Latest / The Women's Soccer Podcast / Episode 101: LDG's Immediate Reaction to the USWNT's First SheBelieves Cup Match! (Yohannes, Macario, and more starred)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome back to the Women's Soccer Podcast.
- 0:02I'm your host, Liam Greco.
- 0:03You may remember me better as LDG.
- 0:06Last night, the US Women's National Team took the pitch
- 0:08for their first match of the She Believes Cup competition
- 0:12against Columbia, a national team that hasn't had
- 0:15the funding needed to be successful, but against all odds,
- 0:18has beaten some of the best teams in the world.
- 0:20They finished in the quarterfinals
- 0:22of the last competition, so it was a really tough test
- 0:25for the US, who ultimately pulled out a 2-0 victory.
- 0:28And today we're gonna be breaking down that match,
- 0:30talking about the roster that Emma Hayes selected
- 0:32for this tournament, which is her first tournament roster
- 0:34since the Olympics, and ultimately discussing the state
- 0:37of the US Women's National Team program,
- 0:39as they look to build for the future in this year
- 0:42without any major tournaments.
- 0:43So let's get right into talking about the roster.
- 0:45When I looked at the roster initially,
- 0:47I was definitely caught by a few different things.
- 0:50I think obviously two goalkeepers is not the customary
- 0:53way of doing things, but I think Emma's logic behind
- 0:58that decision was quite sound in a Shebley's Cup format,
- 1:01where you're playing so many matches
- 1:03in such a short period of time, especially considering
- 1:06that the majority of this roster just play in the NWCEL,
- 1:08which means that they're in pre-season form right now,
- 1:11perhaps not at full fitness to play this many matches
- 1:14in a row.
- 1:14It's great to see that Emma understands and acknowledges
- 1:17the need for tactical flexibility and changing personnel,
- 1:22and not necessarily based on what she wished she could do
- 1:25at a World Cup or an Olympics,
- 1:27but due to the fact that this is not one of those tournaments,
- 1:30you're missing players like Triple Expresso,
- 1:32Gurma, Neyar's now gone, and Nets.
- 1:34So that's definitely something we'll talk about.
- 1:35I think having more different options to bring into a match
- 1:39is a great thing for the team, for the field players,
- 1:42because even though only 10 field players play on the pitch,
- 1:45you really want those people to be rotated in now
- 1:49to ensure that the players are in optimal fitness
- 1:53for the rest of the year, and can just continue progressing
- 1:56in this environment.
- 1:56So I want to talk about the goalkeeping situation first,
- 1:59because last night we saw Jane Campbell start a net.
- 2:02She wasn't really called upon in many severe situations
- 2:07that were signifying of her talent with the program.
- 2:11We've seen her in a lot of matches with the Dash,
- 2:14and she's a quite successful penalty kick, shot stopper,
- 2:17overall a goalkeeper who has a lot of similarities to Neyar,
- 2:21I think, at the club level in the way that she plays.
- 2:24She's not as comfortable for feet,
- 2:26and I think we noticed that she didn't necessarily
- 2:28play with the ball as much as Mandy Haught usually
- 2:30would do for the US Women's National Team, or Mandy McGlynn.
- 2:33Sorry, guys, about that.
- 2:34I'm getting used to all of these name changes this episode.
- 2:37But I was really impressed with how the US team really
- 2:40handled the attack of the Colombian side.
- 2:43I think when you have players like Ramirez, Caicedo, Pavi,
- 2:47who's someone who I think not many American fans may
- 2:50have known in comparison to a figure like Caicedo,
- 2:52who was so influential at the last World Cup,
- 2:54Pavi was so good at the last Gold Cup,
- 2:56scoring multiple goals in the Amiens Panama winner.
- 2:59That was where she first really got on my radar
- 3:02as the host of the show.
- 3:03But I thought they did a really good job nullifying
- 3:06the threat of Caicedo in behind.
- 3:07There was a few instances where she did find the spaces,
- 3:10but the US weren't perfect yesterday.
- 3:13But whenever they made a little mistake
- 3:15or had a lapse in focus, they were able to recover.
- 3:18And I think for a new side, it's all you can really ask for.
- 3:21All these players never played together.
- 3:23So many of them are so new.
- 3:24Many of them barely have any caps.
- 3:26I think almost half the roster has four or less caps.
- 3:29Someone will fact check me on that.
- 3:31But that's really crazy to think about.
- 3:33And I mean, out of the forward line,
- 3:36Alyssa Thompson is one of the more experienced players.
- 3:38That's kind of crazy to think, considering
- 3:40that she's still so, so young.
- 3:42And this is a roster that will obviously need time to build.
- 3:45But I think I was really impressed overall.
- 3:47I was a little confused at why Fallon Tola-Joyce
- 3:50wasn't called up for this camp.
- 3:51But I'll be quite frank.
- 3:52She's been one of the most informed keepers recently.
- 3:55And I felt that she's been doing really well with United.
- 3:58But also, when she's gotten the chance
- 4:01to play different roles for that club,
- 4:03I think she's really succeeded.
- 4:04Her ability to play with her feet
- 4:07isn't at the level of someone like Amanda Hall, which
- 4:10I guess may have been one of the restraining factors for her
- 4:13game and her view, how Emma views her ability to the US
- 4:17team.
