Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E066: Tracking Business Bitcoin Adoption with River's Sam Baker
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of gutless 1974198792972000.
- 0:17And whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. Everyone, welcome back to the
- 0:34last trade. This week we have Sam Baker, who
- 0:37is a research analyst, a River. Sam authored an excellent report
- 0:41that was just recently published on corporate Bitcoin adoption.
- 0:44So we'll be diving into that report among other themes and
- 0:48topics that we've seen in the industry recently.
- 0:51Of course, today joined by my Co host Michael Tanguma and Jesse
- 0:54Myers. Good to see everyone.
- 0:55How's everyone doing today? Good and well.
- 1:00Sam, appreciate you making some time.
- 1:03Good to meet you. And maybe before we get into the
- 1:06report, let's just hear a little bit about your background.
- 1:09I saw that you before joining River earlier this year, you
- 1:13previously worked at Galaxy and I believe City, if, if I recall
- 1:16correctly. So we'd love to just hear about
- 1:18your background in the traditional finance space.
- 1:21It sounds like some other crypto Bitcoin native firms as well.
- 1:24And ultimately, what led you led you to River would be a great
- 1:26place to start. Sure.
- 1:28Well, first of all, thanks for having me.
- 1:30Great to meet all of you. As for some background on
- 1:34myself, I went down the Bitcoin rabbit hole in college.
- 1:38I was going down the I guess investment banking trajectory at
- 1:43Boston College and during that period I found Bitcoin.
- 1:48And so my, my first job out of college was at City.
- 1:51I worked in their digital assets group, so very blockchain focus,
- 1:55not so much Bitcoin as much as I wished.
- 1:58And and then I spent about two years at Galaxy, primarily in
- 2:02their trading business, but also working on some of the other
- 2:05products related to Bitcoin mining and asset management.
- 2:08And then earlier this year, I jumped over to River.
- 2:11It was really great to finally be working for a a Bitcoin focus
- 2:16company and right now I'm focused on research.
- 2:19So most recently put out the report on business Bitcoin
- 2:22adoption, but we'll be putting out reports a couple times a
- 2:26year. That's awesome.
- 2:29It's a good, it's an interesting, you know, on the
- 2:33Bitcoin side because there's only so many companies to work
- 2:35for. So generally kind of have to do
- 2:37a hop and then kind of get into it.
- 2:40A curious like any learnings or big themes from like Galaxy in
- 2:43particular that helps as like you move directly into Bitcoin
- 2:47and that influence you know the report because I know they're
- 2:49pretty well regarded shop as well.
- 2:51Yeah, for for sure Galaxy's very institutional focused where I
- 2:56would say River is more focused on retail and smaller to medium
- 3:02sized businesses. So at Galaxy, we really got to
- 3:05see a lot of the, a lot of the big movers in the market.
- 3:09I was there over the last bear market and so got to see first
- 3:13hand from the trading desk the blow UPS of Luna 3 AC block fi
- 3:19FTX was was sitting on the trading floor.
- 3:23When you know, Galaxy took a big hit during FTX, but it was also
- 3:27a great opportunity because of, you know, how thin the, the, the
- 3:32liquidity was that week. I actually also learned a lot
- 3:36working at Citi, just learning a little bit about how banks are
- 3:41viewing Bitcoin or just blockchain more broadly as an
- 3:47opportunity and a threat. And one of the things I took
- 3:51away from that is I think banks are actually more focused on
- 3:54CBDC's as a threat to their business model in so far as it
- 4:01would take away their deposits. And so I would say just like if
- 4:05you want to, if you want to know a little bit about how the the
- 4:08largest banks out there are like thinking about blockchain,
- 4:11they're actually really thinking about CBDC's as opposed to
- 4:14Bitcoin. So I found that experience like
- 4:18they're very interesting. That's fascinating.
- 4:22It's so funny how you know, crypto and CBDC's provide the
- 4:27sort of air cover for Bitcoin to continue to develop and mature
- 4:32for long enough before before the world, well, the powers that
- 4:36be realized that Bitcoin is actually the thing that that
- 4:40they should have been worried about all along.
- 4:43At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 4:46asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 4:50right There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 4:53exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 4:56arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 4:58concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 5:01solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 5:05ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 5:07possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 5:11your family is protected as well.
- 5:14On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 5:16whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 5:19to your existing self custody set up.
- 5:22For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 5:26Tell us more about that. So like in a bank environment,
- 5:29did you see like decks going around about, you know, how
- 5:32CDC's are threat, how we, how we as a bank can get around this,
- 5:36you know, efforts we can take to lobby against it or perhaps
- 5:40innovate our way around CDC's? What was that like?
- 5:43Yeah. So I, I guess the way I would
- 5:48divide up any digital assets group at a bank would be between
- 5:53and I'm going to say a lot of words that you might cringe at,
- 5:56but CBD, CS, private blockchains, crypto, and then
- 6:02enterprise blockchain. And the the private blockchain
- 6:06and enterprise blockchain sides of things are things that these
- 6:10banks have been working on for years and years, sometimes over
- 6:14a decade, and they haven't really materialized in any way.
- 6:18Basically like an intranet, right?
- 6:20Yeah, yeah. Or like trying to address trade
- 6:23finance because a lot of the banks are at the center of trade
- 6:26finance, which is a multi trillion dollar industry.
- 6:30With regard to CBD CS, I think the way a lot of the banks are
- 6:34trying to position themselves is at the center of the
- 6:39infrastructure. So City, for example, helped
- 6:44manage the release of the CBDC in, in Nigeria, and so they were
- 6:49very involved with the central bank there.
- 6:53One, one thing that listeners could read up on if they're
- 6:57interested is like City released this concept called the
- 7:01regulated liability network, which is basically like a
- 7:04private blockchain run by banks that countries could issue their
- 7:09own CBDC on top of. And like making that sort of
- 7:12model, I think would allow the banks to still have some sort of
- 7:18business model to extract revenues on top of the CBDC,
- 7:22which is preferable to just them being totally worked around from
- 7:28a government. And then as a regard to crypto,
- 7:33I would say the banks haven't really done anything in the
- 7:36space. The most they can do is like you
- 7:39see, you know, Goldman and JP or the APS for a lot of the ETFs,
- 7:46they've always explored issuing products like lending backed by
- 7:50Bitcoin, But you usually have a very high turnover rate of
- 7:54people that actually care about Bitcoin working at the banks.
- 7:58When I left city on the same day, there were 17 other people
- 8:03that like we were all Bitcoiners and we all left because we knew
- 8:07that, you know, no matter how much effort you put into kind of
- 8:12pushing the bank in the right direction, it wasn't going to
- 8:15materialize in anything. And so as a result, you kind of
- 8:19have just very high turnover rate of people that actually
- 8:23understand the space leaving into Bitcoin focused or just
- 8:29like companies in the space, custodians, trading houses,
- 8:32exchanges. It's an.
- 8:34Amazing point that that the brain drain from traditional
- 8:38institutions to Bitcoin makes it so that the institutions are
- 8:42perpetually unequipped with bitcoiners.
- 8:45It's a funny point. It's what I've seen without
- 8:48throwing any other names out there from the biggest regarded
- 8:52institutions that are in Bitcoin, they everyone leaves
- 8:55because it's just too slow. Like, and I think Jesse, this
- 9:00kind of ties into what we've talked about where I've
- 9:03increasingly becoming convinced that the incumbents just won't
- 9:06catch up because by the time they get to something, something
- 9:09else exists, It's like we have a whole investment fund literally
- 9:12titled this like early riders, because the incumbents will
- 9:16refuse to adopt the most disruptive technology.
- 9:18So it'll take the early people that will find it and then build
- 9:21the net new companies because it's just and I think like we
- 9:24see this with AI as well. When you think about the amount
- 9:26of censorship that exists, like you can't like it disrupts the
- 9:32existing model of your solution. If the models are giving
- 9:36everything from an AI perspective, so you have to
- 9:38censor it, well, that's not the best product.
- 9:40And ultimately it's somebody that's net new going to build
- 9:43that in the same way, like when you think about what river is
- 9:46doing or or on ramp, you have to like build things from the
- 9:49ground up that are native to the asset.
- 9:51And sometimes those things are not conducive to the existing
- 9:54legacy model of your whole other business is the whole just wrote
- 9:58Innovator's Dilemma, like right, you know, so that makes complete
- 10:01sense that people leave. I mean, yeah, like there, there
- 10:05are more regulators specialized on regulating JP Morgan than
- 10:11there actually are people on the trading floor of JP Morgan.
- 10:14So if you just think about that, it's like pretty impossible to
- 10:18move forward. There's one exception in the
- 10:20large traditional finance space, which is Fidelity, and that's
- 10:24because Abby Johnson is, I would say, a very outspoken Bitcoiner.
- 10:30And so when when you can have an exception like that, maybe
- 10:34Cantor Fitzgerald would be another example.
- 10:37When you have the one like CEO that came from the top down to
- 10:41move things forward, I think there's a glimmer of hope.
- 10:46But yeah, otherwise I'm I'm not too optimistic on, you know,
- 10:50banks offering Bitcoin products anytime soon.
- 10:52See. Everybody.
- 10:54Before pivoting, because I know we have a jam packed agenda with
- 10:57the, the business side, but I'm curious your thoughts on where
- 11:00like, you know, I think Bitco just came out with their
- 11:04whatever USDCS or, or whatever it is, the token, their, their,
- 11:09their stable coin. And then there's a conversation
- 11:11with Wyoming and having their sovereign backed stable.
- 11:14Where do these like almost private banking dollars play
- 11:18into that stack that you reference, which is like, you
- 11:21know, the CBDC, there's the tethers of the world and like,
- 11:26how does that plan? Because like, I guess these
- 11:28banks can issue their own dollars.
