Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Greenwashing: New Rules and Rising Risks Related to Sustainability Claims
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Greenwashing New Rules and Rising Risks Related
- 0:10to Sustainability Claims. I'm Alla Policastro,
- 0:14Director of Education and Professional Development
- 0:16at Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I'm delighted
- 0:19to introduce our speakers today, Sam Hushhour
- 0:22and Jennifer King. Sam is an attorney at Fresh
- 0:25Fields where he is the compliance and regulations
- 0:28co -lead of the Global ESG Risk and Advisory
- 0:31Group. He's a strategic regulatory advisor to
- 0:35companies navigating evolving regulatory regimes,
- 0:38bringing new products to market or facing regulatory
- 0:41scrutiny. He counsels global brands on sustainability
- 0:44matters, including California's new landmark
- 0:47climate laws, and is recognized in the 2026 Law
- 0:51Dragon 500 Leading Environmental Lawyers Guide.
- 0:54From 2010 to 2016, Sam served in the White House
- 0:58Counsel's Office, ultimately as Associate White
- 1:00House Counsel, where he advised senior White
- 1:03House and executive branch officials on high
- 1:05scrutiny matters and led the White House compliance
- 1:08team. During 2020 and 2021, Sam served as legal
- 1:12director to the Biden -Harris presidential transition
- 1:14team. Jennifer King is an associate at Fresh
- 1:18Fields where she's a member of the firm's global
- 1:20sanctions, export controls, and trade practice.
- 1:23Jennifer advises clients on regulatory compliance
- 1:26and enforcement issues related to sanctions,
- 1:29export controls, and human rights, and engages
- 1:31with government regulators on behalf of her clients
- 1:34in a range of industry sectors. She also advises
- 1:37her clients on issues related to sanctions, export
- 1:40controls, and import customs, human rights, AML,
- 1:43and ABC. And now let's get started with Sam and
- 1:47Jennifer. Hi, thanks so much, Al, for that great
- 1:54warm welcome. And thank you to everybody who's
- 1:57tuning in today. It's great to have you all here
- 2:01for this conversation. And thanks to the Beverly
- 2:04Hills Bar Association for hosting us all. You
- 2:10know, I think the conversation we want to have
- 2:12today, so I'm a disputes counselor for fresh
- 2:15fields at San Francisco and, you know, I think
- 2:18the conversation we want to have today, you know,
- 2:22is about the kind of rising, the rising risks
- 2:28in. in the Green Plains space and the way in
- 2:33which those have been changing over the last
- 2:36few years as additional regulations have been
- 2:38laid on and new topics of interest have arisen
- 2:42for folks in the space. As consumer demand for
- 2:47sustainable products and environmentally conscious
- 2:48brands has risen over the years, companies have
- 2:51faced ever -increasing scrutiny around their
- 2:53sustainability goals and representations, things
- 2:56like the MedZero pledges or carbon neutrality
- 3:01for products. And they face this type of scrutiny
- 3:04from regulators, state attorneys general, consumers,
- 3:08watchdog NGOs, and investors. A wave of new laws
- 3:13recently have aimed at combating greenwashing.
- 3:17And those have been clicking into place at the
- 3:18state level and globally. And they are markedly
- 3:22increasing risks associated with allegedly false,
- 3:26misleading, or unsubstantiated sustainability
- 3:28claims. At the same time, the regulatory and
- 3:32enforcement landscape governing sustainability
- 3:35claims has grown increasingly complex and politically
- 3:38charged. And today, We're here to discuss the
- 3:41developments in three areas. We're going to talk
- 3:43about federal and state regulation. We're going
- 3:45to talk about state attorneys, general enforcement,
- 3:48and we're going to talk about private plaintiffs
- 3:50and competitor litigation. We'll also then compare
- 3:53the US landscape a bit with global developments,
- 3:57particularly in Europe. And we'll close by outlining
- 3:59some practical steps that companies can take
- 4:01in this world to manage risk. We're aiming to
- 4:06save a little time for questions. So if you do
- 4:08have questions throughout, Please submit them
- 4:11and we'll do our best to get to them at the end.
- 4:14All right. With that, I'm going to turn it over
- 4:15to my colleague in New York, Jen, to kick us
- 4:18off with a little talk about greenwashing. Thanks
- 4:24very much, Sam. Could we please advance to slide
- 4:26five? Perfect. Thank you. So before we launch
- 4:35into the trends that we are seeing in this space,
- 4:38let's very quickly align on what we mean when
- 4:40we say greenwashing. So greenwashing is a term
- 4:43applied to the distribution of misleading or
- 4:46false information regarding the environmental
- 4:48impact of a company's products, services, or
- 4:51business operations to make them appear more
- 4:53sustainable or green than they are in reality.
- 4:57Demand for sustainable products and consumers'
- 5:00willingness to pay a price premium in some cases
- 5:03for more sustainable products has made green
- 5:06claims both a valuable part of a business strategy
- 5:08and also a target of litigation. Statutes, guidance,
- 5:12and litigation concerning greenwashing have been
- 5:14around for quite some time now, but the ratchets
- 5:17are turning. As we'll discuss, greenwashing can
- 5:21be a focus for state attorneys general and a
- 5:23source of private litigation risk equally. Companies
- 5:27that engage in greenwashing may suffer reputational
- 5:30harm, regulatory scrutiny and enforcement, or
- 5:33litigation brought under state consumer protection
- 5:35laws. So this is certainly a topic to keep one's
- 5:38eye on. Next slide, please. And one more. So.
- 5:52We'll start today by talking about some trends
- 5:54that we're seeing in the regulatory landscape.
- 5:58Beginning at the federal level, the Trump administration's
- 6:02fossil energy agenda and rollback of climate
- 6:04and environmental protections and goals have
- 6:06set a deregulatory tone at the federal level,
- 6:09with the federal government even looking to intervene
- 6:11to block enforcement of state climate requirements.
- 6:14State lawmakers and regulators, however, continue
- 6:16to be active in this space. with Democratic -led
- 6:20states in particular looking to step in to fill
- 6:22a perceived gap, and Republican -led states often
- 6:25advancing a contrary policy agenda. Since 2021,
- 6:29a growing number of states have enacted sustainability
- 6:31-related statutes, regulations, and policy directives,
- 6:34many of which bear on a variety of aspects of
- 6:37sustainability claims. Next slide, please. And
- 6:43one more. So just spend a moment at the federal
- 6:50level. The FTC has published a guidance document
- 6:54called the Green Guides, which serve as sort
- 6:57of the background federal standard on this topic.
- 7:02To begin at the beginning, the FTC Act is the
- 7:04source of the FTC's legal authority, and it prohibits
- 7:07unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting
- 7:10commerce. Unfair or deceptive environmental marketing
- 7:14claims can violate Section 5. The FTC Green Guides
- 7:18are an administrative guidance document that
- 7:20was published in order to help consumers think
- 7:22about environmental marketing claims in particular
- 7:25and how they can avoid violations of Section
- 7:285. The Green Guides describe how consumers are
- 7:33likely to interpret environmental claims, what
- 7:35substantiation is generally required, and how
- 7:38claims can be qualified to avoid deception. Although
- 7:42they're not legally binding, the Green Guides
- 7:44guide FTC's Section 5 enforcement activity. They've
- 7:48been incorporated into many state consumer protection
- 7:50laws, and they're widely used by regulators,
- 7:52courts, and industry groups to assess compliance
- 7:54with federal and state consumer protection laws.
