then she like thinks
- 2:46:22about for a minute that she won't be chained again. But at this point
- 2:46:26it doesn't. It's obliquely mentioned, and it affects her as a character building
- 2:46:30device, but the trauma's not brought up very often, whereas every woman that's
- 2:46:35ever died near rand is brought up all the time. Yeah, you know,
- 2:46:39it's just kind of like, Okay, it's feeling like they're not.
- 2:46:43The trauma that women experience is not given equal weight. It just isn't.
- 2:46:48And I'm sure people have some arguments about it, but like I just don't
- 2:46:52feel that it is, and I am enjoying that. It feels like Rafe
- 2:46:56is letting the story also go there. Yeah, I agree with that and
- 2:47:01exploring like not just war trauma, but trauma as a whole, and like
- 2:47:05how that can make you do wonderful things right sometimes with that, like you
- 2:47:13can create better worlds for yourself out of trauma, not through trauma, but
- 2:47:18like you can take a terrible experience and make light for yourself. You can
- 2:47:22do that. Or sometimes trauma can make people do awful things, can have
- 2:47:31people traumatize others, very real, very valid. Makes the whole good and
- 2:47:37evil question really big. It's a big complicated thing. In order to have
- 2:47:43a longevity in a series, we kind of have to tackle big complicated things.
- 2:47:48Oh, also ninety having to show difference to Alana due to her orders
- 2:47:52when Land might become one is a fucking lot because Maxim goes, that's a
- 2:47:56lot of soniety to you. I like the relationship they're exploring with nine,
- 2:48:03even the warders. I think it she doesn't like Isidi. It's in the
- 2:48:07books she hates. She really fucking doesn't like Isidai, especially Warrain. But
- 2:48:11she really doesn't like Isidi. And I appreciate that they've given her the warders
- 2:48:16as people to attempt to commune with Ninyve thumping stick al Mira. It stands
- 2:48:24to reason would get along with the guys who like to hit things. Well,
- 2:48:26not to mention they're her only connection to Land. Yeah, yeah,
- 2:48:31like there Land's friends. Lane introduced her to them, Land played with them
- 2:48:35and the with the warders in the training yard, right, like, so
- 2:48:39she is connected to him in doing this, Yeah, and that matters.
- 2:48:41And I think also it's smart from a storytelling perspective because like Ninive cannot confide
- 2:48:48in Agwayne, like Agwayne confides in her, because Agwayne to Ninive is not
- 2:48:52a peer. Niniva is a Gwayne's mentor. Niniva is a Gwayne's protector.
- 2:48:56So Ninive cannot confide in Agwayne like a Gwen can confide in her. A
- 2:49:01teacher cannot confide in a student like a student can confide in a teacher.
- 2:49:05A parent cannot confide in a child like a child can confide in a parent.
- 2:49:07It is not that kind of equal relationship. And whether whether whether or
- 2:49:13not, really quick sorry, whether or not, that is actually the state
- 2:49:16of a Gwenna Ninive's relationship. It is certainly how Ninive perceives it, right.
- 2:49:20That's the thing is Niney perceives it that way, and that matters to
- 2:49:22Ninive when it comes to who Nineve is going to approach, and Ninive is
- 2:49:26never going to approach. I mean, she kind of starts to with Leandron,
- 2:49:30but Ninive is never really going to approach the other eyes to die about
- 2:49:35her problems, right because she doesn't want to admit she needs help from them,
- 2:49:41right, because then she will have to deal with her trauma, right,
- 2:49:46She'll have to address her her like inabilities. And Ninive is not someone
- 2:49:50who can accept that she is not good at something, right, But she
- 2:49:56can look at these warders as appear because they are in her mind equivalent,
- 2:50:03well not equivalent to but the next best thing to land. Yeah, So
- 2:50:07all of that to me, like, so that from a storytelling perspective,
- 2:50:11that one episode where everyone's like, why are we spending so much time with
- 2:50:15the warders, it's so that nine Eve has an outlet so that we can
- 2:50:18get an insight into nine Eve's internal life, which is vital on a TV
- 2:50:22show. We need to be able. Ninive is not a character that will
- 2:50:24open up to just anyone. If like Elaine just showed up and Ninety started
- 2:50:30spilling her guts, that would not be nine Eve. So we had to
- 2:50:33give her early on a vehicle so that when she's in the White Tower she
- 2:50:37has someone to confide in, especially in absence of internal inner monologue. And
- 2:50:43if we don't get that from a book series that is absolutely dripping in rich
- 2:50:48internal monologue, we need to figure out how are we gonna show it,
- 2:50:52how are we going to get into it, how do we externalize the internal.
