Latest / Show, don't Tell Writing with Suzy Vadori / 16. [Show, don't Tell Page Review] Memoir with Susan McKelvey
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to Show Don't Tell Writing with me, Suzy Vadori, where I teach you the tried and true secrets to writing fiction and nonfiction that will wow your readers, broken down step by step.
- 0:20This show explores writing techniques and shows you a glimpse behind the scenes of successful writing careers and coaches writers live on their pages so you can learn and transform your own storytelling.
- 0:31Whether you're just starting out crafting, editing, or currently rewriting your first book or maybe even your 10th, this show will help you unlock the writing skills you didn't know you needed but you definitely do.
- 0:45I'm looking forward to helping you get your amazing ideas.
- 0:48From your mind onto the page in an exciting way for both you and your readers so that you can achieve your wildest writing dreams while having fun doing it.
- 0:58Let's dive in.
- 1:02I am so excited to welcome to the show today, Susan McKelvey, who has been working on a memoir that is about grief for the husband that she lost.
- 1:13I first met Susan about six months ago.
- 1:15She took a course for me, the developmental editing mentorship.
- 1:18And her spirit and her resilience and all the things, her humor, sense of humor just absolutely amazed me.
- 1:27She brought with her the first draft of her book, which was really uniquely written in second person.
- 1:35And, you know, just, it was stuff that she started to write down when she wanted to yell at her husband or she wanted to get comfort from her husband and he wasn't there.
- 1:43And so it's written in that second person.
- 1:45You voice and it's just so very Susan.
- 1:49I can't wait to have you meet her on this podcast episode.
- 1:54And to talk about this one page that she has brought with her that she knew was such an important moment in the book, and she knew that she was telling.
- 2:06And so she brought it to me to give her some feedback.
- 2:09And yeah, there's a lot of things in that page that are really glossed over that could use a little bit more showing.
- 2:16So here's the page, I'm going to read the page for you and then we're going to meet with Susan and talk about it.
- 2:22So I hope that this helps you with your own writing and really makes it clear to you where you can take things that are really hard or those pages where you just know that they could be better and you're not sure how.
- 2:35Take these examples and see what you can do with your own work.
- 2:38Happy writing.
- 2:40So here's the page that Susan submitted for the Show Don't Tell podcast that we're about to discuss.
- 2:47Chapter 16, the transition.
- 2:51So now I found myself again, my Sue ism, the fun me, the confident me, the one you loved and I was actually proud of.
- 3:02What I realized was that there was a greater part of my healing that I had not yet embraced.
- 3:07I kept it hidden somehow in my sorrow so deep.
- 3:10That it was nowhere in my journey.
- 3:13I stayed at our son's home in Virginia a few weeks ago, and I was in the bedroom that you and I shared together when we visited him.
- 3:20I was lying there and I got overwhelmed in sadness.
- 3:24Suddenly, a residual of tears began to flow.
- 3:27Tears that had been dormant, hiding all this time from the storm of grief, trying to find their way out.
- 3:34Somehow, now, they surrendered.
- 3:38I was shaking, lost in a tsunami of tears that would not stop.
- 3:43I wondered why, after all this time and all my progress in healing, that I was yet again filled with sadness.
- 3:49Then I realized that this last step in my journey with grief was incomplete.
- 3:55I have found me.
- 3:56And transformed into the new version of myself, but I realized that the transition of being matriarch for our whole family alone without you to help me left me terrified and lonely again.
- 4:09With the myotonic dystrophy disease that infested our family, I was frozen in the bed, knowing that I will have to face it all alone.
- 4:17And that was too much to bear.
- 4:19I was so focused on trying to find me that I refused to realize that the dynamic of our beautiful family had changed since you are gone.
- 4:28Everything feels off.
- 4:30It's like the magic is gone.
- 4:32We need each other more than ever, but somehow push each other away.
- 4:36I am the glue, and I struggle without you to make it stick.
- 4:40Like every great family, we are perfectly unperfect.
- 4:43But now I'm the family's sole help, sole guidance.
- 4:47I love them all so much, it's terrifying to know that I must deal with all their worries alone.
- 4:52You manage the family issues so differently.
- 4:55You never got upset, but I, on the other hand, caught up in the chaos.
- 5:00In those moments, I miss you the most of all.
- 5:08Welcome, Susan.
- 5:09I am so excited to see you.
- 5:12Me too.
- 5:13I was so glad to see you again last week because it brought everything back.
- 5:17It got me inspired again over there.
- 5:20Oh, amazing.
- 5:20Did you come to a live session?
- 5:22Is that what you did?
- 5:22Did you come to the retreat?
- 5:24Yes.
- 5:25Both of those, they really help.
- 5:27I mean, I think it's just wonderful that everybody in your groups, inspired writers are positive.
- 5:35Well, and that's part of the reason I do this, right, because it's really easy.
- 5:39We have our own inner critics, right?
- 5:41We have our own little voices in our heads that are going to tell us that we're doing crap.
- 5:46Here's the thing, Susan, I've been doing this a long time and I've worked with thousands of writers.
- 5:50Everybody can do this.
- 5:52I mean, it's work and as you know, it's work, you've done my developmental editing mentorship in the past and you know, that's where you were like, Oh my gosh, it's going to be work.
- 6:02And guess what?
- 6:02You finished.
- 6:04I did.
- 6:04I was very proud of that.
- 6:05It was a lot of work.
- 6:06A lot more than I thought I signed up for.
- 6:09Right.
- 6:09And I think that's, that's something that I do want to talk about here before we dive into your one page is yeah, it is.
- 6:16It's more work than you think, right?
- 6:18Like it's like, Oh, I'm going to write a book and I'm just going to sit down and write a book.
- 6:21And I think the problem is, is people know that it's going to be that much work before, maybe they wouldn't do it.
- 6:27I don't, I don't know.
- 6:28I agree with that because I think I would have rethought it.
- 6:30I'm like, Oh, short story.
- 6:33Yeah, because it could have been a short story.
