Latest / Crypto Coin Show / How can Web3 startups succeed? Will AI + Blockchain narrative explode soon? | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashin Addison from the Crypto Coin Show, and today on Blockchain Interviews we
- 0:04have Navin Agnahultrie, CEO and co founder of Cumberland Labs. Navine, welcome
- 0:08to the show and thank you for taking the time. Thank you so much
- 0:12for having me. Very welcome. Excited to dive into your expertise in incubating
- 0:16Web three startups, what makes a good Web three company? A little bit
- 0:21about AI as well, which I know you have a background in, and
- 0:24speaking of that, let's just before we start into current events, I'd love
- 0:28to hear a little bit on your background blockchain business AI, and then we'll
- 0:32dive into everything Cumberland Labs and blockchain. Absolutely so, I have a very
- 0:39background. I have a PhD in computational neuroscience and AI from Columbia University,
- 0:45after which I was a scientist at MIT. I left in my teen two
- 0:48thousand and five to create an AI startup that really became a series of AI
- 0:53startups where basically the idea was, here's an amazing technology, can be apply
- 0:58it to the public domain, do some good with it? Can we apply
- 1:00and solve real world problems using AI? Right? So, the the one
- 1:07of those companies actually became big. It's called Lendo were where we were.
- 1:12It was a fintech company where we're using AI to help assess credit risk for
- 1:19young people, and that sort of brought me closer to fintech and closer to
- 1:26sort of the technology that was around that would ultimately become blockchain. That where
- 1:36you know, I bought my first bitcoin in two thousand and nine, actually
- 1:38twenty ten and sold it as well. But but the the the point.
- 1:46So it was fascinating to see blockchain as a technology grow up through the twenty
- 1:52tens. And we finally began to dabble in it at my company in twenty
- 1:57eighty twenty nineteen, and I exited out of that startup and connected with Don
- 2:05Wilson IDRW, and together we began this incubator, Cumberland Labs, where we
- 2:10said, you know, it's an amazing technology, what interesting things can we
- 2:15make with it? And let's start an incubator where we do that. So
- 2:20that's really what Cumberland Labs is. The genesis isn't taking technologies that are sort
- 2:25of very very cutting edge blockchain AI and solving a real world problem. That's
- 2:31really what the focus is on. Wow, very cool, and it sounds
- 2:36like you've got into AI pretty early. I feel like we're going to circle
- 2:38back into that because one of the use cases and narratives of blockchain, at
- 2:45least in twenty twenty three, has been finally, I think people the light
- 2:49turned on with chat GPT sort of realizing, hey, you know, this
- 2:52is a technology that's a little bit ready for more mainstream ad option and also
- 2:55can be potentially combined with blockchain for even more benefits. But there are you
- 3:00know, since you got involved and since twenty eighteen, there's been an expansion
- 3:07of different use cases and different industries that are now able to start understand the
- 3:10potential blockchain and start integrating into those industries. And with you guys incubating all
- 3:15these different projects, you must be well aware of all the different industries and
- 3:20you know, what are sort of the barriers to entry, what are the
- 3:23first use cases that will actually penetrate into the market, and where blockchain is
- 3:28sort of starting first. So yes, absolutely, I have. I wrote
- 3:34my first neural network in nineteen ninety two. Yeah, so I've been doing
- 3:37this for a very very long time before a lot of your listeners were probably
- 3:40born. Yeah, So the use cases of AI, I think, and
- 3:46broadly of technology have always been tricky to identify early on, right, I
- 3:53was around in the nineties and watching sort of the Internet come up of age
- 3:58and looking at the Internet, and I remember being part of conversations in the
- 4:01nineties with people where people are like, so, what can we actually do
- 4:04with the Internet, And honestly, I didn't have very good answers because,
- 4:09you know, online shopping was sort of horrible thing in the nineteen nineties.
- 4:13You couldn't barely get online, you know, you had you had this modem
- 4:18that you had to log in on, and it was just really cumbersome,
- 4:24really horrible. Right, there was real really, there really was not that
- 4:28much good you could do with the Internet in nineteen ninety six, right or
- 4:30ninety ninety eight, So, and you really couldn't imagine a service like Uber
- 4:36or a service like Facebook or Airbnb, right, You The advantages of the
- 4:42Internet came much later, and it's difficult to prick these things, right.
