Latest / Becker’s Healthcare Podcast / Nirav Shah, Associate Chief Medical Informatics Officer, AI and Innovation, Endeavor Health
Transcript
- 0:02Every year, Becker's annual meeting brings health care
- 0:04leaders together to unpack the most pressing issues
- 0:07facing the industry.
- 0:08And every year, those conversations shift in profound
- 0:11and unexpected ways.
- 0:13This April, more than 3,500
- 0:15healthcare executives will return to Chicago for Becker's
- 0:18sixteenth Annual Meeting.
- 0:20Seven ninety five elite speakers will offer new
- 0:23lessons, new case studies, and predictions about what
- 0:26comes next.
- 0:27Join us April 13 through the sixteenth.
- 0:30For the agenda and event details, visit beckershospitalreview.com
- 0:34and click on the events tab in the
- 0:36upper right.
- 0:38This is Scott Becker with the Becker's Healthcare
- 0:41Podcast.
- 0:42We're thrilled today to be joined by a
- 0:44brilliant physician leader.
- 0:47We're joined today by doctor Nurev Shah, and
- 0:50doctor Shah serves as the associate
- 0:52chief medical informatics officer
- 0:55of AI and innovation.
- 0:56He's also the director of investigational
- 0:59innovation
- 1:00in infectious disease physician, a clinical physician assistant
- 1:04professor.
- 1:05He's works currently for the last decade plus
- 1:08at Endeavor Health. He's also spent time at
- 1:10University of Chicago and Northwestern,
- 1:13a brilliant, brilliant physician leader. Doctor Shah, can
- 1:16you take a moment to tell us about
- 1:18yourself and about your your about your career?
- 1:21Thank you, Scott, for having me on this
- 1:23podcast.
- 1:24And, I mean, that was a great introduction.
- 1:26So,
- 1:27my name is Nirav Shah, an infectious disease
- 1:30physician by training. And like you mentioned, I
- 1:32serve as Endeavor Health's associate CMIO for AI
- 1:35and innovation.
- 1:36So as you can imagine, this role is
- 1:38quite multifaceted,
- 1:40and I belong to a variety of different
- 1:41teams, including innovation,
- 1:43information technology,
- 1:45clinical slash quality, and research teams, which are
- 1:47all critical domains of this work.
- 1:50My passion really lies in leveraging emerging technology
- 1:54with a focus on AI to solve complex
- 1:56clinical and administrative problems, and I work on
- 1:59the entire AI continuum. So you can think
- 2:01about it as strategy and governance
- 2:04to sourcing new tools,
- 2:06implementation,
- 2:07validation,
- 2:08scaling,
- 2:09and producing
- 2:10either white papers for internal consumption or academic
- 2:14output for generalizability
- 2:16on this work. So a little bit about
- 2:18Endeavor Health. So we're an integrated delivery network
- 2:21in Illinois.
- 2:22We serve over 1,400,000
- 2:24patients or a third of the Illinois catchment
- 2:26area. We have nine acute care hospitals, 300
- 2:30sites of care, and generate around 6,000,000,000 in
- 2:32revenue, just to give you an idea for
- 2:34the size.
- 2:35And we're recognized as one of the top
- 2:3725 health systems for AI readiness in The
- 2:39US, and we're actively leveraging greater than a
- 2:42100 AI and automation tools to enhance patient
- 2:45care, improve administrative and operational efficiency, and reduce
- 2:48clinician burnout.
- 2:50Thank you. And and, doctor, talk a little
- 2:52bit about
- 2:53when you think about where AI is having
- 2:55impact,
- 2:56where are the I mean, it seems like
- 2:58it's very much a cascading thing where it's
- 3:00having different impacts in different areas.
- 3:02Where are you seeing the most useful or
- 3:05exciting use cases
- 3:06yet yet endeavor that you or that you
- 3:08see yourself, that you sort of look and
- 3:10say, that's really working and making a difference.
- 3:12Where are you most excited, and what are
- 3:14you seeing the best use cases so far?
- 3:17Think so AI is a tool that we're
- 3:20leveraging across a variety of different areas.
- 3:23So I think there is
- 3:25opportunity to see value,
- 3:28in the clinician space primarily in
- 3:31documentation. So that that is a solution that
- 3:34has spread like wildfire. I don't think there
- 3:36has been a technology solution
- 3:38that has had as fast as adoption
- 3:41as in the ambient space.
