Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline For Wednesday, August 23, 2023
Transcript
- 0:02Hi. Dave Wilson filling in for Hoppy Kirchival lots to get to today It's
- 0:07debate day. Metro News talk Line is underway. Radio turn off from the
- 0:21studios of w VRC Media and the Metro News Radio Network, the Voice of
- 0:26West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This is Talk
- 0:33Live with Hobby Kirchiv Activated cells, telephone switch that chill from Charles stand by
- 0:41you, Hoppy. You're on Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible Liz,
- 0:46brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what
- 0:51you care about most. Visiting coovid dot com to learn more. Good morning,
- 0:55Welcome into the program. Dave Wilson sit again for Hoppy Kirchival. Ethan
- 1:00Collins on the phones. Luke Rowsy running the video stream today eight hundred and
- 1:03seven six five Talk is the phone number, three oh four Talk three oh
- 1:07four is the text line. Going to have plenty of opportunities to hear from
- 1:11you today, and I am interested to hear from you. Are you going
- 1:15to be watching the up presidential debate tonight? Have you already made your mind
- 1:21up. What I really would like to know if you had one question.
- 1:26If you have one question, Brehet Bear, Martha McCollum, and I'm going
- 1:30to turn it over to you. Let you ask a question of the candidates.
- 1:36What would you ask? What do you want to know? What do
- 1:38you want to hear? We'll talk about it throughout the show today eight hundred
- 1:41seven six, five, eight, two, five, five and three or
- 1:44four Talk three or four. A little bit later on second hour, we'll
- 1:47talk to Gary Abernathy get his take on tonight's proceedings. What is he looking
- 1:53for? And again I want to hear from you throughout the show today eight
- 1:57hundred seven and six five Talk and three or four Talk three or four.
- 2:00We start with the editor for Protect Democracy, Amanda Carpenter, author of gas
- 2:06Lighting America While We Love It When Trump Lies to Us. She previously served
- 2:09as a speechwriter for South Carolina Senator Jim Demitt, also communications director for Texas
- 2:15Senator Ted Cruz, and Amanda joins us on Metro News talk Line this morning.
- 2:19Amanda, good morning, Hey, good morning, Dave. Let me
- 2:23pose that question to you. If Brett Bear, Martha McCollum turn it over
- 2:28to you tonight, what would be your one question of the GOP candidates.
- 2:31I have an opening, raise your hands question that I would love to see
- 2:37the answer to you, and it's pretty straightforward. Do you believe the indictments
- 2:44are bad for Donald Trump and the Republican Party? Because I can guarantee you,
- 2:50if you like Donald Trump, if you like everyone on stage, the
- 2:53Democrats are going to be making that argument quite effectively in the general election.
- 2:59And what I am somewhat mystified about now is that we are going to watch
- 3:06a Republican primary debate tonight. But are any of the candidates actually going to
- 3:10make a case against Donald Trump based on what is most definitely coming in the
- 3:15general election? I think not, and I think it's a huge, huge
- 3:20blind spot. I mean, listen, Donald Trump is winning this thing right
- 3:23now, not by ten points, not by twenty points, forty points in
- 3:27most polls, and no one in the Republican primary wants to vet him on
- 3:34the case that Democrats are almost certain to make. I am baffled by that.
- 3:42I'm going to go, okay, I'm trying to figure this out.
- 3:45With Trump polling at I think if the last numbers are like sixty five percent.
- 3:49Are you running the risk though, of alienating the base there and not
- 3:54even giving yourself a chance in the primary if you go after Trump in that
- 3:59way? Oh sure, I mean, but this is part of the problem.
- 4:01It's like, we're not talking about the big thing that's happening, tald
- 4:04Donald Trump is going to have a mug shot right, Like, there may
- 4:09not be any coverage of this debate because that's going to blow everything else side
- 4:13of the water. And so if that's dominating the news, what is the
- 4:17plan B? What is the plan B? That's that's kind of the case
- 4:21when where everyone is convinced themselves that they can't talk about the biggest issues.
- 4:27Therefore they're leaving the eventual candidate extremely vulnerable. And so you know, rond
- 4:32De Santis, who's in most poles, like, let's agree he's the number
- 4:35two guy. You can't make a case to voters saying, hey, I
- 4:40like Donald Trump, you like him, we like his policies, but he's
- 4:44not going to be available to effectively campaign over the next eighteen twenty four months
- 4:49because he has so many court dates. Like that, Ronda stantists can't look
- 4:55every Poltican voters and say, you know what, we likes what happened,
- 4:59but January sixth that it was a bad day. We've got to move past
- 5:01that, and Donald Trump has to deal with that, along with all the
- 5:04lawyers who gave him that really bad advice that he acted on. You know,
- 5:09that's not probably strong enough just for me, But I think you can
- 5:13have a serious conversation with Republican voters if you're actually interested in creating a more
- 5:18positive, optimistic alternate version rather than just mimicking everything Donald Trump is saying and
- 5:26hopefully hoping something happens and maybe you can pick up as crumbs in the wake.
- 5:30Like that's not leadership in what I in just anticipating it's going to happen
- 5:38tonight. What are we actually debating here? We're gonna talk about wal culture,
- 5:42Like those are all fine issues. We should talk about schools, we
- 5:44should talk about pandemic response. But if we're not going to talk about how
- 5:49our political and legal frameworks have to deal with this question about either prosecuting a
- 5:57former president. If you don't have any opinion on that other than to say,
- 6:00well, the systems being weaponized against him, then just let him this.
- 6:04He hand him the reins. Now if you're not going to have a
- 6:09debate. I'm probably that is the most serious issue our country of state,
- 6:13Like how what do we do when a former president has been indicted and rested
- 6:16four times? Like, if you want to be president, I don't care
- 6:20what party you are from, you need to be prepared to address that matter,
- 6:26not just to the former president's most hardcore Republican voters, but everyone,
- 6:30because that is an issue that affects everyone and will set a president that will
- 6:34impact our country for you know, the next two hundred years. Talking to
- 6:39Amanda Carpenter, editor of Protect Democracy, she has a column The huge mistake
- 6:45most of Trump's rivals are making is the headline to that column a man.
- 6:48When it comes to Ronda Santis, it feels like, to me, his
- 6:53whole campaign started out being electability. Trump can't get elected in November. I'm
- 6:59the guy that can get elected. But President Biden's poll numbers are equally I
- 7:04mean, they're so bad the numbers say, well maybe you can, and
- 7:09he's had to pivot. His campaign's never been able to make that pivot and
- 7:14demonstrate why he is different or can win in November versus you know, the
- 7:20presumed front rider here in Donald Trump. Yeah, I can't see where the
- 7:25santis is coming from in that argument. It was probably working for him early
- 7:30on when he was the bright, new shiny thing and everybody was like,
- 7:32wow, this next Republican governor from Florida could be the the future of the
- 7:38Republican Party. Right, he got a very good look. Here's why the
- 7:42electability argument isn't working though. Number One, Donald Trump can get elected.
- 7:46He did in twenty sixteen. Okay, he spent the Republican Party spent the
- 7:51last how many years saying he didn't really lose the twenty two on the election
- 7:57either. But that's not even the worst reason. The worst thing going against
- 8:01Ron Ron decantists can't order electability. When he's trailing Trump by twenty points to
- 8:07the Republican primary, you know that he's kind of lost that argument there.
- 8:11And the other thing that his team is doing and a few other candidates,
- 8:16they're trying to maximize the opportunity of this debate, not my making a case
- 8:20against Donald Trump on the issues, but doing this sort of taunting thing by
- 8:26saying, well, Trump is too weak to come to the debate, he
- 8:28doesn't have the courage to face me. Do any Republican voters believe that.
