Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Using Dungeons and Dragons to Become a Better Litigator
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Dungeons and Dragons to become a better
- 0:06litigator. I am Laurie Critt -Martin, past vice
- 0:10chair of the Beverly Hills Bar litigation section
- 0:12and a certified family law specialist. I'm delighted
- 0:16to introduce our speaker today, Derek Carmen.
- 0:19Derek Carmen is a legal director at Sen. Sertum
- 0:22Group, where he focuses on patent underwriting
- 0:25and supports the company's IP finance platform,
- 0:29including licensing, litigation, funding, and
- 0:31acquisitions. A registered patent attorney with
- 0:34over a decade of experience in patent litigation
- 0:37and prosecution, Derek previously spent nine
- 0:40years as a partner in the IP litigation group
- 0:43at Robin's Kaplan LLP, representing clients in
- 0:47high stakes patent and trade secret disputes
- 0:50across medical, across technologies ranging from
- 0:54software and LTE, 3G to medical devices and laser
- 0:59technology. And now let's get started. All right.
- 1:04Thank you so much, Lori. Just get my slides up.
- 1:30Alright, well hello everyone and thank you and
- 1:33welcome to Using Dungeons and Dragons to Become
- 1:36a Better Litigator. I want to start by giving
- 1:40some background on where this program came from.
- 1:44Some of you attending may be aware that I wrote
- 1:47an article for Law 360 a couple of years ago
- 1:51entitled Playing Dungeons and Dragons Makes Me
- 1:53a Better Lawyer. This program evolved out of
- 1:56that article and through conversations with the
- 2:00Beverly Hills Bar Association. So before we begin,
- 2:03I just want to thank the folks at BHBA for their
- 2:07outreach and support. I'll start by giving you
- 2:13my D &D and legal bona fides so that you know
- 2:17I've got some authority to talk about these sorts
- 2:20of things. So I've basically been a nerd my whole
- 2:23life and a professional one for over 15 years.
- 2:27My undergraduate degree is in physics. I then
- 2:31went directly to law school after which I spent
- 2:34four years drafting patent applications. I then
- 2:38spent the next decade litigating primarily patent
- 2:42suits up until this past May in federal and state
- 2:47courts as well as the International Trade Commission
- 2:50and the U .S. Patent and Trademark Office. In
- 2:54May I transitioned to Servum Group, which is
- 2:56a litigation funder where I run the firm's underwriting
- 3:00on intellectual property cases. So now my job
- 3:03is to diligence potential cases on their merits
- 3:07as well as to evaluate counsel on their litigation
- 3:10strategies. My D &D experience is a little more
- 3:14straightforward. I've been playing D &D since
- 3:17I was in middle school and For those of you who
- 3:21are familiar with the various editions of the
- 3:23game, I started playing in third edition and
- 3:26we are now on the fifth edition of The Rules.
- 3:30I've also been running games for five years as
- 3:33what D &D calls the Dungeon Master or is more
- 3:37generally known as the Game Master. And this
- 3:39means that I run everything in the world that
- 3:42isn't my player's characters. It includes the
- 3:45environment, any monsters that they fight, any
- 3:48non -player characters, etc. So why this program?
- 3:53Why draw parallels between D &D and litigation?
- 3:59Well, despite Majoring in a scientific discipline,
- 4:03I attended a liberal arts school and have always
- 4:06appreciated how certain tools and ideas can cross
- 4:09-pollinate to make us better at seemingly unrelated
- 4:12tasks. For example, when I was a kid, D &D made
- 4:17me better at arithmetic because it involves repeated,
- 4:20rapid math. It also helped my development of
- 4:24social skills, how to start conversations, how
- 4:27to listen and react to others. And later I used
- 4:30it to draw parallels with my career path as a
- 4:34litigator. So I've been using D &D as a skill
- 4:37development tool for most of my life. And I think
- 4:41D &D is such a versatile tool because the players
- 4:45collectively define the world. So players can
- 4:49use D &D as a tool to develop both hard skills
- 4:52and soft skills. Hard skills like rule interpretation,
- 4:56are directly applicable across the barrier of
- 5:00D &D and legal practice. Softer skills like storytelling
- 5:04and persuasion come through more subtle pattern
- 5:09recognition over time. Finally, I think that
- 5:14people don't spend enough time thinking about
- 5:16how we as humans play and we all engage in play
- 5:20in one way or another. and how the ways in which
- 5:23we play connect with the other aspects of our
- 5:26lives. So on the whole, this program will hopefully
- 5:30get you thinking about the ways in which your
- 5:33life outside of litigation can apply directly
- 5:35to your practice. We're going to focus on D &D,
- 5:39but the exercise is more widely applicable. Here
- 5:45are the main areas that I'd like you to take
- 5:47away at the end of the program. First, we're
- 5:51going to talk about rules. Lawyers know all about
- 5:54rules, of course, but in D &D, there is literally
- 5:57a term sometimes used pejoratively for someone
- 6:00that knows the rules really well, and that term
- 6:03is a rules lawyer. So we'll talk a bit about
- 6:08the parallels between D &D rules and the rules
- 6:10encountered in litigation practice. We'll also
- 6:14talk about case theory and narrative. The best
- 6:18litigators tell a compelling story. They use
- 6:21the facts and the law as tools to aid in their
- 6:24storytelling. Similarly, the best D &D players
- 6:27have appreciation for good narrative, including
- 6:29setting, pacing, conflict, promise, and payoff.
- 6:35We'll talk a little bit about negotiation and
- 6:37how you can use D &D as a way to practice good
- 6:40negotiation skills. We'll talk about ambiguity
- 6:45and persuasion, because that's oftentimes where
- 6:47we as litigators find ourselves arguing. The
- 6:50rules aren't always black and white or clear
- 6:52cut, and we have to argue the gray. We'll talk
- 6:57a little bit about improvisation. D &D is a collaborative
- 7:00storytelling game, and one aspect of that game
- 7:03is making snap decisions in the face of the unexpected.
- 7:07There's a dice component to D &D and you don't
- 7:09know what the dice are going to do until they're
- 7:11rolled. You have to react appropriately. Lastly,
- 7:16we'll talk about lessons you can take away from
- 7:18D &D about creating and running effective teams.
