Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / A Day-Before-The-Day-Before-Christmas-Eve BONUS SHOW!
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Okay, this
- 0:56is another extra you can listen or skip, but on a whim, in
- 1:02advance of the Christmas holiday weekend, I thought maybe I'll just do a live
- 1:04stream. So this is actually the audio from the YouTube version. The links
- 1:08in the description box just me going on about whatever, plus some calls.
- 1:15So you got more podcast content than you probably want it. I hope you
- 1:21enjoy just a random conversation you and me just hanging out. I uh just
- 1:29got back from a hearing test. That's always a joy. Getting older is
- 1:36weird. First of all, my wife thinks I need botox because apparently my
- 1:41forehead which is already substantial, is wrinkly. So she's like, oh,
- 1:47you need to go get botox, which is I guess where they shoot botulism
- 1:51into your head or your wherever you are wrinkly. She wants me to go
- 1:57get but she's like, if you don't do it now, you're gonna look
- 1:59like a raisin when you're seventy What. Well, I'm not doing it,
- 2:05but I've seen the procedure. Holy schnikes. I'll tell you. The one
- 2:08that gets me is when they do the lip fillers. I mean, I
- 2:15have a super strong stomach. I love to watch surgery videos online, from
- 2:21initial incision to closing stitch. I am fascinated by the machine of the body.
- 2:27I can watch open hard surgery. There's a micro neurosurgeon channel where he's
- 2:31taken out brain tumors. I'm all over it. I'm just fascinated. But
- 2:38there are a couple little things that do send me over the edge. First,
- 2:44his thumbs. Anything that happens to your thumb. Anyone remember the classic
- 2:49John Carpenter film. The thing when they did the blood test. All they
- 2:53had to do was just pricked like the side of a finger or the ear
- 2:57lobe. Like your doctor does and check the blood to see if it's the
- 3:00thing. But no, no, no, not in the movie, they
- 3:04take a scalpel and go all the way down the thumb. No reason for
- 3:08it. I about came out of my chair every time I've seen I've seen
- 3:13the movie thirty times. Brilliant film. Don't see the remake or the prequel
- 3:19or whatever it was that came out ten years ago. That's crap. But
- 3:23the original, I swear to the thumb, thumbs and needles going into the
- 3:29actual lip. What is that about? We started watching we saw it on
- 3:36Netflix. It's a totally manufactured piece of fluff entertainment called botched or people in
- 3:44Beverly Hills, I guess mostly. And of course they find the most egregious
- 3:47cases, people who decide, oh, I've got one hundred and fifty bucks,
- 3:53and here's an ad for Tommy Tuck in Tiwana, and they go down
- 3:59there. And then one lady they didn't even give her anesthetic. They just
- 4:02put blocks of ice on her stomach for an hour. She did not get
- 4:10up and leave. Let's say you and I are there in the room.
- 4:15Let's say that we somehow talked ourselves into the fact that, yes, if
- 4:17we go to Tijuana and pay one hundred and fifty dollars, a multi thousand,
- 4:23thousand thousand dollars procedure here in the United States can be done by some
- 4:28dude in I don't know, the back of a van in Tijuana. Somebody
- 4:35walks in with blocks of ice. No, no, we don't have any
- 4:39anesthetic for you. Just lay this on your tummy. We'll see you in
- 4:42sixty minutes. Would your first thought not be I'm out of here? No?
- 4:47No, these people go, ah, makes sense to me. And
- 4:50then they allow this cold ice, which is redundant, I guess, to
- 4:56kill the selves of their skin and whatever is underneath the see it literally kills
- 5:02the body and they experience pain anyway, and then finally they decide maybe we
- 5:08should go see professionals, and they go to these two doctors who who fix
- 5:12them up. I mean, the whole thing is totally manufactured. We know
- 5:15Reality TV is cramp anyway, some of the people they bring in. It's
- 5:19a freaking train wreck. I know. My fellow lefties are like, you
- 5:23should never body shame people, let them be who they are. And I
- 5:27get that until I don't. Right, if you want one lady wants to
- 5:34become a human sex doll. Like she wants to look like one of those
- 5:42purchasable life size sex dolls. So she wears a corset every day and she
- 5:46smashes her waist down in an unhealthy way. She's blown her lips out and
- 5:50her whole face. She can't even open her eyes or close her way.
- 5:53She can't close her eyes. I'm not supposed to. No, No,
- 6:00it's not natur You want to go and enhance yourself. Great, that's not
- 6:04enhancement. I think that's almost like a what do they call it? Body
- 6:10dysmorphia, where no matter what you see you have to change it. That's
- 6:14not healthy. Somebody else goes in and he had everything from pectoral implants to
- 6:23ask implants, to fake muscles put under his skin. He wanted a procedure
- 6:27to try to remove the vein from his forehead because there was a tiny bump
- 6:30that bothered him. No, I'm sorry, it's not body shame. I
- 6:33mean when I say wrong, stop it something wrong with this picture. I'm
- 6:40just saying. Anyway, my wife wants me to get botox, and I
- 6:44feel like, is this a gateway thing? Because you go and you get
- 6:47one procedure and then it's like a tattoo, right, you get the tattoo,
- 6:50and then before you know it, you get a second, a third,
- 6:53and then you're covered before you can't stand. Then you're going to get
- 6:55piercings. Some people, I think it's they just can't stop. And to
- 7:00a degree, I get it, until you become like the guy who wants
- 7:03to be the human lizard. You see that dude, he wants to become
- 7:11a lizard. Tattooed his skin green, and he put little beads or actually
- 7:15big beads under his He's got like a some sort of a klingon looking thing
- 7:19in the middle of his head, and he's he's got someone's got fangs.
- 7:26I don't think it's body shaming to say, what the hell is it?
- 7:30Am I wrong? I receive your correction if I'm wrong. I mean some
- 7:36people, honestly, I think it's okay. It's not body shaming to look
- 7:42at them and say something is distorted with what you are doing. Somebody wanted
- 7:51to like a fifteen hundred cc breast implant. What the what are you could
- 7:59you do with that? Even the doctors like I'm sorry, are you trying
- 8:05to cut off all blood supply to the breast. Would you like your nipple
- 8:11to die because the veins cannot get blood to it because you have fifteen hundred
- 8:16seats, is a sell gown in your breast? Hmm, Seth's body shaming?
- 8:22Hm hm hm hm. Now there's something wrong. I'm convinced. Oh
- 8:31I'm gonna get hate mail anyway. I'm not getting botox. But I guess
- 8:35when I wrinkle up my head, I guess there are lines. Natalie thinks.
- 8:39See. I'm like, oh, maybe it's wisdom that comes with age.
- 8:43And she's like, you look like one of the California raisins. And
- 8:46so we have a good laugh about that. Anyway. Oh, what else
- 8:52was on my mind Christmas is? Oh, we just had a little Christmas,
- 8:56a family Christmas party. This is just me chatting as the switchboard populates,
- 9:03and if there's anything you want to talk about, give me a call.
- 9:09So we wanted to do something special for the grandkids, and somebody on
- 9:13the family tree said, I've got an idea. Let's schedule a surprise helicopter
- 9:20Christmas light tour for the grandkids. So we're talking kids that are seven and
- 9:26nine, and then an adult. So three guests and the pilot in this
- 9:31tiny little helicopter. Have you ever done the helicopter Christmas light tour? I
- 9:37did a couple of them back when I was in radio. Was part of
- 9:39a promotion. We were giving these away to listeners and I got to go
- 9:43around the city on one and it was cool, but the view was actually
- 9:48much better from the ground. You fly over him, you see them from
- 9:52a distance, and you go off to the next destination and the next and
- 9:56the next. But for me, it just didn't just didn't do it for
- 9:58me. I'd much rather be down at eye level and you're driving over the
- 10:03bridges and under the trees and around the decorations, and you get out and
- 10:09people are playing Christmas music and you can go and sort of walk through the
- 10:13lit forested areas and it's much more magical. The helicopter for me, was
- 10:18more about just being in a chopper, which you could do anytime. But
- 10:20they're like, we're gonna surprise the grandkids with a helicopter Christmas Light tour,
- 10:26And my first response was this should not be a surprise, not for kids
- 10:33this young, especially knowing the nine year old Braden who is just the best
- 10:39kid. He's just the best kid. But he's a sensitive soul. No,
- 10:46it's gonna be great, you know it's gonna be He's gonna love it.
- 10:52So we have the family get together gifts of exchange to everybody's laughing and
- 10:58care on and the dogs are there, and you know, they even put
- 11:03like fake snow on the wood floor, kind of scattered it around. Who
- 11:07I wouldn't want to have been there for that clean up? You know,
- 11:09who's gonna sweep and vacuum all the fake snow out of the couch cushions.
- 11:13But they've got the faux fireplace, the virtual fireplace on the television. And
- 11:18there's Christmas music, the good stuff too, the classics, you know,
- 11:22and there's food and we're having a great time knowing that this surprise is coming.
- 11:31All right, kids, hop in the car. It's time to go
- 11:33drive to your big Christmas surprise. Yay, we can't wait. Everybody gets
- 11:41in the car and we drive to the airport. This tiny airport called Jones
- 11:46Riverside near Janks, Oklahoma, suburb of Tulsa. Small airport, really busy
- 11:54and as we pull up and walk into the airport hangar, there are helicoptersating
- 12:00outside and inside there are all these jets inside the hangar, and Brayden goes,
- 12:07sheet white, what's going on? We're gonna go on a Christmas Light
- 12:13helicopter tour. Sheet White. No, I don't want to I don't want
- 12:18to go. I've never been a helicopter. I don't want to go in
- 12:22the helicopter. And I'm like, I told you this was going to amp.
