Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [2015] Berkshire Hathaway Letter to Shareholders
Transcript
- 0:00Berkshire Hathaway, Inc to the shareholders of Berkshire
- 0:03Hathaway Incorporated. Berkshire's gain in net worth
- 0:06during 2015 was $15.4 billion, which increased the per share
- 0:11book value of both our Class A and Class B stock by 6.4%.
- 0:16Over the last 51 years, that is, since present management took
- 0:20over, per share book value has grown from $19.00 to $155,501, a
- 0:27rate of 19.2% compounded annually.
- 0:30During the first half of those years, Berkshire's net worth was
- 0:33roughly equal to the number that really counts the intrinsic
- 0:37value of the business. The similarity of the two
- 0:40figures existed then because most of our resources were
- 0:44deployed in marketable securities that were regularly
- 0:47revalued to their quoted prices list, the tax that would be
- 0:50incurred if they were to be sold, in Wall Street parlance.
- 0:54Our balance sheet was then in very large part marked to
- 0:57market. By the early 1990s, however, our
- 1:00focus had changed to the outright ownership of
- 1:03businesses, a shift that diminished the relevance of
- 1:06balance sheet figures. That disconnect occurred because
- 1:09the accounting rules that apply to controlled companies are
- 1:12materially different from those used in valuing marketable
- 1:15securities. The carrying value of fellow
- 1:18service we own is written down, but winners are never revalued
- 1:23upwards. We've had experience with both
- 1:25outcomes. I've made some dumb purchases
- 1:28and the amount I paid for the economic goodwill of those
- 1:31companies was later written off, a move that reduced Berkshire's
- 1:34book value. We've also had some winners, a
- 1:37few of them very big, but have not written those up by a penny.
- 1:40Over time, this asymmetrical accounting treatment with which
- 1:44we agree necessarily widens the gap between intrinsic value and
- 1:48book value. Today, the large and growing gun
- 1:51recorded gains at tour winners make it clear that Berkshire's
- 1:55intrinsic value far exceeds its book value.
- 1:58That's why we would be delighted to repurchase our shares should
- 2:01they sell as slow as 120% of book value.
- 2:04At that level, purchases would instantly and meaningfully
- 2:08increase per share intrinsic value for Berkshire's continuing
- 2:11shareholders. The unrecorded increase in the
- 2:14value of our owned businesses explains why Berkshire's
- 2:18aggregate market value gain tabulated on the facing page
- 2:21materially exceeds our book value gain.
- 2:24The two indicators vary erratically over short periods.
- 2:28Last year, for example, book value performance was superior
- 2:32over time, however, market value gains should continue their
- 2:35historical tendency to exceed gains in book value.
- 2:39All per share figures used in this report apply to Berkshire's
- 2:42A shares. Figures for the B shares are
- 2:4511,500 THF those shown for a three the year at Berkshire.
- 2:51Charlie M Unger, Berkshire Vice Chairman and my partner and I
- 2:55expect Berkshire's normalized earning power to increase every
- 2:58year. Actual year to year earnings, of
- 3:01course, will sometimes decline because of weakness in the USDOT
- 3:06economy or possibly because of insurance mega dash catastrophes
- 3:10that eye. In some years the normalized
- 3:12gains will be small, at other times they will be material.
- 3:16Last year was a good one. Here are the highlights.
- 3:18The most important development at Berkshire during 2015 was not
- 3:22financial, though it led to better earnings.
- 3:26After a poor performance in 2014, our BNSF railroad
- 3:30dramatically improved its service to customers last year.
- 3:34To attain that result, we invested about $5.8 billion
- 3:38during the year in capital expenditures, a sum far and away
- 3:42the record for any American railroad and nearly three times
- 3:45our annual depreciation charge. It was money well spent.
- 3:49BNSF moves about 17% of America's inner city freight
- 3:54measured by revenue, ton miles, weather transported by rail,
- 3:58truck, air, water or pipeline. In that respect, we are a strong
- 4:03number one among the seven large American railroads, two of which
- 4:07are Canadian based, carrying 45% more a ton miles of freight than
- 4:12our closest competitor. Consequently, our maintaining
- 4:15first class service is not only vital to our shippers welfare,
- 4:19but also important to the smooth functioning of the USDOT
- 4:23economy. For most American railroads,
- 4:252015 was a disappointing year. Aggregate ton miles fell and
- 4:30earnings weakened as well. BNSF however, maintained volume
- 4:35and pre tax income rose to a record $6.8 billion, a gain of
- 4:40$606 million from 2014. Matt Rose and Carlice, the
- 4:46managers of BNSF have my thanks and deserve yours.
- 4:50BNSF is the largest of our powerhouse 5A group that also
- 4:54includes Berkshire Hathaway Energy, Marmon, Lubriz OL and
- 4:59IMC. Combined, these companies are 5
- 5:02most profitable non insurance businesses earned $13.1 billion
- 5:07in 2015, an increase of $650 million / 2014.
- 5:13Of the five, only Berkshire Hathaway Energy, then earning
- 5:16$393 million, was owned by us in 2003.
- 5:21Subsequently, we purchased three of the other four on an all cash
- 5:25basis. In acquiring B NSF, however, we
- 5:29paid about 70% of the cost in cash and for the remainder
- 5:34issued Berkshire shares that increased the number outstanding
- 5:37by 6.1%. In other words, the $12.7
- 5:41billion gain in annual earnings delivered Berkshire by the five
- 5:45companies over the 12 year span has been accompanied by only
- 5:49minor dilution that satisfies our goal of not simply
- 5:53increasing earnings, but making sure we also increase per share
- 5:56results. Next year, I will be discussing
- 5:59the Powerhouse 6. The newcomer will be Precision
- 6:02Cast Parts Corp, PCC, a business that we purchased a month ago
- 6:06for more than $32 billion of cash.
- 6:09PCC fits perfectly into the Berkshire model and will
- 6:13substantially increase our normalized per share earning
- 6:15power. Under CEO Mark Donegan, PCC has
- 6:19become the world's premier supplier of aerospace
- 6:22components, most of them destined to be original
- 6:25equipment. Those spares are important to
- 6:27the company as well. Marks accomplishments remind me
- 6:30of the magic regularly performed by Jacob Harp Arizona at IMC,
- 6:35our remarkable Israeli manufacturer of cutting tools.
- 6:39The two men transform very ordinary raw materials into
- 6:42extraordinary products that are used by major manufacturers
- 6:46worldwide. Each is the Da Vinci of his
- 6:48craft. PCCs products, often delivered
- 6:51under multi year contracts, are key components in most large
- 6:55aircraft. Other industries are served as
- 6:58well by the company's 30,466 employees who work out of 162
- 7:04plants in 13 countries. In building his business, Mark
- 7:08has made many acquisitions and will make more.
- 7:11We look forward to having him deploy Berkshire's capital.
- 7:15Throughout this letter. All earnings are stated on a pre
- 7:18tax basis unless otherwise designated for a personal.
- 7:22Thank you. The PCC acquisition would not
- 7:25have happened without the input and assistance of our own Todd
- 7:28Combs who brought the company to my attention a few years ago and
- 7:32went on to educate me about both the business and Mark Thought
- 7:36Odd and Ted. We SC Hiller are primarily
- 7:38investment managers. They each handle about $9
- 7:41billion for us. Both of them cheerfully and ably
- 7:44add major value to Berkshire in other ways as well.
- 7:47Hiring these two was one of my best moves.
- 7:50With the PCC acquisition, Berkshire will own 101 four
- 7:54companies that would populate the Fortune 500 if they were
- 7:57stand alone businesses. Our 27% holding of Kraft Heinz
- 8:02is the one four. That leaves just under 98% of
- 8:05America's business giants that have yet to callus operators are
- 8:09standing by are many Dozens of smaller non insurance businesses
- 8:13earned $5.7 billion last year, up from $5.1 billion in 2014.
- 8:20Within this group, we have one company that last year earned
- 8:23more than $700 million to that earned between $400 million and
- 8:28$700 million, seven that earned between $250 million and $400
- 8:34million, six that earned between $100 million and $250 million,
- 8:39and 11 that earned between $50 million and $100 million.
- 8:44We love them all. This collection of businesses
- 8:47will expand both in number and earnings as the years go by.
- 8:51When you hear talk about America's crumbling
- 8:53infrastructure, rest assured that they're not talking about
- 8:56Berkshire. We invested $16 billion in
- 8:59property, plant and equipment last year, a full 86% of it
- 9:04deployed in the United States. It told you earlier about the
- 9:08NSF's record capital expenditures in 2015.
- 9:12At the end of every year, our railroads physical facilities
- 9:16will be improved from those existing 12 months earlier.
- 9:19Berkshire Hathaway Energy B he is a similar story.
- 9:23That company has invested $16 billion in renewables and now
- 9:27owns 7% of the country's wind generation and 6% of its solar
- 9:32generation. Indeed, the 4423 megawatts of
- 9:37wind generation owned and operated by our regulated
- 9:40utilities is 6 times the generation of the runner up
- 9:44utility. We're not done.
- 9:45Last year he made major commitments to the future
- 9:48development of renewables in support of the Paris Climate
- 9:52Change Conference. Our fulfilling those promises
- 9:54will make great sense both for the environment and for
- 9:58Berkshires economics. Berkshires huge and growing
- 10:01insurance operation again operated at an underwriting
- 10:04profit in 2015 that makes 13 years in a row and increased its
- 10:09float during those years. Our float money that doesn't
- 10:12belong to us, but that we can invest for.
- 10:15Berkshire's benefit grew from $41 billion to $88 billion,
- 10:21though neither that gain nor the size of our float is reflected
- 10:24in Berkshire's earnings. Float generates significant
- 10:28investment income because of the assets it allows us to hold.
- 10:31Meanwhile, our underwriting profit totaled $26 billion
- 10:35during the 13 year period, including $1.8 billion earned in
- 10:402015. Without a doubt, Berkshire's
- 10:43largest unrecorded wealth lies in its insurance business.
- 10:47We've spent 48 years building this multifaceted operation and
- 10:51it can't be replicated. While Charlie and I search for
- 10:54new businesses to buy, our many subsidiaries are regularly
- 10:58making Bolt on acquisitions. Last year, we contracted for 29
- 11:02Bolt on S scheduled to cost $634 million in aggregate.
- 11:08The cost of these purchases ranged from $300,000 to $143
- 11:13million. Charlie and I encourage bolt on
- 11:16S if they are sensibly priced. Most deals offered us most
- 11:20definitely aren't. These purchases deploy capital
- 11:23and operations that fit with our existing businesses and that
- 11:26will be managed by our core of expert managers.
- 11:30That means no additional work for us yet more earnings for
- 11:33Berkshire combination we find highly appealing.
- 11:36We will make many dozens of bolt on deals in future years. 5 Our
- 11:41Heinz partnership with Jorge Paolo le Man, Alex Behring and
- 11:45Bernardo he ES more than doubled its size last year by merging
- 11:49with Kraft. Before this transaction, we
- 11:52owned about 53% of Heinz at a cost of $4.25 billion.
- 11:58Now we own 325.4 million shares of Kraft Heinz, about 27% that
- 12:03cost us $9.8 billion. The new company has annual sales
- 12:08of $27 billion and and can supply you Heinz ketchup or
- 12:12mustard Togo with your Oscar Mayer hot dogs that come from
- 12:16the craft side. Add a Coke and you will be
- 12:18enjoying my favorite meal that we will have the Oscar Mayer
- 12:21Weiner mobile at the annual meeting.
- 12:23Bring your kids. Though we sold no Kraft Heinz
- 12:26shares, GAAP generally accepted accounting principles required
- 12:30us to record a $6.8 billion write up of our investment upon
- 12:35completion of the merger. That leaves us with our Kraft
- 12:38Heinz holding carried on our balance sheet at a value many
- 12:41billions above our cost and many billions below its market value,
- 12:46an outcome only an accountant could love.
- 12:48Berkshire also owns Kraft Heinz preferred shares that pay us
- 12:52$720 million annually and are carried at 7.7 dollars billion
- 12:57on our balance sheet. That holding will almost
- 13:00certainly be redeemed for $8.32 billion in June, the earliest
- 13:05date allowed under the preferred terms.
- 13:08That will be good news for Kraft Heinz and bad news for
- 13:11Berkshire. Jorge Paolo and his associates
- 13:14could not be better partners. We share with them a passion to
- 13:17buy, build and hold large businesses that satisfy basic
- 13:21needs and desires. We follow different paths,
- 13:24however, in pursuing this goal. Their method at which they have
- 13:28been extraordinarily successful is to buy companies that offer
- 13:32it opportunity for eliminating many unnecessary costs and then
- 13:36very prompt Lido make the moves that will get the job done.