- 7:28Here's a brief breakdown of the amount of time
- 7:29I'll spend on each topic. It's not a hard and
- 7:32fast rule. I'll probably spend a little bit more
- 7:34time on the rules and case narrative than on
- 7:37the later sections, but I'm going to do my best
- 7:40to try to balance the time as effectively as
- 7:43I can. All right. So first, we're going to talk
- 7:52about rules. I mentioned a moment ago about the
- 7:55concept of a rules lawyer. A rules lawyer in
- 7:58D &D parlance is a player that knows the rules
- 8:01incredibly well. They can get into trouble sometimes
- 8:04if they're seen as using the rules in a way that
- 8:07breaks the game or as a way that harms the narrative.
- 8:11But what we're going to focus on are the parallels
- 8:14between how D &D and the court system organize
- 8:17their rules as well as how the rules can be viewed
- 8:20to create gray areas in which creative application
- 8:23can be used to your client's advantage. The first
- 8:32and I think one of the most important parts of
- 8:36understanding the rules is that you have to know
- 8:39where the rules come from. I was always surprised
- 8:43when I was litigating cases how many people didn't
- 8:46bother to read the applicable rules early and
- 8:50often in a case. No one can have a perfect knowledge
- 8:55of the rules in all situations, but the better
- 8:59you know them, the better off you'll be. At a
- 9:03fundamental level, knowing what the sources are
- 9:06and how they are organized is critical. In D
- 9:09&D, there are three main sources of rules. First,
- 9:13you have the rule books. This seems obvious,
- 9:16but the rule books tell us the basic rules of
- 9:20the game, both procedurally and substantively.
- 9:23There's a bit of a distinction on the legal side
- 9:25between procedural and substantive rules that
- 9:27we'll talk about in a second. In D &D, they're
- 9:30all treated in the same books. They tell us who
- 9:33can do what and when, as well as what the substantive
- 9:36effects of those actions are. These can include
- 9:40things like spells you can cast, rules for combat,
- 9:43character abilities, ways to engage in negotiations,
- 9:48feats, which are specific category of abilities
- 9:50in Dungeons and Dragons. On the lawyering side
- 9:55of the equation, we have separate sets of substantive
- 9:58and procedural rules. Substantively, We have
- 10:03statutes, case law, regulations, etc. Procedurally,
- 10:09we have the rules of procedure and evidence.
- 10:15Similarly, the substantive rules on the legal
- 10:17side sort of tell us what happens in a given
- 10:20circumstance. The procedural rules tell us who
- 10:23can do what and when. How do you ask for certain
- 10:27relief from the court? Next in D &D, we have
- 10:30something called house rules. House rules are
- 10:34specific rules used by a dungeon master that
- 10:37either add to or alter the rules from the rule
- 10:41books. A famous house rule in D &D is called
- 10:45rolling for resurrection. Ordinarily in Dungeons
- 10:49and Dragons, a character that is the subject
- 10:51of a resurrection spell. The character has died.
- 10:54One of his compatriots wants to bring him back
- 10:56to life. They would cast a spell with certain
- 10:59components to do so. And the rule simply says
- 11:04that the spell works and the character is returned
- 11:06to life. That can be a little unsatisfying sometimes.
- 11:10So there's a house rule that was made famous
- 11:12by a dungeon master named Matthew Mercer, who
- 11:16is very well known in the D &D community, and
- 11:19he requires his players to make a roll of the
- 11:22die before their spell succeeds. And if they
- 11:26roll poorly, the resurrection fails. and the
- 11:29character remains dead. This is used as a tool
- 11:32by him to add tension and narrative stakes to
- 11:37any character action that might result in a death.
- 11:40It's not simply a given that that character can
- 11:42come back to life. So that's one specific house
- 11:47rule. On the legal side, we have house rules
- 11:49as well. We have local rules that courts and
- 11:53judges, individual rules of practice, they implement
- 11:57to govern how practice is performed in their
- 12:01particular courts or in their individual courtrooms.
- 12:07Like the house rules in Dungeons and Dragons,
- 12:10courts and judges use the local and individual
- 12:12rules to add to or alter the procedural rules
- 12:16governing the court. Although less dramatic than
- 12:21the Rolling for Resurrection rule, a common individual
- 12:24rule would be to limit page lengths of certain
- 12:27motions, or perhaps the number or types of summary
- 12:31judgment motions that can be filed with the court.
- 12:34Either way, it is imperative for lawyers to know
- 12:37the rules and know the local rules of the court
- 12:41that they are practicing in and abide by them.
- 12:43There is no faster way to anger a judge or to
- 12:46turn them hostile to you than by ignoring their
- 12:49own individual rules that they have put time
- 12:52and effort into crafting for their court. Lastly,
- 12:58there's another rule that is maybe a little more
- 13:01of a guideline than a hard and fast rule, but
- 13:05it has an analog between D &D and litigation.
- 13:08And that rule is called the Rule of Cool. In
- 13:12D &D, the rule says that at the dungeon master's
- 13:17discretion, a player may attempt something that
- 13:20is not strictly allowed by the rules because
- 13:24it would meaningfully add to the game experience.
