Latest / The Morning Rundown / Asylum for a Juror, Yemen's Forgotten War, and 9/11's Paper Trail
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, a governor just offered a guy asylum inside his own country.
- 0:19[David] I mean, come on.
- 0:21[David] That's not even a sentence that should exist.
- 0:23[Maya] Right?
- 0:24[Maya] We'll explain it, I promise.
- 0:26[David] This is the Morning Rundown.
- 0:27[David] I'm David, that's Maya, and today's a lot.
- 0:31[Maya] A lot.
- 0:32[Maya] There's a shipping lane basically nobody can control anymore.
- 0:36[David] Yeah, and prices are already feeling it.
- 0:38[Maya] And then, okay, this one gave me chills a little.
- 0:42[David] What?
- 0:42[Maya] Declassified files dropping right before the 9/11 anniversary.
- 0:47[David] Wait, this week?
- 0:48[Maya] This week.
- 0:49[Maya] 25 years later, and there's still a paper trail nobody's seen.
- 0:53[David] Okay, we've got a courtroom mess, a war zone, and a national
- 0:56[David] gut punch.
- 0:57[David] Great Tuesday.
- 0:59[Maya] Buckle up.
- 1:00[Maya] Let's start way outside our borders first, because this one's been building
- 1:04[Maya] for years.
- 1:05[Maya] So, The Guardian is reporting something out of Yemen that honestly slipped
- 1:09[Maya] past most people this week.
- 1:11[David] Yemen.
- 1:12[David] Man, that war just never actually ends, does it?
- 1:14[Maya] That's kind of the point.
- 1:16[Maya] Houthi forces are pushing along the Red Sea coast, and something like
- 1:20[Maya] 50,000 civilians have had to run for it.
- 1:23[David] 50,000.
- 1:24[David] That's basically a small city just gone from their homes.
- 1:28[Maya] Right, and it's not random.
- 1:29[Maya] They're fighting over the coastline that sits on the Bab al-Mandab Strait.
- 1:33[David] The choke point.
- 1:34[Maya] Exactly.
- 1:35[Maya] And that's why outside powers keep getting pulled back in.
- 1:39[Maya] Nobody wants a hostile force sitting on the switch.
- 1:42[David] So whoever controls the coast basically controls the toll booth.
- 1:45[Maya] Pretty much.
- 1:46[Maya] And that's why outside powers keep getting pulled back in.
- 1:50[Maya] Nobody wants a hostile force sitting on the switch.
- 1:53[David] It's wild how a civil war turns into a global energy story
- 1:56[David] just because of geography.
- 1:58[Maya] That's the thing with choke points.
- 1:59[Maya] Doesn't matter how local the fight is.
- 2:01[Maya] The second it touches a strait like that, it stops being local.
- 2:05[David] And meanwhile, it's actual people getting displaced while governments argue about shipping
- 2:09[David] lanes.
- 2:10[Maya] Right.
- 2:11[Maya] Fifty thousand aren't an abstraction.
- 2:13[Maya] They're not sitting around waiting for a diplomatic solution.
- 2:16[Maya] They're just leaving.
- 2:17[David] Do we know where they're even going?
- 2:19[Maya] The report doesn't get into resettlement, just that the advance is what's
- 2:22[Maya] pushing them out.
- 2:23[David] Got it.
- 2:24[Maya] It's easy to reduce this to a map and a strait, but
- 2:27[Maya] each of those fifty thousand is somebody who packed up whatever they could
- 2:31[Maya] carry and just left, whether that's on foot or however they could
- 2:34[Maya] manage.
- 2:35[David] Yeah, that's the part I keep having to remind myself of.
- 2:38[David] It's not a statistic.
- 2:39[David] It's families showing up somewhere with nothing.
- 2:41[Maya] And there's no sign this stops soon, because the coastline isn't just
- 2:45[Maya] contested for its own sake.
- 2:46[Maya] It's contested because of what sits offshore, which loops back to something
- 2:50[Maya] we've talked about before on this show, how the Red Sea squeeze
- 2:53[Maya] has already been showing up in prices back home.
- 2:55[David] Right.