- 11:29It's because they're kind of an interesting spot.
- 11:32Yeah, when, when I was at City, that was over two years ago and
- 11:38this is when the stable coin market cap was maybe 1/5 of what
- 11:43it is right now. And so it, it, it was part of
- 11:46the conversation, but not nearly to the extent that I would
- 11:49imagine it is right now. And so to be honest with you,
- 11:54I'm, I'm not entirely sure how banks would play into that.
- 12:00I, I would guess that they would be for, they should be jumping
- 12:04on top of it because it would allow them to, I mean, at the
- 12:08very least they should be cussing the, the, the assets
- 12:12that are collateralizing these stable coins because that's,
- 12:16that's kind of the only way that they can fit in.
- 12:20Sam, appreciate you sharing those perspectives and I find it
- 12:23interesting, you know a couple of the trad Fi organizations you
- 12:26mentioned like Fidelity or now Cantor Fitzgerald.
- 12:30In a lot of ways it does need, it does require a level of
- 12:33sophistication from the top to drive Bitcoin, not crypto or
- 12:38enterprise blockchain, private block, all the buzzwords that
- 12:40you threw out there, right? And it's interesting because
- 12:43most of these firms seem to be mired in it.
- 12:46One quick anecdote is Michael and I have had some
- 12:49conversations with some Swiss private banks and it's
- 12:53interesting to see it might be a combination of their low time
- 12:57preference thinking of both the institutions and also the end
- 13:01clients. Like these are institutions that
- 13:02have been around over 150 years and they also focus on
- 13:06generational wealth, right? And they've effectively seen
- 13:09multiple generations of their clientele preserve and grow
- 13:13wealth over time. And now they have fortunately a
- 13:16couple of Bitcoiners that are kind of sitting within the
- 13:19innovation lab there that really deeply understand Bitcoin, have
- 13:22been in it for over a decade. And it requires like that type
- 13:25of it requires that type of knowledge and individual to push
- 13:30forward within an organization. I also think it comes down to
- 13:34that like a Swiss bank has very low time preference versus a
- 13:38Wall Street firm maybe just looking to beat on quarterly
- 13:40earnings right quarter after quarter.
- 13:42So there is something about maybe just these different
- 13:45financial institutions require, it requires both the leadership
- 13:50and the knowledge around Bitcoin, but then also just how
- 13:53incentives are aligned throughout that organization.
- 13:57I appreciate you sharing those perspectives.
- 13:59So I'm curious, like before getting into the report itself,
- 14:03maybe you could just share, you know, the impetus for writing
- 14:06the report. I was picking through it this
- 14:09week. It was very well done, extremely
- 14:11comprehensive, a lot of interesting data points, way
- 14:14more than we'll even be able to get into through this
- 14:15conversation. So folks will be able to check
- 14:17it out after the fact. But how did you and the team
- 14:21kind of decide on focusing on business adoption as a report
- 14:25and why is kind of now a good time to be looking into that?
- 14:29Sure. So we, we decided to put out the
- 14:32report for a couple of reasons, both selfishly and trying to
- 14:36just benefit the rest of the space.
- 14:39I would say from reverse perspective, we've been serving
- 14:43a lot more business clients over the past few years.
- 14:46That number is now in excess of 1000.
- 14:49And so just seeing that growth in that demand from businesses
- 14:54made us look into, OK, like what what materials are out there to
- 14:59help business owners understand the role that Bitcoin could play
- 15:03on their balance sheet or or otherwise.
- 15:06And there aren't that many resources out there.
- 15:09When you look at business Bitcoin adoption, just in terms
- 15:13of the headlines, I think it, it's very easy to get drawn into
- 15:19focusing on micro strategy or some of the other companies that
- 15:23are just making huge moves, which is great to see, but it's
- 15:27not that replicable to smaller businesses, family run
- 15:31businesses. And so we wanted to really open
- 15:35people's eyes to the breadth of business Bitcoin adoption.
- 15:39If you look at Bitcoin adoption more broadly over the past, I
- 15:44would say year or so, you can divide up the holders into, you
- 15:49know, individuals, businesses, institutions and nation states.
- 15:54And from the beginning of this year at least, I, I don't see
- 15:59retail or individuals driving that price higher, driving
- 16:03Bitcoin adoption. It, it, it really is coming down
- 16:06to businesses and institutions right now.
- 16:10And maybe later in the cycle we'll get a lot more interest
- 16:12from retail. Yeah, yeah.
- 16:15This is the the perfect chart to show.
- 16:18And so we, we just wanted to highlight the state of business,
- 16:22Bitcoin adoption, where where it's coming from, and then
- 16:26provide as many resources as possible to equip business
- 16:30owners to at least consider the role that Bitcoin could play.
- 16:35Yeah, that's excellent. This is such an awesome way to
- 16:41highlight ownership and distribution and there's a lot
- 16:44of themes I want to touch on and I know the group does here too.
- 16:47I'm curious for the clients. So you mentioned over 1000
- 16:49clients, a river business clients, which is remarkable and
- 16:53Congrats on the success there. I'm curious like do those folks
- 16:57typically sign up first as individuals and then bring their
- 17:00businesses in? Or are you seeing a lot of
- 17:02businesses reach out direct without maybe the individuals
- 17:05already being Bitcoiners and wanting to sign up and
- 17:08understand the merits of Bitcoin treasury strategy?
- 17:12Yeah, yeah, good question. Many of them did start off as
- 17:16individuals as as individual clients and then they brought
- 17:19their business on. And I would say, you know, a
- 17:24majority of the remainder were companies that are, you know,
- 17:29small to medium sized businesses that had an existing, I would
- 17:34say Bitcoin champion within their company.
- 17:37That either was a river client or a client somewhere else and
- 17:41was just pounding the table on implementing some sort of
- 17:45Bitcoin strategy for a while and then finally won over, you know,
- 17:49the management or the key stakeholders to finally like on
- 17:52board and buy Bitcoin. Makes a makes a lot of sense.
- 17:57I appreciate you calling out the, you know, there's the folks
- 18:01that get the headlines in the space, but then there's like
- 18:05real applicable stuff in the real world where I personally
- 18:07like gravitate towards when we think about inflation and margin
- 18:11compression because of it, because people have to raise
- 18:13prices and it's not just raising prices and consistently
- 18:17maintaining the same revenue, less clients or less individuals
- 18:19are able to buy those services. And so it really matters for the
- 18:22longevity of a business to be able to have a better form of
- 18:26money to store. So it's, it's cool to see you
- 18:28guys leading that charge and the number of clients you have
- 18:32because it's more tangible. And I like the case studies that
- 18:35were in there with Peony and Tahinis that have been around
- 18:38for a while. And it, that also maps very
- 18:42directionally. So I was previously at Unchained
- 18:44and, and worked with a lot of small businesses or businesses.
- 18:48And what you described is exactly kind of how it looked.
- 18:50It was a private, it was an individual client that then
- 18:52onboarded their business or their friend told them.
- 18:55And what was fascinating that it's kind of like tied into
- 18:58those case studies that most people don't.
- 19:00It makes sense, but they're never like explained.
- 19:02It is, it's always people in the real economy that are feeling
- 19:05inflation that gravitate towards Bitcoin.
- 19:07It's like there's some notion of proof of work when you're out.
- 19:09And this is like a kind of a symptom also of athletes and
- 19:12firefighters getting it. It's like you have this like
- 19:14shelf life and you're out there and you kind of know there's
- 19:16only so much time and then you also see these things happening.
- 19:19And so it like it's a very interesting thing how bitcoins
- 19:22such an emergent technology, that's the people at the edges
- 19:24that feel it. They have to find it.
- 19:26And then it kind of moves up into the stack when it comes to
- 19:28the corporations. And you have all these boards
- 19:31that are like, it's OK, it's OK because they're getting their
- 19:33share buybacks and all the things versus the people that
- 19:35are on the front lines that they need to.
- 19:37So it plays very nicely into that report that I feel like
- 19:39that's probably a lot of what you see today and it'll grow
- 19:41overtime. But like, that's the emergent
- 19:43part of Bitcoin on the business side.
- 19:46Right. Yeah.
- 19:46So 33% of companies in the US, over 10 millionaire family run.
- 19:53And I think when you have a family run business that that
- 19:59means a lot more than just being ACEO or the CFO at a publicly
- 20:05traded company where you get your stock options every quarter
- 20:08and you get your payout. Like for a family run business,
- 20:12it's very much a savings account or a store of wealth that can be
- 20:16passed on. From generation to generation.
- 20:19And so I think these business owners are looking at it with a
- 20:22lot more care than maybe a, a, a much larger CFO and a different
- 20:30time preference as well. Like for, for a publicly traded
- 20:33company, you're, you're focused on the next quarter, two
- 20:37quarters. You know, maybe you, you, you
- 20:39have a slightly longer time horizon, but you know that
- 20:44that's going to incentivize you to focus much more on like
- 20:46mitigating risk over the next six months.
- 20:49Whereas when you have a family run organization like that,
- 20:52wealth matters for longer than your own lifetime.
- 20:56And so I think that's why we've seen a lot of demand from both
- 21:01small businesses and like family run entities.
- 21:06Yeah, I mean, that's such a great point.
- 21:08Sam and Michael too, just around the grassroots nature of Bitcoin
- 21:12and really just becoming like a survival of the fittest type of
- 21:15technology, right where people seek it out, maybe not even
- 21:19because they want to, but because at some point it becomes
- 21:21a need for them to do so. And I thought this was like a,
- 21:24this is a really powerful chart because it's not like any of us
- 21:28are advocating for businesses to be dumping, you know, 100% of
- 21:32their cash reserves into Bitcoin.
