Latest / Play Therapy Parenting: Real Parenting Questions Answered by a Child Therapist / S2E33 - Biting, Aggression, and Emotional Overwhelm: Why Kids Act Out During Life Transitions—And How to Help
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the
- 0:03Play Therapy Parenting Podcast with Dr. Brenna Hicks.
- 0:09Hi,
- 0:09I'm Dr. Brenna Hicks,
- 0:10The Kid Counselor.
- 0:11This is the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast where I give you insight,
- 0:14awareness,
- 0:15and enlightenment about your parenting
- 0:17and your relationship with your kids.
- 0:19In today's episode,
- 0:20I am answering a question from Heather,
- 0:22and Heather is currently going through a divorce and is asking
- 0:27quite a few questions about how to handle
- 0:31assisting their child with the adjustment
- 0:33and some of the behavior things that are coming up from that.
- 0:37So Heather,
- 0:37thank you so much for the email.
- 0:38I really appreciate it
- 0:40and hopefully we can dive into this and,
- 0:42and really kind of make sense of
- 0:44what we can do to assist from a child-centered play therapy perspective.
- 0:49And if you all would like to reach out to me,
- 0:51I would love to hear from you brenna@thekidcounselor.com or you can,
- 0:55if you're in the states,
- 0:56you can call the voicemail number,
- 0:58which is 813-812-5525,
- 1:02and you can leave me a voicemail message and
- 1:03I can answer your question from the voicemail.
- 1:06OK,
- 1:06so let me read parts of the email from Heather,
- 1:09and then we'll kind of dive in together.
- 1:11I'm writing because I'm currently going through a divorce.
- 1:14I think my husband would probably be diagnosed
- 1:16with a personality disorder if he was tested.
- 1:19I listened to the podcast about the effects of divorce,
- 1:22and now I'm scared for my child,
- 1:23having been deployed to war 4 times and knowing and
- 1:26understanding the effects that has and seeing it firsthand.
- 1:29By the way,
- 1:29Heather,
- 1:30thank you so much for serving our country and for everything that you've done for us.
- 1:34My child has had a handful of different behavioral challenges,
- 1:36and I was trying to gentle parent and muddling through.
- 1:39I'm now working with a play therapist.
- 1:41I'm so happy to hear that,
- 1:43and I'm doing filial therapy,
- 1:44good for you.
- 1:45It's different than the parenting that I was raised with
- 1:48and in 2022 when my soon to be ex first deployed
- 1:51and our first au pair was with us for two years,
- 1:54had to leave.
- 1:55That was when my son,
- 1:56who is now 415 and was then 2,
- 1:58started biting kids
- 2:00at the time I had to put him in daycare because I lost individual care.
- 2:04He's now in preschool and he has continued to be
- 2:06aggressive with other children and is also aggressive with me.
- 2:09The aggression and biting returned in early November around the
- 2:12time my husband threatened to take our son from me
- 2:15and after me leaving the house,
- 2:17and we're now splitting time with our son.
- 2:19How do I balance helping my child through the trauma of the
- 2:22divorce with the behavioral challenges with the influence from his dad?
- 2:25I want my child to be resilient,
- 2:27self-contained,
- 2:28and not entitled,
- 2:29and I want him to stop hurting other kids and myself.
- 2:32I welcome any thoughts.
- 2:34All right,
- 2:34Heather,
- 2:35so multi-layered for sure,
- 2:37and
- 2:38I will try my best to kind of look at each of these individual components,
- 2:42but
- 2:43let me just celebrate the fact that you're pursuing play therapy
- 2:47and doing filial.
- 2:48For those of you that are not familiar with that,
- 2:50it is a parenting training program that teaches you as the parent to
- 2:54actually use the play therapy skills with your child at your home.
- 2:58And so,
- 2:58I'm so encouraged to hear that,
- 3:00Heather,
- 3:00and I know that that will just make a world of difference for you and your son,
- 3:03and specifically your relationship,
- 3:05because let's go back to the heart of why
- 3:08we do what we do.
- 3:10It's to preserve the relationship.
- 3:12And based on what you've described,
- 3:15you've been deployed,
- 3:16your husband has been deployed.
- 3:18He had an au pair,
- 3:19for those of you that don't know,
- 3:20fancy way to say nanny,
- 3:22basically someone that
- 3:24takes care of your child when you can't,
- 3:26and
- 3:27that person that was with him for two years,
- 3:29which becomes a parent figure and there's attachment
- 3:32and there's connection and there's relationship there,
- 3:35you've left,
- 3:36your husband has left,
- 3:37and then your au pair leaves.
