Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / Why the Fed Is Debating Rate Hikes With Debt at 122 Percent of GDP
Transcript
- Lucas: So Cleveland Fed president Beth Hammack came out yesterday and said 'now is the time to act' on rates. And the market's initial read is that she means a hike, not a cut. That's a wild place to be in August 2026, with the federal debt sitting at roughly 39 trillion, which is about 122 percent of GDP. Luna: A Fed official openly talking about raising rates while the government is borrowing at 30-year yields near 5.2 percent? That feels like two trains heading toward each other. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just Hammack. The core PCE deflator — the Fed's preferred inflation gauge — came in at 3.3 percent annualized for July. That's well above the 2 percent target. So you have a central bank that's increasingly uncomfortable, and a Treasury that's increasingly exposed to what the Fed does. Luna: Let's put some numbers on that exposure. The 30-year is at 5.17, the 10-year at 4.64. Every basis point move on those yields changes the interest bill by billions. Lucas: Right. And the average maturity of the debt is around six years, so a lot of that higher cost hasn't even rolled through yet. The longer the Fed keeps rates this high — or pushes them higher — the more the Treasury pays when it refinances. It's a feedback loop that a lot of people in the bond market are starting to talk about in very blunt terms. Luna: But isn't the Fed's mandate just price stability and maximum employment? Why should they care about the debt? Lucas: Because the fiscal situation feeds back into monetary policy. If the debt is growing faster than the economy, investors demand a higher term premium to hold long-dated Treasuries. That pushes up yields, which tightens financial conditions, which does the Fed's job for them — but in a messy way. And if the Fed has to hike to fight inflation while the Treasury is flooding the market with supply, you get a real collision. Luna: So Hammack's comment isn't just about inflation. It's about credibility. If the market thinks the Fed will blink because of the debt, then inflation expectations drift up, and that's even worse. Lucas: Precisely. And that's why her wording matters. She didn't say 'we might need to raise rates.' She said 'now is the time to act.' That's deliberate. She's signaling that the Fed is willing to look past the fiscal pain and do what's needed to bring inflation down. Luna: But what about the employment side? The July jobs report was soft. If the labor market is cooling, hiking rates would be a double whammy. Lucas: That's the tension. The Fed is balancing two risks. If they hike and the economy cracks, they get blamed. If they don't hike and inflation stays sticky at 3.3 percent, they lose credibility on their 2 percent target. And with the debt where it is, the fiscal cost of a mistake is bigger than it's been in decades. Luna: So what's the actual trigger that would make them pull the trigger? Is it another hot inflation print, or is it something else? Lucas: Probably a combination. If core PCE stays above 3 percent for another couple of months, and especially if the labor market doesn't collapse, I think you'll see more officials move toward Hammack's position. The market is pricing in maybe a 40 percent chance of a hike by December. That's not nothing. Luna: And how does the Treasury Secretary's bond buyback talk fit into this? Because Bessent's been floating the idea of using the Treasury General Account to buy back long-dated debt. Lucas: That's the other part of the collision. If the Treasury is actively trying to smooth the yield curve by buying back bonds, and the Fed is simultaneously pushing yields up, you have the government effectively fighting itself. The Treasury tries to cap long-term borrowing costs; the Fed tries to raise short-term rates to cool inflation. The signals get muddled. Luna: So who wins? The bond market, I guess, because it just watches both sides and prices in the confusion. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why the 30-year yield is already at 5.17. It's not just about inflation expectations. It's about supply, term premium, and the risk that monetary and fiscal policy are working at cross purposes. That's a dangerous cocktail. Luna: And it's interesting because a lot of retail investors might be looking at 5.2 percent on the long bond and thinking 'great yield, safe asset.' But they're not thinking about the fiscal feedback loop that's driving it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the kind of nuance we try to bring to the show every day. Speaking of which — if this kind of analysis has helped you make sense of the economy, a small group of listeners already chips in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what keeps this podcast ad-free and independent. No corporate sponsors, no agenda. Just the two of us and the numbers. Luna: Yeah, it's