Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow with Force: Chapter 6 - Flow Is Not Passive
Transcript
- DrG: There is a particular kind of mistake we make when we hear the word flow. We assume it means letting go, stepping back, doing less, maybe even caring less. I understand that because I spent much of my life believing that if I wasn't intense, I wasn't really engaged. If I wasn't taking control, I wasn't really contributing. If I wasn't making something happen, I wasn't really being useful. When I began thinking differently about force, I had to confront an uncomfortable question. If I'm not forcing things, what exactly am I doing? Welcome to Catalyst, a podcast of thought. I'm Doctor G, and today I'm talking about flow. But as usual, I'm not really talking just about flow. I'm talking about what it means to be deeply engaged without needing to control everything around you, about the difference between responding to what is actually happening and reacting to the story you've already created about what should happen. Because flow isn't the absence of effort. It isn't passivity. It isn't giving up your agency. Flow is simply another way of participating. I think the first experience of flow I had was when I was learning to play guitar. In the beginning, learning a piece of music was almost entirely an exercise in force. I practiced one note at a time, then three or four notes in sequence, then a series of measures, etc. Every finger had to be consciously directed to the right place on the fretboard. Eventually, after enough repetition, something strange began to happen. There would be days when my fingers seemed to find their own way. The notes came in sequence. There was no buzzing, no muted strings. I wasn't consciously telling every finger where to go. I was simply playing. Then I'd take notice. Hey, I'm doing it. And of course, the moment I became conscious of myself playing the notes correctly and smoothly, the buzzing and muting would begin. So I'd try to fix it. I'd force my fingers back into position, think harder about the mechanics, try to consciously recreate what had just happened. It didn't work. I had learned the sequence well enough to let it flow. As soon as my mind got involved in trying to control something my body had already learned, I disrupted it. That was one of the first times I understood that flow isn't passive. I wasn't disengaged from the guitar. It was quite the opposite. I was completely engaged with it. I was with the guitar, I was with the music, I was feeling what I was playing. The difference was that I was focused on the entire sequence rather than forcing each individual finger into place. I was participating in the music. That distinction has become increasingly important to me. Flow requires attention. It requires intention. It requires participation. What changes is the relationship between those things. Force tends to enter a situation with an agenda. You have a sense of where things need to go, and you measure what is happening against that expectation. When there is a gap, you intervene. You guide, correct, push. Flow starts differently, not without intention. Without the need to impose that intention at every moment. You listen more than you direct, you respond more than you control. You allow what is happening to inform what to do next. And that becomes especially important when things don't go as planned. In moments of force, disruption creates urgency. Something is wrong, off, needs to be fixed. In flow, disruption creates information. Something has changed. That doesn't necessarily mean something is wrong. Instead of immediately correcting it, you take a moment to understand what has actually happened. You stay with it long enough to see what it is asking of you, not what you want from it, what it requires. I've learned to recognize what happens when I lose that distinction. When I become self-conscious about what I'm saying or doing, I start creating a narrative. I can see myself doing whatever it is I'm doing. I can hear myself saying whatever it is I'm saying. Then I start filling in the blanks. For everyone else. I begin imagining what they're thinking. I create the thoughts I think they're thinking. Pretty soon I'm a character in a movie that exists almost entirely in my own mind. Sometimes I get quiet, I get tight, I stop saying anything. Somebody eventually will ask, You okay? Yeah, I'm fine. I'm not fine. I'm in my head. And I'm in everybody else's head too. Except that their heads are actually my own invention. Responding to reality requires something different. I have to wait for the real voices of the real people with their real facial expressions to get real information. I have to stop creating the movie and live in the reality of what is actually happening. It doesn't mean I always move slowly, just intentionally. I've learned the lesson in a rather memorable way. I once walked into a vacation home we were renting and found my wife's cousin holding her dog and her cousin was crying. The dog had eaten rat poison and that had apparently been left I once walked into a vacation home we were renting and found my wife's cousin holding her dog crying. The dog had eaten rat poison, and that had I once walked into a vacation home we were rent. I once walked into a vacation home we were renting and found my wife's cousin holding her dog crying. The dog had eaten rat poison that had apparently been left around the property. I didn't have time to deliberate. I went to the bathroom, rummaged through the cabinets, found some hydrogen peroxide, and came back. We administered it and the dog vomited. The whole thing happened quickly. It was frantic, crazy, stressful. I saw what was happening, assessed what I could do, and acted. Fast was not forceful. It flowed. That