Latest / The Bitcoin Way Podcast / The Worst Way To Do Multisig (And What You Can Do Instead)
Transcript
- 0:00Did you know that almost two out of three people using collaborative custody to secure their Bitcoin are not actually able to recover it on their own?
- 0:08They're depending on their custodian staying in business.
- 0:12This shocking number, taken from one of our own surveys, highlights just one of the risks of collaborative multi-sig custody setups.
- 0:20In the wake of the cold card incident, interest in creating a multisig setup for your Bitcoin has become increasingly popular, with many people pushing it as the ultimate solution.
- 0:31And on the surface, it might seem like having a multisig setup is automatically more secure than having a single SIG one. But is that actually the case?
- 0:40In this video, I'm going to explain exactly what multisig involved, who it's best suited for, and the two options you have if you decide to use multisig to secure your Bitcoin.
- 0:52I'll also explain the hidden risks of collaborative multisig that most people overlook.
- 0:57And finally, I'll share what I think is one of the best alternatives to multisig for most folks.
- 1:04Multi-SIG refers to a Bitcoin custody setup that requires multiple signatures to authorize a transaction.
- 1:11Depending on the configuration, there will be a minimum number of signatures required.
- 1:17For example, with a 2 of 3 multi-SIG, there are 3 possible keys that can sign a transaction
- 1:23and any 2 of them are required for the transaction to be approved.
- 1:28Or, with a 3 of 5 multi-SIG, any 3 of the 5 possible keys are required.
- 1:34In contrast, a single SIG Bitcoin custody setup has only one key and that key is required to sign every transaction.
- 1:42The main purpose of multisig is to create redundancy so that if one of the keys is lost, the entire setup isn't compromised.
- 1:50Before I go any further, if you're learning something from this video, please do me a favor and hit that subscribe button and turn on the notifications bell.
- 1:58and you can see that the Bitcoin way is to help as many people as possible become sovereign individuals and it helps us get this important information out to more folks.
- 2:09Okay, so I've given you a basic definition of multisig. Now the next question is who should actually be using it?
- 2:16There are a few situations where a multisig setup might be a better option than single especially when multiple parties are involved Multi allows you to distribute authority in ways that a single setup cannot
- 2:31Which means multi-sig can be a good fit wherever funds are shared and having a single key will create too much risk.
- 2:38For example, a business treasury that no executive can drain, a family with a shared stack, non-profits and clubs where multiple board members need to approve a spend, or trustees who are holding Bitcoin for others.
- 2:52Multisig can also help with inheritance. For example, an heir and an executor could each hold a key so that neither one can access the Bitcoin while you're alive, but together they can access it when you're gone.
- 3:04So for those who decide multi-sig is the right setup for them, which options do you actually have?
- 3:11Multi-sig custody can broadly be split into two categories.
- 3:15The first option, and this is the one most people associate with multi-sig, is collaborative custody.
- 3:22Collaborative custody means you have a custodian who holds at least one of your keys.
- 3:27The second option is private multi-sig where there is no custodial third party involved.
- 3:32First, I want to dig into the risks associated with collaborative custody.
- 3:38And yes, there are quite a few number of them.
- 3:41But clever marketing often brushes over these risks and make it appear as though having a custodian reduces your overall risk.
- 3:50It doesn't. And here's why.
- 3:52The extra complexity of a multi-six setup is one reason many people end up relying on a custodian to help them manage it.
- 4:00But having a custodial third party involved in your Bitcoin custody goes against the very ethos of Bitcoin.
- 4:08By adding a trusted third party, you're bringing back the very thing Bitcoin was designed to protect you from.
- 4:15Now you have to trust that custodian.
- 4:17You have to trust that they'll be available when you need them and that they won't go bankrupt or out of business.
- 4:22If you lose one key and your custodian is no longer available, you may be unable to sign the transaction needed to move your Bitcoin.
