Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Reaching and Teaching Neurodivergent Learners in STEM: A Deep Dive with Jodi Asbell-Clarke
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:04and today we're speaking to Jodi Asbell-Clark for a deep dive into neurodiversity in STEM.
- 0:10Dr. Jodi Asbell-Clark is a senior leader at TERC, an innovative STEM education R&D organization.
- 0:17She is the author of the recent book, Reaching and Teaching Neurodivergent Learners
- 0:22in STEM, Strategies for Embracing Uniquely Talented Problem Solvers.
- 0:26We're so excited to have you here with us today. Thank you for joining us, Jodi.
- 0:30Oh, thanks so much for having me. It's a pleasure. So tell us a little bit about
- 0:34yourself and what connects you to your work.
- 0:37Sure. Well, I have a background in physics, math, and astronomy.
- 0:42And I actually, my first job after university was working as a programmer on
- 0:47the space shuttle program.
- 0:49And then I became a, then I went to grad school and became a high school teacher.
- 0:54And then for the last 30 years, I've been putting all that together in research
- 0:58on how people learn, particularly in STEM.
- 1:02Throughout all this work, I've met many unique individuals who are really talented,
- 1:08some of the most brilliant people I've met, but some
- 1:12of them didn't fit into the workplace or certain
- 1:15that many of the students didn't fit into school in the
- 1:18way that the systems expected them And I
- 1:21always found that the most unique thing to think about when I was thinking about
- 1:27how to design education and teaching learning materials is how do we capture
- 1:33those special talents that are often masked by the way school is set up?
- 1:39Tell us more about TERC. Sure. So at TERC, I lead a team of educator researchers
- 1:43and designers, and we look at innovative ways to reach marginalized learners instead.
- 1:49And we have some work in makerspaces using EEG headsets to have kids map their
- 1:58own brainwaves and drive robots and do things with brainwaves.
- 2:02We have some work in virtual reality where we're working with,
- 2:07and most of our work, we work with neurodivergent learners to design materials
- 2:11for neurodivergent learners.
- 2:13And we're building a VR experience where you're on a space station floating
- 2:19above Jupiter's moon Europa and doing science investigations.
- 2:23And this is all built with sensory and attention and social needs of people,
- 2:29of autistic people in mind and was designed, again, by many neurodivergent learners.
- 2:36And then we also work a lot in schools and most recently have been working on
- 2:44a project called Including Neurodiversity in Foundational and Applied Computational Thinking.
- 2:49And that's a long way of saying computational thinking are the skills that you
- 2:54need to understand how computers do what So you may need it for programming.
- 3:01You may need it for robotics. You may need it to, you know, deal with your car
- 3:06or your microwave or your refrigerator or your AI bot or whatever.
- 3:12And all those, that knowledge that kids learn has these foundations of breaking
- 3:20up big problems into smaller problems.
- 3:22That's called problem composition and pattern recognition and finding patterns
- 3:28between problems and solutions, generalizing those problems into algorithms or routines.
- 3:35And when we started working in about 2015 with a game called Zumbinis that TERC 45 00:03:42,780 --> 00:03:46,000 created in the 90s, it's a logical thinking game.
- 3:46We wanted to study how kids were building these computational thinking skills in the game.
- 3:51And what happened is while we were doing that, teachers kept on coming up to
- 3:55us over and over and saying, hey, it's these kids that are struggling in all
- 4:00these other aspects of school.
- 4:02They are rock stars in this game. They're the first ones solving the problems.
- 4:07And the other kids are coming to them and saying, how did you do that?
- 4:10So they're becoming a go-to resource in the class.
- 4:14And so their whole identity is shifting and their whole stature in the class is shifting.
- 4:19And so we were like oh that's kind of cool what is it about.
- 4:24Computational thinking game. And we spread it out into other kinds of like puzzles
- 4:28and kinesthetic activities and coding and robotics and found that there's a
- 4:34strong connection for many neurodivergent learners,
- 4:36affinity and a talent for many of these activities.
- 4:40So, okay, that's cool. The other thing that happened is some special educators
- 4:46who were using the material said, wow, problem decomposition,
- 4:50pattern recognition, generalization into routine, These are many of the executive
- 4:55functioning scaffolds that I try to build with my students and supports.
- 5:00And computational thinking just gives me words and a context to think about all that.
- 5:06So all that has really turned our attention to this connection between computational
- 5:12thinking and other forms of STEM problem solving and neurodivergent talents
- 5:19and how we can reveal and embrace those talents while also supporting executive
- 5:24function and social emotional needs.
