Latest / Surrounded / 1 Conservative vs 20 Liberals (ft. The Split’s Austin Julio Broughton) | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00You cannot sit up there and booty clap your cheek
- 0:02for Donald Trump.
- 0:04Do not interrupt a black trans woman when she's speaking.
- 0:06You're anti-black
- 0:08and you're queerphobic.
- 0:09Queerphobic and you're a raging misogynist.
- 0:12You need to unpack.
- 0:13Martin Luther King.
- 0:14What was he?
- 0:15What do you mean what was he?
- 0:16He was a Baptist preacher.
- 0:17You just don't want to say it.
- 0:18Did Joe Biden say he wanted a gay VP or did he say?
- 0:21Of the black people,
- 0:21he said,
- 0:22if you don't vote for me,
- 0:22you ain't black.
- 0:23Is the Republican Party more pro-free speech,
- 0:26or has the left become more willing to police it?
- 0:28I'm Paris Rose from Jubilee Media,
- 0:30and this is Surrounded,
- 0:32where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:35Today we're exploring abortion,
- 0:37civil rights,
- 0:38and Christianity.
- 0:39And if the left cares more about the LGBTQ community.
- 0:42Than black Americans.
- 0:43I'm here with our future guest,
- 0:45conservative Christian and co-host of The Split,
- 0:47Austin Julio Broughton.
- 0:48Hello,
- 0:49welcome in.
- 0:50How are you?
- 0:51I'm great.
- 0:51How are you?
- 0:52You know,
- 0:52to prepare for this,
- 0:53I've wrestled with alligators and I've tussled with whales,
- 0:55and I'm here to give each and every one of these liberals political debate hell.
- 0:59OK,
- 1:00love that.
- 1:01Well,
- 1:01debaters,
- 1:02are you guys ready?
- 1:04Alright,
- 1:05let's go.
- 1:05I'm Austin Julio Broad and I'm a Christian conservative host of Jubilee The Split,
- 1:09and today I have a dream.
- 1:11Actually,
- 1:11no,
- 1:11I take it back.
- 1:12I am in fact actually surrounded
- 1:14by 20 liberals.
- 1:16My first surrounding claim
- 1:18is that the left cares more about the LGBTQ community than black Americans.
- 1:22If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:23please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:30Just myself when I sit down.
- 1:34How you doing?
- 1:34How you doing,
- 1:34brother?
- 1:35Pretty good.
- 1:35Pretty good.
- 1:35What's your name?
- 1:36I'm Wayne Ramsey.
- 1:37Ramsey,
- 1:37Austin,
- 1:37nice to meet you.
- 1:38Nice to meet you as well.
- 1:39Not related to Pharaoh Ramsey,
- 1:40are you?
- 1:40No,
- 1:40I'm not,
- 1:41but that is where my grandfather got the name.
- 1:42Of course it is.
- 1:43Yeah,
- 1:43yeah.
- 1:44Uh,
- 1:44so let me,
- 1:45let me,
- 1:45before we begin,
- 1:46let me identify what it is I'm talking about.
- 1:48Get ready to be shocked,
- 1:49Internet.
- 1:49I am a conservative that believes black people are still owed a
- 1:51check from the US federal government because I'm very pro reparations.
- 1:54So
- 1:54what,
- 1:54what,
- 1:55um,
- 1:55what,
- 1:55what I'm talking about is the speed
- 1:58and efficiency
- 1:59that policy has been used to advocate for
- 2:02members of the LGBTQ community.
- 2:04I don't want,
- 2:04I do not want LGBTQIA citizens' rights slowed down.
- 2:08I just want black justice sped up.
- 2:09That's what I'm talking about,
- 2:10OK.
- 2:11So why do we have to juxtapose
- 2:14the two
- 2:15versus having an intersectional,
- 2:17like an intersectional view on I'll tell you why,
- 2:20because
- 2:20the,
- 2:20the thing for me is my black,
- 2:22the color of my skin should be enough to be
- 2:23seen by the US federal government at every level.
- 2:25When you identify as a member of the LGBTQI community,
- 2:28you're actually adding an additional
- 2:30level of delineation,
- 2:31uh,
- 2:31or you're becoming a minority within a minority.
- 2:33Which
- 2:34there's also,
- 2:34to be honest with you,
- 2:35there's still a white,
- 2:36uh,
- 2:36power structure within the LGBTQ community which allowed
- 2:38that movement to be seen at faster rates,
- 2:40um,
- 2:41and I think,
- 2:42you know,
- 2:42the biggest
- 2:43piece of evidence I would give to this is HR 40,
- 2:44which is the reparations task force proposal
- 2:47that the US government still hasn't authorized,
- 2:49whereas when Obergerfell,
- 2:51the,
- 2:51the,
- 2:51the Supreme Court case that legalized
- 2:53same-sex marriage,
- 2:54I think it took about.
- 2:55Around 58 years or so,
- 2:57fact check me on the left side
- 2:58for
- 2:59same-sex marriage to be,
- 3:00I,
- 3:00I,
- 3:00my,
- 3:01my only issue is,
- 3:02right,
- 3:02I think that
- 3:03Um,
- 3:04obviously as someone who
- 3:05is a double minority and like you've already mentioned,
- 3:08um,
- 3:09who has to live the life of both.
- 3:10OK,
- 3:11I can't take the color of my skin off,
- 3:12but I also can't change my sexuality as we already know.
- 3:15I don't think it's fair to say that
- 3:17one side,
- 3:18um,
- 3:18being the left,
- 3:19pushes for LGTBQ plus representation more or pushes for more advocacy for them,
- 3:24when in reality all you see is that in that community are black Americans.
- 3:27You can't remove the people that are there that are like me.
- 3:30No,
- 3:30no,
- 3:30no,
- 3:30and I'm not,
- 3:31let me be clear,
- 3:31I'm not.
- 3:32I'm not removing it.
- 3:33I'm just saying
- 3:34look at the rhetoric that the Democratic Party has used for the past 60 years,
- 3:37right?
- 3:37The Democratic Party and Malcolm X gave us this warning that the most dangerous,
- 3:40uh,
- 3:41enemy to the black community is the liberals,
- 3:43is in fact the white liberal,
- 3:44because they monopolized the Democratic Party
- 3:47after 1968.
- 3:48The Democratic Party monopolized
- 3:50the civil rights fight,
- 3:52and he allowed into his cartel only those
- 3:54liberals who would agree with him and black,
- 3:56and they've been paying for black people for years,
- 3:57we're gonna get Joe Biden said if you don't vote for me,
- 3:59you ain't black.
- 4:00We're gonna get the study.
- 4:01And what does he do the day he gets inaugurated?
- 4:03He doesn't do anything for black Americans.
- 4:04He literally passes a day of recognition
- 4:06for trans individuals,
- 4:08the,
- 4:08um,
- 4:08AAPI bill,
- 4:10and he puts black people,
- 4:10and the Democrats do this all the time.
- 4:12They put black Americans at the absolute bottom
- 4:14while lying to the black Americans
- 4:16to maintain that that large.
- 4:17Well,
- 4:18we're also a part of that community as well,
- 4:19so all those bills and all those things that you just said were done for those people.
- 4:22We are one of those people.
- 4:23Right,
- 4:24so,
- 4:24so I,
- 4:25I hear you,
- 4:26right,
- 4:26but what it sounds like is you're trying to say is that you feel like
- 4:29sis.
- 4:30Straight
- 4:30black people are being left out,
- 4:32is that what you're more so not,
- 4:33not,
- 4:33not only heterosexual black people.
- 4:36I'm just saying that people that don't even identify,
- 4:38you could identify as asexual,
- 4:39you could identify as anything.
- 4:41What all I'm saying is that the speed
- 4:43and efficiency through which the democratic establishment made
- 4:47um
- 4:48uh
- 4:48LGBTQI policy on the books
- 4:51was vastly faster than anything that had ever happened for black people.
- 4:54Black people were set free from slavery in 1863.
- 4:56The Voting Rights Act wasn't passed until.
- 4:59That's a product of the system though.
- 5:00I,
- 5:00I,
- 5:00you can't blame the Democratic Party for that.
- 5:02I would say it's a product of the system.
- 5:04I can say that they monopolized the message
- 5:05and lied to black people.
- 5:06Yeah,
- 5:06I can blame the Democratic Party for that.
- 5:07They said we'll give you reparations and they ain't even,
- 5:09they haven't even,
- 5:10do you know what HR 40 is?
- 5:10I,
- 5:11I,
- 5:11I do.
- 5:12Well,
- 5:12to address your claim,
- 5:13I do,
- 5:13I do think that we are owed reparations as well,
- 5:15but I don't think that
- 5:16that is a problem in which we can now say,
- 5:19oh,
- 5:19we feel like we're moving more for this group versus this group.
- 5:22OK,
- 5:22I'm gonna pause here.
- 5:23We've been voted out by the majority.
- 5:25That was
- 5:25good,
- 5:26very thoughtful,
- 5:26very good,
- 5:27very good.
- 5:30If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 5:31please get to the chair in 321.
- 5:37How are you,
- 5:37ma'am?
- 5:38What's
- 5:38up?
- 5:39How are you?
- 5:40I'm good.
- 5:40We've met before actually.
- 5:41We have.
- 5:42You look familiar.
- 5:43Tampa,
- 5:43the
- 5:44America tour.
- 5:45I was there.
- 5:45OK.
- 5:46I told you they called the All Stars in here.
- 5:47Now I'm nervous.
- 5:48All right.
- 5:49Hey,
- 5:49at least you paid up when you made that claim about Pam Bondi.
- 5:51If I lose a bet,
- 5:52I'm gonna pay.
- 5:52Pam should have released the files.
- 5:53Oh,
- 5:53good on you for that.
- 5:54Um,
- 5:54well,
- 5:55I think the thing that needs to be addressed first is I think
- 5:57that this is more of a culture war grab than anything at all.
- 6:00I
- 6:00think that the
- 6:02Democratic Party itself doesn't have
- 6:04a racism problem.
- 6:05I don't think that
- 6:06the left has a racism problem.
- 6:08I think America has a racism problem
- 6:09and I think that I'm not talking about racism.
- 6:12I'm saying that no,
- 6:13no,
- 6:13what I'm what I'm saying is that the Democratic Party has
- 6:15consistently appealed to the black voting to its black voting block,
- 6:19which is making,
- 6:20I mean,
- 6:20black people voted for Kamala Harris,
- 6:22was it 89%,
- 6:2388% of black men,
- 6:2492% of black women voted for Kamala Harris,
- 6:27so
- 6:27that black people have been staunch supporters of the Democratic Party for
- 6:30decades after 1960s.
- 6:32So no,
- 6:32there's not a racism problem.
- 6:33I'm talking about the speed and efficiency,
- 6:35right?
- 6:35It's
- 6:35not,
- 6:38it's the speed and efficiency.
- 6:39I'm saying.
- 6:40The Democratic Party cares more about immediately addressing
- 6:42with speed the needs of the LGBTQIA community as
- 6:45opposed to black Americans and I'm going back to
- 6:47HR 40,
- 6:48which is just a proposed investigation to the effects of slavery,
- 6:53the effects of Jim Crow,
- 6:54and that has still been sitting in committee to this day.
- 6:57I think you could also look at Republican states because I,
- 7:00I think that once again this is not a
- 7:02like the,
- 7:03the issue with not addressing
- 7:05black Americans' problems
- 7:07and the economic inequalities.
- 7:08They face and the other systemic like policing issues that they face
- 7:11that is not a problem of the left though you're painting this out to be a
- 7:14left thing because quite frankly I think it's just a dig at the LGBTQ community.
- 7:18I think that that's the only reason that you're doing this
- 7:21is in order to say like
- 7:22oh yeah well look at our problems they're
- 7:23not getting addressed and that's a conversation that
- 7:25we can have but the people that aren't
- 7:27having that conversation aren't the ones on the left
- 7:29it's the people on the right who aren't willing to have that conversation
- 7:31but here's the thing that's I'm not a let me make this clear I'm
- 7:34obviously not a conventional conservative because ain't
- 7:35no conservative gonna get on here.
- 7:37And say that they're pro reparations because the
- 7:38establishment doesn't want them to say that,
- 7:40but to hell with the political establishment.
- 7:41I'm really more of a populist than anything else,
- 7:43to be completely honest with you.
- 7:44But
- 7:44what I'm saying is it's not a jab at the left.
- 7:46I'm literally acknowledging a fact.
- 7:47I mean,
- 7:48if you look at it,
- 7:48the 13th Amendment was ratified in December
- 7:52isn't your claim
- 7:53about politicians
- 7:54or
- 7:55US government,
- 7:56why is it about the left?
- 7:57Because it's not
- 7:58here's why
- 7:59I'll tell you why.
- 8:00I'll tell you why.
- 8:01I'm really telling black people to wake the hell up
- 8:03because
- 8:04why are we still supporting a political.
- 8:05Party that literally has put the last thing that we need
- 8:09on the back burner
- 8:10which political party?
- 8:10I thought it wasn't about political parties.
- 8:12I'm specifically,
- 8:13what is the claim is about the left.
- 8:15It's about,
- 8:15yes,
- 8:16OK,
- 8:16so then why aren't you saying this about the right then?
- 8:18Because Republicans have what Republican has ever advocated for reparations?
- 8:21What Republican has ever advocated directly and actually
- 8:24what I'll tell you,
- 8:25no,
- 8:25but I'll say
- 8:25no,
- 8:26but what I'll say no,
- 8:26what I'm saying,
- 8:27wait,
- 8:28no,
- 8:28what I'm no,
- 8:28no,
- 8:28no,
- 8:29no,
- 8:29don't do that because
- 8:30who Republicans
- 8:32actually supported
- 8:33the civil rights.
- 8:34Bill
- 8:34more than Democrats in 1964.
- 8:36They supported the Voting Rights Act more than Democrats
- 8:39in 1965,
- 8:40and those are,
- 8:41and when I say more,
- 8:42I want to qualify what I'm saying.
- 8:44Those none of those bills passed without Republican support.
- 8:46None.
- 8:47Black Republicans have always been more apathetic
- 8:50to the black community as a whole,
- 8:51so I'm not gonna,
- 8:52I'm not gonna,
- 8:52what do you mean what was the reason?
- 8:53What was the reason for that?
- 8:54I think it's a pretty straightforward.
- 8:55What was the reason for what?
- 8:56No,
- 8:56what was the what were the reason
- 8:58that the majority of supporters of the Civil Rights Act were Republican.
- 9:02It was because they,
- 9:03they didn't mind letting black people stand on their own 2 ft.
- 9:05They wanted to they wanted to see.
- 9:06You think that the Republicans wanted black people to be equitable to white people?
- 9:10Nixon in the 60s?
- 9:11Nixon did for sure,
- 9:12in the 70s.
- 9:13You think that was the consensus amongst Republicans,
- 9:15really?
- 9:16Yeah,
- 9:16are you about to try,
- 9:17are you about to try to bring up the Southern strategy and say
- 9:19that Republicans and Democrats switched ideologies
- 9:20because that's been refuted several times.
- 9:22Oh,
- 9:22no,
- 9:23that's actually not where I was going with that.
- 9:24I think what speaks to that more is that there were more Republicans in office.
- 9:28So the majority of proponents of the bill are gonna be,
- 9:32wait a sec,
- 9:32wait a sec,
- 9:33hold on.
- 9:34Neither the Civil Rights Act of 63 or 64 or the Voting Rights Act of 65,
- 9:37neither of those acts passed without bipartisan support from both parties.
- 9:40So
- 9:40that what I'm saying is that the Republicans acting like
- 9:43Republicans are on this high ground for supporting this,
- 9:45and they're not.
- 9:45It's
- 9:46because they were the majority that they were the majority who supported the bill.
- 9:49So wait a minute,
- 9:50so they didn't have to vote for the passage of the Civil Rights Act,
- 9:52but they did.
- 9:52I understand that.
- 9:53Proves my point.
- 9:54I'm not disputing
- 9:56that they voted for it or did not vote for it.
- 9:58I'm
- 9:58disputing the fact that you're saying
- 10:00that they were the majority proponents of the bill.
- 10:02Well,
- 10:02yes,
- 10:03because they were the majority in office at the time.
- 10:05No,
- 10:05no,
- 10:05no,
- 10:05no,
- 10:05I'm not saying that they were the majority proponents of civil rights
- 10:08legislation because JFK was the one that proposed civil rights legislation.
- 10:11Republicans simply gave damn near unanimous support just like that.
- 10:14All and what I'm saying is
- 10:16what
- 10:16what is so well the fact check will be there.
- 10:18What I'm saying is that.
- 10:19En masse after the passage of the Civil Rights Act
- 10:22when black people began to overwhelmingly support the Democratic Party,
- 10:25the Democratic Party told the greatest political lie I've ever seen,
- 10:28which is
- 10:29we will look into segregation's effects,
- 10:31we will look into slavery's lasting effects,
- 10:33and we'll give you a reparations task force,
- 10:35but the task force I'm talking about HR 40,
- 10:38is still sitting under committee review to this day.
- 10:40Meanwhile,
- 10:42meanwhile,
- 10:43meanwhile.
- 10:45The entire political establishment,
- 10:47but,
- 10:48but the OK,
- 10:50Republicans aren't saying we'll do this.
- 10:52Democrats are saying we will do this and then they're doing this,
- 10:54they're walking back.
- 10:54I don't like that.
- 10:55So would you rather have a feckless
- 10:57Democrat
- 10:57I'm gonna have to pause here.
- 10:58You've been voted out by the majority.
- 11:00Thank
- 11:00you.
- 11:00That was good.
- 11:04If you would like to be the next debater,
- 11:05please get to that chair in 321.
- 11:10Oh,
- 11:11no one tried.
- 11:12How are you man?
- 11:14I saw you on the Officer Tatum one,
- 11:15that was
- 11:16that was
- 11:16interesting.
- 11:16So are they good or?
- 11:18I'd say 50% and 50%.
- 11:19I'll do better.
- 11:21Can you quantify what more policies the left has done for LGBTQ?
- 11:26Yeah,
- 11:26sure.
- 11:26So if you look at,
- 11:27uh,
- 11:27the Obergefell versus Hodges,
- 11:29established nationwide
- 11:31constitutional recognition
- 11:3211 years and 40 days after the first
- 11:34state
- 11:35to issue marriage licenses.
- 11:36Massachusetts started doing that in 2004.
- 11:38Uh,
- 11:38that when was Virginia versus Love though?
- 11:41That was before Obergefell,
- 11:42which was interracial marriages.
- 11:44So,
- 11:44you know,
- 11:44the left cared about black people before gay people,
- 11:46but
- 11:47if we want to talk about just gay marriage there.
- 11:48No,
- 11:48I'm talking about,
- 11:49but again,
- 11:49I'm specifically talking about the
- 11:51that means that interracial marriage and
- 11:52same-sex marriage are two different things.
- 11:53That's comparing Africans that like comparing black people to white
- 11:56people and making them equal to marry each other,
- 11:58rather than it being seen as
- 12:00You know,
- 12:01as Nick Fuentes put bestiality,
- 12:03I wouldn't call same-sex marriage,
- 12:05but that's what people on the right I would
- 12:06absolutely
- 12:06call it unnatural and a sin by 100%.
- 12:08So
- 12:09I,
- 12:09I,
- 12:09I'm also one of these
- 12:10double minorities that's black and gay and
- 12:13I kind of see this as us trying to pin
- 12:14each other against when you don't care about either group.
- 12:17What do you mean I
- 12:17don't care about
- 12:18black
- 12:18people and you don't care about black people.
- 12:20I just sat here and told you I want black people to get a check.
- 12:23Besides reparations,
- 12:25what's the other black
- 12:26populist policies you advocate for?
- 12:28Well,
- 12:28everything we just discussed I would like to see
- 12:30a more egalitarian society crafted between black men and black women where my
- 12:33sisters don't have
- 12:3466 million?
- 12:35What's the policy?
- 12:35Wait a minute,
- 12:36what do you mean what is the
- 12:37policy?
- 12:37You asked me what I'm advocating for.
- 12:39What is the policy.
- 12:40Policy for that.
- 12:41I'm telling you.
- 12:42Well,
- 12:42OK,
- 12:42so you want the left to argue for a policy that doesn't
- 12:45exist,
- 12:45that can't lead to that?
- 12:46There's no policy that leads to egalitarianism.
- 12:48What are you talking about?
- 12:49You just said there's no policy that leads to
- 12:50the equitable or egalitarian to see that created.
- 12:53How?
- 12:54If I say I want to see it created,
- 12:55it means that nothing really exists.
- 12:57We need to actually,
- 12:58the Democratic Party in this case,
- 12:59that's what we're talking about,
- 13:00they would actually need to show me that they're going to create
- 13:02and initiate that HR 40 task force to examine the last.
- 13:05Do you know how much money black people lost from slavery?
- 13:08$286 billion
- 13:09free labor was extracted from black folks.
- 13:11Whether it shouldn't matter whether you're gay,
- 13:13straight,
- 13:13and how much do
- 13:13Republicans talk
- 13:16about it?
- 13:16Did I say
- 13:17what is the claim?
- 13:18No,
- 13:18that's true,
- 13:18that's true.
- 13:20I don't know,
- 13:21I agree.
- 13:21The reason I ask is because the left,
- 13:23how much does the left talk about that?
- 13:25How much does the left talk about it?
- 13:26A lot.
- 13:26Oh,
- 13:27OK,
- 13:27so the Republicans don't talk about it,
- 13:28but the left does.
- 13:29But you want to talk about the left
- 13:30if my claim is the left cares more,
- 13:32the right don't belong in this
- 13:34conversation.
- 13:34OK,
- 13:35let me show you.
- 13:35an issue with
- 13:36that.
- 13:36OK,
- 13:36let me show you an issue where the left does care more about black people.
- 13:39Show me.
- 13:39Did Joe Biden say he wanted a gay VP or did he say he wanted a black VP?
- 13:43He said,
- 13:43if you don't vote for me,
- 13:44you ain't black.
- 13:44OK,
- 13:45that was that the question is racist as
- 13:46hell.
- 13:47Wait,
- 13:47wait,
- 13:47is racist as
- 13:48hell.
- 13:48Can I appeal to the moderator?
- 13:49Was that the question I asked?
- 13:50That was not the question.
- 13:51OK,
- 13:51can you answer the question?
- 13:53He said he wanted a woman,
- 13:54a black woman VP,
- 13:54but come on,
- 13:55OK,
- 13:55OK,
- 13:55OK,
- 13:56OK,
- 13:56now here's the next one.
- 13:57Did he say he wanted a gay Supreme Court member or
- 13:59did he say he wanted a black Supreme Court member?
- 14:01I don't remember what he said.
- 14:03Katanji Jackson Brown is black guys.
- 14:06Oh,
- 14:06you mean the same Katanji Jackson Brown that
- 14:07couldn't properly identify what a woman is?
- 14:08The same Katanji Brown,
- 14:09you call it the DEI hire.
- 14:11What is a woman?
- 14:11Um,
- 14:12in this society,
- 14:13and what is a woman?
- 14:14As someone who attributes to feminine values,
- 14:16but
- 14:17we,
- 14:17that's how we describe it.
- 14:19What is a woman?
- 14:20I just explained it.
- 14:21I actually answered your question.
- 14:22Wait,
- 14:22are we talking about women or are we talking about black Americans?
- 14:25OK,
- 14:26so we're not,
- 14:26you're moving on because you can't answer my question.
- 14:28I answered it.
- 14:28OK,
- 14:29you did.
- 14:29I did.
- 14:30Jackson Brown,
- 14:31the black American that Joe Biden advocated for while the right
- 14:34continue to condemn her.
- 14:35OK,
- 14:35so
- 14:36condemn her
- 14:37for
- 14:38her DEI hire?
