Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / ACA Reporting Enforcement: Filing Duties, Penalties, and Relief Options
Transcript
- 0:03Hello and welcome to ACA reporting, enforcement,
- 0:07filing duties, penalties and relief options.
- 0:09I'm Philipp Behren, Chair of the BHBA Taxation
- 0:12Laws Section. The tax section is sponsored by
- 0:15Hochmann, Salk and Toscher Press. The Hochmann,
- 0:17Salk and Toscher Press advantage is experience
- 0:19and eye for innovation and a genuine dedication
- 0:22to clients, their families and their business.
- 0:25In addition to their national practice in civil
- 0:27and tax criminal tax controversies and related
- 0:30litigation in federal and state courts. The firm
- 0:33is also active and successful in handling other
- 0:36non -tax white -collar investigations and prosecutions.
- 0:41I'm delighted to introduce our speaker today,
- 0:43Joseph Boyles. Joseph is a licensed California
- 0:47CPA and attorney -at -law and the founder of
- 0:50the law office of Joseph A. Boyles, Inc. After
- 0:559 years as an IRS revenue agent, he has spent
- 0:58the past 27 years representing individuals and
- 1:02businesses before the IRS, FTB, BOE and EDD in
- 1:06civil and criminal tax disputes, including income,
- 1:10estate, sales, employment and property tax audits,
- 1:13appeals and litigation. With 36 years of combined
- 1:16experience, Joseph brings an insider's understanding
- 1:20of how the tax agency operates to every case.
- 1:24helping clients resolve even the most complex
- 1:27tax problems. And now we will present to us a
- 1:30topic that is not as publicly known yet, but
- 1:35he has some key insights to share with us. Let's
- 1:38get started, Joseph. Thank you, Philipp. So as
- 1:43Philipp mentioned, I started my career at the
- 1:45IRS, and that was 36 years ago. And I've seen
- 1:50this recurring trend. over the past 36 years
- 1:53where the IRS finds some area that they think
- 1:57is out of compliance or needs enforcement, and
- 2:01they'll focus their resources on some particular
- 2:04area. When I was a revenue agent, we had programs
- 2:08on non -filers. There was a nationwide non -filer
- 2:13program, and we spent a few years identifying,
- 2:17chasing down, and getting non -filers to file.
- 2:21Everyone knows the Offshore Voluntary Compliance
- 2:24programs. That was a really big program that
- 2:29everyone knows. During my career, I've seen that
- 2:34the IRS will target failure to file W -2s. A
- 2:41few years ago, the IRS was issuing these penalties.
- 2:45They called them CARS penalties. CARS is an acronym,
- 2:49Combined Annual Wage Report. And they were checking
- 2:54to see if the W2s matched the W3, matched the
- 3:00940, matched all four 941s. And if those four
- 3:05sets of forms didn't match, then something was
- 3:07wrong. And they would issue this CARS penalty.
- 3:11And this is probably 15 years ago. And for a
- 3:15couple of years, I had a bunch of those cases.
- 3:18I was talking with Philip about these. recent
- 3:22penalty cases that I've got for failure to file
- 3:26forms 1094 and 1095. These forms are required
- 3:32by the Affordable Health Care Act, and there
- 3:37are actually, I guess, six forms. There's the
- 3:42940, I'm sorry, The 1094A, 1094B, 1094C, and
- 3:58the 1095A and B. The 1094 and 5As are required
- 4:05to be filed by a And none of my cases involve
- 4:11marketplaces. So I'm not very familiar with what
- 4:13a marketplace is or who has that kind of insurance.
