Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Navigating Exempt vs. Non-Exempt Classifications: A Guide for Attorneys with Clifton Albright Sr. & Clifton Albright Jr.
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to Navigating Exempt vs. Non -Exempt
- 0:10Classifications, a Guide for Attorney. I'm Lorena
- 0:13Vasquez, Vice Chair of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:15Association's Employment Law Section. I'm delighted
- 0:20to introduce today's speakers, Clifton Albright
- 0:22Sr. and Clifton Albright Jr. Clifton Albright
- 0:26Sr. is founding partner and the president of
- 0:30Albright Yee & Schmitt APC. He has an AV preeminent
- 0:34rating from Martindale Hubble. He is an active
- 0:38trial attorney. Mr. Albright specializes in providing
- 0:41legal representation for employment, labor, and
- 0:44towards defense of governmental and private entities.
- 0:47He has been involved in numerous state and federal
- 0:49jury trials from start to verdict. He also has
- 0:53a successful pellet record. Mr. Albright oversees
- 0:56the firm's litigation, negotiation, business
- 0:58transactions, and conducts employment investigations
- 1:01and Fair Labor Standards Act compliance audit.
- 1:06Clifton Albright Jr. is a partner at Albright,
- 1:08Ian Smith. He is a member of the firm's employment
- 1:11litigation team, handling litigation in all stages
- 1:13from inception through jury trials. His practice
- 1:17includes general and complex business litigation
- 1:19and labor employment matters. Clifton often conducts
- 1:23employment investigations pertaining to discrimination,
- 1:26harassment, retaliation, and wage and hour claims.
- 1:29While attending law school he was a member of
- 1:31the nationally ranked Bryant trial advocacy which
- 1:34is currently ranked fourth in the nation. He
- 1:36also clerked for the Honorable Carol Rose in
- 1:39the Los Angeles County Superior Court. And now
- 1:42let's get started. Good morning, everyone. As
- 1:49Lorena just let us know, let everyone know, my
- 1:52name is Clifton Albright, Jr. and this is my
- 1:54son here, Clifton Albright, Sr. And we are attorneys
- 1:59here at Albright Yee & Schmidt. And it is absolutely
- 2:03a pleasure to be presenting to you. I wish I
- 2:06could see your faces, but I'm happy that you
- 2:09can see mine. So at least I feel like we're friends
- 2:11a little bit. Truly, thank you for joining us
- 2:15today. We're here to delve into one of the most
- 2:18complex yet crucial areas of employment law for
- 2:22businesses operating in California. That's the
- 2:26proper classification of employees as either
- 2:29exempt or non -exempt. Getting this right is
- 2:32absolutely critical for compliance and for mitigating
- 2:37significant legal risks. And then can we go to
- 2:41the next slide? So we're going to be here for
- 2:46a while. So I wanted to give you a roadmap so
- 2:49you know kind of where we're going. We'll begin
- 2:53by discussing the high stakes involved in employee
- 2:56classifications and why it's such a critical
- 2:59issue for employers and attorneys who advise
- 3:02them. Then we'll cover the legal framework focusing
- 3:06on the key differences between California and
- 3:09federal standards. And like to no one's surprise
- 3:12here, the federal standard is going to be what's
- 3:15essentially the floor. California is going to
- 3:18be the ceiling. We'll define the baseline by
- 3:22outlining the robust rights of non -exempt employees,
- 3:27which is the default status in California. And
- 3:30we'll go over that a bunch, but I'll say it here.
- 3:32I'll say it a few more times. The standard in
- 3:36California is that employees are presumed to
- 3:39be non -exempt. And from there, we'll go into
- 3:45the two -part test, which is how we test to see
- 3:49if an employee is exempt or if they fit the standard
- 3:52or the default of non -exempt. Finally, we'll
- 3:55cover the significant risks of getting it wrong
- 3:58and provide some practical best practices for
- 4:01compliance before opening up to questions from
- 4:04you guys. And then can we go to the next slide?
- 4:10Okay. It's so weird doing this where I'm just
- 4:16talking to a screen, but it's okay. We'll do
- 4:18this. Let's begin by emphasizing the gravity
- 4:22of this issue. classification is a very common
- 4:26problem that happens to essentially all employers
- 4:31across all industries. Simply because a manager
- 4:36or an employee holds the title of manager, that
- 4:40does not mean that they themselves are exempt.
- 4:44We'll go through the exemptions, which exemptions
- 4:46apply in those situations in a little bit. But
- 4:50employment misclassification is not a minor administrative
- 4:54oversight. It is in fact one of the most common
- 4:58and costly mistakes that California employers
- 5:01can make. For example, as you all know, in California,
- 5:08employees have the right to go back four years
- 5:10and collect four years worth of meal and rest
- 5:13break violations or skip missed meal and rest
- 5:16breaks and all other wage and hour type of issues.
- 5:22And so that adds up very quickly. And especially
- 5:25when you get into a situation where you're in
- 5:27a class action, you have multiple plaintiffs
- 5:30in a particular case, those fees add up and they
- 5:34multiply very quickly. Yeah, and let me just
- 5:37add, JR, one of the things that you really need
- 5:42to be careful with with overtime and meal breaks
- 5:48is that it's the employer's responsibility to
- 5:53make sure that the employees don't have overtime
- 5:59and if they do have overtime, it's the employer's
- 6:03responsibility to pay them the overtime. And
- 6:08with regard to meal and rest breaks, it's the
- 6:12employer's responsibility to make sure that the
- 6:16employee takes their meal and rest breaks during
- 6:21the proper time. All the employee has to do is
- 6:27say, I didn't get it. And then it shifts to the
- 6:31employer to prove that they did. And a lot of
- 6:35employers don't keep records. And if you don't
- 6:38have a record of it, it didn't happen. And the
- 6:43penalties are substantial. And like JR just said,
- 6:47they can go back quite a ways. And not only can
- 6:51they go back for a particular employee, they
- 6:54can go back for groups of employees. And the
- 6:58waiting time and penalties apply. So just wanted
- 7:02to let you know. that these are significant.