- 14:39I don't think
- 14:40you don't know about that one,
- 14:41right?
- 14:42No,
- 14:42I know about that.
- 14:42I mean,
- 14:43I don't like,
- 14:44I don't like any of the rulings she's given so far,
- 14:45but I mean,
- 14:45hey,
- 14:46I mean,
- 14:46I wouldn't you don't like any of the rulings.
- 14:48None of the rulings,
- 14:48even the ones that went with Amy Cary Barrett.
- 14:50Didn't she vote against,
- 14:51didn't she vote against extending birth or
- 14:53didn't she vote against keeping birthright citizenship just to,
- 14:56um,
- 14:56people that are
- 14:57not.
- 14:58Yeah,
- 14:59she,
- 14:59she kept the precedent.
- 15:00That's good.
- 15:01That's good.
- 15:02Because you know
- 15:03you know what Trump did to,
- 15:04um,
- 15:05you know,
- 15:05black Americans,
- 15:06he started drawing a delineation between
- 15:08Haitians and black Americans and Somalis,
- 15:10and he started condemning those people.
- 15:11Whoa,
- 15:12whoa,
- 15:12whoa,
- 15:12whoa,
- 15:12whoa,
- 15:12do not do that because a black African is not a black American.
- 15:16OK,
- 15:16so Africans that come to America aren't black Americans?
- 15:18No,
- 15:19if Africans,
- 15:19Martin Luther King said this,
- 15:20have you ever read his book Where Do We Go from Here,
- 15:22published in 1967.
- 15:23That doesn't answer the question.
- 15:24You don't,
- 15:25wait,
- 15:25wait,
- 15:25wait,
- 15:25wait,
- 15:25Martin Luther King was also a Marxist.
- 15:27You don't like
- 15:29he was
- 15:29he was
- 15:30he was
- 15:31why did he say this?
- 15:31Why did he say this in his where do we go from your speech in 1967?
- 15:34Why did he say,
- 15:34don't think you have me in a bind today.
- 15:36I'm not talking about communism.
- 15:37Yes,
- 15:37I read,
- 15:38I
- 15:39argue
- 15:39against Martin Luther King's impersonator or am I gonna argue
- 15:41against some actual topic?
- 15:42You
- 15:42just lied on.
- 15:43I did not argue.
- 15:44I did not lie on
- 15:45him.
- 15:45What did he say was the greatest threat?
- 15:46What
- 15:47did he say was the greatest threat?
- 15:50Because he just told a blatant lie on
- 15:52Martin Luther King
- 15:52that I will not stand
- 15:53for it.
- 15:54Martin Luther King said in 1967.
- 15:56From his speech.
- 15:57Don't think you have me in a bind today because I'm not talking about communism.
- 16:00Yes,
- 16:00I read Communist Manifesto and Das Capital
- 16:03many years ago,
- 16:04but I saw that Marx did not follow Hegel enough.
- 16:06He borrowed his dialectics.
- 16:07He then he went to uh Hegel
- 16:09and Marx didn't understand and communism didn't understand.
- 16:12And he said flat out,
- 16:12I have to reject that.
- 16:13Fact check it,
- 16:14go pull the speech.
- 16:15So where's the where's the pro-capitalist speech in that?
- 16:17I'm very pro-capitalist.
- 16:18I'm not,
- 16:19I'm not pro-Marxism.
- 16:20That's why I don't care about whatever you want to go with.
- 16:23I will not lie on a historical figure that did more for black people.
- 16:27What he said was,
- 16:28I have to reject Marx.
- 16:30The solution to mankind's problem is found neither in the thesis of communism
- 16:34nor its antithesis of capitalism,
- 16:35but in a higher synthesis.
- 16:37A higher synthesis that combines the truths of both.
- 16:39So you will not call Martin Luther King a Marxist sitting across the table from me.
- 16:41It's not happening.
- 16:42I don't care.
- 16:43I don't really care if you can you admit you lie?
- 16:45Yeah,
- 16:45sure.
- 16:46I didn't lie.
- 16:47You said he was a Marxist.
- 16:47He lied.
- 16:48He inspired a lot.
- 16:48He got a lot of inspiration.
- 16:51Thank you.
- 16:51Thank you.
- 16:51You're welcome.
- 16:52Now we can continue the conversation.
- 16:53OK,
- 16:53so where are the
- 16:54Capital
- 16:54One.
- 16:55I ain't going for it.
- 16:56It's not a hero,
- 16:57it's not your hero.
- 16:58You don't give a what he
- 16:59talks about.
- 17:00You talk about STDs.
- 17:02You don't care about anything he preaches.
- 17:04Twin,
- 17:05I studied Martin Luther King since I was 8 years old.
- 17:07If anybody at this table cared about Martin Luther King,
- 17:08it's me,
- 17:09I promise you.
- 17:09Did he care about gay Americans?
- 17:11He didn't speak on them.
- 17:12Oh,
- 17:12so you don't think he cared about it?
- 17:13You don't think the civil rights are
- 17:14ever.
- 17:16I don't know,
- 17:17I don't care about,
- 17:17no,
- 17:18I don't care about quotes or figures.
- 17:19I care about
- 17:20financial
- 17:20policies.
- 17:20So you don't care you don't care about
- 17:23what debate is this?
- 17:24Jack,
- 17:24what are we doing?
- 17:25You don't care about policies?
- 17:26I'm telling you we need a policy to give people
- 17:28a chance.
- 17:29What's the policy?
- 17:29Well,
- 17:30hey,
- 17:30let's start with,
- 17:30let's start with,
- 17:32let's start with that.
- 17:33Let's start with that.
- 17:34Let's start with having the Democrats held accountable for the fact
- 17:36that they've kept HR 40 in committee status for decades.
- 17:39Let's start with that.
- 17:39Explain HR 40 to me.
- 17:40It is a study
- 17:41that was,
- 17:42that is to be authorized to,
- 17:43uh,
- 17:44study the effects of Jim Crow segregation and slavery,
- 17:46in short.
- 17:47So you think that the best move for the Democrats is to
- 17:50go back to Jim Crow and segregation to revisit those things?
- 17:54Is that not what he just said,
- 17:56that the Democrats should go get the committee and get it all through?
- 17:58That's you think that's the best strategy?
- 17:59That is not what I said.
- 18:00I didn't say go back to Jim Crow.
- 18:02I said study the effects.
- 18:03And use that to to
- 18:05to calculate the amount of
- 18:06money
- 18:07that's the best thing
- 18:09that's the best thing that they should do for black Americans?
- 18:11It's one of the best things,
- 18:12you damn snippy.
- 18:12If you're gonna get,
- 18:13why would you,
- 18:13why the Democrats have the have have always had historically since the 60s,
- 18:17more of a black voter base than Republicans.
- 18:19Is that right or wrong?
- 18:20Is that right or wrong?
- 18:20So,
- 18:21so why are you lying?
- 18:22So why I'm not lying.
- 18:23So why not you?
- 18:24Wait,
- 18:24let me,
- 18:24let me finish.
- 18:26OK,
- 18:27let's be honest,
- 18:28I'm the kind of American that believes what's good
- 18:29for all Americans is good for black Americans.
- 18:31I don't want a bill
- 18:32from the Democratic Party that says
- 18:34specifically 50% African Americans,
- 18:36you get this,
- 18:37specifically 40%,
- 18:38you get this.
- 18:39Hey,
- 18:39Jim Crow segregation,
- 18:40we followed your family tree from this slave owner,
- 18:42so you get this.
- 18:43This is a meaningless statement that only exists to
- 18:45segregate us more and pin us against each other
- 18:48because you don't care about Americans.
- 18:49You don't care about.
- 18:49Black community,
- 18:50you don't care about gay people.
- 18:51You care about
- 18:52whatever your insane
- 18:54quoting rhetoric is that doesn't matter to people at large.
- 18:57Black people don't want to be singled out by
- 18:59don't matter.
- 19:00Were black people not singled out in this for 244 years.
- 19:05We're gonna have to pause.
- 19:08We have to pause.
- 19:09You've been voted out by the majority.
- 19:10Thank you so much.
- 19:11I love being singled out.
- 19:13Woo,
- 19:14if you would like to be the next debater,
- 19:15please get to the chair in 321.
- 19:24I,
- 19:25I have been
- 19:26dying to debate you because you've had a lot to say about trans women in sports,
- 19:29so I hope one day you and I can have that conversation.
- 19:31But specifically to this,
- 19:34um,
- 19:34my first question to you is,
- 19:36who on the left are we really talking about because I'm black and I'm trans,
- 19:40so I am a part of the LGBTQ plus community.
- 19:42And as much as I hate to admit it,
- 19:44I agree with a lot that you said,
- 19:46especially about the structural hierarchy,
- 19:48especially about how
- 19:49LGBTQ plus people are treated,
- 19:51especially within the black community,
- 19:53because I think there's a hierarchy within the black community.
- 19:55You as a black cis person sit in a higher
- 19:57place of privilege than I as a black trans person.
- 19:59Now that doesn't mean that you don't have your
- 20:02issues with the system and whatnot like that.
- 20:04And so
- 20:05tell me first of all,
- 20:07who on the left are we talking about because we have socialists,
- 20:09we have um establishment.
- 20:11OK,
- 20:11that's a that's a good point.
- 20:12I'm talking about
- 20:13the the democratic establishment.
- 20:15What I mean is the current,
- 20:16well,
- 20:16let's just take for example the current congressional classes going on the,
- 20:19you know,
- 20:19well not current but the congressional classes so everybody that's been
- 20:22in Congress for the past we can just say 40,
- 20:2350 years,
- 20:24just narrow it to that.
- 20:25Anyone that occupies a seat that identifies as a Democrat because you're right,
- 20:28Republicans have a coalition.
- 20:29I'm,
- 20:29I'm still would be
- 20:30a part of the coalition,
- 20:31you know,
- 20:31Republican coalition even though I do lean
- 20:32into Christian populism more than anything.
- 20:34So and again like I said,
- 20:35I'm just talking about the speed and efficiency at which
- 20:38issues
- 20:38that people within your community,
- 20:40uh,
- 20:40they get addressed.
- 20:41Like that,
- 20:42like I said,
- 20:42it took 55 years or 58 years in total from
- 20:44the first documented struggle of the LGBTQIA community in this country
- 20:47to y'all having same-sex marriage legalized and now we have,
- 20:50I mean,
- 20:50there's controversy around that because I know
- 20:52Ennis Cantor and I forget Royce White,
- 20:54they just
- 20:55declared for don't get me started on that.
- 20:56Right,
- 20:57but,
- 20:57but you see what I'm saying?
- 20:58And that's,
- 20:58that's crazy to me because
- 20:59the reason they're able to do that is because the WNBA has a loose definition
- 21:04of what a woman actually is.
- 21:05I disagree with that because
- 21:06let's let's
- 21:07If we even want to talk about the WNBA,
- 21:09let's talk about the pay gap of the WNBA.
- 21:12The NBA players make $11.7 million more than the WNBA players.
- 21:16People,
- 21:17people did not start really caring about the WNBA until
- 21:19they start talking about trans people playing in sports,
- 21:21especially trans women.
- 21:22They weren't talking about,
- 21:23hold on,
- 21:24hold on,
- 21:24no,
- 21:24don't you know that.
- 21:25Do not interrupt a black trans.
- 21:27Woman,
- 21:27when she's speaking,
- 21:29do not erupt a black trans woman when she's speaking because here's the thing,
- 21:32when Brittney Griner was arrested,
- 21:34I think that may have gotten more attention or whatnot.
- 21:37Brittney Griner,
- 21:38excuse me.
- 21:39Yeah,
- 21:39and so
- 21:41I think it's
- 21:42But we ain't gonna shit on the WNBA because I'm a fan.
- 21:44I'm a fan of the WNBA.
- 21:46And
- 21:47again,
- 21:47my twin sister plays basketball and coaches,
- 21:48so we're not doing that.
- 21:50Like,
- 21:50and the pay gap exists.
- 21:51I'm just,
- 21:52I'm not gonna lie,
- 21:52the WNBA is not quite as entertaining as the NBA because,
- 21:55and that's only based around the fact that most of the women.
- 21:57They can't dunk.
- 21:58So you got to really be a true fan of the game of basketball to appreciate the WNBA.
- 22:01But
- 22:03the thing with Royce White,
- 22:04I find it so ironic that,
- 22:06first of all,
- 22:06he's a 3-time politician loser,
- 22:10#1.
- 22:10Number 2,
- 22:11on top of that,
- 22:14He's demeaning black trans women and this is what
- 22:16really bothers me and this is what really irks me
- 22:19because typically the conversation around trans people playing
- 22:21in sports has been white trans people.
- 22:24Leah Thomas,
- 22:25white trans woman.
- 22:26So for me as a black trans person,
- 22:29my community being brought in to something that we really didn't have
- 22:32anything to do with is what's really harmful to the narrative.
- 22:35And
- 22:37here's the thing.
- 22:39We have a lot of,
- 22:40could you,
- 22:40would you,
- 22:41would you agree that we have a lot of work to do in the black community as a whole,
- 22:45as far as being able to uplift each other?
- 22:47Yeah,
- 22:47I mean 100%.
- 22:48I think black people were more,
- 22:49we were most connected,
- 22:50and this is a terrible thing to say,
- 22:52but it's the actual truth.
- 22:53We were the most tightly knit when we were
- 22:55segregated and when the more free that we got,
- 22:57the more we left.
- 22:58I mean,
- 22:58you just look at the numbers,
- 22:59the more That we escaped from Jim Crow when we combated it,
- 23:01we started to see a very huge amount of disunity within the black nuclear family,
- 23:05within the black communities in general.
- 23:06The black dollar,
- 23:07for example,
- 23:07only circulates,
- 23:08I think,
- 23:081.5 times at most within the black community.
- 23:10I think that's just flat out crazy.
- 23:12I think that we need to
- 23:13re-strengthen
- 23:14the core,
- 23:15which is,
- 23:16and of course we're gonna disagree,
- 23:17but I think we need to strengthen the nuclear family.
- 23:18I think we need to move into.
- 23:20You know,
- 23:20re-promoting multi-generational families,
- 23:22the same as our Hispanic brothers and sisters do,
- 23:24same as our
- 23:25Asian brothers and sisters do,
- 23:26White Americans do.
- 23:27We have a we have a family crisis in the black community.
- 23:29We don't treat each other like family.
- 23:30I argue that
- 23:32families are growing.
- 23:33There are many different types of families,
- 23:34you know what I mean?
- 23:35And so we have to be willing to
- 23:37be open to all for the most part.
- 23:39Um.
- 23:41I think
- 23:43it is very challenging to have to admit this out loud,
- 23:46but white supremacy is what's keeping us apart
- 23:49because you've become the black conservative
- 23:51and I am the black liberal.
- 23:52And here's the thing,
- 23:53no,
- 23:53no,
- 23:54I'm bringing it up for a point.
- 23:55I need you to listen to me.
- 23:56I need you to actually listen
- 23:58because I've listened to a lot of the things that you've said,
- 24:01especially about trans people playing in sports,
- 24:03and they do affect me because this is something that's big in my platform.
- 24:06And so for me,
- 24:07when I see when I when I see the typical black
- 24:10conservative.
- 24:11All I think about is,
- 24:12hmm,
- 24:13they know how to grift us.
- 24:15They know how to pull us.
- 24:16They know how to pull us and they know how to
- 24:18have you been,
- 24:19well,
- 24:19let me ask you,
- 24:19have you benefited
- 24:21from being a black conservative?
- 24:22Have you benefited from it?
- 24:24Because let me tell you something,
- 24:25I saw that video
- 24:27of you and the Nazi and how you were yelling and screaming.
- 24:30I saw that video.
- 24:31I don't think you deserve that,
- 24:32but I found it so interesting that your white co-host sat there
- 24:36while you were being.
- 24:37Disrespected
- 24:39and I'm gonna say
- 24:41from
- 24:41what I can see,
- 24:42from what I can see,
- 24:43OK,
- 24:43you didn't see everything.
- 24:44Here's the thing,
- 24:45but here's the thing,
- 24:47don't talk over each other.
- 24:49I'm making a point.
- 24:50I'm just only making a point.
- 24:51I will let you clear the air.
- 24:53I will let you clear the air.
- 24:54I'm making a point here
- 24:56from the footage that I saw.
- 24:57Now I'm not saying that he may not have done anything because I don't know about that,
- 25:00but from the footage that we saw on the internet.
- 25:03Or whatnot.
- 25:04It looks like he was sitting there and that
- 25:05was the thing about some of these white liberals
- 25:08who don't always step up.
- 25:09Now the thing is with white liberals and black conservatives,
- 25:14OK,
- 25:14OK,
- 25:14but with these,
- 25:15with white liberals and black conservatives,
- 25:17that's a very interesting take
- 25:20because
- 25:21we advocate for certain things around blackness
- 25:24and how we don't want whiteness
- 25:26to come in and control us.
- 25:27But then when you have white liberals who are
- 25:29on my side who care more about my rights than you as a black conservative
- 25:33come in and defend me,
- 25:35then it's like a problem.
- 25:36It's like a topsy-turvy thing because I don't know if
- 25:38I should feel sorry for you as a black person
- 25:40or should I step away from you because black conservatives typically attract
- 25:45this type of behavior from Nazis.
- 25:47When you
- 25:48spew rhetoric that is harmful,
- 25:51that is all I'm saying.
- 25:52Please go ahead and make your point.
- 25:53I'm listening.
- 25:54One,
- 25:55David.
- 25:56was only sitting back watching me yell at Jake Lang because
- 25:58he just cooked his Nazi ass at a debate 5 minutes.
- 26:00I was there.
- 26:02Someone sit people sitting here were there at that debate,
- 26:04so you ain't gonna come at my co-host like that.
- 26:05I'm not going for that.
- 26:07I could come at whoever I want to.
- 26:08I could say whatever I was there.
- 26:10I can say whatever I want.
- 26:12But don't talk,
- 26:13but respectfully,
- 26:13do not talk to me like that because I'm coming for whoever I want to.
- 26:16That's cool,
- 26:16but you just told a lie though,
- 26:17and I
- 26:18got
- 26:18my pocket.
- 26:19I literally just told you,
- 26:20I just told you this is.
- 26:21What I saw,
- 26:23what I saw,
- 26:24it's not a lie.
- 26:25It's not a lie.
- 26:26No,
- 26:26please don't say lie.
- 26:27You don't have to say lie.
- 26:28I'm,
- 26:29I'm gonna,
- 26:30I'm gonna say what happened.
- 26:31David was there.
- 26:32He had already cooked Jake Lange in a debate 15 minutes before.
- 26:35No one at that
- 26:36tour was a fan of Jake Lange's rhetoric.
- 26:38Absolutely.
- 26:40Who?
- 26:40How you gonna tell me that I was there?
- 26:41No,
- 26:41I'm agreeing with you,
- 26:42right?
- 26:42So,
- 26:43so what I'm saying is
- 26:44that you asked me a question.
- 26:46You said,
- 26:46did I benefit
- 26:47from what?
- 26:48Part of it
- 26:49from being a black conservative on the other side,
- 26:51because look how they did Candace Owens.
- 26:53When they were done with her,
- 26:54they kicked her to the side.
- 26:55And so for me,
- 26:56I want to know,
- 26:57are you benefiting
- 26:59from it as like a black conservative?
- 27:00This is an important question because I've been dying to ask somebody who's willing
- 27:03to have the conversation.
- 27:05I mean,
- 27:05people tell me,
- 27:06people on the right,
- 27:07what I call the radical right,
- 27:08they don't think I'm a conservative.
- 27:08A lot of them call me,
- 27:09go look at my Instagram comments.
- 27:10A lot of them call me a Marxist in disguise.
- 27:12Oh,
- 27:13you're a Marxist.
- 27:14I mean,
- 27:14I mean,
- 27:15I mean y'all know I ain't lying.
- 27:18Would you agree with that?
- 27:19Hell no.
- 27:20I'm not,
- 27:21I'm not,
- 27:21let me tell you something,
- 27:22before I'm before I'm black,
- 27:24anything,
- 27:24before I'm a Republican,
- 27:25I'm a Christian.
- 27:26Before I'm black,
- 27:27I'm a Christian.
- 27:28Before I'm anything else,
- 27:29I'm a servant of the living God.
- 27:31So I'm indisposable to nobody.
- 27:32As long as he keep me on this earth,
- 27:33I ain't going nowhere.
- 27:34And
- 27:34there are
- 27:35people who are also
- 27:36Christian
- 27:36as well too.
- 27:37And so we
- 27:38I find it interesting that we have a lot,
- 27:40we have a lot alike.
- 27:41We're a lot alike,
- 27:42but I think sometimes the rhetoric that you
- 27:45uphold,
- 27:46I'm gonna say it better,
- 27:47uphold
- 27:48a lot of your viewpoints,
- 27:49especially around like trans women playing in sports.
- 27:51You want to talk about,
- 27:52it's funny because like again,
- 27:53again,
- 27:54I saw the video first and then you turned around and you
- 27:56made another video about trans women playing in sports or whatnot.
- 27:59It's always about
- 28:00biological state.
- 28:01I think they just should.
- 28:02Why would,
- 28:03OK,
- 28:04let me,
- 28:04let me break this down for you.
- 28:05My twin sister is 5'9,
- 28:075'10,
- 28:08about 100.
- 28:09Are you identical or fraternal?
- 28:10It's always a fraternal when it's a boy and a girl.
- 28:12My twin sister might be a good
- 28:1430,
- 28:1435
- 28:15in her prime when she's playing basketball.
- 28:17I would have a serious problem with her
- 28:18playing against somebody my size and my weight,
- 28:20and I'm 6'2,
- 28:22good damn 175.
- 28:24So,
- 28:24no,
- 28:24there are,
- 28:25there are,
- 28:25and,
- 28:25and the.
- 28:26The amount of testosterone in an adult biological male
- 28:29will absolutely outperform an adult,
- 28:31the average adult biological female,
- 28:32especially in the game of basketball,
- 28:33football,
- 28:33whatever.
- 28:33So there are rules to pause
- 28:35here
- 28:35because we're out of time.
- 28:36There are rules and stipulations in place that trans women have to
- 28:39meet certain levels to be able to play in the first place.
- 28:41There's only
- 28:42less than 10 trans athletes,
- 28:44which is only 0.002% of the population of trans women,
- 28:47which is 1%.
- 28:48Yes,
- 28:48thank you.
- 28:48We got to pause.
- 28:49Thank you.
- 28:51Time moves fast,
- 28:52but your credit score doesn't have to stay stuck.
- 28:55I remember how overwhelmed I felt trying to fix my credit.
- 28:59It felt like a catch-22 where you need credit to build credit.
- 29:03Then I found Kickoff.
- 29:04Signing up took minutes on my phone with no credit check and no hidden fees.
- 29:08For users with credit under 600,
- 29:10they see an average growth of 86 points.
- 29:13Kickoff helps you score big when it comes to credit.
- 29:15Plans start at just $5 a month with zero interest.
- 29:18Start building credit with Kickoff today and get
- 29:20your first month for as little as $1.
- 29:23That's 80% off the normal price when you go to getkickoff.com/surrounded today.
- 29:28That's Kickoff without the C.
- 29:29Get KIKOFF.com/.
- 29:32Surrounded must sign up via getkickoff.com/mounted to activate offer.
- 29:35Offer applies to new Kickoff customers first month only,
- 29:36subject to approval.
- 29:36Offer subject to change.
- 29:37Average first year credit score impacted plus 86
- 29:38points between August 2024 and August 2025.
- 29:40For Kickoff credit account users who started with a score below 600,
- 29:41who paid on time and who had no delinquencies or
- 29:43collections added to their credit profile during the period.
- 29:44Late payments may negatively impact your credit score.
