Latest / Podcast Network Insights: Understanding the Business of Podcast "Networks" / Empowering Podcasters Without Taking Creative Control
Transcript
- 0:00I think there's real strength in numbers. I think
- 0:01people take you seriously when they perceive
- 0:04you as an entity or an organization or company
- 0:07versus an individual. I don't think that's right,
- 0:09but I do think it is where we live. not just
- 0:30the company. As you'll hear as soon as my interview
- 0:33starts, my guest doesn't run a network, and she's
- 0:36very specific about it. Instead, she runs a distinct,
- 0:40community - and creator -first philosophical
- 0:43collective. The central message, podcast collectives,
- 0:47or networks, can thrive deeply rooted in relationships,
- 0:51autonomy for creators, and assured ethos, rather
- 0:55than top -down control. or extractive business
- 0:58models. Amanda McLaughlin is the founder of Multitude,
- 1:01an organization she insists is not a network,
- 1:04but a collective. Her audio journey started as
- 1:07a teenage YouTuber, inspired by early creators,
- 1:10before launching the Spirits podcast with her
- 1:12best friend in 2016. She's been running Multitude
- 1:15since 2018, built entirely around this collective
- 1:19operating model, all guided by desire for shared
- 1:23ownership and distributed decision -making. I'm
- 1:27Greg Wasserman, the host of this amazing show,
- 1:29Podcast Network Insights. I've spent 15 years
- 1:32in ad sales, and since 2021, I've been immersed
- 1:35in the podcast industry. I believe life is about
- 1:39time and relationships. You never know where
- 1:41one conversation may lead. I've built a lot of
- 1:44relationships. I spend a lot of time with every
- 1:46different kind of podcaster. Whether it's solo
- 1:48creators, just getting started, to, like my guest
- 1:52Amanda, heads of industry -leading networks.
- 1:55If you've ever wondered whether joining a network
- 1:57makes sense, how these networks actually run,
- 2:01other networks you could enjoy joining, advertising
- 2:04with, partnering with, or learning from, then
- 2:07my goal is to give you a real look behind the
- 2:10scenes so you can confidently navigate whether
- 2:13you host, produce, sponsor, or run a network.
- 2:18In this conversation, focus on what it takes
- 2:20to build and sustain a decentralized collective
- 2:23model. From shared resource pools to keeping
- 2:26financial incentives tightly aligned to intentionally
- 2:29limiting control and maximizing autonomy for
- 2:33every creator under the umbrella. The show wouldn't
- 2:35be possible without some of the amazing companies
- 2:38and sponsors, so I must thank them. The show
- 2:41is produced by an incredible team of stories
- 2:43and strategies. If you don't know Doug and Emily,
- 2:46I suggest you reach out and learn what they do.
- 2:48I'm using RSS .com for my podcast hosting. This
- 2:51podcast hosting is more than just storage. It
- 2:54provides so many features to ensure a great podcast
- 2:56experience, easy to use, maximum distribution,
- 3:00community to learn from, monetization solutions,
- 3:03and so much more. And they have a plan that works
- 3:07great for podcast networks, not just individuals
- 3:09like me. Systems and processes are key for the
- 3:13consistency needed in podcasting, which is why
- 3:16I've turned to Northflow, a dedicated podcast
- 3:18project management platform built by podcasters
- 3:22for podcasters. And then we all know the value
- 3:25of content repurposing. And that's why I lean
- 3:28on Cast Magic. I use them for my content to repurpose
- 3:31it, to give it to my guests, to help me with
- 3:34a lot of these assets that I get to give to you.
- 3:37Check out the links in my show notes and stay
- 3:39tuned after the interview as there's more to
- 3:41this conversation as I share some of my insights.
- 3:45With that all said, let's get into the conversation.
- 3:47Well, Amanda, the show's called Podcast Network
- 3:49Insights, so I love to start with asking, when
- 3:53you hear the word podcast network, what comes
- 3:55to mind? What do you think about? I think about
- 3:58the fact that I don't run a podcast network.
- 4:01I run a podcast collective, which I know you
- 4:04have talked about on the show before. And the
- 4:07reason why I chose that word is because it's
- 4:10important to me that our collective is by and
- 4:13for creators. We are an umbrella under which
- 4:16people can shelter from the rain. We are a place
- 4:19where we share a tone, we share a perspective,
- 4:22we share a quality standard for our listeners.
- 4:24And more than anything at Multitude, we share
- 4:27a grounded, exciting, but still critical perspective
- 4:30on the stuff that we love. So for me, a network
- 4:33is immediate, like, that's not me. I'm like the
- 4:35emoji where the woman's making an X with her
- 4:37hands. But I am a podcast collective, which is,
- 4:40for me, a more decentered, democratic, and equitable
- 4:44method of creators sharing resources to grow
- 4:47together. So then... What would you classify
- 4:51as actually a podcast network? If you are a collective,
- 4:55what do you think about is what is a network
- 4:57then? For me, a network has specific centralized
- 5:03leadership, ownership, or editorial standards
- 5:05in some way. So a network may approve episodes
- 5:08before they go out. They may share in some amount
- 5:10of intellectual property or revenue from their
- 5:13podcasts. They may have a mandated, like, cross
- 5:16promotion or, you know, marketing slot. They
- 5:19may also represent that podcast in some way when
- 5:21it comes to, like, spinoff deals, memberships,
- 5:25you know, merch, sort of other associated forms.
- 5:28I love, I mean, this is what I love about the
- 5:30show is how every person classifies the answer
- 5:32to that question completely different. But one
- 5:35thing you touched on is the categorization of
- 5:38how you look at a network. Correct me if I'm
- 5:41wrong, but like you handle the ad sales for the
- 5:44collective, right? So like there's some components
- 5:47of what you classify as a network that you do
- 5:50handle, but you look at as a network is it's
- 5:52got to handle all these other components than
- 5:55just that in a sense one, right? Yeah, especially
- 5:59in 2018 when we created Multitude together. It
- 6:02was really important to me that Multitude had
- 6:05no ownership over the show's intellectual property.
- 6:07That was very commonplace back in 2018. I'm really
- 6:10glad to see that networks have understood the
- 6:12importance of creators retaining their own IP,
- 6:14and I think that's less common now than it was
- 6:16back then, but that was definitely a founding
- 6:18principle. Second is the only financial relationship
- 6:21that exists between Multitude, the entity, and
- 6:24the shows that are in the collective is just
- 6:26a commission on ad sales. So shows retain 100
- 6:29% of their live shows. dice, Patreon earnings,
- 6:33all kinds of stuff. And for us, if we bring you
- 6:35money, we'll take a small cut of that money.
- 6:37And that is how we approach it. And then so then
- 6:39are you branding? Like if I'm about to show,
- 6:43do people know is there a logo? Do you look at
- 6:45the branding component so that it's You know
- 6:49that there's the Sonic brand or any kind of branding
- 6:52for that matter so that there's a quality check
- 6:55per se. Like you fit under this guise of what
- 6:57Multitude stands for. We could talk about what
- 6:59Multitude stands for next, but yeah. Yes, that
- 7:02is definitely important to us. One of the value
- 7:04propositions that we bring to our member shows,
- 7:07because I think that any network collective should
- 7:09always be proving to their creators why they
- 7:12are worth associating with, is that we have a
- 7:15core audience of people who love multitude, love
- 7:17our shows, love our approach to subject matter.
- 7:19And so when we announce a new member show, which
- 7:22is our terminology, That audience is really excited
- 7:24and we can see measurable traffic, new listeners
- 7:27going to that audience right away. So yes, we
- 7:31have a little M logo bug, but like Multitude,
- 7:34it's just a shape. You can fill in the colors,
- 7:36whoever you like. We're not giving you a big,
- 7:37you know, editorial standard. And we list all
- 7:40of our shows with Multitude in the author line.
- 7:42That way folks can find all of our podcasts if
- 7:44they search their various directories. I mean,
- 7:47look, anyone that's listening, once again, I
- 7:50love how everyone can classify collective, network,
- 7:53whatever that means, you get to define it. But
- 7:56as you actually said, it's like you're defining
- 7:59it, but there's a cohesion to it. There's a purpose
- 8:03of what you're doing. So I guess that leads into
- 8:06what is Multitude Shows? What have you created
- 8:09as this purpose around this collective? The purpose
- 8:12is to open up fields to people who don't know
- 8:17how interested they're gonna be. I don't know
- 8:19if you have a friend, Greg, who, like, you can
- 8:21have, this friend could, like, read the phone
- 8:22book to you, and you're just fascinated. This
- 8:24friend could talk about, like, their, you know,
- 8:26their shopping trip to the grocery store, about
- 8:27baseball, about, like, something that you don't
- 8:29care about, and you're just like, I love you,
- 8:31man. I want to listen to you talk about anything
- 8:32you possibly want to talk about. That's the vibe
- 8:35multitude shows bring. So we have, for example,
- 8:38a historian updating the legacies of guys who
- 8:41sucked in history called This Guy Sucked. We
- 8:43have an astrophysicist, Dr. Moia McTeer, explaining
- 8:47what fascinates her about space for people who
- 8:49are a little bit scared of space. We have a person
- 8:53interested in mythology and folklore, my co -host
- 8:55Julia, talking about everything from ancient
- 8:58Greece to modern day urban legends and explaining
- 9:01why these stories still have resonance for people
- 9:03in the modern era. Overall, it's going to be
- 9:06curious, it's going to be critical, it's going
- 9:08to open it up. If you've never heard of our subject
- 9:10matter before, if you think chemistry and your
- 9:13brain just kind of blurs, I challenge you to
- 9:15listen to tiny matters because they make the
- 9:18science of things you can't see but impact your
- 9:20lives undeniably interesting. I love that. I
- 9:24hope I'm one of those people where you're like,
- 9:26I don't care what Greg has to say, I want to
- 9:28listen to it, right? Because I think you said
- 9:31that brings in energy, and it's like, all right,
- 9:33I want that energy to try and break it down and
- 9:36explain it to me. So selfishly, I hope that's
- 9:39me as well. Totally. So let's take a step back
- 9:41here. We've talked about the standard question
- 9:44of network. We've talked about collective network
- 9:46in that regard. We talked about what is multitude?