- 4:17But I would have loved to see her get called up.
- 4:19But obviously, Campbell is a proven option.
- 4:22Amanda Hott has been exceptional for Utah Royals.
- 4:24You really can't complain about the two keepers picked,
- 4:27although it would have been admittedly really nice
- 4:29to see Fallon selected for this roster.
- 4:31That's just my personal take.
- 4:32I think there's so many great goalkeepers in the pool
- 4:34right now.
- 4:35And even though this is a very chaotic time,
- 4:37it's big, big shoes to fill with Listenaire.
- 4:39I mean, though she was a very controversial figure
- 4:42off the pitch, I hope solo, not in there,
- 4:45there was a lot of questions about who
- 4:47would play solo at the time.
- 4:49And obviously, Listenaire is now one
- 4:50of the most beloved figures for the US Women's National Team.
- 4:53So I think it's going to take time.
- 4:55As Sam Uess mentioned on the women's game yesterday,
- 4:57there is going to be some errors that may be made at points.
- 5:01But ultimately, it's ensuring that the side can grow
- 5:05from the mistakes that they make.
- 5:06And yesterday, luckily for the score sheet and their quest
- 5:10to the win of the trophy, not too many mistakes were made.
- 5:13And a large part of that was due to the defense
- 5:15being super resilient.
- 5:16I was really impressed with Emily Fox, who
- 5:18has prevented Caicedo from shining in recent encounters
- 5:21between the US and Colombia so wonderfully.
- 5:23And I think Fox's experience with the team
- 5:26has definitely been helpful for her.
- 5:28She's more than 60 caps, which is
- 5:30a lot more than anyone who started on the back line
- 5:33last time, except for Emily Sonnet, who is, again,
- 5:36playing on that right side.
- 5:37And so I found it really interesting
- 5:38that the Colombian team was continuously sending
- 5:41Caicedo down that side with Fox and Sonnet
- 5:45when the one time that she got down the side really
- 5:47early on into the match with Neiswonger and Michon, which
- 5:51is a much less experienced side of the pitch.
- 5:55I felt like that would have been a more successful matchup
- 5:58for them.
- 5:58But ultimately, Colombia lacked the clinicality and creativity
- 6:02in the final third.
- 6:03When they did have chances, Maramira
- 6:04set a really good one, where she beat Michon and Neiswonger
- 6:08early on in the first half, or in the middle part
- 6:10of the first half.
- 6:11And she's got it over the bar.
- 6:13And that's what happens when you play a team like the US,
- 6:15even if it's a more newer team for the US side,
- 6:19there's still so much talent.
- 6:21And whenever you get a chance, you have to make it,
- 6:23or you're going to lose the match.
- 6:24And that's what happened for Colombia.
- 6:26They fell victim to their mistakes.
- 6:28Both goals that were scored by the US
- 6:30were ultimately caused by turnovers
- 6:32in the buildup by Colombia in their own half.
- 6:34And when that happens, the US has creative players.
- 6:37The first goal was Lili Johannes,
- 6:39who shined through the entire match.
- 6:40She was the most brilliant player on the pitch yesterday.
- 6:43And we'll get into her a little bit later.
- 6:44And then, of course, the individual brilliance
- 6:47of Ali Sutton, who are shining the second goal.
- 6:48But Tara McKown's high IQ pass to cut
- 6:52through the center of the pitch and play
- 6:54a pretty long ball that was wise beyond her first cap years
- 7:02with the US Men's National Team.
- 7:03So overall, I think I gave this performance a 7 out of 10.
- 7:06We'll get into some more details beyond this.
- 7:09But I think a lot of the areas were really, really good.
- 7:11Technically, there were some mistakes here and there.
- 7:13It was not the perfect match.
- 7:14But when you compare it to the midfield
- 7:16that we saw at the Olympics of Kofi Heran and Albert,
- 7:19that was really just so tiresome, to be frank.
- 7:22Lili Johannes was an incredible player yesterday.
- 7:24She ignited something in this team
- 7:26that we have not seen in a while.
- 7:27And when she made her first cap and not friendly earlier
- 7:30last year, we knew that Lili was going
- 7:33to be the star of this team in the future.
- 7:35But her creativity has really exceeded my expectations
- 7:38at such a young age.
- 7:39You would have figured that it would have taken her some time
- 7:41to adjust to playing at the senior side of the US.
- 7:44She only has two caps after all.
- 7:45But now, I thought that the pass on the ball was beautiful.
- 7:49That first goal was obviously a beautiful play.
- 7:52It was hit with perfect weight to Yasmine, who, to her credit,
- 7:55made the high IQ play, hitting across the six-yard box
- 7:58for Kat to have what was a symbol to happen,
- 8:00but still a good nine strikers goal.
- 8:04So yeah, overall, I was really impressed by Lili
- 8:06in the midfield.
- 8:07And I think also, to her credit, she's not a selfish player.
- 8:11She brings out the traits in others that allows them to shine.
- 8:15I think she helps compensate for some of the liabilities
- 8:18that we saw at the Olympics.
