Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / How Negative Working Capital Creates Cash
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. Today we're plunging into
- 0:03something in finance that, well, it seems completely backwards.
- 0:07It really is the ultimate paradox, isn't it?
- 0:09I mean, if you look at a company's books at its working
- 0:12capital. And that's your liquid assets
- 0:15minus your short term debts. Exactly.
- 0:17And when that number is negative, it's always been this
- 0:19huge flashing red light, an emergency signal, right?
- 0:23It means your immediate debts are bigger than your immediate
- 0:26cash. You literally can't cover your
- 0:28bills. I mean, traditionally that's a
- 0:29one way ticket to bankruptcy. Court.
- 0:31It signals a severe cash flow problem.
- 0:34You're basically borrowing just to keep the lights on
- 0:36day-to-day. But, and this is the whole point
- 0:38of our deep dive today, our source material is all about the
- 0:41wild exception to this rule. We're talking about financial
- 0:45giants like Amazon and even McDonald's, believe it or not.
- 0:49Yeah. And they regularly report
- 0:50negative working capital and they are very, very clearly not
- 0:54failing. Not even close.
- 0:56They're growing like crazy. And they're not just surviving
- 1:00with this number, they're thriving because of it.
- 1:02For certain hyper efficient business models, this negative
- 1:07balance, we can call it NWC for short.
- 1:09It isn't a flaw, it's the engine.
- 1:11So that's our mission today, to really get into the mechanics of
- 1:14this. How do these giants legally use
- 1:16NWC to turn what sounds like a fatal flaw into this massive
- 1:21self funding machine? OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:25How does having less cash than you owe actually make you
- 1:28powerful? Well, first we have to really
- 1:30cement how the standard model works.
- 1:32I mean, for almost every other company, you need positive
- 1:35working capital. Cash has to flow out.
- 1:37First before it can flow back in from customers.
- 1:39Right, you have to buy your materials, make your product,
- 1:42all of that costs money upfront. Let's use that classic lemonade
- 1:46stand example from the source material.
- 1:48It's simple, but it works. You want to sell lemonade Before
- 1:51you make a single dime? You've got to go spend, say,
- 1:54$100 on lemons and sugar. That $100 is gone from your
- 1:58pocket immediately. Your cash is tied up in
- 2:00inventory, the lemons, the Finnish lemonade, for that whole
- 2:03period between paying your supplier and a customer finally
- 2:07handing you a dollar. You need capital to bridge that
- 2:09gap. Cash out, then cash in.
- 2:11That's business one O 1. That's the.
- 2:13Normal economy. But now let's look at the Amazon
- 2:16model, which just completely flips that timeline on its head.
- 2:20This is where their sheer size becomes a financial tool it.
- 2:23Really is a weapon. So imagine a customer goes on
- 2:26Amazon and orders, I don't know, a keyboard.
- 2:28OK, step one, the customer pays right now, their credit card
- 2:33gets charged and that cash flows into Amazon's account on day 0.
- 2:37Instantly, the money's in their bank.
- 2:39But, and here's the crucial part, when does Amazon pay for
- 2:42that keyboard? Not right away.
- 2:44Not even close. Because of their incredible
- 2:46market power, they don't pay the manufacturer or the merchant who
- 2:50sold it for well, it could be 3060, sometimes even 90 days
- 2:54later. Wow, so they are literally
- 2:56holding the customer's cash for up to three months before they
- 2:59have to pay their own supplier? Think about that.
- 3:02In that entire transaction, Amazon did not use one cent of
- 3:06its own corporate cash. They used the customer's money
- 3:09to buy the product the customer just paid for.
- 3:11And for those 90 days, that cash flow is effectively an interest
- 3:16free loan. It's a loan provided by the
- 3:19entire ecosystem, the customer paying early and the supplier
- 3:23agreeing to be paid late. The supplier becomes sort of an
- 3:25involuntary bank funding Amazon's operations.
- 3:28The. Bank that doesn't charge
- 3:29interest and during that time that pool of cash, which is
- 3:33billions of dollars at their scale, could be used for
- 3:36anything. They can invest it, earn
- 3:37interest on it, use it to fund new projects.
- 3:40That's incredible, but you know it's not just for these massive
- 3:43e-commerce platforms. You mentioned McDonald's
- 3:45earlier. How does it work for them?
- 3:46They're not exactly strong arming their potato suppliers
- 3:49into 90 day term. No, they're not.
- 3:50It's a totally different mechanism, but the principle is
- 3:53the same. It's all built into their
- 3:55franchise model. McDonald's requires its
- 3:58franchisees to pay a lot of fees upfront.
- 4:01We're talking franchise fees, rent on the property, royalties,
- 4:05and these are often paid before McDonald's Corporation incurs
- 4:09the related costs. So the liabilities on their
- 4:11balance sheet aren't what they owe vendors, it's what they owe
- 4:14in services. It's what's called deferred
- 4:17revenue. When a franchise pays next
- 4:19month's rent today, that cash is in McDonald's corporate account.
- 4:23Right now, It creates a liability on the books, Sure.
- 4:27The obligation to provide the store for that month.
- 4:29But until that month is over, the cash is free and clear for
- 4:32them to use. Exactly.
- 4:34So whether you're a digital giant leveraging your supply
- 4:37chain or a real estate Titan leveraging your franchisees, the
- 4:41end goal is identical. Get cash in your hand long
- 4:44before you have to pay it out. That's it.
- 4:45That's the core strategy. OK, so that explains that's how
- 4:48it works. But for anyone analyzing these
- 4:50companies, how do you measure this?
- 4:52I mean, how do you quantify this advantage?