- 13:40Their actions significantly boost productivity, the all
- 13:43important factor in America's economic growth over the past
- 13:47240 years. Without more output of desired
- 13:50goods and services per working our that's the measure of
- 13:53productivity, gains in economy inevitably stagnates at much of
- 13:58corporate America, truly major gains in productivity are
- 14:02possible, a fact offering opportunities to Jorge Paolo and
- 14:06his associates at Berkshire. We too crave efficiency and
- 14:11detest bureaucracy to achieve our goals.
- 14:14However, we follow an approach emphasizing avoidance of bloat
- 14:18buying businesses such as PCC that have long been run by cost
- 14:22conscious and efficient managers.
- 14:25After the purchase, our role is simply to create an environment
- 14:28in which these CEOs and their eventual successors, who
- 14:32typically are like minded, can maximize both their managerial
- 14:36effectiveness and the pleasure they derive from their jobs.
- 14:39With this hands off style. I am heating a well known mung
- 14:43RSM. If you want to guarantee
- 14:45yourself a lifetime of misery, be sure to marry someone with
- 14:49the intent of changing their behavior.
- 14:51We will continue to operate with extreme, indeed almost unheard
- 14:55off decentralization at Berkshire, but we will also look
- 14:59for opportunities to partner with Jorge Paulo, either as a
- 15:02financing partner, as was the case when his group purchased
- 15:06Tim horton's, or as a combined equity and financing partner, as
- 15:10at Heinz. We also may occasionally partner
- 15:13with others, as we have successfully done at Burkadia.
- 15:16Berkshire, however, will join only with partners, making
- 15:20friendly acquisitions to be sure, certain hostile offers are
- 15:24justified. Some CEOs forget that it is
- 15:26shareholders for whom they should be working, while other
- 15:30managers are woefully inept. In either case, directors may be
- 15:34blind to the problem or simply reluctant to make the change
- 15:38required. That's when new faces are
- 15:40needed. We though will leave these
- 15:42opportunities for others. At Berkshire, we go only where
- 15:46we are welcome. 6 Berkshire increased its ownership interest
- 15:50last year in each of its BIG4 investments, American Express,
- 15:55Coca-Cola, IBM and Wells Fargo. We purchased additional shares
- 15:59of IBM increasing our ownership to 8.4% versus 7.8% at year in
- 16:062014 and Wells Fargo going to 9.8% from 9.4%.
- 16:11At the other two companies, Coca-Cola and American Express
- 16:15stock repurchase S raised our percentage ownership.
- 16:18Our equity in Coca-Cola grew from 9.2% to 9.3% and our
- 16:24interest in American Express increased from 14.8% to 15.6%.
- 16:30In case you think these seemingly small changes aren't
- 16:33important, consider this math for the for companies.
- 16:36In aggregate, each increase of one percentage point in our
- 16:40ownership raises Berkshires portion of their annual earnings
- 16:43by about $500 million. These four invest EES possess
- 16:48excellent businesses and are run by managers who are both
- 16:51talented and shareholder oriented.
- 16:54Their returns on tangible equity range from excellent to
- 16:57staggering. At Berkshire, we much prefer
- 17:00owning an on controlling but substantial portion of a
- 17:03wonderful company to owning 100% off ASOSO business.
- 17:08It's better to have a partial interest in the Hope Diamond
- 17:10than to own all of a rhinestone. If Berkshire's year end holdings
- 17:14are used as the marker, our portion of the Big Four's 2015
- 17:18earnings amounted to $4.7 billion.
- 17:22In the earnings we report to you, however, we include only
- 17:26the dividends. They pay us about $1.8 billion
- 17:29last year. But make no mistake, the nearly
- 17:32$3 billion of these companies, the earnings we don't report are
- 17:36every bit as valuable to us as the portion Berkshire records.
- 17:40The earnings are invest EES retain are often used for
- 17:43repurchase S of their own stock, a move that increases
- 17:47Berkshire's share of future earnings without requiring us to
- 17:50lay out a dime. The retained earnings of these
- 17:53companies also fund business opportunities that usually turn
- 17:56out to be advantageous. All that leads us to expect that
- 18:00the per share earnings of these four invest EES in aggregate
- 18:04will grow substantially over time.
- 18:06If gains do indeed materialize, dividends to Berkshire will
- 18:10increase and so too will our unrealized capital gains.
- 18:15Our flexibility in capital allocation, our willingness to
- 18:19invest large sums passively in non controlled businesses gives
- 18:23us a significant edge over companies that limit themselves
- 18:26to acquisitions they will operate.
- 18:29Woody Allen once explained that the advantage of being bisexual
- 18:32is that it double s your chance of finding a date on Saturday
- 18:36night. In like manner, well not exactly
- 18:38like manner, our appetite for either operating businesses or
- 18:42passive investments double s our chances of finding sensible uses
- 18:46for Berkshires endless gusher of cash.
- 18:49Beyond that, having a huge portfolio of marketable
- 18:51securities gives us a stockpile of funds that can be tapped when
- 18:55an elephant sized acquisition is offered to us.
- 18:59It's an election year and candidates can't stop speaking
- 19:02about our country's problems, which of course only they can
- 19:05solve. As a result of this negative
- 19:07drum beat, many Americans know believe that their children will
- 19:11not live as well as they themselves do.
- 19:13That view is dead wrong. The babies being born in America
- 19:17today are the luckiest crop in history.
- 19:19American GDP per capita is now about $56,000.
- 19:24As I mentioned last year. That in real terms is a
- 19:27staggering 6 times the amount in 1930, the year I was born.
- 19:31A leap far beyond the wildest dreams of my parents.
- 19:34Or they're contemporaries. You, yes, citizens, are not
- 19:39intrinsically more intelligent today, nor do they work harder
- 19:42than did Americans in 1930. Rather, they work far more
- 19:47efficiently and thereby produce far more.
- 19:49This all powerful trend is certain to continue.
- 19:53America's economic magic remains alive and well.
- 19:56Some commentators bemoan our current 2% per year growth in
- 20:00real GDP, and yes, we would all like to see a higher rate.
- 20:04But let's do some simple math using the much lamented 2%
- 20:08figure. That rate, we will see, delivers
- 20:11astounding gains. 7 America's population is growing about .8%
- 20:16per year, .5% from births minus deaths, and .3% from net.
- 20:21Migration. Thus 2% of overall growth
- 20:24produces about 1.2% of per capita growth.
- 20:28That may not sound impressive, but in a single generation of,
- 20:31say, 25 years, that rate of growth leads to a gain of 34.4%
- 20:37in real GDP per capita. Compounding's effects produce
- 20:41the excess over the percentage that would result by simply
- 20:44multiplying 25 by 1.2%. In turn, that 34.4% gain will
- 20:50produce a staggering $19,000 increase in real GDP per capita
- 20:55for the next generation. Were that to be distributed
- 20:58equally, the gain would be $76,000 annually for a family of
- 21:03four. Today's politicians need not
- 21:05shed tears for tomorrow's children.
- 21:08Indeed, most of today's children are doing well.
- 21:11All families in my upper middle class neighborhood regularly
- 21:14enjoy a living standard better than that achieved by John D
- 21:18Rockefeller, senior at the time of my birth.
- 21:20His unparalleled fortune couldn't by what we now take for
- 21:24granted. Whether the field is, to name
- 21:26just a few, transportation, entertainment, communication or
- 21:30medical services, Rockefeller certainly had power and fame.
- 21:35He could not, however. I live as well as my neighbors
- 21:38now do. Though the pie to be shared by
- 21:40the next generation will be far larger than today's, how it will
- 21:44be divided will remain fiercely contentious.
- 21:47Just as is now the case, there will be struggles for the
- 21:50increased output of goods and services between those people in
- 21:54their productive years in retirees, between the healthy
- 21:57and the infirm, between the inheritors and the Horatio Alger
- 22:01S, between investors and workers, and in particular,
- 22:05between those with talents that are valued highly by the
- 22:08marketplace and the equally decent, hardworking Americans
- 22:11who lack the skills the market prizes.
- 22:14Clashes of that sort have forever been with us and will
- 22:17forever continue. Congress will be the
- 22:20battlefield. Money and votes will be the
- 22:22weapons. Lobbying will remain a growth
- 22:24industry. The good news, however, is that
- 22:27even members of the losing sides will almost certainly enjoy, as
- 22:31they should, far more goods and services in the future than they
- 22:34have in the past. The quality of their increased
- 22:37bounty will also dramatically improve.
- 22:40Nothing rivals the market system in producing what people want,
- 22:43nor even more so in delivering what people don't yet know they
- 22:47want. My parents, when young, could
- 22:50not envision a television set, nor did I, in my 50s, think I
- 22:55needed a personal computer. Both products, once people saw
- 22:58what they could do, quickly revolutionized their lives.
- 23:02I now spend 10 hours a week playing Bridge online and as I
- 23:05write this letter, searches in valuable tone that I am not
- 23:09ready for Tinder. However, for 240 years it's been
- 23:12a terrible mistake to bet against America, and now is no
- 23:16time to start. America's golden goose of
- 23:19commerce and innovation will continue to lay more and larger
- 23:23eggs. America's Social Security
- 23:25promises will be honored and perhaps made more generous.
- 23:29And yes, America's kids will live far better than their
- 23:33parents did. Considering this favorable
- 23:35tailwind, Berkshire and to be sure a great many other
- 23:39businesses will almost certainly prosper.
- 23:42The managers who succeed Charlie and me will build Berkshire's
- 23:46per share intrinsic value by following our simple blueprint
- 23:49of one, constantly improving the basic earning power of our many
- 23:54subsidiaries, 2, further increasing their earnings
- 23:57through bolt on acquisitions, 3, benefiting from the growth of
- 24:01our invest EES for repurchasing Berkshire shares when they are
- 24:04available at a meaningful discount from intrinsic value
- 24:08and five, making an occasional large acquisition.
- 24:11Management will also try to maximize results for you by
- 24:14rarely, if ever, issuing Berkshire shares. 8 Intrinsic
- 24:19Business Value As much as Charlie and I talk about
- 24:22intrinsic business value, we cannot tell you precisely what
- 24:25that number is for Berkshire Shares, nor, in fact, for any
- 24:29other stock. It is possible, however, to make
- 24:32a sensible estimate. In our 2010 annual report we
- 24:36laid out the three elements, one of them qualitative, that we
- 24:39believe are the keys to an estimation of Berkshire's
- 24:43intrinsic value. That discussion is reproduced in
- 24:46full on pages 113 to 114. Here is an update of the two
- 24:51quantitative factors. In 2015, our per share cash and
- 24:55investments increased 8.3% to $159,794.00 with our Kraft Heinz
- 25:03shares stated at market value and earnings from our many
- 25:06businesses including insurance underwriting income increased
- 25:102.1% to $12,304.00 per share. We exclude in the second factor
- 25:16the dividends and interest from the investments we hold because
- 25:20including them would produce a double counting of value.
- 25:23In arriving at our earnings figure, we deduct all corporate
- 25:27overhead, interest, depreciation, amortization and
- 25:31minority interests. Income taxes though are not
- 25:34deducted, that is, the earnings are pre tax.
- 25:37I used the italics in the paragraph above because we are
- 25:40for the first time including insurance underwriting income
- 25:44and business earnings. We did not do that when we
- 25:46initially introduced Berkshire's two quantitative pillars of
- 25:50valuation because our insurance results were then heavily
- 25:53influenced by catastrophe coverage S.
- 25:56If the wind didn't blow and the earth didn't shake, we made
- 25:59large profits. But a meta catastrophe would
- 26:02produce red ink in order to be conservative.
- 26:05Then in stating our business earnings, we consistently
- 26:08assumed that underwriting would break even over time and ignored
- 26:12any of its gains or losses in our annual calculation of the
- 26:16second factor of value. Today, our insurance results are
- 26:19likely to be more stable than was the case a decade or two ago
- 26:23because we have to emphasize catastrophe coverages and
- 26:27greatly expanded our bread and butter lines of business.
- 26:30Last year, our underwriting income contributed $1118 per
- 26:35share to the $12,304.00 per share of earnings referenced in
- 26:40the second paragraph of this section.
- 26:42Over the past decade, annual underwriting income has averaged
- 26:46$1434 per share and we anticipate being profitable in
- 26:51most years. You should recognize however,
- 26:55that underwriting in any given year could will be in
- 26:58profitable, perhaps substantially so.
- 27:00Since 1970, our per share investments have increased at a
- 27:04rate of 18.9% compounded annually an hour.
- 27:08Earnings including the underwriting results in both the
- 27:11initial and terminal year have grown at a 23.7% clip.
- 27:16It is no coincidence that the price of Berkshire stock over
- 27:19the ensuing 45 years has increased data rate very similar
- 27:24to that of there are two measures of value.