- 21:33Like that could present challenges in and of itself, but
- 21:37even just allocating 3% to Bitcoin in the past four years
- 21:43has on inflation just return basis is vastly outperformed
- 21:47holding it in dollars, right? And most people still seem to
- 21:50think that the dollar is a reliable and stable currency,
- 21:56but the four of us know that over time it's been depreciated
- 21:58at a greater clip. And I think, like you just kind
- 22:01of hit the nail on the head where for family businesses,
- 22:04you're not just kind of collecting a paycheck, right?
- 22:06Like this is your livelihood. This is the way that you put
- 22:09food on the table for your spouse and for your children.
- 22:14And there's such a greater need at that point to seek out
- 22:18alternatives to actually preserve and grow your wealth
- 22:21versus having it constantly drained and having to then, you
- 22:24know, compromise maybe on the quality of your business or
- 22:27increasing passing costs on to your customers.
- 22:30So it makes a ton of sense and that that's where you're seeing
- 22:32a lot of the adoption. Well, in a good, a good example
- 22:35of this, like I always think about this notion of like we
- 22:39know we can't have an upside down balance sheet as
- 22:41individuals or you get put in cuffs or bankruptcy and all the
- 22:44things associated, but everyone else is allowed to do it.
- 22:46And Jackson, if you can find the chart with Apple, because that
- 22:50was one that kind of ties into this is like, I think it was 15
- 22:53billion. And like, I guess they're
- 22:56unrealized, but it's via, you know, forget what page it was,
- 23:01but you'll see the the chart that pops up of like losses
- 23:04because of the loss of purchasing power.
- 23:06That if that was our personal balance sheet, like we would
- 23:09never accept that. But nobody talks about it.
- 23:11And if you scroll up, one click, I think, Yeah.
- 23:15And one more, I think, sorry, Yeah, maybe it's the other one,
- 23:20but there was a. I'll find it for you, yeah.
- 23:23And Sam, when you're when you're doing these calculations are
- 23:26you're using the official CPI numbers.
- 23:28So assume or. Yeah, yeah.
- 23:30So I'm being generous with the CPI numbers, but maybe, maybe,
- 23:35maybe it might. Be worse than that.
- 23:37Yeah, yeah, I think the way so, so Lynn Alden recently put out
- 23:41an article on corporate finance and the role that Bitcoin could
- 23:45play. And she took a little bit of of
- 23:49a different perspective. It was a great article, but she
- 23:52looked at the, the rate of monetary inflation and not
- 23:56consumer price inflation. And I think as a business, that
- 23:59might be a better way of looking at it because at the end of the
- 24:02day, you, your, your goal is not to get diluted in terms of the,
- 24:07the size of the money supply. And so really your benchmark
- 24:11should be, you know, either either the stock index that
- 24:14you're in or, you know, M2 at the very least.
- 24:18Yeah, yeah. That that's a we feel
- 24:20passionately about that, or at least I certainly do that the
- 24:24best barometer for true inflation, unless someone can
- 24:27can prove to me that there's a better metric out there is just
- 24:31M2 growth. And the capital markets access
- 24:36is a big one as well, because when you're able to get access
- 24:38to cheap debt, it changes the whole survival game that we're
- 24:42talking about versus when you can't, you have to find the best
- 24:45tool to stay alive. And that's.
- 24:48And then it's also easier when you can make the decision versus
- 24:50the standard. Yeah, this is the 15 billion in
- 24:5310 years, like this is everybody's personal balance
- 24:56sheet as well. Yeah.
- 25:03No, it's, it's so true. I mean, again, like not
- 25:06surprising Sam, I would love for you to correct me if I'm wrong,
- 25:10but it was like something it might have been over 90% of the
- 25:13businesses that have adopted Bitcoin with River were less
- 25:18than 5 stakeholders or something, right, needed to
- 25:21approve that Is that, is that right or generally around there?
- 25:25It's, it's somewhere in the range of 9095% of foreign
- 25:29business clients required less than 5 stakeholders to approve a
- 25:34Bitcoin purchase decision. And the reason we, we wanted to
- 25:39find out that stat is just learning more about how much
- 25:44governance plays a role in making a decision like adding
- 25:48Bitcoin to the balance sheet. And so these these smaller
- 25:53companies do have a first mover advantage because if you have
- 25:58someone in the company that can champion Bitcoin and you can
- 26:01make that decision, it's a lot easier than being at a multi
- 26:05billion dollar public company where you have to, you know, get
- 26:08approval from your whole board. And then you have to spend
- 26:11months finding, you know, all the all the third parties that
- 26:16you're going to deal with. So yeah, props, huge props to
- 26:21Micro Strategy and Block and some of the other large
- 26:25companies for getting that done because it is not easy to do.
- 26:29Did you, did you guys happen to look into how many of those
- 26:33businesses really only needed one person to to make that
- 26:37decision? I would I would guess it's a
- 26:39high number. Yeah, yeah, I think we did ask
- 26:41that question and it it was a high number, yeah.
- 26:44I wouldn't be able to give you it off the top of my head, but
- 26:47yeah, yeah. Yeah.
- 26:49Speaking of MicroStrategy at back in 2020, you know, the four
- 26:53of us remember very well just in terms of that initial
- 26:56announcement being made. And I feel like there was there
- 26:59obviously was so much excitement around it.
- 27:01And I think there was also way more anticipation of other
- 27:06publicly traded stocks or companies doing that as well.
- 27:09And maybe you know, four years later, I'll speak for myself.
- 27:15I'm a little bit surprised that there that we've seen a slower
- 27:18rate of adoption among public companies.
- 27:21But Sam, one of the things that you put in the report that I
- 27:24thought was interesting was a, a table that compared, I guess you
- 27:27would call them like four key pillars or four parts of market
- 27:31structure that are needed for treasury assets, right?
- 27:35So there's liquidity, regulatory and accounting, institutional
- 27:39acceptance and precedent. And I thought this was a great
- 27:42chart that you threw together just to highlight how much has
- 27:45changed in the matter of four years.
- 27:47I'd be curious to hear your thoughts if you share the
- 27:50sentiment that you're surprised that MicroStrategy hasn't really
- 27:53been followed by too many other companies.
- 27:56And when you look at this chart, like, what do you think is most
- 27:58important? Do you think any of these play
- 28:01more of a role than others? Be curious to hear your
- 28:03thoughts, you know looking back for years compared to where we
- 28:06are today. Yeah, great questions.
- 28:10I, I would also love to hear your guys's thoughts on
- 28:13MicroStrategy because, yeah, it's just a fascinating case
- 28:16study. So as, as much as we could talk
- 28:19about liquidity or accounting or, you know, regulatory, I, I
- 28:24really think the most important of these 4 categories is
- 28:27precedent. Because all these companies are,
- 28:31you know, at the end of the day, like you could think of them as
- 28:33sheep and everyone is still following this traditional
- 28:37corporate finance treasury playbook.
- 28:40And so as soon as you have a critical mass of businesses that
- 28:45are starting to look at Bitcoin or other assets as a diversifier
- 28:50against inflation, I think that's going to do more than
- 28:54anything else. And for the other categories,
- 28:56it's just I, I think it's a binary of, you know it, we're,
- 29:01we're, we're liquid enough. So 10 Xing the liquidity from
- 29:04here is not going to be a huge needle mover.
- 29:08Same with the accounting like the accounting standards are
- 29:11fairly clear at this point. So I I don't think that we could
- 29:16have much more progress in that regard.
- 29:20So yeah, I do think precedent is the most important As for micro
- 29:25strategy, So I I don't really know where to start.
- 29:31I might go on a little bit of a rant.
- 29:33I think micro strategies example is very unique and I don't see I
- 29:43don't see their playbook being replicated at least in US
- 29:47capital markets all that much. I think their their strategy is
- 29:51A1. It is A1 company take all
- 29:55approach because they've established themselves as the
- 29:58most liquid issue like company that can take advantage of
- 30:03capital markets to buy Bitcoin. Yesterday they announced the
- 30:08pricing of convertible notes. I don't know if you guys saw
- 30:11that $875 million at at less than 1% interest rate and so. 65
- 30:17bits I think, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 30:19And so their ability to take advantage of the demand from
- 30:24bondholders and take advantage of the volatility that's priced
- 30:29into their stock is a, a, a first mover advantage.
- 30:34And the larger they get, the more they're going to be able to
- 30:37do that. I think where you will see other
- 30:42companies follow the explicit micro strategy playbook is in
- 30:46other capital markets like Metaplanet in Japan.
- 30:50Maybe you'll get another company doing the same thing in, in
- 30:53Europe or Hong Kong, but I, I don't see too many more like
- 30:58similar scientifics doing that. And the main reason why is
- 31:03because I don't think companies will get rewarded all that much
- 31:06in the future for having too much of their business trade off
- 31:10of the value of Bitcoin as opposed to their underlying cash
- 31:14flows. Michael, were you going to say
- 31:17something? No, I think it's spot on.
- 31:18Nobody talks about this. There's all these companies
- 31:21doing their Spacs and this stuff, and it's just like
- 31:24there's what you describe the liquidity, but also the
- 31:27underlying cash flows of micro strategy help protect it from
- 31:30the debt that's owed. And nobody else has that.
- 31:33So you can get wiped out if the market corrects, which is just
- 31:37how everybody gets wiped out when they use leverage in
- 31:39Bitcoin. But nobody says what you just
- 31:41said. So yeah, it's spot on.
- 31:43I kind of have the same sentiment.
- 31:45But I think, yeah, I think that if, if, if another company that
- 31:50had positive cash flows in the US or many of them tried to put,
- 31:54you know, 50% of their enterprise value in the Bitcoin,
- 31:57then they would get some sort of conglomerate discount from the
- 32:01market. Because so every investor in
- 32:05micro strategy knows that they're getting exposure to
- 32:07Bitcoin leveraged. But, but if, if, if Apple were
- 32:13to put 50% or 100% of their treasury in the Bitcoin and
- 32:17their cash flows were, were much lower, they would get a, a like
- 32:23they would be punished by the market for doing that.