- 29:45Individual results may vary.
- 29:46Thank you to Kickoff for sponsoring this episode.
- 29:48Now let's get back to the show.
- 29:50My next surrounding claim is
- 29:52elective abortion is the greatest moral failure
- 29:55of modern America.
- 29:56If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 29:58please get to the chair in +321.
- 30:07Tell me about your actual claim because you said that it's a,
- 30:11uh,
- 30:11the most unjust or unfair or
- 30:14you mentioned morals.
- 30:15I said what do you mean?
- 30:16I said that elective abortion is the greatest moral failure of modern America,
- 30:20meaning
- 30:20that what I'm,
- 30:21I'm gonna confine the claim here.
- 30:22I'm speaking of two consenting adults that are willing to engage in sex,
- 30:26right?
- 30:26That's how
- 30:27children are created.
- 30:2866 million children were killed as a result of
- 30:31abortion since the passing of Roe versus Wade.
- 30:33So
- 30:34these,
- 30:34those deaths
- 30:36didn't have to happen
- 30:37if contraception.
- 30:38would have been used.
- 30:3952% of women that
- 30:40got an abortion
- 30:42did not reported,
- 30:42did not reported not using contraception within
- 30:45the month that they became pregnant.
- 30:46Condoms have a 2% failure rate when used properly.
- 30:49The male condoms have a 13% failure rate um
- 30:52on average with
- 30:53consistent use.
- 30:53Therefore,
- 30:54electively deciding to terminate what is an innocent life is a moral failure.
- 30:58Who moral moral,
- 30:59whose morals?
- 31:01Objective morals.
- 31:03Whose objective morals?
- 31:04God's.
- 31:05Oh,
- 31:05so it's rooted in Christianity.
- 31:07Oh,
- 31:08of course,
- 31:09ultimately because because biology tells us what a person is.
- 31:11We have to move into the realm of philosophy to
- 31:13tell us how that thing ought to be treated.
- 31:15Got it.
- 31:15Do you know the actual trend in Christianity since 1990 until 2020,
- 31:212017?
- 31:22What I don't care about trends.
- 31:23I care about what the
- 31:24don't worry,
- 31:25I got you.
- 31:25Pew Research Center shows in 2025 that there
- 31:28has been a dramatic drop in Christianity,
- 31:30people identifying as Christians
- 31:32going from 90% to 62%,
- 31:35right?
- 31:36More people are shifting towards being either not
- 31:38religious or not actually identifying as anything.
- 31:42So again,
- 31:42when you talk about Christianity and you talk about our
- 31:44Why should,
- 31:45why should we actually stick to something
- 31:47where people aren't even interested in the religion anymore?
- 31:50Well,
- 31:50first of all,
- 31:50let's return to first principles.
- 31:51I'm not here to debate my religion.
- 31:52I'm telling you what,
- 31:53what,
- 31:53what my religion is ultimately grounded in.
- 31:55So let's go back to first principles.
- 31:56I'm here to discuss that elective abortion is
- 31:58the greatest moral theory of modern America.
- 31:59So let me ask you a question.
- 32:00Is it wrong to terminate an innocent life?
- 32:02No,
- 32:02I'm not deflecting.
- 32:02I'm going back to first principles.
- 32:04Your claim is rooted in Christianity ultimately.
- 32:06you're speaking for the country,
- 32:08but the country is saying
- 32:09Christianity doesn't speak for us.
- 32:11First of all,
- 32:11more than half of the United States of America's citizens identify as Christian,
- 32:14especially the black community.
- 32:15So and and as long as In God We Trust is still on our money,
- 32:17which is a government instrument,
- 32:18it will always be,
- 32:19there will always be some religious underpinning in this country.
- 32:21So wait a minute,
- 32:22no,
- 32:22no,
- 32:22no,
- 32:22no,
- 32:22no,
- 32:22I've got a question.
- 32:23Let's go back.
- 32:24First principles.
- 32:24Is it,
- 32:25because you didn't answer this,
- 32:26is it wrong to kill an innocent person?
- 32:29Uh,
- 32:29fetus isn't a person.
- 32:31What does fetus mean in Latin?
- 32:33What
- 32:36does
- 32:36fetus mean
- 32:37in Latin?
- 32:39What
- 32:39does fetus
- 32:40mean in Latin?
- 32:41What does
- 32:42fetus mean?
- 32:42It means little human being.
- 32:44That's what it means.
- 32:45So
- 32:46is Latin a dead
- 32:47language?
- 32:47No,
- 32:47it's not.
- 32:48Oh,
- 32:48it literally
- 32:49is.
- 32:49Latin's
- 32:50literally a dead language
- 32:51you're circling back to something.
- 32:53It's not fine.
- 32:53It is not fine.
- 32:56It is not fine.
- 32:57It is not fine.
- 32:59It is not
- 32:59fine
- 32:59and we will go back.
- 33:01I have a son.
- 33:02How many sons do you have?
- 33:03I have a son.
- 33:04Do
- 33:04you
- 33:05have
- 33:06to be 6
- 33:06years
- 33:06old?
- 33:07My sisters do,
- 33:08my mother does.
- 33:08Some women here do I guarantee you.
- 33:11You are
- 33:11not
- 33:12so we get
- 33:13so we get he refused to answer my question.
- 33:14We get that,
- 33:15right?
- 33:15The question was,
- 33:16is the wrong Terminator
- 33:17is
- 33:18the fetus is not.
- 33:21You're right,
- 33:22forgive me.
- 33:22So let me restart.
- 33:24Yeah,
- 33:24I asked you,
- 33:25is it wrong to terminate an innocent life?
- 33:26You then tried to remove the humanity of a fetus,
- 33:29which is biologically a human organism,
- 33:31so you're comfortable with stripping away based on some,
- 33:34not some arbitrary finding that you're saying that
- 33:37essentially that a fetus is undeserving of protection.
- 33:40I'm saying to you that any human being or member of the human species,
- 33:44regardless of the stage of development they're in,
- 33:46I'm not no longer,
- 33:46I'm telling you what.
- 33:47Your question,
- 33:48so directly,
- 33:49it's not up to me.
- 33:50It's up to women whether or not they actually allow that fetus
- 33:53to continue to actually be a parasite inside of them and grow.
- 33:56But that's not identified as a parasite.
- 33:57A fetus is not identified as a parasite,
- 33:58by the way,
- 33:59you say that the ultimate goal of or like not or outlawing abortion or,
- 34:04you know,
- 34:04the issue is that
- 34:05you want to actually
- 34:07that you want to actually make sure that as many innocent lives are
- 34:10born.
- 34:12No,
- 34:12answer this question because you're not,
- 34:13you,
- 34:13you stripped
- 34:14away.
- 34:14I'm not dodging.
- 34:14I'm forcing you.
- 34:15I'm forcing you back to first principles.
- 34:17I'm going to answer my question.
- 34:18No,
- 34:18no,
- 34:18you didn't you ran for my lives.
- 34:20You absolutely.
- 34:21What's more innocent than an unborn child?
- 34:22OK,
- 34:22perfect.
- 34:23Are you willing,
- 34:23are you willing to do whatever's possible to save innocent lives?
- 34:26Are you willing to strip?
- 34:27Are you willing to give me a second to cook on this one.
- 34:29If you really
- 34:30the flags are raised.
- 34:31Are you cooking?
- 34:32Right here.
- 34:32They whipped you out of here right here,
- 34:33right here.
- 34:34If you want to actually save innocent lives,
- 34:37if you want to save innocent lives,
- 34:39why don't you actually
- 34:40advocate for mandatory vasectomies?
- 34:42Why would I advocate for mandatory vasectomies?
- 34:43I advocate for contraception.
- 34:44Women and men,
- 34:45wait,
- 34:46wait,
- 34:46stop,
- 34:46stop.
- 34:47No,
- 34:47no,
- 34:47no.
- 34:47So you're gonna ask me a question.
- 34:49Can I appeal the moderator here for a second?
- 34:51Can I at least have the floor to answer the question?
- 34:52I appealed the contraception.
- 34:54I just told you,
- 34:5452% of women that got elected.
- 34:56Abortions got them because they reported not using contraception.
- 34:59Condoms have a 2% failure rate,
- 35:01Santana.
- 35:02And you know what has a 99% effective rate?
- 35:05Vasectomies.
- 35:06Again,
- 35:07so you just want to attack men.
- 35:09So you just want to attack men.
- 35:10I want to hold both sides accountable.
- 35:13I thought I was supposed to be.
- 35:14Wait,
- 35:14how is that?
- 35:15How is that holding everyone accountable
- 35:17when you're forcing a woman to have?
- 35:19Baby.
- 35:19Does it not,
- 35:20I'm sorry,
- 35:20it takes 2 to tango,
- 35:21right?
- 35:22My son didn't come into being by
- 35:23saying
- 35:24this woman has to actually have a baby,
- 35:26which women are closest to death
- 35:29while they are actually I'm saying that that is all of that is preventable,
- 35:32but it's by the three words.
- 35:33Wrap
- 35:33it up.
- 35:34We're
- 35:34just
- 35:35about to do to you in just a second.
- 35:36You're a meat watcher.
- 35:36I advocate
- 35:37pause here.
- 35:38We have to pause.
- 35:39You've been voted out by the majority.
- 35:41Thank you.
- 35:42Please let each other speak though.
- 35:45We cannot understand you guys.
- 35:47In the words of Magic Johnson,
- 35:48that's what you call like he,
- 35:49he.
- 35:50If you would like to be the next debater,
- 35:52please get to that chair in 321.
- 35:58OK,
- 35:58now this could take a while.
- 36:00I finally get my TikTok rematch.
- 36:01Oh,
- 36:02I'm actually a little nervous for this 12 and 0.
- 36:07I thought it was a draw.
- 36:09I forgot.
- 36:10Um,
- 36:10yeah,
- 36:11so
- 36:11I think
- 36:12when you say that abortion is the greatest moral failing.
- 36:15I would actually agree with you.
- 36:17I actually agree with you that abortion is the greatest moral failing,
- 36:21um,
- 36:21and I actually think that the way a lot of pro-lifers speak about fetuses
- 36:25can be very offensive and put people who are pro-life,
- 36:28who would actually be a lot more pro-choice,
- 36:30farther on the pro-life side when you call them
- 36:32parasites.
- 36:33Um,
- 36:34but the thing is though,
- 36:36I'm sure there's a disagreement
- 36:37coming right now,
- 36:37oh,
- 36:38of course.
- 36:39I think though that abortion is the greatest
- 36:41moral failing because you have two worlds here,
- 36:43Austin,
- 36:44right?
- 36:44You have world A
- 36:46where,
- 36:46where,
- 36:46where from 1990 to 2014
- 36:50we see in abortion
- 36:52about a 37 to 40% decrease in abortions up until that time.
- 36:57From 2014 to 2025,
- 36:59it goes up.
- 37:00Again,
- 37:01right,
- 37:01so you have one world,
- 37:02right,
- 37:02you have one world
- 37:04where people have a guaranteed,
- 37:06uh,
- 37:06where their health care is guaranteed.
- 37:08They have higher contraceptive care,
- 37:10higher abortion care,
- 37:12sex education increases.
- 37:13All of these things make it so that people engage in both sexes
- 37:17in less risky sex practices,
- 37:19leading to
- 37:20less unwanted pregnancies,
- 37:22less abortions.
- 37:23People are actually able to have the families they want to be able to take care of.
- 37:27Of them,
- 37:27right?
- 37:28Women are more protected because they're not getting pregnant
- 37:31and,
- 37:31you know,
- 37:31unfortunately sabotaging their careers,
- 37:33right?
- 37:34But then in world B
- 37:36you have politicians playing political football with
- 37:39abortions and abortion has gone up about
- 37:4122% when you crunch those numbers
- 37:44and only and only half the time,
- 37:46right?
- 37:46So I would need you to like I would need you to ask like which one would you prefer,
- 37:49uh,
- 37:50world A where we see that people are getting
- 37:52the health care they need and they're actually getting.
- 37:54abortions
- 37:55or world B where people are unsure
- 37:57whether or not even if they want to have the baby
- 37:59they're not gonna get adequate natal care because of the abortion.
- 38:02OK,
- 38:02so you actually raised very interesting questions
- 38:04because one of the largest reported reasons,
- 38:06I'm glad you brought this up by the way,
- 38:07one of the biggest reported reasons that,
- 38:09uh,
- 38:09women get abortions,
- 38:1074% of women to a survey from the Gutmacher Institute stated that
- 38:13they didn't want to keep the child because of financial reasons,
- 38:16didn't want to be a single mother,
- 38:17um,
- 38:17or that they had already had other children they had to care for.
- 38:19So the ideal world.
- 38:21For me
- 38:22is,
- 38:22again,
- 38:23increased contraceptive use
- 38:24because all of these problems are easily prevented.
- 38:26Then you'd want the world with Roe v.
- 38:27Wade,
- 38:27Austin.
- 38:28What do you mean?
- 38:29Why would I want Roe v.
- 38:29Wade in world A,
- 38:31after the passing of Roe v.
- 38:32Wade
- 38:33from 1990 to 2014,
- 38:35we saw a slow
- 38:36yet steady decrease by
- 38:3840%,
- 38:40Austin.
- 38:401.6 million to at its lowest 600,000.
- 38:44How much is that?
- 38:44That's a massive reduction.
- 38:45That's a massive reduction.
- 38:48So which,
- 38:48but the question is Austin,
- 38:50which one do you prefer?
- 38:52OK,
- 38:52which one do you prefer?
- 38:53Will we get less abortions or abortion goes up because people don't
- 38:55know whether or not they're gonna be able to receive healthcare?
- 38:57Well,
- 38:57no,
- 38:58but again,
- 38:58what you're talking about is is an economic problem.
- 39:00I'm gonna,
- 39:02I'm gonna make my own world.
- 39:03That's what I you know that's what that world
- 39:05exists not yet,
- 39:06not yet,
- 39:07you know.
- 39:07I thought you were liberals.
- 39:08I thought liberals believed in manifesting,
- 39:09speaking things into existence,
- 39:10you know.
- 39:11But
- 39:11that's more spiritual.
- 39:12Well,
- 39:12you know,
- 39:13I don't want to get into philosophy with you.
- 39:15Quite yet we know where that conversation is gonna go,
- 39:16but I would,
- 39:17I would say this,
- 39:17that
- 39:18when we look into
- 39:19the,
- 39:19the ideal world for me
- 39:21is one where the life of the mother and her financial
- 39:24well-being is prioritized
- 39:26and the life of the child is protected.
- 39:28That's Roe v.
- 39:28Wade,
- 39:28baby.
- 39:28So if that,
- 39:30if that is in fact the case,
- 39:30I would have to go look,
- 39:31fact check that myself to check into it.
- 39:33Yeah,
- 39:33you could look at Pew Research,
- 39:34you could look at uh Gutmacher that you just cited here,
- 39:36but
- 39:37I
- 39:37still.
- 39:37I,
- 39:38I,
- 39:38that still doesn't necessarily refute the claim that the termination of
- 39:40an innocent life after consensual sex is still morally wrong,
- 39:43and I,
- 39:44and then,
- 39:44then the reason I can't,
- 39:45I can't justify,
- 39:47uh,
- 39:47someone that grew up poor.
- 39:49First of all,
- 39:49I'm,
- 39:50I'm gonna be honest,
- 39:50it costs $300,000 on average,
- 39:53around $300,000.
- 39:53The fact check is gonna save about $286,000
- 39:56to raise a child to age 18,
- 39:57not including college,
- 39:58but
- 39:59let's be clear.
- 40:00If
- 40:00you are too poor to take care of a child,
- 40:02why are you having unprotected sex?
- 40:04But again,
- 40:05but again,
- 40:05Austin,
- 40:06Roe v.
- 40:06Wade expands the education.
- 40:08Sex education means teaching people how to put on condoms,
- 40:11when to put on condoms,
- 40:12how to make sure that the condom success rate is at the highest it could possibly be.
- 40:17That's why we saw not only decrease abortions,
- 40:19but decrease pregnancy.
- 40:21Who's
- 40:21who who who
- 40:22what but OK,
- 40:23here's I get that.
- 40:24Here's the thing then
- 40:25I ask you a question really quickly,
- 40:26right?
- 40:27We live in a world,
- 40:29right,
- 40:29where
- 40:30murder happens
- 40:31and we know that there's no feasible way that we're gonna
- 40:33stop people from murdering each other.
- 40:35Would you prefer a world where people commit
- 40:38more murder or less murder?
- 40:40I mean,
- 40:40obviously you would prefer a world where This murder
- 40:42happens but that's not realistic.
- 40:44But it is realistic though because we've been seeing that.
- 40:47We've been seeing what?
- 40:47The murder rates have been decreasing nationally.
- 40:49They have been,
- 40:50but what I'm what I'm
- 40:51what I'm specifically,
- 40:52what I'm specifically talking about is who is the what race of women
- 40:55specifically gets the most abortions?
- 40:56It doesn't matter
- 40:59what I'm saying
- 41:00is that question,
- 41:01what race of women gets more abortions than anybody else?
- 41:03Your race,
- 41:04my race,
- 41:04the black race.
- 41:05Why does that happen?
- 41:06Financial issues.
- 41:07So what,
- 41:08so
- 41:08no,
- 41:08no,
- 41:10no,
- 41:10what I'm what I'm saying,
- 41:11I'm not disagreeing with your point.
- 41:12I will,
- 41:13I will concede that there is a better world that we can craft.
- 41:15No rational.
- 41:18I don't,
- 41:18I would have,
- 41:18again,
- 41:19I don't know that for certain.
- 41:20I,
- 41:20I
- 41:20would rather
- 41:21go
- 41:21you cited the source
- 41:23that said this,
- 41:24Austin.
- 41:24I'm agreeing with you that it is a moral failing,
- 41:26right?
- 41:27We're not,
- 41:27that's not a disagreement.
- 41:28I'm just saying I want to be certain because somebody's gonna fact check me,
- 41:31the comments are gonna crucify me if I just
- 41:32willingly concede that point without having first researched it myself
- 41:35that the ideal world was one in fact
- 41:37where 600,000 I think it was what did you say reduced to 600,000.
- 41:41So if that,
- 41:41if we could regenerate that,
- 41:43I'm fine with it,
- 41:44but I don't want any innocent,
- 41:45but I don't want any innocent life.
- 41:46terminated,
- 41:47especially when
- 41:48that's how I feel about murder victims.
- 41:49But all I'm saying is this
- 41:51within the confines of two consenting adults wanting to lay down
- 41:53and bump uglies.
- 41:54That's right,
- 41:55I said bump uglies.
- 41:56What if I about it?
- 41:57If you want to do that,
- 41:58sexual freedom,
- 41:59the biggest problem with a lot of people on
- 42:01the left is that they love sexual freedom without while
- 42:04the responsibility,
- 42:05right,
- 42:05I agree with you.
- 42:06I agree with you
- 42:07because
- 42:08there's a reason that I only have one beautiful son.
- 42:10I agree because when I,
- 42:11when,
- 42:11when the relationship with his mother didn't work out,
- 42:13I said,
- 42:13you know what,
- 42:13Austin is not doing this.
- 42:15I
- 42:16fully married
- 42:16and I set a standard for myself and I stuck to it.
- 42:18So I'm trying to understand
- 42:20why is it especially
- 42:21the black woman
- 42:22has to go and that's not a fault of women at all,
- 42:24by the way,
- 42:24because what a lot of the reasons
- 42:26is they don't want to be single parents.
- 42:27That's not a fault of black women at all.
- 42:28That's our failure to not provide the environment for them.
- 42:31But do you think that's,
- 42:32do you think that's more or less likely when they
- 42:34can't get an abortion to have these single parent households?
- 42:36It's obviously more likely when they can't afford it,
- 42:38but again.
- 42:38I go back to,
- 42:39if you know you can't afford
- 42:40it,
- 42:41they can't get an abortion.
- 42:42Can't get,
- 42:42OK,
- 42:42granted,
- 42:43so if you know you can't get an abortion,
- 42:44if you know that
- 42:45and you want to lay down with and you want to
- 42:47lay down with with with with Pookie and Ray Ray,
- 42:50tell that man wrap it up.
- 42:51Austin,
- 42:51I think you know that that's unfair because sexual responsibility is unfair.
- 42:55No,
- 42:55you can still have sexual responsibility,
- 42:56but that doesn't mean that the person you're
- 42:58with that you think you're going to be with
- 42:59for a long term is going to stay when you get pregnant.
- 43:01So what are these women
- 43:02supposed to do?
- 43:04This
- 43:05sounds like victim blaming because we see,
- 43:07hold on,
- 43:08Austin,
- 43:08Austin,
- 43:08hold on,
- 43:08because we see an increase in child abuse,
- 43:10we see an increase in domestic abuse because women are now tied
- 43:13to these people.
- 43:14They wouldn't be tied to these people if they were able to get the adequate care,
- 43:17but not even just that.
- 43:19I'm saying is this,
- 43:20before it even gets there,
- 43:21right,
- 43:21you're not gonna tell me what are women
- 43:23supposed to do?
- 43:24I'm going to tell women to do the same exact thing I tell men to do with women,
- 43:27vet
- 43:28better.
- 43:29Before you have unprotected sex
- 43:31with somebody,
- 43:32make sure
- 43:33that you're either married to them
- 43:35or that you are going to be in a committed relationship.
- 43:36You need to vet the people that you're sleeping with unprotected because
- 43:40hold on.
- 43:40this last point,
- 43:41right?
- 43:41Another problem that we haven't even addressed in the black community,
- 43:44black people have some of the highest STD rates in this country.
- 43:48All of these things can be mitigated if both parties,
- 43:50men and women,
- 43:51sit down and my daddy used to say this before and
- 43:53and and it it it there's too many men today,
- 43:56and shout out to you for this one,
- 43:57Dad,
- 43:57there are too many men today that know what a woman looks like naked
- 44:00and they don't even know her favorite color or her favorite food.
- 44:02That's a problem.
- 44:03That's insane.
- 44:05Now I mean you and I think if we are honest about this,
- 44:08if we both can we both agree that if we start from the baseline
- 44:13from the beginning,
- 44:14abortions would drop.
- 44:15I think I argue domestic abuse would drop.
- 44:17I argue if we vetted better all of the issues that you just described that
- 44:21we've been sitting out here talking about for the last 10 to 15 minutes,
- 44:23I think all of this would serve to create a more harmonious egalitarian society
- 44:27where men.
- 44:28Men are not walking out on their damn responsibilities,
- 44:30while at the same time,
- 44:31women actually feel safe to carry the kids to the men that they sleep with.
- 44:34I actually feel sympathy for women.
- 44:35Alright,
- 44:35so how about,
- 44:36how about this
- 44:36pause.
- 44:37You've been voted out by the majority.
- 44:38Thank you so much.
- 44:40I like that was the best.
- 44:41That was,
- 44:41that was great.
- 44:42That was great.
- 44:42That was really good,
- 44:43really good.
- 44:44We might have to continue that one on TikTok.
- 44:45I don't know.
- 44:46If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 44:48please get to the chair in 321.
- 44:53Oh,
- 44:54she said,
- 44:54she said y'all ain't got the fast enough leg.
- 44:55Gotta be quicker than that.
- 44:57How are you,
- 44:57ma'am?
- 44:57I'm good.
- 44:58What's your name?
- 44:58Alyssa.
- 44:58Austin,
- 44:59nice to meet you,
- 44:59Miss Alyssa.
- 45:00Um,
- 45:01so I kind of wanted to go backwards,
- 45:03um,
- 45:03to back to the prompt.
- 45:04Yes ma'am.
- 45:05Um,
- 45:05I would argue that the biggest moral failing isn't
- 45:09allowing women to have elective abortions.
- 45:11It's rather the regression of rights as a whole.