- 13:30An example of this might be a player is trying
- 13:33to jump further than the rules strictly allow
- 13:37them to. in order to grab onto a ledge and avoid
- 13:40falling to a catastrophic death. The Dungeon
- 13:45Master could permit the player to make a roll
- 13:47just to see if it would be successful because
- 13:51a player making a dramatic dive and save is much
- 13:55more fun for the players and serves the narrative
- 13:59better than simply falling to their doom without
- 14:02any chance to save themselves. Litigation has
- 14:08a similar rule of cool. They use a little bit
- 14:11different language, as you might expect, but
- 14:14these rules are typically governed by judicial
- 14:17discretion. Some of the key words that I look
- 14:20for when I'm looking for a rule of cool opportunity
- 14:24in litigation are things like in the interest
- 14:27of justice. The name sounds almost as dramatic
- 14:31as rule of cool, but the application is accompanied
- 14:37usually by a negotiation with the judge in the
- 14:40case of judicial discretion or with the DM in
- 14:44the case of rule of cool. The player needs to
- 14:47persuade the DM that the rule should be broken
- 14:49or suspended for a good reason. After all, for
- 14:53constantly breaking and suspending rules, we
- 14:55aren't really playing a game. Similarly, making
- 14:59arguments in practice sometimes relies on a negotiation
- 15:03with the judge. Examples include any time you
- 15:07can do something in the interest of justice,
- 15:10such as requesting leave to file a reply or a
- 15:14sur -reply when one is not otherwise allowed
- 15:17by the rules. Perhaps you want to amend your
- 15:20pleadings late in the case. You need to convince
- 15:23the judge that you've discovered some cool new
- 15:25facts that warrant the amendment. So the rule
- 15:28of cool applies across the board between the
- 15:32game world and practice and the way that these
- 15:36rules are organized with the substantive and
- 15:40procedural rules at the top, the rule books at
- 15:43the top, modified by house rules and local rules
- 15:47and individual rules of practice and then the
- 15:50sort of situational rules for the rule of cool
- 15:54and judicial discretion. There are discrete parallels
- 15:59between those two that help me in my brain organize
- 16:03where I'm at in the hierarchy of rules and how
- 16:06best to put those rules into use for my clients.
- 16:16Knowing the rules should be table stakes, but
- 16:18as I mentioned before, I was constantly surprised
- 16:22how many attorneys failed to familiarize themselves
- 16:25with the rules. And that could be anyone from
- 16:28The lead trial counsel not knowing the rules
- 16:31all the way down. Everybody on a team has responsibility
- 16:34to know the rules at all times. That's true in
- 16:36D &D. It's true in litigation. But what does
- 16:42knowing the rules really get you? Sure, sometimes
- 16:45you get the opportunity to build goodwill with
- 16:47the judge by assisting them when your opponent
- 16:50fails to follow the rules. But I think the real
- 16:53magic comes when you know and understand both
- 16:57what the rules teach and what they don't. This
- 17:01is where creative D &D moments come in and great
- 17:04lawyering is born. Take, for example, the possibility
- 17:10that in Dungeons & Dragons your party has a rogue
- 17:13and that rogue's job is to pick a lock. If he
- 17:18fails that check, the party could just pack up
- 17:21and go home. Or your barbarian, your big strong
- 17:26monster of a character, can go into a rage and
- 17:31run headfirst into the door over and over until
- 17:33it breaks. It's not strictly speaking within
- 17:36the rules of a barbarian's rage, but it'll get
- 17:39the job done, and it's an interesting application
- 17:42of a gray area of a rule. Similarly, courts accept
- 17:46and apply gray area arguments all the time. Perhaps
- 17:50the best example is when a court takes a theory
- 17:52of liability or damages from one area of the
- 17:56law and applies it to another. So let's look
- 18:03at how to argue these ambiguous rules and work
- 18:08in this gray area and I'll take the example of
- 18:12persuading a game master and the example of persuading
- 18:15a judge and put them side by side so that we
- 18:18can see how the These frameworks and processes
- 18:21work across both spectra. So working in the space
- 18:27between rules, whether you want a DM to allow
- 18:30some creative action or you want a judge to adopt
- 18:34your novel legal theory, it follows the same
- 18:36pattern. First, we always start with the applicable
- 18:40rule in its truest form. In D &D, we refer to
- 18:44this as the RAW, R -A -W, which stands for rule
- 18:48as written. And it's, plainly speaking, it's
- 18:51a textualist approach to rules interpretation.
- 18:55It assumes that the rule creators meant what
- 18:58they wrote and nothing more or less. But that
- 19:02doesn't end the process at the table or in court,
- 19:06knowing why the rule exists, what its underlying
- 19:10purpose or policy is, and why it is generally
- 19:13a good rule but might have limitations is an
- 19:18opportunity to argue for its extension into an
- 19:22area that it doesn't strictly cover. So we as
- 19:28litigators and as D &D players should pay attention
- 19:30to any commentary or errata. In the case of D
- 19:34&D, as we'll see in just a moment, the game designers
- 19:36actually often weigh in on the scope of the rules
- 19:40after the rulebooks have been published. Similarly,
- 19:45courts refine their local rules. Statutes are
- 19:48amended. Rules of procedure are refined, and
- 19:51comments explaining those refinements are published
- 19:53in new editions. These sources of additional
- 19:57clarity can provide persuasive weight to your
- 20:00arguments. You can cite persuasive authority
- 20:03from other games or other courts. I mentioned
- 20:06Matthew Mercer earlier. If I tell my dungeon
- 20:09master that Matthew Mercer rules in a certain
- 20:11way, that is persuasive support that my dungeon
- 20:15master should adopt a similar interpretation
- 20:17of the rule. Once you've laid out the literal
- 20:21text and purpose of the rule, you have the pieces
- 20:25to extend the rule according to its purpose into
- 20:28a new application. So let's look at a case study.
- 20:31I'll do two, one from D &D and then one from
- 20:34the legal field. So let's consider this spell
- 20:39from Dungeons and Dragons called Liamen's Tiny
- 20:42Hut. In D &D, there's a spell called Liamen's
- 20:46Tiny Hut, and the spell description is here on
- 20:49the screen in its entirety. In essence, the spell
- 20:53creates a small dome. It's 10 feet in diameter
- 20:56that centers around the spellcaster. Any creatures
- 21:00that are inside the hut, when the spell is cast,
- 21:04can move within the hut, and they can move through
- 21:06the barrier of the hut. But no creature on the
- 21:09outside can pass into the hut. The spell description
- 21:14tells us that within the hut, it's comfortable
- 21:17and dry, regardless of the weather on the outside.
- 21:23Lehman's tiny hut is effectively a super tent.
- 21:25The spell's description lends itself to the normal
- 21:28application of providing the adventurers a safe
- 21:31area to sleep at night without worrying about
- 21:33being attacked during their rest. Alternatively,
- 21:37the spell's barrier, permitting creatures and
- 21:40objects within to pass outward but not vice versa,
- 21:44seems to make the Tiny Hut an effective defensive
- 21:46bunker from which adventurers can fire arrows
- 21:49at enemies while being protected from return
- 21:53fire. These are both literal applications of
- 21:56Lima's tiny hut that are directly addressed by
- 21:59the rule itself. But consider this situation.