- 3:43And we're starting to think about other ways
- 3:46that you can use generative AI in the
- 3:48clinical space such as summarization,
- 3:50other types of generation,
- 3:53and thinking about clinical decision support. So the
- 3:56value in those isn't,
- 3:58as proven out as what we're seeing in
- 4:00Ambiance, but there's a lot
- 4:02of literature in areas where we're gonna start
- 4:04seeing how that is,
- 4:06moving forward kind of,
- 4:09the clinical space and reducing burnout and improving
- 4:12patient care.
- 4:13On the administrative and corporate side, I think
- 4:17there is a lot of value that's being
- 4:19generated.
- 4:20And I'll start with the corporate side. So
- 4:21I think health care is probably a little
- 4:23bit later to the game,
- 4:25compared to where other sectors are using kind
- 4:28of AI. And I think we have a
- 4:30lot that we can learn from how it's
- 4:31being deployed in tech and other kind of
- 4:34regulated
- 4:34industries such as financials and others.
- 4:37So there's opportunity
- 4:39in, you know, marketing and HR and a
- 4:41variety of, you know, like, legal and compliance
- 4:43and supply chain. So there's a variety of
- 4:45areas
- 4:46where you can see that AI potentially has
- 4:49the opportunity to make operations more efficient.
- 4:53So I think that's interesting. And,
- 4:56a variety of,
- 4:57different places that you can you know, the
- 4:59way that I think about AI from from
- 5:02a generative AI standpoint is, in order
- 5:04to transform an organization, I think about it
- 5:06in a continuum. You can have productivity
- 5:09hacks. So for example, when you are using,
- 5:12say, chat, GPT, or Gemini, or any of
- 5:15these things, You know, you can use it
- 5:17to basically summarize
- 5:18essentially an email or, you know, generate an
- 5:21email, summarize a document, a variety of different
- 5:23things like that.
- 5:24Then if you move to the next stage,
- 5:26it's really kind of process
- 5:28modifications.
- 5:29If you think about a more complex process
- 5:31than just writing an email, you know, a
- 5:33specific workflow or something like that, there's a
- 5:35lot of steps that are there. And so
- 5:38we're seeing that you can implement generative AI
- 5:41in a variety of different steps to kind
- 5:43of speed up how quickly that process moves
- 5:45forward.
- 5:46And the final is really AI transformation
- 5:49and AI first approach, which is taking a
- 5:52whole process, blowing it up, and getting to
- 5:54the outcome using novel technology.
- 5:57So something like that is where I think
- 5:59we're going to start to see a lot
- 6:00of value,
- 6:01in the administrative operational,
- 6:04areas and then also the clinical space. So
- 6:06that's probably gonna be, you know, the story
- 6:08that we start seeing in '26 and beyond.
- 6:11Thank you. When when you look at the
- 6:13next steps in this and what you're doing,
- 6:16doctor Shah, what are you most excited about
- 6:19as we move to this next year?
- 6:21Yeah. I I mean so as I think
- 6:24about
- 6:25where we're going, you know, I like to
- 6:26think about
- 6:28kind of from where we have approached this
- 6:31at Endeavor Health. Like, what have we done
- 6:33in the last few months, and where are
- 6:35we going in the future? So what
- 6:37I'm most proud about, for what we've done
- 6:39is we've started to build the cultural and
- 6:42structural infrastructure
- 6:43to kind of get started.
- 6:45It's easy to buy a piece of software.
- 6:47It's much harder to align massive newly consolidated
- 6:51health system
- 6:52around a shared vision for the future. What
- 6:54this is, it is it allows us from
- 6:56moving from doing AI to being an AI
- 6:59enabled organization.
- 7:00So where my focus and excitement is going
- 7:02forward is really moving us from being an
- 7:04AI enabled organization,
- 7:06just trying to keep up with AI to
- 7:07building the institutional architecture to shape our destiny
- 7:10and lead it. So essentially moving from a
- 7:13system that uses technology to a system that
- 7:15is defined by its intelligence. So I wanna
- 7:18kinda highlight four key areas to kind of
- 7:20illustrate this. So the first is really,
- 7:23socializing
- 7:24AI from the bedside to the boardroom.