- 4:16I think that's like Obamacare. So I've got a
- 4:20couple of cases where these are private employers
- 4:24who provided healthcare insurance to their employees
- 4:28and they didn't file the required forms. And
- 4:32so if you're a private employer, And if you have
- 4:37more than 50 employees, they're called applicable
- 4:41large employers. And there's a definition for
- 4:46what an applicable large employer is. That definition
- 4:52is in Internal Revenue Code section 4980 cap
- 4:56H. So if you're a private employer with more
- 5:01than 50 employees, then you're required to file
- 5:05forms 1094 C and 1095 C. goes to the IRS and
- 5:20the 1095C goes to the employee. And both of them
- 5:25report whether you provided insurance and for
- 5:30how long. The definition of what a applicable
- 5:38large employer is is kind of interesting. It's
- 5:44not Well, I'm reading from the statute. The term
- 5:50applicable large employer means with respect
- 5:53to a calendar year, an employer who employed
- 5:56an average of at least 50 full -time employees
- 5:59on business days during the preceding calendar
- 6:02year. So let's think about that because it's
- 6:06relevant in one of my cases. In one of my cases,
- 6:11the employer is a It's a corporation that owns
- 6:15nightclubs. And the penalty that they got is
- 6:20for tax year 2021. Well, that was during the
- 6:24pandemic. And a lot of nightclubs were closed
- 6:27during the pandemic. And this particular employer
- 6:30closed a lot of it. It owns nightclubs and multiple
- 6:35nightclubs in multiple cities and multiple states
- 6:38in the United States. They issued, I think they
- 6:44issued like 150 W -2s, which is what triggered
- 6:47this audit. So they issued 150 W -2s, but they
- 6:52didn't issue any forms 1094C or 1095C. And that's
- 6:57what triggered this inquiry. Because the IRS
- 7:02thinks, well, if they have 150 employees, they
- 7:06must be an applicable large employer. This definition
- 7:11analyzes the average number of employees on business
- 7:16days during the preceding calendar year. Well,
- 7:21the proceeding calendar year was 2020. they were
- 7:25out of business most of that. All of their nightclubs
- 7:28were shut down. And so I had their accountant
- 7:33do this analysis of, well, how many business
- 7:36days were there in the year and how many days
- 7:38were you closed and how many employees did you
- 7:41have? And it turns out they don't meet this test.
- 7:44So in that case, I'm responding to the IRS saying
- 7:50that The penalty doesn't apply because they don't
- 7:55meet the definition of a applicable large employer.
- 8:01Now, the other client, it's a business that's
- 8:08located in Los Angeles. And I don't want to describe
- 8:11what they do because you might figure out who
- 8:12they are. They had a business. service that sprung
- 8:19up as a result of the pandemic. They provided
- 8:22a service that was COVID focused. And so they
- 8:27went from having maybe a few hundred thousand
- 8:31dollars in sales to like $50 million in sales
- 8:35in a year. They went almost from zero to $50
- 8:39million in sales in like a year as a result of
- 8:43the pandemic. this explosive growth prompted
- 8:47them to hire. I mean, they grew so fast that
- 8:53they were trying to serve all these contracts
- 8:56that they had. And it turns out they violated
- 9:01a bunch of laws, including this one. They're
- 9:04also in trouble with the city of Los Angeles
- 9:08for violating some other laws. They didn't comply
- 9:12with a bunch of employment laws. They were doing
- 9:16everything that they could to keep up with the
- 9:20contracts for their services. All they cared
- 9:23about was providing the service. They weren't
- 9:25mindful of any sort of regulation and they work
- 9:29in a business that is highly regulated and they
- 9:32just didn't comply with any other regulations.
- 9:37One of which was the requirement to to prepare
- 9:42and issue forms 1094C and 1095C. Now they hired
- 9:50an insurance company, a big nationwide health
- 9:54insurance provider, and the insurance provider
- 9:59prepared and filed the forms 1094B and 1095B.
- 10:05Those forms are required to be filed by the insurance
- 10:10companies. And the insurance company did. The
- 10:16penalty for failure to file these forms is it's
- 10:20the same penalty for failure to file W -2s and
- 10:23failure to file other information returns. It's
- 10:26internal revenue code section. We look at my
- 10:29notes. 6721 is the failure to file the form with
- 10:35the IRS, and 6722 is the penalty for failure
- 10:40to furnish the form to the employees. So this
- 10:45client got hit with both penalties. And these
- 10:51penalties are big. I think the penalty is $300.