- 12:26You cannot ambush a child. So he is literally traumatized. Oh it's
- 12:33gonna be fun. Everybody keeps telling him, Oh, you're going to have
- 12:35a great time. Oh, you're gonna have a great time. And of
- 12:37course I'm over there, going it'll be okay, pal. If you really
- 12:41don't want to go, we'll figure it out. You know, we're gonna
- 12:43it'll be okay. You know you're safe, And I know everybody else kind
- 12:48of felt that way. They're not going to jam him onto the chopper against
- 12:50his will. But the idea was is that he was just going to see
- 12:54this gift and just light up like a Christmas tree and say wonderful. But
- 13:01in truth, he was overwhelmed. So he walks in. We're all in
- 13:07the lobby, and they start filling out all the paperwork. Who's going up
- 13:11And here's a liability waiver, which I guess means if we crash into Terra
- 13:16Firma and everybody dies, we will not be held liable. I get that.
- 13:24Braiden starts to look around. So we walk out and we start to
- 13:28see the choppers and they land and take off, and they land and take
- 13:33off, and he's starting to calm down and get used to the idea.
- 13:37And then this beautiful, lovely person behind the counter, she was the angel.
- 13:46She saw Braiden there and she saw he was nervous, and I'm sure
- 13:50she has seen hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of passengers of all ages. And
- 13:54she said, hey, have you ever been up in a helicopter to the
- 14:00lights? No? No, non helicopter. No, I've never been up.
- 14:05She said, let me show you something, and she reached back behind
- 14:11the counter and she pulled out what looked like the old school three D glasses.
- 14:15Anybody remember those paper glasses that you would This is back before you know
- 14:20the new three D technology. But when you put the glasses on, every
- 14:26light that you looked at became something. And the glasses each had a different
- 14:31image. So if I put the candy clean glasses on and I looked at
- 14:37a Christmas tree, all of the pin lights became little floating candy canes.
- 14:41It was amazing. Put on another pair of glasses, every light became a
- 14:46snowman. Every light became something else. Wow, and he starts to smile.
- 14:56Now, when you go up in the helicopter, you know what's cool
- 15:01is when you put these glasses on and look at it down through the helicopter
- 15:07window, every light you see will become a candy cane. You're gonna try
- 15:13it. You want to try it? Yeah, that sounds cool. Now
- 15:16he's starting to engage. So the helicopter lands and it's time. The door
- 15:26opens, and he's still a little bit wary, but you can see he's
- 15:31gonna do it of his own volition. Everybody crams into this chopper and he
- 15:37you know, they fire up. You can hear the collective increasing and they
- 15:43go up into the sky and then he turns and he hovers and they're hovering
- 15:46probably fifteen feet over the ground, and I'm thinking, oh, oh,
- 15:52shit's going down inside the chopper. Somebody's having a heart attack and wants him
- 15:56to land. But no, no, this is just part of their procedure
- 16:00checklists, I suppose. And then they fly off and they're gone, and
- 16:07the whole time, thirty minutes, we have to wait and go what is
- 16:11happening up there? How's he doing? So we sit back in the lobby
- 16:18on the couches, waiting and waiting and waiting, until finally we hear the
- 16:25sound of rotor blades. Everybody gets off, including Braden, who is smiling
- 16:33ear to ear. Did you take phone pictures? Yeah? Yeah, yeah,
- 16:40yeah, I took a ton of pictures. You got to show me
- 16:41your pictures. Did you get video? Yeah, yeah, yeah, I
- 16:45took video. Did you look through your candy cane and your snowman glasses?
- 16:48Yeah? Yeah, it was cool. It was awesome. And he talked
- 16:52about it over and over and over and over again. He was just delighted.
- 16:59That could have go really wrong. Again. I think he should have
- 17:02been warned. You know, some people in this world love surprises, and
- 17:07some people are like, oh hell no. I was reminded of the childlike
- 17:12wonder of Christmas when you're that age before life has sort of worn you down.
- 17:22I enjoy the holiday, okay, and I love the time I have
- 17:27with my family, but there's a soft focus and a much too pristine and
- 17:37happy sort of mentos commercial vibe to the holiday that rubs me the wrong way.
- 17:45And I like to think I'm a pretty good spirited guy. It starts
- 17:52in November, the commercials. Everybody's wearing one of those big sweaters, beautiful
- 18:00skin, lovely eyes, perfect white, pearly teeth, and they're having the
- 18:07best time in the history of best times. Oh oh, I've got something
- 18:12for you. And the man is with there, and he's with his girlfriend
- 18:17or his wife, and he leans over and he opens up the jewel box.
- 18:21There there's a necklace, diamond necklace, and she's like, he really
- 18:27loves me. And then you know Jared or Moody's or whatever the you know,
- 18:33the de Beer's family, you know, they whoever's selling diamonds, which,
- 18:37by the way, as I understand it, the whole diamond industry is
- 18:41a freaking scam. It's just bullshit. I realize that all value is artificial.
- 18:48The value that we assigned to paper money and gold and silver, etc.
- 18:52This is all arbitrarily subjectively assigned. Put this idea, I'm saying,
- 19:00you want ten thousand dollars. It's a rock, right, it's a rock.
- 19:07I understand now, and I'm thankful for this because of the blood diamond
- 19:15phenomenon, where people are essentially put into a diamond slave trade, often children,
- 19:22and they are horribly treated, sometimes killed by having to you know,
- 19:27mine diamonds for gang's, terrorist, cartel members, etc. Now it's more
- 19:33and more lab created diamonds. Lovely, they're even more pristine and perfect.
- 19:38They are pretty. Don't tell me that the markup on a five thousand dollars
- 19:45or whatever lab created diamond isn't insane. What do you think they created it
- 19:52for in the lab? Maybe I'm showing my ignorance a fifty bucks. I
- 20:02mean, it's just a series of elements compressed into a diamond using a machine.
- 20:08And then they say, ah, look at the purity, look at
- 20:11the clarity, look at the color, look at how it has been shaped
- 20:15and molded. Yes, right now, forty percent off. It's only one
- 20:18thousand, four hundred fifty dollars. And don't you want to get something truly
- 20:25valuable for the person you love? And what's the minefield if you get someone
- 20:30a cheapie? Hey, look, I went to big lots and I got
- 20:34you a knockoff. It's made of glass, but you know it sparkles in
- 20:40the sunlight. I think it would look great around your neck or and your
- 20:42ears, around your finger. And you give that and they look at you
- 20:45and say how much did you spend? And you said, I got it
- 20:48for sixty seven bucks plus tax, and then they kick you in the balls
- 20:56because we have decided that value is monetary. We've decided that if someone truly
- 21:06loves me, they have to go into debts or charge it to the credit
- 21:11card. They have to express it monetarily. I mean some people feel that
- 21:18way. How do people measure the success of the holiday? How do news
- 21:25reporters measure the success of the holiday? They say, retail sales are up
- 21:30this year. The economy seems to be booming in twenty twenty three. More
- 21:33and more shoppers are shopping for this, this, and this, and things
- 21:38are flying off the shelves. It's going to be a beautiful Christmas this year.
- 21:44Well, how do you know that a certain percentage of someone's income was
- 21:51spent between these weeks and these weeks in a year. Therefore it's a great
- 21:56Christmas. I don't know. I've become more and more jaded because I feel
- 22:07like it's you know, when I hear a lot of pop songs, some
- 22:14of them are kind of fun, reinventions of the classics, good stuff.
- 22:19But some of the Christmas songs are so damn cheery, and they sound so
- 22:25manufactured. You can't help but think this artist was smart enough to know that
- 22:33if they wrote a catchy little ditty that came out of the manufacturing machine of
- 22:40corporate radio or corporate you know, album making, the music machine, if
- 22:45they make this, then it will be evergreen, and it will play every
- 22:49December until whenever. That's royalties, that's radio airplay. It's but they's so
- 22:56less ding ding ding ding ding ding. It's a Christmas Christmas Christmas mon monk
- 23:03bunk bump. I just want to put my head through the sheet rock.
- 23:06It's too sweet. I like sweet, it's too sweet. It tastes artificial,
- 23:15and it's being rammed down my throat. This is not how I do
- 23:18sweets. Time with family can be stressful. I'm gonna stop by my family's
- 23:29house tomorrow. Mom and I don't speak. That'll be fun. She'll be
- 23:36in the room. I mean, we're not going to engage each other.
