Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Conquest of Jerusalem 1187: The Peaceful Siege
Transcript
- Lucas: We've talked a lot about Saladin's military campaigns, but I think the most iconic moment of his career was actually a siege that involved very little fighting. I'm talking, of course, about his conquest of Jerusalem in October 1187. Luna: Wait, the conquest of Jerusalem was a peaceful siege? I always imagined it as a bloody assault. Lucas: That's the fascinating part. After the crushing victory at Hattin in July, Saladin's forces swept through the kingdom, taking city after city. By September, only a handful of strongholds remained in Frankish hands: Tyre, Tripoli, Antioch, and Jerusalem. The defenders in Jerusalem were a shadow of what they'd been. Most of the knights who could have defended it had died at Hattin. Luna: So who was left to lead the defense? Lucas: The man who stepped up was Balian of Ibelin. He had actually been at Hattin, but had escaped the massacre. He made his way to Tyre and then to Jerusalem to retrieve his wife, who was a Byzantine princess. But the people of Jerusalem begged him to stay and lead the defense. Balian was a seasoned knight, but he had very few soldiers — maybe a few dozen knights and a ragtag militia of citizens. Luna: So they were massively outnumbered. What did Saladin do? Lucas: Saladin arrived with his army on September 20th. He set up camp near the Tower of David and began bombarding the walls. But here's where it gets interesting: Saladin initially offered the city terms of surrender. He was willing to let the inhabitants leave peacefully if they handed over the city. But Balian refused, saying they would fight to the death. Luna: Why would he refuse a peaceful surrender? Lucas: Partly pride, partly hope that reinforcements might come from Tyre or the West. But also, the inhabitants included many refugees from other captured cities who feared slavery or death. Balian's defiance forced Saladin to assault the walls. The fighting was fierce for several days, but the defenders held. Then, on September 25th, Saladin's men managed to breach the outer wall near the Damascus Gate. It looked like the city would fall by storm. Luna: What happens when a city is taken by storm? Lucas: In medieval warfare, it meant total massacre — the inhabitants had no rights, no quarter. The attackers could kill, rape, enslave at will. Saladin's own chroniclers, like Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, describe how the Ayyubid soldiers were eager for plunder. But Balian, realizing the situation was hopeless, came out with a dramatic gambit. He went to Saladin and said: if you refuse us terms, we will destroy everything. We will kill our own women and children, burn the city, and demolish the Dome of the Rock and the al-Aqsa Mosque. Luna: A bluff, or a real threat? Lucas: Probably both. But it worked. Saladin didn't want to see the holy sites destroyed. He agreed to negotiate. The terms were: the city would surrender, and the inhabitants could ransom themselves — ten dinars for a man, five for a woman, one for a child. If they couldn't pay, they would become slaves. Balian negotiated for the poor: eventually, Saladin agreed to free 7,000 of them for a lump sum of 30,000 dinars, paid from the treasury of the Kingdom. Luna: So it was a ransom, not a massacre. That's remarkable for the time. Lucas: Absolutely. And it's one of the reasons Saladin is so celebrated in both Western and Islamic sources. Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, Saladin's biographer, writes that the sultan was moved by the tears of women and children. But there's also a practical side: Saladin wanted to present himself as a merciful conqueror to the Christian world, hoping to avoid a massive crusade in response. Of course, that didn't entirely work. Luna: Right — the Third Crusade was launched almost immediately. Lucas: Exactly. But let's focus on the immediate aftermath. On October 2nd, 1187, Saladin entered Jerusalem. He was accompanied by his top commanders and his secretary, al-Qadi al-Fadil, who meticulously recorded the event. The first thing Saladin did was to purify the city: he ordered the removal of all Christian symbols from the Dome of the Rock and the al-Aqsa Mosque. The golden cross on the Dome was torn down by his soldiers, and some accounts say Saladin personally wept at the sight. The mosques were sprinkled with rose water and restored to Islamic worship. Luna: What about the Christian holy sites, like the Holy Sepulchre? Lucas: Saladin left the Holy Sepulchre in Christian hands. He allowed Eastern Christian priests to continue services there, though the Latin clergy were expelled. He also allowed a small number of Franks to stay if they paid the ransom. Many poor people were freed thanks to the generosity of Saladin's brother al-Adil, who asked for 1,000 captives and then freed them. Other commanders followed suit. It was a calculated act of magnanimity. Luna: So the city wasn't sacked. That's in stark contrast to the Crusader conquest in 1099, which was a bloodbath. Lucas: Exactly the contrast that the chroniclers wanted to highlight. Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani wrote that Saladin's mercy was a mirror to the Crusaders' brutality. But it's also worth noting that not all Muslims were happy. Some criticized Saladin for being too lenient. They wanted a massacre, both as revenge for 1099 and as a way to send a message. But Saladin overruled them. He understood that controlling Jerusalem required winning hearts, not just walls. Luna: Before we go on, I want to mention that we keep this show ad-free by design. If you appreciate the depth we go into, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps us keep doing this without any commercial interruptions. Lucas: Yeah, that's right. It's a small gesture that goes a long way in keeping these conversations going. So, back to Jerusalem: Saladin's takeover was swift, but it wasn't just about military control. He immediately began remaking the city as a Muslim center. He established new waqfs, or charitable endowments, to support Islamic scholarship. He brought in Sufis and scholars, and he made sure the city's economy revived quickly by allowing trade to resume. Luna: Did the Christian population completely disappear? Lucas: No, many Eastern Christians stayed, and Saladin even allowed some of the defeated Franks to remain if they could pay. But most of the Latin nobility and knights left, heading to Tyre or to Europe. The city became predominantly Muslim again, though with significant Christian and Jewish minorities. Saladin also invited Jews back to Jerusalem — they had been banned by the Crusaders — and they were allowed to settle. Luna: It sounds like he was thinking long-term, not just conquest. Lucas: Precisely. And that's what sets him apart from many of his contemporaries. The fall of Jerusalem was a massive propaganda victory for Saladin, and he used it to consolidate his rule. But it also sparked the Third Crusade, which brought Richard the Lionheart and Philip Augustus to the Holy Land. That's a story for another episode.