- 2:50:56It's fucking hard, which is also why we talk about how parent is
- 2:50:58like the hardest goddamn character to right for screen, which is why we had
- 2:51:01to kill Leila Matt to get him to open up and actually be vulnerable and
- 2:51:07real had to. We've talked about it because we know Matt is vulnerable and
- 2:51:11real in his head, but outside he's like a swaggering guy, right,
- 2:51:15So in order to give us access to that character's internal complexity, we had
- 2:51:18to give him a rough past so that we understood him. Yeah, and
- 2:51:22we can discuss behind all of these choices is our interpretation, And you don't
- 2:51:28have to like how they did it. It's just that's the explanation. So
- 2:51:33the implications of ninety preferring practical weapons when thinking about which I think we will
- 2:51:41get it's it's an iconic moment. Yeah. I do also think we're still
- 2:51:46getting the quarter staff fight, Like I still think we're getting. I think
- 2:51:50the contexts might be different, right like we've seen, but there's no like
- 2:51:54they they want to give us the iconic moments. Yeah, something that to
- 2:52:00be very vague. What I'm liking about season two is it really does feel
- 2:52:05like every episode I'm getting a scene or two or three, or four,
- 2:52:09or five or six or seven that is directly from The Great Hunt or The
- 2:52:13Dragon Reborn, but it's with the different person, or it's in a different
- 2:52:18place, but the dialogue is the same and the core of it is still
- 2:52:24there, but it's presented slightly differently, and it is always so surprising and
- 2:52:31refreshing when I see that. It is always I go, oh shit,
- 2:52:35it's this thing, as opposed to sitting there going all right, now,
- 2:52:39we're gonna go do this. Yeah. I remember when I read that it
- 2:52:41was great, And there's nothing wrong, by the way, with adapting something
- 2:52:43like that. It's just it's very different and this approach of sort of Okay,
- 2:52:48here are the moments, here are the things that people love from book
- 2:52:54two. How are we going to get these items to the screen in a
- 2:52:58way that's fun and in a way that thematically is consistent with the rest of
- 2:53:03everything, and in a way that works with where our characters were at the
- 2:53:05end of season one, because our characters were admittedly in extraordinarily different places.
- 2:53:11Yeah. Right, Book one frankly ends as though it could be a standalone
- 2:53:16Right, it could end there. There is not an extraordinarily strong hook apart
- 2:53:20from the Dragon is Reborn, which you probably already figured that out. Yeah,
- 2:53:26So, how how do we take these chess pieces that are not in
- 2:53:31our expected configuration move them about such that we find ourselves in positions we recognize.
- 2:53:39Yeah. Oh in this scene with Leandren and ninety, Yes, by
- 2:53:43the way, when she says to ninety, there's more than one way to
- 2:53:48channel. Yeah, right, Obviously that's partially I think about, you know,
- 2:53:52you don't you can be angry, you don't have to picture a fucking
- 2:53:56flower whatever. But I was also like, because I just have a hard
- 2:54:00time imagining that, like you know, mcghetti and gets up there and goes,
- 2:54:03all right, picture of rosebud, you know what I mean, surrender
- 2:54:07But yeah, but yeah, it's like there's more than maybe you surrender to
- 2:54:11your anger, right, whatever it is. But I also thought that was
- 2:54:15theoretically a hint at the true power. Oh maybe it would be interesting if
- 2:54:20the rank and file black Audra knew about that, because it's a pretty closely
- 2:54:26guarded secret in the books that the Forsaken know about. It's possible, Well
- 2:54:31yeah, I mean I don't necessarily I don't necessarily think potentially that niney that
- 2:54:37Leandra knew about it. Oh, I think that that like she needs like
- 2:54:41the is said, I don't understand that there's more than one way to channel.