- 32:25Because you would have all these investors that are looking for
- 32:28the cash flows of Apple. And now they have to also
- 32:31include the, the price performance of Bitcoin as well.
- 32:35I mean, personally, I would love to see Apple do that.
- 32:37That'd be awesome. But I don't think too many
- 32:40companies are going to do that. And you're going to have a lot
- 32:42more that are just going to take a measured approach to
- 32:45allocating three or five or 10% of their balance sheet to
- 32:49Bitcoin. Yeah, I think that's right.
- 32:52I think I think you're right too that like Japan, China, Europe,
- 32:57maybe a a few other capital markets could have their own
- 33:01version of MicroStrategy. But you're right, it's kind of a
- 33:05singular play and and a coincidence of a lot of things
- 33:08that needed to line up of Michael Saylor had control of
- 33:11the company. So he could make this decision
- 33:15after reading the Bitcoin standard, you know, like that's
- 33:18the amount of of buy in he needed.
- 33:23And and then also that, as I've said, it was a zombie company.
- 33:28So they were, they were able to make this sort of clean jump
- 33:30from where we're we're an operating company that does
- 33:33business intelligence software into we are a Bitcoin leverage
- 33:39play and, and, and now all of our investors understand that
- 33:44they're not expecting us to be Apple cash flowing.
- 33:47You know that this is a pureplay.
- 33:49So yeah, you're right that you know that a lot of things had to
- 33:52line up. And that's I guess why we it's
- 33:54four years later and we haven't seen many other large public
- 34:00companies do a similar strategy. There's, there's, I think we
- 34:03underestimated at the time how unique Micro Strategy's position
- 34:07was. And, and yeah, now they're like
- 34:10true corporate adoption as like a treasury asset is, is really
- 34:15happening. But that that's on the scale of
- 34:17like 3% rather than 150% like Micro Strategy has done.
- 34:22Yeah, exactly. I, I don't know if you guys
- 34:24remember seeing at at the very beginning of this year, ahead of
- 34:29the ETF launches, when, when people knew that they were going
- 34:32to launch on January 11th, a, a very popular trade was shorting
- 34:38micro strategy. Because the thought was that
- 34:41like they're, they're like the gap between, you know, their,
- 34:47their value in Bitcoin was going to close.
- 34:49Because why would you invest in micro strategy if there's spot
- 34:53Bitcoin ETFs now and the market was entirely proven wrong.
- 34:58Like I think, yeah, yeah, it was an early 2024 where like they
- 35:02just gapped higher, squeezed a bunch of shorts.
- 35:06And I think that is a testament to how successful their strategy
- 35:11is with tapping into bond market investors and volatility
- 35:15investors by just issuing convertible notes like month
- 35:20after month after month. So yeah, I'm curious if you guys
- 35:24have any thoughts on like where they're going in the future.
- 35:27But I don't see micro strategy like going away anytime soon.
- 35:32Yeah, we, we happen to have a Michael Saylor on the podcast
- 35:36earlier this week that'll, that'll be coming out in a few
- 35:39weeks. So, and we, we were quizzing him
- 35:42about I sort of personally as a, as a, as a Bitcoiner, I'm, I
- 35:48just hold Bitcoin and I have FOMO watching what MicroStrategy
- 35:52is doing. And I, I, you know, I'm tempted
- 35:55to, you know, get a micro strategy allocation because what
- 35:59he's effectively doing and, and what they've now oriented their
- 36:02KPIs around is this concept of Bitcoin yield that they are
- 36:07delivering on. And it comes with some risk, but
- 36:11I think it's, it's working. And I think that that risk is,
- 36:15is, is small enough that it's attractive to me as a, as a, as
- 36:20a Bitcoiner and, and someone who would like to grow their stack,
- 36:22right. But so we were quizzing him
- 36:25about this. And, and yeah, that's, that's
- 36:28the strategy. And, you know, they're going to
- 36:30keep leveraging the tools they have at their disposal.
- 36:34We had this conversation a few hours before they announced
- 36:36their latest 875,000,000. So they're just going to keep on
- 36:41doing this so long as capital markets are are inefficient in
- 36:45how they're pricing micro strategy.
- 36:47And also so long as the, the the debt markets don't have any
- 36:52better way to get, you know, exposure to the upside of
- 36:54Bitcoin, right? It's a, it's a hell of an offer
- 36:58to to a debt market of like, I will pay you back.
- 37:02Basically, you know what I borrow from you using my
- 37:05operating company plus 65 bits of of interest, but basically
- 37:09like you're going to get your money back and if there's
- 37:12upside, then you can participate in that upside.
- 37:15What like what a hell of an offer.
- 37:16And I think there's going to be no shortage of, of, of, you
- 37:21know, debt of debt market participants who want more of
- 37:24that into the future. So this is a fun spicy one
- 37:28because I didn't expect we were going to go here, but I'll, I, I
- 37:31think I, I think the micro strategy stuff's cool in the
- 37:35sense of like it's just a fun, you know, you have somebody that
- 37:37can do something different and see how far you can take it.
- 37:41I think it's right where Jesse, I've seen a lot of like folks
- 37:45that are friends that respect like where they have like 4 O1
- 37:48KS and tax advantage accounts get exposure, which makes sense,
- 37:51although you could take a couple extra steps and get reduced to
- 37:55counterparty risk by doing self-directed.
- 37:57But it's an easy form to go get leverage and individuals won't
- 38:00leverage with micro strategy. Where where I think maybe Jesse
- 38:04and others should just think twice about selling Bitcoin for
- 38:08it is because it's the same reason why individuals don't go
- 38:12invested. I know it's different, but it's
- 38:13kind of the same in like Solana, because you can go get some like
- 38:18higher potential leverage on the crypto market by going to
- 38:21another asset. But you basically have like
- 38:23three to four layers of counterparty risk.
- 38:26And one of them is the mental counterparty risk because now
- 38:28you're paying attention to something instead of just doing
- 38:30what somebody was supposed to do.
- 38:31And then when you exit because you have to exit the trade,
- 38:33right, because you ultimately want Bitcoin.
- 38:34But that's just one layer of counterparty risk.
- 38:36The one that shocks me that nobody talks about.
- 38:40Well, there's actually two. One of them is like, where do
- 38:42they custody this? Because it's all centralized
- 38:44custodians. And if they lose the underlying,
- 38:47your sats per share is actually 0.
- 38:50Nobody says that. And the second one is they're
- 38:53basically poking the bear. And I don't like poking the bear
- 38:56when it's messing with the money because what happens when the
- 38:59bear is like, hey, I think I'm going to need that for whatever
- 39:02reason. I'm not saying that ever could
- 39:03happen, but like that has to go in the equation.
- 39:05And so you layer all of that and then the taxable events on the
- 39:08exit of your position into that and then selling that position
- 39:11back in. And it's like, yeah, I think I'm
- 39:14good and I don't. And I'd say for Jesse, I'm
- 39:16saying in general, like that's how individuals should think
- 39:18about it. Like corporates and that need
- 39:20exposure and they want higher leverage and all of it.
- 39:22But I don't think for like the average bitcoiner, they should
- 39:25be selling their Bitcoin to go get it exposure to like a
- 39:29publicly traded company as their Bitcoin price exposure.
- 39:32Yeah. And ultimately for me that the
- 39:34thing that tips the scale big time is the taxable event of of
- 39:38you know, I, I don't, I unfortunately don't have any
- 39:41Bitcoin in a tax advantage account.
- 39:44Otherwise this would be a lot more tempting.
- 39:46Frankly, I think I would, if I did, I would probably chase that
- 39:52with, with some small percentage like, you know, five, maybe 10%,
- 39:57but limited to that because there is a, there are risks that
- 40:01go with it. I just think that, you know,
- 40:03Solana, Solana has greater risks than it's worth.
- 40:08But I feel, I'm inclined to think that this strategy, that
- 40:12micro micro strategy is deploying is less risky than the
- 40:16yield that they are generating. But that's my personal take.
- 40:20But the thing that stops me from doing it is I, you know, Michael
- 40:23Saylor says don't sell your Bitcoin.
- 40:25He's right. Like it's better to have the
- 40:27underlying thing. If this thing's going to 200X
- 40:30over the next 20 years, as, as Michael Saylor says it, it will,
- 40:35and you know, we also say it will, then, then I don't want to
- 40:41screw that up. That's so let's say it another
- 40:43way. Sam, I'm curious your question
- 40:44'cause I was going to pose it as like, let's pretend because this
- 40:46is effective. What we're talking about Michael
- 40:48Saylor or micro strategy is Coinbase.
- 40:51So if they do what they do in in in infinite infinitum, like they
- 40:55get to what they want to, then they have 900,000 whatever the
- 40:58number of Bitcoin. Will we talk about Coinbase not
- 41:02holding all this asset because of of this and where it goes.
- 41:06So how confident like Jesse, where would that breakdown where
- 41:10you'd feel concerned? Because we feel concerned with
- 41:12Coinbase having all this Bitcoin for all the reasons that we
- 41:15feel. It's the same thing with micro
- 41:17strategy. And it's just this is BlackRock,
- 41:22right? Yeah, this isn't the fun part
- 41:25about having these discussions and like where I think we found
- 41:27luck in this or cool part of the show is like this is stuff
- 41:29nobody talks about. Like we got crypto Twitter,
- 41:32Bitcoin Twitter, we have everybody stats per share.
- 41:34But it's like wait, let's break this down.
- 41:36Like what is actually happening here?
- 41:38And let's think about like the actual first principle risk of
- 41:41where it is. And there's this notion of the
- 41:43underline and and I think that's another component of this of
- 41:46there's a centralization of an asset happening that
- 41:49historically does you don't want it to centralized.