- 27:26Charlie and I like to see gains in both sectors, but our main
- 27:30goal is to build operating earnings.
- 27:32Now let's examine the four major sectors of our operations.
- 27:36Each has vastly different balance sheet and income
- 27:39characteristics from the others. So we'll present them as four
- 27:43separate businesses, which is how Charlie and I view them.
- 27:46Though there are important and enduring economic advantages to
- 27:49having them all under one roof. Our intent is to provide you
- 27:54with the information we would wish to have.
- 27:56I4 positions were reversed with you being the reporting manager
- 28:00and we, the absentee shareholders.
- 28:02Don't get excited. This is not a switch.
- 28:04We are considering insurance. Let's look first at insurance.
- 28:08The Property Casualty Peak branch of that industry has been
- 28:11the engine that has propelled our expansion since 1967 when we
- 28:16acquired National Indemnity and its sister company, National
- 28:20Fire and Marine for $8.6 million.
- 28:24Today, National Indemnity is the largest property casualty
- 28:27company in the world as measured by net worth.
- 28:31Moreover, its intrinsic value is far in excess of the value at
- 28:34which it is carried on our books. 91 reason we were
- 28:38attracted to the PC business was its financial characteristics.
- 28:42PC insurers receive premiums upfront and pay claims later.
- 28:47In extreme cases, such as those arising from certain workers
- 28:50compensation accidents, payments can stretch over many decades.
- 28:55This collect now pay later model leaves PC companies holding
- 28:59large sums money we call float hat will eventually go to
- 29:02others. Meanwhile, insurers get to
- 29:04invest this float for their own benefit.
- 29:07Though individual policies and claims come and go, the amount
- 29:10of float an insurer holds usually remains fairly stable in
- 29:14relation to premium volume. Consequently, as our business
- 29:18grows, so does our float and how we have grown, as the following
- 29:22table shows. Year flaught and millions 1970
- 29:27dollars 3919 Eighty 237 1991 thousand 632 Two thousand 27,871
- 29:392010 65,832 2015 87,722 further gains and float will be tough to
- 29:48achieve. On the plus side, GEICO and
- 29:50several of our specialized operations are almost certain to
- 29:54grow at a good clip. National Indemnity's reinsurance
- 29:57division however is party to a number of runoff contracts whose
- 30:02float drifts downward. If we do in time experience a
- 30:05decline in float, it will be very gradual.
- 30:08At the outside no more than 3% in any year.
- 30:11The nature of our insurance contracts is such that we can
- 30:15never be subject to immediate or near term demands for sums that
- 30:19are of significance to our cash resources.
- 30:21This structure is by design and is a key component in the
- 30:25strength of Berkshire's economic fortress.
- 30:28It will never be compromised. If our premiums exceed the total
- 30:32of our expenses and eventual losses, we register an
- 30:36underwriting profit that adds to the investment income our flow
- 30:39produces. When such a profit is earned, we
- 30:42enjoy the use of free money and better yet, get paid for holding
- 30:46it. Unfortunately, the wish of all
- 30:49insurers to achieve this happy result creates intense
- 30:52competition, so vigorous indeed that it sometimes causes the PC
- 30:57industry as a whole to operate at a significant underwriting
- 31:00loss. This loss, in effect, is what
- 31:03the industry pays to hold its float.
- 31:05Competitive dynamics almost guarantee that the insurance the
- 31:09industry, despite the float income all its companies enjoy,
- 31:13will continue its dismal record of earning subnormal returns on
- 31:17tangible net worth as compared to other American businesses.
- 31:20The prolonged period of low interest rates the world is now
- 31:24dealing with also virtually guarantees that earnings on
- 31:27float will steadily decrease for many years to come, thereby
- 31:31exacerbating the profit problems of insurers.
- 31:34It's a good bet that industry results over the next 10 years
- 31:38will fall short of those recorded in the past decade,
- 31:41particularly for those companies that specialize in reinsurance.
- 31:45As noted early in this report, Berkshire has now operated at an
- 31:49underwriting profit for 13 consecutive years, our pre tax
- 31:53gain for the period having totaled $26.2 billion.
- 31:57That's no accident. Disciplined risk evaluation is
- 32:01the daily focus of all of our insurance managers, who know
- 32:04that while float is valuable, its benefits can be drowned by
- 32:08poor underwriting results. All insurers give that message
- 32:11lip service. At Berkshire it is a religion,
- 32:14Old Testament style. So how does our float affect
- 32:17intrinsic value? When Berkshire's book value is
- 32:20calculated, the full amount of our float is deducted as a
- 32:24liability, just as if we had to pay it out tomorrow and could
- 32:27not replenish it. But to think of if float is
- 32:30strictly a liability is incorrect.
- 32:33It should instead be viewed as a revolving fund.
- 32:36Daily we pay old claims and related expenses a huge $24.5
- 32:41billion to more than 6,000,000 claimants in 2015.
- 32:45And that reduces float. Just ask.
- 32:47Surely we each day write new business that will soon generate
- 32:51its own claims, a dinto float 10 If our revolving float is both
- 32:56cost less and long enduring, which I believe it will be, the
- 33:00true value of this liability is dramatically less than the
- 33:04accounting liability owing $1.00.
- 33:06That in effect will never leave the premises because new
- 33:09business is almost certain to deliver a substitutious world
- 33:13different from owing $1.00 that will go out the door tomorrow
- 33:17and not be replaced. The two types of liabilities
- 33:20however are treated as equals under GAAP.
- 33:23A partial offset to this overstated liability is a 15
- 33:27point $5 billion goodwill asset that we incurred in buying our
- 33:32insurance companies and that increases book value.
- 33:35In very large part, this goodwill represents the price we
- 33:38paid for the float generating capabilities of our insurance
- 33:41operations. The cost of the goodwill,
- 33:44however, has no bearing on its true value.
- 33:47For example, if an insurance company sustains large and
- 33:51prolonged underwriting losses, any goodwill asset carried on
- 33:55the books should be deemed valueless, whatever its original
- 33:58cost. Fortunately, that does not
- 34:00describe Berkshire. Charlie and I believe the true
- 34:03economic value of our insurance goodwill, What we would happily
- 34:07pay for float of similar quality were we to purchase an insurance
- 34:12operation possessing it'll be far in excess of its historic
- 34:15carrying value. Indeed, almost the entire $15.5
- 34:19billion we carry for goodwill in our insurance business was
- 34:23already on our books in 2000, yet we subsequently tripled our
- 34:27float. It's value today is one reason,
- 34:30a huge reason, why we believe Berkshire's intrinsic business
- 34:34value substantially exceeds its book value.
- 34:37Berkshire's attractive insurance economics exist only because we
- 34:41have some terrific managers running disciplined operations
- 34:44that possess hard to replicate business models.
- 34:47Let me tell you about the major units.
- 34:49First by float size is the Berkshire Hathaway Reinsurance
- 34:52Group, managed by AJ at Jane AJ. It insures risks that no one
- 34:57else has the desire or the capital to take on.
- 35:00His operation combines capacity, speed, decisiveness and, most
- 35:05important, brains in a manner unique in the insurance
- 35:08business. Yet he never exposes Berkshire
- 35:11to risks that are inappropriate in relation to our resources.
- 35:15Indeed, Berkshire is far more conservative in avoiding risk
- 35:19than most large insurers. For example, if the insurance
- 35:23industry should experience a $250 billion loss from some mega
- 35:27catastrophe, a loss about triple anything it has ever
- 35:30experienced, Berkshire as a whole would likely record a
- 35:33significant profit for the year because of its many streams of
- 35:37earnings. We would also remain awash in
- 35:40cash and be looking for large opportunities to write business
- 35:43in an insurance market that might well be in disarray.
- 35:47Meanwhile, other major insurers and reinsurers would be swimming
- 35:51in red ink if not facing insolvency.
- 35:54When AJ entered Berkshire's office on a Saturday in 1986, he
- 35:58did not have a day's experience in the insurance business.
- 36:02Nevertheless, Mike Goldberg, then our Manager of Insurance,
- 36:05handed him the keys to our reinsurance business.
- 36:09With that move, Mike achieved sainthood.
- 36:11Since then AJ it has created 10s of billions of value for
- 36:15Berkshire shareholders. We have another reinsurance
- 36:18powerhouse in General Re, managed by T Admont Ross.
- 36:22At bottom, a sound insurance operation needs to adhere to 4
- 36:26disciplines. It must one, understand all
- 36:29exposures that might cause a policy to incur losses, to
- 36:33conservatively assess the likelihood of any exposure
- 36:36actually causing a loss, and the probable cost if it does.
- 36:40Three, set of premium that on average will deliver a profit
- 36:43after both prospective loss costs and operating expenses are
- 36:47covered, and four, be willing to walk away if the appropriate
- 36:51premium can't be obtained. 11 Many insurers pass the first
- 36:55three tests and flunk the 4th. They simply can't turn their
- 36:59back on business that is being eagerly written by their
- 37:02competitors. That old line, the other guy is
- 37:05doing it, so we must as well. Spells trouble in any business,
- 37:09but in none more so than insurance.
- 37:11TAT has observed all four of the insurance commandments and it
- 37:15shows in his results. General Residential huge float
- 37:19has been considerably better than cost free under his
- 37:21leadership and we expect that on average to continue.
- 37:25We are particularly enthusiastic about General Residential
- 37:29international life reinsurance business, which has grown
- 37:32consistently and profitably since we acquired the company in
- 37:361998. It can be remembered that soon
- 37:39after we purchased General Rhee, it was beset by problems that
- 37:42cost commentators and me as well briefly to believe I had made a
- 37:47huge mistake. That day is long gone.
- 37:49General Rhee is now a gem. Finally, there is GEICO, the
- 37:53insurer on which I cut my teeth 65 years ago.
- 37:57GEICO is managed by Tony Nicely, who joined the company at 18 and
- 38:01completed 54 years of service in 2015.
- 38:05Tony became CEO in 1993 and since then the company has been
- 38:10flying. There is no better manager than
- 38:12Tony. In the 40 years that I've known
- 38:14him, his every action has made great sense.
- 38:17When I was first introduced to GEICO in January 1951, I was
- 38:21blown away by the huge cost advantage the company enjoyed
- 38:25compared to the expenses borne by the giants of the industry.
- 38:28It was clear to me that GEICO would succeed because it
- 38:31deserved to succeed. No one likes to buy auto
- 38:34insurance. Almost everyone, though, likes
- 38:37to drive. The insurance consequently
- 38:39needed is a major expenditure for most families.
- 38:42Savings matter to the manned only a low cost operation can
- 38:46deliver these. Indeed, at least 40% of the
- 38:50people reading this letter can save money by ensuring with
- 38:53GEICO. So stop reading right now and go
- 38:56to geico.com or call 800 three 6-8 2734 Geico's cost advantage
- 39:02is the factor that has enabled the company to gobble up market
- 39:06share year after year. We ended 2015 with 11.4% of the
- 39:11market, compared to 2.5% in 1995 when Berkshire acquired control
- 39:16of GEICO. The company's slow costs create
- 39:19a moten enduring one that competitors are unable to cross.
- 39:23All the while our gecko never tires of telling Americans how
- 39:27GEICO can save them important money.
- 39:29I love hearing the little guy deliver his message. 15 minutes
- 39:33could save you 15% or more on car insurance.
- 39:37Of course, there's always a grouch in the crowd.
- 39:40One of my friends says he is glad that only a few animals can
- 39:43talk, since the ones that do speak seem unable to discuss any
- 39:47subject but insurance. In addition to our three major
- 39:51insurance operations, we own a group of smaller companies that
- 39:54primarily write commercial coverage, as in aggregate, these
- 39:58companies are a large, growing and valuable operation that
- 40:02consistently delivers an underwriting profit, usually
- 40:05much better than that reported by their competitors.
- 40:08Indeed. Over the past 13 years, this
- 40:11group has earned $4 billion from underwriting about 13% of its
- 40:15premium volume, while increasing its float from $943,000,000 to
- 40:21$9.9 billion. Less than three years ago, we
- 40:25formed Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance BHSI, which
- 40:29we include in this group. Our first decision was to put
- 40:32Peter Eastwood in charge. That move was a home run.
- 40:36The HSI has already developed $1 billion of annual premium volume
- 40:41and under Peters direction is destined to become one of the
- 40:45world's leading PC insurers. 12th Hay race.
- 40:48Our cap of underwriting earnings and float by division.
- 40:52Underwriting profit year and float in millions.
- 40:55Insurance operations 2015, 2014, 2015, 2014.