- 7:27So innovation fails in a vacuum and bringing
- 7:30along the organization on this work is critical.
- 7:32So I'm working with,
- 7:34some of my colleagues and leaders, and we're
- 7:36making a concerted effort to socialize the why
- 7:39of AI at every level from the board
- 7:41and our CEO counsel
- 7:42to our frontline clinical and operational teams. So
- 7:45in a large health system, everyone is focused
- 7:47on the friction of daily operations,
- 7:49and we've been successful,
- 7:51in a in creating enthusiasm amongst our team
- 7:54members, showing them that AI isn't just one
- 7:56more task that they need to do, but
- 7:57a potential solution to some of their pain
- 7:59points.
- 8:00So where I'd like to go
- 8:02is moving from this top down socialization
- 8:05to a frontline led innovation model,
- 8:08where our goal is really to empower our
- 8:10clinical, operational, and corporate teams to not just
- 8:12use AI, but to articulate the complex problems
- 8:15it can solve. Shifting from quick productivity hacks,
- 8:18like I mentioned, to process modification, to an
- 8:21AI first redesign,
- 8:22which is kind of that continuum that, I
- 8:24was talking about. And we wanna empower our
- 8:26staff to blow up outdated processes and rebuild
- 8:29them around intelligence
- 8:31with the novel capabilities brought forward with AI.
- 8:34So and then at the leadership level, we
- 8:36are actively crafting a proposal for financial investment
- 8:39to accelerate our work and lead in the
- 8:41deployment of AI for community based health systems.
- 8:44The the second kind of area is we've
- 8:47launched our own internal Google Gemini platform,
- 8:50which has been a game changer for engagement,
- 8:53socialization.
- 8:55And, by giving our team members a safe,
- 8:57secure enterprise grade environment to experiment with, we're
- 9:00moving beyond theory into actual, like, use cases.
- 9:03So we're seeing real time enhancements in day
- 9:06to day productivity. We've kind of captured that
- 9:08in a variety of surveys and feedback. And
- 9:11what is happening is we're seeing a grassroots
- 9:14innovation culture, and we're starting to see some
- 9:16intractable systemic problems such as policy consolidation,
- 9:21that are getting solved. And that's a huge
- 9:23problem that, you know, I've kind of discussed
- 9:25in other,
- 9:26podcasts, which is quite interesting because it's a
- 9:29really challenging problem as you're getting the health
- 9:31system together,
- 9:33figuring out how to standardize,
- 9:36consolidate
- 9:37massive amounts of documentation. That's where kind of
- 9:39AI is really, really helpful and,
- 9:42perfectly tuned to do. So going
- 9:44forward from democratizing
- 9:47our Gemini platform, we're moving from single use
- 9:49tools to moving into the space of agentic
- 9:52orchestration. And so we have on our road
- 9:53map the build out of a central nervous
- 9:56system, so a unified infrastructure
- 9:59that will manage the growth of autonomous agents
- 10:01across our core platforms.
- 10:03And this, ensures that as we develop and
- 10:05deploy agents, we build the infrastructure to do
- 10:08so safely to handle critical problems within applications
- 10:11and then also across applications.
- 10:14The third kind of pillar is really building
- 10:16the structure and process around AI governance
- 10:19that enables AI transformation. So we've and what
- 10:22we've done in the last year is really
- 10:24centralizing our AI innovation among, admits con consolidation.
- 10:28So building AI structures are really difficult,
- 10:31if you talk to leaders across other health
- 10:34systems, and they frequently change.
- 10:37Doing so
- 10:38in normal circumstances is challenging, but it's really
- 10:41challenging when you're simultaneously consolidating
- 10:44EHR. So we're doing a three for one
- 10:46consolidation right now, infrastructure and clinical and operational
- 10:49structures
- 10:50as a result of, the mergers that we
- 10:52have, over the last few years. So I'm
- 10:54proud that we've managed to stand up by
- 10:56unified AI governance, ensuring that innovation is built
- 10:58into our new system identity.
- 11:01And going forward, we'll be launching a comprehensive
- 11:04center for trusted AI that builds on the
- 11:06centralized governance to include more domains and teams
- 11:09to centralize how we intake,
- 11:11validate, and monitor AI, how we upscale our
- 11:14teams, how we internally and externally communicate our
- 11:16AI work, and build bidirectional sophistication
- 11:19with state and federal government regulators
- 11:22and consumer perception of AI.