- 22:04Party of adventurers have been captured by pirates.
- 22:06The pirates tie the party together along with
- 22:09weights and prepare to toss them overboard. Party's
- 22:12rogue can pick the locks on their bonds, but
- 22:15it'll take some time. So the party's wizard tells
- 22:18them that they have a plan once they all sink
- 22:21to the bottom. When the party hits the bottom,
- 22:24the wizard casts Lehman's tiny hut around them.
- 22:27So here's the question. Can Lehman's tiny hut
- 22:30be used to form an air pocket when cast underwater?
- 22:36The rule does not really say one way or the other.
- 22:40The closest description is that the atmosphere
- 22:43inside the emanation is comfortable and dry,
- 22:47regardless of the weather outside. In the camping
- 22:51sense, this makes sense. You can use the spell
- 22:54to keep the rain off you and get a good night's
- 22:56sleep. But can you really expel ocean water to
- 23:00create an air pocket? I would argue that this
- 23:04is a creative but permissible use of the spell.
- 23:08We know from the purpose of the rule that it
- 23:10is meant to protect players. It has environmental
- 23:15properties for their defense, including creating
- 23:18a warm and dry environment and preventing objects
- 23:22from outside the hut encroaching inside, such
- 23:25as water. This application matches the purpose
- 23:29of the rule. One argument, however, could be
- 23:33that the hut simply creates a dome and water
- 23:36could still get in from underneath. This would
- 23:41be an area where it would be helpful to know
- 23:43what the game designers had in mind when they
- 23:46designed the rule. And people have actually asked
- 23:49them that. So Jeremy Crawford is a name you see
- 23:54here. He was the lead game designer on the fifth
- 23:57edition of Dungeons & Dragons, and he used to
- 24:01field questions on Twitter at X, later X, and
- 24:06someone actually asked about the shape of Liam's
- 24:08tiny hut. They asked Jeremy Crawford if Lehman's
- 24:12tiny hut has a floor. Jeremy initially answered
- 24:16no, saying that the spell simply creates a dome.
- 24:21But then he actually changed his answer once
- 24:23he went back and looked at the rule, finding
- 24:25that the description in the book describes the
- 24:27effect as hemispherical, which he interpreted
- 24:31then to mean that it does indeed have a floor.
- 24:35So here's another example of using the rule and
- 24:39information from the rule drafter that they refined
- 24:42after the fact and commented on in real time
- 24:47in a way that's useful for the players to achieve
- 24:49their goal. Looking at this context on top of
- 24:53the purposes of Liam's Tiny Hut, I would say
- 24:55one could put together a pretty good case that
- 24:59casting the spell underwater provides an air
- 25:02pocket for the players and they can achieve their
- 25:04goal. So let's look at a legal analog then to
- 25:08this gray area sort of argument. I'm gonna look
- 25:13at Griswold versus Connecticut, which for those
- 25:17of you who are a few years out of law school,
- 25:20is a case from 1965 that dealt with attempts
- 25:26by Connecticut to outlaw the use of contraceptives,
- 25:30including by married couples. The Griswolds challenged
- 25:34the law, advancing a constitutional argument
- 25:37that the proposed law violated their right to
- 25:40privacy. Now, since we're all lawyers and hopefully
- 25:47don't live under a rock, we know that the Constitution
- 25:49does not include and express right to privacy.
- 25:53So the Griswolds found themselves in a bit of
- 25:55a gray area. Where there's no express rule on
- 25:58point, what could they do? They focused on the
- 26:04purpose of the amendments to the Constitution
- 26:07and pieced together a case for extending the
- 26:11protections of the Constitution to an area in
- 26:14which they found themselves. The argument was
- 26:17successful, and we can track the pathways I discussed
- 26:20earlier through the excerpts on the slide here.
- 26:25These are excerpts from the decision itself,
- 26:27and we can track the course reasoning. First,
- 26:30The court acknowledged that the Constitution
- 26:32does not expressly address a number of rights
- 26:35that have been recognized as protected. Then
- 26:39the court extrapolates those various findings
- 26:41to a general rule, which it calls a penumbra
- 26:45where privacy is protected from government intrusion.
- 26:48It then shortens that to what it calls a zone
- 26:50of privacy. Finally, the court applies the zone
- 26:56of privacy doctrine to the specific facts in
- 26:59this case. And it focused on the maximum destructive
- 27:05impact on that relationship, that relationship
- 27:08being the marital relationship to conclude that
- 27:11the law cannot stand. So whether your party is
- 27:15trying to breathe underwater or you're trying
- 27:17to expand a constitutional right to privacy,
- 27:21the same gray area argument structure can apply.
- 27:24Focus on the rule as written, acknowledge its
- 27:27limitations, draw from related areas of the law,
- 27:33and make your case to the judge for a reasonable
- 27:36extension to your particular facts. Next, we'll
- 27:45spend a little time on the storytelling aspects
- 27:48of D &D and litigation. In particular, we'll
- 27:52focus on preparation, for the quote unquote episodes
- 27:56of the game, as well as the sessions of litigation,
- 28:01which are arguments typically. In the case of
- 28:04D &D, preparing for game sessions, which are
- 28:07typically a few hours in length. And on the litigation
- 28:10side, we'll talk about preparing for hearings
- 28:12and arguments before a court. The first thing
- 28:18to think about is just a mental framework. In
- 28:21D &D, a campaign is a connected string of adventures.
- 28:26They may single around an overarching narrative
- 28:30and world, or the only linking component may
- 28:35be that the players themselves are the same.
- 28:45First point that I'd like to stress is that the
- 28:48Game Master isn't winging the world most of the
- 28:51time. Sometimes they are. But in general, the
- 28:55best campaigns that I've played in have been
- 28:57very well thought out in advance. And the same
- 29:01is held true with the cases that I've worked
- 29:03on. The strongest cases that I've been able to
- 29:07put together were very intentionally designed
- 29:10from the outset. Obviously you can't... plan
- 29:15for every contingency in a case, but establishing
- 29:17a clear narrative early in the case shows the
- 29:21court and the opponent that you're serious and
- 29:24that you mean business. To that end, every fact
- 29:28should have a job in the case. Just like every
- 29:31non -player character in a game serves some purpose,
- 29:35even if that purpose is just to flesh out the
- 29:37fictional world. We used to talk about storytelling
- 29:40facts when I was a litigator. What are the facts
- 29:42that make a compelling story, but perhaps don't
- 29:46fit into the legal test, strictly speaking. Every
- 29:51fact has a role, whether it's in the legal test
- 29:54or just a narrative fact. And drawing on our
- 29:58previous section, remember that ambiguities are
- 30:00not threats, they are opportunities. As far as
- 30:09storytelling goes, I think it's important for
- 30:12attorneys to know how to read the room and for
- 30:16Dungeon Masters to know how to read the table.
- 30:19There's another well -known Dungeon Master named
- 30:21Brennan Lee Mulligan, who once explained that
- 30:24when a player asked him if he had had fun as
- 30:27a DM, his response was to reverse the question
- 30:31and to ask the player if they had had fun. The
- 30:34point being that from his perspective, if the
- 30:37player had fun, then he had fun. Thus, to have
- 30:42more fun as dungeon master, he needed to be aware
- 30:45of how his players were feeling. And I think
- 30:47the same analysis can hold true when you're trying
- 30:51to determine whether you are being an effective
- 30:54advocate or not. You are an effective advocate
- 30:57if the judge and the jury are listening to and
- 31:00engaged with what you're saying and appear to
- 31:03be on your side. If you want to have a good time
- 31:06as an advocate, be primarily concerned with how
- 31:10the judge and jury are feeling about what you're
- 31:13presenting, and do your best to tailor your presentation
- 31:16to ensure that they are positively reacting to
- 31:19your message. If they're not, you may want to
- 31:23tweak what you're focusing on or how you're presenting
- 31:25it. You should be aware of pacing. While the
- 31:30best trial lawyers are not over -the -top showmen,
- 31:32they can subtly build tension and payoff in a
- 31:35way that holds the jury's attention. When I DM
- 31:40for my players, I adjust and bend the narrative
- 31:43to what the players are showing interest in.
- 31:45Similarly, when I would litigate, I tried to
- 31:48focus on the issues and theories that were gaining
- 31:51traction with the judge and jury. The judge seemed
- 31:54fixated on a particular legal argument. That's
- 31:56where I would spend my time. So let's look at
- 32:04how to prepare for an argument using the Dungeon
- 32:09Master Guide's framework for preparing a session
- 32:12in one hour. Obviously, we'll all be preparing
- 32:16for arguments over a greater time period for
- 32:19one hour, but we'll use this sort of one -hour
- 32:21framework to build our structure. We'll take
- 32:28this step -by -step, and I'll bounce back and
- 32:30forth between the D &D context and the argument
- 32:33context. So step one in the D &D context is focusing
- 32:38on the big picture. What story are you trying
- 32:40to tell? What are the overarching themes and
- 32:43plot points? Can we distill this information
- 32:46down to a bulleted list? Similarly, in the litigation
- 32:52context, you need to know your theory of the
- 32:55case, how the specific issues you're arguing
- 32:58fit into that overarching case narrative, and
- 33:01this involves rereading any relevant pleadings,
- 33:04and emotion papers, and generating a bulleted
- 33:07list of the key facts and issues. Step two, as
- 33:15a DM, we're planning encounters for players.
- 33:18That's fundamentally our job. These could be
- 33:21combat encounters where the players fight monsters.
- 33:24They could be social encounters where the players
- 33:26must converse with non -player characters. Exploration
- 33:30encounters where they have to unlock puzzles
- 33:32or disarm traps. But in step two, you're identifying
- 33:35primarily which encounters are going to come
- 33:40up and categorize them by the priority. They
- 33:42might be definite, they might be possible, they
- 33:45might be unlikely. You can take the same tactic
- 33:49with preparing for an argument. We're going to
- 33:53identify the specific counter arguments and questions
- 33:56that we could potentially face from the court
- 33:59in opposing counsel. Like in the D &D scenario,
- 34:03I like to categorize the arguments into definite,
- 34:06possible, and unlikely. Here we have a bit of
- 34:11a leg up because the parties in the litigation
- 34:14will have to submit motion papers prior to the
- 34:17argument most of the time. But there are still
- 34:20occasionally curveballs where the judge could
- 34:23latch on to a throwaway argument in the papers
- 34:26and spends the entire hour of the argument focused
- 34:29on that one issue. Regardless, I like the categorization
- 34:34method because it allows me to triage my limited
- 34:36prep time. In step three, you're gathering the
- 34:45materials you need for all the definite and possible
- 34:48encounters. In D &D, this could be maps, miniatures,
- 34:52dice, sheets that describe the monsters or the
- 34:56traps so that you know what sort of roles they
- 34:59might need to make. But the important thing here
- 35:02is you're focusing on what matters most, recognizing
- 35:05that we will always have a limited amount of
- 35:08time. In step three, we're not doing anything
- 35:11with the unlikely encounters. We're only focused
- 35:13on the definite and the possible encounters.
- 35:22The same tactic holds true in litigation. You
- 35:25can gather your materials to address the definite
- 35:27and possible arguments. This includes cases,
- 35:32any demonstratives needed. It could include a
- 35:34slide deck to illustrate the point. I recall
- 35:38in one case I had, we had an argument over a
- 35:41balancing test for sovereign immunity. And we
- 35:44built an animated scale in our PowerPoint so
- 35:46that after we analyzed every factor, we could
- 35:49drop the factor onto one side of the scale and
- 35:51show that it outweighed the opposing side's arguments
- 35:55and the judge should rule in our favor. In step
- 36:04four, this is really a synthesis step. Thinking
- 36:08about anticipating player reactions, how does
- 36:12each encounter relate to your players, their
- 36:14goals and motivations, and their abilities. This
- 36:18is going to help you gauge your player reaction.
- 36:21If you put them into a scenario where they don't
- 36:24have any useful abilities to help them, they're
- 36:27not gonna have very much fun because they're
- 36:28not going to feel very useful. Similarly, in
- 36:33the litigation context, thinking about how your
- 36:36cases and your facts fit in with your case narrative
- 36:39and synthesizing those facts and arguments together
- 36:43is what's going to create the most persuasive
- 36:47presentation for your judge and your jury. You
- 36:50can consider how this information is likely to
- 36:52play with the judge. And finally, step five,
- 36:59we'll spend a little bit of time just skimming
- 37:01the encounters that were flagged as possible.