- 3:39So,
- 3:39your son has been through a lot of
- 3:42fractured relationships and,
- 3:44and for no fault of you all,
- 3:46you serve in the military,
- 3:47thank you for that.
- 3:48And there are sacrifices that you make every day,
- 3:51and this is one of them.
- 3:53That said,
- 3:54your child is now struggling because
- 3:58there needs to be relationship repair.
- 4:00Then pile on top
- 4:02that now there's a divorce and separation going.
- 4:05So now here's another uprooting,
- 4:07and now there's OK,
- 4:09so now I'm only with dad part of the time,
- 4:11mom part of the time,
- 4:12and again this is relationship that needs to be repaired.
- 4:17This is why you're listening to this podcast.
- 4:18This is why you're pursuing filial therapy,
- 4:21because what we know about this approach
- 4:23is that
- 4:24it preserves the relationship
- 4:26and it puts the relationship at the heart of everything we do.
- 4:29Let's go back to the four pillars.
- 4:31If you're new to the podcast,
- 4:32please go back and at least start at season 2,
- 4:35but it would actually be better if you go back and listen to season 1.
- 4:38If you're not familiar with the four pillars,
- 4:40it's the 4 basic ways that we interact with our children.
- 4:43We reflect their feelings,
- 4:44we set limits,
- 4:45we give them choices,
- 4:47and we encourage them.
- 4:48It's relationship preserving.
- 4:51We have our rules of thumb and our tenets
- 4:53and our philosophies that undergird everything we do.
- 4:56We focus on the relationship,
- 4:57not the problem.
- 4:59Just noticing a child is a powerful builder of self-esteem.
- 5:02If we can't say it in 10 words or less,
- 5:04don't say it.
- 5:04We have all of these principles
- 5:06that guide and direct our interactions with our kids.
- 5:10So Heather,
- 5:11every time that you are using these pillars,
- 5:14every time
- 5:15that you let these rules of thumb and
- 5:16these tenants support what you're saying and doing,
- 5:20it's repairing relationship,
- 5:21it's building relationship,
- 5:23there's connection,
- 5:24there's communication,
- 5:26there's trust,
- 5:27there's respect,
- 5:28there's all of the things that need to be repaired
- 5:31because
- 5:31through all of these experiences,
- 5:34he has felt that some of these things are unsteady and unstable.
- 5:38So as you are starting to pour into him,
- 5:42it will naturally adjust that.
- 5:44Now,
- 5:45let's normalize a little bit.
- 5:46He started biting kids.
- 5:48It's an emotional and a behavioral reaction
- 5:52to what's going on internally.
- 5:54He has pent up emotion,
- 5:56he's little,
- 5:57doesn't have language skills,
- 5:58doesn't have self-control,
- 5:59doesn't have emotional vocabulary.
- 6:02The only way I know how to release this
- 6:05is aggressive behavior,
- 6:07and biting is an easy thing for kids to do.
- 6:11So that's actually very age appropriate number one,
- 6:13but it's also understandable
- 6:15based on the circumstances.
- 6:18He was dealing with so much emotionally and he didn't know
- 6:21how to channel that appropriately.
- 6:23No,
- 6:24no 2.5 year old does.
- 6:26Let's be really clear,
- 6:27we cannot expect a 2 year old to channel their emotions appropriately.
- 6:31They're here and now,
- 6:32they're emotional beings,
- 6:33and they're going to show you how they feel.
- 6:36So his biting is his demonstration
- 6:39of the upheaval that he's feeling.
- 6:41That's appropriate.
- 6:43And then you say that he's continued to be
- 6:46aggressive with other children and aggressive with you.
- 6:49OK,
- 6:49what we know
- 6:50is that
- 6:51the child will naturally.
- 6:54I have a tendency to anyway,
- 6:56doesn't always work this way,
- 6:57but children have a tendency
- 6:59to be at their worst
- 7:01for the person that unconditionally loves them the most.
- 7:04So Heather,
- 7:05you might be the safe place for him to land.
- 7:08If he knows that you're going to
- 7:09unconditionally love him and unconditionally accept him
- 7:13and even at his worst
- 7:15you love him through it anyway.
- 7:17He will hold it together for other people as much as possible
- 7:20and then fall apart with you.
- 7:23So often kids are the most aggressive with the person they feel the safest with,
- 7:26and that doesn't seem to make sense
- 7:28at an adult cognitive intellectual level,
- 7:31but it makes perfect sense to a child because
- 7:34you'll love me tomorrow even if I yell at you today.
- 7:38And there's no fear
- 7:40that
- 7:40uh if I take it too far,
- 7:43they won't love me anymore.