- 7:59To give a little bit of background on this sort
- 8:02of very influential document, the guides lay
- 8:06out several general principles for environmental
- 8:08marketing. First, as expected, Claims must be
- 8:14true, and they must not overstate an environmental
- 8:17attribute or benefit. Any qualifications or disclosures
- 8:21on a claim should be clear, prominent, and understandable.
- 8:25Claims should specify whether they refer to a
- 8:27product, that product's packaging, a service,
- 8:30or just some portion of the same. And comparative
- 8:34claims should be clear to avoid consumer confusion.
- 8:38Ultimately, the FTC expects claims to be substantiated
- 8:41before they're made. The central substantiation
- 8:44requirement is that environmental claims have
- 8:46a reasonable basis, which in practice generally
- 8:49requires competent and reliable scientific evidence
- 8:52to support the claim. The guides instruct marketers
- 8:56to consider both express claims and implied claims,
- 8:59so companies ultimately must ensure that all
- 9:01reasonable interpretations consumers might take
- 9:03from an advertisement are supported by the proper
- 9:06scientific evidence. The guides also provide
- 9:09specific guidance regarding numerous specific
- 9:12categories of environmental claims, such as a
- 9:15general environmental benefit claim, recyclable
- 9:18claims, claims that a product contains recycled
- 9:21content, renewable materials claims, carbon offset
- 9:24claims, and others. The guides were originally
- 9:28published in 1992 and they were last updated
- 9:31in 2012. The FTC began a review in December of
- 9:352022 and sought public comment, but No revised
- 9:38guides have been issued to date. The status of
- 9:41that review remains a bit unclear. We would note,
- 9:44however, that bills have been introduced in Congress
- 9:46to update or replace certain aspects of the green
- 9:49guides, including by borrowing from newer state
- 9:51statutes. This is certainly a space to watch
- 9:54as there appears to be some bipartisan and industry
- 9:56support for some of this legislation. And to
- 10:04take a look at another agency that has been active
- 10:05in this space as well, Under the Biden administration,
- 10:10the SEC took a number of steps aimed at cracking
- 10:12down on greenwashing and standardizing companies'
- 10:14climate -related disclosures. For instance, the
- 10:17SEC launched a climate and ESG task force, adopted
- 10:20its climate -related disclosure rules, which
- 10:22were ultimately challenged and stayed, and amended
- 10:24the names rule to subject ESG and sustainability
- 10:27funds to an 80 % investment requirement. Under
- 10:31the Trump administration, however, the SEC disbanded
- 10:34the climate and ESG task force proposed rescinding
- 10:37the climate related disclosures rule and is currently
- 10:39reviewing the names rule amendments. We'll leave
- 10:43the names rule and SEC considerations outside
- 10:45this presentation as that would be a completely
- 10:47separate specialized presentation. But we did
- 10:50want to highlight the general SEC pullback in
- 10:52light of state efforts in the climate disclosure
- 10:54space in particular. Even though there's been
- 10:58some slimming, Many public companies continue
- 11:00to publish sustainability reports, net zero commitments,
- 11:03climate transition plans, and other ESG disclosures
- 11:07due to investor, customer, lender, and stakeholder
- 11:09expectations. And an increasing number of companies
- 11:11are subject to mandatory reporting in state or
- 11:14global jurisdictions separate from any federal
- 11:18requirements. The lack of a federal standard
- 11:21and fragmentation of the sustainability disclosure
- 11:23landscape contributes to opportunities for inconsistency
- 11:26in reporting it claims. So now I'm going to hand
- 11:30it over to Sam to tell us a little bit about
- 11:32the state regulatory landscape. Thanks, Jen.
- 11:40So state regulation. As Jen was saying, this
- 11:47is an area in which we see in the US, at least,
- 11:50a lot of the substantive work being done right
- 11:52now. said that the state consumer protection
- 11:59law serves as the foundation for green claims
- 12:03regulation and enforcement. And that in light
- 12:06of concerns about potential corporate greenwashing,
- 12:11state legislators, and particularly in California,
- 12:13have taken a number of steps to tighten anti
- 12:16-greenwashing provisions and requirements. And
- 12:20so today I want to talk about three different
- 12:22buckets of laws. One, consumer protection laws
- 12:27that provide the basic foundation and apply in
- 12:32the context of potential misrepresentations or
- 12:37misleading statements about green matters. Two,
- 12:42circular economy laws that increasingly are adding
- 12:45specificities to certain types of claims or specific
- 12:50requirements to certain types of claims around
- 12:52packaging and product contents. and three sustainability
- 12:58disclosure laws, like the landmark SB 253 and
- 13:02SB 261 laws in California, and perhaps a lesser
- 13:07-known one, AB 1305, that are all applying a
- 13:11powerful new transparency function, particularly
- 13:13around climate and emissions and carbon -related
- 13:17claims. Next slide, please. So on consumer protection,
- 13:30every state in the background has a UDAP statute,
- 13:35an unfair and deceptive acts of practices statute.
- 13:39These are sometimes called the little FTC acts,
- 13:42and they prohibit unfair, deceptive acts of practices
- 13:44in trade or commerce. Each one is a little bit
- 13:48different, and how closely they track to section
- 13:52five is a little bit different depending on states.
- 13:55But many are construed in harmony with FTC Act
- 13:59Section 5. Some even have expressed provisions
- 14:04to that effect. But a key point about the UDAP
- 14:10statutes is that many of them also, and in California
- 14:13it does, carry a private right of action, which
- 14:16is a remedy that the FTC's Section 5 does not
- 14:19provide. And which means that they serve as the
- 14:22basis for forcing the significant amount of class
- 14:25action and consumer litigation. Depending on
- 14:29the statute and the context also, violations
- 14:32of other laws can serve as predicates for UDAP
- 14:34claims. So in California, for example, there's
- 14:36an illegality prom that means that the violation
- 14:42of other laws in connection with business activity
- 14:46can give rise to a private enforcement risk,
- 14:49can be leveraged under UDAP. And so that means
- 14:52that there's enforcement, it can create enforcement
- 14:54risk related to violation or private enforcement
- 14:57risk related to violations of more administrative
- 14:59state statutes such as some of the other ones.
- 15:02I'm going to talk about the disclosure statutes.
- 15:06So a number of state UDAP or green marketing
- 15:08laws also incorporate the FTC green guides explicitly
- 15:12by reference. And so if that's true in California,
- 15:15for example, section 17580 .5, It makes it unlawful
- 15:20to make an untruthful deceptive or misleading
- 15:22environmental marketing claim and expressly incorporates
- 15:25the FTC green guides. Conformity with those green
- 15:28guides is a defense under that section. And then,
- 15:32Section 17580 actually also requires that the
- 15:36marketer maintain documentation substantiating
- 15:39its environmental representations, and that documentation
- 15:42needs to include whether it conforms to the FTC
- 15:45standards. So the documentation requirement also
- 15:48embeds essentially the green guides within it.