- 37:04Same is true on the litigation side. Spend a
- 37:07little time at the end flagging the counter arguments
- 37:09in cases that you identified as possible so that
- 37:14you are prepared should the argument not go as
- 37:18expected. In section three, we can talk a little
- 37:29bit about the social aspect of D &D and litigation
- 37:32through the context of negotiation. I will note
- 37:36that there are libraries filled with books on
- 37:40negotiation tactics, and this is in no way meant
- 37:43to replace or even really scratch the surface
- 37:46of those repositories of information. But D &D
- 37:50can be an effective tool for practicing. the
- 37:54analysis underlying negotiation theories. In
- 38:00my mind, I always have a negotiation checklist,
- 38:03whether I'm at the D &D table or the settlement
- 38:06negotiation table. I follow a basic checklist
- 38:10that includes the following. What does the other
- 38:13side actually want? This seems like an obvious
- 38:18question to ask, but a lot of people are so focused
- 38:21on what their side wants they forget to consider
- 38:24what the other side is actually trying to get.
- 38:27And crucially, I think you have to consider what
- 38:29they actually want, which could be different
- 38:32from what they say they want. Two is knowing
- 38:38what you have to offer. We're always giving something
- 38:41up at the table. So we need to know what we're
- 38:45willing to give up and what we're not willing
- 38:47to give up ahead of time. This dovetails with
- 38:50Step number four, which is knowing how much is
- 38:53too much to give up, and you can set your floors
- 38:56and your ceilings before the negotiation starts,
- 38:59not during it. Number three, consider your leverage.
- 39:04What are the things that you know that the other
- 39:06side doesn't? Oftentimes to be effective in negotiations,
- 39:11these can be the what are called known unknowns.
- 39:16for the other side where they are aware that
- 39:19they don't know something that you do. But what's
- 39:26the upshot here is the same analysis and framework
- 39:29is applicable whether you are at the D &D table
- 39:33haggling with the devil or discussing a settlement
- 39:36with opposing counsel. So let's just consider
- 39:41some case studies once again around We'll do
- 39:46one in Dungeons and Dragons and one in Litigation
- 39:49so we can see how these common concepts apply.
- 39:55Let's set a scenario where a local baron wants
- 39:58an artifact from a nearby temple. This is a straightforward
- 40:01statement of what the other side, the baron,
- 40:04wants. What does the party have to offer? Let's
- 40:09suppose they have in their possession a map of
- 40:12the temple. What do we know that the Baron doesn't?
- 40:19The Baron doesn't know that he's in competition
- 40:21with a neighboring noble who also seeks the artifact.
- 40:26The party can use this information during the
- 40:28negotiation. For example, they could reveal that
- 40:30they have a competing offer for the map or reveal
- 40:33the existence of the competition but not the
- 40:35identity of the other Baron. Lastly, the party
- 40:39can decide that they have a floor or a ceiling.
- 40:43They're not willing to turn over the map. that
- 40:45could be a non -negotiable for them, but they
- 40:48are willing to use their possession of it as
- 40:50leverage to negotiate a favorable deal for themselves.
- 40:54For example, they can negotiate a deal in which
- 40:57they get to keep anything that they recover from
- 41:00the temple while retrieving the artifact for
- 41:03the baron. Now, looking at a possible settlement
- 41:11negotiation in legal context, we can see in the
- 41:15same framework at play. Let's suppose we know
- 41:20that the other side wants to resolve a litigation
- 41:23because it's causing problems in a merger negotiation
- 41:26for them. We have a lot to offer because we're
- 41:31the plaintiffs in the case and we can end the
- 41:33litigation. We can give them precisely what they
- 41:36want. And what do we know that they don't? Well,
- 41:40suppose that we have several subpoenas in the
- 41:42works that can undermine their defenses. We can
- 41:45choose the proper time to reveal this information
- 41:48in the midst of the negotiation or whenever it
- 41:51best serves our purpose. And then lastly, we
- 41:56can set our floor, which is that we will not
- 41:59accept any less than a given sum to resolve the
- 42:02litigation. You can see how the same principles
- 42:07apply across the board, whether you're engaged
- 42:10in a fictional negotiation with a baron or in
- 42:13a very real negotiation with opposing counsel
- 42:16with your client's interests on the line. And
- 42:21I think D &D provides a useful opportunity to
- 42:26gain repetitions and practice the framework of
- 42:31the negotiation skills, even if the facts are
- 42:35of course a little bit contrived and not directly
- 42:38applicable. In section four I want to talk a
- 42:48little bit about improvisation because improvisation
- 42:51is a skill and those who practice it often make
- 42:55it look effortless and natural and those who
- 42:59don't practice it end up looking awkward and
- 43:03uncomfortable and distracted when forced to engage
- 43:06in it. The skill of improvisation is separate
- 43:10from the context. You can really develop the
- 43:14skill of being cool under pressure, of adapting
- 43:18to rapidly changing circumstances, and that skill
- 43:22can apply across different areas, even if the
- 43:28underlying situations are different. Somebody
- 43:31who can pitch in the bottom of the ninth, can
- 43:34also stay cool under unrelated pressure situations.
- 43:44We'll start with the concept of risk. And there's
- 43:48a common phrase in D &D that we hear, which is,
- 43:52you can certainly try. And that describes an
- 43:55action that is likely to fail, but has a very
- 43:58small chance of success. These are often improvised
- 44:02Hail Mary attempts to save the day. These moments
- 44:07don't come out of nowhere. They often arise out
- 44:11of unforeseen circumstances where our best late
- 44:15plans have already gone south. The most important
- 44:23thing to do, though, is to not do nothing. You
- 44:26must make an attempt. For example, Say you're
- 44:31in the legal context your damages expert gets
- 44:34excluded. Now you need to use the cross -examination
- 44:38of the other side's expert to make your own damages
- 44:40case. This is of course far from ideal, but you
- 44:44have to make the attempt to save the day. This
- 44:47would be a you can certainly try attempt. Obviously
- 44:51the stakes are different at the D &D table and
- 44:54in the courtroom. At the table you might lose
- 44:56some pride if you fail. In the courtroom, the
- 44:59stakes can be much higher. But the attempt is
- 45:03what's important. Just a note to get client approval
- 45:09before you go out on any limbs. In D &D, the
- 45:17dice sometimes tell the story. So no matter...