- 4:46So it's something similar with blockchain as well. You can see the potential of
- 4:49the technology. You can see the potential of creating a way in which you
- 4:54can publicly identify a fact, right, I can publicly identify the fact that
- 5:00AS owns this thing, whatever this thing is, and there's all kinds of
- 5:05benefits to it, but it takes a while for the benefits to permeate and
- 5:09for us to be able to create products that are widely useful and people are
- 5:14comfortable using right because onboarding is an issue. There's all kinds of things that
- 5:18we have to tackle with blockchain, similar by the way to how we tackle
- 5:25it with the Internet. Mm hmm. Yeah, that's a great point,
- 5:30and I feel like you're probably seeing some synonyms of that Internet days when it's
- 5:34like, well, what are the use cases? You know, there's a
- 5:36lot of things that people are trying, but it's going to take a few
- 5:41years for them to build up. Many will die and then some will sort
- 5:45of prevail, and then in hindsight people will be like, of course those
- 5:48were the main use cases of blockchain. So, being in Cumberland Labs and
- 5:55seeing a lot of Web three startups in their incubation phase, what are some
- 5:59of those synonyms that you're seeing, or what are some of the things that
- 6:01you think might stick as we move into the later year supply chain. So
- 6:08I think there's several different types of things that are happening in the world of
- 6:13blockchain. I mean early on we got into these this phase of you know,
- 6:18these I c O s and these token offerings and companies using tokens basically
- 6:25to sell I don't want to say equity, but something that akin to equity.
- 6:31It's almost like a futures contract on the company, right, where your
- 6:35your token will get be more valuable if the company does well or the protocol
- 6:40does well or something like that. Right, So that that is simultaneously a
- 6:44good and a bad. It's good because it allows you to access liquidity as
- 6:47a founder. It's not good because that liquidity is actually very expensive because if
- 6:54you think about it, you know, your your typical investor, your typicult
- 6:58VC or something like that. But when they when we see invest in your
- 7:00company there, they have a four eight year outlook on that investment, right.
- 7:06They know that it takes that long for any young company, any young
- 7:11product, to mature, to become profitable, to have you know, some
- 7:15kind of good outcome. Right, Whereas your typical guy who's buying your token,
- 7:24uh, you know, Joe Schmo in Idaho or Indonesia or whatever,
- 7:30they don't have any four year outlook, right, they have a two month
- 7:33outlook. They're like, dude, this is either going to the moon or
- 7:38I'm selling. Right. So, as a result, your your token is
- 7:42actually extremely volatile. Right, So the majority of tokens out there, you
- 7:46know, for typical projects, are extremely volatile, and companies are not set
- 7:50up to deal with that. Right, your typical founder, you know,
- 7:54lots of things are going wrong. If you're a founder, I can tell
- 7:57you all about the things that go wrong, as I'm sure you're familiar with
- 8:01some of those. Yourself fires are burning every day as you go home,
- 8:05and you can't deal with everything. Now you also have a token that is
- 8:09just going up and down doing all kinds of crazy things. Right, So,
- 8:13uh, it's it's it's it's tough, it's it's a you know,
- 8:16yes, you get liquidity, you get access to liquidity, but it's a
- 8:20it's it's it's it comes with the price, and it's a price that not
- 8:24all founders I think are prepared for. You know. So that that whole
- 8:28way of using blockchain to create tokens, I think where we're gonna be defining
- 8:35this in the next in sort of the the next wave of of this thing,
- 8:41the of of crypt crypto adoption. Right. Where adoption is going to
- 8:46come from is we expect it to come from UH solving typical use cases.
- 8:52Right. It could be as simple as money transfer or payments. It could
- 8:58be other interesting things like establishing facts, right, like there are these proof
- 9:05of attendance protocols and other kinds of things where you want to prove something that's
- 9:09online. We trust app, which is the above project that we are very
- 9:13proud of that we just started. We are actually taking sort of tackling misinformation
- 9:20on the internet. Right, So this is our counter to the problems exacerbated
- 9:24by AI, which is people say these things and you have no idea is
- 9:28it's real, is it not real? Did they make it up? Are
- 9:31they lying? Are they misrepresenting some facts? Like what's going on? So
- 9:35our approach there is we use blockchain to create permanent pieces of content that are
- 9:41publicly accessible, and then we give you a little tool as a browser extension.