- 8:33Does anybody actually think Donald Trump is weak and afraid of a media appearance,
- 8:37especially a confrontational one. I think not, because we've witnessed the entire twenty
- 8:43sixteen Republican primary and his entire life in the public eye, and so I
- 8:48feel like that's another way they're just niddling around the edges and not actually addressing
- 8:54the real issue. The real problem with Donald Trump's keeping this debate is that
- 8:58he's showing content for voters. Do you think I don't have to play by
- 9:01these rules? Which maybe you know you like that, but that has bigger
- 9:05implications because it's exactly what's landed him for indictments. This idea that he doesn't
- 9:13have to play by the rules because he's politically powerful has had very serious repercussions
- 9:18and we are going to be dragged through that for the next two or three
- 9:22years as these things wind painfully through the courts. Can any of these candidates
- 9:31separate themselves if the biggest issue in the room, Amanda is former President Donald
- 9:35Trump? Can any of these candidates make a statement tonight and pull closer in
- 9:41the polls or really provide a serious contender here? Going into the primaries,
- 9:48which it's still early, and I get that, but I mean that is
- 9:52Trump is pulling huge numbers at this point. Can any of these guys separate
- 9:56themselves. Seems like people are most excited for Chris cre See to go hard
- 10:01on this issue, which okay, number one, Chris Christie has sort of
- 10:05staked his entire candidacy and around this idea that he's going to have a big
- 10:09confrontation with Donald Trump at the debate, and Trump said I'm not going to
- 10:13debate, So I'm not really sure what Chrissy is going to have to work
- 10:18with on that stage, unless he tries to make this sance as a proxy
- 10:20for Trump, which could happen. But the problem with Chris Christie is that
- 10:26he's doing he's you know, making a good case, but I don't think
- 10:31people believe him because if you're a Trump voter, you see him as a
- 10:35figure who detray Trump. And if you're someone in the know very tiny life
- 10:41of a never Trump category, you say, okay, that's it, Triss
- 10:45Christie. But have you ever said sorry or asked for forgiveness? And everything
- 10:52you did to enable Trump the whole way? So he has a real credibility
- 10:54for problem, and so I'm not sure it's going to work for him,
- 11:00but we'll see that. Honestly, I'm not looking to see what any individuals
- 11:03candidate can do because I am worried about the fate of our politics. I'm
- 11:09looking to see what is the field doing to make our politics fafer and to
- 11:13actually move forward in a way that I believe is consistent with Republican commitment to
- 11:20rule of law. You know, the idea, if they're just going to
- 11:22stand up in stage and say January sixth is generally okay and we should pardon
- 11:28Trump, etc. I don't think that makes our politics more safe. If
- 11:31ron De Santis is going to rail against the Lac Des Nations government while these
- 11:35trials have to proceed against Trump, and I am worried about keeping those processes
- 11:39safe and the jurors safe and Georgia so we don't have another bad event like
- 11:45January sixth. That does not make our politics more safe, That is not
- 11:48moving forward in a positive direction. And so I would love I would love
- 11:52it to stake of this unite and the rule of law saying you know what,
- 11:56you might think these insitements are unfair, but we have a process because
- 11:58see through and we want to keep that process safe. And so we're not
- 12:03going to tolerate these attacks and judges and prosecutors, etc. Because we believe
- 12:07we have good arguments and we hope Donald Trump makes them and he will have
- 12:11his day in court and leave it at that and move on and quit jamming
- 12:16everything up. So that we're at such a hot theory that people are storming
- 12:24the capital to shut down the process. Is there? I was going to
- 12:28ask you to pick a winner or loser, but let me phrase it this
- 12:30way. Is there any way the winner tonight is not former President Donald Trump?
- 12:39Seeing how things line up is very, very difficult to see. And
- 12:43that, you know, how do you feel about Donald Trump? The idea
- 12:48that a candidate in the United States of America becomes politically stronger after he is
- 12:54accused credibly of multiple accounts of criminal behavior and skips out I'm explaining himself to
- 13:01his own voters, you know, subjecting himself to scrutiny from his fellow candidates,
- 13:05from his fellow party. That is not a good sign. Because we
- 13:11like debate in America, We like descent, We like you know, feisty
- 13:16exchange of ideas. That is what we're supposed to be about. And if
- 13:20we look at tonight and that doesn't happen, it's just another time to self
- 13:26evaluate what direction we're taking and how we can fix it. Amanda Carpenter she's
- 13:31the editor for a Protect Democracy, nonpartisan anti authoritarianism group. Also, she
- 13:37was a former communications director for Senator Ted Cruz and speechwriter for South Carolina Senator
- 13:43Jim Daman. Amanda, I appreciate it, thanks so much, and we'll
- 13:46be watching tonight. Thank you so much. Absolutely coming up, I want
- 13:50to hear your thoughts at eight hundred seven six five talk or text me three
- 13:54or four talk three oh four. Dave Wilson set again for Hoppy Kirchbill talk
- 13:56line from the Cove Insurance Studios. Cantinues right after this. Are you tired
- 14:01of joint pain or muscle injuries holding you back? Trust the experts at CMC
- 14:07Orthopedics and CMC Orthopedic Trauma for personalized treatment options tailored to your needs. CMC
- 14:13offers comprehensive orthopedic treatment for all types of pain and injuries. Our specialists provide
- 14:18tailored options from diagnosis to rehab with state of the art facilities for top quality
- 14:24care. Visit CMC dot org slash orthopedics to learn more. Metro News talk
- 14:41Line with Hobby Kirchibile is brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you
- 14:46with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visitingcovid dot com to learn
- 14:50more here at four talk three or four is the text line eight hundred seven
- 14:54six five eight two five five the phone number. What's the one question you
- 14:58would asked night if you were on the debate stage from asking the GOP presidential
- 15:05candidates? And a man is right, the biggest question in the room,
- 15:09the nine hundred pound gorilla in the room is Donald Trump? And where do
- 15:15the candidates stand? And how do you differentiate yourself? I don't think there's
- 15:22an appetite within the GOP for Trump Light. If I want someone like Donald
- 15:31Trump, I'll take Donald Trump. So I don't know that there's room for
- 15:35somebody who's Who's Trump Light? How do you differentiate yourself from him? My
- 15:41biggest question is this, how do you win a November? And this is
- 15:46more of a question, probably for the Republican Party than it is for the
- 15:48individual candidates. How do you win in November? How do you convince because
- 15:58the people who did not vote for Donald Trump in twenty twenty and independents who
- 16:06are fed up with both sides because look, the numbers are horrible really when
- 16:10it comes to likability and approval for both and I'm talking about President Biden and
- 16:15foreign President Trump. How do you convince those voters? How do you win
- 16:19in November? Again, more of a question for the party than it is
- 16:26for the individual candidates there, But that's what I would be curious tonight.
- 16:30How can you differentiate yourself? Are you willing to be Are you willing to
- 16:37be confrontational? Chris Christy is, but I mean, let's let's be serious.
- 16:41He's he's not going to be the nominee, nor is nor do I
- 16:45think he's going to make any serious push for it. Either three or four
- 16:48talk three or four is the text line some of you are responding to.
- 16:56What would you ask when it comes to Ukraine? What is enough enough to
- 17:03cruise? That's my question this morning. Yeah, I'm curious. There are
- 17:07issues I am curious about. What is the exit strategy? How do you
- 17:14deal with the situation Ukraine? Sure, Dave been worried about foreign countries or
- 17:18corporations buying our farm land. David, my question would be do any candidates
- 17:23support repealing Citizens United and ending individual stock trading amongst elected officials? Very specific.
- 17:33David's obvious Amanda was Ted Cruz's communications director. Her one question that she
- 17:37had a chance to ask had something to do with Donald Trump. Not the
- 17:40border, not the economy, not China, not Russia, not me,
- 17:42everything about Trump. I'm surprised you didn't know. Didn't throw in a hunter
- 17:47Biden, Well, he is the biggest topic, even not being there.
- 17:52He sucks the hair out of the room. He is the biggest topic in
- 17:56the Republican Party right now, isn't it. Yes? I do want to
- 18:03hear everything you just mentioned there, border security, economy, all of those
- 18:12issues, Ukraine, all of those issues, energy. Yes, I want
- 18:18to hear about all of those. But you can't ignore the albatross in the
- 18:23room, Dave, how much money you have or your family made off the
- 18:29position in state or federal government. Answers should be zero for the candidates,
- 18:33Dave, I don't know. Will you protect our cultural resources, including Confederate
- 18:37monuments including the Arlington Cemetery. Reconciliation monument and the Department of Defense that the
- 18:45Department of Defense is proposing to remove. Dave, here's my question. Do
- 18:51you agree that Vice President Harris can you'll latterly declare the winner of the twenty
- 18:55twenty four presidential election? And if not, why was it okay where the
- 19:00disgraced Trump to try this with Mike Penson twenty twenty. I see what you
- 19:03did there, Dave. My mind has been made up the past seven years
- 19:07Trump Trump, Trump, says the Texter Dave. The Trump worm is in
- 19:14everybody's here. Nothing can get done. The best stunt ever. Not going
- 19:18to debate, Dave, give us a break with this woman, another disconnected
- 19:25media member, non partisan lmao, Dave, Republicans are for rule of law,
- 19:33question Mark, Give me a break. People who voted for Trump love
- 19:36liars and cheaters as long as they are not Barack Obama. All right,
- 19:41I'll get back to more of your text. Coming up, we'll continue to
- 19:45discuss. Gary Abernathew will join us coming up at the top of the hour.
- 19:48Up next, we've got an update to one group's look into the Marcellus
- 19:53Shale and its impact when West Virginia. We'll talk about that next Dave Wilson
- 19:57in for Hoppy Kirchil's talk line on Metro News the Voice of West Virginia.
- 20:18Stay Wilson in for Hoppy Kurgival mentioned news talk line continues, hop will be
- 20:23back. He's taking an extended vacation. You're stuck with me all next week.
- 20:30Two. Yeah, just settle in. We'll get back to the GOP
- 20:34debate. I want to know what you would ask, what do you want
- 20:37to hear tonight? What do you not want to hear tonight? Maybe that's
- 20:41a better question. Gary Abbernatthew, who on the top of the hour,
- 20:44will discuss further. Your phone calls, text tweets coming up eight hundred seven
- 20:48six five talks. The phone number three or four Talk three or four is
- 20:51the text line. Earlier this week, the Ohio Valley or the Ohio River
- 20:56Valley Institute released an update to its study entitled Frakalasha See what they did there?