- 2:54:46Could also be not a hint that Leandred knows about the true power,
- 2:54:50but also a nod to the true power. Sure, we'll get to the
- 2:54:54funeral scene. Want I did want to talk about this because what you thought.
- 2:55:00I've seen varying reactions online between book readers who who argue they're pushing way
- 2:55:07too hard, Intar is way too obvious, and then new readers not twigging
- 2:55:11on Intar at all, and also new readers going what a sweet man,
- 2:55:16and also some new readers going interesting. I wonder why he's saying that,
- 2:55:18I'm suspicious. I really kind of appreciate because of that how effective this choice
- 2:55:28was. You know, I think it's very you know, it can certainly
- 2:55:33be read as there are good people on both sides, but that's really not
- 2:55:37how I see it. I think he's saying, essentially, he's not trying
- 2:55:41to justify when he talks about padent Fane's actions. He's not saying he had
- 2:55:46a good reason, right. Yeah, He's telling Parrien, this guy certainly,
- 2:55:50almost certainly had some reason for doing this. And I'm not saying you
- 2:55:54have to agree with it or respect it, but remember that he is he
- 2:56:00came to this process by he came to this point by way of a process,
- 2:56:05and I think if we tie that back to the cold open to the
- 2:56:11season, which I really think is the choice to use the Dark Friend's social
- 2:56:16in this way as a prequel kind of really marries quite well with one of
- 2:56:20Robert Jordan's core themes, which has to do with how you're not not too
- 2:56:24far gone, et cetera. Is its balance, its grayness, et cetera.
- 2:56:28And I think it means we're going to be exploring much more of sort
- 2:56:33of why have the Friends of the Dark become Friends of the Dark? Yeah,
- 2:56:39in a way that perhaps by dint of intent, or by dint of
- 2:56:45the time they were released, or by dint of something else, I don't
- 2:56:48know. The books tend perhaps to go a little bit more towards well,
- 2:56:50they were greedy, so therefore now they are dark friends. Mm hmm.
- 2:56:54And I think a lot of us know people have made bad decisions or done
- 2:56:58bad things or hurt us. Where By the way, I'm not saying that's
- 2:57:01the books don't treat dark Friends greatly. They absolutely do. Yeah, I'm
- 2:57:07just saying a lot of them are very correct. I mean, I think
- 2:57:11I think a lot of us know people who have done bad things and bad
- 2:57:16things to us where you go, Okay, it doesn't excuse what they did,
- 2:57:20but there are explanations for why they behaved a certain way, right they
- 2:57:24thought maybe they thought they were doing the right thing based on flawed principles.
- 2:57:28Maybe it is self preservation. Maybe, And that doesn't excuse them doing horrible
- 2:57:33things. It's just like most of the time, people don't do bad stuff
- 2:57:37for no reason. Yeah, there's usually kind of a trail. And I
- 2:57:41think in deepening the backstories of some of these dark Friends a little bit,
- 2:57:45Yeah, like you said, it gets at Robert Jordan's thesis. But I
- 2:57:46think the other thing that it does is it makes them more fleshed out and
- 2:57:52complicated, which makes us more invested in them, in their journey and their
- 2:57:56arc. But it also and like it grounds the story in something very real,
- 2:58:03which I think serves again what Robert Jordan was doing. But the other
- 2:58:07thing that I think is that it makes the characters actually more threatening to me
- 2:58:11because they have motivation. And so you know, like while Leandren might do
- 2:58:18might seem invested in nine Eve, perhaps there are additional things that are fueling
- 2:58:26her that she won't she would put before nine Eve. Yeah, do you
- 2:58:31know what I mean, yeah, and of course we can talk more about
- 2:58:35that too, But I liked that in this scene he is showing compassion for
- 2:58:43people even though they maybe don't deserve it. And I think there's a way
- 2:58:48to do that in a hot, nuanced way where you are still protecting yourself
- 2:58:52but holding space for the fact that, yeah, you did a shitty thing.