- 41:51And I think Jesse, where you where this would come in, where
- 41:54would make more sense is a 5A3A55O7 where Fidelity Coinbase
- 42:01bit go river on ramp like all these keys.
- 42:03Now you can actually know this underline and maybe they're all
- 42:06over the world. So when somebody has an issue
- 42:07with it, it's like, well, now you're protected and micro
- 42:10Sailor probably should hold micro strategy as a tech
- 42:12company, they should probably participate in that.
- 42:15Then I think you start to de risk it.
- 42:17But it's pretty wild that like they're just allowed to like
- 42:19leave all this Bitcoin on a central point of failure, which
- 42:22historically hasn't really worked very well for the 1st 15
- 42:24years in Bitcoin. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 42:28keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 42:30sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 42:33Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 42:35with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 42:38device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 42:42and our multi institution custody solution.
- 42:45Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 42:48multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 42:52a key on ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 42:56unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 43:00over your coins with on ramps multi institution custody.
- 43:04You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 43:06with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 43:10sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 43:12going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 43:16exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench of tax
- 43:20in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 43:23you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 43:26custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 43:29eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 43:33attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 43:36financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 43:39Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 43:43warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading
- 43:46and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 43:49asset. Secure it right.
- 43:51Learn more at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 43:54Yeah, Yeah. No, it's, it's a very fairpoint.
- 43:56And Sam, you brought up the ETFs as well and 90% of those assets
- 44:01are custody with Coinbase too. So that poses a huge risk of
- 44:04centralization and becoming an unsecured creditor of that firm.
- 44:08I'm curious because there was also a little bit of information
- 44:13in the report, I believe about ETFs, right?
- 44:16And there's obviously one big inhibitor to firms purchasing
- 44:22the ETF is if, if you have over 40% of your treasury
- 44:26insecurities, you have to register as an investment
- 44:29company, if I understand that correctly.
- 44:31Are there other considerations you think that firms will think
- 44:36through as it relates to ETF exposure versus spot exposure
- 44:40beyond just investment company versus commodity?
- 44:44Are there other things you think people are are considering?
- 44:50I think there are a lot of reasons why a business should
- 44:53hold spot Bitcoin instead of an ETF, and I think those reasons
- 44:58are pretty straightforward. And I haven't seen a single
- 45:01company buy the ETFs as opposed to spot Bitcoin.
- 45:07I think you know, Yeah, yeah, as you mentioned, there's the Forty
- 45:10Act, which requires a company to hold less than 40% of their
- 45:15assets as securities. That may be one reason why a lot
- 45:22of companies haven't bought a lot of gold on their treasuries
- 45:25in the past, because you you either have to hold GLD and pain
- 45:30management fees on it and potentially be an investment
- 45:33company, or you have to buy gold which is not liquid at all.
- 45:38And so you don't get any of the advantages or like roles of a
- 45:43traditional treasury asset. So Bitcoin can really just play
- 45:49a perfect role with both the liquidity and the price
- 45:53appreciation while serving as a commodity.
- 45:56And so I think I think it's a pretty obvious decision for
- 45:59companies to just buy spot Bitcoin.
- 46:02Maybe the one consideration would be custody because a lot
- 46:05of business owners or or not all that familiar with custody.
- 46:10But yeah, until until I see an example of a company that's
- 46:14buying the the ETFs instead of spot Bitcoin, I'm not all
- 46:17concerned about that. How how do you think about
- 46:21custody for as much as you could share that cohort and the
- 46:25percentages in the reason, one of the reasons I ask is part of
- 46:28the, you know, our firm is, was realizing back when you talk
- 46:32about the five person investment committee, an individual's very
- 46:35easy to make decisions. They can specifically like they
- 46:39can do self custody live on river using ETF.
- 46:41But the second they have to go to a committee that's looking at
- 46:44this anything past like, OK, they're like, well, wait,
- 46:47where's the custodian? And if you tell them you're
- 46:49going to hold it on plastic devices, they're just like,
- 46:52absolutely not. That's where like the ETF kind
- 46:54of comes in because it's like, I'd rather nobody gets fired for
- 46:57buying an ETF there. If they lose the assets.
- 46:59Well, it's at least we did the thing.
- 47:01So I'm curious how you guys have seen that play in because you
- 47:04guys have, you know, world class custody, Alex, just put out, you
- 47:07get your team put out the the reserves stuff where if you want
- 47:12to plug that's that'd be great. But like how you guys think
- 47:14about that and how firms, if it's a if it precludes them for
- 47:17getting exposure or like what I've seen sometimes is when
- 47:21there's material, when it gets to a certain threshold, that's
- 47:23when people start to really get concerned with allocating more
- 47:25because they're like, well, I felt good about this.
- 47:27Now I don't really feel good because I don't really know what
- 47:30the fault tolerance or redundancy is in this.
- 47:33Yeah. Well, I doubt that there will be
- 47:35any disagreement between us when it comes to custody.
- 47:38I think that businesses should always be very concerned about
- 47:42custody and should always be very thoughtful about where
- 47:46they're holding their Bitcoin. You mentioned like no one gets
- 47:50fired for like buying an ETF. I, I don't think anyone in the
- 47:56public company space gets fired for onboarding with Coinbase and
- 48:01that's why eight of the 9 ETF issuers are custoding with
- 48:05Coinbase. The one exception, Fidelity has
- 48:08their in house custody. And I think the same is going to
- 48:11be for a lot of the largest publicly traded companies.
- 48:16I think that most of them are going to go to Coinbase because
- 48:20simply like you're not going to get fired for going to the
- 48:24largest, most regulated custodian.
- 48:28That being said, there are, you know, I, I think there are only
- 48:3220,000 companies in the US that are over 500 employees.
- 48:37There are 33 million other smaller companies that can take
- 48:41the time to actually think more deeply about like what custody
- 48:45solution makes most sense for them.
- 48:48As As for River, we we've built all our custody in house.
- 48:54So many companies trust us with our own custody solutions in in
- 49:00cold storage. I I'd be happy to speak a little
- 49:03bit about the proof of reserves maybe a little bit later, but we
- 49:08also encourage companies to withdraw to self custody if they
- 49:12have the technical expertise to do so.
- 49:15I think another great solution for for for businesses is some
- 49:21sort of collaborative custody or like multi institutional custody
- 49:26model where they're dividing up that risk because I think you
- 49:30can mitigate both the risks of self custody and just trusting a
- 49:35single third party. And so, yeah, yeah, I think that
- 49:40all businesses at any point should be concerned about it, no
- 49:44matter how large or small their allocation is.
- 49:48Yeah. I think just on that note,
- 49:49what's interesting, it's a good slide to keep up, Jackson, is I
- 49:53think the interesting part where you said, Sam, and like what we
- 49:55feel as individuals is we have too much exposure, maybe just
- 49:59the right amount depending on who you ask on Bitcoin.
- 50:02So you naturally have to think through custody really deeply
- 50:05because it's majority if not all of one's net worth.
- 50:09And if we believe where we're going is this is the best store
- 50:11of value, that's ultimately where businesses store all their
- 50:14value that all these things ultimately hit ahead, right?
- 50:17They have to plan ahead because whether the price appreciation
- 50:20or they're increasing adoption of the asset and divesting from
- 50:23other investment vehicles, it's just something it's like it's a
- 50:28just natural kind of like it hits an inflection point and it
- 50:31kind of almost like it hinders increasing and people don't talk
- 50:34about it. It's almost implicit versus
- 50:37explicit in that they don't buy more because they're just like,
- 50:42oh, I don't feel comfortable. And is it like this is the
- 50:44threshold I'm willing to lose or I'm willing to mess up versus
- 50:47like creating the tools and solutions that let people
- 50:50actually be able to get as much as they want and feel that
- 50:54there's like you reference, you know, multi institution.
- 50:56One of the aspects is like this, this notion of financial
- 50:59controls that exists for wires and any movement of assets at
- 51:02any corporate level. Like that's what we have to
- 51:05figure out from a Bitcoin perspective.
- 51:07And you probably want that with multiple institutions.
- 51:09So then the assets can't move unless there's all of these
- 51:12things that happened in place. And that's where like going back
- 51:14to the MSTR thing, I think would need to be in place for that.
- 51:17Like what happens when it's 3X, right?
- 51:19We're at 180 K and we all know like that's just going to never.
- 51:23I mean, it'll happen. And they're like, what do they
- 51:25do then? And what do the shareholders do
- 51:26that like when you know? Just a bit, yeah.
- 51:30You got to be thinking a cycle or two cycles ahead at all
- 51:33times. Sam, I'm curious, so on this
- 51:37slide right there's about 1/4 of businesses surveyed have
- 51:41concerns about custody and trading.
- 51:44And you mentioned that you provide kind of like an unbiased
- 51:48menu or choice of different custody models, right, self
- 51:52custody, collaborative custody, multi institution, traditional
- 51:57third party custody. I'm curious like to the extent
- 52:00you're able to share or have the insights, how do you, how do you
- 52:05perceive business owners comfortability around self
- 52:08custody? Like do you find a lot of times
- 52:10as it relates to their business that there is discomfort there
- 52:13and they're typically opting to keep their Bitcoin parked with
- 52:16river or is it, you know, is it the other way around?
- 52:20You're finding that most people prefer to have self custody or
- 52:23collaborative custody even for their business assets.
- 52:26Yeah, I, I think for a lot of the smaller and medium sized
- 52:30businesses, the, the thought process is very similar to
- 52:34probably how we, we all approached it as individuals,
- 52:38right. You, you kind of buy Bitcoin
- 52:40first, you have it on an exchange for a little bit, then
- 52:43you Start learning more about self custody and then you
- 52:46eventually start dipping your toes in the water.