- 45:14So what do you mean regression of rights as a whole?
- 45:16Yeah,
- 45:17so when we
- 45:17take,
- 45:18when we have progress,
- 45:19it feels like we're almost taking like 5 steps forward and 10 steps back.
- 45:23Um,
- 45:24I wanna make sure that I'm understanding what
- 45:25you're just following your train of thought.
- 45:26You're saying that women's rights have regressed,
- 45:28yeah,
- 45:29and,
- 45:29and the overturning of Roe v.
- 45:30Wade,
- 45:31um,
- 45:31is very indicative of that.
- 45:33When we look at the data from states that have abortion bans and restrictions,
- 45:37we see an increase in maternal mortality and infant mortality,
- 45:41and I think if the.
- 45:41The idea here is protecting the sanctity of human life.
- 45:45You don't do that by
- 45:47passing legislation that ultimately harms and kills more people.
- 45:51So,
- 45:52OK,
- 45:52I don't,
- 45:52I don't know that that ultimately harms and kills because what I'm looking at is
- 45:55a,
- 45:56a,
- 45:56a child is,
- 45:57first of all,
- 45:58is a child a human being to you?
- 46:00A,
- 46:00a child is a human being.
- 46:01Is a fetus a human being to you?
- 46:03A fetus is a fetus.
- 46:04A fetus,
- 46:04what does the fetus mean in Latin?
- 46:06So we can,
- 46:07we can argue
- 46:08no,
- 46:08it's not semantics.
- 46:09That's a very,
- 46:10that's a definition.
- 46:11What does fetus mean in Latin?
- 46:13It means little human being.
- 46:15The reason that that term was ascribed is because it's exactly what it is.
- 46:17All it's describing is a human being at an early stage of development.
- 46:20When that,
- 46:21when that when that same embryo develops into a fetus,
- 46:23it is the same human organism.
- 46:25Nothing about the organism changes except the fact
- 46:27that new abilities are added to that organism,
- 46:29such as sentience,
- 46:30consciousness,
- 46:31all of that.
- 46:32So it is a human being.
- 46:33Being
- 46:34fundamentally,
- 46:34and if I,
- 46:35if I can't just say I want to protect women while while also
- 46:38not recognizing that
- 46:40that individual organism that is using her body for nine months,
- 46:42there was no point that at any at any point in my son's
- 46:45early development that you would get me to say he's not a human.
- 46:47From the time that I knew his mother was pregnant,
- 46:49my son was a human being and it became my job as his daddy to protect him
- 46:53and I say that to my I would say that to my niece becomes a
- 46:56conversation
- 46:57about rights then,
- 46:58right?
- 46:59You
- 46:59you're stating that.
- 47:00This
- 47:01right to life
- 47:01should take precedence over a woman's right to bodily autonomy.
- 47:04That that is what you're saying.
- 47:05No,
- 47:06I'm saying that
- 47:07her her autonomy comes into is not in question,
- 47:10but she did,
- 47:11she,
- 47:11as a woman,
- 47:11when you become pregnant,
- 47:12you develop,
- 47:13you develop a specialized obligation
- 47:15to another organism.
- 47:16That's what happens when a mother is carrying a fetus in her body.
- 47:19When I was in my mother's stomach,
- 47:20she carried a special obligation
- 47:22to protect me
- 47:23because I was inside of her body.
- 47:25Yes,
- 47:25I'm,
- 47:25but I am still a separate organism.
- 47:28Is that,
- 47:28can we agree to that?
- 47:29That's fine,
- 47:30but the rights of the,
- 47:31the host trump the rights of the fetus every time.
- 47:34And what we are looking at the data,
- 47:36states that have abortion bans and restrictions have
- 47:38higher rates of maternal mortality and infant mortality.
- 47:41So if the idea,
- 47:42so if the idea here is again protecting the sanctity of human life,
- 47:45why are we supporting legislation that's ultimately causing infants to suffer?
- 47:50When you say ultimately how is.
- 47:51OK,
- 47:51how is an abortion ban calling in causing,
- 47:53wait a minute because you said something very key.
- 47:55How is an abortion ban causing
- 47:57infants to suffer?
- 47:57Well,
- 47:58yeah,
- 47:58so if we look at states like Texas
- 48:00that don't have an exception for fetal abnormalities,
- 48:04um,
- 48:04those fetuses and those pregnancies are being forced to be
- 48:07carried to term when they could have been terminated,
- 48:08that's a little,
- 48:10that's a little different because fetal abnormalities,
- 48:12but see,
- 48:12I'm,
- 48:12I'm talking about,
- 48:13remember,
- 48:13I'm talking about elective abortion.
- 48:15So we can't,
- 48:15I'm not talking about something where the life of the mother is in question,
- 48:18a victim of or where the health of the embryo of the mother is in question.
- 48:21That that's a separate category
- 48:22and by the way,
- 48:23that only affects less than 6% of the population.
- 48:26Universal health care,
- 48:27affordable education,
- 48:28and affordable housing.
- 48:29Hold on,
- 48:29hold on,
- 48:29how much does a pack of condoms cost in this country?
- 48:31About
- 48:32$10 on a bad day.
- 48:33If you want the Trojan Magnums,
- 48:34it's about $10.10 to $12.
- 48:36So if you know you're too poor to raise a kid up,
- 48:38I told you.
- 48:38I told y'all that it costs $286,000 at least to get a kid age 18.
- 48:42If you don't want them problems,
- 48:43wrap it up and tell the man you're sleeping with rep.
- 48:45How hard
- 48:45is that?
- 48:45Yeah,
- 48:45I don't disagree.
- 48:46Everybody we don't
- 48:47disagree.
- 48:48Wait,
- 48:48but,
- 48:48but consequences happen,
- 48:50right?
- 48:50Even if you are doing everything the exact right way,
- 48:53you can still get pregnant.
- 48:542% chance.
- 48:55That's fine.
- 48:56I reckon
- 48:57it doesn't
- 48:58matter.
- 48:58You've been voted out by the majority.
- 48:59Thank you.
- 49:00Thank you.
- 49:01Very good,
- 49:01very good.
- 49:05If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 49:06please get to the chair in 321.
- 49:13Oh,
- 49:13let's see if I'm randomly based this time.
- 49:16We'll see.
- 49:16Um,
- 49:17so yeah,
- 49:17you talked about poor people and how they shouldn't have,
- 49:21uh,
- 49:21you,
- 49:21I quote,
- 49:22raw.
- 49:23Why do you think poor people have raw?
- 49:26I,
- 49:27because they're because they're still gonna,
- 49:28I mean they're human beings,
- 49:29they're going to engage in that activity regardless.
- 49:31I mean human nature,
- 49:32we're sinful creatures,
- 49:33we do
- 49:34things when we look at the data,
- 49:36right,
- 49:37poor people are overrepresented in people who have abortions that's going to
- 49:41obviously more represent black people because of the history of this
- 49:43country,
- 49:44right?
- 49:44100%.
- 49:45Why do you think that is?
- 49:47Restate the question.
- 49:49Poor people are overrepresented
- 49:50in individuals who have abortions.
- 49:53Why do you think that is?
- 49:54They're overrepresented because they have gotten pregnant and they cannot
- 49:57afford to take care of the child that they've created.
- 49:59OK,
- 49:59so
- 50:00the problem here that we're seeing is,
- 50:02is,
- 50:02is multifaceted,
- 50:03and I think the problem is that you point the gun
- 50:05at the people who are a product of a system.
- 50:08This system that we're talking about is a capitalistic system.
- 50:11OK,
- 50:12so essentially
- 50:13what happens is
- 50:15when you're poor.
- 50:16Your schools are funded by your property taxes,
- 50:18OK?
- 50:19When your schools are funded by your property taxes and it's an
- 50:21impoverished area,
- 50:22you're gonna have less literacy rates in general,
- 50:25right?
- 50:25You're gonna see a lower
- 50:26kind of capacity of educational capacity.
- 50:30That's why you're gonna see people on average
- 50:32not only do you probably not want to spend the extra money on contraceptives,
- 50:36but you don't have the literacy and the educative facilities
- 50:39to,
- 50:39to do that.
- 50:40So why do you point the issue at the individuals if they're not
- 50:43a product of context
- 50:44because.
- 50:45We are in 2026 Xena,
- 50:47and there is no way today in 2026 black people are still overrepresented
- 50:50in impoverished that
- 50:52has nothing to do with what I'm about to say.
- 50:53What I'm saying is that black people in this country
- 50:56are the average black child reads at 1/4 grade level.
- 50:59The average black girl reads at 1/6 grade level.
- 51:01The average US citizen,
- 51:02regardless of race,
- 51:03reads at 1/6 grade level.
- 51:04So we do have an education problem here.
- 51:06What I'm saying is that there's no way today
- 51:08that you can't access this information and know it.
- 51:10So if you're not and and the and and poor people,
- 51:12if you're too poor.
- 51:14To make sure your rent is paid,
- 51:15make sure you're,
- 51:16you know,
- 51:16you have food on the table and all of that.
- 51:18You really just simply should not I'm
- 51:20I'm not pointing the gun at it and this
- 51:21has nothing to do with I'm hearing this shouldn't,
- 51:23right?
- 51:23I understand what you're saying is that certain things shouldn't happen.
- 51:26I think everyone in this room is educated and
- 51:28would understand that contraceptives are a great thing.
- 51:31My thing is though is that
- 51:33we're not seeing the facilities in place that would prompt someone
- 51:36to go ahead and look for the help,
- 51:38right?
- 51:39Motivate.
- 51:40comes from the ground in which you're bred,
- 51:42OK?
- 51:42When someone is
- 51:43from a family who has come from a set of norms that's in proximity to wealth,
- 51:47their
- 51:48cultural understanding of things,
- 51:50um,
- 51:50their
- 51:50actual inclination towards doing things can be drastically different from
- 51:54someone who was born into cycles of generational poverty.
- 51:56That's not true.
- 51:57I can give you what are you talking about?
- 51:58You don't believe in nature or nurture?
- 52:00I believe in nature and nurture.
- 52:01OK,
- 52:01so that's what I'm talking
- 52:02about.
- 52:02OK,
- 52:02cool.
- 52:03Ben Carson was born dirt poor.
- 52:05What's one person?
- 52:06We're talking about systems.
- 52:07Systems don't,
- 52:08OK,
- 52:082 people,
- 52:093 people.
- 52:10Individual instances do not brand the entire system
- 52:13that produces poverty and then cultural illiteracy.
- 52:16You understand that,
- 52:17right?
- 52:17You don't use individual examples to explain the trend.
- 52:22It's possible but it's clearly not prompted for.
- 52:25That's why we don't see it happening at mass.
- 52:26Systems work in a way where it's inputs and outputs.
- 52:28So of course you're gonna see some people,
- 52:30for example,
- 52:30It's like if I start twitch streaming tomorrow
- 52:32there's a chance that I could become a millionaire
- 52:34on average based on you know how things work,
- 52:36the system works,
- 52:38that's very,
- 52:38very unlikely.
- 52:39You're turning this into
- 52:40a very Marxian the state versus I'm a Marxist.
- 52:43I'm not a liberal.
- 52:44Let me just say that.
- 52:45I'm well aware.
- 52:46I know
- 52:47let's talk about it.
- 52:48I know,
- 52:48right.
- 52:49The problem with Marx is that he first of all,
- 52:50Marx didn't follow Hegel enough.
- 52:52He took his dialectic but he left out his idealism and his spiritualism and then
- 52:55Marx goes over to a German philosoph.
- 52:56Of a brother named Aoyabor who takes his materialism
- 52:59and turns it into this system that he calls dialect
- 53:01which I reject because what Marx
- 53:04ignores blatantly in this conversation,
- 53:06his whole issue is that it's the state
- 53:09against the little man
- 53:10with which which is which doesn't actually work regardless of the economic system.
- 53:15Sexual freedom does not mean does not is not an escape from sexual responsibility.
- 53:19Xena
- 53:20Marx never even addresses that I think you're still.
- 53:22Not addressing the point that is that
- 53:24systems create individuals that creates inclinations,
- 53:26actions,
- 53:27etc.
- 53:28You're not addressing the fact that our
- 53:30system has systematically created certain populations to be
- 53:33on average
- 53:34more,
- 53:34you know,
- 53:34impoverished and then in general their systems.
- 53:36Let me ask you this question,
- 53:37not to cut you off,
- 53:38but let me ask you this question.
- 53:39Have we lived in an easier,
- 53:41have we,
- 53:41have we lived in a better age where ease
- 53:43the ease to access information is better now or
- 53:46better does not mean equitable and.
- 53:48And this also does not account for the fact that again
- 53:50it's
- 53:51that doesn't mean that it shouldn't be
- 53:53first of all,
- 53:53second of all,
- 53:54can I answer your question though?
- 53:55And second of all,
- 53:56it doesn't account for the fact that
- 53:57um Roe v.
- 53:58Wade has been tampered with and with the statistics that Tashika Tashika sorry
- 54:02brought up we've noticed that because of the way that our politics has been playing
- 54:06with women's bodily autonomy we're seeing
- 54:08more abortions happening,
- 54:09right?
- 54:10So
- 54:10things being easier,
- 54:11we have more access to information and as a result.
- 54:14Much more distractions,
- 54:15much more,
- 54:16uh,
- 54:17ads on our screens every single day.
- 54:19Why do the most powerful people in our system seem to want people to,
- 54:22you know,
- 54:23pay for people to have more of sexually illicit content
- 54:26in their faces all the time?
- 54:28Things are not,
- 54:29I wouldn't even say things are easier.
- 54:30I'll tell you why that happens because the love of money is
- 54:32the root of all evil and all I need to do,
- 54:34all I need to do.
- 54:35So why don't you blame the corporations that create the system
- 54:38that cause people to act the way that they do?
- 54:40Why do you not look at them.
- 54:42because I don't think it's just the corporations.
- 54:43I hold them accountable but it's not just,
- 54:44but it's not just the corporations.
- 54:46Money is one of the things that will change your life in ways that are
- 54:49unimaginable.
- 54:50One of the most greatest indicators of someone's difference in personality,
- 54:53how they act,
- 54:53how they function,
- 54:54is going to be the class that they're in because the
- 54:56class that you're in creates the culture that you're in.
- 54:58So,
- 54:58OK,
- 54:58but
- 54:59before we get to economic class,
- 55:00we get to that's the whole conversation actually.
- 55:02No,
- 55:02it's not because
- 55:0370% of women who have abortions are low income.
- 55:07So
- 55:07that's going to.
- 55:08What I said with the previous speaker that all of that is avoidable.
- 55:11So wait a minute,
- 55:12if you can afford
- 55:13all of that is avoidable.
- 55:14Listen,
- 55:15before,
- 55:15on average,
- 55:16before a woman has sex,
- 55:17unless,
- 55:17unless she's just it's about the knowing to get the contraceptives.
- 55:20It's about the
- 55:21education
- 55:21and what I'm saying is on a typical,
- 55:22on a typical,
- 55:23if we take two random individuals,
- 55:24unless the woman is an OnlyFans model or a prostitute
- 55:27before she sleeps with a man,
- 55:28he's
- 55:29courted her,
- 55:29he's taken her on dates,
- 55:30he's done something.
- 55:30So if,
- 55:31if within that process
- 55:32you can't find a way to go to a Kwik E Mart or well not a Kwik E Mart.
- 55:35You can't find a way to go with Texaco,
- 55:37QuikTrip something and pick up a pack of Trojans.
- 55:39It's not just about getting the Trojan.
- 55:41It's about the knowing of the fact this is super important.
- 55:43It's about the trends of your culture
- 55:46and even still,
- 55:47human beings know when you have sex you have
- 55:49a chance to produce babies just like when you
- 55:50know when you get in
- 55:51you got a chance to get in an accent.
- 55:54OK,
- 55:55while
- 55:55Roe v.
- 55:56Wade,
- 55:56right,
- 55:57protected sex ed,
- 55:58right,
- 55:58when we see tampering,
- 56:00can I finish?
- 56:00You're you're talking over me again,
- 56:02respectfully.
- 56:03OK,
- 56:03so not really
- 56:04you are,
- 56:05but anyway,
- 56:05um,
- 56:06when we look at sexual education in,
- 56:08um,
- 56:09areas where property taxes are funding,
- 56:11right,
- 56:12their education,
- 56:13right,
- 56:13maybe someone learned the pullout method,
- 56:15right?
- 56:15Maybe somebody learned,
- 56:17especially in the fact that like you're gonna have more
- 56:18mistrust of your institutions when you're in an impoverished area.
- 56:21Someone has less access
- 56:23to the literacy,
- 56:24sexual literacy than someone who's going to a private
- 56:27school and the daughter of like a congressman.
- 56:29So I'll give you this.
- 56:30Let that particular section of Roe v.
- 56:32Wade where where I'm assuming you're saying that there was a section in Roe v.
- 56:35Wade where sex education was made mandatory at the federal level.
- 56:37Is that,
- 56:37is that?
- 56:38Well,
- 56:38we're just sex education
- 56:39provided protections not just for abortion but
- 56:41also for sexual education to push that,
- 56:43etc.
- 56:44So I would be fine with sexual education being mandatory across the country.
- 56:47I wouldn't that wouldn't that sounds great,
- 56:49right?
- 56:50So I think to tailor
- 56:52we're out of time.
- 56:53Can I finish my statement?
- 56:54Yeah.
- 56:55To tailor your statement.
- 56:57Abortion is a product of a system,
- 57:00right?
- 57:01OK,
- 57:01yes,
- 57:02but it's a product of a system that does not address the economic inequality
- 57:06that
- 57:07for the most part brown and people face the brunt of.
- 57:10Can you unders can you accept that?
- 57:11I mean,
- 57:11I,
- 57:11I know that.
- 57:11That's why I'm saying because we understand the problems,
- 57:14wrap it up.
- 57:15Going back to that same principle.
- 57:17OK,
- 57:18got a lot to learn.
- 57:19Thank you so much.
- 57:24My next surrounding claim is that civil rights were won with Bibles and churches,
- 57:27not pronouns and DEI.
- 57:29If you would like to be the first debater,
- 57:31please get to the chair in 321.
- 57:37Zippy,
- 57:38it helps to be in track.
- 57:40Oh,
- 57:40my sister ran that.
- 57:41How are you?
- 57:41I'm awesome.
- 57:41I'm doing good.
- 57:42What's your name?
- 57:43I'm Gabriel.
- 57:43Nice to meet you,
- 57:44Gabriel.
- 57:44So I think my
- 57:47issue with the framing of this question
- 57:48is more of the fact that,
- 57:51firstly,
- 57:51DEI and pronouns,
- 57:52I would not argue like,
- 57:54yes,
- 57:54of course,
- 57:54they didn't necessarily win civil rights,
- 57:56but they are the they are the result of civil rights that are being won.
- 57:59Like DEI is literally the actualization,
- 58:01the cement,
- 58:02like cementing.
- 58:03Uh,
- 58:04the protections of black people and other such people
- 58:07in the workplace,
- 58:08in government,
- 58:08making
- 58:08sure that,
- 58:09who's the number one benefactor for DEI initiatives?
- 58:11White women,
- 58:12right?
- 58:12So which didn't do
- 58:13for my people.
- 58:14Well,
- 58:14it's not necessarily that it do anything for your people.
- 58:16It's 3% of all DEI hires in the last one of the last major
- 58:20reported studies showed that black people only made up 3% of all DEI hires.
- 58:23Over
- 58:23over 50% were made up of white women.
- 58:25Civil rights was the black,
- 58:27and I'm obviously we're talking about
- 58:28civil rights,
- 58:29so.
- 58:30The,
- 58:30the,
- 58:30the,
- 58:31you just said it.
- 58:32DEI was a result,
- 58:33uh,
- 58:34and,
- 58:34and an improperly used result of work that was done by Martin Luther King Jr.
- 58:38Medgar Evers,
- 58:39A.
- 58:40Philip Randolph,
- 58:41uh,
- 58:41Adam Clayton Powell Jr.
- 58:42Malcolm X,
- 58:43and what is the foundation of that movement,
- 58:45and this is what the left loves to do.
- 58:46The left loves to borrow the moral fruit of my religion,
- 58:48Christianity,
- 58:49while rejecting the root of that religion in and of itself.
- 58:51And actually,
- 58:52I don't want to dispute at all the,
- 58:54the role of the black church because I think the black.
- 58:56Obviously
- 58:57saying that the black church wasn't involved at all or essential to the movement
- 59:00would be a ridiculous claim.
- 59:01But I think uh my issue with the framing of this of this would be probably that
- 59:05the people that were essential to the establishment of the civil rights,
- 59:09like MLK,
- 59:10Malcolm X,
- 59:11all of these people,
- 59:12they would probably be the people that
- 59:15today the conservative movement would or the religious movement
- 59:17would likely view as traitors or people that,
- 59:20yes,
- 59:20because Malcolm X already Malcolm X was no liberal and Martin Luther King wasn't.
- 59:23Yeah,
- 59:23but that's my point,
- 59:24because the modern conservative movement and the
- 59:27modern religious movement as it is,
- 59:28because they're kind of intertwined,
- 59:29unfortunately,
- 59:30um,
- 59:31they kind of established that like,
- 59:33um,
- 59:33especially with like MAGA,
- 59:35like anti-Christianity,
- 59:36like anti anti-capitalism,
- 59:38anything like that is considered to be like this big evil thing.
- 59:42And we have reports like,
- 59:43for example,
- 59:44or like even like
- 59:45Islamophobia is a big problem.
- 59:46Like,
- 59:46for example,
- 59:47you know,
- 59:47this like Malcolm X was a big Muslim.
- 59:49He was um very much like very strong,
- 59:51not a liberal,
- 59:52not a conservative.
- 59:53He was a strong leftist.
- 59:55And that's
- 59:56like he was a leftist.
- 59:57So wait,
- 59:57wait,
- 59:57wait,
- 59:57wait,
- 59:58wait,
- 59:58wait,
- 59:58wait.
- 59:59Malcolm was not a leftist,
- 1:00:00but that just historically is inaccurate.
- 1:00:02He literally said that the liberal is the greatest enemy
- 1:00:04of black people in this country.
- 1:00:05But that's the thing,
- 1:00:06those are his words,
- 1:00:07not so I would disagree on the use of liberal as a term for the left.
- 1:00:10I would,
- 1:00:11Malcolm wouldn't.
- 1:00:12I'm not using his definition.
- 1:00:13He said if you can vote as black people for a a A party that has controlled 2/3 of
- 1:00:18the house of government and yet they've done nothing
- 1:00:20for black Americans and you continue to support them,
- 1:00:22you are a traitor to your race and you are a house negro.
- 1:00:25Yeah,
- 1:00:25I,
- 1:00:25in
- 1:00:26his words,
- 1:00:26yes,
- 1:00:27but what is the difference between the application of that,
- 1:00:29what is the difference of the Liberal Party of the 1960s,
- 1:00:31their platform
- 1:00:32versus today?
- 1:00:33There's almost no difference.
- 1:00:34Also,
- 1:00:35you've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:00:37Thank you so much.
- 1:00:38Thank you very much.
- 1:00:40If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:00:41please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:00:48Good to see you again.
- 1:00:50Um,
- 1:00:50OK,
- 1:00:51I do want to clear up something that you said in your earlier,
- 1:00:53uh,
- 1:00:53conversation that Malcolm X was never anti-capitalist.
- 1:00:56That's not true.
- 1:00:57Um,
- 1:00:57after Malcolm X traversed through African countries,
- 1:01:01he realized
- 1:01:02that the propping up of capitalist countries
- 1:01:04can only happen if they extract values,
- 1:01:06valuable resources,
- 1:01:08um,
- 1:01:08from colonized countries,
- 1:01:10um,
- 1:01:10from third world countries what we call them today,
- 1:01:12identify the flaws.
