Latest / Grief Talks / Episode 11 - Dr Hannah Knows
Transcript
- David: Welcome to Grief Talks, a podcast in which we discuss grief and all that surrounds it, but also try to show that there is hope amongst all the pain. I'm David and I'm joined by my regular co-hosts, Steve and Lorna. And today, Steve, you have a special guest on if you'd like to make introductions. Steve: Well we have a special guest and and I'd like to introduce you to Doctor Hannah Rogers. Hannah's a personal friend of mine, but she is also somebody that's heavily involved in looking after people. But like listen, I'm not gonna introduce myself. Hannah, welcome to the podcast. It's great to have you here. Would you like to tell the listeners and viewers who you are and what what you're all about? Because I know but I need you to tell that. hannah: Thanks Steve. Hi everybody, my name's Hannah. I'm a clinical psychologist and I work in the NHS and also privately. And I have a specialist specialism in trauma and I've worked a lot with grief both professionally and personally. I come with my own journey. I've also done work with staff teams in the NHS who also deal with grief when they lose long-term patients. So yeah, I'm I suppose I'm here to to come at this conversation from a number of different angles today. Steve: Well listen, thank you very much. And we' listen, first of all, we want to say how pleased we are to have you here. Now we have multitude of questions for you, but we don't want to throw them all at you, okay. We just want to really just find out a little bit about how you can help us to help other people because I think that's part of what we've we're trying to achieve. so I'm gonna start off with the first question, okay? And it's a general question that I think a lot of people really probably think they have the answers, but maybe not necessarily get it right. So question was, is there such a thing as n the normal grieving process? Is there such a thing as a normal? we talk about the five stages of grief. Are are there stages or does it all mix in together? hannah: Yeah, so the the five stages of grief is something that was popularized by Kubler Ross, who did some research in the late seven late sixties, actually working with with people with a terminal illness. and then her research got sort of that's put on sort of the grieving process. and it's actually she herself has sort of refuted the stages idea because it's it it's it makes people think that there's a certain linear process to grieving and that there is the a right way to grieve which is absolutely not the case. So nowadays we try to move away from a stages model of grief and it's The the Kubleros idea, if you're not familiar with it, it's this idea that there are five different stages. So there's the denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance. and the these are useful ideas to have in terms of making sense of what we're feeling at at different points within our grieving process. but it's really important to understand that you don't go through one and then hit the next one and then hit the next one. You know, you can be burning with rage, you know, f five years after after losing somebody, even though, you know, the the previous years of you've been living in a place of acceptance, you know, it like it's it's a very messy process realistically. Steve: Brilliant. That that sorry Dave, did you want to ask me a question? David: Yeah, I just want to touch upon that because certainly for me, I think maybe that for the lay person, they still think it's the linear. And I've had people say to me, you'll go through a stage B this, this, this and this, where it's a medical profession will say, as you said, it's like it's like a spaghetti, it goes all over the place, it's not linear. But for lay people who haven't gone through what we've gone through, I think there is a big lack of knowledge in You know, and I sometimes get the impression when I have spoken to people, they almost think, well, you've you've gone through the stages. So it's two and a half years now. Why, you know, aren't you over it? And I think that is obviously a big misconception. But from your point of view, from professional point of view, do you think maybe that the lay person who hasn't gone through it will still think like that? And there's not enough awareness out there. That grief is this muddled, jumbled, you have no idea when it's going to hit you. hannah: Yeah, definitely. I I think they're yeah, it's it's quite a taboo subject still. people are frightened of of death and dying and grieving. and so, you know, sometimes it's because it's because they're frightened of talking to people who are bereaved. they don't don't want to sort of kick the dust up or make them sad or and other times it's because they've got their own stuff about death and dying and they don't want to know. and so there aren't often there aren't the opportunities to to sort of dispel myths, I suppose. unless you're you're looking for the information. Steve: That's a love that's a that's a lovely way of putting it because that's what we want. We want to make this as simple as possible because we want e everyone to have access to some degree of knowledge. And I'm really glad you've dispelled that because I I knew the stages everyone everyone's heard of those stages and because it's it's kind of then bit of an unwritten law, so people talk about it, and I knew that it would simply wasn't true because we've this is the 11th episode and we've discussed many things and one of the things we've discussed is that there is no one fits all. Ever all of us deal with things differently and hannah: Mm. Steve: grief hits us at different times and affects us all in a different way. Which kind of rolls