- 11:24And then finally, developing the change muscle of
- 11:26the organization,
- 11:27the ability to pivot and adopt new tech
- 11:29as fast as it evolves, and it's evolving
- 11:31very fast.
- 11:33Final pillar is really our AI validation schematic.
- 11:36This
- 11:38seems trivial, but it's actually so important.
- 11:40So we've developed a robust,
- 11:42repeatable,
- 11:43multimodal, and mixed methods validation schematic for AI
- 11:46tools.
- 11:48We don't just take a vendor's,
- 11:50word for it. We've deployed this framework on
- 11:52our most complex AI use cases that involve
- 11:55patient care. And so we're doing this to
- 11:57ensure that our models are clinically safe, operationally
- 12:00sound, and ethically transparent. And where I'd like
- 12:03to go in the future is to refine
- 12:05this, which in its current state is very
- 12:07robust and to make governance as efficient as
- 12:10it is effective.
- 12:11So I like to,
- 12:13I like this phrase that in health care,
- 12:16AI scales at the speed of trust.
- 12:18So far, clinicians and patients don't trust the
- 12:20output. The technology is useless and is not
- 12:22going to scale. So by building that transparent,
- 12:25efficient, repeatable, and fast moving governance engine, we're
- 12:28ensuring that Endeavor Health is ready to be
- 12:30a leader in this transformation.
- 12:32And and what resonates so well, doctor Shah,
- 12:35is this concept of the single use cases,
- 12:37like, so many of us use
- 12:39day to day or individual tasks on
- 12:43chat GPT or whatever platform anybody's working on
- 12:46to this next stage of doing this at
- 12:48scale and with systems.
- 12:50And I how much of a learning curve
- 12:53is there for people on that? Because it
- 12:55seems like so many of us have gotten
- 12:57comfortable
- 12:58with the single use cases, you know, the
- 13:00you know, whatever it might be. But but
- 13:03then moving towards systemic use cases and governance,
- 13:06talk a bit about the complication of that
- 13:09and
- 13:10and how hard is it to start seeing
- 13:12results and real results, and it does it
- 13:14it differ by area? And does it differ
- 13:16by team member or or
- 13:18or or or the teams that are leading
- 13:20different areas?
- 13:22I think
- 13:23this is probably the multibillion
- 13:25trillion dollar question
- 13:27is how do we take generative AI and
- 13:30move from what it is that we're doing
- 13:32right now to draft an email
- 13:34to transforming how we operate? And I'll give
- 13:36you the example. I kind of touched on
- 13:38it earlier with policy consolidation.
- 13:41So our health system,
- 13:43is a product of four individual
- 13:46health systems slash hospitals that have come together
- 13:48in the last five years,
- 13:50and we all bring,
- 13:51our own policies and procedures of how we
- 13:53do things.
- 13:55And that, equates to about 10,000
- 13:57distinct policies
- 13:59that we have across our system.
- 14:01And we're now building out a way to
- 14:04kind of redefine this into an endeavor way
- 14:08of how we do policies and procedures.
- 14:10And we had a single use case where
- 14:12we did it in a manual way where
- 14:15it took about 30 different,
- 14:17team members
- 14:18to consolidate a single policy, and it took
- 14:21about three months to do that. And variety
- 14:23of different meetings, in person,
- 14:26over Zoom, etcetera, a variety of different things.
- 14:28So you can imagine doing this for 10,000
- 14:30policies is really complicated.
- 14:32So I wanna kind of highlight these three
- 14:34different steps. So
- 14:36we initially, we were asked to kind of
- 14:38help solve this problem,
- 14:40from our chief clinical officer, and we took
- 14:43the approach of, let's just see if we
- 14:45can do the productivity hacks. Can we take
- 14:47three policies
- 14:48and just summarize them and consolidate them? A
- 14:51very basic kind of task that's, generative AI
- 14:54is very suited to do.
- 14:56We tried to do that. We realized that
- 14:58for this complex problem, there were certain
- 15:01policies
- 15:02that didn't completely equate to other policies. So
- 15:05if you for example, if we have a
- 15:06policy
- 15:07on, I don't know, catheter associated urinary tract
- 15:11infection prevention.