- 8:19If you play a lineup with Harana Lavallem,
- 8:21a dealer who are both talented players,
- 8:23but more attacking-oriented, having a player like Johannes
- 8:26in the midfield with them would have been really helpful
- 8:28because, of course, her creativity shines through.
- 8:30And she can play an eight.
- 8:31She could play a 10.
- 8:32But she's also so sound defensively for a 17-year-old,
- 8:36but also not even just for a 17-year-old.
- 8:37I think the Washington Spirits mindset of these players
- 8:40aren't rookies.
- 8:41Their first-year players really is something
- 8:43that Emma Hayes has embraced with the Oceman National team.
- 8:46She's given so many players their first caps,
- 8:48and she leaves competition where they're
- 8:49playing top international sides.
- 8:51And I think all of them have really
- 8:53shown what they're made of.
- 8:55I think Michelle Cooper, though she didn't make the score
- 8:57yesterday, she came in with such a bright piece of energy
- 9:00on that right-hand flank.
- 9:01I thought she was getting down the line so beautifully,
- 9:05beating defenders, putting some good crosses in.
- 9:07She had won to Ali Centenor that, in some ways,
- 9:10probably should have been finished,
- 9:11but it's a hard ball in, I think, to convert on.
- 9:14So ultimately, it wasn't the perfect game.
- 9:16I think the US could have easily had a few more goals
- 9:18if they had a little bit more clinicality in the final third,
- 9:21but it was a much better performance than we've seen
- 9:24for in a while for this US team.
- 9:26So I wanted to give a few of my star shine-outs of the day.
- 9:29I usually give three, but this game was much better.
- 9:31So I'm going to give four or five.
- 9:33We'll see how many I give.
- 9:34I think I'm going to start with my MVP of the match, which
- 9:36is Lilio Jannis.
- 9:37The 17-year-old, balled out in the midfield,
- 9:39was just so, so talented.
- 9:41I think it's important to mention how influential she's
- 9:43been for Ajax at such a young age.
- 9:45She came into the Ajax squad and comparing her
- 9:48using our same handy data set, except not the top nine leagues,
- 9:52but against midfielders from the 2023-24 Champions League.
- 9:55And mind you, she's gotten even better this season.
- 9:58I believe it's 94th percentile in assists,
- 10:0197th percentile in goals in assists.
- 10:05So many amazing stats.
- 10:07Average shot distance, 81 percentile.
- 10:10Progressive carry, 72nd percentile.
- 10:13So many statistics that really just wow you all in all.
- 10:16Just defensive action, 99th percentile.
- 10:20So many stats.
- 10:21Take-ons, 95th percentile.
- 10:24Shots blocked, 94th percentile.
- 10:26Carries into the final third, 88th percentile.
- 10:28Lily has the traits to play anywhere in the midfield
- 10:30when you're that talented, and you can do that.
- 10:32Genuinely put the 6th, the 8th, and the 10th.
- 10:34It means that you're going to be one of the best players
- 10:37for this team in the future, which is why I gave her an 8.5
- 10:40out of 10 for today's rate match.
- 10:42That's my unofficial LDG rating of Lily.
- 10:45I thought she was so magnificent all across the pitch today
- 10:48in all three thirds of the field.
- 10:50She was essential to orchestrating in the middle
- 10:53third of the pitch, obviously, but also in the attacking third.
- 10:56The assist was great, but so many other plays that she made.
- 10:58And of course, her incredible slide tackle
- 11:01that perhaps may have saved a goal.
- 11:03Lily's influence extends far beyond the secluded area
- 11:06where midfielders have often stayed for the US.
- 11:09And I think her addition is amazing right now.
- 11:12I said the same thing about a lot of young players in this team.
- 11:15They're not just the future, they're the now.
- 11:17But the thing about Lily that's so exciting for me
- 11:19is the fact that she'll continue to grow and grow,
- 11:22which is why, selfishly, I would love to have her in the NWSL,
- 11:24because there's no midfielder really in the world that thinks
- 11:28like Lily Johannes does, and definitely no midfielder
- 11:31that when they were 17 had the ability to execute the plays
- 11:34that they can see out like Lily.
- 11:36I think that's the thing that I love about her game so much
- 11:39when she played at Ajax, and now it's translating to the US
- 11:42from the national team, her ability to execute the pass
- 11:45and make the smart play that looks so brilliant.
- 11:49And you see the ball go off your foot, you're like,
- 11:51are you sure she's going to be able to get it there?
- 11:52But somehow, some way, with all the talent
- 11:55that Lily Johannes possesses in both her feet,
- 11:57she's able to be that creative 10 for the US.
- 12:00At some points, but also drop back into a six.
- 12:03She does whatever she needs for her team,
- 12:05and she's just a selfless player that I cannot wait to continue
- 12:08seeing with this US side, and ultimately,
- 12:11she's going to be a player that by 2027 will be one of the most
- 12:13instrumental parts of this US midfield.
- 12:15And speaking of someone who will be instrumental by 2027,
- 12:19Ali Centenor is looking into breaking into that triple
- 12:21espresso for N3, along with Kat McCarvey,
- 12:23who are my two next MVPs, or players that I give a gold medal
- 12:28to, or the gold star for this match,
- 12:30because the two of them combined it so brilliantly.
