Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Beyond Borders: The Role of Law in a Changing World with Professor Gary Meyers
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, illuminating the human
- 0:06side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and we discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:22Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating
- 0:24the Human Side, the podcast that breaks barriers,
- 0:27challenges the status quo, and uncovers the human
- 0:29stories behind science, policy, and the fight
- 0:32for our planet. Today, we explore the intersection
- 0:36of law, conservation, climate change, and rights,
- 0:39both human and non -human. Our guest, Professor
- 0:42Gary Myers, is a leading expert in environmental
- 0:45law, indigenous land rights, and natural resource
- 0:48governance. Currently based at James Cook University,
- 0:52with a career spanning the U .S. and Australia,
- 0:55he has shaped legal frameworks addressing some
- 0:58of today's more pressing environmental changes.
- 1:01A JETIS doctor graduated from the University
- 1:03of Wisconsin -Madison, Professor Meyers has led
- 1:07groundbreaking legal research, including directing
- 1:09the Center for Mining, Energy, and Natural Resources
- 1:13Law. His work has strengthened indigenous land
- 1:16rights, redefined ecosystem protections, and
- 1:19expanded the public trust doctrine, a key legal
- 1:23tool now being used to make wildlife conservation
- 1:25and government responsible. Gary, welcome. Thank
- 1:29you very much. To start, can we talk a little
- 1:33bit about how the law has evolved to recognize
- 1:36the intrinsic values of ecosystems behind human
- 1:40use? Can you give us a little bit of a background
- 1:42of that? About the law and the recognition of
- 1:46treaties, generally speaking. Is that what you're
- 1:48saying? Yes, so it's like how the intrinsic value
- 1:51of ecosystems goes behind the human use. The
- 1:58interesting thing about treaties and international
- 2:01law in general is it's distinct from the domestic
- 2:05legal systems that we live with because everything
- 2:09in international law depends upon consent as
- 2:14opposed to... domestic legal systems. There's
- 2:18a parliament or a Congress, what have you. It
- 2:20passes laws. It doesn't check with you to see
- 2:23if you want to be bound by the law. It just passes
- 2:26laws and you are bound by the law. And the same
- 2:29thing is true when the law is enforced. You know,
- 2:31if you disobey the law, if you speed or something
- 2:35and they pull you over and they give you a ticket,
- 2:37you're expected to go to court. You don't get
- 2:40to say, well, I'm too busy today. I'm not coming
- 2:43to court. But in international law, as I tell
- 2:46my students, the magic word is consent, consent,
- 2:49consent. Every treaty that a country signs is
- 2:53an act of consent to be bound by that law. And
- 2:57then if there's a problem and you're seen to
- 3:01be not complying with the treaty, again, there's
- 3:05no police force. They're not going to pull you
- 3:09up and say, well, here's your ticket. Please
- 3:11come to the court. But even if you get taken
- 3:14to a court like the International Court of Justice,
- 3:17there's the third consent. When you join the
- 3:22United Nations, you effectively agree to abide
- 3:25by the rules of the International Court of Justice.
- 3:28But if you don't show up to argue your case,
- 3:31that's okay. They can't make you show up and
- 3:34argue your case. On the other hand, for example,
- 3:39there's a case of Nicaragua versus the U .S.,
- 3:41the U .S. mined Nicaraguan waters. And the U
- 3:44.S. said, well, I'm sorry, we're not coming today.
- 3:47And the court ruled anyway. U .S., you've got
- 3:49to take those mines out of Nicaraguan waters.
- 3:51And the U .S. said, maybe, maybe not. So it's
- 3:56consent, consent, consent. You've got to show
- 3:59up and you're supposed to abide by the rules.
- 4:02It's a very different sort of legal system than
- 4:05the one that, you know, that the three of us
- 4:07are used to. You know, where we did the law.
- 4:10It's like a kind of kind of like a treaty, but
- 4:13at the same time, like a well, if I want to do
- 4:17it, I do it or not. Exactly. Exactly. I mean,
- 4:21the treaty is there. I mean, you look at currently
- 4:23you've got you've got a war in the Ukraine. You've
- 4:27got Russian invasion of Ukraine. You've got Israel's
- 4:30effective retaliation. I don't know what you
- 4:34want to call that situation in Gaza. Putin is
- 4:38facing two indictments from the International
- 4:41Criminal Court for not following the rules. Netanyahu
- 4:45is facing five indictments from the International
- 4:48Criminal Court. And yet, they're still walking
- 4:52around free as birds. Netanyahu went to the U
- 4:55.S. Now, if the U .S. had been a member of the
- 4:58International Criminal Court, they would have
- 5:00been obliged to arrest him and turn him over
- 5:03to the jurisdiction of the court. But the U .S.
- 5:05isn't a member of that treaty. And the same thing's
- 5:07true with, you know, with Putin. If Putin and
- 5:12what's his name, Rumpier, are supposed to get
- 5:14together at some point in time, you know, if
- 5:17that were to happen in the U .S., nothing. It
- 5:23limits, you know, neither Netanyahu or Putin,
- 5:25for that matter, can travel a whole lot these
- 5:28days. The only places they can travel are countries
- 5:30that are not members of the International Criminal
- 5:32Court, because those countries have to arrest
- 5:35them, whether they do or don't. Again, it's a
- 5:38question of whether you follow the rules. And
- 5:39if you don't follow the rules, there's really
- 5:40nobody there to, you know, hit you on the head
- 5:43and make you follow the rules. Yeah. And I guess
- 5:46that's like an ecosystem level and nature level.