- 23:37We did a drive by Thanksgiving Hi Hi Mom. Separate rooms and I spent
- 23:44time with other people who were engaging in fun. We had a good time,
- 23:47eat some good food, and then we were out of there. And
- 23:48I'm gonna do the same thing tomorrow, go hang out with the people that
- 23:52I engage and enjoy. But the person who continued to trespass has lost their
- 23:56gate privileges. We're not gonna hang That's just how it is. So it's
- 24:00weird. It's a weird Christmas thing. Some people think I'm stupid for even
- 24:07why would you even go in there? I can't really decide why I have
- 24:11this conversation every year. I'm sure some people find me tedious. Part of
- 24:18me wants to go on principle, like I just I'm not going to be
- 24:21locked out by this. Part of me wants to see my siblings, see
- 24:23how they're doing, and catch up with some people. Usually have a pretty
- 24:29good time. But how can it not be weird when you've got a parent
- 24:33that you have essentially sliced out of your life and they are right there in
- 24:37potentially in the room. What happens if she sits down at the table,
- 24:42Hey, how's your month been? No? Do I say something like the
- 24:48less we speak, the better, I don't know. Do I just simply
- 24:53quietly get up, excuse myself and relocate. I don't know. I don't
- 24:57know. It's weird. Some people feel like I'm being inappropriate. She's your
- 25:07mother, you're being petty. Other people say screw her. You don't know
- 25:11her at the time of day, and there are people in between. The
- 25:15one that gets me, I'll get to the switchboard in just a second,
- 25:19is you don't know how many days on this earth she has left. You
- 25:29don't want that time to pass and her be gone, and then you look
- 25:33back with regret. That's the one that gets me. That feels manipulative to
- 25:40me. But I blocked mom. You know what it felt like blocking spam.
- 25:47That's how bad it is. So I mean when it's all over,
- 25:53I don't know. I just feel it feels manipulative. I don't know.
- 25:57I don't know how. I didn't mean to get off mom. I was
- 26:00going to try to keep things really light and talk about you know, the
- 26:03grandkid and all the other stuff that is going on. But anyways, we
- 26:08head into the Christmas holiday weekend, you may celebrate. You may not.
- 26:14I know that most of my Christian you know, Jesus is the reason for
- 26:18the seasoned friends, they're surrounded by the pagan traditions of old, the pre
- 26:23Christian traditions that if they realize the origins, it might give them a moment
- 26:29of bause. It's beautiful. Jesus is the reason for the season. Jesus
- 26:33is the only reason we celebrate December twenty fifth, because obviously he would have
- 26:38been born in December. Hell no, that's crap. Keep the christ in
- 26:44Christmas. Don't say happy Holidays. Have you been to Starbucks and seen that
- 26:48they have red cups that don't have pictures of Jesus on It into an attack
- 26:53on my faith. By the way, love your tree. Look it's Missletoe,
- 27:00the magic druid plant. Oh, it's yule log. Say hi to
- 27:06the Norseman for me. Enjoy the Norse festival of ewle gift giving, Happy
- 27:12Saturnalia. It's just awesome. It's awesome. Nobody wants to talk about it
- 27:18either. Like I've occasionally posted online, it's fascinating and I do it.
- 27:22Try to be positive. It's fascinating to look at the traditions of Christmas.
- 27:29Did you know that the evergreen tree stems back to the festival of Saturnalia,
- 27:36honoring the gods Saturn and Methris. Did you know that the missletoe plant was
- 27:42once used as a magical plant to bring people together. They would even bring
- 27:48warring armies in the same place for a truce, and they would hang mistletoe
- 27:53because it apparently had peaceful properties, magical, calming, peaceful properties. Did
- 28:00you know that's fascinating, fascinating. Did you know that Odin they used to
- 28:07ride in the sky behind his sleigh of stallions, and on those who had
- 28:12pleased him, or better yet, had not displeased him, he would drop
- 28:17favors down upon the common people, upon the mortals, the great god Odin,
- 28:22who was one of the many inspirations for today's Santa Claus. Did you
- 28:27know that? Ye. I've heard people say you shouldn't teach your kids about
- 28:33Santa because Christians don't tell your kids there's Santa Claus, because when they find
- 28:40out Santa's bullshit, then they're going to distrust you on the whole Jesus thing.
- 28:45And I think you're onto something. Mom and Dad lied to whists about
- 28:51Saint Nicholas. What if they lied to us about Jesus. I just think
- 28:56that's awesome. It's an actual discussion that people have inside the awesome the story
- 29:03if Saint Nicholas is fascinating. I encourage you to go and just do a
- 29:07cursory look at it. You know, there was an actual saint, right,
- 29:11Saint Nicholas of Myra, who became the patron saint of children, who
- 29:15used to give gifts to impoverished people. This is the story which gave birth
- 29:21to the legend. And then you've got Thomas Nast who was illustrating the old
- 29:27Clement Moore poem. And then you've got Coca Cola. They come in and
- 29:32use some of the nasty illustrations and their marketing campaigns in the early twentieth century,
- 29:37So you got Santa helping to sell coke. I think this may have
- 29:41been back when there was actual cocaine in the Coca Cola here. You know,
- 29:48even Santa Claus, whom I loved as a child. Now I look
- 29:52at it and I'm like, they know, it's a Santa doll that's being
- 29:57sold. It's a Santa to statue. Look, it's a Santa greeting card.
- 30:02Gotta buy one of those Santa ornaments I purchased and put on the tree,
- 30:06the Santa Santa Santa. But almost always there's a freaking price tag on
- 30:10it. You know, if it's done in the purest sense, say take
- 30:12your kid to the mall and there's a Santa that doesn't look creepy, that's
- 30:15always a plus. And then your kid can sit on his lap and say,
- 30:19hey, Santa, here's what I want for Christmas. Yay, And
- 30:22then you know they have a memory in a photo. But even there,
- 30:26you're buying the photograph. Hey, would you like a picture of this encounter?
- 30:30We took one. It'll cost you twenty five dollars to get it.
- 30:33Eight and a half by eleven or eight by ten. I think eight and
- 30:37a half by eleven's paper. Eight by ten is photo just pedantic, but
- 30:42it's true anyway. Christmas, I guess, is what we make it.
- 30:49That's my goal. I'm going to will cynicism out. I'm gonna push cinis
- 31:00out, and I'm going to say I am here in this space with the
- 31:06woman I love and her kids whom I love, and my dogs and my
- 31:12cat whom I love, and I'm going to put the music that I want
- 31:15to listen to, and I'm going to cook the food that we all want
- 31:21to enjoy. Will do whatever traditions make us the happiest, and screw anybody
- 31:26and everybody else who doesn't like it. But it's not easy that it is
- 31:33a force of will. I think getting older does it to you? What
- 31:41is that line from the movie worn Down by Life? You get worn down
- 31:45by life. That's the reason I've got forehead wrinkles, because you get worn
- 31:48down by life. Are you even remotely interested in anything that I've been saying.
- 32:00I don't even know why I'm streaming. I'm wasting your time. I'm
- 32:06taking up oxygen. This is bandwidth you could be using for other things.
- 32:13Short break your calls, next extra show, bonus show. Just hanging out
- 32:28on this day before the day before Christmas? Eve five seven five? Is
- 32:37it Jamie? Are you there? It's Jamie Set. Yes, I'm calling
- 32:40from New Mexico. Welcome to the show. Let's talk what's on your mind?
- 32:45Well, first of all, I just I love your content. I'm
- 32:50a former fundamentalist Pentecostal Christian for over thirty years and sort of deconstructed over the
- 32:55last decade. And the stuff that you've got has been really good. My
- 32:59wife this remains a believer, and our three adult kids not really, and
- 33:04so that's been an interesting dynamics. I've never really loved Christmas, lots of
- 33:07you know what to give people and anxiety my whole life, but I've always
- 33:12tried to go along with it. And when I really came out as an
- 33:15atheist that really really didn't like Christmas, my wife loves Christmas. The house
- 33:19is fully decorated and everything else. But this Sunday, Christmas Eve. I
- 33:23also play music for a part of my job, and I played music in
- 33:27church for twenty five years. And so this Sunday, my wife and kids
- 33:34and some friends are hosting a little Christmas Eve jam at a local venue in
- 33:38a very touristy area, and I'm completely embracing it. I'm practicing Christmas music.
- 33:44I'm going to do it the way I want to do it. My
- 33:45kids or adult children who are great musicians, and my wife are going to
- 33:49come and sing with me, and I'm just going to try to be happy
- 33:52about the parts of Christmas I loved, because it's so much about it that
- 33:54drives me mus And you know, you were talking about you know, as
- 33:58time goes on. I'm almost sixty years old. I've been an atheist now
- 34:00for about ten years, and I'm just going to try to embrace the parts
- 34:06I like and not worry about the stuff that makes me crazy. What a
- 34:08generous and lovely thing, though, I mean, your wife sees that,
- 34:13you know, you're you're more interested in making a memory and doing something together
- 34:17than you are and squabbling about whether or not there's a God or you know,
- 34:22whether there's a baby Jesus or whatever. I mean, that's I think
- 34:24that's lovely. Yeah, it's it's been interesting that whole thing between us sometimes
- 34:30because she'll just sort of make it an issue occasionally. I'm like, you
- 34:34know what, we've already discussed this. Let's just not Let's just love each
- 34:37other and do the stuff where we know we can do together. We don't
- 34:39go to church together, and I get that. I get that, make
- 34:44the day whatever you want to make it, and merry Christmas and happy Holidays
- 34:49and all the other holidays. And I appreciate you very much, thanks man.
- 34:54It was it was fun to get into visits you'd like to call some
- 34:58other times, all right, appreciate you man. Be safe. Take thanks.
- 35:05It's weird, uh all of these? Uh? All right? Can
- 35:12you hear me? Now, those of you in the chat, I require
- 35:19your assistance? Can you hear me? Testing? One? Two? Lo?
- 35:23Do I see my father? Lo? Do I see my mother?
- 35:28And my sister and my brother? Lo? Do I see? How's it
- 35:35go? The line of my people? Back to the beginning where the brave
- 35:42may live forever. I can't remember all of it. Okay, I can't
- 35:45remember all of it. My fault. Uh. Lo. They do call
- 35:52to me, Thank you, Mark, thank you for that? Okay?
