Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Tech Stocks Weather Sharp Drawdowns
Transcript
- Lucas: Let me start with a number that stopped me this morning. Palantir, which went public in 2020 at ten dollars a share, is down fifteen and a half percent over the past five trading days. That's the kind of drop that gets CFOs on the phone with their bankers before the market opens. Luna: Fifteen and a half percent—that's not a normal weekly wobble. And it's not just Palantir. Shopify is down nearly twelve percent. Coinbase down over sixteen. Something broader is happening. Lucas: Exactly. I want to use those numbers as a lens into a question that every post ipo tech company eventually faces: what do you do when your stock gets cut in half—or even just takes a twenty percent haircut—and you still have employees holding options, lockup deadlines approaching, and institutional investors asking for answers. Luna: So we're not talking about why the stocks are falling—macro, sector rotation, whatever—but about what management teams actually do when the decline is already happening. Lucas: Right. And the playbook has changed a lot since the 2022 downturn. Back then, a lot of recent IPOs had no earnings, no buyback programs, and very little experience managing a bear market. They basically had to sit and take it. Now, we're seeing a different set of tools being deployed. Luna: What tools specifically? I know buybacks have become more common among post ipo tech companies. I think the show covered that in a recent episode. Lucas: We did. But the nuance is timing. A buyback is only effective if you execute it while the stock is actually falling. A lot of companies announce a buyback program but then wait to see if the stock goes lower. That hesitation can destroy credibility. The ones that do it best—and I'd point to how some of the larger-cap tech firms handled the 2022 rout—are the ones that start buying immediately, even if it's small amounts, to signal confidence. Luna: But isn't there a risk that buying back stock during a downturn uses up cash that could be needed for operations? Especially for companies that aren't yet profitable. Lucas: That's the tension. And it's why the second tool is actually more interesting: convertible note repurchases or exchanges. A few post ipo companies have used the downturn to buy back their own convertible debt at a discount. That reduces future dilution and lowers the interest burden. It's a smart move if you have the cash, because you're effectively retiring expensive financing at a bargain price. Luna: So you're using the weakness in your equity to strengthen your balance sheet. That's counterintuitive—most people would think you'd hoard cash when things get scary. Lucas: Exactly. But the companies that come out of a drawdown stronger are the ones that act offensively during the panic. Let me give you a specific example that isn't in the headlines but illustrates the point. A mid-cap SaaS company that IPO'd in 2021 saw its stock drop about forty percent over two months earlier this year. Instead of just riding it out, they did a private exchange offer with convertible note holders, swapping near-maturity debt for longer-dated notes with a lower coupon. They effectively lowered their annual interest expense by about eight million dollars. That's real cash flow improvement. Luna: And that sends a message to the market that management is being proactive, not just reactive. Lucas: It does. And there's a third tool that I think gets overlooked: insider purchases. Not the CEO buying a token ten thousand dollars' worth of shares, but meaningful open-market buying by the C-suite and board members. When the CFO and the COO are putting their own money to work at the lower price, it's a much stronger signal than any press release. Luna: But a lot of post ipo insiders are still in a lockup period or restricted by trading windows. How do they navigate that? Lucas: That's the catch. Most employees and executives are prohibited from buying or selling during certain periods. And even when they're allowed, they may not have the cash liquidity—their wealth is already concentrated in the stock. So the signaling power is limited. Some companies have started using pre-arranged trading plans, 10b5-1 plans, to allow insiders to buy on a schedule regardless of blackout periods. That's a relatively new trend, and it's worth watching. Luna: So we've got buybacks, convertible note exchanges, insider purchases—but what about the companies that don't have the cash or the balance sheet flexibility? What's their play? Lucas: Honestly, their play is mostly communication. They have to manage expectations with investors, explain why the long-term thesis hasn't changed, and show progress on the metrics that matter—revenue growth, gross margin, path to profitability. And they have to do it without sounding desperate. That's harder than it sounds, especially when the stock is down double digits in a