- 7:07In California, the employee is presumed correct,
- 7:12and it's up to the employer to show that the
- 7:16employee is incorrect and did get all the particular
- 7:22benefits that they were supposed to receive as
- 7:26employees. Go ahead, Jim. Yeah, absolutely correct.
- 7:32And you know, and this is, and I'm repeating
- 7:33it for the second time, probably going to repeat
- 7:35it about 10 times. And that is that the legal
- 7:38presumption in California is that every employee
- 7:41is non -exempt unless proven otherwise. And yes,
- 7:48unless proven otherwise. All right, can we go
- 7:50to the next slide? So Before we start talking
- 7:58about what the exemptions are and how to classify
- 8:01which employee qualifies as non -exempt versus
- 8:04exempt, it's important to understand what rule
- 8:07of law that we're dealing with. In California,
- 8:10we're obviously going to be dealing with California
- 8:11state law, but we also have federal law. Now,
- 8:16federal law is going to be the FLSA, the Fair
- 8:20Labor Standards Act, which sets the baseline
- 8:23for labor standards across the nation. As you
- 8:27all know, California has a stricter requirement
- 8:32and is more generous towards employees. Where
- 8:41there is a conflict between the federal labor
- 8:45standards and California state law, to go with
- 8:49the law that is more protective of the employee.
- 8:56In California law we have the California labor
- 8:59code as well as the IWC wage orders and they
- 9:02provide what is the ceiling. The key principle
- 9:07for your clients is simple. If federal law and
- 9:10state law conflict on a particular issue, go
- 9:13with the one that protects the employee more.
- 9:16And that's always going to be California law.
- 9:19California is very heavily employee favored and
- 9:25So employers are well advised to figure out the
- 9:33California law and make sure you're in compliance,
- 9:36because if you're in compliance with California
- 9:39law, generally you're going to be in compliance
- 9:41with federal law. Yeah, absolutely. And can we
- 9:47go to the next slide? So before we get into the
- 9:51specifics, let's start talking about, let's just
- 9:53go over when overtime pay is applicable, when
- 9:59meal and rest periods are applicable. For overtime
- 10:02pay, there's nothing special. It's the same as
- 10:04it's always been, which is if you are paid for
- 10:07one and a half times your regular rate of pay
- 10:10for any. more than eight hours worked in a day
- 10:14or more than 40 hours worked in a week. And then
- 10:18that's for consecutive days. And on that seventh
- 10:21day, as you know, we're going to employers are
- 10:24required to pay double pay for any hours worked
- 10:27on a seventh day or for any hours worked in excess
- 10:31of 12 on on any particular day for meal periods.
- 10:37employees are entitled to an unpaid 30 -minute
- 10:42rest break for all shifts over five hours. It
- 10:49is for over five hours. If a shift is five hours,
- 10:51you may not need to provide that rest break.
- 10:56And there is a paid rest break, which is a paid
- 11:0010 -minute rest break for every four hours work.
- 11:04The reporting time pay. The reporting time pay
- 11:07is for when an employee is called into work but
- 11:10is essentially sent home and not required to
- 11:13perform any work. Typically, the employer is
- 11:16required to pay at least half of that day's wages
- 11:19or the equivalent of two hours. So now we get
- 11:26to the exempt status and how to classify. For
- 11:30the most part, all employees are going to be
- 11:33considered non -exempt. And there are a few exceptions
- 11:37where they are exempt. But the test to determine
- 11:41whether an employee is considered exempt, it's
- 11:43a two -part test. The first is the salary basis
- 11:46test, which is essentially going to be, does
- 11:49this employee meet California's or make more
- 11:53than twice California's minimum wage for full
- 11:56-time pay? Part two is going to be the duties
- 12:00test, which is going to analyze what specific
- 12:03tasks an individual performs on a day -to -day
- 12:08basis. There's going to be some differences we'll
- 12:11discuss with federal law and California law when
- 12:13it comes to the duties test. Federal law looks
- 12:18more so at what the person's job description
- 12:21says they do. And it just looks at what does
- 12:24it say that it's this individual's most important
- 12:27functions are on paper. Whereas California looks
- 12:29and says, what do you actually do in a day, not
- 12:34just what's on your what's on your job description.
- 12:37So the federal is qualitative, California quantitative.
- 12:42And we'll get into that a little bit. Yeah. And
- 12:45you're going to have the same penalties. You
- 12:49may need a federal test. You may meet the federal
- 12:52test by describing what you have the employee
- 12:58doing. But when you get to the state test for
- 13:01California, they're going to be looking at exactly
- 13:05what the particular job functions are. Is this
- 13:10person a supervisor? Is he supervising two or
- 13:13more people? And what percentage of his workday
- 13:18is doing things that require his judgment as
- 13:25opposed to what the employer tells him to do.
- 13:29Exactly. Exactly. The exercise of discretion
- 13:35is absolutely huge when it comes to the duty
- 13:38test. Every exception we go through, one of the
- 13:42questions that's asked is, does this individual
- 13:44have discretion outside and are they not being
- 13:48supervised on their normal routine decisions?