- 45:22How strong or smart or resilient your character
- 45:25is, sometimes you just roll poorly and things
- 45:28go bad. The same is true in litigation. Sometimes
- 45:34you do everything right, but the judge isn't
- 45:36buying it, or the facts just aren't as good as
- 45:39you need them to be, and these problems can arise
- 45:41in the moment without warning. A witness testifies
- 45:46in a way you weren't expecting. Judge issues
- 45:48a ruling you weren't expecting. The important
- 45:51thing to do when this happens is to not panic
- 45:54and to go back to your toolkit. Go back to the
- 45:57preparation you spent so much time on and adapt
- 46:00from there. So I want to watch a brief clip here.
- 46:13The clip moves very fast, so I'm going to set
- 46:15the scene ahead of time. We're going to see Matthew
- 46:18Mercer here in just a moment who I mentioned
- 46:20earlier. He is the Dungeon Master and he is playing
- 46:25a bad guy who casts a spell. Marisha Ray, who's
- 46:30the second person we'll see and is a player,
- 46:33she has braided hair for reference. She's going
- 46:39to use a spell called Counterspell. As the name
- 46:42suggests, that spell is used to negate the original
- 46:46spell cast by Matthew Mercer's bad guy. The bad
- 46:51guy then uses his own reaction to counterspell
- 46:54the counterspell. So we now have two counterspells
- 46:57on the table, which brings us to our third person,
- 47:01Emily Axford, who you can see on this slide here,
- 47:05who uses her own quick thinking to cast a third
- 47:09counterspell of the bad guy's counterspell. So
- 47:12what we get is a Matroshka doll of counterspells
- 47:16that illustrate the quick thinking of well -prepared
- 47:19players. Everyone's plan was challenged here,
- 47:23Matt's initial spell was countered, then Marisha's
- 47:26counter was countered, and finally Emily, using
- 47:29her own quick thinking, cast a third counterspell.
- 47:48So this is an excellent example of each player
- 47:52knowing their own abilities so that when another
- 47:55player does something unexpected, they can adapt
- 47:57accordingly. Improvisation often comes back to
- 48:02preparation. If you know what you're doing and
- 48:05you know the possibilities, you know the rules,
- 48:09and you know the facts, improvisation in the
- 48:12face of unexpected events becomes much easier.
- 48:21In the legal context, let's look at one of the
- 48:29greatest advocates in history, Paul Clement.
- 48:32This excerpt is from NIFB versus Sebelius, which
- 48:37challenged the individual mandate of the Affordable
- 48:39Care Act. Justice Kagan sets forth a seemingly
- 48:44compelling argument that Congress can choose
- 48:47as a matter of timing when it wants to regulate
- 48:51a given transaction. Mr. Clement reacts quickly,
- 48:57challenging the underlying premise of Judge Kagan's
- 49:01question that timing is the only factor. He redirects
- 49:06the analysis to the broader considerations that
- 49:08he likes. In this case, it's the fact that timing
- 49:13alone fails to account for the very people that
- 49:15Congress was seeking to include in the statute.
- 49:19So if we look at the excerpt, Justice Kagan asks,
- 49:23well, Mr. Clement, now it seems as though you're
- 49:25just talking about a matter of timing, that Congress
- 49:28can regulate the transaction. And the question
- 49:31is, when does it make sense to regulate the transaction?
- 49:34Congress surely has, within its authority to
- 49:37decide, rather than at the point of sale, given
- 49:40an insurance -based mechanism, it makes sense
- 49:42to regulate it earlier. It's just a matter of
- 49:45timing. And Mr. Clement, instead of accepting
- 49:51the premise, he redirects it. Justice Kagan,
- 49:54we don't think it's a matter of timing alone,
- 49:57and we think it has a very substantive effect,
- 50:00which is An important redirect here, he's pointing
- 50:03her to the purpose of the law, not just the mechanics
- 50:08of how it operates. If Congress tried to regulate
- 50:11at the point of sale, the one group that it wouldn't
- 50:14capture at all are the people who don't want
- 50:17to purchase health insurance and also have no
- 50:20plans of using health care services in the near
- 50:23term. And Congress very much wanted to capture
- 50:26those people. I mean, those people are essentially
- 50:30the golden geese that pay for the entire lowering
- 50:33of the premium. So going back to our earlier
- 50:37discussion here about rules and understanding
- 50:40how to extend the rules and how to formulate
- 50:45an argument about the rules, we can see here
- 50:47exactly how Mr. Clement is improvising his answer
- 50:52to Justice Kagan's question in a way that is
- 50:56tied back to the specific rules at issue. I think
- 51:01this is an excellent example of somebody improvising
- 51:05under pressure and coming up with a persuasive
- 51:09and concise answer to a difficult question. Lastly,
- 51:18I want to discuss the importance of a balanced
- 51:20party. In D &D, a party of adventurers usually
- 51:24try to diversify their skill sets to increase
- 51:27the likelihood of success. And the same is true
- 51:31in litigation, or at least it should be. So let's
- 51:34talk about what a balanced party looks like.
- 51:39In D &D, we often want someone with some form
- 51:43of physical strength and endurance, such as a
- 51:45fighter or a barbarian. Sometimes they'll be
- 51:49described as tanks or meat shields. These are
- 51:53characters that can take a lot of damage but
- 51:56also can dish out a lot of damage. We also want
- 52:00somebody with strong magical abilities like a
- 52:02wizard, a sorcerer, a warlock. In D &D, magic
- 52:07tends to scale more steeply than other abilities.