- 5:50raise their awareness of trying to protect our
- 5:52land is going to have the same issue. Yes. Because
- 5:57internationally, well, a country can protect
- 6:01one part of their land, for example, but the
- 6:04other one can say, well, I don't follow the rules.
- 6:09So what are the tools that can be used to avoid
- 6:15this kind of issue? That's an extremely difficult
- 6:18question. And the answer is none of us know.
- 6:21The standard answer, you know, if you're teaching
- 6:23an introductory international law class or human
- 6:26rights law class or something like that, is this.
- 6:30Most countries follow most of the international
- 6:33rules most of the time because they want to be
- 6:38seen as good international citizens. You know,
- 6:41it's very rare, for example, for the UN Security
- 6:43Council to... Send a peacekeeping force to another
- 6:46country because you've got to get basically a
- 6:48unanimous agreement in order to do that from
- 6:51the Security Council. And so that's extremely
- 6:55rare. But if you look around, if you've got a
- 6:59relative in another country and you want to get
- 7:01on a plane and go see that relative, you can
- 7:03do that. When you get off, they're going to take
- 7:06your passport. They're going to stamp your passport
- 7:07and say, thank you very much for coming. If you
- 7:09want to go on to Amazon. and order a product
- 7:13from the US or the UK, you can do that. And you
- 7:19can pay with a card that you have in Australia.
- 7:23If you want to make a phone call to somebody
- 7:27in Kazakhstan, you can do that. And you couldn't
- 7:31do any of those things if international law didn't
- 7:33work because they all depend on international
- 7:36cooperation. So most of the time, most countries
- 7:40will follow. most of the rules. But beyond that,
- 7:44there's very little that can be done to, I mean,
- 7:47there are sanctions, there are economics, there
- 7:49are huge economic sanctions against Russia. At
- 7:52the moment, it doesn't seem to be making any
- 7:54difference. There are countries with sanctions
- 7:56against Israel. Again, it doesn't seem to be
- 7:59making a lot of difference. So sometimes the
- 8:01answer is, we don't know. Yeah, that is kind
- 8:05of terrifying, Gary, what you say, because I
- 8:08think that if people can't trust that there there
- 8:12are mechanisms that make this kind of agreements
- 8:16or treaties binding to to those countries or
- 8:20those governments that sign those treaties well
- 8:23people stop believing in this kind of institutions
- 8:27and i think it's pretty much the feeling that
- 8:30that is going around nowadays because well you
- 8:33see uh russia has you know the president has
- 8:38the these detention orders And he's rather president
- 8:41as well, but nobody cares. They are here and
- 8:44there. Maybe they don't go to some countries,
- 8:47but they decide pretty much which treaties they
- 8:50want to respect and which don't. So the trust
- 8:54of most of the citizens, I believe, in the world
- 8:58is pretty much being undermined under this scenario.
- 9:03Oh, I agree. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. It's
- 9:07very difficult. I mean, we are so tied economically
- 9:11that it's very difficult to get outside the economics
- 9:17and say, oh, look, you know, we don't want your
- 9:19grain. We don't want your beef. We don't want
- 9:22this. We don't want that. You know, you need
- 9:26to comply. And but those kinds of sanctions and
- 9:29like I say, the economic sanctions against Russia
- 9:32at the moment are very, very serious. And they
- 9:35managed to get around it. You know, they're not
- 9:37buying, you know, who did they buy weapons from?
- 9:39Well, they bought weapons from China. Who's helping
- 9:42them fight in the Ukraine? North Korea. Who else
- 9:45is supplying them with weapons? Well, interestingly
- 9:48enough, Israel is supplying Russia with weapons.
- 9:52Who's supplying the weapons to Israel? Well,
- 9:54that's the U .S. So, you know, it's so complex
- 10:00and so complicated, and we are so intertwined
- 10:03with each other. that it's very, very difficult
- 10:05to separate and really follow up on the sort
- 10:09of sanctions that would bring a country to heel.
- 10:12And then having said that, what have led to different
- 10:17changes in law that can make, I know that you
- 10:21mentioned before that there is a mutual agreement
- 10:23between countries, right? But then what have
- 10:27led to these bigger changes in law? If one country
- 10:32is bullying the rest of them, it's like, no,
- 10:34we have to agree in this and it can continue
- 10:38happening. So what is the push to get a change,
- 10:44to make a change in these kind of cases? I think
- 10:50the standard answer is this. The United Nations
- 10:53itself is flawed in a very, very serious way.
- 11:01192, 193 members. Each one of them has an equal
- 11:04vote in the General Assembly. But the General
- 11:07Assembly votes, the recommendations of the declarations
- 11:11that the General Assembly makes are what they
- 11:14call soft law. It's not binding. It's a recommendation,
- 11:20a serious recommendation, or it's a clear message
- 11:23that this is what most of the countries in the
- 11:25world believe ought to be occurring. But then
- 11:28you come to the Security Council and the Security
- 11:31Council comprised of 15 members. Five of them
- 11:34are permanent members. That's the U .S., the
- 11:37U .K., France, Russia and China. And any one
- 11:41of them can veto any measure that comes to the
- 11:43Security Council. And that's the huge that's
- 11:47probably the single biggest flaw. And it was
- 11:49set up that way right after World War Two. by
- 11:53the powers that were effectively the allied powers
- 11:56that run that war. And they preserved for themselves
- 11:59that ability to veto. So, and during the Cold
- 12:03War, you know, whether it was, you know, you
- 12:05had Russia on one side, the U .S. on the other,
- 12:08and then Russia and China on one side. And, you
- 12:10know, it's very, very difficult to get a unanimous
- 12:14vote. There are more peacekeeping forces today
- 12:17than there have ever been in the past. But, you
- 12:19know, they're located in Africa, for God's sake.
