Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Microsoft (MSFT) Business, Valuation, Growth, and Risk Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00How does a company that's already worth, well, trillions
- 0:02of dollars keep growing, keep dominating, and what does that
- 0:04actually mean for its financial health, its future?
- 0:07We're talking about one of the absolute biggest names in tech
- 0:10today, a company whose products, whose services you probably
- 0:13interact with constantly. Welcome to the deep dive.
- 0:17This is where we take source material, often complex
- 0:20financial reports, and really pull out the key insights for
- 0:22you. Today, we're diving deep into
- 0:24Microsoft Corporation. The ticker is NASDAQ dot, OSFT,
- 0:29and we're using data right up through 2025.
- 0:31Our mission to breakdown it's, let's face it, complex business
- 0:34model, get a sense of its financial pulse, look at the
- 0:36challenges and view it all through the lens of a value
- 0:39investor. Now this deep dive is built on a
- 0:41pretty comprehensive financial research report.
- 0:43It really digs into Microsoft's performance and its outlook.
- 0:45And look, before we jump in, a really crucial point for you,
- 0:48our listener, this discussion, it's purely for informational
- 0:50and educational purposes. It is not financial advice.
- 0:53All the analysis is based on publicly available sources.
- 0:56Things can change, interpretations differ.
- 0:58Investing always involves risk. You could lose money.
- 1:00So please always do your own homework, your own due
- 1:02diligence, or talk to a financial advisor before making
- 1:04any investment decisions. What you learn here is about
- 1:07understanding, not about making a specific move.
- 1:11OK, so let's get into it. How has Microsoft managed to
- 1:14become just so pervasive? I mean from the software on your
- 1:17desks, the cloud infrastructure running huge parts of the
- 1:19Internet. Yeah, it's, it's fascinating,
- 1:22isn't it? The sheer breadth is one thing,
- 1:24but it's how they did it. That transition from selling,
- 1:27you know, software in a box, one time sales to this incredibly
- 1:32steady stream of recurring revenue services like Azure,
- 1:35Microsoft 365, that's the real story.
- 1:38Recurring revenue, yeah, that changes the game.
- 1:40It absolutely does. It builds resilience.
- 1:42Think about it. If PC demand softens, which
- 1:44happens right, sure, that weakness can be significantly
- 1:47offset. If Azure is still firing in all
- 1:49cylinders, it acts like a shock absorber.
- 1:51Very few tech companies have that kind of balance across such
- 1:54massive different markets. It's a huge evolution because
- 1:57for a lot of people, Microsoft still means Windows, right?
- 2:00But the sources we looked at paint a very different picture,
- 2:02a huge diversified conglomerate. They report across three main
- 2:06segments now based on a fiscal year 2024.
- 2:08Can you break those down for us? Sure.
- 2:10So first up is productivity and business processes.
- 2:13This is where you find the heavy hitters like Office 365,
- 2:17LinkedIn in their Dynamics business software Then, and this
- 2:21is really where the massive shift has occurred, Intelligent
- 2:24Cloud, that's Azure, their cloud platform plus server products.
- 2:29This segment is now the biggest, around 40% of revenue in FY24.
- 2:3340% Wow. Yeah, and finally, more personal
- 2:36computing. This still includes Windows,
- 2:37their Surface devices, Xbox, and also search advertising like
- 2:41Bing. So that diversification really
- 2:43means no single product is carrying the whole company
- 2:45anymore. Within those segments, what are
- 2:47the real revenue engines? Right, exactly.
- 2:49No single point of failure. Looking at the breakdown from
- 2:51our sources for FY24 Azure and the related server products,
- 2:55that's the clear leader pulled in almost $98 billion. 98
- 2:58billion staggering. It really is.
- 3:00Then you've got Microsoft 365, That's Office, plus the cloud
- 3:03services adding nearly $55 billion, also huge.
- 3:07And Windows licensing, while still important, is now actually
- 3:09less than 10% of total revenue by $23 billion.
- 3:12Less than 10%. That really shows the shift.
- 3:14It does. And don't forget gaming Xbox
- 3:16content services, plus the big Activision Blizzard acquisition
- 3:20that's around $21.5 billion and LinkedIn chipping in a very
- 3:23solid $16.4 billion. So you see this mix, right?
- 3:27Steady recurring subscriptions from 365 in Azure providing
- 3:31predictability alongside those what's called transactional
- 3:34sales like Windows licenses or a Surface device.
- 3:37It makes the whole model very robust.
- 3:39And the scale, yeah, it's not just dollars, it's the user
- 3:42base, the ecosystem. It feels like they're embedded
- 3:45everywhere. Oh, absolutely.
- 3:46The scales and that you're talking well over a billion
- 3:48users globally. Windows is on 1.4 billion active
- 3:51devices, 1.4 billion, Microsoft 360 five, 345,000,000 paid
- 3:55subscribers. And Azure isn't just big, it's
- 3:57fundamental, used by over 95% of Fortune, 505%.
- 4:00LinkedIn just passed a billion members, Xbox Live over 100
- 4:03million monthly active users. Yeah, it's not just numbers,
- 4:06it's the network effect. The deep integration makes it
- 4:09very sticky, very hard for customers to switch away.
- 4:11OK, this is where it gets really interesting, though.
- 4:13No company, no matter how big, has a perfectly smooth ride.
- 4:17What are the big challenges, the headwinds on Microsoft's radar
- 4:20both near term and maybe more structural?
- 4:24And how do costs fit in? Yeah, that's a great question.
- 4:27And if you connected to the bigger picture, there's this
- 4:29constant tension right between making these massive essential
- 4:32investments, especially in AI and cloud data centers now and
- 4:36the potential for, you know, clients to tap the brakes on
- 4:39spending. Sometimes.