- 21:03Peak Natural Gas and the Economic Implications for Appalachia. Joining us all mentioned
- 21:10news talk line is senior researcher from the Ohio Valley Or from the Ohio River
- 21:14Valley Institute, Sean oh Leary Sean, Good morning morning, Dave good to
- 21:18be here. What was the key takeaway from this update that looked at the
- 21:25natural gas industry here in parts of West Virginia. Well, it's that,
- 21:30you know, much of West Virginia's economic development strategy is based on the natural
- 21:36gas industry and the belief that its expansion will bring jobs and prosperity. But
- 21:41the report and the facts show precisely the opposite. Did What did the report,
- 21:48fine Sean, Well, it found that in the county's in West Virginia
- 21:52and Appalachia where the natural gas production is the greatest, are also counties that
- 21:57are suffering from severe job in population loss, which I know it's counterintuitive because
- 22:04a lot of people look around, they see a lot of activity and a
- 22:08lot of natural gas being produced. But at the same time, as I
- 22:12said, that production has been accompanied not by games in jobs and prosperity,
- 22:18but actual losses of both jobs and people. What counties are did you specifically
- 22:26look at, Well, there are twenty two counties in Ohio, Pennsylvania,
- 22:32and West Virginia that collectively produce about ninety percent of the gas coming out of
- 22:37the region. Seven of those counties are in West Virginia, and they're clustered
- 22:41in the northern Panhandle and along the Ohio River. So Ohio, Marshall,
- 22:47Websil, Tyler, Harris and Doddridge, and Richie are the seven West Virginia
- 22:55counties that produce most of the natural gas coming out of the state. So
- 23:00what did you find it in those counties? Loss of population? It seems
- 23:03like you said, I drive by, I see the activity. It's you're
- 23:10saying that's not translating into individual gains gains for the counties. Yeah, exactly.
- 23:18I mean when you look, for instance, at the West Virginia natural
- 23:25gas counties, they have experienced in terms of jobs they have lost since the
- 23:33beginning of the fracking boom in about two thousand and eight. They've lost a
- 23:38seen a job loss of about three percent, and they've seen a population loss
- 23:45of eight percent during that time. Is that a direct correlation to the fracking
- 23:52industry. Yeah, it is. That's one of the questions. Well,
- 23:56one of the questions that you know, I'm asked most often is well,
- 24:00g couldn't it be because other parts of the economy are failing, that the
- 24:06natural gas industry is bringing jobs in employment, but that other parts of the
- 24:11economy are not doing well. And we tested that proposition last year in an
- 24:17analysis in Pennsylvania, where there's a natural experiment. In Pennsylvania, you've got
- 24:22thirty counties that are rural counties that prior to the natural gas boom were on
- 24:30almost exactly the same economic trajectory, and then in the wake of the natural
- 24:36gas boom keat of those calties were heavily drilled and became major producers. Twenty
- 24:42of the calties did not. And the remarkable thing is that when you look
- 24:48at the comparison of those two calties, or those two sets of calties,
- 24:52the ones that got a lot of gas productions saw their gross domestic product their
- 24:57output guy rocket. But when you look at measures of prosperity, jobs and
- 25:04income and population, they were indistinguishable from the calves that did not have the
- 25:11natural gas boom. All of them saught job losses and population losses, which
- 25:18suggests that all other things being equal, the natural gas boom simply did not
- 25:25make a contribution to jobs and income growth. It did make a contribution,
- 25:32though, did it not. I mean, you can go through I'll pick
- 25:34on Doddridge County for just a moment. They have a brand new high school,
- 25:37brand new athletic facilities, and that is a direct result of the natural
- 25:44gas boom. They're in Doddridge County. They don't have that without that industry
- 25:48moving in now. And that is true. There are many many cases throughout
- 25:55the region where the natural gas boom has made two kinds of contributions. One
- 26:00is the kind you're talking about, where we do see new schools, new
- 26:03athletic fields, and other projects that have been funded by the industry. And
- 26:10the other positive effect we've seen is that there are lots of property owners who
- 26:15are receiving royalties as a result of gas being produced on their land. Problem
- 26:22is that when you take the helicopter up though, and you look at the
- 26:26economy as a whole, you realize dust brankets in the context of a much
- 26:32larger picture, Notdridge. Doddridge, by the way, has the game all
- 26:36of Appalachia that saw the greatest economic growth of over almost seven hundred percent over
- 26:44the course of the fracking boom. But at the same time Doddridge was seeing
- 26:48that kind of growth in output, it was also seeing severe losses in population.
- 27:02You know, Doggridge's population has actually shrunk by four percent and Doddridge did
- 27:08do relatively well with jobs compared to many counties, so it but you know,
- 27:18Doddridge is a fairly small plate, so we're talking about it added a
- 27:22couple of hundred jobs, but it lost as many residents as it added jobs.
- 27:27Well, there are only three counties in the state last year that added
- 27:30any population that the other fifty two all lost population, and certainly not all
- 27:34fifty two have had have been impacted by the shale or the fracking boom.
- 27:40So I mean, are we are we drawing false correlations here? No,
- 27:45No, that that actually is a great parallel. So for instance, you
- 27:48just talked about the ratio in West Virginia, right of colties that actually saw
- 27:53population growth as opposed to population loss. The picture in the Fraca and counties
- 28:00is exactly the same as the picture in West Virginia. And that is,
- 28:03of the twenty two counties that I mentioned in Fracolachia, twenty of them experienced
- 28:08population loss. So again it goes back to the point that I was making
- 28:15before, which is that even you know, when you compare the Fracolachian counties
- 28:21to the region, they are not doing any better, and in most cases
- 28:25they're doing worse. So what's the endgame here, Sean? What do we
- 28:30do with this information? Well, the information is a good news is that
- 28:37it points us in two really useful directions from policymaking and from an economic development
- 28:45standpoint. The first lesson that we need to learn, I think from this
- 28:49is that we need to get a better deal because right now, as I
- 28:53mentioned before, a lot of natural gas is being produced in the region,
- 28:57and that's not going to change. That's going to continue to be the case.
- 29:02But what we're seeing is that the calviies that are producing that natural gas
- 29:07are frankly getting a pretty bad deal. They're not getting they're not seeing economic
- 29:11growth, they're not seeing actual local investment as a result of it. And
- 29:18so there are measures that local and state policy makers can take to make sure
- 29:23that more of the money, more of the wealth being generated, is retained
- 29:29in those counties. So then, well, hang on, yeah, I
- 29:33mean, they paid one hundred eighty four million dollars in property taxes, I
- 29:37think last year that that's wealth staying in the county. Isn't it getting a
- 29:40new school, getting new athletic facilities, and that wealth staying in the county?
- 29:44The well, yeah, I mean, there are contributions. Absolutely,
- 29:48there is money being received in taxes. But at the same time, what's
- 29:52happening is that because we're seeing the industry driving population laws, we're seeing doctor
- 30:00hang on, Sean, Sean, let me jump in. I'm just I'm
- 30:03missing the connection here that the industry is driving population loss. If the industry
- 30:07is not there, there would be even more population loss, wouldn't there in
- 30:11all of these counties. There would be no reason to stay now. Actually,
- 30:15when you look at it, overall, population loss is greater in the
- 30:18fracking counties than it is in the States as a whole, and even another
- 30:23comparable. Aren't there other factors though that would that play into that. I'm
- 30:29just I'm having a hard time drawing the connection that an industry that's providing jobs
- 30:32and providing revenue is driving people out of Tyler and Wetzel and Marshall and Doddridge
- 30:37counties. The reasons are and you know, if you've lived there, or
- 30:41if you've been in many of those counties, you know you can see the
- 30:45level of development. Frankly, it's you know, pretty disruptive to lifestyles.
- 30:49In many of those cases, there are some very rural counties and doggridges,
- 30:53you know, one of those where you do see some population growth because the
- 30:57counties were so little developed before the natural gas boom. But in most of
- 31:03the counties, as I said twenty at the twenty two, you see significant
- 31:07population loss and population loss at a level greater than that of the surrounding counties
- 31:15and states. I mean, that's that's a simple statistical fact. Now.
- 31:21The opportunity, though, that this presents is that, again, there is
- 31:26a lot of wealth being created. Yes, some of it, a small,
- 31:30small fraction of it is captured in the form of taxes and in some
- 31:34of the local investments that companies are making. But it's a very very small
- 31:41share, you know too. I think to put it in context, you
- 31:47have to understand that about nationwide, about ninety percent of all of the output
- 31:55that is generated as GDP comes back to local residents in the form of income.