- 35:55Where was I? Oh? My god? What an unbelievably unkept stream this
- 36:02has been. Forgive me. I try to bring polish to the channel,
- 36:07and instead I'm just I'm a mess. I've got nine eight zero? What's
- 36:10your name? Nine eight zero? Are you there? Nine eight zero?
- 36:24Are you with me? I think that is a problem. I therein.
- 36:35I've got four to two three? Hi? Are you with me? Hello?
- 36:43Four two three? Are you there? I'm here? Hey, what's
- 36:46your name? Can you hear me? I can? What's your name?
- 36:50Will? I will? What's on your mind? I've been thinking a lot
- 36:59lately about the Christmas time and the spending time with family and stuff like that.
- 37:06Because I'm not a super sociable person. I don't like spending a ton
- 37:10of time, especially with my family, because there's a lot of us.
- 37:15The big family get together is like Christmas and Thanksgiving with my dad's side of
- 37:21the family is like forty people when they try to get everyone together and it's
- 37:27a lot and they're doing it again this coming Sunday, Christmas Eve, and
- 37:35I have missed the past few because of work, but I've been I'm trying
- 37:40to go to this one kind of as a challenge to myself and as a
- 37:45I can see some of the family because they're trying to get as many people
- 37:47back as possible, but I always am hesitant to do it because of I
- 37:54am like definitely the black sheep of the family, and so many everyone is
- 38:05like very devoutly conservative Christian and that would be the furthest description from me,
- 38:14and they tend to inject a whole lot of religion into their Christmas get togethers.
- 38:20And one of the things they do is they they'll read the Nativity Story
- 38:24at the beginning of the night, and my grandmother makes some effort to read
- 38:30it to all the little kids and stuff like that, and I've just been
- 38:37like, we're kind of hesitant because every time I go, I feel like,
- 38:42even though some of these get togethers are pretty they go pretty well,
- 38:50there's always something that happens, like a conversation or something where I feel further
- 38:55isolated from the rest of them. You feel like some of it's not just
- 39:00passive aggressive, but actually aggressive, Like even when they talk to each other,
- 39:04you feel like it's for your benefit. I'm it's hard to say a
- 39:17lot of the extended families that are kind of wanted to go see I don't,
- 39:22of course, because they're like further extended. I don't know a lot
- 39:24about them too much in a personal sense, but I just know the the
- 39:30mindset and the pilosophy of like some of the family that I'm closer to,
- 39:36they are very intolerant of a lot of things. They're all like, you
- 39:45know, proud Trump supporters. They're like you mentioned, they're conservative Christians.
- 39:51And so what will bound to happen in like some of the conversations is the
- 39:55subject of politics will come up, because they of course still come comfortable because
- 40:00they're in you know, they're in the group of the like minded, all
- 40:04of them there are in agreement, so they feel like they can say some
- 40:09things that are a little bit off color because they feel comfortable in that.
- 40:19Sure, well, you know, I understand the feeling of I don't know,
- 40:24being outside of not being able to relate. I certainly understand the frustration
- 40:30of watching this stuff being sold and told to children. I would personally love
- 40:35the I wish they were someone that would ask me to tell the Nativity story.
- 40:38I would love the opportunity. I'll give me that shot. People let
- 40:44me let me teach the children what's in the Bible. I think that would
- 40:47be big fun. Ultimately, though, you know, I feel you watching
- 40:53the chat, watching the comments blow through, A lot of people are feeling,
- 40:58you know what you're I think a lot of people are dealing with what
- 41:01you're dealing with, and so you're not alone. Your frustrations are shared.
- 41:07Ultimately, I you know, I hope that you can find time with some
- 41:10people who will accept and celebrate you on your own terms. Okay, yeah,
- 41:17thanks for taking my call on a longtime listener. And this is the
- 41:21first time I've tried to calling you, so I'm really surprised I got in.
- 41:22It's an honor to speak to you and happy holidays, Merry Christmas,
- 41:27Happy New Year and all that stuff. Okay, yeah, you two,
- 41:30all right, take care. By the way, I want to say thank
- 41:36you to Ryan for the super chat. I don't do a lot of like
- 41:42soliciting for superchats, but I certainly do appreciate the support, and if you
- 41:49want to support me into the new year, I'm not too proud to say
- 41:53Patreon dot com, slash Seth Andrews or a super chats are more than a
- 41:59welcome as well. So it's lovely, all right, Seth. We would
- 42:02like you to tell the Nativity story to the children. We would like you
- 42:09to relate the story from the Gospels for this next generation. Okay, I'm
- 42:15delighted to all right, kids gather around. A long, long, long
- 42:24time ago, a being named Yahweh, who knew everything, decided to create
- 42:35one of the most incompetent things ever. He developed a plan destined to fail
- 42:42from the very first chapter of Genesis, and then when it failed, he
- 42:47got angry, because of course, someone who knows everything, past, present
- 42:52and future would gets surprised. Then he wouldn't just punish the imperfect creatures who
- 42:59were acting imperfectly He decided to punish the billions and billions and billions and billions
- 43:06and billions of people who came later, you know, the ones who were
- 43:09created through incest, you know, whenever the kids had sex with mom to
- 43:15make the other people. What a beautiful story. And then everybody was drowned.
- 43:20But that didn't work out. And then there were wars, and there
- 43:22was genocide and slavery and rape and all these other things. Human sacrifice,
- 43:27the execution of children your age because you were so disobedient. And God said,
- 43:31well, shit, that didn't work out. But kids, God had
- 43:37yet another solution, and this time he wasn't gonna fuck up. He decided
- 43:44to rescue humankind. I will impregnate an unweed teenager with myself via ghost sex,
- 43:52and I will do it in a time when unweed teenagers were pariahs in
- 43:58their community. Do you know what a pariah is? A pariah is an
- 44:02outcast, someone who is named and blamed and shamed for being immoral or outside
- 44:09the norm. And that's what God's mother should be, an unwed teenager named
- 44:15and blamed and shamed by her community. Of course, Joseph would kind of
- 44:21be the husband and sort of be the dad, but not really. And
- 44:25then the baby would be born in a manger or in a stable, or
- 44:30in the basement of a poor person's house, and there would be wise men
- 44:35or magie, I can't really remember. And then they would go back and
- 44:37there was a census, but there wasn't you know what a census is.
- 44:40Never mind, kids, it's boring, you don't care. And then there
- 44:44was a guy named Harrot who killed babies, kill kill, kill, kill
- 44:49little in the Baby's Beautiful story, except that the other book of the Bible
- 44:52doesn't talk about him, so maybe it didn't happen anyway, Try to put
- 44:57baby killing out of your mind. Here's the Christ child, ah angels light,
- 45:02a big star, a star big enough, large enough, bigger than
- 45:07the Sun, which would have incinerated the whole planet, but somehow didn't.
- 45:10In fact, it was tiny enough to follow people around the planet. What
- 45:15a miracle. And then this baby Jesus disappeared from the record for thirty years.
- 45:25No one gave a shit about what he was doing. Was he just
- 45:30hanging around Mary's house? Was he watching tebow? Was he making furniture and
- 45:37stuff? Because you know he was a carpenter, He playing Hackey Sack with
- 45:42all of his non deity buddies of the same age. We don't know.
- 45:46It's all the Big three decade mystery. And then God showed up in human
- 45:53form, and he did three years of unverifiable miracles in a tiny, tiny,
- 46:00tiny tiny place on planet Earth, right with all of the other life
- 46:05on Earth. No, no, Jesus was going to focus on this tiny
- 46:08little blip on the planet well be fourteen hundred years before the invention of the
- 46:15printing press. In fact, it wouldn't be documented until decades later, a
- 46:19generation later, by authors whose identities have never once been proven. It's beautiful,
- 46:27and the reason this Christ Child came to us is so that he could
- 46:30save us from the torture chamber that he himself made and threatened us with.
- 46:37And his solution for that salvation would be to have himself turned into a bloody
- 46:43meat pinata, so then the corpse could be thrown in behind some rocks,
- 46:49his spirit could go visit Heaven and Hell. After three days he would return
- 46:53and say, psych look at the holes, and then he would float up
- 47:00into Heaven and become Hide and Seek champion of the universe for two thousand years,
- 47:07and this deity would be so effected in sharing his message that two thirds
- 47:14of the planet would believe in another God or no god at all. Thanks
- 47:20for listening, kids, and Merry Christmas. You're welcome. That's a freebie,
- 47:29folks. Off the top of my head. Can you tell I'm can
- 47:34you tell about an activist for a while? Just throw this shit out?
- 47:40Did I just do? I did it extamboraneously. You're welcome, folks.
- 47:46That's worth the super Chat donation, isn't it all right? I'm gonna try
- 47:52Vicky again at nine age zero? Hi, NICKI, Vicky are you there?
- 48:00Are you calling me? Mister Seth? I've got nine eight zero.
- 48:04Please tell me your first name? Becky, Becky. I'm so sorry.
- 48:10Let's talk. It's okay. I wasn't sure. I wasn't sure how you
- 48:14were going to do it. I was waiting on my last four digits and
- 48:16my phone number, and it's something else you let's talk. Name is My
- 48:22name's beck I'm from Charlotte, North Carolina, and I have been watching you
- 48:28on and off here for a couple of months now. I'm really very interested
- 48:34in the subject. I'll preface this by saying I was once a Christian and
- 48:38I am absolute stone cold atheists. I don't even have the bitterness anymore.