- 14:02So part one is this is going to be the first
- 14:06test, which is meeting California's minimum pay
- 14:09requirement. So the rule is very clear. An employee's
- 14:16monthly salary must be at least two times the
- 14:18state's minimum wage for full -time employment.
- 14:22To illustrate this point with 2025 figures, California's
- 14:26minimum wage currently is $16 .50. And so just
- 14:31I just want to take a quick pause here. The requirement
- 14:34is California state's minimum wage, not the local
- 14:38jurisdiction or what that industry's set minimum
- 14:43wage is. So it's always going to be California
- 14:46state minimum wage in fast food. We don't go
- 14:49and say it has to be double the $20 minimum wage.
- 14:53We just stick with California state minimum wage,
- 14:56which is $16 .50. So the calculation is $16 .50
- 15:02multiplied by two, so I'll give you double, multiplied
- 15:06by 40 hours a week, a full work week, multiplied
- 15:09by 52 weeks per year, which gives you an annual
- 15:13salary of $68 ,640 per year. So this amount will
- 15:22increase any time that the state's minimum wage
- 15:25goes up so it has to be checked on an annual
- 15:27basis or whenever the Whenever the state's minimum
- 15:31wage is changed this salary test is updated and
- 15:37is this salary test is updated And just bear
- 15:41in mind that this is only one test of a multiple
- 15:46test determination because some employers, oh,
- 15:49he's making $70 ,000 a year. It still may be
- 15:55non -exempt. So don't use this as your only marker
- 16:02in terms of whether the employee is exempt or
- 16:05not exempt. Absolutely. And when it comes to
- 16:10the person's salary, it's also important that
- 16:13it the $68 ,640 that they receive at least is
- 16:18a set salary. That doesn't include what they
- 16:22make if they have a salary plus commission. This
- 16:26has to be just strictly salary. No matter what
- 16:29they do, they're making at least $68 ,640 per
- 16:33year. There are some permissible deductions when
- 16:38it comes to quantifying This is step one. California
- 16:47generally follows federal rules. Employers can
- 16:50make deductions for full -day absences due to
- 16:53personal reasons or for sickness if there's a
- 16:56bona fide wage replacement plan. So deductions
- 17:00are also allowed for leave taken under FMLA or
- 17:04CFRA for major safety rule infractions or for
- 17:08legally required withholdings like taxes. However,
- 17:12Improper deductions can jeopardize an exempt
- 17:16status, so it's very important that you instruct
- 17:19your clients to be certain about which deductions
- 17:23they're making and why. This brings us to part
- 17:30two, to the second test, which essentially is
- 17:35the California duties test or the 50 % rule.
- 17:38We're going to talk about quite a few different
- 17:42exemptions that do apply in California. But the
- 17:47one thing that is consistent between all of them,
- 17:51besides having to meet the first test, is that
- 17:55discretion. Management tasks have to account
- 18:02for more than 50 percent of the work being performed.
- 18:08So, an employee must spend more than 50 % of
- 18:12their work time performing duties that explicitly
- 18:15qualify for this exemption. This is a major difference
- 18:19from the federal FLSA standard that we previously
- 18:23talked about that simply asks, are the primary
- 18:27job functions that you perform, the most important
- 18:30things you do, are they considered exempt? Are
- 18:34those tasks exempt? In California, the emphasis
- 18:38is always actually on task performed, not job
- 18:41titles or descriptions. So what's on paper doesn't
- 18:44count if it doesn't reflect reality. And there's
- 18:48a case I cite here at the bottom, high envy Safeway,
- 18:51which for to keep it short. The court found that
- 18:57store managers who spent most of their time on
- 18:59non -exempt tasks like stocking shelves and working
- 19:02a register were not in fact non -exempt despite
- 19:06their title and apparent managerial authority.
- 19:17Let's move into the specific duties for our first
- 19:20common exception. That's going to be the executive
- 19:23exemption. And this is going to apply to your
- 19:27department heads and business leaders. And so
- 19:32to qualify as an exempt executive, an employee
- 19:34must spend more than 50 % of their work time
- 19:37on duties that include managing a department,
- 19:41customarily and regularly directing the work
- 19:44of two or more employees, or the equivalent,
- 19:47which is interesting. The work of two or more,
- 19:52the work of the equivalent of two or more, so
- 19:54that can be one full -time employee and two part
- 19:58-time employees. That would count for two full
- 20:02-time employees or two employees. Third, having
- 20:06the authority to fire or hire people. If they
- 20:13aren't able to hire and fire, their opinion and
- 20:16their input is considered strongly by the deciding
- 20:21person in management. Finally, customer. Just
- 20:28clarify that. When you have a manager who has
- 20:36the ability to uh terminate someone's employee
- 20:40or make a decision the higher that goes heavily
- 20:44towards whether or not that person is a manager
- 20:46and and would be exempt if the person does not
- 20:51have that ability if they only are making suggestions
- 20:56to management that would probably not qualify
- 21:00as uh someone who has managerial authority and
- 21:06It's a question I know you all had situations
- 21:09where there is a person who, when their opinion
- 21:14comes out, they make the decision and pretty
- 21:18much that's going to be what's going to happen.
- 21:21That's when he says significant weight, that's
- 21:24what that means. Absolutely. And so some of the
- 21:32case law, when discussing where what it means
- 21:35to have a particular weight. It goes to the level
- 21:39of the employee to which a termination decision
- 21:42is being made. So if you have a department head
- 21:48who wants to fire someone in the lower tier of
- 21:52their department, they have the authority to
- 21:54do that. But if they were wanting to make a decision
- 21:58to fire someone directly below them and they
- 22:01needed managerial approval or a supervisor's
- 22:07approval, then their input would be considered
- 22:10heavily. and if it's considered heavily under
- 22:13California's test it may apply for an exempt
- 22:17as exact. Did we touch on this last one yet?