a model that works because it's listener-funded. And we appreciate every single one of you who's part of that. Lucas: Anyway, back to the collision. The other thing to watch is the Treasury's quarterly refunding announcement, which is coming up in early September. That's when they lay out their borrowing plans for the next quarter. If they have to increase auction sizes again, that's more supply hitting the market just as the Fed might be tightening. Luna: And more supply means higher yields, which means higher interest costs. The debt clock just keeps ticking. Lucas: Right. The interest on the federal debt is now running over 1.1 trillion dollars a year. That's more than the defense budget. And every rate hike makes that number bigger. So when Hammack says 'now is the time to act,' she's not just talking about inflation — she's implicitly accepting that the fiscal cost of that action is going to be significant. Luna: But isn't there an argument that raising rates could actually help the debt by anchoring inflation expectations and keeping term premia from blowing out? I've heard that from some economists. Lucas: There is a version of that argument. If a credible hike today prevents a bigger inflation problem tomorrow, then long-term yields might actually come down because investors believe the Fed is serious. That's the 'pain now, gain later' scenario. But it only works if the hike actually does bring inflation down. If it doesn't, you're just adding to the debt with no benefit. Luna: Given the current data, what's your gut feeling? Do they actually hike, or does this turn out to be more talk than action? Lucas: My honest take is that they'll probably stay on hold through the September meeting, but the risk of a hike in November or December is real. The Fed likes to move gradually, and they already cut a lot in 2025. If core inflation doesn't show a clear downward trend by October, I think they'll feel compelled to act. The market is not fully pricing that in, which is why long yields are so elevated. Luna: So the bond market is essentially saying 'we don't believe the Fed will do what it takes,' and that's why the term premium is so high. Lucas: Exactly. The 10-year term premium — the extra compensation investors demand for holding long-term bonds — has been creeping up for months. In August it's been hovering around 50 to 60 basis points. That's a massive shift from the negative term premia we saw in the 2010s. It's the market's way of saying 'we're not comfortable with the fiscal path.' Luna: And that directly feeds into the debt spiral. Higher term premium means higher yields, which means higher interest costs, which means more borrowing, which pushes the term premium even higher. Lucas: That's the loop. And it's not just a US phenomenon. You're seeing similar dynamics in other large economies, but the US is unique because the dollar is the world's reserve currency. That gives us a little more room, but it's not infinite. At 122 percent debt to GDP, we're in territory where other countries have started to lose market confidence. Luna: Are there any historical parallels that give you hope? Like post wwii, when the US had debt over 100 percent of GDP and managed to grow out of it? Lucas: That's the classic example. In the late 1940s, we had debt to GDP around 106 percent. And we grew out of it through a combination of strong growth, inflation, and financial repression — keeping real rates negative for a long time. But the situation today is different. We don't have the same growth tailwinds, and we don't have the ability to suppress rates the way we did back then, because the Fed is independent and the market is much more integrated globally. Luna: So no painless way out. It's either growth, inflation, or some kind of restructuring — and none of those are easy pills to swallow. Lucas: Right. And that's why the next few months are so consequential. If the Fed hikes and the economy holds up, maybe we get a soft landing and the debt stabilizes. But if the economy cracks, we could be looking at a recession with high debt and limited fiscal room to respond. That's the nightmare scenario for policymakers. Luna: Bottom line for our listeners? What should they be watching in the next few weeks? Lucas: Three things. First, the August jobs report on September 4th. If it's strong, that green lights a hike. If it's weak, the Fed might hold off and the market will get messy. Second, the next core PCE print in late September. Third, the Treasury's quarterly refunding announcement on September 3rd. Those three things will tell us a lot about where yields are heading for the rest of the year. Luna: And for anyone who wants to navigate that, staying informed is half the battle. We'll be here every day breaking it down. Lucas: That's the plan. The debt story is going to be with us for a long time, but the decisions made in the next few months will shape how ugly it gets. Thanks for listening, and we'll be back tomorrow.