Latest / Deep Dive / Waterloo South: The Fight Over Sydney’s Future
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to this explainer. Today we're diving straight into
- 0:03one of the absolute biggest and frankly most fiercely debated
- 0:07urban transformations happening in Australia right now.
- 0:10We're talking about the Waterloo S redevelopment in Sydney.
- 0:13We are going to unpack this massive project by looking at it
- 0:17through three very different lenses.
- 0:19We'll explore the actual physical blueprints, the intense
- 0:22political resistance that has sparked on the ground, and
- 0:24finally, the psychological dimension of what actually
- 0:27happens to a community during a decade long urban renewal.
- 0:31So whether you're a city planner, a local resident, or
- 0:33just someone who's fascinated by how cities evolve over time,
- 0:36this explainer is going to give you the complete picture.
- 0:39OK, let's dive into this with a question that might sound a
- 0:42little bit like a Riddle. Can you be displaced without
- 0:46physically moving? We usually think of displacement
- 0:49as, you know, packing up boxes and being forced to leave a
- 0:51neighborhood. But as we look at the plans for
- 0:54Waterloo S, we're going to explore a really fascinating
- 0:56central paradox. What happens to the residents
- 0:59who stay behind, or those who are promised a right to return
- 1:02when the very fabric of their neighborhood is entirely erased
- 1:05and redrawn? Keep that question in the back
- 1:07of your mind as we look at the sheer scale of what is being
- 1:09proposed here. Section 1, the Waterloo renewal
- 1:13plan. Let's look at the blueprint.
- 1:15To truly wrap your head around the sheer scale of the NSW
- 1:19Government and Stockland's proposal for this 12.3 hectare
- 1:22precinct, you really just need to look at this one number 3300
- 1:27now. The estate currently contains
- 1:29750 social housing dwellings and 120 private homes, but over the
- 1:33next 10 to 15 years, this master plan is going to more than
- 1:36quadruple those numbers. We are talking about completely
- 1:39replacing the existing buildings with 3300 brand new homes
- 1:43spanning a cost 10 St. blocks with building heights ranging
- 1:46from two stories all the way up to 33 stories.
- 1:50It's a massive undertaking. So how exactly is all this new
- 1:54housing being divided up? Well, here is the data exactly
- 1:57as it's presented by the government and the developers.
- 1:59When the men's government came into office in 2023, they
- 2:02actually increased the public and affordable housing
- 2:05allocation from 35% up to 50%. So the breakdown looks something
- 2:09like this, a maximum of 50% market housing, a minimum of 30%
- 2:14social housing, and roughly 20% affordable housing.
- 2:17And they really emphasize that these new homes are going to
- 2:19meet modern accessibility and six star Green Star
- 2:22sustainability standards, completely replacing aging
- 2:25infrastructure that is frankly nearing the end of its lifespan.
- 2:28But let's flip the perspective for a second and look at how the
- 2:31exact same project is framed by the Action for Public Housing
- 2:34group, because their calculations paint a wildly
- 2:37different picture. See, they group the private
- 2:40market homes and most of the affordable housing together,
- 2:43arguing that a lot of that affordable housing isn't
- 2:45actually permanent. Because of that, they calculate
- 2:47that out of the 3300 total homes, 71.8% will effectively be
- 2:52private, leaving only 28.2% as true social housing.
- 2:56So for them, this represents a severe loss of public land to
- 2:59what is majority private development.
- 3:01Which brings us to Section 2. The community push back the
- 3:05resistance, moving from the macro blueprints to the raw
- 3:09emotional level on the ground. This debate recently boiled
- 3:12right over when tenants received demolition notices on May 19th.
- 3:16It sparked intense grassroots rallies.
- 3:19And to understand this conflict, we really have to look at the
- 3:22vastly different visions for this piece of land.
- 3:24The government views this as an absolutely crucial upgrade.
- 3:28Minister for Planning Paul Scully argues the project brings
- 3:31thousands of new homes and reshapes the precinct for
- 3:33generations. They're capitalizing on the
- 3:35brand new Waterloo Metro station, aiming to create a
- 3:38vibrant mixed tenure community with new open spaces in retail.
- 3:42But then you juxtapose that with the voices of the actual tenants
- 3:46and their advocates. Tenant Karen Brown and Green's
- 3:49MP Jenny Leong describe the demolition of what they call
- 3:52perfectly livable homes in the middle of a housing crisis as
- 3:55literally criminal and an unforgivable betrayal.