- 2:55[David] We've covered how tanker traffic getting threatened or rerouted pushes costs up
- 2:59[David] the chain.
- 3:00[David] This is the ground level version of that same fight.
- 3:03[David] Whoever controls that coast isn't just fighting for territory.
- 3:06[David] They're fighting for leverage over everybody who ships through there, and that's
- 3:09[David] why no ceasefire fixes it and no single country wins it either.
- 3:13[Maya] That's the trap.
- 3:14[Maya] The stakes for the people leaving and the stakes for the powers
- 3:16[Maya] circling the strait are almost completely disconnected from each other.
- 3:20[David] Depressing, but that's about the size of it.
- 3:22[Maya] Speaking of things that get messier the closer you look-
- 3:25[David] Uh-oh.
- 3:25[Maya] Let's go Stateside, because there's a story that seemed simple on Monday,
- 3:29[Maya] and by Wednesday was a whole mess.
- 3:31[David] Wait, is this the asylum thing from the top of the show?
- 3:34[Maya] That's the one.
- 3:35[Maya] DeSantis.
- 3:36[Maya] Okay, so this DeSantis juror thing.
- 3:39[David] Oh, boy.
- 3:40[David] Here we go.
- 3:41[Maya] The Hill reported that Governor DeSantis said Florida would offer, quote, "asylum"
- 3:46[Maya] to the holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy case.
- 3:49[David] Asylum, like the guys fleeing a war zone.
- 3:52[Maya] Right, for not voting guilty.
- 3:55[David] Which is, you know, literally what a hung jury is.
- 3:57[Maya] Sure, but he framed it like the guy was under siege.
- 4:01[David] I mean, asylum is usually for people fleeing persecution, not people who
- 4:04[David] just didn't vote guilty in a jury room.
- 4:07[Maya] Right.
- 4:07[Maya] It's such a strange word choice for what's basically a disagreement over
- 4:11[Maya] a verdict.
- 4:12[David] It's the kind of language that's built for a clip, not for
- 4:15[David] an actual legal explanation.
- 4:17[Maya] Sure, but it worked.
- 4:18[Maya] Everybody's been talking about it, including us.
- 4:21[David] Speaking of the family side, Clancy's own attorney, Kevin Reddington, went on
- 4:25[David] Good Morning America and asked President Trump to consider a pardon.
- 4:28[Maya] Wait, a presidential pardon?
- 4:31[Maya] This is a state case.
- 4:32[David] But there's a catch.
- 4:34[David] Good Morning America's own reporting clarifies pardon power only covers federal crimes.
- 4:39[David] Clancy's charged under Massachusetts law, so Trump can't touch it.
- 4:43[David] She'd have to go through the state.
- 4:44[Maya] So the whole ask was a non-starter from the jump.
- 4:48[David] Legally, yeah.
- 4:49[Maya] It's a good reminder that not every legal ask this news cycle
- 4:53[Maya] actually holds up once you check how the process works.
- 4:56[David] Yeah, presidential pardon power sounds like a big gesture until you realize
- 4:59[David] it doesn't even reach the case in question.
- 5:01[Maya] And Reddington had to know that going in, so it's more a
- 5:05[Maya] public plea than an actual legal strategy.
- 5:08[David] Which is fair.
- 5:08[David] Sometimes the ask is about public sympathy, not the paperwork.
- 5:12[Maya] Meanwhile, the juror himself, NBC10 Boston reported that he had a
- 5:17[Maya] 2021 domestic violence charge and an active restraining order against him during
- 5:22[Maya] the trial, and DeSantis fired back that the outlet was running a
- 5:25[Maya] smear campaign.
- 5:27[David] During the trial?
- 5:28[Maya] During.
- 5:29[David] That's a hard smear campaign case to make when the record's sitting
- 5:32[David] in a court file.
- 5:33[Maya] Right.
- 5:34[Maya] Nobody invented that one.
- 5:36[David] It's wild that the same day the asylum comment goes viral, this
- 5:39[David] detail is sitting in public record the whole time.
- 5:42[Maya] Yeah, that's the disconnect.
- 5:43[Maya] The gesture happens fast.