- 15:52Other states, just Minnesota and Maine, also
- 15:55include expressly incorporate the FTC green guides.
- 16:00So the green guides, while not a binding legal
- 16:02document at the federal level, functionally become
- 16:07a binding document at the state level as they
- 16:09get incorporated by reference into the enforcement
- 16:13of state new DAP laws, which then in some cases,
- 16:16include a private right of action. So in that
- 16:17sense, the guides then flow through. Next slide,
- 16:25please. Yeah. So the second chunk of laws I want
- 16:32to talk about are the circular economy laws.
- 16:34And there we are seeing a trend of additional
- 16:39law that is specifying, more carefully specifying,
- 16:45certain types of claims. So in California, for
- 16:47example, there's a new truth in recycling law,
- 16:50SB -343, that prohibits deceptive recyclability
- 16:56claims and deems a chasing error symbol misleading
- 16:58unless the item meets very specific statewide
- 17:01recyclability tests. that cover the extent of
- 17:05the population that's available for recycling,
- 17:09but also a number of other state -specific criteria.
- 17:13This law has recently been enjoined and is being
- 17:17litigated and was recently enjoined and is unenforceable
- 17:20at present, but it's one to follow. Similarly,
- 17:25AB 1201 in California prohibits selling or offering
- 17:29items that are labeled with the term compostable
- 17:32or home compostable unless they satisfy certain
- 17:35specific criteria. And there's a new law, well,
- 17:39there's a new potential law. AB 2253 was just
- 17:44passed by the legislator and sent to Governor
- 17:47Newsom's desk. It would tighten standards so
- 17:50we don't know whether it is law or not, but we're
- 17:52waiting to see what happens. It would tighten
- 17:54standards for all recycled content claims beyond
- 17:57just containers and limit the methods of calculation
- 18:00allowed for determining the percentage of recycled
- 18:03content. This is another example of areas in
- 18:07which claims about the specific nature of product
- 18:14Green sustainability claims about the specific
- 18:16nature of the product and its content are increasingly
- 18:19being policed at a more granular level through
- 18:22legislation and regulation, as well as being
- 18:29litigated in terms of whether or not they exist,
- 18:32even absent this more specificity, whether these
- 18:35claims are misleading. And another one I want
- 18:38to talk about is is the California organic food
- 18:40and farming act, which board, which has been
- 18:42around for quite some time, but has been typically
- 18:45interpreted to apply to food. There's a case.
- 18:49pending right now where the California Supreme
- 18:53Court is set to decide whether COFA will apply
- 18:56also to non -food items, in which case it controls
- 19:02the use of the term organic or contains organic.
- 19:09And so those, if it applies, then it will impact
- 19:13claims in areas such as apparel or other spaces.
- 19:19And I think the last one I'm talking about here
- 19:21is the Environmental Marketing Claims Act, which
- 19:23requires record keeping, as I mentioned in the
- 19:26prior section, requires record keeping to substantiate
- 19:28the green claims and make any untruthful, deceptive,
- 19:31or misleading environmental marketing claim unlawful
- 19:34and bootstraps into FTC green guides. All right,
- 19:38next section, please. So the last set of laws
- 19:46I want to talk about and legal developments I
- 19:48want to talk about at the regulatory level is
- 19:51on disclosure. And so in disclosure, I think
- 19:54there's sort of two key areas. We've seen new
- 19:59laws requiring corporate level disclosure. So
- 20:02that would be in California SB 253, the Climate
- 20:06Corporate Data Accountability Act, which covers
- 20:08emissions disclosure, GHG emissions disclosure,
- 20:11and SB 261, which is requires disclosure on climate
- 20:15-related risks and opportunities under a format
- 20:21called TCFD, the Task Force on Climate -related
- 20:27Financial Disclosure. And that format also covers
- 20:33a number of things that we might not think of
- 20:36as directly within the context of climate risk.
- 20:39It can cover targets and governance mechanisms.
- 20:43for example. So the combination of these disclosures
- 20:46means that there is a significant amount of additional
- 20:50granular information about companies, emissions,
- 20:56carbon, carbon offsets, carbon targets, and progress
- 21:02against those targets that is about to be placed
- 21:06into the public eye under regulatory pains and
- 21:11penalties. And as a result, it creates the potential
- 21:15for there to be more information for stakeholders
- 21:19to use in scrutinizing claims that are being
- 21:22made by companies about their corporation or
- 21:26about their products, as well as it creates the
- 21:30opportunity for there to be... errors in the
- 21:35reverse direction of inconsistency or compliance
- 21:38failure that can be bootstrapped under the UDAP
- 21:41as part of an argument that a company is engaging
- 21:46in misleading practices or is marketing without
- 21:50fully complying with required disclosures and
- 21:53obligations, thus creating new risks. Next section,
- 22:00please. Next slide, please. And in fact, you
- 22:09can advance two. All right. So there, so having
- 22:12talked just a little bit about the kind of developments
- 22:14in the regulatory space at the state level, I
- 22:16want to talk about enforcement at the state level.
- 22:18So enforcement at the state level is not entirely
- 22:22done by the state attorney general, but they
- 22:23play a strong role. They play a role in that.
- 22:27And depending on the state, they may, most of
- 22:29them are elected. A few of them are appointed.
- 22:33But we have seen increasingly in this space of
- 22:37sustainability, we have seen a political divide
- 22:40between the Democratic -led states and the Republican
- 22:44-led states. And so I'm going to talk about it
- 22:47in these two buckets. There's some crossovers,
- 22:50but we're seeing actually both sets of AGs mobilizing
- 22:58UDAP and other claims. uh you know in the sustainable
- 23:03into the uh to kind of police claims in the sustainability
- 23:06space um driven by different sets of concerns
- 23:09some sometimes so beginning with the the democratic
- 23:12state ag's um the kind of the areas that we're
- 23:16seeing of enforcement from them uh have been
- 23:19focused uh you know on uh on Well, we'll kind
- 23:24of cover three different topics here. Net zero
- 23:27and emissions claims. So in the world of corporate
- 23:32emissions claims, we've seen the state agencies
- 23:35looking at and policing areas where they believe
- 23:38that claims are allegedly unsupported by companies'
- 23:47actual kind of operations. And so, in November
- 23:51of 2025, New York Attorney General Letitia James
- 23:55secured a million dollar settlement with JBS
- 23:57USA. And there have been similar settlements
- 24:00involving other meat packers over allegedly misleading
- 24:05claims that the company would reach net zero
- 24:07greenhouse gas emissions by 2040. and questioning
- 24:12the viability of the company's plan to be able
- 24:14to achieve that goal. So the takeaway from that
- 24:17is that that's a space where we're seeing active
- 24:20scrutiny by DAGs and where companies need to
- 24:23think about the viability of their plans and
- 24:26the goals that they're actually articulating.