- 12:33I thought Ali Centenor's creative playmaking was a big factor
- 12:37as to why I loved her game far more than her long shooting
- 12:40ability, which, of course, the second goal of yesterday's
- 12:43match clearly replicated that from what
- 12:46she's seen in that NWSL.
- 12:47But her goals numbers are not the things
- 12:49that impress me the most.
- 12:50Though Ali is a player who's quite a goal for a rookie
- 12:53in front of net, she's also someone
- 12:55who looks for her teammates.
- 12:56And I think last season, she was not
- 12:59given the best hand of cards with the roster
- 13:02that she started the year out with Utah.
- 13:03And obviously, Mia Tanaka, among many others,
- 13:06like Clonius, Arizona, joined in the middle of the season.
- 13:08And Mina was incredibly impressive yesterday
- 13:11in the first match of the Sheetleaves Cup
- 13:13Doubleheader for Japan, as they defeated the Matilbas 4-0.
- 13:16So I'm really excited to see the second dimension of Ali
- 13:19Centenor, as she can now feel the comfort of being
- 13:22a US women's national team player going
- 13:24into her second season, understand
- 13:26that she has a big role and responsibility
- 13:29to continue performing at the highest level.
- 13:31Once you make this team, there is really nowhere but up
- 13:34from here.
- 13:35But we've seen in the past that that's not always
- 13:37the case, if players cannot maintain
- 13:39the appropriate level for this team at the youth level.
- 13:42And I think everyone was still impressive yesterday.
- 13:44Ali was definitely at that level.
- 13:46And of course, our other goal scorer of the night,
- 13:48Kat McCarrio.
- 13:49But what I love about Kat so much is her movement on the ball.
- 13:53And I wanted to get into that a little bit more.
- 13:55Of course, she's been dealing with so many injuries.
- 13:57It's been almost three years since she last
- 13:59was able to find the back of the net for the US team.
- 14:01And it was an emotional moment, to see Kat back
- 14:04into the pitch for the US side.
- 14:05But her score goal in her debut is just really
- 14:08fitting for the player that Kat McCarrio is.
- 14:10In only 18 appearances with the senior side, now 20,
- 14:14she already has nine goals with the team.
- 14:16And that speaks volumes to what Kat's abilities are
- 14:21in front of that.
- 14:21She's not a nine, the traditional nine
- 14:23that you see on these teams, like Amara Amira
- 14:26as a tight player who loves the holding up in tight paces.
- 14:29Although Kat can do that.
- 14:31She's like a nine and a half.
- 14:32I love using that description for Jayden Shaw as well.
- 14:35She can be a 10 and a nine, whatever you need her to be.
- 14:38She'll do it.
- 14:38And she'll do it pretty freaking well.
- 14:40Kat has been coming back into form playing 90 minutes
- 14:43with the Chelsea side.
- 14:44She's not even there yet.
- 14:45But she did a pretty good job playing more than a half
- 14:48for the US yesterday.
- 14:50She has four goal contributions and four matches for Chelsea
- 14:54in their Champions League campaign so far this year.
- 14:56In just 183 minutes, she's gotten on the score sheet
- 14:59so consistently.
- 15:00And her expected assist is only 0.3.
- 15:02So the fact that she's gotten an assist, expected goals,
- 15:052.6, three goals so far in the Champions League.
- 15:08The fact that she is so clinical for her sides
- 15:11and is always finding a way to get them on the back.
- 15:13And that's what I find so impressive of Kat.
- 15:15Though she's been injured for a lot of the time.
- 15:18If you compare her to forward, which I'm doing today
- 15:20because she is a nine for the US team.
- 15:23She is 99 percentile in so many different statistics
- 15:26over the last 455 days against her peers positionally
- 15:29in the top nine leagues in women's football.
- 15:3199 percentile in assists, expected assists,
- 15:34passes attempted, progressive passes recorded,
- 15:38and many, many more statistics that can go on and on
- 15:41about every single one of her stats is green.
- 15:43And you don't have to look at these stats by the way
- 15:46to see how incredibly gifted Kat McCarrio is as a player.
- 15:49Her passing abilities are second to none.
- 15:51Her ability to finish in front of net
- 15:54and find the way to get the ball in the back of the net
- 15:57even when it feels like it's impossible for a player
- 16:00to finish from where she finishes from.
- 16:02She does, she scores the creative goals,
- 16:04but she also scores the smart goals.
- 16:05She scores a nine's goal even if she's not a nine.
- 16:07She plays the pass of an eight, even if she's not an eight.
- 16:10Kat McCarrio does whatever you need her to do
- 16:12and she does it pretty freaking well.
- 16:14And although everyone was getting very, very hyped up
- 16:16by Triple Expresso, the real ones knew that
- 16:19there's a lot more than Triple Expresso in this program.
- 16:22And I think it's amazing to see,
- 16:24we love Triple Expresso, right?
- 16:25I have a Sophia Smith trooper,
- 16:28Harvard Kit with the US team and the Thorns.
- 16:30She's a player who I've loved watching
- 16:32and obviously Trinity and Mal have been influential
- 16:35on the wings of this team.
- 16:35I'm not discounting the work that Triple Expresso have done,
- 16:38but I think looking beyond the three of them,
- 16:40we need to build a forward pool
- 16:41and this pool is getting expanded real quickly.