- 10:58for failure to provide the form to the employee
- 11:01and $300 for failure to provide the form to the
- 11:04employer for a total of $600. And the maximum
- 11:08penalty is $1 .5 million. And this client got
- 11:12hit with the maximum penalty of $1 .5 million.
- 11:16So it's a big penalty. And again, these are Codes
- 11:19Sections 6721 and 6722. But there's a reasonable
- 11:26cause provision in Section 6724. And so for this
- 11:34client, I've prepared a reasonable cause request
- 11:38and I put this on a form 843 and I'm requesting
- 11:45reasonable cause relief. Whenever I have a new
- 11:52client and we're talking about seeking reasonable
- 11:56cause penalty relief, I tell the client, very,
- 12:00very high probability we're going to get a rejection
- 12:03without any inquiry. This reminds me of that
- 12:07Matt Damon movie, The Rainmaker, where Matt Damon
- 12:12plays a young lawyer who is fighting an insurance
- 12:16company. And during the trial, it comes out that
- 12:19this insurance company denies all claims. Every
- 12:22single claim gets denied. And only if the insured
- 12:27fights and and complains and follows up and causes
- 12:32a problem, only then do they consider paying
- 12:35a claim. I feel like that's how the IRS treats
- 12:40reasonable cause penalty relief requests. It
- 12:45seems like that they just deny the request without...
- 12:49perhaps without even reading it. And then when
- 12:52I appeal, the case goes to an appeals officer.
- 12:56And now there's a real live person to talk to.
- 13:02And that's where these cases get resolved. So
- 13:07I told this client, we will file your request
- 13:11for a reasonable cause penalty relief. It is
- 13:15almost certainly going to be denied. And then
- 13:19when it gets denied, we'll appeal. And there's
- 13:23$1 .5 million on the table. And one of the facts
- 13:27of this case is that after this explosive growth,
- 13:32the company went out of business. The owners
- 13:35ended up fighting over all that money. And there
- 13:38were two owners of this company. They fought
- 13:42over all of these tens of millions of dollars
- 13:45that they made from this COVID service that they
- 13:49provide. And the company went out of business.
- 13:53And so now there's actually a receiver. And so
- 13:58the receiver is sitting on some money. I think
- 14:01there's about half a million bucks left in this
- 14:04corporation subject to the control of the receiver.
- 14:08So there's only half a million dollars left.
- 14:11And so I'm going to incorporate collectibility
- 14:15into the appeals settlement of whether there's
- 14:20reasonable cause or not. And collectibility and
- 14:23reasonable cause are completely separate concepts.
- 14:25But I was telling this client that in IRS appeals,
- 14:31everything's negotiable. And I think the fact
- 14:34that this company is out of business and only
- 14:37has half a million dollars left and there's a
- 14:41receiver and there are other people competing
- 14:43for that half a million dollars. I think that's
- 14:46probably gonna drive this settlement. So the
- 14:52claim. The request for penalty abatement was
- 14:56denied. I have filed the appeal and I'm waiting
- 14:59for appeals to contact me. And that's where that
- 15:06case is. The other case, I filed the request
- 15:11for penalty relief on the grounds that the penalty
- 15:14just doesn't apply. And the IRS hasn't responded
- 15:19yet. Philip, can you join me? I feel like I've
- 15:24told my story, and I'm kind of out of time. Philip,
- 15:28are you there? Well, I guess I'll keep going
- 15:35here. So I feel like this is one of the enforcement
- 15:43programs that the IRS is working on right now.
- 15:50I think that these two cases that I have, that
- 15:53they're both section 6721 and 6722 penalty programs.
- 16:00In the last couple years, I've also had cases
- 16:04where the IRS is imposing section 6721 penalties
- 16:08for failure to file W -2s. So I wonder if...
- 16:14the enforcement of the 1094 and 1095s, I wonder
- 16:21if that is just part of an overall program to,
- 16:28whether it's part of a failure to file program
- 16:31in general. Because I'm seeing this with the
- 16:34failure to file 1099s. I'm representing a client
- 16:39who got a penalty for, it's the same code section,
- 16:446721 for failure to file 1099s. I've got a couple
- 16:51of cases where employers, they filed 941s and
- 16:58940s, but not W2s. they got hit with these penalties.