- 5:45[Maya] The fact check happens slower.
- 5:46[David] And once it's out there, the he's under siege framing gets a
- 5:50[David] lot harder to sell.
- 5:51[Maya] Which is basically what happened here.
- 5:53[David] And there's more.
- 5:54[David] Other jurors told NBC10 Boston the panel actually leaned towards not
- 5:57[David] guilty by reason of insanity.
- 5:59[Maya] So the holdout wasn't blocking some slam dunk conviction.
- 6:03[Maya] The room was already close to acquitting her.
- 6:05[David] One outlet went further.
- 6:07[David] IBTimes UK reported that juror Nick Dargie alleged the holdout reenacted
- 6:11[David] the strangulations with an exercise band during deliberations, a claim nobody's verified
- 6:16[David] in court.
- 6:17[Maya] He acted it out?
- 6:18[David] That's the allegation.
- 6:19[David] Take it as one juror's account, not a verified fact.
- 6:22[Maya] Doesn't mean it's false, just means we shouldn't treat it like it's
- 6:25[Maya] settled.
- 6:25[David] Fair enough.
- 6:26[Maya] Still, not exactly the profile of a guy who needs asylum.
- 6:30[David] And for what it's worth, even sympathetic conservative commentary online called the
- 6:33[David] whole thing overblown.
- 6:35[Maya] I get the instinct, though.
- 6:37[Maya] You see a family torn apart, you want to defend them.
- 6:40[Maya] But defending the Clancy family is one thing, and granting political theater
- 6:44[Maya] to a juror with a restraining order in his past is another.
- 6:47[David] Yeah, the theatrics outran the facts pretty fast on that one.
- 6:51[David] Plays great in a sound bite, terribly in a courtroom transcript.
- 6:54[Maya] Sympathy for a family and sympathy for this particular juror turned out
- 6:58[Maya] to be two very different asks.
- 7:00[David] Before we forget, this week's actually a big one historically, way outside
- 7:04[David] any courtroom.
- 7:04[Maya] Yeah?
- 7:05[David] There's old intelligence surfacing right before the towers fell.
- 7:08[Maya] New stuff?
- 7:09[David] Yeah.
- 7:09[David] Stick around.
- 7:11[Maya] Ugh, so the CIA just dumped a batch of declassified documents on
- 7:14[Maya] Bin Laden and Al-Qaeda right in the middle of anniversary week.
- 7:18[David] Uh, like, how many are we talking?
- 7:20[Maya] Al Jazeera says dozens of documents all at once.
- 7:23[David] Dozens.
- 7:24[David] Okay.
- 7:25[David] And one of them's from 1998.
- 7:26[David] A briefer sat down with President Clinton and told him Bin Laden's,
- 7:30[David] quote, "Preferred option is to strike the US on its own soil
- 7:33[David] in Washington."
- 7:34[Maya] Wait, that's word for word in 1998?
- 7:37[David] In 1998, three years before it happened.
- 7:40[Maya] That's, I mean, come on.
- 7:41[Maya] That's not a vague warning.
- 7:43[Maya] That's specific.
- 7:44[David] It names the country.
- 7:45[David] It basically names the target.
- 7:47[Maya] And it just sat in a drawer for 25 years?
- 7:50[David] Well, it's declassified now, so somebody decided this was the week to
- 7:53[David] let it out.
- 7:54[Maya] Convenient timing.
- 7:55[David] Or deliberate.
- 7:56[David] Take your pick.
- 7:57[Maya] Hmm.
- 7:57[David] What gets me is how normal it must have sounded at the
- 7:59[David] time.
- 8:00[David] Just another briefing.
- 8:01[Maya] Right.
- 8:01[Maya] Nobody's pounding the table over it.
- 8:04[David] No.
- 8:04[David] It's filed, and life goes on.
- 8:06[Maya] Ugh, that's the part that gets me too, because you read it
- 8:08[Maya] now, and it's chilling.
- 8:10[Maya] But read it then, it's probably one memo out of a hundred.
- 8:13[David] Yeah.
- 8:14[David] Hindsight does that.