- 2:58:56We will acknowledge that shitty thing. It doesn't excuse or just to buy
- 2:59:00your shitty thing, but we'll also hold space for the fact that maybe you
- 2:59:03are also suffering in a different way. I think that's really interesting as a
- 2:59:07concept. I think it's something that's very hard to do. Maybe after a
- 2:59:13lot of therapy in my case, I've been starting to be able to do
- 2:59:16that. But it's hard. Yeah, it's hard, and you know,
- 2:59:20obviously there's some selfish motivation behind him being like, have a heart for the
- 2:59:24dark friends, right, But I also think that it gets at potentially,
- 2:59:30and this also happens in the books. If I does, yeah, he
- 2:59:33insists they bury them. Yeah, so he also it shows the intar is
- 2:59:39a little bit about self preservation rather than principle. Yeah. He also clearly
- 2:59:43feels some humanity for the Shine Hour and that betrayed them because obviously, and
- 2:59:48I think this question if I know anything about framing, which I hope I
- 2:59:52do, or bookending something in terms of a plot. So he says to
- 3:00:00Paren, have you thought about asking Pat? And I'm going to bastardize this
- 3:00:03quote, but perhaps Pad and Fane again had a reason for doing what he
- 3:00:09did. You may not like the answer, but you may find it worth
- 3:00:11asking the question. Yeah. I feel like when ang Tar does sacrifice himself,
- 3:00:16and I think he will because I think that's where this is going,
- 3:00:20Paren is going to ask him that question. I think. So, yeah,
- 3:00:24I heard that. I think so that's what's coming and we're all gonna
- 3:00:28go, oh my god, the book end. We love a bookke Nd,
- 3:00:30I think And I've seen discussion about this on Twitter. Somebody I don't
- 3:00:35remember who put this very well. They said, I think that, as
- 3:00:39you say in Tar's sacrifice revelation, moment is going to be to Paren,
- 3:00:45not to Rand. And in light of Perrin's journey being dealing with what he
- 3:00:52considers to be a darkness within himself, dealing with the urge to do what
- 3:00:56he thinks to be dark things, violence, to kill, to be peaceful,
- 3:01:01to stand by, to not stand by. I do agree with what
- 3:01:05I've seen online that that has a lot of echo with Paren's later plot line
- 3:01:11that it you know, it works with Rand too, it affects Ran,
- 3:01:16but I think it's more directly impactful on Paren's arc down the line. Yeah,
- 3:01:22I would agree with that. I also feel like I back me up
- 3:01:26here. I clocked ingk Tar pretty fast in the books. You clockeding Tar
- 3:01:30almost immediately. Yeah, but I was still uber invested in seeing if I
- 3:01:33was right about that. Yeah, And that in itself is very exciting.
- 3:01:39So I think regardless of whether or not people latch onto ing Tar either being
- 3:01:45like that's totally a dark friend or it's totally not a dark friend, what
- 3:01:48a sweetheart or what have you, I think that the fact that opinions are
- 3:01:52forming about this character and that people are invested in seeing where that character goes,
- 3:01:56whether they think he's bad or not, is kind kind of the goal.
- 3:02:00Ultimately. I agree with that. You know, like, you're not
- 3:02:03going usually you're not going to get everything by everyone. There's always someone who's
- 3:02:07like, oh, yeah, I thought that's where that was going. Yeah,
- 3:02:09right, especially if you're someone who pays attention to storytelling patterns. You
- 3:02:15know, it's it's kind of rare that I get fully surprised by something.