- 9:48It's a little tool that will put markers next to your social media posts
- 9:50saying sort of red, green, or or gray, which means we don't
- 9:54know, right, And the biggest, the biggest idea here is don't don't
- 10:00trust us, right, You don't have to believe our rating every time we
- 10:03rate something, or we we we put a marker next to something. Uh,
- 10:07you can actually go check the energy yourself. You can actually check that
- 10:11the fact that, uh, yes, this is real, the source is
- 10:15real, it's publicly available. You don't have to trust us, right,
- 10:20So it's it creates a way of you know, this trustlessness. We want
- 10:24to bring it to the idea of preventing misinformation. That's again, that's a
- 10:30typical example of the type of use cases that we expect to become popular,
- 10:33where blockchain is used not necessarily to create tokens that people trade, but instead
- 10:39used to create tokens that establish established facts about the world that are then irrefutable
- 10:45and unchangeable. Mm hmm. That's a great example, Levine, and I
- 10:50think you're right. There needs to be some way to align expectations when you
- 10:56increase that liquidity for and and you also break down the barriers of entry to
- 11:01investing. Now you're getting more people that you know previously couldn't invest because they
- 11:05didn't have a million dollars, they had a small amount of money in part
- 11:09was in part those old regulations were to keep people safe and protect their investment.
- 11:16But now people are throwing in ten dollars and expecting it to turn into
- 11:20one hundred dollars within two days, and they don't really have the financial attainment
- 11:26to understand that. Yeah, a startup, especially founders and long term investors,
- 11:31you know, they have five to ten or more year investment horizons and
- 11:35none. You know, Amazon wasn't built in a year, and it took
- 11:39them ten fifteen years for the revenues to start going exponential, you know.
- 11:46And I think a lot of people they when they get into blockchain, they
- 11:50want to go they want to make it all right away. And I feel
- 11:54like it when you do that, it's also really easy to lose a lot
- 11:58right away. Absolutely, And I think what happens in these sort of crypto
- 12:03bull markets when everything is just sort of going up into the right it's,
- 12:09uh, it's easy to start believing that you know, your investment strategy is
- 12:15working, whereas in reality or investmentality is by any token, it's all going
- 12:18up, you know. Uh, So the and people have outsize gains,
- 12:24which leads to further sort of them telling telling their friends, and everyone comes
- 12:30in and everyone investing under bucks and whatever. Right, so, and now
- 12:33you're invested in this token and it's a great product, but you're not looking
- 12:39at the revenue of the company or the potential of the product, or the
- 12:45potential of that product to dominate the market or anything like that. You're just
- 12:48looking at what's it bosn't my token doing? Is it going up or not?
- 12:52Is it going up? Is it down? Oh? My god?
- 12:54Is now? Let's sell. Let's sell. So it's a completely different type
- 12:58of game that that people play. And for founders like we we we have
- 13:07I met the two or three of these companies where they're like, look,
- 13:13you know, we had a great six months and now we don't know what
- 13:16to do because now our token is down massively and they have trouble now raising
- 13:22even venture money because people are like, well, you know, you have
- 13:24a bad reputation out there because your token is down. You're like, no,
- 13:26but actually it's a good product, you know. So that that's that
- 13:31those two things conflate with each other. Yeah, it's a bit of a
- 13:35curse of the market and in some part beyond the control of the company.