- 24:28And it's an area that intersects with the disclosures
- 24:30I was just talking about in the prior section
- 24:33because those disclosures, some of which are
- 24:36subject to audit, will be applying greater granularity
- 24:40and transparency to companies' efforts to meet
- 24:42their articulated climate targets. Another area
- 24:46where we're seeing action from the AGs and attention
- 24:49is in plastics and plastics recycling particularly.
- 24:54And there we've seen a couple of cases around
- 24:56plastic bag manufacturers. and focus on the marketing
- 25:02of recycling bags and whether those bags are
- 25:05recyclable. So that's an area that has drawn
- 25:09a lot of attention from several AGs and it's
- 25:11hot. Fossil fuels, that's been an area where
- 25:16there's been a number of long running cases,
- 25:20but there's an important test case going up from
- 25:25New York City. In April of 2026, oral arguments
- 25:29were heard in New York City's appeal of the dismissal
- 25:31of its case, where it has been suing several
- 25:34oil and fuel companies, alleging greenwashing
- 25:37in both product claims and corporate claims regarding
- 25:41what they were saying about and what the public
- 25:46knew about the impact of those products on climate.
- 25:52And so that's a test case to see how broad the
- 25:54reach of city consumer protection statutes can
- 26:00be with respect to the marketing of fossil fuels.
- 26:07Next slide, please. From the Republican state
- 26:14AGs, we've also been seeing action on net zero,
- 26:17but going in a different direction. So from the
- 26:20Democratic state AGs, we've seen them policing
- 26:22the viability of claims. From the Republican
- 26:26AGs, we've seen them essentially attempting to
- 26:28discourage these types of claims. And part of
- 26:31that, though, has relied on making similar types
- 26:33of arguments. So the Attorney General of Iowa
- 26:35in a 2025 letter stated that not only are net
- 26:43zero programs unrealistic and harm American agriculture
- 26:45and industry, but made the assertion that making
- 26:49a net zero goal Is well is unrealistic and in
- 26:55certain context the ages have. Have have suggested
- 26:59that companies are going to need to sort of come
- 27:03clean about whether or not they about the fact
- 27:06that they can't hit their net zero goal. So from
- 27:08the Republican side as well, there have been
- 27:11there's been pressure around net zero goals by
- 27:13companies as well as. A lot a number of quite
- 27:17a number of of letters and investigations launched
- 27:19around the net zero industry initiatives, which
- 27:22is mobilized under an antitrust theory typically,
- 27:25but some of these things relate to claims as
- 27:27well and put pressure on how companies talk about
- 27:30what they're doing and the types of industry
- 27:34initiatives that they can participate in and
- 27:36how those are how those are articulated. So that's
- 27:39an area of scrutiny from both sides and where
- 27:41where. In -house compliance teams and outside
- 27:45council should pay close attention to what companies
- 27:48are saying, doing there, and how they're doing
- 27:51it. Two other key areas we've seen, or I guess
- 27:57three other key areas I want to talk about briefly.
- 27:59So renewable energy, the Republican AGs have
- 28:02sent some letters regarding 100 % renewable energy
- 28:06claims, questioning whether the use of RECs Adequately
- 28:12adequately supports such claims. Those are renewable
- 28:14energy market certificates and that's a space
- 28:18in which companies need to be careful about being
- 28:20clear when they're saying that they use renewable
- 28:23energy, whether they're talking about electrons
- 28:24or whether they're talking about having purchased
- 28:27the rights to the clean energy rights to some
- 28:31energy, sustainable plastics. This is also an
- 28:34area where the AGs have issued some letters,
- 28:37Republican AGs have issued some letters to different
- 28:41groups around sustainable plastics collaborations.
- 28:48And then in the chemicals space, I'm going to
- 28:51talk briefly about that. It's a bit outside,
- 28:54but it's adjacent. The Republican AGs have announced
- 28:59a number of recent investigations where they've
- 29:02raised misleading marketing concerns about alleging
- 29:07that products contain harmful or toxic chemicals,
- 29:10where one of the sort of bases of their concern
- 29:13or claim is that the brand's messaging is around
- 29:17health and lifestyle. For example, in one letter,
- 29:21the Texas attorney general says, I will not allow
- 29:24or rather in a press release about About an investigation,
- 29:28the Texas attorney general said, I will not allow
- 29:30any corporation to sell harmful toxic materials
- 29:33to consumers at a premium price under the guise
- 29:35of wellness and sustainability. And likewise,
- 29:38terms like clean and non toxic have also drawn
- 29:41inquiry. So, in the, you know, and this is covered
- 29:45apparel. And food and and and help personal health
- 29:52care products. So these are areas in which. the
- 29:55use of wellness and sustainability type language
- 29:59has been mobilized as a potential misleading
- 30:02claim in the context of toxics, which is sort
- 30:09of an interesting twist on that. With that, I'm
- 30:11going to turn this back to my colleague, Jen,
- 30:14to talk about the private side of this. Thanks,
- 30:19Sam. Okay. So... We've heard how the state AGs
- 30:26are shaping sort of trends in this space, and
- 30:29now let's talk a little bit about what we're
- 30:31seeing in terms of private litigants, NGOs, class
- 30:35actions, things like this. So Truth in Advertising
- 30:40has reported that greenwashing class action lawsuits
- 30:43have been filed in 18 states since 2015, so in
- 30:46the last 10 years or so, with nearly half of
- 30:49those being filed in California. There's been
- 30:52a steady stream of these cases filed every year
- 30:55since 2020 with a spike of about 40 cases in
- 30:582023 and a bit of a drop -off since then with
- 31:01only about 10 cases filed in 2025. Truth in Advertising
- 31:06further reports that about half of the cases
- 31:08brought have been dismissed. About a quarter
- 31:10have settled and about a quarter remain pending.
- 31:13And a variety of industries have been targeted
- 31:15by these types of cases. A few examples include
- 31:18home and garden, food and beverage, clothing
- 31:21and textiles, aviation. And just to give a little
- 31:25bit of a flavor for the types of claims that
- 31:27we're seeing per industry, if we think about
- 31:31the claims we've seen in the home and garden
- 31:33space, we can highlight a case in which plastic
- 31:36bag manufacturers have been sued over plastic
- 31:41bags that were allegedly not made of recyclable
- 31:43materials, but were marketed as recyclable. water
- 31:47bottle manufacturers have been sued for marketing
- 31:49water bottles as 100 % recyclable, where they
- 31:51included parts, for example, a cap or a label
- 31:54that were not recyclable, even if the rest of
- 31:57the bottle was. And in the food and beverage
- 32:00space, we've seen a coffee company faced with
- 32:02a lawsuit for advertising coffee pods as recyclable
- 32:05when they were not, in fact, recyclable in various
- 32:09locations. And again, a water bottle manufacturer
- 32:12sued for advertising bottled water as carbon
- 32:15neutral when the manufacturing of that product
- 32:17involved the release of carbon dioxide. In the
- 32:22clothing and textiles industry, we've seen clothing
- 32:24brands challenged on marketing claims, marketing
- 32:29clothing as sustainable when allegedly it was
- 32:31not actually made of sustainable materials. And
- 32:34we've also seen brands suit for marketing clothing
- 32:37as made with recycled materials when they were
- 32:39in fact not. There have been two primary waves
- 32:45of greenwashing claims, and we can kind of think
- 32:47about this as sort of wave one and wave two.
