Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Parent Empathy and Bad Therapists
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, Bob, Well, it's been a long time since you've been on
- 0:03the podcast. A long time. Yeah, and let's get into it.
- 0:06What do you say? Yep, glad you're better. Thanks. So this
- 0:11email is from anonymous Uppertier patron. She says, Dear Kirk and Bob,
- 0:17I'm a mental health technician at this impatient mental health rehabilitation center, and I'm
- 0:23struggling with this patient with borderline personality disorder. She complains, she snaps and
- 0:30goes off at me. Sometimes she goes off at staff and at other patients
- 0:35over the smallest stuff that annoys her, or when things don't go her way.
- 0:40Every time I have to work in the same unit or interact with her,
- 0:44I get this feeling of dread, and I have to brace myself.
- 0:48Even though I understand why people with borderline personal disorder are the way that they
- 0:53are thanks to you, doctor Kirk, it still doesn't shake the feeling of
- 0:58dread. Away any advice on this, but yeah, it happens to me
- 1:03too. When I have people that are really angry and irritable, I get
- 1:07I get dread to see them. And what I've found is to do my
- 1:15very very best to join them to just join them, like if they're if
- 1:19the person is upset about the food, join them. Yeah, food here
- 1:23is not so great sometimes absolutely, even though they're snapping and hostile is unfair,
- 1:32you know, Yeah, you're not just you know, agreeing or being
- 1:34with someone who is being reasonable or maybe a little mift or something. They
- 1:41might literally be yelling at you because the food isn't good there or something,
- 1:47and you don't feel even necessarily safe. Yeah, but if you're going to
- 1:53well, why do you do that with those folks? Because they're in pain?
- 1:57And because by joining I have noticed that sometimes when I'm successful with that,
- 2:02it shifts the valance of the thing. It shifts the attitude of the
- 2:07other two more cooperative, more you know, yeah, I mean, at
- 2:13the very least, what it does is it erases the dynamic that you're in
- 2:20opposition. You know, even if they continue to get hostile, it's like,
- 2:25well, I judoed it, and it's on the record that I'm not
- 2:30opposed, I'm not the enemy, so I don't feel And it might even
- 2:37be like for you because initially, as you're receiving the hostility, there's a
- 2:43natural tendency to want to meet that and and oppose it. But if you
- 2:50in your heart are with someone, then in your heart you feel less Depending
- 2:57on the situation, you feel less tension because you're not in opposition. They
- 3:01might be in opposition with you, but you're not in opposition with them,
- 3:05and so that might lower your stress, you know that kind of thing.
- 3:08Yeah, yeah, Well, what I'll say, patron, is that it's
- 3:15yeah, it's totally normal. The other thing I'll say is not everyone with
- 3:17borderline will do this sort of thing. So, you know, just because
- 3:22the person's primary diagnosis is borderline doesn't mean that that's the primary reason as to
- 3:25why they're doing You know, people can be dicks with all sorts of diagnoses
- 3:32or not. So it sounds like the person is just a dick and that's
- 3:38awful. And you know, being an impatient, the road to inpatient and
- 3:43then being an impatient can't be a pleasant experience for the patient. So I'm
- 3:50guessing that there's a lot of stress for this individual. Doesn't make it justified,
- 3:54but it's a hard life for this individual. You get to go home
- 3:59at the end of your shift, you know that sort of thing. So,
- 4:00I mean, maybe it's not a lockdown facilities, but the circumstances that
- 4:06landed them and impatient are probably you know, pretty significant anyway. So there's
- 4:12that, But I would also say that there's no way to cope with this
- 4:17sort of thing, you know, Like for Bob and I, the folks
- 4:21that we work with occasionally that will be like this one. We only see
- 4:27them for an hour a week, maybe two and two. They tend not
- 4:31to yell at us as therapists because we have an authority, and also often,
- 4:40especially for Bob and I, the clients are really wanting to work with
- 4:44us. They're not forced to work with us. Also, given our position,
- 4:49we have a very much easier time being with someone and soothing them and
- 4:56being a strong relationship because it's just the two us in a room talking,
- 5:00right, Whereas when you're in a facility, there's all these practical things like
- 5:04food and dealing with other patients in the inpatient word, Yeah, there's a
- 5:11lot of things that are going to annoy everybody, including the patient. So
- 5:15it's a hard situation that Bob, if I were in your situation, given
- 5:19even my expertise, I don't think I'd be able to handle it. It
- 5:25would be very stressful. So the thing that I'll say to that is that
- 5:31there's maybe not a way to cope really with the situation. There are impatient
- 5:39experiences that I'll hear about that I find to be really, really stressful for
- 5:46everyone involved. If I had it my way, we would allocate more tax
- 5:51dollars or something, or insurance dollars so that the impatient facilities had a quarter
- 5:59of the patients and double the staff, because it would make it a lot
- 6:02less stressful for everyone, including the patients, and then they would be less
- 6:06likely to snap at you this kind of thing, because when you have that,
- 6:12then the patients and the staff are I'm not getting burnt out over time,
- 6:16it sounds like you're getting burnt out. You're you're having to wake up
- 6:21in the morning and go to work and you know that you're going to be
- 6:26treated in a hostile, maybe even a scary fashion. You know that that
- 6:30feeling you get on the way to work, like ugh, or when you're
- 6:33going to bed at night and you're thinking, oh, I got to wake
- 6:36up tomorrow, or Sunday night when you think, oh, the work week
- 6:42starts tomorrow. I've got to face those you know, kinds of experiences.
- 6:46You know that that's that's tough. I don't know if there's a way to
- 6:49exactly, quote unquote cope with that. I was daydreaming about when I worked
- 6:54at the psych hospital back when I got out of school, out of college.
- 7:00First off, nobody calls it mental health tech. They all call it
- 7:01psych tech. So it's nice to hear someone because that's what I was,
- 7:05called a mental health tech. But I worked with children, and I guess
- 7:10the reason it came to mind is because I was thinking about a kid that
- 7:12I had a particularly ornery sense of I felt ornery inside and they were kind
- 7:17of ornery with me and and I maybe it's different with a kid. I
- 7:23could join him in a way that worked really well with him, But it's
- 7:28the same thing isn't available with a grown up because maybe because of the power
- 7:31dynamic, you know, kids and adults, adult being kind of an authority
- 7:38or whatever. And he was he was he was. I guess they call
- 7:44it opposition or whatever. I don't know. He's angry little kid. And
- 7:47you know he'd go in time out. Sometimes he'd go in the seclusion room.
- 7:49Did I ever tell you this story? So he'd go in the seclusion
- 7:53room, and you know the seclusion room is literally a padded room. It
- 7:56didn't have a padded floor, but I had. It was padded room,
- 7:58and we used to take kids in there with a punching bag. That was
- 8:01back in the early nineties when we used to think that was a good idea.
- 8:03Now I don't know that they would do that now, but I remember
- 8:07this kid really bug me and I was in therapy, and my therapist said,
- 8:11you got to join him, and made some suggestions about how to do
- 8:13that. So one day, this kid goes into time out in the seclusion
- 8:16room. And after the time out time like ten minutes or whatever, supposed
- 8:22to process it with it. And so instead of talk about what got him
- 8:26in there, I just walked in with some paper, like a half arema
- 8:28paper and handed him some and I took some and I sat down with him
- 8:33and we tore it together, and we tore it for about fifteen minutes.
- 8:37And you know, you tear paper, it gets kind of small in a
- 8:39hurry. So every now and again, he'd he'd be out of paper to
- 8:43tear. I'd give him a little bit of mine and he'd tear that up.
- 8:46And you know, we're talking like a little you know, centimeter bits
- 8:50of paper. Then he'd hand me some paper to tear up, and that
- 8:54was it for the rest of his time there. We were buddies. It
- 8:58won't necessarily work with the person that the person wrote in here about good to
- 9:03love to love that kid, that was what was needed. M I feel
- 9:07sad. That kid's probably about forty now. Wow, it's a long time
- 9:11ago. Yeah, yeah, you wonder, yeah, like how they're doing.
- 9:16Yeah, yeah, yeah. Your story reminds me of some of the
- 9:22greats and their stories. The difficult client who no one else can meet or
- 9:33get through too. And a simple but out of the box intervention works.
- 9:41And so what was it that gave you the intuition to do that? So
- 9:48what were you thinking at the time. It's so long ago, I don't
- 9:50remember. It might have been just before you're a therapist. Oh yeah,
- 9:54yeah, yeah. This was back in early in the early nineties, so
- 9:56before I moved here and long before graduate school. I don't know. Maybe
- 10:03my therapist suggested it, because it's not the kind of thing that I can
- 10:05imagine me thinking up. So that's probably something like that. I think he
- 10:09was lonely. I don't know if the person that you know we're talking about
- 10:13hearing this is lonely. Maybe they're lonely. I mean it's something like that,
- 10:18yeah, right, yeah, feeling rejected, feeling unfairly betrayed, right,
- 10:24that sort of thing. Yeah, yeah, asterix. Yeah, I
- 10:28feel compelled to define the word join for my fellow marriage and family therapists people.
- 10:35The way you use joint is fine, yep, you can use that
- 10:37because you're not in marriage of family therapy, but it'll literally be on the
- 10:43exam potentially to get licensed. The definition of joining is joining the system.
- 10:50Yeah, it's not rapport building. Yeah, it is potentially not even a
- 10:56report building. It can overlap. But to join a client, to join
- 11:01a system is to become a member of the system, which could be joining
- 11:07the system by being the scapegoat or joining the system by being the asshole that
- 11:13galvanizes the family against you. It's not usually what it means, but that's
- 11:18what joining means. And when I would hear my students who I knew were
- 11:22heading towards the exam we're using, they almost all use there's something so fitting
- 11:30to use the word joining to mean rapport, to build rapport. And the
- 11:35other thing is is that in the clinical literature, nobody uses the word joining
- 11:39in my experience. They all use building rapport or the therapeutical alliance or the
- 11:45working alliance or to improve the relationship. I don't ever hear in the literature
- 11:52people use the word joined, But when people talk, at least in Seattle,
- 11:56at the very least, it's always the word join. And I upun
- 12:01it's been a while because I've it's been a while since I've taught, so
- 12:05it's been a while since I've been around uh, students in this way,
- 12:11and you using it in that way, And I was like, huh,
- 12:13because I was wondering if it was a marriage of family therapist word, but
- 12:18apparently as a counselor for yourself, Like do you know where you picked that
- 12:24picked up that idea, because I don't think you've used that word with me,
- 12:28or have I have I've had this asterisk in the past. I mean,
- 12:33it's a very fitting word when you were using it, it's absolutely it's
- 12:39even better than build rapport because it's not just building a report, it's it's
- 12:46joining with someone that's being with them. That's why I kept kind of wording
- 12:48it, you know, being with somebody. But for my marriage of family
- 12:54therapy. Folks out there that are heading towards the exam know that that's not
- 12:58the definition. Not that you were going to fail the test anyway, because
- 13:03I'm sure you would have studied all the other things. You can get a
- 13:07few wrong. Most people do not this one though. The other reason why
- 13:13I pointed out to my students is that it's one of the most fundamental techniques
- 13:20and ideas within family therapy, within systems theory, you know, the application
- 13:26of systems theory to families, in that if you're going to affect change within
- 13:31a system, you can't be outside of that system. You have to be
- 13:37inside, at least partially the system. And different theorists would have different ideas
- 13:41about it. They would say you have to fully become like the Seteers,
- 13:45and the Whittakers would say you have to literally become someone in this family.
- 13:52Other people might say that you would have one foot in the family and one
- 13:58foot out of the family, and other people postmodern folks might even say that
- 14:01as soon as you sit down with the family, you're a member of the
- 14:05system. You're a member of us system, maybe not of their system,
- 14:09but you and the family are now a system of a sort you can't be
- 14:13objective about that cybernetics of cybernetics, that kind of thing. But so it's
- 14:18a fundamental idea, and systems theory is so hard to comprehend anyway, and
- 14:22there's such a pull back towards linear thinking, and which isn't a bad word.
- 14:28It often can be a bad word linear thinking within family therapy service,
- 14:33but the way I teach it, linear thinking is fine, and it's very
- 14:39useful and does provide wisdom regarding causality which can help drive treatment. But it's
- 14:46so easy to think linearly and it'll come to you automatically because you've been trained
- 14:52your whole life to think that way. So the tough thing is to also
- 14:56dip your mind at times into the pool of systems theory. And you need
- 15:01to do a lot to obtain that quick paradigm acquisition. And part of that
- 15:07is really absorbing these notions of joining and other kinds of things so that you
- 15:15are you have them instinctually in your bones so you can call upon them in
- 15:18a session. You know what I mean? Anyway, So next email is
- 15:24from patron Gaia from Italy. She says, Hi, Kirk and Bob,
- 15:30I'm in my mid I'm in my thirties and I've been in a long term
- 15:33relationship with my partner for almost four years. He started to talk about having
- 15:39kids, but I'm not so sure because of my childhood. My mother emotionally
- 15:46neglected me greatly while I was growing up. I can't recall a single moment
- 15:50of tenderness between us. I've been going to therapy for six years now and
- 15:54trying to cope with the wounds of my childhood, and I'm slowly accepting that
- 16:00I will always feel like there is a gaping whole of sadness at the very
- 16:03core of my soul. I often feel like that whole has somehow inhibited my
- 16:10capacity for empathy. When we hear a kid crying, my partner's reaction is
- 16:15to immediately go into alarm mode, and he feels a genuine connection to the
- 16:21discomfort or pain or sadness that the kid is feeling. But I don't feel
- 16:23that connection at all. If we had a kid, I fear that I
- 16:27would be like my mom and neglect my kids. While I've already explored the
- 16:33topic with my therapist, any advice you might have on the matter is greatly
- 16:37appreciated by what do you think. I hope you're talking to your partner about
- 16:41it, because that might be a deal breaker for them. And you know,
- 16:45like they might want to have kids and you might not, And it's
- 16:48fine. Everybody is going to walk their road. I'm not a parent.
- 16:52I chose not to have kids because I didn't want to perpetuate the legacy of
- 16:56abuse that I come from. It is possible that that's exactly what would happen
- 17:02if you had a kid. You might find yourself having similar kind of emotional
- 17:06responses what parents have told me, though, like my brother. I think
- 17:11about my brother, who's really good. Daddy has four kids in this day
- 17:14and nhs four kids, and he said to me, when it's my kid,
- 17:18something's changed in me. Like other people's kids, if they were,
- 17:22say, crying, you know, I'd be annoyed by it, and I
- 17:26could care least, But when it's my kids, something is crossed over inside
- 17:30and I feel different toward him. I feel kinship. I mean, he
- 17:34didn't your brother literally said that that with random kids. Yea, he notices
- 17:41he doesn't have that that compulsion. Yeah, so this so your brother was
- 17:45talking directly to what guy I was talking about. Yeah, so it's possible
- 17:49that when you have your own kid, and I've seen this with a lot
- 17:55of my couples who have kids. They tell about how they're parenting children,
- 18:00and I find that even though many of my people come from some kind of
- 18:03trauma, some kind of abuse or neglect or something, they are excellent parents.
- 18:08They really know how to respond to their kid. They often respond to
- 18:11their kid in a way that wasn't modeled for them, a sort of an
- 18:15innate wisdom that comes to them. The thing about this is for guys like,
- 18:18you can't know till you know, right, and so I don't know
- 18:22what's going to happen. Maybe they'll find that they love parenthood, or that
- 18:27something shifts inside them or whatever. It's possible that that's the case. It
- 18:33certainly happens. Yeah. The only caution, So, the only thing I'll
- 18:40add to what you're saying, because that's really great, is if, in
- 18:45general, Guaya, you lack empathy for everybody, then yeah, but it
- 18:51doesn't sound like it. So if you have a capacity for empathy that you
- 18:55notice but for some reason, and your litmus test here is a extremely limited
- 19:00situation. You are on the bus and you hear another kid crying. You
- 19:04know, there's a lot of different other situations that you could use to test,
- 19:10like having pets or something. Right, is an approximation of what it
- 19:15would be like to have a kid, you know, But even then it's
- 19:18not necessarily analogous, depending on how you bond with your animals or how you
- 19:22consider that. But it's not the best Lipman test. The other thing is
- 19:27that you might have a reaction to a baby crying on the bus, but
- 19:33you don't really notice it, or it doesn't compel you to care for this
- 19:40random child. It also could be your partner just has this huge heart for
- 19:45children that is very you know, at one end of the bell curve,
- 19:52if you will, Because I imagine the average anecdotally response to a baby crying
- 19:59is either indifference or annoyance. Really that I'll hear from people. In fact,
- 20:03when I was younger, I noticed that my friends would get annoyed with
- 20:10babies crying in public, and I wouldn't. It wouldn't bother me at all
- 20:17even if I noticed it at all. And over time I hypothesized because my
- 20:22mom had a daycare and there were babies and kids crying all the time,
- 20:26right, and it was a normal thing to me. I was very habituated
- 20:32to it, and I saw my mom take care of the kids in this
- 20:37very adept way. My mom didn't flip out when kids were crying, so
- 20:41it wasn't a scary situation. I think for some people it might carry with
- 20:47it some tension because of their past experiences. Maybe they had a younger brother
- 20:52that was chastised for crying or something. I don't know. Also, it's
- 20:56known and makes sense evolutionarily that us humans have a stress response when a child
- 21:02is crying because it compels us to take to take action for our tribe,
- 21:07you know, back in the day. So there's very different ways of coping
- 21:12with that, you know. But anyway, Yeah, if you have empathy
- 21:18in general, which you probably do, then in all likelihood you would have
- 21:22the same empathy and another thing. In the same way that having this sort
- 21:27of trauma can help you be a therapist, it can also help you be
- 21:33a parent, because you know what it feels like to be neglected. Having
- 21:37said that to piggyback on or just to repeat what Bob was saying, Yeah,
- 21:42you will parent your kids. There will be themes that will be related
- 21:48to the way you retreated, and you can No parent can avoid that.
- 21:52That is, it is impossible, you know. I sort of think about
- 21:56it like how you are at a job interview. If you are annoying in
- 22:03some way and you know it, like you talk too much or you don't
- 22:07talk enough. At a job interview, you can clamp down on that for
- 22:11an hour. But if you're married to someone, you're not going to be
- 22:17able to hide that flaw from your partner. And it's even more so that
- 22:22whatever flaw you have, you're not going to be able to hide it from
- 22:26your kids because there's just so many minutes of the day for you to express
- 22:33that flaw. And also you can only manage to exert control over something like
- 22:40that for so long, so it'll happen. But how do you make up
- 22:45for it? How do you account for it? How does your parenting team
- 22:51deal with it? Maybe your partner would notice when you're being neglectful or something
- 22:55and alert you or make up for it or whatever. You know, it
- 22:57doesn't limit the possibility of raising a happy kid, or what I always say
- 23:03is raising a kid that needs the commensurate five to ten years of therapy,
- 23:08because that's just the norm, you know, because people parents, you know,
- 23:17rightfully, so I suppose are terrified of damaging their kids. But it's
- 23:21not possible to not damage your kids. You're all parents are going to damage
- 23:26their kids because of the things I was saying earlier. No one is perfect.
- 23:30Everyone's been through some shit, and that shit will express itself in your
- 23:34parenting, undoubtedly, in all the thousands of ways it will, it will
- 23:40be expressed and will damage your kids, and just let go of that need
- 23:48for perfection, you know. So knowing your issues is a leap, a
- 23:53huge leap forward from most parents. You know. Sometimes if you if you
- 23:59have significant issues growing up and you've been in therapy a long time and have
- 24:03a lot of self awareness, even though you have these tendencies, you're a
- 24:10lot better than the average parent, because the average parent maybe hasn't been through
- 24:14as much difficulty, but also hasn't been through any therapy or any kind of
- 24:18self awareness, and so the moderate to minor flaws that they have, they
- 24:23have no idea they exist, and they just sort of run rampant in their
- 24:27parenting, whereas you at least know what you should be looking for, so,
- 24:33you know, But another thing to think about, Guya is just the
- 24:38bottom line is to how badly you want kids, because if you don't,
- 24:44then you don't. And if you're looking for some kind of hook to hang
- 24:48your coat on regarding justifying not having kids, then you know it. If
- 24:56you really want kids, I would you know, there wouldn't be any reason
- 25:03to dissuade you from having right. But if you're on the fence, then
- 25:07you know, I would just continue to explore. Or maybe Guyan knows she
- 25:11doesn't, or they don't want kids and they have a partner that does that
- 25:15they love and cherish and value and treasure and don't want to give that person
- 25:21up, and so it gets muddy. Yeah, balancing what I want with
- 25:26what my partner wants? Yeah, yeah, Yeah, all right, second
- 25:30break, can we get back more emails? Way? Yeah? All right?
- 25:37Back from the break, let's do an opp bob. These people became
- 25:41patrons all the way back in twenty twenty and have stayed patrons through thick and
- 25:45thin. Wow. The following folks didn't list where they live, which is
- 25:48fine, So they are from god knows where. We have Hillary, Kylie,
- 25:53Sarah Deanna, Chelsea, Indira Blanca, Tiffany, Emily, Laura Walid,
- 26:02Zuzanna and Liza, and then the other folks here listed where they live.
- 26:07I'm not gonna listen. I'm not going to list their address of course,
- 26:11well, which would be weird. I'll just list the approximate area of
- 26:15the world the van. And these are all middle tier patrons, so they're
- 26:21extra special. We have Autumn from Bancroft, Michigan. We have Mark from
- 26:26Brooklyn, New York. Stephanie's from Drumheller, Alberta, Troy from aDNA Adena,
- 26:33Minnesota. And we have from Friendswood, Texas. That's a nice name,
- 26:40Friendswood, Texas. Tao is from Texas. We have Katya from Long
- 26:45Beach, California. We have Lauren from Sydney, Australia. We have Black
- 26:49from Tampere, Finland, Tampier, Finland. We have Michael from Hawaii from
- 26:56Oahu, not not Maui. You've have you been to Maui? Yeah,
- 27:02it's pretty awful what happened right now? Yeah, it's terrible, folks,
- 27:06Yeah, just awful. Leah from Illinois, So thank you so much for
- 27:12being a patron since twenty twenty and staying a patron through thick and thin,
- 27:17y'all. Okay, so next email, getting to my list of emails here.
- 27:22This is a long one, but apparently I considered it important to read
- 27:26the whole thing because I didn't edit it much. So let's see why I
- 27:30didn't edit it much. A patier patron Gabby from Texas. She says,
- 27:37Hi, Kirk, and Bob, I recently had to terminate with my therapist
- 27:41because sorry, I recently had to terminate with my therapist I was seeing for
- 27:45five sessions, and I have a lot of complex feelings about it. I
- 27:49recently moved to another state and had to get a therapist. I am currently
- 27:55diagnosed with generalized anxiety disorder, but I think I might have ADHD or another
- 28:00type of neurodiversity I'm struggling with. I saw a male therapist, and I
- 28:06told him I was nervous about him being male because part of my issues are
- 28:11women's issues, he asserted. He assured me. He assured me this would
- 28:15be fine, and he had the male perspective on things and would be able
- 28:21to let me know how he thinks rather than just agreeing with me like a
- 28:25female therapist might. What that's weird. Wait, he assured me that everything
- 28:32would be fine, even though I do have, so I'm just sort of
- 28:34summarizing him even though I have women's issues. As Gabby puts it, he
- 28:41assured me everything would be fine, and he would have the male perspective on
- 28:45things okay, and would be able to let me know how he thinks rather
- 28:49than just agreeing with me like a female therapist might. It's kind of offensive.
- 28:55That's if he even came close to even just intimating that. That's not
- 29:00only offensive and sexist, but just flat out stupid. It is pretty dumb.
- 29:08There's you know, you can be sexist in a smart way, not
- 29:12that that's that makes it any better, but there's a sophisticated level of sexism
- 29:21and this is not one of them. Going on. We gave it a
- 29:25B on crappy and c minus on smart. Yeah, this made sense to
- 29:33me at the time, so I continued to go. In our first session,
- 29:37he laughed a lot at me and told me I was really funny,
- 29:41and it's a shame I don't see what a great person I am. I
- 29:45was kind of confused because we had just met, and I took the compliment.
- 29:48He continued to tell me in our following sessions how he looked forward to
- 29:52our sessions and he enjoyed our conversation. Any thoughts on that so far?
- 29:56Your face is one of astonished it is, isn't it. Yeah, I
- 30:02don't know. I don't like it. Seems like, okay, I'm just
- 30:06saying what my impression is, he's trying too hard. What do you mean,
- 30:10well, laughing at what you said and being so overly solicitous about I'm
- 30:15enjoying knowing you whatever. It just feels like early early days. But you
- 30:21know what, it's just an impression. What early days of a therapist?
- 30:23Yeah, yeah, early days and early days of their relationship. Yeah,
- 30:26oh yeah. Well, it's hard to know what really happened because it's possible
- 30:33hearing it through the client's eyes. But at least we have two potential indications
- 30:40that the therapist is pretty desperate to have a client. Ye, someone who
- 30:45is, Because if someone came to me and said they were reticent about talking
- 30:51to me because I'm a man, which has happened, of course in my
- 30:53life. I at least at this phase in my life, if it was
- 30:59significant, and I would say, well, let's find you a female therapist.
- 31:03I'm not desperate for clients, right, And by the way, just
- 31:07while I'm on the topic, people occasionally will email or call or something,
- 31:11and I haven't accepted a new client in several years. I'm trying to think
- 31:18when was the last time I actually had room and on my schedule for a
- 31:22new client, and I'm thinking it would have been seven years ago, maybe
- 31:26maybe longer. I don't know, the reason being that I have been transitioning
- 31:32more and more my career and paying the bills via media, podcasting and YouTube,
- 31:38so I don't have time for clients, which kind of bumps me out.
- 31:42And occasionally, whatever I say that to Bob Off Mike, Bob will
- 31:48try to give me a client. It is a fact. And I regretted
- 31:55having opened that door less because you were really handing me about couple of people,
- 32:00which you know, it's fine, but it does tug at something inside
- 32:06of me. But I don't have enough time as it is, do you
- 32:09know what I mean? Like you got to be good at right. Yeah.
- 32:14Although I will say, for folks that care to hear this, that
- 32:19I have been establishing a much better balance this summer. Oh good for you.
- 32:25Yeah. And the big factor is that I'm scaling back on YouTube quite
- 32:30a bit, so that gives me at least some free time because I will
- 32:36talk on the podcast sometimes, how you know, they'll be like, I
- 32:39mean, it's it's still a problem. Like I don't know if you can
- 32:43see it, Bob, But over there's a Lego set. It's there in
- 32:46the side. It is of the Lunar Lander Apolo eleven. And I bought
- 32:54that probably a year and a half ago and have not had the time to
- 33:00actually sit down and put it together. It's like, yeah, or I
- 33:04got it for Christmas, maybe a year and a half agos Anyway, I
- 33:09keep looking at that Lego set just thinking when I managed to put that Lego
- 33:15set together, that means that I'm done with my work sufficiently done, and
- 33:22I'm done with my chores, and I'm done with the kind of bigger chores
- 33:27like putting up curtain rods and fixing that door downstairs or whatever. And I've
- 33:32managed to get all my obligations out of the way. Maybe not everything,
- 33:37but you know, close to it. Because in the past, like four
- 33:40years ago, I would have bought that and put it together in the same
- 33:45day or at least in the same week. And it would be dumb for
- 33:47me to buy a Lego set and just have it sit in the box,
- 33:50you know. So, so I'm not quite there yet, but I'm I'm
- 33:57closer to the Apollo eleven lunar lander than I was a few months ago anyway.
- 34:02So why am I saying that work life balance? You're not taking new
- 34:08clients around you to take new people? Yeah, okay, we're working our
- 34:12way backwards. And your mind's like a trap. When it comes to this
- 34:16sort of thing, the thing about you and dementia, it will be very
- 34:20noticeable because your memory will be noticed when it's gone. You know, with
- 34:25people who already have trouble with the remembering things, it'll be hard to detect
- 34:30if they start to decline cognitively. Anyway, So going on with the email
- 34:37here, Well, so what I think about this second bit is yeah,
- 34:43solicitous of the therapist. But yeah, there's nothing wrong, man, it's
- 34:47just an impression. We don't I don't know nothing. Yeah. A therapist
- 34:52is like, oh my god, you're really funny. It's a shame that
- 34:53you you don't recognize that you're such an interesting, funny person. And then
- 35:00he says he continued to tell me in our following sessions, how we looked
- 35:02forward to our sessions, and he enjoyed our conversation. You know that in
- 35:07and of itself is a wonderful thing, especially if it's genuine. Right going
- 35:10on for context, he was around age fifty and I'm twenty five. I
- 35:15felt kind of strange that he kept complimenting me. He told me he believes
- 35:20my self esteem was low, when I'm not sure if I agree, And
- 35:24I told him, and I told him, oh sorry, And he told
- 35:30me that I am beautiful and intelligent. So okay, I'm starting to get
- 35:35a little a little weird. But you know, nothing, nothing terrible.
- 35:39When I would talk about difficulties in my childhood and how I look at the
- 35:44world, he called me complex. I felt like I felt kind of like
- 35:51a specimen on display and felt weird. He put pressure on me by telling
- 35:55me how much he enjoyed our talks and how much he liked me. What
- 36:00do you think about that? Which part like it's specimen and pressure? It
- 36:07felt like a specimen. He didn't say she was a specimen, but she
- 36:10felt like she was a specimen to him, and he's saying that she's beautiful.
- 36:15It sounds a little skivy. It Have you ever told a client that
- 36:21they're beautiful or attractive. I may have Yeah, well, what would have
- 36:27been the circumstances, Because I just talked about this in a recent episode,
- 36:30like last month, because someone wrote in of a situation I was kind of
- 36:35like this, and you know the summary that I came to, and I
- 36:39sort of came to this conclusion while I was recording the episode, that there
- 36:45are extremely limited situations where a therapist would say something like that and not have
- 36:52it be a problem, you know, and I find that and tell me
- 36:57what you think about this, because I my sense is like there are two
- 37:00camps of people. The big camp is, never talk about your attraction.
- 37:07In fact, there's something wrong with you if you're attracted to your clients.
- 37:09And of course that's not accurate, that's not wise because it's normal statistically and
- 37:17humanity wise that occasionally a therapist would find a client to be attractive. Nothing
- 37:22wrong with that. So either the big group that I anecdotally will hear from
- 37:29is never talk about it. It's shameful, there's something wrong with you,
- 37:31right, yeah, And then another group of people, smaller group will say,
- 37:37always tell your client, because it's crazy making not to tell your client
- 37:40you've heard that before, right, Well, yeah, that sounds weird though
- 37:44it's too extreme, right, Yeah. So those are the only two groups
- 37:47that I hear from because it's so rarely talked about. And I think the
- 37:52second group is perhaps a little wiser, even though they might be more harmful
- 37:59to the clients, but at least they're acknowledging that humans are humans and that
- 38:04maybe attraction, you know, they might be a little bit more aware of
- 38:07countertransference and that kind of thing. But what I came to in terms of
- 38:13during this episode that is recording, was that you should absolutely not feel ashamed
- 38:19of yourself if you're attracted to a client, but you should absolutely acknowledge it
- 38:22and get consultation and think about it and work on it, because you don't
- 38:30want it to interfere and you also don't want to go down a slippery slope
- 38:34of boundary violations and then eventually harming the client through some kind of dual relationship.
- 38:39And that's a process. Most people I think don't do that, though,
- 38:45and they are ashamed of themselves or they are being shamed if they bring
- 38:51this up with people, and then that will cause suffering or client or therapists
- 38:57that don't know what they're doing, so they might actually just they give a
- 39:00vibe. So they either are giving a vibe that they're attracted and the client
- 39:04is being made to feel crazy because the client as the therapist isn't saying anything
- 39:08right there, or it starts to run rampant and the therapist ends up without
- 39:15any checks and balances because they're in denial of it. They start to act
- 39:19on some of these things, right, Yeah. So, but I was
- 39:23trying to think of a of a situation and I was role playing. I
- 39:27was like, well, I tried to role play a situation in which I
- 39:30might be attracted to a client, and I would and how I would tell
- 39:36them, because if you did get to that point where you felt like it
- 39:40was important. In the only situation I'd come up with was if I,
- 39:45as a therapist, Let's say I was you know, moderate to severe attraction
- 39:51to a client and it was hard for me to hide it, and the
- 39:54client picked up on it and asked me about it, and then I said,
- 39:59in this very quick, disjointed way that that wasn't true or something that
- 40:07denied it, and I detected a rupture there of some kind because the client
- 40:10detected that something was Wonking. Yeah, well then I would feel maybe compelled
- 40:19to say something because I have created a problem by letting it show itself,
- 40:27but and the client has noticed it, but I'm denying it. So it
- 40:31is kind of a crazy making situation. So in that situation, I was
- 40:35thinking maybe, But then even as I was role playing, and I'm like,
- 40:39it's still not necessarily something that you would want to dump on a client.
- 40:45It's by issue. You know, Attraction is fine, but obsessing and
- 40:52entertaining and daydreaming that's often controllable. So to if I'm doing that kind of
- 41:00a thing, then that's on me. There's something going on in my personal
- 41:06life. Yeah, because we all know, especially once you have these relationships
- 41:14play themselves out, that the two individuals, if there is attraction and interest
- 41:19in dating outside of the therapy office, that you're not really attracted to them.
- 41:23You're attracted to the client and they're attracted to you as a therapist.
- 41:29And then when you actually engage in an outside relationship, ninety nine times out
- 41:32of one hundred, both people are deeply disappointed because the therapeutic relationship does not
- 41:39last and it gets into real relationship time and real persona time you know what
- 41:46I mean. But but I did also say that I can't imagine certain grant
- 41:54if we stick to male therapist female clients. I can imagine grandfatherly client therapists
- 42:04that I know who probably have because they're you know, one grandfatherly therapist that
- 42:10I know really well. He's very authentic and upfront, and I could imagine
- 42:17him saying to someone a client, a female client, that she was beautiful.
- 42:22And I could see the client not receiving it as being creepy, but
- 42:25as as very non threatening and very unsolicitous. If you will, Yeah,
- 42:32I've done that. Oh you have, I have done that? Okay,
- 42:36Like tell me what was the what you were thinking at the time if I
- 42:38I know I've said this. I can't remember which person I said it too,
- 42:44but they were struggling with, you know, dating, and I said,
- 42:50you know, you're you're good looking, you're bright. I should think
- 42:54that any man that gets to be with you be very lucky. That's it,
- 42:59right, And but it isn't based on I found them attractive. It
- 43:02wasn't some sneaky way of you know it expressing that now oh no, or
- 43:08even expressing like a personal like draw more like just a recognition, Hey man,
- 43:14you're you're there's a lot to love about you. There's lots of that
- 43:17someone would be very lucky to have, right right, yeah, So and
- 43:22before saying something like that, I'm guessing you would have it would have butted
- 43:29up against an editor in your mind, right, Oh yeah, yeah,
- 43:30I wouldn't just fly on your own? What was that? What was that?
- 43:36Why in the road? What was that decision? Tree, if you
- 43:39will, that would have said, yes, I'm going to say this though,
- 43:45it would have been recognition that they struggled with a sense of esteem,
- 43:50self esteem, and a desire to offer some friendly encouragement, friendly encouragement for
- 43:57them to keep trying on dating. Yeah, keep trying for partnership, not
- 44:01give up. Not about me. I mean, I'm very frank about the
- 44:06fact that I'm married. I talk about Colleen fairly regularly. All my people
- 44:09know I'm married to somebody called Colleen, and I'm not I'm not interested in
- 44:16anybody someone called Colleen. What'd you say? Everybody that I work with knows
- 44:21that I'm married to somebody. They all know it. Oh, that she's
- 44:23called Colleen. I thought you said out one of your clients called Colleen.
- 44:28On the phone or something. Yeah, no, no, no, no,
- 44:29okay, everybody knows that I'm married to Colleen and and I'm not I'm
- 44:35not interested in anything except providing good therapy. Right, So to say that
- 44:43a client is attractive, it's different than saying I'm attracted. Oh yeah,
- 44:46yeah, No, I ain't going to say that. I never say that.
- 44:50It isn't important to say that. There's no use in saying that.
- 44:52When I have had clients that are attractive, I find it very distracting for
- 44:58a while, and then it goes away and I talk about it with my
- 45:00colleague, like I'll talk about it with you, or I'll talk about it
- 45:04with you, know, like my treatment team, if I'm on a treatment
- 45:07team or whatever. Because it's better to not have that as a secret inside
- 45:12me. It's just better to have it I have it shared. Why it
- 45:16takes away a lot of its power. Yeah, We've talked about this before,
- 45:21and I've said this before that for whatever reason, this doesn't happen to
- 45:25me. It's weird. I'm an anomally. You do not get attracted to
- 45:30your clients. No, I don't know why. It's just easier if you
- 45:34don't, Because it's not like I'm not a human being in other contexts,
- 45:42I'll just put it that way. But when it comes to clients and students
- 45:45for that matter, there's probably a lot more opportunity for me to be attracted
- 45:51to a student than a client. But your students are your clients from a
- 45:55certain point of view, that the right treat them as right. I'm I
- 46:00have a responsibility, a fatherly, brotherly responsibility. Not I'm not in the
- 46:07club. And if I were, then yeah, then all bets are off
- 46:14in that department. But for whatever reason, it just doesn't even register for
- 46:20me. And if I thought about it objectively, I've had clients and students,
- 46:24I think students in particular. I've had some just I guess, knockout
- 46:31gorgeous female students and clients in my in my twenty five plus years. But
- 46:40it just doesn't affect me. I don't even register it. Really. I
- 46:46might note it in the beginning, like like oh, wow, she looks
- 46:51like she could be a supermodel or whatever, you know, just like wow,
- 46:54I mean that she has like the exact bone structure of of gazelle.
- 47:00I don't know what's one of the supermodels, Well, who's the one from
- 47:05the eighties Crawford Crawford, Cindy Crawford, right with with the mole on a
- 47:10face anyway you taught Cindy Crawford. So I just don't so I have to
- 47:21ask you, like what you do with it? Yeah? And let me
- 47:25ask you so rough estimate how often does this happen where you're attracted Joe client,
- 47:32oh? Or you find yourself attracted Joe client. Oh. I don't
- 47:37know. Maybe it's all couples nowadays, so somehow the dynamic with that's different.
- 47:42But maybe once a year, maybe once every two years. I can
- 47:45think of some clients that I've had over the years that okay, I found
- 47:49very attractive. So fifteen clients over the years, maybe, yeah, fifteen,
- 47:53twenty. And what's the difference with I can imagine why. But what's
- 47:58the difference with couples is individuals with this topic, I'm busy with their relationship,
- 48:04that the relationships my client. That's the way I feel, even with
- 48:07individuals. I think I even said that in a recent episode that I equated
- 48:12it to being a first responder, which is a little extreme, but if
- 48:15you're a first responder at a car accident, you have bigger fish to fry,
- 48:21and your brain is so galvanized on a task that this other aspect of
- 48:28your personality just doesn't have room to express itself or or be in existence really,
- 48:35And so that's how it feels to me. It's I'm so concentrated on
- 48:43helping or teaching or mentoring that this other aspect of myself that would only engage
- 48:52if I were relaxed, I guess, is just not accessible, you know.
- 48:57So you're saying that with couples, you could have you know, so,
- 49:00say you have or I guess the litmus test would be a client,
- 49:07say ten years ago, that you found to be particularly attractive, but instead
- 49:13of coming in for individual therapy at the beginning, they came in on a
- 49:15couple of therapy. You're saying you might not You might have noted their attractiveness,
- 49:20but you wouldn't have felt the attraction it because of how active you have
- 49:27to be. You have to be on your toes so much with couples as
- 49:30opposed to individual With individuals, you can kind of sit back and relax a
- 49:32little bit. Yeah, yeah, interesting, Okay, I can imagine that
- 49:37being a factor for a lot of people. One thing I want to say,
- 49:39though, is I've said that, not just to women, I've said
- 49:44that to men. You know, like, you're attractive, you're a good
- 49:46looking right, You've got a lot to offer here. Yeah. In fact,
- 49:50I would be much more likely to say that sort of thing to a
- 49:55man, gay or straight, because I would one in all likelihood not into
- 50:05it that they would feel threatened by that, because they would know me to
- 50:07be a heterosexual guy. Also, men traditionally don't have to beat other people
- 50:16off of them, meaning that that's a way a weird way to put it,
- 50:20but many women, and particularly attractive women, are in a constant Have
- 50:25you seen the movie Barbie No Stacey and I saw it last night, and
- 50:32it briefly gets into this, so you know, it's not really spoiling,
- 50:37but Barbie lives in Barbie Land, and it's this perfect idealized feminist world where
- 50:45women can be anything, and the kens of the world are very secondary and
- 50:52very much, you know, trying to get Barbie's attention, this kind of
- 50:58thing. Barbie comes into the real world and she's walking around Venice speech and
- 51:02these guys are leering at her and you know, innuendos, and she says,
- 51:07I feel this strange sense of dread and threat and I can't really put
- 51:14my finger on it, you know. She mentions it right away, and
- 51:17Ken's right next to her, having also passed into the real world, and
- 51:22it's just like, yeah, you know, suddenly I feel really powerful.
- 51:24I don't know what's going on because of they're looking around and the dynamics between
- 51:30genders everywhere, you know, and it's very different than it. It's some
- 51:32more everything. And so my point is is that that's a context that needs
- 51:37to be taken to consideration. You would imagine that most therapists would have that
- 51:42consideration before if you're a male theraparticularly if you're yeah, well we're regardless of
- 51:47how old you are, I guess and as a male therapist telling a client
- 51:51that they're attractive is you know, you would just have to But anyway,
- 51:57so for you, when what did it feel like when you first Is it
- 52:01in the first session when you note you know, these fifteen to twenty clients
- 52:07over the span of your career, what is the feeling? What do you
- 52:10note? What do you how do you notice it? Well, I know
- 52:15what it feels like to be attracted to somebody, and then I know what
- 52:16it feels like to be nervous because this is going to be a distraction at
- 52:21least for a while. So immediately you feel nervous. Yeah, like,
- 52:24well, what's the fear? Well, okay, the fear is that I'll
- 52:30act on it. That's terrifying. The fear is that it'll bleed out.
- 52:36And the fear is, I don't know, I'm not really afraid I'm going
- 52:42to act on it. The fear is that it will become a distraction and
- 52:44you'll get in a way of being able to provide good therapy. That's really
- 52:47the fear. What would that distraction look like? What would it look like?
- 52:52I don't know if I've ever really thought about it. Would I would
- 52:55I avoid something? Would I say something that would be out of my countertransferential
- 53:04response as opposed to in for the benefit of the client? Would that like
- 53:08leak out? Would that right? Okay? So I could imagine. I
- 53:13don't know about you, but a therapist would maybe try to steer things like
- 53:20if they are talking about their spouse and they're complaining. You know, there's
- 53:25a lot of factors that swim through our minds as we have impulses to ask
- 53:31the next question or to reflect a particular part of what they're saying, or
- 53:37to have a particular demeanor. There's so many things and factors that are swimming
- 53:44around in our minds that affect us as we act towards our clients, even
- 53:51in just listening, the way that we listen, the facial expression, the
- 53:54the the pace at which we nod at them, or you know, all
- 54:00these kinds of things, let alone the kinds of things you might ask after
- 54:05they stop talking, you know, the things you focus on. So with
- 54:10attraction, all the factors swing through your mind. One of them could be
- 54:17an unconscious desire to want to be with her, and thus she's complaining about
- 54:22her spouse. You might be a little bit more negative about the spouse,
- 54:28trying to convince her to leave him or something, maybe not explicitly but I
- 54:32hope not, but the vibe of just like wow, he sounds like he's
- 54:37got a problem there or something, instead of saying like how do you feel
- 54:40about that? You know, more neutral, or something like a distorted lens
- 54:44that would impact you know, the things that they focus on, the things
- 54:47that they think about. Absolutely, So that's what you might worry about.
- 54:51I would worry about that also, you say distraction. I mean when I
- 54:53think of distraction, I think of you're just like sitting there oggling her without
- 55:01keeping her eye on the ball regarding helping her. If you're if you're at
- 55:07a picnic, you might notice that the gnats are flying around and they're just
- 55:12part of the backdrop, but you're, you know, you're at your picnic.
- 55:16I think it's more like that. For me, it's sort of like
- 55:17this is occasionally I can feel this thing buzzing around that I don't like,
- 55:22but you know, still at the picnic. Still I don't love my metaphor
- 55:29well I do. The way that I might think about it more concretely,
- 55:31I suppose, is that most of the time with your clients, you have
- 55:37a lot of aspects of yourself directed towards helping and paying attention. Attraction is
- 55:44generated, you could say, selfishly within us, right, it's a need
- 55:47of ours, Like if we had to go to the bathroom or we were
- 55:52hungry or something. Those are also distractions on they would distract us away from
- 55:59all the efforts and focus on trying to help the client, listening to them
- 56:04and thinking about them. So it's another aspect of our personality or our need
- 56:09structure that is going to occupy part of our I like how you put it,
- 56:15mindspace, and that's the NATS, right, Yeah, that's the NATS,
- 56:19right. Yeah. I'm thinking about a person that I when I first
- 56:22started with them was many years ago, and I saw them for a number
- 56:25of years, and I was very attracted to them. Really just quite a
- 56:30lovely young person, and over the course of knowing her, I found myself
- 56:37feeling mostly just avuncular, just like like really caring about her. The attraction
- 56:43part it passed and I could pay attention to her and care about her in
- 56:49the way that I want to care about my people and not be bothered by
- 56:52it. And that was nice to just not be to not have the NATS
- 56:57buzzing around. Yeah, it's just it just paid it and you know,
- 57:01still when I think about him, think that's lovely, just lovely. Well,
- 57:07So if it was a particular problem and then you would consult with me
- 57:12or someone else, what would that entail and how what would you hope would
- 57:19happen from that? It would entail just owning it, just saying I noticed
- 57:27that this is happening for me, and I'm distracted by it, and in
- 57:30my younger days, I would be describing being afraid, being what afraid?
- 57:35Afraid? Yeah, like the first time this happened to me when it's when
- 57:37I moved to Seattle and I was working as a case manager down written and
- 57:44I had a client who I found very attractive, and I told my team,
- 57:49and they were really lovely and supportive. Nobody condemned me, nobody really
- 57:53said much of anything one or the other. A mentor of mind there pulled
- 57:58me aside and he's like, you know, it happens. It's not that
- 58:01big a deal one way or the other. And what you want to do
- 58:06is ask yourself what it's about, because it isn't about being attracted. It's
- 58:09about some kind of countertransference that's coming up here, some kind of some kind
- 58:13of thing that's just coming up for you. And I found that advice implicitly
- 58:19validating and supportive. And and then I got some advice about what to do
- 58:25because the client actually expressed attraction to me. And I asked my mentor what
- 58:31do I do? And he said, this person has so few positive men
- 58:37in her life, and you want to stay being one of those. And
- 58:44I don't remember exactly what I said because it came up that I wanted to
- 58:51remain a very positive force and I wanted to I don't. I didn't say
- 58:53this way. Did you tell her you were attracted to her? No?
- 58:57I did not. Did you vibe you're attracted to her? I may have
- 59:04no. Yeah, how did it end? How did it end? Well?
- 59:08I mean I left that job to essentially sort of to go to graduate
- 59:14school. But that's I ended my connection with her among many of my clients.
- 59:20Positively, I was still working with her. I still cared about her
- 59:25quite a bit and still did my job and kept it to my job.
- 59:31And as far as I know that that went fine. Yeah. Yeah,
- 59:38has it ever the attraction actually grown and did become a problem such that you
- 59:45would consider referring or something that's never happened to me. Usually what happens is
- 59:50it just fades on its own, right, maybe maybe a few months,
- 59:53maybe less. Another thing, and I don't know if this is a thing,
- 1:00:01but do you have a particular thing about attractive people in general, like
- 1:00:12not just clients, but people that are very very attractive? Is that?
- 1:00:17Yeah, it's distracting just in general. Yeah, like if you had a
- 1:00:22cashier or a friend or something. Yeah, like, what's that. It's
- 1:00:27a similar kind of distraction. It's sort of a sort of a kind of
- 1:00:30a gnat or an inner focus on that. Nothing I ever intended to do
- 1:00:34anything with or about, because that's not that's for any reasons against my morals.
- 1:00:39I don't want to be displayed a colleen. But yeah, I don't
- 1:00:45know if I'm different from the people, because I can't see inside of the
- 1:00:47people. I don't know how other people feel. I think there's a range.
- 1:00:51I think some people have think most things. I think some people that
- 1:00:54I know are very very distracted by it and have no self awareness around it
- 1:01:00and are maybe even entertaining it at times. Yeah, I know I have
- 1:01:04awareness, Yeah, and the other people, it just doesn't even register that
- 1:01:10someone's attractive necessarily, you know what I mean. That's not something I would
- 1:01:14ever entertain. Yeah, Okay, so let's take a breaking. When we
- 1:01:19get back, let's continue with the email. What do you say? Right
- 1:01:21on? Okay, So we went down that tangent because the patron, Gabby
- 1:01:31from Texas, she said that her therapist told her that she was beautiful.
- 1:01:36Remember, he's fifties, she's twenty five. When I going on to through
- 1:01:40email. When I would talk about difficulties in my childhood and how I look
- 1:01:45at the world, he would call me complex. Oh, and he found
- 1:01:47me to be a special I felt like I was a specimen. And he
- 1:01:52also told me how much he enjoyed our talks and how much he liked me.
- 1:01:57Okay, again, hard to know what he means by that or what
- 1:02:01is what the vibes are. In one session, he took a phone call
- 1:02:06and I assumed he would say he was in session and hang up right away.
- 1:02:10He then talked for less than three minutes, but I felt ignored and
- 1:02:15sort of uncomfortable. The next session, I told him that this hurt my
- 1:02:20feelings. When he took the phone call, he said it was an insurance
- 1:02:22thing and he had to answer, and I don't remember if he said sorry.
- 1:02:27In our last session, he checked his phone a couple of times.
- 1:02:30By what do you think about that? I think both of those suck.
- 1:02:34Yeah you do, not an insurance company. That's what's going to trump your
- 1:02:37work. Yeah, like come on, man's nuts? Yeah, what the
- 1:02:43fuck? It's yeah? Yeah? Remember, stupid is a stupid does?
- 1:02:47I never know if that's the appropriate use. But if you're dumb in one
- 1:02:52way. As a therapist, you're probably dumb and in a lot of words.
- 1:02:55And so we're starting to see that I've had this happen to me.
- 1:03:00I was doing co therapy with another family therapist with a family and we were
- 1:03:07in session with I don't know six seven family members and her phone rang.
- 1:03:13And this is back when there it was pre iPhone, so it was,
- 1:03:19you know, a flip phone. I remember that. I don't know why
- 1:03:21that detail matters, but the phone rings, and of my colleague and I
- 1:03:28and immediately I'm just like Jesus Christ, why isn't it on silence? And
- 1:03:32so I was already judging her harshly for that, but then she proceeds to
- 1:03:37flip the phone open and starts talking, and I'm looking at the family like
- 1:03:42with big eyes, thinking what the buck are is she doing right now?
- 1:03:46And yeah, I'm pretty sure I talked with her about it afterwards. It's
- 1:03:51like, you know, I don't think it's a good idea that I mean,
- 1:03:55the obliviousness that you would have. There are things like this where because
- 1:04:01if my phone just had a notification like a ding in the middle of a
- 1:04:06session, that I would be ashamed of that for months, I'd be like,
- 1:04:14what happened there? Or you know, and I'm guessing that's happened at
- 1:04:17some point in my career. But I'm pretty diligent about silencing my phone.
- 1:04:21It's always on silent period, right. Mine's always on silent period as well,
- 1:04:27which isn't always great if someone's trying to get a hold of me right
- 1:04:30away, you know what I mean. But I just don't like to hear
- 1:04:33my phone going off anyway. The chasm and of differences that would have to
- 1:04:42be present for someone to leave their phone on, you know, on alert
- 1:04:48and answer it in the middle of a session, like there have to be
- 1:04:53there there. I just don't understand how what's going on with these people?
- 1:04:57And if they have that difference, then how different are they from the standard
- 1:05:02of care as a therapist, you know, Like, what's what's going on
- 1:05:05with this person? Right? Yeah, I can imagine if my partner was
- 1:05:13pregnant and gonna give birth. Right there are situations fine, or your kid
- 1:05:17is in the hospital, or your kids sick at home. The only situation
- 1:05:21where I've run into this that's analogous is I'll have students that because I it's
- 1:05:30I never even have to say this to students to make sure their phone is
- 1:05:33silenced and not to answer their phone. But occasionally, and I might even
- 1:05:38say this during orientation that if you have an emergency at home, like your
- 1:05:43kid's sick or something, just tell me. And that's fine. If you
- 1:05:48know, if your phone rings and you have to dip out of class to
- 1:05:50answer the phone, then but be professional and tell me before it happens,
- 1:05:58you know. So anyway I would tell if I if I was in a
- 1:06:03situation, and then to tell my client upfront coming into the meeting, this
- 1:06:08might happen. And if it does, I got a check right, and
- 1:06:10I'm terribly sorry. I apologize up and down if this happens, but I
- 1:06:17kind of need to take care of this. I don't know. Has that
- 1:06:20ever happened to you? Has it ever happened to me where you've had to
- 1:06:25tell a client I might be receiving a phone call. Yeah, it has
- 1:06:28a couple of times, like if my phone rings incessantly, if it's on
- 1:06:30buzz, If it buzzes incessantly, then I'm like, oh, it could
- 1:06:34be calling, and it could be an emergency, and she knows that I
- 1:06:39don't answer the thing, and so she's calling multiple times, so I have
- 1:06:43to look and then I look, has that ever happened? Yeah? What
- 1:06:45was the emergency? Oh? Has it ever happened that I don't remember?
- 1:06:54I don't remember because it's so rare, and I'll check and I'll be like,
- 1:06:59oh, no, I don't know this number. So I just put
- 1:07:01it aside and you know whatever. And with a therapy, so your phone's
- 1:07:06on vibrate. Yeah, doesn't that annoy you when you're in session? It
- 1:07:12would annoy this shit out of me going out with the email. Lastly,
- 1:07:15I recently wrote and illustrated a children's book about the death of a grandparent.
- 1:07:21When I came to a session, he showed me that he bought it.
- 1:07:26Okay, So she wrote and illustrated a children's book and then when she came
- 1:07:30to session, he's like, hey, I bought your book. He asked
- 1:07:33me to sign it and I agreed, and then he asked if he could
- 1:07:38use this book in his therapy as it had to do with grief. Any
- 1:07:43thoughts on that it gets dangerously close to breaking confidentiality. It absolutely breaks confidentiality
- 1:07:49because it's not you know, if he shows this book to people and it's
- 1:07:55signed, especially you know what I mean. I mean, I don't know
- 1:07:58if you'd be handing the book. I mean, so there's a way to
- 1:08:00do it. Like I'm gonna occasionally read from this book to my clients,
- 1:08:06but I won't tell them that you're my client. I'll just say that I
- 1:08:11just found this great book. You know, that's a possibility. But it
- 1:08:16unless you explicitly talk about that with your client, that would be a worry.
- 1:08:24Right, given everything else that he's done, I don't know if we
- 1:08:27can trust him to not say this book was written by one of my clients.
- 1:08:30Right, Yeah, well, but who knows a lot of the things
- 1:08:36that we've heard so far, aside from the cell phone thing, are not
- 1:08:42slammed on comunications of something that was wrong. That's true going on? He
- 1:08:46asked if he could tell people a client if has made it as to show
- 1:08:50people who struggle can do great things. Oh, so, what's the problem
- 1:08:57there. It's totally a violation of company. Well not only that, Well,
- 1:09:00it's not a violation of confidentiality if she agrees. I think that's such
- 1:09:05a high demand situation, right, you should never like, like, what
- 1:09:10are you here for? Right? It's a dual relationship that it compels the
- 1:09:16client because it'd be rude for the client to refuse. And the client should
- 1:09:21not be the the keeper of ethics, you know, it's that the therapist
- 1:09:27should be. It should be the keeper. We should never put clients in
- 1:09:30the position of having to monitor their safety regarding issues like this, like confidentiality
- 1:09:36and privacy and stuff. Yeah. You know. Now again, if if
- 1:09:42I were in a consultation group with ten other therapists and average therapists and one
- 1:09:49of them said that they were going to do this, you know, it's
- 1:09:51like, I have this client who wrote this really great book on grief,
- 1:09:55and I want to, you know, use it because it's it's such a
- 1:10:00great and I also want to honor how great this book is that my client
- 1:10:02wrote. And I also want to try to highlight this and say this person
- 1:10:10is my client because I want other clients to know that just because you're a
- 1:10:15client doesn't mean you can't do great things. You know, if if someone
- 1:10:18said that, I would have my uh, you know, red flags go
- 1:10:24up because of the high demand situation as you're putting it. But I imagine
- 1:10:28a lot of clients, a lot of other therapists in the room, maybe
- 1:10:32half would actually not even have that red flag. That's my finding anyway.
- 1:10:39So my point in saying that is is that this isn't one of those things.
- 1:10:43It's not like having sex with a client, and these sort of things
- 1:10:46happen sometimes they're they're not recommended, but you're probably not going to lose your
- 1:10:51license everything that's happened so far, Gabby. If you complain to the licensing
- 1:10:58board, I'm guessing that maybe they would do something, but I'm guessing at
- 1:11:03the boast it would be a slap on the wrist or a suggestion to just
- 1:11:08hey, you might want to watch that kind of stuff. Nothing here is
- 1:11:13this egregious act, although for Bob and I give it our standards for ourselves
- 1:11:18and my trainees and supervises, there's a lot of really agree. You know,
- 1:11:24there's a difference between what is agregious to you and me and what would
- 1:11:28be considered to be an offense regarding or an ethical violation that would justify sanctions
- 1:11:35or licenses being revoked, or it can be shitty without being actionable. Right
- 1:11:42going on, It's always been a goal of mine to inspire others to take
- 1:11:45care of their mental health. But I wasn't sure this was ethical, as
- 1:11:48he would be using my name and showing people. I went to see him
- 1:11:54again to put a fine point on it. If you sign off on it
- 1:11:58verbally, is potentially upholdable if he were to document that. Of course,
- 1:12:05the standard is to have you sign an ROI that just has a release of
- 1:12:11information, that just has this line item and says you release the you authorize
- 1:12:17the release of information about your name. When I show people this book,
- 1:12:23I will say that you're a client, but that's it. I'm not going
- 1:12:26to talk about your issues or you know that that would all be laid out
- 1:12:29in the release of information. It's not unethical if you were to approve of
- 1:12:33that. It could be unethical that he asked you, though, is the
- 1:12:38thing. But again, I don't know how many people would consider that to
- 1:12:42be an actionable ethical boundary issue going on. He put me on the spot
- 1:12:47at the beginning of our session, so I said, yes, so right
- 1:12:50there there we are. What's wrong with you as a therapist. But it's
- 1:12:56been making me feel weird and uncomfortable. He even asked to ever, he
- 1:13:00even asked to do this. Ever since I terminated for these reasons and more.
- 1:13:04But even though it has been months, I still feel icky about how
- 1:13:09I felt going to see him. It feels like I need more therapy after
- 1:13:13going to see him, and he hurt me more than he helped. Even
- 1:13:15so, I feel scared to bring it up or report him, as he
- 1:13:19told me so often how much he liked me, and now I feel put
- 1:13:24in an odd space. Any final thoughts on this email bomb? It sounds
- 1:13:28sloppy. I think it's totally legit to withdraw that agreement. It's your privacy,
- 1:13:34it's you have a right to revoke the permission that you gave under really
- 1:13:40shitty circumstance. I hope that you will find a therapist, a good therapist,
- 1:13:48to help with this, because you deserve it. You didn't do anything
- 1:13:53wrong or bad. It's kind of curious that you would feel guilty about somebody
- 1:13:58else's crappy behavior. Though not it's something I can personally relate to something happened
- 1:14:08recently. Oh yeah, oh yeah, now I'm remembering I was feeling guilty
- 1:14:12about somebody else's poor behavior, and that's worth talking about. In learning about
- 1:14:18like this paradoxical response, you have two in my case, it's a paradoxical
- 1:14:25response to anger. Like I was angry with the person who behaved in a
- 1:14:30crappy way, and I was feeling guilty. It turns out that I feel
- 1:14:34guilty for being angry or upset. So I don't know if that's the case
- 1:14:39for Gabby. But there's no reason to feel bad except something's causing you to
- 1:14:45feel bad, right. I think what you're saying, correct me if I'm
- 1:14:48wrong, is that given one's traumas, you might feel completely unjustifiable guilty for
- 1:14:59have a very normal, healthy reaction to something. Yeah, and it's this
- 1:15:06external voice that's being internalized as shaming you for advocating for yourself. Yeah.
- 1:15:12Yeah. So so I hope Gabby will find a good therapist and yeah,
- 1:15:15and give yourself a shot. Yeah, and maybe a male therapist if you
- 1:15:19do find a male therapist, because it you know, it's up to you.
- 1:15:23It's not like you need to find a male therapist, but it could
- 1:15:26be helpful. And I would find an ethical one and maybe even vet them
- 1:15:31and literally just tell them this story that you have with your previous therapist and
- 1:15:38hear what they have to say, and if they respond in kind. With
- 1:15:44Bob, and I in terms of like he answered the phone and session yea,
- 1:15:48and yeah he did. Why was he telling you these things that?
- 1:15:54Did he ask you how you felt about it? You know? Ye?
- 1:15:59Now I will say that there is a possibility that if we had a video
- 1:16:01camera of what happened, aside from the video from answering the phone, but
- 1:16:05even answering the phone, like maybe there's if we heard from the therapist and
- 1:16:10he was like, oh, yeah, me too. I would I'm a
- 1:16:13guest to answer the phone in session. But there was this insurance situation because
- 1:16:18I had a suicidal client that needed to get into inpatient and the insurance was
- 1:16:24calling, and I absolutely need to answer the phone because the patient was literally
- 1:16:29waiting in the wings at the hospital. You know, it doesn't sound like
- 1:16:32that, but it's possible. And all the other incidents that the client,
- 1:16:39Cabby is laying out regarding this solicitous or complimentary, it's a lot of compliments.
- 1:16:46He was, You're a great person, You're beautiful, you're interesting,
- 1:16:50what a great book? You know. It's it's possible that if we had
- 1:16:54a videotape of it, we would say, well, I get where Gabby
- 1:16:57is coming from, and her feelings are a complete fine. But the way
- 1:17:01it looks, it looks like he's not trying to invade or hit on her
- 1:17:09or express his inner attraction or creepiness. It's just that he's just a very
- 1:17:15complimentary person and that's his style of therapy. He just really tries to pump
- 1:17:19people up. You know, because especially when you think about the children's book
- 1:17:25thing, that that whole conversation, because that's not related to the client's attractiveness
- 1:17:30or personality or you know, that sort of thing. It's just it's possible
- 1:17:36that this therapist is doing this to everyone. He's just really nice and kind
- 1:17:44and complimentary and sees sees the good and other people and oh my god,
- 1:17:47you're beautiful, and oh my god, you're you're so smart, and oh
- 1:17:50my god, this book is so great. You know, there's a style
- 1:17:53of therapist that is like that, and it's possible that Gabby just it just
- 1:17:59kind of rubbed her. And that is the risk you take when you do
- 1:18:01that kind of stuff as a therapist. And you should check in with your
- 1:18:04clients if you do that kind of thing, because it is a risk.
- 1:18:09Dual relationship, yeah, and can be creepy and can you scare people,
- 1:18:15really so, but who knows. It's also possible that he literally was attracted
- 1:18:23to her and was grooming her. I don't see any strong indication of that,
- 1:18:28but I've heard grooming stories that start the way that this story did.
- 1:18:32You know? So I don't know. And the reason why I say all
- 1:18:35that is because for you, Gabby, I don't know the situation like you
- 1:18:42do. You were there. But if let's say that he wasn't nefarious,
- 1:18:46and he was just a therapist that is oblivious to how his mission to compliment
- 1:18:56everyone is not necessarily a good thing for all clients. Like, let's just
- 1:19:00say he's just oblivious to that. But he's but he's not creeping. And
- 1:19:05if that's true, which we don't know, and you develop a narrative that
- 1:19:10is nefarious about him, that actually could set you back in terms of your
- 1:19:15schemas and your availability to be open to relationships with everyone, maybe men included,
- 1:19:24who are potentially there to be a corrective experience for you, you know
- 1:19:29what I mean. So, but even saying that out loud, you know,
- 1:19:35unless I know the situation, I don't really know, it's possible that
- 1:19:41he was being a creep and by me saying that I'm just blaming the victim
- 1:19:45kind of a thing. So I just don't know. I would talk about
- 1:19:47it with a therapist at the point. Yeah, yeah, good luck.
- 1:19:53Yeah, and everyone out there please take care of yourself because you deserve it.
- 1:20:00My pa or my fama or