into a little bit about the sort of the next question I've got, which is really what actually Well actually it's a difficult question. What actually happens to us psychologically when we experience grief? And that's a really big question there. But but what happens into our minds, our bodies, when we lose somebody that we really, really love? It's quite a broad question, but I just yeah, because a lot of people don't know. They just they they have an idea, but then we the reality is is very different. hannah: Hmm. Yeah. It is a big question, Steve. Thanks for that one. no, the it's I think the first thing, and from my own personal experience, I I the the first thing I always try to help people understand is that grief is physical in a way that lots of people don't necessarily expect. and at your core. you really have to pay attention to to the the real basics. You know, your your appetite will change, you know, your sleep will will shift. You'll feel heavy sometimes. Physiological anxiety is a common experience. And when I say physiological anxiety I mean racing heart out of nowhere. agitation, difficulty sitting still. it can be different for for everybody. Some people might feel like they're walking through treacle just trying to just trying to get up out of bed in the morning. and and it hurts. It's physical pain. you know people talk about Steve: So it's not so it's not unusual to experience physical so it's not unusual to experience hannah: Mm-mm. Steve: physical pain. It's not. It's it's it's would you hannah: No. Steve: say it's normal? hannah: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. You know, the the common the the if you think about common ways that people talk about loss, heartache, is a is a common phrase, isn't it? And it's it's in the the common language for a reason. Your heart hurts. and if you think about what you're going through psychologically, a loss is a psychological threat. And when we are in a state of threat, we go into the fight or flight response, fight, flight, freeze. These are common physiological responses to being under threat that that change our body so that we're ready to deal with a threat. So if you imagine, you know, a bear is coming, is coming at you, your muscles will tense up because you don't know whether to go very still or you need to run away or at worst case you need to defend yourself. So our our bodies change in response to in in response to loss. and then psychologically there are all sorts of different emotions that that are associated with grieving. you know the obviously we we talk about the sort of the anger and the depression Confusion, frustration, disappointment, you know, numbness, feeling completely unable to feel anything is also very normal. go on, Lorna. Lorna: Yeah, I was just going to ask you Dr. Rogers, I find it really interesting. Is that OK? thank you, Hannah. I hannah: please call me Hannah. I can't Lorna: was just going to ask you, people seem to cope very differently with grief. And I hannah: Well. Lorna: was wondering, why do some people appear to cope better than others with grief? Are there things that might pre-exist, the loss that help you, or things that you can do that particularly might help you with the grief? hannah: it that it's very different for for different people and I think there's always a danger of of looking at at other people's external and judging it against your own internal because we never know it what is going on in inside somebody else's head. And there are some people who are just very good at masking what's going on inside. but also if we think about some other theories of of normal grieving, there's there's one theory that That talks about sort of different orientations within grief. So, and how we sort of oscillate between the two. So sometimes we will be focused on the tasks of grieving itself, we'll be focusing on the loss, and sometimes we'll be focused on focused on restoration and the process of needing to live. And so you might catch somebody when they're in that sort of doing coping mode and at other times they may be totally totally absorbed in the process of of of working through their emotions. Lorna: think that's really interesting because I think a lot of people have said to me over the however long, but I've kept very busy and done lots of things and that it has been part of my coping strategy, but really surviving. But I've also done the work. I've also been in therapy. I've also cried a lot. still cry a lot and let it out and live the grief very much so. That hannah: Mm-hmm. Lorna: oscillation is really, I read about that theory and it was so helpful to me to think it's okay to have both. I don't have to sit in the grief all the time. I don't have to keep busy all the time. can have both and move between those two worlds. I was going to ask you, does grief fundamentally change you as a person? hannah: I would ask you three, what do you think? Lorna: Yes, David: Yes. Lorna: definitely. Yeah. Yeah. hannah: Yes. Yes. I would agree. David: Wonderful. hannah: You know, the it's I think there's there's always this fear that I'm never gonna be the same again. but the way I think about it and sort of reflecting on on my my own experience of loss is that that not being the same again is a reflection of the part that the pe the people that I lost played in my life. And there's something quite special about that. so I I we all are forever changed, but that doesn't have to be a negative David: Part of you dies hannah: thing. David: with that person. Part of you metaphorically dies with that person. I certainly have got this before and after. And I think I read, I listened to someone, I think it might've been a Rich D Grant who said, you you mourn the person that you were