- 13:41When you know some of these companies, I'm sure you understand there's a lot
- 13:46of blockchain projects that are still looking for a product market fit, or they
- 13:50haven't really found it. You know, there's sort of a solution in search
- 13:52of a problem, but there are some that actually have great solutions and they
- 13:56are solving things. But then the market as a whole, you know,
- 14:01if there's Bitcoin crashes, and you know, the rising tide rises all ships,
- 14:05but also sinks all ships, and how do you survive. You know,
- 14:11as a startup, you've probably had experience with this personally, where you
- 14:13know, there was you start your company right at the peak of excitement,
- 14:18and then all of a sudden, there's four or five years where nobody wants
- 14:22to invest in any capital, even though you have the next uber in your
- 14:26hands. So absolutely, I have experienced this myself a couple of times,
- 14:31at least once in two thousand and eight when that big crash happened, and
- 14:35once in twenty fourteen fifteen when sort of the fintech investments slowed down. And
- 14:41what saves you as a startup is the fact that you have a good product
- 14:46that your customers love, right and you're able to if you're if I'm able
- 14:48to show to an investor or to a VC that look, it's it's a
- 14:54solid product, it has this potential. We're addressing this market, we have
- 15:00this customer, we have discustomer growth. You know, it's like, I
- 15:03don't know if you've seen that. They're the talk that Paul Graham gave nine
- 15:07ten years ago on like should you have a startup or not? And one
- 15:11of the things he says is the most important thing in startup is to actually
- 15:15do good. Right. If you're doing good whtweans if you're if you have
- 15:18a product that your customers love and you have traction, then you don't You
- 15:24generally don't have trouble raising money. Valuations get tricky, right, So yes,
- 15:30you raise money at a fifty million dollar valuation and the market now that
- 15:33just doesn't bear it. That's okay, Now you'll raise it. You'll have
- 15:35a down round and have a raise money at a twenty minute dollar whatever.
- 15:39Right, And and that by itself, by the way, also is huge
- 15:43problematic because now you have to go start reshowing your stock options to employees and
- 15:48number of other complications that happen. It's a bit of a red black computure
- 15:50investors. But still ultimately you will survive and come out of it. If
- 15:56you are actually doing good, if you're if you actually have a product that
- 15:58works. So but you have to hunker down. We at one point in
- 16:03one of my companies, we went from we sort of did a very radical
- 16:07pivot and we went from having you know, one hundred and ten employees to
- 16:12about twenty five employees. Right, We just really hunkered down and said,
- 16:15what is the most important thing that we're doing. Can we just focus on
- 16:18that? And you know, you you come up against hard times and you
- 16:26have to make hard decisions, and ultimately what matters is do you have something
- 16:32that that your customers love? Mm hmm, yeah, great points. And
- 16:34I mean and now to go back to the example that you gave of the
- 16:38new venture that you're working on with the trust app and AI. You know,
- 16:44there's been discussion around fake content for a few years now, and I
- 16:48think, you know, the Tom Cruise deep fakes was one of the first
- 16:52example, but we haven't really seen it with everyday people. But in the
- 16:56last year, I've seen the technologies grow drastically with the expansion of you know,
- 17:02chatgybt into the video and audio, and it's starting to get to that
- 17:06point where you know, your everyday person might be impersonated or you know,
- 17:11worse, political leaders, fake videos images. I feel like this is something
- 17:15that is an ever more growing threat that I don't think anything like any global
- 17:22potential catastrophe has happened yet, but I feel like it very well could.
- 17:26And I'm curious on your insights into you know, how serious of an issue
- 17:30you think this might be and how important this technology could be for the future.
- 17:37Absolutely, So I'll sort of add a little bit of historical context,
- 17:42and this is I want to warn you it's a little bit opinionated, but
- 17:45I'll put it out there anyways. So, you know, there was a
- 17:51time when sort of trust was very high. Let's talk about the unios,
- 17:56right, So in the nineteen seventies was a time when trust in institutions was
- 18:00generally high. It was like, you know, your news institutions or the
- 18:04government or whatever. Right. And since the nineteen seventies, no matter what
- 18:07your metric is, trust has been eroding in the US at least, and
- 18:11actually more recently all around the world. The different countries have different cultures,
- 18:15have different ways of establishing trust, and you know, and even within the
- 18:21US, it was not universal. Right. I actually lived in Georgia for
- 18:25a couple of years in the nineties, and they have a whole other system
- 18:30of establishing trust, and their level of distrust of the federal government is not
- 18:34new, right, so the so, but trust was very high, and
- 18:38when people came to the Internet in the nineteen nineties, they sort of brought
- 18:44their trust with them, right. So the phrase, the phrase was,
- 18:49well, it must be true. I read around the internet. It was
- 18:52only a true thing, like people actually said that in the nineties. It
- 18:56must be truth on a website, it must be true. It wasn't until
- 19:02the advent of user generated content with my Space and Facebook and these other things
- 19:07where really anyone could post anything. Right. Again, the default is that
- 19:14people tend to believe things that they read, right, that's because they're they're
- 19:18bringing that from from from their sort of that that's an overhang from a different
- 19:26time, from a different era where people tend to believe institutions. I think
- 19:30the place where we're getting to now is that people are now beginning to or
- 19:34should I think, adopt a very defensive posture where you need to first start
- 19:41by not believing anything as you ready, So if you see a photo of
- 19:47whatever, it doesn't matter what it is, it doesn't matter who's posting it.