- 22:26Yes. Okay got it. So next we have the administrative
- 22:34exception and unfortunately this is the one exception
- 22:38that most business owners get wrong. To qualify
- 22:43under the administrative exception, the employee
- 22:48needs to spend more than 50 percent of their
- 22:51times including performing office or non -manual
- 22:55work that is related to the management policies
- 22:58or general business operations of the employer.
- 23:05This isn't someone who is helping with sales.
- 23:09It's not someone who's selling outside of the
- 23:14company. This is someone more so helping the
- 23:17company itself function and enforcing policies.
- 23:27So an example for this one that I found that
- 23:30I really liked was an HR manager. an HR manager
- 23:35who is responsible for implementing and developing
- 23:38policies for a company would be considered exempt,
- 23:42given those tasks. But an HR administrator who
- 23:46is only processing vacation time or something
- 23:50like that, they would not be considered exempt.
- 23:54Yeah, and when we talk about exempt versus non
- 23:58-exempt, it's pretty important that you understand
- 24:02why this makes a difference. And the reason it
- 24:06makes a difference because if an employee is
- 24:09exempt, they can work all day and all night,
- 24:13no lunch, no overtime pay. They don't get any
- 24:17of that. And so every employer wants everybody
- 24:21to be exempt. So they can work them as many hours
- 24:24as they want without paying them. But if they're
- 24:31exempt, which is if they're non exempt, that
- 24:36means that anytime they hit that eight hour mark,
- 24:40they gotta get more money. And if they have worked
- 24:45four hours, then you gotta give them that break.
- 24:48You don't have to give a break to an exempt person.
- 24:52At five hours, they have to get the 30 minute
- 24:56lunch break and they have to get it without any
- 25:00responsibilities. without anybody calling their
- 25:04phone, talking to them, walking in the break
- 25:07room, talking to them, because if you do, they
- 25:10get to start all over again. So that's non -exempt.
- 25:14You can sit right next to an exempt person and
- 25:18talk to them right through lunch, and it's no
- 25:20big deal. So that's why you need, you know, so
- 25:23you really need to understand the difference
- 25:25and why it makes a difference if somebody's exempt
- 25:29or non -exempt. And so I thought I wanted to
- 25:32make sure those of you who are on this call have
- 25:36a clear understanding of why it makes a difference
- 25:39when a person wants to be or the government is
- 25:45qualifying someone as exempt or non exempt. It's
- 25:50just not the penalties that are so important.
- 25:53It's that the government, if they do determine
- 25:56a person is non -exempt and you've been treating
- 26:02them as exempt, then there's going to be a lot
- 26:06of consequences to that for the employer and
- 26:10the monetary compensation is going to be significant.
- 26:15If you go over a certain level, then you reach
- 26:18into another category of the law and JR will
- 26:22talk about that coming up. Okay. Yeah, go ahead.
- 26:27Okay. And I see we have some questions in the
- 26:32chat. What do we have here? Why don't you wait
- 26:37until we finish your outline and then you can
- 26:39go back for questions. Understood. No problem.
- 26:43Let's see. So this, we just finished talking
- 26:46about the business exception. Now we're going
- 26:50to go to the one that applies to us as lawyers.
- 26:53That's going to be the Learned or Artistic Exemption,
- 26:59and also known commonly as the Professional Exemption.
- 27:05To qualify an employee must spend more than 50
- 27:10% of their time on exempt duties and fit into
- 27:13one of two paths, either be a licensed certified
- 27:17professional or a learned professional. And I'll
- 27:22go through those right now. A licensed certified
- 27:27professional is going to cover someone who is
- 27:30licensed by the state of California in the professions
- 27:35such as law, medicine, dentistry, optometry,
- 27:39architecture, engineering, teaching, and accounting.
- 27:45While pharmacists are given a special carve out
- 27:49here, Pharmacists and registered nurses are generally
- 27:54excluded as exempt employees unless they specifically
- 27:59meet the exempt criteria. Although it says medicine,
- 28:06nurses are not always considered to be exempt
- 28:09employees. What about paralegals? Paralegals
- 28:14are not considered exempt. Unfortunately. Learned
- 28:24professionals. Learned professionals, this is
- 28:28gonna be someone who has an advanced degree.
- 28:32Typically this is in science where you have someone
- 28:35who's a PhD and they are essentially just in
- 28:38a lab doing research and they're in a very highly
- 28:43specialized field and they're researching something
- 28:48that is very unique. and requires someone of
- 28:52their experience, someone of their experience
- 28:56and intelligence. The learned professional is
- 29:01often a lesser used criteria, but it is available.
- 29:05There's also the artistic professional, which
- 29:08is going to apply mostly to musicians. Musicians
- 29:12and all types of artists, whether it be someone
- 29:15who paints or whatever it is that they do. Under
- 29:21the artistic professional is actually where paralegals
- 29:25are specifically designated as not being an exempt
- 29:30professional. So it'll be journalists, news writers,
- 29:35and paralegals are all considered non -exempt
- 29:39employees under the artistic professional standard.
- 29:43Exemption. So there are three others. These are
- 29:51lesser disputed. The computer software exemption.