- 41:02BH Reinsurance 421 Dollars 606 Dollars 44,108 Dollars $42,454
- 41:12General Rhee 132 Two Hundred 771856019280 GEICO
- 41:2246011591514813569 Other Primary 824626 990686 Eighteen 1837
- 41:38Dollars 2668 Dollars 87,722 Dollars $83,921.00 Berkshire's
- 41:48great managers, premier financial strength and a variety
- 41:52of business models protected by wide moats amount to something
- 41:55unique in the insurance world. This assemblage of strengths is
- 41:59a huge asset for Berkshire shareholders that will only get
- 42:03more valuable with time. Regulated capital intensive
- 42:06businesses We have two major operations, be NSF and Be He,
- 42:11that share important characteristics distinguishing
- 42:14them from our other businesses. Consequently, we assigned them
- 42:18their own section in this letter and split out their combined
- 42:21financial statistics in our GAAP balance sheet and income
- 42:24statement. Together they last year
- 42:26accounted for 37% of Berkshire's after tax operating earnings.
- 42:31A key characteristic of both companies is their huge
- 42:34investment in very long lived regulated assets, with these
- 42:39partially funded by large amounts of long term debt that
- 42:42is not guaranteed by Berkshire. Our credit is in fact not needed
- 42:46because each company has earning power that even under terrible
- 42:50economic conditions would far exceed its interest
- 42:53requirements. Last year, for example, in a
- 42:56disappointing year for railroads, BNSFS interest
- 42:59coverage was more than 8 to 1 dot.
- 43:02Our definition of coverage is the ratio of earnings before
- 43:05interest and taxes to interest. Note bit DA interest, a commonly
- 43:10used measure we view as seriously flawed.
- 43:13At Behe, meanwhile, two factors ensure the company's ability to
- 43:17service its debt under all circumstances.
- 43:19ATB NSF Price comparisons between major railroads are far
- 43:23more difficult to make because of significant differences in
- 43:27both their mix of cargo and the average distance it is carried
- 43:31to supply. A very crude measure.
- 43:33However, our revenue per dawn mile was just under 3 last year
- 43:37while shipping costs for customers of the other four
- 43:40major US based railroads were at least 40% higher ranging from
- 43:454.2 to 5.3. Both B he and BNSF have been
- 43:49leaders in pursuing planet friendly technology in wind
- 43:53generation. No state comes close to Iowa
- 43:56where last year MW hours we generated from wind equaled 47%
- 44:01of all MW hours sold to our retail customers.
- 44:05Additional wind projects to which we are committed will take
- 44:07that figure to 58% in 2017. BNSF, like other Class 1
- 44:14railroads, uses only a single gallon of diesel fuel to move a
- 44:18ton of freight almost 500 miles. That makes the railroads 4 times
- 44:23as fuel efficient as trucks. Furthermore, railroads alleviate
- 44:27Hwy. congestion in the taxpayer funded maintenance expenditures
- 44:31that come with heavier traffic in a major way.
- 44:34Here are the key figures for B HE and BNSF.
- 44:37Berkshire Hathaway Energy 89.9% owned earnings in millions.
- 44:43Our income and expense data conforming to GAP is on page 38.
- 44:47In contrast, the operating expense figures above are non
- 44:51GAAP because they exclude some purchase accounting items,
- 44:54primarily the amortization of certain intangible assets.
- 44:58We present the data in this manner because Charlie and I
- 45:01believe the adjusted numbers more accurately reflect the true
- 45:05economic expenses and profits of the businesses aggregated in the
- 45:09table than do GAAP figures. I want to explain all of the
- 45:13adjustments. Some are tiny and arcane, but
- 45:15serious investors should understand the disparate nature
- 45:18of intangible assets. Some truly deplete in value over
- 45:22time, while others in no way lose value.
- 45:25For software, as a big example, amortization charges are very
- 45:29real expenses. Conversely, the concept of
- 45:32recording charges against other intangibles, such as customer
- 45:36relationships, arises from purchase accounting rules and
- 45:39clearly does not reflect economic reality.
- 45:42Gap accounting draws no distinction between the two
- 45:45types of charges. Both that is are recorded as
- 45:49expenses when earnings are calculated, even though from an
- 45:52investor's viewpoint they could not differ more. 15 in the gap
- 45:57compliant figures we show on page 38, amortization charges of
- 46:01$1.1 billion have been deducted as expenses.
- 46:05We would call about 20% of these real, the rest not.
- 46:09The non real charges once non existent at Berkshire have
- 46:13become significant because of the many acquisitions we have
- 46:16made. Non real amortization charges
- 46:19are likely to climb further as we acquire more companies.
- 46:22The table on page 55 gives you the current status of our
- 46:26intangible assets as calculated by GAAP.
- 46:29We now have $6.8 billion left of a mortise able intangibles, of
- 46:34which $4.1 billion will be expense D over the next five
- 46:38years. Eventually, of course, every
- 46:41dollar of these assets will be charged off.
- 46:43When that happens, reported earnings increase.
- 46:46Even if true earnings are flat. That MY gift to my successor.
- 46:50I suggest that you ignore a portion of gap amortization
- 46:53costs, but it is with some trepidation that I do that
- 46:57knowing that it has become common for managers to tell
- 46:59their owners to ignore certain expense items that are all to
- 47:03real dot Stock based compensation is the most
- 47:05egregious example. The very name says it all,
- 47:09Compensation. If compensation isn't an
- 47:11expense, what is it? And if real and recurring
- 47:14expenses don't belong in the calculation of earnings, where
- 47:18in the world do they belong? Wall Street analysts often play
- 47:22their part in this charade. 2 parroting the phony
- 47:25compensation, ignoring earnings figures fed them by management S
- 47:29Maybe the offending analysts don't know any better.
- 47:32Or maybe they fear losing access to management.
- 47:35Or maybe they are cynical, telling themselves that since
- 47:38everyone else is playing the game, why shouldn't they go
- 47:41along with it? Whatever their reasoning, these
- 47:44analysts are guilty of propagating misleading numbers
- 47:47that can deceive investors. Depreciation charges area more
- 47:51complicated subject, but are almost always true costs.
- 47:55Certainly they are at Berkshire. I wish we could keep our
- 47:58businesses competitive while spending less than our
- 48:01depreciation charge, but in 51 years I've yet to figure out how
- 48:05to do so. Indeed, the depreciation charge
- 48:08we record in our railroad business falls far short of the
- 48:11capital outlays needed to merely keep the railroad running
- 48:14properly, a mismatch that leads to gap earnings that are higher
- 48:18than true economic earnings. This overstatement of earnings
- 48:22exists at all railroads. When CEOs or investment bankers
- 48:27tout pre depreciation figures such as EBITDAS Evaluation
- 48:31Guide, watch their noses lengthen while they speak.
- 48:35Our public reports of earnings will of course continue to
- 48:38conform to GAP. To embrace reality, however, you
- 48:42should remember to add back most of the amortization charges
- 48:45report. You should also subtract
- 48:47something to reflect the NSF's inadequate depreciation charge.
- 48:51Let's get back to our mini manufacturing, service and
- 48:55retailing operations, which sell products ranging from lollipops
- 48:59to jet airplanes. Some of this sector's
- 49:01businesses, measured by earnings on unleveraged net tangible
- 49:05assets, enjoy terrific economics, producing profits
- 49:09that run from 25% after tax to far more than 100%.
- 49:14Others generate good returns in the area of 12% to 20%.
- 49:19A few, however, these are serious mistakes I made in my
- 49:22job of capital allocation have very poor returns.
- 49:26In most of these cases, I was wrong in my evaluation of the
- 49:29economic dynamics of the company or the industry in which it
- 49:33operates, and we are now paying the price for my misjudgments.
- 49:37At other times, I stumbled in evaluating either the fidelity
- 49:41or the ability of incumbent managers or ones I later
- 49:44appointed. I will commit more errors.
- 49:47You can count on that. If we luck out, they will occur
- 49:50at tour smaller operations. Viewed as a single entity, the
- 49:54companies in this group are an excellent business.
- 49:57They employed an average of $25.6 billion of net tangible
- 50:01assets during 2015 and, despite their holding large quantities
- 50:06of excess cash and using only token amounts of leverage,
- 50:10earned 18.4% after tax on that capital. 16 Of course, a
- 50:16business with terrific economics can be a bad investment if it is
- 50:19bought at too high a price. We have paid substantial
- 50:23premiums to net tangible assets for most of our businesses, a
- 50:27cost that is reflected in the large figure we show for
- 50:30goodwill and other intangibles. Overall, however, we are getting
- 50:35a decent return on the capital we have deployed in this sector.
- 50:38Earnings from the group should grow substantially in 2016 as
- 50:43Duracell and Precision Cast Parts enter the fold.
- 50:47We have far too many companies in this group to comment on them
- 50:49individually. Moreover, there competitors both
- 50:53current and potential read this report.
- 50:55In a few of our businesses we might be disadvantaged if others
- 50:59knew our numbers. In some of our operations that
- 51:01are not of a size material to an evaluation of Berkshire,
- 51:05therefore we only disclose what is required.
- 51:08You can nevertheless find a good bit of detail about many of our
- 51:11operations on pages 88 to 91. Finance and financial products.
- 51:17Our three leasing and rental operations are conducted by
- 51:20Court Furniture, XDRA semi trailers and MARM on primarily
- 51:24tank cars, but also freight cars, intermodal tank containers
- 51:28and cranes. These companies are industry
- 51:31leaders and have substantially increased their earnings as the
- 51:35American economy has gained strength.
- 51:37At each of the three, we have invested more money and new
- 51:41equipment than have many of our competitors and that's paid off.
- 51:45Dealing from strength is one of Berkshire's enduring advantages.
- 51:49Kevin Clayton has again delivered an industry leading
- 51:52performance at Clayton Homes, the second largest home builder
- 51:56in America. Last year the company sold
- 51:5934,397 homes, about 45% of the manufactured homes bought by
- 52:06Americans. In contrast, the company was #3
- 52:09in the field with a 14% share when Berkshire purchased in
- 52:142003. Manufactured homes allow the
- 52:17American dream of home ownership to be achieved by lower income
- 52:21citizens. Around 70% of new homes costing
- 52:24$150,000 or less come from our industry.
- 52:28About 46% of Clayton's homes are sold through the 331 stores we
- 52:33ourselves own and operate. Most of Clayton's remaining
- 52:37sales are made to 1395 independent retailers.
- 52:41Key to Clayton's operation is it's $12.8 billion mortgage
- 52:45portfolio. We originate about 35% of all
- 52:49mortgages on manufactured homes. About 37% of our mortgage
- 52:53portfolio emanates from our retail operation, with the
- 52:57balance primarily originated by independent retailers, some of
- 53:01which sell our homes while others market only the homes of
- 53:04our competitors. Lenders other than Clayton have
- 53:07come and gone with Berkshire's backing.
- 53:09However, Clayton steadfastly financed home buyers throughout
- 53:13the panic days of 2008 to 2009. Indeed, during that period,
- 53:18Clayton used precious capital to finance dealers who did not sell
- 53:22our homes. The funds we supplied to Goldman
- 53:25Sachs and General Electric at that time produced headlines.
- 53:29The funds Berkshire quietly delivered to Clayton both made
- 53:32home ownership possible for thousands of families and kept
- 53:36many non Clayton dealers alive. Our retail outlets, employing
- 53:40simple language and large type, consistently inform home buyers
- 53:44of alternative sources for financing, most of it coming
- 53:47from local banks and always secure acknowledgments from
- 53:50customers that this information has been received and read.
- 53:54The form we use is reproduced in its actual size on page 119.
- 53:59Seventeen Mortgage origination practices are of great
- 54:03importance to both the borrower and to society.
- 54:05There is no question that reckless practices in home
- 54:09lending played a major role in bringing on the financial panic
- 54:12of 2008, which in turn led to the Great Recession.
- 54:16In the years preceding the meltdown, A destructive and
- 54:19often corrupt pattern of mortgage creation flourished
- 54:23whereby one an originator in say, California would make loans
- 54:27end to promptly sell them to an investment or commercial bank in
- 54:31say New York, which would package many mortgages to serve
- 54:35as collateral for a dizzyingly complicated array of
- 54:39mortgage-backed securities to be 3 sold to unwitting institutions
- 54:43around the world. As if these sins weren't
- 54:46sufficient to create an unholy mess, imaginative investment
- 54:50bankers sometimes concocted a second layer of sliced up
- 54:53financing whose value depended on the junkier portions of
- 54:57primary offerings. When Wall Street gets
- 54:59innovative, watch out. While that was going on, I
- 55:02described this doubling up practice as requiring an
- 55:05investor to read 10s of thousands of pages of mind
- 55:09numbing prose to evaluate a single security being offered.
- 55:13Both the originator and the package are of these financing S
- 55:16had no skin in the game and were driven by volume and markups.