- 15:12So some policies would allow for the consolidation
- 15:15of it, but other ones would also mention
- 15:18other things that were completely distinct from that.
- 15:21And so that that baggage that we have
- 15:23from our how our health systems have defined
- 15:25these problems, you know, we were able to
- 15:26do some basic things, but we needed to
- 15:28take a, you know, a broader approach to
- 15:30that.
- 15:31So we spent time thinking, you know, how
- 15:32do we take the whole process
- 15:34and modify things that, you know, we could
- 15:37using generative AI? So we thought about you
- 15:39know, we have 10,000 policies.
- 15:41That's, like, 200
- 15:43domains. We have, like, 500 plus owners of
- 15:46this.
- 15:47How do we simplify,
- 15:48like, the larger process that we have? How
- 15:50do we reduce the dimensionality? How do we
- 15:52use generative AI to do that? So we
- 15:54took time to basically take the 10,000 policies,
- 15:58put them into 20 buckets, reduce the number
- 16:00of owners. Think about that. We use generative
- 16:03AI to create these buckets and do all
- 16:04these things. So we're figuring out how do
- 16:06we simplify the process where we can using
- 16:09generative AI. And then we tried to say,
- 16:12can we still figure out with this consolidated
- 16:14approach? Can we consolidate the policies using generative
- 16:17AI?
- 16:18Again, we really couldn't do that. And so
- 16:20we have this problem again where because of
- 16:23the,
- 16:24historical
- 16:25tendencies of how we built these policies across
- 16:27these different systems, generative AI was not suitable
- 16:30to kind of bring them together.
- 16:33So the final step and this this kind
- 16:35of took months for us to to figure
- 16:37out and to do.
- 16:38The final step is we realized that there
- 16:41is no way that we're gonna be able
- 16:42to do this.
- 16:43There are some policies that were procedures. There
- 16:46are some procedures that were policies. They're, you
- 16:48know, referencing different things, referencing old policies,
- 16:51a variety of different problems. So the final
- 16:54approach, the AI first approach is, you know
- 16:56what? We're gonna blow up the whole system,
- 16:58and we're gonna generate net new policies.
- 17:01And we're going to make sure that the
- 17:03prompt when we develop this is looking at
- 17:06what is best practice from the literature, so
- 17:08the evidence based practice,
- 17:10from societies that are, you know, providing thoughts
- 17:13around this, whether it's infectious disease society or
- 17:16OBI in society, you know, variety of different
- 17:18areas,
- 17:19looking at what are the policy drivers,
- 17:22what are the regulations
- 17:23at a state and, federal level that, you
- 17:26know, that would, shape these types of policies.
- 17:29And we put it all into one master
- 17:31prompt. And now what we're doing is when
- 17:33we,
- 17:34are redoing a policy,
- 17:36we are building a new policy from scratch
- 17:39so that our team members don't have to
- 17:41fight and try to figure out how you
- 17:43know, which policies do we wanna keep, and
- 17:44there's a lot of inertia to keep what
- 17:46you know from your existing legacy institution.
- 17:49And instead, we have a net new that
- 17:51is novel, that is new, that is up
- 17:53to date, that is tied to the most,
- 17:55relevant policy drivers.
- 17:57And they get that as a starting point
- 17:58and then that is speeding up the process.
- 18:01This so to get at your question, to
- 18:03do that for all of these net new
- 18:06processes
- 18:07takes a lot of time, and it takes
- 18:09a lot of you know, you have to
- 18:10be willing to blow up stuff and start
- 18:12fresh because we have a lot of,
- 18:14you know, processes that are really,
- 18:17complicated
- 18:18based on what we can do from a
- 18:20manual standpoint. So with this new technology, if
- 18:23you think about where are we starting from,
- 18:25where are we trying to go from, it
- 18:27enables you to really rethink how we do
- 18:29this, and that is where you'll see the
- 18:31value come forward.
- 18:33I mean, it is simply amazing. And and
- 18:35and doctor Shah, it it's such a fascinating
- 18:37cascade of how this moves from individual use
- 18:40cases to bigger use cases to really
- 18:43systematic and agentic.