- 29:56So this actually has a different criteria for
- 29:59how it evaluates what the standard pay for a
- 30:05computer software exemption is at $56 .97, which
- 30:10is a lot more than the $33 that is normally required
- 30:14for the other exemptions. So a computer specialist,
- 30:20this applies to skilled computer professionals.
- 30:23They must be engaged in duties like applying
- 30:25systems analysis techniques or designing, developing,
- 30:29and analyzing computer systems or programs, stuff
- 30:31I could never do. Outside sales exception, this
- 30:36is actually probably the most straightforward
- 30:37one. All it requires is that the individual is
- 30:4218 years old. spends 50 percent of their time
- 30:46or more outside of the place of business in the
- 30:53act of selling while they're selling or servicing
- 30:57customers of the business. Then lastly, there
- 31:00is no salary test. Do you spend more than 50
- 31:04percent of your time outside of the business?
- 31:07Are you at least 18? There's actually one more
- 31:10I just remembered. The majority of your pay comes
- 31:17from commissions. Lastly, we have commissioned
- 31:21inside sales. And this is limited to the industries
- 31:26governed by IWC Order 4 and 7. And if you don't
- 31:30know what those are, that's OK. I got you. IWC
- 31:334 is going to be the professional, technical,
- 31:35and mechanical fields. Whereas IWC 7 is basically
- 31:40think merchants, retail, wholesale, and warehouses.
- 31:44That is IWC 7 for them. They require that an
- 31:49employee must earn 1 .5 times the state minimum
- 31:53wage, less than the double, two times the minimum
- 31:56wage for the others. More than 50 percent of
- 32:00their compensation must come from commissions.
- 32:05Also, there has to be a written agreement for
- 32:10payment. The financial repercussions of misclassification
- 32:23are severe. Unfortunately, if an employee is
- 32:27misclassified, that opens up a company to potentially
- 32:31four years of back pay for unpaid meal, rest,
- 32:39and lunch. It's important to continually audit
- 32:44your own staff. and make sure that your job descriptions
- 32:48are up to date and that everyone who is being
- 32:53classified as exempt truly is exempt. Just as
- 32:59an example with regard to that and the payment
- 33:04of wages and properly classifying employees,
- 33:08we had a situation where one employee complained
- 33:13that they weren't being paid properly. And the
- 33:17lawyer that they went to went around and gathered
- 33:20up a bunch of employees and the employer didn't
- 33:25have the records that they should have had. This
- 33:28one employee said that he was owed $200. By the
- 33:34time that they got the other employees and the
- 33:39employer didn't have the proper documentation
- 33:42of meal breaks and overtime. The actual penalties
- 33:49and liability to the company came out to about
- 33:53$3 .5 million. They had quite a few employees.
- 33:58We were able to negotiate it down to about $650
- 34:02,000. But this all came from one employee complaining
- 34:08and when they had to produce all the records.
- 34:12And that did not include the attorney's fees
- 34:15that they had to pay us. So it's really important
- 34:19because you might be dealing with one employee,
- 34:22but with Paga, and now Paga has changed, we were
- 34:27dealing with the previous Paga. And Paga is private
- 34:31attorney general act. And it allows... an attorney
- 34:39to act as though the attorney general and on
- 34:42behalf of the state and so they can get groups
- 34:47of employees. So it's just very important that
- 34:51you are cognizant of what the penalties and exposure
- 34:56is for making a mistake. Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 35:02And like you said, those penalties, they add,
- 35:05then they multiply because more people get involved
- 35:07and it just becomes a big issue. So one of the
- 35:12other penalties that actually happens is from
- 35:15waiting time penalties. And so waiting time penalties
- 35:18are assessed up to 30 days of waiting time penalties
- 35:22for every violation that is found to have occurred.
- 35:26And that accounts for each and every violation.
- 35:29So that adds up insanely. The litigation exposure.
- 35:37Beyond direct penalties, misclassification is
- 35:40a primary driver for class action lawsuits in
- 35:43Paga, like my dad was just saying, and it can
- 35:46truly lead to massive, massive penalties. The
- 35:53court in Rodriguez v. Paravar, I hope I'm saying
- 35:58that right, in Paravar made that very clear because
- 36:02what they found is that despite the management
- 36:05claiming that they believed that their employees
- 36:08were exempt, They weren't and the court basically
- 36:13said it's your responsibility to make sure your
- 36:16employees are properly classified and they were
- 36:18hit with a fairly large judgment. So what can
- 36:28employer do to mitigate these risks? Well, proactive
- 36:32diligence is absolutely key. Getting ahead of
- 36:35the issues before they occur. making sure that
- 36:38your policies are up -to -date, making sure that
- 36:41the job description that you provide your employees
- 36:45actually matches the job duties that employees
- 36:48actually have. The audit should involve detailed
- 36:54questionnaires where employees and their managers
- 36:57document actual time spent. This is the big issue
- 37:01that a lot of management will have is specifically
- 37:04with these questionnaires. It's because management
- 37:08is going to want an employee to be working on
- 37:12A, B, and C. But if the day actually requires
- 37:15that the employee work on D, E, and F, it becomes
- 37:21an issue. Management's expectations and the realities
- 37:24of what the employees on the ground are experiencing,
- 37:27they differ. And that's where we get into this
- 37:30issue of misclassification. I can imagine that
- 37:34some of you might be asking, why is it so difficult
- 37:37for employers to have proper classification for
- 37:44their employees? The answer is actually fairly
- 37:46simple. Things change. As individuals grow within
- 37:51companies, they assume more responsibility, job
- 37:57descriptions are not updated. and they may shift
- 38:01around from different location to different location.