- 12:23and the Africans don't have a permanent member,
- 12:28so it's not as if they can jump in and veto anything.
- 12:31But during the height of the Cold War, there
- 12:34was only one peacekeeping operation that was
- 12:39sanctioned, and that was the Korean War. And
- 12:43the only reason that happened was because the
- 12:45Russian delegation went home on protest. That's
- 12:48no way to run a railroad. So that single flaw
- 12:53of individual member veto across the Security
- 12:57Council, correct that, and that will probably
- 13:00go a long ways to solving many of the problems.
- 13:04But it's not going to happen. Sorry. Sorry. Not
- 13:08going to happen. Pretty crazy because, well,
- 13:13trying to translate everything that we discussed
- 13:16so far to environmental things and this kind
- 13:21of stuff, I think that recently in Colombia we
- 13:24had the COP16 of biodiversity. And pretty much
- 13:28over there, the government said it was a huge
- 13:31success because they host the reunion and many
- 13:36leaders around the world went there. tried to
- 13:40figure out, but at the end of the convention,
- 13:43of the reunion, they didn't get pretty much any
- 13:47advance on the protection of biodiversity. And
- 13:51these kind of things happen a lot in these international
- 13:53scenarios. I think because of some flaws, like
- 13:59those that you were discussing. So I don't know
- 14:02if there is maybe other ways to try to advance
- 14:07in the laws that protect environment or that
- 14:11protect human rights that doesn't involve this
- 14:14kind of international scenarios that maybe aren't
- 14:18actually working out because of this kind of
- 14:22laws. Look, in environmental matters in particular,
- 14:26there are, I mean, there have been some huge
- 14:28successes. The, you know, the ozone treaty to
- 14:32the Montreal Protocol is a very, very significant
- 14:35success. But it occurred because DuPont discovered
- 14:40an alternative for chlorofluorocarbons. And,
- 14:43oh, the politics, the economics just sort of
- 14:47disappeared. We can do this. We don't have to
- 14:49put CFCs in the air anymore. So the ozone convention
- 14:52is working. But the politics, you know, even
- 14:55the climate change stuff is not bad. You know,
- 14:58many countries are meeting their obligations
- 15:00under the Climate Change Convention, the Kyoto
- 15:03Protocol, the Paris Agreement. Many, many countries
- 15:06are doing so. Australia is attempting to do so,
- 15:09and it's getting reasonably close. The U .S.
- 15:11was doing well. But then, you know, you've got
- 15:16a new administration and the new administration
- 15:18has renounced that agreement for the second time.
- 15:21Well, renounced it in 2018. Yeah, Biden rejoined
- 15:26in 2021 and and Rumpi version two has just pulled
- 15:32out of the Paris agreement again. So politics,
- 15:36huge potential constraint on the operation of
- 15:40international environmental law. Economics, again,
- 15:44a huge constraint. on the operation of international
- 15:47environmental law. But since 1975, every international
- 15:52environmental law treaty has contained a provision
- 15:54for financial and technical assistance to developing
- 15:59countries. That's why, to some extent, they're
- 16:02working. And then the science stuff gets in there.
- 16:05You know, everybody agreed that there was a problem
- 16:07with the ozone layer. You've got climate change
- 16:10deniers running all over the place saying, well,
- 16:12there's no climate change. Or it's not human
- 16:14-caused climate change. It's very difficult.
- 16:17And then you get a convention. I mean, you mentioned
- 16:19biodiversity. You get a convention like the Biodiversity
- 16:23Convention. There's one mandatory duty in the
- 16:26Biodiversity Convention. If you're going to do
- 16:29something in country A and it's going to have
- 16:32an impact on your neighboring country, country
- 16:35B, you have to do an environmental impact assessment
- 16:38and tell country B what you're going to do. Country
- 16:41B has no option. You can do it. Or not do it.
- 16:46Country B may be able to negotiate something
- 16:48with you, but there's no mandatory duty to mitigate
- 16:52your impacts. So the Biodiversity Convention
- 16:55is a tricky one. It's there. It's useful. But
- 17:01like I say, there's very little in the way of
- 17:03mandatory duties in that convention. Talking
- 17:06about legal rights of biodiversity. Why do we
- 17:10focus on animals, for example, that in the case
- 17:15of Australian animals are property, but they
- 17:18don't have legal rights? And to have legal rights,
- 17:22you also have legal obligations, right? When
- 17:25a kid or a child have legal rights, the obligations
- 17:30are different. Yeah. How does it work or how
- 17:34an animal or, for example, an ecosystem can get
- 17:37legal rights? Can you explain us a little bit?
- 17:40Well, they can. And I mean, we trace the I just
- 17:45I just had a student last year who did her honors
- 17:48in this area. And it related to indigenous people
- 17:53being able to name and provide legal rights to
- 17:56things like rivers and mountains, et cetera,
- 17:58et cetera. It began really with a with a piece.
