Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / A Biography Of A Mountain Mt Rushmore From Historian Matthew Davis
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Hey wanna thank you for supporting all of my podcasts,
- 0:02all seventeen of them, and now they are centrally located.
- 0:06You don't have to go to a digital platform going
- 0:08what did he say? Just go to Aero dot net,
- 0:10a r roe dot net and enjoy. Thank you so
- 0:14much for all your love and support. Matthew Davis. I
- 0:17wish I would have had this book back in the
- 0:19latter part of the nineteen sixties when I was studying
- 0:21Mount Rushmore in the state of Montana, because this book
- 0:24right here is more than I ever wish I could
- 0:26ever have as a child. And you have no idea
- 0:29what you're doing to my imagination.
- 0:32Speaker 2: That's great, that's great. To hell, thanks for having me
- 0:34on aara.
- 0:35Speaker 1: Oh my god, where did you dig up all this information?
- 0:37Because there's just so much about this and the people
- 0:40and the and the inner battles and the challenges and
- 0:43oh my god. I mean it's like you really go
- 0:45to town on.
- 0:46Speaker 3: This westward expansion, our relationship to indigenous communities, our search
- 0:51for gold, you know, our creativity or ambition. These these
- 0:54code words are important words like democracy and freedom. They
- 0:58all sort of come together in Mount rush More and
- 1:00it really allowed me as a writer a lot of
- 1:04leeway to explore different kinds of topics and issues.
- 1:08Speaker 1: I would love to see your notes though, I really would, Matthew,
- 1:10because I want to see how you put this together
- 1:12in the way that you do it in chronological form.
- 1:15But at the same time, you're allowing me to see
- 1:17the future. And I don't know if it's because as
- 1:18a reader, I know the future.
- 1:22Speaker 2: Yeah, well, thank you for that.
- 1:23Speaker 3: I mean, I think part of it is starting the
- 1:25book starts in July through twenty twenty and sort of
- 1:28then works its way backwards and then comes back out
- 1:30to that to the present day. And I think, you know,
- 1:33that's one of the things that I'm really hoping to
- 1:36get forward in this book is that the present really
- 1:39deeply influences the past. And what I mean by that
- 1:42is that how we think about the past today, you know,
- 1:46impacts and what's happening today impacts how we think about
- 1:49the past. And so, you know, as we as people,
- 1:51as we as Americans are celebrating our two hundred and
- 1:53fiftieth birthday, questions about how we got here. For me,
- 1:57the question of well, how did Mount Rushmore or get
- 2:00into the Black Hills really allowed me to look at
- 2:04the present day and then go backwards to sort of
- 2:06answer that question.
- 2:08Speaker 1: Well, I mean, my father useduld call the Mount Rushmore.
- 2:10He said, yeah, we don't have to go to Saint
- 2:12Louis to see the arch. When you want to get
- 2:14into the real wild West, it starts at Mount Rushmore.
- 2:17Speaker 2: Was he wrong?
- 2:20Speaker 3: That's interesting. I have never heard that before. But I
- 2:22don't think he is wrong. I mean, I think that
- 2:24you have if you're talking about the wild West, Okay,
- 2:27what that conjures you're really talking I think about about
- 2:30sort of three things, Right, You're talking about gold rushes,
- 2:33You're talking about our relationships with indigenous communities, and you're
- 2:36talking about sort of this sort of individual lawlessness that
- 2:39sort of associated with the wild West. And I think
- 2:41all three of those things are deeply important at Mount Rushmore,
- 2:46and in particular, you know, the reason, the reason why
- 2:49the memorial is controversial, the reason why I think it's
- 2:52important to take a wide lens view of it is
- 2:55because of the land itself and our relationship, in particular
- 2:58with the Lakota Nation. Right, you had the United States
- 3:01and the Lakota signed a treaty in eighteen sixty eight,
- 3:04called the Treaty of Fort Laramie. In that treaty, the
- 3:07US basically sued for peace and gave the Lakota a
- 3:10lot of land which included present day western South Dakota,
- 3:13which included the Black Hills of South Dakota, which of
- 3:16course is where Mount Rushmore is today. And no sooner
- 3:19was that treaty signed than several years later it was
- 3:23violated after George Custer was defeated and the Battle Little Beecorn,
- 3:28the Battle of Greasy Grass as a Native Americans call
- 3:30it in your home state of Montana, the United States
- 3:33was enraged at this defeat and took over the Black Hills,
- 3:36breaking the treaty. And so that legacy is very present
- 3:39at the memorial today, and it's sort of a history
- 3:42that sometimes is there and sometimes it is not.
- 3:45Speaker 1: Please do not move. There's more with Matthew Davis coming
- 3:48up next. Hey, thanks for coming back to my conversation
- 3:51with Matthew Davis. You just said something here where you
- 3:55opened up my heart. Because nobody talks about the Greasy
- 3:58Grass of Montana because unless you have really done your
- 4:01homework and you understand what that area of history is
- 4:05all about. Man I commend you on that you understand
- 4:08where this process took place.
- 4:11Speaker 2: Thank you, I appreciate that.
- 4:13Speaker 1: But the thing is that you bring up Custer. I
- 4:16guess the angle that I had growing up in the
- 4:18state of Montana was I was on the Native American side.
- 4:21That's just who I am as a person, and so
- 4:23to see what was going on on that sacred land
- 4:25to this day, my heart is still going why there
- 4:29had to have been another place. But then again, in
- 4:32reading the book, I'm going, no, I think it was
- 4:33the perfect place, because this is if that ground was
- 4:36so sacred, then Mount Rushmore had to happen.
- 4:41Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 4:41Speaker 3: Well, I think one of the interesting things about why
- 4:44Mount Rushmore came to be in the Black Hills is
- 4:47that the story is more of an economic story than
- 4:50a political story.