- 17:05So I'm not certain that the enforcement of the
- 17:11forms 1094 and 1095 are standalone, or if they're
- 17:15part of this overall failure to file and enforce
- 17:19section 6721. Let me refer to my notes and see
- 17:24if there's anything else interesting I can say
- 17:27about the forms nine. 1094 and 1095. I mentioned
- 17:37that the 1094 and 1095 A's are filed by the marketplace.
- 17:461094 B and 1095 B are filed by insurance companies.
- 17:53Maybe I'll tell you about my reasonable cause.
- 17:56And the 1095 C and the 1094 C are required to
- 18:02be filed by the applicable large employers. So
- 18:06in my reasonable cause statement, this client
- 18:12really doesn't have reasonable cause. This company,
- 18:16I think it was formed in 2019. They didn't know
- 18:20the pandemic was coming. They had this explosive
- 18:23growth from a few hundred thousand dollars in
- 18:27sales to 50 million dollars in sales, and they
- 18:31were doing everything that they could to keep
- 18:32up with these sales, that they violated all kinds
- 18:35of regulations for their highly regulated industry.
- 18:39They really don't have a good reasonable cause.
- 18:46The best idea I could come up with was to say
- 18:51that they hired this top -notch, nationwide,
- 18:54well -regarded health insurance provider, and
- 18:58they thought that the health insurance provider
- 19:00would take care of all of the reporting requirements.
- 19:04And there is a provision in their contract that
- 19:07says that the health provider will comply with
- 19:11required reporting requirements. And I referred
- 19:14to that provision in the contract in my reasonable
- 19:18cause statement, but the insurance company did
- 19:22comply with its reporting requirements. It was
- 19:25required to file the forms 1094B and 1095B, and
- 19:31they did. They weren't required to file the form
- 19:341095B or 1095C. That's the employer's requirement.
- 19:42Now, I didn't know any of these rules until,
- 19:45I guess it was last year when I had to learn
- 19:47all this. When the case gets to appeals, I'm
- 19:52guessing that it'll be assigned to an appeals
- 19:55officer who, like me, was a former revenue agent
- 20:01who probably isn't specially trained in the Affordable
- 20:06Care Act and isn't going to know these rules.
- 20:11My reasonable cause statement might seem reasonable,
- 20:15but having done the research, It's apparent to
- 20:20me that the 1095B and the 1095C, the filing requirement
- 20:27is on the employer, and that's in Internal Revenue
- 20:32Code Section 6055. And I do think that is all
- 20:43I had to say about this. Philip, do you have
- 20:46any, are there any questions? Well, you look
- 20:51at the chat. Not seeing any questions and I feel
- 21:01alone here. Well, it took me 21 minutes to cut.
- 21:09Let me I'm going to go ahead and check to see
- 21:11if our audience is shy and asking questions up
- 21:15through the help desk rather than. Through the
- 21:20zoom Q and a. Yeah, it's a pretty pretty simple
- 21:30topic. The requirements, if you're a applicable
- 21:35large employer, section forty nine eighty H.
- 21:39fifty, fifty employees or more, but it's the
- 21:42average over the. Work days in the prior year.
- 21:48Yeah, I think that's pretty much, that's it.
- 21:54All right, so it does look like there's a couple
- 21:57of questions here. When an employer receives
- 21:59an IRS notice concerning ACA reporting, what
- 22:02should council do before responding and what
- 22:05mistakes in the initial process tend to make
- 22:07matters worse? Well, in this case, I didn't know
- 22:11these rules until these clients hired me, so
- 22:12I had to learn them. They're there. So you've
- 22:17got to learn the rules and then know the facts.