week. Luna: It reminds me of something a venture capitalist once told me: 'In a downturn, the best companies don't just survive—they gain market share because weaker competitors can't raise capital.' Is that relevant here? Lucas: Very relevant. The drawdown we're seeing right now—Palantir down fifteen percent, Shopify down twelve, Coinbase down sixteen—it's not uniform. Some of these companies have strong cash positions and recurring revenue. They can use the downturn to hire talent, acquire competitors at depressed valuations, or invest in R&D while others are cutting. The ones that panic and cut too deeply often lose the long-term game. Luna: But there's also a psychological element for the employees, especially those with underwater stock options. How do you keep them motivated when their equity package looks worthless? Lucas: That's the hidden cost of a drawdown. Employee retention becomes a real challenge. Some companies have repriced options—lowering the strike price to the current market value—but that creates accounting charges and dilutes existing shareholders. Others have issued new grants to key employees. The best practice I've seen is transparent internal communication: the CEO holds an all-hands, explains the stock drop in context, and reiterates the long-term roadmap. People can handle bad news if they trust the leadership. Luna: Speaking of trust, I want to ask about the IPO candidates watching this from the sidelines. If you're a private company planning to go public later this year or in 2027, what do you learn from watching Palantir and Shopify take these hits? Lucas: You learn that the public market is unforgiving. A fifteen percent drop in a week can happen for reasons that have nothing to do with your business. So you need to have a capital structure that can withstand that volatility. That means having enough cash on hand to operate for at least eighteen months without needing to access the equity markets. It also means being realistic about your valuation expectations. If you price your IPO at a level that assumes perfect execution, you're setting yourself up for a painful post ipo experience. Luna: And having a credible story about how you'll generate cash flow. Not just growth at any cost. Lucas: Exactly. The market is rewarding profitability and free cash flow generation more than it did in 2020 or 2021. If you're a private company burning cash and showing no path to breakeven, you better have a very compelling growth narrative—and even then, the reception might be chilly. Luna: So the big takeaway for me is that the post ipo playbook has matured. Companies have more levers to pull during drawdowns, but those levers require preparation and cash. It's not something you can improvise when the stock is already falling. Lucas: That's exactly right. And if this conversation has been useful for thinking about how your own company or investments might handle a downturn, honestly, that's the kind of thing that makes this show worth doing. If today was worth a coffee to you, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's the smallest ask, and it keeps these episodes ad-free and focused on what matters. Luna: Yeah, I think a lot of listeners get real value from these deep dives. It's a way to support the show without any strings attached. Lucas: And we really appreciate that. Now, let's come back to one more angle I want to touch on before we wrap. I mentioned that some companies use downturns to acquire talent or technology. There's actually a specific pattern emerging where post ipo companies with strong balance sheets are buying private AI startups at distressed valuations. That's a trend worth watching, especially if the drawdown continues. Luna: Are you seeing that happen already, or is it more anticipatory? Lucas: A bit of both. There have been a few small acquisitions in the last quarter that fit the pattern—public tech companies picking up AI teams for relatively low prices. The theory is that as private AI companies find it harder to raise their next round in this environment, they become acquisition targets for public companies that have stock as currency. It's a way to buy growth without taking on dilution at a low stock price. Luna: That makes sense. If your stock is down, using it for M&A is less attractive, but if you have cash, it's a buyer's market. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings us full circle. The companies that prepared for a downturn—by building cash reserves, maintaining access to credit, and having a clear capital allocation strategy—are the ones that can turn a drawdown into an opportunity. The ones that didn't are forced to react, and that's rarely a winning position. Luna: It's a good reminder that in public markets, volatility isn't the exception—it's the norm. And the best defense is a good offense. Lucas: Well said. That's all for this episode of Tech IPO Conversations. Thanks for listening, and we'll be back with another angle soon.