- 1:01:13He specifically said,
- 1:01:14no,
- 1:01:14he specifically said
- 1:01:15you show me a capitalist,
- 1:01:16I show you a bloodsucker.
- 1:01:18In
- 1:01:18nature he was anti-capitalist
- 1:01:20to start there.
- 1:01:21Do you recognize that?
- 1:01:22No,
- 1:01:22because I identify he identified himself as
- 1:01:24a black nationalism black nationalism is not incompatible
- 1:01:27with anti-capitalism.
- 1:01:28You recognize that.
- 1:01:29Capitalism is an economic system.
- 1:01:30Well,
- 1:01:31Malcolm Malcolm X is never on record self-identifying as a communist,
- 1:01:34so that's what you're engaging
- 1:01:35in.
- 1:01:36We can fact check it.
- 1:01:37I can't wait to see that fact check because he said
- 1:01:38it's showing you a saying that someone is a bloodsucker.
- 1:01:40I mean I could tell you that politics is a
- 1:01:41combination of two words poly which is great for me
- 1:01:43how about this?
- 1:01:43What do you think capitalism is?
- 1:01:46What do you mean?
- 1:01:46What do I think capitalism is?
- 1:01:47I think it's a it's a laissez-faire free market economy.
- 1:01:50We don't have capitalism in the United States right now,
- 1:01:52we have a mixed economy.
- 1:01:53What's the specific difference between capitalism?
- 1:01:55OK,
- 1:01:55we have to focus on the
- 1:01:57claim.
- 1:01:57I don't want to talk about I think it's important though because we're
- 1:02:00Talking about the values of the civil rights movement,
- 1:02:02where it comes from,
- 1:02:03what it supports,
- 1:02:04right?
- 1:02:04This was to create an equitable society.
- 1:02:06I don't think that you can do that
- 1:02:07with when when in a system that extracts resources from other individuals.
- 1:02:11What's funny about that?
- 1:02:12Because you keep talking about extracting of wealth.
- 1:02:14What was the founding principle of the civil rights movement,
- 1:02:16Xena?
- 1:02:16To establish an equitable society on a racial basis
- 1:02:20rooted in that value of equitability rooted in what?
- 1:02:23Equity.
- 1:02:25Are
- 1:02:26you trying to make me
- 1:02:27conform to some objective morality to say that people should have equal rights?
- 1:02:31I'm not trying to make you conform
- 1:02:32to it.
- 1:02:33I'm gonna say that that's what the case is.
- 1:02:34Martin Luther King
- 1:02:36Martin Luther King made the statement
- 1:02:37that all we say to America is be true to what you're saying on paper.
- 1:02:40Which is that somewhere where the freedom of speech,
- 1:02:42freedom of freedom of assembly,
- 1:02:44and that the greatness of America is the right to protest right.
- 1:02:46He's making a larger ontological appeal
- 1:02:49to
- 1:02:49a lot of waffling there.
- 1:02:51I'm not gonna lie to you.
- 1:02:52What was he?
- 1:02:53What do you mean what was he?
- 1:02:54What
- 1:02:54was his occupation?
- 1:02:56Jesus
- 1:02:57Christ.
- 1:02:59That's a better question.
- 1:03:03He was a Baptist preacher.
- 1:03:04You just don't
- 1:03:05say it.
- 1:03:09Obviously
- 1:03:09you didn't
- 1:03:10say that
- 1:03:11he
- 1:03:12was a
- 1:03:12human being.
- 1:03:12You asked me what he
- 1:03:14asked me what his occupation.
- 1:03:17You gotta
- 1:03:17stop that.
- 1:03:18Um,
- 1:03:19there's nothing wrong with supporting this idea that we should,
- 1:03:22you know,
- 1:03:23values that are good are values that are good.
- 1:03:24However,
- 1:03:25you have to actually isolate what is this
- 1:03:27quality of the black church that you believe
- 1:03:29actually pushed us to,
- 1:03:31um,
- 1:03:32OK,
- 1:03:33specifically what about the Bible?
- 1:03:34The belief that all men
- 1:03:35are made in the image of God and
- 1:03:37as a result of being made in the image of God you're entitled to certain rights
- 1:03:40that are intrinsic
- 1:03:42objectively intrinsic
- 1:03:44Deuteronomy,
- 1:03:44is that how you
- 1:03:45say it?
- 1:03:46Thank you.
- 1:03:4621 1014.
- 1:03:47Do you know what that,
- 1:03:48um,
- 1:03:49those verses say?
- 1:03:50Not right off the top of my head.
- 1:03:51OK,
- 1:03:51cool.
- 1:03:51So they basically talk about how God
- 1:03:54affirms your ability to
- 1:03:56take,
- 1:03:56um,
- 1:03:56a woman captive if you go to war with her with their country,
- 1:04:00and you can take her,
- 1:04:01have her mourn her father for a month,
- 1:04:03and then
- 1:04:04you have a wife,
- 1:04:05right?
- 1:04:05It also there are other,
- 1:04:06um,
- 1:04:06what is it?
- 1:04:07Ephesians 6:5.
- 1:04:08Ephesians 6:5 also is New Testament
- 1:04:10which
- 1:04:11I'm not done.
- 1:04:11I'm not done.
- 1:04:13Nothing to do with the fact that you're you're not gonna
- 1:04:16like
- 1:04:16what's your problem,
- 1:04:17bro?
- 1:04:17Anyway,
- 1:04:18Ephesians 6:5,
- 1:04:19New Testament,
- 1:04:20another verse that affirms
- 1:04:21one's ability to hold slaves.
- 1:04:24That is a value that is directly
- 1:04:26quoted from the Bible.
- 1:04:27Are those the values that civil rights movement would have proposed?
- 1:04:30So what you're doing is engaging in what's called
- 1:04:32I'm gonna tell you what you're doing so you don't want me to interrupt you,
- 1:04:34but you're gonna interrupt me.
- 1:04:35That's what I'm doing.
- 1:04:35You're you're engaging in the borrowed capital fallacy because you're an
- 1:04:38atheist and now you're trying to tell me how to interpret.
- 1:04:41You're OK,
- 1:04:41we're even better.
- 1:04:42You don't even,
- 1:04:43you don't know,
- 1:04:43you don't know definitively whether or not there is a God,
- 1:04:45so you're still engaging in the borrowed capital fallacy.
- 1:04:46You don't believe in the Bible.
- 1:04:48You don't believe in the Bible
- 1:04:50Deuteronomy
- 1:04:52or not?
- 1:04:53It said that under the mosaic,
- 1:04:54it said that under the mosaic
- 1:04:56woman
- 1:04:56as a captive and make her his wife.
- 1:04:57Within the confines of the book of Deuteronomy,
- 1:04:59since you want to go about the Bible,
- 1:05:00what is that?
- 1:05:01OK,
- 1:05:01right,
- 1:05:01let's do that now.
- 1:05:02So that's that's an institution of the Mosaic law,
- 1:05:04right?
- 1:05:05When did the Mosaic
- 1:05:05Was the Mosaic law established?
- 1:05:07Can you affirm the question I asked?
- 1:05:08I'm answering the question.
- 1:05:09I did the Bible,
- 1:05:10yes,
- 1:05:10it says that.
- 1:05:11OK,
- 1:05:11so slavery under
- 1:05:13under biblical morality,
- 1:05:14slavery is OK.
- 1:05:15No,
- 1:05:15it's not,
- 1:05:16not the same kind of slavery.
- 1:05:17There's a difference because what you're kind of slavery is OK
- 1:05:19because you're doing
- 1:05:20there's another verse.
- 1:05:21What you are doing Exodus 21:20.
- 1:05:23I
- 1:05:26mean,
- 1:05:26look,
- 1:05:26listen,
- 1:05:27I've had this discussion.
- 1:05:28I'm a former atheist.
- 1:05:29While you were a former,
- 1:05:30while you're a current agnostic.
- 1:05:30I'm a former atheist.
- 1:05:31I've gone through all of them,
- 1:05:32and I'm a former Christian.
- 1:05:33Beautiful,
- 1:05:33fantastic.
- 1:05:34But what you're still,
- 1:05:35no,
- 1:05:35we're not twins.
- 1:05:36I got one already.
- 1:05:37I'll keep my twin sister.
- 1:05:39Take her 100%.
- 1:05:40What you're engaging in is the borrowed capital fallacy.
- 1:05:42The book of Exodus,
- 1:05:43the Book of Deuteronomy,
- 1:05:44if you allow me to finish,
- 1:05:45you're quoting it incorrectly.
- 1:05:46What you're dealing with,
- 1:05:47I'm,
- 1:05:48if you allow me to finish,
- 1:05:49I'm gonna tell you how
- 1:05:50what you're talking about is under the is a
- 1:05:51is a set of rules established by the Mosaic law
- 1:05:54which came in.
- 1:05:55After the fall of mankind in the Garden of Eden.
- 1:05:58So if we're gonna really be
- 1:05:59true to the Bible,
- 1:06:00you have to follow it within its chronological
- 1:06:02orders.
- 1:06:02So what you're in the slavery piece,
- 1:06:04the,
- 1:06:04the chattel slavery that was practiced in the United States is any
- 1:06:08kind of slavery
- 1:06:09any kind of slavery OK?
- 1:06:10Indentured
- 1:06:11any kind of slavery
- 1:06:13question.
- 1:06:18I mean,
- 1:06:18because there's no point in us continuing this conversation that's gonna be.
- 1:06:21I'm trying to tell you that what the the comparison you're
- 1:06:24attempting to make between chattel slavery
- 1:06:25and biblical slavery or indentured servitude
- 1:06:28are completely different things.
- 1:06:29You just asked me a question that
- 1:06:32we're gonna have to pause here because you've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:06:35Thank
- 1:06:35you.
- 1:06:39If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:06:40please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:06:47You have been a co-host,
- 1:06:48you have been a co-host of my opponent.
- 1:06:50Oh no,
- 1:06:50I'm nervous now.
- 1:06:51Oh God.
- 1:06:52Good to see you again.
- 1:06:53Good to see you.
- 1:06:53Um,
- 1:06:54OK,
- 1:06:54so I think I just want to focus on the Bibles and churches aspect of this because it
- 1:06:58seems like that's your broader main claim that Christianity
- 1:07:00was largely responsible for producing this moral victory,
- 1:07:03right?
- 1:07:04OK,
- 1:07:04I can't necessarily disagree with some of that.
- 1:07:07Thank you very much.
- 1:07:08Don't color me impressed.
- 1:07:10You know why?
- 1:07:10OK,
- 1:07:11or don't impress me of color,
- 1:07:12OK?
- 1:07:12You know why?
- 1:07:14Because the exact same Bible.
- 1:07:17was invoked by all of the people who were
- 1:07:19against the civil rights movement in the first place.
- 1:07:22Yeah,
- 1:07:22absolutely.
- 1:07:23OK,
- 1:07:23so then the Bible is not what's doing the heavy lifting.
- 1:07:25The church is not what's doing the heavy lifting.
- 1:07:27It's the people who are doing the heavy lifting.
- 1:07:29They just happen to use that as a vessel because
- 1:07:31everyone happened to belong to a church back then.
- 1:07:33So it's not that impressive that that was the fact,
- 1:07:35right?
- 1:07:36Well,
- 1:07:36what's impressive is the fact that I think that
- 1:07:38the Bible was properly interpreted by the people that
- 1:07:41said all men are made in the image of God,
- 1:07:43that read the Bible for what it was.
- 1:07:44You know,
- 1:07:44when they,
- 1:07:45and this is something that people often do with Christian.
- 1:07:46Christianity,
- 1:07:47they,
- 1:07:47you know,
- 1:07:48they call it the white man's religion,
- 1:07:49right?
- 1:07:49But the problem is when they gave,
- 1:07:51they didn't give slaves actual Bibles.
- 1:07:52They gave them what was called selected scriptures for the American Negro.
- 1:07:55You know what was,
- 1:07:56you know,
- 1:07:56the books that were missing?
- 1:07:57Deuteronomy was missing.
- 1:07:58Numbers was Exodus was missing.
- 1:08:00The whole story of
- 1:08:01the Jews escaping slavery in Egypt was missing out of the Bible.
- 1:08:03They were so if you misuse something and you misquote something,
- 1:08:07you're just a lying asshole.
- 1:08:08Well,
- 1:08:08I agree,
- 1:08:08I agree they misuse it,
- 1:08:09and I,
- 1:08:10and I agree they lied about part of the message,
- 1:08:11but that,
- 1:08:12that kind of proves my point,
- 1:08:13doesn't it?
- 1:08:14Because it just proves humans can do stupid shit.
- 1:08:15No,
- 1:08:15it proves my point.
- 1:08:16Because
- 1:08:17if two people can interpret it in both sides in different
- 1:08:19ways to utilize their means of whatever they want to achieve,
- 1:08:23then it's not the Bible,
- 1:08:24then it's not the Bible doing the producing the unique moral good.
- 1:08:27Interpreting and altering are different,
- 1:08:29Jake.
- 1:08:29You gotta be honest there,
- 1:08:30because if I take verses out of that thing and then I'm like,
- 1:08:32you know,
- 1:08:33let me just give you.
- 1:08:34We already talked about slavery.
- 1:08:35It says a lot about slavery.
- 1:08:36The one thing it doesn't do is it condemns slavery in the Bible.
- 1:08:38So you can use it does.
- 1:08:39It says that in the story.
- 1:08:40You can use the OK,
- 1:08:41you can use the wait,
- 1:08:42wait,
- 1:08:42wait,
- 1:08:42no,
- 1:08:43approves slavery.
- 1:08:44No,
- 1:08:44it approves indentured servitude.
- 1:08:45OK.
- 1:08:46Fine.
- 1:08:47I mean,
- 1:08:48I've read,
- 1:08:48I used to not believe in the book.
- 1:08:49I've I've read.
- 1:08:50So do you believe in indentured servitude?
- 1:08:52No,
- 1:08:52right?
- 1:08:52To a degree,
- 1:08:53to a degree,
- 1:08:54OK,
- 1:08:54I,
- 1:08:54I don't wanna get this conversation off.
- 1:08:56I don't wanna get this conversation off into an indentured servitude
- 1:09:00discussion.
- 1:09:00I wanna go back to the,
- 1:09:01the Bibles are,
- 1:09:02you say,
- 1:09:03kind of the independent variable in the equation of liberty,
- 1:09:06but I fundamentally disagree.
- 1:09:08Good leadership and good strategy is the independent variable
- 1:09:11in the equation of what is rooted liberty.
- 1:09:13What is that leadership rooted in?
- 1:09:15In
- 1:09:15what do you,
- 1:09:16does it have to be rooted in Christianity?
- 1:09:17Wait,
- 1:09:18wait,
- 1:09:18was Gandhi was Gandhi rooted in Christianity like he went through the church.
- 1:09:22OK,
- 1:09:22so you don't have so clearly civil rights movements,
- 1:09:25successful civil rights movements can happen
- 1:09:27without the church or without Christianity.
- 1:09:28But what,
- 1:09:28what happened was that the the
- 1:09:30same principles appeared across multiple iterations,
- 1:09:32right?
- 1:09:32I'm not saying you have to,
- 1:09:33you don't even have to know the Bible exists to practice biblical principles.
- 1:09:36The fact that you don't know or the fact that you can't directly ascribe
- 1:09:40how you move in a certain way
- 1:09:41to a particular religious text doesn't matter.
- 1:09:43If you practice the fruit of the tree while
- 1:09:45not recognizing that that's where it came from,
- 1:09:47doesn't matter.
- 1:09:47So by that logic,
- 1:09:48because
- 1:09:49I'm gonna have to pause here.
- 1:09:50You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:09:52Let's do it.
- 1:09:53Good to see you again.
- 1:09:55If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:09:57please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:10:08The rematch.
- 1:10:09Why do you feel so comfortable
- 1:10:10parroting white Christian nationalist talking points?
- 1:10:13I don't parrot white Christian nationalist talking points.
- 1:10:16Literally,
- 1:10:16you sitting here saying
- 1:10:17DEI
- 1:10:19and talking about like
- 1:10:20pronouns and civil rights.
- 1:10:21First and foremost,
- 1:10:22just to get this out of the way,
- 1:10:23uh,
- 1:10:24the Civil Rights Act,
- 1:10:25civil rights as a whole,
- 1:10:26that was quote unquote DEI,
- 1:10:28but it wasn't
- 1:10:31it was
- 1:10:32finally being forced to.
- 1:10:33It was finally America,
- 1:10:34wait a minute,
- 1:10:35it was finally.
- 1:10:36America being forced to recognize that it
- 1:10:38to live up
- 1:10:39to its stated principles in the Constitution.
- 1:10:40Title 1 voting,
- 1:10:42Title 23,
- 1:10:43public spaces,
- 1:10:44government spaces,
- 1:10:45Title 4 education,
- 1:10:47Title 6,
- 1:10:48federal aid assistance,
- 1:10:49Title 7,
- 1:10:50you know,
- 1:10:50all that legal language serves to make
- 1:10:52all that legal language serves to make sense
- 1:10:54when the one of the worst criminal justice,
- 1:10:56I'm gonna respond,
- 1:10:57one of the
- 1:10:58worst rulings in the history of this
- 1:10:59country that all those titles you just beautifully
- 1:11:00named addressed was the fact that Chief Justice Roger Tanney at one point said.
- 1:11:03A black man
- 1:11:04or a negro,
- 1:11:05to quote his words,
- 1:11:05has no rights that he as a white man is bound to respect.
- 1:11:07So what and that was codified into law.
- 1:11:09So if bullshit was codified into law,
- 1:11:11the truth had to no,
- 1:11:12I ain't
- 1:11:13I ain't pontificating.
- 1:11:14I'm extrapolating,
- 1:11:15you understand?
- 1:11:15I'm sure there's a difference.
- 1:11:17What is the A?
- 1:11:19You don't know what the A is in DEIA?
- 1:11:21I mean,
- 1:11:22I didn't know there was an A.
- 1:11:23Y'all y'all add new letters every other week.
- 1:11:26Whoa,
- 1:11:26whoa,
- 1:11:26whoa.
- 1:11:27First and foremost,
- 1:11:28the A is for accessibility.
- 1:11:30Who does that cover?
- 1:11:31I would imagine it's people that may be disabled.
- 1:11:34Exactly.
- 1:11:34What do you know how
- 1:11:35long
- 1:11:36Bibles and
- 1:11:37wait,
- 1:11:37wait,
- 1:11:37wait,
- 1:11:37do you know how long DEIA has been a thing?
- 1:11:40I don't.
- 1:11:41That's not what I'm here talking about the 1960s.
- 1:11:42I know it's I said DI so if the A is not there,
- 1:11:44they're actually not even part of my
- 1:11:46parroting
- 1:11:47white supremacist
- 1:11:48talking points.
- 1:11:49DEI
- 1:11:50for everyone who may not know,
- 1:11:51what is,
- 1:11:52what is,
- 1:11:52wait a minute,
- 1:11:53what is white supremacist about?
- 1:11:54Don't worry.
- 1:11:55I have
- 1:11:57a.
- 1:11:59I have a good track record of schooling
- 1:12:01black conservatives and I got you.
- 1:12:03You don't have me on anything.
- 1:12:04You're obfuscating.
- 1:12:05You added a letter to something that wasn't even my original
- 1:12:07claim.
- 1:12:09The reason why they say DEI
- 1:12:11is because
- 1:12:12the word is a dog whistle.
- 1:12:14It has an etymology.
- 1:12:16We're here to talk about the fact that civil rights were
- 1:12:18Bibles in churches,
- 1:12:19not pronouns in DEI and now you added a letter that isn't even my claim.
- 1:12:22So really I don't have to listen.
- 1:12:23Listen,
- 1:12:24no,
- 1:12:24it's not
- 1:12:25in my claim.
- 1:12:25The reason why he said DEI is the same reason
- 1:12:28they used to say the word,
- 1:12:29uh,
- 1:12:30uh,
- 1:12:30critical race theory,
- 1:12:32right?
- 1:12:32CRT.
- 1:12:33Wait,
- 1:12:33wait,
- 1:12:34wait.
- 1:12:34Listen,
- 1:12:35I need you to hear me.
- 1:12:36CRT
- 1:12:38before CRT
- 1:12:39they used to say BLM,
- 1:12:40Black Lives Matter.
- 1:12:42What does that have to do
- 1:12:43with
- 1:12:43BLM
- 1:12:45before BLM
- 1:12:46they used to before they said BLM
- 1:12:48they used to say the word thug.
- 1:12:50And before
- 1:12:51Who's the?
- 1:12:52Who is the?
- 1:12:53They said the word boy.
- 1:12:55And before the word boy,
- 1:12:57they called us the N-word.
- 1:12:59So you actually say DEI,
- 1:13:01they only talk about DEI when they talk about black people.
- 1:13:04This is not TikTok.
- 1:13:05Nothing you said has anything to do with my claim.
- 1:13:07It's the etymology of the word.
- 1:13:08The etymology.
- 1:13:09I'm talking about the action.
- 1:13:10I'm talking about the action.
- 1:13:11You just sat here and tried to say that
- 1:13:13I'm parroting white supremacist talking points when I'm because
- 1:13:15you don't.
- 1:13:16That has ever been on the
- 1:13:17internet.
- 1:13:18Anti-black
- 1:13:19anti-black
- 1:13:20and you're queerphobic.
- 1:13:22Queerphobic?
- 1:13:23You and you're a raging misogynist.
- 1:13:26You need to unpack.
- 1:13:27I need to unpack.
- 1:13:28He
- 1:13:32hasn't addressed my claim at all.
- 1:13:33He has said nothing of the fact that he can't because you know why?
- 1:13:36Because he can't run from the reality of it.
- 1:13:38The reality of it is the civil rights movement does
- 1:13:40not win without God being at the center of it.
- 1:13:42That is exactly why Martin Luther.
- 1:13:43King is the only American in this country's history
- 1:13:45that passed more legislation.
- 1:13:47The womanizer,
- 1:13:48sure,
- 1:13:48the womanizer,
- 1:13:49whatever.
- 1:13:50We can talk about Ella Baker.
- 1:13:52We can talk about James Baldwin.
- 1:13:54We can talk
- 1:13:54about WE Bolton.
- 1:13:55I want to talk about Martin Luther King Jr.
- 1:13:57and Malcolm X.
- 1:13:57I
- 1:13:58was
- 1:13:59talking
- 1:13:59about
- 1:13:59how was Martin Luther King Jr.
- 1:14:01Martin Luther King Jr.
- 1:14:02No,
- 1:14:02they didn't legislative.
- 1:14:05Who got invited to the White House?
- 1:14:06None of them.
- 1:14:06Who got invited to the White House.
- 1:14:09Martin Luther King was a token figurehead.
- 1:14:10The FBI surveilling him and telling him to kill himself.
- 1:14:12He was a token figurehead.
- 1:14:14Bullshit.
- 1:14:14When I tell you
- 1:14:15the movement was bigger
- 1:14:18than your Messiah.
- 1:14:19So you have called me a token.
- 1:14:22You've said I'm supporting white supremacist token.
- 1:14:25No,
- 1:14:25you said Martin Luther King was a token.
- 1:14:26You said King was falsely a Marxist,
- 1:14:27which is a lie.
- 1:14:28I just quoted that I refuted that poem when we were talking.
- 1:14:31Absolute lie.
- 1:14:32You said that I am a
- 1:14:33raging misogynist,
- 1:14:34I don't know how the hell that's possible.
- 1:14:36What about me is misogynistic.
- 1:14:38The fact that me and Zena can have a disagreement and
- 1:14:39argue back and forth because I guarantee you I would,
- 1:14:41I would do whatever it took
- 1:14:43to make sure that I want to
- 1:14:45create an egalitarian society,
- 1:14:46but I'm a raging misogynist.