- 55:21Many housing borrowers joined the party as well, blatantly
- 55:24lying on their loan applications, while mortgage
- 55:27originators look the other way. Naturally, the gameiest credits
- 55:31generated the most profits. Smooth Wall Street salesman
- 55:35garnered millions annually by manufacturing products that
- 55:38their customers were unable to understand.
- 55:41It's also questionable as to whether the major rating
- 55:44agencies were capable of evaluating the more complex
- 55:47structures, but rate them they did.
- 55:49Barney Frank, perhaps the most financially savvy member of
- 55:53Congress during the panic, recently assessed the 2010 Dodd
- 55:57Frank Act, saying the one major weakness that I've seen in the
- 56:01implementation was this decision by the regulators not to impose
- 56:05risk retention on all residential mortgages.
- 56:08Today, some legislators and commentators continue to
- 56:11advocate a 1% to 5% retention by the originator as a way to align
- 56:17its interests with that of the ultimate lender or mortgage
- 56:20guarantor. At Clayton, our risk retention
- 56:23was and is 100%. When we originate a mortgage, we
- 56:27keep it, leaving aside the few that qualify for a government
- 56:30guarantee. When we make mistakes in
- 56:32granting credit, we therefore pay a price, a hefty price that
- 56:36dwarfs any profit we realized upon the original sale of the
- 56:40home. Last year we had to foreclose on
- 56:438444 manufactured housing mortgages at a cost to us of
- 56:48$157 million. The average loan we made in 2015
- 56:53was only $59,942. Small potatoes for traditional
- 56:58mortgage lenders, but a daunting commitment for our many lower
- 57:02income borrowers. Our buyer acquires a decent
- 57:04home. Take a look at the home we will
- 57:06have on display at our annual meeting requiring monthly
- 57:09principal and interest payments that average 522 dollars.
- 57:14Some borrowers, of course, will lose their jobs and there will
- 57:18be divorces and deaths. Others will get over extended on
- 57:21credit cards and mishandle their finances.
- 57:24We will lose money then and our borrower will lose his down
- 57:28payment, though his mortgage payments during his time of
- 57:30occupancy may have been well under rental rates for
- 57:33comparable quarters. Nevertheless, despite the low
- 57:37FICO scores and income of our borrowers, their payment, the
- 57:40behavior during the Great Recession was far better than
- 57:43that prevailing in many mortgage pools populated by people
- 57:47earning multiple. So for typical borrowers income,
- 57:50the strong desire of our borrowers to have a home of
- 57:53their own is one reason we've done well with our mortgage
- 57:56portfolio. Equally important, we have
- 57:59financed much of the portfolio with floating rate debt or with
- 58:02short term fixed rate debt. Consequently, the incredibly low
- 58:06short term rates of recent years have provided us a constantly
- 58:10widening spread between our interest costs and the income we
- 58:13derive from our mortgage portfolio which bears fixed
- 58:17rates. Incidentally, we would have
- 58:19enjoyed similar margins had we simply bought long term bonds
- 58:22and financed the position in some short term manner. 18
- 58:27Normally it is risky business to lend long at fixed rates and
- 58:30borrow short as we have been doing at Clayton over the years.
- 58:34Some important financial institutions have gone broke
- 58:37doing that. At Berkshire, however, we
- 58:40possess a natural offset in that our businesses always maintain
- 58:44at least $20 billion in cash equivalents that earn short term
- 58:48rates. More often, our short term
- 58:50investments are in the $40 billion to $60 billion range.
- 58:55If we have say $60 billion invested at one 4% or less, a
- 59:00sharp move to higher short term rates would bring benefits to us
- 59:03far exceeding the higher financing costs we would incur
- 59:06in funding Clayton's $13 billion mortgage portfolio.
- 59:10In banking terms, Berkshire ICE and always will be heavily asset
- 59:14sensitive and will consequently benefit from rising interest
- 59:18rates. Let me talk about one subject of
- 59:20which I am particularly proud, that having to do with
- 59:23regulation. The Great Recession caused
- 59:26mortgage originators Service Rs and Package Rs to come under
- 59:30intense scrutiny and to be assessed many billions of
- 59:34dollars in fines and penalties. The scrutiny has certainly
- 59:37extended to Clayton, whose mortgage practices have been
- 59:40continuously reviewed and examined in respect to such
- 59:43items as origination, S, servicing, collections,
- 59:47advertising, compliance, and internal controls.
- 59:51At the federal level, we answer to the Federal Trade Commission,
- 59:55the Department of Housing and Urban Development, and the
- 59:58Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
- 1:00:00Dozens of states regulate us as well.
- 1:00:02During the past two years, indeed, various federal and
- 1:00:06state authorities from 25 states examined and reviewed Clayton
- 1:00:10and its mortgages on 65 occasions.
- 1:00:13The result? Our total fines during this
- 1:00:16period were $38,200 and our refunds to customers $704,678.
- 1:00:24Furthermore, though we had to foreclose on 2.64% of our
- 1:00:28manufactured home mortgages last year, 95.4% of our borrowers
- 1:00:33were current on their payments at year end as they move toward
- 1:00:36owning a debt free home. Marmont's rail fleet expanded to
- 1:00:40133,220 units by year end, a number significantly increased
- 1:00:46by the company's purchase of 25,000 and 85 cars from General
- 1:00:51Electric on September 30th. If our fleet was connected to
- 1:00:55form a single train, the engine would be in Omaha and the
- 1:00:58caboose in Portland, ME. At year end, 97% of our rail
- 1:01:03cars were leased, with about 15 to 17% of the fleet coming up
- 1:01:07for renewal each year. Though tank cars sound like
- 1:01:11vessels carrying crude oil, only about 7% of our fleet carries
- 1:01:15that product. Chemicals and refined petroleum
- 1:01:18products are the lead items we transport when trains roll by.
- 1:01:22Look for the UTLXOR proc or markings that identify our tank
- 1:01:26cars. When you spot the brand, puff
- 1:01:29out your chest. You own a portion of that car
- 1:01:32Investments. Below we list our 15 common
- 1:01:35stock investments that at year end had the largest market
- 1:01:39value. We exclude our Kraft Heinz
- 1:01:41holding because we are part of a control group and account for
- 1:01:45it. On the equity method.
- 1:01:46Berkshire has one major equity position that is not included in
- 1:01:49the table. We can buy 700 million shares of
- 1:01:53Bank of America at any time prior to September 2021 for $5
- 1:01:58billion. At year in the shares were worth
- 1:02:0111.8 dollars billion. We are likely to purchase them
- 1:02:05just before expiration of our option and if we wish we can use
- 1:02:09our $5 billion of Bank of America 6% preferred to fund the
- 1:02:13purchase. In the meantime, it is important
- 1:02:16for you to realize that Bank of America is in effect our 4th
- 1:02:21largest equity investment and one we value highly. 20
- 1:02:25productivity and prosperity. Earlier, I told you how our
- 1:02:29partners at Kraft Heinz root out inefficiencies, thereby
- 1:02:32increasing output per hour of employment.
- 1:02:35That kind of improvement has been the secret sauce of
- 1:02:38America's remarkable gains in living standards since the
- 1:02:41nation's founding in 1776. Unfortunately, the label of
- 1:02:46secret is appropriate. Too few Americans fully grasp
- 1:02:50the linkage between productivity and prosperity.
- 1:02:53To see that connection, let's look first at the country's most
- 1:02:57dramatic example, farming and later examined 3 Berkshire
- 1:03:00specific areas. In 1900, America's civilian
- 1:03:04workforce numbered 28 million. Of these, 11,000,000, a
- 1:03:08staggering 40% of that total worked in farming.
- 1:03:12The leading crop then, as now, was corn.
- 1:03:15About 90 million acres were devoted to its production, and
- 1:03:19the yield per acre was 30 bushels, for a total output of
- 1:03:222.7 billion bushels annually. Then came the tractor and one
- 1:03:27innovation after another that revolutionized such keys to farm
- 1:03:30productivity as planting, harvesting, irrigation,
- 1:03:34fertilization and seed quality. Today, we devote about
- 1:03:3885,000,000 acres to corn. Productivity, however, has
- 1:03:42improved yields to more than 150 bushels per acre, for an annual
- 1:03:47output of 13 to 14 billion bushels.
- 1:03:50Farmers have made similar gains with other products.
- 1:03:53Increased yields, though, are only half the story.
- 1:03:57The huge increases in physical output have been accompanied by
- 1:04:00a dramatic reduction in the number of farm laborers.
- 1:04:03Human input. Today, about 3 million people
- 1:04:06work on farms, a tiny 2% of our 158,000,000 person workforce.
- 1:04:12Thus improved farming methods have allowed 10s of millions of
- 1:04:16present day workers to utilize their time and talents.
- 1:04:19In other endeavors are allocation of human resources
- 1:04:22that enables Americans of today to enjoy huge quantities of non
- 1:04:26farm goods and services they would otherwise lack.
- 1:04:30It's easy to look back over the 115 year span and realize how
- 1:04:34extraordinarily beneficial agricultural innovations have
- 1:04:38been, not just for farmers, but more broadly for our entire
- 1:04:42society. We would not have anything close
- 1:04:45to the America we now know had we stifled those improvements in
- 1:04:48productivity. That it was fortunate that
- 1:04:51horses couldn't vote. That on a day-to-day basis,
- 1:04:54however, talk of the greater good must have rung hollow to
- 1:04:57farmhands who lost their jobs to machines that performed routine
- 1:05:01tasks far more efficiently than humans ever could.
- 1:05:04We will examine this flip side to productivity gains later in
- 1:05:08this section. For the moment, however, let's
- 1:05:11move on to three stories of efficiencies that have had major
- 1:05:14consequences for Berkshire subsidiaries.
- 1:05:17Similar transformations have been commonplace throughout
- 1:05:20American business. In 1947, shortly after the end
- 1:05:24of World War 2, the American workforce totaled 44 million.
- 1:05:29About 1.35 million workers were employed in the railroad
- 1:05:33industry. The revenue ton miles of freight
- 1:05:36moved by Class 1 railroads that year totaled 655 billion.
- 1:05:41By 2014, Class 1 railroads carried 1.85 trillion ton miles,
- 1:05:47an increase of 182%, while employing only 187,000 workers,
- 1:05:54a reduction of 86% since 1947. Some of this change involved
- 1:05:59passenger related employees, but most of the workforce reduction
- 1:06:03came on the freight side. As a result of this staggering
- 1:06:07improvement in productivity, the inflation adjusted price for
- 1:06:10moving a ton mile of freight has fallen by 55% since 1947 to
- 1:06:16drop, saving shippers about $90 billion annually in current
- 1:06:20dollars. Another startling statistic.
- 1:06:22If it took as many people now to move freight as it did in 1947,
- 1:06:27we would need well over 3,000,000 railroad workers to
- 1:06:31handle present volumes. Of course, that level of
- 1:06:34employment would raise freight charges by a lot.
- 1:06:37Consequently, nothing close to today's volume would actually
- 1:06:40move. 21 Our own BNSF was formed in 1995 by a merger between
- 1:06:46Burlington Northern and Santa Fe.
- 1:06:48In 1996, the merged company's first full year of operation for
- 1:06:5311,000,000 ton miles of freight were transported by 45,000
- 1:06:58employees. Last year the comparable figures
- 1:07:01were 702,000,000 ton miles plus 71% and 47,000 employees plus
- 1:07:08only 4%. That dramatic gain in
- 1:07:10productivity benefits both owners and shippers.
- 1:07:13Safety ATB NSF has improved as well.
- 1:07:17Report able injuries were 2.04 per 200,000 man hours in 1996
- 1:07:23and have since fallen more than 50% to 0.95.
- 1:07:28A bit more than a century ago, the auto was invented and around
- 1:07:31it formed an industry that insures cars and their drivers.
- 1:07:35Initially this business was written through traditional
- 1:07:38insurance agencies, the kind dealing in fire insurance.
- 1:07:42This agency centric approach included high commissions and
- 1:07:45other underwriting expenses that consumed about 40 of the premium
- 1:07:49dollar. Strong local agencies were then
- 1:07:52in the drivers see, because they represented multiple insurers
- 1:07:56and could play one company off against another.
- 1:07:58When commissions were being negotiated, cartel like pricing
- 1:08:02prevailed and all involved were doing fine except for the
- 1:08:06consumer. And then some American ingenuity
- 1:08:08came into play. GJ Micher Liu, a farmer from Or
- 1:08:13Nah Illinois, came up with the idea of a captive sales force
- 1:08:17that would sell the insurance products of only a single
- 1:08:20company. His baby was Chris and State
- 1:08:22Farm Mutual. The company cut commissions and
- 1:08:25expenses, moves that permitted lower prices and soon became a
- 1:08:29powerhouse. For many decades, State Farm has
- 1:08:32been the runaway volume leader in both auto and home owners
- 1:08:36insurance. Allstate, which also operated
- 1:08:39with a direct distribution model, was long the runner up.