when you lose your partner or a child or something and all those plans that you haven't had in the future. mean, for me, you know, we had this kids getting older. going to go off and do cruises or whatever it might be, but now that's all gone, that life is gone for me. And so, yeah, I mourn part of what I've lost. hannah: Absolutely. Yeah. Lorna: Hannah, do you mind sharing a little bit about your own experiences? Because I'm just really interested how to suffer your own grief whilst also being sort of an expert in trauma. Would you mind sharing a little bit about that? hannah: No, not at all. so when I was fifteen, my brother died in a a traffic accident. so that was my first experience of of loss. my my my grandparents died when I was a lot younger than that. So I don't sort of it's not the same sort of experience. so all of the all of the loss that I have experienced has been sudden. so my brother at 15 and then when I was twenty five, my partner who I lived with at the time, he had sudden adult death syndrome. So his heart electrics just stopped whilst I was with him. So and I'm you know I'm in my mid to late forties now so it's a long time since. So I've I'm I'm much further along in my grief journey than the three of you are and I suppose I come here a little bit in the hope of sharing a a hope story too. so to your to your point, David, the that feeling that a part of you died, I totally can relate to to that, the sort of the pre and the post. But this much further on in my journey, I think of it less as as that and more what I carry with me, what they gave me. if that makes sense. But that's taken a Lorna: That sense. hannah: lot of time to to move with that, or shift that perspective. Yeah. Lorna: Thank so much for sharing that because that's really personal and I think it certainly gives a lot of context to the work that you do as well. mean it's interesting, an interesting career path having already experienced grief really hannah: Mm-hmm. Lorna: young. was obviously something that you actually experienced which gives you even, we've talked before about working with professionals who've actually experienced it as opposed to those who haven't and whether or not we feel they can offer as much if they haven't experienced it. I don't know whether you have a thought on that in terms of. the profession, guess for me, hearing you explain about your own experience gives even more credibility, if possible, to everything that you're saying because you've lived it. You've actually lived that pain. hannah: Yeah, the that's not I'm I don't want to give the impression that if if you haven't experienced it you can't you can't work with somebody who is is grieving by by any stretch because the the I I I tend not to share my story with my clients. and I and I it may give me a a depth of empathy perhaps that somebody else might not have. but the a good therapist will meet you wherever you're at. I I don't have to have experienced you know, significant mental health problems to be able to work with somebody with a significant mental health problem. But yeah, it's I think there is there is something about sort of knowing what it feels like that perhaps that that I might come with that other therapists might. Steve: Thanks, thanks Anna. That's I think that's a really important point, because part part of the podcast is that we we We share our own experiences, but more importantly, we say to people there may all be somebody that is out there that can help you. Don't they don't necessarily have to have been through the same thing. They may offer you the guidance and support that you need anyway. So I think that's a really good point, and I'm glad you've you've you've you've made that. because part of this this podcast, the whole purpose of it is to make sure that everyone has access to the right person, and the right person may not be the therapist. all of us, I think I can speak for the other two, all of us have of sought professional help. So we've all been to a therapist, we've all met brilliant people like yourself. And we we would suggest that it's it may well help people to seek professional advice, but it's not necessarily for everyone. Some people can't do it. And there's nothing wrong with that. hannah: Hmm. And I think I one of the things that I really wanted to get across in this in this conversation is that it that Steve: Okay. hannah: I don't want to pathologise grief. it me being a mental health professional, it it might give the impression that it's a mental health problem and it absolutely is not. It's a universal experience. and not everybody needs therapy. not everybody has access to therapy as you as you say, Steve. And the I suppose the the key thing is finding finding your way through the best way you can. But from my point of view, the it's it's how you how you process your emotions basically. We can get stuck when we don't know how to process our emotions or we don't have the support systems around us to allow us to to process our emotions or our circumstances mean that it's sort of impossible to process our emotions. You know, if we are if we are suddenly thrown into single parenthood, as I know both both of you have been, you've just got to survive and that can that can delay a process of of grieving for for many, many people. So it's it's about the right time, it's about the right people, and not attaching too much meaning to to the feelings that you're having, in my opinion. David: Hannah, let's talk about guilt. And I think it's something that we've all experienced, you know, what could we have done more when quite honestly there that there was nothing and I know from my son's experience who's 16 back in the last year, he felt really guilty that he couldn't do anything, even