- 52:10So if you can get a spellcaster up to a high
- 52:12level, they can be a dominating force in a lot
- 52:14of different circumstances. We also want a healer
- 52:19to make sure that our fighter and our barbarian
- 52:22don't take too much damage and go down, or to
- 52:25help our wizards who are typically glass cannons,
- 52:29meaning they can pack a punch but they also go
- 52:32down quite quickly. And then lastly you want
- 52:36something like a rogue who can handle things
- 52:38like stealth and picking locks and any sort of
- 52:43less than savory activities that the characters
- 52:45might get up to. And I'll also toss in, it's
- 52:48not on the sheet, but a bard to handle social
- 52:51encounters. This is typically a performer, somebody
- 52:54who can really put on a show, song and dance,
- 52:57wow the locals or sometimes the bad guys as well
- 53:02to get what the party needs. On the litigation
- 53:09side of things, what do we need? We need Trial
- 53:13counsel, who's going to be doing most of the
- 53:15arguing in court and likely much of the in -person
- 53:18buildup of the case. They could be doing depositions,
- 53:23cross examinations, arguments in front of the
- 53:26judge, engaged in negotiations with opposing
- 53:29counsel. They are oftentimes the face of the
- 53:32team. We're gonna need subject matter experts.
- 53:37This could be technical expertise, as in my arena
- 53:40of patent litigation. It can also be about specific
- 53:43legal expertise, such as particular areas of
- 53:46the law, damages, discovery, et cetera. A successful
- 53:53litigation team also needs support staff, paralegals,
- 53:58who keep the administrative and scheduling aspects
- 54:01of the case running smoothly. And finally, I
- 54:04think having appellate counsel looking over the
- 54:06shoulders of the trial team is always a good
- 54:09idea. Having someone who can protect the record
- 54:13and call out issues in real time with a mind
- 54:15to appeal can really save the case long term.
- 54:25One of the unavoidable parts of any sort of team
- 54:31environment is that you've got to be able to
- 54:33manage competing personalities, and this is true
- 54:36in both D &D and litigation. There are always
- 54:39those who want to solve every problem with a
- 54:42sword and others that can never make a decision
- 54:44without a three -hour discussion. The party members
- 54:48have to figure out where best they fit and how
- 54:50to manage their relevant skills to achieve a
- 54:52common goal. The same is true in litigation.
- 54:57Having a mix of talents and personalities is
- 54:59invaluable, but they have to be managed appropriately
- 55:03so that everybody is rowing in the same direction.
- 55:07Sorry. Good DMs give each player type a time
- 55:14to shine and good lead litigators do the same
- 55:17thing with their teams. So just a quick recap
- 55:22before we wrap up here. These are, I think, the
- 55:25key takeaways. You have to master the rules.
- 55:30You have to know them deeply enough to argue
- 55:32the gray areas creatively and persuasively. You
- 55:36should build your case theory like you build
- 55:37a campaign, one adventure or session at a time,
- 55:41one argument, one motion, one discovery request
- 55:44at a time. Persuasion and negotiation is a checklist.
- 55:50It's not an instinct. Knowing, going into every
- 55:54negotiation with a plan, knowing what you know,
- 55:57what the other side wants, what they don't know,
- 56:00and what your floors and ceilings are will make
- 56:02you a better negotiator. You can practice the
- 56:07skill of improvisation and prepare for when your
- 56:09plan collapses, as it will at some point in time.
- 56:14And last, you should choose and manage your team
- 56:16deliberately and effectively to bring out each
- 56:19person's talents to the best of their ability.
- 56:25With that, if anybody has any questions, step
- 56:29it up the Q &A here. Somebody asked if I've ever
- 56:36played Penta. I have not played Penta, so I'm
- 56:40not familiar with that. Have I ever done a legal
- 56:43themed D &D game is also a question that was
- 56:48asked. I have not done a legal themed D &D game,
- 56:53but I have had attorneys ask me to run games
- 56:58for them. Could you counter spell the counter
- 57:06spell could it go on indefinitely? Yes to a degree
- 57:09until you run out of people who have Reactions
- 57:12in D &D there's something called the action economy
- 57:15Which means everybody has a certain a limited
- 57:18number of turns and around that they can go so
- 57:22everybody gets one reaction per round once you
- 57:24run out of people with reactions and Access to
- 57:28the counter spell spell then it would definitely
- 57:32end Somebody asked, to what extent does the cross
- 57:39application skills utilized in the game and while
- 57:42practicing become different when factoring in
- 57:45that the DM ultimately wants players to have
- 57:47fun and enjoy themselves too, whereas the judge
- 57:50probably cares more about proper application
- 57:52of the rules only. Yeah, so I think that's a
- 57:57good question and probably does hit the limits
- 58:01of the analogy. I think ultimately what I'm focused
- 58:06on here is skill development. Some of the analogs
- 58:10are a little more fun. Some of them are a little
- 58:12more skill -based. And, you know, I've also been
- 58:16in circumstances where the DM and myself as the
- 58:20DM have had to tell players no, and maybe they
- 58:23didn't like that very much. So it is a real situation,
- 58:29both as a DM and a judge, where you have to issue
- 58:31a ruling that preserves the game for some reason
- 58:35or preserves the integrity of the process, even
- 58:40in a way that a particular party might not enjoy.
- 58:48Did I read about the judge in Idaho who was playing
- 58:50D &D in court? I have not read about that judge,
- 58:53although I will look it up afterward. What character
- 59:00do you play? So I have not played a character
- 59:02in Five years now, I run a game for several of
- 59:08my friends, some of which I've been playing with
- 59:12since I started in middle school, as well as
- 59:15some college friends. So I run the environment,
- 59:18I run the non -player characters, and they create
- 59:21their own characters and bring them to my table.
- 59:24We play over Zoom. Do you see analogy with D
- 59:33&D also building professionalism that would benefit
- 59:35lawyers? Yeah, I think that's definitely true.
- 59:44Learning, I think everybody in our current somewhat
- 59:47segmented world would do better to just interact
- 59:51with people, real people more often face to face.
- 59:54And I think D &D is a great tool for just putting
- 59:57people together. having people put their phones
- 1:00:00down and, you know, engaged in some sort of social
- 1:00:04interaction. D &D is one great way to do that.
- 1:00:06There are lots of others as well. All right.
- 1:00:13I think I answered all the questions in the Q
- 1:00:16&A. Thank you to all of you who also just added
- 1:00:20thanks and appreciation. I appreciate that as
- 1:00:22well. And I think that will end the program.
- 1:00:25Thanks.