- 1:08:42Both State Farm and Allstate have had underwriting expenses
- 1:08:46of about 25% in the early 1930. Yes, another contender United
- 1:08:51Services Auto Association, USAA Mutual like company was writing
- 1:08:56auto insurance for military officers on a direct to the
- 1:08:59customer basis. This marketing innovation rose
- 1:09:03from a need that military personnel had to buy insurance
- 1:09:06that would stay with them as they moved from base to base.
- 1:09:09That was business of little interest to local insurance
- 1:09:12agencies, which wanted that steady renewals that came from
- 1:09:15permanent residents. The direct distribution method
- 1:09:18of USAA, as it happened, incurred lower costs than those
- 1:09:22enjoyed by State Farm and Allstate and therefore delivered
- 1:09:26an even greater bargain to customers.
- 1:09:28That made Leo and Lillian Goodwin, employees of USAA,
- 1:09:33dream of broadening the target market for its direct
- 1:09:36distribution model beyond military officers.
- 1:09:39In 1936, starting with $100,000 of capital, they incorporated
- 1:09:44Government Employees Insurance Company, later compressing this
- 1:09:48mouthful to GEICO. Their fledgling did $238,000 of
- 1:09:52auto insurance business in 1937, its first full year.
- 1:09:57Last year, GEICO did $22.6 billion, more than double the
- 1:10:01volume of USAA. Though the early bird gets the
- 1:10:04worm, the second mouse gets the cheese.
- 1:10:07Geico's underwriting expenses in 2015 were 14.7% of premiums,
- 1:10:13with USAA being the only large company to achieve a lower
- 1:10:17percentage. GEICO is fully as efficient as
- 1:10:20USAA, but spends considerably more on advertising aimed at
- 1:10:24promoting growth. With the price advantage Gsos
- 1:10:27low costs allow, it's not surprising that several years
- 1:10:30ago the company sees the number two spot in auto insurance from
- 1:10:34Allstate. GEICO is also gaining ground on
- 1:10:37State Farm, though it is still far ahead of us in volume.
- 1:10:40On August 30th, 2030, my 100 TH birthday, I plan to announce
- 1:10:46that GEICO has taken over the top spot.
- 1:10:48Mark your calendar. GEICO employs about 34,000
- 1:10:52people to serve its 14,000,000 policyholders.
- 1:10:55I can only guess at the workforce it would require to
- 1:10:58serve a similar number of policyholders under the agency
- 1:11:01system. I believe, however, but the
- 1:11:04number would be at least 60,000 a combination of what the
- 1:11:07insurer would need and direct employment and the personnel
- 1:11:11required at supporting agencies. 22 in its electric utility
- 1:11:15business, our Berkshire Hathaway energy B.
- 1:11:18He operates within a changing economic model.
- 1:11:21Historically, the survival of a local electric company did not
- 1:11:24depend on its efficiency in in fact, a sloppy operation could
- 1:11:29do just fine financially. That's because utilities were
- 1:11:32usually the sole supplier of a needed product and were allowed
- 1:11:35to price at a level that gave them a prescribed return upon
- 1:11:39the capital they employed. The joke in the industry was
- 1:11:42that a utility was the only business that would
- 1:11:45automatically earn more money by redecorating the boss office,
- 1:11:48and some CE OS ran things accordingly.
- 1:11:51That's all changing today. Society has decided that
- 1:11:54federally subsidized wind and solar generation is in our
- 1:11:58country's long term interest. Federal tax credits are used to
- 1:12:01implement this policy support that makes renewables price
- 1:12:05competitive in certain geographies.
- 1:12:08Those tax credits or other government mandated help for
- 1:12:11renewables may eventually erode the economics of the incumbent
- 1:12:15utility, particularly if it is a high cost operator.
- 1:12:19BH ES long established emphasis on efficiency even when the
- 1:12:23company didn't need it to attain authorized earnings leaves us
- 1:12:26particularly competitive in today's market and more
- 1:12:30important in tomorrow's as well. B.
- 1:12:32He acquired its Iowa utility in 1999.
- 1:12:36In the year before that, utility employed 3700 people and
- 1:12:40produced 19,000,000 MW hours of electricity.
- 1:12:44Now we employ 3500 people and produce 29 million MW hours.
- 1:12:51That major increase in efficiency allowed us to operate
- 1:12:54without a rate increase for 16 years, a period during which
- 1:12:58industry rates increased 44%. The safety record of our Iowa
- 1:13:03utility is also outstanding. It had .79 injuries per 100
- 1:13:07employees in 2015, compared to the rate of 7.0 experienced by
- 1:13:13the previous owner in the year before we bought the operation
- 1:13:16in 2006. B.
- 1:13:18He purchased Pacific OR P, which operated primarily in Oregon and
- 1:13:23Utah. The year before our purchase,
- 1:13:25Pacific or PE employed 6750 people and produced 52.6 million
- 1:13:32MW hours. Last year the numbers were 5700
- 1:13:36employees and 56.3 million MW hours.
- 1:13:40Here 2 safety improved dramatically with the accident
- 1:13:44rate per 100 employees falling from 3.4 in 2005 to .85 in 2015.
- 1:13:52In safety, B now ranks in the industry.
- 1:13:55Stop decile those outstanding performances explain why B.
- 1:13:59He is welcomed by regulators when it proposes to buy a
- 1:14:02utility in their jurisdiction. The regulators know the company
- 1:14:06will run an efficient, safe and reliable operation and also
- 1:14:10arrive with unlimited capital to fund whatever projects make
- 1:14:14sense. That B.
- 1:14:15He has never paid a dividend to Berkshire since we assumed
- 1:14:18ownership. No investor owned utility in
- 1:14:21America comes close to matching BH ES enthusiasm for
- 1:14:25reinvestment. The productivity gains that I've
- 1:14:27just spelled out and countless others that have been achieved
- 1:14:30in America have delivered awesome benefits to society.
- 1:14:34That's the reason our citizens as a whole have enjoyed and will
- 1:14:38continue to enjoy major gains in the goods and services they
- 1:14:42receive. To this thought, there are
- 1:14:44offsets. First, the productivity gains
- 1:14:46achieved in recent years have largely benefited the wealthy.
- 1:14:50Second, productivity gains frequently cause upheaval.
- 1:14:54Both capital and labor can pay a terrible price when innovation
- 1:14:58or new efficiencies upend their worlds.
- 1:15:01We need shed no tears for the capitalists, whether they be
- 1:15:04private owners or an army of public shareholders.
- 1:15:08It's their job to take care of themselves when large rewards
- 1:15:11can flow to investors from good decisions.
- 1:15:14These parties should not be spared the losses produced by
- 1:15:17wrong choices. Moreover, investors who
- 1:15:20diversify widely and simply S it tight with their holdings are
- 1:15:24certain to prosper in America. Gains from winning investments
- 1:15:28have always far more than offset the losses from clunkers.
- 1:15:32During the 20 TH century, the Dow Jones Industrial Averaging
- 1:15:36Index Fund of sorts soared from 66 to 11497 with its component
- 1:15:42companies all the while paying ever increasing dividends. 23 A
- 1:15:47long employed worker faces a different equation.
- 1:15:50When innovation in the market system interact too produce
- 1:15:54efficiencies, many workers may be rendered unnecessary, their
- 1:15:58talents obsolete. Some can find decent employment
- 1:16:01elsewhere, for others that is not an option.
- 1:16:04When low cost competition drove shoe production to Asia, our
- 1:16:08once prosperous Dexter operation folded, putting 1600 employees
- 1:16:13in a small main town out of work.
- 1:16:15Many were past the point in life at which they could learn
- 1:16:19another trade. We lost our entire investment,
- 1:16:22which we could afford, but many workers lost a livelihood they
- 1:16:25could not replace. The same scenario unfolded in
- 1:16:28slow motion, a tour original New England textile operation which
- 1:16:33struggled for 20 years before expiring many older workers.
- 1:16:37A tour New Bedford plant, as a poignant example, spoke
- 1:16:41Portuguese and knew little, if any English.
- 1:16:44They had no Plan B. The answer in such disruptions
- 1:16:47is not the restraining or outlawing of actions that
- 1:16:50increase productivity. Americans would not be living
- 1:16:53nearly as well as we do if we had mandated that 11 million
- 1:16:57people should forever be employed in farming.
- 1:17:00The solution? Rather there's a variety of
- 1:17:03safety Nets aimed at providing a decent life for those who are
- 1:17:06willing to work but find their specific talents judged of small
- 1:17:10value because of market forces. I personally favor a reformed
- 1:17:14and expanded earned income tax credit that would try to make
- 1:17:17sure America works for those willing to work.
- 1:17:20The price of achieving ever increasing prosperity for the
- 1:17:23great majority of Americans should not be pinery for the
- 1:17:27unfortunate important risks. We, like all public companies,
- 1:17:31are required by the SEC to annually catalog risk factors in
- 1:17:35our 10 Ki can't remember, however an instance when reading
- 1:17:40a 10s risk section has helped Maine evaluating a business.
- 1:17:44That's not because the identified risks aren't real.
- 1:17:47The truly important risks, however, are usually well known.
- 1:17:51Beyond that, A10 KS catalog of risks is seldom of aid in
- 1:17:55assessing 1 the probability of the threatening event actually
- 1:17:59occurring, to the range of costs if it does occur, and three, the
- 1:18:03timing of the possible loss. A threat that will only surface
- 1:18:0750 years from now may be a problem for society, but it is
- 1:18:10not a financial problem for today's investor.
- 1:18:13Berkshire operates in more industries than any company I
- 1:18:16know of. Each of our pursuits has its own
- 1:18:18array of possible problems and opportunities.
- 1:18:22Those are easy to list but hard to evaluate.
- 1:18:25Charlie, I and our various CEOs often differ in a very major way
- 1:18:30in our calculation of the likelihood, the timing, and the
- 1:18:33cost or benefit that may result from these possibilities.
- 1:18:37Let me mention just a few examples.
- 1:18:39To begin with, an obvious threat BNSF along with other railroads
- 1:18:44is certain to lose significant coal volume over the next
- 1:18:48decade. At some point in the future,
- 1:18:50though not in my view for a long time, Gseos premium volume may
- 1:18:54shrink because of driverless cars.
- 1:18:57This development could hurt our auto dealerships as well.
- 1:19:00Circulation of our print newspapers will continue to
- 1:19:03fall, a certainty we allowed for when purchasing them.
- 1:19:07To date, renewables have helped our utility operation, but that
- 1:19:11could change, particularly if storage capabilities for
- 1:19:14electricity materially improve. Online retailing threatens the
- 1:19:18business model of our retailers and certain of our consumer
- 1:19:22brands. These potentialities are just a
- 1:19:25few of the negative possibilities facing us, but
- 1:19:28even the most casual follower of business news has long been
- 1:19:31aware of them. None of these problems, however,
- 1:19:34is crucial to Berkshire's long term well-being.
- 1:19:37When we took over the company in 1965, its risks could have been
- 1:19:41encapsulated in a single sentence.
- 1:19:44The northern textile business, in which all of our capital
- 1:19:47resides, is destined for recurring losses and will
- 1:19:50eventually disappear. That development, however, was
- 1:19:53no death knell. We simply adapted and we will
- 1:19:56continue to do so. 24 everyday Berkshire managers are thinking
- 1:20:01about how they can better compete in an always changing
- 1:20:04world. Just as vigorously, Charlie and
- 1:20:07I focus on where a steady stream of funds should be deployed.
- 1:20:10In that respect, we possess a major advantage over 1 industry
- 1:20:14companies whose options are far more limited.
- 1:20:17I firmly believe that Berkshire has the money.
- 1:20:20Talent and culture to plow through the sort of adversities
- 1:20:23I've itemized above and many more, and to emerge with ever
- 1:20:26greater earning power. There is, however, one clear,
- 1:20:30present, and enduring danger to Berkshire against which Charlie
- 1:20:34and I are powerless. That threat to Berkshire is also
- 1:20:37the major threat our citizenry faces.
- 1:20:40A successful as defined by the aggressor, cyber, biological,
- 1:20:44nuclear, or chemical attack on the United States.
- 1:20:47That is a risk Berkshire shares with all of American business.
- 1:20:51The probability of such mass destruction in any given year is
- 1:20:55likely very small. It's been more than 70 years
- 1:20:58since I delivered a Washington Post newspaper headlining the
- 1:21:02fact that the United States had dropped the first atomic bomb.