- 32:53The first wave regards representations about
- 32:55a product itself. So for example, marketing about
- 32:59a particular piece of clothing. The second wave
- 33:05regards representations about a company's broader
- 33:08climate goals, such as a pledge to obtain net
- 33:10zero emissions by a certain date or a certification
- 33:13that products will become carbon neutral by a
- 33:15certain date. Carbon neutral net zero and offset
- 33:19claims have become some of the most targeted
- 33:21types of sustainability claims in the greenwashing
- 33:25space. And we've also seen some of the biggest
- 33:28successes in that context. State consumer protection
- 33:33statutes are the primary vehicle for greenwashing
- 33:36claims. Notably, although the FTC green guides
- 33:39don't create a private right of action on their
- 33:41own, courts often rely on the guides in determining
- 33:43whether a claim is violated state consumer protection
- 33:46law. And that goes back to a number of the points
- 33:48that Sam touched on earlier and how the guides
- 33:51have sort of been incorporated into state law.
- 33:56Okay, let's go to the next slide, please. So
- 34:04we'll start by highlighting some of the challenges
- 34:07to climate goal representations that we've seen.
- 34:09So this is sort of an analysis of wave two. We've
- 34:15seen plaintiffs, largely NGOs, experiencing some
- 34:18success challenging broad corporate claims, such
- 34:20as claims regarding companies' plans to get to
- 34:22net zero. For instance, in June 2021, a nonprofit
- 34:27called Earth Island Institute filed a complaint
- 34:29in DC Superior Court alleging a beverage company's
- 34:32portrayal of itself as sustainable and committed
- 34:34to reducing plastic pollution were misleading
- 34:36under the DC Consumer Protection Procedures Act.
- 34:39And their argument there was that the company
- 34:41was taking no active steps to achieve those goals.
- 34:46The plaintiff challenged a series of claims,
- 34:48including among others, a sustainable business
- 34:51webpage. statements on social media that the
- 34:53company was focused on scaling sustainability
- 34:55solutions and statements in its sustainability
- 34:58report, including that the company was working
- 35:00to build a more sustainable future. Although
- 35:04the court dismissed the case, the DC Court of
- 35:08Appeals reversed, stating that aspirational statements
- 35:10about a company's sustainability can be actionable
- 35:13under the CPPA and that plaintiff adequately
- 35:15alleged the company neither takes nor intends
- 35:18to take any steps to achieve its goals. The court
- 35:22further states that a series of statements can
- 35:24be considered in combination misleading, even
- 35:27if individually the statements would not be misleading
- 35:31by themselves, which is an important point to
- 35:34keep in mind. As Sam sort of previewed earlier
- 35:39in discussing the case brought by the New York
- 35:42attorney general against JBS, we've also seen
- 35:46several cases brought against food companies,
- 35:48both by private plaintiffs and state AGs. Alleging
- 35:51deceptive practices under state consumer protection
- 35:53laws for allegedly making net zero commitments
- 35:56without taking meaningful steps to meet those
- 35:58goals or having plans to achieve them. Two of
- 36:01those cases have resulted in settlement and one
- 36:04is currently making its way through the court
- 36:05system. And the takeaway for companies here is
- 36:08that where net zero claims are going to be made,
- 36:12companies should ensure that they have a feasible
- 36:14plan in place to achieve those goals and ensure
- 36:17that they can articulate those plans. Next slide,
- 36:20please. Okay, so sort of a sister to this second
- 36:32wave of claims concerns carbon offsetting claims,
- 36:36carbon neutral claims. In 2023, a class sued
- 36:40an online marketplace in the central district
- 36:42of California under a theory that it falsely
- 36:44represented carbon offsetting from its shipping
- 36:46activities and that that customer would not have
- 36:49paid a premium price on certain products had
- 36:51they not been marketed as environmentally friendly.
- 36:55That claim was unsuccessful. The court rejected
- 36:57that argument, noting that the price of products
- 36:59sold in the marketplace could result from a variety
- 37:03of different factors that might have nothing
- 37:05to do with whether the platform on which the
- 37:07product was sold attempted to offset the carbon
- 37:09from the shipping activities. After dismissal
- 37:13of both an original and an amended complaint,
- 37:16the plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed that claim
- 37:18in 2024. And then more recently in February of
- 37:252026, the Northern District of California dismissed
- 37:28a class action against Apple, claiming that the
- 37:33company had made deceptive statements regarding
- 37:35its corporate global emissions and claims that
- 37:37its smartwatches were carbon neutral. The case
- 37:40alleged that the company's representations regarding
- 37:43carbon neutrality were misleading because they
- 37:45relied on carbon credits. The court there granted
- 37:48the company's motion to dismiss after finding
- 37:50the plaintiff's allegations were based on unsubstantiated
- 37:53assumptions. Plaintiffs have appealed and that
- 37:56appeal will ultimately have implications for
- 37:58other cases challenging company's reliance on
- 38:01voluntary carbon markets. Next slide, please.
- 38:10Okay, so now taking a step back and considering
- 38:13that first wave, so basically the types of claims
- 38:16that were the bread and butter of greenwashing
- 38:18of the greenwashing landscape for a very long
- 38:21time. Here we will highlight the apparel industry
- 38:26and some of the claims that we've seen retail
- 38:29brands facing in this space. So first of all,
- 38:37in November 2025, the Eighth Circuit affirmed
- 38:40a district court's dismissal of a class action
- 38:43against Nike for falsely and misleadingly advertising
- 38:45their sustainability collection products as sustainable
- 38:48and environmentally friendly. Their plaintiff
- 38:52claimed that none of the products in that collection
- 38:54contained recycled or organic fibers as claimed
- 38:57in the sustainability collection campaign. Ultimately,
- 39:00the court dismissed that case. Earlier in June
- 39:052021, a class action was filed in SDNY against
- 39:08Allbirds Inc, alleging the company's eco -friendly
- 39:11advertising, which showcased phrases such as
- 39:14sustainability meets style, low carbon footprint,
- 39:18environmentally friendly, and made with sustainable
- 39:20bull, as well as its advertising campaign around
- 39:23its carbon footprint, deceptively misrepresented
- 39:26their actual carbon footprint, which plaintiffs
- 39:28alleged was higher than advertised. In April
- 39:32of 2022, SDNY granted the defendant's motion
- 39:35to dismiss that case. The court viewed the plaintiff's
- 39:38claims to concern more so the methodology of
- 39:41Alford's tools to determine what its carbon footprint
- 39:45was rather than its representation about what
- 39:47the calculations meant. In November 2022, Plaintiffs
- 39:56filed a class action in the Eastern District
- 39:57of Missouri alleging H &M's conscious choice
- 40:00product line was not sustainable or environmentally
- 40:02friendly as claimed because the products were
- 40:04not made from sustainable or environmentally
- 40:06friendly materials. That claim was also dismissed
- 40:10in May of 2023 for lack of personal jurisdiction
- 40:12and failure to state a claim. And then one final
- 40:16example in this space. In March and April of
- 40:212023, plaintiffs filed class actions against
- 40:23Walmart and Kohl's, which were fairly similar,
- 40:26alleging the companies were selling bamboo products
- 40:30or advertising bamboo products, which in fact
- 40:34were not made from bamboo, but were made from
- 40:36rayon. According to the complaint against Walmart,
- 40:42the FTC had filed a similar complaint against
- 40:44Walmart in April of 2022, so about a year earlier.