- 6:35And so when you came to the Developmental Editing Mentorship, you had quite a bit written, but it wasn't a book yet.
- 6:41And you, you didn't really.
- 6:42You know, that was one of the things that you were like, Oh my goodness, how am I going to get it there?
- 6:47And then I saw your email last night as I was preparing for this today.
- 6:51And you were like, I finished.
- 6:53And I, and I was like, okay, well, I needed 160.
- 6:56So I went with 161 pages.
- 6:59Yeah.
- 7:00So I opened it up and I saw that it was 160 pages.
- 7:03And I was like, amazing.
- 7:05It's a memoir.
- 7:05Do you want to tell us a little bit about your book here?
- 7:08Yeah, I did write the whole book as I'm talking to my husband who's deceased kind of like bringing him into the whole thing like, you know, yelling at them, whatever you do when they're dead, you know, when you even when they're alive, you know, and, and I like that because it kept me focused on The us and our story like it was never separating him from me It was like how I feel you're dying and like why are you doing this?
- 7:35Are you you know, help me in that kind of stuff, you know I mean, I think it puts a little more humor and a little more just Camaraderie, like normal dates, how you are with somebody that you, that you love and you're married to for 44 years.
- 7:49Yeah.
- 7:50That's one thing that's hard to teach writers is to put your voice on the page.
- 7:54And that's never been an issue with you, Susan.
- 7:56I just, you know, you've got such an amazing humorous personality and you have such spontaneity and such joie de vivre, right.
- 8:04And it is there on the page.
- 8:06And one of the choices that you did right from early on.
- 8:09Was that a lot of it is written in second person, right?
- 8:12Or first and second person.
- 8:13And that's not very common for a memoir.
- 8:17And so I think it makes it really cool.
- 8:19It allowed you to really have your voice on the page.
- 8:23Well, when I got stuck on this.
- 8:26I was trying to get some more, you know, chapters and figure out where I go, and I'm going to tell you the little story behind it.
- 8:32I was on of my sons who also has this disease.
- 8:35We didn't know my husband had it and that my grandson was born.
- 8:38Finally, we all had all that.
- 8:40But, to long story, I was staying in the room where he and I stayed together.
- 8:45Right.
- 8:45On the idea of being there for my three kids and five grandkids, suddenly I realized that that part of my grief I had not gone through.
- 8:56It was like I was trying to write, here I am, like the matriarch of this family.
- 9:01And I might have watched, possibly my daughter, but my, for sure my son, who's already bad and my grandson die.
- 9:09And like writing that, like when you write something to me, it like becomes a lie.
- 9:14And then it's staring you in the face.
- 9:17I like couldn't write it and I couldn't finish it.
- 9:20And I realized sounds easy, but it isn't.
- 9:23So it took me a while to write it down because once you write it for somehow it comes alive to me, like it's like there and now you can't.
- 9:31You have to face it.
- 9:33Yeah, right.
- 9:34And, and this process can be cathartic.
- 9:37Also, you're going to help so many people through this process of grief by sharing.
- 9:42I hope so.
- 9:42I know that you know that.
- 9:44I know that you know that and that's why you're doing it.
- 9:46So thank you.
- 9:47Thank you from the bottom of my heart for writing this.
- 9:49Do you, can you just share a little bit, Susan, before we dive into your page, can you share just a little bit about the disease that is hereditary in your family that your husband has?
- 9:58Yeah, I do have a daughter.
- 10:00Very common.
- 10:00Yeah, I do have a chapter.
- 10:02It's a form of muscular dystrophy, which everyone knows about muscular dystrophy.
- 10:06Actually, it's your muscles.
- 10:08And so my husband, he had heart disease, he had diabetes, all the things that this causes, but were never connected to that disease.
- 10:18I mean, they felt he had this, he had that.
- 10:20Oh, he had five heart attacks, he had a quadruple bypass, then he had stents in his bypass, like all these things happened.
- 10:26Them allowing, but he just had the heart disease and that.
- 10:29But then when my grandson, my, my grandson was born, he was actually born dead and intubated.
- 10:36As he got to be like three, four, it takes a while, like genetically they do all these tests, but it takes a while for it to envision what it could be, so they're not just constantly, you know, insurances, they can't just constantly test for like everything in the world, so they have to wait.
- 10:52And then they figured out that he had it.
- 10:54Now, because it comes from, if it comes from the mother, which my daughter has it, they gave it to him.
- 11:01And my son has it, but if it comes from the mother, because it's on the Y chromosome, this is way past my math.
- 11:07Ability, but it's like, it's, they usually die.
- 11:11The boys don't survive.
- 11:13Yeah.
- 11:13And so he has the splints and bless his heart.
- 11:16He got in a trial.
- 11:18Now, my son and my daughter, because it came from their father, not me, they have the adult onset.
- 11:26Now, my daughter just turned 40 and my son is 45.
- 11:29Now he's been having AFib and heart issues.
- 11:33But now that we know he was tested and he has it.
- 11:36Thanks.
- 11:37Yeah, and then that's a whole other piece of grief, and so that's what, yeah, and that's what this page is about.
- 11:43Thank you for sharing that, Susan, and, and, you know, I actually have a first cousin who died at 19 from muscular dystrophy.
- 11:49It is, yeah, my aunt just wrote a memoir on the 10th anniversary of that.
- 11:53She just put her memoir out to help families that are going through this to celebrate, like he had an amazing life.
- 12:00And so, yeah, it's, it's that sort of balance.
- 12:03And you don't really think about it, but like, once I'm dealing with this kind of stuff, I started to write that, that chapter because I realized that I never transitioned my mind into the fact that it's me now.
- 12:17Like there's no, and I'm dealing with this alone and, and it's a lot, you know, and like I said, I tried to write some of the, finally I did put it down on the page cause I'm like, listen, that I can write this.
- 12:32So I did.
- 12:32You can write this.
- 12:33Yes.
- 12:34And I did, but the problem with it even being there is, you know, it puts you back in the funk.
- 12:40Yeah.
- 12:41It puts you back in the funk, but, but processing it and thank you.
