Latest / Newcomer Pod / A Wall Street Veteran & Investor Explains Silicon Valley Bank's Unraveling (with Laurence Tosi)
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric newcomer host of newcomer, the Silicon Valley
- 0:05just blew up or at least Silicon Valley Bank just blew up.
- 0:08So I called in an audible rescheduled the podcast guests
- 0:13invited on Laurens. Tosi the former CFO of
- 0:17Blackstone, the former CFO of Airbnb, former Chief Operating
- 0:22Officer of Merrill Lynch. This is a real behind-the-scenes
- 0:25player. Somewhat, I go to to gut-check
- 0:28ideas and to figure out what's really happening.
- 0:30Happening in Silicon Valley, as will tell you on this podcast,
- 0:34he spent the weekend talking to members of Congress and Bank
- 0:37Executives to try and figure out what's going on and what's been
- 0:41going on and why Silicon Valley Bank unravels.
- 0:44What's this mean for Silicon Valley?
- 0:46Going forward, certainly I think a.com style bust looks much more
- 0:52plausible. Now that we've got our big Bank
- 0:55explosion. So stick around.
- 0:57Listen, I think it's a fantastic episode.
- 1:00Thanks. Welcome to newcomer.
- 1:02Thanks for coming on the show. Sure.
- 1:04Thanks for asking me. It is been the craziest period
- 1:08in Tech. I don't know, covid may be
- 1:10Rivals it or where would you score this in terms of wild
- 1:15periods for private technology companies?
- 1:17It is probably been the most volatile five-year period.
- 1:20I think we've ever seen through, including my, before the
- 1:23pandemic, the pandemic itself, the recovery, the hype cycle, if
- 1:26you will, and the public markets than the dramatic crash.
- 1:28And now, of course, The infrastructure crumbling
- 1:31underneath the industry. It's been remarkable, right?
- 1:34These last few days, in particular, I mean, some of, the
- 1:37fastest movie I've ever seen, I feel like, I think that's true.
- 1:40I mean, I was Chief Operating Officer at Mel in 2007, and then
- 1:44I was one of the senior partners and CFO Blackstone 2008.
- 1:47And to be honest, Eric it felt like I was right back there in
- 1:51the coming week. Is felt like, you know, rate
- 1:53hikes have a deteriorating effect and I think the FED
- 1:58really was late The red State too low for too long, we over
- 2:02stimulated. The economy that led to really
- 2:04the type probably saw, then you have a valuation crash first
- 2:08after the evaluation crash, usually then have a period of
- 2:11stagnation and eventually declining growth, which you're
- 2:14seeing now you're seeing lots of downward revisions and what
- 2:17really happened here was that the rates Rose so fast.
- 2:20It actually did an enormous amount of damage to the banking
- 2:23infrastructure. So before you even get the
- 2:25Silicon Valley Bank, there's 600 billion dollars of unrealized
- 2:29losses on back. Balance sheets across the u.s.
- 2:31So this is one of those latent effects of a fast rate rise in
- 2:35the aggression fed broke the system, right?
- 2:38Okay. So your financial experience
- 2:40plus, you know, CFO of Airbnb. Now, sort of a major investor
- 2:44seen it both on the fun side and directly someone who helps me
- 2:48understand things behind the scenes, wanted to bring you on
- 2:50to really translate this for everybody about what's
- 2:54happening. This has been such a confusing
- 2:56period that I think we're going to try and keep it as
- 2:59chronological. Possible, just so people can
- 3:01follow it. So sorry at the beginning.
- 3:03I think he laid it out. The biggest picture event that's
- 3:06happened. Is this sort of interest rate
- 3:08hike, that sort of set the stakes here, right?
- 3:11Is that the starting gun if you have fly?
- 3:13I think, I think it actually starts with this.
- 3:14The economy in December of 2019 was very strong as strong as
- 3:20we've seen in years. And the Fed was poised then to
- 3:23begin. Raising rates, the pandemic hit
- 3:25six weeks later and that gave people pause about three months
- 3:29later, we To seeing the stimulus going, you need economy,
- 3:32obviously was an election cycle, had a lot to do with it as well
- 3:34and in a lot of ways, you over stimulated the economy but rates
- 3:37remain low, that began when I would call the hype cycle into
- 3:4120 and coming out of the pandemic in the late 20s and
- 3:44early 21. You saw multiples for technology
- 3:47companies, expand the levels that we've never seen before.
- 3:50You know, tech companies that would trade at 8 to 10 times
- 3:52revenues for trading in 25 30 and even more both in the public
- 3:56and private markets and late twenty you saw a really good
- 3:59idea. Market moving at 21 and then
- 4:02inverted when the public markets, Tech markets went down
- 4:06then the private markets followed shortly after about six
- 4:09months. So this is really been a cycle
- 4:11are that's been in place for a couple years.
- 4:13So what happened? Then offense started raising
- 4:15rates later than they probably should have been too low for too
- 4:19long, which created a lot of distortions and then they super
- 4:22aggressively went at the rate rise basically, from 0, all the
- 4:25way, to four point seven, five and just over a year and that
- 4:28always has a latent. Affect the GDP of the country.
- 4:32Usually feels more pain in the second year after rate Rises
- 4:36that in the first. And I think that's what we're
- 4:38seeing now, all right? So one character you know the
- 4:41fed and interest rates but probably the main character that
- 4:44everybody is following here is Silicon Valley Bank.
- 4:47What are they doing? Like 2020 2021?
- 4:51Just give us a little bit of like where Silicon Valley Bank
- 4:54sits in. I guess the boom time ecosystem
- 4:57of Silicon Valley in 2021 social justice.
- 5:00Their size force all incredibly unique business model around for
- 5:0340 years. Had really been the go-to key
- 5:06bag for the Venture Community. Not just friendship, adventure
- 5:09and growth and really, actually, not just the company's but a lot
- 5:12of the firm's themselves. So you could say, it was a
- 5:14critical part of the ecosystem and much like the hype cycle of
- 5:18money pouring into technology at the end of the pandemic and the
- 5:23markets hot. And like there's a lot of IPOs
- 5:26Silicon Valley Bank start rocking.
- 5:27They went from about 60 billion dollars in assets.
- 5:30In 2022 106 billion in 2021 to 211 billion on December 31st of
- 5:37last year, which is a remarkable amount of growth by any
- 5:40institution. And that's just driven by record
- 5:43fundraising levels record, exit levels and just a general
- 5:47technology economy exploding and then they were definitely the
- 5:49beneficiary that because they were the best position.
- 5:52I don't think any Bank comes close to me.
- 5:53Think about this sir. If you had said five years ago,
- 5:57that Silicon Valley Bank would be a 16th largest bank in.
- 6:00U.s. I don't think anybody would
- 6:01believe you because they would say well it's a little bit more
- 6:02Niche and it's right. Why didn't start on time.
- 6:06So the key piece of this is that startups are raising these
- 6:09enormous rounds. I mean, we saw a proliferation
- 6:11of hundred million dollar rounds.
- 6:13In 2021, they take that money and some of them are just
- 6:17putting that into Silicon Valley Bank, right?
- 6:20And then Silicon Valley Bank. I think we saw what Sequoia had
- 6:23like five billion in the bank somehow there.
- 6:26So we've got Venture firms that have a lot of money in Silicon
- 6:28Valley Bank to is. You know, on that are fertile.
- 6:31They did a great job. I mean they really serve the
- 6:34community really well, they were really great at relationships.
- 6:37Honestly everybody I've ever met from that bank from Silicon
- 6:39Valley Bank was really professional.
- 6:41They knew what they were doing and I think the community
- 6:44rewarded them for being there. There's a couple interesting
- 6:47things that are idiosyncratic about Silicon Valley Bank.
- 6:50Do one is a lot of the Venture debt that they lent bit about a
- 6:5375 billion dollar loan book. They don't do things like
- 6:56mortgages and what typical bags do, but there's a lot of venture
- 6:58debt that's a Highly unique asset, / liability I guess in it
- 7:04when they did the 75 billion to lending they quite often in
- 7:06their terms would say you have to keep 80% of your deposit to
- 7:09the bank. So it was kind of a circular
- 7:11reference in the sense that was creating a dependence of a lot
- 7:14of these small companies on the bank and the way they did
- 7:17business. But they serve the community
- 7:18well and they were rewarded by the row.
- 7:20The Venture debt I think all in, you know, made a big deal about
- 7:24the Venture debt and I so I am interested.
- 7:26How much you think that is at the core of this but it's a
- 7:30Assessment that many of the other Banks didn't want to do
- 7:32right? Or what sort of controversial or
- 7:34challenging about these Venture debt deals.
- 7:38So I'll give you examples. We've actually studied some of
- 7:40the term sheets that have come across some of our businesses
- 7:43and said, oh we've stayed away from Venture debt by and large
- 7:45and give you a bunch of reasons why.