- 4:31And even if you still have access to two of the three keys, would you know how to transact without the custodian's assistance?
- 4:40Would you be able to rebuild the wallet in new software if you had to Collaborative custodians often use proprietary software for their multi setups
- 4:50So if you suddenly had to recover your remaining keys without their guidance,
- 4:54would you actually know how to do it?
- 4:56According to our survey, only one of three people using collaborative custody
- 5:00have complete recovery data.
- 5:02That means two-thirds of them would be completely stuck if their provider disappeared.
- 5:07These are terrible odds.
- 5:10Another overlooked risk of collaborative custody is KYC and compromised privacy.
- 5:15You'll need to provide your personal details and identification when signing up for their service.
- 5:21On top of that, your custodian will know when you make a transaction and exactly how much Bitcoin is involved.
- 5:29You have zero financial privacy.
- 5:31And finally, you need to be aware that you'll be paying ongoing fees.
- 5:36Most platforms charge a flat annual subscription fee, but some charge based on a percentage of your holdings.
- 5:44That means the more Bitcoin you hold, the more you pay.
- 5:47It essentially becomes like a wealth tax, and if you stop paying those fees, you may no longer be able to rely on that custodian.
- 5:55So what was supposed to be a backup has now become dependent on you continuing to pay for their service.
- 6:02And worse, some custodians will charge exit fees if you decide to move your Bitcoin elsewhere.
- 6:08It's like having an exit tax that some countries apply when you give up tax residency.
- 6:14So, is there an alternative to collaborative multisig?
- 6:18Of course there is.
- 6:20And it's called private multisig.
- 6:23It doesn't require a third party.
- 6:26And it's available to everyone.
- 6:29Let me explain.
- 6:30Multisig is a Bitcoin capability. Collaborative custody is a service built around it. That means anyone can have a multisig setup with or without a custodian. For example, you could have a private two of three multisig setup where you alone hold all three keys. Or you can have each key held by a different family member or trusted member. It's completely up to you.
- 6:54and you are not required to pay a custodian simply because you decide to use multisig So what are the trade if you decide to use a private multi arrangement Well every type of self setup has benefits and drawbacks including private multi
- 7:14First, you have at least three sets of keys to backup and protect, and that needs to be done with plenty of foresight.
- 7:21If you put all three backups in the same drawer, you still have a single point of failure.
- 7:26Second, this setup requires additional hardware and therefore more expense.
- 7:32You also have more devices to learn how to use, update and restore.
- 7:36And third, you need to make sure you always have a copy of the wallet configuration file.
- 7:41Without it, you may not be able to create the original multisig wallet if you ever need to restore it.
- 7:47So private multisig does add complexity to your Bitcoin self-custody.
- 7:51And that's the trade-off that comes with the additional security a properly configured private multisig can provide.
- 7:59So what is the best alternative to multisig custody?
- 8:03If you've weighed up your options and decided that multisig would add too much unnecessary complexity for your situation,
- 8:11there is another option that may be more suitable for you.
- 8:14You can still achieve an extremely secure Bitcoin self-custody setup with single SIG as long as two requirements are met.
- 8:23First, your seed phrase needs to be created with maximum entropy and second, you'll combine it with a highly secure passphrase.
- 8:31Together, a secure seed phrase and a passphrase can create an extremely robust self-custody setup without the added complexity of multi-SIG.
- 8:41And for most people, that is enough.
- 8:44If you need help with your Bitcoin self-custody, whether that's multi-sig or single-sig, or you simply want advice on which option is best for your situation, you can get in touch with us at The Bitcoin Way.
- 8:56This is what we do all day, every day. We never hold any of your keys and we don't KYC you. Our job is to train you to become a fully self-sovereign individual.
- 9:07So click the link below to download our self-custody guide or schedule a free 30-minute one-on-one call to speak with a member of our team.
- 9:15Thanks for watching and as always, stay safe and above all, stay sovereign.