- 1:14:47Sure,
- 1:14:48you have done nothing to actually address the claim because
- 1:14:50you came up here to obfuscate and pontificate about some bullshit
- 1:14:53because the claim that I gave is irrefutable.
- 1:14:55There is no way that the civil rights movement wins in this country without the.
- 1:14:58The Bible being at its foundation,
- 1:14:59and you know that as well as I do.
- 1:15:01The reason you don't want to run from it is because you're not a Christian.
- 1:15:03That's fine.
- 1:15:04You don't have to accept my worldview,
- 1:15:05but you have to accept the fact that no American besides Martin Luther King Junior
- 1:15:10other than Martin Luther King Junior got more legislation passed
- 1:15:12for us within the same time frame as the Malcolms,
- 1:15:14as the
- 1:15:15James Baldwin's,
- 1:15:16as the Adam Clayton Powells,
- 1:15:17and he was in Congress,
- 1:15:18by the way,
- 1:15:19one of the most effective congressmen of all time.
- 1:15:20None of that is possible without religion being
- 1:15:23perfect,
- 1:15:23perfect.
- 1:15:24First and foremost,
- 1:15:24the reason why you are a misogynist,
- 1:15:27a raging misogynist,
- 1:15:28is because you haven't taken the time to actually unpack any of the things
- 1:15:33specifically black men.
- 1:15:34I sat here quietly for a minute,
- 1:15:37the things that black men have done specifically during the civil rights era,
- 1:15:41you know what's funny about the civil rights era?
- 1:15:44Black women
- 1:15:45actually gave up their pursuit of feminism
- 1:15:47in order to actually uplift the.
- 1:15:49Civil rights movement.
- 1:15:50They literally put themselves
- 1:15:52to the back
- 1:15:53in order to ensure that black people as a whole had what they,
- 1:15:56they had to get.
- 1:15:56And they were,
- 1:15:57they were abandoned,
- 1:15:58they were abandoned by black men
- 1:16:00and by women,
- 1:16:01white women.
- 1:16:02The point that I'm saying
- 1:16:05you're specifically trying to call back to a time
- 1:16:08where you are,
- 1:16:09you,
- 1:16:09you're uplifting these leaders
- 1:16:11that did the same that you're doing,
- 1:16:13but yet you don't listen to black women.
- 1:16:16Do you
- 1:16:17I recommended a book for you.
- 1:16:18I recommended a book for you.
- 1:16:21That has nothing
- 1:16:22to do with
- 1:16:22what I'm talking about.
- 1:16:23What was the point of reading the book?
- 1:16:24That has nothing to do with what I was the point of reading the book?
- 1:16:27To understand opposition's viewpoints.
- 1:16:29You were supposed to read the book to understand
- 1:16:31black women and their struggle.
- 1:16:33You wanted to read the book
- 1:16:34so you could tear down black women that are feminists.
- 1:16:36That was your entire point.
- 1:16:38My entire point of reading Bell Hook.
- 1:16:40to
- 1:16:41go to a different point
- 1:16:42so you can
- 1:16:43attack
- 1:16:44black
- 1:16:44women
- 1:16:46and you're misogynist and you're queerphobic.
- 1:16:49You have no
- 1:16:50evidence to support
- 1:16:50any of this.
- 1:16:50Your claim
- 1:16:52put black people in the queer community against each other.
- 1:16:55No,
- 1:16:56it identifies
- 1:16:56it identifies the fact that Democrats have been lying to black people for decades.
- 1:17:00I ain't going for this shit.
- 1:17:01If you're gonna get,
- 1:17:01if you're gonna stop.
- 1:17:03If
- 1:17:03Democrats have had the black voting base.
- 1:17:05To a rate of over 80%
- 1:17:06over 20 years,
- 1:17:08conservatives are flat out,
- 1:17:09they're not they're not holding them accountable.
- 1:17:12You put two marginalized communities against each other
- 1:17:15because you have a problem.
- 1:17:16I'm making a statement that the left who has,
- 1:17:18who has more voted black support on average?
- 1:17:20The the left or the right?
- 1:17:21Answer that.
- 1:17:22Who
- 1:17:22has more than the left?
- 1:17:24OK
- 1:17:24then,
- 1:17:24so the problem is the country as a whole
- 1:17:26he's honest in that regard.
- 1:17:27The problem
- 1:17:28is
- 1:17:28you're not willing to talk.
- 1:17:29Talk about the conservatives because then you have to talk about yourself.
- 1:17:31That's why you're not willing to unpack.
- 1:17:33That's why you're not willing to address your misogyny.
- 1:17:35That's why you're not willing to address your anti-blackness.
- 1:17:37That's why you're not willing to address your queer phobia.
- 1:17:39It's
- 1:17:41clearly people,
- 1:17:41I hold conservatives accountable all the time.
- 1:17:43I,
- 1:17:43I,
- 1:17:43I go look at the video I did on Brandon Tatum.
- 1:17:45Go look at the video I did on the president for the past 4 months.
- 1:17:47Go look at the fact that I said that the
- 1:17:48president in the current administration has not been America first.
- 1:17:51If anybody is a genuine pro-black conservative.
- 1:17:54you actually listen to another marginalized community
- 1:17:58and
- 1:17:58took
- 1:17:58that.
- 1:18:00I listen to them every
- 1:18:01day.
- 1:18:02I've listened to Tashika's live.
- 1:18:03She's here,
- 1:18:03she's fantastic.
- 1:18:04I've listened to Zena's live.
- 1:18:05She's fantastic.
- 1:18:06Ari
- 1:18:06for
- 1:18:07education.
- 1:18:07She's fantastic.
- 1:18:08Shout out to Ari for education.
- 1:18:09One of the most intelligent black women
- 1:18:11that I know.
- 1:18:13Why
- 1:18:13is it that
- 1:18:15she's fantastic.
- 1:18:16Even though we disagree,
- 1:18:17any and every time you speak
- 1:18:19to her,
- 1:18:19you crash out.
- 1:18:20Just like this.
- 1:18:21You
- 1:18:21do this.
- 1:18:22Because it's a black film voice
- 1:18:24that actually gets.
- 1:18:25It's not.
- 1:18:25I just gave you two,
- 1:18:26I just gave you two great black female content creators that
- 1:18:28even though I disagree with both because they're sitting right here.
- 1:18:30No,
- 1:18:31because they're sitting right here.
- 1:18:32Ishika,
- 1:18:32have I not sent you,
- 1:18:33does he want to do that?
- 1:18:34Have I not sent you
- 1:18:35sitting
- 1:18:35right here.
- 1:18:35Xena,
- 1:18:36have I not tapped on your TikTok?
- 1:18:37Of
- 1:18:37course.
- 1:18:38Whether we disagree or not,
- 1:18:38we said no,
- 1:18:39stop,
- 1:18:39because now you're just tapping.
- 1:18:40I sat at a round table with Xena and while we may disagree vehemently,
- 1:18:44wouldn't you
- 1:18:44let her speak?
- 1:18:45What do you mean?
- 1:18:46As she sat here trying to speak to you,
- 1:18:48we
- 1:18:48talk to each other.
- 1:18:49We're human
- 1:18:49beings.
- 1:18:50Who
- 1:18:50cares?
- 1:18:51Other people,
- 1:18:52the
- 1:18:52only
- 1:18:52people.
- 1:18:52telling me all the time.
- 1:18:54What are we
- 1:18:54talking
- 1:18:54about?
- 1:18:55There's been a real overtalking
- 1:18:57nonstop,
- 1:18:57you and I,
- 1:18:58sure,
- 1:18:58but when Xena sat up here and tried to get her point across multiple times,
- 1:19:02you couldn't stop to
- 1:19:03hear the
- 1:19:04black.
- 1:19:05You had a good conversation with Tashika.
- 1:19:07I'll give you that.
- 1:19:07I'll give you that.
- 1:19:08When you had an issue with Xena,
- 1:19:10you had an issue
- 1:19:11with
- 1:19:11you have a personal relationship,
- 1:19:13you have a personal relationship with Tashika.
- 1:19:14No,
- 1:19:15I do not.
- 1:19:16I
- 1:19:16met her on TikTok
- 1:19:17before.
- 1:19:17You said you messaged her.
- 1:19:18I'm gonna square the circle.
- 1:19:19What?
- 1:19:20I got it.
- 1:19:21The big issue is
- 1:19:24the big issue is
- 1:19:26the black conservative man is the weakest link
- 1:19:29in the black community,
- 1:19:30and that's you.
- 1:19:31You need to unpack all of those things.
- 1:19:34I'm the one sitting at the table surrounded by 20 people.
- 1:19:36And I've been pretty strong for the past 4
- 1:19:38masculinity,
- 1:19:40masculinity,
- 1:19:40masculinity is toxic.
- 1:19:42Uh,
- 1:19:43that's not what we're here to talk about,
- 1:19:44but if you want to go down that road,
- 1:19:45but that's the reason why you're sitting here.
- 1:19:47It's your ego.
- 1:19:47The only reason I'm sitting here is because I'm a man.
- 1:19:50Not
- 1:19:50because I'm qualified.
- 1:19:51No,
- 1:19:51no,
- 1:19:51no,
- 1:19:51no,
- 1:19:52no,
- 1:19:52because I do the same thing you do.
- 1:19:53The reason why you're sitting right here right now,
- 1:19:56the reason why you're sitting here right now
- 1:19:58and doing this is because of your masculinity.
- 1:19:59No,
- 1:19:59it's because I put in the work.
- 1:20:01It's because I was not working to sit
- 1:20:02across.
- 1:20:03You just said I'm sitting here because of my masculinity.
- 1:20:05You just did it twice.
- 1:20:06You just sat here and negated the work that I,
- 1:20:07as a black man,
- 1:20:08no,
- 1:20:08you can't hear
- 1:20:09me because I just tailored your ego.
- 1:20:10OK,
- 1:20:11Santana,
- 1:20:11you gotta let him finish though.
- 1:20:12You guys are talking over each other.
- 1:20:14You just sat here and said,
- 1:20:16the only reason I'm sitting in this chair is because I'm a man.
- 1:20:18That's not it.
- 1:20:19The reason I'm sitting in this chair is because I put.
- 1:20:21Over 10,000 hours of work making content since
- 1:20:24from 2020 on Clubhouse
- 1:20:25to 2026 sitting right here,
- 1:20:26my brother.
- 1:20:27That's work.
- 1:20:28That has nothing to do with it.
- 1:20:29My
- 1:20:30sister
- 1:20:30could have done this,
- 1:20:31my twin could have did it,
- 1:20:31my mama could have did it,
- 1:20:32my daddy could have did it,
- 1:20:33you're doing it now.
- 1:20:33I'm not negating the work that you've done.
- 1:20:35I'm not saying that.
- 1:20:36No,
- 1:20:36I didn't.
- 1:20:37I was very clear.
- 1:20:38I said
- 1:20:38the reason why you're doing this right now is because of your ego.
- 1:20:42The reason,
- 1:20:42the reason why you can't
- 1:20:43hear me,
- 1:20:44the reason why you can't hear me is because of your ego.
- 1:20:46No,
- 1:20:47the reason I
- 1:20:48heard
- 1:20:48what you said.
- 1:20:49This is the first time I've told you this.
- 1:20:51Yes,
- 1:20:51100%.
- 1:20:52And so,
- 1:20:52so why did I recommend Bell Hooks to you?
- 1:20:55Because we were having a conversation,
- 1:20:56if I'm not mistaken,
- 1:20:57I
- 1:20:57told
- 1:20:57you about
- 1:20:58to unpack your
- 1:20:59misogyny.
- 1:20:59Yeah,
- 1:21:00and I said I'm not a misogynist.
- 1:21:00I disagree with you.
- 1:21:01I said you're wrong.
- 1:21:02I said you're wrong.
- 1:21:03I'm saying you're wrong again.
- 1:21:03I'm gonna keep saying you're wrong.
- 1:21:04The reason we disagree the reason why you're crashing out in front of everybody
- 1:21:08right now.
- 1:21:09It's
- 1:21:09because your
- 1:21:09fragile masculinity.
- 1:21:11You're saying shit that is patently false.
- 1:21:13If you call this a crash out,
- 1:21:14then hey,
- 1:21:14I guess I'm,
- 1:21:15I guess it's in control.
- 1:21:15I crashed out on Jake White.
- 1:21:17That was a crash.
- 1:21:17It's your fragile masculinity.
- 1:21:18Jake,
- 1:21:19that was a crash out.
- 1:21:19Jake White was a crash out.
- 1:21:20This is just correcting bullshit.
- 1:21:22I,
- 1:21:22I'll square the circle with all of this.
- 1:21:24When you talk about
- 1:21:25the WWE.
- 1:21:27When you talk about the 19,
- 1:21:28um,
- 1:21:28I'm sorry,
- 1:21:29when you talk about the Civil Rights Act,
- 1:21:31at the heart of the Civil Rights Act was Jesus Christ
- 1:21:33and Christ and him crucified.
- 1:21:35It was Martin Luther King saying,
- 1:21:36I believe and I have a
- 1:21:37dream.
- 1:21:38And one day,
- 1:21:38who don't?
- 1:21:39The people on YouTube want to hear this.
- 1:21:41They wanted to hear it and
- 1:21:42watch
- 1:21:42it.
- 1:21:42250,000
- 1:21:43of the Civil Rights Act
- 1:21:45was Jesus Christ
- 1:21:46and him crucified
- 1:21:48equity and the gospel.
- 1:21:49Equity,
- 1:21:50inclusion.
- 1:21:51And you do that how?
- 1:21:52By believing that all men are made in the image of God
- 1:21:53and because all men are made in the image of God,
- 1:21:55they're endowed by their Creator with certain.
- 1:21:58And we're gonna be honest,
- 1:21:59Jesus was a black communist.
- 1:22:01So
- 1:22:01like show me where in the Bible he was a communist.
- 1:22:04Show me where.
- 1:22:05Because you're just actions.
- 1:22:07You're
- 1:22:08a lot.
- 1:22:08He took care of everyone.
- 1:22:10He didn't want people to uphold money or worship money.
- 1:22:12He said render unto
- 1:22:13Caesar.
- 1:22:14He said render
- 1:22:15unto
- 1:22:15Caesar.
- 1:22:15Yeah,
- 1:22:15he's God.
- 1:22:16He did.
- 1:22:17That's not communist.
- 1:22:18So doing the right thing automatically makes you communist.
- 1:22:20Communism communism is making
- 1:22:22sure that people have
- 1:22:23what they need.
- 1:22:24Tell me what about Christianity.
- 1:22:27Tell me what about Christianity makes sure
- 1:22:29we
- 1:22:29have to pause here.
- 1:22:31My next surrounding claim is that the Republican
- 1:22:33Party cares more about free speech than Democrats.
- 1:22:36Alright,
- 1:22:36if you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:22:38please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:22:44No
- 1:22:45How are you,
- 1:22:45sir?
- 1:22:45What's your name?
- 1:22:48What's good,
- 1:22:48yo?
- 1:22:50I'm Zerry.
- 1:22:51Nice to meet you.
- 1:22:52Nice to
- 1:22:52meet you.
- 1:22:52Is that a diamond button?
- 1:22:54It's Crystal.
- 1:22:55Oh,
- 1:22:55it's Crystal.
- 1:22:55That's my bad.
- 1:22:56Uh yeah,
- 1:22:57my name's Eric.
- 1:22:58Eric.
- 1:22:58Austin,
- 1:22:58nice to meet you.
- 1:22:59First of all,
- 1:22:59I wanna just ask,
- 1:23:00why do you think the Republicans hold freedom of speech
- 1:23:03to more importance than the Democrats do?
- 1:23:05Well,
- 1:23:06because when you look at what happened in 2020 with COVID,
- 1:23:08for example,
- 1:23:09the Biden administration.
- 1:23:10Pressured Facebook,
- 1:23:11Meta,
- 1:23:12and Twitter
- 1:23:12to silence people that may have offered what they called misinformation about
- 1:23:15the COVID vaccine and the COVID virus in and of itself,
- 1:23:18um,
- 1:23:18and President Trump actually,
- 1:23:20when he was running this past time,
- 1:23:21he said that upon his inauguration he would have Congress send a bill to his desk
- 1:23:25revising Section 230 of the Digital Communications Act
- 1:23:27which would force,
- 1:23:29uh,
- 1:23:29if you know,
- 1:23:29done the right way,
- 1:23:30it would force TikTok,
- 1:23:31Instagram,
- 1:23:31YouTube,
- 1:23:32you name it,
- 1:23:32to give us the option to have a chronological feed of.
- 1:23:35Information versus an algorithmically AI curated
- 1:23:38feed
- 1:23:39that would be the that's more pro free speech than anything I've seen
- 1:23:41the Democrats present in the past 20 years and him appointing Brendan Carter,
- 1:23:44the chair of the AFCC,
- 1:23:45um,
- 1:23:46and has is helping to slowly bring that in and he passed an executive order
- 1:23:49when he first got in this time,
- 1:23:50uh,
- 1:23:51attacking government censorship on social media specifically.
- 1:23:53See,
- 1:23:54I'll let you say everything we can take our time,
- 1:23:55you know we can we can.
- 1:23:56It don't always gotta be a bunch of yelling 100%.
- 1:23:58I,
- 1:23:58I like yelling too though,
- 1:23:59you know,
- 1:23:59we might get there.
- 1:24:00I don't know.
- 1:24:01Well,
- 1:24:01I mean,
- 1:24:01I think the biggest thing there I have to address,
- 1:24:03yes,
- 1:24:04I'm gonna say
- 1:24:04I think the stifling of freedom of speech on both sides is completely wrong,
- 1:24:07you know.
- 1:24:08You and I may disagree,
- 1:24:09but you can hop on TikTok and call me a dumb stupid Democrat and be like,
- 1:24:11damn man,
- 1:24:12that kind of hurt,
- 1:24:12but that's cool,
- 1:24:13you know,
- 1:24:13let's chill,
- 1:24:14that's fine.
- 1:24:15However,
- 1:24:15I do think we have to also note the egregious amounts of
- 1:24:18stifling of freedom of speech that this current administration has done.
- 1:24:21Throwing the Associated Press out,
- 1:24:23right?
- 1:24:24Saying because they're saying the Gulf of Mexico.
- 1:24:26And also now Trump lobbying and like kind of lobbying the TikTok ban
- 1:24:30so
- 1:24:31his biggest allies in the Ellison family and Oracle
- 1:24:34can control the biggest social media platform in this country
- 1:24:37in addition to him as well.
- 1:24:38Look,
- 1:24:39I don't like the fact that he got banned off of X,
- 1:24:40uh,
- 1:24:41but I also don't like the fact that he has this thing called True Social
- 1:24:44where he is selling earlier tweets for insider information as well.
- 1:24:47I think all of that is complete that more gets
- 1:24:49me
- 1:24:49I mean I'm not.
- 1:24:50I'm not a fan of that either and that gets into,
- 1:24:52you know,
- 1:24:52crony crony capitalism which I'm not again I'm not a fan of but at the same time,
- 1:24:56you know what what I what I'm for
- 1:24:58is
- 1:24:58pro free speech across the board.
- 1:25:00Alright,
- 1:25:00do you have to pause here?
- 1:25:01You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:25:05It's all right.
- 1:25:05Good,
- 1:25:06very good conversation,
- 1:25:07very good,
- 1:25:07very good.
- 1:25:08If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:25:10please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:25:15Too fast.
- 1:25:16Gotta be quicker than that.
- 1:25:17I'm Mukobo.
- 1:25:18Mukobo.
- 1:25:18I'd say nice to meet you,
- 1:25:19but I saw what happened to Z,
- 1:25:20so
- 1:25:21don't wanna get what happened to Z?
- 1:25:22Well,
- 1:25:22she said nice to meet you to Jake Lang and got like totally killed online.
- 1:25:26Well,
- 1:25:26I'm not.
- 1:25:26Well,
- 1:25:26damn,
- 1:25:27I'm not Jake Lang.
- 1:25:28My job is messing with you.
- 1:25:29All right,
- 1:25:29so,
- 1:25:29uh,
- 1:25:30your claim,
- 1:25:30uh,
- 1:25:31Republicans are more,
- 1:25:32uh,
- 1:25:32pro-free speech than Democrats.
- 1:25:34I,
- 1:25:34I disagree with that.
- 1:25:35I.
- 1:25:35I,
- 1:25:35uh,
- 1:25:35I do work for the San Diego County Democratic Party.
- 1:25:38My views are my own,
- 1:25:39um,
- 1:25:40but there's a lot with the Democratic Party I disagree with.
- 1:25:42I disagree with our views on the Middle East.
- 1:25:43I,
- 1:25:43I don't think we should be funding,
- 1:25:44uh,
- 1:25:44genocide in Palestine.
- 1:25:46I disagree with a lot of what we're doing,
- 1:25:48uh,
- 1:25:48including,
- 1:25:49uh,
- 1:25:49with your claim about
- 1:25:50the,
- 1:25:51uh,
- 1:25:51black,
- 1:25:52black Americans.
- 1:25:53Uh,
- 1:25:53we should have reparations,
- 1:25:54and it's a shame that we haven't done anything about it.
- 1:25:56Well,
- 1:25:56we agree there.
- 1:25:57Yeah,
- 1:25:57I also,
- 1:25:57I also disagree on a lot of our views on free speech.
- 1:26:00OK.
- 1:26:00Uh,
- 1:26:01both parties do this.
- 1:26:02I don't think this is a left versus a right issue.
- 1:26:04I think this is us,
- 1:26:05the people versus them,
- 1:26:06the establishment issue.
- 1:26:07I agree.
- 1:26:07I don't,
- 1:26:08I don't disagree.
- 1:26:09It's always good because we,
- 1:26:10we can,
- 1:26:10we can sit here for 20 minutes like picking and choosing examples of each side,
- 1:26:14like Democrats with COVID.
- 1:26:15Yes,
- 1:26:15I,
- 1:26:15I,
- 1:26:16I do think that it's a slightly
- 1:26:17different situation because millions of People died.
- 1:26:19And when you have,
- 1:26:20uh,
- 1:26:21you know,
- 1:26:21influencers and people claiming to inject
- 1:26:23highlighter fluid into your bloodstream,
- 1:26:25I think it's dangerous.
- 1:26:27I think it's dangerous,
- 1:26:28but I disagree with you on that.
- 1:26:29I understand there,
- 1:26:30but there are examples,
- 1:26:31you know,
- 1:26:31you're pro free speech when it benefits you,
- 1:26:33you're anti-free speech,
- 1:26:34not,
- 1:26:34not you personally.
- 1:26:35I'm talking about the establishment.
- 1:26:37So like Trump,
- 1:26:37for example,
- 1:26:38in my opinion,
- 1:26:38freedom of speech
- 1:26:40is,
- 1:26:40um,
- 1:26:41well,
- 1:26:41I'm shaking.
- 1:26:41Just
- 1:26:42freedom of speech is,
- 1:26:43uh,
- 1:26:44it's agreeing,
- 1:26:45it's allowing people to say something you disagree with.
- 1:26:47Yeah,
- 1:26:47so me,
- 1:26:48I think it is
- 1:26:49very un-American to burn the American flag.
- 1:26:51I think it is
- 1:26:52absolutely ridiculous,
- 1:26:54but it is part of freedom of speech.
- 1:26:56So what I'm not,
- 1:26:57not to cut you off,
- 1:26:58when I'm saying this is like,
- 1:26:59let's look at this in practice,
- 1:27:00right?
- 1:27:01I don't know,
- 1:27:02and you can feel free to tell me if I,
- 1:27:03if there is an example.
- 1:27:05I don't know of a Democratic leader that was assassinated because
- 1:27:08of the stuff that they said that they disagree with.