- 38:04Their duties may change. And so a company may
- 38:08be acting in good faith by classifying someone
- 38:10as exempt when they're truly not exempt. So it's
- 38:17not necessarily like a reckless disregard for
- 38:20proper auditing of employee services that often
- 38:23lead to these problems. A lot of times it's honestly,
- 38:26like many other things, just honest mistakes.
- 38:29So I just thought I'd throw that out there. Yeah,
- 38:32and the determination is arbitrary because a
- 38:36judge has to decide whether or not the duties
- 38:41that this particular employee are performing
- 38:45are actually considered managerial because there's
- 38:51no bright line that, you know, like it's A4.
- 38:55If it's A4, then it's fine. But if it's A7, it's
- 38:58not. I mean, those are clear standards, right?
- 39:01But the arbitrator or the judge has to look at
- 39:06the task performed and make a decision as to
- 39:10whether or not these are exempt duties based
- 39:14on case law. But it's still his opinion or her
- 39:19opinion as to whether or not those duties constitute
- 39:22exempt or non -exempt. And of course, you can
- 39:25always challenge it. but it's going to cost a
- 39:28lot yeah you know appeals are very expensive
- 39:31very very expensive yeah um okay yeah i just
- 39:42want to remind you you got 20 minutes so you
- 39:44want to get some question and answer then so
- 39:46i'm not corrupting you now we're near the end
- 39:50here um i think we only have about two slides
- 39:53left just check in We've talked about conducting
- 40:02regular job duty audits and also maintaining
- 40:06accurate job descriptions that reflect reality,
- 40:09not aspirations. This goes back to management,
- 40:12what management thinks employees should be doing
- 40:15versus what the job actually requires. Training
- 40:19managers. Managers are on the front line of every
- 40:23organization. They must understand what meal
- 40:26and rest break requirements are applicable and
- 40:28what constitutes hours worked, particularly regarding
- 40:32off the clock work. And this also comes into
- 40:34play with having a good HR department or legal
- 40:37counsel that's advising you on what job functions
- 40:41actually qualify as truly managerial tasks. Lastly,
- 40:49when in doubt, the classified employee is not
- 40:52exempt. It's always cheaper to obtain legal advice
- 40:59on the front end than it is to defend a lawsuit.
- 41:03It's always going to be cheaper to have your
- 41:07client call you than for your client to call
- 41:09you once they have a lawsuit on their desk. Just
- 41:14have them call when they have a question. Then
- 41:19lastly, first, remember that the exempt status
- 41:31is truly the exception, not the rule. When in
- 41:34doubt, non -exempt them out. Second, The more
- 41:39than 50 % duties test and the twice the minimum
- 41:42wage salary test are non -negotiable pillars
- 41:45of the compliant classification. If the test
- 41:49doesn't fit, you must classify them as not exempt.
- 41:54Third, meticulous documentation of your classification
- 41:57analysis is the best defense against future claims.
- 42:01Make sure you know what your employees are doing.
- 42:03Make sure you know what it is that they're actually
- 42:05doing, not just what you want them to be doing.
- 42:09Finally, this area of law is incredibly dynamic.
- 42:17There's new legislation and court decisions constantly
- 42:20shaping interpretations and changing the legal
- 42:23landscape of how we interpret. exemptions. So
- 42:28it's important to stay up to date and to make
- 42:31sure your clients trust you and call you and
- 42:33that you stay up to date on what is and is not
- 42:37an exempt position. And always err on the side
- 42:42of non -exempt. If there's any question in your
- 42:46mind, go to the non -exempt. And also another
- 42:52area that is very closely related to this, that
- 42:56some employers who think that they're really
- 42:58smart do, and that's independent contractors.
- 43:04But, you know, and what would happen in a situation,
- 43:09and I know this is not to summon off independent
- 43:11contractors, but some employers will determine
- 43:15that this person is an independent contractor,
- 43:19so they hire them and say you're an independent
- 43:22contractor and work them as so, and they have
- 43:27no responsibility for that employee's conduct
- 43:31or meals. And then that employee complains and
- 43:35gets, and then there's a determination that that
- 43:39person does, is performing, duties that are very
- 43:45close to what the employer does. And so they
- 43:48get determined to be an employee. And when they
- 43:53get that determination, then they're not exempt.
- 43:57And so now you got a bunch of meal periods, you
- 44:01got overtime, and all that comes into play. you
- 44:07have to deal with that and they can go back as
- 44:10long as they want, the three years or four years
- 44:15in some cases, and you really got a problem on
- 44:19your hands. But the independent contractor versus
- 44:23employee is another area that you should really
- 44:27look into because a lot of employers get that
- 44:30wrong. because they want to save money or they're
- 44:34trying to be more productive and some guys they
- 44:37you know some people think they're really smart
- 44:39and then they end up getting you know hit with
- 44:42a bunch of fines okay sorry just wanted to put
- 44:45that in there now absolutely true absolutely
- 44:48true and super important That's the end of our
- 44:54presentation. Thank you so much everyone for
- 44:57hanging out with us. I see we've got 41 people
- 44:59and it's been an absolute pleasure to be able
- 45:02to present. You have a lot of questions in your
- 45:05Q &A. You need to go there and answer those.
- 45:08Yeah, I will. I just wanted to say thank you
- 45:10first and then we'll get to questions. I got
- 45:13you. I just want to say thank you again. Now
- 45:17we're happy to open the floor to any questions
- 45:19you may have. Okay, the first question is, I
- 45:24was under the impression that the SOL was three
- 45:27years, statute limited, three years for most
- 45:30wage issues, but you can use unfair competition
- 45:34to go back four years. Is that right? And just
- 45:39quickly, I would say, it's 70 % right. The four
- 45:45years goes back if you knowingly did it, not
- 45:48unfair competition. work somebody, they can go
- 45:54back four years, not three. All right, next question.