- 8:15[David] It rewrites how loud something was.
- 8:17[David] The warning existed.
- 8:18[David] It just didn't turn into action in time.
- 8:20[Maya] Which is almost worse in a way.
- 8:22[Maya] It wasn't secret.
- 8:23[Maya] It just wasn't loud enough.
- 8:25[David] So switching over, this weekend wasn't just documents.
- 8:28[David] Baseball marked it too.
- 8:29[Maya] Oh, tell me.
- 8:30[David] Basically, Yankees and Mets both wore first responder caps at Yankee Stadium.
- 8:34[Maya] That's a good image.
- 8:35[David] Leagues across MLB did God Bless America, moments of silence, the whole
- 8:39[David] thing.
- 8:40[Maya] I love that it's still automatic.
- 8:42[Maya] 25 years later and nobody has to be told to do it.
- 8:45[David] No.
- 8:45[David] It's just what the day is now.
- 8:47[Maya] It's kind of remarkable it's still league-wide too, not just one team
- 8:51[Maya] doing its own thing.
- 8:52[David] Yeah.
- 8:53[David] This is one of those rare things that everybody just agrees on.
- 8:56[David] No debates, no politics attached.
- 8:58[Maya] It's one of the few rituals in this country that hasn't gotten
- 9:01[Maya] a debate or a hashtag attached to it.
- 9:03[David] Exactly.
- 9:04[David] Nobody's arguing about whether the moment of silence should happen.
- 9:06[Maya] There's something almost grounding about that, honestly.
- 9:09[Maya] You've got this cold, bureaucratic memo from '98 on one side-
- 9:13[David] And thousands of people standing quiet in a stadium on the other.
- 9:17[Maya] Right.
- 9:18[Maya] Same day, same anniversary, totally different register.
- 9:21[David] One's paperwork, one's people.
- 9:23[Maya] And somehow they both say the same thing.
- 9:26[Maya] We didn't see it coming, and we still haven't stopped thinking about
- 9:30[Maya] it.
- 9:30[David] That's fair.
- 9:31[Maya] It's strange how the country can be so split on nearly everything
- 9:34[Maya] else, and then a day like this still gets universal quiet.
- 9:37[David] Maybe that's the one thing that hasn't eroded in 25 years.
- 9:41[Maya] Yeah.
- 9:41[Maya] Everything else about how we talk about that day has changed, but
- 9:44[Maya] the stadium moment hasn't.
- 9:46[David] That's a nice note to end this one on, honestly.
- 9:48[Maya] Anyway, that's where the week landed for us.
- 9:50[Maya] A governor stunt, a war nobody wants to own, and a warning
- 9:53[Maya] nobody acted on soon enough.
- 9:55[David] Heavy show today.
- 9:56[Maya] A little, but that's the news for you.
- 9:59[David] Alright.
- 9:59[David] Let's get you out of here.
- 10:00[Maya] Stick around.
- 10:01[Maya] We've got the wrap right after this.
- 10:03[Maya] So three totally different stories today, but honestly, same lesson.
- 10:08[David] Yeah.
- 10:08[David] A governor's photo op, a shipping fight nobody controls, and old CIA
- 10:12[David] paperwork.
- 10:13[Maya] And then every single one, the headline was bigger than the paperwork.
- 10:18[David] The juror thing especially.
- 10:19[David] Everybody clapped before anyone read the file.
- 10:22[Maya] Right?
- 10:22[Maya] Same with the strait.
- 10:24[Maya] Sounds simple till you see who's actually fighting over it.
- 10:27[David] And the declassified stuff just quietly proves the warnings were there the
- 10:30[David] whole time.
- 10:31[Maya] Nobody had to spin that one.
- 10:33[Maya] The documents did it themselves.
- 10:35[David] Which is kind of the whole show, honestly.
- 10:37[David] Check the paperwork before you believe the gesture.
- 10:39[Maya] All right, David.
- 10:40[Maya] Go check yours.
- 10:41[David] Already on it.
- 10:42[Maya] That's the show for today, guys.
- 10:44[Maya] Thank you so much for tuning in.
- 10:45[Maya] We'll catch you next time.