- 1:21:06Subsequently, we've had a few close calls but avoided
- 1:21:09catastrophic destruction. We can thank our government in
- 1:21:12luck for this result. Nevertheless, what's a small
- 1:21:16probability in a short period approaches certainty in the
- 1:21:19longer run that if there is only one chance in 30 of an event
- 1:21:23occurring in a given year, the likelihood of it occurring at
- 1:21:26least once in a century is 96.6%.
- 1:21:30The added bad news is that there will forever be people and
- 1:21:33organizations and perhaps even nations that would like to
- 1:21:37inflict maximum damage on our country.
- 1:21:39Their means of doing so have increased exponentially during
- 1:21:43my lifetime. Innovation has its dark side.
- 1:21:46There is no way for American corporations or their investors
- 1:21:49to shed this risk. If an event occurs in the US
- 1:21:53that leads to mass devastation, the value of all equity
- 1:21:57investments will almost certainly be decimated.
- 1:22:00Noon knows what the day after will look like.
- 1:22:02I think, however, that Einstein's 1949 appraisal
- 1:22:06remains apt. I know not with what weapons
- 1:22:09World War 3 will be fought, but World War 4 will be fought with
- 1:22:13sticks and stones. I am writing this section
- 1:22:16because we have a proxy proposal regarding climate change to
- 1:22:19consider at this year's annual meeting.
- 1:22:22The sponsor would like us to provide a report on the dangers
- 1:22:24that this change might present to our insurance operation and
- 1:22:28explain how we are responding to these threats.
- 1:22:31It seems highly likely tone that climate change poses a major
- 1:22:34problem for the planet. I say highly likely rather than
- 1:22:38certain because I have no scientific aptitude and
- 1:22:41remember, while the dire predictions of most experts
- 1:22:44about Y2K. It would be foolish, however,
- 1:22:48for me or anyone to demand 100% proof of huge forthcoming damage
- 1:22:52to the world if that outcome seemed at all possible, and if
- 1:22:56prompt action had even a small chance of thwarting the danger.
- 1:23:00This issue bears a similarity to Pascal's wager on the existence
- 1:23:04of God. Pascal, it may be, he recalled,
- 1:23:07argued that if there were only a tiny probability that God truly
- 1:23:11existed, it made sense to behave as if he did, because the
- 1:23:15rewards could be infinite, whereas the lack of belief
- 1:23:17risked eternal misery. Likewise, if there is only a 1%
- 1:23:21chance the planet is heading toward a truly major disaster,
- 1:23:25and delay means passing a point of no return in action now is
- 1:23:30foolhardy. Call this Noah's Law.
- 1:23:32If an ARC may be essential for survival, begin building it
- 1:23:35today, no matter how cloudless the skies appear.
- 1:23:39It's understandable that the sponsor of the proxy proposal
- 1:23:42believes Berkshire is especially threatened by climate change
- 1:23:46because we are a huge insurer covering all sorts of risks.
- 1:23:50The sponsor may worry that property losses will skyrocket
- 1:23:53because of weather changes, and such worries might in fact be
- 1:23:57warranted if we wrote tenor 20 year policies at fixed prices.
- 1:24:02But insurance policies are customarily written for one year
- 1:24:05and repriced annually to reflect changing exposures.
- 1:24:09Increased possibilities of loss translate promptly into
- 1:24:12increased premiums. 25 Think back to 1951, when I first
- 1:24:17became enthused about GEICO. The company's average loss per
- 1:24:21policy was then about $30 annually.
- 1:24:24Imagine your reaction if I had predicted then that in 2015 the
- 1:24:28loss costs would increase to about $1000 per policy.
- 1:24:33Wouldn't such skyrocketing losses prove disastrous, you
- 1:24:36might ask? Well, no.
- 1:24:38Over the years, inflation has caused a huge increase in the
- 1:24:41cost of repairing both the cars and the humans involved in
- 1:24:45accidents. But these increased costs have
- 1:24:48been promptly matched by increased premiums.
- 1:24:51So, paradoxically, the upward March in loss costs has made
- 1:24:55insurance companies far more valuable.
- 1:24:57If costs had remained unchanged, Berkshire would now own an auto
- 1:25:01insurer doing $600 million of business annually, rather than
- 1:25:06one doing $23 billion. Up to now, climate change has
- 1:25:10not produced more frequent nor more costly hurricanes, nor
- 1:25:14other weather related events covered by insurance.
- 1:25:17As a consequence, US Super Cat rates have fallen steadily in
- 1:25:22recent years, which is why we have backed away from that
- 1:25:24business. If super cats become costlier
- 1:25:27and more frequent, the likely, though far from certain effect
- 1:25:31on Berkshires insurance business would be to make it larger and
- 1:25:34more profitable. As a citizen, you may
- 1:25:37understandably find climate change keeping you up nights.
- 1:25:40As a homeowner in a low lying area you may wish to consider
- 1:25:44moving, but when you are thinking only as a shareholder
- 1:25:47of a major insurer, climate change should not be on your
- 1:25:50list of worries. The Annual Meeting Charlie and I
- 1:25:53have finally decided to enter the 21 SD century.
- 1:25:57Our Annual meeting this year will be webcast worldwide in its
- 1:26:00entirety. To view the meeting, simply go
- 1:26:03to https://finance.yahoo.com. Briquet live stream at 9:00 AM
- 1:26:08Central Daylight Time on Saturday, April 30th TH.
- 1:26:12The Yahoo webcast will begin with 1/2 hour of interviews with
- 1:26:16managers, directors and shareholders.
- 1:26:19Then at 9:30, Charlie and I will commence answering questions.
- 1:26:23This new arrangement will serve 2 purposes.
- 1:26:26First, it may level off or modestly decrease attendance at
- 1:26:30the meeting. Last year's record of more than
- 1:26:3240,000 attendees strained our capacity.
- 1:26:36In addition to quickly filling the CenturyLink Center's main
- 1:26:39arena, we packed its overflow rooms and then spilled into two
- 1:26:43large meeting rooms at the adjoining Omaha Hilton.
- 1:26:46All major hotels were sold out, notwithstanding Air BNBS stepped
- 1:26:51up presence. Airbnb was especially helpful
- 1:26:54for those visitors on limited budgets.
- 1:26:57Our second reason for initiating a webcast is more important.
- 1:27:01Charlie is 92 and I am 85. If we were partners with you in
- 1:27:05a small business and we're charged with running the place,
- 1:27:08you would want to look in occasionally to make sure we
- 1:27:11hadn't drifted off into La La Land.
- 1:27:13Shareholders, in contrast, should not need to come to Omaha
- 1:27:18to monitor how we look and sound.
- 1:27:20In making your evaluation, be kind.
- 1:27:22Allow for the fact that we didn't look that impressive when
- 1:27:25we were a tour best. Viewers can also observe our
- 1:27:28life prolonging diet. During the meeting, Charlie and
- 1:27:31I will each consume enough Coke, sees fudge and sees peanut
- 1:27:35brittle to satisfy the weekly caloric needs of an NFL lineman.
- 1:27:40Long ago, we discovered a fundamental truth.
- 1:27:43There's nothing like eating carrots and broccoli when you're
- 1:27:46really hungry and want to stay that way.
- 1:27:48Shareholders planning to attend the meeting should come at 7:00
- 1:27:51AM when the doors open at CenturyLink Center and start
- 1:27:55shopping. Carrie Sovia will again be in
- 1:27:58charge of the festivities. She had her second child late
- 1:28:01last month, but that did not slow her down.
- 1:28:04Carrie is unflappable, ingenious and expert at bringing out the
- 1:28:08best in those who work with her. She is aided by hundreds of
- 1:28:12Berkshire employees from around the country and by our entire
- 1:28:16Home Office crew as well, all of them pitching in to make the
- 1:28:19weekend fun and informative for our owners. 26 Last year we
- 1:28:23increased the number of hours available for shopping at the
- 1:28:26CenturyLink. Sales skyrocketed, so naturally
- 1:28:30we will stay with the new schedule.
- 1:28:32On Friday, April 29th TH you can shop between noon and 5:00 PM
- 1:28:37and on Saturday exhibits and stores will be open from 7:00 AM
- 1:28:41until 4:30 PM. On Saturday morning, we will
- 1:28:44have our fifth international newspaper tossing challenge.
- 1:28:48Our target will again be a Clayton home porch located
- 1:28:51precisely 35 feet from the throwing line.
- 1:28:54When I was a teenager, in my 1 brief flirtation with honest
- 1:28:58labor, I delivered about 500,000 papers.
- 1:29:01So I think I'm pretty good at this game.
- 1:29:03Challenge me, humiliate me, knock me down a peg.
- 1:29:07The papers will run 36 to 42 pages and you must fold them
- 1:29:11yourself. No rubber bands allowed.
- 1:29:13The competition begins at 7:15, when contestants will make
- 1:29:17preliminary tosses. The 8 throws judged most
- 1:29:20accurate, four made by contestants 12 or under and four
- 1:29:24made by the older set, will compete against Meat 7 Fourty 5.
- 1:29:29The young challengers will each receive a prize, but the older
- 1:29:32ones will have to beat me to take anything home.
- 1:29:35And be sure to check out the Clayton home itself.
- 1:29:38It can be purchased for $78,900 fully installed on land you
- 1:29:43provide. In past years, we've made many
- 1:29:46sales. On the meeting day, Kevin
- 1:29:48Clayton will be on hand with his order book.
- 1:29:51At 8:30 AMA new Berkshire movie will be shown.
- 1:29:54An hour later we will start the question and answer period
- 1:29:58which, including a break for lunch at CenturyLink stands,
- 1:30:00will last until 3:30 PM. After a short recess, Charlie
- 1:30:05and I will convene the Annual meeting at 3:45 PM.
- 1:30:09This business session typically lasts only 1/2 hour or so and
- 1:30:13can safely be skipped by those craving a little last minute
- 1:30:16shopping. Your venue for shopping will be
- 1:30:18the 194,300 square foot hall that adjoins the meeting and in
- 1:30:23which products from dozens of Berkshire subsidiaries will be
- 1:30:27for sale. Say hello to the many Berkshire
- 1:30:30managers who will be captaining their exhibits and be sure to
- 1:30:33view the terrific BNSF railroad layout that salutes all of our
- 1:30:37subsidiaries. Your children and you will be
- 1:30:40enchanted with it. We will have a new and very
- 1:30:43special exhibit in the Hall this year, a full size model of the
- 1:30:47world's largest aircraft engine for which precision cast parts
- 1:30:51makes many key components. The real engines weigh about
- 1:30:5420,000 lbs and are 10 feet in diameter and 22 feet in length.
- 1:30:59The bisected model at the meeting will give you a good
- 1:31:02look at many PCC components that help power your flights.
- 1:31:06Brooks, our running shoe company, will again have a
- 1:31:09special commemorative shoe to offer at the meeting after you
- 1:31:12purchase a pair with them on Sunday.
- 1:31:14A Tour 4th Annual Berkshire 5K, an 8:00 AM race starting at the
- 1:31:19CenturyLink. Full details for participating
- 1:31:22will be included in the Visitor's guide that will be
- 1:31:24sent to you with your meeting credentials.
- 1:31:27Entrance in the race will find themselves running alongside
- 1:31:30many of Berkshire's managers, directors and associates.
- 1:31:34Charlie and I, however, will sleep in.
- 1:31:37The fudge and peanut brittle take their toll.
- 1:31:39Participation in the 5K grows every year.
- 1:31:43Help us set another record. A GEICO booth in the shopping
- 1:31:46area will be staffed by a number of the company's top counselors
- 1:31:49from around the country. Stop by for a quote.
- 1:31:52In most cases, GEICO will be able to give you a shareholder
- 1:31:55discount, usually 8%. This special offer is permitted
- 1:31:59by 44 of the 51 jurisdictions in which we operate. 1 Supplemental
- 1:32:05point. The discount is not additive.
- 1:32:07If you qualify for another discount, such as that available
- 1:32:10to certain groups, bring the details of your existing
- 1:32:13insurance and check out our price.
- 1:32:15We can save many of you real money.
- 1:32:17Spend the savings on our other products. 27 Be sure to visit
- 1:32:22the Bookworm. It will carry about 35 books and
- 1:32:25DVDs, among them a couple of new titles.
- 1:32:28Andy Kil Patrick will introduce and be glad to sign the latest
- 1:32:32edition of his all-encompassing coverage of Berkshire.
- 1:32:35It's thirteen O 4 pages and weighs 9.8 lbs.
- 1:32:39My blurb for the book? Ridiculously skimpy.
- 1:32:42Check out Peter Bevelins new book as well.
- 1:32:45Peter has long been a keen observer of Berkshire.