- 52:49Anecdotally from the businesses I've spoken with, all of them
- 52:54that that I've spoken with would would like to eventually get to
- 52:59a place where they're very comfortable holding their own
- 53:02assets and self casting their Bitcoin.
- 53:04And they're kind of in the process of getting comfortable
- 53:09with the flows of, you know, putting their excess cash
- 53:13reserves in the Bitcoin. And you know, as that allocation
- 53:17grows in size, then they end up starting to move some off of the
- 53:22river and into self custody. Yeah.
- 53:26No, that's interesting. I mean we all kind of just spoke
- 53:30to it. But the idea that you have to be
- 53:32thinking one or two cycles ahead, right?
- 53:34And I I would almost take the inverse of what you said, not in
- 53:38an argumentative way, but like in the instance that Bitcoin is
- 53:42100,100 and 2200 thousand 500,000, you know, thinking 5,
- 53:47let's call it about five years down the line.
- 53:50I would be shocked if more people were moving their assets
- 53:53off of river and doing self custody versus leaving it on
- 53:56river or using another third party solution like what we have
- 53:59here at on ramp, Especially now that you guys have the proof of
- 54:02reserves right and you're extremely transparent as a
- 54:04business about how those assets are.
- 54:06I mean, commend you guys for doing that.
- 54:08I think that's fantastic. So I'd almost, I'd almost
- 54:11disagree. I think it's the price
- 54:12increases, there's going to be more and more discomfort and
- 54:15especially if there's, you know, let's call it 5-10 or more
- 54:19stakeholders involved in the business, it becomes
- 54:22challenging, I'd imagine to figure out who actually manages
- 54:25keys. How do you think about
- 54:26succession planning? How do we actually get like
- 54:28technically savvy enough to be managing these within our
- 54:31organization? So it'll certainly be
- 54:33interesting to play out over the next couple of years, I think.
- 54:36The the caveat with that is it's.
- 54:38It's very much sure. The problem is it's part of the
- 54:41founding like of in this business is that 2022 everyone
- 54:46blew up. So you don't know who to trust.
- 54:48So you just see all the assets move out of central exchanges.
- 54:51They don't know like who's a good player, who's the bad
- 54:53player? People don't they just see the
- 54:54right and they leave it for a while and they go into, you
- 54:58know, we just forget. We have short memories in space.
- 55:00And so like a net new wave will come in and they'll be like,
- 55:03it's cool, like all the custodians have all the world
- 55:05class stuff like river, but we know that's not true and we
- 55:09can't help ourselves. And so then they lose assets.
- 55:12And then I think Jackson, it starts that vicious cycle of
- 55:15like, oh, we got to take self custody.
- 55:16And it's like, because custody, it's just the problem that
- 55:20there's a digital bearer asset and you don't know who not to
- 55:24trust. This is a problem with the self
- 55:26custody. So that's like the OP the and I
- 55:28don't think that that moves away.
- 55:31It just consistently every cycle goes and it's kind of where we
- 55:34have this like longer term vision where individuals, if
- 55:38we're right, we'll catch you into it or we'll go in and we're
- 55:41like ahead of it. But it's like this is a logical
- 55:43progression because it's the middle ground between not having
- 55:46to deal with the pain of self custody and holding millions of
- 55:49dollars in your house on a plastic device, but also not
- 55:52having to just singularly rely on the best institution.
- 55:56Because it's almost hard to fully know, especially when
- 55:59people as you know in the business world, like they're
- 56:01literally trying to survive in their core competency to go from
- 56:04a technical perspective and know who the best is.
- 56:07It's almost. It's very hard for them to do
- 56:11so. Yeah, as as much as we do
- 56:14encourage River clients to self custody and just withdraw their
- 56:20coins every month, it's also very encouraging to see like
- 56:23now, now that we have our proof of reserves, you you can see our
- 56:27assets under custody, it's publicly available information.
- 56:30And to see that number grow and grow month after month compared
- 56:34to like, you know, coin bases or some other large crypto
- 56:38exchanges assets under custody decline.
- 56:41It, it's encouraging to see that because I think it's a sign of
- 56:44how much trust is placed in in river.
- 56:48And so, yeah, yeah, we're very much paying attention to that.
- 56:52Yeah, it, it's, it does remind me of the, I mean, we talked
- 56:56about that nobody ever got fired buying IBM and buying IBM right
- 57:03now in terms of custody is trust in Coinbase.
- 57:06And I feel like, you know, there's always a lag between the
- 57:10reputation of a brand and like what they're actually, you know,
- 57:13like what what they've actually built.
- 57:14And and, you know, you see, I think that's a great point that
- 57:18rivers Bitcoin under custody growing over time is it is a
- 57:22sign of trust building for river.
- 57:25And whereas, you know, coins coming off of these larger older
- 57:30exchanges like Coinbase is, is a sign of the inverse.
- 57:34And, and I think it just goes back to like the market in
- 57:39general is still quite naive, naive about what they should
- 57:42consider with regard to custody solutions for Bitcoin.
- 57:47And so you default to reputational brand and, and
- 57:52Coinbase is the big player still in that sense.
- 57:56But but that's really all they they've got going for them.
- 57:58They've got a long track record and and they're the name that
- 58:03people know and they're not investing in in, you know, proof
- 58:08of reserves the way the river is.
- 58:10They're not in investing in an improvement on multi sig that
- 58:17like on ramp is doing with multi institution custody.
- 58:21And I think there there's, it's just a lag function between the
- 58:24market realizing, learning more about what matters and shifting
- 58:28away from IBM and towards, you know, the, the, the newer
- 58:33solutions that have better properties and maybe just our
- 58:39younger brand. And client services, like I
- 58:42would commend, I was, I won't call it the person, but working
- 58:45with River on a investment fund and we're accepting wires and,
- 58:49and some of it was going into to River and like one of the, on
- 58:53the client service side was like sending me texts and helping
- 58:55onboarded. Like you can't get that at a
- 58:58coin base or, or crack it. Like you just get no help and
- 59:01it's a black box. It's always been like that
- 59:03because the market's too reflexive and they have too many
- 59:04clients to have to serve. And they aren't really financial
- 59:07institutions. They're more of like this weird
- 59:09mix between attack in a, in a financial institution and you
- 59:12don't get that. So that's another big thing
- 59:15going for firms that really care about the client experience.
- 59:18Sam, on the, on the note of those like 4 cohorts, and I was
- 59:22kind of surprised to see the, what was the objection?
- 59:25What was the 1st? The main one that was a
- 59:28hindrance. Liquidity.
- 59:32I was thinking through. Accounting.
- 59:34It was accounting. That was everyone.
- 59:36I was kind of surprised. Oh yeah, yeah, that.
- 59:39Like it, it makes sense, but also just curious like, like the
- 59:42regulatory concerns, I feel like is this big backdrop and maybe
- 59:46that's more because we're further in the weeds.
- 59:48But like this election and a lot of that we've anecdotally heard,
- 59:52you know, people are just stay out of the markets or waiting
- 59:54till election because there's just a natural kind of it's
- 59:57turned into an issue from from a political perspective like
- 1:00:00Bitcoin or crypto in general. Like just what surprised you in
- 1:00:04those findings or or was there anything that it was a pretty
- 1:00:08much on par with kind of like the anecdotes you've seen in the
- 1:00:10market? Well, yeah, I think I think that
- 1:00:13chart may be slightly misleading in that it it is representative
- 1:00:19of a survey of businesses across many different industries.
- 1:00:23And I think the regulatory concerns are very valid for
- 1:00:29certain businesses that either have money transmitter licenses
- 1:00:34or they're in the mining space and they think that, you know,
- 1:00:36they could be discharged from where they're operating.
- 1:00:41So there are certain specific businesses that should be
- 1:00:44thinking about regulatory risk very carefully, but for for your
- 1:00:51mom and pop, you know, restaurant or home builder or
- 1:00:56construction worker that is just following a simple strategy of
- 1:01:01buy and hold. Anecdotally, I've not heard
- 1:01:05regulatory as a a large concern about adding Bitcoin.
- 1:01:13Yeah, the one. That surprises me on this is the
- 1:01:14stakeholders to agree like because we all know, you know,
- 1:01:18it's like the way I think about this is like a family, right?
- 1:01:21Like if we went to our family and it's our balance sheet,
- 1:01:23we're like, hey, we should buy some Bitcoin.
- 1:01:26I guess if you're the patriarch and the person's leading, that's
- 1:01:28that's what you see come through.
- 1:01:29And there's probably a lot of people you never see or you get
- 1:01:32an interest, but they never make it through because if you're the
- 1:01:35son and try to get the family to buy Bitcoin, it's a hard sell,
- 1:01:40if that makes sense. Like that certain businesses
- 1:01:42never get to see you guys because it's not the right setup
- 1:01:46for there's no shorter people that probably have somebody part
- 1:01:49of their firm that wants Bitcoin, but everyone else is
- 1:01:51like, this is not the thing we're going to do.
- 1:01:54Yeah, yeah. Often times it's a family run,
- 1:01:56you know multi generational business where the son or the
- 1:01:59grandson is trying to orange pill their their parents and it
- 1:02:04takes sometimes years to to drive it to completion.
- 1:02:10What about on this chart, Sam, with accounting and tax
- 1:02:13treatment as it relates to public companies Like what are
- 1:02:15your thoughts going into 2025? Well, yeah.
- 1:02:19So, so the Fast B is the organization that establishes
- 1:02:24gap accounting, which is the accounting standards that every
- 1:02:28company follows in the US. And last December they put out
- 1:02:32guidance that updated how Bitcoin is accounted for on
- 1:02:39financial statements, which makes it a lot more favorable
- 1:02:43for especially a public company to hold because you're, you're
- 1:02:48no longer going to get punished by having to account for Bitcoin
- 1:02:51at at its lowest observable value in, in like since you
- 1:02:58bought it basically. So it was very punitive for a
- 1:03:02while. And then they put out this
- 1:03:04statement in, in December that is officially going into effect
- 1:03:09this December, I believe. But companies may choose to
- 1:03:14implement it at any point before then.