- 16:45There's so many talents and I think some have just,
- 16:48not even done weaker than others,
- 16:50but some have just signed above the rest.
- 16:51And so far in this team, we've got Kat and Ali Setnor
- 16:54have done that, but I don't want to leave Yas Rhyne
- 16:56out of the equation.
- 16:57She had a great assist yesterday.
- 16:59Ultimately her movement on and off the ball,
- 17:00just like Kat McCarrio is sublime.
- 17:02I think the three of them pair so well together.
- 17:05Of course, Linvianne Dodo is a player
- 17:07who has been pretty consistent for this team,
- 17:09US team all in all, 21 goals and 75 appearances.
- 17:13Having that little bit of veteran experience
- 17:14is really important as well.
- 17:15I think people realize that there's so many new players
- 17:18coming into this camp.
- 17:19Only one player on that forward line
- 17:21has more than 20 caps and that's Lin.
- 17:23So Lin, even though she may not have that new flair
- 17:28that someone like a Kat McCarrio has,
- 17:30fans should still be just as excited to see Lin
- 17:32on the pitch because the intangibles that Lin brings
- 17:34off the field plus her abilities on the pitch are incredible.
- 17:37And I think that this is obviously a bonus.
- 17:39Kat's abilities on set pieces are so much better
- 17:42than anyone we've had on the team for a while.
- 17:44I love Arisabelle, she's great and all.
- 17:46But Kat, that ball, Jenna's one in the first half
- 17:49was so perfect, I was fuming that Jenna couldn't find it
- 17:52but got in the back of the net.
- 17:53It was a good attempt all around.
- 17:54Nothing I've done up personally,
- 17:56but it was a perfect ball from Kat McCarrio.
- 17:58And this just speaks volumes to who she is as a player,
- 18:01but also I think perhaps as a preview of what we'll see
- 18:05with these players going into the mix in the future.
- 18:07The potential to have Kat as a 10 with triple espresso
- 18:10as the front three is just something
- 18:12that any opposition around the world,
- 18:13I don't care if you're ranked second or 180th
- 18:16to be scared of.
- 18:17And I think these three players have such bright futures
- 18:21ahead of them.
- 18:21And I've obviously gotten to see Yaz's growth
- 18:25from a firsthand view,
- 18:26but watching from maybe a farther way perspective
- 18:31for players like Centenor and McCarrio
- 18:32who don't play for my clubs has been just as delightful.
- 18:35Named three of my MVPs,
- 18:37it said I was gonna do one more today.
- 18:38So I think I have to give it to one of the players
- 18:41who has really just shined every time
- 18:45she stepped in the pitch for the US team.
- 18:46She's done whatever they've asked of her.
- 18:49She's always the player who you can really rely on
- 18:51in situations and that's Emily Fox.
- 18:53I spoke to her about her a little bit earlier,
- 18:56not to her personally, but on this podcast,
- 18:59I spoke about the ability that Fox has to manage
- 19:02getting out the pitch,
- 19:03making those incredible attacking runs.
- 19:04We saw her goal for Arsenal in their North London Derby
- 19:08against Tottenham Hotspur,
- 19:10where of course it was just the cherry on top
- 19:12being the fifth goal in a shutout performance
- 19:14for the Gunners.
- 19:16But having a player like Fox who can shoot from long range,
- 19:19yes, and do all the flashy things that full backs
- 19:22love to have that in their back pocket,
- 19:24but her ability to be a one-on-one defender
- 19:26and balance going forward and getting back,
- 19:28that's an area that I think Fox is far more long in
- 19:31than Nye's longer.
- 19:32And again, I think this game is not something
- 19:36that should be hyper-analyzed, right?
- 19:39And that's why I never loved doing episodes
- 19:42critiquing roster selections,
- 19:44even though of course we all have our feelings about that
- 19:47before we see the game on the pitch,
- 19:48because that is something that is really important
- 19:51to be able to watch the players on the pitch and see,
- 19:53okay, how did Emma Hayes view this perspective?
- 19:55We obviously won't have any more insight
- 19:58into the board room before that first match than after it,
- 20:00but seeing the tactics, now she implements
- 20:02the player skill sets on the pitch
- 20:04is the best insight that anyone, a fan,
- 20:06or a podcaster slash journalist alike can have.
- 20:09As an insight into what this US new way is going to be.
- 20:12So though I've been very impressed
- 20:15with many of these players on the pitch yesterday,
- 20:17there are a few changes that I would have liked to see
- 20:20in this roster, and now for this first game,
- 20:21I think I can provide a little bit more insight
- 20:23into why that would be.
- 20:24Starting in the midfield,
- 20:25I've spoken about Corbin Alpert multiple times
- 20:27in this podcast, and though of course,
- 20:29I have incredibly differing beliefs
- 20:31to her homophobic ideals,
- 20:33I'm also not impressed by her performance on the pitch,
- 20:36to be frank, and have not really seen
- 20:39why she should have some sensational team.
- 20:42Sorry for this slander, I guess.