- 5:27So it's not the approach of kind of adding something new to a teacher's plate.
- 5:31That's something that I always hear, right?
- 5:33Like, well, there's just so much on our plate. There's so much going on.
- 5:36What you're really investigating is how these ideas are actually like intrinsically linked, right?
- 5:42Computational thinking is STEM. STEM is problem solving.
- 5:47It's not a extra. It's not a different thing.
- 5:51Even if we wanted to do what you suggest, it's impossible.
- 5:55Right, right. It has always been a struggle.
- 5:59And in the last five, 10 years, even before COVID, it was hard. And now it's unfair.
- 6:06I would say it's unfair as an educational researcher to go in and try to pile
- 6:11something new onto teachers unless it's going to help them do what they're already trying to do. And-
- 6:19problem solving in general is an area that everybody kind of dances around in
- 6:25science standards and in math standards and all that, but it's in there with all that.
- 6:30And it's in there with daily life and in, you know, completing tasks in a classroom of any kind.
- 6:38And there's a lot of really good problem solvers out there.
- 6:43There's great systematic thinkers and pattern
- 6:47recognizers and detailed thinkers and also
- 6:50idea generators and people who see big pictures
- 6:53and connect ideas and other people who are non-conforming and just will spout
- 7:00out anything and come out with something brilliant when nobody else would have
- 7:03and other people who are so persistent that they're going to just stick to that
- 7:07task until it is done no matter what.
- 7:11Those are all really great talents that we need to seize and that workplaces
- 7:16are already seeing as a competitive advantage, they call it.
- 7:20So I just really try to think of ways to wrap education around those talents
- 7:26and then, again, support what needs to be supported in the midst.
- 7:30And I will say that in my experience going into lots and lots of classrooms,
- 7:36and I've been invited to co-teach with STEM teachers in junior highs in my own city quite frequently.
- 7:44And it's amazing when we change things up a little bit and do something like
- 7:52project-based learning where kids are pursuing their own interests and passions
- 7:56and we mold all their learning and assessment around whatever it is they want to do.
- 8:04Yes, some kids still need some support for something, But much less than when
- 8:09we force them to sit in a chair and be quiet and listen to something that they're not engaged in.
- 8:15A lot of this stuff goes away.
- 8:18Not everything, but a lot of this stuff goes away when we put the child at the
- 8:24center of the learning experience. parents. Yeah.
- 8:26Let's talk about your book, Reaching and Teaching Neurodivergent Learners in STEM.
- 8:32You know, why is this so important to you? What made you want to write this
- 8:37book? Where did this come from?
- 8:38So I've been doing research in the field for 30 years and I,
- 8:43for about 20 of those years, I was like.
- 8:47Knew I was trying the right things, but felt like I was missing the mark.
- 8:51I never aligned with what was needed in the classroom.
- 8:55I could teach what I, the way I taught, and I, and a few teachers would love it and catch on.
- 9:01And I would say this, not just about my work, I would say this about almost
- 9:04any reform-based innovative work.
- 9:07But the way the schools were set up and the systems of education,
- 9:12especially through things like No Child Left Behind, which had its pluses and minuses.
- 9:17There were benefits for a lot of people, and there was also some losses through that.
- 9:24And one of the losses was the autonomy of the teacher and to be able to do some
- 9:30of the things that worked.
- 9:32So through all that, I just felt like I wasn't really making the mark that I wanted to make.
- 9:37And then I will say around 10 Ten years ago, I started to go into classrooms
- 9:41and really around my own neighborhood just as a volunteer and co-teach with
- 9:47some fabulous teachers as they were trying to do project-based learning.
- 9:52And the first school I went to was a really high needs, very,
- 9:57nobody was stigmatized because everybody had something going on.
- 10:01So and the teachers were
- 10:04there because they chose that school
- 10:07because anybody who didn't came in didn't last
- 10:10and the teachers i worked had been there for a
- 10:13decade or so or more because they loved
- 10:16working with these kids and so and they
- 10:20let me in nobody was watching there were no nobody from above top was worried
- 10:25about me coming into the school even to recover but i got to go in And I actually
- 10:31did a lot of work with the teachers during COVID to get the teachers through
- 10:35that hurdle, which is a whole nother issue.
- 10:37But through that, when I got into that school early on, I realized there is
- 10:43nothing I'm going to do to help these kids learn science and technology,
- 10:47which is where I was working, those areas, if I don't deal with their executive function.