- 7:45So while that's hard being in that position,
- 7:47Heather,
- 7:48it does indicate the kind of relationship that you might have
- 7:51built with him and that he defaults to that belief.
- 7:55However,
- 7:56we know
- 7:57that aggression warrants an immediate limit,
- 7:59no matter what.
- 8:01So you said that the aggression and the biting returned in
- 8:03November when your husband threatened to take him from you.
- 8:06Of course,
- 8:07he would have aggression again because he's upheaved again and he's scared.
- 8:12And
- 8:13after you left the house,
- 8:15it's another huge change for him,
- 8:16huge upheaval.
- 8:18So kids will naturally default to what they've always done.
- 8:22Humans default to what they've always done,
- 8:24let's be clear.
- 8:25But kids specifically behaviorally and emotionally,
- 8:28they will default to what they've always done
- 8:30because it's easy and it requires no work.
- 8:33However,
- 8:34if he's being aggressive with you,
- 8:36it warrants an immediate limit.
- 8:38So as soon as he hits or kicks or bites or whatever it is,
- 8:43Heather,
- 8:43you jump straight to the limit.
- 8:46I am not for hurting.
- 8:49And if you are familiar with limit setting,
- 8:50notice that I went straight to the communicate the limit.
- 8:53I did not reflect the feeling first.
- 8:56We only do that before the behavior,
- 8:58not during the behavior.
- 9:01So if he's already being aggressive,
- 9:03it's straight to the limit.
- 9:04I am not for hurting.
- 9:06And if you need to hold his arm,
- 9:08if you need to hold his leg,
- 9:09if you need to stop
- 9:11the behavior,
- 9:13You do it calmly,
- 9:14you do it neutrally,
- 9:16you're not emotional,
- 9:17you're not reactive.
- 9:19You're not
- 9:20grabbing at his arm and making it's not a big production.
- 9:24You just hold it firmly and you say,
- 9:26I am not for hitting.
- 9:29If he's able to control himself,
- 9:30you let go.
- 9:32If he tries again,
- 9:33you hold it again,
- 9:34and you say,
- 9:34I am not for hitting.
- 9:36I am not for kicking.
- 9:39Then you go back through the process.
- 9:42You're upset.
- 9:44You're angry,
- 9:45you're frustrated,
- 9:46you're scared,
- 9:47you're confused,
- 9:48whatever it is that you think he's feeling.
- 9:52Please do not default.
- 9:54This is for everyone.
- 9:55Please do not default to your mad or you're angry.
- 9:59Aggression is very rarely about anger.
- 10:02It's usually about a vulnerable emotion that they're masking.
- 10:06So be really intentional about looking into your child's eyes.
- 10:09Let's go back to the reflecting feelings pillar.
- 10:12Look into your child's eyes and get a clue.
- 10:15Please don't assume that they're mad.
- 10:18They're probably not.
- 10:20That's just their mask.
- 10:22They're probably trying to hide a vulnerable emotion.
- 10:25So
- 10:26you're confused,
- 10:27you're worried,
- 10:27you're upset,
- 10:28you're scared,
- 10:29you're frustrated,
- 10:30you're irritated,
- 10:31you're annoyed,
- 10:31whatever.
- 10:32Probably not angry.
- 10:35But I am never for hurting.
- 10:38If you want to enlarge it,
- 10:39since this is happening with children as well,
- 10:41people are never for hurting.
- 10:44People are not for hitting,
- 10:46people are not for kicking,
- 10:47people are not for biting.
- 10:49You can go broad or you can go specific,
- 10:51which with me,
- 10:52I am not for.
- 10:55Now,
- 10:56if we stop there,
- 10:58the missing link is the choice and the returning of responsibility.
- 11:01He needs to have alternatives.
- 11:04So
- 11:05you can choose to punch.
- 11:07The pillows on the couch.
- 11:09Or you can choose to kick.
- 11:12The beanbag chair.
- 11:15I don't know what your options are.
- 11:16I'm just throwing out hypotheticals.
- 11:18If he needs a release for the aggression.
- 11:22If he has all of this pent up stuff and he needs to get it out,
- 11:25he needs to have opportunities to do that,
- 11:27but it needs to be appropriate.
- 11:30So if he can punch the pillows on the couch,
- 11:31or if he can kick a beanbag chair,
- 11:33or if he can
- 11:35pummel his stuffed animals,
- 11:36whatever it is.
- 11:38You give him alternatives,
- 11:39Heather.
- 11:40So let's go through this all together.
- 11:42People are not for hitting.