- 7:47But I actually think Eric Venture death pretty close to
- 7:50equity, but it's prices back then.
- 7:52So the typical package from like in spb would have eight to ten
- 7:56percent paid. In kind not cash interest, it
- 7:59would have Very, very broad collateral.
- 8:01Climates, exact exceptionally broad, I guess all assets of the
- 8:04company they would typically ask for some warrant coverage about
- 8:08one percent of the loan amount and they would also ask that 80%
- 8:12of the deposits were made the bank.
- 8:13So it created a dependency, that's quite unusual.
- 8:16We recommend all of our portfolio companies.
- 8:18They have three or four Banks a mixture of regionals and the
- 8:21large National Banks and they do that.
- 8:24But when you think about, you just said some rounds are 50 to
- 8:26100 million. If you were to keep under the
- 8:29FDIC Limits erased, 50 million dollars.
- 8:32You would need 200 Banks to stay under the limits.
- 8:35Of course, that's not feasible. So I think a lot of people just
- 8:38kept keeping their money to looking guy back after the race.
- 8:40It as their companies grew and the rounds got bigger.
- 8:43I think they just stayed with the relationship because I think
- 8:45they were well, served by the bank, and you're a key part of
- 8:50Silicon Valley, Bank steelmaking was his relationship with like,
- 8:53venture capitalist, It was an LP in some VCS, it had the trust of
- 8:58VCS and so it felt like it could underwrite these debt deals
- 9:03better than other Banks. Because it also could sort of, I
- 9:07don't know. Go to the Venture firm and say,
- 9:09oh, you weren't straight with us or whatever.
- 9:10Is that your impression, you think it was that loose or like,
- 9:13how much is the relationship between the VC's in Silicon
- 9:17Valley Bank sort of key here? So I think they had very good
- 9:20relationships. I never saw them being loose.
- 9:22They would do their work, and they do their due diligence the
- 9:24companies. But the Howdy was they were
- 9:26investing in technology companies that are highly
- 9:29competitive environments, a lot of them are losing money and
- 9:31have extended period Runway before they'll make money.
- 9:34And I actually think in the end one of the failings wanted been
- 9:38they expected the Venture Capital Community or the growth
- 9:41Community to backstop, right? Because you look at the client
- 9:44Sarah. I mean, they own the company if
- 9:47somebody default to one of their women their laws, I'll go even
- 9:49further. Even before you draw an SV be
- 9:52long, they have covenants against all of your assets, And
- 9:55so effectively, they were a wedge in front of even the
- 9:59preferred Equity or common early.
- 10:01And so, there are some chinoise, the kind of moral hazard for the
- 10:04Venture capitalists, you're going to have to make sure that
- 10:07Silicon Valley Banks made whole. Because if you don't your
- 10:10equities wiped out right now, turned out you Vlad assumption.
- 10:14That's also Eric. If I had to guess, that's why
- 10:16they couldn't auction the bag off here in the US because I
- 10:19don't think anyone else would take a 75 billion dollar
- 10:21Adventure book. I don't know.
- 10:22That's awful. If I billion ventured, but a lot
- 10:24of it's been I don't think anybody else is capable of
- 10:27servicing it and you know what, that's a 10% her turning paper.
- 10:30Maybe that's not mezzanine, or even Equity level returns.
- 10:34So I'm not sure they were getting paid for the risks.
- 10:36They were taking. All right, so we'll get into
- 10:38sort of whether anybody will buy this down the road, but 2021
- 10:42great year, for Silicon Valley Bank does a ton of deals.
- 10:45Lots of money raised 2022. I think we see more of these
- 10:50Venture debt deals, right? Because startups need them way.
- 10:55Her hair, if they didn't want to deal with the valuation, right?
- 10:58So a lot of video as valuations came down late. 22, right?
- 11:02Right. Right startups.
- 11:03Don't want to do. They wanted to have a way to
- 11:05delay him. Yeah, Kick the Can trade, right?
- 11:09We were warning companies early last year that that was very
- 11:13dangerous to keep the candy much.
- 11:15Rather forget a good company valuation changed, take your
- 11:18medicine, raise the equity. It may be more diluted and get
- 11:21back to work, trying this. You know, all I'm going to do
- 11:24this Venture decks. The fact that we Blocking the
- 11:26equity. It's like super preferred.
- 11:27And so it actually creates a downdraft even further on
- 11:30valuation. You may think you're preserving
- 11:32your value, but you're definitely, you know, impacted
- 11:35yourself to a downside because the liabilities are taking on.
- 11:39All right. So then for Silicon Valley Bank,
- 11:41any Bank sees that there are some interest rate movement.
- 11:45But how do I ask or explain the the mortgage security issue
- 11:52basically sort of Silicon Valley, Bank's own Style of
- 11:55investing. And I think in particular touch
- 11:57on this is a bank. But in some ways, it's
- 12:00investing, you know, like more of an investment firm or what
- 12:04are the moves, they're making this sure if a lot of time
- 12:06thinking about this because obviously had Treasury and risk
- 12:08porting to be in Blackstone Merrill.
- 12:10And actually went, I was later. I actually had a treasury fund
- 12:14at Blackstone where I would actually managed to balance
- 12:16sheets of our portfolio companies.
- 12:18I did the same thing at Airbnb. We carefully manage the balance
- 12:21sheet. At one point, we were making
- 12:22more than a hundred million dollars of ebitda just off of
- 12:25her. There's the balance.
- 12:26So the reality is treasure. You should never lose money.
- 12:28You should never take directional baths and you should
- 12:31run a very balanced liquid book. The book should be liquid
- 12:34according to what the demands of the business are and it should
- 12:36be balanced according to rate, shocks or credit exposures.
- 12:40So a typical treasury, this is what's really ironic are a
- 12:44corporate treasury. Actually could not put money in
- 12:49Silicon Valley Bank because before this run, it was a BB
- 12:53credit and typically, corporate SRI has to be an investment
- 12:56grade. A credit a - credit or above.
- 12:59She, they couldn't take large cap, corporate deposits.
- 13:02Like, they couldn't take deposits from a black stone
- 13:03portfolio. So here's what happened rates.
- 13:07Went up so fast that at the same time, so, can I back was
- 13:11aggregating so much assets? They had to put it somewhere and
- 13:14so they made investments in long-term bonds that quickly
- 13:18came under water. When rates went up so much.
- 13:20So let's say they, I think they're yield on their 30-year
- 13:23book was in around A half to three and a half percent and
- 13:27because they will bring that one in and you were investing in
- 13:29treasuries the same time, their deposit accounts.
- 13:32They were paying their depositors about 4.6 percent.
- 13:36Hmm, after it was, when rates are went from basically zero, to
- 13:41four point seven five in such a short period of time, their
- 13:44long-dated treasury book and their mortgage backed security
- 13:47book was underwater because the rates were lower than you can
- 13:50get with other Securities now, right?
- 13:53To begin very layman terms, as I Stand it.
- 13:55The idea was that if they held these bonds forever till they
- 14:01could be exercised, they would be up but it would be smaller
- 14:04than if you bought something else on the open market.
- 14:06This is why the mark-to-market ish, right?
- 14:09Because if you Market to Market, then you you'd sell it at a loss
- 14:14because nobody wants it because they can get a better deal from
- 14:17what's available today. We can agree.
- 14:19Is that that's close. That's right, so we expect this.
- 14:22We are so in a treasury book, there's two parts of There's
- 14:25available for sale, which would be money market fund like that.
- 14:29That's shorter term and that's mark-to-market then there's held
- 14:32to maturity right or held for investment.
- 14:36That means that you can hold that 30 year bond and you can
- 14:38get your two and a half percent interest and you'll get paid out
- 14:40before principal in the 30th year, the problem with Silicon
- 14:43Valley Bank as I understand, it was once there was a demand for
- 14:47withdrawals, they needed to go into they're held to maturity
- 14:51book. Sell 21 billion dollars of
- 14:54mortgage-backed securities. He's and treasuries at a 1.8
- 14:57billion dollar loss, which you know, it's eight half percent.
- 15:00It's not a huge loss but it's unusual to do that which means
- 15:03that their company was under pressure because they had to dip
- 15:06into what they would have held for a long time and realized
- 15:09losses. You now do you think that held
- 15:11to maturity distinction makes sense?
- 15:14I mean part of the reason they want all these assets is if they
- 15:16ever need to liquidate them. So they can pay their account
- 15:19holders, they can do you have a view on whether the any is non
- 15:24mark-to-market accounting? Make sense for a bank like this.
- 15:26Well y'all comes out judgment call and make the judgment is
- 15:29that he put it in your held to maturity book.
- 15:32That should be a capital that you never have to access before
- 15:36it goes to maturity. Number one.
- 15:37Number two, thirty years was an awful long time for bank.
- 15:40That's growing at that rate, right?
- 15:42Because they being a fan but I pretty years awful lot and you
- 15:45you're running the risk and it's very hard at that scale when
- 15:49they have 211 billion in assets that scale hedging, it is really
- 15:53almost impossible. So the way you had your teeth,
- 15:55You just take shorter term, treasuries and you grind through
- 15:58those and they did. And so they have this
- 15:59longer-dated book. And also, everything is 50% of
- 16:02their assets were these long dated treasuries and agencies.
- 16:05That's a pretty aggressive mix for a bank.
- 16:08Like this puts judgment calls me, we'll never know.
- 16:10I wouldn't want to second-guess what they were doing, but it
- 16:13appears what they had to do was sell 1.8 billion that wasps hit
- 16:17their Equity at the time that he the sale, their market cap was
- 16:20only 12 billion and that's a big lost, 15% lost the market cap,
- 16:24and now I think Deposit withdrawals just started to
- 16:27accelerate they were downgraded or they were put on watch by
- 16:30Moody's on March 2nd March 3rd not also began to then quench
- 16:36their credit and create the more of the withdrawals that you saw.
- 16:39So, in November, 20, 22, I believe, Green Oaks it's been
- 16:44reported, sent a letter to their portfolio, companies warning a
- 16:48little bit about Silicon Valley Bank.
- 16:50So now I just said as a data point that there were some
- 16:52concerned then. And then I think in January, I
- 16:55think Seeking Alpha, I think another sub stack started
- 16:59publishing pieces, questioning Silicon Valley Bank or like
- 17:03yeah, is that November January is when this sort of really
- 17:06started to turn against the bank?
- 17:08Or how are ya. A think about it this way?
- 17:10I mean, the objective news, we know, is that least by late
- 17:15February? They had to dip into their held
- 17:16to maturity book to get with quiddity to make deposit.
- 17:19So that point it must have been deteriorating for a while and I
- 17:22give hats off to kneel Meadow and the Green Oaks post.
- 17:24You'll agree Master. We've done a bunch of things
- 17:26with him. He understand public markets,
- 17:28and private markets, and I think he was right to warn the
- 17:31companies to be careful that this could change.
- 17:34Remember, it started as a BB back so it was starting from a
- 17:37position that had. Let's call it a higher risk
- 17:40profile in a typical Bank. You know JP Morgan's double-a.
- 17:44First Republic's in a 1 or a minus mean, those are much
- 17:47higher rated banks by a wide margin would.
- 17:49Yes, I would say that in the end will probably find out that the
- 17:52deterioration in deposits began as a crawl.
- 17:54And Finished with I think they have been reported that they had
- 17:5842 billion dollars or redemptions last Thursday.
- 18:01I think that's Mark's job creation, and deposits.
- 18:04At first isn't necessarily all driven by fear of Silicon Valley
- 18:09Bank having problems, right? Part of the issue is an SUV
- 18:13talks about this that, you know, companies have burning even
- 18:17though they weren't raising as much money.
- 18:18So suddenly they're just burning through their bank, accounts, an
- 18:21SUV and suddenly Seb has less money and A really broad Point
- 18:26as we be with sort of double exposed to interest rates going
- 18:30up. The obvious one, was they bought
- 18:33these investment vehicles that just had to low of interest rate
- 18:37and it could have waited or found some other vehicle to
- 18:40optimize for higher interest rate.
- 18:41And then the second is obviously that the start of Industry which
- 18:45SV B is overweight in is so exposed to high interest rates,
- 18:49right? It's robbed a low interest rate,
- 18:51environment and struggle to not high interest, rate environment
- 18:54and so SUV. So, if anything should have been
- 18:56hedging and preparing for a downturn, in a world where
- 18:59interest rates went up, would you ask me?
- 19:01I think, I took away, but it's almost like an echo effect.
- 19:04Eric, as you point out, there were a bunch of factors their
- 19:06client base was weakening on the corporate side, the firm's the
- 19:11funds, which slowing down fundraising and funding new
- 19:14companies valuations were going down because they're under
- 19:17pressure interest rates. Their book was deteriorating
- 19:20because they were mismatched on both maturity and liquidity and
- 19:24the interest rate. Don't leave out.
- 19:25One other thing too is that just wasn't that attracted when rates
- 19:28you were able to get, just think about this just last week you
- 19:32could get five point zero seven percent on a 2-year treasury.
- 19:37So even if Silicon Valley Bank was giving people four and a
- 19:40half, they were better options in the market, Eric.
- 19:42So I would say that there was and that's what's happening a
- 19:44lot of regional Banks. I mean people were moving money
- 19:47to higher yielding opportunities with less risk, right?
- 19:51The bank's thought their customers would be sticky.
- 19:53Turns out they're going to chase the best.
- 19:55Interest rate they can which makes us very competitive and it
- 19:58was interesting. And you know, you're a leader in
- 20:00this space, the Silicon Valley bag.
- 20:03He's in the middle of an ecosystem, that's pretty close.
- 20:06Meaning once the Run started, it's not like thousands of VCS
- 20:10need to move for this thing to collapse pretty quickly.
- 20:12It's right, we hundreds because there's scale players, you know,
- 20:1580% of the acids from the top 30 firms.
- 20:18And so I think it moved pretty quickly and rumors started going
- 20:23around. I was getting texts and emails
- 20:24and Of inbounds to our company's last week and that can usually
- 20:28tell ya, when does The Run start in your mind?
- 20:31Do you have a date or you? So the first time we started
- 20:35seeing people approach our company's other investors
- 20:38approach. Our company's versatile, we want
- 20:40treasury centralized and we were way ahead.
- 20:42So we didn't have any of this exposure.
- 20:44That means, you can see all your companies sort of.
- 20:47Yeah, I think we built a proprietary system.
- 20:49I built it when I was a black stones called eye level that
- 20:52most of the industry is and you can load into it real time
- 20:54information. Information companies.
- 20:56So, you know where their treasury cash is by Bank by
- 21:00amount by interest rate and we haven't full treasury practice.
- 21:03In fact, we have our own money market fund Etc that we offer.
- 21:06And so one of the things we do, we underwrite a company is we
- 21:09make sure they do treasury right, that they diversify their
- 21:12deposit base that they have the right asset liability match and
- 21:16that they, you know, move away. So, it wasn't really an issue
- 21:18for us. There was some exposure, but we
- 21:20move quickly. Here's when I saw an error on
- 21:22say, starting last Tuesday, was the first time I Started seeing
- 21:25PCS calling our companies say it is March 7th, right?
- 21:29At March south or six months out.
- 21:32I started seeing BCS calling the company.
- 21:34Saying, hey, we're your deposits.
- 21:36What do you have with SV B? And it was interesting.
- 21:39Are there see to be like two teams?
- 21:42One was keeping deposits? Everything's fine.
- 21:45And some of those firms were telling their portfolio
- 21:47companies that through Thursday and some of them were like move
- 21:50quickly. Get out and see if here we feel.
- 21:53It seems very clear and so at least, Some of Founders fund was
- 21:56on move out. I mean, do you have a sense of
- 22:00I'm trying to think who I mean us V.
- 22:02I think even before last week, I had warned their portfolio.
- 22:05Companies Fred Wilson. Yeah, I mentioned Green Oaks.
- 22:08I'm trying to think if I've left any one notable out that's been
- 22:11public about this. Well, the I can tell you the
- 22:14buyout firms which are not their parting would not be doing
- 22:17business with SVG, but the buyout firms began last week
- 22:20taking assets away from Regional banks are there The streets were
- 22:25doing because the buyout usually use Regional Banks because it's
- 22:28a cheaper source of funding, so they'll use PNC or something
- 22:31like that. So they started pulling out and
- 22:33moving to the money center Max. There's kind of there's three
- 22:36tiers of bags, their Community Banks, then you've got the
- 22:39middle to your bench, which would be considered like a
- 22:41Silicon Valley Bank earlier huge.
- 22:43Then you have the top five banks that are but if you call
- 22:46systemically important Banks, or since they have a different set
- 22:49of rules and expenses around, that's Banks above 250 billion
- 22:53and then five hundred billion other break.
- 22:55St. Cyr Morgan Bank of America City.
- 22:58Well Wells Fargo. Yeah, interestingly so think
- 23:02about this 60% of all deposits in u.s. banks are above two
- 23:06hundred fifty thousand dollars because the FDIC was set up in
- 23:091933. As part of glass-steagall, it is
- 23:12clearly an anachronism. And I think when people realized
- 23:16wait a minute, I could be an uninsured depositor and clearly
- 23:19all the most Venture companies have a lot more than 250,000 in
- 23:22Silicon Valley Bank that created like a Tinderbox.
- 23:25Box that I think people move to protect really quickly and the
- 23:28Run happened really quickly. They had 100 send word word
- 23:31spread so quickly, right. I think Andreessen Horowitz
- 23:34Founders were messaging each other, you know, saying, hey,
- 23:37like if you see one big company, you know, pull their money from
- 23:41SV B. Then it just becomes it becomes
- 23:45a game theory problem. I'm and I talked about this in
- 23:47my newsletter before, everything blew up.
- 23:50It's just like Even if you don't really want to support the run
- 23:53on the bank, it's just like as an individual player, it makes
- 23:57sense to defect, you know it feels logical to be safe.
- 24:01Like why do you want to take some big stance and risk your
- 24:04money here, right? I mean, yeah, it seems like a
- 24:06simple Game Theory problem to me.
- 24:08You're actually right there, it's a painful decision.
- 24:10When you've got a relationship with a bank like Silicon Valley
- 24:12back, but in the end we're all 50 shares.
- 24:15And as fiduciaries yeah, protect your investors.
- 24:18Investors have to come first and if you believe there's a risk
- 24:21surface, You can't analyze or you're fearful of you have to
- 24:24move. I think that's when you saw like
- 24:26the cascading. I mean, they had a hundred
- 24:28seventy five billion in deposits and the end of last year's, the
- 24:31last reported amount if it is in fact true, the Press reports
- 24:35that they had 42 billion pulled on Thursday, there had to be
- 24:38another 20, 30 billion before that and so you're looking at
- 24:41half their deposit base was probably out and then the other
- 24:44thing is with receivership so technically the bag spb went
- 24:49into receivership at 844 Friday morning.
- 24:52They stopped processing wires after 3 o'clock on Thursday, but
- 24:55there's a difference, had there, not been the intervention of the
- 24:58government. There's a difference between
- 25:00someone who submitted a wire on Thursday and someone who didn't
- 25:04until after see Burton. I think people do that Silicon
- 25:07Valley Bank in my view, sort of bungled the communication with
- 25:13investors, right? I mean, if we talk about the
- 25:15government not communicating much, I mean Silicon Valley Bank
- 25:18basically raised the money's Money.
- 25:22And now to deal with General Atlantic that was contingent on
- 25:25other fundraising, right? As what is Silver Gate was
- 25:29failing, right? So it was you know it was like a
- 25:32dark time for banks and then they announced this at the worst
- 25:35time. It's not all buttoned up and
- 25:38then they get all the VCS on the phone and they I mean from what
- 25:43we've seen in like the information report is basically
- 25:46they say we're fine unless all of you guys panic and it's like
- 25:51if you're You see it's like what we are all panicking right now.
- 25:54So while that somewhat reassuring if you're saying well
- 25:58we're not fine if everyone behaves irrational and you look
- 26:01around and everybody's behaving irrationally you're sending
- 26:04yourself in the sprawl of your own demise.
- 26:06So why would you say about how SV be managed and handled the
- 26:10crisis. So our did I really hesitate?
- 26:13I think the whole Community should be careful with what they
- 26:15assume and what they want they do you already have Liz war and
- 26:18saying all and put them all in a steak like that file just right.
- 26:22It was a Confluence of events that was very hard to manage.
- 26:25And you have the downgrade, or at least the signal downgrade
- 26:28from BB. To BB - you had the sale of
- 26:30Securities which obviously meant they were under enormous
- 26:33withdrawal. Pressure at that point, then you
- 26:35have the financing Jamie General Wax & amazing firm that do great
- 26:38work. They were willing to step in.
- 26:40They were right to make their funding contingent on filling
- 26:43out the full two point, two five billion and then you know quite
- 26:46Becker got em that 10-minute call that you just referenced
- 26:49all our interactions with Greg. He's been in his decent.
- 26:52I was just complimenting on what a business.
- 26:53He built six months ago when we met.
- 26:55I think it with all the best of intentions and they left that
- 26:58dangling. Participle out there.
- 26:59Well, unless, and I think when these things happen a bank run
- 27:03his background, it's not, it's not rational, it's not doesn't
- 27:06make sense. The math, doesn't matter.
- 27:08You can point to all you want. I have a couple conversations
- 27:11with some Regional back heads over the weekend person.
- 27:13Like you can't say enough for doing off.
- 27:15You got to get out there and got to keep hammering it home
- 27:17because it was just so much misinformation.
- 27:20And we all communicate so quickly people are Texting each
- 27:22other you out you out. Boom gone and so that's the
- 27:25minister live in this world of like control anymore, right?
- 27:29You can imagine this cycle plane out a decade or two decades ago.
- 27:33The Venture firms would have been able to sort of meet with
- 27:36each other and say, hey we're gonna like show support the
- 27:40media would have been much more reluctant to like talk about
- 27:44runs like I tried to not fuel the run and say like okay this
- 27:47is already a thing. So I'm going to talk about it
- 27:49but because you know just a few weeks ago I think there was a
- 27:52similar case with one of Mercury's Bank where there was
- 27:55some fear uncertainty and doubt and then, you know, it was fine,
- 27:58but because there's no media control is my point.
- 28:01It's much easier for these rumors to start all over
- 28:03Twitter. So you have the lack of ECU
- 28:05control, lack of media control, and so rumors, and, and message
- 28:10boards. And sort of direct communication
- 28:12is so powerful, for short, a little bit, less controlled, and
- 28:15that, and that if you watch would happen in crypto, that
- 28:18was, it was one run after another one after another run.
- 28:21I mean, who Never thought you'd ever run an exchange.
- 28:23Like FTX exchange should have segregated accounts, but it
- 28:26happened because they didn't have the account.
- 28:28So I agree with you. This is to be analyzed, like the
- 28:31speed with which this happened. And this is the conversation.
- 28:33I had with both politicians and some of the banking sector Julie
- 28:36week on the speed with, which this has happened the depth of
- 28:39the misinformation. And even the seniority of the
- 28:42people trapped. I mean, had one very senior
- 28:45magic apples and one very senior CEO of a public company,
- 28:49literally text me the exact same.
- 28:52Misinformation about one of the bags over the weekend and to a
- 28:56point where like the fdic's at this Branch.
- 28:58So clearly with Maggie circles and Bible dead Rock.
- 29:02And so I agree with you. That's why I made the comment
- 29:04about and I was talking about this with representative Connie
- 29:07yesterday, there needs to be a facility.
- 29:09I think about if the stock it's a run and it's too volatile,
- 29:12they stopped it, right? They have these Breakers, there
- 29:15shouldn't be a breaker. If there's a run in one of these
- 29:18bags in that breaker would be the ability for the bank to
- 29:20immediately. Tap the Said to be able to pay
- 29:23these deposits. You know what make it a t-bill,
- 29:27get paid back into positives and charge the bank, whatever the
- 29:29going rate for a 2-year bond is, right?
- 29:32Just keep that out too, because this is going to keep happening.
- 29:34If this just misinformation gets out there, it seems incredible.
- 29:38Was there a skill in getting the money out?
- 29:40It felt like, you know, smaller individual companies struggled,
- 29:43there is definitely a sort of a game trying to figure out how to
- 29:46get the money out. There is, we did have a couple
- 29:49of our small companies smaller Investments had some Closure
- 29:52and, you know, we would treasury death.
- 29:54So we just immediately moved as fast as we could.
- 29:56This is earlier than week. We felt like we really around
- 29:59the Moody's down raise, when we started really pay attention to
- 30:01it, there is some art to it because if you got people that
- 30:04know how to get to the bank had to get to the people at the
- 30:07bank, get out quickly. Unfortunately, that is how it
- 30:09works. The site didn't go down until I
- 30:12think they stopped about. As I said about three o'clock on
- 30:14Thursday that became a big issue, some people didn't move
- 30:17until after that thankfully the government stepped in, I wrote
- 30:20about people from Friday morning, you know, going to the
- 30:23New York office of Silicon Valley Bank and like trying to
- 30:26get into the point. You know, very friendly.
- 30:29Police officers were brought in to tell people that, you know,
- 30:31they couldn't go into the office.
- 30:33So a pretty dramatic. Yeah.
- 30:35Seeing just a pause on Silicon Valley Bank.
- 30:37I get this sense that, the bank thought like it's relationships
- 30:41with the VCS would protect it from like defectors of his, the
- 30:45word I'm using, you know, and there clearly were some VCS that
- 30:48were trying to put their relationship with the bank.
- 30:52First, what's your view on that? It's such a hard question Eric
- 30:55because, you know, even with the best of intentions you do have
- 30:59that tension between your fiduciary duty to your investors
- 31:02and your loyalty to the bank. And I think that by Thursday, it
- 31:06was pretty clear that things were getting out of hand and I'm
- 31:09sure if left to its own devices. I mean, I'm sure that silicon
- 31:11dog magwood then I've been they could have for their investors
- 31:14that gets into the question. Erica, did the government way
- 31:16too long? So then on Friday and there's
- 31:21where we start to talk about the government, California declares
- 31:26that Silicon Valley, Bank had failed and brings in the FDIC,
- 31:30right? And then we basically have
- 31:36That's Friday, right? Or is that Saturday starts
- 31:38pissed, Rascal sauces, use this term here, it starts to 60 hour
- 31:42clock over 60. Our clock is from the filing and
- 31:45844 PST Friday to the announcement from treasury
- 31:50yesterday, right now. So then we have this Collective
- 31:55Panic on Twitter. Basically, the issue is that,
- 31:59you know, obviously everyone is protected up to 250,000 dollars.
- 32:04But after that, they're basically I like debt holders
- 32:07and so they get paid out from the bank's actual assets as the
- 32:10government liquidates that my sense is the vast vast majority
- 32:14of banks that have failed have seen depositors get fully
- 32:19covered right. But despite that there seemed to
- 32:22be a ton of concern with in Silicon Valley about depositors
- 32:27not getting covered. Why do you think this was
- 32:29exceptional? So a couple things you write
- 32:32when he took one thing, you said that you absolutely on the last
- 32:36My can remember depositor losing money in a bank.
- 32:39Failure was probably the Savings and Loan crisis in all of the
- 32:42great financial crisis, not a single deposit or lost a single
- 32:45Dollar in. But the frankly in action of
- 32:50government and their lack of saying me, so Silicon Valley
- 32:52Bank had almost a nine hundred and fifty eight billion dollar
- 32:55deficit. By the time they filed an on
- 32:58Friday morning and obviously once you have that deficit, the
- 33:00match between redemptions of deposits and your ability to
- 33:04liquidate assets to meet them, And then at that moment, the
- 33:08government was not signaling that it would step in.
- 33:10You know, we've heard a lot for the last few years about too big
- 33:13to fail and we don't want any more bailouts and there's an
- 33:16underlying social thing. Here are, there's a real
- 33:18antipathy, from the government, towards Silicon Valley, towards
- 33:22technology companies towards Venture capitalists and I think
- 33:25that there was a fear that the government just wouldn't step
- 33:28in. And I think we could talk about
- 33:30the events over the weekend. I think what you saw yesterday
- 33:33afternoon was brought to very begrudgingly and Like to Italy
- 33:36and may be too late to contain some of the damage.
- 33:39Because if you really think about it, so we could all you
- 33:41back wasn't. It was just how to liquidity
- 33:43crunch. If they had extended the what
- 33:45they call defend window error, which allows a bank like Silicon
- 33:49Valley Bank to pledge assets. So they could have taken those
- 33:52long-dated. Treasuries under the new plan.
- 33:54That just announced yesterday, they could have taken those long
- 33:57dated Securities, put them back to the FED par, which in itself
- 34:03is a bailout, could have put them back at par gotten look.
- 34:06Witty and made the redemptions. But for some reason, the
- 34:08government decided, well, we're gonna let that one go, and we'll
- 34:11see what the contagion isn't that?
- 34:13I think what we remember is the biggest mistake, because over
- 34:16the next 60 hours, you have a real Roshan of faith in deposit.
- 34:19You think they shouldn't have let s UB fail in the first
- 34:22place. They should have taken those
- 34:24assets. I don't know that they shouldn't
- 34:27have put them in receivership, because I think that those rules
- 34:29are hard to break, but what they should have done is when
- 34:32immediately said, will honor, all the positives because the
- 34:34assets were, there are not like Thankfully, the Savings and Loan
- 34:37room. The underlying assets fella
- 34:38Parks was real estate and stuff. The assets were there including
- 34:41those elongated Securities. They should have said okay we
- 34:44have the assets will pledge more of them to the event window and
- 34:48then help them to the liquidity crisis.
- 34:50And no depositors will lose money.
- 34:51If they said what they said yesterday in conjunction with
- 34:55the receivership on Thursday, the world will be a very
- 34:58different place in the loss of jobs and the damage to the
- 35:01economy, much more limited. But that sounds they did as of
- 35:04yesterday morning and I spent a lot of Time on the phone over
- 35:06the weekend with both Senators. Congresspeople was obviously
- 35:10I've seen this before the government was not going to make
- 35:13the decision of that announcement as a Sunday
- 35:16morning. When we secretary yelling, went
- 35:18on Face the Nation. If you listen to her words, she
- 35:21had no interest in bailout was not going to come to any help
- 35:24and was saying systems. Fine.
- 35:26She was wrong. And by later in the afternoon, I
- 35:29think she H elated and I think they realized they had to do
- 35:32something or the contagion would be much bigger.
- 35:34And that still can't stem? The Damage Done over the prior
- 35:3860 hours, just as a personal anecdote after SUV failed, you
- 35:43know, my small newcomer Mercury account.
- 35:46You know, I moved money out of that into a Chase account just
- 35:49to be safe. So just as a purely anecdotal
- 35:52experience, you can sort of feel it.
- 35:53Like over the weekend people are like, why not being a big Bank?
- 35:57You know, it just like the incremental value of a small
- 36:00Bank even if you know you're going to get your money back,
- 36:03it's just like I don't want you know that.
- 36:05So I'm not having a Access to my money when I need it.
- 36:08I guess the big question here in terms of the government's action
- 36:12is like how much was this? An SV be specific problem, right
- 36:17SV be specific and they're sort of decisions in terms of
- 36:21Investments as we be specific in terms of their exposure to
- 36:25startups and then SV be specific and that they had customers that
- 36:29seemed like loudly, you know, telling everybody to bail and
- 36:32like if other Regional Banks didn't have that same sort of I
- 36:36don't know, network of communication.
- 36:39Would that have happened? I think there's evidence against
- 36:41that. So, what's your view in terms of
- 36:43how SV be specific this was? I think SUV was unique but not
- 36:47idiosyncratic. It was unique in the industry.
- 36:50It served with probably unique that the ecosystem is relatively
- 36:54concentrated was certainly unique that their loan book
- 36:57include Adventure mean really when they compete for Venture.
- 36:59There's not really any other banks that underwrote ventured
- 37:02out like that. Eric, what they would compete
- 37:04with on term sheets would be alternative.
- 37:06Asset managers that do that like, like, right funds.
- 37:10So they were unique, there are thing that has this was the 16th
- 37:13largest bank. I think people forgot that, you
- 37:16know, a few years ago, it wasn't top 100 and now it's 60.
- 37:20And so it's size. And scale was bigger that I
- 37:23think and the government just they didn't move fast enough to
- 37:26at least two swage the concerns and folks did exactly what you
- 37:29did error. They're like, well, why wouldn't
- 37:30he go to Money Center? Banks, the issue now is we're
- 37:33going to drive more concentration risk with the top
- 37:35Banks, which Create more too big to fail.
- 37:38It's exactly the opposite of a policy of helping the system.
- 37:40Now, in the end, the government did the right thing.
- 37:43I think everyone is safe. Now across all the bank's.
- 37:46That's great, but you have to go back and look at what damage was
- 37:49caused in and what assets moved around in the meantime, the
- 37:51government on Sunday announced that it would cover depositors
- 37:57across the banks and that they would take some of these
- 37:59long-held assets, right? We talked about that.
- 38:02They also at the same time, they announced one additional bank
- 38:05failures Right. So signature Eric is a pretty
- 38:08now that is an idiosyncratic back, we had sure has a crossbow
- 38:11bank, right? They do take some crypto
- 38:14signatures long but in the eyes of The Regulators, they
- 38:16struggled in 2008 because they had a lot of real estate that
- 38:19they were very concentrated in commercial real estate and the
- 38:22tri-state area. They were taking some crypto.
- 38:25There was a back and forth so that was no surprise to anyone
- 38:29Silicon Valley Bank is a surprise for sure.
- 38:32Like, do you think First Republic, if the government had
- 38:35taken? No action.
- 38:36Do you think First Republic? What did well they're, they're
- 38:39unique, they're one of these collateral damage just by rumor
- 38:42and other things me, right? Is their stock price was down.
- 38:45There's somewhat smart questions down.
- 38:46I thought, honestly, I saw some pretty irresponsible
- 38:49Communications to some of our companies by other investors
- 38:53saying oh it's first of all. It's next.
- 38:55We just totally irresponsible like right actually
- 38:57misinformation such as they had FDIC at their brains just first
- 39:01of all because Billion dollars of liquidity.
- 39:04It's always been a really well-managed back there, fine.
- 39:06They were always fine. It's just a perception thing.
- 39:08You can't hurt and, of course, that impacted their stock price,
- 39:12but it's always been a very steady bank.
- 39:13It's an a-minus rated back the same goal.
- 39:16Do you think without government action is so would have been
- 39:18fine? Are you?
- 39:18I do? I think they would absolutely
- 39:20would have got then, what is the contagion?
- 39:22If signature was a sort of unique already?
- 39:24Troubled bank. If the one that was sort of
- 39:27perceived as next in line was probably going to be okay.
- 39:31Then why not just let Silicon Valley Bank customers?
- 39:34Get paid out the old-fashioned way off the assets of SBB.
- 39:38First off, the thing they opened yesterday which they call it
- 39:41Bank treasury funding program. Our is the same thing that
- 39:44existed in 2008. As I was saying the FED opens up
- 39:47its Windows, you could pledge assets.
- 39:49Not that back then, it was mark-to-market now.
- 39:50It's par which is effectively a bailout effectively.
- 39:53This is really interesting. The FED is admitting that they
- 39:56raise rates too fast and they created six hundred billion of
- 39:59unrealized losses in these Banks.
- 40:00Well, they're saying Say I'll give it back to me at par even
- 40:03though it's not worth far. So right, Silicon Valley Bank
- 40:06had that facility available last week they would have pledged to
- 40:1121 billion. They would have gotten 21
- 40:13billion, not 21 billion, minus 1.8 billion in losses, and would
- 40:16be in a different position. So I think the problem the
- 40:18government is they were too reactive, not proactive and now
- 40:21they're put in place things that could be helpful, but I'll go to
- 40:24the psychology point. You actually said it perfectly
- 40:27in your own words. Why not why not move from a
- 40:30Regional Bank to one of these? Your systemic Banks and I think
- 40:33that's the longer term thing that the government's going to
- 40:36have to Grapple with. Because, you know, I think these
- 40:39programs are going to be permanent in terms of like
- 40:41culpability Silicon Valley Bank, lobbied successfully, the Trump
- 40:47Administration to lower the sort of the standards for a Regional
- 40:52Bank, like Silicon Valley Bank great.
- 40:54I mean, in terms of the regulatory regime to protect
- 40:59consumer confidence in the bank, SUV management intentionally
- 41:04undermine. I mean do you just?
- 41:05Yeah I'm not I don't disagree that a little better.
- 41:07Eric, I don't know specifically in conversations with a Lobby
- 41:10for I would just say the 2018 act I think the argument from
- 41:15the regional Banks like a Silicon Valley Bank was that the
- 41:18owners regulations and requirements and capital
- 41:21requirements that were put in place in 2008 we're limiting
- 41:25their ability to serve smaller businesses and I think that's
- 41:29really what was coming from you're saying look okay Have the
- 41:32same thing at JPMorgan and if it's a little bit looser than
- 41:36I'll be able to serve the growth of the community, I think it was
- 41:38more a genuine interest in that and that's that's what was the
- 41:41intent, obviously that meant that maybe the boundaries of
- 41:44that were pushed and they turned out to create a risk services
- 41:47that now come true. I mean, thank you for answering
- 41:52to some of the arguments, the whole valley is going to face,
- 41:54but I mean Larry Summers, you know, tweeted out something that
- 41:58was like now is not the time to worry about moral hazard, you
- 42:01know, over the weekend when the government was debating this
- 42:04decision. And if anything that gave me
- 42:07such like a negative reaction because it's always, you know,
- 42:09when something's inconvenient and uncomfortable that people
- 42:13want to abandon holding actors accountable for moral hazard,
- 42:18obviously, so, Look on Valley Bank management would prefer to
- 42:21have, like an existing bank that they can continue to get paid by
- 42:24and like, that's their careers. But, you know, we are in some
- 42:28ways incentivizing people to take more risk, run an
- 42:31aggressive strategy, get paid well.
- 42:33And then, you know, if the government picks up the pieces,
- 42:37when everything falls apart, I mean it's such a conundrum,
- 42:39right? He's, you can make marks on both
- 42:41sides. They should have assumed
- 42:42interesting. Now, Summers was saying last
- 42:45week s, VB was just isolated incident will not sit.
- 42:49Still Exactly. So you how do you square those?
- 42:51And then he then he turned his mind.
- 42:53She didn't realize yeah, you played a critical role in this.
- 42:55There's a young Congressman that covers the district where
- 42:58silicon die Bank was named real Kana.
- 43:00I see ultimately. He was exactly what you'd want
- 43:04for representative. He was super well-informed.
- 43:06He went on Face the Nation the same time yelling did.
- 43:09He was much more articulate and convincing that the contagion
- 43:12will cost jobs and hurt the larger economy and we shouldn't
- 43:15thumb her nose. Is it bailing out?
- 43:16Bankers, forget about the executives.
- 43:18It's all about the climb. - really and he was very
- 43:21articulate and he was tenacious over the weekend and I think he
- 43:23had a big role to play and how they tied the term.
- 43:26Because as of yesterday morning they weren't going to do
- 43:29anything and today would have been a cataclysm.
- 43:30I'm glad they did something. I still think they moved too
- 43:33late and I think they need permanent rules that just help
- 43:36banks with liquidity. Crunches, you should never
- 43:38bailed it out a bad behavior of. They make bad loans and stuff
- 43:41like that, but if it's just simply a mismatch because
- 43:44they've got a conservative balance sheet and they need to
- 43:46be depositors and there's a run. They should.
- 43:49A way to do that with a public facility, that allows this, and
- 43:52that will be something, I think that they need to look out and
- 43:55going back. And we're all day trying to
- 43:57lobby for that. And to the extent that people
- 43:59are fighting on Twitter about, whether it's a bailout, like, I
- 44:01feel like that, who cares? You know, it's like depositors
- 44:03got bailed out not shareholders, not the executive would sort of
- 44:07all understand like what happened there.
- 44:10So I feel like I'm not getting into the equity, in the
- 44:13bondholders, stuff like that, right?
- 44:15So, that is so paid 40 billion a year ago.
- 44:19Now Zero. Does the government really have
- 44:21to move so fast? I mean, was Friday to Sunday.
- 44:23I am sympathetic to Biden and, you know, the fed and all that
- 44:27in that, you know, you need a couple space to think about
- 44:30these things, right? Is is the standard they needed
- 44:32to have a solution like Friday? Yeah.
- 44:36No. I was thinking more like the
- 44:37Surfers. All the rules work because once
- 44:39they were going to fall, they were in a receivership in the
- 44:42blink of an eye. So that process worked although
- 44:44as I point out for the fdic's an anachronism, it's just not
- 44:47effective for a world where the capitals at the It is now and I
- 44:50do sympathize with the administration trying to figure
- 44:53out what to do. I just think there should have
- 44:54been something place, so they could access the liquidity
- 44:57rather than having to sell that kind of Securities in this
- 45:01environment at a loss. That's all I'm saying.
- 45:03I don't agree with what bailouts.
- 45:05I don't believe in the bailout but just giving them the
- 45:07quiddity would have avoided. A lot of us.
- 45:08Yeah. The other solution would have,
- 45:10just been a buyer, right? Or like maybe a buyer comes but
- 45:14like right now, it seems like they're trying to sell it piece
- 45:17by piece, right? Or why Won't Anyone One by we
- 45:20saw. What was it?
- 45:21The UK version of it, Silicon Valley Bank did get acquired
- 45:25right by it. Did I believe, I believe it's to
- 45:27be acquired by HSBC. You know her as soon as this
- 45:30started happening part of our risk analysis, we were looking
- 45:33at it really over the last month or so was that you couldn't see
- 45:37a buyer for this one because I'll get back to that 75 billion
- 45:41dollar loan book. I just don't think it's
- 45:42something that you can analyze like what does a 20 million
- 45:47dollar loan to a money-losing technology?
- 45:49A that's not paying current interest but that pays
- 45:52interesting kind, what does that mean?
- 45:54I think in this kind of free fall on Tech valuation.
- 45:57I don't think anybody knows. So I'm actually not surprised
- 46:00that they weren't able to do it. And it might have been and he
- 46:02and Eric we may find out that the final straw was that with
- 46:06the bids were due at 2 p.m. EST yesterday that they were
- 46:10underwhelming or not at all and it was only what, three hours
- 46:13later that the FED came out their joint announcement.
- 46:16I want to move on to the broader effect but do you think without
- 46:19like, The run without the dynamic of everybody texting
- 46:22each other like, in a short period of time that this was in
- 46:24trouble. Do you think Silicon Valley Bank
- 46:27still fails at some point? I mean, they had, I mean, that's
- 46:31so hard. I don't really have the sense
- 46:33for that kind of thing. It's like, okay, they have these
- 46:35challenge Holdings, their startup investment.
- 46:38Somebody else would make like, does this play out the same way,
- 46:40just slower if there is inserted the fear so hard to tell her,
- 46:45it's so hard to tell, I think they are very unique in the fact
- 46:48that they were so Spurs to a single ecosystem that will be
- 46:51the thing that will come out. Now, is there a role for a
- 46:55viable bank that lends to the Venture community and all these
- 46:58great entrepreneurs and ideas? Sure.
- 47:00Is that the right format the way, they did Venture debt stuff
- 47:03like that. I just don't know.
- 47:04I don't know. I don't think we're going to see
- 47:06another Silicon Valley Bank though.
- 47:08I don't think anybody's going to try to recreate that great
- 47:11framing for the next set of questions.
- 47:12So we survived the depositor risk but like what tools will
- 47:16start ups. Not have VC's not have now that
- 47:18SV B is Gone, right? I mean, it was a key part of the
- 47:21ecosystem without it, especially if you're saying nobody's going
- 47:25to step in to do some of the same things.
- 47:27What are the things that are going away here?
- 47:30This is the hardest part here because there's no question by
- 47:34some reports. They were covering fifty percent
- 47:36of startups or what's called Venture Capital Stage companies,
- 47:39or maybe even growth stage. So there's no question, it will
- 47:41leave a giant void. There are some uses of the
- 47:45Venture debt that work. So, some companies have, you
- 47:48know, season Revenues or seasonal expenses or they have
- 47:52something on their balance sheet, that they need to fund
- 47:55that they need for operation. That's an appropriate use of
- 47:58venture debt, and it shouldn't be funded by Equity.
- 48:00It should be funded by Venture debt the lines blur, when you
- 48:04get to a replacement for equity and it's just a, you know, an
- 48:08accruing note that has all these covenants, that's less
- 48:11productive, we try to avoid that in all of our companies, but
- 48:13there was a productive side of this that was priced correctly.
- 48:17Like, you know, collateralized Lending.
- 48:19Against, you know, whatever is needed to maintain operations.
- 48:23For example, that's going to be missing and that means cost of
- 48:26capital for Silicon Valley is going to go up because they were
- 48:29a cheaper than Equity cost of capital and that whole is gone.
- 48:34And he's 75 billion is a lot of money in veteran.
- 48:37Deta if in fact, that's what the whole book was and that will
- 48:41leave a real void and I think I don't see that book getting re
- 48:44underwritten. Now in a receivership Eric you
- 48:47can hold on those loans until As long as you played by the
- 48:50company, play out over time. Although I'll bet a lot of
- 48:52people breach their covenants last week when they took Capital
- 48:55out of Silicon Valley back. Exactly.
- 48:57So you know the part of the loan covenants that you're
- 49:00referencing was that people had to keep their money in spb, if
- 49:03they pulled it they would be breaking it.
- 49:05So then there's this real decision.
- 49:06Like do I break the Covenant, take the money or do I hold the
- 49:09Covenant, do you have a sense now?
- 49:11I mean, I guess it would seem given depositors or cover that
- 49:15the people who stuck to the Covenant are in a better place.
- 49:18Or is it clear? Which decision was smarter like
- 49:21a great, such a great question her because I actually had two
- 49:23entrepreneurs call me on this exact issue.
- 49:26My advice was to call the bank, which both of them did and the
- 49:29bank actually said, will waive it.
- 49:31Oh, great. Yeah, they were this is but this
- 49:34is like Tuesday, Wednesday, they weighed if they didn't waive it
- 49:37and you move the cash. Now you're receivership, they
- 49:41may have a technical argument that you breached it, but my
- 49:45thinking is I just don't see any receiver saying, we'll wait a
- 49:47minute. You breach, the Covenant by
- 49:49Acting yourself. Therefore I'm going to your oil.
- 49:51Not I know it's hard to say the last time we had something
- 49:54similar to, this would be One Bank of New England went out of
- 49:56business in 1991 and then they put all the loans is something
- 50:00called recall management and then they work their way through
- 50:03over a Year's situation by situation.
- 50:05And you know, obviously you know they don't but they would be go,
- 50:08she ate longer holds and things like that so they could get more
- 50:12recovery because they're answer. Now on those loans is to get
- 50:15maximum recovery, so they're not going to go in and call it and
- 50:18put companies in distress. They're going to work with the
- 50:20companies. At least they did in the case of
- 50:21banking, one recall management. They did work through with the
- 50:25company's way to get the most maximum recovery.
- 50:28Which might mean giving extension things like that.
- 50:31Do you think there's going to be a banking Story?
- 50:33I mean, obviously Silicon Valley is obviously going to be
- 50:35affected but like do you think we've stemmed in this is a hard
- 50:38thing to predict, but do you think we have stemmed the bank,
- 50:40the financial piece of this or do you think there's a lot more
- 50:43to drop still in terms of the regional Banks?
- 50:47It's hard to tell with those. I mean that was like, He had a
- 50:49bazooka with the government did so there shouldn't be any more
- 50:51failures. I think there's a lot of
- 50:53speculation and better. Probably a lot of assets moving
- 50:55around and now have an impact on value, but there shouldn't be
- 50:58any more speculation on. They have the ability to save it
- 51:02and I don't think the government's gonna let any more
- 51:03Banks. Go, I just don't think that's
- 51:05going to happen. And so it should stabilize.
- 51:08I think if you asked about the headlines, for this whole thing,
- 51:10Eric, it's going to be like, who's going to fill the void for
- 51:13Silicon Valley? Will it increase the cost of
- 51:15capital? You know, should bags?
- 51:17Take Venture debt? What's the government's role in
- 51:20providing liquidity? When there's a liquidity crunch,
- 51:23I think those are the type of issues that we're going to be
- 51:25hearing about over the next fall out of the next couple of years.
- 51:28I mean, a couple months ago, in terms of the Silicon Valley
- 51:31story, you know, I was pulling people of whether this was
- 51:34anything like.com and most people said, no, you know, it's
- 51:38very different, Bill girly replied that he thought it was,
- 51:42but then he didn't elaborate, but my point is just that it
- 51:44does feel like a bank, failure attached to Tech startups.
- 51:49Makes it feel much more like, okay.
- 51:50This is a seismic moment and I've been arguing for a long
- 51:54time, just and I'm not the only one that, you know, companies
- 51:57the raised hundreds of millions of dollars, fails slowly, right?
- 52:02That like, it takes a long time to show that, you know, those
- 52:06companies aren't working. Do you think this speeds that
- 52:09up, how does this impact of the failure rate of growth stage
- 52:12startups? I think it will push values
- 52:15down. I think it will definitely have
- 52:17an impact of values that we're Already Under Pressure, I think
- 52:20it will result in some cases fewer startups.
- 52:23Making it where they would have had an option like a venture
- 52:25debt or something like that to bridge them.
- 52:27So, I, unfortunately, I do think it will have a devastating
- 52:29material impact on the ecosystem, valuation, the
- 52:32success of the companies and we went into this post Bubble
- 52:35World. There were 350 Tech unicorns, it
- 52:39would take four years of a very healthy IPO Market to digest
- 52:42that. And I think to what your point
- 52:43is, a lot of them aren't going to turn out to be what they were
- 52:46worth is just going to take longer to kill him because there
- 52:47was so much Capital other What's your play going forward?
- 52:51Or how do you react to this situation?
- 52:54As somebody investing in startups and funds and all that
- 52:58we've been preaching to our clients.
- 52:59You know 2000. I could be some examples in
- 53:012021. We thought the fundraising
- 53:03environment was credible. You know, we took one of our big
- 53:06Holdings in their view the public at Lake 2020 2020 and
- 53:092021, we raised a ton of capital for businesses in 2022.
- 53:14It was all about being more, conservative, extenuating
- 53:17extending Runway. If necessary 17.
- 53:19One of our assets are high cash flow business.
- 53:21Anyway, we don't do a lot of venture, we do more, we call
- 53:23more growth, Equity later stage, we had people in a conservative
- 53:26operating posture for a while. And right now, the big question
- 53:29that companies are asking us. We ate companies that are
- 53:31pre-ipo, this will put those dates back for sure, where we
- 53:36were saying we thought some of the strongest biggest names
- 53:38could go out in the fall and that would be getting the IPO
- 53:41Market. I think that's probably now
- 53:43closer to the beginning of next year and it's going to take some
- 53:45time. So this all have real
- 53:47reverberations reverberations are going.
- 53:49That market just take a longer in play through what we're
- 53:51telling. Our investors is setting up to
- 53:53be a great vintage if you have a lot of dry powder and capital
- 53:56because the you know, the leverage if you will switch it,
- 53:59even more firmly in the hands of the GPS who have Capital you're
- 54:02not competing with Venture debt anymore and you know I think
- 54:06that there's curricular saying good for valuations makes
- 54:08ventral I wish to come down in the best companies would be a
- 54:11ruse Capital but you know it's also me it's gonna be a really
- 54:14good investment period for people that have scale stuff.
- 54:16Everything is right now. Eric the biggest Thing that
- 54:19we're seeing is one of the biggest a lot of distress GPS.
- 54:22A lot of GPS didn't sell anything over the last couple of
- 54:24years and didn't return our people to their investors.
- 54:27And so we're seeing investors even in the companies that we're
- 54:30in some of our best, capful businesses are just selling your
- 54:33shares at a discount because there is a lot of distress in
- 54:36the GPS system before. So it cannot back.
- 54:38And now you have that on your buying a venture firm shares in
- 54:41the company you believe in, or you're buying out an LPS
- 54:43interest in those Venture for. Thanks for clarification, buying
- 54:46out other Venture firms. That are on the cap tables of
- 54:50our companies that might have gotten it earlier, or did
- 54:53something else because they haven't returning Capital to
- 54:55their investors. And, you know, that it was the
- 54:58opposite of what we were doing last two years.