- 20:45You know, I've been really trying
- 20:47when I'm watching Alpert's matches to try and put aside
- 20:50all of the commentary that has gone around
- 20:52with her political views that are very harmful,
- 20:55and I think it's been really disappointing
- 20:57to see the lack of response,
- 20:58but albeit that may be for another podcast.
- 21:01However, I do feel genuinely like aside from that,
- 21:04that her performance on the pitch has not merited her,
- 21:07the continuous call up of Alpert.
- 21:10She's not playing in the Champions League,
- 21:12and if Gaiento is not gonna get a call up for PSG,
- 21:14then why is Alpert getting called up?
- 21:16I don't get it, although I guess you have to ask Emma,
- 21:19not me, I think that Hal Arsfeld
- 21:21would have been a great replacement, I know,
- 21:22like the least unique answer I could have given,
- 21:24but whatever, her responsibilities
- 21:26were not just great for a rookie,
- 21:28they were pretty great for any player in the NWSL.
- 21:31Besides tallying two goals as the fifth overall pick
- 21:34of last year's draft,
- 21:36Hirschfeld's defensive abilities shine
- 21:37against other midfielders in the league.
- 21:39If you look at her passing, even as a six,
- 21:41when you compare to all midfielders,
- 21:42and this includes 10s, this includes eights,
- 21:45she shines incredibly with many green statistics,
- 21:48and that usually means statistics
- 21:49that are above 70th percentile.
- 21:52Her pass completion percentage for long passing
- 21:54is the 89th percentile.
- 21:56That is an incredible total for shooting,
- 21:59it's the 81st percentile for shots and targets.
- 22:01Again, she's a six, this is not usual behaviors here.
- 22:05Blocks and her defensive abilities,
- 22:07her stats are shown as well.
- 22:0992nd percentile in blocks,
- 22:1188th percentile in percentage dribblers tackled.
- 22:14She's such a good player and she's so instrumental
- 22:17in how the spirit play in possession,
- 22:18and I really feel like Emma would really use her skills
- 22:21in a team that's still building
- 22:23how they use double pivot, of course,
- 22:24Koffi and Johannes is now gonna be a really big part of that,
- 22:28but I would love to see Hirschfeld get that opportunity again.
- 22:31The intention of the segment is not to provide
- 22:34any sort of slander towards players
- 22:36that have gotten called up over these people,
- 22:38which is why I usually don't say the person
- 22:41that I think shouldn't have gotten called up,
- 22:43but considering all of the controversy
- 22:45that's surrounded Albert's off the field performance,
- 22:47I feel like the locker room cancer, to be frank,
- 22:50that she has proven to be for ideals
- 22:54doesn't merit getting called up.
- 22:56And again, taking this out of the equation completely,
- 22:59I still don't think that she's right now
- 23:01at the caliber of the O-7 National team.
- 23:03Her play in possession is not nearly as good
- 23:06as Hirschfeld's and Olsen-Millenny.
- 23:08On the O-7 National team to be a six,
- 23:10you have to be able to do that,
- 23:11and we've seen Albert in a decent amount of games now, right?
- 23:14She's had a lot of the experience
- 23:16in comparison to someone like Hirschfeld.
- 23:18She's 22 caps, and she really has not made an impression
- 23:21on not just me, but it seems that many of you
- 23:24in the O-7 National team fandom
- 23:25have disagreed with this choice,
- 23:27and that's why I think, though this is a cliche opinion,
- 23:30when you take a look at Hirschfeld's
- 23:32and Albert's statistics side by side,
- 23:33it really shows why they may have not
- 23:35made the right decision here.
- 23:37In the long passing percentage,
- 23:38where Hirschfeld is 89th percentile,
- 23:41Albert is 81st percentile, and again,
- 23:43this is against teams that are significantly weaker
- 23:45than the NWSL.
- 23:47Liga FA is a much weaker league than the NWSL,
- 23:49and so even though a lot of her numbers
- 23:51offensively are inflated, she plays as an eight slash 10
- 23:54for the PSG side, so I really don't take that
- 23:59with that much of a grain of salt, to be frank,
- 24:02and I've seen more than enough
- 24:05about both the O-7 National team, just the eye test.
- 24:07Of course, statistics provide invaluable perspectives
- 24:11that are unbiased, statistics don't lie,
- 24:13as many people within the sporting industry would say,
- 24:16but also the eye test has not really impressed me,
- 24:18and Albert hasn't really shown why she deserves
- 24:21to over someone like Hirschfeld to get continuously called up
- 24:25and really not shine in the matches that she has.
- 24:27She turns the ball over a lot, and ultimately,
- 24:30when she's on the pitch, she just has failed
- 24:31to make an impression on me that she's at the level
- 24:34of the O-7 National team right now, and again,
- 24:36that can change, Albert's still a really young player,
- 24:38and this is why, again, this is not personal whatsoever,
- 24:41I'm not trying to say that Albert should be barred
- 24:43from getting called up for this team ever again.
- 24:45If she continues to perform for PSG, then great,
- 24:47but she has two goals and one assist as a 10
- 24:50in 13 matches in Liga FA against significantly
- 24:53weaker competition, and Albert doesn't necessarily
- 24:56have the statistics to merit being played higher
- 24:58up the pitch, nor playing defensively,
- 25:00and I think she was definitely a solution
- 25:03for the lack of midfield depth at the Olympics,
- 25:06and she slotted in there, wasn't great by any means,
- 25:10but she got the assist in the gold medal games,
- 25:13but again, there's not a black and white answer to this,
- 25:15because it's not a black and white problem.