- 18:02University professor Christopher Stone back in
- 18:041974, 75. wrote an article called Should Trees
- 18:09Have Standing? Since that time, there have been
- 18:12incidents of actually naming natural objects
- 18:19and giving them legal rights. There are two or
- 18:21three rivers, I think, in New Zealand that have
- 18:24legal standing, and they have guardians to protect
- 18:27them. There's an old U .S. case sometime, I think,
- 18:31in the 1980s called Palila versus Hawaii. The
- 18:34palila is a bird. It was an endangered bird living
- 18:37in Hawaii. And guardians for that bird went to
- 18:41court to protect it from culling by, or I think
- 18:45it was timber harvesting, by Hawaiian authorities.
- 18:48So it can happen and it can work. You know, if
- 18:52you think about it, it's not really particularly
- 18:55novel use of the legal system. Ships have legal
- 19:01rights. and corporations have legal rights. A
- 19:03ship can be sued. A ship can sue. A corporation
- 19:08can be sued, and a corporation can sue. A two
- 19:12-and -a -half -month -old baby has legal rights.
- 19:15Well, how do we know what a two -and -a -half
- 19:17-old baby wants? Well, we appoint a guardian,
- 19:19and it's the guardian's job to represent the
- 19:21baby's best interests. So it's not a huge leap,
- 19:25and I'm hoping that that... student of mine.
- 19:28She's now doing a master's. She's doing a master's
- 19:30degree, though, in English, and she's writing
- 19:32fictional stories about indigenous people naming
- 19:36natural objects and seeing how that works. And
- 19:40I think it's fantastic. You know, I'm glad she's
- 19:42doing it. It will broaden the scope of, I think,
- 19:46people's interest to look at it through fiction,
- 19:49for example, rather than thinking about it through
- 19:51the hard discipline of law. How this becomes
- 19:56a reality that an animal ecosystem have legal
- 20:00rights? So who can propose that? How can make
- 20:04it happen? Well, courts make it happen in certain
- 20:10instances when someone brings a lawsuit. I mean,
- 20:15the answer really is the same one as, you know,
- 20:17how do you know what a two and a half month old
- 20:20baby wants? Well, you go on. What is the best
- 20:22interest of that baby? That baby wants to live.
- 20:25It wants to be fed. It wants to be clothed. It
- 20:27wants to be warm. It wants to be loved. You or
- 20:29I, if we're the guardian of that child, we can
- 20:33represent that child's interest, his interest,
- 20:36her interest in a courtroom and argue for, you
- 20:40know, what is in the best interest. Now, think
- 20:43about a river, for example. What does a river
- 20:45want to do? Well, the river wants to flow. That's
- 20:48what a river wants. It wants to live, too. It
- 20:50wants to do what rivers do. It wants to provide
- 20:53habitat for fish. It wants to provide water for
- 20:57wildlife who need to come to the river to have
- 21:00a drink. And if you somehow poison the river
- 21:03and the wildlife can't come to the river and
- 21:05get a drink, well, that's not in the river's
- 21:07interest. I'm not perfect in any respect, and
- 21:12I might need to consult an ecologist, but, you
- 21:15know. We could get together, me, the lawyer,
- 21:17and him or her, the ecologist, and we could figure
- 21:20out how to go to court and say to the court,
- 21:22this is what this river wants. This is what this
- 21:25mountain wants. This mountain doesn't want you
- 21:27to strip its trees. If you strip its trees, it
- 21:30has steep slopes. And what will happen when the
- 21:33rain comes? Well, that mountain will lose those
- 21:35steep slopes because they will flow into the
- 21:37river below. And when they flow into the river
- 21:39below, what will happen to that river? Well,
- 21:41that river is salmon habitat. And if you block
- 21:43the river, the salmon won't be able to get up
- 21:45the river. I mean, it's possible for the human
- 21:50to represent the interests of the non -human,
- 21:53I think. That is very interesting, Gary, and
- 21:56actually a good example of a different way to
- 21:59try to protect these big issues like environmental
- 22:05assets. and animals, as Linda said. Also, thinking
- 22:09about that, I think this represents a good advance
- 22:14in these environmental law things in respect
- 22:18of the international things, but there are problematics
- 22:22that are transnational problematics, like you
- 22:25were talking about the war, for example, for
- 22:29the human rights, and also we have things like
- 22:33the climate change and... What happened in these
- 22:37things that are transnational and that we know
- 22:40that the laws are getting a little behind? Why
- 22:44can we have this kind of legal figures that cover
- 22:47protection for things in a wider way, maybe geographically,
- 22:55when we talk about different nations? Well, you
- 22:58guys aren't in the habit of asking easy questions,
- 23:00are you? And it's not an easy question. I think
- 23:05countries are, to some extent, like humans. They
- 23:10tend to act in what they think is their best
- 23:12interest. And every treaty that a country enters
- 23:16into reduces, to some extent, their sovereignty.
- 23:19That is their capacity to do what they've always
- 23:22done, because they have to give it up. It's like,
- 23:25you know, getting a group of kindergarten kids
- 23:29together and saying, OK, now you, little Johnny
- 23:32over there, I'm sorry, you're going to have to
- 23:35play fair with little Mary over here. And Mary,
- 23:38you're going to have to stop sticking your tongue
- 23:40out at little Billy because little Billy's getting
- 23:43upset. At some point in time, and it may not
- 23:46happen right there in kindergarten, but at some
- 23:48point in time along the line, little Johnny,
- 23:50little Mary, little Billy, they all learn to
- 23:53play together nice. And that's by giving up some
- 23:56of their sovereignty, what it is that they want
- 23:58to do. We're relatively young in terms of international
- 24:03law governance. There wasn't much in the way
- 24:07of public international law until the last century.