- 3:59They point straight to a wait list of over 1000 households in
- 4:02the inner city. And a massive sticking point for
- 4:04the community here is that according to their data, only 7%
- 4:07of the total new affordable housing will actually be managed
- 4:10in perpetuity. Now, what's really interesting
- 4:12about this slide is how deep this fracture actually goes.
- 4:17It's not just about the housing numbers.
- 4:18You know, even the environmental data is deeply contested.
- 4:22The Developers Ecological Consulting report noted about 30
- 4:25planted native species on the site.
- 4:27However, the community activists went out, did their own tally,
- 4:30and counted 60 native species, pointing out that many were
- 4:33clearly naturally occurring, not just planted.
- 4:36It just brilliantly illustrates how two different groups can
- 4:38look at the exact same physical space and see 2 completely
- 4:42different realities. All right, let's move to Section
- 4:453IN placed displacement. The theory.
- 4:48So how do we make sense of these two conflicting realities?
- 4:51We can actually look through an academic lens.
- 4:53To help us out, we're drawing on some fascinating ethnographic
- 4:57research published in the Housing Policy Debate journal by
- 4:59sociologists Laura Wynn and Dallas Rogers.
- 5:02They spent years studying the Waterloo Estate, conducting
- 5:05research with residents between 2010 and 2017, and they really
- 5:08wanted to understand one specific phenomenon.
- 5:11What exactly happens when public housing tenants are allowed to
- 5:13stay in a gentrifying area, but the area itself is fundamentally
- 5:17transformed all around them? To explain this, they use a
- 5:21framework called M placed displacement.
- 5:23Let's define that really quick. It is the removal of the sense
- 5:26of belonging to a home space, rupturing the ties that link
- 5:29people to a space over time, even without physical
- 5:32relocation. And this right here answers our
- 5:35paradox from the very beginning of the explainer.
- 5:37The government promises tenants they can eventually return to
- 5:40the new site, but the sociologists argue that the
- 5:42looming threat of eviction and the total erasure of the
- 5:45physical neighborhood fundamentally alters the space
- 5:48these residents carry with them. The researchers actually break
- 5:51this subjective experience down into three specific ruptures of
- 5:54replacement. First up is spatial.
- 5:57This is the total loss of the familiar built environment.
- 6:00Second is temporal. I mean, consider that this is a
- 6:0310 to 15 year project. Imagine your own life plans
- 6:06being put on hold, living in a state of limbo for over a
- 6:09decade. And 3rd is sociocultural.
- 6:12This represents the breaking of deep, long standing community
- 6:15networks. See, the government sees
- 6:17objective mathematical borders on a map that can be optimized,
- 6:21but the residents experience a subjective human loss.
- 6:25They feel replaced by incoming affluence, even if they are
- 6:28eventually given an apartment in one of those shiny new towers.
- 6:31Let's zoom out and see how this builds on the history of the
- 6:34land itself. Because, you know, displacement
- 6:37here isn't exactly a new concept.
- 6:39This land originally belonged to the Gadigal clan of the Arra
- 6:43nation who were displaced by European settlement.
- 6:46Then in the 1930's the area saw massive slum clearances
- 6:50displacing lower income residents.
- 6:51Fast forward to the 1970s and the current high rise public
- 6:55housing blocks were built and now we arrive at the current
- 6:58renewal plan. It is worth noting the
- 7:00government is working with Birby Housing, an Aboriginal housing
- 7:03provider, to manage 20% of the new social homes, aiming to
- 7:07honor that ongoing connection to country.
- 7:09But ultimately, this modern renewal is part of a much longer
- 7:12historical cycle of upheaval and change in Waterloo.
- 7:15So the absolutely crucial point we need to take away is this
- 7:19urban renewal is never, ever just about concrete and glass.
- 7:22It's about the friction between objective data, the number of
- 7:25dwellings, the transit access, the green star ratings, and the
- 7:28subjective lived realities of the real people whose lives are
- 7:31embedded in those streets. Which leaves us with a final
- 7:34thought to chew on today when we talk about protecting housing.
- 7:37Is physical space the only thing that makes a home?
- 7:40Or does a home also include the community, the history, and the
- 7:43Peace of Mind that a bulldozer can destroy, even if you never
- 7:46actually have to change a zip code?
- 7:48Thank you so much for joining us for this explainer and we will
- 7:50see you next time.