though and he really blamed himself for not being able to do anything. And I had to explain to him, you know, none of us could we're not medical professionals. So can he just talk about the experience of guilt that people feel and everything around that. And maybe that is a mental health issue because it put my son into a very, very low mental state where we had, know, there was suicide was talked off him. So I had to get, you know, an intervention. We talk a bit about if you more experienced the guilt. hannah: Yeah, absolutely. It it's it's a really common experience following a loss. and I suppose I I I conceptualize it as part of an attempt to make sense of the depth of pain that we're feeling. so in in a nonsensical situation, the the the need for for to feel like there's a degree of control can sometimes move us in a direction where in the absence of any other ex explanation for why this why this could have happened I'll pin it on me. you know and and weirdly it it might give people some sense of of of life being slightly less chaotic than it is. And I think it's it's an it's a normal part of the grieving process. but where we're where we're tipping from normal grief into mental health that needs support is exactly what you're describing, David, where where these sorts of thoughts and feelings don't pass. So normal emotions it they come and they go. If we're not picking at the wound too much. if we can just sort of allow them to be there, they will they will move through. that's not to say they will move through and never come back again. It's it's just that they're it they're a bit like the weather, if you like. but if if, for example, if a guilt cloud comes through and we attach additional meaning to that, or or we get bogged down in in the meaning they're attaching to that emotion, then we run the risk of of moving into a more depressed state. David: that's what I think what we're driving out the fact that, there is a difference between grief and depression. Grief can certainly lead to depression. hannah: Yes. David: So if you're not a professional sort of point of view, what's difference between if you could say difference between grief and depression, and at what point would you suggest that someone would should maybe seek professional help? Because you can't deal with this all in your most people can't deal with it all on their own. hannah: No, the I think the from my point of view it it's often down to impact on function. because if you if you think about sort of the standardized measures for for identifying sort of depression, you know, the the key symptoms are loss of interest in in things that you used to enjoy, loss of appetite, difficulty sleeping, feelings of worthlessness, All of these are symptoms that all of us will have experienced in the context of grieving. So it can be quite difficult to sort of tease these things apart. So generally it's about length of time and consistency of those sorts of experiences. So those sorts of experiences will come and go in normal grief. If they are lasting fairly consistently for more than two weeks, and certainly more than a month. where you're experiencing these sorts of symptoms for more than half the days of the of the week, then it's worth talking to talking to a GP or you know talking to to somebody who might be able to to help you a little bit. Certainly the thoughts of suicide are not uncommon in a in grief. you know, fleeting moments of I wish I wasn't here or I wish I'd gone as well, or you know, those sorts of thoughts are really common. and often they completely freak people out. but just having the thought doesn't mean that you're going to do it. but if it is if that is an experience that is becoming more frequent, feels a bit more live, then absolutely the you know, seeking professional. And and crisis support is really important. Lorna: I wondered about PTSD and grief. certainly for, we've had very different experiences of loss here. So Steve's was very sudden with his daughter and the losses you shared have been very sudden. For Dave and I, we had a very long period of time prior to losing our partners where we witnessed some unthinkable things when they had long-term illnesses. And I just wondered about how, where it gets to the point where someone has PTSD in addition to their grief or how that works, how that looks. hannah: again different for different people, but the the sort of defining the defining aspect of post-traumatic stress disorder is to do with how memory was encoded at the time of of sort of peak horror, if you like. and so what happens in in post-traumatic stress disorder is that at a moment that is that is so horrifying, For some of us, a part of our thinking brain just shuts down. there's neuropsychological evidence to suggest that that in in sort of moments of peak fear, the the frontal lobes, the the bit that thinks and gives context to to like story and time, it just goes quiet, but the rest of your of your memory centres are continuing to. To process information, so the senses, the sounds, the sights. So all of that gets stored but without the sort of the context, if you like. And so PTSD is characterized by intrusive fragments of memory. Now sometimes these fragments of memory are literal sort of movies in your mind, sometimes they're physiological experiences, sometimes it's sounds. but what happens is that something in the here and now which feels similar to that worst moment will trigger the brain to go, I've got an unresolved memory fragment here. Let's see if we can we can resolve it. And so it throws it back at you and you feel like it's happening again. And that's the particularly that's the particular sort of defining aspect post-traumatic stress disorder is that the them them