experience challenged another misconception about flow, that flowing means slowing down. It doesn't. Flow allows for speed without tension. A person acting from force and a person acting from flow may both be moving quickly. They may both be decisive. They may both appear highly engaged. The difference is what is happening inside the action. I've also learned that not all force is the same. Reactive force protects something in me, my ego, my sense of competence, my need to be right, my need to demonstrate that I'm useful. Aligned force is different. It is still force. It may involve speaking firmly, making a hard decision, advocating for myself, confronting someone, or taking decisive action. But it is aligned with something beyond the immediate moment. It is aligned with my values and with an envisioned future. Reactive force protects ego. Aligned force exercises agency. I once had a conversation with a friend who was frustrated with his son. They had been arguing about a logistical issue that had happened before and kept happening. My friend was asking what he might be able to do differently. I asked him a simple question. Do you want to be right or have a relationship? Pick one. He was, in fact, right about the logistics. But that wasn't the point. He was using force to protect something in the moment, being right, winning the argument, establishing that his interpretation was correct. If the long term objective was a relationship with his son, continuing to mean the argument wasn't going to get him there, he made a different choice. He let go of the logistical argument. He let go of the argument and established some standards for how they would communicate going forward. He ceded the position in service of the relationship. That wasn't passive, it was aligned. He didn't stop exercising his agency. He changed what his agency was serving. For much of my life I didn't know how to make that distinction. I had been taught to step up. In hockey, that meant stepping into the gap and making the body track. In football, when the ball was snapped, You got off the ball quick. Instantaneous aggression, forward movement, responsibility. There was nothing wrong with those lessons. Somewhere along the way, though, vigilance became hypervigilance, intensity became identity, responsibility became the expectation that I should be the person who made things happen. And if I didn't take control, what was I afraid would happen? Well, for a long time, the answer was surprisingly simple. If I didn't take control, I thought people would think I was weak, emotionally weak, physically weak, inept, inert, benign, not useful. That's why flow was psychologically difficult for me to engage with. My sense of usefulness and purpose had become directly tied to my ability to intervene. On a football field or hockey rink, I could protect people physically. In other parts of my life I could protect people by having the answer. I could solve problems, anticipate needs, force solutions into existence. That gave me something to hold on to. It gave me evidence that I was contributing. If I wasn't that person making things happen, who was I? I'm beginning to discover another answer. I can participate without possessing the solution. I can influence without controlling. I can act without forcing. I can be engaged without being so intense. I've learned some of this through parenting. Some of my most engaging and influential conversations with my children have happened when I wasn't forcing solutions upon them. I was simply asking questions. Instead of telling them what I thought about a social situation, I helped them clarify what they thought they knew. Instead of providing an answer about a decision they were considering, I helped create an environment where they could discover more about what they wanted and why. That idea became even clearer while teaching six-year-olds. We had a recurring problem that sounds almost laughably simple lining up. We had to line up for gym, music, recess, or the buses. It was chaos. Herding cats, as they say. My response was predictable. I tried to force a solution. One at a time, two at a time, small groups, tightly controlled. It was pretty militaristic, and it was not working. Eventually, I stopped telling them what to do and told them what I was actually struggling with. I explained the problem and why solving it mattered. More time in the day meant more time for things they actually wanted to do. Then I gave them a voice in the choice. They came up with solution. They suggested timing themselves. They turned it into a game. They figured out groups and which groups should be closest to the door. Within a week or two, we had taken something that could consume three minutes every time we did it and reduced it to roughly fifteen seconds. Six year olds. The remarkable thing wasn't simply that they solved the problem. It was that I hadn't given them enough credit to solve it in the first place. I thought leadership meant coming up with a solution and getting people to follow it. Instead, I discovered that sometimes leadership means creating the conditions in which other people can discover the solutions themselves. That lesson has stayed with me. It has also changed how I think about impact. For much of my life I wanted impact. Impact meant making something happen, making a difference, leaving evidence. But sports had taught me another lesson that I didn't fully understand at the time. In football, you don't necessarily have to knock someone onto their back to make a block. You can influence their route just enough that the runner can get through. In hockey you can get into someone's lane and change their path without ever making a dramatic hit. You influence them. The impact came later. Now I think differently about