- 24:11We acted on the basis of custom. There was something
- 24:16called a just war. Well, a just war meant, well,
- 24:19yeah, you had a good cause and you thought you
- 24:20could win. That's not international law. So much
- 24:24of our international law, most of our international
- 24:27environmental law is sort of, you know, post
- 24:301960s. We had the whaling convention back in
- 24:33the in the late 1930s, early 1940s. But that
- 24:37that was about it. We had a bit of customary
- 24:40international law. There was a case in the 19
- 24:43in the 1930s called the Trail Smelter case. And
- 24:47Canada was doing something. Canada had a smelter
- 24:50by smelting iron or iron ore or whatever the
- 24:53heck it was. And the stuff was going up in the
- 24:55air, right? And out the smokestacks and then
- 24:57coming down on the forests in the Pacific Northwest.
- 25:01The U .S. took Canada to the international court
- 25:03and the court said, well, you can't do that.
- 25:06You can't do that. It's the good neighbor principle,
- 25:08you know, the no harm principle. But most of
- 25:11our international law, our treaty law is like
- 25:13I say, it's post 1960s. The Convention on International
- 25:17Trade in Endangered Species was 1973, I think
- 25:21it was. Ozone Convention was 1975, 1976. It took
- 25:2830 years to negotiate the UN Convention on the
- 25:33Law of the Sea. And once it was negotiated, it
- 25:35took another 10 years for people to sign up to
- 25:38it. So we're really only dealing with, you know,
- 25:40in terms of international environmental law,
- 25:4450 years. of trying to get people to cooperate
- 25:47together. And the same thing's true with human
- 25:50rights law. And in fact, it's less, 40 years
- 25:54for human rights law. And the International Criminal
- 25:56Court didn't come into being until 2001, I think
- 26:01it was, or 2002. This international law stuff
- 26:04outside of the business area, you know, you being
- 26:06able to get on the plane, show your passport,
- 26:08get on a plane, get off the plane, show your
- 26:10passport, and go see Uncle Bill, you know. That's,
- 26:15you know, that's the easy stuff. But the human
- 26:18rights stuff, the environmental law stuff, that's
- 26:21very, very different. Countries want to do what
- 26:23countries do. We have, for example, an almost
- 26:27recent case with climate change on the people
- 26:30forcing to migrate to other places because they
- 26:34live in islands. They start sinking. that, for
- 26:39example, we have and it hasn't been considered.
- 26:43It's like they mentioned recently in a paper
- 26:45that bears in the border with Mexico and U .S.
- 26:52were able to cross because of the wall. Yeah.
- 26:56And they don't have these boundaries. No. So
- 27:02this is like a forced migration, but also what
- 27:05are the legal protections for these communities
- 27:08and also these animals that is playing into a
- 27:14role now with climate change and with displacement?
- 27:18Again, your questions get trickier and trickier.
- 27:22There's no such thing, though, as an environmental
- 27:25right to refugee status. And every country knows
- 27:30that. If you want to be a refugee, you have to
- 27:34be in fear of – it's not economic conditions.
- 27:37You can't be an economic refugee. You can't be
- 27:39an environmental refugee. You can't be a refugee
- 27:43fleeing from – well, you can be a refugee fleeing
- 27:47from a country with a revolution if that revolution
- 27:51puts you in danger of persecution because of
- 27:55your religion or your race or your – social status,
- 28:00for example. That's all that gets you refugee
- 28:02status. Because, again, and that convention isn't
- 28:06particularly old either. That's 1953. Again,
- 28:10a post -World War II convention in which it was
- 28:13trying to deal with huge numbers of people that
- 28:15had, in fact, been displaced during World War
- 28:17II. But there's no such thing, I'm sorry, there's
- 28:20no such thing as an economic refugee. It just
- 28:23doesn't exist. It could. And countries do take
- 28:27large numbers of displaced persons because of
- 28:31both economic and, I suppose, political issues
- 28:37as well. But they're not going to end up being
- 28:40refugees. I mean, we could change that. I'm not
- 28:43saying we couldn't change the law. We could change
- 28:45the law and make it more possible for people
- 28:49to avoid those sorts of circumstances like climate
- 28:53change -induced. disasters, but we don't at the
- 28:57present. Yeah, I understand that we are lacking
- 29:01of a framework, a legal framework in many problems
- 29:06that we are facing today that are very recent
- 29:09for the law and in general for human conception
- 29:14of these problems, the climate change, the pollution,
- 29:20the immigration, the human rights. It doesn't
- 29:23have a framework because we are starting to realize
- 29:27pretty recently that there are pressing problems.
- 29:31And since they are very pressing, how do you
- 29:33think that we can move faster on creating these
- 29:37kind of frameworks locally and internationally?
- 29:40It's like dealing with, you know, little Billy,
- 29:43Mary and Johnny. We get these countries together
- 29:46and we indicate to them that it's in their interest
- 29:51to... take a concerted action, to give up some
- 29:55sovereignty, to make some sacrifices. And it
- 29:59depends, you know, on, in a sense, who's in charge
- 30:02and, you know, are there any economic incentives
- 30:07for countries to cooperate better? Or are the
- 30:10economic incentives there for people to, countries,
- 30:14in effect, to act selfishly, to protect their
- 30:18own particular interests? I think most of the
- 30:21time we can make good arguments that cooperation
- 30:25is the better route to go. I'll give you another
- 30:29example coming out of Australia. UNESCO, United
- 30:33Nations Education, Scientific, Cultural Organization,
- 30:36is the one that effectively manages compliance
- 30:39with the World Heritage Convention. We've got
- 30:43three sites here where I'm sitting. At the moment,
- 30:47I've got one site to this side, and I think that's
- 30:50the wet tropics, the World Heritage Area. That
- 30:55way, I've got the Daintree World Heritage Area.