- 12:44Thank you for this work.
- 12:45It's amazing.
- 12:46Okay.
- 12:47We're going to dive into this page, Susan, that I read at the beginning of the podcast for you.
- 12:52And.
- 12:52Can you tell us, this is chapter 16, the transition.
- 12:55So is this near the, this is near the end of the book?
- 12:59First of all, this one page is, yeah, it's that transition.
- 13:03And this is the moment that you realized that there was more than just the grief of his death.
- 13:08And this is that moment when you realize it.
- 13:11And you've done some things really well here, Susan.
- 13:13You've grounded us in a moment.
- 13:15So part of what's really hard about memoir is, you know, we're introspective and we kind of like share our thoughts and inner thoughts, which is one thing, but for people to really feel like we're there, you need to bring us into that moment.
- 13:29So you've done that.
- 13:30You've chosen a moment in time, which is when you are actually visiting your son's house.
- 13:37And you're laying in the bed that you used to share with your husband when this grief hits you that he's no longer here, you're the matriarch, all the things that you've just been talking about, which is perfect.
- 13:47So you've done that really, really well.
- 13:49There is some room and I know that this is a first draft and this is why you submitted it, right?
- 13:54There's some room to, there are, there is some room to bring in some more detail to make it even more alive.
- 14:02Right.
- 14:02And I appreciate that because I might have changed a little, but this was just such a hard chapter for me because it was like, it was an awakening for me too.
- 14:11Like, I feel like, oh, I'm grieving and that goes back and forth, but I'm doing better.
- 14:15And then all of this hit me.
- 14:16Like, I never even addressed this at all.
- 14:18Like, I never even.
- 14:19You know, you just don't even put it in your mind.
- 14:22And you want, and you want that, you want your readers to feel all of that.
- 14:28And so, you know, even hearing you talk about it now really helps.
- 14:32Uh, see what it is that you want to convey.
- 14:35So this is, you know, when we go through and you've taken my developmental editing mentorship.
- 14:39So you understand this, but when we go through, we want to know what the emotional impact is of this writing.
- 14:44So it's about more than just grammar and spelling.
- 14:47But like, when I hear you talk about this.
- 14:50I want this to hit your reader just as hard, and there's some things that you can do to sort of get those emotions onto the page that we're going to talk about now.
- 14:58You game?
- 14:59Okay.
- 14:59You ready?
- 15:00Yes.
- 15:01Okay.
- 15:02So the first thing is, before we dive into that, the first thing is here that this is near the end of the book, right?
- 15:10And so even though there's this new wave of grief and there's this sort of revelation, That happens.
- 15:17We actually have been with you on a long journey.
- 15:19We've been through 160 pages or however long it takes in the end.
- 15:23And this is just one page.
- 15:25We don't want to be introducing too many new things.
- 15:28And so sometimes when we write these sort of out of order, or when we write them as a chapter or a thought, we reintroduce things that the reader already knows.
- 15:36So, so I want you to take a look, especially in the introduction here.
- 15:40And know, like, how much of this world will we already know?
- 15:44Because you say, you know, we were in, I was visiting our son.
- 15:47Well, we're gonna know his name, right?
- 15:49It's in the book.
- 15:50Let's get as specific as possible and, because, you know, just give your readers some credit.
- 15:56They've been with you on this journey.
- 15:58They, they don't want you to be vague, right?
- 16:00They don't want you to be vague here.
- 16:02You know, you can refer to these events really specifically and connect these dots together, right?
- 16:07So we don't want to be introducing new topics.
- 16:10We're kind of wrapping things up, even though this is a revelation here.
- 16:13So that part is new, but the rest of it, it feels like a bit of a tease.
- 16:17I'm reading these, you know, the opening lines.
- 16:20When I realized that there was a greater part of my healing, I hadn't embraced, I kept it hidden somehow in my sorrow.
- 16:26So make sure that somewhere, maybe it's right here, that hidden somewhere in my sorrow that I really unpack that you can, you can add another sentence or two about what that feels like in your body so that we can suddenly be there.
- 16:39Right?
- 16:40Like, we're saying I saved my son's home.
- 16:42I stayed in our son's home in Virginia.
- 16:44Right?
- 16:45We've been with you on this journey.
- 16:46Hopefully, you know, we either use his name or change his name.
- 16:49We don't want to just call it my son throughout because it's very impersonal.
- 16:52If you decide not to use his real name, you can change it.
- 16:55Okay.
- 16:55Yeah, that part I had to decide it, but I think I'll use them as long as they're all okay.
- 16:59Yeah, as long as they're okay with it.
- 17:01And, and, you know, in Virginia, but where, right?
- 17:03Like, get specific because hopefully, probably we've already visited their home somewhere in this memoir, right?
- 17:09I'm not sure, to be honest, but in other words, you want me to just get more specific.
- 17:14It feels very generic.
- 17:16And for the last, you know, from the second last chapter in the book, we need to get a little bit deeper.
- 17:20So I'm going to send you all of these notes.
- 17:22You can see where it is.
- 17:22Oh, yes.
- 17:23Thank you.
- 17:24But again, like, give me like, and then the next sentence here, I was lying there and I got overwhelmed.
- 17:30With sadness, right?
- 17:31And, and so lying there around us in that moment, here's where your show to tell techniques need to be in here, right?
- 17:38So give me a detail or two of the bed even.
- 17:41So I made something up here.
- 17:43It's not going to be right because I've never been to your son's bedroom, your son's guest bedroom.
- 17:47But I said, you know, Yeah.
- 17:49That's good to know.
- 17:50I don't think I have.
- 17:51I don't think I have.
- 17:53Um, under the quilt that your mother made for the, you know, like I was lying there under the quilt that your mother made for him, my son, it was warm, but your side of the bed was ice cold, right?
- 18:04Like bring us there, bring us there.
- 18:07Or I, that may not be the right, that's what I've used throughout this about this cold side of the bed.
- 18:12And if that resonates with you, awesome.
- 18:14But if it doesn't think about that, what is it?
- 18:17Perfect.