- 48:45I mean a lot of that. It's gone. It's I'm done with it.
- 48:47But I wanted to tell you a funny little story back when I was
- 48:52back when I was in church. In the church, we had this group.
- 48:57It was kath It puts that way. We have outreach interfaith outreach group
- 49:01with the group of Jewish people in Charlotte, North Carolina, and wonderful group
- 49:06of people, and they have a great campus in Charlotte and had just just
- 49:09wonderful folks and whatnot. And so it's Catholic faith, our churches and whatnot.
- 49:14I'll say that Charlotte is a great town. However, when we catgether,
- 49:20we were one of the people, one of the gentlemen there, he's
- 49:22relating a story about Christmas and how they dealt with it in the South and
- 49:27whatnot, and he said, well, you know, I have no problem
- 49:30with Christmas trees and whatnot in decorations. He says, but when I go
- 49:34into one of my fellow Jewish friends or families homes and I see a Christmas
- 49:37tree, I'll turn around and walk right back out the door. So some
- 49:45of the Catholic folks, they they kind of looked around, you know,
- 49:47things got a little uncomfortable, and I said, well, now you know
- 49:51that the Christmas Tree has absolutely nothing to do with Christianity. And at that
- 49:55point I began to relate a lot of this stuff. But you had just
- 49:59talked about Santa being no sort of like Odin's. It's sort of like this.
- 50:02We're like different things that have been thrown together over the years thousands,
- 50:07a thousand years, or you could say, of European pagan influences and whatnot
- 50:13upon Christianity. That I think it surprised them. And you know what,
- 50:16I think at that point, that was when I thought to myself, I
- 50:20am done with myself long enough. I've had enough of this BS and out
- 50:29with it all. That's where you came. Yeah, I was, uh,
- 50:36it was just well, I had started says. I came from one
- 50:42of those families where Christianity we was all over the place. We didn't have
- 50:45a set face. It was whatever. You know, we we've had the
- 50:49Bible and we prayed what dinners and want and stuff like that, and occasionally
- 50:52we went to church. It was nothing. We were all kind of like
- 50:58like free Grange Christians, whatever you want to call it. But however,
- 51:01when I got into my probably about forty, I had a bad health scare.
- 51:07That's where I reordered in my life. And when I came back from
- 51:09that, you know, I really thought, well, you know, I've
- 51:13always been attracted to Catholic faith and whatnot. So I decided to go into
- 51:16it. And I really went into it when it was just a good time.
- 51:21It was in the nineties, right around ninety nineteen ninety, and the
- 51:24particular priest that was running the RCI, he was great. He was retired
- 51:30Air Force chaplain and he was just great with people and whatnot. And if
- 51:35it hadn't been for him, I probably wouldn't have stayed. But he spotted
- 51:38me right off the bat. He said that you're sort of like a scholar
- 51:44and whatnot, and I can see that you're very interested. And I said,
- 51:46you know, he's right. So after several years of going and being
- 51:51in a Catholic church and experiencing that, I decided to go to back to
- 51:54school and get my Bachelor of Arts degree in academic study of religion. And
- 52:00so I really took a deep die. I mean, I went very deep
- 52:02into into studying Christianity and studying religion in general on how it affects our culture.
- 52:08And now I'm pretty much I'm into Marvel comics and I've been doing a
- 52:12lot of podcasting and up with that, so I won't go into that.
- 52:15But if you want to hear some more funny stories, I can tell you
- 52:17something there too. Anyway, I just really enjoy your show, and I
- 52:22enjoy you, and you know I've been looking at you. It'll be say
- 52:24like seven years ago, three years ago, five months ago, and now
- 52:29I'm looking at you live and you are one more handsome dude. Oh stop,
- 52:32well, you're very kind. It's all soft focus, you know,
- 52:36it's all done with mirrors or whatever. So have a wonderful holiday. Thanks
- 52:40for being so skeptical. Take care, oh absolutely, and I love you,
- 52:45seth and Merry Christmas to everybody. Happy you, You're happy, honk
- 52:49Kwanza, whatever you want to call it. All right, goodnight, begs
- 52:52a bunch, We'll see you all right, bye bye. I saw forgive
- 52:57me. I want to do my due diligence. Gary. He sent me
- 53:01ten bucks for the Nativity Story. Bless your heart, Bless you and the
- 53:07Lord Matthew, thank you very very much. Tickled by the words you spoke.
- 53:13I'm a giver. Yeah, that's what I do. Linda, thank
- 53:15you very much for the super chat. I'm a storyteller and occasionally i'm a
- 53:22little sarcastic. I guess sometimes when those two go together, some people like
- 53:27that. I used to be afraid of making fun of the Jesus story because
- 53:30it had been so programmed into me. You know, you don't make fun
- 53:34of Jesus. Hey, yeah, make fun of Jesus now. Honestly,
- 53:37it's a liberation exercise. I love Jesus' swear words, Jesus Christ. I
- 53:44do it all the time. I used to be even as an atheist.
- 53:46I was weird about it, Jesus Christ, but I would force myself through
- 53:52it because I thought, the reason you're weird is because someone trained you to
- 53:57be afraid one. And I don't say it a lot on I don't say
- 54:02it a lot in public, but I'll admit I say it a lot in
- 54:07private. God damn it, I do it all the time. I'm in
- 54:10the kitchen. I forgot an ingredient when I'm making dinner. Goddamn it,
- 54:17I miss my turn when I'm driving somewhere. Goddamn it, I do it
- 54:21all the time. I'm gonna slip one of these days and do it in
- 54:24front of my religious family. Maybe you'll be in Christmas, you know,
- 54:30I'm over there and a piece of food falls on the floor. God damn
- 54:32it, they would have a heart attack. Thou shalt not use the name
- 54:39of the Lord thy God in vain. That's one of the sins. You
- 54:45don't commit that sin anyway, Linda, you're very kind. Thank you so
- 54:51much for h for supporting me and supporting the show. Let's see who else
- 54:57is on my switchboard. I've got so seven eighty six. Tell me your
- 55:00name, Xavier, great name, like professor x I think what's on your
- 55:09mind? Yeah, you've given up. I think you give up on religion
- 55:15too early. Like you can try other ones. It's like saying, like
- 55:19you live in North Korea, therefore I'm not gonna live in any country.
- 55:22Which religion would you recommend? Buddhism? Like I love Christianity, it was
- 55:30doing a lot of toxic damage. So I've been trying Buddhism and it's really
- 55:34enhanced my well being. Describe you forgive me. I'm gonna jump in.
- 55:38Describe your flavor of Buddhism, because there are non theistic flavors of Buddhism that
- 55:44I actually really like. Do you believe in a supernatural Buddhist philosophy or theology?
- 55:52No, I'm a secular Buddhist like Steven Asthma. Well, you and
- 55:59I'm probably lying up on the side. There's a lot about Buddhism. I
- 56:01dig mindfulness, you know, trying to focus on what you can control,
- 56:07making the most of the moments, you know, centering yourself. There's a
- 56:12lot about secular Buddhism I dig, you know, even mindfulness meditation. So
- 56:16I don't think you and I stand apart on that. Yeah, yeah,
- 56:22I just I'm so used to being obsessed with religion, but it was taking
- 56:27such a toll on me, but I couldn't get it out of me.
- 56:29So I just took. I just took a better religion, and Buddhism supports
- 56:35in permanent suffering and non self all backed up. I signed, and the
- 56:38meditation practices have really enhanced my life. So I guess I'm technically an atheist,
- 56:43but I do believe somehow in a higher power. So I'm just going
- 56:46to call that secular Buddhism, and you should try it. What's the higher
- 56:52power? The universe itself? Just uh out for me? I'm not pushing
- 57:00back. I just I'm curious. Do you mean, like an involved higher
- 57:06power that affects you in some intentional way with agency, or just there's something
- 57:10bigger than us out there, even if it's unconcerned. It's larger than we
- 57:15are, something bigger than us, but we're probably part of whatever it is.
- 57:22Like, there's scientific support for the interconnectedness of all things, and that's
- 57:27the aspect of Buddhism. So I don't want to call it God. So
- 57:31I'm still nonbious, but I believe in something that's holding us all together.
- 57:37And I guess you can call it the universe, but it's just it's a
- 57:40good way to replace God in your mind. Yeah, I'm not going to
- 57:44get pedantic about that. We are all stardust, right, we are all
- 57:47the universe expressing itself for just a little while. Why not? Beautiful stuff?
- 57:52I wish you the best, Thank you for calling, and happy holidays.
- 58:00Why I think these I see them? What was I going to say?
- 58:05Oh, we've talked a little bit about the power of ritual and why
- 58:08even secular people will often gravitate to ritual. It's why I think we see
- 58:14secular Jews. So many people in the Jewish religion are not part of a
- 58:19Jewish faith. They like the ritual, the tradition, the framework of it
- 58:25that enhances the human experience, but they don't necessarily believe in gods, the
- 58:30Satanic temple, right, they don't believe in the supernatural. They're atheists,
- 58:35but they like the framework and that enhances the human experience. And for secular
- 58:42Buddhists, they like the framework and many of the rituals involved, but they
- 58:49haven't talked themselves into magical thinking. That's different. And I used to think
- 58:53all religions need to be eradicated, but I've evolved my point of view to
- 58:59a allow for the religions that are non theistic, that are non supernatural.