- 3:02:22I would say it happens, But I think it's the kind of thing where
- 3:02:26the more the more homes you build, the more you notice how other people's
- 3:02:31homes are built. Right, Yeah, I know. The more the more
- 3:02:35you construct something, the more you look around and can the more the more
- 3:02:39you can look around and say, oh, I see you did this here,
- 3:02:43and that was to support this sort of roof, and you put these
- 3:02:46cabinets in for this reason because it complements this. And again it's not to
- 3:02:50say that we're in any way omnipotent or you know, it just means this
- 3:02:54is the thing that we have examined and studied, and therefore we can sometimes
- 3:02:58pick up on pick up on patterns. Yeah, and when you already know
- 3:03:03what where Intar's character goes, of course you're gonna think it's obvious. Yeah,
- 3:03:07because you know the result. I think that's the biggest thing that I've
- 3:03:11had to a couple things that I'm having to divorce myself from, which I'm
- 3:03:16very happy and I don't mind doing. I'm happy to divorce myself from one
- 3:03:20of them is sort of remembering I already know the broad strokes of everything that's
- 3:03:24going to happen. Right, So and Brie are our good friend who will
- 3:03:31be joining us for various full spoiler sections, probably not this episode. I
- 3:03:35don't have anything to really discuss with her this episode. But something she said
- 3:03:37is from a psychological perspective. If you're watching the show expecting to see X
- 3:03:46Y or Z thing, if you're watching the show because you're a fan of
- 3:03:50Matt, if you're watching the show because you love Intar, if you're watching
- 3:03:54the show because you really want to see you know Roydian, you are going
- 3:04:00to selectively And this isn't the criticism. This is how brains work, and
- 3:04:03we do this too. Everybody does this. You're going to selectively filter out
- 3:04:07things that don't matter to to what you are watching it for, right in
- 3:04:13the same way that your memory you filter out things that are repetitive or that
- 3:04:20the reason why the past always seems rosiers because your brain highlights the things that
- 3:04:22you liked. When you watch an adaptation of a story that you know,
- 3:04:28and you have a particular lens on that story, and certain things are more
- 3:04:31important to you than others. Your brain is going to highlight the things that
- 3:04:35matter and discard the things that don't. So because of that, all of
- 3:04:41us watching The Wheel of Time are going to have different things that we think
- 3:04:46this matters because this this matters, because that this doesn't matter. I don't
- 3:04:50understand why they're doing this because it doesn't set up X, Y, and
- 3:04:54Z thing that I care about. And oftentimes you know it'll be, uh,
- 3:05:00it may be setting something else up, but that's the plot line that
- 3:05:03either your brain has decided isn't really important, or that you forgot about,
- 3:05:07or that is new for the books, and it's derived from from for this
- 3:05:11for the show, and it's derived from something else. And and so something
- 3:05:13that I've really had to do hard is try to separate my viewing of this
- 3:05:20show from in a way, from doing what we do on the podcast,
- 3:05:24because a lot of what we do is discuss this is working for me because
- 3:05:30it ties into this thing from the book, and I like doing that and
- 3:05:33I think that that's a good thing to do. But when I'm watching the
- 3:05:37show, I also am trying really hard to judge it as sort of what
- 3:05:41story is this telling and how does that relate thematically? How does that relate
- 3:05:46more broadly? How? How? How? How does this? How can
- 3:05:50this new thing add to what I like? How can this thing that is
- 3:05:54missing take away from it? Right? This is a very long winded way
- 3:06:00to describe something. But I mean, I don't know how I got on
- 3:06:03this topic, but that's something that I've really been focusing on as we watch
- 3:06:09these new things. By the way, we're probably way to hell overdue for
- 3:06:11ads, so let's just throw a quick ad break in here. Welcome back.
- 3:06:30I'm done rambling. Oh okay, moving on from the funeral scene when
- 3:06:35we were at if I may please please, I hope you do. But
- 3:06:41yes, I think that's a really good point. I think, just to
- 3:06:43summarize, the perfect adaptation for me is going to be very different than the
- 3:06:46perfect adaptation for Gus. Yeah. Yeah, but I'm my kind of like
- 3:06:52weird little trick is I'm always like, watch it, feel your feelings,
- 3:06:56you know, and then watch it again as if you're seeing just the show.