- 9:50How did you get into this? I like somewhat of
- 9:52an origin story because when we were talking,
- 9:53like, I started off in YouTube and my hold on.
- 9:57So part of the understanding for anyone that's
- 10:00listening, it's not only how networks operate,
- 10:02but like how the network operator got to where
- 10:05they are versus so many other networks that are
- 10:09operated in different ways. So, I was a teenage
- 10:12YouTuber. YouTube started the year that I started
- 10:15middle school, and I very soon found Brotherhood
- 10:192 .0, which was the original YouTube project
- 10:21of John and Hank Green, who went on to make the
- 10:24Vlogbrothers, Project for Awesome, Complexly,
- 10:26all kinds of incredible companies. And it was
- 10:29just two brothers video blogging back and forth
- 10:32to stay in touch, because as adults, they sort
- 10:34of fell out of that habit of just seeing each
- 10:36other every day and being friends. It's something
- 10:39that I have also... with my younger siblings,
- 10:41the oldest of four kids, and it's different and
- 10:44hard to become friends as adults and not just
- 10:46be kids living in your own house. So I was so
- 10:49enraptured by this sort of first wave of video
- 10:52bloggers, people who weren't necessarily filmmakers.
- 10:54They weren't necessarily there for like the art
- 10:56of cinema or digital video, but they were there
- 10:59to be able to like see what other people's lives
- 11:01were like across the globe. I was a queer teenager
- 11:04in a fairly conservative suburb, and I really
- 11:07wanted to make friends with people whose lives
- 11:09were different. different in mind in setting,
- 11:11but we had a similarity together. That was really
- 11:15where I had my first experiences making video
- 11:18blogs, doing video replies, meeting people from
- 11:20the internet who I'd never met IRL before. I
- 11:23went to the first 10 editions of VidCon, which
- 11:25remains like the biggest kind of video online
- 11:28video industry conference. And I have been chasing
- 11:31the feeling of that very special first wave video
- 11:35blogger community ever since. And I found it
- 11:37in podcasting in 2012, 13, 14. audio dramas and
- 11:42fascinating shows about mental illness and queer
- 11:44identity and gender and literature and all of
- 11:47these subjects I was fascinated by, I got to
- 11:50meet people who were into the stuff that I was
- 11:52into via podcasts. And so going from being an
- 11:56enthusiastic fan into starting to make my own
- 11:59show, when my own best friend, Julia Shafini,
- 12:01moved back to New York City for the first time,
- 12:03we were not just... shithead theater kids in
- 12:06high school getting to see each other every day,
- 12:08but adults who needed to like make plans to hang
- 12:10out. And so as huge fans of podcasts, both of
- 12:14us, we decided to come up with a show that would
- 12:17give us an excuse to hang out every week and
- 12:20be something that we could see ourselves doing
- 12:22for some incredible amount of time. Like, I don't
- 12:24know, a hundred episodes. Fast forward 11 years,
- 12:27and we have made Spirits podcast, which is all
- 12:29about mythology and folklore for going on 500
- 12:33episodes or recording episode 500 tomorrow as
- 12:36you and I speak. So we have talked every single
- 12:38week about a different story from mythology and
- 12:41folklore. And from that podcast, just growing
- 12:44that audience, being so excited, starting to
- 12:47pay myself back for the microphones I put on
- 12:49my credit card. Then we started to pay our phone
- 12:51bills. Then we were able to pay a little bit
- 12:53more of our bills. so excited about the momentum
- 12:57we were building with the show that we launched
- 12:59in 2016 that we started emailing networks. I
- 13:02emailed PRX and Maximum Fun and The Herd and
- 13:05all kinds of places, many of whom are closed
- 13:08now, sadly, saying like, hey, I've got something
- 13:11on my hands. Can you help me take it to the next
- 13:13level? I wanted sponsorships. I wanted help growing.
- 13:16I wanted to speak at podcast movement, right?
- 13:18Like I wanted to start becoming a member of this
- 13:20industry and no networks existed that would do
- 13:25the thing I wanted them to do. So I decided to
- 13:28make my own. So together with a few other friends
- 13:31who were running podcasts and who shared a tone,
- 13:34we had shows about fandom, shows about gaming,
- 13:36and Spirits, the mythology show. We decided to
- 13:39launch a website of multitude. It was just easier
- 13:41to say one name than it was to promote three
- 13:44or four different podcasts in the call to action
- 13:46of a show like this. And things really spiraled
- 13:49from there. Within about six months, we had our
- 13:51first consulting contract to help a radio station
- 13:54in Chicago, launched their first podcasts. A
- 13:57year after that, I was able to quit my day job
- 13:59and do multitude full time starting in 2018.
- 14:02And then we rented a studio in Brooklyn. That
- 14:05was our base of operations for about five years
- 14:07in 2019. Wow. So much unpacked there, but it's
- 14:14incredible. Mean, it's it's incredible that you
- 14:16found podcasting as a as a youtuber that you
- 14:20found your voice in podcasting and then we look
- 14:22at where YouTube and Video podcasting is today.
- 14:26Well, we could talk about that later, right like
- 14:28The fact that if anyone's listening like what
- 14:32I want to kind of walk away with is a you've
- 14:36continued to do this 500 episodes so the the
- 14:39theme is continued there and everyone that's
- 14:42in your shoes it says like Consistency is key,
- 14:45just keep showing up, keep refining. The fact
- 14:48that you were looking for a network to help you
- 14:51get to the next level and you kind of knew that,
- 14:53which is part of the reason why I started the
- 14:55show is everyone's trying to figure out, I need
- 14:58to go find a network and they didn't end. There's
- 15:02no knock, I always say this. There's no knock
- 15:03to iHeart, but most people think of iHeart and
- 15:05the big ones because, or as you mentioned, PRX,
- 15:08certain categories, those are the names we know.
- 15:11They've done an amazing job in doing what they
- 15:13do, but that doesn't mean it's the right fit.
- 15:15And clearly, no one was either willing to take
- 15:19you on or there wasn't a right fit and you created
- 15:21your own, which is part of why I'm like, hey,
- 15:24you can go and join another network. You can
- 15:27join with your friends like you've done and create
- 15:29your own. Or stay solo, which I guess becomes
- 15:33the question, like, why didn't you stay solo?
- 15:36I think there's real strength in numbers. I think
- 15:37people take you seriously when they perceive
- 15:40you as an entity or an organization or company
- 15:43versus an individual. I don't think that's right,
- 15:45but I do think it is where we live. And I had
- 15:47a much easier time getting tours booked, getting
- 15:51speaking engagements accepted from festivals
- 15:53and conferences, and importantly, getting sponsorships.
- 15:56When I was able to come to people as the representative
- 15:59of an organization to look polished, professional
- 16:01with a domain name, with a brand, as opposed
- 16:03to saying, hey, I I am making a project I really
- 16:06believe in. Will you also back my project? I
- 16:09know folks who have ways to be successful in
- 16:12both realms, but for us being able to collect
- 16:14together a bunch of podcasts that individually
- 16:17were able to pay their hosts, you know, a modest
- 16:19part -time wage to go to a company and then say,
- 16:23you know, I have six shows that have 20 to 30
- 16:25,000 downloads per episode each as opposed to
- 16:28just the one. I was able to unlock a higher tier
- 16:31of respect and budget from, for example, sponsors
- 16:35than I would on my own. Makes sense. I mean,
- 16:40strength in numbers, there you go. Now, you've
- 16:42mentioned multitudes focuses really just on the
- 16:47advertising sales side of things and everyone
- 16:49else has their own. Everything they do is on
- 16:52their own. So they have full autonomy and control,
- 16:56but we provide assistance and help. So we have
- 16:59like a merch provider that we refer our podcast
- 17:01to. We have all kinds of professionals where
- 17:04if you need a creative accountant or a lawyer
- 17:06or folks like that, we have people that we can
- 17:08refer you to. We also have editors on staff.
- 17:10So our member shows enjoy an at -cost rate on
- 17:14episode editing. If our editors make $70 an hour,
- 17:17we charge our clients $70 an hour. The rate is
- 17:20a little bit higher for people who are not in
- 17:21the collective. But we really want to make the
- 17:24resources of a larger company available to people
- 17:27at a scale that is still deeply human. I think
- 17:30it's impossible to represent 2 ,000 shows for
- 17:33ad sales or 200. 20 shows that I work with. And
- 17:37so being able to really deeply know each show
- 17:41and each audience is what equips us to do a great
- 17:44job. And listen, ultimately, I think the job
- 17:46of every network is to help their shows grow.