it's not necessarily identifiable as a memory, it feels like it's now. Does that David: Would you include flashbacks in that as well? Sort of when you're sitting there, like hannah: That's that's a flashback, David: you're lying awake at night at three o'clock in the morning and you start, I I certainly, I relive almost hour by hour, Gail's last sort of days and moments. I can, and I often, I have to think about it every day. I'm driving and I'll just start thinking about it. So is those sort of associated with PTSD as well? hannah: To to an extent, so it's it's quite normal to go over the story, perhaps. and if and if you're clear that yeah, this is this is me sort of processing something that has happened in the past, then I wouldn't I wouldn't sort of name that a flashback as as such. The the defining characteristic of a flashback is that it feels like it's happening again, like the the intensity of the emotion is is the same. so there might be there might be particular aspects of of that experience as you're going through that story that bring that sort of like feeling, that whoosh. you might consider that a sort of a flashback type memory. But there are other sort of symptoms that come along to that that would define it as a sort of a diagnosable post-traumatic stress disorder. but it's really common for for memories to to come back. in an unwanted way. when you're least expecting it and you're hit hit like it's a truck has just hit you. yeah. Lorna: I had some EMDR therapy that one of Mike's friends who's a doctor of trauma, she straight away said, I think you should have this. And I personally found that really helpful. It was very painful to relive those worst moments, but I definitely think it did help me with the processing of those. Is that something you've ever recommended or you know much about or you with your hannah: Yeah, I'm I'm trained in EMDR. Lorna: amazing. hannah: yeah. So the the I would I would treat somebody with EMDR if there's a stuckness about the the grieving process or or as as we're describing here, particularly particular memories that are that are keep coming up and are are causing sort of acute dys distress. Steve: Mm-hmm. hannah: so Often that it's it's the the meaning that we attach to the worst moment that that causes the stuckness. and that that can be processed using something like EMDR or a trauma focused cognitive behavioural therapy. There's also good evidence base for that in terms of sort of trauma focused interventions. There are a number of different approaches. Lorna: What can we do to most help ourselves? So if we've suffered a loss for our listeners that are listening, what are the things we can most do to help us process and cope with such catastrophic loss? hannah: I think it depends on on what stage you are in. but just go gently with yourself more than anything. I think if if we can learn to roll with our emotions, to hold them lightly, to not attach too much meaning to them and just sort of allow them to be when they arrive, then then we don't get in our own way in terms of processing those emotions. so allow ourselves to be sad, allow ourselves to be furious. you know, sometimes anger is an interesting one in in grief. quite often people feel very uncomfortable to admit that they might be angry with the person who has left, person who has died. that can be a really uncomfortable thing to work through but it's it's an important it's an important part of of of that grieving process i i remember so dreams we we often process a lot of our emotions through our dreams i remember a couple of years after losing my partner had a really really vivid dream of just beating the crap out of him and I woke up just like whoo that was something that needed to needed to be worked through. but I I could have woken up and gone, my God, what's wrong with me? and then it's the meaning that you attach that that would sort of supercharges the distress almost. Whereas Lorna: Yeah, that makes sense. That makes a lot of sense. hannah: yeah, so just sort of going, Christ, that was a that was a a thing, wasn't it? and and holding it lightly. Steve: That's an interesting one. We've never raised that before, dreams. David: No. Steve: It's a really interesting hannah: Mm. Steve: one. So for for our listeners, I think it that's a really a a w a way that we can actually maybe expand on that because I think that might be very, very helpful. the guys know and my in my case, mine was a suicide that was unexpected. So my trauma was was was incredibly acute. and like Nora and and like Dave I I I had therapy and I I I found I needed to have therapy. went to some support groups as well, which again for me helped me. Only because when when you when when somebody commits suicide, there are so many unanswered questions, unlike Dave and and Lorna and in some respects yourself, you knew what what happened and you knew that there was a s a sequence of events with Antonio I didn't know. So for me the trauma and the guilt was was huge and very, very difficult to manage. Most of my friends who knew me knew that I would probably feel guilty because of the career that I had. I think for the listeners, people don't know I was a policeman, and and during my career I was fortunate to save quite a few people and I was commended for it. So it was almost an additional layer of trauma on top of that when I didn't save wasn't able to save my own child. So we've spoken about it before on the podcast. I I'm happy to share it, but it was it was one of the things that I found the most difficult bit to move on from that bit where we seem being stuck. And it's that's a phrase and a condition that lots of people go through. Part of the podcast, and why we're here is to make sure that people don't