- 18:17Cause I felt it.
- 18:19Yeah.
- 18:20So, but can you see the difference there between saying I was lying there and telling me where you were lying and bringing me there in the moment, right?
- 18:28And the same thing here in the second part of the sentence, I got overwhelmed with sadness, right?
- 18:33What did this feel?
- 18:34You can show that.
- 18:36Right?
- 18:36Show that overwhelm.
- 18:38I want to feel what we just talked about when we were catching up about what this page was about, why you decided to come on the podcast and why this one, you're so proud of this page because when you were writing it, something happened to you that you want to share, right?
- 18:54You realize in that moment why that was so powerful.
- 18:58We can feel that, but you gotta, you gotta let us in, and that's where Chonotel writing is so powerful, is in these moments.
- 19:06You don't have to do it everywhere in this book, but you've chosen the perfect page, and I think that's probably why you sent it to me.
- 19:12This is the most powerful emotion that you felt, maybe, when you wrote this?
- 19:17I don't know.
- 19:18Well, the first, just the first page where he was dying, those first couple pages were bad, but I got through that so long ago, and I've been kind of like, you know, you get sad to get it out, but this page crippled me.
- 19:31Right, and so thank you for being so brave.
- 19:35Usually when I ask, Writers to send in a page to discuss.
- 19:38It's the one that you know needs more.
- 19:41Yeah, I know it could be a lot better, but I just couldn't get it.
- 19:45Like every time I started writing it, it came alive.
- 19:48And I'm like, how do I do this?
- 19:50It came alive in your brain and how do you share that with your reader?
- 19:53Okay, so we're going to keep going here.
- 19:55So when you get overwhelmed with sadness, there's a lot of ways you're sort of, you're sort of naming an emotion there, right?
- 20:02Which is one of the tells, it's a tell.
- 20:04So what did that feel like in your body?
- 20:06So I, again, I'm going to make something up.
- 20:08It might be totally wrong because I haven't been there in that moment with you, but think about it this way.
- 20:14So I said here.
- 20:16It was as if a dark cloud of sadness settled over me and blankets and that cold space in the bed next to me.
- 20:24Oh, I love that.
- 20:24You're writing that down, right?
- 20:26Oh, yeah, you're getting all of it.
- 20:28But yeah, right.
- 20:29So rather than just tell us that you got overwhelmed with sadness, I want to feel it.
- 20:35I'm sure, you know, I haven't been in your specific moment of grief, but I can imagine that.
- 20:40And so, you know, give us something to hang on to what that feels like.
- 20:46It doesn't have to be anything.
- 20:46It doesn't have to be 10 sentences.
- 20:48It isn't even really that long, right?
- 20:50Well, to be as honest as I can, hearing you say it like puts me in it and knows that it's, it's grasping what I felt, but I was like crippled to write or even able to write because it was powerful in my emotions.
- 21:06Amazing.
- 21:06And as always, Susan, I mean, as an editor, like any suggestions that I make, you are welcome to take, but if they don't quite resonate, it's not about me saying that your story has to be different.
- 21:18It's about me helping you unlock that.
- 21:21So even if it's a different emotion, Or, or that's, or you're like, Susie, that doesn't make sense, but, but, or that isn't the way I felt.
- 21:30Sometimes that's even better when you don't like what I wrote because you're like, Oh, I didn't feel that way.
- 21:35Because it gets me to put the words of how I really feel like, yeah, I get it.
- 21:38Like you, I mean, the, the unlock is what I needed and I knew you were my girl.
- 21:43Yeah.
- 21:44I'm totally your girl for the unlock because really it's, it's, it's, you don't need my permission, but sometimes we need to give ourselves permissions as writers.
- 21:54We don't realize that people care, right?
- 21:57See, I think that's a true statement.
- 21:59Like, we wanna, we wanna say it and then we're like, are we really okay to say it?
- 22:03Like, there's some sort of a permission.
- 22:08Is a reader gonna care?
- 22:09Is a reader gonna care?
- 22:10You know what, this, this page is powerful as it is, but hearing you talk about it and saying that this absolutely crippled you, if, if it could absolutely cripple your reader just for that moment, just for that page, to help them feel that grief and help them see that there's something on the other side, that you're this strong matriarch of the family and all these things and One of the things that happens when we write memoir in particular is at some point you're going to have doubts, right?
- 22:37Because you're portraying yourself in one way and then you're like, uh, But Susie is not always really like that.
- 22:43That's okay.
- 22:44Right.
- 22:45That's okay.
- 22:45Because you're going to have ups and downs, but you're sharing one piece of this journey, which is from feeling lost to, you know, finding the strength to be there for the rest of them.
- 22:57Yes.
- 22:58Right.
- 22:59Okay, so, and, and in that moment, part of Show, Don't Tell writing is about being in your shoes for this, or being in this bed with you.
- 23:08That sounds wrong, doesn't it?
- 23:10No, but it's true.
- 23:12But, but it's true, right?
- 23:14Like being in this moment with you is about really being there.
- 23:17So every single comment here is about, you know, you've got suddenly a residual of tears began to flow.
- 23:24Okay, we're not in your body there.
- 23:26Okay.
- 23:27It's not tears pricked at my eyelids.
- 23:29What does it feel like?
- 23:30Right?
- 23:30Like flip it, flip it.
- 23:32Make sure that you're in your body.
- 23:34Okay.
- 23:34And probably to actually write this, you had to sort of feel like you were outside of your body.
- 23:40So this might be a little bit difficult, right?
- 23:42But, but yeah, the more that you can put us through the hardest emotions through the whole book that I was having, like, I guess I was dealing with it and I wasn't ready to like, look at it.
- 23:53Yeah.
- 23:53From someone else's standpoint to like make them feel it.
- 23:56You know what I mean?
- 23:57I, I totally understand and I, I am so honored that you trust me and this group and the listeners enough to, to share that because yeah, this is, this is the moment there might be other moments that you can gloss over.
- 24:13But if this is so like, every time you talk about this, I get goosebumps, right?