- 25:17These takes are going to change over time,
- 25:22but I really do feel that Hirschfeld
- 25:23should have gotten called in over her based on the numbers,
- 25:26and considering the competition that Hirschfeld faces
- 25:29and the stylistic that Hirschfeld has with the US side,
- 25:33and that leads me to why I think Alyssa Malensohn
- 25:35should have been called in, just generally speaking,
- 25:39but I guess if you had to compare it to someone,
- 25:41I would compare it to Jenna Neisbonger,
- 25:42who I felt whose crossing was not nearly
- 25:45at the level of the US team yesterday.
- 25:47So Neisbonger's offensive abilities
- 25:49have often shined for the US team,
- 25:50and I'll go into her more in next episode,
- 25:53it'll come out around Monday or Tuesday,
- 25:55I finished it already, it's in the back burner,
- 25:57waiting to be published about the European,
- 25:59and then be sold to European Exodus, as it's been dubbed,
- 26:02although I, in that episode, debunked that theory,
- 26:04I guess I just spoiled it, but he's just a lesson anyway,
- 26:07and I talk about Neisbonger's game as being
- 26:09the reason why she was such a self-fulfilling
- 26:10swim national team as a left-back
- 26:12was because of her offensive ability,
- 26:13and I felt that with the US team,
- 26:16it hasn't necessarily shined,
- 26:17I felt like she had a little bit of a sophomore
- 26:18sem last year, ultimately led to her getting benched,
- 26:20I mean, not gonna repeat the same thing I'm gonna mention
- 26:22in the next episode, so you should wait for that,
- 26:24but I'll focus more on this game specifically,
- 26:26I felt, though I'm not specifically blaming her
- 26:28for that one crossbar attempt,
- 26:30I mean, she got under the ball,
- 26:32I thought that she could have slammed through it, whatever,
- 26:34I mean, it was a good attempt overall,
- 26:35but I felt like her crossing, she had a lot of crosses
- 26:37that were, she had multiple crosses on the left-hand side,
- 26:40where they went out of bounds, and that's not okay,
- 26:42for the US swim national team,
- 26:43you can't be making those simple mistakes,
- 26:45they're so unavoidable, and against better teams
- 26:48than Columbia, like Perse, Lionesses of England,
- 26:52and those games, like we played them last time in the fall,
- 26:56and it was a normal draw, and against those teams,
- 26:58you can't make those mistakes,
- 26:59every opportunity needs to be cherished,
- 27:00and I felt like it was a little bit wasteful yesterday
- 27:02from Niswonger, she looked to lack the comfortability
- 27:06on the field, and again, I'm a huge fan of her game
- 27:09in a lot of different areas, offensively speaking,
- 27:10she's quite sound, I don't think that she's at the level
- 27:13to be on the US swim national team in the midfield,
- 27:15but that's a different conversation,
- 27:17I feel like there's a lot of different players
- 27:19who could have been more defensively oriented,
- 27:22and I think Melanson's offensive abilities
- 27:24also have problems, right, when you look at her numbers,
- 27:26they're not great either on the offensive end,
- 27:29but at least Melanson provides the stability defensively,
- 27:31and though Niswonger was quite fortunate
- 27:34to not have to match up against Caicedo
- 27:35in many, many 1v1 opportunities,
- 27:38I do feel like her liabilities that were shown
- 27:40in that match against the Netherlands,
- 27:42and for the US, and also in that Gotham season last year,
- 27:47are not isolated instances, they're something
- 27:49that Emma should be on the watch for,
- 27:50and ultimately, if these trends continue to occur,
- 27:53they should be something that should be worrying some,
- 27:54but all in all, Niswonger and Albert didn't really
- 27:58do that much bad yesterday, it was more that they were
- 28:01just like a step below the rest of the team, to be frank,
- 28:03and I felt over the last year specifically,
- 28:07those were moves when I saw this roster first
- 28:08that were frustrating to me, and after changing the match
- 28:11for Niswonger more specifically,
- 28:12I feel like my opinions have become more secure.
- 28:17I don't like to say these things before we get to see a match.
- 28:21I know everyone loves the second the roster comes out,
- 28:23and I love thinking through the same thought process as well,
- 28:26going, oh, I'm so mad this person's on,
- 28:28she shouldn't have been on over this person,
- 28:30but at the end of the day, Emma has a plan,
- 28:31we trust Emma Hayes, and though we may have different paths
- 28:35in our mind for where the US-US team should be going,
- 28:38Emma's path seems to be going pretty good so far,
- 28:40so I'm not raising any red flags yet.
- 28:43I do think that there should be some changes made
- 28:45in personnel, but that's just my opinion.
- 28:47Who knows what I think?
- 28:48I'm a podcaster, and Emma's ability to complete,
- 28:51transform this program so far has been immense.
- 28:53She has done what she's done at Chelsea.