- 40:47and Walmart entered into a stipulated order and
- 40:50judgment in which it paid $3 million as part
- 40:52of a civil penalty for violations of the FTC
- 40:54Act. Both of these claims were voluntarily dismissed
- 40:57without prejudice, the first in July of 23 and
- 41:00the second in August. So as you can see, these
- 41:05claims can be a bit harder, but they can be a
- 41:12bit harder, but they are nevertheless annoying
- 41:15and they take time and money to defend against.
- 41:19So it's important to keep an eye on them in any
- 41:22event. Next slide, please. The US is certainly
- 41:32not the only jurisdiction active in regulating
- 41:34the greenwashing space. So we thought we would
- 41:37spend a little bit of time talking about what's
- 41:41going on in Europe and compare and contrast sort
- 41:43of the US landscape with the EU landscape. It's
- 41:51important to keep in mind, so as as marketing
- 41:56campaigns can tend to be global, any marketers
- 42:00who are going to be issuing campaigns and claims
- 42:03in multiple jurisdictions should ensure that
- 42:06those claims comply with sort of the strictest
- 42:09common denominator, if you will. So the strictest
- 42:12applicable standard in order to promote compliance
- 42:14with all applicable standards. So to set the
- 42:20scene a little bit here, the EU tends to front
- 42:22-load compliance a little bit more than the US
- 42:24does at this stage, requiring substantiation,
- 42:27verification, and mandatory reporting. Whereas
- 42:30the US tends to rely a bit more on enforcement
- 42:33and litigation after a claim is made. Thinking
- 42:41through piece by piece here, in the United States,
- 42:45as I mentioned, we tend to see more ex post enforcement
- 42:49under instruments like the FTC Act, section five
- 42:52and state consumer protection laws. In the EU,
- 42:55the consumer protection framework includes case
- 42:59by case assessments of misleading claims and
- 43:01specific per se bans and requires mandatory substantiation
- 43:04upfront. In terms of who bears the burden of
- 43:09proof, In the US, a state AG or a plaintiff generally
- 43:13has to prove that a claim is deceptive and that
- 43:15an advertiser then generally must demonstrate
- 43:20that that claim was substantiated. In the EU,
- 43:25courts and authorities may require traders to
- 43:27provide evidence supporting factual claims. With
- 43:31respect to vague or generic claims, which are
- 43:33a common sort of point of focus in this space,
- 43:37In the US, they tend to be addressed on a case
- 43:39-by -case basis. In the EU, they are per se banned
- 43:43unless there is recognized excellent environmental
- 43:46performance shown or sufficiently specified on
- 43:50the same medium. With respect to carbon offset
- 43:55or carbon neutral claims, in the US, these are
- 43:58addressed through the same sort of regulatory
- 44:01framework and subject to the same enforcement
- 44:03as other types of green claims. In the EU claims
- 44:07that a product has a neutral reduced or positive
- 44:10environmental impact based on greenhouse gas
- 44:12offsetting are strictly prohibited. With respect
- 44:17to pre -market verification we don't see this
- 44:20in the United States and in the EU there's no
- 44:23general pre -market verification requirement
- 44:25under current EU law but proposed green claims
- 44:28directive envisaged ex -anti third -party verification
- 44:32but that proposal is currently stalled. So that's
- 44:35a place to keep an eye on. And then finally,
- 44:40with mandatory sustainability reporting. In the
- 44:43US, that's retreating at the federal level. So
- 44:45we discussed the SEC rules that have been rolled
- 44:48back over the last few months and years, leaving
- 44:52reporting to be a state -by -state matter. In
- 44:55the EU, mandatory audited reporting under the
- 44:57CSRD and ESRS aligned with taxonomy and SFRD.
- 45:05Next slide, please. And then we also wanted to
- 45:12highlight an interesting development in the UK.
- 45:16So the UK Advertising Standards Authority has
- 45:19recently launched an enforcement suite for potential
- 45:21greenwashing claims and has employed regular
- 45:23and proactive AI assisted monitoring to scrape
- 45:26the internet for vague or overreaching sustainability
- 45:28claims. And that's particularly interesting because
- 45:31instead of waiting for a complainant or a consumer
- 45:36to raise a flag to the ASA. The ASA is proactively
- 45:40going out and scraping the internet using some
- 45:42of these powerful AI tools to try and determine
- 45:46whether brands are making any misrepresentations.
- 45:55Okay, next slide. So we're going to talk a little
- 46:03bit about some steps that companies can take
- 46:07to mitigate risk in this space. But before we
- 46:10get there, just to wrap up a few of these trends
- 46:13that we've been talking about. First, companies
- 46:17face heightened scrutiny of sustainability, climate
- 46:20and environmental claims from regulators, state
- 46:22AGs, private plaintiffs, NGOs, consumers, investors
- 46:25and competitors. And a growing patchwork of state,
- 46:28federal, and international requirements is making
- 46:30compliance increasingly complex. So risk is coming
- 46:34from a number of different places in this context.
- 46:39Both Democratic and Republican AGs are actively
- 46:42pursuing sustainability -related claims, although
- 46:44often from different policy perspectives. Recent
- 46:47actions have targeted net zero commitments, recyclability
- 46:50claims, renewable energy representations, and
- 46:53ESG related initiatives, demonstrating that greenwashing
- 46:56risk exists across the political spectrum. It's
- 46:59not an issue that sort of belongs to one platform
- 47:01or the other. And greenwashing lawsuits are frequently
- 47:06brought under state consumer protection laws
- 47:08and generally fall into two categories. We see
- 47:11those product level claims that we've discussed.
- 47:14a claim that a product is recyclable, it's sustainable,
- 47:18it's eco -friendly, it's green, the collection
- 47:22is sustainable, and then there are more corporate
- 47:26level claims so that the company as a whole is
- 47:29going to reach net zero by a certain date, sometimes
- 47:332040, 2050, that they're going to reach carbon
- 47:37neutral and other types of climate commitments.
- 47:40They're all fair game. Even where defendants
- 47:43ultimately prevail in those types of cases, litigation
- 47:46can be costly and very reputationally damaging
- 47:50for those brands. Okay, which begs the very large
- 47:58question, what do companies do to mitigate their
- 48:03risk in this space? So first, foremost, the preparation
- 48:09and issuance of environmental marketing claims
- 48:11should always involve the in -house legal team.