- 24:17Like, this is the moment that you have to bring in that showing to make sure, right?
- 24:22So then, then we've got, I was shaking, lost in this tsunami of tears that would not stop.
- 24:28Again, That's, that's really close, right?
- 24:31The tsunami of tears is an amazing visual, but here you could get an even more specific, right?
- 24:36You could show me a body part rather than I was shaking, which is a tell, um, make it feel less generic, right?
- 24:42My torso was shaking.
- 24:44My teeth were chattering, like put us in your body.
- 24:47I don't know if those are right.
- 24:48I don't know what you mean by that.
- 24:50When you say I was shaking, you know what you meant, right?
- 24:56Do you know what you meant?
- 24:57Yeah, I do.
- 24:58I think I, no, I think I was literally shaking like my legs, my head, like it was almost like a out of body experience that I was.
- 25:08Yeah.
- 25:08So put that, so put that and it's fine.
- 25:12I mean, you got through this whole thing in one page, Susan, one page for all of this.
- 25:18So this is a place where you could absolutely expand because you need us to really get it.
- 25:25And I think it's right at the time of the book where we've gotten through where I'm, you know, I found myself and I'm coping and, you know, all the stuff's in there.
- 25:33Manitonics, just like all the other chapters.
- 25:35And when I got to this one, I, you know, I knew this one was like one of the most important because it's showing that I still had something that I was hiding and never dealing with it.
- 25:47It was more emotional.
- 25:49And stronger than anything I've written.
- 25:53So I really wanted to get it through.
- 25:54And then I made one other Wormwood Dumpton, just kind of like ending it all out about how it all worked.
- 26:01And, you know, I, I needed more pages than I thought it worked.
- 26:04Well, and that's true.
- 26:05I mean, after something like this, like you could have an ending and then we have, what's called the denouement, right.
- 26:11And lots of story mountains now don't have this denouement concept and because it's a hard word.
- 26:16But basically, we want to know what the new status quo is.
- 26:20So if you've got another chapter that sort of says what your new life is and shows you after this transition.
- 26:27That's what I thought.
- 26:28I called it like redemption, like now I'm just redeeming, I'm finding my way through whatever.
- 26:32Yeah, it's kind of like.
- 26:33Now, you know what I mean?
- 26:35It puts you where I've done this and that and I forged through and all that.
- 26:39And it worked.
- 26:40I think I, the only thing that I have most trouble with, because I have to have it that way, I have to have the chapters mesh to each other.
- 26:48You have to have them what?
- 26:49Next to each other?
- 26:50Yeah.
- 26:51You know, no, like mesh in like, I think one has to immediately bring you to the other and you're still there.
- 26:58You know, like I get upset when I read a book and like, and then the new chapter, like, is like, Wait a minute, I was over here and now you put me here.
- 27:07Yeah, you know, you know how to fix that, right?
- 27:10We ground us in the, we ground you, right?
- 27:12Because it's true, as a, as a reader, we trust the writer to take us anywhere in time when there's a chapter break.
- 27:19And if they find that discombobulating, it's bad.
- 27:21Probably because they didn't do the grounding well, um, which is, which is where you share, where are we?
- 27:27Who's head are we in?
- 27:28Who's in the scene?
- 27:29And where are we in time and space?
- 27:31So like, where are we in is setting?
- 27:33And then where are we in time and space relative to the chapter that we just left?
- 27:37Because you're right.
- 27:38We can bring you forward in time.
- 27:40We can bring you backward in time and we can put you on the moon and, and readers will trust you.
- 27:46It's that doorway effect, right?
- 27:48It's like when you're looking for your key.
- 27:49Yes.
- 27:50And then you walk through the doorway and you're like, what was I looking for again?
- 27:54Because you trust that room to reset.
- 27:57Yeah.
- 27:57A new chapter resets your brain.
- 28:00Yeah.
- 28:00And you need that grounding.
- 28:01Even if it was just like, even if it's exactly the same thing, it's like, oh, I'm in a new room now.
- 28:06And then your brain kind of resets.
- 28:07It's like, oh, I'm in a new chapter and you need to feed them that information.
- 28:11So yeah, if you feel, if you read books and you feel like, Like disoriented as you go to a new chapter, they probably haven't done that.
- 28:19So even especially writers often resist this with me.
- 28:22They're like, but Susie, I just left them in the bed in the room.
- 28:26And the next chapter is still in the bed in the room.
- 28:29I'm like, so tell me that because I'm waiting for that information.
- 28:33Okay.
- 28:34So, and on that, yes.
- 28:36And on that, you need to give your reader like some, some credit, right?
- 28:42They they're on the second, last chapter.
- 28:45So here we need to make sure that we need to make sure that it flows.
- 28:50And so here, this next bit here in the middle of the page, I wondered why after all this time and all my progress and healing that I was yet again filled with sadness.
- 28:59So I'm a little bit confused here because at the beginning and the opening here, it kind of feels like this is the first time that you felt grief or like that this was the most grief that you'd felt.
- 29:13And so, and so here you're saying it's again, so I just make sure I haven't read the rest of the book yet.
- 29:19I will at some point, I'm sure, but, you know, at some point, make sure that you're keeping that consistent.
- 29:25So, if this is right back to where you were, or if this is, or if this is larger, sometimes a neat thing to do through a book is if you have something that feels repeated to make sure that there's new information or that it's building.
- 29:38Right.
- 29:38And this is a memoir, so we don't want to like, change the actual story.
- 29:42But if, if what I'm hearing you say is this grief was bigger somehow, yeah, I think feeling wise it was, I mean, when someone dies, well, I think, and I don't know that putting this back, you know, mean anything, but.
- 29:57There was a kind of calming it from my husband suffered so long that there was a little bit of, you know, sanctuary with it.
- 30:07Like, I, as much as I knew I was going to miss him, there was this side that I was no longer watching him suffer and he was in a better place.
- 30:16So that gave me some comfort when I got to this, this was like overwhelming to me because we had our own business.
- 30:23We worked together, we were partners together, lovers together, like it was us.
- 30:27Yeah.