- 1:32:48We will also have a new 20 page longer edition of Berkshire's 50
- 1:32:52year commemorative book that at last years meeting sold 12,000
- 1:32:57copies. Since then Carrie and I have
- 1:32:59uncovered additional material that we find fascinating such as
- 1:33:03some very personal letters sent by Grover Cleveland to Edward
- 1:33:07Butler, his friend and the then publisher of the Buffalo News.
- 1:33:11Nothing from the original edition has been changed or
- 1:33:14eliminated and the price remains $20.
- 1:33:17Charlie and I will jointly sign 100 copies that will be randomly
- 1:33:21placed among the 5000 available for sale at the meeting.
- 1:33:25My friend Philby, Utah has written Limping on Water, an
- 1:33:29autobiography that chronicles his life at Capital Cities
- 1:33:33Communications and tells you a lot about its leaders, Tom
- 1:33:36Murphy and Dan Burke. These two were the best
- 1:33:40managerial duo both and what they accomplished and how they
- 1:33:43did it hat Charlie and I ever witnessed.
- 1:33:46Much of what you become in life depends on whom you choose to
- 1:33:49admire and copy. Start with Tom Murphy and you'll
- 1:33:52never need a second exemplar. Finally, Jeremy Miller has
- 1:33:56written Warren Buffett's Ground Rules, a book that will debut at
- 1:33:59the annual meeting. Mr. Miller has done a superb job
- 1:34:03of researching and dissecting the operation of Buffett
- 1:34:06Partnership Ltd and of explaining how Berkshire's
- 1:34:09culture has evolved from its BPL origin.
- 1:34:12If you are fascinated by investment theory and practice,
- 1:34:16you will enjoy this book. An attachment to the proxy
- 1:34:19material that is enclosed with this report explains how you can
- 1:34:22obtain the credential you will need for admission to both the
- 1:34:25meeting and other events. Airlines have sometimes jacked
- 1:34:28up prices for the Berkshire weekend.
- 1:34:31If you are coming from far away, compare the cost of flying to
- 1:34:34Kansas City versus Omaha. The drive between the two cities
- 1:34:38is about 21 two hours and it may be that Kansas City can save you
- 1:34:43significant money, particularly if you had planned to rent a car
- 1:34:46in Omaha. The savings for a couple could
- 1:34:48run to $1000 or more. Spend that money with us at
- 1:34:52Nebraska Furniture Mart located on a 77 acre site on 72 in D
- 1:34:58Street between Dodge and Pacific.
- 1:35:00We will again be having Berkshire Weekend discount
- 1:35:03pricing. Last year in the week
- 1:35:05encompassing the meeting, the store did a record
- 1:35:08$44,239,493.00 of business. If you repeat that figure to a
- 1:35:15retailer, he is not going to believe you.
- 1:35:17On average week for NFMS Omaha Store, the highest volume home
- 1:35:22furnishing store in the United States, except for our new
- 1:35:25Dallas story is about $9,000,000.
- 1:35:28To obtain the Berkshire discount at NFM, you must make your
- 1:35:31purchases between Tuesday, April 26th TH and Monday, May 2nd ND
- 1:35:37inclusive and also present your meeting credential.
- 1:35:40The period special pricing will even apply to the products of
- 1:35:44several prestigious manufacturers that normally have
- 1:35:47ironclad rules against discounting, but which in the
- 1:35:50spirit of our shareholder weekend have made an exception
- 1:35:54for you. We appreciate their cooperation.
- 1:35:56During Berkshire Weekend, NFM will be open from 10:00 AM to
- 1:36:009:00 PM Monday through Friday, 10:00 AM to 9:30 PM on Saturday,
- 1:36:06Antenna dot m.to 8:00 PM on Sunday from 5 Colon, 30P dot
- 1:36:11m.to 8:00 PM on Saturday, NFM is hosting a picnic to which you
- 1:36:17are all invited. At Borschi IMS we will again
- 1:36:20have two shareholder only events.
- 1:36:22The first will be a cocktail reception from 6:00 PM to 9:00
- 1:36:26PM on Friday, April 29th TH. The second, the main gala, will
- 1:36:31be held on Sunday, May 1st SD from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM.
- 1:36:36On Saturday we will remain open until 6:00 PM.
- 1:36:40During last year's Friday through Sunday stretch, the
- 1:36:43store wrote a sales ticket every 15 seconds that it was open 28.
- 1:36:48We will have huge crowds at Borschi IMS throughout the
- 1:36:51weekend. For your convenience, therefore,
- 1:36:53shareholder prices will be available from Monday, April
- 1:36:5625th TH through Saturday, May 7th TH.
- 1:37:00During that period, please identify yourself as a
- 1:37:04shareholder either by presenting your meeting credential or a
- 1:37:07brokerage statement showing you own our stock.
- 1:37:10On Sunday in the mall outside of Borschi, IMS Norman Beck, a
- 1:37:14remarkable magician from Dallas, well bewilder onlookers on the
- 1:37:18upper level. We will have Bob Ham and and
- 1:37:21Sharon OS Berg, 2 of the world's top bridge experts, available to
- 1:37:25play bridge with our shareholders on Sunday
- 1:37:28afternoon. I will join them and hope to
- 1:37:30have a Jayet and Charlie there also.
- 1:37:33My friend Ariel Shing will be in the mall as well on Sunday,
- 1:37:37taking on challengers at table tennis.
- 1:37:39I met Ariel when she was 9, and even then I was unable to score
- 1:37:43a point against her. Now she's a junior at Princeton,
- 1:37:47having already represented the United States in the 2012
- 1:37:50Olympics. If you don't mind embarrassing
- 1:37:52yourself, test your skills against her.
- 1:37:55Beginning at 1:00 PM. Bill Gates and I will lead off
- 1:37:58and try to S often her up. Gore Otts will again be open
- 1:38:02exclusively for Berkshire shareholders on Sunday, May 1st
- 1:38:05SD, serving from 1:00 PM until 10:00 PM.
- 1:38:09To make a reservation at Gore Otts call 402551 3733 on April
- 1:38:161st SD but not before. As for my other favorite
- 1:38:20restaurant, Piccolos M Sad to report it closed.
- 1:38:23We will again have the same three financial journalists lead
- 1:38:26the question and answer period at the meeting asking Charlie
- 1:38:30and me questions that shareholders have submitted to
- 1:38:32them by e-mail. The journalists and their e-mail
- 1:38:35addresses. R Carol Loomis, the pre eminent
- 1:38:38business journalist of her time, who may be emailed at
- 1:38:42loomisbrkgmail.com, becky.quickofcnbc@berkshirequestioncnbc.com
- 1:38:49and Andrew Ross Sorkin of the New York Times
- 1:38:52addersorkanytimes.com. From the questions submitted,
- 1:38:56each journalist will choose the six he or she decides are the
- 1:39:00most interesting and important. The journalists have told me
- 1:39:03your question has the best chance of being selected if you
- 1:39:06keep it concise. Avoid sending it in at the last
- 1:39:09moment. Make it Berkshire related and
- 1:39:12include no more than two questions in any e-mail you send
- 1:39:15them. In your e-mail, let the
- 1:39:17journalist know if you would like your name mentioned.
- 1:39:19If you're question is asked, an accompanying set of questions
- 1:39:22will be asked by three analysts who follow Berkshire.
- 1:39:26This year the insurance specialist will be Cliff Gallant
- 1:39:29of Nomura Securities. Questions that deal with our non
- 1:39:32insurance operations will come from Jonathan Brandt of Rua
- 1:39:36Northeast. See you in an IFF and Gold Far B
- 1:39:39and Greg Warren of Morningstar. Our hope is that the analysts
- 1:39:43and journalists will ask questions that add to our owners
- 1:39:46understanding and knowledge of their investment.
- 1:39:49Neither Charlie nor I will get so much as a clue about the
- 1:39:52questions headed our way. Some will be tough for sure and
- 1:39:56that's the way we like it. Multi part questions aren't
- 1:39:59allowed. We want to give as many
- 1:40:00questioners as possible a shot at us.
- 1:40:03All told, we expect at least 54 questions.
- 1:40:06Which will allow for six from each analyst and journalist in
- 1:40:10418 from the audience. Last year, we had 64 in total.
- 1:40:15The questioners from the audience will be chosen by means
- 1:40:17of 11 drawings that will take place at 8:15 AM on the morning
- 1:40:22of the annual meeting. Each of the 11 microphones
- 1:40:25installed in the arena and main overflow room will host, so to
- 1:40:29speak, a drawing 29. While I'm on the subject of our
- 1:40:33owners gaining knowledge, let me remind you that Charlie and I
- 1:40:37believe all shareholders should simultaneously have access to
- 1:40:40new information that Berkshire releases and, if possible,
- 1:40:44should also have adequate time to digest and analyze it before
- 1:40:48any trading takes place. That's why we try to issue
- 1:40:52financial data late on Fridays or early on Saturdays and why
- 1:40:56our annual meeting is always held on a Saturday.
- 1:40:59We do not follow the common practice of talking one-on-one
- 1:41:02with large institutional investors or analysts, treating
- 1:41:06them instead as we do all other shareholders.
- 1:41:09There. Is noon more important to us
- 1:41:11than the shareholder of limited means who trusts us with a
- 1:41:14substantial portion of his savings.
- 1:41:17For good reason, I regularly extol the accomplishments of our
- 1:41:20operating managers. They are truly All Stars who run
- 1:41:24their businesses as if they were the only asset owned by their
- 1:41:27families. I also believe the mindset of
- 1:41:29our managers to be a shareholder oriented as can be found in the
- 1:41:33universe of large publicly owned companies.
- 1:41:36Most of our managers have no financial need to work.
- 1:41:40The joy of hitting business home runs means as much to them as
- 1:41:44their paycheck. Equally important, however, are
- 1:41:47the 24 men and women who work with me at our corporate office.
- 1:41:51This The group efficiently deals with a multitude of SEC and
- 1:41:55other regulatory requirements. Files a 30,400 page federal
- 1:42:00income tax return that's up 6000 pages from the prior year.
- 1:42:05Overseas, the filing of 3530 state tax returns.
- 1:42:10Responds to countless shareholder and media inquiries.
- 1:42:13Gets out the annual report. Prepares for the country's
- 1:42:16largest annual meeting, coordinates the board's
- 1:42:19activities, fact checks this letter, and the list goes on and
- 1:42:23on. They handle all of these
- 1:42:25business tasks cheerfully and with unbelievable efficiency,
- 1:42:28making my life easy and pleasant.
- 1:42:31Their efforts go beyond activities strictly related to
- 1:42:34Berkshire. Last year, for example, they
- 1:42:37dealt with the 40 universities selected from 200 applicants who
- 1:42:41sent students to Omaha for AQ and a day with me.
- 1:42:44They also handle all kinds of requests that I receive to
- 1:42:48arrange my travel and even get me hamburgers and French fries
- 1:42:52smothered in Heinz ketchup. Of course, for lunch, no CEO has
- 1:42:56it better. I truly do feel like tap dancing
- 1:42:58to work every day. In fact, my job becomes more fun
- 1:43:02every year. In 2015, Berkshire's revenues
- 1:43:06increased by $16 billion. Look carefully, however, at the
- 1:43:11two pictures on the facing page. The top one is from last year's
- 1:43:15report and shows the entire Berkshire Home Office crew at
- 1:43:18our Christmas lunch. Below that photo is this year's
- 1:43:21Christmas photo portraying the same 25 people identically
- 1:43:26positioned in 2015. No one joined us, no one left,
- 1:43:30and the odds are good that you will see a photo of the same 25
- 1:43:34next year. Can you imagine another very
- 1:43:37large company who employ 361,270 people worldwide enjoying that
- 1:43:42kind of employment stability? At headquarters at Berkshire we
- 1:43:46have hired some wonderful people and they have stayed with us.
- 1:43:50Moreover, no one is hired unless he or she is truly needed.
- 1:43:53That's why you've never read about restructuring charges at
- 1:43:56Berkshire on April 30th TH. Come to Omaha, the cradle of
- 1:44:01capitalism, and meet my gang. They are the best.
- 1:44:04February 272016 Warren E Buffett, Chairman of the board,
- 1:44:1030 Front. Robeck, IA Mick Sharon Heck,
- 1:44:13Melissa Hawk, Jalyn Abu SSE. Warren Buffett, Angie Wells,
- 1:44:18Elisa Krueger Debray Carries Ova Ellen Schmidt Back Row Tracy
- 1:44:23Britt Cool Jennifer Seylentes, Ted We S Siehler, Joanne
- 1:44:27Manhart, Bob Rees On Todd Combs, Dan Jack Sich, Debbie Bossinek,
- 1:44:33Mark Sisley, Mark Hamburg, Kerby Ham, Mark Millard, Allison
- 1:44:38Ballard, Stacy Gottschalk, Tiffany Voe KT.