- 30:58And this way, I've got the Great Barrier Reef.
- 31:01So we're surrounded by World Heritage. And so
- 31:04UNESCO came. It does its annual reports or not
- 31:08annual reports every five years, I think, for
- 31:10the UNESCO reports. And it comes and it recently
- 31:13came and it visited the Great Barrier Reef. And
- 31:16it was considered listing the Great Barrier Reef
- 31:18as in danger. And it's in danger largely due
- 31:21to climate change. The problem is for Australia
- 31:25is that Australia produces less than 1 % of climate
- 31:29change gases. It could cut all of its climate
- 31:33change gas emissions tomorrow, and the Great
- 31:35Barrier Reef would be in no better position than
- 31:38it is today. There are a couple of things it
- 31:40could do. It could stop agriculture or prevent
- 31:42or curtail agricultural runoff. But really, the
- 31:46big problem is China burning a whole lot of coal,
- 31:50the U .S. burning a whole lot of coal, India
- 31:52burning a whole lot of coal. And, you know, it's
- 31:55not their Great Barrier Reef. So we have to figure
- 31:59out a way to convince China, the U .S., India
- 32:01and the rest of the countries in the world that
- 32:03the Great Barrier Reef is, you know, is theirs
- 32:06in a sense. And it's worth protecting. And if
- 32:10we can do that. you know, we'll be better off.
- 32:14But as a species, we may just have a way to go
- 32:17before we actually get to that point of view.
- 32:21Maybe my daughter will get there. I don't know.
- 32:25It's like, for example, the International Treaty
- 32:28of the Protection of the Oceans. Yes. Some of
- 32:32the countries are on board, but then it's like,
- 32:36as you said, if we think that... It's a country
- 32:39thing that is not like a property. Yes. Like
- 32:42I know that's belonging to someone else. Yes.
- 32:45To all of us. I think that it would be a better
- 32:49case to protect them. Oh, I think you're right.
- 32:53And in fact, one of the things that I'm not sure
- 32:56the Oceans Treaty is live yet or not. I think
- 32:59that's still trying to gather. Yeah. Yeah. But
- 33:02the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea reverses
- 33:06an old. adage about the commons property and
- 33:09what was commons property. The old version of
- 33:12the commons is that, well, nobody owns it, so
- 33:15nobody can regulate it. The new version in UN
- 33:19Convention on the Law of the Sea is common heritage
- 33:21of mankind, and it particularly applies to seabed
- 33:25resources. And it says, well, those resources
- 33:27are common heritage of mankind. That means everybody
- 33:32owns it. Everybody can regulate it. And that's
- 33:36how Sea Shepherd operates. Whether you like the
- 33:39way that they operate or not, they operate on
- 33:41that basic principle. This is ours. It's our
- 33:44future, our heritage. And so we can go out and
- 33:47protect it. So there's some movement in that
- 33:49direction internationally. Now, I think Russia,
- 33:52China, and the U .S. have all objected to that
- 33:55section of the UN Convention on the Law of the
- 33:57Sea, but they're complying with the rest of the
- 33:58provisions. And again, it may take some time.
- 34:03It's just difficult. I mean, international law
- 34:05is difficult. Environmental law, even domestic
- 34:08environmental law is difficult. Getting states
- 34:10to cooperate back and forth in Australia, for
- 34:13example, with provision, getting them to sign
- 34:15up to restrictions on activities, whether it's
- 34:19coal mining in Western Australia or coal mining
- 34:21in Queensland. Any place there's money, it's
- 34:23just difficult. policy choice? I think so, yeah.
- 34:36I think it can. And we have imposed rules in
- 34:41terms of conservation. Australia, for example,
- 34:45has endangered species protection legislation.
- 34:49The U .S. has endangered species protection legislation.
- 34:52Most Western countries have it. And that includes
- 34:54protection of habitat. Australia is engaged in
- 35:00buying back water rights to preserve Rivers in
- 35:03the Murray -Darling Basin, you know, stretch
- 35:06from Queensland through New South Wales, Victoria,
- 35:09and empty out into South Australia. Every mine
- 35:15that is built in Australia or, for example, in
- 35:20the U .S., I know, there are requirements that
- 35:23the land has to be returned to as close as possible.
- 35:27It's what it was before it was mined. that may
- 35:32disperse species, but hopefully not. Hopefully
- 35:35they are protected. So, I mean, conservation
- 35:37has become a fairly binding, at least in the
- 35:40West, I would say conservation has become a fairly
- 35:43binding principle that you can't undertake activities,
- 35:46development activities, without engaging in,
- 35:49at least at some level of conservation. But again...
- 35:56You know, money talks, and economics can sometimes.
- 36:00I won't finish the money talks saying, but it
- 36:03does talk. And on occasion, maybe many occasions,
- 36:06the economics prevail over what's actually beneficial
- 36:10for the environment. Yeah, because in mining,
- 36:13the impact that they cause and returning back
- 36:17to normal is not an animal. I know, I know, I
- 36:21know. It's unrealistic. I have a question related
- 36:26with the Environmental Protection Act. I don't
- 36:29know how it works here. It depends. Is it federal
- 36:34or is it by a state? Both. Okay, so it's by choice?