- 11:44I am not for hurting,
- 11:46whatever you want to say.
- 11:47Start there,
- 11:48then go through the three-step process.
- 11:51You're really angry,
- 11:53you're really sad,
- 11:54you're really upset.
- 11:55You're really whatever,
- 11:56whatever is the most appropriate emotion.
- 11:59But I am never for hurting.
- 12:01You can choose to punch the pillows on the couch
- 12:03or you can choose to kick the beanbag chair,
- 12:05which do you choose?
- 12:08And the goal is that he learns to self regulate,
- 12:12he learns to self-control.
- 12:14And here's the beauty of this limit setting involves 3
- 12:18of the pillars,
- 12:20all in one.
- 12:20So this is kind of,
- 12:21uh,
- 12:21this is a bonus,
- 12:22one fell swoop for 3.
- 12:25You're reflecting his feelings,
- 12:26which means he's building an emotional vocabulary.
- 12:29You're setting neutral limits,
- 12:30so he's learning to regulate.
- 12:33And you're giving him choices,
- 12:34so he's learning self-control and ownership of outcome.
- 12:38And Heather,
- 12:39you specifically said,
- 12:40how do I help him
- 12:41through the trauma and the behavioral challenges.
- 12:44I want him to be resilient,
- 12:45self-controlled,
- 12:46and not entitled and stop hurting others.
- 12:48Well,
- 12:48limit setting is,
- 12:49is your path
- 12:51because you reflect his feelings,
- 12:52you set a neutral limit and you give him choices,
- 12:55you'll achieve all of those goals through that process.
- 12:59And be consistent.
- 13:01Now,
- 13:01if he violates the limit 3 times,
- 13:04so you've made it very clear you're not for hitting,
- 13:07kicking,
- 13:07biting,
- 13:08whatever is going on,
- 13:09and he does it.
- 13:11And he does it 3 times.
- 13:13You move to ultimate limit setting,
- 13:15which I don't think we've talked about it often,
- 13:17but let me just refresh for those of you
- 13:19that have been veteran listeners from the very beginning.
- 13:22If you're new to this,
- 13:23get a,
- 13:24get a notepad.
- 13:25Once the child is unwilling or unable to comply with the limit 3 times,
- 13:31you move to ultimate limit setting.
- 13:33So in that scenario,
- 13:34you say,
- 13:34I'm gonna say that your son's name is Jake.
- 13:36I don't know.
- 13:37So you say,
- 13:39Jake.
- 13:40You've chosen to hit me and you know that I'm not for hitting.
- 13:44If you choose to hit me,
- 13:46you choose negative consequence.
- 13:49It needs to be a doozy.
- 13:50He's 4,
- 13:51it has to be immediate,
- 13:52and it has to be that day only.
- 13:55Can't be later that night.
- 13:56It can't be later that week.
- 13:57It can't be this weekend.
- 13:58It has to be immediate
- 14:00because his
- 14:01time frame is very skewed.
- 14:04So there has to be immediacy,
- 14:06and it has to be his currency.
- 14:07What matters to him.
- 14:10Is it time with his friends?
- 14:11Is it snuggle time before bed?
- 14:13Is it reading a book together?
- 14:15Is it dessert,
- 14:16whatever it is?
- 14:18It has to be immediate and it has to be that day.
- 14:21Never let it carry over.
- 14:22He's too young.
- 14:24So
- 14:25Jake,
- 14:26you.
- 14:27Chose to hurt me and you know that I'm not for hurting.
- 14:30If you choose to do it again,
- 14:32you're choosing negative consequence.
- 14:35If you choose not to hurt me
- 14:37and you choose to kick
- 14:39the beanbag instead,
- 14:40you choose to keep
- 14:42said thing.
- 14:43You choose to have said thing.
- 14:46Make sure that you give the positive and the negative.
- 14:49If you choose positive,
- 14:51then you choose positive.
- 14:52If you choose negative,
- 14:53then you choose negative.
- 14:54Which do you choose?
- 14:55Notice that I said the word choose 5 times.
- 14:58It doesn't work without saying choose 5 times.
- 15:01It's not the same thing to say if you do that again,
- 15:04I'm going to,
- 15:05if you don't do that again,
- 15:06you're going to,
- 15:07those are threats.
- 15:09The child learns nothing about self-control and self-responsibility.
- 15:13It's a choice
- 15:15If you choose positive,
- 15:16you choose positive.
- 15:17If you choose negative,
- 15:18you choose negative,
- 15:19which do you choose?
- 15:21And then here's the beauty heather and for all the rest of us.
- 15:25You would always choose for him to have the best things.