- 19:48Let's start by the union that that's wrong. Right, Let's start the
- 19:52assumption that it is that someone's lying to us, and let's question the motives.
- 19:56Right. Then we have to gradually expand our circle of belief and say,
- 20:04who is it that we want to believe, what content do we want
- 20:07to believe? How would we decide what to believe or not? Right?
- 20:10So that there's a few different initiatives that are trying to do that. So
- 20:12going back to your point about deep fakes and pick things. So Adobe has
- 20:15started a a content authentication initiative where there's a consortium of many different companies and
- 20:25the idea is that original that you want to be able to label original content
- 20:32in a way such that a consumer can decide. Of course, the problem
- 20:37is that most consumers aren't deciding. The consumer that is consuming content and social
- 20:41media where there's no way of verifying. Right. So with with our effort
- 20:45with trust app, we're trying to address that head on, right. So
- 20:48we we begin by saying, what is a very very narrow slice of truth
- 20:55that we can get at. Right, So let's let's not tackle uh,
- 20:59Let's tackle providence. Right, so you're saying that, Look, guys,
- 21:03the New York Times is claiming that Israel bond the hospital in Kasa. Uh,
- 21:07this is something that happened a couple of weeks ago. Well, let's
- 21:11just start with is the New York Times actually saying that? Right? So
- 21:15at least when you browse your social media, we can just put little red
- 21:19marks next to everyone that's saying that New York Times saying that, because New
- 21:22York Times is not saying that, you know, so that you know we
- 21:27can we can at least stop you from forwarding, the retweeting or whatever,
- 21:32those those pieces of content that are clearly misrepresenting the sources. Right, whereas
- 21:37somebody else who says, yes, this is something that whoever the BBC is
- 21:42saying or CNN is saying or whatever, we can put a green thing saying
- 21:48yes, they're accurately representing their sources. Right. Let's just start so we
- 21:52you know, from a product perspective, I'm a big believer in sort of
- 21:56taking small wins. Right. You make something small and you and you get
- 22:00it right first before you start to go broader. Right, So our first
- 22:04attempt is in establishing from sort of information provenance, right, which is the
- 22:10idea that we can confirm that something, uh, that a source that you're
- 22:15quoting is did actually say the thing that you're coding. Right, then we
- 22:18can talk about, well, you're not coding a source, you're just saying
- 22:22something. Right, how likely it is that what you're saying matches a number
- 22:26of other sources? Right? What is how do we establish ground truth?
- 22:30So, for example, the the the c a I, the initiative that
- 22:34I just spoke about, they actually publish some tools, and we want to
- 22:37be able to use some tools to establish authenticity of content itself, right,
- 22:41And and we want to use those tools to then add that to our little
- 22:45green and red check marks and say, yes, this is true according to
- 22:51the authentic authenticity established here uh with with the with the with the tool that
- 22:56Adobe created, Yes this was actually photoshopped not you know, it has been
- 23:03photoshopped in a way that is not consistent with it being the truth or it
- 23:07being real. Right. And we right now, the c AI initiatives don't
- 23:14plug into blockchain, but we want to be We want to do that.
- 23:17So we want we believe that blockchain represents a sort of fundamental technology that allows
- 23:22you to establish facts in a way that is platform agnostic, in a way
- 23:26that is undeleteable and unchangeable. And once you establish it, yes, this
- 23:32piece of content was published by this person at this time. That's it.