- 17:48And so it is my primary responsibility to help
- 17:52my creators, the shows that have decided to publish
- 17:56under Multitudes Umbrella, under our brand name.
- 17:59It's a big decision. And I want to make sure
- 18:00that they are stronger, better, and better equipped
- 18:04with us than they would be without us. That looks
- 18:06like pitching those hosts for guest spots. That
- 18:09looks like arranging cross promotions, trying
- 18:11out new earning and growth opportunities. We
- 18:14have a ton of tools we work with that we're able
- 18:16to negotiate more affordable or free use of tools
- 18:20because we represent several shows with a couple
- 18:23million downloads a month, again, as opposed
- 18:25to just the one. So try to bring value in lots
- 18:27of ways while only taking money when we bring
- 18:31them money. And so you took the question I was
- 18:34going to ask and you ran with it before I asked
- 18:37it. So I'll ask it in a different way than I
- 18:41want to. What, as a network operator, as a collective
- 18:45operator, as the head of a group of shows, if
- 18:49I'm listening to this right now as one of those
- 18:52people who's either thinking of starting or actually
- 18:55running a network or collective, what tools,
- 18:59what makes your operation Successful. It's a
- 19:04really good question and I'm gonna be a little
- 19:05bit cliche for a moment and say the people like
- 19:08our COO Brandon Gruegel has been with us since
- 19:112018 our Senior audio editor Misha Stanton has
- 19:15been editing shows as actually a fan of theirs
- 19:17of their show star tripper before I started spirits
- 19:19So that was insane. And then our other editor
- 19:22Julia Shafini I've known since preschool and
- 19:24we have been working together on spirits for
- 19:26the last almost 11 years when you count pre -production
- 19:29So we have an incredible team. We also have freelance
- 19:32editors like DM and Bren who work with us. And
- 19:35it really is because we are creators that we
- 19:39know what creators need. Every single week I
- 19:41am recording a show, posting social clips, reading
- 19:44ad copy, using spreadsheets, using the same tools
- 19:47that the rest of our hosts are using. And so
- 19:49it's really a by and for podcast creators type
- 19:53of perspective. I have never had the opportunity
- 19:56to work in podcasting apart from this job that
- 19:59I made for myself. And so while I have definitely
- 20:02liaised with lots of people who are professional,
- 20:04you know, network heads or salespeople or operations
- 20:07people at networks, I don't have that experience.
- 20:10I'm as close to what my creators need as I possibly
- 20:15can be because Like I'm my own primary customer.
- 20:18And so I feel like that knowledge about what
- 20:21I need, what I'm looking for, and I don't know
- 20:24what makes me like trust and, you know, fall
- 20:27in like friendship love with the people I get
- 20:29to work with is something that I really understand
- 20:32very deeply. And so does everybody else who works
- 20:34at Multitude. So with that said, where would
- 20:38you, what blinders, what blind spots do you have
- 20:42based on the fact that like I am I'm doing what
- 20:46I'm doing without knowing others that are out
- 20:49there like where do you see? Potentially your
- 20:52blind spots, but other networks could be saying
- 20:54hey I don't know what I don't know which is part
- 20:57of the reason why I have this show is to help
- 20:59fill in some of those Answers that no one's talking
- 21:01to each other about right? Yeah, you know when
- 21:04I started multitude in 2018. I was applying to
- 21:07every job in podcasting at every company that
- 21:10I possibly could. I was applying WNYC when Gimlet
- 21:13started. I applied to, I'm pretty sure the head
- 21:15of operations at Gimlet, a thing which I was
- 21:18woefully under -qualified for. Every single place
- 21:21you could work to work on podcasts, I was trying
- 21:23to work. I had no experience. I was an English
- 21:25major. My day job was in finance. Like I had
- 21:28absolutely no qualification. I didn't realize
- 21:30I loved audio until after I'd already graduated.
- 21:33So I kind of missed out on that like internship
- 21:35track into audio that a lot of folks take. And
- 21:38so I bring that up because I think what I thought
- 21:42was a negative is actually a positive. I've never
- 21:45worked at a nonprofit, for example. I have never
- 21:48worked in public media. And so I think some of
- 21:51the ways that the podcast industry has inherited
- 21:55forms of business and culture and fundraising
- 21:59from the public media ecosystem, I think there's
- 22:01a lot to love there. And I also think there's
- 22:03a lot that's holding us back. I am really a person
- 22:05who believes that podcasters are creators first
- 22:09and foremost, and that we need to look to other
- 22:12creators, models like membership. that's sustaining
- 22:15and not just like a yearly kind of pledge drive.
- 22:17We need to look at, you know, affiliate and referral
- 22:20ads, something that does not happen in a public
- 22:22media ecosystem. We need to basically expand
- 22:25our horizons about what can make a sustainable
- 22:29and well -funded show. And I'm really glad that
- 22:32my frame of reference for that are the digital
- 22:35creators who have been making a living online
- 22:37for the last, you know, 25 years or more versus
- 22:41the world of shows that I deeply admire. and
- 22:44listen to all the time, the This American Life
- 22:46and radio labs of the world. I love those, but
- 22:49I never got to work on them. And so I think if
- 22:52the remit was, if the job was make a very beautiful,
- 22:56expensive, you know, short run or even ongoing
- 22:59public radio program within the resources, but
- 23:02also the expectations of a traditional radio
- 23:05station, that's something I don't know how to
- 23:06do. But ultimately, I think that that has helped
- 23:09us figure out our own way forward. So do you
- 23:12think I mean because you mentioned public radio
- 23:14you wanted to go to PRX at one point Is the the
- 23:19collective that you've built the style mirrored
- 23:23in the public radio storytelling and and that's
- 23:27something you've taken or or Because at some
- 23:30point you want it like hey, I think PRX would
- 23:32be the right place for my show But that could
- 23:35just be who else knows where to go. So PRX is
- 23:38what you knew, right? I am definitely inspired
- 23:41by those shows, but you know what? To be honest
- 23:43with you, I didn't have the training, resources,
- 23:46equipment, or other team members to make those
- 23:49kinds of stories. I, for the most part, don't
- 23:52make reported journalistic nonfiction. I make
- 23:56shows where they are deeply researched, well
- 23:59-produced, carefully edited, lovingly transcripted,
- 24:02and they are shows where we find out information
- 24:05in conversation, whether that's with two hosts
- 24:07talking or host interviewing a guest. I see those
- 24:11kinds of shows referred to as like chat casts
- 24:13or always on shows or a more casual show. It's
- 24:17important to me and I think it's a value that
- 24:19my show is a sustainable production. I am proud
- 24:22to have made almost 500 episodes of this mythology
- 24:24and folklore show, which has many hours of research
- 24:27that goes into every episode. A researcher on
- 24:29staff, right? Like we edit it for like six or
- 24:32eight hours per episode. We really make sure
- 24:34that it's a great product, but it's somewhere
- 24:36in between two dudes in a basement with a microphone,
- 24:39chit chatting, and, you know, 12 people doing
- 24:42a table read of this American life script. If
- 24:45I had those resources, I probably would have
- 24:47made that. Me and Julia at first wanted to make
- 24:49an audio drama set in like an interdimensional
- 24:52diner where Greek gods stopped by alongside like
- 24:55taxi drivers. And then we said to ourselves,
- 24:57We have no money and no experience. Let's start
- 25:00with a show we know we can make. And we have
- 25:02decided to level up that show over the years,
- 25:05adding sound design, research, more frequent
- 25:07schedule, all of that. I definitely love working
- 25:11on those shows now. I have learned that professional
- 25:14skill over the last 10 years. But it's not what
- 25:17was available to me first off. And I really deeply
- 25:21believe that a show that is sustainable to make
- 25:24and fun and pleasurable and exciting and feels
- 25:27easy in the best moments, easy listening can
- 25:30be hard creating, but... You can also make something
- 25:34that feels good and is relatively easy and accomplishes
- 25:38your goals, which for me and Julia was hang out
- 25:41and remain good friends, even get better friends
- 25:43if we can, get to some kind of community where
- 25:46other queer weirdos and librarians and former
- 25:50kids who would collect rocks on the playground
- 25:52could come together and talk about history and
- 25:54folklore. I love it. I love it. Well, I guess
- 25:58pivoting to that. Uh, you mentioned community
- 26:01and what I love about podcasting is community
- 26:04is key. You've also mentioned like the fact that
- 26:07you are a creator and how close you are to your,
- 26:10uh, to your other, the other creators on the
- 26:13network. So where do you see community within
- 26:16the collective and how do you, how do you structure
- 26:18community, not for your show, but for the actual
- 26:20collective? Incredible question. So we really
- 26:24have that. community of creators within Multitude.
- 26:27We have a Slack. We have all kinds of prompts.
- 26:31We have a food channel, a pet channel. We compare
- 26:34notes. If someone gets a weird spam solicitation
- 26:36email, of which there are many in podcasting,
- 26:38they'll say like, hey, anyone else get this?