- 30:27Okay.
- 30:28So when I got to this moment, I realized that I have all of this still to deal with and be strong for that's our family, but I'm alone and he's gone.
- 30:40And that kind of like really resonated.
- 30:42I don't know why it didn't resonate so much before, but it just right.
- 30:47It really kind of, I just kind of stopped in my shoes there for a minute.
- 30:52Yeah.
- 30:53So don't gloss over it and say yet again.
- 30:57This is something different.
- 30:59This is something new.
- 31:00It's not the same.
- 31:02It's bigger, right?
- 31:04Yeah, in my feelings.
- 31:06It was way bigger.
- 31:08Hey, I flagged all of the named emotions here for you.
- 31:11And again, it's really hard to see it because you can feel it here.
- 31:14It says I You know, the transition of being the matriarch of our whole family alone without you to help me left me terrified and lonely.
- 31:23What does it feel like in your body?
- 31:25You're naming emotions here and you can feel them, Susan.
- 31:28So if you can feel them when you're writing, share a little more, share a little more here.
- 31:32What does terrified and lonely feel like in your body?
- 31:36And again, we're glossing over it a little bit.
- 31:39I was frozen in the bed knowing that I will have to face it all alone.
- 31:43Show me would be a few specific things that you'll have to face alone to make this real define quote unquote, it all you're glossing over it.
- 31:52I'm going to have to face it all.
- 31:54I'm going to have to face this, that the other thing, you know what those things are list.
- 31:59Yeah.
- 31:59And I did put in there that I will actually, I could actually, and not long from now have to watch our son and grandson die.
- 32:07And that's what I couldn't write there, but I did write it and I knew it had to be there.
- 32:12Okay.
- 32:13Because that was what was bothering me, you know, and I think.
- 32:19Yeah, and I think it is really hard, Susan.
- 32:21And thank you for taking this hard step.
- 32:23And for those of you listening who are also writing memoir, I want to just say that writing a memoir does not give everybody an all access pass into your life.
- 32:33Like, you don't have to share any of this, but the things that you do choose to share.
- 32:40Go a little deeper, share them well, right?
- 32:43You don't have to do any of this and there's certainly things that you can leave out.
- 32:46But if you address them and you say it all or it or something, go a little deeper, right?
- 32:52Because we're not going to get it.
- 32:55I'm not going to get from this what Susan in the bed is actually thinking about because my mind hasn't gone there.
- 33:01I haven't been there.
- 33:02So take a beat, share with us what it is so that we can experience that grief with you and we can support you.
- 33:09I agree.
- 33:10And I think it, I think once I.
- 33:12Write it more more so.
- 33:15I think it, it does help.
- 33:17I mean, it, it is therapeutic to me as well.
- 33:20It's just hard to do.
- 33:22It is hard to do.
- 33:23And you are doing something that is really hard.
- 33:25Writing a book is harder than you could ever imagine, but it is worth it, right?
- 33:30Even this moment that you came to on this page is worth it.
- 33:34And if you can share that with somebody else.
- 33:37And prepare them for that or when this happens to someone else, who's in a similar situation, they can read this and know that they weren't alone.
- 33:46Susan, that is worth it.
- 33:49Oh, I agree.
- 33:50Thank you.
- 33:51No, you've been a great help.
- 33:52Thank you so much.
- 33:53You're so welcome.
- 33:55Okay.
- 33:55So we need each other more about somehow push each other away.
- 33:59Right.
- 34:00So, so here I'm asking again, this is because I haven't read the previous chapters, but have we seen this already?
- 34:06Are there some specifics that you can share here?
- 34:09I mean, this is kind of your wrap up, your ending.
- 34:11So you're pulling together all the threads.
- 34:14So rather than just kind of gloss over it and say, we need each other more than ever, but we're pushing each other away.
- 34:19We need each other more than ever, but this is happening.
- 34:23This is happening like some examples.
- 34:25Right.
- 34:26Okay.
- 34:26And now you're like, okay, I got to buck up.
- 34:28I got to get out of this bed.
- 34:30I got to go back and help.
- 34:31I got to go do this or whatever you're thinking in that moment, just, just be specific, right?
- 34:37And then again, I love them all so much.
- 34:40It's terrifying to know that I must deal with all their worries alone.
- 34:44You manage the family issues so differently.
- 34:47You never got upset, but I, on the other hand, get caught up in the chaos.
- 34:50Okay.
- 34:51So now you're comparing to how he would have dealt with us if he was still the patriarch.
- 34:55Right.
- 34:56And so again, I'd love some specifics.
- 34:59This is so important.
- 35:01You don't have to make it only one page.
- 35:03Okay.
- 35:04So I would love some specifics here because Our minds want, like, our minds will automatically be able to picture that if you do that, if you get more specific.
- 35:15Okay.
- 35:16Okay.
- 35:16So what are the examples?
- 35:18Like, how would you, how are you handling it?
- 35:20I don't know how you're handling it.
- 35:22I didn't read it, but maybe it's in there.
- 35:24Are you quicker to fly off the handle and he would be more patient?
- 35:27Are you, I don't know.
- 35:28I'm not, I'm not judging here or assigning anything.
- 35:31Are you more patient?
- 35:32And he would have flowed off the handle.
- 35:33I don't know.
- 35:34But if you've got some, you know, specifics to tie that to rather than just telling us, That he was, you know, he handled things differently.
- 35:42If you could show us, I would take a paragraph there, right?
- 35:48And then I miss you the most of all.
- 35:50In those moments, I miss you the most of all, really take a beat here.
- 35:54One last place in this submission where I'd love to know how that felt in your body, right?
- 35:58So here you could even tie it back.
- 36:00If you like that cold spot on the bed, if in these moments, the cold from your side of the bed seeps into my skin.
- 36:07See if you can do something that brings us into your body, that shows us, that brings us there.
- 36:13The metaphor that I've created, it sounds like it resonates with you, that cold, that cold side of the bed.
- 36:18I know that's true.
- 36:20Yeah, but if you, if you didn't, you could still, you know, stay true to your story and keep that authentic.