- 36:43Look, every state has some form of an Environmental
- 36:49Protection Act. We'll maybe set standards in
- 36:53terms of the amount of pollution that can be
- 36:55emitted from a stack or be in effluent leaving
- 37:00a factory. But also that provides, more importantly,
- 37:03for environmental impact assessment before a
- 37:06project gets started. And so every state has
- 37:09that. And then on top of that, there's the Commonwealth
- 37:12Environmental Protection and Biodiversity Conservation
- 37:14Act. That act can be triggered by an activity
- 37:19in a state, even if that activity takes place
- 37:22on land that is not Commonwealth land, by what
- 37:27they call matters of national environmental significance.
- 37:30So any impact on a World Heritage Area is covered
- 37:34under the Environmental Protection Biodiversity
- 37:36Conservation Act. Any impact on, and most of
- 37:40it's international stuff. So migratory bird treaties,
- 37:43covered. Ramsar, protected wetlands, covered.
- 37:49Species listed under the Commonwealth EPBCA,
- 37:53covered. Something about nukes and I think fracking
- 37:56is now covered as well. So any of those sorts
- 37:59of impacts or any impact in those areas is covered.
- 38:03And if the impacts are potentially significant,
- 38:07you have to have an assessment. And the assessment
- 38:09has to go to the state. And then from the state,
- 38:12it has to go to the feds. And the federal minister
- 38:16can impose conditions or decide not to approve
- 38:20the project altogether. And the same thing is
- 38:23available at the states when you don't have commonwealth
- 38:27involvement. The states can do the same thing,
- 38:29impose conditions or say no to a project altogether.
- 38:35This is very, very interesting because, well,
- 38:38we talked many times over here that The laws
- 38:42exist and there are, as you said, in many Western
- 38:46countries, like robust environmental law. But
- 38:51always, as you also said, money talks. And there
- 38:54are ways to get around those laws. Many times,
- 38:59even for the corporations, they don't even care
- 39:01to pay huge fines after they made the impact
- 39:07or whatever. Even then, they can pay the fines
- 39:13or anything. Where are we failing there? Are
- 39:17we being too soft on enforcing these laws? Maybe
- 39:22the penalizations for not complying with these
- 39:26laws? Or maybe we are failing all the way in
- 39:29the economic system. There is a way to change
- 39:31this. Because, you know, everything seems to
- 39:37reduce. to is economics and politics, because
- 39:40the law is like a subject of those two in a way.
- 39:46Yeah, it is. It is. Look, I do think that in
- 39:50countries like Australia or the US or Canada,
- 39:54any number of the Germany, France, UK, any of
- 39:58the big Western countries, their environmental
- 40:01laws are pretty good. And it's not necessarily
- 40:04easy to get around them. But it can be done.
- 40:09And in some instances, you know, that getting
- 40:12done is actually facilitated by the political
- 40:15system. Back before I left the U .S., along with
- 40:19the National Wildlife Federation, we took the
- 40:23United States Forest Service to the federal court
- 40:26because they had failed to pair an environmental
- 40:29impact assessment on timber logging. This was
- 40:33in the Siusla National Forest in the state of
- 40:35Oregon. And we won. And they appealed. And we
- 40:39went to the United States Circuit Court of Appeals
- 40:42for the Ninth Circuit. And we won again. What
- 40:45happened after that? Well, after that, one of
- 40:49the Oregon representatives during the budget
- 40:51hearings introduced a measure that said, well,
- 40:54for the purposes of the National Environmental
- 40:56Policy Act, we will. confirmed now that the Siusla
- 41:01National Forest does not need any more environmental
- 41:03impact statements. And they put it on the budget.
- 41:06That was a budget rider. Everybody's interested
- 41:08in getting the budget passed. And it passed.
- 41:11So we lost. We didn't lose in court, but we lost
- 41:16in Congress. And it happens. And that's another
- 41:19one of, you know, the money talks. I'll say it
- 41:21again. You know, we're young. We're still growing
- 41:23into all this stuff. My big hope is that we manage
- 41:27to somehow grow into it before we've lost a planet
- 41:31that's capable actually of supporting us and
- 41:34a whole lot of other species. I mean, if you
- 41:36look at Western Europe, 95 % of their natural
- 41:40species are gone. It's gone. The U .S., Australia,
- 41:43a little bit better. Much of the natural world
- 41:45is just gone. Yeah, 70 % or even more. Yeah,
- 41:51yeah, gone. Yes. And then... Also, you mentioned
- 41:55that you work a lot in the public trust doctrine.
- 42:00That is a legal principle that holds that specific
- 42:03natural resources like air, water, and shorelines.
- 42:07Yes. And are held in trust in the government
- 42:10for a public use and benefit. That's true. How
- 42:15does your work expand the public trust doctrine
- 42:19behind this traditional scope? turning into a
- 42:23legal obligation for governments to protect entire
- 42:26ecosystems biodiversity and even specific species
- 42:30threatened that just waterways and public lands
- 42:33well it's interesting outside of common law countries
- 42:36like you know like the uk canada new zealand
- 42:39the us etc etc i don't know if there's a There
- 42:43is what you would call a public trust, but there's
- 42:45an old public trust doctrine that operates in
- 42:47the UK and that operates here in Australia and
- 42:50that operates to great effect in the US. It does
- 42:53require leaving those areas. It doesn't work
- 42:57so much on air, but it does on water. Navigation,
- 43:02fishing, wildlife protection, habitat protection
- 43:05that depends upon water. That's reasonably well
- 43:08covered in the US. We're getting there in Australia.