- 32:01You know. Those are two statistics that the federal government tracts regularly in
- 32:07the counties that we're talking about in West Virginia. Instead of ninety percent of
- 32:10that money coming back in the form of income, it's less than sixty five
- 32:15percent. The translation is that very little of the investment going into pumping and
- 32:22producing natural gas, and very little of the revenue that's earned from it actually
- 32:28ever lands in local economies. Doesn't mean that none does. Some absolutely does,
- 32:34but it's just a very small amount, and that's why it's a pretty
- 32:37bad deal. So what do we do, Sean, Where do we go
- 32:39from here? There are two things that we can do. One, as
- 32:44I said a moment ago, is that we can do a better job of
- 32:47retaining more of the revenue that's being earned in the counties. And that means,
- 32:52frankly, taking a look at taxes, steverance taxes and property taxes and
- 33:00other mechanisms were capturing more of that, so we can relieve things like income
- 33:05taxes and sales taxes that regular folks who live there have to pay. The
- 33:10second thing that we can do is look for other kinds of economic development by
- 33:15investing, particularly in our state, in energy transition and in embracing things like
- 33:23energy efficiency and things that put money into local economies. When you've got door
- 33:30and window contractors and electrical contractors and h tract contractors, we can put them
- 33:37to work doing things that have much much greater effects in local economies and safe
- 33:45people money on their utility bills at the same time, Sean O'Leary, senior
- 33:49researcher for the Ohio River Valley Institute, Sean, I appreciate the conversation.
- 33:52Thanks so much this morning, Dave. Thank you, bye, absolutely your
- 33:57thoughts welcome. Three or four Talk three or four and eight hundred seven five
- 34:00Talk eight hundred seven six five eight two five five Metro News talk line from
- 34:04the in COVID Insurance Studios continues in a moment. Metro News talk Line with
- 34:17Hobby Kirchibill is brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you with coverage
- 34:22to protect what do you care about most? Visiting coovid dot com to learn
- 34:27more. Went a little along there, but we'll try to make up for
- 34:30it. Let me go to the phones squeeze in a quick call or two.
- 34:32Dale in Morgantown, Hey Dale, Hey, Dave, heybody, Yes,
- 34:38so just listen to the whole segment. I mean, I agree with
- 34:43you fully on where very difficult to draw the connection between the causation and the
- 34:49correlation because, as you know, the correlation does not always equal the causation.
- 34:52And I think the perfect example of that was in that interview because we
- 34:58know that the Northern Panhandle, and you can look this up with regard to
- 35:02the state's demographics, the Northern Panhandle and a lot of those areas, even
- 35:07in western Pennsylvania, actually have a lot older of a population than the rest
- 35:13of the state. And there are other factors too that would contribute to that
- 35:16population decline other than the gas industry, which again I fully agree with you
- 35:23to say that the gas industry alone has been a driver of people leaving.
- 35:30That's a very difficult bridge to build there, and I just wanted to express
- 35:35that I agree with you. And on top of that, look at the
- 35:37demographics of the Northern Panhandle, they're very bad compared to other areas of the
- 35:43state. Dale, I appreciate it very much. Let me squeeze in Bobby
- 35:45from Clarksburgh before we take the break. Bobby, keep it tight, all
- 35:50right. So oil and gas industry is going the same way as the coal
- 35:53industry. And what you've got happening is that the technology you just don't need
- 35:59the power anymore to operate and drill these wells a well. Let's i'm would
- 36:04take this well. In twenty twenty one, in mont County made three point
- 36:07five million mcf in twenty twenty one. In two thousand and five, that's
- 36:13about one hundred and fifty shallow wells. So that's one hundred and fifty so
- 36:19in one well equals one hundred two hundred and fifty wells drilled twenty years ago.
- 36:24How many people did it take to drill it produced that three point five
- 36:29million mcf in twenty twenty one, It probably took a rig of five to
- 36:34ten people. You know, you're looking at maybe fifty people to get that
- 36:40amount of gaps two thousand and five, you would have probably have needed by
- 36:47twenty to twenty five times the personnel to produce that gap. Good point,
- 36:52Bobby, Hey, appreciate the phone call. I gotta run, like I
- 36:53said, I went along, and I'd sayment gotta take her final break back
- 36:57to wrap up hour number one. Right after this. Jack potts are in
- 37:10the millions here in West Virginia. Who does not want to be a millionaire?
- 37:14Get into powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays, and Saturday's Mega Millions drawings are
- 37:19Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big winner? Play today?
- 37:22The powerball jack pot is three hundred thirteen million dollars. Mega Millions jack pot
- 37:27is fifty two million dollars. Dave Wilson sing in for Hoppy Kirchivill. Let
- 37:34me get to some text, Dave. Most of my work in oil and
- 37:37gas can be done remotely, so I can sit on my mountaintop home and
- 37:40Tucker County while doing work in your guest subject counties. No one hundred,
- 37:45fifty or sixty wants to live in those twenty two counties. Let me see
- 37:52they are correct. That's all the texture, says Dave. Typical Democrat talking
- 37:58point from your last game. Take even more money from successful business through higher
- 38:02taxes and reinvest it in the in their pet projects to do transition, to
- 38:07transition the public to something they don't want. Day. The last guy totally
- 38:13left out royalty in the towns where people live big payments. He's not from
- 38:16here or he'd know better. Day. The anti fossil fuel guide does not
- 38:22understand causation versus correlation. The industry has the highest severance and mineral property taxes
- 38:28of surrounding states, Dave, How much fossil fuel money do you take a
- 38:34lot of pushback from you on that expert in natural gas, because it's not
- 38:38what you wanted to hear, not an expert in natural gas. And look,
- 38:45it is fair to say that the fracking boom didn't live up to all
- 38:52the hype. Member they remember the game change your talk from about a decade
- 38:57ago. That's a fair criticism. But to say that fracking is driving population
- 39:02loss in those counties, I think there are other factors at play, a
- 39:07lot of other factors at play, and there have been measurable benefits to it.
- 39:13So I think it's it's a broader look than to just say this one
- 39:17factor drove population loss. And that's the point I was really just I could
- 39:23not make the connection to fun first hour, at least I thought. So
- 39:28we'll get back to the Republican presidential primary debate that is tonight. Gary Abernathy
- 39:32going to join us at the top of the hour, and then we'll totally
- 39:36switch gears. We'll talk a little high school football coming up toward the end
- 39:39of the show as well with the SSAC kickoff game tonight. Doddridge is at
- 39:45front of the mine Doddridge County in Saint Mary's tonight. Dave Wilson in for
- 39:47Hoppy Kurtz What's talk Line on Metro News The Voice of West Virginia, our
- 40:04number two Metro News talk line underway. Dave Wilson sitting in for Hoppy Kerchival.
- 40:10Hoppy's just taking some time off. I'm sure he's just relaxing, curled
- 40:16up with a good book, nestled next to the fire. Well it's August.
- 40:20Maybe he's not nestled next to the fire, maybe next to the air
- 40:22conditioning. Eight hundred and seven six five talks the phone number three or four
- 40:25Talk three or four is the text line. More presidential debate talk this hour.
- 40:30Also Scott Cochrane, Principal Doddridge County High School, We'll join us,
- 40:35and the voice of high school sports in West Virginia, Fred Hersinger, will
- 40:38be by as high school football kicks off tonight with the SSAC kickoff game Saint
- 40:45Mary's at Doddridge County. Watch it at the Metro News Channel and on AT
- 40:49and T sports Net. Joining us now on Metronews talk Line. The contributing
- 40:54columnist for The Washington Post, former executive in the West Virginia Republican Party,
- 41:00and friend of the show, Gary Abernathy, Gary, good morning, Good
- 41:02morning, Dave. How are you, I'm doing well. I tossed this
- 41:06out to listeners in the first segments and asked them, what do you want
- 41:12to ask? If you had one question, Brett Bear, Martha McCollum,
- 41:15turn it over to you, Gary, what would you ask the presidential candidates
- 41:20tonight? Why are you here? That would be my question, because this
- 41:25is Trump's nomination. I mean, there's there's two tiers. There's two tiers
- 41:31in the eyes of Republicans, most Republican voters. Let's be honest. The
- 41:36first tier has Donald Trump and the second tier has all these other people.
- 41:42It's something that I thought would would change over time. It's something I thought
- 41:45should change over time. You know, Dave, I was a Trump supporter,
- 41:50still like most of what he did as president, but when he refused
- 41:53to accept the election results, etc. It's my opinion voters should look elsewhere.
- 41:59But clearly polls tell us voters aren't looking elsewhere. They're very, very
- 42:04satisfied overall by huge margins with Donald Trump. And so I really you know
- 42:13this debate tonight, Dave. You know you're going to have people, some
- 42:15of them like Chris Christi and Asa Hutchinson. They're gonna beat up on Donald
- 42:20Trump even though he's not there, and that's that's what they should do.
- 42:22That's strategically what they should do. A lot of people are going to be
- 42:25defending Trump, a lot of people are going to be picking on Ron DeSantis
- 42:29or targeting folks like you know, Ramaswamy and so on. But this is
- 42:35all about Trump. He's not going to be there. To me, this
- 42:38is just an exercise and as someone who enjoys politics, I'll enjoy watching it.
- 42:44But a few months from now, Donald Trump's going to be the Republican
- 42:46nominee. There's not much mystery about that. But is this a problem for
- 42:52the Republican Party? Then? Gary to have the presumptive nominee here is facing
- 42:57four indictments, He's going to have to spend a lot of time in over
- 43:00the next year, and we're talking about him. Nobody is bringing up Some
- 43:06of the Texters are bringing up because they actually want to hear some policy debate.