- 59:05There are some religions which are more about a philosophy and value system, ritual,
- 59:10tradition, structure, and if that floats your boat, as long as
- 59:15you're not lying to yourself or somebody else, good for you. Some people
- 59:20might give me shit for that. Scott, thank you for the super chat
- 59:24with a voice like butter leading us out of the fog. God, damn
- 59:29it. I'm not leading anybody. I'm just I'm just here. We're all
- 59:35together, side by side, shoulder to shoulder, elbow to elbow. I'm
- 59:38just I happen to have a microphone and a camera and I have I do
- 59:44have a big mouth. I do have a big mouth. Let's take a
- 59:50look here, six one six high? Is it? Ben? Oh yeah,
- 59:55yep, that's me Ben. What's on your mind? Well, I
- 1:00:00just I saw your show was going, and I've been watching your stuff for
- 1:00:04a while, so I decided i'd just call in and see how see what
- 1:00:07kind of things we could talk about, what kind of things I could ask
- 1:00:10you about? You just wanted to be on the air. Well, not
- 1:00:15really just on the air. I was just more I've been trying to like
- 1:00:21re examine a lot of my beliefs, not just like you know, Christianity
- 1:00:25and whatnot, because I grew up in like a I don't know if it
- 1:00:29was necessarily fundamentalist, but like pretty hardline religious family where I was just I
- 1:00:37don't know, it felt like I never really clicked with what they thought.
- 1:00:39So I was just trying to when I or whatever. That's just kind of
- 1:00:45my thing. But I was just I wrote down here, I kind of
- 1:00:50made a little bit of notes, like what kind of ideas do you kind
- 1:00:52of what's the word? What would you think for like if I want to
- 1:01:00find some more ideas for political ideas or like religious economic stuff for examination?
- 1:01:08Okay, what are you trying to achieve? I'm not sure I understand the
- 1:01:15question? Are you looking to sort of absorb various perspectives when it comes to
- 1:01:23your value system or the values of others their opinions about the major issues of
- 1:01:30the day. What do you want to get out of this? Well,
- 1:01:34ultimately, I want to be able to make a difference. Some of that
- 1:01:37is changing minds, and some of them is actually going out and like doing
- 1:01:40activism and whatnot. I'm just wondering, like what places I could look to
- 1:01:46get I don't know, maybe even just a historical idea like facts and stuff
- 1:01:53that I can that I can use to form opinions on things. I mean,
- 1:02:02I can't think of a broader question, brother, the sorry, you
- 1:02:07know, how what resource do I use to develop an opinion about everything?
- 1:02:15Is a pretty broad question? Right? Here's not really asking for like one
- 1:02:21source for everything more just like, no kind of things do you think would
- 1:02:23be good for like individuals? I get it, I got it. Let
- 1:02:29me let me ask you. Let me start by asking a couple of questions.
- 1:02:31Hopefully everybody in the chat is cool with me taking a second. Here.
- 1:02:37Are you a religious person? You mentioned Christianity? Uh well, I
- 1:02:45was for a while not really heavily into it, but during my uh,
- 1:02:49I guess senior year, I went to a religious a pretty big religious gathering,
- 1:02:53and that kind of, you know, kind of brought me out of
- 1:02:59it. I guess. So are you what we would call a seeker?
- 1:03:05You're kind of on the journey, not sure where you're at, but you're
- 1:03:08kind of tapping more or less. I mean, I'm kind of, I
- 1:03:13guess what people would call an agnostic. Not actually like, I'm pretty sure
- 1:03:17Christianity is just not true from my perspective what I know about it. But
- 1:03:23other than that, I'm just trying to get to know like the all the
- 1:03:28ideas. Yeah, Okay, I'm gonna I'm going to be like a rock
- 1:03:35skipping over the lake for just a second, because there's no fine, there's
- 1:03:39no short way to go here. Okay. When you and I were around
- 1:03:46the faith of Christianity, and this is true for all FUNDI cultures. They
- 1:03:52become information silos where they teach you to rely on one source only and distrust
- 1:03:58everybody else. In the faith, it was the Bible was our book,
- 1:04:02but if there were other books out there, we were all always wary about
- 1:04:06them. You'll find that there were many people, especially evangelicals, who they
- 1:04:14lock themselves into these narrow conduits where they only hear one thing one way all
- 1:04:19the time, and they are told distrust everybody else. Even the scriptures say
- 1:04:25trust not in your own understanding, leane on this source, lean on the
- 1:04:30other. You're in this enviable position now where you get to say, hey,
- 1:04:35what are the resources out there, what are the people saying? What
- 1:04:40are some of the other opinions that I may not have heard that might affect
- 1:04:44my own opinion? How can I learn more? Well, I think that's
- 1:04:47the headline. You are right now at the sponge phase that we should all
- 1:04:53aspire to be. I want to accumulate, No, stay here for as
- 1:04:57long as possible. Yeah, I want to figure out I can figure out
- 1:05:00and what I don't know if I'm not going to make things up, But
- 1:05:03how do I find the best ideas. How do I hear the opinions of
- 1:05:08others to determine what I think about those ideas. That's a beautiful place to
- 1:05:12be, man, It's an honest life lived honestly. In my own life.
- 1:05:18What happened to me was I came out of the faith and realized that
- 1:05:21my Christian background, culture, family school, church, et cetera. Had
- 1:05:28formed my opinions about everything. So then I stop and I say, wait
- 1:05:32a minute. They had told me what to think, but I never found
- 1:05:36out for myself what do I think. I'm going to go back point by
- 1:05:41point, and I'm going to learn as much as I can about everything.
- 1:05:45And I did this with evolutionary science, with climate science, with the Second
- 1:05:51Amendment, with the death penalty, with health care, the role of government,
- 1:05:57foreign nations, other religions. I just went to point by point that
- 1:06:00gay marriage, and I found that, you know, holy shit, my
- 1:06:06opinions are widely different than the ones I was programmed with. You will find
- 1:06:13that the people who I think are the most well informed have a variety of
- 1:06:16sources. So beware, Hey, we are fair and balanced. Trust only
- 1:06:21us Fox News and be one of those people who you're sampling at the buffet.
- 1:06:29If you're reading the news, go to NPR, go to the New
- 1:06:32York Times, go to CNN. You can watch Fox News if you want.
- 1:06:35But I mean, take a look at all of it, and then
- 1:06:39make your assessments based on a more wide variety of information. Find out if
- 1:06:44the sources of your information are themselves credible, Read what their critics are saying
- 1:06:49about them, and if those criticisms are valid. I really think that it's
- 1:06:56not about what's the book that's going to send me or what's the video that's
- 1:07:00going to do it for me. I think it's more about the attitude of
- 1:07:03how am I going to approach learning in this world? And if your mind
- 1:07:09is wide open and your your buffet table is wide open, I think you
- 1:07:14can sample and decide what tastes right and what should be rejected, and congratulate
- 1:07:19yourself for living an authentic life, taking the journey, a curious journey of
- 1:07:24discovery, seeking truth on your own terms. I mean, it's kind of
- 1:07:28a it's vague, but I think it has to be a vague answer.
- 1:07:30If somebody has a better answer in the chat or the comments, please type
- 1:07:34it in For this guy, you know, let Ben know because I'm I
- 1:07:40fallen short. Ben, does that help you at all? Oh? Yeah,
- 1:07:44No, I think I think I got I got something out of that.
- 1:07:46I can I think I can use that. I just know that if
- 1:07:50if your opinion changes, it's not weakness, right, Or if you don't
- 1:07:57know the answer yet, it's not weakness. That's just honest. And I
- 1:08:02think being willing to adjust when you get better ideas. What's that Maya Angelou
- 1:08:06quote that says when we know better, we do better. That's a strength,
- 1:08:11that's a positive, that's a net plus. And that's my hope for
- 1:08:15you. Stay freaking curious. You know, life kicks curiosity out of the
- 1:08:18minds of people as they get older. Often they kick it out of young
- 1:08:23children. If you remain curious, interested in discovery, the world is wide
- 1:08:28open. It's going to be a beautiful and amazing life. Okay, all
- 1:08:32right, thanks for picking up. I appreciate you. Ben. Hang in
- 1:08:35there. I mean, there's a lot of books that I could. You
- 1:08:40know, if you want to read about evolutionary science. Hell I just narrated
- 1:08:44doctor Abbi Hafer's book on evolution, or you can read the work The Magic
- 1:08:50of Reality by Dawkins was a really I mean, there's so many you could
- 1:08:54go into Stephen J. Goole's books. Oh God, Sagan has so much
- 1:09:00much great information about you can learn about cosmology if you want to get into
- 1:09:03hell. Ben, if you're still listening, this sounds totally self serving.