- 1:27:10I know Charlie Kirk was killed because,
- 1:27:12uh,
- 1:27:13someone just said,
- 1:27:13Hey,
- 1:27:13fascist catch.
- 1:27:14Charlie Kirk wasn't a fascist,
- 1:27:15and I would have loved to debate Charlotte on a lot of things,
- 1:27:17but that's the kind of thing that I'm speaking to.
- 1:27:19When I,
- 1:27:19so when I say pro-free speech,
- 1:27:20I mean,
- 1:27:21even if you disagree with me,
- 1:27:22for example,
- 1:27:22well,
- 1:27:23I mean,
- 1:27:23here,
- 1:27:23let me,
- 1:27:23let me,
- 1:27:24can I respond to that because you're gonna keep going with the same
- 1:27:26Democratic lawmakers look at Minnesota.
- 1:27:27Like the,
- 1:27:28the state lawmakers were murdered
- 1:27:30for their political beliefs.
- 1:27:31I think that's,
- 1:27:32I am
- 1:27:32not even 19 years old.
- 1:27:34I have 4700 followers on Instagram.
- 1:27:36I'm not that famous.
- 1:27:37I have had 118 death threats
- 1:27:40since January 1st of 2026.
- 1:27:41I have had my phone number.
- 1:27:43multiple times.
- 1:27:43I have people,
- 1:27:44I've had people call me
- 1:27:46and say my address and say they're gonna kill me.
- 1:27:48So I've had,
- 1:27:48I've had death threats.
- 1:27:49Yeah,
- 1:27:49no,
- 1:27:50I understand we've
- 1:27:51got black
- 1:27:51Republicans ain't had no death threats.
- 1:27:52100% you've seen my TikTok,
- 1:27:54but this is,
- 1:27:54this is not a left versus right thing,
- 1:27:56right?
- 1:27:56It's,
- 1:27:56it's true and,
- 1:27:57and.
- 1:27:58It's,
- 1:27:58it's,
- 1:27:58it's,
- 1:27:59it's
- 1:28:00us versus something like,
- 1:28:01like I've been saying.
- 1:28:02So
- 1:28:02I don't think you can say one party is more pro-free speech than another party.
- 1:28:05Well,
- 1:28:06what I'm looking at is what we're looking at is within recent,
- 1:28:08within
- 1:28:09recent memory and as,
- 1:28:10and as a whole.
- 1:28:10That's what I'm saying.
- 1:28:12We just have,
- 1:28:12we have Donald Trump kicking the AP out.
- 1:28:15Thank you for saying that
- 1:28:16because they called it the mixer and that's you have
- 1:28:18him calling reporters and he's wrong to do that.
- 1:28:21So how are you saying you can't see more recent examples?
- 1:28:23Of Republicans and Democrats because
- 1:28:25our president is the most anti-free speech president we have had in decades.
- 1:28:29No,
- 1:28:30that's not true.
- 1:28:31It
- 1:28:31is 100% true.
- 1:28:32I just told you that he's the only president that I've
- 1:28:34seen that called for a revision of the digital communications,
- 1:28:37so you can do one
- 1:28:38good
- 1:28:38thing
- 1:28:38and many
- 1:28:38bad things like that.
- 1:28:39Don't understand if that's you don't understand,
- 1:28:41oh
- 1:28:41my God,
- 1:28:42you don't
- 1:28:42you're not understanding,
- 1:28:43stop yelling.
- 1:28:44We don't have to yell.
- 1:28:45You're not understanding.
- 1:28:46OK,
- 1:28:46pause.
- 1:28:47You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:28:50If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:28:51please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:28:59You're back.
- 1:28:59I'm back.
- 1:29:00We're ready to do this again,
- 1:29:01huh?
- 1:29:01We're gonna try.
- 1:29:02Give me a little bit more of your why behind this claim.
- 1:29:04So like I said,
- 1:29:05I'm going back.
- 1:29:05My chief example is that if,
- 1:29:06if Donald Trump does actually get the US government
- 1:29:09to revise Section 230 of the Digital Communications Act,
- 1:29:11then the Internet is no longer going to be algorithmically curated.
- 1:29:13They can't,
- 1:29:14they can't,
- 1:29:14they can't,
- 1:29:15uh,
- 1:29:15places like TikTok,
- 1:29:16Instagram,
- 1:29:17YouTube,
- 1:29:17everybody gets a fair shot to go viral.
- 1:29:19Essentially,
- 1:29:19because
- 1:29:20you're offering users
- 1:29:21any platform that has over a million active monthly users
- 1:29:23would be forced to offer you either a chronological feed
- 1:29:26or a for you page essentially
- 1:29:27where
- 1:29:28chronologically you see every post just at the time the creator posted it,
- 1:29:31um,
- 1:29:31algorithmically curated they can modify it,
- 1:29:34promotes push stuff up,
- 1:29:35tear stuff down based on
- 1:29:36whatever arbitrary bullshit that they want.
- 1:29:38OK,
- 1:29:38I appreciate the word salad.
- 1:29:41Oh,
- 1:29:41it's definitely worse,
- 1:29:42because let me tell you something,
- 1:29:43I think the right
- 1:29:44wants to make free speech benefit
- 1:29:46them
- 1:29:47when they want to
- 1:29:48because you gave an example of Charlie Kirk.
- 1:29:51Hold on,
- 1:29:52let me pull up my seat.
- 1:29:54Get ready.
- 1:29:55So let's talk about Charlie Curt's assassination.
- 1:29:57Liberals had a lot to say about it.
- 1:30:00They called him racist,
- 1:30:01bigoted,
- 1:30:02he was very transphobic,
- 1:30:03he had his views.
- 1:30:05And yet I found that Republicans,
- 1:30:06excuse me,
- 1:30:07do not interrupt a black trans woman when she's speaking.
- 1:30:09I found it very ironic.
- 1:30:11Excuse me,
- 1:30:13excuse me,
- 1:30:14I find it ironic that a lot of Republicans
- 1:30:16were trying to come for the liberals that had a lot to say about Charlie Kirk's death.
- 1:30:20Is that not
- 1:30:21free
- 1:30:21speech?
- 1:30:22Exactly.
- 1:30:22And so the problem is
- 1:30:24y'all were the biggest snowflakes when it came to free speech.
- 1:30:28I mean
- 1:30:28you deserved it.
- 1:30:29Did you
- 1:30:29forget that the
- 1:30:30fact of the matter is
- 1:30:32that it's still covered under free speech though.
- 1:30:34That's the point.
- 1:30:35But let me finish.
- 1:30:36Hold on,
- 1:30:36let me finish.
- 1:30:38And no,
- 1:30:38no,
- 1:30:38no,
- 1:30:38let me finish my point,
- 1:30:39and you can say what you need to say,
- 1:30:40I promise.
- 1:30:42They created an Excel sheet
- 1:30:44to go out to make a list of liberal people who had a lot to say about Charlie Kirk.
- 1:30:48They call their jobs.
- 1:30:50They
- 1:30:51doxed them.
- 1:30:52It was so much,
- 1:30:53but your party started that.
- 1:30:55Wait a minute,
- 1:30:55stop.
- 1:30:56Hold on a second.
- 1:30:56Let me respond to that.
- 1:30:57When they do that type of stupid shit,
- 1:30:59they're wrong.
- 1:30:59Anybody getting doxed is wrong.
- 1:31:00But while I may never agree with a lot of the stuff you may say,
- 1:31:03I will defend to the death your right to say it.
- 1:31:05There should be nothing wrong with me saying
- 1:31:07biological men should only play with biological men.
- 1:31:09There should be nothing wrong with me saying that a trans that
- 1:31:11that a ran that the trans community
- 1:31:13should stick with,
- 1:31:14should play against some other members of that community.
- 1:31:17There should be nothing wrong with making a statement.
- 1:31:18You can disagree all day long.
- 1:31:19That's the purpose of America.
- 1:31:20Second example,
- 1:31:21when Trump
- 1:31:22Starting an illegal war
- 1:31:23and everybody in the media criticized him for it.
- 1:31:26All of a sudden this is a war with Iran.
- 1:31:28Oh,
- 1:31:28so you want the US government to
- 1:31:31let's not go down that rabbit hole.
- 1:31:32I'm just making an example.
- 1:31:33I'm making an analysis,
- 1:31:35so follow me on the analysis.
- 1:31:36Can you follow me?
- 1:31:38I've been I've been leading the conversation,
- 1:31:39not following y'all are sitting here around me,
- 1:31:41not the other way around.
- 1:31:42I've been leading the conversation.
- 1:31:43Whatever you say,
- 1:31:44OK,
- 1:31:46I doubt it,
- 1:31:46but anyways,
- 1:31:48when we talk about like
- 1:31:48Donald,
- 1:31:49this whole thing with Donald Trump,
- 1:31:50Donald Trump has tried his best to shut down the media in any
- 1:31:53way possible.
- 1:31:54All of a sudden these big corporate mergers,
- 1:31:56um,
- 1:31:57excuse me,
- 1:31:58hold on,
- 1:31:58hold on,
- 1:32:00let me finish,
- 1:32:01let me finish my point
- 1:32:02with these big corporations that are merging together
- 1:32:06like with the whole thing with CBS News becoming much more conservative,
- 1:32:09I find it ironic that they want to suppress
- 1:32:12what is really going down.
- 1:32:14Donald Trump is trying to find.
- 1:32:16bias
- 1:32:16against
- 1:32:17Donald Trump since the first time he ran
- 1:32:18the CEO of CBS
- 1:32:20has ties to Donald Trump,
- 1:32:22and what I'm trying to say to you is when Barry Weiss took over CBS News,
- 1:32:27that is when the downhill started.
- 1:32:28Staff has been laid off.
- 1:32:30The ratings in CBS News ratings have declined
- 1:32:34so much.
- 1:32:35But no,
- 1:32:35what I'm saying,
- 1:32:36what I'm saying is,
- 1:32:37but what I'm saying is I just need you to listen to me then.
- 1:32:40What I'm saying is the right.
- 1:32:42The right
- 1:32:43wants to make it beneficial to them when it comes to free speech.
- 1:32:46Both sides do that shit.
- 1:32:48I don't,
- 1:32:48I disagree with you.
- 1:32:49OK,
- 1:32:50so if you disagree with me.
- 1:32:51All right,
- 1:32:51cool.
- 1:32:51So then answer me this.
- 1:32:52Back in 2011,
- 1:32:542010,
- 1:32:54somewhere around there,
- 1:32:55didn't Donald Trump take his ass on The View and Whoopi gave him a hug and a
- 1:32:58kiss and Joey Bayard gave him a hug and a kiss before he ran for president?
- 1:33:01Did that not happen?
- 1:33:01Yes or no.
- 1:33:03It was
- 1:33:04Donald Trump.
- 1:33:04No,
- 1:33:04let me finish.
- 1:33:05Don't interrupt the black man when he's speaking.
- 1:33:08Right,
- 1:33:08right,
- 1:33:09right.
- 1:33:09So
- 1:33:10did they not give him a hug and a kiss when
- 1:33:12he was on The View before he ran for president?
- 1:33:14Before Donald Trump ran for president,
- 1:33:15amazingly,
- 1:33:16the media with Sheen was not against him.
- 1:33:18When Donald Trump ran for president,
- 1:33:19now he's a racist,
- 1:33:20now he's all this,
- 1:33:21that and third.
- 1:33:21You wasn't hearing none of this.
- 1:33:22There were black rappers saying,
- 1:33:23I want to have money like Donald Trump.
- 1:33:28Left-handed they have always had an inherent bias against conservatives.
- 1:33:32What is the exact why?
- 1:33:34Because Donald Trump has always been a racist.
- 1:33:36He's always been a bigoted.
- 1:33:38It's just that now
- 1:33:39he is given free permission for those who are already like that
- 1:33:43and that are in this country to
- 1:33:45express it.
- 1:33:46Racists are able to do that.
- 1:33:49I'm from Mississippi,
- 1:33:50baby.
- 1:33:50I
- 1:33:51come from,
- 1:33:51I come from him.
- 1:33:52What are you saying?
- 1:33:53I'm from Atlantic Corps.
- 1:33:54I come from.
- 1:33:54The Freedom Summer.
- 1:33:55My ancestors was all part of that,
- 1:33:57and I was born
- 1:33:58Martin Luther King was born in the same town,
- 1:33:59so you,
- 1:34:00you cannot sit up there and,
- 1:34:01and booty clap your cheeks
- 1:34:03for Donald Trump
- 1:34:04when you stepped out.
- 1:34:05I think you are.
- 1:34:06I think you are
- 1:34:08because the thing is,
- 1:34:09and the way,
- 1:34:09and the way that he has demean
- 1:34:11black people,
- 1:34:11the way that he has demeaned black people,
- 1:34:13you really would sit up here and defend
- 1:34:15something like that.
- 1:34:16He is misogynistic.
- 1:34:17He is transphobic.
- 1:34:19He has taken rights away from trans people like.
- 1:34:21Nobody's
- 1:34:21business.
- 1:34:22Trump is
- 1:34:22responding.
- 1:34:24You're saying something
- 1:34:26you are saying something that is patently false.
- 1:34:28If he's misogynistic,
- 1:34:30I can prove it with one of my good friends,
- 1:34:32Michaela Montgomery.
- 1:34:32Y'all should go look her up.
- 1:34:34Why would he,
- 1:34:34if he's misogynistic,
- 1:34:35why would he appoint a black woman as one of
- 1:34:36the first speakers at all of his rallies in Georgia?
- 1:34:38Just because he's misogynistic
- 1:34:39one black woman,
- 1:34:40he does not
- 1:34:42misogynist.
- 1:34:43So why,
- 1:34:43why
- 1:34:44would
- 1:34:44he,
- 1:34:45so if that's the case,
- 1:34:46why would he appoint a black woman
- 1:34:47if that's.
- 1:34:48Why would Donald Trump then also appoint a black woman by
- 1:34:50the name of Alice Johnson to be his pardon czar?
- 1:34:52Alice,
- 1:34:52you're gonna be the pardon czar,
- 1:34:53and she has now overturned
- 1:34:55multiple convictions
- 1:34:56for
- 1:34:57misdemeanor crimes and others.
- 1:34:58And who,
- 1:34:59who,
- 1:34:59who most locked up?
- 1:35:00Who most benefits from that?
- 1:35:01Why
- 1:35:02we have an administration with Pam Bondi,
- 1:35:04Christie Norm,
- 1:35:05all these white,
- 1:35:06all these white women
- 1:35:07and she got fired and
- 1:35:09fired.
- 1:35:09She didn't release the files and then
- 1:35:11turn around and,
- 1:35:11yeah,
- 1:35:12we're gonna have to pause here.
- 1:35:13Thank you.
- 1:35:15You tried it.
- 1:35:17You tried it.
- 1:35:18I'm one of them ones,
- 1:35:18twin,
- 1:35:19I promise you.
- 1:35:19If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:35:21please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:35:27She said y'all ain't fast enough.
- 1:35:28What's your name?
- 1:35:30Austin,
- 1:35:30nice to meet you,
- 1:35:30Mr.
- 1:35:30Abby.
- 1:35:31OK,
- 1:35:31so I just want to talk about,
- 1:35:32I think you've conceded a lot of points about like things
- 1:35:34that you don't agree with that Donald Trump has done,
- 1:35:36right?
- 1:35:36Oh,
- 1:35:36he's done a lot.
- 1:35:38OK,
- 1:35:38so
- 1:35:38the argument is Democrats versus Republicans and Donald
- 1:35:41Trump is a part of the Republican Party.
- 1:35:43Isn't that things that the Republican Party has done
- 1:35:45because he is the leader of the Republican Party.
- 1:35:47Party that is anti-free speech.
- 1:35:49No,
- 1:35:49what I'm
- 1:35:50remember what I'm saying specifically is that he's done something
- 1:35:53with advocating for the revision of Section 230 of our communications,
- 1:35:56right?
- 1:35:56No,
- 1:35:56that's a huge thing though.
- 1:35:57That's what I'm saying.
- 1:35:58But there are other huge things that have happened,
- 1:35:59right?
- 1:35:59He's taken away funding from PBS and or threatened
- 1:36:02to take away funding from PBS and NPR,
- 1:36:03right?
- 1:36:04Because they don't agree with they were running anti-Trump,
- 1:36:06right?
- 1:36:06OK,
- 1:36:07OK,
- 1:36:07so
- 1:36:07that is that not.
- 1:36:08Anti-free speech.
- 1:36:09OK,
- 1:36:10so then he's banned certain,
- 1:36:12he's banned AP news from the press room.
- 1:36:13Is that not anti-free speech?
- 1:36:15Yeah,
- 1:36:15again,
- 1:36:15he has done a lot of things that are anti-free speech,
- 1:36:17but
- 1:36:18there
- 1:36:18is not a majority of things that he's done that are
- 1:36:20anti-free speech that I would say overpower that one thing.
- 1:36:22No,
- 1:36:23because of this,
- 1:36:23I'll tell you why,
- 1:36:24because of scale of impact.
- 1:36:25If the Digital Communications Act is actually revised and put into law.
- 1:36:29That would literally allow everyone
- 1:36:30imagine
- 1:36:31we could all say I think we'd all agree that
- 1:36:33going viral on the Internet is essentially a lotto ticket,
- 1:36:35right?
- 1:36:35You gotta throw more stuff at the wall and see what sticks.
- 1:36:37You revise that law,
- 1:36:38you now force the Internet to give
- 1:36:40everybody the same amount of potential viewership
- 1:36:43regardless of algorithmic curation.
- 1:36:44So if he does that and gets that passed into the law,
- 1:36:47damn him banning the press away because presidents can
- 1:36:49do that like that's the power of the president.
- 1:36:50If you don't want a press member in
- 1:36:51in your
- 1:36:52meeting room,
- 1:36:52you have the right to ban him.
- 1:36:53Alright,
- 1:36:53we're gonna have to pause here.
- 1:36:54You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:36:56That was good.
- 1:36:57That was good.
- 1:36:59If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:37:01please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:37:07How are you sir?
- 1:37:08What's your name?
- 1:37:09Alex
- 1:37:09Alex Austin,
- 1:37:10nice to meet you Alex.
- 1:37:11Alright,
- 1:37:11I just kinda wanted to expand a little bit on this bill that you're talking about,
- 1:37:15right?
- 1:37:15So we're talking about,
- 1:37:17well,
- 1:37:17it'll be a revision,
- 1:37:17it's not a bill yet or revision,
- 1:37:18right?
- 1:37:19So if we're going from getting rid of algorithms,
- 1:37:21which I agree with,
- 1:37:22right,
- 1:37:22big tech has done a lot of,
- 1:37:24uh,
- 1:37:24damage that way,
- 1:37:25right,
- 1:37:25to something that becomes
- 1:37:27strictly chronological,
- 1:37:28how do we.
- 1:37:29No,
- 1:37:29no,
- 1:37:29no,
- 1:37:30no,
- 1:37:30not strictly it's just giving people the option
- 1:37:32that's all it's giving people the option yeah if you
- 1:37:34if it was revised you would have the option to either
- 1:37:36choose a chronological feed
- 1:37:38or a curated feed,
- 1:37:39OK,
- 1:37:39so it doesn't take one thing away,
- 1:37:40it just adds another option that we actually should have already had.
- 1:37:43So how does that help address what I feel like the deeper problem is is that like
- 1:37:47we get into echo chambers my echo chamber might be different than your echo chamber,
- 1:37:50but we're kind of siloed,
- 1:37:51right?
- 1:37:52So how does that bill
- 1:37:53necessarily address that problem,
- 1:37:55right,
- 1:37:55even if you're doing a chronological choice,
- 1:37:58I'm still picking what I follow.
- 1:37:59You still pick what you follow.
- 1:38:00So I just wanted to hear,
- 1:38:01well,
- 1:38:01it's just,
- 1:38:02I mean,
- 1:38:02everybody's gonna have preferences.
- 1:38:03It's the,
- 1:38:04the,
- 1:38:04the revision of Section 230 is not designed to
- 1:38:06eliminate people's ability to choose what they want.
- 1:38:08It just frees up the amount of choice that you have.
- 1:38:10If you,
- 1:38:10I should be able to know that when I open TikTok or wanna go on YouTube and get the news
- 1:38:14that every.
- 1:38:14Creator I'm seeing
- 1:38:16has the same access to me as the people
- 1:38:18that already have these huge big ass established platforms.
- 1:38:20There should be no
- 1:38:21reason that Officer Tatum is guaranteed more reach than someone like
- 1:38:24Tashika or that
- 1:38:25uh Zena is guaranteed more reach than
- 1:38:27me.
- 1:38:27I mean,
- 1:38:28there,
- 1:38:28there should be no reason for that.
- 1:38:29Everyone should have
- 1:38:30the equality of opportunity in the on the Internet that way the truly talented of us
- 1:38:34would
- 1:38:34rise to the top,
- 1:38:35the cream of the cream,
- 1:38:35as I would say,
- 1:38:36sure,
- 1:38:37but I.
- 1:38:37Like that's really an idealistic way of looking at how the internet works.
- 1:38:40People get backed by,
- 1:38:41you know,
- 1:38:41bigger companies they get funding on the payroll.
- 1:38:44I still don't think that's really
- 1:38:46addressing,
- 1:38:47um,
- 1:38:47this divide in trying to get both sides,
- 1:38:50uh,
- 1:38:51on the table.
- 1:38:51That's not gonna happen in the real world.
- 1:38:53You're never,
- 1:38:53I mean,
- 1:38:53because like prime example,
- 1:38:55right,
- 1:38:55uh,
- 1:38:56not to poke fun at her again,
- 1:38:57but Zena's a Marxist.
- 1:38:57I'm a conservative Christian.
- 1:38:59We're always gonna be.
- 1:39:00Ideologically opposed.
- 1:39:00Tashika is a
- 1:39:01leftist.
- 1:39:02I'm a Christian.
- 1:39:03I'm surrounded by liberals.
- 1:39:05I'm never going to agree with all of you ontologically.
- 1:39:07It's impossible.
- 1:39:08But you know what this does?
- 1:39:09Conversations like this fosters good dialogue.
- 1:39:11So videos like this,
- 1:39:13news,
- 1:39:13you know,
- 1:39:13people that want to post news,
- 1:39:15all that,
- 1:39:16everyone should have the same access to see it just as quick.
- 1:39:18That's all I'm saying.
- 1:39:19All right,
- 1:39:19we have to pause here.
- 1:39:20We're out of time for this claim.
- 1:39:21Thank you.
- 1:39:25All right,
- 1:39:25now it is time for our final debate.
- 1:39:28It's been a great debate.
- 1:39:29So far
- 1:39:29Austin,
- 1:39:30in our final debate you get 10 minutes uninterrupted,
- 1:39:33so we'll look around the circle and choose wisely
- 1:39:35someone you want to continue the conversation with.
- 1:39:37Well,
- 1:39:38I'd love to continue this conversation with someone that wouldn't
- 1:39:40necessarily call me a misogynist or think I'm white cosplay,
- 1:39:42so
- 1:39:43I'm gonna pick Tashika
- 1:39:44because we had a pretty decent dialogue and
- 1:39:47uh she tried to beat me,
- 1:39:48but I,
- 1:39:48I think she was trying to have a conversation
- 1:39:50while also trying to win.
- 1:39:52All right,
- 1:39:52Tashika.
- 1:39:57My surrounding claim is conservatives' rejection of
- 1:40:00gay rights is a losing strategy.
- 1:40:03Hello again,
- 1:40:03Austin.
- 1:40:04Hello again.
- 1:40:05I didn't think you'd pick me.
- 1:40:06Can we agree that I've sat at this table?
- 1:40:08I have been called a misogynist.
- 1:40:09I have been called a,
- 1:40:10a,
- 1:40:11a token.
- 1:40:11I've been called a sellout.