- 46:02I just got here. What is it that gets an employee
- 46:05to make a move against the employer initially?
- 46:09Well, It could be a number of things, but the
- 46:13first is, you know, the most easy thing to think
- 46:16of, which is just a general disagreement between
- 46:19management and employees. There's normally a
- 46:21discrepancy on on a time sheet and the time and
- 46:25if the. issue isn't resolved to the satisfaction
- 46:29of the employee, they may go talk to a lawyer.
- 46:32Unfortunately, we've, well, fortunately, because
- 46:35now we all have, we have jobs, but California
- 46:37has become such a state that, you know, it's
- 46:40so sue heavy that most mistakes that should be
- 46:45resolved quickly end up going to litigation.
- 46:48Yeah. And no one from the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 46:52fits into the category of those lawyers that
- 46:56have people go get jobs only to determine whether
- 47:00or not they're complying with all the different
- 47:04orders so they can sue them. But there are a
- 47:07number of, there are some law firms that will
- 47:11have people go and get jobs to determine whether
- 47:16or not they're right for a lawsuit. So that might
- 47:19be one of the not very many. people act like
- 47:23that, but there are some. That might be a reason
- 47:26that it motivates people. The next one is, how
- 47:33do collective bargaining agreements impact classifications
- 47:36or do they? A collective bargaining agreement
- 47:41can affect certain wage and hour rights like
- 47:45overtime and meal periods. only if the CBA meets
- 47:50specific statutory requirements. But if it doesn't,
- 47:53if it doesn't, then it does not override the
- 47:57requirement. Oh, let me actually say this. Either
- 47:59way, the collective bargaining agreement cannot
- 48:03override the requirement to meet California's
- 48:06exemption criteria unless the law provides a
- 48:10clear carve out. But anything short of that,
- 48:14the CBA doesn't have any effect. Okay, and the
- 48:18last one is, is interest accrued? Technically,
- 48:25yes. And I saw this through quite a few cases
- 48:29where interest would be accrued through prejudgment
- 48:32interest. So from the initiation of the lawsuit,
- 48:35so it's not technically interest from the time
- 48:38of issue, but from the time the lawsuit was brought.
- 48:45Okay, I'm sorry. There's some more jar if a person
- 48:50If a person works less than five hours a shift
- 48:55do they get overtime and meal breaks I'm sorry.
- 49:03I was reading I was reading the next one. Sorry
- 49:05what it was if a person works less than five
- 49:07hours a shift Do they get over? time and meal
- 49:10breaks. So no, if a person works less than five
- 49:14hours a shift, they will they would qualify for
- 49:18a rest break because you get that at your fourth
- 49:20hour. But over time, you would have to work over
- 49:25eight hours and then meal breaks, you would have
- 49:27to work past the fifth hour. What about two five
- 49:31hour shifts in one day? That's a great question.
- 49:37That would be a split shift issue. Let's say
- 49:41you work eight to three and then five to 10.
- 49:46Those shifts are considered independent of one
- 49:48another. It's as if they're separate days. workaround
- 50:00that the law has built in is through something
- 50:03called a split shift payment, which is if your
- 50:06workday is interrupted for any significant period
- 50:09of time where you have a morning shift and then
- 50:11an afternoon shift, your employer is required
- 50:15to pay you the equivalent of one hour of minimum
- 50:19wage for the inconvenience, essentially. Under
- 50:25the Fair Labor Standards Act, A willful violation
- 50:29extends to the statute of limitations from two
- 50:33years to three years, or occurs when an employer
- 50:37either knew or should have, knew or showed reckless
- 50:43disregard for whether or not its conduct was
- 50:46prohibited by the FSLA. The four year is to extend
- 50:51California labor code not. non one -year penalty
- 50:55violations is under the UCL. So I don't think
- 51:03that's a question. That's a comment. Thank you.
- 51:05Appreciate that. Yeah. Can employers deduct from
- 51:11and exempt employees leave bank for partial work
- 51:15days? Yes. but there are specific criteria for
- 51:26when that's permissible. It's normally not a
- 51:31good idea, but there are situations where that's
- 51:38permissible. Here, let me show you. Permissible
- 51:51deductions here at the bottom. Only for full
- 51:55-day absences, personal reasons, sickness under
- 51:58a bonafide plan, FMLA, CFRA, major safety rule
- 52:02infractions, or legally required withholdings.
- 52:06Does that answer your question? I don't believe.
- 52:12We do have some additional questions that we
- 52:14receive via email if you'd like me to read those
- 52:17out for you. Is that okay? Sure. That'd be great.
- 52:20So with companies shifting to remote work, have
- 52:24you seen that cause any complications with figuring
- 52:27out exempt versus non -exempt classifications,
- 52:30particularly regarding break tracking and managing
- 52:33hours worked? You want me to answer that? There
- 52:43are situations where you get, it doesn't change
- 52:47the exempt to non -exempt. or non exempt to exempt.
- 52:52The way you run into a problem with that is they
- 52:56are still entitled to the meal breaks and rest
- 53:00breaks. And so what we have suggested to our
- 53:06clients is that on time sheets, the employee
- 53:11must indicate that they did actually take their
- 53:15meal break and they have to sign in and sign
- 53:17out. for the meal and rest breaks because they
- 53:22are non -exempt employees. Now, if you have an
- 53:26exempt employee, then you don't have to worry
- 53:28about that. But if they're non -exempt, you need
- 53:32to be able to prove that that person took their
- 53:36meal break and their lunch break and any other...