- 1:09:11I talked about my own journey into what I thought about all those other things,
- 1:09:16like what do I think about all of these major issues in the world,
- 1:09:21And I chronicle that and defended my change of opinion or my evolution of
- 1:09:29opinion in a book called Confessions of a Former Fox News Christian And I'll send
- 1:09:34it to you. Let me gift it to you. Just send me an
- 1:09:38email, all right, sath atsath Andrews dot com. Tell me it's Ben,
- 1:09:43and tell me where to send it. And I'm not trying to sell
- 1:09:46you a book. I'll just give it to you Merry Christmas, and it
- 1:09:49will show you, point by point how I got out of this mindset and
- 1:09:57began to sort of think differently based on my own experiences and education and being
- 1:10:02free from being, you know, under this authoritarian umbrella where I was afraid
- 1:10:08to be curious or I was afraid to disagree or criticize or condemn sat at
- 1:10:13Seth Andrews dot com. Stand by my friends for just a second. I'm
- 1:10:20you know what, I should have Biddy or Kristen or someone helped me manage
- 1:10:24the the chats on these It's just that I I don't always think of it
- 1:10:32in advance, because honestly, I'm kind of an idiot. Ronda said,
- 1:10:39Seth, you were my gateway drug out of religion. Thank you for doing
- 1:10:43what you do and how you do it. Ronda, I bow in your
- 1:10:47general direction. You are an encourager and that means a lot to me.
- 1:10:53Thank you. You have to spell your name for everybody, Ronda. It's
- 1:10:57ro not r right, Joe, do you have to do that for everybody?
- 1:11:00You know? How many people get Seth wrong? Doesn't happen as much
- 1:11:03as it used to. How do you? How do you screw up Seth's?
- 1:11:08Someone call me Zith? Zith? What am I starring in? And
- 1:11:15this sounds like some a character in Dune? You know? Someone tells Zeith
- 1:11:20the spice must flow? Uh. The evangelicals never lie, question Mark,
- 1:11:28I don't see a name. Analyze carefully and you will see the Christian try
- 1:11:31omni god model with a pre wait a minute, with a predetermined plan can
- 1:11:38only work with pre determination. Thus Christianity does not matter case Sarah, Sarah,
- 1:11:46I don't know what that means. Sorry, you're amazingly generous. Thank
- 1:11:55you for the gift. I don't know what that means. Zeith, Yeah,
- 1:12:01I have a twin sister named Beth. They thought it was cute Seth
- 1:12:05and Beth growing up. There we are. They put us in the I
- 1:12:12was in the little sailor shorts and she was in this the little sailor skirt.
- 1:12:16They put us in the double high chair, gave us chocolate cake.
- 1:12:19We mashed it all over our faces. They took polaroids. They thought it
- 1:12:23was cute. Raggedy ann and andy costume. Oh yeah, yeah. There
- 1:12:30is a little lesson in humiliation. And you will not find two people who
- 1:12:39are more dramatically different than me and my twin. We shared a womb.
- 1:12:45That's it. I enjoy engagement, confrontation, get into the mix, and
- 1:12:55I speak my mind. She's passive, hates inflict once peace. I'm an
- 1:13:03atheist activist. She is a Bible literalist Christian. And you know I don't.
- 1:13:11We don't get into the conversation. But I don't think it's a betrayal
- 1:13:15of any confidence to say this. But she's one of those people, my
- 1:13:18whole family. I'll do it this way. So and so is going into
- 1:13:23the hospital. They've got to have stints put in because there's a blockage in
- 1:13:28their artery or whatever and their heart's not getting enough blood. Praying, praying,
- 1:13:34praying, praying, praying, praying, everybody praying, praying for good
- 1:13:38results. Pray, pray, pray, pray. He's in the hospital and
- 1:13:42I'm over here. I don't say it, but I'm like, if prayer
- 1:13:45worked, there would be no stints. Praying that the doctors will do their
- 1:13:53good work, Praying there will be a one, Praying he will be released
- 1:13:59same day. Praying if prayer worked, there would be no hospital. Well,
- 1:14:08prayer doesn't work like that. Sometimes the Lord uses the hands of the
- 1:14:12physicians in ways that are totally indistinguishable from just regular healing. Sometimes the Lord
- 1:14:20needs to go into the procedure room and he grabs the hands of the doctors
- 1:14:25and it's like a marionette. Here, stick the stint in like that,
- 1:14:31Praise Jesus. So he goes home the same day. In the text thread.
- 1:14:36Does anyone say, who thank you doctor so and so wow brought their
- 1:14:41expertise to bear and really saved the day. He feels much better. No,
- 1:14:45it's Jesus, Jit Jesus, stand by because I've got another caller standing
- 1:14:56by coming up next. Three one zero high. Who's this? This is
- 1:15:15Jamar, Jamar, what's up? Hey? Calling me from Austin, Texas.
- 1:15:24Newly discovered your content over the last two weeks and I've been really enjoying
- 1:15:28it. Thank you. I guess one of my questions would be, I
- 1:15:33think my whole life I've been pseudo Christian, not really brought up in the
- 1:15:39church, but always feeling like there was something out there. And then you
- 1:15:45know, during the military, finished the military, and now I'm at a
- 1:15:48point in my life where I'm forty four years old and I can see how
- 1:15:55religion which has been used to control and manipulate anxiety, and so now I'm
- 1:16:01like, Okay, where did I base all of my what's right and wrong
- 1:16:06from? And then how do I move forward in the world that still seems
- 1:16:11like it's being covered by the shadow a religion? How do I fit in?
- 1:16:16How do I find community and tribe and people who believe the difference between
- 1:16:24right and wrong because of just the goodness of humanity? Are you asking me
- 1:16:32as a question? It sounds rhetorical. It sounds like this is a journey
- 1:16:35you've been taking on your own. Well, yeah, but I mean,
- 1:16:41I guess the question is, you know, where do you go to find
- 1:16:45that community that you get somewhat from from being a part of religious organizations.
- 1:16:50Yeah. I feel like this is one of the challenges. I am convinced
- 1:16:55my friend that a great many people don't engage theologically with their religion. That's
- 1:17:03why I think the average household has three Bibles. Nobody knows what's in it.
- 1:17:10Right. They go to church not because they care all that much about
- 1:17:15what the pastor says. They go because they want to belong. Somebody welcomes
- 1:17:20them. They have ministries that greed, they're trained to properly greet people.
- 1:17:26You have communal music. You're standing shoulder to shoulder, and you get that
- 1:17:30endorphin rush and the bonding elements as we you know, as you sing together,
- 1:17:34and there's a place for your kids and they become sort of woven into
- 1:17:39the fabric of your life. And we hear as non religious people have a
- 1:17:43we've got a challenge because we're shit. We're often shit at community. We're
- 1:17:47really struggling. Many people say, well, if we do a group thing,
- 1:17:51or if we have some sort of a like oasis or a free thought
- 1:17:56group, or a convention or some formal gathering or a weekly service, we're
- 1:18:01just doing church. We're being religious, which I find tragic because they've surrendered
- 1:18:06to the church something that human beings need and do. Naturally, we community
- 1:18:12predates the church. But you know, we struggle. We're hurting cats.
- 1:18:16And I know that online I have found the majority of my own community of
- 1:18:24people who accept me for who I am. But I don't know. You
- 1:18:29say you're in the Austin area. I believe there may be an oasis or
- 1:18:32freethought group in Austin. I don't even know if you're there on your journey,
- 1:18:35if you're like you know, ex religious or secular. But I think
- 1:18:39a lot of freethought or secular groups are like anybody's welcome. But you speak
- 1:18:45mostly to a challenge that we have. If we're going to ask people,
- 1:18:49hey, walk away from the belief system, what else are they leaving the
- 1:18:57whole net that they are used to falling into we have to weave one for
- 1:19:00them as well, based on humanity and humanism. I don't know. I
- 1:19:04think it's worth a Google search to see if maybe there's an oasis group or
- 1:19:09a free thought group in your town, in your city. And beyond that.
- 1:19:14I have sort of scratched that itch, mostly with the family that I
- 1:19:16have here online. Does that help it all? That helps tremendously, just
- 1:19:24you know, dropping those little resources. But you're right, I think it's
- 1:19:30that yearning for community and connection that human beings have had before, like you
- 1:19:34said, pre dates religion. I have built a pretty decent online community myself,
- 1:19:41just in my own business pursuits. But you know, as a speaker,
- 1:19:45as a comedian, I love bringing people together. And the ideas for
- 1:19:51me is let's question everything and explore it and have an open dialogue and debate
- 1:20:00about it versus pretending is that someone knows the right answer because it was given
- 1:20:05to them by God. And to me, I just I can't buy into
- 1:20:10that. It just doesn't make sense enough to me. I think you and
- 1:20:14I probably have this in common. If a God shows up tomorrow, we'd
- 1:20:17want to know that, and then after that we'll ask the questions as to
- 1:20:23whether or not that is a worthy God that deserves to be admired worshiped followed,
- 1:20:28I don't know whatever, but I think a truthful life is always one
- 1:20:32worth living. Ultimately, you and I don't profess to have all the answers,
- 1:20:36but I think we embrace the right to ask the questions. That's something
- 1:20:42that's amazing and it's a gift that I think you can give to yourself every
- 1:20:45single day. So if you come out of a faith you know, and
- 1:20:47just take the next step on your own terms, and at least here at
- 1:20:51the Thinking Atheist online community and on our social media pages for what it's worth,
- 1:20:58I think you will have support and you can be reminded that you're not
- 1:21:00alone. And if you discover something we have yet to learn, we would
- 1:21:03want to know that. I think we should make that pledge to you,
- 1:21:08and if we discover something, we'll tell you and we'll all try to figure
- 1:21:11it out together. Okay, thank you so much, TIK. One quick
- 1:21:15question before I go. If I produce an event here, kind of a
- 1:21:21think tank, an of mind thinking tank, how would I get in touch
- 1:21:27with you if I wanted to maybe have you come speak and do a session,
- 1:21:30even if it's remotely. I don't know. If I belong at a
- 1:21:32think tank, I'm kind of an idiot. No no, sorry, not
- 1:21:38a think tank, a mastermind. No, no, no, don't even
- 1:21:42I understand what you mean. I'm sorry as being kind of a jerk there,
- 1:21:45but no, I always resist. Someone's like, oh, you know,
- 1:21:47Seth needs to come and bring the wisdom, and I'm like, whoa,
- 1:21:53wait a minute, you just at that bar way higher. If you
- 1:21:56know, if you were to organize something in the Austin area down the way
- 1:22:00and all my schedule and everything. You know, it's hard to say this
- 1:22:03far out, but if something came together and the pieces were all there and
- 1:22:06in the proper place, I'd be open. You know, you got my
- 1:22:11email, Seth A's Seth Andrews dot com. Just drop me a line,
- 1:22:15let me know what it is and we'll talk. Okay, sounds great,
- 1:22:17Seth, I have a great one. Thank you. All right, Happy
- 1:22:19New Year. We'll see them, I say, Happy New Year. I'm
- 1:22:24a little bit pessimistic about twenty twenty four. I just think, honestly,
- 1:22:28no matter who wins the election, shit's gonna go down. Not that I
- 1:22:31think the candidates are equal. I just think each scenario is going to produce
- 1:22:35awfulness in some way, you know. And so I look at twenty twenty
- 1:22:42four honestly, and I am I'm going to go on, is there a
- 1:22:46bubble wrap store and I can just wrap my whole body in it. I'm
- 1:22:50just gonna wrap myself in bubble wrap. And then I'm just going to go
- 1:22:55sit in the darkest, safest place. Maybe I'll go crawl into the storm
- 1:22:59shelter underground in the garage. I've got a tornado shelter. I'm just gonna
- 1:23:02wrap myself the bubble wrap and sit at the bottom in twenty twenty four and
- 1:23:06just be like, I hope we live. I hope we live. If
- 1:23:14there is any hope for the new year, it comes really from you and
- 1:23:17people like you. And I know it sounds like a fucking Hallmark movie when
- 1:23:20I say it that way, but it's true. So much bigotry and cruelty.