- 43:07But nobody's bringing up the economy to Ukraine, the border, any of
- 43:13the failings of the by administration. We're talking about Donald Trump here, You
- 43:16and I we're talking about Donald Trump. Is that a problemactly, it's a
- 43:21big problem. And this is this is one thing, you know, one
- 43:23reason even though I think Trump should not be president again, I'm against these
- 43:28indictments in part because especially you know, most of them outside of the classified
- 43:34documents indictment, I think most of them really don't have a chance of conviction.
- 43:38And I think that the two state indictments are really just completely unnecessary.
- 43:45They're just very political. The only ones that have any merit would be the
- 43:47two that are federal indictments. And if we could get down to those two,
- 43:52we wouldn't maybe be talking so much about the indictments. As you say,
- 43:55there's four indictments. Who knows there may be more to come. I've
- 43:59heard other states making noise about maybe they're going to do it and diet into
- 44:04Eventually it just becomes more sound. But you're right, Dave, we're not
- 44:07talking about issues. You know, Trump sucks up all the oxygen and so
- 44:13but some of the candidates tonight, I think to break through, they will
- 44:15try to focus on issues. They will lay out their three or four point
- 44:20plan for the economy or foreign policy or for the environment or whatever it may
- 44:25be. But you know, you know what's going to be at the headlines
- 44:30tomorrow, Dave, you know what's going to make the headlines are the shots
- 44:32taken at Trump. Are what people have to say about Trump. And the
- 44:37moderators, because this is a ratings driven situation, are probably going to ask
- 44:42about Trump. They're going to try to pick these candidates against each other about
- 44:46Trump. So this will be all about Trump. Well, we're talking to
- 44:50Gary Abernathia, contributing columnists for The Washington Post, former executive West Virginia Republican
- 44:53Party Gary. Tomorrow, will the story even be the debate President Trump scheduled
- 45:00to turn himself into authorities in Atlanta. Yeah, we may not even be
- 45:05talking about the debate at this point tomorrow morning. No, probably not.
- 45:08That's a very good point. You probably have about an hour or two post
- 45:12debate analysis where we'll still focus on this, and then it'll all be back
- 45:15to Trump tomorrow, which he knows well when he could have waited until Friday
- 45:20to turn himself in, but he's gonna He's gonna do it tomorrow, and
- 45:23you know, take all the oxygen from from this debate again. Probably,
- 45:28like you, Dave is someone who's interested in politics and enjoys the political season,
- 45:32even though it never ends now. I'm I'm looking forward to watching the
- 45:37debate. I want to hear these folks. But listen, I'm just when
- 45:42you look at poll after poll, and no matter the Trump's right when he
- 45:45said before the fourth indictment and he said, I just need one more indictment,
- 45:50I just need one more indictment to guarantee my victory, to guarantee my
- 45:55election, to guarantee and he's probably right. You know, he gets stronger
- 46:00with every indictment because Republicans by and large, obviously we know there are exceptions,
- 46:07Republicans by and large rally around him, recircle the wagons against what they
- 46:14think are these unfair attacks against him. Is there can one of these candidates
- 46:19separate themselves. Can they make up some ground and at least make Trump sweat
- 46:23a little bit going into the primary season. The only way to do that.
- 46:29And I know Chris Christie fan never have been you know, just politically
- 46:31speaking, but Christy is taking the right approach. If you're going to run
- 46:36against Donald Trump, you need to run against Donald Trump. You can't be
- 46:40defending Trump. You can't be seen to pile on the whole. Trump's a
- 46:45victim of the deep state. And the swamp and so on is out to
- 46:50get him. You've got to be someone who's willing to say what Trump's done
- 46:53is wrong and we should all be against it, and we should all be
- 46:58You've got to really stake that out. But you have folks like DeSantis,
- 47:02Ramaswami obviously, even Mike Pence to a degree, who kind of walks back
- 47:08and forth between, you know, defending Trump. If you're going to defend
- 47:13Trump, all you're doing is making Trump stronger. All you're doing is helping
- 47:16his candidacy. Or maybe, in the case of a couple of folks,
- 47:20maybe they're kind of auditioning for the vice presidential role when Trump gets around to
- 47:24making that decision. Talking to Gary Abernathy, contributing columnist for The Washington Post,
- 47:29why hasn't the DeSantis campaign been able to get traction? Well, it's
- 47:35a good that's a good question. It always starts with the top, Dave.
- 47:37I think the answer to any failed campaign, you know, usually starts
- 47:40with the candidate not being someone who catches on. Desanta seems to, you
- 47:45know, present himself as I'm Trump without the baggage, I'm Trump without all
- 47:51the negativity, which which made a lot of sense early on, but it's
- 47:54just not you know, Republicans instead are saying, well, yeah, you're
- 47:59you're kind of trump blight. We like real coke, we like the real
- 48:01thing we've we've got Trump, so we like your you know, all the
- 48:06polls show that people who like Trump tend to like to Santus, But in
- 48:09their minds, why do we want to go somewhere else We've still got We've
- 48:14still got Trump. Plus De Santis has had an issue with what they call
- 48:16the likability problem. You know, he's not he doesn't seem to be the
- 48:22people person. Some people want the retail campaigner that is very helpful to be
- 48:25like Trump obviously is. And so he's just you know, again, when
- 48:30you have a staff shake up, that sends a bad message. It's it's
- 48:35maybe necessary sometimes, but it also makes people think, well, you don't
- 48:37have your act together. You've had to shake up your whole staff. So
- 48:40he's just not caught on. This may not be Ron de Sandus's time,
- 48:45although maybe four years from now it will be. Again, Gary, when
- 48:52I when I look at any race, whether it's a Republican or Democrat,
- 48:54it can be either side. My question always comes back to this, what's
- 48:58the winning strategy in November? If you can win the primary, and you
- 49:01can win the primary a landslide, but can you win in November for Republicans?
- 49:07Is nominating Donald Trump a winning strategy for November? I don't think so.
- 49:14I mean, I think that's your weakest strategy. Now. When it
- 49:16comes to any given election, anything can happen. People who say Trump can't
- 49:22win, I've thought that, I've probably said that before, But the reality
- 49:28is anything can happen. I mean, if the economy really tanks, if
- 49:31Biden's the nominee and he really just has a bad few months for whatever reason
- 49:37might be. You know, even Trump could look preferable in some circumstances.
- 49:43But it's the worst case. It's He's the worst chance that Republicans have.
- 49:47I think someone like a Nicki Haley probably or Tim Scott gives us the best
- 49:52broadest appeal for Republicans come November of twenty twenty four. I think that,
- 49:59you know, but the trouble is, you know, under our system,
- 50:01you got to get through the primary, and Trump is just such a favorite
- 50:07through the primary. So I think you're right. I think the best chance
- 50:09of Republicans would have are going to be a different direction if winning in November
- 50:13of twenty twenty four is the goal, which it should be, But that's
- 50:15not the direction the GOP's going, Dave. It's it's going to be Trump.
- 50:22Well, it kind of makes me shake my head. And I understand
- 50:24the appeal, Garrett. Don't get me wrong. I get it. I
- 50:28understand why folks still gravitate toward him. But if you if you are conservative,
- 50:35you're Republican, you want to win the White House, I'm like you,
- 50:37I don't see that as a as a winning strategy because even if President
- 50:42Biden has you know, the economy goes south, or he makes gaff after
- 50:47gaff to after gaff, that's not what's going to be talked about for the
- 50:51next twelve months. There's there's four indictments and President Trump cannot stay off of
- 50:57well, it's truth, social right, truth, social, he can't stay
- 50:59off We're not gonna be talking we media at large. Widen's not going to
- 51:04be the story. It's going to be Trump and that you know, I'm
- 51:07no expert strategies here, Gary, but that's not a winning formula in November.
- 51:12No, No, you're right, Dave, Except for one thing.
- 51:16The media is like one of the and it's sad, it's unfortunate. I
- 51:20hate it because I'm part of it. You're part of it. But the
- 51:22media has lower ratings than most politicians, in some cases even worse than Donald
- 51:28Trump, and so there's not a lot of trust there. So the pile
- 51:30on effect. This is why, this is why I was sorry to see
- 51:34all the indictments come. There's a risk of not just Republicans, but even
- 51:38swing voters eventually saying, wait a minute, this is just overkill, this
- 51:44is just ridiculous, and even them coming to the defense of Donald Trump when
- 51:47it seems like all the powers of the state, and especially there's no doubt
- 51:52about it, you have to be cautious, cautious and aware of the situation
- 51:59where it looks like the Biden administration, especially on these federal indictments. The
- 52:02Biden administration his you know, Trump's main opponent, if the one bringing to
- 52:08bear the powers of the government, the federal government against Joe Biden's top political
- 52:14rival, that's a real concern that will just grow as time goes by.
- 52:20So Gary Abernathy, contributing columnists from The Washington Post, former executive with the
- 52:24West Virginia Republican Party. I'm going to break the talk line syllabus. You
- 52:29want to come back tomorrow, we'll do a little post view of the debate.