influence. Many small moments of influence can create a much larger impact over time. I've experienced that with former students. I've heard people, I've coached, describe small moments that changed how they thought or decided or acted. I didn't control those outcomes. I simply influenced them. Perhaps that's a more mature relationship with impact. Influence doesn't require possession, it requires participation. That also changes the way I think about confidence. Earlier in my life, confidence meant I know I can fix this. The confidence I'm developing now sounds more like whatever happens, I can meet it. I can work to and through the problem with the problem. The preposition has changed. I don't have to believe I can control every situation to trust myself. I need to trust that I can respond accordingly. That also means trusting other people. I could inadvertently disrespect the competence of other people. If I always needed to be involved, always needed to have the answer, always needed to anticipate the problem, the message could become I don't trust you to handle this. Flow requires trust. I now trust myself enough not to have complete control over every situation. I trust other people enough to let them handle what belongs to them. And I don't make my involvement evidence of my value. This is where I think flow is often misunderstood. It isn't about removing structure. It's about relating to structure differently. I can still prepare, think ahead, establish an intention, bring discipline to something I'm doing, make a a really hard decision. I can force myself to do the workout, sit down and write, say yes to the job, go to a networking event, take some kind of action. The difference is that I don't have to force every part of the process just because I care about the outcome. There's an ebb and flow to almost anything worth accomplishing. But we just have to let the experience settle and then act again. Sometimes we need to force our way into something. Other times, step back, let something develop. Maturity isn't about choosing flow over force. It's about becoming capable of recognizing which one the moment requires. That requires a pause. I learned to make that pause simpler over time. At first I needed language. I would say there is no past, there is no future, there's only The now. Later it became don't deal with imagined problems, deal with the real ones. Now I don't always need the words. Sometimes I just take a breath. And the words that come to mind might simply be Stay here, stay present, be real. The pause is designed to be a movement from the imagined to the real. It is the moment when I stop responding to the movie I was making in my head and start responding to the reality in front of me. And I can see the difference in myself now. I sit still more, I pause more, I listen longer. I make fewer decisions for other people, especially those that aren't solicited. And I am more physically, emotionally, and socially present. The old pattern hasn't disappeared. I still feel myself tightening, still have anticipation, I still want to get ahead of things. But I recognize that tension sooner. And that recognition creates a choice. That may be the real difference. Flow isn't a state I achieve and then maintain. It's a relationship I keep practicing. Sometimes I force, sometimes I flow, sometimes I move quickly, sometimes I wait. Sometimes a moment calls for a decision. Other times, for me to get out of the way. The question isn't how do I avoid using force? It's what does this moment require of me? That question doesn't remove effort, it refines it, it redirects it, it brings it into alignment with the situation. rather than reacting to the situation. And perhaps that's what I'm finally beginning to understand about engagement. For much of my life I believed being engagement, being impactful, taking control, being forceful, hypervigilant. I'm beginning to discover that engagement can mean something very different. It can mean staying close enough to the realities in front of me to participate in them. Not passively, with intention. I can participate, influence, act, Listen, respond, and when the moment requires it, I can use force. But I don't have to use force simply to prove that I'm engaged. Perhaps that is the confidence flow offers, not the confidence that I can control what happens, the confidence that I can meet what happens. Maybe that's the more useful definition of flow I've found, not letting go of action, letting go of the need to control the outcome of the action. That isn't passivity, it's participation. And perhaps that is the whole point of living. Beginning to understand that flow isn't about stepping away from life. It's about staying close enough to what's actually happening that I can respond to it. I can act, make decisions, use force, use flow. But I don't have to control every part of the process to be fully engaged. I can influence without possessing. I can participate without taking over. I can trust myself to meet what happens rather than needing to make everything happen. For much of my life I believed engagement meant making an impact. Now I'm beginning to see that sometimes engagement means simply being present enough to influence what happens next. That is not being passive, it is participating. And that leads to a different question. If flow requires intention, attention, trust, and participation, what creates the conditions in which flow becomes possible? In chapter seven, the conditions for flow will explore what has to be present before we can actually let go of unnecessary control. Perhaps flow isn't something we can make happen. Maybe we can only create the conditions in which it has a chance to occur. I'm doctor G, those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.