- 18:45Talk a bit about
- 18:47what advice would you give to evolving leaders
- 18:50trying to work with AI? Where where do
- 18:52you start with on advice to to to
- 18:54evolving leaders in the AI world?
- 18:57Yeah. So I think three pieces of advice,
- 19:00for AI leaders or health systems in general
- 19:03that are navigating this transition.
- 19:06The first is really
- 19:07optimize the workflow and not the tool. The
- 19:10second is build change fitness into your culture,
- 19:13and the third is prioritize governance as a
- 19:15strategy and not a hurdle. So let me
- 19:17go a little bit more in-depth into this.
- 19:19So the the first is start with optimizing
- 19:22the workflow.
- 19:23The biggest mistake I see is leaders are
- 19:25looking for a magic software solution
- 19:29that they can bring in to solve a
- 19:31systemic problem. And,
- 19:33you know, as I've been saying, AI is
- 19:35not plug and play. It's really a process
- 19:37transformation catalyst that enables
- 19:40us to rethink the process and to transform
- 19:42completely with an AI first approach.
- 19:44So before you automate this process, you have
- 19:47to deeply understand it. And my advice is
- 19:49stop asking what can this AI do, and
- 19:51what's the most painful fifteen minutes of a
- 19:54team member's day, and how do we use
- 19:56intelligence to eliminate it, automate it, etcetera.
- 19:59And then that may sometimes require blowing up
- 20:02the whole process and starting it from fresh.
- 20:04And then iteratively keep doing that. What's the
- 20:07next fifteen minutes that are the most painful?
- 20:09And keep doing that to kind of,
- 20:11you know, make the make the day less
- 20:14painful.
- 20:15So the second issue is really change fitness.
- 20:18And so a differentiator will be an organization's
- 20:20ability to quickly adapt to change,
- 20:23and we know technology is moving really fast.
- 20:26And I think the big challenge that we
- 20:28face as health systems and just in general,
- 20:30you know, probably all sectors of the economy
- 20:33is our ability to absorb it. I'll give
- 20:35you an example. I think if you look
- 20:37at our EHRs, they have hundreds of solutions
- 20:40on their road map coming out, and it
- 20:42takes us a long time to implement a
- 20:45single solution.
- 20:46So we need to move away from top
- 20:48down mandates towards codesign and agile deployment.
- 20:51So we need to bring physicians, nurses, operations,
- 20:54corporate team members,
- 20:56you know, etcetera into the room on day
- 20:58one to help shape adoption, be able to
- 21:00test it, learn quickly, and scale thoughtfully,
- 21:03and that will be critical.
- 21:05And
- 21:06we need to also be able to pivot
- 21:08when a solution doesn't work because a lot
- 21:09of these solutions may not work. So that
- 21:11gets at the concept of, you know, change
- 21:13fitness, which is a combination of change management
- 21:16and then rapidly
- 21:17building that into
- 21:19the culture. And the third is really around
- 21:21governance. And I, you know, I can't stress
- 21:22this enough. You can't scale AI across a
- 21:251,400,000
- 21:26patient system without rigorous multidisciplinary
- 21:29and multimodal framework
- 21:30that ensures accuracy, equity, transparency,
- 21:33and safety.
- 21:35And, again, AI will scale at the speed
- 21:37of trust. So putting in that investment to
- 21:39build that trust layer
- 21:41will allow for movement, like, 10 times faster
- 21:44later because the foundation
- 21:46is solid.
- 21:47So, in all I mean, all of these
- 21:49three things really the goal is to get
- 21:51to high touch. So we aren't just implementing
- 21:54algorithms. We're transforming.
- 21:56We're architecting a future where technology handles the
- 21:59data, and so we can handle
- 22:01care and relationships. So that's really the goal
- 22:04of, you know, all of these three different
- 22:05things and just in general, like, what we're
- 22:07trying to do with AI.
- 22:09Doctor Shah, thank you so much. I've I've
- 22:11had a chance to watch out upfront and
- 22:13close the Endeavor Health System. I live in
- 22:15the area. It's amazing the transformation of the
- 22:17system over the last few decades and amazing
- 22:20what you do on the AI side.
- 22:22Thank you so much for joining us, and
- 22:24what an impressive background you have. It's incredible.
- 22:26Doctor Shah, thank you for being with us.
- 22:29Thank you, Scott, for having me on this
- 22:30podcast.