- 52:30See if anything stuck out to you, check your skate. I know,
- 52:34I just put you on the spot. Yeah, no, I think
- 52:36I can do that. So yeah, unless I find a conflict I can't
- 52:38think of right now, let's do it, Dave. I'll have my people
- 52:42call your people. You'll have to call me, but that'll be fine.
- 52:45Trust me, Gary, I don't have any Hoppy does not give me any
- 52:49people when he goes out of town. Okay, appreciate it, Gary,
- 52:52thanks much, handling it yourself. Yeah, that's it. That's it,
- 52:57Gary, I appreciate it. Thanks so much. Okay, all right.
- 53:00Gary Abernathy, contributing columnist, Washington Post. Yeah, we'll happen back tomorrow.
- 53:04I'm interested to hear his post view on this tomorrow before Trump is arrested.
- 53:09And you know, fingerprinting eight hundred seven six five talks the phone number
- 53:14three or four Talk three or four is the text line. I'm interested to
- 53:16hear your opinions. We'll get to those next Metro News talk line with hobby
- 53:32Kirchibill is brought to you by in Covid Insurance, encircling you with coverage to
- 53:37protect what you care about most. Visit incovid dot com to learn more.
- 53:42Three or four Talk three or four is the text line your thoughts? What
- 53:45would you ask the candicks? What do you want to hear? Are you
- 53:49gonna watch the football game instead? Not about the debate doesn't start till nine
- 53:54o'clock, which I am a very very early riser. That is late for
- 54:00me. I need an extra cup of coffee tomorrow morning. I suppose text
- 54:07line three or four talk three or four Dave. If Joe B and Donald
- 54:12T are the choices, I'll be voting for Joe Mansion or some other third
- 54:15party candidate. Yeah, it's a good question about Mansion. Non committal,
- 54:28noncommittal, Still don't know exactly what he's going to do it. No,
- 54:31I do not think a third party candidate can win, but a third party
- 54:37candidate could certainly influence this election, if if it's Mansion or someone else.
- 54:43Because I do believe, and I don't have a lot of data sitting here
- 54:46in front of me, this is a bit of a gut reaction kind of
- 54:52a gut feeling. There are a lot of people who are well, actually,
- 54:53there is plenty of data to back this up. People who are dissatisfied
- 54:57with both Trump and Biden and would love a viable third option. But across
- 55:06the country historically you could get maybe ten percent, maybe twelve thirteen percent.
- 55:14I don't see a third party candidate winning any electoral votes, but could certainly
- 55:21influence the outcome of the election. Could that be Joe Manson? We'll have
- 55:25to wait and see. Dave Trump gets arrested for pointing out the truth.
- 55:30The election fraud was and is real. The lockdown's coming for more mail in
- 55:36voter fraud. No, there was the election. No. I mean that's
- 55:42no, there was no voter fraud. Are we going to do that?
- 55:50Let see three or four? Talk three or four. Dave Garry's right,
- 55:53The only federal charges should likely be only the federal charges should be pursued.
- 55:58The bigger goal here is to broadbrush nationally, to have Trump situation impact the
- 56:02state races for the GOP and to finish those candidates chances for re election slash
- 56:08election day. Forty eight percent of Republicans don't want Trump in the polls.
- 56:15I can't understand why people think he can't be beat When we get down to
- 56:19a couple of candidates, he can look, the polling numbers are what they
- 56:25are right now. Can he be beat? Sure? Trump himself proved in
- 56:34sixteen that anybody can win, that the polls don't always get it right.
- 56:39But I have not seen data to support one that any of these candidates on
- 56:45stage tonight can beat him in the primary. Maybe. But two, I've
- 56:51also not seen any data that indicates that he can win. That Trump can
- 56:54win in November. And if you are the Republican Party, that is my
- 56:58question to you, what is your strut of two win in November? Do
- 57:02you want to win in November or not? I just don't see data that
- 57:08supports that he can do that. Even with the failings of the Biden administration.
- 57:17There are plenty of things to attack and criticize the Biden administration. Four,
- 57:22I just don't see the numbers there. I don't see the data yet.
- 57:27Could it happen? Sure? I think there is a path there.
- 57:30If you have low voter turnout, if you have a third party candidate who
- 57:32draws away from the Democratic ticket, Sure there's a pathway there three or four
- 57:39Talk three or four, Dave. The reason most Republicans are still supporting Trump
- 57:43is that they see what is happening right now to him and is wrong and
- 57:46could happen to them in this faux free speech, fascist state our country is
- 57:54now in. It is also actual election interference in which these Marxists are trying
- 58:00to pick the GOP candidate for the voters. Truth is, they're scared to
- 58:04death that Donald Trump's policies struck a chord with the working class patriots. Network
- 58:09security is serious business, and sitting net is serious about protecting your business and
- 58:15your employees from today's constant barrage of cybersecurity threats. Let's sitting net be your
- 58:19cybersecurity hero. Learn more at cittynet dot net. We get some more of
- 58:23your text phone calls. Of course, they're always welcome as well. Eight
- 58:27hundred seven six five Talk is the phone number, three or four Talk three
- 58:30or four is the text line on the other side of the news break.
- 58:32We'll switch gears a little bit. Take a deep breath. I'm gonna talk
- 58:36to the principal at Doddridge County High School, Scott Cochrane. His bulldogs will
- 58:39be taking on the Saint Mary's Blue Devils tonight in the SSAC kickoff game.
- 58:45As the high school football season gets underway, we'll see what's going on in
- 58:47West Union today. Also, the voice of high school sports, Fred per
- 58:52Singer, will stop by Metro News high School Sports Line season debut tonights and
- 58:59of course it'll be in the host chair along with Dave Jacquelin and Joe Braccado.
- 59:02Get to some more of your text as well before we call it a
- 59:06day. At the top of the hour, eight hundred seven six five talks.
- 59:09The phone number at three or four Talk three or four is the text
- 59:13line. All right, we'll talk to doctors. County Principal Scott Conchran coming
- 59:15up on the other side of the news break, Fred per Singer a couple
- 59:19of minutes from now as well. Ethan Collins running the phones today. Luke
- 59:22Rowsy, it's his first day flying totally solo on the video stream. As
- 59:27far as I can tell, he's doing a fantastic job. Right now,
- 59:30we're gonna get a news update. It's talk Line on Metro News, the
- 59:32Voice of West Virginia just her. Chris Lawrence mentioned in the Metro News update
- 59:52The SSAC kickoff game is tonight, presented by in Taro Resources. It'll be
- 59:59the same Mary's Blue Devils visiting the Doddridge County Bulldogs. Watch the game at
- 1:00:04ww metronews dot com, on the Metro News Channel, and on AT and
- 1:00:07T Sports Pittsburgh. Joining me this morning the principal at Doddridge County High School,
- 1:00:12Scott Cochran. Scott, good morning, good morning, good morning.
- 1:00:15How are you doing today? I'm doing well. How are things in West
- 1:00:19Union this morning? Things in West Union are awesome, great place, great
- 1:00:23place, and we're excited for the day. Are all the students back for
- 1:00:28the start of the school year. We are are back in session. We
- 1:00:30started last Wednesday with our first day for students, so we are often running
- 1:00:35and things are going well. I can't get used Scott to school starting in
- 1:00:39the middle of August. Now I understand it, it is the way it
- 1:00:43is, but I just I can't get used to it. It feels like
- 1:00:45it's still summertime. What it is still summertime to some degree it is.
- 1:00:50It is. It's different, But I'll tell you what. Our students here
- 1:00:52and our staff are just amazing on a daily basis. They come in and
- 1:00:57get right to work. Our students are our focused on all of the opportunities
- 1:01:01of Dodgers County has provided for them, and they're taking advantage of those opportunities.