- 26:40If someone has a question at work or needs a
- 26:42source or wants extra ears on a draft that they're
- 26:45editing, there are, you know, 10 to 15 people
- 26:48online at any given time who can just pop in
- 26:50and give you some feedback. The way I like to
- 26:53talk about it is back when I worked investment
- 26:54banking. I worked in a cubicle and there were
- 26:57like all kinds of different teams sitting on
- 26:58the floor. And if I wanted to kind of like get
- 27:01up and like chat through a problem and like go
- 27:03to someone else's cube, that wasn't really the
- 27:05culture of the place. It was very quiet and you
- 27:07couldn't really like just do an unplanned drop
- 27:09by. I want the kind of coworkers who are going
- 27:12to leave you alone until you want to chat with
- 27:15them. It's someone there to talk something through
- 27:17with, to bullshit with, to just hang out with,
- 27:19and ideally to collaborate. So that's what it
- 27:21feels like. And then we have our listener community.
- 27:24So we have a Discord that anyone who listens
- 27:26to multitude shows can join for free. Each show
- 27:29has their own Patreon, some of which have additional
- 27:31communities as well. But the Discord is really
- 27:33a central gathering place where we have monthly
- 27:35hangouts. We'll do Jackbox trivia. We'll do,
- 27:38you know, just a a Q &A, we'll do a video game
- 27:41play through, we'll do a never have I ever, where
- 27:44the hosts just get to hang out in a broadcast
- 27:47with the listeners, which is good for internal
- 27:50culture, for us getting to know each other better,
- 27:51and also for the audiences to just have a little
- 27:54bit of extra sort of understanding and insight
- 27:57into who we are as people. When you're talking
- 28:01right now, thoughts are coming to my mind and
- 28:04in how you're creating this I mean, I asked the
- 28:08question community, but how you're creating this
- 28:10collaborative environment around hosts showing
- 28:14up together and cross -pollinating not just as
- 28:17hosts on their shows, but just their communities
- 28:19and coming together in that regards, right? Like,
- 28:23for example, one of our hosts, Dr. Claire Aubin,
- 28:25just announced yesterday as we recorded a new
- 28:28book deal. She's going to write an incredible
- 28:30book about the great man theory of history and
- 28:32why it's failed us. I didn't send that to every
- 28:35single multitude host and say like, please share
- 28:37this, but all of them did, right? Like they,
- 28:39they saw Claire's announcement. They got excited
- 28:41for her. We've known that this deal was in the
- 28:43works. And so immediately, you know, I don't
- 28:46want to use that word organic cause it's so overused,
- 28:48but like we're friends and we like each other
- 28:49and we're fans of what each other does, particularly
- 28:52because we all take similar approaches to different
- 28:54kinds of subject matter. So while we have two
- 28:56historians, Matt Gabriel does medieval history
- 28:59and Claire is a history. and Claire is a historian
- 29:02of Nazi perpetration in the U .S. in the 20th
- 29:05century and beyond, unfortunately, they get each
- 29:08other and they collaborate and they hang out.
- 29:10And it's absolutely the best. I don't make money
- 29:13on that, but I think it is the thing worth doing.
- 29:16It's the reason why making stuff in community
- 29:19feels so good. I guess you may not make money,
- 29:22but it allows all the shows to ultimately grow.
- 29:25And the more they grow, the means you can go
- 29:27and get larger ad deals because they're growing,
- 29:29right? So it, uh, one helps the other. I'm excited
- 29:34when Dr. Moya McTier gets to go on Wow If True
- 29:36to talk about some crazy like space theory on
- 29:38the internet. Like that's amazing. I feel a little
- 29:41bit like I get to be playing with dolls and like
- 29:43making my Ken doll hang out with my Power Ranger.
- 29:44And I get to do a crossover event of the century,
- 29:47but it's my friends who make great podcasts at
- 29:49work. So then if you were to start a network,
- 29:54how do you, in a sense, capture this lightning
- 29:56in a bottle moment? How do you create this environment
- 30:00that you've created? Is it possible to create
- 30:02it elsewhere? Because you also said part of the
- 30:04reason Multitude is successful is the people.
- 30:06So if I was listening to this and I wanted to
- 30:09create a network or I'm running a network, how
- 30:11do I create that culture? How do I create what
- 30:13you're doing? Is it possible? I think it's definitely
- 30:16possible and it starts with, I think, representing
- 30:19yourself as uniquely and specifically and weirdly
- 30:24as you possibly can. I made no qualms about the
- 30:28fact that I am a queer, tattooed person who works
- 30:32in finance that is also obsessed with death and
- 30:34ghosts and Aphrodite. That is a very specific
- 30:38kind of person. That means that when I meet Lauren
- 30:42Shippen, who is an incredible queer artist, writer,
- 30:47director, producer, making The Bright Sessions,
- 30:50an incredible audio drama that people should
- 30:53still return to and still has quite an audience,
- 30:55we meet and we vibe. in a legitimate way. No
- 30:59one's putting on airs here. We're also friends
- 31:02first. I'm not going around saying, hey, who
- 31:04can send me a new sponsor? Who can refer me to
- 31:08someone who will give me some money? I want those
- 31:10things. Don't get me wrong. But first, I want
- 31:12to make genuine relationships. I'm a genuine
- 31:14fan of Lauren's, and so now the fact that we
- 31:17get to work together on ad sales makes me really
- 31:19happy, but it's rooted from a place of genuine
- 31:22relationship and trust. It's not extractive.
- 31:25I'm not going on LinkedIn, spamming people's
- 31:26inboxes, saying, hey, can you do this thing for
- 31:28me? I'm saying, hey, I'm a fan. I like what you're
- 31:31doing. We have this in common. Let's be peers
- 31:34and pals in this industry because I'm here for
- 31:37a long time. And so my advice to people who are
- 31:40trying to find their people would be to represent
- 31:43yourself as honestly and authentically as you
- 31:46can, to express your admiration and fandom of
- 31:50people whose work you really admire, and to see
- 31:53relationship building as something that is inherently
- 31:56worthy and not a means to an end. Relationships
- 32:00fill us, they challenge us, they of course may
- 32:02have the potential for money to change hands
- 32:05down the line, but it's something that you get
- 32:07to approach first with the lens of, how can I
- 32:10help this person of whom I'm a genuine fan? That's
- 32:13how I start almost all my calls, is at some point
- 32:15on the call, I'll say like, how can I help you?
- 32:17Like, do you need anything? What can I send your
- 32:19way? What should I be looking out for? And 10
- 32:21years of asking those questions means that...
- 32:24I also have a good sense in other people's minds
- 32:27of who I am, what I need. And they know when
- 32:30I hear somebody who needs like a really talented
- 32:33editor for a weekly interview show where they
- 32:35have like a modest budget, but they've never
- 32:37trusted anybody else with an outside edit and
- 32:39they really want to get it right. The answer
- 32:41is multitude. I mean, if you're watching, I'm
- 32:46clapping. I'm snapping. If you're listening,
- 32:48that's the sound of snap because I mean, Going
- 32:50back to the start of the answer, you know, relationships
- 32:54and that is my whole thing, right? But the end
- 32:57of your piece is, I want to be the person that
- 33:00knows these other people and is able to connect
- 33:02to you. And that's a core piece. We're colleagues
- 33:05and not competition, Greg. Like we are here in
- 33:07podcasting. in a small, weird, patchworked boat
- 33:11on the giant seas of e -commerce and digital
- 33:14advertising and entertainment writ large, okay,
- 33:17like the steamships of like Spotify and Netflix
- 33:21and the Comcast conglomerate are all sailing
- 33:23past us. We need to hunker down together and
- 33:27genuine relationship building, helping others
- 33:29succeed, and just being a vocal fan will never
- 33:32steal you wrong. There you go. Well, to this
- 33:36point, you've got You're you represent what 25
- 33:40shows, but there's what eight shows part of the
- 33:44actual network. That's right. Okay. So if I'm
- 33:47listening right now and everything you've kind
- 33:49of been talking about, what should I be looking
- 33:52for to join a network? Right? Like whether I'm
- 33:56Hey, Amanda, I would love to join your network,
- 33:59just like you were trying to do with PRX. What
- 34:02are the green flags? What are the red flags?
- 34:05What are the opportunities that one should be
- 34:06looking for as they're exploring the network's
- 34:11journey? I would definitely encourage all podcasters
- 34:15to ask themselves and to ask any potential network
- 34:19or sales partner what... they can give and get
- 34:23from each other. It should be a mutual exchange.
- 34:26If I am bringing you ad dollars, I think I get
- 34:29a commission. That's pretty straightforward.
- 34:31But if you are going to add a branding of another
- 34:34organization or network to your show, it should
- 34:37be really clear what you're getting in return.
- 34:39How is the network or partner invested in helping
- 34:42you grow? What specifically are they committing
- 34:45to? I think a lot of folks will say, we'll help
- 34:47you grow, but like, How many guest pitches per
- 34:50month? How many impressions of cross promotion?
- 34:52If you are promoting other shows in the network,
- 34:55are they promoting you reciprocally? Making sure
- 34:58that there is a really clear and definable value
- 35:01exchange happening. Something I like to say is
- 35:04that, you know, networks don't do what they do
- 35:07for their, for your health. Like a network is
- 35:11offering to work with you to get something from
- 35:13it. In the best case scenario, I think there
- 35:16is that mutual exchange, but too often I see
- 35:19creators just be like honored to be nominated,
- 35:22you know what I mean? And like not kind of fight
- 35:25for the worth that they have. I would argue ultimately
- 35:28networks are useless and meaningless without
- 35:31the podcasts that comprise them. Multitude only
- 35:35has value as a brand because creators have trusted
- 35:38us to associate with us and to make their incredible
- 35:41stuff in solidarity and in a group with the other
- 35:44shows around. So I get to my desk every day and
- 35:48ask myself, how can I improve the lives of the
- 35:51podcasters who trust me? And I want to make sure
- 35:54that any podcaster considering joining a network
- 35:56of any kind finds that sensation and that commitment
- 36:00and the specifics about how is this network going
- 36:03to help you? And also, how are you helping them?
