Latest / Braver New Worlds / What It Takes to Start a Religion: Identity, Community, and the Search for Meaning | Colin Campbell
Transcript
- Nathan: As much as I love doing this podcast, sad truth of it all is that doesn't pay the bills. It actually cost me money to make this podcast. That's okay, I love doing it, so we're doing it. So what does pay the bills for me is I help individuals and organizations leverage the power of storytelling for leadership and persuasion. This is the work I do and I want to tell you about it real quick here. For organizations, a lot of times the work is very much focused on fundraising for nonprofits or developing a narrative strategy for the important messages that they want to get out in their campaigns. Hello and welcome back to Braver New World. a podcast about the stories we to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I your host. If you haven't figured that out by now, you probably Right, so today's conversation is a little bit different and this is one I was super looking forward to. I'm glad we were able to do it. And about religion not just like religion, about like starting a religion. It can also be about developing leadership and communication skills amongst a team that you've already got working within your organization. For individuals, a lot of my work revolves around helping develop a narrative-based communication approach for those high-leverage career moments that come up from time to time, like giving a public And maybe you're like me, I have always had a mix of fascination and frustration with the role that religion plays in our culture and in our lives. Like on one hand, it's great to have a community, there's a moral code, a framework for understanding our world, a set of institutions that have persevered through the ages. And I know a lot of people that are believers and they're like wonderful people and they interviewing for a new position, integrating into a new role at a new company, making the leap for yourself to jump into entrepreneurship and how you talk about the work that you do with external audiences there too. These are very much the moments that can have a huge impact on your career. And by utilizing storytelling and narrative, you can not only communicate a more resonant message about what it is you're doing, but also what is going to stick. affiliation with their church is a very positive aspect of their lives and it a very important and powerful role in their lives. So if this is intriguing to you and you wanna know more, you can check out my website, storycultureconsulting.com. I'll have a free tool on there that's available for download, or you can check out the show notes too. I'll have the same tool down there that you can grab too. on the other hand, like what the fuck, right? People believe some crazy stuff in religions. There are so many problematic figures that glom onto it for audience and credibility. And it's become a sort of funnel for swindling and social control and really ideas. if we're perfectly honest, it's probably been part of the deal with religion Once again, that's story culture consulting.com and now back to the show. since very first religion was founded. And so I'm sitting here thinking like, oh, like that community is great and wonderful all the benefits that that confers on the people that participate in it. but also, you if I'm gonna be like completely blunt about it, it just often feels like so much social progress and wellbeing is held back in the name of fairy tales and superstition. I say this as somebody that went to church growing up. It was mostly a pretty positive experience for me, but at some point I just had a hard time believing the story anymore and couldn't justify. spending my Sunday mornings participating in it, so I quit going. But I always did really appreciate the community that came from it. And so I always wondered, is there a way to have a religion, or at least a community or a doctrine that brings people together in a more positive and progressive-minded way, and offers that community, that institution, that framework for understanding our world, for a more thoughtful, progressive-minded, set of people? Like, is that an option that exists out there? And so... When Colin Campbell reached out to me, I was like, yes, let's do this. Let's do this podcast. ⁓ I met him couple of years ago, like pre-pandemic and frankly lost touch since, probably been connected on social media this whole time. Just didn't even quite realize it, guest for today's podcast is Colin Campbell. He's the founder of Artaenianism. Hopefully I said that right. and the assemblage of And this is a non-theistic religion that he started from scratch. And yes, we get into what that means and what the doctrine of the religion is. we also explore something deeper. What is the role that religion actually plays in our lives? And why are people drawn to it? ⁓ what happens when you lose those structures that your life meaning, identity, and community in the context of religion? And so whether you're skeptical of religion or you're searching for something, you're just curious how people make sense of their lives, I think you're gonna get a lot out of this episode. Colin has a very interesting story that brought him to the place that he's at now. yeah, so without any further ado, let's get into it. Alright, thanks so much for Colin for being on here. It a really fascinating conversation. A couple things that are sticking with me is one is this idea that religion isn't just about belief. It's about what binds people together. And whether we call it that or not, we're all participating in some version of this already. I have a whole separate rant that could go on about how if alien anthropologists were to look at our society, they would probably presume that capitalism is our religion. Colin brought up the example of sports, but this is also our jobs. so many other things we connect to that bind us together as a set of humans. the second is this kind of question of identity. Like what happens when we lose that structure that tells us who we are and intentional we actually are about rebuilding something in its place. ⁓ And something I've been thinking about since we talked, because I've always been almost adverse taking on an identity outside of like whatever the hell I am. And so... It's been a very interesting thing for me to sit with the last couple days. So ⁓ if you found this conversation or thought provoking or just, you know, feel like there's something in your life that could benefit from hearing it, please share it with someone. It helps us get the word out and, you know, hopefully they'll appreciate it And you can find the full episode along with show notes and ways to connect with Colin in the links below. ⁓ If you haven't already. Make sure to subscribe so you don't miss any future episodes and it helps us in the algorithm or something. And you can also follow Braver New Worlds on Instagram, YouTube, TikTok. We're on all the sort of video-based social media channels. So thank you so much for listening and we will see you in the next one. Colin welcome to the podcast. Colin Campbell: Hi, it's great to be here. Nathan: so I did a little intro about you, but I'm really intrigued about this conversation. I'm pretty excited about it because we're talk something that I've thought about a lot, which is starting your own And whether, I guess, And we can say like religion or community or whatever that is. But I think kind of based on our previous conversations, a little bit of both here, but before we get it, let's just start, can you just kind of like introduce yourself broadly before we jump into all of that too? Colin Campbell: Yeah, absolutely. And thank you again, Nathan, for having me on the podcast here. I'm really excited about what you're doing in general, people together and exposing them to new ideas, things that might really help transform us and help us be better people and live better lives. This is what it's all about. So I'm Colin Campbell and am the founder of Aretéanism and also the Assemblage of Areté. So Aretéanism is a new non-theistic religion that's designed to help bring people Nathan: Yeah, thank you. Colin Campbell: And the Assemblage of Areté is the organization that helps do that. So you can kind of think of it as like the difference between Catholicism and the Catholic Church that we have Aretéanism and then we have the Assemblage of Areté, but they go together. And so a little bit about me. I am from all over the United States. I've lived all over the place, but I consider myself to be from Boston. I grew up in a Mormon family. And then my whole family left the Mormon church when I was... serving a Mormon mission and then a few years later I left the Mormon Church. ⁓ Yeah, was definitely a big deal. I was caught quite by surprise when they left the church. Ultimately they made the right move. It took me a few years to figure out that they had made the right move, but I ended up making that same move too a few years down the road. After that was left a little bit adrift. I ended up joining the Marine Corps. I had come pretty close to joining the Marine Corps Nathan: I kind of you hanging there. Okay. Colin Campbell: right out of high school and ended up not doing that. But now that I had left Mormonism, I was looking for something to do. So I joined the Marine Corps. I served in Afghanistan in intelligence operations for, well, I was in the Marine Corps for five years and I was in Afghanistan for less than a year. then I got out, finished my college education and a variety of odd jobs. But also it was at that time that I got out of the Marine Corps that I realized that I was going to do this, that I was going to start a new religion. Kind of crazy, but that's, Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: that's the basics of my story and where I'm at. Nathan: Okay, so starting religion, that's an undertaking, right? what goes into starting religion? Colin Campbell: ⁓ it is a massive undertaking it has been an absolute mountain range of work. There is so much do involved in starting a religion and then running it once it gets started. Incredibly difficult, but it also has been very rewarding. Something that's been nice on a personal note for me is that now I get to practice a lifestyle that is sort of like exactly what I was looking for. I was struggling to find something that was exactly what I was looking for and by having made it from scratch for myself it means that now I get to do exactly what I'm looking for. So that's kind of cool. It's also been really rewarding to see the way that this has changed other people's lives and the way that this is helping lots of people be the best versions of themselves and then ultimately I've got a pretty strong belief that this is going to change the world in the long run. I think it'll take a while to get there but I do think that what we are doing is radically different from most other attempts to change the world ⁓ this might take longer to work, I think it has better chances of working than some other approaches you could take to saving the world, quote unquote. Nathan: Yeah, yeah, okay. So there's like, there's so many threads I want to get into about this topic too, what is your background and what's the nature of the religion and where your adherents come to. Also, but I guess I just don't want to also start by kind of calling this out too, because starting a religion, it doesn't have the best reputation, right? So what like, Colin Campbell: Right. Yeah, we make a lot of jokes within our group of us being a cult and me being a cult leader. That is often how I introduce myself when I meet new people out in the wild. They ask me, oh, what do you do for a living? And I tell them, oh, you wouldn't believe me if I told you. And now they're all the more intrigued and I say, oh, I'm a cult leader. And they're like, no. I'm like, yeah, actually. Actually, I am. Now, of course, that word cult has a very strong derogatory sort of connotation to it. But if you take the word more literally, what a cult literally is, is it's just a small culture. That's literally where the word comes from, is just small culture. And we are a small culture. There's not very many of us, but we have a distinct culture. We have distinct practices, that kind of thing. ⁓ I think more broadly, if we talk about the word religion, what word religion means, I think this is a thing that especially Americans sometimes have a slightly wrong definition about what a religion is. They think of religion as being believing in God. I guess what I would say is that's just a very American point of view. not actually true when we start to look at the world, and it's not really true when we look at history. The etymology of the word is Religare, is Latin, and it means to bind together. So religion is all of the trappings that bind a group of people together. That can be a shared belief in some sort of supernatural phenomenon, but it can also be a shared belief in something else. Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: And it's also the rituals you do, and it's also the symbolism that you use, and it's also just the everyday phrases that you use, and it's all, you the meals that you have, and when you have those meals, and all of those things are the trappings that bind a culture together and becomes a religion. Another way of thinking about this is that if you do it religiously, then it's a religion. ⁓ I'm from Boston, and Boston, Red Sox fandom is a religion. Nathan: Yeah, yeah, okay. Colin Campbell: And I'm not really being facetious about that. I'm like only being slightly facetious. Like, no, there's no belief in God, but you do have to do all the things. You have to agree to believe in certain ideas, like the Yankees suck. have to attend mass. You have to go to the ball game ⁓ watch it on TV. You have to wear the right kind of religious garb, the hats and the t-shirts and whatever, right? The There ⁓ certain that people in Boston use. It's... Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: It's a thing, right? it binds people in Boston together that we are ⁓ Red Sox fans together. ⁓ really is a religion just as much as any other religion. And so ⁓ I've done is I've also created a religion. It doesn't have any gods associated with it. There's no supernatural element to this. This is non-theistic. If you believe in God, you're totally welcome to participate and to be part of our community. Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: But what we're preaching, the thing that is binding us together isn't a belief in God. What's binding us together a desire to be the best version of ourselves ⁓ an agreement to use our specific framework of ⁓ and rituals and some specific vocabulary and that kind of thing. Nathan: I have a lot more questions on this topic, but we'll get, come back to it and put a pin in it. So I want to back up and just kind of hear a little bit more about your religious background and like kind of how that led you up to feeling like this was a thing that you wanted to do. Colin Campbell: Yeah. Yep. Yeah, happy to share about that. So ⁓ I mentioned, I grew up Mormon and I took it very, very seriously. And at time that I was growing up Mormon, it was a thing where basically everyone who was Mormon took it very, very seriously. Nowadays, things are starting to change. Decades of the internet and globalization are changing things a little bit. But yeah, at the time, if you were Mormon, this was thing ⁓ that really dominated your entire life. there people who believed more or less, but everyone ⁓ took the practice of very seriously. So I believed, I was a deep believer, and my one goal in life was to be a Mormon missionary. I knew that when I grew up, I wanted to go serve a two-year Mormon mission the way that most Mormon young men do. So from the time that I was 19 to 21, I was called to in Connecticut and Rhode Island to preach Mormonism to people and try to get them to convert. honestly, was a wonderful experience for me in a lot of ways. I'd really looked up this moment for all my life. I deeply believed and really wanted to share what I thought was really good with other people. I believe that sharing with other people is going to help improve their lives. That's why wanted to do this. And then as I mentioned, while I was a missionary, the rest of my family, the formal word would be apostatized they left the LDS church. they that for a variety of reasons, but the short version is that they came across a bunch of information that showed them that the Mormon Church was not capital T true the way that it claims to be. So it really hurt to have my leave when I'm out there trying to convince people to join, but I stayed true ⁓ for a years. I finished off the and then I... I went home and stayed active in the LDS church, took on leadership responsibilities in my local congregation, which at the time I had moved to Seattle. But as time went on, I gradually had experiences that made me start to question ⁓ And I looked more and more into information that had ⁓ convinced my family to leave. And it very difficult, but I did realize that no, just, Joseph Smith, is not actually a prophet. And I started to become skeptical that even a god exists and these kinds of things. And so eventually when I was 24, I decided to walk away from the LDS church. One of the hardest decisions of my life. I would say actually probably the hardest decision of my life. Probably even harder than starting this new religion of Aretéanism. It was very, hard for me to leave because it just felt like there was huge existential risk involved. That like, if I got this wrong, I was damning my eternal Yeah. ⁓ wager kind of thing, right? Of feeling like, yeah, if I've guessed wrong and I'm walking away from the LDS church when it is true, whoo, like now just screwed for literally forever. So yeah, so ⁓ that was big deal for me to walk away from that. ⁓ But I ⁓ I'm sorry, ahead. You were gonna ask something. Nathan: Oh, interesting. We got, I yeah, I curious to know more. Yeah. Yeah. Was that like the main, yeah. Well, yeah, was that like the main piece? Because when you're in that situation, yeah, you have this sort of belief about like, and you're talking about like the reason that you were afraid to walk away was like a literal fear of hell, it sounds like, right? I mean, how powerful was that? Or how was your relationship with community or the sort of identity you had adopted or Colin Campbell: Mm-hmm. Right, yes. Nathan: just the way you thought of yourself and the way you felt like you were supposed to behave, how much of that factored into your fear or desire to leave or not leave? Colin Campbell: Yeah, that was really, really hard. I was nervous that I was going to lose my entire community, lose all of my friends. I was fortunate in some ways that, first off, my family had already left the church. And my parents were adult converts the church themselves. They joined the when I was a little baby. And so it was easier for to leave in that regard than someone who grew up in the LDS church and had all of their extended family still in. So I already had a little bit of an easier path compared to some people who have made the decision to walk away. But it was still hard to risk losing friends and community. Ultimately, I trusted that these were good people that I really cared about and loved and believed that they cared about and loved me. And I'm proud of them that I was right about this. That, yeah, they stayed with me. That I didn't become... Nathan: Okay. Colin Campbell: a pariah to them. think that definitely hurt other people the same way that it had hurt when my family left and I was left feeling like I was a little bit hanging. I'm sure it hurt a little bit for me to walk away, especially because I had been on leadership responsibilities. And I think that they had started to look up to me as something of an example of, his family has left and he still believes. I had even kind of put myself into that position a bit, to be honest. And so, so I'm sure that stung Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: for me to be walking away at that point. But were all great people. Honestly, something that I can say is that broadly, Mormons are excellent people. There are of course exceptions, but broadly, this is culture of great people who are to do the best that they know how. And I think that for all of my friends and community members there in the church, they took this as well, we still love Colin. We disagree with him, but we still love him. so I didn't feel like I was kicked out. I continued to attend after I had sort of officially said, I don't believe in, I'm out. I would still go to like parties and things like that. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Okay. Well, that's nice because that's very different than the story you normally hear about people, especially leaving the Mormon church, right? Isn't like their especially thing where they really kick people out and there's like a whole kind of Colin Campbell: You're probably thinking of Jehovah's Witnesses. Witnesses are much harder about shunning people. ⁓ I'm not an expert on Jehovah's Witnesses, but I think that there are some adjustments happening to that policy in the last couple of years, maybe the last year even. ⁓ Mormons don't do that so much. Mormons may modulate their relationship with you if you're leaving the church. In particular, what they probably don't want to do is they don't want to Nathan: Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Colin Campbell: talk about your reasons for leaving the church. Mormons get very deeply conditioned to avoid any of conversation that might hypothetically shake their faith. ⁓ There's certainly a thing that I did, like when my family left, I did not engage in a lot of ways with what their reasoning was. I just ⁓ mentally looked other direction. ⁓ But Mormons don't necessarily shun. Nathan: Okay. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Colin Campbell: You can be excommunicated and get some of that, but you really have to be doing genuinely bad things for that to happen to you. Nathan: Okay. You're talking about like what shook your faith there. And like you said, like your parents got some information. So I'm curious, like what was it that ultimately did shake your faith? Colin Campbell: Yeah, well, so the full story is a little bit longer. I was living here in San Diego. I had taken a temporary sales job down here in San Diego. And I had started dating this gal and she seemed perfect for me. And Mormons put a lot emphasis this idea of like finding the one, in quotes. The one you're supposed to bear to marry, essentially your soulmate. Mormons put a lot of stock in the idea of you can pray and ask God anything and he'll give you the answer by the way that you feel inside your heart and particular young Mormons will pray to see if they found the one. And so I prayed and prayed prayed and I felt like I had gotten the clearest from God had ever gotten in my life about anything even clearer than when I had prayed to ask God if the Mormon Church is true, which is a that Mormons do. Nathan: wow. Colin Campbell: They pray to get confirmation of that for And so I felt like God had given me a very clear answer that this lady is the one, and it's really no fault of hers, it's not like she did anything bad or anything like that, but basically two days after I felt like I had this clear answer, then it became evident that no, she wasn't the one, maybe more accurately, I the one for her or whatever. But it really just smacked me in the face in a way that... Nathan: Yeah. ⁓ Yeah. Colin Campbell: I had never had it happen before. In retrospect, there had been other times that I had prayed and asked God for something and got an answer, and that's not really how things worked out. But in the past, I'd always been able to excuse it. I'd always been able to make justifications and say, oh, well, this is all just part of God's bigger plan. But this time, it was so clear cut. I had a yes from God. This lady is the one. And then she wasn't. She just wasn't. ⁓ And there was no reconciling this. And so that really rocked me back on my heels. what it made me think about is, okay, only a couple of possibilities here. One, God to me. Two, ⁓ I can't understand God he talks to me. Or three, God was not talking to me at all and I made this up in my head, right? And I didn't want to believe the first option. I didn't want to believe the idea that God was lying to me. Nathan: Okay. Colin Campbell: That just seemed like, well, geez, I'm to have an antagonistic relationship with God? What is that? So quickly ruled that out of my thinking. I looked at the next two options of, I can't understand or there is no God. And I sort of defaulted to the first one of those two. Maybe I just can't understand when God's talking. But it made me realize, well, if I can't understand when God is talking to me, then now I can't really presume to get answers from God on anything. If I pray to God and get an answer, am I sure about that Because evidently I am capable, and maybe other people get it right, maybe other people can understand, but apparently for me, I can get it wrong. Not to say that I will get it wrong, but can get it wrong. So maybe instead of trying to ask God for everything, maybe I'd be better asking me for things. And that was a real shift in mentality for me to say you know what, I might be better off just going off of my own wisdom, asking some really hard hitting questions, doing my research, thinking things through. So yeah, so I became an agnostic for a while and really I thought maybe there is a God, but it seems like I can't hear him. So it's best if I just kind of like step back from that for a bit. Eventually, as I continued down this path of Nathan: Okay. ⁓ Did you discuss this? Colin Campbell: asking hard-hitting questions and doing my research, I decided that I was an atheist, and I eventually even became kind of a militant atheist. I think that you're part of a high-controlled religion like Mormonism is, there ends up being a lot of harm done to you. There was certainly a lot of good too, and we can come back to that, but there was definitely harm done, and I was angry about that harm. And so that anger led me to be fairly militantly atheist when I eventually got to that point in my mentality. Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: it was a journey to get to that point. And then eventually I did come out of militant atheism and now is where I am. But it was process of going from hardcore believer to like shaken and then to an atheist. I guess the last thing I'll say in there is, yeah, the facts mattered. Learning the history of Joseph Smith mattered. the bigger thing was that fundamental shaking of my relationship with God, where I thought I had a relationship, and then calling that into question and saying, wait, do I really have a relationship? Or am I just talking to myself? Yeah, and concluded I was just talking to myself. Right, yeah, I wanted this gal to be the one. Yeah, yeah. Nathan: Yeah, okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Just telling yourself what you wanted to hear maybe even. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Did you discuss this with any of other people that you knew in the church or friends in the church at the time at all or? Colin Campbell: kind of. So as I mentioned, I had this experience in San Diego, but I was living in Seattle primarily at the time. And so I was in San Diego, I had a bunch of other LDS Mormon friends with me who were part of the same cadre of salespeople. They had mostly come Utah. And so they were a great group of people for me to confide in. These were people that I loved and trusted closely, but they also didn't live at home with me in Seattle. And so, if they decided they hated me for leaving the church, well, they going to go back to Utah and I was going to go back to Seattle. Fortunately, that's not happened. They did not hate me, but they were a great group of people for me to talk to and bounce these ideas off of and to get constructive criticism about my ideas, that of thing. And so then when I returned to Seattle, I was now ready. I had sort of like practiced being a non-member a few months while I was gone in San Diego. And when I went back to Seattle, it was easier for me to say, yeah, I'm committing to this. I'm actually just gonna come out essentially, almost coming out of the closet except as a non-believer to the rest of my LDS community. Yeah. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, I always find these stories of like walking away from religion so interesting because I'll kind of give my sort of background here a little bit because I grew up going to church and I grew up going to a Lutheran church. To be honest with I don't know a whole lot about like the other different denominations and what they do and how they work. But my church, it was very mellow. There wasn't things weren't really pushed on us necessarily or reinforced. There was some of the kind of trappings of religion were like the morality and stuff like that. When I quit going, I just kind of quit going. And And there wasn't even like a big expectation. Now that I know a little bit more about like the dynamics of Lutheranism versus other religions too, I mean, was you know, from Martin Luther which at the time, I I see it all like the politics of like, I know the history of the politics of Germany at that time, too, where it's very convenient for this guy to come out and be like, here's this book, and this book is really valuable. And you kind of believe what you want to believe based off of this book and all these German princes that were sick of paying to the Pope, like, yeah, yeah, I like that. I like that. It's a great idea. Let's do that. Let's I like that. We'll do that. And so but like that was, but that's the framework of religion I got where it was about it was almost like the Bible as a sort of core philosophical book and were derived from that. And there was like prayer and stuff, but there wasn't even like a huge expectation that you believed in God. Like you were allowed to have your doubts about God's existence or even like not believe Him at all. And I say Him, like believe in the at all. But there was a of a faith and ideals and yeah, you could still Colin Campbell: Hmm. Nathan: like the teachings of Jesus as just a regular mortal dude could serve in as like a facsimile for your faith and your belief on some level also. And I'm sure if there's like any like real hardcore Mormons in here, they could pick this apart and stuff. But that was like, I'm speaking more to the impression that I got. But for me, if this book is so I'm not necessarily saying yes or no, but like there's books too. Colin Campbell: Right? Nathan: That was just sort of my thing. It wasn't, like, it's like, dude, we've been talking about this one book in this year every Sunday for the last like, you know, 14 years, 10 years, or however old I was at the time, I think it was like 16 when I decided just like, I'm not gonna go anymore. And I was mostly just because I was like bored of it. And it was just kind of a weird thing to sit and listen to a pastor. And I liked our pastor and everything too. We had a very small community oriented church. And to this day, I really value like that aspect of it. I remember that, but it was just like had to wear these certain clothes and it was kind of stuffy and it was hot and everything. As much as I had a faith and grew up with a religion, wasn't this like strongly held thing. And that was never an expectation that came up in my church upbringing. And when, Colin Campbell: You Nathan: when you walked away, it wasn't really that big of a deal. Maybe that's why Lutheranism isn't quite as big of religion these days as maybe it could be, is because they're, just let us all walk away, whatever. Colin Campbell: Right? it is a little bit ironic that there's evidence these days that stricter religions are performing better in terms of like membership and attendance metrics and that kind of thing ⁓ ⁓ strict churches, which is it's interesting to think about what does that mean about human psychology. But, ⁓ know, you Nathan: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, definitely. okay, so I'm to know kind of like were the things about the church that you remember sort of most fondly and most perhaps if you're willing to get into it. ⁓ Colin Campbell: Right. Yeah, no, these are great questions. So I would say that the things that I loved about church is I loved having community, real community. And I feel like there's a lot of Americans these days that have just never experienced it. And so therefore they don't really know what they're missing, but what it's like to live with a close-knit group of 100, 200, maybe 300 people who... span the entire range of generations from little babies to children young kids to teenagers young adults to medium adults to older adults to elderly adults, right? You just have have everyone in the mix. It provides a richness to life to live in that kind of group and to get those kind of different that come with being multi-generational that way. Also, when you're in a real community, there is real support. And again, this is the kind of thing where I think that sadly a lot of Americans, just, don't even know what they're missing, but they don't know what it's like how when you get sick, you get five people coming over to like drop off soup and crockpot meals and whatever, right? It's not, not just like maybe your best friend goes to the store for you to pick up some Nyquil, but like actually having like Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: real community support. I the oldest of five kids. And as my parents continued to have kids, then when my mom would go to the hospital to have the next baby, then like literally there were people we stayed at, right? And weren't family right? Cause we didn't live particularly close to all of our family lived on other parts of the country, we would go and stay at somebody's house for a couple of days, just some other member of the church. When we moved, when we would pack up when we going across town or across country, then ⁓ of the guys in the church would show up and help load that moving truck. There's real support there in a that I think is a little bit hard to fathom unless you've lived through it. It's not the as having a best friend. It's not the same as having a group of five cool friends. These are great things. Having community is larger and deeper than that. then the other thing that I really love is that it gives you the sense of purpose. You get a sense of purpose in part just from having community because now you need to contribute into the community. And every time that you are the person who is load the moving truck or bringing over the the crockpot meal, then are getting meaning out of that experience, meaning out of So a great meaning maker there. Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: But then also the religion, separate from the church community, also is a source of purpose. really believe that I am a child of God and I have this eternal destiny. And Mormons actually believe that they're going to go on to become gods themselves. And I believe that I was working towards this eternal goal. It really everything in your life sharp focus. And helps you make decisions. And one of the worst... day-to-day experiences is being indecisive of just not knowing what you want to do in a given moment or what you want to do with your life. Having a belief structure like that gives you crystal clear focus of, am to do this and that means that when I face this decision, I'm making this one, right? So those were all awesome. The things that I didn't like about being LDS is there's just a of thought control. The thought police is very prevalent. And you police yourself as a result because you know that if you don't police yourself you will be policed by other people so you're just always vigilant about how you are coming off to other people hyper vigilant about what you are saying, what your body language is even all of this kind of stuff and it gets exhausting to be hyper vigilant about this stuff all the time so so I didn't that. Nathan: Yeah, it's super exhausting. Colin Campbell: A lot of the beliefs, well, I mean, so I think that basically all of the fundamental belief structure is factually incorrect, and can lead you to make all kinds of bad decisions in life. I mean, like, I think about, like, what if I had married that gal that I was saying was the one? Well, I mean, she wasn't. So that have been bad. That would have been a bad relationship to be in. And when I around at other LDS folk, I see a lot of them who I think have made that decision, and they're doing their very best in that circumstance. I really want to honor the efforts that they are putting in. But I think that objectively, I have, there's a lot of my peers in my generation of the LDS church that I can speak to directly, who I think got married to someone who wasn't the one, but false beliefs convinced them that they had to do that anyway. ⁓ And then of course the Mormon church has a lot of like straight backwards beliefs on things that I just cannot get behind anymore. There weren't necessarily for me at the time. I want to be honest and say that like, Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: as a true believer, I swallowed a lot of bad ideas myself. I believed a lot of regressive ideas at the time, but I have since deconstructed and now have opposite beliefs on almost all these things. But like, certainly attitudes about sex, the Mormon Church is extremely puritanical and now I'm very sex positive. I believe that sex is part of human life and it should be celebrated and you should enjoy it. You should do it with consent. And if you don't want to do it, then don't do it. But I think that people who do want to do it, they should... They should do it and have a great time, right? So yeah, there was massive amounts of guilt that I had over things like pornography and that kind of stuff. And I just can't get behind that. And then, course, really attitudes about LGBTQ issues, really regressive attitudes about women. And since Mormons believe that they're holding women up, but they're holding them up to a very specific pedestal and not letting them off that pedestal. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: It's definitely not feminist. ⁓ So yeah, there's just a lot of like backwards beliefs. Backwards beliefs about race are still baked into the church. The church is less racist than it used to be, but the racism is actually still there. And I think a lot of members don't realize that. ⁓ Yeah, so there's just backwards galore ⁓ and the that aren't backwards, they're still just wrong and that can lead you to make bad decisions in life. Yeah. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Still there. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Okay. now take us to this like period of your life in between after the Mormon and then on your way to starting your own religion, Aretéanism, did I say that right? Okay. So yeah, walk us through that period your life and then up to like leading up to deciding like, all right, I'm gonna found a religion. ⁓ Colin Campbell: right, yeah. How does one go from leaving mormonism saying, fuck sorry, I don't know if i'm allowed to swear, I'll admit it, okay, okay. See, there's ex-mormon kicking in of like, I have to be hypervigilant of like, have I said the wrong word in front of someone? ⁓ Nathan: No, you can, you can swear, it's fine. Well, you know, have to check a box, an explicit box because you swore, you know, but it's fine. I do it, I end up doing it for every episode, so it's fine. ⁓ Colin Campbell: Right. Right. So yes, so going from fuck this and I'm now an anti-theist and I'm gonna go around trying to convince people to now I'm gonna start my own religion. It's a pretty intense 180. So I'd say that basically what happened is that I left the LDS church, was floundering for a little bit, decided to join the Marine Corps because I had come very close to joining the Marine Corps before. The only reason why I hadn't joined the Marine Corps is because I had wanted to be a Mormon missionary and was told by my recruiters that I basically had to pick and choose. So I said, well, being a Mormon missionary is more important to me than joining the military. So I did not join right out of high school. But now that I was not Mormon anymore, I was free to do whatever I wanted. And I started to think, oh, well, what if I had joined the military? So I joined the Marine Corps. And that was good. It provided some of that community. It provided some of that sense of purpose, having the mission in mind is similar to feeling like I'm a child of God is similar feeling as I'm a Marine. So gives you the sense of identity. ⁓ like the LDS church, comes with a lot of toxic beliefs, and behaviors. So yeah, so that worked for a while, but as I got further and further away from the LDS church, Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: started to realize that being this ⁓ atheist was not serving me very well anymore. That like, I just angry a lot. I was angry all the time. And some of it was probably induced by being in the Marine Corps, which is a circumstance that will make you angry all the time. ⁓ But I to look for, okay, what can I do to be less angry? I couldn't get out of the Corps, ⁓ you're locked into your contract once enlist, but ⁓ I... Nathan: Mm-hmm, yeah. Colin Campbell: could maybe stop being so angry about religious upbringing. And that was hard because I had legitimate reasons to be angry. Again the Eldest Church had done real damage to me in my life. And I was to work through so much bullshit because of the indoctrination that I had. But I realized that like maybe I can go of this stuff. I can just change and be a different person and get to a place where when I... myself to a new person, I'm not going, hi, I'm Colin Campbell, I'm an ex-Mormon. ⁓ ⁓ almost literally how I behaved. That it was the first thing that I said about myself, ⁓ I wanted to have my own identity that was a positive identity instead of a negative identity. An identity of here's what I am instead of an identity of what I'm not, right? Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: yeah, I'd already deconstructed my relationship with Mormonism, now I was beginning to deconstruct my relationship ex-Mormonism. to say, how long do I really want to be an ex-Mormon for? Right? I like, you know, yeah, technically I will be an ex-Mormon for forever, but like, do I want that to be what my identity is? ⁓ Right. Right. I'd be me. But I also found that that answer is a little bit of a cop-out. Like, everyone wants to be not me-me, but like, they want to be themselves, right? Everyone... But what does that mean? What does it mean to be you? And... Nathan: Yeah, you want to be an ex-mormon. Colin Campbell: It's so nebulously defined that ⁓ it does not provide that clear sense of identity that being a Mormon or being a Marine will give you. And it also definitely doesn't come with a community. Being me doesn't automatically mean that I get to live in a multi-generational healthy community that'll bring soup over five times a week or whatever. And then also is around this time that I was... Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: meeting new people through the Marine Corps and on several occasions people would say to me shortly after meeting me, you should be a preacher man, have you ever thought about being a preacher? People sometimes talk about what are you gonna do after the Marine Corps? And it hard for me to swallow that it was like, I was a preacher and I loved being a preacher. It was the perfect job for me was to be a preacher but I don't believe in that shit anymore. I can't allow myself to my calling in life. Nathan: You Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: And that really hurt. So I was thinking about this and thinking about this and thinking about, man, like, is there any way I could go back? maybe I couldn't be Mormon, but is there some other, maybe Lutheran, more mild, some other Christian church that maybe I could kind of like pretend to believe in order to be a preacher? ⁓ And just couldn't make, there's no way I could actually get myself to do that. It would feel too wrong to misrepresent myself that way. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Colin Campbell: So I was just still wrestling with this problem, wrestling with this problem. And then I get deployed to Afghanistan. while I'm in Afghanistan, I'm at this distance from the United States and life is in danger every day on behalf of the United States. And I this willingly. I actually had to kind of fight for my opportunity to go on this deployment to Afghanistan. I was willing to sacrifice my life for the United States. But now that I got there and was actually literally putting my life on the in that fashion. And looking back at the United States from a distance, I started to feel increasingly like, man, the United States is not going in a good direction. Am I sure that I want to sacrifice my life for this? And feel like the answer would be, yes, I would want to sacrifice my life for the US to be a healthy, wonderful, prosperous that is a light to all other nations, that kind of thing. ⁓ But that's not what was like if I died in it wasn't going to make the United better. Nathan: Yeah. . Yeah. Colin Campbell: that if anything, it was making the United States worse, maybe. So yeah, I started to get really concerned about this. I deeper and deeper at the problem of what the US culture was like and how it was changing. And yeah, this vantage point of being outside the country, it got to be easier for me spot out the flaws in American culture and to recognize the ways that those flaws were now even starting to spill out of America and into other countries. Other countries were being infected with our cultural problems. So I got really concerned by this and eventually became pretty clear to me that the writing was on the wall that we were going to A, lose the war in Afghanistan for starters, ⁓ B, the United States as a country was definitely in decline, that we would not stay the superpower that we were. And it was just kind of a matter of time before someone like Trump came along. And so this is, was in Afghanistan in 2013 and 2014. So this is long before Trump even runs for president the first time. But I could just see the writing on the wall that like politics was going to get ⁓ more nasty and more more stupid. And stupid and nasty people were going to win more often. And yeah, that just general, we were headed for bad times. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: And I couldn't live with this. The reason why I joined the Marine Corps, the reason why I signed up to go to Afghanistan specifically was because I loved this country. I loved it that that I would hypothetically be willing to die for it. This was not an acceptable outcome to me just let the United States wither this way and to let the world wither the way that I was concerned that the whole world might wither with the United States. So I... started getting a little bit desperate thinking about how do we fix this? Is there actually a way to systemically fix these problems, which I saw as stemming from culture? Like we could point to like, There's this specific game theory issue in Congress or whatever, but that all comes down to the fact that we, as a society elect certain kind of people to be our representatives who will then certain kinds of decisions. If we want to better Congress people, we have to be better people ourselves elect better people. So I was thinking about, how do you get better people? How do you change a culture? How do you get a nation in decline, an empire in decline to pivot and rebound you know, go back to have a second golden age? So I looked at history to see if there are examples where this has ever happened. And I didn't like what I saw. I'm sort of an armchair student of history. And I really tried to comb through history and Nathan: Yeah. Hmm? Colin Campbell: mostly I found it doesn't happen. Mostly once the nation starts in decline, it just stays in decline and eventually becomes or destroyed or whatever. The only two times that nations do bounce back are under pretty extreme circumstances. The first is the nation is invaded. That will generate a of a grassroots movement amongst the remainder of the people that can sometimes lead a nation bouncing back. But being invaded sucks. I can tell you from first hand experience having Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: been the invader in another country. You don't want to be invaded. It's not good. So that option is right out the window. I'm not okay with invading the United States. The other option I was also not okay with, but I I was ⁓ less not with, and that is a new religion is organically developed within that culture. I didn't like that option at all. Nathan: I'm invader. Yeah. Colin Campbell: Because at the time I was still definitely in my anti-theist, anti-religion phase of religion is the source of all the world's problems, I hate religion, blah blah blah. To consider the idea that like, oh, maybe we need religion, I did not like that. But it got me thinking, it got me thinking, hey, is it possible to have a new religion instead of trying to like, fix an old religion, what if you just had a new one and you could build it using first principles logic to say what would actually be good here? If we're trying to get this outcome, what sort of symbolism, tradition, rituals, doctrine, holidays, what would generate that outcome that you're trying to achieve? the more I started to think about that, the more I started to believe, okay, this might be possible. Maybe you could have a religion that doesn't suck, right? Nathan: Okay. Colin Campbell: And then I started to realize, I'm actually even thinking about this question wrong. You don't want to ask you know, how do get a religion that doesn't suck? You want to ask how do get a religion that's awesome? Because if a religion is awesome, then by default if it's kick-ass, by default, won't. Nathan: Yeah, let's shoot, like aim for something cool, not like that's the difference between what's it called, abundance versus scarcity or something, right? Colin Campbell: Right, Yeah, like, you know, if you just go for doesn't suck, well, okay, great. you know, So what? Like now you have a religion that's not accomplishing anything. Like you might as well have not have made that religion in the first place. So aiming for know, how do you make a religion that's punk rock, that kicks ass, right? That really makes people be awesome, inside and out. Nathan: selling yourself short, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: Then yeah, in the process of making that religion, it also will not suck. It also will not have the problems that say Mormonism does, I would argue most of Christianity, most religions, maybe even religions period. Nathan: okay. And you're like, all right, I'm to start a religion. Step one, what is, how did you some there, but like, where do where do you go? Are like, is there a book you get the library and you start thinking about like, what are the pieces of that of a religion that make up religion? Or were you kind of like working backwards from like, okay, what about Mormonism was working and why was it there? And how do I create a facsimile, tell What the process of putting this all together. Colin Campbell: Yeah, I mean, I think you've pretty much nailed it. I was doing all of these things. Certainly there was a whole lot of copy and paste from Mormonism, because that's the thing that I was relatively expert in and also was fairly convinced even as an ex-Mormon, I still had a lot of respect for how well organized Mormonism is. All religions I would argue are invented. Some are much older than others, but Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: since Mormonism was invented in the modern era in the then it ⁓ a little bit more designed than other religions are. You most religions were created just basically using the telephone game, right? Of ⁓ said this and sure, add that in. And somebody else said this and sure, add that in, right? Whereas Mormonism did have a little bit more of like, there was a purpose, not necessarily a good purpose, but there was a purpose in the way that it was created. And so it was built some... Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: effectiveness, some efficiency to it. I'm not sure what word I'm looking for there, but So I did want to copy some things from Mormonism, but obviously not everything. So I spent a lot of time thinking very carefully about what was good, what was not good there. I also did my research on lots of world religions. I had always been fascinated by world religions, even when I was Mormon, and then had studied it even more when I got out of the church. And now that I was in sort of a designer religion phase, Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: I was really hard every big small religions. I tried to learn a fair amount about lots and of different religions. ⁓ But I think that the better answer to your question is that it really had do with first principles logic, like I was saying before. Had to do with thinking about what is the desired outcome and so then what produces that. And so one of the first key questions is ⁓ what is point this religion, right? Nathan: Okay, cool. Yeah. Colin Campbell: What is its objective? And I had for kind of a long time with the idea that it was wisdom, that the goal was wisdom, because I think that a lot of philosophers put wisdom on of a pedestal. But then eventually I deconstructed that idea a little bit and realized, well, yeah, of course philosophers put wisdom on a pedestal. ⁓ They love philosophy. ⁓ they are going naturally presume that philosophy is the most important thing, right? Nathan: Yeah, it's very self-serve. Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: And so I tried to say, good about philosophy? Like, why do philosophy? And I think that the answer is because it helps you be a greater person. It helps you achieve your potential, both as an individual and as collectives, as whether it's you and your group of friends, or whether it's your church community, or whether it is your entire nation or the entire planet Earth, achieving our potential collectively. And so I became convinced, as I tried to like attack that I did a lot of what I would call red teaming, where I intentionally take an oppositional point of view to whatever it is that I'm thinking and try to tear my idea down and engage in arguments where sometimes I asked them to red team or ask them to take, to steal me in my position while I red team. So lots and lots of debates about this stuff and eventually became convinced that the logic behind trying to be a great person is pretty solid. seeking wisdom supports this, that is not the goal in and of itself. Wisdom is a stepping stone towards personal greatness. ⁓ You wisdom, you need philosophy to become personally great and to become collectively great. But it's not actually the end all, it's not the end state to just gain wisdom. Nathan: Yeah. Okay. Okay. Do you have like, you know, how do you define greatness? Colin Campbell: Yeah, so in our Aretéanism we do have some doctrine that we use to sort of like definitionally define this stuff, but I think it's important to note that even with our doctrine, we leave sort of an open door for our definitions say that greatness must include at least these things, but there's there's undoubtedly other things that are also components to greatness that maybe we're not spelling out or maybe we're not in 100 % agreement about as a Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: as a community. We define as being practical, loving, virtuous, and Or defining word Areté, which is this word that means being as great as you possibly can in all ways. So that's our goal is Areté, to be as great as we can be. Some of these we're using a little bit differently than the regular population. Practical, I think, is pretty straightforward. Loving is pretty straightforward. Thoughtful we're using slightly differently. I think thoughtful people usually think of like, that's so thoughtful that you got me this gift. And that's more like loving. When we say thoughtful, we mean full of thoughts. We mean to a thinker. We mean to do things intelligently. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, contemplative about how the whole world works and all these things. Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: Right, to be well-educated, to be smart, to be a thinker. Yeah. that's what we mean by thoughtful. Virtuous also we use just slightly differently than, I think that a lot Christianity, and particularly American Christianity, has turned the word virtue into this thing that has to do with sexual purity kind of stuff. And we do not mean it in that context. We mean it in the context of virtue ethics, a philosophical concept. Right, yeah. ⁓ I mean, yeah. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah, Okay. Okay. So you could be like just a total slut and still be virtuous. Yes. Okay. Cool. Yeah. Colin Campbell: Sex positive, you yay sluts. Yeah, not care about what you're doing in your personal life in that regard. As long you're having a good time and you're doing it with consent, because consent is one of our core doctrines, then please, by all means, go have a great time. ⁓ So yeah, when we say virtuous, what we mean is having a code of virtues Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: that we strive to live by and that we prioritize living by those virtues over the outcomes. Now we do still care about the outcomes, that's part of being practical, but we mean that being to sacrifice the short-term outcomes for living by this code. So for example, we believe in being honest and being honest might cost a promotion perhaps, but we believe that you be honest anyway, right? Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. What? Okay. All right, you've developed this sort of like philosophy and this doctrine. And then how do go getting adherents and like building that up? Cause cause that'd be like, that'd be very Are you like, pitching people at work or like you kind of have your friends that working on this with you or like where does that go? Colin Campbell: Yep. Well, so I guess I should back up just a little bit and say that part of what convinced me to actually start a... I went from knowing that we needed a religion and part of what convinced me that I was actually going to start one instead of just acknowledging the need for one was I had the uncomfortable realization that it may just so happen that the circumstances of my life have created me as an individual who has the skills to do this in a way that maybe most people don't have that complete combination of skills. People have all kinds of other great skills, but it takes a certain set of skills to be the founder of a religion, and most people maybe have one or two of those skills, and I just happen to have some. And so one of those skills is that I had been a Mormon missionary, and I had gone around convincing people to join a religion. And then I had spent a lot of time as a salesman too. And so these were things that eventually when I realized that I had all the requisite skills, I started to feel a little bit more of that Peter Parker, Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: Spider-man quote of like with great, well, it's actually not Peter Parker, it's actually his uncle, but with great responsibility, with great power comes great responsibility, right? And realizing, okay, if I, I know we need a religion and I know that I have the skill set to create and start one, then maybe it's actually my responsibility to start one. And that was very heavy. And I had to sit with that for a long time before I was willing to actually act on that responsibility. But I did start to become convinced that, yeah, I might actually be failing humanity Nathan: Yeah. Mm-mm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: which is a bold thing to say, but I might actually be letting humanity down if I don't do this, ⁓ there are so few people who could that if I don't do this, then like ⁓ might never have this thing, and then we might suffer the consequences of never having this thing. So, yeah, back to like, how do you get new members? Well, it helps that I have professional training ⁓ in to convert people to a religion. ⁓ Right. Nathan: Hmm? Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Like sharing your gifts. Yeah. Okay, have excess. Colin Campbell: You're right, it involved pitching people at work, pitching people at school, doing all kinds of things that people find uncomfortable. And I know this will make people in your audience uncomfortable. They're gonna hear this and they're gonna go, ⁓ man, proselytizing is just wrong. You should never proselytize ever, right? dare that man talk to his coworkers about this, right? Sorry, that's what I had to do. I had to do it. Nathan: Yeah. Well, a big theme of this podcast has been about communication and communicating outside ideas into a mainstream. No, this isn't, I think anybody's listened, this has been a tension that's come up in basically every episode of how do we pitch this idea? And I come from a background in sales also, so that's come up in almost every episode also. So think my audience has probably been eased into this idea of we gotta sell these ideas. ⁓ Colin Campbell: Okay, well, good. I'm they've been, what's the I'm looking for? Like, slowly introduced this idea. Let them warm to it a little bit. I think the reality is that American culture has changed, know, this is a small part of some of broader changes I'm saying that I didn't like. But like American culture used be more resilient to salesmen. It used to be more resilient to the idea that like, yeah, people are gonna try to sell you things. That's okay, right? You can say no. Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: ⁓ have gotten so conflict-averse, we've gotten so insecure as individuals broadly in American culture, ⁓ we are not as good at saying no to people anymore, and because we're not as good at saying no, we no longer have tolerance for someone trying to get you to say yes. ⁓ I think that that actually has done harm to our culture in a lot of ways. When you invite conversation, even it's conversation that you might later say no to, but when you invite that conversation, when you invite the salesman in to convince you of something, Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: you're opening the door in your mind to seeing the world in a new way. ⁓ And yeah, we don't want to buy a whole ton of crap. think that we want to be open-minded to consider new ideas, but not so open-minded that our brains fall out. We want to retain some autonomy and think for but also you can't think about a thing unless someone has introduced that idea to you. ⁓ And so I it is valuable Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: to let people give you their sales pitch ⁓ and then say no to it if it's not for you. So yeah, I did friends, at the time I was on Facebook, I'm not on Facebook anymore, but I had a pretty wide network of Facebook friends from around the country and so I sort of advertised to them and then I definitely about it with people in my classes. I was attending university at the time on the GI Bill. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, totally, yeah. Colin Campbell: I talked about it with people at work and I on Meetup and I even like bought some advertisements on Facebook at the time. That was not a smart investment, but I did. Yeah, so did a bunch of things and then word of mouth starts to happen. Someone comes and they bring a friend and then they bring their friend and yeah. Nathan: What were those first meetings like? Because I remember when I went to church, there was like, you walk in, everybody says hi, and you sing a song, and then some verses I read from the Bible, and then there's sermon, and then you sing some more songs, and there's a prayer, then there's more songs, then that's it, right? How you structure your Colin Campbell: Yeah, this is where, yeah, again, having exposure to lots of different churches helped that I already was familiar with a lot of different ways they could structure a church meeting. Most churches have something that's vaguely similar to each other. There will be some differences between, Lutheran church and Mormon church in terms of what the Sunday service is like, but they're similar enough and most churches fall into that sort of similar enough category. And so I also use a similar model. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: When I first started, then it was similar to sort of a standard meeting. did add in some unique features of our own, but I think some of the thesis here behind Aretéanism is if it ain't broke, don't fix it. ⁓ And there are lots of things broke with Christianity, modern religion, the format of the service actually isn't one of them. ⁓ The format of the service has worked for literally 2000 years. That works just fine. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: And it may not be for you individually, perhaps, ⁓ also more likely it may be that those beliefs that are being communicated to in that format are not for you. And that those songs specifically are not for you, right? But the format is tried and tested. I would encourage who are to this right now as they listen to your podcast to consider, maybe you personally don't like church, but think some intellectual honesty would agree that like the format works. ⁓ Yeah. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Mm. and Yeah, yeah. What do you feel like the people that initially came, what do you feel like they got out of it? Or like, what kind of feedback did you get even? Colin Campbell: Yeah, the people who initially came, I think that there was a few things. One, they get a weekly source of inspiration. I mean, I think this is a thing that people still get. Getting the motivational talks and some music inspiring, just to pump up for week. It's an opportunity to socialize. I that for a lot of the people at the beginning, maybe didn't have like large friend groups. They weren't very established in some sort of existing other community. And so this meant that like at least once a week, you're go hang out with people. And that helps you to just not be lonely, right? Is to at least once a week, go have a group of other people that you're spending time with. also think that frankly, especially for the people at the very beginning, but still to this day, we're still not that large. There's a sense of getting in on the ground floor. That's kind of exciting. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, totally. Okay. Colin Campbell: While I founded this, I'm not the end all be all. ⁓ Lots of people have now participated and have contributed their ideas and helped me polish things, helped me correct things, have introduced new ideas that I had never thought of. And so people who got involved the very beginning and even people at this stage are still, I think, cementing their in history. ⁓ As an ex-Mormon, I tell you that Mormons know all about the early Mormon. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Colin Campbell: ⁓ It's a thing to know your Mormon history trivia. And even some non-Mormons will get interested in Mormon history trivia. And to know about of, not just the big names like Joseph Smith and Brigham Young, but some of the other names too. I think that some Mormonism is a couple hundred years old. I think that when Aretéanism is a couple hundred years old, I think that they're gonna know names like Claire Zimmerman and Josh Beeler. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: I think that they're gonna know names like Ken Campos and Al Smith. They're gonna know some of these other names of people who were early adopters, people who rose through the leadership ranks. I go on and listen to all of the names. I think that basically everyone who's been involved again has earned their spot in history at this point. So it's not just those names I've just said. Nathan: Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. And so yeah, you, you, you kind of like a vision. This is gonna, this is gonna take off. It's gonna do its thing here. Like what, what kind of gives you that faith or that belief? Colin Campbell: Yeah, well, probably being delusional helps. ⁓ I would encourage everyone to take what I say with a grain of salt here, but no, I do genuinely believe that this is going to be big eventually. And I think it actually not take that long to get big. Certainly, you know, comparing to other new religions, Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: shows that it's possible for things to get big quickly. And I don't, I'm not saying that we want to emulate these organizations, but when you look at Mormonism, when you look at Jehovah's Witnesses, when you look at Scientology, when you look at any of these of like new religions that popped up in the last couple hundred years, and again, I don't want to be them per se, but like, but we can just see that like, it can grow. It actually in the space of 20, 30, 40 years, you can get to the millions of followers Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm. Colin Campbell: to the tens of millions of followers, maybe even into the hundreds, given the information economy that we have available to us today. It be possible to grow even faster than it was possible back then. There are things that might slow us down compared to back in the but I think it's at least mathematically possible to grow big. I think that we are also providing a really unique product for lack of a better term. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Colin Campbell: Again, we're not selling this, but I don't have better language to describe this than to call it a product. That there's only a few other institutions that are in this kind space at all, and what they are doing is definitely not the same as what we are doing. ⁓ We are really the only group that is providing a genuine, fully fleshed out, non-theistic religion then also offers a Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: church community space that is easily, and again, I'm use like business language to describe it, franchisable. ⁓ Now that we have got the model going in San Diego for a in-person community, that model can be explicitly copied, can be exported to another location, ⁓ and we get the benefit of all of our lessons learned and would literally get us locally working to like, we would provide them with all of the artifacts that they need, and we would provide them with all the documentation they would be like, Nathan: Okay. Mm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: literally they could get Assemblage of Areté in a box, in a kit, right? And so it's possible for this to actually pop up lots of, no one else is doing what we're doing. There are other non-theistic or theistic out there, if you're looking for a progressive church community to participate in, but none of them provide the same sort of like cohesive value system. None of them provide the... Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: the ability to immediately transfer from one congregation to another congregation and be in the same exact belief environment. And none of them provide that sense of purpose the that our religious doctrine does. ⁓ I about being a Mormon and being a Marine, being an Aretéan likewise has kind of punchiness to it that some of our Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. ⁓ Colin Campbell: competitors, so to speak, in the non-theistic lightly theistic church space don't really provide. They provide They absolutely provide community, but they are providing a sense of identity the way that our Aretéanism does. Nathan: Yeah. I'm so interested by this idea because yeah, I've long felt that my experience going to church was like that community was really valuable. Even when I sort of lost faith in the idea. I was like, well, this community, see the value of this community and the value of like having communities like this. And for all the reasons you outlined earlier too, like there was a sort of sense of connection and people checking on each other and all that stuff. And like that doesn't exist in the same way today. I've about this a lot too, like how to build up towards that community again. ⁓ I had this sort of notion of like, how can these... event series that I did with like the new narrative was the event series I did about like the narratives that we inherit as a society and how can we develop new narratives towards that. And I had this notion of like what if we start hosting these like Sunday mornings and how to operate as a sort of like non-theistic church type thing. I never went so far as like develop a philosophy around it or anything like that. But I saw this sort of need that I think a lot of us have of like being a part of something and that sort of like cohesive community and regularity of it that, yeah, and I do think we are just sort of a little bit lost and adrift without it. Colin Campbell: Yeah, I think that's exactly right, unfortunately, I think that you're exactly right that we're in this crisis of meaning. I think that there's guy, John Vavaki, if I'm saying his name right, who coined this term of like the meaning Yeah, and so in response to that, I do think that there are a lot of people now who are starting to look for meaning, started to look for community. Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: Yeah, and I think that in terms of growing to a large scale to something that's akin to the size of Mormonism or akin to the size of Scientology or something like that, I think that people join organizations for different reasons. Some people join explicitly for the community and other people do join more for the philosophical goal, the philosophy itself. Maybe they're joining less for the community. Nathan: Yeah. Mm? Mm? Mm-hmm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: Or it can be some sort of balance in between. Maybe it's three quarters this and one quarter that or whatever. But I think that this is the thing that has held other non-theistic churches back. Because I've definitely done lot of research on other non-theistic churches. ⁓ Not there's that much research to do because there's just not that many of them. But I think that something that has held them back from being able to grow is that they're basically ⁓ only offering Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Colin Campbell: and they are not offering philosophy per se. not to say there's zero philosophy there, but they don't have a philosophy that attracts people. They don't have a philosophy that you can adopt as your identity and have it be part of your tribe. People a tribal identity. Certainly it turn toxic, but I think it's foolish to pretend that we don't need a tribal identity. Even really intelligent still need to belong to a tribe. not a thing that you can just grow out of. Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: I think all humans psychologically need to belong to a tribe. So we're trying to do is to actually hit both sides of that. Like can come to our meetings, call them convocations. You can come to our convocations just for the community sake, just because you want to be around other people and rub elbows with people who are trying to be their best selves and that's great. Or you can for the grand vision of we're saving the world and like one day our Aretéanism is going to change the course of history. Either way, right? You know, or anywhere in between, right? Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I've got so like, I've got so many questions and stuff like there's so many different directions I want to go with this conversation, but also like probably get to a point where we should probably start bringing it back home here. Well, yeah, because you know, I just, think I'm quite at the spot where I want to commit anybody to listen to us for two hours quite yet. But so I guess one thing I'm curious about is, yeah, like where is it now? Where is... Colin Campbell: Sure, yeah, it's a little information to digest. Yeah Hahaha! Nathan: Aretéanism now and like what is your sort of theory of the case for like how you're gonna be able to grow it. Colin Campbell: Yeah, so we've been in existence for a little bit more than 10 years now. We celebrated our 10 year anniversary in February and that was a really wonderful time to, we had a lot of people kind of come out of the woodwork, people that have maybe been absent for a while, came back in to help us celebrate the 10 year anniversary, it was awesome. We are still small. I think the reality is that trying to start a new religion, like, mean, you asked about what those first few meetings were like, I guess what I didn't say is that literally, for the first couple of meetings, I might get one person to come and then was just me and them and it was super awkward, know, just hella awkward of like, and now, you you take a turn reading this passage and now I'll take a turn giving a talk and now we're going to look into each other's eyes as we sing this song together, just the two of us singing this song together. It was super awkward, right? ⁓ And when it's that it's hard to get people to stay, right, and to come back and when they don't come back, then that means that now the next person who comes, they're now the only person coming, right? ⁓ So, Nathan: Mm-mm. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: it took a long time to go from one person just me. There were so many meetings. I literally held the meeting every Sunday, and I would say that for the first two years, probably 70 % of the time, it was just me. Now, the other 30 % of the time, you it might be one, probably out of that other 30%, like 20 % of that was like one other person, and then 5 % of that time was two other people, and then like 1 % of the time, it was like five other Nathan: wow. Mm-mm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: people, right? But it does start to snowball. ⁓ The more people who are participating, the real it feels, the more natural it the more cool it looks. So the bigger it gets, easier it is for to stay attached. But then we have ups and downs, you know, there's all kinds of random things that happen. People move away, people get sick. Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: People get upset with somebody else in the community. They get in a relationship with somebody in community and then they break up and now we get one side of that relationship and the other person has to go away or whatever, right? ⁓ So we've had some ups and downs. And so our in-person attendance right now is still small. We in one of our members' living rooms just because a cheap available space for us and we can still fit in that right now. But we're growing fast enough that I'm expecting us to outgrow this living room Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: probably this summer, definitely this year, we'll have to ⁓ a space of some kind to hold the number of people that wanna attend. ⁓ I say that right now we're sort of like at 10-ish people in attendance. Sometimes it's less, sometimes it's more, yeah, given our current growth trajectory, I expect us to be in the 20s ⁓ the of the year easily. And I expect the growth factor will just sort of like, will exponential from there. Nathan: Yeah, Colin Campbell: there is enough people that we're not, that get ⁓ everyone their three friends kind of thing, but then when two of their three friends stay instead of zero of their three friends stay, the math changes. So I think that we are on the of hitting the steep inflection point. We do things try to grow. We do tabling events ⁓ where we'll go to yeah, any kind of big where there's gonna be a lot of people, Nathan: Mm. Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: a little tent and a table and talk to people about it. do things like this, where I give interviews, I was interviewed for a book last year for example. And then there is just a lot of of mouth that happens. People share this with their friends, they maybe share of our content online. Yeah, so I do think it's going to grow. And I don't that we have to push it a lot to make it happen. Nathan: What? Yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah. Colin Campbell: I think that just natural organic growth is working for us and will, again it might take a few decades, but I think that within a few decades it is actually possible to get to those hundreds of thousands, maybe up to the millions by the time we get to like 50 years out. ⁓ Nathan: Yeah. Okay, all right. Is that what motivates you? I was curious, what motivates you to do all this? Because it sounds like you're making a pretty big commitment here to something up and not getting the big returns that most people would want early off. Colin Campbell: Right, yeah, am not getting paid for any of this. In I put a lot of money in. Yeah, I a of things out of this. I get personal growth, first of all. I that since Aretéanism is all about being the best version yourself, we have developed a really excellent program for developing people. And I have personally benefited from this program. Nathan: Yeah. Colin Campbell: not that was a bad person or anything like that before. In I think I was a pretty great person, if I'm honest, before I the Assemblage. But now, after years of attending our meetings and doing our weekly challenges and this kind of stuff, I am better. I just a more awesome person than I was 10 years ago. And that's awesome. I really enjoy that. ⁓ So that's a big that I get out of it for myself, is just getting to participate. Getting to have the community awesome. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: also get a lot out of being a That is, you we talked about how it was sort of my calling in life to be a preacher. I finally get to be a preacher again, and I love it. ⁓ I do really enjoy giving talks. I really enjoy inspiring people. I really enjoy to do pastoral duties ⁓ of people come me with their problems and their concerns, and I help them navigate that. It can be very difficult sometimes. Nathan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: But the challenge is rewarding, right? To be there for other people. So on a personal level, I get something out of the pastoral duties. And do get something out of the projected big historical growth that I about. I get out that is maybe less egoic than you might think. It's not to say that the ego's not there. Like there is a little bit of like, you know, I do feel proud that I've started this. I do feel proud that I've started something that I'm confident is going to make a difference on the big stage of history eventually. Nathan: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Can I just say, there's always going to be in these situations, there's always going be a little bit ego that comes up to like, you know, do something like this because it's so easy to not, and it's always so easy to just like kind of fall in line and do what's expected. And so when you step out of line, there's some ego. What I appreciate is I'm not hearing hubris. Colin Campbell: Right, yeah, I tried very hard to avoid that. I feel like a big part of my when I was designing this is looking at other religious founders and trying to learn some important lessons from, I knew a whole lot about Joseph Smith as an ex-Mormon, and particularly as an ex-Mormon, I then learned a whole other side of his story that you don't get told in the church. Joseph Smith was kind of an amazing person in lot of ways. Nathan: Yeah, yeah. Colin Campbell: He was also a terrible person in a lot of ways. And so trying to study his story to learn, okay, these are things that I could do that could help this movement be successful, but also these are things that ⁓ absolutely under no circumstances ever want to do. And setting some boundaries for myself of I have to be careful to never become like him in these regards or to never become like L. Ron Hubbard or you name it. Nathan: Yeah. Yeah. Ha ha. Yeah. Yeah. That's what. Colin Campbell: Russell, I think is the name of the founder of Jehovah Witnesses, right? There are important lessons of what to but there's also important lessons of what not to do. Yeah, ⁓ hubris is of that. So yeah, so is some ego involved with like, yeah, I do feel proud of this. ⁓ But actually what get more out of the big picture stuff than ego is I get a sense of peace, a of hope that things gonna okay. Nathan: Yeah Yeah. Mm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: The world is in a terrible place right now, unfortunately I think that in the short to medium term it's going to get worse, not better. And know that's hard for people to hear, because things are already pretty bad right now. And yeah, think that an intellectually look at the future says that the short to medium term is going to get pretty bad. ⁓ But when I am down about that, I then remember that Aretéanism is growing, and that it Nathan: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Colin Campbell: is on track, as far as I can tell, to be maybe in the millions of members a handful of decades from now. And that we actually don't need everyone to be an Aretéan. I mean, that would be cool, but like we don't need it. And you're not going to go to hell if you don't join, you Aretéan. You can still be a kick-ass person if you don't join the Assemblage of Areté, right? But when do have millions of members, I about the difference that'll make not just for those millions, but for the hundreds of millions around them, When we have Nathan: Yeah Yeah. Colin Campbell: millions of people who are religiously, zealously dedicated to being the best version of themselves that they can possibly be, and are in an organization that facilitates their cooperation to get a thing done together. Whoa! The difference they're going to be able to make for the world? It kind won't matter how many Trumps there are in the world when we have a million Aretéans, right? You know, I think that a million, Frankly, I think that probably even 10,000 Aretéans easily outstrips Trump in terms of power differential, right? Nathan: Yeah. Okay, okay. Colin Campbell: ⁓ It's not to say that, of course, 10,000 people is more than one person, but I'm saying in terms of power. 10,000 Aretéans who are you know, just people like you and me, but are members, are committed to the process, committed to the identity. I think that 10,000 of those people, none of them have to be senators, none of them have to be politicians. But like that many people who are religiously dedicated to good, I think that'll easily outstrip the power of one Donald Trump as president. Nathan: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Okay. I think that's probably a good place to wrap things up here. So how can people find you? If people want to know more, where can they go? Colin Campbell: Yeah. Yeah, the answer is areteanism.org. Aretéanism is a hard word the Greek Areté is this weird word for us in English. So I'll spell that out, but I'm sure you can also just find it in the show notes and that kind of thing. it's a-r-e-t-e is So a-r-e-t-e-a-n-i-s-m dot org. Areteanism.org. And if you to that website, then you can find all of our contact information. Nathan: Put it to show notes. Yeah. Okay. Colin Campbell: really encourage people to join our Discord server. Even you just want to lurk, you're welcome to come join us. What we ask is that compared to most Discord servers, we do ask people to change their name in the server to their real name, to not be anonymous, ⁓ because that a healthier, less toxic online community. But it's a way to find out more details about us and to sort of like watch us from afar. If you join our Discord, you can then get the links to join our meetings on Zoom if you don't live in San Diego. If you do live in San Diego, then you can come and meet our Nathan: Mm. Yeah. Colin Campbell: our group in person at any one of our weekly meetings. it all starts with just going to the website, areteanism.org. Nathan: know like social media and stuff too, like Instagram, right? ⁓ Colin Campbell: Yeah, you'll find for all of the major platforms than we're just at Aretéanism. ⁓ We're not super active on social media. would be great for us to find someone who is a social media expert who could take over for us. ⁓ you'll find us on all of the platforms as at Aretéanism. Nathan: Okay. Hahaha Okay, cool, All right, I mean, there's like, literally, I could talk twice as long, because I have like so many things I want to talk about. just sort of like, yeah, yeah, exactly, come back. Yeah, yeah. But all right. Well, awesome, Colin. Thanks so much for being on here. Really appreciate it. And yeah, we'll just have to come back and do it again at some point. All right. Wait, okay, wait, wait, we're, we're, we're, we're, we're, Colin Campbell: Well, if the audience likes it, they can invite me back. Yeah, thanks Nathan. Be excellent to each other and party on. Nathan: Yeah, because I thought, okay, but that's for Bill of Tens, right? Like, okay, all right. Colin Campbell: That's what we say. That is from Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure. Correct, yeah. We use that instead of like, amen. ⁓ Whoever's done speaking will say BX onto each other, and then the whole crowd will say, party on. Nathan: Okay. Okay, because I saw that on your website and I was wondering if like you were, first thought, ⁓ man, I'm kind opening a can of worms here, but like your first thought, you know how like there's like the flying spaghetti monster religion? I wondered if like your religion was based off of that ⁓ of faux religion on Bill and Ted's and that was like kind of the, an art tape. ⁓ Colin Campbell: Yeah, kinda. We openly embrace being silly. difference is that we are very serious about being silly. ⁓ We are serious about having fun. We that being awesome people, being people Areté, should not be this dour or somber experience. It should be this joyous party experience. It should be awesome, right? It should be kick-ass. Nathan: Okay. Okay. All right. Mm-hmm. Okay. Colin Campbell: so yeah, so we do take inspiration from Bill and Ted. We jokingly refer to them as the great ones, but not ⁓ These are characters, but we're inspired by these fictional characters. We're inspired by a lot of fictional characters, but in terms of thing that binds us all together, we all sort of like communally agree. These are fictional characters that we could aspire to be more like. Yeah. Nathan: Okay. Yeah. Okay. ⁓ Yeah. I mean, I'm a fan of Bill and Ted too, so all