- 55:00We returned you know billion dollars of capital in the last
- 55:0218 months to our investors. And so I think it's important
- 55:05that, you know, the u.s. is a lot of stress in the system
- 55:08right now and that will make for opportunities.
- 55:10And one of the opportunities is buying from other GPS.
- 55:12The other opportunities, good companies, that need operating
- 55:15intervention. There's companies that need
- 55:17capital for Ian's and growth, and make up for the whole
- 55:22old-school guy backs. There's gonna be a lot of.
- 55:23What are they? Give me like a, um, or fund.
- 55:26You're investing out of, like, with Wes cap.
- 55:28I feel like you like to live a little under the radar, but
- 55:30since I have you anyway, just educate people little bit on
- 55:34whatever where are you doing? Is this like, how much is this,
- 55:38your, your wealth versus LPS or yeah, just give me a sense.
- 55:42It's not so it's fully third party.
- 55:44The biggest investors in the fund are the partners themselves
- 55:47but we're 28 billion offer. Do typically later stage after
- 55:51VCS and we invest in the operating scaling of the
- 55:54business and that's what we've always done.
- 55:56That's been 25 years will start in three businesses that got to
- 55:58unicorn status. And we, that's what we focus on.
- 56:01WE focused we just do marketplaces, are because their
- 56:03asset light and they scale, you know, we build our positions in
- 56:06the companies as we gain confidence in the management
- 56:09teams. And I have to say with
- 56:10top-performing growth fund in the Cambridge and x and because
- 56:13we have an operating strategy. So that's why we were talking
- 56:15before, take like treasury. So we managed centrally Sorry
- 56:19for all the companies, their caps, their positions, their
- 56:21liabilities, we have our own money market fund.
- 56:23And so we go in and operationally, improve the
- 56:25company's and then steal them an answer.
- 56:27That's our strategy. Do you think we're going to see
- 56:29like, a lot of funds go away? Or I just I mean, it feels like
- 56:32if you didn't return a lot of money in 2021, some of these
- 56:36managers are going to be challenged and to fit into the
- 56:39SV B question. I guess it's like what are on
- 56:42limited partners heads right now?
- 56:43Because I mean, they just face this potentially like
- 56:46existential crisis for all Venture Investments.
- 56:49Do you think that's gonna breed a lot, more conservatism and a
- 56:52little bit more action from LPS, in terms of Shifting away from
- 56:56the Venture industry, I was just at the institutional limited
- 57:00partner, sociation on Oppa board meeting last week and we were
- 57:03talking about these issues. I would say, most of them, I
- 57:05have the LPS is who return Capital before things cracked
- 57:10whose best position they think, frankly during the Go-Go days
- 57:13last five years, that some managers behaved badly, raised
- 57:16funds that were too big, put them in the ground.
- 57:19How quickly did pay attention evaluation, and the last pieces,
- 57:22are a lot of them were very skeptical evaluation there
- 57:25looking at the disconnect between you, look at the NASDAQ,
- 57:28you look at the private markets and they scratch their heads
- 57:30going. Well, how is your fun?
- 57:31Not down and that level. So there's a little bit of
- 57:34Suspicion. I'd say the big takeaway is the,
- 57:36LPS are now concentrating and the better performing bigger
- 57:40managers and there's a lot of worry in the Venture space that
- 57:43some of the funds have just got too big and they're doing too
- 57:45many deals too fast or too little due diligence and so when
- 57:48you see some of these kind of Tackler blow-ups.
- 57:50You know, he's our tributing into a breakdown, the risk
- 57:53system, because VCS are really set up to go find great
- 57:57companies, develop ideas, find to go to market fit, maybe not
- 58:02do two, three, four hundred million dollar checks and
- 58:04companies at an early stage. And so, I think there's a view
- 58:07that, that it'll calm doubt, but, you know, from every crisis
- 58:10comes, good thing, we're actually launching our treasury
- 58:12fund and our treasury platform as a third-party service.
- 58:15Because I think this proves something that I think is, how
- 58:18companies can Do a better job managing their balance sheets
- 58:20and exposures I think there's a real business opportunity.
- 58:23Hmm. You're like selling software or
- 58:25what do you? Yeah.
- 58:26So we built software that connects all the banks so that
- 58:29you can move around your bank balances.
- 58:31You can see where you're getting certain level of interest rate
- 58:34versus not, you can look at, go even deeper.
- 58:37Look at everybody. I could tell you how much we had
- 58:39in each different sector. How many investment grade bonds?
- 58:41We had how many Treasures you had Etc, and then we can manage
- 58:44the interest rate exposure. So it's automating treasury
- 58:47because most companies before they go public, Don't even have
- 58:49a treasure. Hmm.
- 58:50If it's a start-stop, something to focus on, you just put the
- 58:53money in the bank and just don't think about it.
- 58:55And where I mean, that was it funny dynamic, in terms of like,
- 58:58if you want to say, oh, depositors shouldn't get bailed
- 59:01out because they're, like, sort of supposed to be Savvy.
- 59:03Customers, it's like so many of these startups.
- 59:05Don't even have CFOs, you know, they're, they're not necessarily
- 59:08the savviest Shoppers of like which banks to go to, you know,
- 59:13and to some degree they deferred to their investors.
- 59:15And it will be interesting to see how much blame like he is
- 59:19get from startups. In terms of the decisions they
- 59:22made it, I think it'll change. I think even at early stages,
- 59:25people will start to realize that Treasury and cash
- 59:28management is an incredibly important part of being a
- 59:29successful company, whether or not you were treasure.
- 59:31You don't need somebody who's like, making Market Beth, but
- 59:34there's subtle ways that you can put money to work.
- 59:36You can manage your cash cycle. Like you can create something
- 59:39very powerful in almost any business, get treasury piece,
- 59:42right? Yeah.
- 59:43My last question, I mean, is this going to be a hard year for
- 59:46the tech industry? I mean, how long does it?
- 59:49Downturn last. It feels like this really killed
- 59:52any hope. You know, I don't know, there
- 59:54would be a rebound and we just move on, from this, at least in
- 59:57my mind, January was great month of markets looked like it was
- 1:00:00coming back. The bankers have been talking to
- 1:00:02her seeing people dust off their previously filed S1.
- 1:00:06We've got two of them that we did it with.
- 1:00:07We're starting to get a sign and then this comes about and I'm
- 1:00:10very positive person by nature. But I'll continue my analysis.
- 1:00:14You know, you had the 2-year. Treasury was five, as I said,
- 1:00:17507 two weeks ago. So today it's at 425 typically,
- 1:00:21what happens when there's a rate rise, the second year of the
- 1:00:24rate, Rises hits harder, and the typical impact on GDP is a
- 1:00:29negative 2 and a half percent. So we are in the second year
- 1:00:33now. And right now gdps clocking in
- 1:00:35at about 1:00 or so, actually slightly lower about .95.
- 1:00:39So you could see this turning more to a hard Landing, I hate
- 1:00:41to say, I think it's going to be a tough year.
- 1:00:43This will be the tougher than two years last year was about
- 1:00:46valuations. This one will be about growth
- 1:00:48and funding. We'll get sweet.
- 1:00:50And if you're saying GDP is shrinking, then it's also
- 1:00:53effects like consumer spending and sort of the revenue for
- 1:00:56these company consumer defaults are creeping up.
- 1:00:59Obviously, mortgage rate things, there are things that are
- 1:01:01hitting, bassoon a hard to get high energy prices.
- 1:01:04You've got a consumer, you know, mortgage rates are going to,
- 1:01:06I've got quite a bit and so you've got a lot of pressure on
- 1:01:09the consumer and starting to play itself through.
- 1:01:11So I think watch one in the spring and summer travel season
- 1:01:14comes around. I think you'll see down flat
- 1:01:16from where it was last year, and that's the beginning.
- 1:01:19Of the signs of discretionary spending coming in and so you
- 1:01:22know the worst of tips come they raised rates so fast here, the
- 1:01:25shock to the body after. So many years of such a dull
- 1:01:29bosz, you know, stance and zero rates.
- 1:01:31It's going to take some time. LT.
- 1:01:35Thanks so much for coming on the show and explain it to everybody
- 1:01:37really appreciate our key. Doing a great job in for me
- 1:01:39people. So thanks for all your work.
- 1:01:41Thank you, that's our episode. Thanks so much for listening to
- 1:01:45my interview with Lawrence Tosi like comment, subscribe I'd go
- 1:01:49to newcomer dotco and follow along on the sub stack.
- 1:01:52Thanks so much to Tommy Heron or editor O'Reilly.
- 1:01:54Can sell my chief of staff. Young Chomsky for the music.
- 1:01:58I'm Eric newcomer. Thanks so much.
- 1:02:00See you next Tuesday? Goodbye.
- 1:02:03Goodbye.