- 28:56She built a perennial powerhouse at Chelsea,
- 28:58and here with the US, she's not necessarily after building
- 29:01the brand of a perennial powerhouse,
- 29:02but she's having to live up to the standards
- 29:05that are so immensely high and almost unreachable,
- 29:07to be like having to go beyond the stars,
- 29:09and yet Emma Hayes at every step so far
- 29:10has certainly made the right decisions,
- 29:12giving players like Lily Johannes a chance
- 29:15to acclimate to the environment,
- 29:16while also letting their skills stand on the pitch.
- 29:19You don't just have to let the player
- 29:21who's such a young gem rot on the bench.
- 29:23She can get taken some time on the pitch.
- 29:25She, of course, needs time to get into the environment,
- 29:28but it's a balance of everything, and I think so far,
- 29:30it's been really fun watching the US-US team,
- 29:32and I've loved getting to cover this tournament so far,
- 29:35and I cannot wait to watch Sunday's match,
- 29:37which you all should watch the US international team
- 29:39take on the Australian side.
- 29:41The Matilbas who have struggled lately,
- 29:43I think it's gonna be a really interesting game.
- 29:44I predict that the US should have a lot more
- 29:47of a comfortable time on the defensive part,
- 29:50just because Australia's lacking a player in Sam Kerr,
- 29:54who is their nine.
- 29:55I felt like Rasso playing the nine yesterday
- 29:57looked really weird at parts.
- 29:58I don't know why that was happening,
- 30:00and ultimately Australia lacked the threat going forward,
- 30:02so if I can make a prediction for Sunday's match,
- 30:04I think there's gonna be lots of rotation.
- 30:06I would love to see a player like Emily Sams
- 30:08come into the 11.
- 30:09I'd love to see someone like a Corbin Albert star
- 30:11and prove me wrong.
- 30:12Who knows?
- 30:13Again, Nijs Wanger, maybe she'll get another chance
- 30:16on next week's game in Japan and prove me wrong again.
- 30:18This is why I'm not holding grudges.
- 30:21I hope that in a week, you all can come back to this episode
- 30:23and look at me so amused by saying that Nijs Wanger
- 30:28and Albert did do better, because ultimately,
- 30:30I think everyone just wants the success of the US team,
- 30:32and my journalism, I hope, at least comes off
- 30:35as quite honest, but also kind.
- 30:39That's my goal.
- 30:39All these players are such immense talents
- 30:41that none of us who are talking into a microphone
- 30:44or typing into our computer or on our phones
- 30:46have the talent to do, and I think it's important
- 30:48to remember that even when we get into these discussions,
- 30:51because though it might seem lighthearted and serious,
- 30:53these players put their lines, their bodies on the lines,
- 30:58their heart into this team, and we should honor that,
- 31:01even if we have had some disagreements
- 31:04with choices Emma's made in the past, it's ultimately
- 31:06going to be a really fun ride for the US team this year,
- 31:08although there's not going to be as many
- 31:10international competitions.
- 31:11I love the friendlies.
- 31:11I mean, you all should stay tuned for all these matches.
- 31:14Stay tuned for the content that we're going to be bringing here
- 31:17at the Women's Soccer Podcast.
- 31:18If you haven't already, follow us on Blue Sky.
- 31:20We're over there now at the Women's Soccer Podcast,
- 31:23the Women's Soccer Pod, sorry, and then on Instagram,
- 31:26if you're still over there, at the Women's Soccer Podcast,
- 31:28one of the squares between each word.
- 31:30We post on both platforms equally.
- 31:31Whenever we post an episode, it'll be posted on both.
- 31:34So don't worry about that.
- 31:35So thank you so much for tuning into this episode.
- 31:37I really loved having this conversation,
- 31:40ultimately just digressing off of what
- 31:43was a great performance from the US last night.
- 31:46It wasn't perfect by any means, but many players
- 31:48are still in preseason.
- 31:49We should offer them grace, the grace that we have,
- 31:52and just be happy to get the three points
- 31:54and get a good start to the Shape Leagues Cup.
- 31:56So I hope that you all have enjoyed this podcast.
- 31:58If you liked it a lot, then please
- 31:59feel free to follow us or figure our podcast
- 32:01as additional on social media.
- 32:03Tell all your friends about us.
- 32:04We love growing this women's soccer community
- 32:06and making it a safe and accepting space that
- 32:07welcomes all fans of the world's beautiful game.
- 32:10And ultimately, by leaving a five star review,
- 32:12you're helping us achieve that by bringing our faces,
- 32:15our show, to the faces of more different fans.
- 32:17And we hope to just make a community that's even better.
- 32:20So if you have any feedback for this episode,
- 32:22feel free to message us wherever you get social media
- 32:25or anything.
- 32:26We really love hearing from you all.
- 32:28And leave a question for a Q&A episode.
- 32:30We just had one, so we're not going
- 32:31to have one for a while.
- 32:32Yeah, I'm rambling now, so I won't take up
- 32:34any more time on your day.
- 32:36Thanks so much for listening to this episode,
- 32:37the 100th and 3rd episode of the Women's Soccer Podcast.
- 32:41This is Friday, February 21st, LDG signing off,
- 32:44saying peace out and good luck.
- 32:47And enjoy the weekend.
- 32:48Peace out and see you next time.
- 32:50Bye.
- 32:50This is your host, LDG, signing off.