- 15:29You would choose for him to have dessert or have the book,
- 15:33or have the cuddle time,
- 15:34or have time with friends,
- 15:35or have his favorite TV show,
- 15:37whatever.
- 15:37You would always choose for him to have those things,
- 15:41but sometimes he's going to choose not to.
- 15:44It's not your burden.
- 15:45It's not your responsibility.
- 15:47You're not the disciplinarian.
- 15:48You're not the ruler with the iron fist.
- 15:51You very calmly,
- 15:52very neutrally.
- 15:54Very light.
- 15:56You're able to say,
- 15:58I see you've chosen
- 15:59to have dessert tonight because you chose not to hurt me,
- 16:02or I see you've chosen not to have dessert tonight because you chose to hit me,
- 16:06but you can try again tomorrow.
- 16:09And Heather and all the rest of you.
- 16:12If your child chooses the negative consequence.
- 16:16That child chooses the negative consequence.
- 16:19This does not work if you give in.
- 16:22When he cries,
- 16:23when he throws a fit,
- 16:24when he tries to hit you again,
- 16:25when he screams,
- 16:26when he throws himself on the ground,
- 16:28when there's alligator tears pouring out of his eyes,
- 16:31and he's screaming and crying,
- 16:32and it's a terrible,
- 16:32horrible,
- 16:33no good day.
- 16:35You do not give in.
- 16:37And here's how you stalwart yourself against it,
- 16:39and here's how you make sure that you stick to it.
- 16:42He chose.
- 16:44He chose
- 16:46that outcome
- 16:47you didn't.
- 16:49And you're not choosing to make his life miserable,
- 16:52you're just enforcing the choice that he made.
- 16:55So you reflect feelings and you let him know that tomorrow's a new day.
- 16:59Oh,
- 16:59you're so disappointed that you chose to hit me
- 17:02and you chose not to have dessert tonight,
- 17:03but you can try again tomorrow.
- 17:06No,
- 17:07oh,
- 17:08you're really upset,
- 17:10but you chose to hit me,
- 17:11but you can try again tomorrow.
- 17:14At the very moment that you chose to hurt me,
- 17:15it was at that very moment that you chose not to have books tonight,
- 17:18but you can try again tomorrow.
- 17:21Guess what?
- 17:22You're going to outwit and outlast and outplay your child.
- 17:26I talk about this with my therapists all the time.
- 17:29You're going to outwit,
- 17:30outlast and outplay.
- 17:32One of you is going to give in and it's not going to be you.
- 17:36Because choice giving falls apart and limit setting falls apart if you cave.
- 17:41Because guess what the child learns.
- 17:43Well,
- 17:43I just have to escalate and I get my way.
- 17:46True,
- 17:47we don't want that.
- 17:48You know what we want?
- 17:50Dang,
- 17:51that was terrible.
- 17:52I didn't get books 3 nights in a row.
- 17:54I'm not doing that anymore.
- 17:56I'll just stop hitting her.
- 17:57It's not worth it.
- 17:59Self-control.
- 18:01Self-regulation
- 18:03It only works when we don't cave.
- 18:05So I hope that is a huge encouragement to you.
- 18:08Limit setting.
- 18:10Straight to the neutral limit if the behavior is already taking place,
- 18:14then the 3-step limit setting process,
- 18:16then if the child is unwilling or unable to comply with the limit on the 3rd go round,
- 18:21we go to ultimate limit setting.
- 18:24So Heather,
- 18:24I hope that that's helpful and I hope that as you
- 18:26do filial and as your child is in play therapy,
- 18:30I hope that you see monumental changes.
- 18:32I,
- 18:32I'm looking forward to getting an update from you.
- 18:34Please email me and let me know how things are going,
- 18:36and thank you so much for the email.
- 18:38For those of you that are in a similar situation,
- 18:41dealing with big feelings,
- 18:42big emotions,
- 18:43big behaviors,
- 18:44limit setting process is the most effective tool in your toolbox.
- 18:48So I hope that encourages you,
- 18:49and again,
- 18:50Heather,
- 18:50thank you for sharing.
- 18:52All right,
- 18:52I appreciate y'all so much.
- 18:53Thank you for the commitment that you make to your kids.
- 18:56Thank you for the commitment that you make to your families,
- 18:58and thanks for allowing me to be a small part of it.
- 19:00We'll talk again soon.
- 19:01Bye.
- 19:02Thank you for listening to
- 19:03the Play Therapy Parenting Podcast with Dr. Brenna Hicks.
- 19:07For more episodes and just subscribe to our newsletter,
- 19:10please go to www.playtherapyparenting.com.