- 3:07:01And I have found that that has really cemented my personal love for the
- 3:07:05show. It doesn't have to cement yours, but I do think it's helpful
- 3:07:09to just be like Okay, now that I know what is going on,
- 3:07:13let me just watch it for the enjoyment of it and see if I do
- 3:07:16enjoy it, because I'm having a freaking blast. But during the Matt scene
- 3:07:22where he pulls the armore down to pull a shashank, at first both I
- 3:07:26and a friend thought he was going to try hanging himself. I didn't get
- 3:07:30that at all. I'm okay, fair, but I just thought that was
- 3:07:33kind of interesting considering that happened to Matt in the books. Yes, absolutely,
- 3:07:39I didn't get that at all. Again, we're talking about how we
- 3:07:41perceive things differently, but I get what you're saying. I just thought that
- 3:07:43was kind of interesting. Yeah. Yeah, oh, Leandren lies while reading
- 3:07:48him the letter. Probably I can see how one could construct an argument that
- 3:07:52a five mentions are not a single mention. But I'm gonna go ahead and
- 3:07:56call this one a lie because a lot of new readers I saw online said
- 3:07:58I thought, and I said, I couldn't lie when that happened, which
- 3:08:01I kind of delighted it. Yeah, I do think that was deliberate,
- 3:08:05Yeah, I do. I do think it was kind of like for those
- 3:08:07of you paying attention, which it slipped by me at first when we first
- 3:08:11watched it, it slipped by me that she was lying. And then I
- 3:08:15went back and I went, oh my god, and someone else pointed it
- 3:08:18out to me. A friend of mine pointed out to me. She was
- 3:08:20like, oh my god, she lied, and oh my god, she
- 3:08:22did. They're setting they're setting these clues up very subtly. And that's kind
- 3:08:28of all I have for spoilers. Yeah, anything else you want to talk
- 3:08:33about? Yeah, yeah, I want to talk about the faith fight.
- 3:08:35I want to talk about the end. I want to talk about the fad
- 3:08:37fight. I want to talk about spoilers. Yeah, okay, Yeah,
- 3:08:41I want to talk about landin Warain's relationship a little bit. I already touched
- 3:08:48on this earlier, but I think this is something I want to address,
- 3:08:52which is that I've seen a lot of people on Twitter both say and by
- 3:08:56the way, the point of this podcast is not rebut Twitter. It's just
- 3:08:58I know I know that this is something when we say we saw X on
- 3:09:01Twitter, it's not And here's why you're wrong. That's not the intention.
- 3:09:05It is sort of here is our perspective on this thing that we know people
- 3:09:09are talking about and here's why you're wrong. No, People arguing on Twitter
- 3:09:13both that it is unrealistic that Lan lost to two Fades okay, and also
- 3:09:22it is it is massively sorry, people saying both the Fades seemed way way
- 3:09:31stronger and Lan has been nerved versus how he is in the books. And
- 3:09:35I've also seen people say it is unrealistic that Lan wasn't made mincemeat of in
- 3:09:41five minutes, okay by two fades. And there's a wonderful Twitter thread by
- 3:09:48at Amy KCT on Twitter, and I did speak with Amy got Amy's permission
- 3:09:52to talk about this because I think this is a fantastic thread. I'm going
- 3:09:56to read all of it that I can. Given fadegate aka whether Land should
- 3:10:01have been able to do better than he did against all those Fades, I
- 3:10:05thought it would be worth doing a thread of fade scenes from the books Chapter
- 3:10:09thirty nine, Dragon Reborn seven Ieel are about to fight three Fades. Before
- 3:10:13the fight can begin, the Wonder Girls kill the Fades. Rourke says he
- 3:10:18is glad of it, as the Aeel could have killed the Fades, but
- 3:10:20that the Fades would have killed at least two or three more of them.
- 3:10:24Five IELs survived this Chapter eighteen I of the World. Quote. Then Lan
- 3:10:30was on the mere drawl. Warren Warden's blade met black steel with a clang
- 3:10:35like a great bell. Those two fought in a great circle, black horses
- 3:10:39marching step for step, swords matching stroke for stroke. End quote. Land
- 3:10:43did kill the Fade, but it took time and they were evenly matched.
- 3:10:48M Chapter twenty five, Great Hunt. Tom says that his leg was injured
- 3:10:52by the Fade in Whitebridge, but he survived because the Fade ran off after
- 3:10:56Matt and Rand at the first opportunity. He has a limp that cannot be
- 3:11:01healed. Oh that's another thing. Tom. Killing that Fade is going to
- 3:11:03make him seem way more badass. He doesn't kill it. Oh I forgot.
- 3:11:07He isn't. Oh you just said that he doesn't kill it. But
- 3:11:09Tom at least holding his own against it. It's big. Yeah, it's
- 3:11:13like because I maintain he's not just an average singer and storyteller, so well,
- 3:11:20you know he's not. Well, I know he's not, but I
- 3:11:22you know, I think that the reader the watchers will start to feel that
- 3:11:26way too when he shows up Chapter ten, Shadow Rising quote for a time
- 3:11:31it was all Rand could do to keep its blade from his own unarmored flesh.