- 10:52I didn't even know what that meant at the time, but I just knew there's something
- 10:57going on that is blocking these kids from being able to learn.
- 11:01And we've got to deal with that first.
- 11:04And I then sat back and watched how these teachers built relationships with
- 11:10these kids and how the school, yes,
- 11:14it was about content and there was certainly, you know, academics there,
- 11:17but the school was about supporting the kids.
- 11:20And I learned so much and hopefully introduced some ideas and did a whole bunch
- 11:27of research during that time to say, okay, how are these kids' brains working?
- 11:32Like, what is going on? What is this fight and flight and what is hypervigilance?
- 11:37And what are these extraordinary, twice exceptional type kids,
- 11:42what's going on with them? Like, why are they so...
- 11:47Brilliant in this area and cannot put a
- 11:50piece of paper into their notebook if it saved their lives like
- 11:53what's going on and and does it matter whether they
- 11:56can put a piece of paper in the notebook can we get oh that's a
- 11:59good point the notebook and and so
- 12:03so all those questions were so much
- 12:06more interesting to me than how do i teach this individual science
- 12:10concept to a presumably homogeneous set you
- 12:13know right so the book actually has
- 12:16a chapter about how the brain works and a chapter about
- 12:19extraordinary learners and over excitability literature
- 12:23and a chapter about the stem problem solving habits and those are all encased
- 12:30within these stories that come out my work with each kid taught me something
- 12:35and then i went and researched it and then you know resulted in a chapter.
- 12:40And really what it comes down to is something that I've believed all my life, all my career,
- 12:45that if you can give a learner agency and autonomy in their process while supporting
- 12:51them along the way in what Pugazzi calls the zone of proximal development.
- 12:57Yes. You know, that's it.
- 13:00And that comes from understanding what motivates that child,
- 13:05Understanding where their trigger points are,
- 13:08where they're having guardrails around their learning experience so that you
- 13:13can keep them in their optimal zone.
- 13:15And that's all about relationship building. And the only way that I can see
- 13:20that we can do that in classrooms is by things like PBA, project-based learning,
- 13:26or I'm sure there are others, game-based learning can help, but it's really
- 13:31that, but ways that you engage the student in something that they have their
- 13:37own goals and mission and you support them along the journey.
- 13:40And what happens when we do that is we free up the teaching time.
- 13:44The teachers, every teacher I've worked with in a PBL classroom has said,
- 13:50oh my God, I'm not teaching. They all of a sudden, like, I'm not teaching,
- 13:54but all my kids are learning right now.
- 13:57And what happens is that frees up their time to be able to go work with each
- 14:02individual group, but have a conversation,
- 14:05figure out where they are, where they're excelling, where they're struggling,
- 14:09support their struggles, record their, where they're excelling because that's real-time assessment.
- 14:14It's, they're performing at stuff that that's your
- 14:17measurement right there and then and
- 14:20guide them along their way and support them emotionally in
- 14:24their journey as well and I've seen
- 14:26it happen in so many different settings that it's
- 14:30I was going to say it's not rocket science but
- 14:34that's I mean it's
- 14:37yeah I was an arts educator for 10 years in New York City and those are kind
- 14:42of my favorite units or lessons those days or those weeks where I got to the
- 14:46point where I could release the kids and they could work on their own projects
- 14:51because you laid the groundwork, you gave them the framework,
- 14:54and now I'm walking around and facilitating, right?
- 14:58But I'm not doing the heavy lifting. The kids are doing the heavy lifting.
- 15:02And that's the idea, right? Is that you give the students the tools to have
- 15:08agency over their own and learning.
- 15:09You give them the agency and you also have to give them supported autonomy in
- 15:15that, you know, not every kid's going to want to make a data table.
- 15:19Some might want to want to make a visualization or graph.
- 15:22Not every kid's going to want to write everything down.
- 15:25Some might want to make a video or, or, and some might just want to tell you about it.
- 15:29And then you have to figure out with them how to translate that into something that's more permanent,
- 15:34but giving them those avenues to show their success and to see their own success
- 15:40before you shut them down and say, no, you have to do this thing that you really struggle with.
- 15:45Right. Right. You know, some of us, it feels intimidating, but when you really
- 15:50dig into it, especially the way that you've written this out, it's very digestible.
- 15:54So you, I was trying to do that.