- 53:42benefits that go after, you know, you gotta show
- 53:46that they clock out at five, they clock in when
- 53:48they clock in and clock out. And you can have
- 53:52a real issue if you don't do that because even
- 53:55though remote work is something that came upon
- 53:58us from COVID, it doesn't change the law as it's
- 54:03written in terms of protecting employee rights.
- 54:08Just to add on to that, we also had a case where
- 54:12it's a fully remote company based out of Illinois,
- 54:16but staff in California, Texas, Utah, and Nevada.
- 54:22The practice they had that actually turned out
- 54:25to be really good. I don't know if we've talked
- 54:26about this, but we're normally on the defense
- 54:28side of most litigation. We're normally representing
- 54:32employers. This employer's practice was to instruct
- 54:36their staff through a group teams or whatever
- 54:40chat they were using at the time. Anytime they
- 54:43were going to take a break, they just had to
- 54:47mention it in the actual chat log itself. That
- 54:52came in handy like you would not believe. We
- 54:56were able to eliminate so many claims just because
- 55:00we had had a company that implemented. a good
- 55:04record -keeping policy. I know it may be different
- 55:07for most remote workers. They may not be keeping
- 55:11a time sheet as good as they should, or companies
- 55:13may not have policies requiring that. But if
- 55:16you have a situation where your team has a remote
- 55:19setup and they can send their managers a message,
- 55:24no judgment on it, just like, hey, I'll be back
- 55:27in 10 minutes taking a break. having those records
- 55:30for employers later down the road is amazing.
- 55:34Yeah. I just want to comment. There's a comment
- 55:38here by Seth that says that even on a split shift,
- 55:44if you work more than eight hours in any one
- 55:48day, that you are entitled to overtime. I believe
- 55:53that that is the law. may have gotten that wrong,
- 55:58JR, because if you, in any 24 -hour period, if
- 56:03you work more than eight hours, then you're entitled
- 56:06to overtime, even if it's a split shift. It's
- 56:12only, you're not entitled to it if it's less
- 56:16than eight hours in a day. And then I believe
- 56:21you are also entitled to overtime if you work
- 56:24so many hours within a week. But I mean, the
- 56:29question was the split shift. And I think we
- 56:33should look at that again, because my understanding
- 56:36was any time you work more than eight hours in
- 56:40a day, because if you did that, every employer
- 56:42would have people working split shifts. So they
- 56:45didn't have to pay overtime. Thank you for that,
- 56:49Seth. And I'm hoping I'm saying it right, S -E
- 56:51-T -H. Yeah. Well, Seth, I'm going to look into
- 56:55that. But either way, I appreciate your input.
- 57:03One final question because you guys touched on
- 57:05audits. This attendee is wondering how often
- 57:09they should suggest that their clients audit
- 57:12exempt classifications and are there any specific
- 57:16red flags that should prompt a deeper review?
- 57:21Yes, I think a great time to perform an audit
- 57:25would be during performance reviews. If performance
- 57:29reviews are given annually, I don't necessarily
- 57:32see that you have to, assuming that the employee
- 57:36doesn't change positions within the company within
- 57:39the year, I don't think that there's, there may
- 57:41not be a need to, let me rephrase that. It can
- 57:45be helpful, but it is not necessary to have a
- 57:48check more than once a year. Maybe if you do
- 57:51every six months, that's being extremely cautious.
- 57:54And it can be something as simple as a questionnaire
- 57:57asking the individual to fill out, describe to
- 58:00me what you do in a day. What tasks do you typically
- 58:06complete? And go through, there's a series of
- 58:10questions that you can ask just to get a feeling
- 58:12for what it is that they do in a day. Can you
- 58:15repeat that last part of the question? I forgot
- 58:17it. They were wondering if there were any specific
- 58:21red flags that they should be on the lookout
- 58:24for when they're doing these reviews or audits,
- 58:28I should say. That's a great question. I think
- 58:33that would vary quite a bit job by job. There
- 58:40are just so many different things that could
- 58:42happen. but for a red flag when doing audits,
- 58:50red flag number one, refusal to participate,
- 58:54that could be an issue. Also, Seth, I just saw
- 59:01your question regarding the fast food minimum
- 59:07wage being $20. We touched on that in the beginning
- 59:10and that is the Minimum wage requirement is only
- 59:20we only look at California's minimum wage policy.
- 59:24Industry specific minimum wages aren't applicable
- 59:27when we're determining what the legal threshold
- 59:33is for this. point 25 calculation of like what
- 59:40the salary threshold is. It's just this constant
- 59:43$16 and 50 cents. We don't go industry specific.
- 59:47Yeah, and Michelle says that the four years under
- 59:52the UCL and And I think I said that the four
- 59:57years, if it's intentional, Michelle says that
- 1:00:01that's not true. It's under the UCL. And that's
- 1:00:05something that I will look into because that's
- 1:00:08not my understanding, but I will look into it
- 1:00:11because she may be correct. Yeah. OK. There is
- 1:00:19I just want to make sure we got everybody that
- 1:00:23was asking a question. So that about wraps up
- 1:00:31Q &A. I have no more questions from the attendees.
- 1:00:38Thank you so much for your time this evening.
- 1:00:40We appreciate you giving this presentation and
- 1:00:42I hope our attendees enjoy the rest of their
- 1:00:44evening. All right. Thank you so much, everyone.
- 1:00:48Appreciate your questions. Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:00:51You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:00:54Visit bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.