- 4:54There's a formal metric for it. It's called the Cash Conversion
- 4:56Cycle or CCC. And the CCC is basically the
- 5:00time, measured in days, that it takes for a company to turn its
- 5:04spending on inventory into actual cash from sales.
- 5:08It's a simple formula really. It's just inventory days plus
- 5:12customer payment days, and then you subtract supplier payment
- 5:15days. For a normal, healthy company,
- 5:17that number would be positive, right?
- 5:19They need to fund their operations for, say, 20 or 30
- 5:22days. Correct.
- 5:23But when you run the numbers for a company like Amazon, the
- 5:26result is, well, it's pretty mind blowing.
- 5:30OK, let's walk through it with those rough numbers from before
- 5:33inventory days, let's say 30. They're very efficient. 30 days
- 5:36now customer payment days since you pay by credit code
- 5:39instantly. That's zero.
- 5:40Zero. Another big one, supplier
- 5:42payment days. Let's use the high end 90 days
- 5:44because of their leverage. OK, so 30 + 0 is 30 -, 90.
- 5:49You get -60 days. -60 that single number is the secret
- 5:53sauce. That's it.
- 5:54It means for every single thing they sell, Amazon generates 2
- 5:58months of free cash that just sits in their account.
- 6:01They're not just avoiding spending their own money.
- 6:04The very act of doing business generates a cash surplus for
- 6:08them. And when you're a company the
- 6:09size of Amazon with revenues in the hundreds of billions, I
- 6:13mean, what does a 60 day float actually represent in dollars?
- 6:17You're talking about 10s of billions of dollars at any given
- 6:20moment, 10s of billions sitting on the books.
- 6:23It's a massive rolling interest free loan.
- 6:26And here's where it gets really interesting.
- 6:28They're not just letting that money sit there.
- 6:30Oh. Absolutely not.
- 6:31That float, that supplier funded capital, is what they use to
- 6:34build their empire. So they don't need to take on as
- 6:36much traditional debt or issue new stock to build, say, a new
- 6:40network of warehouses. Precisely.
- 6:42They use this float. It's the silent financier behind
- 6:44their massive logistics centers, their delivery fleets, and,
- 6:47critically, the huge capital investment needed for things
- 6:51like Amazon Web Services, AWS. So the growth literally funds
- 6:55itself. It sounds, well, it sounds
- 6:57almost too perfect, like a perpetual motion machine for
- 6:59money. It does sound perfect, and
- 7:01that's where the danger comes in.
- 7:03Our sources are very clear on this.
- 7:05The NWC model has a huge, potentially fatal flaw baked
- 7:09right into it. I'm guessing that flaw only
- 7:11shows up if that incredible growth starts to slow down.
- 7:15That is exactly right. This whole beautiful machine is
- 7:18completely dependent on two things.
- 7:21Continuous aggressive growth and that ironclad market leverage.
- 7:26Because if you're a small shop and you try to tell your
- 7:28suppliers, you'll pay them in 90 days.
- 7:30They'd laugh and cut you off immediately.
- 7:32The whole thing would grind to a halt.
- 7:34You need that power. But there's a deeper risk here.
- 7:37Some analysts have compared it, maybe a bit dramatically, to a
- 7:40kind of legal Ponzi scheme. That's a strong comparison,
- 7:43let's be careful with that. But what's the logic there
- 7:45structurally? The comparison works not because
- 7:48it's fraud, it's perfectly legal, but because the cash flow
- 7:51structure is the same. The company is fundamentally
- 7:54using cash from new customers today.
- 7:57To pay off the debts they owe to old suppliers from 90 days ago.
- 8:01Yes, the system requires a constantly growing stream of new
- 8:04cash to seamlessly pay off the old obligations as they come
- 8:08due. So what happens if that growth
- 8:10stops? If there is a recession or a big
- 8:12market shift, you get what the analysts call the crunch
- 8:16scenario. And the crunch is absolutely
- 8:19brutal because that stream of new cash from sales can dry up
- 8:23almost overnight. But those massive payments you
- 8:26owe from 90 days ago, they're still there.
- 8:29And they're due now. And they must be paid.
- 8:32Suddenly, a company that looked invincible is facing a
- 8:34catastrophic liquidity crisis. They don't have the incoming
- 8:38cash to cover the outgoing bills.
- 8:40Which could lead them straight to bankruptcy, even if the
- 8:42business is fundamentally sound long term.
- 8:45This is exactly why we see some of these fast expanding retail
- 8:48chains to suddenly collapse at the first hint of an economic
- 8:51downturn. Their greatest strength, using
- 8:53growth as financing instantly becomes their greatest weakness.
- 8:56So bringing it all together, negative working capital is like
- 8:59this powerful business crown, but only the absolute strongest
- 9:02companies, the ones with unstoppable growth and leverage,
- 9:05can actually wear it without getting crushed.
- 9:07That's the real lesson here for you as an analyst or an
- 9:10investor. When you look at a company's
- 9:12balance sheet and see that they owe suppliers way more than they
- 9:16have in cash, don't just immediately assume they're in
- 9:19trouble. Right, it might be the opposite.
- 9:21It might be a sign of incredible strategic strength.
- 9:24Before you judge, you have to do one thing.
- 9:26Calculate their cash conversion cycle.
- 9:29If that CCC is highly negative, you're not looking at a business
- 9:34on the brink of failure, You might be looking at a growth
- 9:36machine. So what does this all mean for
- 9:39you? It means that looking at a
- 9:41simple debt number isn't enough. You have to understand the cash
- 9:44flow dynamics underneath it. That's where the real story is.
- 9:48And you know a highly negative CCC isn't a sign of death, it
- 9:51could be the clearest sign you found the next self funding
- 9:54money printing machine. As long as you believe their
- 9:57growth and their market power are going to last.