- 4:51Speaker 2: I mean, I.
- 4:51Speaker 3: Think because people view the memorial itself as this very ambitious,
- 4:57giant monument. Many as soon that it was the federal
- 5:01government that said, you know what, We're going to build
- 5:03a memorial in the Black Hills. But really the idea
- 5:06was from a state historian in South Dakota, a guy
- 5:09named Doan Robinson, who was very attuned to the economic
- 5:14fluctuations of South Dakota in the nineteen twenties, and at
- 5:17that time, the state was going through a very difficult
- 5:19economic period, and Doan Robinson wanted to diversify South Dakota's
- 5:24economy away from agriculture and commodities, and so he had
- 5:28an idea to build a sculpture in the Black Hills
- 5:31that would attract car tourists that were beginning to grow
- 5:34around this part of the United States. And so he
- 5:36wanted to create sculptures in the Black Hills that were
- 5:39representative of the American West, like people like Custer, people
- 5:44like the Great Lakota Leader Red Cloud, people like Saka
- 5:47Joweyah who guided Lewis and Clark West, people like Lewis
- 5:50and Clark. So that was his initial idea and it
- 5:53was a way to drum up tourism. Now, when the
- 5:56idea came into the hands of the sculptor of Mount Rushmore,
- 5:59a men in guns Borglum, Yes, it completely changed and
- 6:02metamorphosed into a much more political project that I think
- 6:05has lasting resonance today.
- 6:08Speaker 1: I can't be the only one time kid who still
- 6:10sits there and looks at Mount Rushmore, going can they
- 6:13really fit another face up there? Or are we going
- 6:15to have to continue this story in another part of
- 6:17the country.
- 6:20Speaker 3: Most people you speak to will tell you that there
- 6:22is no room for another face on Mount Rushmore.
- 6:25Speaker 2: Geologically, it's just not possible.
- 6:27Speaker 3: And you know, I don't know if that means that
- 6:30it will never be attempted, but I think most people
- 6:33say that it can never be done.
- 6:34Speaker 1: Yeah, but do we have the time. Let's be honest, Matthew.
- 6:37We are the generation that wants everything right now. And
- 6:39you can look at Crazy Horse, which is still unfinished,
- 6:42and sit there and say, I mean, look, how many
- 6:44years have gone by.
- 6:47Speaker 3: Yeah, that's a great point. Crazy Horse Memorial is right
- 6:50down the road from Mount Rushmore, and that is an
- 6:52ongoing memorial that is still not completed, although it's under
- 6:55new leadership now and I think there's a lot of
- 6:57hope that it might get completed at some point. But
- 7:00even you know, in the way that Mount Rushmore was
- 7:02built in the nineteen twenties and nineteen thirties, it would
- 7:05be an entirely different process today. I mean, back then,
- 7:08there was no laser technology. There weren't even environmental studies
- 7:12that were done on whether it could happen. Gunsten Borgland
- 7:15the sculptor really had to act on faith to try
- 7:19to get this thing completed, and he ended up, you know,
- 7:22completing it, at least he didn't complete it to what
- 7:25he had originally envisioned.
- 7:26Speaker 2: But the four faces stand today.
- 7:29Speaker 1: You know, I are you getting speaking engagements there at
- 7:32Mount Rushmore, and I would love to see you even
- 7:34at Battle of the Little Big Horn, that monument there.
- 7:36And the reason why is because all of this is connected,
- 7:39and that's what people need to understand. It's all connected
- 7:43together in history.
- 7:45Speaker 2: It is all connected together in history.
- 7:47Speaker 3: And that's one of the things I try to do
- 7:48in my book, A biography of a mountain is really
- 7:50sort of with this through line, show how the memorial.
- 7:53Speaker 2: Came to be. I will be speaking in South Dakota.
- 7:56Speaker 3: I will not be at the actual memorial itself, but
- 7:59I'll be doing a couple of events in Rapid City.
- 8:00Speaker 2: I would love to come to the bat a little big.
- 8:02Speaker 3: Corner to Montana and speak there as well, because I think,
- 8:06you know, obviously that story what happened on that battlefield
- 8:09is absolutely crucial to the story of Mount Rushmore.
- 8:12Speaker 1: Gerard Baker, we don't hear much about this guy. Hopefully
- 8:15they're talking about him there because I mean, this guy
- 8:17was the first. But does everybody know his.
- 8:20Speaker 2: Name Gerard Baker? No? No one. I mean I wouldn't
- 8:24say no.
- 8:24Speaker 3: People know Gerard bag people within certain communities in the
- 8:27National Park Service, and Native Americans know Gerard Baker. But
- 8:31he was the first. He was the first Native American
- 8:33superintendent of Mount Rushmore. And he was the one that
- 8:36introduced a lot of different Lakota themes, Native American themes
- 8:40to the memorial that still continue today, and that really
- 8:43expanded the story of Mount Rushmore.
- 8:46Speaker 1: Wow, where can people go to find out more about you, Matthew,
- 8:49Because I want them to dive into your research because
- 8:52you get it. You understand the process of preservation in
- 8:55this nation.
- 8:58Speaker 3: The best way to reached me is to go to
- 8:59my website matthewdaviswriter dot com and you can find all
- 9:03different ways to interrupt with me there.
- 9:04Speaker 1: Well, you got to come back to this show anytime
- 9:06in the future, dude. I mean, heck, I'd like to
- 9:08meet you out there in Montana where we could just
- 9:09go for a walk.
- 9:11Speaker 2: That would be great. It can have me on any
- 9:13time or I really appreciate it.
- 9:14Speaker 1: Man, Will you be brilliant today.
- 9:16Speaker 2: Okay, thank you, appreciate it.