- 1:40:13I've been called a grifter,
- 1:40:14and I don't think that's what I am.
- 1:40:15Would you call me one of those?
- 1:40:16No,
- 1:40:17I think,
- 1:40:18I think when someone butchers a pro-black woman argument like that,
- 1:40:21I think it actually sets us back overall.
- 1:40:23So I'd actually agree with you.
- 1:40:25Um,
- 1:40:26so,
- 1:40:27uh,
- 1:40:27so yeah.
- 1:40:28I brought up this argument because in our previous debate,
- 1:40:31you say that gay people shouldn't be able to get married.
- 1:40:36Oh,
- 1:40:37I remember this.
- 1:40:38I remember that we had a TikTok debate about that,
- 1:40:40yes,
- 1:40:41yes.
- 1:40:42I gave you the qualifying reasons as to why that was the case too.
- 1:40:44Please go ahead.
- 1:40:45I would like you to answer to me
- 1:40:46what exactly conservatives gain
- 1:40:48uh by being against something,
- 1:40:50especially if the reason why it passed is because it was a bipartisan agreement.
- 1:40:54Uh,
- 1:40:54everyone was pro it,
- 1:40:55but now when you look at these statistics,
- 1:40:57um,
- 1:40:57we see that conservatives have been lessening their support
- 1:40:59of gay rights,
- 1:41:00particularly gay marriage.
- 1:41:01I would like to know why you are one of those people.
- 1:41:04Well,
- 1:41:04because gay same-sex marriage is not that that's rooted in religion,
- 1:41:08uh,
- 1:41:08100%
- 1:41:09and what I told you on TikTok and I'd say it here again,
- 1:41:12I would if if two same-sex couples want to engage in what they would call a marriage,
- 1:41:15I would label it.
- 1:41:16I would give them every protection that would exist for a married couple,
- 1:41:18but I simply would not call it marriage.
- 1:41:20The Defense of Marriage Act,
- 1:41:21which was a law at one point in this country,
- 1:41:22had properly identified,
- 1:41:24um,
- 1:41:24marriage as between a man and a woman.
- 1:41:27Uh,
- 1:41:27one of the foundational
- 1:41:28ultimate goals of marriage or one of the
- 1:41:30things that tends to happen is reproduction.
- 1:41:3222 people that are of the same sex cannot have kids naturally,
- 1:41:36right?
- 1:41:36It's they can't do it.
- 1:41:37And this,
- 1:41:38and what they do is,
- 1:41:39in my,
- 1:41:39in
- 1:41:40not my only my opinion but based on my religion,
- 1:41:42they borrow
- 1:41:43from what is again part of the fruit of the moral Christian tree while rejecting
- 1:41:47or frankly changing the meaning of what God Himself.
- 1:41:50Unfortunately Austin,
- 1:41:51the question was what exactly do conservatives
- 1:41:53gain by making this into policy because I
- 1:41:54would assume that you would want for this to be like an actualized piece of
- 1:41:57legislation,
- 1:41:58correct?
- 1:41:58Well,
- 1:41:58no,
- 1:41:59not nec not necessarily.
- 1:42:00I'm not gonna go on go on record and change the
- 1:42:02something that's already established if I I I don't think that's
- 1:42:05so
- 1:42:06then what would you gain by this being a reality?
- 1:42:08You would gain you would go back to actual Christianity
- 1:42:11Christian principles you would get more to objectively true Christian principles
- 1:42:14because like for example what this gets into to to you know this is a good question
- 1:42:17what this gets into is I don't think that a pastor
- 1:42:20should preside over a same-sex marriage because it's literally anti-biblical
- 1:42:24and marriage is a religious institution in the West and it always has been
- 1:42:27so.
- 1:42:28My issue with that
- 1:42:29is
- 1:42:30when you're engaging in a same-sex marriage while calling yourself a Christian,
- 1:42:33that is literally the equivalent of being a married bachelor.
- 1:42:36It's an impossible contradiction.
- 1:42:38Yeah,
- 1:42:38so my contention here is the fact that you
- 1:42:39are trying to appropriate an entire word and concept,
- 1:42:43and we know that the concept of marriage has
- 1:42:44always existed even before the concept of Christianity,
- 1:42:46right?
- 1:42:46And again,
- 1:42:47I have to remind you,
- 1:42:48Austin that we live in a secular society,
- 1:42:50right?
- 1:42:51Heavily influenced by God.
- 1:42:52Heavily influenced by God.
- 1:42:53It doesn't that doesn't matter because the point is that it is
- 1:42:55a secular society,
- 1:42:57right?
- 1:42:57To have Any laws
- 1:42:58that attribute
- 1:42:59to have any laws that attribute itself
- 1:43:01to a specific religion
- 1:43:03literally goes against everything that this country was built off of,
- 1:43:06right?
- 1:43:06So wait a minute.
- 1:43:07So
- 1:43:08I'm sorry,
- 1:43:09again,
- 1:43:10in the reality where your laws would be the case,
- 1:43:12right,
- 1:43:12in the reality where,
- 1:43:13where,
- 1:43:13where this kind of legislation where gay people are unable,
- 1:43:15wait,
- 1:43:15I'm sorry,
- 1:43:16actually,
- 1:43:16let's restate real quick.
- 1:43:18Are you saying that they just shouldn't be able to
- 1:43:21call it marriage?
- 1:43:23So they'll have all the same rights.
- 1:43:26So everything that a married couple would get,
- 1:43:28a gay couple would get,
- 1:43:29they just wouldn't be able to call it marriage.
- 1:43:32Despite the fact that marriage,
- 1:43:33the concept of that has already existed before Christianity,
- 1:43:36we're supposed to allow for Christians to appropriate that word
- 1:43:39and then
- 1:43:40completely,
- 1:43:40it is an appropriation of the word though,
- 1:43:42because they had the concept.
- 1:43:43And the word has existed before
- 1:43:45then.
- 1:43:45So,
- 1:43:45OK,
- 1:43:46but
- 1:43:46the Bible is older than the United States of America,
- 1:43:48so let's start with that.
- 1:43:52Uh,
- 1:43:52that's,
- 1:43:53that's that's much less,
- 1:43:54it was a different kind of cause you
- 1:43:56cause if you go back to the African spiritual religions,
- 1:43:58that wasn't,
- 1:43:58it wasn't monogamous.
- 1:43:59They were actually most African cultures actually believed that
- 1:44:04it's not the same way that God originally defined it.
- 1:44:07That's why we live in a secular country where
- 1:44:10God
- 1:44:11doesn't matter what the what the
- 1:44:12what the dominant
- 1:44:13religion is.
- 1:44:13No,
- 1:44:14no,
- 1:44:14no,
- 1:44:14it does in this conversation because you'd have to agree with me
- 1:44:17that
- 1:44:17yes,
- 1:44:18do we overall live in a secular society?
- 1:44:19Sure,
- 1:44:20granted,
- 1:44:21but
- 1:44:2152% of the population of this country
- 1:44:24identifies as Christian,
- 1:44:25which means,
- 1:44:26and you're not going to tell me that someone's politics
- 1:44:28don't flow downstream from their religion of course it does,
- 1:44:30but that's the entire
- 1:44:31point of living in a society.
- 1:44:33But no,
- 1:44:33no,
- 1:44:33wait a minute,
- 1:44:33no,
- 1:44:33no,
- 1:44:34no,
- 1:44:34that's the entire.
- 1:44:35You need to listen to me.
- 1:44:36Yeah,
- 1:44:37no,
- 1:44:38that's the entire point of living in a secular society,
- 1:44:40right,
- 1:44:40because regardless of the like how many people,
- 1:44:42uh,
- 1:44:43uh,
- 1:44:43uh,
- 1:44:43prescribe to a particular religion,
- 1:44:45the laws that we all live under and the rights
- 1:44:47that we all have are consistently going to be secular
- 1:44:50to maintain the rights of everyone else.
- 1:44:51You are advocating it doesn't need to,
- 1:44:53it's influenced by equality,
- 1:44:54right?
- 1:44:55You don't think the Bible influenced American law.
- 1:44:56It doesn't need to.
- 1:44:57That's the entire
- 1:44:58point.
- 1:44:59OK,
- 1:44:59but that doesn't mean that it needs to stay that way.
- 1:45:01Again,
- 1:45:02you are trying to appropriate the word marriage and that is just not how that works,
- 1:45:07right?
- 1:45:08Then why was the Defense of Marriage Act passed originally?
- 1:45:10Hold on,
- 1:45:10address that first.
- 1:45:11If that's the case,
- 1:45:12then why was the Defense of Marriage Act passed prior to?
- 1:45:15Because in the United States of America
- 1:45:16we have always maintained a Christian ethos.
- 1:45:19One of America's greatest taglines is we
- 1:45:21were founded on our Judeo-Christian principles.
- 1:45:23That's why the Defense of Marriage Act had to be repealed in order for
- 1:45:27uh.
- 1:45:27Same-sex marriage should be legalized at the federal level.
- 1:45:29So what I'm saying is that there's a legitimate inseparability
- 1:45:32of
- 1:45:33of religion and politics across any country
- 1:45:35and you can see
- 1:45:37in
- 1:45:38this country is religious
- 1:45:40and
- 1:45:41it is the case that we
- 1:45:42look at the sweep of history across the United States
- 1:45:45because some people have been influenced by a
- 1:45:47by by by a bit of philosophy
- 1:45:48doesn't mean that
- 1:45:51the laws that they create also have to follow that for everyone else.
- 1:45:54Again,
- 1:45:54you Have to justify why Christianity has the ownership over marriage.
- 1:45:59That's the point.
- 1:46:00Because in the confines of the
- 1:46:01United States when Christian when monogamous Christian
- 1:46:03marriage was practiced at its highest rates that led to some of the greatest
- 1:46:06periods of success.
- 1:46:08No,
- 1:46:08I'm answering it.
- 1:46:09I'm answering it.
- 1:46:10When we,
- 1:46:10when the nuclear family in black America was at its strongest,
- 1:46:13the US had produced some of the had some of
- 1:46:15the strongest years economically in the history of the country,
- 1:46:17especially in particular when we focus on the black community,
- 1:46:19and you know this as well as I do
- 1:46:21when Daniel Patrick Moynihan released his.
- 1:46:23Uh,
- 1:46:23which was the breakdown of the nuclear family in 1965,
- 1:46:26he noted quite a few things
- 1:46:27that
- 1:46:28from 1940 through 1965,
- 1:46:30black males began to leave the house and
- 1:46:32abandon their families and abandon their responsibilities.
- 1:46:34At the very same time we began to see drifting away
- 1:46:37from religious religious principles and from religion as a whole.
- 1:46:40That trend is continuing today
- 1:46:41and look at the,
- 1:46:42look at the economic and the societal problems that are caused
- 1:46:44when we don't have some sort of ultimate ontological
- 1:46:47I don't think you're gonna be able to prove that these two things are connected.
- 1:46:50I would need you to provide
- 1:46:51I wouldn't need you to provide anything for that,
- 1:46:53like literally anything.
- 1:46:55You are not going to be able to say that because we incentivize for like
- 1:46:59Christian heterosexual marriages
- 1:47:01and that we don't do that now that they're decreasing.
- 1:47:03I don't see how that would be
- 1:47:04right,
- 1:47:04but you cannot say that these two things
- 1:47:07are,
- 1:47:07you cannot say that these two things are connected,
- 1:47:08right?
- 1:47:09You can say that the reason marriage overall has been going down
- 1:47:11is because people don't make enough money to afford a rank.
- 1:47:13People don't make,
- 1:47:14people don't want to get married anymore.
- 1:47:16It is unnecessary for people to get.
- 1:47:17Married.
- 1:47:18That's why we also see like increased divorce because
- 1:47:20excuse me,
- 1:47:21women in general don't even need men.
- 1:47:22People don't see the need to get married anymore.
- 1:47:24Before,
- 1:47:25marriage was an
- 1:47:26economic,
- 1:47:28financial contract between two bodies.
- 1:47:30Now it is a symbol,
- 1:47:31one second,
- 1:47:32baby.
- 1:47:33Now it is a symbol of love,
- 1:47:34right?
- 1:47:34People don't necessarily find
- 1:47:36no it wasn't.
- 1:47:37So marriage wasn't always to some degree a symbol of love.
- 1:47:39It was not.
- 1:47:40You'd have to justify that
- 1:47:42because I don't know.
- 1:47:42Um,
- 1:47:43the entire
- 1:47:44British monarchy.
- 1:47:46I said I'm talking about,
- 1:47:47I'm talking about the United States of America.
- 1:47:49I'm not talking about
- 1:47:52you just asked me to give you an
- 1:47:54example of
- 1:47:55an agreement I should have specified,
- 1:47:56I meant within the United States,
- 1:47:57my apologies.
- 1:47:58People,
- 1:47:58wait a minute,
- 1:47:59so people still don't have like dowries and things in the United States?
- 1:48:01I'm sure
- 1:48:02people don't have arranged marriages in the United States?
- 1:48:04Not,
- 1:48:05not as often as they do in other countries.
- 1:48:06Asking me if it happens.
- 1:48:07Sure,
- 1:48:07OK,
- 1:48:08I don't know why you have to ask me that.
- 1:48:10Anyway,
- 1:48:10so like I was saying before,
- 1:48:11you would have to provide like an actual causal link
- 1:48:14between these two things because that's just not true.
- 1:48:15My
- 1:48:15content,
- 1:48:16no you didn't,
- 1:48:16baby.
- 1:48:17My contention,
- 1:48:19my contention,
- 1:48:20right,
- 1:48:20is the fact that
- 1:48:21you as a Christian
- 1:48:22want to appropriate the definition of marriage even though that concept
- 1:48:26has.
- 1:48:27existed
- 1:48:28far beyond Christianity.
- 1:48:31What do you mean in the same way between two people?
- 1:48:33Yes it has.
- 1:48:34So
- 1:48:35what culture are you saying
- 1:48:37practiced monogamous marriage in the same way that the American Christians did?
- 1:48:41Humans are a lot of humans are just typically naturally monogamous.
- 1:48:43Are you saying that this has never
- 1:48:45happened
- 1:48:45before Christianity?
- 1:48:46Are you,
- 1:48:47that's not what I'm saying.
- 1:48:48I'm asking specifically
- 1:48:50what I should have asked it this way.
- 1:48:51What nation has
- 1:48:52monogamy at the same time.
- 1:48:55Well,
- 1:48:55that's what that's what I'm saying.
- 1:48:56Why would I need to know the particular nation?
- 1:48:57Because what I'm getting at is
- 1:48:59the scope and scale of which the United States practiced monogamy led to
- 1:49:02the strongest nuclear family,
- 1:49:04especially for the most affected race in this country,
- 1:49:06being black people.
- 1:49:06And that was rooted in,
- 1:49:08that was rooted in religion.
- 1:49:09That was rooted in religion predominantly.
- 1:49:11What do you mean by the strongest nuclear family?
- 1:49:12The black nuclear,
- 1:49:13excuse me,
- 1:49:13I should have said the black nuclear family was at its
- 1:49:15strongest when religion was at the epicenter of our worldview.
- 1:49:17That's
- 1:49:18Right,
- 1:49:18but that doesn't mean that marriage is also attributed to that.
- 1:49:21You could say that because they were Christian
- 1:49:23they know about the concept of marriage,
- 1:49:24but that doesn't mean that marriage is where that comes from.
- 1:49:26I'm saying that many people
- 1:49:27that comes from.
- 1:49:28No,
- 1:49:28I'm saying that many people that are Christians get married because that's
- 1:49:30what we're commanded to do as Christians and when we follow that,
- 1:49:33when we follow those things,
- 1:49:34that leads to some of the highest levels of productivity.
- 1:49:36It leads to lower mental health rates among children,
- 1:49:38leads to
- 1:49:39better education for kids,
- 1:49:41it leads to children having less mental health issues.
- 1:49:43Less disciplinary problems.
- 1:49:44There's so many.
- 1:49:44OK,
- 1:49:45so if we care about these things,
- 1:49:46if we were if it were the case that we were to actualize what you want here,
- 1:49:49do you not see how this is like a separate but equal type policy,
- 1:49:51right?
- 1:49:52And
- 1:49:53yeah,
- 1:49:53what was the result of the separate but equal policies amongst black people?
- 1:49:56Well,
- 1:49:56there they weren't equal,
- 1:49:57but that's because one of them is ascribed to
- 1:49:59race and we're talking about something completely different.
- 1:50:01We can't that's the entire point of the analogy,
- 1:50:02baby.
- 1:50:03Yeah,
- 1:50:03but you're trying to conflate two things that one
- 1:50:06of them
- 1:50:06I asked you a direct question.
- 1:50:08Separate but equal didn't work back then.
- 1:50:09Why didn't it work?
- 1:50:10Because it wasn't actually,
- 1:50:11it was separate but it was never actually equal.
- 1:50:13What I'm saying is
- 1:50:15you're saying that in this society
- 1:50:17where we separate
- 1:50:18marriage between
- 1:50:20hetero people and homosexual people,
- 1:50:22right?
- 1:50:23let me say this
- 1:50:24in 2004,
- 1:50:25before Massachusetts
- 1:50:27started recognizing same-sex marriage,
- 1:50:28what were they called?
- 1:50:28They were called civil unions.
- 1:50:29Barack Obama talked about it,
- 1:50:30right?
- 1:50:30So I'm just saying
- 1:50:31how are people with civil unions treated?
- 1:50:34I don't know.
- 1:50:35They weren't treated well,
- 1:50:36that's the entire point,
- 1:50:39because when you go into certain spaces,
- 1:50:40right,
- 1:50:40and also civil unions change,
- 1:50:42whether or not you were married
- 1:50:44change based upon where you were.
- 1:50:45So if you had to move to
- 1:50:46I'm not disagreeing with that.
- 1:50:47I'm saying.
- 1:50:49On top of that,
- 1:50:50they still face increased social discrimination
- 1:50:53because of the fact that despite the fact that they may get the same rights,
- 1:50:56socially they're going to be treated differently.
- 1:50:58The
- 1:50:58fact that
- 1:50:59we saw this,
- 1:51:00I'm saying that we saw this in a separate but equal.
- 1:51:06We saw that back then in the sixties,
- 1:51:07but what I'm asking is,
- 1:51:08do you think in 2026,
- 1:51:09as modernized as America has become,
- 1:51:11do you actually believe
- 1:51:12people would still be discriminated against?
- 1:51:14Absolutely.
- 1:51:14With the,
- 1:51:15with the fact that Republicans have poured what,
- 1:51:17$215 million into anti-trans ads,
- 1:51:20into anti-queer ads?
- 1:51:22Of course!
- 1:51:23What are you talking about?
- 1:51:25You're you're going to deny that those ads influence how people.
- 1:51:27Thing.
- 1:51:28It changed elections by the double digits.
- 1:51:30What
- 1:51:31do you have to support that?
- 1:51:32That was the entire like Russian collusion thing.
- 1:51:35That was the but but they found no evidence of Russian collusion.
- 1:51:37No,
- 1:51:37no,
- 1:51:38no,
- 1:51:38no,
- 1:51:38the OK,
- 1:51:39you need to understand this.
- 1:51:40Citizens United,
- 1:51:41do you know what that is?
- 1:51:42Absolutely.
- 1:51:42Right.
- 1:51:42So you know that
- 1:51:44uh that Supreme Court case gave
- 1:51:46gave corporations
- 1:51:47the same level of free speech as you.
- 1:51:48correct?
- 1:51:49Yes,
- 1:51:49which I think needs to be overturned by the way.
- 1:51:51Why do you think it needs to be overturned,
- 1:51:52Austin?
- 1:51:52Because Citizens United allows corporations to buy politicians,
- 1:51:54which is
- 1:51:55corporations from here and where?
- 1:51:57All over.
- 1:51:59So that's what I'm talking about.
- 1:52:00So it doesn't even matter
- 1:52:01where this is coming from,
- 1:52:02right?
- 1:52:02It could come from companies from outside the United States funding PACs
- 1:52:06within the United States to influence people to be against gay people.
- 1:52:09Well that has changed elections.
- 1:52:11You like this is why this is why the
- 1:52:12left and the right don't even doesn't even actually know
- 1:52:15the types of people that are in these two different
- 1:52:17groups because we are consistently lied to by these PACs.
- 1:52:20It has changed
- 1:52:21the political,
- 1:52:22uh,
- 1:52:22our political conversations.
- 1:52:24It has completely bastardized our public squares.
- 1:52:27Can we at least agree,
- 1:52:28can we at least agree here
- 1:52:29that
- 1:52:30if we overturn Citizens United.
- 1:52:32And if we got billionaires and millionaires out of the
- 1:52:34business of running the game of politics and purchasing politicians,
- 1:52:37that we might be having at some point a
- 1:52:39different I think we'd be having more of an honest
- 1:52:41conversation
- 1:52:41because at the very least,
- 1:52:43most of the stances or more of the stances that we have are going to be influenced by
- 1:52:47Americans to Americans,
- 1:52:48not Americans and Russians,
- 1:52:49not Americans and Israelis,
- 1:52:51not Americans and Chinese.
- 1:52:53I'm all for that.
- 1:52:53I'm listen,
- 1:52:54I'm I'm not pro-Russia,
- 1:52:55Russia,
- 1:52:55Russia,
- 1:52:56not at all,
- 1:52:56never pro-Russia,
- 1:52:57Russia,
- 1:52:57Russia,
- 1:52:58but I,
- 1:52:59I,
- 1:52:59I would,
- 1:52:59I would,
- 1:52:59I would grant you that.
- 1:53:00I would grant you that if we would have
- 1:53:02a more,
- 1:53:02I think
- 1:53:03political discourse in this country would absolutely be more
- 1:53:04honest if you got the money out of it
- 1:53:06because again,
- 1:53:07the love of money is the root of all evil.
- 1:53:08Alright,
- 1:53:08pause.
- 1:53:09That's all the time we have for today.
- 1:53:11Thank you.
- 1:53:13And Austin,
- 1:53:14thank you so much for joining the circle.
- 1:53:16It was an honor
- 1:53:17to be here.
- 1:53:17It was a pleasure.
- 1:53:18All right,
- 1:53:19and thank you guys for watching at home.
- 1:53:21Please let us know your thoughts in the comments.
- 1:53:22Sound off,
- 1:53:23and we'll see you next time.
- 1:53:29Now anyone that watches the video,
- 1:53:30anyone who's watching my content,
- 1:53:31they're going to see Austin is probably one
- 1:53:32of the most pro-black conservatives that exists.
- 1:53:34You get used to being mislabeled when you sit in my position.
- 1:53:37There's a lot I wanted to say to Santana that I didn't get a chance to.
- 1:53:39He was an outright liar.
- 1:53:40He was calling me things that he couldn't prove.
- 1:53:43He crafts his positions very well.
- 1:53:46So people were looking to kinda superimpose what they
- 1:53:48thought on him and he doesn't actually do that.
- 1:53:51He says the things that he says and he,
- 1:53:53he stays on his square.
- 1:53:54I think he is a very intellectual debater
- 1:53:57and he is very quick on his feet.
- 1:53:58I think he is one of the more reasonable conservatives.
- 1:54:01Being a black conservative comes with
- 1:54:03allowing for yourself to experience a level of.
- 1:54:05Subjugation and I just haven't seen that with
- 1:54:07Austin that's why I like talking to him.
- 1:54:08It's so interesting to me that liberals have a problem with me being
- 1:54:11conservative because I'm black as if to say that
- 1:54:13the color of my skin defines my political ideology
- 1:54:16or that it's supposed to the color of someone's
- 1:54:17skin should not ever dictate their political ideology,
- 1:54:20but that's what the left tried to make happen,
- 1:54:22especially if you saw the
- 1:54:23surprise on their faces in this conversation.