- 1:03:17And so you've had companies like Block already implement these
- 1:03:21new standards. And so I think, I think that
- 1:03:26with this new, you know, standard set, it'll make it a
- 1:03:29lot easier for businesses to be able to actually pull the
- 1:03:34trigger on making a Bitcoin investment and not having to
- 1:03:38worry about like how investors are going are going to, you
- 1:03:43know, complain about net earnings being lower than they
- 1:03:48otherwise should be. Yeah.
- 1:03:50It feels like a massive roadblock that's been lifted.
- 1:03:53But at the same time, I'm almost skeptical now of the degree of
- 1:03:57which public companies will adopt Bitcoin only because of
- 1:04:00what we kind of talked about earlier as it relates to micro
- 1:04:03strategy, right? And like in 2020, everyone on
- 1:04:06Bitcoin Twitter was just talking about how this would just be the
- 1:04:09first of many companies to kind of deploy the strategy.
- 1:04:11And I agree with you, Sam, and kind of what's been discussed
- 1:04:14today that they're uniquely suited.
- 1:04:16And we probably won't see many other companies beyond what
- 1:04:18we've seen already deploy that strategy.
- 1:04:21But actually thinking about now just making an allocation within
- 1:04:24public companies as a treasury asset, right?
- 1:04:26Like maybe 1125 percent. Do you actually think that we're
- 1:04:30on the precipice now with these accounting changes, that we'll
- 1:04:33see a surge in demand next year? Or do you think that maybe it
- 1:04:36could play out being a little bit more tepid than some, you
- 1:04:40know, some commentators are making out to be?
- 1:04:43Yeah, I think you might see some marginal growth in the number of
- 1:04:48public companies that are adding Bitcoin to their balance sheet.
- 1:04:51But I think the primary drivers of business Bitcoin adoption
- 1:04:56will continue to be from private and smaller companies.
- 1:05:00You know, they're the ones that don't have to be worrying about
- 1:05:04next quarter's earnings. They don't have to, you know,
- 1:05:07get 100 people to sign off on a Bitcoin investment.
- 1:05:12All those concerns will will, will still be there for public
- 1:05:15companies. And so, you know, it would be
- 1:05:18very encouraging to see some more public companies invest in
- 1:05:22Bitcoin. I mean, we've seen 40% growth in
- 1:05:25the number of public companies that have a Bitcoin strategy in
- 1:05:27the past year, but that number is still quite small.
- 1:05:32I believe it's less than 60 public companies worldwide.
- 1:05:36And so you know, we'll, we'll probably still be below 2 or 300
- 1:05:42in a few years if we just follow that follow that growth, whereas
- 1:05:46I think you'll, you'll continue to see a lot more growth from,
- 1:05:51from smaller businesses. Yeah, I think that's that's dead
- 1:05:55right. I I do think that the one aspect
- 1:05:58of the fasby change that people are under estimating the impact
- 1:06:04of is that companies with significant Bitcoin holdings,
- 1:06:09their quarterly earnings calls, those CF OS and CE OS are going
- 1:06:14to start looking like rock stars quarter after quarter after
- 1:06:18quarter. And to date, it's been punitive
- 1:06:21and you've looked like a loser because you've had to mark down
- 1:06:25to the lowest point that Bitcoin got to during the quarter and
- 1:06:28then take the the hit every single quarter, no matter what,
- 1:06:33you know, the actual value of of your coins got is now.
- 1:06:36And and that's going to switch to companies, C suites that have
- 1:06:41Bitcoin as part of their treasury looking like geniuses
- 1:06:44or just like, you know, being able to advertise like, yeah,
- 1:06:48we, we, we, yeah, we had a operating, operating income of
- 1:06:54100 million this quarter, but we also had a $1 billion gain in
- 1:06:59our Bitcoin holding. So we made $1.1 billion this
- 1:07:02quarter. Look how much better we are this
- 1:07:04year versus a few years ago. Like that's going to start
- 1:07:07happening. And that's going to, it's going
- 1:07:09to, it's going to be kind of stark between companies that
- 1:07:12don't have that tailwind on their, on their earnings calls
- 1:07:16and those that do. And I think that's going to just
- 1:07:19seep into the psychology of C suites of like, well, you know,
- 1:07:22I'm, I'm jealous, plus I'm envious of these companies that
- 1:07:25get that tailwind. So maybe we we should take a
- 1:07:27more serious look at, you know, adopting that as part of our
- 1:07:31strategy too. Yeah, I mean, same on that note,
- 1:07:34like I was thinking through what Jesse was referencing and part
- 1:07:38of what probably seems like it's hard adoption for institutions
- 1:07:42or, or specifically publicly traded companies.
- 1:07:45Is this multifaceted, not only in the understanding of Bitcoin,
- 1:07:49but getting the groups internally to to buy in.
- 1:07:54But then ultimately where do you park it?
- 1:07:56Because it has a liquidity profile of a, of a treasury,
- 1:08:00like we're talking about treasuries and as a liquidity
- 1:08:02profile of cash equivalents. But they can't actually treat it
- 1:08:06like that because of the volatility.
- 1:08:08So they have to look at it as a longer term player.
- 1:08:11That doesn't make any sense to allocate.
- 1:08:13They're not coming for six months as like a money market
- 1:08:15fund. It's like a, you know, 2-4 year,
- 1:08:17whatever the duration. And so then they have to
- 1:08:19naturally like manage that internally.
- 1:08:22And that seems like a very complex thing to get by and
- 1:08:25especially at a significant amount.
- 1:08:27How do you think about that? And do you think that like is
- 1:08:29hindered some of this because it's not that many companies
- 1:08:33like thinking in that way as well.
- 1:08:36And then why wouldn't you just do stock buybacks and do other
- 1:08:38things with your capital? And then that's where goods you
- 1:08:40start damaging or getting punished for allocating to it as
- 1:08:43well. Yeah, well, I do.
- 1:08:45I do think it makes sense for most companies, both public and
- 1:08:50private, to hold on to a lot of excess cash because those that
- 1:08:55do are going to be able to withstand, you know, cyclical
- 1:08:59downturns a lot better because they're not going to have to
- 1:09:02dilute their shareholders every time they need to raise money.
- 1:09:06And so I think, I think this whole thing is going to require
- 1:09:10just a rethinking of treasury management generally, because to
- 1:09:15your point, Bitcoin doesn't fit into any existing sleeve of a
- 1:09:21treasury. Like if you if you look at
- 1:09:23Apple's balance sheet, they you know, all of its low duration,
- 1:09:28all of its fixed income. And so there's not really a
- 1:09:32place that could easily that you could easily say, Oh yeah, like
- 1:09:35I'm going to swap this out for Bitcoin and it's going to serve
- 1:09:38the same purpose. And so, yeah, yeah, I think it's
- 1:09:43going to take a long time for for CF OS to come around to just
- 1:09:48rethinking their approach to treasury management with a
- 1:09:53longer term time horizon. Would you?
- 1:09:56Would you agree? Yeah, it's just a hard thing.
- 1:09:59I mean, we, we see it on the institutional side, right, Like
- 1:10:01pensions and institutions in generals, like what what bucket
- 1:10:05falls in? We had a, we have an advisor, he
- 1:10:07had his firm bought by Blackstone and he, he was a
- 1:10:10hedge fund and he said that he had the same problem 20-30 years
- 1:10:13ago. They said well, bucket and he
- 1:10:15and they were doing like crazy returns.
- 1:10:16He's like, I don't care what bucket you put it in, just you,
- 1:10:19you figure that out. That's your job.
- 1:10:21When you would talk to institutional investors,
- 1:10:23obviously we can't say that, but it reminds you of something like
- 1:10:25this. It's like, do you want the best
- 1:10:26performing asset of all time or not?
- 1:10:27You figure out the bucket, Sam, Sam, I know we're running up on
- 1:10:34time. I'm curious like you had three
- 1:10:35head notes on three interesting parts of like future adoption
- 1:10:41with Bitcoin, so it's cross-border wages and commerce.
- 1:10:45Curious where you see the anecdotes from the interest and
- 1:10:49also what's because I think that's a different angle and
- 1:10:51flavor of adoption is people don't want to come at it from
- 1:10:55money, they want to come at it from operational efficiencies
- 1:10:58and then that's the Trojan horse into coming into it as a store
- 1:11:00of value. And curious like any if what you
- 1:11:03saw there. Well, a a report on business
- 1:11:07Bitcoin adoption would not be comprehensive if we only focused
- 1:11:12on Bitcoin as a treasury asset, because for many companies and
- 1:11:17nonprofits, they're they're using it very much so as a
- 1:11:21payments mechanism. And so, you know, we, we really
- 1:11:25wanted to be inclusive of bitcoins payments use case.
- 1:11:29Of course, it's not nearly, you know, adopted at the level of of
- 1:11:35Bitcoin as a treasury asset. And frankly I don't anticipate
- 1:11:38it to to be adopted at the same rate.
- 1:11:41But we wanted to highlight a few specific like niche use cases
- 1:11:46where some businesses are getting a tremendous amount of
- 1:11:49value from using Bitcoin. A few of the of the case studies
- 1:11:54we have in the report focus on some of these companies that are
- 1:11:58that are using Bitcoin for payments.