- 36:07To that point, you've kept your network small.
- 36:11I'm guessing you get at least a good amount of
- 36:13pitch because I understand the industry, right?
- 36:16We do. Ideally, the goal of this show is to help
- 36:19more people know about Multitude. Go like, oh
- 36:21my God, I loved what Amanda had to say. Multitudeshows
- 36:23.com slash pitches. I'd say it again. I was talking
- 36:27over you. multitudeshows .com slash pitches.
- 36:29You're welcome to pitch us. There you go. What
- 36:32would, what are you looking for in a pitch? What
- 36:34are you looking for in someone that's wanting
- 36:36to join the network? And I know I asked double
- 36:39questions, but the second side of that is if
- 36:41they're not a fit for you, where do you send
- 36:44them? I mean, do you have a Rolodex of like,
- 36:47Hey, I love what you have to do. You don't fit
- 36:49our network. Here are other places that I thank
- 36:51you. Or is it like, thank you. And we move on.
- 36:55Anyone who pitches Multitude gets on a call with
- 36:57me where I give them as much advice, insight,
- 37:00next steps as I possibly can. Whether or not
- 37:02they're a good fit for the collective, I am here
- 37:05for independent podcasters making a sustainable
- 37:08living in 2026 and beyond. So I make sure that
- 37:12if it's the not... So I make sure that even if
- 37:14it's not the right fit for us or not the right
- 37:16time, or we just added another show in a similar
- 37:19subject matter, there could be a million reasons
- 37:21why it's not necessarily the right fit, including
- 37:23that I don't want to overwhelm our audience.
- 37:25I want to add two or three shows a year, not
- 37:2710 or 15. I want to keep it special and keep
- 37:29it exciting. So I make sure that we talk it through.
- 37:33If they want feedback, I'm happy to give it.
- 37:34If they want help on ad sales or editing or marketing
- 37:38or growth, I have a ton of ideas and referrals
- 37:40that I'm happy to just give folks for free. The
- 37:43shows that are a really good fit for multitude
- 37:45are shows that have dedicated communities or
- 37:49a plan on building one. collaborators and creators
- 37:52that are excited to make a podcast a focus for
- 37:56them. There are a lot of people who like have
- 37:57a podcast and it's item, you know, four or five
- 38:00or six on their agenda. Lives are busy. I get
- 38:03it. I want people who are really excited about
- 38:06the podcast in particular, and for whom this
- 38:08is like a central pillar of their work, whatever
- 38:10that looks like. Because we do need to keep the
- 38:13lights on, they do need to be open to ad sales.
- 38:16Though all of our hosts have final right of refusal
- 38:19over any advertiser. We bring them. We don't
- 38:22pitch companies that are terrible or embarrassing
- 38:24or compromise the ethics or trust that audiences
- 38:27have in our hosts. And we really make sure to
- 38:30get that right and get that really specific.
- 38:32And then finally, they should fit in with Multitude's
- 38:34overall ethos of curiosity, criticism, compassion,
- 38:38and keeping the door open. If you're holding
- 38:40the door open to welcome people into a thing
- 38:43that they don't know they're going to be obsessed
- 38:44with, that's a show I want to talk to. I love
- 38:47it. So there you go. You've got the pitch. You've
- 38:51got where to go pitch it. If you listen to this
- 38:54show and you heard it, let Amanda know. Yeah,
- 38:59put Greg in the notes. Let me know where you
- 39:01came from. So we talked about ad revenue and
- 39:05that's kind of the core function from a collective
- 39:08standpoint, besides all the value you provide.
- 39:11Is it hard? I mean, if we look at, I mean, my
- 39:15background's in media sales, so I could only
- 39:17imagine your background wasn't in media sales
- 39:20and you fell into that the whole ad sells kind
- 39:23of eight shows 25 in the collector 25 overall
- 39:27like where do you see right now the media space
- 39:31and is it hard to get your foot in the door or
- 39:35are people like I don't want this content like
- 39:38where are you seeing the ad game for a small
- 39:41network like yourself. I think this is a really
- 39:45interesting point in podcast ad sales. We are
- 39:48in some ways still a juvenile medium, right?
- 39:52Like depending on how you date it, podcasting
- 39:54is roughly 10 years in the public consciousness,
- 39:56right? Roughly 20, 25 years old. There really
- 40:00hasn't been a robust market with years and years
- 40:04of insight and data and behavior building for
- 40:08our medium yet. And yet at the same time, video
- 40:11ad sales, right? There have been people negotiating
- 40:13brand deals for YouTube videos since roughly
- 40:162007, 2008, depending on how you define it. So
- 40:19that's even just coming up on its first 20 year
- 40:21anniversary. This shit is so new compared to
- 40:25billboards and newspaper ads and radio ads and
- 40:28classifieds and even cable television, which
- 40:30is only 30 years old. Like we are, we are really
- 40:34at an entry point as we see the influencer economy,
- 40:38the creator economy writ large, starting to understand
- 40:41the power of creators and their audiences and
- 40:44kind of borrowing that trust that creators build.
- 40:47Right now, it is very choppy. I have wildly different
- 40:51CPMs. I have wildly different response rates
- 40:53from big companies versus small companies. I
- 40:55no longer have to explain what a podcast is most
- 40:57of the time, but I do have to explain what podcast
- 40:59sponsorship is and means. So I am really, really
- 41:02bullish on the creator economy largely. I know
- 41:05that we are seeing huge amounts of ad dollars
- 41:08shifting from more traditional spends to digital
- 41:12and creator influencer, and I would argue podcast
- 41:14spends as well. So we're I think it is absolutely
- 41:18not too late. I felt like I was too late to get
- 41:20into podcasting in 2015, and I think 2026, we
- 41:23are still very early. What it does require is
- 41:26a real deep understanding of who you are, what
- 41:29your value is, who your audience is, and why
- 41:32you should partner with someone. What would a
- 41:35brand get from working with you? My friend DB
- 41:37has a wonderful podcast called Sex Ed with DB,
- 41:40and she talks really often about how she has
- 41:44approached sponsorship sales. as a show that
- 41:46is modest in size and yet making a really good
- 41:49income from sales. And I would encourage anybody
- 41:53who is curious about doing their own sales, representing
- 41:56themselves, getting brand deals. The folks who
- 41:59work at ad agencies don't know any more than
- 42:01you, okay? They just have bigger sort of Rolodexes.
- 42:04So get in there, make a deck, get excited, talk
- 42:07to somebody about who you are and what you make,
- 42:10start pitching because you might have to send
- 42:12100 emails, but at least one of them is gonna
- 42:14get back to you. The grit the hustle, I mean
- 42:18that's if you haven't heard that Anyone that's
- 42:21already in a network, you know that anyone that's
- 42:24listening to this and thinking about joining
- 42:26a network Every person I bring on the show because
- 42:29of their experience myself included will continue
- 42:32to say it's the grit It's continued to do it.
- 42:34It's it's found the pavement like Podcasting
- 42:36is hard and and this is why you're at 500 episodes
- 42:4111 years in and just still say there's a lot
- 42:44of potential in this Yeah, it's a lot of work
- 42:47and not everyone has that time, which I totally
- 42:49understand. Like, listen, I didn't go to school
- 42:52for podcast ad sales. I do a pretty good job
- 42:54at it. I've been doing it for a long time. And
- 42:57the only reason why I know more than somebody
- 43:00else is just reps, right? It's just like the
- 43:02experience under my belt. And if a creator...
- 43:05doesn't have the capacity to add yet another
- 43:07task to their growing list, that's a really good
- 43:10reason to seek out a partner. But I really want
- 43:12to reassure anybody listening that it is not
- 43:15rocket science. It is understanding who you are,
- 43:17what you bring, and what a brand could benefit
- 43:19from in partnering with you, and then just the
- 43:22hours in the week. This is my job. I'm very lucky
- 43:25that I don't have to do other things in addition
- 43:27to podcasting. And so I have those hours during
- 43:30the week to make it happen in a way that folks
- 43:32who are like I was 10 years ago go podcasting
- 43:35at night after a 60 -hour work week with a shitty
- 43:37Blue Yeti microphone and a radiator that won't
- 43:40turn off even in the summer. Thank you, Astoria.
- 43:43It doesn't quite benefit you and give you that
- 43:47time if you are still balancing podcasting with
- 43:50so much else on your plate. This is true. Well,
- 43:54I want to go back to an idea that you talked
- 43:57about and I want to explore a little more. You
- 44:00want to only add a few shows to the network,
- 44:03two to three. So anyone that's coming, you're
- 44:05like, hey, I don't want to overload. How is it
- 44:08collective? Like how do you think about, I mean,
- 44:12you could get five pitches that are like, wow,
- 44:14this is amazing. And it's January 1st. You're
- 44:18like, I can't add all five right now because
- 44:20that's like overwhelming. Like how have you figured
- 44:23out over these years to which shows when and
- 44:27how you go about strategically adding a show
- 44:29to a network? The answer is we do it when it
- 44:32feels right. And so while we aim to add two to
- 44:36three shows a year, there are years where we
- 44:39come in under, there are years where depending
- 44:41on how you define the start and the end of the
- 44:42year, if it's the calendar year, if it's the
- 44:44sort of like, you know, a broadcast year, whatever,
- 44:47that might be a little bit different, but...