- 36:28Well, my son keeps, my son keeps it cold in there, so I was freezing, so I was definitely part of it shaking.
- 36:35Well, there, maybe that's why you were shaking, Susan.
- 36:38Maybe this is all, no.
- 36:39Um, but, but all of those details are kind of fun to put in there, and it makes it more well rounded.
- 36:45And I know how hard this page must have been to write.
- 36:48It probably took you a long time.
- 36:50Did this take you a long time?
- 36:51Or did it just come out?
- 36:53It just came out.
- 36:54Like I, I went and found, he has his printer down there, so I just got the pages and I just started writing it.
- 37:00But I realized those, there were things I couldn't write, like about realizing that, you know, seeing them die.
- 37:06And it was, it was, it was very, part of it was maybe lethargy, you know, like, I don't know, I just, part of it was healing and getting that last part of me where I didn't deal with that.
- 37:18And I'm, Facing it.
- 37:20Part of it was good because it made me realize that and I don't think I had and that I'm the person and I got a man up and be the person.
- 37:28So, okay, Susan, let me just, let me just back up for a moment.
- 37:32Were you at your son's house having this moment and then you got up and you wrote about it?
- 37:37Yes.
- 37:40Oh my goodness, down.
- 37:41I thought, oh my goodness, I never even saw this.
- 37:44This is like one of the hugest part of my healing.
- 37:46And people need to know that there might be something that they've wr they inside that is really something they've gotta do.
- 37:54And I just grabbed paper from a printer and I wrote it all.
- 37:58Oh, wow.
- 37:59I didn't realize that you wrote this in the moment.
- 38:01I thought that you've revisited it later.
- 38:03Well, I revisited and might have fixed a few words, but of course, of course, but the first draft and that's, that's one of the reasons why that's so raw, right?
- 38:12Is because you, yeah.
- 38:13And, and, you know, I, I would almost put that in here.
- 38:18You don't need to hide that you're writing a book.
- 38:22Well, that's true.
- 38:23Okay.
- 38:23You mean that I had to write this now because I had to go to bed and you wrote it down because, because I think, you know, all of these things, there's a positivity to it too.
- 38:36And like you said, at the beginning of this show, you know, you really want to bring that positivity to this, you know, really heart wrenching experience of life.
- 38:48This is life and death and all the things.
- 38:51And, you know, what are the, what are the next steps and how, how are you dealing with it?
- 38:57Well, one of the things is you're writing this book and you want to share that with other people.
- 39:02Um, so think about that.
- 39:03I mean, you don't have to put the writing of the book in there, but, but if you really, you know, got up and you were cold or whatever.
- 39:11I don't know about you, but I think when I get an idea, if it's the middle of the night, we all write it down.
- 39:15But this I, I wrote like three pages and like, I just kept writing it was like I needed to, and maybe I felt like I was feeling it.
- 39:24I probably held back on some of it.
- 39:26Like I couldn't write that I won't watch them die.
- 39:29And there were certain things because it was so it's a revelation, but, but I think some of my feelings are there because I was in that moment and feeling it as I was writing it.
- 39:39Yeah.
- 39:39Yeah.
- 39:39Yeah.
- 39:40Yeah.
- 39:41So what's next, Susan, because last night as I was preparing and reviewing this and knowing that we were going to be talking today, I was so excited.
- 39:49Susan took a course for me in the spring and my developmental editing mentorship and, and it took her book so far.
- 39:56And I got an email from her last night that said, I finished it.
- 40:00And how did that feel?
- 40:03Awesome.
- 40:03It really does.
- 40:04And I like the way it came through this kind of put the ending and then I had another chapter which kind of brings it together, you know, like, because I feel guilty, like, you know, how wonder how it would be if it was reversed and I was gone.
- 40:17Like, how would you have handled things?
- 40:18I mean, it's just kind of like a bring it all together.
- 40:20And it kind of brings the chapters together.
- 40:22Like I had to cope.
- 40:23One of those coping, you know, I had to deal with this.
- 40:26I went to a medium and you know, it's all I kind of try to bring it all to here.
- 40:31I am now.
- 40:31Yeah.
- 40:32I'm a new me.
- 40:33I've got my Sue ism back, you know, Sue ism.
- 40:36I love it.
- 40:37I love it.
- 40:38And I think, end it saying here's where I am.
- 40:41And I even say, you know, everybody would probably like to think that there's a new person in my life, but this journey wasn't about me finding someone else.
- 40:50It was about me finding me.
- 40:53You know, that's kind of how it ends.
- 40:56Absolutely.
- 40:57Absolutely.
- 40:57I love that.
- 40:58Sue ism.
- 40:59You know, we, we share, we almost share a name.
- 41:02You and I, I'm a Suzanne, but similar by Sue, but I was Susie to my, anybody that grew up with me, my parents, there you go.
- 41:09Well, and that's the thing is I think, you know, most people grew out of the name.
- 41:13I never did.
- 41:14I worked on wall street for a brief time and I went by Suzanne because.
- 41:17If I introduced myself as Susie, they would say, Oh, Susan, it's nice to meet you.
- 41:23They wouldn't call me Susie.
- 41:24Cause it was just felt wrong.
- 41:25Like, and so they wouldn't do it.
- 41:28And so now I finally in a career where Susie, I can just embrace it.
- 41:32And my husband's name is Jamie and we're Susie and Jamie, and we just never grew up, I guess.
- 41:36I don't know.
- 41:37But one day.
- 41:39You're both, you know, Susie and Jamie.
- 41:41I like it.
- 41:42Yeah, and then we named our kids things that couldn't have any nicknames.
- 41:45So I guess don't have nicknames.
- 41:48So it sounds like that was planned, right?
- 41:50It was a little bit planned.
- 41:52We couldn't give them some junior names.
- 41:54Um, so yeah, so I'm excited.
- 41:56So when you say that you're finished, of course, this is the first draft you're going to go back through.
- 42:00That's why this was perfect timing to go back through.
- 42:03You've got this one page to work on.