- 48:14Your lawyers should always be involved. Brands
- 48:19are also going to want to consider their marketing
- 48:21reach. So if brands are going to be marketing
- 48:24in the US, the UK, and the EU, then they'll want
- 48:28to consider the regulations around greenwashing
- 48:31in all of those jurisdictions, not just, for
- 48:34example, the primary market that they operate
- 48:35in. Let's see. A very helpful step is to develop
- 48:43a claim substantiation protocol. So we've thrown
- 48:46that word around a little bit. The FTC green
- 48:49guides require that environmental marketing claims
- 48:51be substantiated generally with appropriate scientific
- 48:55evidence. So it's important to document a reasonable
- 49:00basis for every objective claim, whether that
- 49:03claim is expressed or implied, before the claim
- 49:06is disseminated. So generally that requires identification
- 49:10of the type of claim, what level of support would
- 49:13be required for that claim, and then how that
- 49:15claim is ultimately going to be conveyed to consumers.
- 49:18And that should all be done before the claim
- 49:19is ever made public. The Green Guides advise
- 49:23that with respect to environmental marketing
- 49:25claims, a reasonable basis often requires competent
- 49:28and reliable scientific evidence. That evidence
- 49:30can consist of tests, analysis, research, or
- 49:34studies that have been conducted and evaluated
- 49:36in an objective manner by a qualified person
- 49:38and are generally accepted in the profession
- 49:40to yield accurate and reliable results. That
- 49:44evidence should be sufficient in quality and
- 49:46quantity based on standards generally accepted
- 49:48in the relevant scientific field when considered
- 49:50in light of the entire body of relevant and reliable
- 49:52scientific evidence to substantiate that each
- 49:55environmental marketing claim is true. Next slide,
- 49:59please. And there are certain types of claims
- 50:06that should be approached with particular care.
- 50:09So for example, it is prudent to avoid unqualified
- 50:14general benefit claims. So that a product is
- 50:18green or eco -friendly or environmentally safe.
- 50:22Those words are, for lack of a better word, quite
- 50:24squishy. They're difficult or impossible to substantiate.
- 50:28It's very hard to qualify them to the necessary
- 50:31degree. So more specific claims are generally
- 50:35preferable here. Aspirational claims such as
- 50:40net zero by 2040. That's a type of claim that
- 50:42we've seen in some of the litigation that we've
- 50:44talked about during this presentation. Aspirational
- 50:48claims. with a specific objective goal should
- 50:51be backed by evidence that the company is committed
- 50:53to that goal and taking realistic action toward
- 50:55meeting that goal. If a plan is exploratory,
- 50:59then a claim should be narrowed to describe the
- 51:02current steps that are being taken. So it's all
- 51:05about being transparent there. With respect to
- 51:16disclosures and qualifiers, A qualifier should
- 51:19never contradict the primary claim that's being
- 51:21made. They can be used, but they should be clear,
- 51:24conspicuous, and unavoidable. And material information
- 51:28that consumers would need to understand the claim
- 51:31should be included in the claim itself rather
- 51:33than in the small print, for example, at the
- 51:35bottom of the page. Next slide, please. It's
- 51:45also important to invest in a robust compliance
- 51:49and disclosure controls infrastructure, just
- 51:51like you would in other types of compliance areas.
- 51:56It can be helpful to appoint a cross -functional
- 51:59team to review sustainability claims and the
- 52:02substantiation that's needed. Brands will want
- 52:06to coordinate across communications and disclosure
- 52:09channels, including internally, so to expound
- 52:12on that a little bit more. A company would not
- 52:15want their internal messaging, for example, in
- 52:18emails or memos to contradict the claims that
- 52:23they're putting out into the world. So you wouldn't
- 52:24want to say that you are extremely confident
- 52:29in the ability to meet that zero by 2050 and
- 52:31then have a memo sitting in your file that says
- 52:33there's no way that the company could meet that
- 52:35goal on the current trajectory. So you want to
- 52:37make sure that all of the comms that are circulating
- 52:40are consistent. Companies will want to extend
- 52:45disclosure controls to voluntary ESG statements
- 52:48as well as any compelled ESG statements. Data
- 52:52should be reviewed and verified for consistency.
- 52:57And finally, companies will want to ensure alignment
- 52:59of sustainability claims and disclosures in various
- 53:02contexts and jurisdictions. So ensuring that
- 53:05obligations are being met cross jurisdictionally.
- 53:10And so with that, I'll turn it back over to Sam
- 53:12if there are any closing remarks. Sorry, I was
- 53:23on mute there. Yeah. Thanks, Jen, for that great
- 53:27wrap up. I think this is an area in which we
- 53:34are seeing that clients who are multinationals
- 53:37who operate and market all over the globe are
- 53:44having to get their arms wrapped around what
- 53:48the sustainable marketing compliance approach
- 53:53looks like. And the helpful suggestions Jen was
- 53:56just giving, I think, are based on our experience
- 53:59working with a variety of large companies in
- 54:03different industries who are seeing inquiries,
- 54:07who are seeing litigation in different jurisdictions.
- 54:10And these inquiries and litigation build on each
- 54:12other. So you can get an inquiry from a regulator
- 54:17driven by an advocate in one jurisdiction, like
- 54:20in Canada. And then that can help. produce information
- 54:24that fuels litigation in other jurisdictions.
- 54:31And so these things can kind of bop around where
- 54:35different jurisdictions have different discovery
- 54:39rules in the U .S. I think it's easier to get
- 54:41discovery in civil litigation, for example. But
- 54:45other jurisdictions may have stronger substantive
- 54:48rules or greater penalties available. And so
- 54:53there's a number of things happening on a global
- 54:54scale that I think are driving an increase in
- 54:59attention within companies and legal teams to
- 55:05what are the claims that are being made? Where
- 55:08are we making them? What do we actually know
- 55:12about the facts that are in the background here?