- 15:57It's very digestible and you don't need to be a neuroscientist to get so much
- 16:03out of this book. You know, who is this for?
- 16:05Who do you want to read this? I mean, everybody, of course.
- 16:09It's funny when you said, you know, you don't have to be a neuroscientist.
- 16:13My father was an author and he often said in nonfiction author,
- 16:17he said, write about what you don't know because it's much more interesting.
- 16:20Oh, I love that. This is a journey. I am not a neuroscientist.
- 16:25So I had to digest what are the things I read a lot and then I had to come back
- 16:29with like what are the few things that I really think need to be understood
- 16:34without being able to label all the different parts of the brain,
- 16:38which, you know, now that there's chat GBT, we'll never have to label anything ourselves again.
- 16:43But and so so focusing in on executive function and the executive networks of
- 16:48the brain and how those can get tripped up and how those can get stimulated
- 16:52and motivated was really what I needed the practitioners to come away with.
- 16:57And so I really did write it from my research to practice experience.
- 17:03And so therefore, for practitioners who are in the classroom who want strategies
- 17:09and strategies and also vignettes or stories of like, how did we do game-based
- 17:16learning in the classroom?
- 17:18And what did that look like? And what worked and what didn't?
- 17:21And how do we do project-based learning? And how do we come up with new ways of assessment?
- 17:25And what did those look like through project-based learning?
- 17:28And how do we come up with those supports?
- 17:30And I actually put those supports in the book, the milestone documents and stuff.
- 17:35So I hope that it really helps teachers not only understand why this is important,
- 17:41but have some real tangible ways to do that.
- 17:44And then the last chapter is a call to everyone because it is not just on teachers by any means.
- 17:51It's on administrators and policymakers to change some things about the school
- 17:56day and about assessment and about teaching models and time,
- 18:00how teachers can spend their time together.
- 18:03And then also just on all of us of how we see neurodivergent people differently, how,
- 18:10I mean, I came, as you saw in the book, to see even people that I knew 30,
- 18:1640 years ago and crossed paths with in my career.
- 18:19And I now realize the fact, the missed opportunity to be mentored by brilliant
- 18:26people who just communicated differently than I did.
- 18:28And I just, my eyes are wide open to what's behind somebody's perceived struggle
- 18:37with speech or with emotion or with sitting still.
- 18:42There's so much more to that person than that.
- 18:46Can we talk about some of the challenges that come up in this work?
- 18:49I mean, what would you say are some of your lessons learned,
- 18:52big takeaways, something that you could, looking back on all the things, pass along?
- 18:57I think how unbelievably innovative and forward-thinking industry has already been in this area.
- 19:07I interviewed over 100 employees and employers of STEM companies for the book,
- 19:13as well as families and neurodivergent learners and their families and educators.
- 19:17But I was calling the manager of a neurodivergent hiring program and I'd ask
- 19:23them, why is the company doing this?
- 19:25And I really expected it to be for philanthropic reasons.
- 19:28Oh, the CEO has a nephew or something with autism or something.
- 19:32And they were like, oh no, for the talent, hands down for the talent.
- 19:36We see neurodiversity as a competitive advantage.
- 19:39Our teams are stronger when we have really strong on systematic thinkers working
- 19:44with great idea generators and nonconformers and innovators.
- 19:49And that's what their clients wanted. And they want more.
- 19:53So we're almost out of time. How can folks get involved or stay informed, keep up to date with you?
- 19:58Well, so my group at TERC has a website called Neurodiversity in STEM at TERC.
- 20:06We'll have it in the description of the podcast. great so all our
- 20:09in fact materials are open source and so
- 20:12they're all there and then of course
- 20:15is the link to get my book reaching and teaching marriage urgent learners in
- 20:19stem strategies for embracing uniquely talented problem solvers and it's available
- 20:24online or you can always go into your local bookstore and ask them to order
- 20:28it and they will correct but don't don't get the a hard copy. It's very expensive.
- 20:33Get the paperback. Or the ebook.
- 20:40Awesome. Thank you so much for joining us today, Jodi. It was great to chat with you.
- 20:44Oh, thank you, Aurora. It's always good to talk to you. I'm glad to talk to your audience as well.
- 20:49Well, folks, that's it for us today. Thank you to Dr.
- 20:53Jodi Asbell-Clark. And to learn more, check out their website at TERC.edu slash nd in STEM.
- 21:00I'm Aurora from ELA, and this was a deep dive into neurodiversity in STEM.
- 21:06Music.