- 44:48I approach adding shows to multitude very similar
- 44:51to how I send newsletter updates, which is like,
- 44:54I don't want to send one with nothing in it just
- 44:56to send an email. I don't want to add a show
- 44:59that is not the proper fit and time and host,
- 45:02you know, composition and community. if it's
- 45:04not a good fit. I'd rather stick to and, you
- 45:08know, love the shows I'm with and make sure that
- 45:10they are getting all of the love and attention
- 45:11that they need. And when it's time to expand
- 45:14your heart a little bit more and add another
- 45:15show, that's just the time. There are people
- 45:18who pitch us and then we revisit it three or
- 45:21six months later. There are folks who talk to
- 45:24us about one idea, that show is perhaps not the
- 45:26right fit, but their next show may be. So I hope
- 45:29that it's never a no, it's a not at this time.
- 45:32I really think that you know the folks who get
- 45:35in touch and we chat I'm gonna give them my honest
- 45:38feedback and if the answer is you know we should
- 45:40be in touch a little bit later you should come
- 45:42back with a different idea I might be thinking
- 45:44about a show that we're developing that I might
- 45:46want to loop them into at some point never hurts
- 45:48to reach out even if the answer is not right
- 45:50now so let's say you said yes yes what is the
- 45:55onboarding process like what have you created
- 45:57is the experience ago great let's do this Walk
- 46:02me through that because I know most of the the
- 46:05the ho or I guess most of the operators guests
- 46:08I've had on the show like each one's got a different
- 46:10onboarding experience and that's so unique to
- 46:12each each company I love that you're answering
- 46:15this question I am such a geek for process and
- 46:17that is one of the reasons why I love running
- 46:19a company is like you get to make processes and
- 46:22hopefully not make silly ones that waste everyone's
- 46:25time. So yes, our first step is a kind of like
- 46:29creative consultation with the hosts. So we,
- 46:31in part of getting to know them and in deciding
- 46:33to come together, we explain really honestly
- 46:35like what, again, our tone is, what our expectations
- 46:38are. If we listen to a show that has a great
- 46:40deal of potential but we'd like to see the audio
- 46:43quality or the editing style refined, we'll be
- 46:45honest with them before we sign any documents.
- 46:48Once they decide to join, we will have a really
- 46:50comprehensive, like three hour, just like deep
- 46:53dive. We're going to listen to all the episodes
- 46:55of the show that exists so far. We'll get all
- 46:57of our team on a call with the hosts and producers
- 47:00and editors if there are of the new member show
- 47:02and really talk about what they like, what they
- 47:05don't, where they can improve, what kind of feedback
- 47:07they're open to, what their non -negotiables
- 47:09are, and really give them like what a client
- 47:12would pay several thousand dollars for like a,
- 47:14you know, really intense audit of every part.
- 47:17of their podcast in order to make sure it is
- 47:19as good as it can be. And from there, it's just
- 47:22a question of when they want to put those changes
- 47:24into place, if they want to update their branding,
- 47:27their theme song, their Patreon, do they have
- 47:29a website? How can we help set them up for success,
- 47:32take as much time as we need to get all of that
- 47:33in place, and then coordinate the announcement,
- 47:36which is press releases, announcements on the
- 47:39other multitude shows, hopefully some collaborations
- 47:41and guest appearances with the new folks. And
- 47:44in the meantime, they are getting to know folks
- 47:46on Slack. They're getting to know our community.
- 47:48We'll typically tease the new show and introduce
- 47:50them first to our members in our Discord and
- 47:53our paying members in our multi -crew so that
- 47:55they are the first to hear about this new news.
- 47:59And then we make sure that we set up check -in
- 48:01meetings. at first every month and then every
- 48:04quarter, just to make sure that if anyone has
- 48:06questions, thoughts, things that they're unsure
- 48:09about or want to try, the development and refinement
- 48:13and leveling up doesn't stop once we announce
- 48:16you and you join our website. I love that. Because
- 48:21too often, as you said, we spend what you would
- 48:26normally pay thousands of dollars for, how you're
- 48:29looking at... you're joining the family, and
- 48:32by joining the family, this is what I want, this
- 48:34is what we should be looking for. To that point,
- 48:39am I paying? Am I joining your network? Am I
- 48:42paying anything? Or the only thing I'm paying,
- 48:44because I'm getting a lot of benefits by joining
- 48:46Multitude, the only thing I'm paying is technically
- 48:48the percentage for the ad sales. You're absolutely
- 48:50not paying us a cent. we take a portion of dollars
- 48:55we bring you. That is the way it works. And I
- 48:59feel really strongly that, like, listen, I wouldn't
- 49:01have a business if not for the shows that trust
- 49:03multitude to publish under our umbrella. I take
- 49:06that trust really seriously. I don't think anybody
- 49:08should pay to play for any application to a network,
- 49:12admission to a network, membership to a network.
- 49:15In my opinion, that is not something that's worthwhile.
- 49:18That power dynamic is off for me. So if... Hosts
- 49:22want to utilize our editing services. They get
- 49:24to do that at cost. We send them an invoice every
- 49:26month in exchange for editing their shows. And
- 49:29otherwise it's just my commission on dollars
- 49:31that I give you. You're right. It is a different
- 49:36model. And that's what I love. Each person that's
- 49:39running their network or collective has different
- 49:42business model where it's like, you know what,
- 49:45for what you're providing, for the value you're
- 49:47providing. Great. That could be a hundred dollars
- 49:49a month. And that's it. Plus the percentage you
- 49:52get. Each person gets to do it. So I think anyone
- 49:55that's listening here, it's like, look, there's
- 49:57different ways to run a business. Do with what
- 50:01makes you feel comfortable. Yeah, for us, we
- 50:05are mutually incentivized to help each other
- 50:07grow. For every Apple Podcasts feature that one
- 50:10of our shows gets, they are bringing traffic
- 50:12not just to that podcast, but also to multitude.
- 50:14Our name is something people know because of
- 50:17the great work that our hosts are doing. So for
- 50:19me, it is really crucial that any benefit they
- 50:22bring me is absolutely inarguably matched if
- 50:27not bested by value that I bring them in return
- 50:30as the person they've trusted to be their publisher.
- 50:35I guess a publisher. It's a good, worst choice
- 50:39as we look at, you start off in YouTube, found
- 50:42your passion for podcasting, and now we look
- 50:46at this whole video craze. I know we've talked
- 50:50about this, but we can dive deeper from a publishing
- 50:53standpoint for the shows that you're working
- 50:55with. Where do you see all their mediums? Where
- 50:59do you see this video craze versus just the audio
- 51:02only? opportunity Listen, I am old enough to
- 51:07have been working through all three waves of
- 51:10the pivot to video. Look at the Wikipedia page,
- 51:12familiarize yourself. It is at this point the
- 51:15equivalent of like a drinking game among digital
- 51:17media old heads, most of whom were in our 30s,
- 51:21so not quite old heads. But I think that short
- 51:25form video and video overall is the current obsession
- 51:28of the tech companies whose platforms we use
- 51:32in order to reach our audiences. I know that
- 51:36it will come and go. I am really good at making
- 51:38video podcasts because that is what clients want
- 51:41right now, and it happens to be where my specific
- 51:44background began. But ultimately, the thing I'm
- 51:46here to do is to help digital creators make sustainable
- 51:50livings online. Multitudes tagline is podcasts
- 51:53with purpose. Okay. We are here to build community,
- 51:56to change minds and hearts, to educate people,
- 51:59to, to improve your lives via the shows that
- 52:01we're making. And I think just like sound design,
- 52:05video is a tool that you can decide whether or
- 52:08not to utilize in making your thing. I am a media
- 52:12theory geek. Okay. I was an English major. My
- 52:15concentration was media theory. I've read things
- 52:17like the medium is the message, right? Like we
- 52:20- the way we encounter a work influences the
- 52:26meaning we take away from it. And it's really
- 52:28important to me that If I want to get a certain
- 52:31message out there, a certain project, a certain
- 52:32goal, I am choosing the medium that best fits
- 52:35me and my goals, not the one that helps Spotify
- 52:38or Google make the most money they want to each
- 52:41quarter. So my advice to creators would be to
- 52:45really cast a critical eye on the trends and
- 52:48the FOMO and the like, oh no, like I should be
- 52:51doing this because someone else is doing this.
- 52:53Other people have different resources and different
- 52:55goals and priorities. I want you to choose the
- 52:57tools and the forms and the trends that make
- 53:00sense for your audience and your goals and cast
- 53:04the rest aside. There is always going to be something
- 53:07new, some new feature or app or, you know, mode
- 53:10or trend that is popping up. The only constant
- 53:13in digital media is change, okay? So I really
- 53:16encourage creators to... get a sense of their
- 53:20judgment, to trust themselves, to make the best
- 53:22decision for them and their audiences. So long
- 53:25story short, am I producing short -form video
- 53:28clips to help people find my shows on social
- 53:31media? Absolutely! Do I think that it's worth
- 53:34hiring 50 people to work exclusively in video
- 53:37podcasting only to lay them off six months later
- 53:40when my, you know, imaginary shareholders realize
- 53:44that this is not actually the single silver bullet
- 53:47that will make a, you know, 10 X return in digital
- 53:50media. No. So because your background's in YouTube
- 53:56and we've seen clips, reels, I mean, clipping
- 54:01is a business now. How much of that is helping?