- 3:11:35Rand fought as coldly as he ever had, and as desperately the fade
- 3:11:39knew the use of a sword. Then an instant came when he could strike
- 3:11:43a blow squarely at the sword itself. So very much either series, are
- 3:11:48they made knowing how to sword fight? Or is there a little adorable good
- 3:11:52question? He seems so. Chapter twenty two, Fires of Heaven, the
- 3:11:56trolic went down with a ruined throat, and Matt found himself facing a Mirr
- 3:12:01drawl just as it finished, killing two y eel who would commeted together two
- 3:12:05of them end quote. He talks about the need to overwhelm them and not
- 3:12:07being able to spare a glance for the battle around them. Chapter eight I
- 3:12:13of the World quote. Mir drawls see like eagles in darkness or in light,
- 3:12:18but they have no eyes. I can think a few things more dangerous
- 3:12:22than facing a Mirr drawl. Waain said, I and I both tried to
- 3:12:26kill the one that was here last night, and we failed every time.
- 3:12:31End quote. And I also say we saw Land and Moraine and Land's sword
- 3:12:35fighting abilities very clearly from the pilot right the pilot. They worked hand in
- 3:12:41hand. They were, you know, fluid. They were basically in this
- 3:12:46dance that connected one another's movements. I think that also Land is purposefully weaker
- 3:12:50here due to the bond between him and Morain not existing. It's possible,
- 3:12:56but I think we don't know enough about the metaphysics to say for sure.
- 3:13:00But I think that's very positive. I mean, I think whether or not
- 3:13:03he's physically weaker or whatever metaphysics society, there is mental. Yeah, there's
- 3:13:09a mental aspect to it that I feel is prevalent. Like prior, when
- 3:13:13he's going into battle, he has Morain to back him up. Also,
- 3:13:18not to mention, she's wounded and he doesn't know how badly, and he's
- 3:13:22trying to keep them away from her, whereas in the past he was trying
- 3:13:26to keep them away from her, but she was fully capable of taking care
- 3:13:31of herself. Also, it's a very different kind of fight because they could
- 3:13:35easily while he's distracted with one show up in front of her and stabber why
- 3:13:39not. Yeah, clearly she's the target. Chapter six, Great Hunt.
- 3:13:45Rand turns a corner and finds six dead Chinarins, a seventh man dies at
- 3:13:50the hand of a mirr drawl. As Rand watches, the Fade moves with
- 3:13:52viparous grace. That's Chinarns, they're really tough. It starts toward Rand.
- 3:13:56Next, Rand's hands shake as he raised is his sword. Suddenly the Fades
- 3:14:01stops smiling, and finally, chapter five, the Dragon Reborn, a pack
- 3:14:05of seven wolves bring down a Fade at the cost of all but one of
- 3:14:09their lives. So I think my personal opinion is this scene is pretty well
- 3:14:15balanced. Considering that Land decapitates one Fade. I'm okay with it being down
- 3:14:20after it's decapitated, and that one of them took a massive stab through the
- 3:14:24neck and then got back up. As far as I can tell, I
- 3:14:26think I think Land being ultimately felled by one and a half Fades makes sense
- 3:14:33to me. Yeah, I think. Also with no Morain and no Bond
- 3:14:37and him trying to protect a injured woman, yeah, I think, yeah,
- 3:14:41that makes sense to me. It also, it doesn't have to make
- 3:14:43sense one to one. From the books, fades can be more or less
- 3:14:46powerful. These Fades might be holding back. There's a lot of things we
- 3:14:50can talk about here. I just wanted to bring that up in the context
- 3:14:52of discussion of is this unrealistic with what we know about fades, either from
- 3:14:58the show or from the books. I think it is easy for us to
- 3:15:03get lost in without giving too much away later books where people are kind of
- 3:15:07nuke and fades on site. Yeah, but here's the thing about that.
- 3:15:11We have to give them room to grow. Yeah, it's power creepy.