- 43:12I've referred to the public trust doctrine in
- 43:14Australia as a sort of a submerged doctrine.
- 43:17It needs to come out of the water and get a bit
- 43:19more amphibious. But yeah, it's there. But again,
- 43:22there's an old paper. Garrett Hardin wrote a
- 43:25piece called The Tragedy of the Commons. And
- 43:28the tragedy of the commons is that with common
- 43:30property, let's say you've got an area, Rose
- 43:34in England, you've got a parkland, a reserve
- 43:37or something or other, and everybody can graze
- 43:40their sheep there. I can graze my sheep. You
- 43:43can graze your sheep. He can graze his sheep.
- 43:45Is there any incentive for us to mitigate and
- 43:49cut back on the grazing so that there will be
- 43:52enough grass there so that we can graze our sheep
- 43:55next year? No, there is not. What's the incentive?
- 43:59The incentive is for me to get my sheep to that
- 44:02area as quickly as possible and they can eat
- 44:05as much of it as possible so I can make as much
- 44:07money. You don't count. That's the tragedy of
- 44:10the commons. you need to flip that notion that
- 44:14the commons doesn't belong to anybody, so nobody
- 44:17can do anything about it. Two, the commons belong
- 44:19to everybody. So we all have a role to play in
- 44:22preserving the commons. That's, you know, a matter
- 44:24of education and a matter of time, I think. Today,
- 44:28like kind of common spirit, I saw that that was
- 44:33like internationally, that the spirit maybe at
- 44:35the end of the 90s, beginning of this century.
- 44:39Because these, like, first world countries, so
- 44:44to speak, the US and Europe and north of Europe,
- 44:48they have policies and politics addressing, like,
- 44:53assistance to countries to protect biodiversity,
- 44:57to protect indigenous people, this kind of policy.
- 45:02But today, the political climate, it seems to
- 45:06be changing because... These countries are turning
- 45:10to a protectionism politics and to these kind
- 45:15of things we see in the recent U .S. elections
- 45:18and in many countries. Do you think there is
- 45:21place nowadays to evolve this kind of community
- 45:27sense in the country? Because it seems like it's
- 45:31essential to advance on these matters. Yeah,
- 45:35I do. think so. Again, I think it will take more
- 45:41time, maybe considerably more time, but I certainly
- 45:44did a piece back in the early 1990s looking at
- 45:49the question of commons and made the argument
- 45:54that the Amazon rainforest produces 50, 60 percent
- 46:00of the oxygen that we breathe. We breathe it
- 46:03here. We breathe it in the U .S. We breathe it
- 46:06where you are. And so we need to be treating
- 46:09the Amazon rainforest, in a sense, as a commons.
- 46:12Well, how do we treat it as a commons if Brazil
- 46:15and other countries want to harvest timber out
- 46:18of the rainforest? Well, the only way to treat
- 46:21it as a commons is for us to get together and
- 46:23say, look, we, the rest of the world, we're breathing
- 46:26that air. We need that air. We will pay you not
- 46:30to harvest the timber. So that we keep a resource
- 46:34that provides all of us around the world with
- 46:37oxygen. But again, it's a matter of, you know,
- 46:40you give up a bit of sovereignty. You recognize
- 46:42that, you know, acting on behalf of all of us
- 46:45is better than acting selfishly. You know, maybe
- 46:48we'll get there. Maybe. I'd like to think we
- 46:51get there. I hope so. Well, I mean, and that's
- 46:54a difficult question. You talk about environmental
- 46:56law, you talk about international law, you talk
- 46:59about human rights law. The answers are just
- 47:02not easy. I mean, for me, they're easy. I know
- 47:05what I would do if I was in charge. But, you
- 47:08know, I'm not in charge. Well, no, we don't want
- 47:12to hope that I'm in charge. What we're going
- 47:14to hope for is that the rest of the country sort
- 47:18of come together and get smart and work with
- 47:21each other. Yes. Thank you very much, Gary, for
- 47:25your time. Oh, you're welcome. Enlighten us.
- 47:30Tell us the truth. I don't know. Well, it was
- 47:33fun. Thank you very much for the invitation.
- 47:35As we bring this conversation to a close, one
- 47:38thing becomes clear. Law is not static. It is
- 47:42a living, evolving framework that both reflects
- 47:45and shapes our values. To Professor Gary Mayer's
- 47:48insights, we reminded that the battle for environmental
- 47:51justice, indigenous land rights, and the recognition
- 47:54of nature's intrinsic worth is not merely a legal
- 47:58debate. He's a human one. Science Behind the
- 48:00Glass is independently produced and edited by
- 48:03your hosts Linda Hernández and Daniel Esqueda.
- 48:05With the valuable support of our dedicated technical
- 48:08director Rafael Giordano and the original music
- 48:11by our colleague and friend Bernardo Aguilar.
- 48:14Stay connected on Instagram, Facebook and LinkedIn
- 48:16and TikTok. And visit our website for updates
- 48:20and stories. Don't forget to subscribe and share
- 48:23this podcast with your friends and colleagues
- 48:25to amplify these essential narratives. If you
- 48:27are moved by our mission, we invite you to make
- 48:30a contribution via PayPal. Simply click the Support
- 48:32Us button on our website. Your support is vital
- 48:36for keeping this project thriving. If this conversation
- 48:40sparked something new, keep asking questions.
- 48:42Challenge the boundaries. And remember, the law
- 48:45can be a barrier, but it can also be a bridge.
- 48:48Let's keep building. Until next time.