remain in those places for too long, because you've just described it. Because that's when that's when grief becomes the depression. And I think it being able to unstick yourself from that huge bit of trauma really helps you move forwards. And for me, and I say to everyone, I've had to learn to live with Antonia dying. And the way she did it. I know Dave is doing it, I know Lauren is doing it, and you have as well. You've just described and we really do appreciate that you have shared that with us and for everyone that's listening. You you weren't asked to do that. That was something that you you did willingly. And we were we're really pleased that you were able to do that. Because it it certainly makes us makes us feel that it can happen to anyone. You know, it it's no no one is excluded from it. And and sadly everyone during their lifetime will go through some of the things that we're describing. hannah: Mm-hmm. Steve: And we are All of us, all four of us I can say, we we all have a sense of purpose here that we've we want to make those those people on those journeys a little bit easier, whether it's listening to the advice that you've given tonight, Hannah, and we're really happy that you've given us great advice personally and to to other people, but just so that everyone feels normal. It's not a subject that people feel comfortable with. People Lorna: Mm. Steve: don't wanna know that your husband died from cancer or that your wife had bowel cancer or that Or that your daughter killed herself. my god, it's but it happens. It happens to real people. We are Lorna: Yeah. Steve: all going through various things. And I'm the thing I'm proud about is that we've we've put together this podcast not for ourselves, although we are it's helping us. It's helping us understand ourselves. And I think that's part of the journey that I think everyone should really maybe listen to. Is that you will you will grow as a person, sadly. I mean I didn't know Dave before Gail. I knew I knew Lorna and I knew Mike. But I I've watched both of them just grow as people since knowing them. And that's that's not something that I'm not proud to say. I I really am. I'm proud that we are here, all three of us. Now four of us that that are are are trying to help people and I and I I do I I that's still one of the reasons why we we we decided to create this podcast. Lorna: was going to ask you about post-traumatic growth actually because we had a previous discussion about this about what positives, hate the word positives, but what good things can potentially come from such catastrophic loss and I certainly have felt that there definitely have been, certainly my perspective on life has changed, what I prioritise, lots of good things have come from it in that respect but is there an element of that that people can offer people hope about post-traumatic growth? hannah: Yeah, certainly. the the I I say this with caution because because often the the concept of post post-traumatic growth feels too difficult for for people to think about depending on what stage they're at in their in their grief journey. but definitely I mean, you know, I'm I'm 30 years on and twenty something years Steve: A hannah: on from my really significant losses. and and the the growth the growth that that you sort of that I have come to certainly is is a sort of a the the meaning that I've made from it I guess like would I have become a psychologist if I hadn't experienced these things? I don't know. I mean I've always been a bit nosy so probably but but, you know, I think I think certainly it probably guided me in in a particular direction. you know, the a trauma specialism seem seems a bit on the nose, doesn't it? But considering my experiences. but who knows? so I think the and coming back to to what we were saying before about about what you take with you of the person that you lost, that that for me feels like growth. my experiences and how I coped with with those experiences are my growth Steve: Yeah. hannah: because I'm still here so we have grown if that makes sense. David: Okay, I've got a question. It's about sort of people's views on people who are grieving. You know, I've experienced it. People struggle to talk to me about or even mention it. And I've had an experience where, you know, a year or so ago, well, no, no, it wasn't that long after girl passed away. I was at my daughter's school and one of the mums just, you know, I saw her repeatedly and say a word to me, not even. I'm so sorry to hear about your loss." And she knew, nothing at all. And that made me so angry. And I spoke to another parent and they like, look, she struggles coping with the reality of life sometimes. So why is it people struggle to talk to someone who's bereaved? hannah: It could be for so many different reasons. you you've given you've given a a good reason there that this this person maybe it it makes the the chaos of life a little bit too real to speak to somebody who's who's bereaved. sometimes people are are so worried about putting their foot in it or worried about the consequences of bringing it up. You know, if if people if people don't know how to contain emotion. for other people, then they might not want to poke the bear if you like. you know, i if if you ask the question, you have to feel confident that you can take the answer. and perhaps people don't sometimes. but David: It made me angry. It made me angry that there wasn't even a, I'm so sorry to hear about your loss. Are you okay? Nothing at all. I just thought that was rude, insensitive, and quite frankly, not a good reflection on that person. That's my opinion because I know on the other foot, if it was on other foot, I would see someone say, how you doing? You're right. Just how you doing? hannah: such a tricky one, David, because I've also had people say to me, I can't believe they asked me about it in public. how how could they bring it up? So I think our experiences are so individual and I think that's part of what makes makes it quite difficult socially. Is that some people who want to keep keep it buttoned up would be horrified if you were if you were to to put them in in a position where they risked losing it. Or, you know, other people want to be reminded all the time. They want to they want to know that people are thinking about them. and some people really don't. So whenever we bring this up, whenever we ask people how they're doing, we run the risk of annoying somebody or saying the wrong thing. Steve: The yeah. Lorna: Yeah, yeah. And I think that's really interesting because David and I at one point, we both at the same moment, we had a conversation a while ago where he wanted people to just stop talking to him about it. And I still wanted to talk about it because we're literally on the same path. We lost our partners a couple of weeks apart, both to cancer, both similar timeframe with it all. And he didn't want he wanted people to stop talking to him about it. And I wanted to keep so it does really highlight how hard it is for those around us to know exactly what what we need. think my family friends said to me, they found it easier because I've always been quite an open person emotionally. So they felt like they knew that they couldn't really get it wrong by talking about it with me, that's what I would want. But then it's not always that easy with everyone. I certainly know I've got friends here. I've got a friend who's grieving at the moment and it's hard to always know how to best play it with her. But equally, what I found hardest is people who kind of... ignored it. I just needed recognition of it. That was important to me and so I just make sure with her I do that. But yeah, you can't always get it right. hannah: No, and I I think that that's the that's the the message I suppose to anybody who's listening because because they are supporting somebody who's grieving. one day you might say the same thing as another day and get two completely different reactions. and trying not to take it personally is probably the best the best thing that you can do as as somebody supporting somebody who's going through grief. because it's rarely about the individual, it's more just an expression of the pain in that moment. Steve: I think it's interesting because as you can see, Hannah, we have interesting discussions because everyone has their own viewpoint, and that's one of the reasons why we we enjoy these discussions because some people don't know when to stop and some people just keep going. It's a really difficult one. So the thing that the message we want to say is that just try to be kind both ways. Try to be kind in terms of there are going to be people that will feel slightly offended by not mentioning it and those equally that want a voice for it. And it's be about being kind and being respectful. and sometimes we get it wrong. And just because you get it wrong once doesn't necessarily mean that that's your viewpoint. So that's that's why I think it's such an interesting subject and and one that we we like to discuss because there will be people out there that just don't know when to do it. Lorna's just described she's got a friend that's going for it now. And even though she's going through her own experience of grief on her own journey, it's still difficult to navigate whether or not that person needs the conversation or actually just wants as Dave might say I just want it to be quiet because And again, it's normal. Each one is normal. It's just the timing might be slightly off. It's bit like hannah: Yeah. Steve: I teach I teach Lorna teachers, I I love teaching children with S E N S E N D's because they're slightly wired differently. So you have to think, how am I gonna get this person to understand when they don't see it like the way that I'm gonna teach them? And there's an a way of doing that, and it's a skill, and I now Love doing it because I literally try and work out what do I need to do for this child, Lorna? I can see that's because the the deputy head's kicking in there. Go for it. What do you want to say? Lorna: Well, I was going to ask a question about grief and neurodiversity actually, because my son's autistic and he's had play therapy throughout when Mike was diagnosed and all the way through, which has been unbelievable. And actually the play therapist three years in has now said, we think he's in a position where he doesn't need it anymore. And that was just breathtakingly amazing slash sad slash everything this week. But I was going to ask you how, if you're neurodiverse, whether grief is experienced differently for people that are neurodiverse or whether there's anything about that to discuss. hannah: That's a really good question that I can't answer. I I don't know the the evidence base for that, if I'm if I'm completely honest. I d I just c I just can't answer that question. It's and yeah. Lorna: I just realised I don't really know what I was asking in terms of what Steve: Mm-hmm. Lorna: I want to know. Everything about being neurodiverse feels different anyway in everyday life in terms of the way you think about the world or the way you process the world. So I just was really... I think I might go and actually look into this really interested about how grief looks. hannah: Yeah. Lorna: certainly for me, What I've seen is it's often very literal with his grief. It's very much like, daddy died in this year. It's just very factual based, whereas with my other son, it's a lot more emotive. So I think I wonder if there's any elements of that. Is