Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Abortion, Maternal Health, and Gender Identity
Transcript
- 0:02[♪♪]
- 0:10GOOD EVENING.
- 0:11WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:11I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:12THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:15JUST TWO DAYS LEFT IN THE 2025
- 0:16KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 0:19SESSION.
- 0:20LAWMAKERS RETURN TO WORK
- 0:21THURSDAY AND FRIDAY, TO CONSIDER
- 0:23OVERRIDING GOVERNOR ANDY
- 0:24BESHEAR’S VETOES.
- 0:25THERE’S ALSO TIME TO PASS BILLS
- 0:27WITHOUT AN OPPORTUNITY TO
- 0:29OVERRIDE THE GOVERNOR’S VETOES.
- 0:31TONIGHT, WE’RE LOOKING AT WHAT
- 0:32LAWMAKERS DID — AND DIDN’T DO —
- 0:34REGARDING GENDER IDENTITY AND
- 0:36ABORTION/MATERNAL HEALTH ISSUES.
- 0:39WE’LL GET TO GENDER IDENTITY IN
- 0:40OUR NEXT HALF HOUR.
- 0:42BUT FIRST, AN EXAMINATION OF
- 0:43HOUSE BILL 90 THAT STARTED OFF
- 0:45AS A MEASURE MAKING WAY FOR
- 0:46FREESTANDING BIRTH CENTERS.
- 0:50IT WAS AMENDED TO ALSO INCLUDE
- 0:52LANGUAGE, THAT SUPPORTERS SAY,
- 0:53CLARIFY WHEN DOCTORS CAN
- 0:56TERMINATE A CRISIS OR COMPLEX
- 0:57PREGNANCY.
- 0:58CRITICS CLAIM THE MEASURE WILL
- 1:00ENDANGER WOMEN EVEN MORE WITH
- 1:02DOCTORS DELAYING INTERVENTION
- 1:03UNTIL NEAR DEATH.
- 1:05FOR PERSPECTIVES ON BOTH SIDES
- 1:06OF THE ISSUE WE HAVE IN OUR
- 1:08STUDIO• ADDIA WUCHNER, EXECUTIVE
- 1:10DIRECTOR OF KENTUCKY RIGHT TO
- 1:11LIFE;
- 1:13AND TAMARRA WIEDER, KENTUCKY
- 1:15STATE DIRECTOR OF PLANNED
- 1:16PARENTHOOD ALLIANCE ADVOCATES.
- 1:19WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU.
- 1:20YOU CAN SEND YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:21COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:23-- AT PUB AFFAIRS KET.
- 1:25SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 1:28K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 1:29OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 1:31O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 1:32OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:41WELCOME.
- 1:42THANK YOU BOTH FOR BEING HERE
- 1:43WITH US ON THIS VERY IMPORTANT
- 1:45TOPIC.
- 1:45I WANT TO GET RIGHT TO MS.
- 1:48WUCHNER FIRST TO ASK YOU THIS
- 1:50MEASURE HAS BEEN DESCRIBED AS
- 1:52PROVIDING CLARITY FOR THE
- 1:54EMERGENCY TREATMENT OF
- 1:55CONDITIONS LIKE MISCARRIAGE,
- 1:58ECTOPIC PREGNANCIES, SEPSIS AND
- 2:01HEMORRHAGE TO PREVENT MATERNAL
- 2:03DEATH OR PERMANENT ORGAN DAMAGE.
- 2:07CLARIFYING SOME OF THE LEGAL
- 2:08AMBIGUITY THERE.
- 2:09SO THAT DOCTORS CAN USE AS YOU
- 2:11WOULD SAY, THEIR BEST HOMELESS
- 2:15JUDGMENT.
- 2:15CONSIDERING THAT KENTUCKY HAS A
- 2:16NEAR TOTAL BAN ON ABORTION THAT
- 2:18WENT INTO EFFECT IN 2022.
- 2:21ARE MEDICAL ORGANIZATIONS ASKING
- 2:22FOR THIS MEASURE?
- 2:24>> YES.
- 2:24ACTUALLY IT WAS BROUGHT TO
- 2:26REPRESENTATIVE 19 MITTS BACK IN
- 2:29THE --
- 2:30KNEE MISS BY Dr. GOLDBERG AND
- 2:33KENTUCKY ACOG.
- 2:37>> Renee: AMERICAN COLLEGE OF
- 2:39OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY.
- 2:41>> YES, IT WAS BROUGHT TO HIM TO
- 2:43LOOK AT WHAT THEY WERE ASKING.
- 2:44AS YOU BEGIN TO LOOK AT IT,
- 2:46EVERYBODY WOULD LIKE TO REPEAL
- 2:49EVERYTHING AND WHAT WE GOT DOWN
- 2:51TO AS WE BEGAN TO ADDRESS IT
- 2:53ONCE THE SESSION STARTED, AND I
- 2:58KNOW Dr. GOL BERG --
- 3:03Dr. GOLDBERG AND LOOKED AT THE
- 3:05MEASURE AND WHAT THEY WERE
- 3:06PROPOSING AND CALLED AND
- 3:08SPEAKING AS A NURSE SPEAKING
- 3:11PRACTITIONER TO PRACTITIONER,
- 3:12NURSE TO DOCTOR, WHAT ARE THE
- 3:14BIGGEST CONCERNS?
- 3:15ARE THEY REAL?
- 3:16AND WHAT DO WE NEED TO CLARIFY?
- 3:19AND WE WENT THROUGH IT
- 3:21STEP-BY-STEP COMING UP WITH THE
- 3:23LANGUAGE.
- 3:23IS IT PERFECT?
- 3:24DID WE IDENTIFY THERE'S LOTS OF
- 3:27MULTIPLE DEFINITIONS IN THE LAW
- 3:29WE COULD CLEAR UP?
- 3:30THIS IS A 30-DAY SESSION AND
- 3:32WHAT WAS MOST IMPORTANT TO DO
- 3:33FOR THE MATERNAL HEALTHCARE FOR
- 3:35THE WOMEN IN THIS COMMONWEALTH
- 3:37AND ALSO GIVE THE PHYSICIANS
- 3:39ASSURANCES THAT WHEN --
- 3:41WHAT IS THE INTENTIONAL ABORTION
- 3:42AND WHAT IS NOT.
- 3:43AND THAT'S WHAT WAS SET FORTH
- 3:46WHEN WE TOOK ON THE ISSUES AS
- 3:48YOU NAMED THEM OUT.
- 3:50>> Renee: I THINK MANY PEOPLE
- 3:51WOULD HAVE THOUGHT THAT THE 2022
- 3:54TRIGGER LAW THAT WENT INTO
- 3:55EFFECT THAT PROVIDED AN
- 3:56EXCEPTION FOR THE LIFE OF THE
- 3:58MOTHER IT WOULD HAVE COVERED ALL
- 3:59OF THOSE CONDITIONS.
- 4:03RIGHT?
- 4:03SO IS THIS MEASURE LEAST
- 4:07RESTRICTION THAN THE CURRENT
- 4:08UNDERSTANDING?
- 4:09>> IT IS NOT LEAST OR LESS OR
- 4:11MORE.
- 4:12IT'S CLARIFICATION.
- 4:13BECAUSE THE TRIGGER LAW FOR THE
- 4:15LIFE OF THE MOTHER BUT AT THE
- 4:16SAME TIME, PHYSICIANSES WERE
- 4:21HESITANT I HEARD ON CASES AND
- 4:22Dr. GOLDBERG AND I SPOKE ABOUT
- 4:24IT THE PHYSICIAN NEEDED TO DO A
- 4:26PROCEDURE AND THE
- 4:29ANESTHESIOLOGIST WAS NOT SURE
- 4:29AND YOU HAVE THE HOSPITAL
- 4:31ATTORNEYS THAT COME INTO PLAY.
- 4:33WHAT WAS IMPORTANT IS TO SAY
- 4:35THIS IS AN INTENTIONAL ABORTION
- 4:37AND THIS IS NOT AND MAKING SURE
- 4:39THERE'S NOT AMBIGUITY IN THE LAW
- 4:40WHEN IT COMES TO SPONTANEOUS
- 4:45MISCARRIAGE, MISCARRIAGE,
- 4:45ECTOPIC PREGNANCIES, MOLAR
- 4:48PREGNANCIES, SEPSIS, HEMORRHAGE
- 4:50SO THE DOCTORS HAVE THAT WEIGHT
- 4:52OFF THEIR SHOULDERS.
- 4:53>> Renee: DOES THIS MAKE THE
- 4:54LANGUAGE MORE CLEAR?
- 4:55>> NO.
- 4:56IT DOES NOT.
- 4:57AND I THINK IF YOU WANTED TO
- 4:59MAKE THE LANGUAGE CLEAR YOU
- 5:00WOULD HAVE USED CLEAR MEDICAL
- 5:03LANGUAGE NOT ANTIABORTION
- 5:06JARGON.
- 5:06>> Renee: WHAT IS THE
- 5:07DESCRIPTION OF THOSE CONDITIONS
- 5:09IS THAT ANTIABORTION JARGON.
- 5:12>> NO, THEY INSERTED LANGUAGE
- 5:18FETAL MATERNAL SEPARATION.
- 5:22WHEN THEY CAN ACT FOR WHEN YOU
- 5:24HAVE PRESENT WITH MISCARRIAGE OR
- 5:26SEPSIS OR HEMORRHAGE.
- 5:28AND WITHOUT, I THINK IT'S REALLY
- 5:30IMPORTANT TO KNOW ONE OF THE
- 5:32MAIN PROBLEMS IS DOES NOT
- 5:33PROVIDE A DEFINITION WHAT IT
- 5:35MEANS TO SEPARATE A PREGNANT
- 5:37WOMAN FROM THE FETUS.
- 5:38THIS IS NOT A MEDICAL TERM IT IS
- 5:40MISLEADING JARGON THAT IS
- 5:42PROMULGATED BY ANTIABORTION
- 5:46ORGANIZATIONS LIKE THE
- 5:47INSTITUTE.
- 5:47AND AGAIN WITH CLEAR --
- 5:49WITHOUT CLEARER LANGUAGE IN THE
- 5:51LAW AND THIS SEPARATION
- 5:53PROCEDURE THAT IS LISTED IN THIS
- 5:56LAW, IT ISN'T BASED IN MEDICINE
- 5:58AND IT'S HARD TO SAY EXACTLY
- 5:59WHAT THE LAW WOULD REQUIRE BUT
- 6:01IT IS VERY TELLING THAT THE LAW
- 6:04REFERS VAGUELY TO AN
- 6:05INTERVENTION RATHER THAN A
- 6:07DILATION AND CARE TAJ OR
- 6:11ABORTION.
- 6:11THE PROCEDURE THAT WOULD BE
- 6:12STANDARD CARE IN AN EMERGENCY
- 6:15CARE FOR PREGNANCIES.
- 6:17FURTHER ACCORDING TO THE
- 6:21NATIONAL UMBRELLA ORGANIZATION,
- 6:22THE TERM FETAL MATERNAL
- 6:24SEPARATION IS USED BY OPPONENTS
- 6:26TO JUSTIFY OR MANDATE PERFORMING
- 6:29MEDICAL PROCEDURES THAT CARRY
- 6:30MORE RISK FOR THE PATIENT SUCH
- 6:34AS CAESARIAN DELIVERIES RATHER
- 6:36THAN ABORTION.
- 6:37WHEN WE ARE TALKING ABOUT THE
- 6:40ECTOPIC PREGNANCIES AND MOLAR
- 6:42PREGNANCIES IF THEY WANTED TO
- 6:43MAKE IT CLEAR YOU COULD HAVE
- 6:44MADE IT CLEAR BUT YOU DIDN'T.
- 6:48AND WE HAD 85 DOCTORS AND
- 6:49MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS LAST WEEK
- 6:51SAY THIS WAS NOT CLEAR.
- 6:53>> MAY I SAY SOMETHING?
- 6:55IN WORKING WITH Dr. GOLDBERG,
- 6:58WE WERE NOT GOING TO BE
- 7:00PRESCRIPTIVE IN WHAT TYPE OF
- 7:01PROCEDURE TO DO FOR WHAT.
- 7:03YOU KNOW, THERE ARE IT DOES SAY
- 7:07SPONTANEOUS ABORTION.
- 7:07IT CLEARS IT UP WHAT IS AN
- 7:10INTENTIONAL ABORTION AND WHAT IS
- 7:11NOT.
- 7:12NOW, HOW THEY WANT TO ADDRESS A
- 7:15SPONTANEOUS ABORTION A
- 7:17THREATENING ABORTION, SEPSIS,
- 7:18THAT IS HOW THE PHYSICIAN IS
- 7:20GOING TO ADDRESS IT.
- 7:21AND WHAT THAT PARTICULAR WOMAN
- 7:23NEEDS.
- 7:24NOT BE PRESCRIPTIVE IN DOING A
- 7:27DNC OR PRESCRIBING WHAT THE
- 7:29PROCEDURE WOULD BE BECAUSE IT'S
- 7:30NOT NECESSARY.
- 7:31IT WAS WHAT WERE THE CONDITIONS
- 7:33THAT WOULD ALLOW THEM TO ACT
- 7:35WITHOUT HAVING IT HELD OVER
- 7:37THEIR HEADS THAT THIS WAS AN
- 7:40ILLEGAL ABORTION IN KENTUCKY.
- 7:41AND THAT WAS THE INTENT OF THE
- 7:43LAW AND EXACTLY WHAT WE DID.
- 7:44>> YOU ARE BEING PRESCRIPTIVE ON
- 7:47PAGE 48 LINE 1 YOU DEFINE AN
- 7:50ABORTION EXCLUDING SEPARATION
- 7:51BUT IT REDEFINES MEDICAL
- 7:55PROCEDURES AND AT WORST IT WOULD
- 7:57BE READ AS PROHIBITING A DNC IN
- 8:00THE LIFE-SAVING CASES YOU SET
- 8:01OUT EVEN IF A DNC IS A STANDARD
- 8:04OF CARE.
- 8:05EITHER WAY, THE VAGUENESS OF
- 8:08THIS BILL AND IS NOT IN LINE
- 8:09WITH MEDICAL STANDARDS WILL
- 8:11CREATE CONFUSION AND LEAD TO
- 8:13MORE PROVIDERS TO RELY ON
- 8:16CAESARIANS.
- 8:17>> Renee: DO YOU AGREE OR
- 8:18DISAGREE THERE NEEDS TO BE
- 8:19CLARIFICATION OF THE LAW IN
- 8:21THESE CIRCUMSTANCES OF A MEDICAL
- 8:23CRISIS PREGNANCY?
- 8:24OR COMPLEX PREGNANCY THAT
- 8:26REQUIRES THESE TYPES OF
- 8:27INTERVENTIONS DO YOU AGREE THAT
- 8:30IS NEEDED?
- 8:30>> WHAT WE HEARD FROM DOCTORS
- 8:31ACROSS THE STATE IS THAT THE
- 8:33LAWS AND THE FELONIES PUT IN
- 8:35PLACE LEAVE LITTLE ROOM FOR THEM
- 8:37TO OPERATE WITHOUT THEIR
- 8:39HOSPITAL ATTORNEYS AND
- 8:42ADMINISTRATORS.
- 8:42BUT WHAT IS REALLY INTERESTING
- 8:44IS THAT IN THE COMMITTEE, THE
- 8:45FIRST COMMITTEE THAT WE HEARD
- 8:47IN, WHERE THIS BILL WAS
- 8:49PRESENTED THEY HAD NOT TALKED TO
- 8:50ANY HOSPITAL ATTORNEYS OR
- 8:52HOSPITAL ADMINISTRATORS.
- 8:53THEY HAD NOT BROUGHT IN ANY OF
- 8:56THE MEDICAL EXPERTS THAT
- 8:58ACTUALLY WORK IN THIS FIELD AND
- 8:59ARE FACED WITH THIS ON A DAILY
- 9:02BASIS.
- 9:02AND I UNDERSTAND THAT THEY DID
- 9:04BRING IN Dr. GOLDBERG BUT WHEN
- 9:06WE TALKED TO MEMBERS OF ACOG
- 9:09THEY WERE NOT AWARE OF THIS
- 9:11LEGISLATION MOVING FORWARD.
- 9:13AND NATIONAL A GOING IS NOT
- 9:17SUPPORTIVE OF MOST OF WHAT IS IN
- 9:18THIS LEGISLATION AND THAT IS
- 9:20VERY IMPORTANT.
- 9:20>> WHAT I THINK IS IMPORTANT TO
- 9:22SAY, TOO, THE LIST OF THINGS
- 9:24THAT ACOG WOULD HAVE WANTED
- 9:26WOULD HAVE BEEN TO REVERSE SOME
- 9:28OF THE LAWS INTENTIONAL ABORTION
- 9:30AND THAT IS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
- 9:32THE REPRESENTATIVE SAID THAT ON
- 9:33THE FLOOR.
- 9:34KENTUCKY IS A PRO-LIFE STATE WE
- 9:36ARE NOT GOING TO ROLLBACK THOSE
- 9:39PROCEDURES BUT WE WANTED TO DO
- 9:40AND I THINK THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 9:42THOUGHTFULLY WORKING WITH THE
- 9:43MEDICAL COMMUNITY, WORKING WITH
- 9:46ACOG AT THE TABLE, I WAS THERE
- 9:49THAT MORNING WITH ACOG Dr.
- 9:51GOLDBERG WAS ON SCREEN AND
- 9:53MEMBERS OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 9:54WORKING ON LANGUAGE THAT WAS TO
- 9:57BRING CLARIFICATION WHICH SEEMED
- 9:58TO BE IMPORTANT TO THE MEDICAL
- 10:01COMMUNITY AND ACTUALLY WAS TAKEN
- 10:04TO THE MINORITY PARTY THE NEXT
- 10:06DAY.
- 10:06THIS WAS EARLY IN MID-FEBRUARY
- 10:08TO LOOK AT.
- 10:10AND I THINK I MENTIONED IT TO
- 10:13YOU WHEN I SAW IN THE HALL
- 10:17FEBRUARY 18TH WE CAN TAKE AWARE
- 10:19THE FEAR AND MISINFORMATION AND
- 10:20THE CONCERNS THAT ARE THERE IN
- 10:21THE MEDICAL COMMUNITY.
- 10:22>> WELL, INDEED, Dr. JEFFREY
- 10:25GOLDBERG SAID WHEN HE TESTIFIED
- 10:27RECENTLY DURING A COMMITTEE
- 10:28HEARING THAT THE LANGUAGE ISN'T
- 10:30PERFECT AND IT STILL NEEDS MORE
- 10:32WORK.
- 10:33THE COMMON SENSE QUESTION MAYBE
- 10:35WHY RUSH IT?
- 10:36WHY NOT GET THE LANGUAGE RIGHT
- 10:37THE FIRST TIME?
- 10:38>> WELL, BECAUSE WE HAVE A
- 10:4130-DAY SESSION AND WE SEE MEDIA
- 10:44WOMEN ARE GOING TO DIE.
- 10:46MOST IMPORTANT THING WAS TO MAKE
- 10:47SURE TO GIVE CLARITY TO THOSE
- 10:49MEDICAL CONDITIONS.
- 10:51THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF
- 10:54SPONTANEOUS ABORTIONS WE WOULD
- 10:54CALL A MISCARRIAGE, INTENTIONAL
- 10:58MISCARRIAGE TO SPELL THOSE OUT.
- 11:00SEPSIS, NO PATIENT WHEN SOMEONE
- 11:02SAID TO ME, THEY HAD A DOCTOR
- 11:03THAT WAS SO CONCERNED HE WAS
- 11:05WAITING FOR HIS PATIENT TO SPIKE
- 11:07A TEMPERATURE WHEN SHE WAS
- 11:09THREATENING A MISCARRIAGE THAT
- 11:10SHOULD NEVER HAPPEN AND WE DON'T
- 11:12WANT THAT TO HAPPEN FOR ANY
- 11:13WOMEN IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF
- 11:14KENTUCKY.
- 11:15THERE WAS A LOT OF DISCUSSION ON
- 11:16WHAT WAS THE MOST IMPORTANT TO
- 11:18ADDRESS AT THIS TIME?
- 11:21>> ADDIA, THESE PROBLEMS EXISTED
- 11:22WE CAME TO YOU BACK IN 2022 AND
- 11:25WE SAID THE DOCTORS TOLD YOU
- 11:27THAT THE OMNIBUS ANTIABORTION
- 11:30BILL, THE TRIGGER BANS ALL THE
- 11:32BANS WERE GOING TO CAUSE THESE
- 11:34PROBLEMS.
- 11:35YOU DIDN'T LISTEN TO US THEN.
- 11:37YOU DIDN'T BRING US INTO THOSE
- 11:38CONVERSATIONS.
- 11:39YOU FLAT OUT IGNORED THE SCIENCE
- 11:41AND ALL OF THE STATISTICS.
- 11:43THE SAME DOCTORS ARE TELLING YOU
- 11:45NOW THAT THIS ISN'T GOING TO
- 11:47WORK.
- 11:47AND THE LEGAL CHANGES HOW THEY
- 11:49CAN DEFEND THEMSELVES IN COURT
- 11:50WILL MAKE IT HARDER.
- 11:53AND YOU ARE NOT MAKING --
- 11:55>> ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT
- 11:57THINGS WAS TO MAKE SURE
- 11:59REASONABLE MEDICAL WAS INCLUDED
- 12:00AND THAT MAKES IT OBJECTIVE AND
- 12:02THAT IS EXACTLY.
- 12:03>> IT'S WHAT MAKES IT WORSE FOR
- 12:05THEM.
- 12:05WHEN WE LOOK TO OTHER STATES
- 12:06THAT HAVE IT LET'S TAKE TEXAS
- 12:08FOR EXAMPLE.
- 12:09TEXAS USES THAT SAME PRACTICE
- 12:11AND IT HAS BEEN WHAT STOPPED
- 12:13THEM FROM BEING ABLE TO PROVIDE
- 12:15ABORTION CARE IN
- 12:18LIFE-THREATENING, LIFE-SAVING
- 12:19CASES LET'S TAKE COX FOR
- 12:21EXAMPLE.
- 12:22A JUDGE --
- 12:23>> DEFINE IT IN THE LAW.
- 12:25WE DEFINED REASONABLE MEDICAL IN
- 12:27THIS PIECE OF LAW RIGHT NOW.
- 12:28BECAUSE WE WANTED TO MAKE SURE
- 12:30IT WAS CLEAR.
- 12:31>> Renee: HOW IS IT DEFINED?
- 12:33>> BECAUSE REASONABLE MEDICAL
- 12:37INTERVENTION INDUCE.
- 12:38LET ME GIVE YOU THE DEFINITION.
- 12:39>> WE ARE USING THE SAME
- 12:42TERMINOLOGY, THE SAME MEDICAL
- 12:43TERMINOLOGY.
- 12:44>> REASONABLE MEDICAL JUDGMENT
- 12:45THE RANGE OF CONCLUSIONS ARE
- 12:47MEDICAL RECOMMENDATIONS THAT A
- 12:48LICENSED MEDICAL PRACTITIONER
- 12:49WITH SIMILAR SUFFICIENT TRAINING
- 12:51AND EXPERIENCE MAY COMMUNICATE
- 12:52TO THE PATIENT UPON CURRENT
- 12:54AVAILABLE MEDICAL EVIDENCE.
- 12:55THIS IS OBJECTIVE AND NO LONGER
- 12:58SUBJECTIVE AND THAT WAS THE
- 12:59PROBLEM BEFORE IN PAST LAW.
- 13:00THIS IS STANDARD IN FOR THE LAW.
- 13:03WE DID TALK TO ATTORNEYS.
- 13:05>> WE TALKED TO ATTORNEYS, TOO,
- 13:07WHO WORK ON THE CASES.
- 13:08THESE ARE TAKING THE ABILITY OF
- 13:10DOCTORS TO USE GOOD FAITH
- 13:11JUDGMENT IN MOMENTS OF EMERGENCY
- 13:13AND GIVING IT OVER TO THE JUDGES
- 13:15TO DECIDE WHETHER OR NOT THEY
- 13:17ACTED IN THE APPROPRIATE
- 13:19REASONABLE.
- 13:19>> TOOK AWAY.
- 13:20>> I KNOW.
- 13:21I KNOW.
- 13:21>> THIS WOULD BE A REASONABLE
- 13:24MEDICAL OBJECTIVE NOT SUBJECTIVE
- 13:26CONCLUSION.
- 13:27>> THEY ARE TAKING AWAY --
- 13:29>> BASED ON MEDICAL KNOWLEDGE OF
- 13:32THE CASE AS IT'S PRESENTED.
- 13:34AND IN TORT LAW THAT WAS VERY
- 13:37IMPORTANT FROM THE ATTORNEYS WE
- 13:38WERE WORKING WITH.
- 13:39>> THE ATTORNEYS SAID IT'S GOING
- 13:41TO TAKE AWAY THE POWERS OF
- 13:43PROVIDERS AND PUT IT IN THE
- 13:45HANDS OF JUDGES.
- 13:46AND WE'VE SEEN IT PLAY ACROSS
- 13:48THE COUNTRY AND SPECIFICALLY IN
- 13:49TEXAS WHERE PROVIDERS ARE NOT
- 13:51ABLE TO DEFEND THEIR CHOICES FOR
- 13:54ABORTION CARE OR FIGHT FOR
- 13:56PATIENTS IN THE COURTS.
- 13:57LIKE WITH KATE COX.
- 13:59>> Renee: EXPLAIN TO US WHO KATE
- 14:02COX IS?
- 14:03>> KATE COX WAS SEEKING AN
- 14:05ABORTION FOR A LIFE-THREATENING
- 14:06NEED.
- 14:08HER DOCTOR, Dr. CARSON
- 14:09APPEALED TO THE COURTS THE
- 14:11SUPREME COURT DENIED HER THE
- 14:13ABILITY.
- 14:13>> IN WHAT STATE?
- 14:15>> IN TEXAS.
- 14:16THE TEXAS ABORTION BAN FOR
- 14:19INSTANCE, PROVIDES A SO-CALLED
- 14:20EXCEPTION FOR INSTANCES WHERE A
- 14:22PREGNANT PERSON IS EXPERIENCING
- 14:24A LIFE-THREATENING PHYSICAL
- 14:27CONDITION AGGRAVATED OR CAUSED
- 14:28ARISING FROM PREGNANCY.
- 14:30THE REASONABLE MEDICAL JUDGMENT
- 14:31REFERS TO A SPECIFIC STANDARD OF
- 14:33LAW THAT RELIES ON A COMMON
- 14:35PRACTICE IN A STATE OR REGION.
- 14:37CURRENT KENTUCKY LAW IS AMENDED
- 14:40TO LOOK TO A PROVIDER'S GOOD
- 14:43FAITH CLINICAL JUDGMENT IN
- 14:44DETERMINING WHETHER THAN
- 14:45ABORTION IS NECESSARY.
- 14:45THE CHANGE IN THE STATUTE WOULD
- 14:48REMOVE THE DEFERENCE AND LEAVE
- 14:49THE ASSESSMENT OF REASONABLENESS
- 14:51IN THE HANDS OF AA COURT
- 14:55CREATING INCENTIVES FOR A
- 14:56HOSPITAL TO BE CAUTIOUS OR
- 14:58CONSERVATIVE.
- 14:58FOR THE COX CASE SPECIFICALLY,
- 15:01IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THEY
- 15:05DENIED HER THE ABORTION.
- 15:07BECAUSE THEY DID NOT BELIEVE
- 15:09THAT HER DOCTORS REASONABLE
- 15:11JUDGMENT MET THE SUFFICIENT
- 15:13STANDARDS EVEN THOUGH SHE NEEDED
- 15:15THE ABORTION.
- 15:16>> Renee: WHAT SHOULD THE
- 15:17LANGUAGE BE?
- 15:17>> THEY NEED TO LEAVE IT IN THE
- 15:19GOOD FAITH WHICH GIVES MORE
- 15:21POWER TO THE PROVIDER TO DEFEND
- 15:22THEIR NEEDS.
- 15:23AND WE'VE SEEN THAT PLAY OUT.
- 15:25IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE'RE
- 15:27MIRRORING THE LANGUAGE IN TEXAS
- 15:28WITH THE BILL PUT OUT WITH THE
- 15:31LIFE-THREATENING AND THE
- 15:32LIFE-SAVING FOR MISCARRIAGES AND
- 15:34SEPSIS AND HEMORRHAGE, WE ARE
- 15:37ADDING THIS LANGUAGE IN THAT IS
- 15:38GOING TO TIE THE HANDS OF
- 15:40PROVIDERS JUST AS IT HAS IN
- 15:42TEXAS.
- 15:43BUT JUST LAST WEEK, A REPUBLICAN
- 15:45FILED LEGISLATION TO REMOVE THAT
- 15:48LANGUAGE, BECAUSE IT HAS TIED
- 15:49THE HANDS OF PROVIDERS IN TEXAS
- 15:53VMENT.
- 15:54>> WE KEEP TALKING ABOUT TEXAS
- 15:56IT'S KENTUCKY.
- 15:56>> IT IS RELEVANT BECAUSE IT IS
- 15:59CREATED CONFUSION.
- 16:00>> THE FISHIONS --
- 16:05PHYSICIANS CAME.
- 16:06>> Dr. GOLDBERG IS ONE
- 16:07PHYSICIAN.
- 16:08>> REFLECTING ON HIS EXPERIENCE
- 16:10AS POLICY FOR KENTUCKY ACOG.
- 16:13>> HE IS A PHYSICIAN.
- 16:15>> AND WHAT THEY NEEDED TO
- 16:16ADDRESS THESE ISSUES TO EASE
- 16:18SOME OF THE CONFUSION AND
- 16:22CONCERNS THAT THE PHYSICIAN
- 16:23COMMUNITY HAD.
- 16:24WE HAVE NOT GOT THEM ALL CLEARED
- 16:27UP BUT THESE WERE IMPORTANT.
- 16:29>> Renee: THE KENTUCKY CHAPTER
- 16:30HAS DIFFERENT CONCERNS PERHAPS
- 16:31THAN THE NATIONAL ACOG
- 16:33ASSOCIATION, RIGHT?
- 16:34SINCE THE NATIONAL GROUP DOES
- 16:35NOT ENDORSE THIS LEGISLATION?
- 16:38>> PROBABLY CORRECT.
- 16:39AND NATIONALLY THEY DON'T ALWAYS
- 16:41ENDORSE ALL THE RESTRICTIONS WE
- 16:43HAVE CURRENTLY ON ABORTION HERE
- 16:45IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY.
- 16:46BUT THAT'S NOT --
- 16:48THIS WASN'T ABOUT ABORTION LAW
- 16:51IT WAS ABOUT CLARIFICATION,
- 16:52MATERNAL HEALTH.
- 16:53IT BEGAN WITH THE PREGNANCY THE
- 16:56FREE STANDING PREGNANCY CENTERS.
- 16:59>> BUT IT IS ABOUT ABORTION IN
- 17:01THE END.
- 17:02>> ONE SECTION ON CLARIFICATION
- 17:05ON MEDICAL MATERNAL HEALTH AND
- 17:06THE NEXT SECTION ON PERRY NATAL
- 17:11PALLIATIVE CARE WHICH IS
- 17:12IMPORTANT WHEN A WOMAN IS
- 17:14EXPERIENCING A PREGNANCY FACING
- 17:16A FETAL ANOMALY OR THE CHILD MAY
- 17:21DIE SHORTLY BEFORE OR AFTER
- 17:23THEIR TERM.
- 17:24WE HAVE PROVIDERS IN THE STATE
- 17:25AND WE WANTED ALL WOMEN TO HAVE
- 17:28THE OPPORTUNITY.
- 17:29>> Renee: WHY NOT BILL STAND ON
- 17:30ITS OWN.
- 17:31WHY ATTACH TO GO TO THE
- 17:34PREFANNEDDING BIRTH CENTERS
- 17:35MEASURE?
- 17:35>> RUNNING OUT OF TIME.
- 17:36WE HAD PRESENTED IT EARLY ON.
- 17:41AND TO THE MINORITY PARTY.
- 17:45AND TO WE TALKED ABOUT IT IN THE
- 17:47HALL AND THEY RESISTED THE BILL.
- 17:48WE HAD TO FIND ANOTHER WAY TO
- 17:50GET IT THROUGH.
- 17:51WE WERE RUNNING OUT OF TIME.
- 17:53AND BY -- WE DID PUT THE
- 17:55LANGUAGE ON 414 A PALLIATIVE
- 18:02CARE WHEN IT HIT THE FLOOR THEY
- 18:03LOADED IT UP WITH MORE
- 18:05AMENDMENTS TO IT.
- 18:05WE NEEDED THIS TO GO THROUGH
- 18:08BECAUSE IT WAS IMPORTANT FOR THE
- 18:09MATERNAL HEALTH OF THE WOMEN OF
- 18:11THIS COMMONWEALTH.
- 18:12>> Renee: HOW MANY WOMEN HAS
- 18:13THIS IMPACTED?
- 18:14NUMBERS YOU CAN PUT TO THIS?
- 18:15>> I DON'T HAVE NUMBERS.
- 18:17BUT WE DO KNOW THAT THIS IMPACTS
- 18:20KENTUCKIANS PEOPLE ARE GETTING
- 18:23PREGNANT THEY HAVE COMPLICATIONS
- 18:26ARE A FACT OF LIFE WHEN YOU ARE
- 18:28PREGNANT.
- 18:28AND I THINK THAT THE CHALLENGES
- 18:31AND UNCERTAINTIES IS PART OF
- 18:32WHAT THIS BILL IS DESIGNED TO
- 18:34CREATE.
- 18:35THE GOAL OF THIS LEGISLATION IS
- 18:36TO DIVIDE THE PUBLIC THAT
- 18:38SUPPORTS ACCESS TO REPRODUCTIVE
- 18:39HEALTHCARE AND DEEM SOME PEOPLE
- 18:41AND SOME CONDITIONS MORE
- 18:43DESERVING OF TREATMENT.
- 18:44AND I THINK THAT IS SOMETHING WE
- 18:46REALLY HAVE TO COMBAT.
- 18:48>> Renee: THIS QUESTION OR
- 18:48COMMENT FROM A VIEWER AND I WILL
- 18:50READ IT AS PRESENTED.
- 18:52WHY CAN'T ANYONE AT PLANNED
- 18:54PARENTHOOD THE WORLD'S LARGEST
- 18:56PROVIDER OF INTENTIONAL CHILD
- 18:59ELIMINATIONS CALL THE BABY A
- 19:02BABY.
- 19:03FETUS IS IN LATIN IS CHILD.
- 19:07>> THAT IS AN UNFAIR QUESTION.
- 19:11PEOPLE COME TO PLANNED
- 19:12PARENTHOOD FOR A VARIETY OF
- 19:14HEALTH SERVICES IN KENTUCKY WE
- 19:16PROVIDE LIFE-SAVING LIFE
- 19:18AFFIRMING CARE FOR A VARIETY OF
- 19:21DIFFERENT THINGS.
- 19:22WE PROVIDE GENDER AFFIRMING
- 19:23HEALTHCARE.
- 19:24WE PROVIDE STI TREATMENT, BIRTH
- 19:28CONTROL AND SEXUAL HEALTH
- 19:30SCREENINGS.
- 19:30I THINK THAT IS AN UNFAIR
- 19:32QUESTION.
- 19:33WE ARE AN ADVOCATE FOR ABORTION
- 19:35CARE BECAUSE THAT IS HEALTH
- 19:36SAVING AND LIFE AFFIRMING.
- 19:39>> Renee: THIS QUESTION TO YOU
- 19:40MS. WUCHNER.
- 19:43QUOTE, WHY DON'T THE RIGHT TO
- 19:45LIFERS ADOPT THE KIDS THAT WOMEN
- 19:46ARE FORCED TO CARRY WITHOUT
- 19:48STATE OR FEDERAL ASSISTANCE WHY
- 19:50ARE THE LIVES OF WOMEN NOT
- 19:52IMPORTANT TO THEM?
- 19:52>> OF COURSE THE FACT WE'RE HERE
- 19:55TODAY WITH THE MATERNAL HEALTH
- 19:56BILL MEANS THE LIVES OF WOMEN
- 19:58ARE IMPORTANT.
- 19:59AS A NURSE THEY ARE EXTREMELY
- 20:01IMPORTANT.
- 20:02AGAIN WE PROMOTE IT FROM DAY ONE
- 20:05ADOPTION NOT JUST AN OPTION BUT
- 20:08TO HELP PARENTS WITH ADOPTION.
- 20:11THAT HAS NEVER BEEN SOMETHING
- 20:14THAT PRO-LIFERS, I CAN TELL YOU
- 20:16MULTIPLE FAMILIES RIGHT HERE IN
- 20:18THE COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY WHO
- 20:19NOT ONLY HAVE ADOPTED ONE OR TWO
- 20:21BUT THREE OR FOUR CHILDREN.
- 20:24AND SO CAN WE DO MORE FOR
- 20:26ADOPTION?
- 20:26DO WE WANT TO WORK ON ADOPTION?
- 20:30ADOPTION IS EXPENSIVE WE KNOW
- 20:32THAT.
- 20:32BUT WE HAVE WORKED ON THOSE
- 20:34ISSUES AND WORKED ON IT AS A
- 20:36LEGISLATOR.
- 20:37SO I KIND OF OBJECT TO THAT A
- 20:39LITTLE BIT.
- 20:40IT'S LIKE ALWAYS THROWN OUT THAT
- 20:42WE DON'T CARE ABOUT THE CHILDREN
- 20:43THAT ARE BORN BUT WE DO.
- 20:45PROVIDING SCHOLARSHIPS FOR MOMS
- 20:47WHETHER THEY KEEP THEIR CHILD OR
- 20:49NOT OR PLACE THAT BABY FOR
- 20:51ADOPTION OR NOT HELPING FOR
- 20:53SCHOLARSHIPS SO NO MOTHER HAS TO
- 20:56CHOOSE BETWEEN HER CHILD AND
- 20:59EDUCATION.
- 21:00WHEN YOU ARE SAYING RIGHT TO
- 21:02LIFERS MAKING SURE THAT WOMEN
- 21:04HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO CONTINUE
- 21:06THEIR EDUCATION.
- 21:07AS AN ORGANIZATION, I'M
- 21:08PRESENTING THAT POINT.
- 21:09>> I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THAT
- 21:11SOMETIMES WE ARE ALWAYS PUT ON
- 21:13OPPOSITE ENDS AND QUESTIONS LIKE
- 21:15THAT TAKE AWAY OUR HUMANITY AT
- 21:16TIMES.
- 21:17>> Renee: AND THOSE ARE VIEWER
- 21:18QUESTIONS.
- 21:19I WANTED TO MAKE THAT CLEAR.
- 21:21>> A LOT OF TIMES WE TALK ABOUT
- 21:23THINGS WE COULD AGREE ON IN
- 21:25TRYING TO ADDRESS WOMEN'S
- 21:26HEALTH.
- 21:27>> Renee: CAN YOU AGREE IN THE
- 21:28FIVE MINUTES WE HAVE REMAINING?
- 21:30A CONVERSATION THAT HAS BEEN HAD
- 21:32IN KENTUCKY FOR SOMETIME WITHOUT
- 21:33MUCH TRACTION ARE EXEMPTIONS FOR
- 21:36RAPE AND INCEST.
- 21:37MS. WIEDER WE KNOW WHERE SHE
- 21:39STANDS.
- 21:40DO YOU SUPPORT SUCH EXEMPTIONS
- 21:42AND WOULD YOU CONSIDER SUCH
- 21:45LEGISLATION AND ADVOCATING FOR
- 21:46IT IN THE LEGISLATIVE SESSION?
- 21:48>> FROM KENTUCKY RIGHT TO LIFE
- 21:51WE DON'T LOOK MOVING BACKWARDS
- 21:53FROM THE LAWS WE HAVE.
- 21:55>> Renee: WHAT IS THE OPPOSITION
- 21:57TO --
- 21:57>> BECAUSE IT IS A LIFE AND
- 21:59EVERY LIFE HAS DIGNITY EVEN IF
- 22:01YOU WERE AT OUR RALLY WHEN I
- 22:03LOOK AT CRYSTAL WHEN I ASKED
- 22:06CRYSTAL YOUR MOTHER WAS RAPED AT
- 22:08KNIFEPOINT YOUR MOTHER WAS RAPED
- 22:10AT KNIFEPOINT IN A HOTEL BY THE
- 22:12BAND BY A MUSICIAN THAT IS HER
- 22:15FATHER.
- 22:15AND I SAID, DID YOU EVER ASK HER
- 22:19WHY AND SHE SAID I DID.
- 22:20AND MY MOTHER LOOKED AT ME AND
- 22:23SAID YOU WERE INNOCENT.
- 22:25WHEN WE POLLED INDIVIDUALS AT
- 22:28OUR STATE FAIR MUTUAL TELL
- 22:30SETTINGS, DO YOU BELIEVE THAT A
- 22:33CHILD CAN SEE A LOVING EMBRACE
- 22:36OF PARENTS OR AN ACT OF SEXUAL
- 22:40VIOLENCE ANY LESS DIGNITY AND
- 22:42THEY SAID NO.
- 22:42THEY ARE EQUAL IN DIGNITY.
- 22:43IT IS A TOUGH ISSUE BUT WE DO
- 22:46SUPPORT IS THE PROSECUTION OF
- 22:48ANYONE WHO HARMS A CHILD OR A
- 22:51WOMAN SEXUAL ASSAULT TO THE MOST
- 22:54DEGREE.
- 22:55IF RAPE IS OCCURRING IN THE
- 22:57COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY, WHY
- 22:58AREN'T WE SEEING MULTIPLE
- 23:00PROSECUTIONS.
- 23:02>> Renee: MS. WIEDER?
- 23:03>> WE KNOW THERE HAVE BEEN 3,000
- 23:06RAPE RELATED PREGNANCIES SINCE
- 23:08ROE.
- 23:09OUR ABORTION BAN IS EXTREME IN
- 23:10KENTUCKY AND LOOKING LIKE IT'S
- 23:12GOING TO GET HARDER FOR PEOPLE
- 23:14TO ACCESS EMERGENCY CARE WHEN
- 23:15THEY NEED IT.
- 23:17OUR LANDSCAPE NEEDS TO CHANGE.
- 23:18AND I THINK THAT WE NEED A
- 23:22PATHWAY FORWARD FOR PEOPLE TO
- 23:23GET ACCESS TO ABORTION CARE.
- 23:25AND ESPECIALLY FOR ANYBODY IN AN
- 23:28EMERGENCY SITUATION, THOSE WITH
- 23:30RAPE AND INCEST.
- 23:32AND THOSE WHO NEED ACCESS TO
- 23:36CARE REGARDLESS OF THEIR REASON.
- 23:38I THINK WE NEED TO BROADEN OUR
- 23:40PATHWAYS FORWARD TO ABORTION
- 23:42CARE.
- 23:42I DEFINITELY HAVE --
- 23:45I'D LIKE TO SEE ABORTION CARE
- 23:50BROADENED.
- 23:50>> Renee: BROADENED TO HOW WIDE?
- 23:51>> YOU KNOW, I'M ON THE OPPOSITE
- 23:54END OF ADDIA.
- 23:56>> RAPE AND INCEST, THEIR
- 23:58STATEMENT IS ALWAYS THAT IS JUST
- 23:59THE BEGINNING.
- 24:00>> LOOK, ABORTION CARE IS
- 24:02HEALTHCARE AND I'M NOT GOING TO
- 24:05BE APOLOGETIC ON THAT.
- 24:07>> Renee: ANY LIMITATIONS ON
- 24:08THAT ACCESS?
- 24:09>> THAT IS BETWEEN THE DOCTOR
- 24:10AND THE PATIENT DEPENDING ON THE
- 24:12NEED OF CARE AND IF IT'S
- 24:13EMERGENCY HEALTHCARE THAT IS
- 24:14SOMETHING BETWEEN THE DOCTOR AND
- 24:15THE PATIENT.
- 24:16BUT WHAT I THINK IS MORE
- 24:19SUBSTANTIVE TO THIS BILL IS THAT
- 24:21THERE ARE 85 DOCTORS OUT THERE
- 24:22WHO SAY THIS IS NOT CREATE A
- 24:25PATHWAY TO ANY FORM OF
- 24:26CLARIFICATION AND WE NEED TO BE
- 24:29HAVING REAL TANGIBLE
- 24:31CONVERSATIONS ON HOW WE FIX OUR
- 24:34DRACONIAN BAN THAT IS GOING TO
- 24:35TAKE US INTO A FUTURE WHERE
- 24:37WE'RE GOING TO BE BACK IN TWO
- 24:39YEARS, ADDIA, TALKING ABOUT HOW
- 24:41YOU DIDN'T LISTEN TO THE DOCTORS
- 24:43AGAIN.
- 24:44>> Renee: WOULD YOU BE OPEN TO
- 24:46LANGUAGE TWEAKING IN THE NEXT
- 24:47SESSION THAT YOU TWO COULD COME
- 24:50TOGETHER AND BE COMPROMISE
- 24:52LANGUAGE TO HOUSE BILL 90.
- 24:53>> I WOULDN'T BE ADDRESSING IT
- 24:56WITH PLANNED PATTERN HOOD BUT
- 24:58CONVERSATIONS WITH PHYSICIANS WE
- 25:00LOOKED AT THE LAW.
- 25:01THERE WERE AREAS WE SAID WE NEED
- 25:02TO CLEAN THIS UP.
- 25:04SO WE ARE --
- 25:05WE'VE HAD THAT OPEN DISCUSSION
- 25:07ABOUT COMING BACK TOGETHER
- 25:08SITTING AT THE TABLE AND WHAT DO
- 25:10WE NEED TO DO.
- 25:13WHERE --
- 25:13AMBIGUITY IN THE LAW CAUSES
- 25:15CONFUSION AND WE WERE TRYING TO
- 25:16REMOVE AS MUCH AS WE COULD AS A
- 25:18START AND THAT WAS IMPORTANT IN
- 25:20THE 30-DAY SESSION FOR THE
- 25:22MATERNAL HEALTHCARE FOR THE
- 25:23WOMEN IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF
- 25:25KENTUCKY.
- 25:25NEXT STEP IS ANOTHER
- 25:26CONVERSATION.
- 25:27>> THAT IS WHAT CONFUSES ME.
- 25:29BECAUSE IF THIS WAS SUCH AN
- 25:31IMPORTANT BILL IT'S BEEN HURTING
- 25:32KENTUCKIANS FOR THREE YEARS, AND
- 25:34THE LANGUAGE YOU USED IS NOT
- 25:36BASED IN SCIENCE IT IS NOT
- 25:38GROUNDED IN MEDICINE AND WHILE I
- 25:40APPRECIATE THAT Dr. GOLDBERG
- 25:41WAS THERE YOU DID NOT BRING THE
- 25:43DOCTORS FACING THIS CRISIS DAY
- 25:45IN AND DAY OUT.
- 25:45AND USING LANGUAGE THAT IS BASED
- 25:49FROM MEDICINE AND SUPPORTS THEIR
- 25:51WORK.
- 25:52WE DESERVE BETTER.
- 25:55KENTUCKIANS DESERVE BETTER.
- 25:56MY AREA IS THIS.
- 25:57AND SO WE DESERVE BETTER
- 26:00KENTUCKIANS DESERVE RESPECT NOT
- 26:02MORE BILLS THAT ARE PASSED
- 26:03THROUGH IN 11TH HOUR
- 26:07SHENANIGANS.
- 26:07>> Renee: WE'LL LEAVE IT THERE,
- 26:08LADIES I APPRECIATE YOU BOTH
- 26:10COMING TO TALK THIS THROUGH.
- 26:12AND IMAGINE THAT THE GOVERNOR
- 26:14WILL HAVE A SAY SO AS WELL AND
- 26:15THE LEGISLATURE AGAIN.
- 26:17WE WILL BE FOLLOWING THAT AND WE
- 26:18THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE THIS
- 26:21EVENING.
- 26:28AFTER THIS BREAK, WE’LL DISCUSS
- 26:29LEGISLATION IMPACTING
- 26:29TRANSGENDER RIGHTS AND LIMITING
- 26:30ACCESS TO HORMONE THERAPY AND
- 26:31GENDER REASSIGNMENT SURGERIES.
- 26:32STAY WITH US.
- 30:04[♪♪]
- 30:04WELCOME BACK TO KENTUCKY
- 30:05TONIGHT.
- 30:09PART TWO OF OUR DISCUSSION.
- 30:11GOVERNOR ANDY BESHEAR VETOED A
- 30:13BILL THAT REVERSED HIS EXECUTIVE
- 30:15ORDER BANNING CONVERSION THERAPY
- 30:16AND KEEPS MEDICAID FROM COVERING
- 30:18TRANSGENDER-AFFIRMING MEDICAL
- 30:19CARE.
- 30:20THAT BILL IS HOUSE BILL 495.
- 30:22THERE’S ANOTHER BILL FOR THE
- 30:24GOVERNOR TO REVIEW SENATE BILL
- 30:26TWO• THAT PROHIBITS KENTUCKY’S
- 30:28PRISONS AND JAILS FROM PAYING
- 30:29FOR AND PROVIDING HORMONE
- 30:30THERAPY TO TRANSGENDER INMATES.
- 30:31JOINING US FOR THIS SEGMENT
- 30:32ARE..
- 30:34NOW JOINING US TO TALK ABOUT
- 30:37THOSE TWO MEASURES ARE...
- 30:41DAVID WALLS, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
- 30:41OF THE FAMILY FOUNDATION;
- 30:42CHRIS HARTMAN, EXECUTIVE
- 30:43DIRECTOR OF THE FAIRNESS
- 30:44CAMPAIGN;
- 30:45COLIN SMOTHERS, EXECUTIVE
- 30:46DIRECTOR OF THE COUNCIL ON
- 30:48BIBLICAL MANHOOD AND WOMANHOOD;
- 30:50AND EMMA CURTIS, LGBTQ+ ADVOCATE
- 30:53AND LEXINGTON-FAYETTE CO.
- 30:54COUNCILWOMAN.
- 30:56WE STILL WANT YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 30:57COMMENTS.
- 31:00SEND THEM BY X — FORMERLY
- 31:01TWITTER -- AT PUB AFFAIRS KET.
- 31:04SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 31:06K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 31:07OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 31:08O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 31:10OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 31:19WELCOME, THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING
- 31:20HERE.
- 31:21A QUICK SWITCH OUT OF GUESTS FOR
- 31:22THIS IMPORTANT TOPIC.
- 31:24WE WON'T WASTE MUCH TIME.
- 31:26HOUSE BILL 495 FIRST.
- 31:28AND I MENTIONED WHAT THAT DOES.
- 31:30I FIRST WANT TO HAVE OUR VIEWERS
- 31:32UNDERSTAND IF THEY MAYBE NEW TO
- 31:34THIS TOPIC, CHRIS DEFINE FOR US
- 31:37WHAT CONVERSION THERAPY IS?
- 31:38>> IT'S THE PRACTICE OF TRYING
- 31:41TO CONVINCE AN LGBTQ YOUNG
- 31:43PERSON THAT THEY CAN SOMEHOW
- 31:46TURN, NOT BE LGBTQ ANY LONGER.
- 31:50NOT BE GAY, BISEXUAL OR
- 31:55TRANSGENDER AND THIS PRACTICE
- 31:57ONLY LEADS TO HARM FOR LGBTQ
- 31:58YOUTH.
- 31:59IT'S NOT JUST SNAKE OIL IT'S
- 32:03SNAKE VENOM.
- 32:05NOTHING DESTROYS FAMILIES AND
- 32:06HARMS LGBTQ YOUTH MORE THAN THE
- 32:08DANGEROUS PRACTICE OF
- 32:11CONVERGENCE THERAPY WHAT ALICE
- 32:13KERR USED TO CALL CONVERSION
- 32:16TORTURE.
- 32:16>> Renee: A REPUBLICAN FROM THE
- 32:18LEXINGTON FAYETTE COUNTY AREA.
- 32:19WHAT IS INVOLVEDDED IN
- 32:21CONVERSION THERAPY AND WHY DO
- 32:22YOU FEEL THAT IT SHOULD BE
- 32:23PRACTICED?
- 32:23>> WELL, I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT
- 32:27TO STATE THAT WHAT THE GOVERNOR
- 32:29DID HERE, SEEKING TO USE HIS
- 32:31EXECUTIVE AUTHORITY TO BAN
- 32:33CONVERSION THERAPY WAS A
- 32:36TREMENDOUS OVERREACH.
- 32:36AND WE'RE CERTAINLY THANKFUL
- 32:38THAT THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS
- 32:40TAKEN ACTION TO REIN THAT ACTION
- 32:43IN.
- 32:43AT ITS CORE, THE OTHER SIDE CAN
- 32:46USE TERMS LIKE TORTURE.
- 32:47THAT IS NOT WHAT WE'RE TALKING
- 32:48ABOUT.
- 32:49READ THE DEFINITION OF IN THE
- 32:51GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER AND
- 32:52WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IS I
- 32:55AONE-SIDED COUNSELING BAN.
- 32:56IT WOULD SAY IF YOU SOUGHT TO
- 32:59COUNSEL SOMEONE TO AFFIRM THE
- 33:01REALITY OF WHO THEY ARE TO
- 33:03AFFIRM THEM IN THEIR BIOLOGICAL
- 33:05SEX THAT YOU COULD LOSE YOUR
- 33:07LICENSE.
- 33:07LIKE WISE, YOU COULD COUNSEL
- 33:10SOMEONE TOWARDS A GENDER
- 33:12TRANSITION WHICH IS NOW ILLEGAL
- 33:14UNDER SB150.
- 33:15THE GOVERNOR'S COUNSELING BAN
- 33:19WAS A ONE-SIDED ACTION.
- 33:21IT SUPPRESSES FREE SPEECH AND IT
- 33:25TRAMPLES THE RIGHTS OF PARENTS
- 33:26TO SEEK OUT COUNSELING THEY
- 33:28DESIRE FOR THEIR CHILDREN.
- 33:29I CAN'T THINK OF ANOTHER AREA OF
- 33:31COUNSELING WHERE WE WOULD SAY
- 33:32THAT CAN YOU ONLY COUNSEL
- 33:34SOMEONE ONE WAY.
- 33:35IF A PERSON, A CHILD OR A PARENT
- 33:38DESIREDDED TO GET COUNSELING
- 33:41FROM SOMEONE SUFFERING FROM A
- 33:42PROBLEM THEY WANT TO GET GET
- 33:44HELP FROM WE CAN ONLY AFFIRM
- 33:46THEM IN WHAT THEY ARE DESIRING.
- 33:48>> IF IT'S MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
- 33:51WHY WOULD YOU ENCOURAGE IT?
- 33:53CHILDREN WHO ARE SUBJECTED TO IT
- 33:56ARE MORE THAN TWICE AS LIKELY TO
- 34:00ASEPTEMBER SUICIDE.
- 34:00WHAT PARENT WOULD SEND THEIR
- 34:03CHILD INTO TORTURE.
- 34:04>> ALL THE DATA SHOWS WHEN YOU
- 34:08PUSH A CHILD TOWARDS TRANSITION.
- 34:11>> ALL THE DATA SHOWS THEY ARE
- 34:14MORE LIKELY TO HAVE DEPRESSION,
- 34:15SELF HARM AND SUICIDAL IDEATION
- 34:19AND UNFORTUNATELY COMPLETING
- 34:20SUICIDE.
- 34:21>> MS. CURTIS YOUR THOUGHTS?
- 34:23>> WELL, I THINK THAT IT'S VERY
- 34:25IMPORTANT THAT WHEN WE TALK
- 34:26ABOUT THIS WE WANT TO TAKE A
- 34:28CLOSER LOOK AT WHAT GOVERNOR
- 34:31BESHEAR EXECUTIVE ORDER OWE
- 34:33DOES.
- 34:34IT PREVENTS THE USE OF STATE
- 34:36FUNDS FOR CONVERSION THERAPY ON
- 34:38MINORS.
- 34:39THIS IS NOT A QUESTION OF A
- 34:42MINISTER OR A COUNSELOR TALKING
- 34:44TO A PARISHIONER OR CLIENT ABOUT
- 34:47THE OPTIONS THAT SOMEBODY WHO IS
- 34:50EXPERIENCING A QUESTIONING THEIR
- 34:52IDENTITY OR EXPERIENCING GENDER
- 34:55DYSMORPHIA CAN PURSUE.
- 34:56THIS IS A BAN ON SAYING TO
- 34:58SOMEBODY WHO KNOWS WHO THEY ARE,
- 35:00YOU ARE NOT THAT AND WE ARE
- 35:03GOING TO TORTURE YOU OUT OF
- 35:06BEING THAT WAY.
- 35:07>> Renee: WHY USE THE WORD
- 35:09TORTURE?
- 35:09>> EVERY PERSON I SPOKED TO WHO
- 35:13EXPERIENCE CONVERSION THERAPY
- 35:14COMES BACK TO THAT WORD.
- 35:17SOME BEAR PHYSICAL SCARES NOT
- 35:18JUST THE EMOTIONAL SCARES THAT
- 35:21THIS --
- 35:22SCARS THAT THIS PRACTICE
- 35:24INFLICTS ON THEM.
- 35:25>> Renee: YOU ARE SAYING
- 35:26PHYSICAL HARM IS USED?
- 35:27>> IN SOME CASES.
- 35:29TO DAVID'S POINT WE HAVE
- 35:31PROTECTIONS IN PLACE FOR MEDICAL
- 35:34PROVIDERS FOR MENTAL HEALTH
- 35:35HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS IN ALL
- 35:37AREAS.
- 35:39A MENTAL HEALTHCARE PROVIDER
- 35:40CANNOT TELL A CLIENT THAT OH,
- 35:42YOU'RE DEPRESSED AND SUICIDAL
- 35:45OBVIOUSLY THAT IS YOUR REALITY
- 35:46AND YOU SHOULD PURSUE SUICIDE.
- 35:49THAT IS NOT AN APPROPRIATE THING
- 35:50TO DO.
- 35:51SO WE PROTECT OUR PATIENTS FROM
- 35:54SAID PRACTICES.
- 35:55THAT'S WHAT GOVERNOR BESHEAR WAS
- 35:57ATTEMPTING TO DO FOR MINORS IN
- 35:58THIS EXECUTIVE ORDER.
- 35:59>> Renee: Mr. SMOTHERS HOW DO
- 36:00YOU LOOK AT CONVERSION THERAPY?
- 36:03AND IS IT TORTURE AND DO YOU
- 36:04AGREE WITH THE USE OF PHYSICAL
- 36:06HARM IN ORDER TO CONVINCE
- 36:09SOMEONE OR PERSUADE THEM TO BE
- 36:13HETERONORMATIVE.
- 36:13>> I WOULD LIKE TO TAKE A STAND
- 36:16BACK FOR A MINUTE.
- 36:19AS A MINISTER GOD CREATED THEM
- 36:22MALE AND FEMALE.
- 36:25AFFIRM AND QUOTED BY JESUS IN
- 36:27MATTHEW.
- 36:28>> AND NOT AN ANSWER TO THE
- 36:29QUESTION.
- 36:30>> SO WHEN WE HEAR ABOUT
- 36:32CONVERSION THERAPY IT IS AN
- 36:34IRONIC USE OF THE WORD
- 36:35CONVERSION THERE'S BEEN A PRIOR
- 36:37CONVERSION AND THAT IS THE
- 36:39CONVERSION FROM A YOUNG MALE OR
- 36:41YOUNG FEMALE TO IDENTIFYING WITH
- 36:43THE OPPOSITE SEX AND THEN
- 36:45UNDERGOING TREATMENTS OR HORMONE
- 36:46THERAPIES.
- 36:48AND MY CONVICTION IS ALONG WITH
- 36:50THE FOUNDING OF THIS COUNTRY,
- 36:52THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
- 36:54WE HAVE THE LAW OF NATURE AND
- 36:55THE LAW OF NATURE'S GOD.
- 36:57AND THAT IS THAT SEX IS NOT
- 36:59ASSIGNED AT BIRTH.
- 37:00SEX IS DETERMINED AT CONCEPTION.
- 37:03YOU CAN SEX AND EMBRYO AND IT
- 37:06CAN BE DETERMINED MALE OR FEMALE
- 37:08FROM THE BEGINNING OF
- 37:10CONCEPTION.
- 37:10IT'S GOD WHO ASSIGNS MALE AND
- 37:12FEMALE AND WHO ARE WE TO ACT
- 37:14OTHERWISE.
- 37:15IT'S GOD WHO MADE US NOT
- 37:18OURSELVES.
- 37:18IN OTHER WORDS WHAT ANDY BESHEAR
- 37:20IS DOING WITH THE EXECUTIVE
- 37:22ORDER, WHAT THESE THIS EXECUTIVE
- 37:24ORDER IF IT WERE TO STAND THIS
- 37:26VETO ON HB495, IS ACTUALLY
- 37:30PREVENT CHRISTIAN CLINICIANS,
- 37:32CHRISTIAN COUNSELORS FROM
- 37:34ADDRESSING THE FIRST CONVERSION,
- 37:36THE CONVERSION AWAY FROM THEIR
- 37:38SEX DETERMINATION AT CONCEPTION.
- 37:40>> FROM ENGAGING IN MEDICAL
- 37:43MALPRACTICE.
- 37:43>> RESPECTFULLY PASTOR, GLA
- 37:47LAYIONS TEACHING US THERE IS NO
- 37:49MALE NOR FEMALE FOR ALL ONE IN
- 37:52JESUS CHRIST THIS IS NOT A SHOW
- 37:55WE'RE HERE TO DEBATE THEOLOGY
- 37:57WE'RE HERE TO ANTIBIOTIC PUBLIC
- 37:58POLICY AND THE UNITED STATES
- 38:00PROTECTS YOUR FREEDOM OF
- 38:01RELIGION TO BELIEVE THAT.
- 38:02BUT IT DOES NOT PROTECT YOUR
- 38:05RIGHT TO FORCE THAT NARROW
- 38:07DEFINITION INTO LAW.
- 38:08>> WHICH IS WHY I'M THANKFUL FOR
- 38:11PRESIDENT TRUMP'S EXECUTIVE
- 38:12ORDER THAT DEFINES NOW SEX BASED
- 38:14IN BIOLOGY BASED IN OUR
- 38:19CHROMOSOMAL REALITY WHICH
- 38:19ANYBODY CAN TAKE ONE OF THESE
- 38:21TESTS AND THEY CAN BE DETERMINED
- 38:23THIS IS MALE OR OR FEMALE AND WE
- 38:25CAN ACT BASED ON THE SCIENCE.
- 38:28>> NOW, THEY SUPPORT SCIENCE.
- 38:30I BELIEVE THAT.
- 38:31>> WE CAN ACTUALLY TALK ABOUT
- 38:33WHAT IT BEST FOR THESE YOUNG
- 38:35CHILDREN, MALES AND FEMALES AND
- 38:38YUCK ADULTS AND EVEN THOSE
- 38:39ADULTS IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF
- 38:41KENTUCKY.
- 38:42>> Renee: THE OTHER PART OF THAT
- 38:44BILL, ALSO BANS MEDICAID FROM
- 38:46FUNDING GENDER AFFIRMING CARE
- 38:48LIKE HORMONE THERAPY AND GENDER
- 38:51REASSIGNMENT SURGERY WAS THAT
- 38:52ALREADY HAPPENING?
- 38:53WAS MEDICAID PAYING FOR THAT?
- 38:55>> YES.
- 38:56THERE IS A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF
- 38:57GENDER AFFIRMING CARE THAT STATE
- 38:59MEDICAID HAS BEEN COVERING,
- 39:02LARGELY HORMONE REPLACEMENT
- 39:03THERAPY WHICH IS MEDICALLY
- 39:05NECESSARY HEALTHCARE FOR
- 39:08TRANSGENDER KENTUCKIANS AND WHAT
- 39:09THEY ALLOWED TO BE SLIPPED IN AT
- 39:11THE LAST MOMENT IS A BAN THAT IS
- 39:13GOING TO CUTOFF THOUSANDS OF
- 39:14TRANSGENDER KENTUCKIANS FROM THE
- 39:15HEALTHCARE THEY NEED.
- 39:17>> Renee: THE PHRASE MEDICALLY
- 39:18NECESSARY.
- 39:19THERE WAS A LOT OF DEBATE ON THE
- 39:21HOUSE AND SENATE FLOOR ABOUT
- 39:23THAT.
- 39:23SOME BELIEVE THIS IS AN ELECTIVE
- 39:25PROCEDURE.
- 39:26AND NOT MEDICALLY NECESSARY.
- 39:27MS. CURTIS TELL US WHY IT'S ONE
- 39:30AND NOT THE OTHER?
- 39:32>> FIRST OFF I WANT TO CLARIFY
- 39:33SOMETHING WHICH IS THAT KENTUCKY
- 39:35MEDICAID HAS NEVER COVERED
- 39:37GENDER AFFIRMING SURGERIES FOR
- 39:39TRANSGENDER PEOPLE.
- 39:40IT HAS ONLY COVERED HORMONE
- 39:44REPLACEMENT THERAPY CLINICALLY
- 39:45ACCEPTED COURSE OF TREATMENT FOR
- 39:48GENDER DYSMORPHIA ACCEPTED BY
- 39:51EVERY MAJOR MEDICAL ORGANIZATION
- 39:52IN THE WORLD FOR DECADES.
- 39:53I KNOW THIS IS LIFE-SAVING CARE
- 39:55BECAUSE I'M A TRANS KENTUCKIAN
- 39:58WHO RECEIVED HORMONE REPLACEMENT
- 40:00THERAPY COVERED BY MEDICAID.
- 40:02THIS IS NOT A HYPOTHETICAL.
- 40:05THIS IS SOMETHING WHERE MY
- 40:08DOCTOR RECOGNIZED THAT I WAS
- 40:10EXPERIENCING DAILY SUICIDAL
- 40:12IDEATION.
- 40:13I SOUGHT COUNSELING.
- 40:14I SOUGHT BELIEVE IT OR NOT,
- 40:16COUNSELING THROUGH THE CHURCH AS
- 40:17WELL.
- 40:18AND WE DETERMINED THAT THIS WAS
- 40:19THE APPROPRIATE COURSE OF
- 40:21ACTION.
- 40:22MY DOCTOR ASSESSED ME AND SAID
- 40:24THIS IS MEDICALLY NECESSARY AND
- 40:26PRESCRIBED ME HORMONE
- 40:27REPLACEMENT THERAPY.
- 40:28PRIOR TO THAT MEDICATION I WAS
- 40:31EXPERIENCING SUICIDAL IDEATION
- 40:33ON A DAILY BASIS AND SINCE I
- 40:34BEGAN THAT COURSE OF MEDICATION
- 40:36I DON'T EXPERIENCE IT AT ALL
- 40:39ANYMORE.
- 40:39THIS ISN'T A QUESTION ABOUT IS
- 40:43MEDICAID COVERING COSMETIC
- 40:45SURGERIES FOR PEOPLE TO MAKE
- 40:48THEMSELVES MORE BEAUTIFUL OR
- 40:50ATTRACTIVE.
- 40:50THIS IS A QUESTION ABOUT WHETHER
- 40:51WE ARE GOING TO PROVIDE THE
- 40:56ACCEPTED TREATMENT THAT HAS BEEN
- 40:58ENDORSED BY EVERY MAJOR MEDICAL
- 40:59ASSOCIATION IN THE WORLD FOR
- 41:00DECADES FOR PEOPLE LIKE ME.
- 41:02>> Renee: Mr. WALLS.
- 41:04>> SO YOU ARE SEEING ACROSS THE
- 41:08WORLD A RADICAL PULLBACK FROM
- 41:11TRANSGENDER IDEOLOGY.
- 41:12FROM PUSHING THESE TYPES OF
- 41:15TREATMENTS FROM SURGICALLY,
- 41:18PHYSICALLY, CHEMICALLY
- 41:19MUTILATING HEALTHY BODIES.
- 41:20YOU ARE SEEING IT ACROSS THE
- 41:21UNITED STATES, KENTUCKY IN 23
- 41:24MAYBE MORE STATES HAVE TAKEN
- 41:26ACTION TO PROTECT KIDS FROM
- 41:27BEING HARMED IN THIS MANNER.
- 41:30AS WAS MENTIONED PRESIDENT TRUMP
- 41:33IS SIGNED MULTIPLE EXECUTIVE
- 41:35ORDERS INCLUDING AN IMPORTANT
- 41:36ONE TO PROTECT OUR TAX DOLLARS.
- 41:38I BELIEVE THAT KENTUCKIANS WERE
- 41:40SHOCKED WHEN THEY FOUND OUT THAT
- 41:42GOVERNOR BESHEAR WAS SEEKING TO
- 41:44USE OUR TAX DOLLARS TO PAY FOR
- 41:47TRANSGENDER INTERVENTIONS IN OUR
- 41:51PRISONS.
- 41:52THEY WERE SHOCKED TO FIND OUT
- 41:53THAT OUR TAX DOLLARS ARE BEING
- 41:55USED IN MEDICAID AND THE NUMBERS
- 41:56THAT WE'RE HEARING COULD BE UP
- 41:59TO $10,000.
- 42:01>> RESPECTFULLY DAVID I BEGAN
- 42:03RECEIVING MEDICAID COVERAGE
- 42:06UNDER GOVERNOR BEVIN.
- 42:07>> KENTUCKIANS DO NOT WANT THEIR
- 42:09TAX DOLLARS SPENT PAYING FOR
- 42:10SOMETHING THAT IS NOT POSSIBLE.
- 42:12>> IT IS NOT POSSIBLE TO
- 42:15TRANSITION FROM A MAN TO A WOMAN
- 42:17FROM A BOY TO A GIRL.
- 42:19OUR TAX DOLLARS SHOULD NOT BE
- 42:21PAYING FOR IT.
- 42:22THANKFULLY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY,
- 42:25HAS TAKEN ACTION TO PROTECT OUR
- 42:27KIDS.
- 42:28IF ADULTS WOULD LIKE TO TAKE
- 42:29PART IN THOSE PROCEDURES, THEY
- 42:32ARE FREE TO DO SO.
- 42:33BUT OUR TAX DOLLARS SHOULD NOT
- 42:34PAY FOR IT.
- 42:35AND SO I THINK MOST KENTUCKIANS
- 42:38WILL BE OVERWHELMINGLY
- 42:40ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT THESE TWO
- 42:41PIECES OF LEGISLATION.
- 42:43AND I SUSPECT IF THE GOVERNOR
- 42:46DOES INDEED VETO BOTH YOU WILL
- 42:47SEE THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 42:49ENTHUSIASTICALLY TAKE ACTION.
- 42:52>> DAVID HAS NOTHING TO BASE
- 42:54THESE IDEAS ON.
- 42:55WE POLLED KENTUCKY VOTERS ON
- 42:58WHETHER OR NOT THESE WERE
- 42:59PRIORITY ISSUES NOT ONLY ARE
- 43:01THEY NOT SHOCKED TO FIND OUT
- 43:02THAT HEALTHCARE IS COVERED FOR
- 43:04TRANS KENTUCKIANS WHETHER ON
- 43:06MEDICAID OR JAILS AND PRISONS
- 43:08BUT NO VOTERS CARED ABOUT THIS
- 43:10ISSUE.
- 43:1010 TO 15% OF KENTUCKY VOTERS
- 43:13SAID THIS WAS A HIGH PRIORITY
- 43:14FOR THEM AS OPPOSED TO 80%
- 43:17SAYING THAT ACCESS TO AFFORDABLE
- 43:19HEALTHCARE FUNDING PUBLIC
- 43:21EDUCATION AND DISASTER RELIEF
- 43:22FOR THE HISTORIC AND DEVASTATING
- 43:24FLOODS WE'VE HAD AMONG THE TOP
- 43:27PRIORITIES THIS IS THE BOTTOM OF
- 43:28THE BARREL.
- 43:29AND THE ONLY REASON THAT
- 43:31KENTUCKY LAWMAKERS ARE PURSUING
- 43:33THIS IS BECAUSE IT'S POLITICAL
- 43:35RED MEAT.
- 43:36DAVID AND HIS GROUP AT THE
- 43:38FAMILY FOUNDATION SAID YOU HAVE
- 43:39TO SUPPORT THESE ISSUES OR WE'RE
- 43:41NOT GOING TO SUPPORT YOU IN YOUR
- 43:44REELECTION BIDS.
- 43:45THE ONLY REASON THE ISSUES ARE
- 43:47RUNNING IN KENTUCKY.
- 43:48KENTUCKY VOTERS DO NOT CARE
- 43:49ABOUT THESE ISSUES.
- 43:50>> WITH ALL DUE RESPECT THE
- 43:52REASON THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS
- 43:54TAKEN UP THE TWO BILLS IS
- 43:56BECAUSE OF THE ACTIONS OF OUR
- 43:58GOVERNOR.
- 43:59SIGNING AN EXECUTIVE ORDER,
- 44:02ESSENTIALLY TRYING TO PUT INTO
- 44:04LAW LEGISLATION THAT HAD
- 44:05REPEATEDLY FAILED.
- 44:07AND ALSO WAS GAINING LESS AND
- 44:09LESS SUPPORT EACH LEGISLATIVE
- 44:11SESSION.
- 44:12HE DESIGNED AN EXECUTIVE ORDER.
- 44:14AND THEN AS WE SAW ESSENTIALLY
- 44:16TRYING TO SECRETLY PUT A POLICY
- 44:18IN PLACE NOT JUST TO PAY FOR
- 44:21GENDER TRANSITION MEDICAL
- 44:23PROCEDURES FOR THOSE IN PRISON,
- 44:26IT DOES MUCH MORE THAN THAT.
- 44:28IT SETS UP A POLICY WHERE
- 44:30PRISONERS CAN ESSENTIALLY DECIDE
- 44:32FOR THEMSELVES WHAT FACILITY
- 44:33THEY WANT TO BE IN?
- 44:35>> THAT'S NOT TRUE.
- 44:36>> IT'S RIGHT IN THE POLICY.
- 44:38I CAN READ IT TO YOU.
- 44:39>> AND WHERE DID THAT POLICY
- 44:41COME FROM?
- 44:42THE PRISON RAPE ELIMINATION ACT
- 44:44THAT IS DECADES OLD.
- 44:45>> IT CAME FROM THE BIDEN
- 44:47ADMINISTRATION SO WE'RE THANKFUL
- 44:49THAT TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IS
- 44:51REVERSING COURSE AND BRINGING
- 44:53SANITY BACK INTO THIS ISSUE.
- 44:54THE IDEA THAT THE GENERAL
- 44:55ASSEMBLY WAS THE ONE THAT FORCED
- 44:58THESE ISSUES TO HAVE TO COME UP
- 45:00THIS SESSION IS NOT TRUE.
- 45:01>> Renee: FROM MARK A VIEWER
- 45:02NAMED MARK FROM NORTHERN
- 45:04KENTUCKY WHO SAYS THE STATE
- 45:05GOVERNMENT IS SPENDING SO MUCH
- 45:07TIME ON THIS ISSUE WHEN THEY
- 45:09SHOULD BE SPENDING TIME ON OTHER
- 45:11ISSUES.
- 45:12PASTOR, ANSWER THAT ARE THERE
- 45:14OTHER ISSUES THAT THE GENERAL
- 45:16ASSEMBLY SHOULD BE TENDING TO
- 45:17AND WHY IS THIS A PRIORITY?
- 45:18>> I THINK IT IS A PRIORITY
- 45:20BECAUSE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
- 45:21TAXPAYER MONEY AND PEOPLE'S
- 45:22LIVES AT STAKE.
- 45:23AND YOU KNOW, IT MUST BE SAID
- 45:26THAT THESE TREATMENTS, THESE
- 45:28HORMONAL REPLACEMENT THERAPIES
- 45:29THESE SURGERIES ARE
- 45:31STERILIZATION SURGERIES.
- 45:33TAXPAYER MONEY GOING FOR
- 45:35PROCEDURES AND TREATMENTS THAT
- 45:36WILL END IN AND RESULT IN THE
- 45:40LONG-TERM IRREVERSIBLE DAMAGE TO
- 45:41THESE INDIVIDUALS.
- 45:42AND WHY WOULD A TAXPAYER WANT TO
- 45:43BE INVOLVED IN SUCH A PROCEDURE
- 45:46AND SUCH A SITUATION I DON'T
- 45:49THINK THAT THEY WOULD WANT TO DO
- 45:51THAT.
- 45:51AND I WOULD ASK CHRIS IF HE IS
- 45:53USING THE SAME POLLING SITUATION
- 45:54THAT PREDICTED THAT KAMALA
- 45:57HARRIS LANDSLIDE AND GO BACK TO
- 45:59THE POLLING.
- 46:01THE 2024 SURVEY SAID THAT 65% A
- 46:04NATIONAL SURVEY 65% OF VOTERS DO
- 46:06NOT WANT THEIR TAXPAYER MONEY
- 46:07GOING TO THESE PROCEDURES THAT
- 46:09IS 84% OF REPUBLICANS, 40% OF
- 46:11DEMOCRATS AND 72% OF SWING
- 46:15VOTERS.
- 46:17[ALL TALKING AT ONCE]
- 46:17>> YOU ARE RATTLING OFF NUMBERS
- 46:19THAT WERE NOT VETTED.
- 46:21WE RELEASED THE MASON DIXON POLL
- 46:24YOU DON'T POLL ON THE ISSUES
- 46:26BECAUSE YOU DON'T CARE WHAT
- 46:29VOTERS CARE ABOUT.
- 46:30YOU CARE ABOUT YOUR STRICT
- 46:32IDEOLOGY AND FORCING YOUR
- 46:34BELIEFS ON TO OTHERS IN THE LAW.
- 46:35AND FRANKLY IT'S NOT THE SAME
- 46:39SENTIMENT THAT KENTUCKY VOTERS
- 46:40HAVE.
- 46:41>> I DON'T DO POLLING BECAUSE I
- 46:43AM A PASTOR AND I'M CONCERNED
- 46:46ABOUT CAPITAL T TRUTH TRUTH,
- 46:48ACCORDING TO NATURE AND NATURE'S
- 46:51GOD.
- 46:51AND I BASE MY ETHICAL OUTLOOK ON
- 46:54THE PEOPLE THAT COME TO ME FOR
- 46:56COUNSELING I WANT TO BASE MY CON
- 46:58SELL ON AND ALSO WHAT I WANT THE
- 47:02COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY TO
- 47:04FLOURISH UNDER NOT AN
- 47:06EXPERIMENTAL.
- 47:07>> DON'T SEND YOUR KIDS TO
- 47:09COLIN.
- 47:09>> I THINK THAT KENTUCKY
- 47:13TAXPAYERS DO NOT WANT TO BE ON
- 47:14THE HOOK FOR EXPERIMENTAL
- 47:15PROCEDURES ACCORDING TO A STUDY
- 47:18RELEASED OXFORD ACADEMIC JOURNAL
- 47:20OF SEXUAL MEDICINE IT REVIEWED 1
- 47:28107500 PATIENTS GENDER
- 47:31AFFIRMING CARE SURGERY WHILE
- 47:33BENEFICIAL IN AFFIRMING IDENTITY
- 47:35IS ASSOCIATED WITH INCREASED
- 47:36RISK OF MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES.
- 47:38THAT IS STUDY PUBLISHED IN THE
- 47:40OXFORD ACT ASSEMBLYIC JOURNAL OF
- 47:42SEXUAL MEDICINE.
- 47:43LOOK THAT UP.
- 47:44WE ARE NOT SEEING THE SAME
- 47:46RESULTS THAT THE OTHER SIDE IS
- 47:48SAYING IS GOING TO BE RESULTING.
- 47:50>> Renee: I WANT YOU TO RESPOND
- 47:51THAT.
- 47:51>> I HAVE SEEN THAT STUDY PASTOR
- 47:53AND IN THAT STUDY ONE OF THE
- 47:54THINGS THAT THEY DID WAS THEY
- 47:58MEASURED THE MENTAL HEALTH OF
- 48:01SOMEBODY BEFORE THEY RECEIVED
- 48:04GENDER AFFIRMING SURGERIES AND
- 48:06AFTER THEY RECEIVED SURGERIES.
- 48:07FIRST OF ALL WE ARE NOT HERE TO
- 48:09TALK ABOUT GENDER AFFIRMING
- 48:12SURGERIES BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT
- 48:13PAID FOR BY TAXPAYERS.
- 48:15TWO THEY DID NOT GAUGE ANY
- 48:17CONTROLS IN THAT.
- 48:18THIS WAS TALKING ABOUT A MORE
- 48:22GENERALIZED SURVEY OF THE
- 48:23TRANSGENDER POPULATION.
- 48:25WE ARE MORE LIKELY TO EXPERIENCE
- 48:27MELODIES TRES AND SUICIDAL
- 48:29IDEATION BECAUSE WE HAVE TO COME
- 48:31ON PUBLIC POLICY SHOWS AND TALK
- 48:33TO PEOPLE WHO ARE DEEPLY UNDER
- 48:35ROUSE ABOUT PUBLIC POLICY AND
- 48:37ONLY SERIOUS ABOUT THEIR
- 48:39THEOLOGY.
- 48:39WE EXIST IN A CULTURE THAT TRIES
- 48:41TO TELL US TIME AND TIME AGAIN
- 48:43THAT WE DO NOT EXIST.
- 48:45WE DO EXIST.
- 48:47AND DESPITE WHAT Mr. WALLS HAS
- 48:50CONSISTENTLY SAID THERE'S NO
- 48:51SUCH THING AS A TRANSGENDER
- 48:53CHILD AND THERE'S NO SUCH THING
- 48:55AS A TRANSGENDER KENTUCKIAN I'M
- 48:57SITTING BEFORE YOU AS A
- 48:58TRANSGENDER KENTUCKIAN.
- 48:59AND YOU HAVE YOUR RIGHT TO
- 49:01BELIEVE WHATEVER YOU MIGHT WANT
- 49:02TO BELIEVE ABOUT ME.
- 49:03BUT YOU DO NOT HAVE THE RIGHT TO
- 49:05TAKE AWAY MY ACCESS TO THE
- 49:07HEALTHCARE THAT SAVES MY LIFE
- 49:08AND SAVES THOUSANDS OF OTHER
- 49:10LIVES BECAUSE YOU DON'T
- 49:13UNDERSTAND ME.
- 49:14HOW MANY TRANSGENDER PEOPLE HAVE
- 49:15YOU REACHED OUT TO WHEN YOU
- 49:18DISCUSS THIS ISSUES?
- 49:20>> I HAVE CLOSE RELATIONSHIPS
- 49:23WITH SEVERAL DETRANSITIONERS AND
- 49:26WE'VE HEARD TESTIMONIES HOW THIS
- 49:28ISSUE HAS HARMED PEOPLE BOTH
- 49:30YOUNG AND OLD.
- 49:31AND SO AND I'LL JUST.
- 49:33>> I WOULD LIKE TO REMIND YOU I
- 49:35AM A D TRANSITIONER.
- 49:38I D TRANSITIONED WHEN I WAS 18
- 49:40BECAUSE I WAS TERRIFIED AND
- 49:42AFRAID BECAUSE PEOPLE LIKE YOU
- 49:43COME ON THESE SHOWS AND YOU
- 49:47PEDDLE THE BAD FAITH ARGUMENTS
- 49:49WHO DON'T KNOW A TRANS PERSON
- 49:51INTO BELIEVING THIS LANGUAGE
- 49:53LIKE YOU USED.
- 49:54THE TERM MUTILATION IS MORE AT
- 49:56HOME IN A DISCUSSION ABOUT
- 49:58HORROR FILMS IN A DISCUSSION
- 50:00ABOUT SERIOUS PUBLIC POLICY
- 50:02MATTERS.
- 50:03>> ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS LOOK AT
- 50:05THE SURGERIES AND THE PEOPLE
- 50:07THAT HAVE BEEN HARMED AND IT'S
- 50:09MUTILATING.
- 50:10YOU SAID WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT
- 50:13TRANSGENDER SURGERIES.
- 50:13THIS IS THE GOVERNOR'S MEMO
- 50:15RIGHT HERE.
- 50:15AND THERE IS A SECTION THAT
- 50:18TALKS ABOUT AN INMATE IN PRISON
- 50:21REQUESTING A TRANSGENDER
- 50:22SPECIFIC SURGERY.
- 50:24SO THIS --
- 50:25>> WHICH THEY DO NOT RECEIVE.
- 50:26>> THIS IS THE CONTEXT WHAT WE
- 50:28WERE TALKING ABOUT.
- 50:29>> Renee: THE REQUEST IS
- 50:30DIFFERENT FROM HAVING RECEIVED.
- 50:32>> RIGHT, BUT THE IDEA THAT THE
- 50:35REQUEST WAS MADE IT ABSOLUTELY.
- 50:37>> SOMEBODY IN PRISON CAN ACCEPT
- 50:39TO LEAVE PRISON BUT IT DOESN'T
- 50:41MEAN THEY ARE GOING TO.
- 50:42>> READ THROUGH THE POLICY IT'S
- 50:45CLEAR THAT THAT IS THE DIRECTION
- 50:46THE GOVERNOR WAS PUSHING THIS
- 50:48COMMONWEALTH TO GO.
- 50:48AND AS I SAID THERE'S MANY MORE
- 50:51CONCERNS INCLUDING THE ISSUE OF
- 50:52FORCING THOSE IN OUR PRISON
- 50:55FACILITIES IN THOSE CORRECTIONAL
- 50:56WORKERS TO HAVE TO USE PREFERRED
- 50:59PRONOUNCE AND VIOLATE THEIR FREE
- 51:00SPEECH AND RELIGIOUS LIBERTY AS
- 51:02WELL.
- 51:04IT IS WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE
- 51:06ACTIONS THAT THE GENERAL
- 51:07ASSEMBLY RIGHTLY TOOK TO REIN IN
- 51:10ACTIONS OF OUR OUT OF CONTROL
- 51:12GOVERNOR.
- 51:12THEY TOOK RIGHT ACTIONS TO
- 51:14REVERSE COURSE.
- 51:14THE LEGISLATURE IS THE ONE THAT
- 51:16SHOULD BE MAKING THE LAWS IN
- 51:17THIS COMMONWEALTH.
- 51:18AND THEY HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO
- 51:19ENSURE THAT OUR TAX DOLLARS ARE
- 51:21PROTECTED.
- 51:21>> Renee: WHEN IT COMES TO
- 51:22GENDER AFFIRMING CARE FOR
- 51:24INMATES IN KENTUCKY WE
- 51:26UNDERSTOOD THERE ARE 67 INMATES
- 51:29THAT SENATE BILL 2 SEPARATE FROM
- 51:32495 THAT SEEMS TO BE A SMALL
- 51:35NUMBER, Mr. HARTMAN, EXPLAIN?
- 51:36>> ZERO --
- 51:410.35% OF KENTUCKY INCARCERATED
- 51:44POPULATION LESS THAN HALF A
- 51:46PERCENT.
- 51:4867 KENTUCKIANS WILL BE DENIED
- 51:50THEIR PRESCRIBED MEDICALLY
- 51:53NECESSARY HEALTHCARE IN JAILS
- 51:54AND PRISONS.
- 51:55AND KENTUCKY IS OPENING ITSELF
- 51:57UP TO SOME REALLY SERIOUS LEGAL
- 51:59CHALLENGES BECAUSE THIS IS
- 52:01CLEARLY UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND
- 52:02FEDERAL COURTS HELD THAT IT IS A
- 52:04VIOLATION OF THE 8TH AMENDMENT.
- 52:06IT IS CRUEL AND UNUSUAL TO DENY
- 52:09ANY INMATES THE HEALTHCARE THAT
- 52:10THEY'VE BEEN PRESCRIBED BY THEIR
- 52:12PHYSICIANS.
- 52:12>> Renee: SO WE UNDERSTAND WHAT
- 52:13THE LEGISLATION SAYS.
- 52:15IF AN INMATE COMES TO A
- 52:17CORRECTIONAL FACILITY AND THEY
- 52:19ARE ALREADY ON THOSE HORMONAL
- 52:21THERAPIES IT WOULD BE CEASED?
- 52:22>> THAT'S CORRECT.
- 52:23THERE IS THIS TAPERING OFF
- 52:25PERIOD IN THE LEGISLATION THAT
- 52:27SAYS IF THE MEDICAL TEAM
- 52:29DETERMINES THAT IT WOULD BE
- 52:31HARMFUL TO COME OFF OF THE
- 52:33MEDICATION RIGHT AWAY THAT THERE
- 52:34CAN BE A SORT OF STEPPING DOWN.
- 52:37BUT NO MATTER HOW YOU LOOK AT
- 52:39IT, DENYING FOLKS THE
- 52:41MEDICATIONS THAT THEY'VE BEEN
- 52:43PRESCRIBED IS SIMPLY WRONG.
- 52:45>> Renee: TO Mr. WALLS' AND
- 52:50REVEREND'S CONTENTION THAT
- 52:51TAXPAYER DOLLARS SHOULD NOT BE
- 52:52FUNDING THOSE THERAPIES.
- 52:53>> LET ME SAY ALL INMATES IN
- 52:55JAILS AND PRISONS DESERVE ACCESS
- 52:58TO HEALTHCARE.
- 52:58AND IT INCLUDES TRANSGENDER
- 53:00FOLKS.
- 53:00AND THE MONEY THAT THE STATE
- 53:03THINKS IT'S GOING TO SOMEHOW
- 53:05SAVE BY DENYING THESE
- 53:07PRESCRIPTIONS TO INMATES IN
- 53:09JAILS AND PRISONS IN THE
- 53:11COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY IS NOT
- 53:12GOING TO OUT WAY THE --
- 53:16OUTWEIGH THE SUICIDE THOUGHTS
- 53:17AND THE MEDICATIONS FOLKS WILL
- 53:19NEED WHEN TAKEN OFF THE
- 53:21MEDICATION THAT IS LITERALLY
- 53:22SAVING THEIR LIVES.
- 53:25>> I THINK BESHEAR'S OPPOSITION
- 53:29DEMONSTRATING HE IS TRYING TO
- 53:30PUT HIS HAND ON THE SCALES AND
- 53:32VOTE IN FAVOR OF A TROUBLED MIND
- 53:34INSTEAD OF A HEALTHY BODY AND I
- 53:36DON'T THINK THE TAXPAYERS IN
- 53:37KENTUCKY WANT TO SIGN UP FOR
- 53:39THAT.
- 53:39AND WANT TO BE ON THE HOOK FOR
- 53:41PROVIDING THOSE SURGERIES AND
- 53:43TREATMENTS THOSE HORMONAL
- 53:44THERAPIES THAT ARE GOING TO
- 53:45RESULT IN STERILIZATION THAT
- 53:47WILL RESULT IN AS SUSPECTS YOU
- 53:50LOOK AT THESE WOMEN THAT HAVE
- 53:52UNDERGONE THE HORMONE
- 53:55REPLACEMENT SURGERIES EARLY
- 53:57ONSET OSTEOPOROSIS.
- 53:58THERE IS A REASON WHY THE CLINIC
- 54:02IS BACKING OFF OF THE AFFIRMING
- 54:03CARE.
- 54:04THERE IS A REASON WHY JOHNS
- 54:06HOPKINS STOPPED THEIR TREATMENT
- 54:07AND RESTARTED IT.
- 54:08AND THE WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY IN
- 54:10ST. LOUIS STOPPED PROVIDING THIS
- 54:12CARE AND IT HAS TO DO WITH THE
- 54:13LEGAL CHALLENGES THAT THEY KNOW
- 54:15ARE COMING BECAUSE OF THE CASES
- 54:17THAT DAVID CITED WITH THE
- 54:22DETRANSITIONERS.
- 54:23>> Renee: JOHNS HOPKINS STOPPED
- 54:23IT AND RESTARTED IT.
- 54:24>> UNDER THE BIDEN
- 54:25ADMINISTRATION FOR IDEOLOGICAL
- 54:27PURPOSES AGAINST THE STUDY AND
- 54:29THE WELL WISHES OF PAUL McCUE,
- 54:33AND HIS RESEARCH.
- 54:35GO LOOK THAT UP FOR LISTENERS.
- 54:38ALL LITERATURE IS AVAILABLE.
- 54:39ALL OF THESE STUDIES ARE OUT
- 54:40THERE.
- 54:41I THINK RIGHT NOWER WE ARE IN A
- 54:43DEBATE AND THIS IS A DEBATE THAT
- 54:44WE NEED TO HAVE.
- 54:46WHY THEN WOULD THE GOVERNOR, WHY
- 54:48THEN WOULD THE TAXPAYER BE ON
- 54:49THE HOOK FOR ONE SIDE OF THE
- 54:51DEBATE INSTEAD OF HAVING THIS
- 54:52OUT IN THE OPEN AND LET'S TALK
- 54:53ABOUT THE LAWS OF NATURE AND
- 54:56NATURE'S GOD.
- 54:56>> RESPECTFULLY PASTOR, YOU CITE
- 54:58ALL OF THESE COUNTRIES THAT ARE
- 55:01GOING BACK AND CLINICS AND NOT
- 55:04CITING THE FACT WE HAD NEW
- 55:06GUIDELINES ISSUED IN SWEDEN BY
- 55:07THE WAY THE SWISS STUDY THAT WAS
- 55:10CITED AGAIN IN SENATE BILL 150
- 55:12DEBATING THIS ISSUE TWO YEARS
- 55:14AGO THIS IS NOT A NEW DEBATE.
- 55:16YOU MIGHT BE NEW TO IT, WELCOME.
- 55:19WE SAW THAT SWEDEN ACTUALLY
- 55:23INCREASED THEIR SUPPORT FOR
- 55:26GENDER AFFIRMING CARE AND WE SAW
- 55:28THAT IN OTHER EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
- 55:29AS WELL.
- 55:30BECAUSE THEY BECAME MORE AWARE.
- 55:32THEY STUDIED THEY DID THE WORK
- 55:33AND DID THE SCIENCE.
- 55:36LAWS LIKE HOUSE BILL 495 THAT
- 55:38STRIP MARGINALIZED KENTUCKIANS
- 55:39OF THEIR HEALTHCARE SPECIFICALLY
- 55:42TRANSGENDER KENTUCKIANS MY
- 55:44COMMUNITY HAPPEN BECAUSE MOST
- 55:45KENTUCKIANS DON'T KNOW A
- 55:48TRANSGENDER PERSON INDIVIDUALLY
- 55:50ONE-ON-ONE THEY DON'T KNOW WHAT
- 55:52THE CARE LOOKS LIKE AND THAT
- 55:54ALLOWS BAD FAITH ACTORS TO USE
- 55:57THIS HORROR FILM LANGUAGE LIKE
- 56:01STERILIZATION AND MUTTLATION TO
- 56:03FEAR MONGER.
- 56:04IT LOOKS LIKE THIS.
- 56:06THIS IS ESTROGEN PROVIDED TO ME
- 56:09THROUGH A PRESCRIPTION BY MY
- 56:11DOCTOR.
- 56:11>> Renee: THANK YOU.
- 56:11WE'LL HAVE TO LEAVE IT THERE.
- 56:13WE APPRECIATE YOU CERTAINLY.
- 56:16APPRECIATE THE COMMENTARY OF YOU
- 56:17ALL AND WE WILL BE FOLLOWING
- 56:19THIS ISSUE AS IT MOVES THROUGH
- 56:21THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY ON THE DAYS
- 56:23TO COME THURSDAY AND FRIDAY YOU
- 56:25CAN WATCH THAT ON-LINE AS IT
- 56:27HAPPENS AT KET.ORG.
- 56:29I'M RENEE SHAW I WILL SEE YOU
- 56:30TOMORROW NIGHT FOR KENTUCKY
- 56:33EDITION.