- 23:36Now they can't go and take it back or you, they can't, that
- 23:41cannot ever be deplatformed or whatever. You know, Like that's not a The
- 23:45whole point of blockchain is it's your own thing, you and it's the public
- 23:51good in that sense. Right, So we're trying to use blockchain as a
- 23:53public good in that sense to be able to publish content that is accessible to
- 24:00everyone at all times. Very interesting, Vean, And you're right about you
- 24:06know, the recent news and it's hard to tell what's what's real and what's
- 24:10not. And there's so much information coming out, you know, even on
- 24:15on YouTube and videos is like days and days of content every second that comes
- 24:19out. It's almost impossible to monitor the entire Internet. I'm curious, how
- 24:23would you measure the you know, the attainable market size for this kind of
- 24:30like monitoring this kind of information and using AI to determine the authenticity. Uh
- 24:37so we are not So we're trying to tackle small use cases, and we're
- 24:41trying to empower users to protect themselves. That's really the attempt that we have
- 24:48right now, Right, we want to give the user a tool by which
- 24:51they can protect themselves as they're browsing the internet. Uh is this information true
- 24:59or likely to be true or something like that. The market for that empowering
- 25:03users is as big as the number of users who browse the internet. Right,
- 25:08But it's difficult to say what the what? Uh? You know,
- 25:15like what features we need to have to be able to attract more and more
- 25:18people? Right? Because you can imagine that there's a class of user who's
- 25:22interested in establishing providences, and then a different types of user who's interested in
- 25:26finding deep the different types of user who's interested in something else. So we
- 25:30need to keep adding features to attract increasingly more users. In response to your
- 25:36question, which is I think you're looking at from the other side, like
- 25:37there's so much content, how will you ever process everything? Uh? That's
- 25:42where I think, uh sort of, that's where blockchain really begins to work
- 25:47because it really opens up us up to decentralization. Right. I have zero
- 25:52hope that just as one entity or one company or one product, we'll be
- 25:56able to process all of the world information right. But our goal is to
- 26:02make to create a platform where lots of people are publishing content on the internet,
- 26:10are publishing content on chain, and that is again it's decentralized in the
- 26:17way that it is put on chain, which is really the only way that
- 26:21you solve a scale. You have tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of
- 26:25entities that are putting content on chain and the same thing when it is consumed,
- 26:30you have to consume it in ways so that it's not one single API,
- 26:33but it's served in a decentralized way supported by blockchain. That's that that
- 26:37that decentralization actually becomes really important to achieve scale. M okay, no,
- 26:42great point. And if I wanted to try that this AI, is it
- 26:47already available for everyday user? Not yet. It's coming out at the end
- 26:52of this month, so we are planning a post Thanksgiving type release in early
- 26:57December, but before the holidays starts. Sounds great. And what other advice
- 27:03would you give to people that are trying to stay on top of blockchain,
- 27:07news, AI and all of this kind of technology. I think they should
- 27:15they should read sort of you know, listen to informed podcasts, but really
- 27:21look at what the AI experts are saying. I think the AI experts are
- 27:25there's a lot of concern around regulation and the potential of AI to do harm
- 27:32and these types of things, and I think those are very important issues because
- 27:37if we regulate AI in wrong ways or in ways that prevent innovation, I
- 27:42think that's a recipe for bad things to happen, right, that's a recipe
- 27:47for protecting incumbents and bad things happen. So it's very important for AI sort
- 27:52of research to be able to continue, and it's important for everyone to understand
- 27:56what the issues are, Understand what generative AI is capable of doing, and
- 28:00what how these ais differ from ais of ten years ago, for example,
- 28:06and what is it that you can do that and how can it how can
- 28:11we market, for example, in a way that it's clear that this is
- 28:14AI generated. You know, all of those things are are important considerations and
- 28:19what's going to happen in the future, and it's important for everyone to stay
- 28:22informed. Mm hmm definitely. Well, thank you for all your insights,
- 28:26Navian, And is there any place that we can follow you and your team's
- 28:30work for this kind of stuff? At Cumberland Labs, our website where we
- 28:34post all of our projects, and our Twitter handle as well. Cumberland Labs
- 28:40sounds great. I can leave those links in the show notes as well.
- 28:41Appreciate your insights into all of this technology and innovation. Ivan you're you're really
- 28:47on top of it, and it's going fast, it's it's sometimes it's a
- 28:49little hard to keep up. Absolutely absolutely happy to be here. Thank you
- 28:53so much for having me appreciate it.