- 1:01:07I would like to thank Superintendent Chieaveman and the Dodgers County Board of Education
- 1:01:10for the vision that they have set forward for our students, and also to
- 1:01:15the residents of Dodgers County for their continued support of our students here in Dodgors
- 1:01:20County. It's a great place. What are some of the opportunities. I
- 1:01:22think folks are pretty aware of the still almost brand new school up on the
- 1:01:29hill there, the immaculate facilities you have, But what are some of the
- 1:01:32opportunities those facilities provide students at Dodgers County High School. Yeah, just to
- 1:01:37build up on that comment there. You know, there's great traditions here in
- 1:01:43Dodgers County, both athletically and academically, and the opportunities are endless here for
- 1:01:49our students. We are we are kind of on the cutting edge of providing
- 1:01:52some opportunities for us students here to make this successful in life. Let's not
- 1:01:59post secondary entering the workforce with some skills, right, out of high school
- 1:02:02where they can go into our workforce here in the area and and be very
- 1:02:07successful. We provided some localized curriculums that lead to students obtaining skills and certifications
- 1:02:15that can we get them right into a job perform graduation. We really expanded
- 1:02:22our collaborations with our institutions of higher ed. We have fifteen students on track
- 1:02:28this year to finish with an associate's degree. We are offering around four hundred
- 1:02:34and thirty eight dual credit classes this school year to our students. So things
- 1:02:39are moving, thanks are moving, and it's just a good place. And
- 1:02:43I think that's evident again by the tradition. I believe there's thirty ninth state
- 1:02:46championships in the history of the school. Here. We're coming off our second
- 1:02:51year of top ten finish academically in the state. We're the highest ranked small
- 1:02:55school district as it relates to academic performance. So it's just a good place
- 1:03:00to be and I'm thrilled and blessed to be a part of this uh this
- 1:03:04district, And Scott was I was talking about this yesterday. I was talking
- 1:03:07to Saint Mary's principal, Laurie Barnhardt that when you are the only school in
- 1:03:13town or the only school in the county. The community support the school and
- 1:03:19the community. There's really no separation there. Like Doddridge County is green and
- 1:03:23gold, Saint Mary's is purple and gold. The community is the school,
- 1:03:28the school is the community, and that's a special bond that sometimes it's hard
- 1:03:31to explain if you're, uh, you know, you haven't been a part
- 1:03:34of that type of a tight knit community. Totally agree, correct on that
- 1:03:39point, and it is it is just the community support. It's overwhelming here
- 1:03:45and I think the people that attend the event tonight will see that from the
- 1:03:49time they get here till the when the lights go off, you know,
- 1:03:52later tonight. But it is it's just it's just an amazing place and the
- 1:03:57students are blessed and the staff year is just I need to point that out.
- 1:04:01I have a tremendous staff here at Dotters Channing High School. They go
- 1:04:04above and belong on the daily basis. And what that said again, Dodters
- 1:04:09County continues to be ranked in the top five districts to work in statewide,
- 1:04:13So that's evident, evident on what's going on here on a daily basis.
- 1:04:16Talking to Scott Cochrane. He's the principal at Doddridge County High School. At
- 1:04:19Saint Mary's versus Doddridge in the SSAC Kickoff game presented by in Taro Resources.
- 1:04:25That's coming up tonight. Watch it at the Metro News Channel or on at
- 1:04:28and T Sports Pittsburgh. I said yesterday also that we talk a lot about
- 1:04:32what we need to fix with education, what's broken, where we can get
- 1:04:36better at, what's right, what's going on that's that's right with education in
- 1:04:42particular. You know at Doddridge County High School. Well, I'll tell you
- 1:04:45what our focus here again, our focus Doctors County is built upon two fundamental
- 1:04:49principles and that his character and commitment. Those both both of those characteristics are
- 1:04:57discussed with our with our students here. Basis, both of those characteristics lead
- 1:05:01to be successful, just not in school, been in life. The positive
- 1:05:04relationships that we build with students here on a daily basis, it impacts them,
- 1:05:10It makes a difference, and that's our message to our students, and
- 1:05:14that's what we continue to build upon the last couple of years. It's just
- 1:05:17creating a positive environment that they want to be here. They enjoy this place,
- 1:05:25and we as adults, provide them with opportunities to make them successful.
- 1:05:30You know, Scott, since it's the you know, the kickoff game,
- 1:05:32it's going to be on television. It's on a Wednesday night. I tried
- 1:05:35to, you know, push Principal Barnhart over at Saint Mary's into us some
- 1:05:39sort of a friendly wager between you two, and she said you two could
- 1:05:45work it out. I was, I'm trying to make something happen here,
- 1:05:47just to make it a little bit more interesting. I'm sure that we will
- 1:05:50have a discussion here to see me prior to kickoff. I'm looking forward to
- 1:05:57having that discussion and I will be up to that channel. I have all.
- 1:06:00I have all my trust and faith and Coach Burnside and his staff,
- 1:06:05his resume and the tradition he's built with this program continues to amaze me.
- 1:06:12But he does an amazing job, and I just wish I wish both team
- 1:06:15success tonight and hopefully everyone comes out injury free. Is there a little extras
- 1:06:18excitement? You're the only show in town tonight. It is, man,
- 1:06:24It's just a tremendous opportunity. And again, this is one of those things
- 1:06:28that you know, I probably need to thank mister Price and his staff with
- 1:06:31the w SSAC to providing this opportunity for student athletes, and it's going to
- 1:06:36be one of those things, but they're going to make memories and they're going
- 1:06:39to remember this for the rest of their life. So we are looking forward
- 1:06:42to it for sure. Scott Cochran, Principal at Doddridge County High School.
- 1:06:45Again, it's the SSAC Kickoff game presented by in Taro Resources, Saint Mary's
- 1:06:48and Doddridge County. Watching on the Metro News Channel at ww metronews dot com
- 1:06:54or at and T Sports Pittsburgh. Scott, good luck tonight, good luck
- 1:06:58for the school year and the rest the season as well. Thank you so
- 1:07:01much, thanks for having me. Absolutely. Coming up, we'll talk a
- 1:07:04little more high school football. The voice of high school sports in West Virginia
- 1:07:09Hall of Famer Fred Persinger will join me next Dave Wilson in the big chair
- 1:07:12for Hopy Kirchible. We'll get some more of your texts as well at three
- 1:07:15or four Talk three oh four. The text line. WU Medicine Dermatology offers
- 1:07:19comprehensive services for adults and children. Board certified dermatologists treat a variety of skin
- 1:07:26conditions from acne to complicated skin cancers. Schedule and evaluation online at my wv
- 1:07:31chart dot com or call eight five five WVU Care. Metro News talk Line
- 1:07:48with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you with
- 1:07:53coverage to protect what do you care about most? Visiting coovid dot com to
- 1:07:57learn more. Jack bonds are the millions here in West Virginian Who does not
- 1:08:08want to be a millionaire? Get in the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and
- 1:08:12Saturday's. Megabillion's drawings are Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big
- 1:08:16winner? Play today? The Powerball and jackpot is three hundred and thirteen million
- 1:08:19dollars. The Megamillions jackpot is fifty two million dollars. SSAC kickoff game tonight
- 1:08:27St. Mary's and Doddridge County. Also Tonight's on the Metro News Radio Network,
- 1:08:30the season debut of the Metro News High School Sports Line. Fred Purse,
- 1:08:34Singer, Dave Jacqueline and Joe Braccado will be your guides and joining us
- 1:08:39now on Metro News Talk Line the voice of high school sports in West Virginia,
- 1:08:43the one, the only, the impeccable Fred Pursinger, Fred, Good
- 1:08:45morning, Fred M I don't think Frank can here? Good morning? Are
- 1:08:57you sir? Very are Fred? Oh? I'm here, but you can't
- 1:09:01hear me? Huh? I can hear you? Can you hear me?
- 1:09:06You know what? I know what the problem is. I think I know
- 1:09:10what the problem is. And Fred's eight seconds behind me. That's what the
- 1:09:15problem is. I think. Let's see, Fred, did we get the
- 1:09:20delay fixed? All right? Tell you what, We'll take a break.
- 1:09:26We'll get this straightened out, because clearly it's the first day in radio for
- 1:09:29both Fred and me. It happens. We'll figure it out. Eight hundred
- 1:09:34seven six five talks. The phone number three or four Talk three or four
- 1:09:38is the text line. We'll figure this out, I promise you. Fred
- 1:09:41Persinger Animal, Are you ready to start your career? The path to employment
- 1:09:57can sometimes feel overwhelming. Workforce West Virginia is here to guide you every step
- 1:10:00of the way. We understand the challenges you face. Where to begin and
- 1:10:04how to stand out from the crowd and finding the right opportunity. With Workforce
- 1:10:09West Virginia you can access resources, personalized guidance and hidden opportunities. Discover apprenticeship
- 1:10:15programs and virtual job fairs tailored to your interest. When you're ready to start
- 1:10:19your career, start with Workforce West Virginia. Visit workforce ww dot org to
- 1:10:23learn more this outreach campaign. It's one percent financed by federal funds. All
- 1:10:28right, we've got them all straightened out. I gave the big introduction before
- 1:10:30Fred Pursing or choice to sew Metro News talk line. Hey Fred, Hey
- 1:10:33buddy, you know what it is is that eight second delay is kind of
- 1:10:38the final fail safe. Once you introduced me, folks still have eight seconds
- 1:10:42to say do I want to hang around for this or not? You know,
- 1:10:44these do have time, But I fixed that, so now they don't
- 1:10:46have time. They're stuck. Now they're stuck with It's right, all right.
- 1:10:49First of all, SSAC kickoff game tonight Saint Mary's Doddridge. A lot
- 1:10:54of tradition with both these teams, but both teams like all high school teams,
- 1:10:57Fred, and that's kind of the beauty of the sport having to adjust
- 1:11:00from graduation. So it should be an interesting matchup tonight. I think it
- 1:11:02will be you and I were talking earlier in the fact that a lot of
- 1:11:05folks on the success that Doddridge County Bobby Burnside has had recently, certainly Jody
- 1:11:11Mode always has a great team in Saint Mary's, but most folks over the
- 1:11:14last four or five years early game would say, well, Doddridge County's got
- 1:11:16the edge, and they may tonight. I just don't think it's that cut
- 1:11:19and drive. I think it's going to be a great ball game tonight,
- 1:11:23I really do should be a lot of fun. You can watch it at
- 1:11:25the Metro News channel ww Metro News dot com, at and T Sportsnet,
- 1:11:29as well more games tomorrow night. And things really cranked up on Friday.