- 3:15:15Yeah, it's not right now. I mean season one trollis were the real
- 3:15:20big dads difficult to kill? I mean, obviously there was like one or
- 3:15:24two fades, but we never saw them really engage in battle that I remember,
- 3:15:28not really. Yeah. I mean there were three at the end there
- 3:15:30in the throne room. Yeah, but we never we didn't get to see
- 3:15:33their skill. Yeah. Oh, did you want to talk at all about
- 3:15:35the stab? You had some frustration with that. I was a little bit
- 3:15:41surprised that they didn't mention how anything about them having been stabbed. But at
- 3:15:50the same time, when I'm thinking about the explanations of things, it is
- 3:15:54months later, so those stab wounds might not be relevant. They might not
- 3:15:58know I mean, because I think only Loyal was shown to be stabbed by
- 3:16:03Padent Fane with the dagger, I think everyone else it looked like got taking
- 3:16:05now by faith, yes, which made me kind of go, Okay,
- 3:16:09maybe they're playing with the metaphysics of the dagger a little bit and saying that
- 3:16:13O gear might not be as suscepted. You know, what kills a human
- 3:16:18might not kill an elephant kind of thing. I was a little surprised that
- 3:16:20they didn't provide an explanation, but that doesn't necessarily mean they won't once they
- 3:16:28understand the metaphysics of the dagger with like to Rock's death, yeah, I
- 3:16:33will also doesn't a stabbed by the dagger, Yeah he does. No Rand
- 3:16:37kills him with the strok. I thought that that battle Matt stabs somebody with
- 3:16:43the dagger. Matt doesn't have the no yeah, and someone melts face to
- 3:16:48God in Great Hunt. I swear to God, No, No Rand kills
- 3:16:52Tuak in a sword fight in the book. I thought that that Matt slashed
- 3:16:56him like defending Rand. He slashes a sogoon or a duck all with it.
- 3:17:03Doesn't slash tarrok Oh, but he does slash somebody somebody somebody like withers
- 3:17:07and dies from it. Yeah, I think you're right. I'm remembering now,
- 3:17:09but it's not to rok Rand kills to Rock with a sword, which
- 3:17:13is how he kind of formally becomes a blade master. But I think that
- 3:17:16that's probably the opportunity if they're going to explain it at all, which maybe
- 3:17:20they won't, but I have a hard time believing that they won't to explain
- 3:17:24it just because it is such a big thing. But like I mean,
- 3:17:28if Matt, but they've never seen a human be affected by the Dager.
- 3:17:31It is a big thing in the books. It is possible that the Dagger
- 3:17:35in the show is evil to hold, less, evil to stab, and
- 3:17:39that's possible that they're altering that too. Yeah, maybe they're like, I
- 3:17:43want to spend my special effects budget on something else. Could be I don't
- 3:17:46know. We'll, we'll, we'll, we'll wait and see. I guess
- 3:17:48it might be fair considering how much how many effects there are and how expensive
- 3:17:56they are. They're so expensive. Yeah, so that's uh, that is
- 3:18:00all I have. I think this episode did a great job of I mean
- 3:18:05again, our friend Bree described it as like eleven thousand inciting incidents and it
- 3:18:11still had fight scenes. Yeah, it was great. Yeah, I quite
- 3:18:16enjoyed it, and I'm excited to discuss the rest of the episodes we have
- 3:18:20seen. Yeah. I think this is a strong start to the season.
- 3:18:24Yeah for sure. I feel really good about this launch point. Yeah,
- 3:18:28thank you so much everyone, Take it away? Ye oh sorry, please
- 3:18:31no go. This has been real takes. If you want to keep in
- 3:18:35touch with us, tell us how stupid and wrong we are just kidding.
- 3:18:37Please don't do that. Well, do it in a nice way if you
- 3:18:41must. Our social media and email are below. In addition to that,
- 3:18:48if you want to support us further, you can either leave us a rating
- 3:18:50or a review. It always makes our day and helps read the word about
- 3:18:52the podcast, or you can become one of our patrons on Patreon that details
- 3:19:00for that are below. Yeah, anything else, Gus? Have I been
- 3:19:05doing the anything else Gus? For these? I have no idea A long
- 3:19:09time since we've done these. It was a bit of a way. Thank
- 3:19:11you so much everybody, Bye bye, Thank you again for listening. This
- 3:19:41was Wheel Takes with Ali and Gus. Music by Alexander Nacarata.