- 54:04How much have you seen for your shows? Because
- 54:06we've got a niche in that regards. Those help
- 54:09drive the revenue drive, your ability to sell
- 54:13more, their ability to make more, or it's all
- 54:18just noise. For me, social video is a helpful
- 54:23way to build a brand. it's nice to see the faces
- 54:28that you listen to, right? At many, many live
- 54:30shows, listeners have come up to Julia and me
- 54:33and said, like, oh, my God, I can't believe your
- 54:35voices are coming out of a face and a body. Like,
- 54:38it's wild. It's an experience that lots of podcast
- 54:40listeners, I'm sure, can relate to, where you
- 54:42see a picture of a host and you're like, really?
- 54:43That's what they look like? And it's nice to
- 54:46be able to put an expression and body language
- 54:49and, you know, those nuances of, like, my eyes
- 54:51widening when Julia says something out of pocket
- 54:53about a yokai. Like, that's all great. For us,
- 54:57we record video when recording the show with
- 55:00the only purpose of cutting a couple of social
- 55:02clips. That's not making money for us, okay?
- 55:04We're paying our editor to do that. I think it
- 55:07helps overall with people continuing to deepen
- 55:09their relationship with who we are and what we
- 55:11make. I really see social video and social media
- 55:14more broadly as a tool for engaging the audience
- 55:17I already have, and hopefully meeting people
- 55:20interested in my stuff who might get curious
- 55:22about what it is that we do. I am not changing
- 55:26the allocation of my staff and my business based
- 55:29on that help. What was interesting tweets eight
- 55:32years ago and fun Tumblr posts six years ago
- 55:35and a cool Instagram carousel four years ago
- 55:40is right now a clip. All of it just serves to
- 55:43help the people who might be interested in what
- 55:45you do find you and to help your audience understand
- 55:48more of the vibe, the memes, the excitement that
- 55:52exists in this show. It's a quick little, hey,
- 55:56if you don't know who I am, here's what I look
- 55:59like, here's what I sound like. You either vibe
- 56:02with me or you don't, right? Totally. So where
- 56:06do you see, we're recording this in July of 2026.
- 56:11We've talked about the change in constant in
- 56:13media. Where do you see the next few years in
- 56:17podcasting? And what is a podcast, right? So
- 56:20where do you see all of this going? I think that
- 56:24I have never been more optimistic about the future
- 56:27of dedicated communities and creators online.
- 56:31If you find somebody who makes you think, oh
- 56:34my God, I'm not alone. Somebody whose perspective,
- 56:37whose lived experience, whose criticism, whose
- 56:39curation makes you feel like you are learning
- 56:43and growing and being affirmed and meeting friends
- 56:45who have something in common with you. That is
- 56:47a magical experience. It is hard to meet your
- 56:50people. It is hard to make friends as an adult.
- 56:52It is hard in just the drudgery of like daily
- 56:55life and work and caring for people and meal
- 56:58prepping and like whatever. It's just, it's hard
- 57:00to remember that we are people with interests.
- 57:03And so one of the reasons I love podcasts is
- 57:05because it reminds me every single week when
- 57:07I listen to my favorite show or watch my favorite
- 57:09streamer or see a new post for my favorite creator,
- 57:12it affirms something about my interest, my perspective
- 57:15and who I am as a person. That is only going
- 57:18to get more important as I think life gets more
- 57:21fractal and more hectic and more unpredictable.
- 57:24I hope that I also see a corresponding rise in
- 57:28advertising dollars, in membership adoption and
- 57:32tools available to creators. It's amazing to
- 57:35me that 15 years ago, Patreon wasn't a thing.
- 57:38Like the fact that I have paid my rent with Patreon
- 57:41money since 2019 is astonishing and would not
- 57:45have been possible 15 years ago. I hope that
- 57:4810 years from now, there are tools supporting
- 57:50independent creators, independent communities
- 57:52to not just make stuff and connect with people,
- 57:55but also to make a sustainable living from that
- 57:58work than there are right now. And that's something
- 58:00I'm excited to see. Once again, I'll snap to
- 58:03that. Amazing. Now, as we come up to, I guess,
- 58:09the end of our time here, it's a good transition
- 58:11to independent creators. Discovery is difficult,
- 58:16which is why every Monday I post three podcasts
- 58:18I think people should listen to. So I always
- 58:20love to turn to my guests and go, besides the
- 58:23shows you've already listed, and we'll have listed
- 58:25in our show notes, what's one show that you think
- 58:28people should be discovering? I think people
- 58:30should listen to Consider This for Comfort. It's
- 58:33a fabulous show about the comfort media that
- 58:37we consume and what that says about us by Ateng
- 58:40Atah. I think it is absolutely fantastic. A new
- 58:43season is coming up soon and I love that show.
- 58:47It makes me feel like even though I'm not a Gilmore
- 58:49Girls girly, I'll listen to an episode about
- 58:51Gilmore Girls and be like, yes, you go Gilmore
- 58:53Girls. So it is that perfect mix for me of talking
- 58:57about something that we all have a lot of experience
- 58:59with. through a lens that is scholarly, enthusiastic,
- 59:02critical with a small C, and ultimately here
- 59:05to just interrogate human experience. And I love
- 59:08Etang as a host. Thank you for that one. And
- 59:11so the flip side to that is we always hear in
- 59:13the podcast space, oh my God, there's so many
- 59:15podcasts, but no one complains about there being
- 59:17too many books. And as you mentioned, one of
- 59:20your shows has a new books coming out. So what's
- 59:23one book that you would want to recommend that...
- 59:26It could be a children's book. It could be a
- 59:28book you're reading now. It could be anything
- 59:30that you think, hey, here's something that I've
- 59:33already given you something for your ears. Here's
- 59:35something for your eyes in that regards. Well,
- 59:38first of all, if you want to read the fabulous
- 59:40books that have been written by multitude hosts,
- 59:43go to multitudeshows .com slash books. We have
- 59:46a wonderful collection over on bookshop .org
- 59:48where you can find all those books by the independent
- 59:51booksellers and support those sellers at the
- 59:53same time. People are so smart and they write
- 59:56a lot of books. The book that I'm working my
- 59:58way through right now that is really helping
- 1:00:01to change how I think about commerce and creation
- 1:00:04and just what I do with my life is pleasure activism.
- 1:00:08It's something that I've seen quoted very, very
- 1:00:10often, Adrienne Marie Brown. And it's really
- 1:00:13about how can we think about activism, building
- 1:00:16a future, being citizens in community and in
- 1:00:18society in a way that's not just about like minimizing
- 1:00:21suffering, but building a dignified and pleasurable
- 1:00:25life. for all. And so every day, I have a little
- 1:00:28post it here on my monitor, I'm trying to get
- 1:00:31toward an emphatic yes. How can I make sure that
- 1:00:34my body and soul are like, you know, resonating
- 1:00:37together and harmonizing? And when I get to get
- 1:00:39on the call with Greg, I'm like, hell yes, I
- 1:00:42want to do this. Yes, this is exactly what I
- 1:00:44want to be doing with my day. And how can I take
- 1:00:46that energy and help make sure that other people
- 1:00:49get the same opportunities to again, not just
- 1:00:52survive, but thrive? Pleasure, activism. Gonna
- 1:00:56have to I mean that'll be in the show notes,
- 1:00:57but I have to go check that one out I like that
- 1:01:00and and that's I guess a good segue to Something
- 1:01:04we talked about and it's been described multiple
- 1:01:06times by other hosts or I guess other guests
- 1:01:09that are running networks Capitalism and yeah,
- 1:01:12you and I have both talked about like your view
- 1:01:15on which is an interesting one. So Hearing you
- 1:01:19mention this book give me a little concept of
- 1:01:22how you think about capitalism, but what you've
- 1:01:24done with multitude around that. Because there's,
- 1:01:27yeah, like I said, other guests have followed
- 1:01:29that same trend, which is great to hear that
- 1:01:32you can run a network and have that view. Yeah,
- 1:01:35I'm a registered socialist. I have been a registered
- 1:01:38socialist since 2020. It is really important
- 1:01:41to me that until we can overthrow capitalism,
- 1:01:45while we work to overthrow capitalism, which
- 1:01:48is inherently unfair, unjust, racist, misogynist,
- 1:01:52heteronormative, right, like ableist, all of
- 1:01:54these things. No one is going to build the kind
- 1:01:57of future I want to live in under capitalism.
- 1:01:59Until then, I think it is our mandate to use
- 1:02:02the systems that exist to try to benefit as many
- 1:02:06mutual aid groups, independent artists, and folks
- 1:02:09who are doing good work and deserve to make a
- 1:02:11living as possible. If this is interesting to
- 1:02:14you, I encourage you to reach out and Google
- 1:02:17things like the Solidarity Economy Movement,
- 1:02:20like worker -owned cooperatives, like collectivism,
- 1:02:23mutual aid, all of the ways that we can make
- 1:02:26sure that the dollars that exist in society keep
- 1:02:29circulating and are productive and try to get
- 1:02:32distributed to as many people as possible. And
- 1:02:34I think we see people following us, right? Like,
- 1:02:37it is very common for folks who love a podcast
- 1:02:41to contribute to that podcast, whether it's through
- 1:02:43buying a t -shirt or a one -time donation or
- 1:02:45joining a Patreon, even if they don't get any
- 1:02:48rewards. Like, people want to make sure that
- 1:02:50the stuff they love continues to exist and the
- 1:02:53people whose work they value are compensated
- 1:02:55for that value. And if you don't have the dollars
- 1:02:57right now... you share, you like, you comment,
- 1:03:00right? Like you send it to a friend, you try
- 1:03:01to make sure that you are giving back and moving
- 1:03:05toward that reciprocal, circular, generative
- 1:03:08economy that is better for people and artists
- 1:03:11and the planet. And consumers, I think all of
- 1:03:15that is incredibly important to build into our
- 1:03:18daily practice and to say to people, you know
- 1:03:21what, I don't do that for this reason. I don't
- 1:03:23use generative AI because it's destructive to
- 1:03:25artists and the environment. I actually don't
- 1:03:27charge, you know, this percent of interest, or
- 1:03:30I don't partake in loans or products from this
- 1:03:33company. We run based on Proton, not Google.
- 1:03:37really trying to live our principles in the flawed
- 1:03:40and messy and evolving reality that we find ourselves
- 1:03:43in. Thanks so much, Amanda, because like I said,
- 1:03:47it's been interesting to hear each person come
- 1:03:51on this show. And when I started this, I could
- 1:03:54bucket people into like, all right, you started
- 1:03:56your background in Like myself, ad sales, therefore,
- 1:04:00this type of network you're starting is nearly
- 1:04:02very much a ad sales kind of rep. But I look
- 1:04:05at how many networks are actually started, but
- 1:04:08also functioning to the same degree that you
- 1:04:11are, where it's like, hey, it's a collective.
- 1:04:13How do we help each other? We're all winning
- 1:04:15together. We're supporting. And so anyone that's
- 1:04:17listening to this, whether you are running a
- 1:04:19network, you can think about that and go, great.
- 1:04:22Amanda's doing it, and she's doing it the way
- 1:04:24she wants, but finding success. Or you could
- 1:04:27run it the way you've got. There's no right or
- 1:04:30wrong way, which I guess goes to one of the last
- 1:04:33questions here. How do you define success with
- 1:04:35multitude? I define success as helping creators
- 1:04:41make a sustainable living online. myself being
- 1:04:44one of them. And so I would say to people that
- 1:04:47if your success comes at someone else's expense,
- 1:04:50that is a really good data point to see how you
- 1:04:54can start untangling those things. How can you
- 1:04:56make it so that your success helps everybody
- 1:04:59around you, that that rising tide truly lifts
- 1:05:01all boats? That was a Wi -Fi password in our
- 1:05:03studio, by the way. How can you make sure that
- 1:05:06you are extending that ladder behind you, helping
- 1:05:09folks come up, documenting, sharing resources,
- 1:05:12sharing your insights, helping people out, helping
- 1:05:15others only ever comes back to you in the gift
- 1:05:18economy. Another great phrase to look up. Redoubled,
- 1:05:22right? And I really firmly believe that anyone's
- 1:05:26success in podcasting, any independent creator
- 1:05:28who gets to make a living, scale down a day job,
- 1:05:31quit a day job, that is good for all of us. And
- 1:05:34it's something I'm trying to fight for, not just
- 1:05:36for myself, not just for our creators, not just
- 1:05:38for our clients, but for everybody out there
- 1:05:40in podcasting. Well, on that note, Amanda, thank
- 1:05:43you so much for coming on Podcast Network Insights
- 1:05:46and sharing your insights. I appreciate it a
- 1:05:50lot and I appreciate you. Thank you for having
- 1:05:51me even though I am not a network, Greg. I really
- 1:05:53appreciate it. You know, collectives, as you
- 1:05:57said at this top, how a collective, how a network
- 1:05:59operates, I think the ideology is up for debate
- 1:06:04and that's why I love about this show. Well,
- 1:06:06listen, if you resonate with what I've got, then
- 1:06:08come on over to multitudeshows .com, join our
- 1:06:10ecosystem. You're gonna love it. There you go.
- 1:06:13Thanks, Amanda. Thanks, Greg. Well, you made
- 1:06:15it this far, and I really appreciate it. Like,
- 1:06:17truly, I do. If you've listened to this episode,
- 1:06:19you know that most of us don't make it this far,
- 1:06:22so thank you. And if you give me a few extra
- 1:06:24minutes, let me give you some of my thoughts
- 1:06:26about my conversation with Amanda. Coming back
- 1:06:28to the beginning of my conversation... The way
- 1:06:31Multitude draws such a sharp boundary around
- 1:06:33aligned values, personalities, and culture stood
- 1:06:35out to me. It isn't about slapping a logo onto
- 1:06:39a host. It's about whether you fit as a person,
- 1:06:42as much as you do as a show. That's not something
- 1:06:45you'd see at a lot of networks, where scales
- 1:06:47sometimes win over right fit. Besides that, there
- 1:06:51are a few other things that I walk away from
- 1:06:52this conversation. First is a former ad sales
- 1:06:55rep and someone who understands that the podcast
- 1:06:58industry really looks at monetization through
- 1:07:00the lens of ad sales. Amanda's view on ad sales
- 1:07:04is that she treats ad sales as a focused service
- 1:07:07that builds around deep knowledge of each show,
- 1:07:10not generic inventory. It's a multitude scale.
- 1:07:14It's not about automated or high volume deals.
- 1:07:17but about personal connections, intentional matching
- 1:07:20of advertisers and hosts, and never forcing anything
- 1:07:23that doesn't fit the show's ethos or audience.
- 1:07:26She openly shares the grind it takes. Hundreds
- 1:07:29of emails, lots of rejections, work with small
- 1:07:32numbers, but deep understanding. So the implication
- 1:07:35is, add sales and done well. It's about trust
- 1:07:39and fit at a human scale, not just about stuffing
- 1:07:42in sponsors to fill spots. and a collective can
- 1:07:46prioritize that individual alignment over raw
- 1:07:49value, which changes what creators might expect
- 1:07:53or value out of network support. Second thing,
- 1:07:57the approach on Amanda's onboarding. When a new
- 1:08:00show joins the multitude, they get what's basically
- 1:08:02a production consultation. Multiple team members
- 1:08:05pour over the show, map out what's working and
- 1:08:08what isn't, and gives deep, specific feedback.
- 1:08:11Most creators would expect something more like
- 1:08:14a plug -and -play approach, but this is hands
- 1:08:17-on and customized. And the only fee that the
- 1:08:21show is paying for all this knowledge and resource
- 1:08:24is a percentage of ad sales that Amanda sells.
- 1:08:27Whereas the value Amanda and her team brings
- 1:08:29is worth thousands of dollars. It's not how most
- 1:08:32networks operate. And for me, it raises the question
- 1:08:35of whether most networks are generally invested
- 1:08:37in the show they're bringing in. or if they're
- 1:08:40just building a catalog. Third, her journey from
- 1:08:44YouTuber to podcaster and that ongoing optimism
- 1:08:47for the industry. Amanda didn't start with a
- 1:08:50playbook. Instead, she carried out that fan -first
- 1:08:53ethic from early YouTube into podcasting and
- 1:08:56built Multitude to reflect it. She's still bullish
- 1:08:59about membership, ad sales, and whatever comes
- 1:09:02next for creators. This isn't a nostalgic play.
- 1:09:06It's a belief that the best is still in front
- 1:09:07of us. Fourth, what struck me was that even though
- 1:09:11Multitude focuses on ad sales, Amanda is vocal
- 1:09:15about the need for creators to diversify revenue.
- 1:09:18No one's banking on a single path. Live shows,
- 1:09:21merch, membership. There's a message that sustainability
- 1:09:24for creators won't look the same for everyone,
- 1:09:27and a collective job is not to control that,
- 1:09:30but to clear the runway for it. There's a lot
- 1:09:34there to sit with, and I'm curious what you learned
- 1:09:36from there. Once again, thank you for tuning
- 1:09:39in. To those of you who have rated and reviewed,
- 1:09:41reached out with comments, thank you. Make sure
- 1:09:44you leave a review, subscribe on your platform
- 1:09:46of choice. As I say, life is about time and relationships.
- 1:09:50You have no clue where one conversation may take
- 1:09:52you. This is why I'm able to have this show and
- 1:09:55provide you with these conversations. This is
- 1:09:58why I love networking. You have no clue where
- 1:10:01listening to these conversations will take you.
- 1:10:03now or in the future, but I guarantee you, your
- 1:10:07future self will thank you for tuning in. I live
- 1:10:10on LinkedIn, reach out, let's talk. To those
- 1:10:13of you who have already done so, I appreciate
- 1:10:15that. That alone means this podcast is value
- 1:10:18and is creating more conversations that I want
- 1:10:20to happen. I have a newsletter that promotes
- 1:10:23podcasts because as we talked about, podcast
- 1:10:25discovery is difficult. So find it on my LinkedIn,
- 1:10:29subscribe, and find podcasts that I review weekly
- 1:10:32along with my guest's recommendations. And as
- 1:10:34always, subscribe where you listen. New episodes
- 1:10:37come out on Thursday wherever you consume your
- 1:10:39podcast. And until next time, I appreciate you.