- 55:16What do we have to say and when do we have to
- 55:17say it? and what risks should be exposed to by
- 55:27making these types of claims. And so I think
- 55:30that's, and one critical point I actually want
- 55:34to put on your calendars is that, I think we've
- 55:37mentioned also that on the 27th of this month,
- 55:40so in two weeks, and the Empowering Consumers
- 55:43Directive goes into force in the EU, which for
- 55:46folks who are marketing into the EU, will apply
- 55:49a significantly greater ratchet to a lot of these
- 55:53substantiation. issues and questions, and particularly
- 55:56around certifications as well, and potentially,
- 55:59you know, and some parts of it involving third
- 56:02-party verification for certain claims and progress
- 56:05against claims. So the one -way ratchet has continued
- 56:09to crank forward, which means that for companies
- 56:13all around the globe, it's time to, you know,
- 56:18I think if you make claims in this space, then
- 56:24it's timely to audit them, to understand what
- 56:30the claims are, to understand how they relate
- 56:32to your disclosures, the ones you're currently
- 56:33making, and for many companies, the ones you're
- 56:36about to make in November for California's first
- 56:40round of GHG emissions disclosures, as well as
- 56:43that you might have to make in other jurisdictions
- 56:45like Australia, Mexico, the European Union, or
- 56:49the UK. around these topics to make sure that
- 56:53these things are consistent, that the company's
- 56:56leadership is bought in on the plans, the programs,
- 57:04and the claims that you want to make in this
- 57:06space, and that the path ahead is realistic and
- 57:14supports the company's long -range business objectives
- 57:20in a fashion that makes the claims non -misleading
- 57:24and defensible, that those are documented appropriately,
- 57:28and that the company's in a position to make
- 57:32this a value -add rather than a source of potential
- 57:35destruction, risk, or liability. So I think that's
- 57:41what we have. to discuss today. Again, I'm Sam
- 57:44Hushhour in San Francisco as my colleague, Jen
- 57:47King in New York. And we're going to say thank
- 57:53you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for
- 57:56organizing this great event. Do we have any questions
- 58:01from the chat to respond to? I didn't catch questions
- 58:10in the chat, but I did receive one from our help
- 58:13desk. This one being, with California's environmental
- 58:17marketing laws SB 253, 261, and AB 1305 operating
- 58:22simultaneously, how should companies coordinate
- 58:25their compliance efforts so that a disclosure
- 58:27made for one statute doesn't create a problem
- 58:29under the other? Yeah, well, I guess that goes
- 58:33a little bit to what I'm saying in closing, but
- 58:34yes. They cover slightly different things, but
- 58:41first off, SB261, the climate risk statute is
- 58:47currently enjoined, so you don't have to comply
- 58:50with it. The first report was due January 1 of
- 58:52this year, but CARB, the regulator, has said
- 58:56that they will announce that they're going to
- 59:03wait for the litigation to resolve, and then
- 59:05they will announce a new deadline, assuming that
- 59:07they're successful. So you don't have to worry
- 59:09about that one yet. SB 253, which is due November
- 59:1410th, is the GHG emissions report. And so on
- 59:19that one, you need to make sure that it's consistent
- 59:22with any other reports you're doing, including
- 59:24on a voluntary basis, and that the claims that
- 59:28you're making in this space, for example, if
- 59:30you're making claims about having a a net zero
- 59:34goal. If you're making claims that you have made
- 59:40significant reductions in your carbon intensity
- 59:43on a product or your corporate level over a period
- 59:46of time, you need to go and workbook those because
- 59:51advocates will be workbooking those. And with
- 59:54AI, they can workbook them rapidly and across
- 59:56a whole bunch of companies. So you need to make
- 59:58sure that you know in advance, like, you know,
- 1:00:01Do our claims hold up against the progress that
- 1:00:04we're actually showing now that we have to report
- 1:00:06on a granular basis and publicly what our progress
- 1:00:10is. And then when you look at AB 1305, this is
- 1:00:12one that I think is a sleeper for some people
- 1:00:14because it's called the Carbon Markets Disclosure
- 1:00:17Act. And the primary part of it is about disclosures
- 1:00:22or about carbon markets. So if you market or
- 1:00:25sell carbon offsets, then There's detailed disclosure
- 1:00:29about carbon offsets that you have to publish,
- 1:00:32which makes sense. But many people say, that's
- 1:00:34not me. I don't do that. However, if you make
- 1:00:38claims that rely on carbon offsets, you also
- 1:00:41have to provide very voluminous disclosure about
- 1:00:43those offsets. So for many companies, that actually
- 1:00:46does entangle them, because they utilize carbon
- 1:00:50offsets as part of how they hit emissions goals.
- 1:00:53And so if they're doing that, or making carbon
- 1:00:56neutrality claims, if they're doing that about
- 1:00:59a product, if they're doing that, then they have
- 1:01:01to disclose a bunch of information about those
- 1:01:03offsets, which is not in the SB 253 emissions
- 1:01:06report. It's a separate type of disclosure, and
- 1:01:09it's quite detailed. And if you're selling things
- 1:01:11and you haven't made that disclosure, then arguably
- 1:01:14you might be selling product without having made
- 1:01:17a required disclosure about it. And so that's
- 1:01:21a source of potential litigation risk under UDAP.
- 1:01:26So that's the bootstrap provision. But then the
- 1:01:29third dimension of AB 1305 is the one that gets
- 1:01:31almost everybody, which is that to the extent
- 1:01:34that companies are making claims about substantial
- 1:01:37emissions reduction, which can be interpreted
- 1:01:40potentially to include their emissions targets
- 1:01:43like net zero, carbon neutral, or reducing emissions
- 1:01:47or emissions intensity by 30 % by 2030 or something
- 1:01:51like that. then that potentially puts them in
- 1:01:54that space of needing to report publicly on their
- 1:01:57website on an annual basis about the basis of
- 1:02:01that claim and their progress against it in a
- 1:02:05detailed fashion. And so that is one that I think
- 1:02:09has been a sleeper for a variety of folks. and
- 1:02:13one that folks need to pay attention to. And
- 1:02:15then the three of those do interact in that,
- 1:02:18like, if you're putting up information about
- 1:02:19the basis of your emissions reduction claim on
- 1:02:22your AB 1305 report, it needs to correspond with,
- 1:02:27be consistent with the information that you're
- 1:02:30then putting out in an audited SB 253 report
- 1:02:34about your GHG emissions. And so that's how these
- 1:02:36things start to intersect. And it needs to be
- 1:02:39consistent with the report. that you put into
- 1:02:41Australia and the report you put into the UK
- 1:02:44and then eventually the report that you put into
- 1:02:45the EU if you're operating in all these different
- 1:02:47jurisdictions. And so there's a and some of them
- 1:02:50define their boundaries or their terms in slightly
- 1:02:52different fashions. And so as you work on these,
- 1:02:56you need to make sure that in the background
- 1:02:58they're coming from cohesive data and that there's
- 1:03:03a review of what are we saying? How do these
- 1:03:06things intersect? Are they consistent? And how
- 1:03:08do they play into our Into our statements about
- 1:03:11what we're trying about what we've committed
- 1:03:13to do as a company. Let's see. Is there another
- 1:03:25question there? It looks like there was something
- 1:03:27that came up. We did get another question now
- 1:03:32in the Q and A box. What type of law would they
- 1:03:35say they practice class action? I'm not too sure
- 1:03:37what that is in relation to. Oh, yeah, I guess
- 1:03:42I say this. So I'm a regulatory lawyer and I
- 1:03:47do, I do government investigations, audits, compliance,
- 1:03:52council compliance programs, and sustainability
- 1:03:57council, including sustainability marketing council
- 1:03:59for a variety of large and leading brands. My
- 1:04:02colleague in New York is part of this practice.
- 1:04:05Jen, and also is a civil litigator and litigates
- 1:04:09a variety of litigation as well as government
- 1:04:13investigations, including climate litigation
- 1:04:15that involves being claimed as well. All right.
- 1:04:21It looks like that's it for questions. This concludes
- 1:04:24today's presentation. Thank you so much again,
- 1:04:26Sam and Jennifer, for an excellent presentation
- 1:04:28today. And thank you so much to our audience
- 1:04:30for joining us. Have a great day, everybody.
- 1:04:34Thanks very much all.