Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Handle a Mentorship That Has Gone Stale
Transcript
- Lucas: Listener question today, and it's one I think a lot of people feel but rarely say out loud: 'What do you do when your mentor has plateaued — and the relationship is holding you back more than it's helping?' Luna: Oof. That's a tough one. Because mentors are supposed to be these sacred figures — you're not supposed to outgrow them, right? Lucas: Right. But the data says otherwise. A study from CNBC and SurveyMonkey a couple years back found that 76 percent of professionals say a mentor is critical to career success — but only 37 percent say their current mentor is still helping them grow. That gap is huge. Luna: So most of us are walking around with a mentor who's basically a rearview mirror. They helped you get here, but they can't see where you're going. Lucas: Exactly. And the listener's situation is a perfect example. She's a senior product manager at a fintech company, been paired with a vp level mentor for eighteen months. The first six were great — she learned how to navigate org politics, how to present to the C-suite. But lately, every meeting is her giving updates and him saying 'sounds good.' No new strategies, no stretch assignments, no connections to people above his pay grade. Luna: So she's getting the cheerleader version of mentorship, not the challenger version. That's where growth actually happens — when someone pushes you into discomfort. Lucas: Right. So step one is diagnosis. Is the mentor actually plateaued, or have you just stopped asking the right questions? I tell people to run a quick audit: In the last three meetings, did you leave with one specific action that changed how you think about your role? If the answer is no three times in a row, it's time for a conversation. Luna: And that conversation — how do you even start it without sounding ungrateful? I had a mentor once who was amazing when I was an individual contributor, but once I moved into management, he kept giving me advice for a role I no longer had. I ended up ghosting him, and I still feel bad about it. Lucas: Yeah, ghosting is the worst option. It burns the bridge and leaves the other person confused. Better to frame it as an evolution. You say something like: 'I really value everything you've taught me, and I want to make sure I'm not wasting your time. I think my growth areas are shifting toward X — do you feel equipped to help me with that? Or should we think about how I can supplement this relationship?' Luna: I love that. It's not 'you're not enough,' it's 'my needs have changed.' And it gives the mentor a graceful exit if they're honest about their limits. Lucas: Exactly. And let's be honest — a good mentor will appreciate that. They'd rather know than keep having hollow thirty-minute coffee chats. The worst case is they get defensive, but if that happens, you already have your answer about whether the relationship was truly healthy. Luna: So what's the script if the mentor says, 'No, I can still help' — but then nothing changes? Do you give it another month? Lucas: I'd say two more meetings max. And in the second one, you add a little more weight: 'I appreciate you wanting to stay involved, but I'm not feeling the traction I need. Let's talk about how we can restructure our time — maybe shorter sessions, or a specific project focus — or if it's time to transition to a different kind of support.' Luna: So you're essentially giving them a chance to co-design the reset. And if they still don't deliver, you've given yourself permission to move on. Lucas: Right. And moving on doesn't mean cutting them off cold. You can downgrade the frequency — go from monthly to quarterly check-ins — and let the relationship become more informal. That's actually the natural lifecycle of most mentorships. Luna: I think the bigger question, though, is how do you avoid getting stuck again? Once you leave this mentor, how do you find the next one who won't plateau in another eighteen months? Lucas: That's the million-dollar question. And I think the answer is: don't look for one mentor. Build a personal board of directors. You need different people for different things — someone for technical skills, someone for political savvy, someone for industry trends. That way, no single person has to be everything. Luna: So it's like an ETF for mentorship — diversified, lower risk. I love that framing. Lucas: Exactly. And when you're looking for a new mentor, the best ones are often two or three steps ahead of you, not ten. A senior director who just made the leap to VP is going to have more relevant, actionable advice than a CEO who hasn't been in the weeds for a decade. Luna: Speaking of relevant — I want to bring up something that surprised me when I was making my own mentor shift. I realized I needed peer mentors, not just senior ones. People at my same level who were a year or two ahead in their trajectory. They understood my day-to-day struggles in a way my VP mentor never could. Lucas: That's underrated. A peer mentor can give you the 'how I survived that exact project' insight, while a senior mentor gives you the 'how this fits into the broader strategy' view. You need both. Luna: Alright, so let's get practical. Say our listener has diagnosed the plateau, had the conversation, and decided to move on. She's now mentorless. How does she find her next mentor without it feeling awkward or transactional? Lucas: First, she should make a list of three specific gaps. Not 'I need a mentor' — but 'I need someone who can help me build a business case for a new product line' or 'I need someone who's successfully navigated a re-org.' Then identify people inside or outside her company who've done that. Luna: And when she reaches out, what's the pitch? Because a cold LinkedIn message that says 'will you be my mentor?' is usually a no. Lucas: Yeah, don't lead with the M-word. Lead with a specific ask. 'I admired how you handled the X project. Could I buy you coffee and ask you three questions about how you approached the stakeholder management?' That's low commitment, high signal. If they say yes and the conversation goes well, you can say, 'This was incredibly helpful — would it be okay if I reached out again in a month?' You're building the mentorship organically. Luna: And if they say no or don't respond, you haven't lost anything. You just move to the next person on your list. Lucas: Exactly. And I'd also suggest she look for reverse mentorship opportunities. Maybe she has a skill — like AI tools or social media — that a more senior person wants to learn. Offering to teach something in exchange for their strategic advice is a great way to level the power dynamic. Luna: That's smart. It makes the relationship reciprocal from day one. Lucas: And that reciprocity is what keeps a mentorship from going stale. If both people are learning, the relationship naturally evolves. That's the goal. Luna: You know, we've been talking about the tactical side, but I think there's an emotional piece here too. Letting go of a mentor can feel like a breakup — you might feel guilty or like you're being disloyal. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why I think it helps to reframe it. You're not ending the relationship — you're changing its shape. A mentor who truly wants the best for you will be happy that you've outgrown their advice. That's literally the point of mentorship. Luna: I had a mentor once tell me, 'If you're still learning the same things from me a year from now, I've failed.' That stuck with me. Lucas: That's a great line. And I think it captures what we're really saying here: mentorship is a tool, not a trophy. It should have a shelf life. And the best mentees are the ones who know when to rotate their shelf. Luna: And if today's episode helped you think about that shelf a little differently, it might be worth a small gesture of support. We keep this show ad-free, and listener contributions are what make that possible. If you found value in this conversation, you can find the link at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a tiny ask for a lot of free advice. And it genuinely helps us keep the lights on. So thank you to anyone who considers that. Luna: Alright, back to the listener's question. One more thing I want to touch on: what if the mentor is also your boss? That's a different beast. Lucas: It's a much more delicate situation because the power dynamic is real. If your boss is your mentor and the relationship has plateaued, you can't just 'rotate' them. But you can supplement. You can say, 'I'd like to broaden my perspective — would you support me finding a mentor in a different department?' A good boss will say yes. Luna: And if they say no, that tells you something about your boss's view of your growth. That's useful information too. Lucas: Exactly. So to wrap it up for our listener: audit your recent meetings, have the honest conversation, build a diversified board, and don't feel guilty about outgrowing a good thing. That's the sign you're growing. Luna: And if you have a mentorship story — good, bad, or awkward — we'd love to hear it. You can reach us on the show's LinkedIn page or through the Fexingo network. Lucas: Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next time on Office Hours with Fexingo.