- 22:21I was quite surprised. In the first case, that
- 22:25employer issued 150 W -2s. They looked like an
- 22:28applicable large employer. But based on the unique
- 22:32facts of that case, they were closed during most
- 22:36of the business days in the preceding year. And
- 22:39so when I read the statute, and the statute says,
- 22:43and let me read it again, The statute says, the
- 22:49term applicable large employer means with respect
- 22:52to the calendar year, an employer who employed
- 22:54an average of at least 50 full -time employees
- 22:57on business days during the preceding calendar
- 23:01year. Well, I thought, well, they were closed
- 23:07during most of the business days in the prior
- 23:09year, so they didn't have any employees on business
- 23:14days during the. during the prior year. Yeah,
- 23:18I didn't expect that. Also, in both of these
- 23:24cases, the IRS sent notices to these taxpayers
- 23:27asking them to explain why they didn't file their
- 23:331094C and 1095C, and they didn't respond to them.
- 23:40So they might have been able to resolve this
- 23:44before they got hit with the penalty, but they
- 23:47didn't respond to these. And the inquiries looked
- 23:50like a correspondence audit. So they were sent
- 23:54a sort of correspondence audit inquiry, which
- 23:59in both cases, they didn't respond. Then they
- 24:03got hit the penalty. And when they saw how big
- 24:07the penalty was, then they reached out for help.
- 24:10Suzy, what was the other question? So it actually
- 24:13looks like they input it in, let's see, looks
- 24:17like I have the question in the Q &A box here.
- 24:19In your cases, did your clients receive letter
- 24:225699 asking for compliance or letter 5699 in
- 24:26a case that the employer may be an ALE and request
- 24:29the employer to fill out a response and provide
- 24:31the forms where necessary? They did. And in both
- 24:35cases, they didn't respond. So in both cases,
- 24:38they got the inquiry. They didn't respond. That's
- 24:43when the IRS hit them with the penalty. And then
- 24:45they came to me for help. Another exception.
- 25:01I'm looking at Section 4980H, the definition
- 25:06of applicable large employer. One of the exceptions
- 25:09is for seasonal workers. That wasn't relevant
- 25:12to either one of my cases. Although I did, actually
- 25:17I have twice represented employers in the middle
- 25:20of California who like their business is providing
- 25:25farm workers to pick the crops. And so they have
- 25:29seasonal workers. that under section 4980 HAB,
- 25:42there's an exemption for seasonal workers and
- 25:47the definition of what a seasonal worker is.
- 25:55Any other questions? All right, let's see. This
- 26:02one looks fun. What is the single most effective
- 26:04compliance control an employer can implement
- 26:07to reduce ACA reporting errors and what should
- 26:10legal counsel fit into that? Where should counsel
- 26:12legal counsel fit into that process? I think
- 26:16having a good HR if they're if they have 50 employment
- 26:20there, but by definition, they're a large employer.
- 26:22And so I think having either in -house or external
- 26:26HR, this is the kind of thing that an HR person
- 26:30would take care of. In both of these clients,
- 26:38in one case, they have not really a CFO. The
- 26:43person that I'm interfacing with is not really
- 26:45a CFO. They're more like a... Maybe not the CFO.
- 26:51He's not a CPA. But he's the one who's responsible
- 26:56for all the compliance. This is for the nightclub
- 26:58business. This other business just exploded in
- 27:01growth so fast. In one year, they went from $200
- 27:06,000 in sales to $50 million. They grew so fast
- 27:10that they weren't able to do anything correct.
- 27:14And so, yeah, I mean, if they had to do it over
- 27:17again, they would have done a lot of things differently,
- 27:20including having someone in HR to take care of
- 27:23it. So, yeah, I think the answer to your question
- 27:26is, have an HR person whose job it is to make
- 27:31sure the company is complying with all the wage
- 27:33and hour and other employment regulations, including
- 27:38the filing of the 1094C and 1095C. All right,
- 27:47that looks like that's it for questions. This
- 27:49concludes today's presentation. Thank you again,
- 27:51Joseph, for taking the time to educate our members
- 27:54today. And thank you so much to our audience
- 27:56for joining us. Have a great day everyone. Thanks.