- 1:11:32What scots you excited here? Week one? I'll tell you you know,
- 1:11:36it's just week one, you know. I High School Sports Line begins tonight
- 1:11:41and tonight a custom our guests are going to include the state champions from last
- 1:11:45year. We'll have Billy Seals on, We'll have John Lily on, and
- 1:11:49we will have coach Baits of course from Williamstown on. Also, I'm going
- 1:11:56to have on Wayne Ryan. We're going to talk about a golf tournament for
- 1:11:58the girls. It's coming up the Monday of Labor Day that area. And
- 1:12:02then also we're gonna be talking with who is my other Oh, we're going
- 1:12:08to bring back Dave Walker because he transferred back. Did you? I don't
- 1:12:15know, And I'm sure this transfer rule is going to come up. I'm
- 1:12:16not a fan. I hate it. I don't think it's right, but
- 1:12:18it is what it is. And we have a few legislators to thank for
- 1:12:21that. That's another story. But still be a lot of things come up
- 1:12:26tonight, and then of course, as you mentioned, a lot of good
- 1:12:28games coming up tomorrow around the state. And then on Friday, it really
- 1:12:32really does kick off. I know the team that you cover is going to
- 1:12:35be in action. University and Morgantown will be in action, and it's going
- 1:12:40to be all over the state. Spring Valley is going to be at Huntington
- 1:12:42this year. Only lost Huntington had last year was at one point lost to
- 1:12:45Spring Valley, So we'll see what happens there. And the Martinsburg's going to
- 1:12:49Ironton, Ohio on Saturday afternoon for a game. So a lot of good
- 1:12:53stuff to open it up. And yeah, football's underway and you can't ever
- 1:12:57forget about Graham and Bluefield where they'll be about ten thousand people down at the
- 1:13:00Mitchell Stadium on Friday night. So it is high school football time. It's
- 1:13:04the best time of the year. I was going to ask you that,
- 1:13:09Fred, from the time this goes back to one's five six years old going
- 1:13:14to watch you know, Saint Mary's high school games on a Friday night,
- 1:13:17being a player, now as a as a broadcaster, it's still my favorite
- 1:13:21time of the year. It has it has a smell to it, it
- 1:13:26has a feel to it. I can't describe it, but I love it.
- 1:13:29I enjoy it, and I try to tell these I'm getting to be
- 1:13:31an old guy, Fred, I try to tell these young guys to enjoy
- 1:13:34it while at last. It goes by so quickly, but it is absolutely
- 1:13:36the best time of year. It definitely is for those that are getting to
- 1:13:40play the game, and even for those that go to the games and get
- 1:13:43to run on the sidelines, you know, behind the fence, if there's
- 1:13:45a fence there. That's how I remember watching it when I was young.
- 1:13:48So I am just so so fortunate that even at my age I get to
- 1:13:53stay and have a hand still into it, and it's a fun time.
- 1:13:57It really is, and it is my favorite time of the year. And
- 1:13:59I'm I'll get back with Dave Jacquelin if he hasn't transferred on me, I
- 1:14:02find that out tonight, I guess. But now we're looking forward to year
- 1:14:05number twenty two of Game Night. Yeah, when you start a game when
- 1:14:10that first season of Game Night, did you think it would take off the
- 1:14:14way it did? It's a staple now. People not only want to listen
- 1:14:17Fred, they expect to hear you on a Friday night. You know,
- 1:14:20I when I first started it, I didn't think. I didn't think that
- 1:14:25much of it, to be honest with you know, I had a job
- 1:14:27to do and I had to go do the job. But after the first
- 1:14:29night, I looked at Jacquelin and I said, we got a chance here
- 1:14:31because the phones were crazy. It was just unbelievable the response that was given
- 1:14:39to that program, and that first year it just flew by. And I'm
- 1:14:43honest when I say, those fourteen weeks really go by fast. Dave and
- 1:14:46I'll look at each other and it'll be the tenth week of the season.
- 1:14:48So are you kidding me? Regular season is over with already? But that's
- 1:14:54just the way it goes. But it's not Fred, it's not Dave.
- 1:14:57It's high school football and that's what makes it special. Yeah, that's absolutely
- 1:15:00Do you do you remember the first game you ever called, the first game
- 1:15:03I ever called, the first game you ever called on radio. It was
- 1:15:09Beckley Woodrow Wilson playing Charleston Catholic. It's when Charleston Catholic had a football team.
- 1:15:13Wow. Beckley Woodrow Wilson was of course a Triple A team at the
- 1:15:16time, and Charleston Catholic, Uh, I guess they had to be double
- 1:15:21A. But anyways, only lost Beckley gotten a kevil out of the playoffs,
- 1:15:25they only took four, only took four teams that year, and that
- 1:15:29was the one at god Him. So yeah, I remember it well.
- 1:15:31Is there an archive of that somewhere? Fred? I hope not. I
- 1:15:36hope not. I hope there's not an archive of the first year of Game
- 1:15:41Night. To be quite honest with you, as Dave and I, we've
- 1:15:43learned so much and uh wow, it is just so fun to talk with
- 1:15:47play by play cruise across the state and we get cheerleaders calling in, we
- 1:15:51get players calling in. Of course, we get coaches calling in. Uh,
- 1:15:55it's just it's a fun show to do. I don't think we realized
- 1:15:59and I'll give credit where it's due Dale Miller's idea, And I don't think
- 1:16:03we really knew what we had when we first started it because our scoreboard on
- 1:16:08the network was a fifty minute show, and then it was a thirty minute
- 1:16:12show, and now all of a sudden, we're going to do two and
- 1:16:13a half hours. Are you kidding me? But it has been a tremendous,
- 1:16:17tremendous success, has more affiliates than any program we do on the network.
- 1:16:23It is a great time. It really is a great time, and
- 1:16:25I'm looking forward to Friday night. I really am. He is the voice
- 1:16:29of high school sports in West Virginia, Fred per Singer Again, it's the
- 1:16:30Mention News high School Sports Line coming up tonight seven h six until nine o'clock,
- 1:16:34following your regular sports line from six h six till seven, and then
- 1:16:40high school Game Night coming up Friday night after your local broadcast. Fred.
- 1:16:45If I don't talk to you before Friday night, have a great Wednesday,
- 1:16:49Thursday and game day Friday, and at the very minimum, I will talk
- 1:16:53to you Friday night. After the Mohegans take on South Charleston. I will
- 1:16:58look forward to it, my friend, all right, Fred Singer, Fred
- 1:17:00looking forward to it. Thank you everybody, all right, it's the best
- 1:17:03time of here it. Uh. You know, I I'm not that old,
- 1:17:10but I'm I'm an older guy now. But still you can't when you
- 1:17:15are a teenager, you don't heed the advice of the adults around you who
- 1:17:18say, enjoy it. It's gonna go by fast, and eventually your knees
- 1:17:21are going to hurt and your stories will be embellished. Well, it's true,
- 1:17:27it's all true. Let me get to a few texts here before we
- 1:17:30call it a day. Three or four talk three or four. H David
- 1:17:36is not Western high school sports without Fred. I agree, Hey, Dave
- 1:17:42sounds like Doddridge County has a great education system, but it's losing population.
- 1:17:45Therefore, great secondary education leads to population loss, says the text of referring
- 1:17:50back to the fracking conversation we had Dave. Donald Trump is a draft dodger
- 1:17:59who called soldiers who died on D Day in France suckers. No one else,
- 1:18:03no one who respects our military service can logically support him, says the
- 1:18:06Texter. I see three or four Talk three or four, Dave. Dear
- 1:18:16fellow West Virginians, please do not vote for anyone who has contributed to the
- 1:18:19national debt. These huge spinning bills like the I r A are destroying the
- 1:18:25dollar, raising our taxes, and increasing inflation. Let's wake up, Dave.
- 1:18:32You're blind if you think there was no voter fraud, and you're blind
- 1:18:35if you think Biden didn't take money from Ukraine. Uh sorry, if I'm
- 1:18:44not going to get to your text today, we got up. We got
- 1:18:45a bunch of them. I will try to do better tomorrow. Gary Abattathy
- 1:18:49will join us tomorrow. We'll get a post view of the GOP presidential primary
- 1:18:55debate tomorrow, so Gary will join us for that. Interested to hear your
- 1:19:00thoughts as well. Coming up on tomorrow's show three or four Talk three or
- 1:19:05four in eight hundred seven and six five eight two five five, we'll leave
- 1:19:09some open line opportunities for you again. SSAC kickoff game coming up tonight.
- 1:19:14Saint Mary's Dodd Rage watching at the Metro News Channel and at and T Sports
- 1:19:17Pittsburgh. Also Metro News High School Sports Line back across the network tonight as
- 1:19:21well. That'll kick off at seven oh six. Dave Wilson in for Hoppy
- 1:19:26Kurtzwilt's talk line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia