Latest / Resilient Kid: Therapy and tips for raising strong kids and teens / S10E9 - The Science of Small Things
Transcript
- 0:00It's Mental Health Week and I want to start by saying
- 0:04something that might surprise you.
- 0:06This episode is not going to tell you to do more.
- 0:09It's not going to give you a 17 step programme.
- 0:12It's not going to suggest you download an app, a book, a
- 0:16course overhaul the way you parent or teach.
- 0:19It's not going to add to the already very long list you feel
- 0:25like you should be doing and aren't quite managing it.
- 0:29In fact, it's going to do the opposite.
- 0:31Because one of the most important things that research
- 0:35tells us, and we're going to get into the science today properly
- 0:39because it's fascinating and is really hopeful, is that the
- 0:44things that most protect children's mental health are not
- 0:47the big things. They're not the grand gestures
- 0:50or the perfectly crafted conversation or the very
- 0:54expensive interventions. They're the small things, the
- 0:58ordinary things, the things that most of you parents, educators,
- 1:04the people who love children and who show up for them every
- 1:08single day, are already doing without realising it counts.
- 1:14The problem is, nobody told you it counted.
- 1:18Nobody handed you the research and said that thing you did this
- 1:22morning, that quiet thing, that unremarkable Tuesday morning
- 1:26thing, or I should probably should say Thursday, that is
- 1:30doing something in your child's brain and body that will stay
- 1:34with them. So that's what today's about the
- 1:37science of the small and why in a world that keeps telling us
- 1:41that we need to do more, the most powerful thing we can offer
- 1:45a child is the simplest thing we can imagine.
- 1:49If you're new here, I'm Ashley Costello.
- 1:51This is the Resilient Kid podcast and this is our Mental
- 1:54Health Week episode. Why we got this wrong.
- 1:59Before we get into what works, I want to spend a moment on why
- 2:03we've been looking in the wrong direction.
- 2:06Children's mental health is rightly a national conversation.
- 2:10Right now, the stats are sobering.
- 2:14We are looking at one in six in England between the ages of five
- 2:19and six, which meet the criteria for a probable mental health
- 2:23condition. That's five children in every
- 2:26classroom of 30. Referrals to CAHMS, the Child
- 2:31and adolescent Mental Health Service, have been increased
- 2:33dramatically in the years since the pandemic.
- 2:36Waiting lists in many areas stretch over a year.
- 2:40And I want to just add a caveat here.
- 2:44So I live up north, very proud Northerner, lots of friends,
- 2:48lots. I've done lots of work down
- 2:49South and up north is one of the reasons, not just because I live
- 2:54here, it's one of the reasons we started our franchise up in the
- 2:58north, because that number one in six, it's one in five in the
- 3:03North. And I suggest the one in six.
- 3:07That's not a true indication either.
- 3:10I think it's probably lower than that.
- 3:12So in response to this crisis we have understandably with the
- 3:17best of intentions, looked for big solutions.
- 3:22We have looked for massive programmes, whole school
- 3:28approaches and to be fair, I have a whole school approach.
- 3:33We look at resilient schools, we earmark schools that need a
- 3:37helping hand. There are awareness campaigns,
- 3:41there are workshops. They are resources, all of which
- 3:44have value and none of which are wrong.
- 3:48But somewhere in the search for that big solution, we started to
- 3:51overlook something. Something that the research has
- 3:54been quietly, consistently pointing to for decades.
- 3:59Something that doesn't require a budget or a referral or a
- 4:03training day. Everyday protective factors, the
- 4:07small, the repeated, the ordinary interactions between
- 4:11child and adults who love them and care for them, that build
- 4:17brick by brick, day by day. The neurological and emotional
- 4:22architecture of a resilient mind.
- 4:26If we look at the research on adverse child experiences, or
- 4:30Aces as we call them, the landmark A studies which we'll
- 4:35come back to tells us that stress and trauma in childhood
- 4:39have real measurable effects on the developing brain.
- 4:43And what's the same body of research also tells us.
- 4:47And what gets talked about far less is the protective
- 4:50relationships have an equal, real, equally measurable counter
- 4:56effect. So every small moment of safety,
- 5:00of warmth, of being seen and heard, it doesn't just feel
- 5:05good, it does something in the brain, in the body, and in the
- 5:10developing nervous system of a child or a team.
- 5:14Those moments are available to every single one of us every
- 5:19single day. So let's have a look at the
- 5:22science behind what small things actually do.
- 5:27Let's really dig deep into the research.
- 5:31Once you understand what's actually happening in a child's
- 5:34brain during these ordinary moments, you'll never look at
- 5:37them the same way again. So let's start with the stress
- 5:41response. Every child is born with what
- 5:44neurosciences call the HPA axis, the hypothalamic pituitary
- 5:51adrenal axis, which is essentially the brain and body's
- 5:56alarm system. So when a child encounters
- 5:59something threatening, overwhelming, uncertain, this
- 6:02system activates stress hormones are released, primary cortisol,
- 6:07sometimes adrenaline too, and the body prepares to respond.
- 6:12And this is normal, this is healthy.
- 6:15And we know that GCSEs are going on up and down the country, Sats
- 6:21are going up and down country. Stress in small doses with
- 6:25support, builds resilience and it helps us focus.
- 6:30It's what researchers call tolerable stress.
- 6:34But here's the critical part. Here is where the adults in the
- 6:38room become the most important variable in this equation.
- 6:42There's some research by Doctor Charles Nelson at Harvard Centre
- 6:46on the Developing Child found that when a child experiences
- 6:50stress in the presence of supportive responsive adult, an
- 6:56adult who notices, who soothes, who Co regulates the stress
- 7:00response, has buffered. The cortisol spike is blunted
- 7:04and the nervous system returns to baseline more quickly.
- 7:09And over time, with repeated experiences of this kind, the
- 7:13child's own stress regulation system become stronger, more
- 7:18flexible, more resilient. The adult in that room is
- 7:24literally physiologically shaping the child's capacity to
- 7:29handle difficulty. And you'll hear me say this
- 7:33often, we are wired for hard things and the adult doesn't
- 7:38have to do anything dramatic. They just have to be there,
- 7:42present, regulated, themselves and noticing.
- 7:47This is what Harvard Centre calls the serve and return
- 7:50relationship. Like a game of tennis, the child
- 7:53sends out a signal, a sound, a look, a behaviour.
- 7:56The adult returns, It responds, acknowledges that back and
- 8:00forth, repeated thousands of times across childhood, builds
- 8:03the neural pathways that underpin emotional regulation,
- 8:07communication and resilience. We see this in babies, don't we,
- 8:12when they're first alert, just after they're born and they are
- 8:17looking for that serve and return.
- 8:19That's how they learn to speak and communicate.
- 8:23Thousands of tiny serves and returns is the architecture of a
- 8:28healthy mind. Now let's bring in the ACE
- 8:32research because this is where it gets really important.
- 8:37The Adverse Childhood Experience study, one of the largest
- 8:41investigations into childhood trauma ever conducted and I
- 8:45think it involves something like over 17,000 participants, found
- 8:50that experiences of stress, abuse, neglect, and household
- 8:55dysfunction in childhood have a profound long term effect on
- 9:00their physical and mental health into their adulthood.
- 9:05This research is often cited in conversations about trauma.
- 9:10What it cited far less is the equally robust finding about
- 9:14what protects children from those effects.
- 9:18Doctor Nadine Burke Harris, a paediatrician, researcher and
- 9:22one of the world's leading expert on childhood adversity,
- 9:26puts it simply The dose of adversity matters, but so does
- 9:31the dose of protection. A child who has a trusted,
- 9:35consistent adult in their life, who experiences warm
- 9:39predictability and felt safe, is significantly buffered against
- 9:45the long term effects of adversity, even significant
- 9:49trauma. The buffering agent is not a
- 9:52programme. It's a person showing up day
- 9:55after day in small, ordinary ways.
- 9:59And then there's a work of Doctor John Gottman.
- 10:03I've mentioned him before, whose research on what he calls
- 10:07emotional coaching has transformed the way we
- 10:09understand the parent child relationship.
- 10:12Gottman study has found that children whose parents
- 10:15acknowledge and validated their emotions, rather than dismissing
- 10:19or minimising them, showed significant better outcomes
- 10:23across every measure. Every measure of well-being.
- 10:26That's emotional regulation, social skills, academic
- 10:30achievement, physical health markers.
- 10:33How important is that? We look at academics all the
- 10:36time, but actually this is more than academics, more than their
- 10:41physical health. The intervention was not
- 10:44complex, it was this. When your child feels something,
- 10:49name it alongside them. You will.
- 10:53Something along the lines of you seem really frustrated right
- 10:56now. That sounds like it was really
- 10:59disappointing. You're not fixing, you're not
- 11:02solving, you're not redirecting. You're just naming, witnessing,
- 11:08being a witness, being present with the feeling rather than
- 11:11rushing past it. Children whose parents did this
- 11:15consistently were, in got man's words, emotionally intelligent.
- 11:21And emotional intelligence, the research shows, is one of the
- 11:25strongest predictors of long term mental health and life
- 11:29outcomes that we have one sentence named alongside them,
- 11:34repeated across a childhood. Small thing, small thing.
- 11:40So let's have a look at small things in practise.
- 11:45I want to get really practical now because the science is
- 11:48compelling, but I know what you're thinking.
- 11:50You're thinking fine, but what does that look like on a
- 11:53Wednesday morning when everyone's late, someone can't
- 11:55find the shoe, the permission slip was due yesterday,
- 11:58etcetera, etcetera. It looks like this.
- 12:01The 22nd hug. Research by Virginia Sattar,
- 12:06family therapist, pioneer in human connection, suggested that
- 12:10we need multiple meaningful touches everyday for
- 12:15maintenance, more for growth, more still for healing.
- 12:20Physical warmth, like a hug hand on the shoulder of ruffling
- 12:23somebody's hair, releases oxytocin both for the giver and
- 12:28the receiver of that physical warmth.
- 12:33It literally signals safety to the nervous system. 20 seconds
- 12:38is long enough to feel it. You have 20 seconds Even on a
- 12:43Wednesday morning when someone can't find their shoe.
- 12:46I have often when things are starting to get stressy or
- 12:51heated, I have gone stop, let's stop everyone and they'll all
- 12:56look as if it's got Oh my God, what's happening?
- 12:59And I got I just need a hug and they got all booked a bit.
- 13:03Please, just a hug, just a quick hug and I almost make it like I
- 13:08need it, but I also know they need it.
- 13:10In that moment. It brings us all back down,
- 13:13resets our nervous system. On the way out of the door I
- 13:17will often put my hand on my son's shoulder as he's leaving
- 13:21for school. Go mate and I'll keep it there.
- 13:25Go have a great day, I'll see you later.
- 13:28Another one, the transition check in.
- 13:32In moments of transition, the school run the school gate at
- 13:36the moment they come home, come through that door.
- 13:40These are neurologically significant.
- 13:44The brain is shifting States and these are the moments when a
- 13:48simple warm acknowledgment lands deepest not How was your day?
- 13:53Because that question has a wall built around it for most
- 13:56children, something smaller. Oh, lovely to see you.
- 14:01I've missed you today. Eye contact presents 30 seconds.
- 14:06You don't need to interrogate them.
- 14:08You don't need to ask a question.
- 14:10We've got into a habit of asking kids about their school day that
- 14:14will come. Just tell them you missed them.
- 14:17Tell them that you love them and save the questions for later.
- 14:22When they're chilled, when they're regulated, when they've
- 14:24had a snack, maybe when you're eating dinner together.
- 14:27Anything interesting happened today, any chat today, That's
- 14:32all it takes. Third one, the named feeling
- 14:36when a child is upset, overwhelmed, dysregulated.
- 14:41Before you problem solve, before you correct, before you explain
- 14:46why they shouldn't feel that way.
- 14:49Name what you seem really overwhelmed right now or that
- 14:54looks really hard one sentence that's all you need it tells the
- 14:59child you're in a world is real it's visible and it's not too
- 15:03much for me I can handle that you're dysregulated the single
- 15:08experience repeated across time is the foundation for emotional
- 15:15regulation. This one, I think sometimes as
- 15:19parents, after they've got out of the toddler's stage, we, we
- 15:26rebel. I was trying to think of the
- 15:27word we rebel a little bit against their predictable
- 15:31ritual, whether it's bedtime, breakfast, the same song in the
- 15:36car, a joke that only your family understands.
- 15:40Rituals, particularly in families, and I would go so much
- 15:45as to say in class and neurologically soothing because
- 15:50they are predictable and the predictability is safe for a
- 15:54child whose nervous system is always to some degree asking
- 15:58what's next. The ritual answers that question
- 16:01before is asked, small, repeated, ordinary, profoundly
- 16:07regulating for them. So think about what is it that
- 16:12you do on a regular basis that is ritualistic in your
- 16:20household. For us, we have breakfast
- 16:24together before the day starts. Now this is not every single
- 16:29day, but if we are, I would probably say 8 out of 10 things
- 16:35like saying goodnight before they go to bed, that hug, kiss
- 16:42goodnight, love you, see you tomorrow, see you in the
- 16:45morning, all of that. They are predictable rituals
- 16:49that just help the brain and the nervous system feel safe.
- 16:54This is your safe space, the repair.
- 16:59This is the one for parents and teachers who we all are human.
- 17:05We all get it wrong. We know we can mess up, but if
- 17:12we get it right, 30% of the time they'll still turn out OK.
- 17:17The research, particularly the work of edtronic, is on the
- 17:22still face. Paradigm shows us that not the
- 17:26absence of rupture that builds a cure attachment, it is the
- 17:30presence of repair. Children do not need perfect
- 17:35adults. They need adults who, when they
- 17:37get it wrong, come back, say sorry, try again.
- 17:41The repair is the message, the relationship is stronger than
- 17:46the hard moment. You are safe here even when
- 17:50things go wrong. The repair, that 70% that we met
- 17:54up, as long as we've repaired it will still be OK.
- 17:59Just a moment from the work because I want to share you a
- 18:02little something from the work at The Resilient Kid that we do
- 18:06because all of this research is important, but I want you to
- 18:10hear what it looks like in a real family, in a real week with
- 18:13real pressures. We're working with a mum, I'm
- 18:16going to call her Sandra, whose son has been struggling
- 18:20significantly. Anxiety, can't get to school,
- 18:24nights when can't sleep, days when he can't leave the house.
- 18:27And Sandra was exhausted. She read everything, tried
- 18:30everything, felt like she was failing at everything.
- 18:34One of our sessions I asked her to tell me about a normal
- 18:37morning, just walk me through it.
- 18:40She described getting up, getting breakfast ready, trying
- 18:45to get her son downstairs, of the usual.
- 18:48She described the negotiation, the rising anxiety on both
- 18:52sides, she trying to get him out the door.
- 18:57Somehow standard was recognisable.
- 19:01It was hard. And then she mentioned
- 19:04something, almost as an aside, something she did every single
- 19:07morning without thinking about it.
- 19:09While the son was eating breakfast, she sat across from
- 19:12him, not on her phone, not making packed lunch, just sat.
- 19:16Sometimes they talk, sometimes they didn't.
- 19:18Sometimes they read something, sometimes they played a game.
- 19:22But she was there, present across the table, every morning
- 19:25without fail. And I said, Sandra, do you know
- 19:28what that is? She looked at me.
- 19:31So that's the most protective thing you could be doing.
- 19:34That quiet, ordinary, daily presence that is building
- 19:39something in your son's nervous system that no programme, no
- 19:43intervention, no waiting list appointment can replicate.
- 19:46And she cried, not because she was sad, but because nobody had
- 19:51ever told her that she was already doing what she was
- 19:55already doing was enough, and the small things she'd never
- 19:59thought to count. We're in fact, everything.
- 20:02We talk at the Resilient Kid about meeting young people where
- 20:07they're at, but we also meet parents where they're at too.
- 20:11And so many of the parents are exhausted.
- 20:13They're overwhelmed, and they're convinced they're not doing
- 20:15enough or that they're failing. This episode is me telling you
- 20:20you are doing more than the small things count and science
- 20:24says so. I want to just put in a little
- 20:28segment here for our educators, and I want to speak directly to
- 20:34them for a moment because everything I said applies to you
- 20:38just as much. Your version of the small things
- 20:41might look a little bit different.
- 20:43You might have 30 young people in a room and you can't be
- 20:47everything to everyone. I know that, but here is what
- 20:51research tells us about what a teacher can do that cost nothing
- 20:55and changes everything. Learn their name, Use it warmly.
- 21:00Don't be afraid to keep getting them to put name badges on or
- 21:07write a little what do you call it?
- 21:09Like a little card that has their name on.
- 21:12Keep that around. Research consistently shows that
- 21:18being called by name, not as a correction, not as a warning,
- 21:21but warmly impassing, activates a sense of being known and
- 21:25belonging that is neurologically significant.
- 21:28And it's easy to do notice the quiet ones.
- 21:33The children who present notable don't ask for anything and yet
- 21:42are still there. Quiet managing check in a quiet
- 21:49word. You OK?
- 21:51Today takes 10 seconds, and it can be the only moment in a
- 21:56child's day where the adult looks directly at them and
- 21:59choose to see them. Regulate even yourself first,
- 22:04because this is the hardest one. But Poly vagal research tells us
- 22:08that nervous systems are contagious.
- 22:11A regulated adult in the room regulates the whole room, even
- 22:16if there's thirty kids. When you are calm and you're
- 22:19present, when you're grounded, your children feel it in their
- 22:23bodies, irrespective of age. Before a word is said.
- 22:28Your state is the most powerful classroom management tool you
- 22:32have. Acknowledge the heart stuff
- 22:35without fixing it. When a child comes in carrying
- 22:39something heavy and you can often feel it even when they
- 22:43don't say anything, you don't have to fix it, just acknowledge
- 22:46it. Looks like today's a tough one.
- 22:50I've got you. And that is enough.
- 22:53And sometimes for some kids, that is everything.
- 22:57So it is mental health week. And every year Mental Health
- 23:01Week asks us to do more, share more, do more.
- 23:04And those things matter. But I want to leave you with
- 23:06this. The most powerful mental health
- 23:09intervention in a child's life is not waiting on a waiting
- 23:14list, does not require a referral or a diagnosis.
- 23:18It does not cost money, and it does not require you to be a
- 23:22therapist or a coach or to have read all the right books.
- 23:27It requires you to be warm, consistent and present.
- 23:31To name up to repair when you get it wrong.
- 23:34To sit across the breakfast table without your phone, to say
- 23:38good to see you and really mean it.
- 23:41To notice the quiet ones stay regulated when everything in you
- 23:46wants it to escalate. The small things are not the
- 23:49consolation prize. When the big things aren't
- 23:51available, the small things are. They think the science has known
- 23:56this for decades. It's time we are caught up.
- 23:59You are doing more than the breakfast table matters.
- 24:03The school gate matters. The name feeling matters.
- 24:08The repair matters. The 22nd hug matters.
- 24:15It all matters. Every ordinary, unremarkable,
- 24:19quietly revolutionary bit of it. Happy mental health week.
- 24:25Go home. Do the small things, but please
- 24:29know they are anything but small.
- 24:33Thank you for spending this mental health week with the
- 24:35Resilient Kid Podcast. If this episode resonated,
- 24:38please share it with a parent, educator, colleague, anyone who
- 24:42needs to hear that they are already doing well and it
- 24:47counts. All the research, references and
- 24:50further reading are in the show notes.
- 24:52But before we go, I'd just like to give a little shout out to
- 24:56Amy. I met Amy on a corporate job
- 24:59this week. And without going into too much
- 25:02detail, she said to me, do you know, I love listening to your
- 25:08podcast and I feel like it's changed my life.
- 25:11And Amy, lots of love to you and yours.
- 25:16And I just want to say, comments like that make it worthwhile.
- 25:21So thank you, thank you and thanks to all the listeners out
- 25:26there. Until next time, please keep
- 25:29doing the small things because they are everything.