there anything else I was going to ask about that you think? No, not almost anything else, but what is the most hopeful thing you can let our listeners hear? Because I think a lot of people who are coming here are hearing, are here because they ultimately want to feel hopeful that things won't always feel so painful that there is a way through. What is the most hopeful thing you think you can share? hannah: I mean I think just the fact that the four of us are here getting through it is very hopeful in and of itself. I I think from my point of view the I really like Tomkins' theory of grief. I I call it the fried egg theory because Because it well visually it looks like a fried egg. So the Tonkin's theory of grief is that when when we first lose somebody, the if you imagine a circle and the middle of the circle is yellow like a yolk, an egg yolk, and you can't see hardly any of the white round the edges. So if the white is your life and the yolk is your grief, the whole circle is almost yellow. And it fills up your whole life and your whole experience. And over time, the size of that yellow circle remains the same. But you get to see more of the white around the edges, which is the life. So you grow around the grief. And as time goes on even further, the yoke might no longer be in the centre, it might be slightly off to the left Steve: Okay. hannah: or the right. And certainly that's my experience. I have grown around my grief. and now I I can think about my loved ones without the pain. you know, sometimes aspects what what I have lost hit me, even now still. but largely I'm able to honour them with. the love and the, you know, the the wistfulness and all the happy memories that they deserve. and that is a really lovely thing. I feel very lucky to be in that position. Not everybody can get there. and that's that's when sort of seeking professional help Steve: Yeah. hannah: might be something to help Steve: I was just gonna say Hannah Hannah, that's that's a really a good one. Because what what we like to do is we've discussed gratitude, that that comes from comes from a number of different areas and we what we're trying to do is find those areas that people can grab onto because sometimes in the darkness you you don't you're reaching in the dark and you can't feel them. So and and some of it is time. I've certainly found That being able to feel comfortable with people has helped me. Also, something that I found again, which is very personal to me, maybe not so not the other, maybe Lorna, but I know Dave's w I train quite a lot, you know that Hannah, we've discussed it. I'm somebody that that really felt that during my grief that the one way in which my mind could help deal with the trauma was to to to help myself physically. Is there any links between managing grief and depression. I know certainly depression is slightly different, but in terms of using your body to help you get through it. It's I know it's a a bit of a funny way question, but does does does that make sense at all? I just I for me it definitely helped me. hannah: Yeah, absolutely. And it's it's different for different people. I think activity is is there's a really strong evidence base for for the benefits of activating yourself in terms of managing mood. and but that doesn't have to be going to the gym. activating yourself can be can can be all sorts of different things. generally from a from a mood management point of view. we recommend a balance of activities that give you a sense of achievement, closeness to others and enjoyment. so, you know, going for a going for a walk and appreciating the you know the beautiful oranges of the trees in the autumn can can be an activating thing to do. Steve: I'm a dopamine junkie. I'm a dopamine junkie. I have to have my dopamine. Yeah, I have to have it. I have Lorna: Yeah, me too. I'm with you. Steve: to find I'll go out and run in the cold. I'll go and climb a mountain. I'll do something. Lorna: Yeah. hannah: Mm. Steve: I that that well but that's what I mean. I I my body works on dopamine and so I need to do something physical. I you know, I I don't think I'd get the hit from reading a book. Lorna: just can say, Steve, I think it's about, for me, I make time. I'm a solo parent with two little boys. One's got special needs. I work, I've got lots of stuff on, but for me, it's such a priority for mental health, physical health, is exercising. I actually got a load of my friends to do Tough Muddle with me in Mike's memory. As just one of mine, and a hundred mile run, and I threw myself into stuff like that, because it works for me, but it's not for everyone. For others, I completely understand. And for others, it's that calmness in a different way. hannah: Mm. Lorna: Hannah, you've been incredible. Honestly, I've learned so much and I've found it so helpful speaking to you. Thank you so much for giving us your time today. David: Yeah, thank you. This has been a hannah: It's pleasure. David: real eye-opener and I think the three of us will go away and probably maybe at some stage in the future ask you back on because we'll have lots of questions after speaking Lorna: Yeah. David: to you. hannah: Mm-hmm. David: thank you so much for coming on. think it was, it was great to finish on some, positive notes, notes of sort of. Hopefulness amongst amongst the dark clouds. Hannah, Dr. Hannah Rogers, thank you so much for coming on Steve Lorna. Thank you again, as usual for, being a huge part, well, being two thirds of the three musketeers for, for brief talks. And, if you do have any. issues that have come out of this, then please contact Samaritan's psychologists, your doctor. There are plenty of groups out there who will give you the support that you need and we will see you next time.