- 1:23:31People want to shrink the world to make it look like them. They
- 1:23:35seem to enjoy. Some people seem to enjoy declaring war on their fellow human
- 1:23:42beings. They run after every conspiracy theory they hear. They live in fear,
- 1:23:51fear of everybody. They cording themselves off in these sort of and they
- 1:24:02peer through the stained glass at everybody else and they're terrified, or they're just
- 1:24:10bigots and hateful people, and they throw the rocks out of everybody over the
- 1:24:14fence. They are willing to set fire to the world if the world doesn't
- 1:24:23validate them. I was naive about how bad things are. Did a speech
- 1:24:31maybe ten years ago in Australia, and I hold to some of it about
- 1:24:35the good old days. You know, we do live in an amazing time
- 1:24:43and we are seeing statistically that we are actually in many ways more peaceful,
- 1:24:48more civilized, more well off in many ways. But I'm also thinking,
- 1:24:55how in the hell somebody posted a meme I'm sorry, I'm just babbling.
- 1:24:58Is this okay? And said if someone what would surprise How did they say
- 1:25:04it? If somebody from the nineteen eighties teleported here today to twenty twenty three,
- 1:25:12what would surprise them the most? I thought, Nazis flat earthers,
- 1:25:27How does this happen? The impending fall of democracy? Neo Nazis are protesting
- 1:25:39in front of the entrance of Disney. One of the book bans you told
- 1:25:47somebody in nineteen eighty five, Hey, there will be book banning going on
- 1:25:50in this country. Even as a Christian, I wouldn't have believed you.
- 1:25:59Anti Semitism, Jewish people being vilified, their property destroyed, their temples being
- 1:26:05vandalized. I don't know how I feel about it. I can't decide.
- 1:26:15Are we statistically, despite the fact that the bad is so amplified, are
- 1:26:18we statistically still ultimately getting the growing secularization of the culture, despite the fact
- 1:26:26that the Christian nationalists have weaponized our halls of government. The ground swell,
- 1:26:31the grassroots part that's encouraging, And even the believers. The Christians of today,
- 1:26:40especially the thirty and unders, are much less interested or not interested at
- 1:26:44all, in the fundamentalist nonsense of their parents and grandparents. They don't buy
- 1:26:47into hell, they don't judge gay people, they don't believe that. They
- 1:26:53believe in the Jesus that loved everybody and wanted them to be charitable. It
- 1:26:57tells me they don't read their Bible, by the way, But okay,
- 1:27:00I'll take it a more egalitarian faith. I'll take that given the alternative.
- 1:27:05Is that a reason to be optimistic? Or do I worry that we may
- 1:27:12not survive to see that generation do the good that they will ultimately hopefully do.
- 1:27:21Sometimes I've thought about, man, maybe we should move, and I
- 1:27:26don't mean move to the like a more progressive state. Maybe we should go
- 1:27:30to like Switzerland. Maybe we should go to a part of the world that's
- 1:27:40not on fire. But then I spend time with you, and I see
- 1:27:54that the tide of reason, at least in many of important ways, is
- 1:28:00rising, and that there are those out there, many of those who celebrate
- 1:28:08science. You know, they don't want to see scientists vilified and even threaten
- 1:28:14the way they are being vilified and threatened. They want to stand up and
- 1:28:16advocate. These are the people who are trying to find what's right and trying
- 1:28:23to protect other people. And they are ambassadors of the right way to determine
- 1:28:28what is true and what is not. They stand up for the marginalized.
- 1:28:35They care. They'd rather love than hate. They have wide open arms and
- 1:28:40say I get you, I support you, you got somebody, Yeah,
- 1:28:48I get that. You know a guy estranged from so many in his family,
- 1:28:54who you know, it's funny I walk into a room and people,
- 1:29:00we'll just reach out and I get a great, big bear hug, and
- 1:29:03hey, what is that if it's not family? What is that? If
- 1:29:05it's not family? The family I choose, the family you choose. We
- 1:29:10chose each other. I got your back. Doesn't mean we're pushovers, but
- 1:29:14it does mean that you deserve an authentic life, and I support you and
- 1:29:19I've got your back. If shit goes down, I got you. What
- 1:29:24is that if not family? Guess what happens when a stream goes on too
- 1:29:30long. I get all introspective and I can everybody's left, everybody's gone.
- 1:29:36Yeah, I'm sorry and good goodbye. Yeah anyway, No, no,
- 1:29:42no, I'm just kidding. I I appreciate to all of you. I
- 1:29:45appreciate you putting up with me, and it's I'm gonna go. I'm gonna
- 1:29:49I've got one more present to wrap. I need to let the dogs out.
- 1:29:54I'm not getting botox, not doing it. You know, you got
- 1:29:57to live with this. You know, if you see me in three weeks
- 1:30:00and I can't close my eyes or whatever, you're going to know that I
- 1:30:03was forced into it, but I'm not doing it. And in the meantime,
- 1:30:06I've got some really, really really good stuff coming up. Next week.
- 1:30:11I've got a conversation with doctor Robert P. Jones. He is a
- 1:30:14Christian, but he and I are on the same side, and he's talking
- 1:30:17about the often religious roots of white supremacy in this country. And it's a
- 1:30:25sobering conversation. I've got a conversation with Stacy Grohn. She is an ex
- 1:30:30evangelical freshly emerged from the faiths. She tells her story. I'm going to
- 1:30:34be talking to Jenni Scyrimanga in January. She and I both escaped the ACE
- 1:30:40program, the Accelerated Christian Education System. Oh my god, is that a
- 1:30:45cult? A cult? Are going to talk to her, and I'm not
- 1:30:54going to charge patrons for it. I'm just going to release it off into
- 1:30:57the wild. But I had an opportunity to talk to Mark Shostrom, who
- 1:31:03is a special effects guru who has done practical special effects for the Nightmare on
- 1:31:12elm Street films. I think at least one of the Friday the Thirteenth movies,
- 1:31:18especially in the eighties and nineties, he was right there. He was
- 1:31:23on Evil Dead too, Mark Shostrom, and on a lark. I just
- 1:31:28reached out and said, hey, dude, I'm a horror movie fan.
- 1:31:31I love your work. If you ever want to talk about just special effects
- 1:31:36in the industry and all that, if you ever just wanted to chat,
- 1:31:41I'd love to talk. And within an hour I got a response. He's
- 1:31:46like, hey, dude, I'm an agnostic. I love to talk.
- 1:31:50What do you want to talk about? So that's coming up at some point
- 1:31:55in January. He has nothing to do with religion. We're not going to
- 1:31:58talk religion. We're going to talk about, like, you know, shooting
- 1:32:01fake arrows into people's eyeballs in eighties horror films or or whatever it comes up.
- 1:32:10You know, we're gonna talk about Bruce Campbell and his dismembered hand,
- 1:32:14crawling across the floor and evil dead. That's the kind of thing we're going
- 1:32:16to talk about. And I'm not gonna charge anybody. It's just extra.
- 1:32:20But from time to time, I just want to do something different and maybe
- 1:32:25you'll enjoy listening and enjoy it the whole conversations as well. Okay, that's
- 1:32:31it. Merry Christmas, Happy New Year, all that good stuff, and
- 1:32:34I'll see you back here next time. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and
- 1:32:40Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts. And videos. Products like mugs and
- 1:32:44t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 1:32:48and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 1:32:54The Thinkingatheist dot com