- 1:12:00So just as a few examples, like if you're a nonprofit that is
- 1:12:04paying out, you know, wages across borders or you're
- 1:12:10settling, you know, cross-border contracts, for a lot of them, it
- 1:12:15makes sense to paying Bitcoin as opposed to dealing with the
- 1:12:19local currency. Alex Gladstein from HRF has
- 1:12:24spoken about this Like they, they, they settle their
- 1:12:27contracts in Bitcoin out of convenience, not because they're
- 1:12:30big corners, but because it helps them reduce jurisdictional
- 1:12:35and like political risk of a government in this, in, you
- 1:12:40know, Kenya or whatever, not wanting a certain business or
- 1:12:45group to get funded by HRF. And so for them, it makes a lot
- 1:12:49of sense for, you know, another nonprofit like Students for
- 1:12:54Liberty, most of their or sorry, I think it's 40% of their
- 1:12:58employees worldwide prefer to get paid at least a little bit
- 1:13:02in Bitcoin because a lot of those employees are based in
- 1:13:07Turkey or Argentina. And so they're, they're, they're
- 1:13:10dealing with a very different environment than we are in the
- 1:13:14USA. Final use case that I want to
- 1:13:18highlight is just the amount of demand from the Bitcoin
- 1:13:22community that I think business owners can like extract a
- 1:13:27tremendous amount of value by like being very supportive of
- 1:13:31the Bitcoin community. So P&E Lane is a vineyard in
- 1:13:35Colorado run by Ben Justman and Adams is a shoe company based in
- 1:13:41New York. And they have both very
- 1:13:44successfully tapped into just the, the demand from Bitcoiners
- 1:13:49that, you know, maybe they don't love selling Bitcoin all the
- 1:13:52time, but if there's a company that you can buy shoes from in
- 1:13:56Bitcoin, then like they're going to be supported.
- 1:13:59And one of the stats that Adams shared with me is that their,
- 1:14:04their average order size that's paid in Bitcoin is more than
- 1:14:09double their, their average order size that's paid in
- 1:14:12dollars. And I think that just speaks to
- 1:14:15like the, the quality of a of a Bitcoiner client.
- 1:14:20And so I don't see that being like a widespread thing where
- 1:14:25every business is going to start catering to bit corners.
- 1:14:28But if you are a small business owner and like you're trying to
- 1:14:31bootstrap your growth, I think that is a great strategy.
- 1:14:36One other one that you didn't mention, I think it was kind of
- 1:14:39in there and it's, we feel it and I think a lot of Bitcoin
- 1:14:42businesses feel it as like as people grow to appreciate
- 1:14:46Bitcoin, individuals, they naturally own businesses and
- 1:14:49their businesses, they want to accept Bitcoin because if they
- 1:14:51don't, they have to sweep the cash into Bitcoin and they get
- 1:14:53fees on that. There's just some price.
- 1:14:56And so and then if you take the dollars, you have interchange
- 1:14:59fees and you're paying 3%. And this is something that we're
- 1:15:02like actively working on. Well, you want to offer the
- 1:15:04convenience of the dollar system, but there's the
- 1:15:07inconvenience of the fees associated and where you can
- 1:15:10have a reduction in price by paying in Bitcoin.
- 1:15:13And I think that's an also growing trend that we'll see
- 1:15:16more as individuals want more Bitcoin accumulate.
- 1:15:19You'll make it easier for individuals to pay in Bitcoin,
- 1:15:21which is a nice like feedback loop for individuals that maybe
- 1:15:23you've never heard of it, that you go and you have your cash
- 1:15:26app already, you can just instantly swap and get your 5%
- 1:15:28off and everybody kind of wins. I think it's an interesting use
- 1:15:31case as well. Totally.
- 1:15:35Well, Sam, appreciate you being generous with your time.
- 1:15:38Is there anything else on the reserve side for River that you
- 1:15:41wanted to cover or do you feel like we're in a good place in
- 1:15:45terms of what we covered already?
- 1:15:46Yeah. Well, I, I guess briefly just to
- 1:15:50mention that the, the headline yesterday on on Wednesday, we
- 1:15:54finally released our proof of reserves.
- 1:15:57So if if anyone wants to read more about that, you can go to
- 1:16:00our Rivers blog. And we're going to be putting
- 1:16:04out a monthly attestation of both our assets and our
- 1:16:09liabilities. And it's something we've been
- 1:16:11working on for a long time. I think it's a great step
- 1:16:15forward for the industry and I think, you know, hopefully it'll
- 1:16:18become the industry standard at least for at least for Bitcoin
- 1:16:22focus companies. Maybe, maybe the coin basis of
- 1:16:25the world won't be too quick to follow.
- 1:16:28But yeah, please check that out. I thought the proof of
- 1:16:31liabilities part was really clever and and as far as I know
- 1:16:36the first of its kind. Did you guys get that model from
- 1:16:40any other precedent or did you come up with the proof of
- 1:16:43liabilities concept there? Yeah, I, I believe there are a
- 1:16:47few other companies that have Twitter around with providing a
- 1:16:51similar sort of proof of liabilities.
- 1:16:54Bitmex is one they, they have a blog post on like how that works
- 1:16:58to to briefly explain the way. So proof of liabilities is a lot
- 1:17:04more difficult than a proof of assets for a proof of reserves
- 1:17:07because with the proof of assets, it's as simple as just
- 1:17:10posting your addresses and then having some sort of predefined
- 1:17:16transaction formula to like prove that you were the owner of
- 1:17:20those assets. With the proof of liabilities,
- 1:17:23it's a lot more difficult because you somehow have to
- 1:17:27prove that you, you know that, that, that you are not hiding
- 1:17:33any users, you know, balances from your liabilities while also
- 1:17:37maintaining their privacy. And so the way the way we do it
- 1:17:42and the way I believe Bitmex does it is by publishing a
- 1:17:46Merkel sum tree of all of our account balances and then
- 1:17:51sharing the the root hashes with our clients so that they can go
- 1:17:56on our website and pretty easily just find their account balance
- 1:18:02within the sum of our liabilities.
- 1:18:05And so the way the way the user could find out if we're gaming
- 1:18:10the system is by simply verifying the reserves.
- 1:18:14And if the reserves aren't there, then they would know that
- 1:18:17rivers excluding their reserves from the proof of liabilities.
- 1:18:21And so this this concept almost requires a certain level of
- 1:18:25participation from our clients because the more clients that
- 1:18:30prove their liabilities, the more likely it is that their
- 1:18:34funds are safe. But without without being
- 1:18:37audited on a monthly basis, which I think no one does, This
- 1:18:42is the best method for just providing an attestation of your
- 1:18:47of your. Liabilities, yeah, just to share
- 1:18:49some, you probably appreciate. So we have an investment fund
- 1:18:53that we have institutional allocators and it's kind of like
- 1:18:55a private placement ETF. And one of the things we've done
- 1:18:58and they're very sophisticated, like pensions have asked for
- 1:19:01segregated wallets, right? And generally a firm wouldn't do
- 1:19:04that. And from a liability
- 1:19:06perspective, it still sits under as a pull vehicle.
- 1:19:08But from an audit perspective, you can always know that your
- 1:19:10funds are there. And if everyone sets up, then
- 1:19:12eventually it's that alarm bell effectively, which is important
- 1:19:15that funds are moving, then they shouldn't be moving.
- 1:19:19So we've always liked that. And then like the multi
- 1:19:20institution naturally is a, is a, is like a proof of reserve
- 1:19:23built in because of the segregated account.
- 1:19:26But yeah, the, the more that we can provide transparency as an
- 1:19:29industry where it's generally opaque, it doesn't fix
- 1:19:32everything, but it gives better foresight into when things
- 1:19:35aren't working very well versus like remember grayscale to like
- 1:19:40trust us, it's at it's at Coinbase and then BlackRock
- 1:19:42trusts us, it's at Coinbase. You know, like, well that that
- 1:19:46didn't work out so good at 2022. So maybe we need a little bit of
- 1:19:49audit. So it's, it's awesome to see
- 1:19:50that you guys are focused there and really great to have, you
- 1:19:53know, see you guys doing that. Yeah, I appreciate it.
- 1:19:57Yeah, it's a great president to be set.
- 1:19:58And I also think it's timely as well, just ahead of the bull
- 1:20:01market really picking up steam where I know River would never
- 1:20:05do it. But I know a lot of other
- 1:20:06companies have gotten themselves into some shenanigans as Bitcoin
- 1:20:10begins to RIP. And this is just like a nice
- 1:20:12additional layer of transparency to give your clients.
- 1:20:15And I'm sure you'll get the participation that you need on
- 1:20:18the liability side. There's no shortage of
- 1:20:19Bitcoiners who will want to test that out.
- 1:20:21And I'll try it out myself. But Sam, anyways, I know we're
- 1:20:24running up on time here. Thank you again for joining us.
- 1:20:27Want to give you a hand off. I'm not sure if you're going to
- 1:20:29mention it, but I did notice you're a published author.
- 1:20:32So that's pretty cool. But anything you want to share
- 1:20:35with the audience before we end the call here?
- 1:20:39Well, first of all, thank you for having me on.
- 1:20:41This was a lot of fun. You can follow me on Twitter at
- 1:20:46Macromule I I mainly post about Bitcoin and reports that we put
- 1:20:51out. And yeah, I did published a book
- 1:20:54over the past year on the history of money more targeted
- 1:20:58towards I would say like family members and no corners that you
- 1:21:03know, are just dipping their toes in the water.
- 1:21:05So maybe not recommended material for for most the
- 1:21:08listeners on this, but yeah, yeah, I appreciate pointing that
- 1:21:12out. Awesome.
- 1:21:14Well, thanks, Sam. Really good to have you joined
- 1:21:15today. Appreciate your time.
- 1:21:17Sam, thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:21:22If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:21:24episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:21:27app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:21:28today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:21:31Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:21:34for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:21:37nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice,
- 1:21:40regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey.
- 1:21:42We'd love to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:21:46to. Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:21:48of our private client advisors.