- 42:04You're going to go back through your draft and find those moments, Susan, like it's the 80, 20 rule for writers, right?
- 42:10It's about not rewriting the whole darn thing, but taking specific moments in time.
- 42:17That are important to the story that are important to your readers experience and just giving them a little bit extra love, right?
- 42:24Just giving them a little bit of extra love.
- 42:26I'm finding those moments where you can, especially I'm seeing a lot of, you know, naming emotions.
- 42:31Look for those look for when you're glossing over something to get a little bit more specific.
- 42:37To ground us in that moment, and you're going to be off to that I was going to ask you, Chris, just to make sure.
- 42:42I, you know, I did the word count and all that stuff, and I'm okay.
- 42:45But the thing about it is, I have 17 chapters, and nowhere did it say, does it matter how many chapters you have?
- 42:52It doesn't matter how many chapters you have.
- 42:54Okay.
- 42:54I wasn't sure.
- 42:54No, it doesn't matter.
- 42:55There's no, there's no, there's no hard and fast rules, in fact, in publishing about how long a chapter is.
- 43:02There are some guidelines.
- 43:03Most people won't give you an answer.
- 43:04I always give you an answer.
- 43:06I would say if your child, you know, if your chapters and it depends, because I think I haven't read the whole thing, but the earlier drafts that I saw of yours, you do have some shorter chapters that are snippets, right?
- 43:18And that's allowed.
- 43:19Now there's some more, well, I added more content to every chapter first, and then I put these on the end knowing I would get my word, my, uh, yeah, my, all my, um, you know, In a sort of most of them have more.
- 43:33There's a couple of them, which only have maybe.
- 43:36Three pages or four.
- 43:38Um, okay.
- 43:38So, so Susan, yeah.
- 43:40So if you were writing like a long form novel, traditionally, a short chapter would be anything under seven pages and a long chapter would be anything over 25.
- 43:50But you're not writing that.
- 43:52You're writing a memoir where you've got sort of some moments in time.
- 43:56And so you can do whatever you want.
- 43:58If you look at like the format, everybody tells me that they want to write a book like Untamed, right?
- 44:03Like Untamed, it's got a whole bunch of one page chapters.
- 44:06There's a few that are less than that.
- 44:08And so yeah, but then it ends up being like 100 chapters.
- 44:11So there are no hard and fast rules.
- 44:13If you kind of want, you know, if you're writing a more traditional style, then you might want to combine some of those and you can use a scene break chapters are relatively arbitrary.
- 44:23The one thing I would say is that the only chapter break that matters is by the end of chapter 3, you kind of want to have yourself on that journey.
- 44:31Right?
- 44:32And so pay attention to that chapter 3 break because psychologically, Your reader, and again, I'm all about the reader's brain, your reader will give you those first three chapters to kind of set them on a journey and also an agent or publisher will kind of give you three chapters to set that tone.
- 44:48So sometimes when I'm working with a writer, especially if you've got.
- 44:52You know, if, if you've got these little snippets that are short chapters, we might want to combine a few of them at least.
- 44:58We're doing like the first three just to show that.
- 45:02I did put some, my husband and I, I always wrote like I was only one.
- 45:07one credit, one class short of a literary degree, but I went to business world like you did, you know, and, and got a real job like my dad thought I should.
- 45:17Okay.
- 45:18Got a real job like my dad thought I should.
- 45:19Absolutely.
- 45:20Sorry, dad.
- 45:20I know you listened to the podcast.
- 45:22Yeah.
- 45:24You know, so, but I wrote a lot of poems and a lot of poems for him.
- 45:27So I did put some of them in there.
- 45:29Like I was doing a remembering like how we met and I put some in there and then in the one where grief was, I put some in that I wrote.
- 45:35That I felt like will, will get people in the moment of how I felt.
- 45:40I hope the way I did it, it's okay, because I said you loved my writing.
- 45:45Remember this one, this was my favorite, and I put them in kind of giving them a basis of like our relationship.
- 45:51Absolutely.
- 45:52Yeah.
- 45:53That sounds amazing.
- 45:53Absolutely.
- 45:55Just, just pay attention to the spacing of them.
- 45:57The one thing I would say is something that writers don't do well all the time.
- 46:01If you look at the whole book and you've only got three poems, right?
- 46:05Don't put them all in the first chapter and then don't have any poems.
- 46:08Like it's kind of a contract.
- 46:09I think I have some in the remembering and then I know I have some in the grief because I wrote grief ones and I had one.
- 46:16You know, just pay attention to how they're spaced so that they're not sort of all in the one half of the book, because that could be a little bit jarring.
- 46:24Well, not overbearing.
- 46:26Even it's just, you have a contract with your reader about what kind of book you're writing and what they can expect.
- 46:31And when you break that contract, it can feel really like jarring.
- 46:35Thank you, Susan.
- 46:35We'll, we'll, uh, ask listeners to go and follow you on social media and follow this journey so that when this book comes out, they'll know where to find you.
- 46:42And we'll drop some links in the show notes.
- 46:44Thank you so much for being on the show.
- 46:45I can't wait to see what you do next and to help you.
- 46:49Okay.
- 46:49Bye.
- 46:51Bye.
- 46:59Thanks for tuning in to Show Don't Tell Writing with me, Suzy Vadori.
- 47:03Help me continue to bring you the straight goods for that book you're writing.
- 47:07planning to write.
- 47:08Please consider subscribing to this podcast and leaving a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you're listening.
- 47:15Also visit suzyvidori.
- 47:17com forward slash newsletter to hop on my weekly inspired writing newsletter list to stay inspired and be the first to know about upcoming training.
- 47:28You're feeling brave, check the show notes, and send us a page of your writing that isn't quite where you want it to be yet for our Show Don't Tell page review episodes.
- 47:37Remember, that book you're writing is going to open doors you haven't even thought of yet, and I can't wait to help you make it the absolute best it can be.
- 47:45You're feeling called to write that book?
- 47:48Keep going, and I'll be right here cheering you on.
- 47:51See you again next week!