- 4:41This creates a real balancing act for managing investor
- 4:43expectations. You have this long term vision,
- 4:45but you also have short term market volatility.
- 4:48So what are those short term pressures right now?
- 4:50Well, management themselves have signaled a bit of caution
- 4:52recently. Their guidance for upcoming
- 4:54quarters points to revenue growth maybe closer to 10%.
- 4:57That's a bit of a step down from the mid teens they've been
- 4:59delivering. OK, 10% still good.
- 5:01But yeah, slow down. What's driving that caution?
- 5:03It seems to be a few things. The softer demand in the PC
- 5:06market is definitely hitting that more personal computing
- 5:09segment and still sluggish. There's also talk of a potential
- 5:12digestion phase for AI and cloud spending.
- 5:15Companies spend huge amounts very quickly.
- 5:17Maybe now they pause, optimize, figure out the ROI before the
- 5:20next big wave. We might see some data center
- 5:22projects paused temporarily. Makes sense.
- 5:24A breather. Exactly.
- 5:25Plus you have the macro environment, higher inflation,
- 5:28interest rates, maybe making IT departments a bit more cautious
- 5:31with budgets worldwide and a strong U.S. dollar always takes
- 5:35a bite out of international revenue when they convert it
- 5:37back. We saw that play out a bit even
- 5:39with Azure grew an amazing 33% in Q3 fiscal 25, but management
- 5:44still kind of tempered expectations for Q4, citing some
- 5:47of these factors. Got it.
- 5:48So those are the near term bumps.
- 5:49What about the longer term? Maybe more structural challenges
- 5:52they have to navigate? Yeah, those are always there.
- 5:54For a company this size, competition is just relentless,
- 5:56isn't it? Azure is in a constant dogfight
- 5:58with Amazon's AWS and Google Cloud.
- 6:01Microsoft 365 has Google Workspace nipping at its heels.
- 6:04Always looking over their shoulder.
- 6:05Constantly. Then there's regulatory
- 6:08scrutiny. Being this big and dominant puts
- 6:10a target on your back. Antitrust questions, especially
- 6:13around bundling services like teams with office, has been a
- 6:15hot topic in Europe. Potential fines maybe force
- 6:18changes to how they operate. And geopolitical risks, too.
- 6:21Yeah, definitely. Things like US, China, trade
- 6:23tensions can impact supply chains, market access, data
- 6:26regulations. It's a complex global landscape.
- 6:29And the ever present threat of technological disruption itself.
- 6:32Absolutely. You can never rest on your
- 6:33laurels. The threat from new
- 6:35technologies, maybe open source alternatives, a different OS
- 6:38paradigm, it's always out there. You could argue Microsoft's huge
- 6:42bet on open AI and integrating AI everywhere is partly a very
- 6:46smart to sense of play, making sure they own the next big wave,
- 6:49not get disrupted by it. Good point.
- 6:50And finally, there's valuation risk.
- 6:53We'll talk more about this later, but the stock trades at a
- 6:55premium maybe 30 to 35 times earnings recently.
- 6:58That means the market expects near perfection.
- 7:01Any slip up in growth, any disappointment could hit the
- 7:04stock price harder than if we were trading at, say, 15 times
- 7:07earnings. Make perfect sense?
- 7:09OK, let's shift to costs. A company delivering these kinds
- 7:12of services? Software, cloud.
- 7:14How does their cost structure work?
- 7:16Well, the beauty of software in cloud for Microsoft is
- 7:18incredibly high. Gross margins around 70% in FY20
- 7:2224. 70%. Yeah, because after you make the
- 7:25huge upfront investments, the cost of adding one more user or
- 7:28one more unit of software is relatively low.
- 7:30Those are low variable costs, but the fixed costs are
- 7:33enormous. R&D is a big one, nearly $30
- 7:35billion in 2024. That's about 12% of their
- 7:38revenue. That's salaries for engineers,
- 7:40labs, infrastructure. It doesn't really change much if
- 7:43they add another million office users.
- 7:45And the CapEx for all those data centers must be astronomical
- 7:48now, especially with AI. Astronomical is the right word
- 7:51was over $30 billion in 2024, but the projection for fiscal
- 7:5625? Maybe $80 billion, primarily for
- 8:00data centers to power Azure and all the AI ambitions. 80
- 8:03billion. Wow.
- 8:04That flows through as higher depreciation, which is a fixed
- 8:06cost over time and of course labor.
- 8:08Around 228,000 employees in 2024.
- 8:11That's a massive fixed expense base, even if they make
- 8:14adjustments sometimes. So despite these huge and
- 8:17growing fixed costs for R&D and data centers, their operating
- 8:21margins have actually improved over the last decade.
- 8:23That's operating leverage in action, right?
- 8:25Exactly. That's the textbook definition.
- 8:26As revenue grows, those fixed costs get spread over a larger
- 8:30base, so each additional dollar of revenue brings more profit to
- 8:33the bottom line. Revenue growth is outpaced
- 8:36expense growth. It's a really powerful dynamic
- 8:38in their financial model. OK, so you have this complex
- 8:40machine, huge scale, big challenges, but incredible
- 8:43financials. Who's actually running the show?
- 8:45What about the management team and how aligned are they with
- 8:47shareholders? Like if you're a shareholder,
- 8:49are they working for you? Well, what's quite striking
- 8:51here, and reassuring from a governance perspective is the
- 8:54alignment. You see significant stock
- 8:56ownership by top execs, compensation tied heavily to
- 8:59performance. It creates stability, right?
- 9:01When management's interests are closely tied to shareholders.
- 9:04Especially for a company navigating something as complex
- 9:07and capital intensive as the AI transition, that stability is
- 9:11crucial. Let's talk specifics.
- 9:13Satya Nadella, CEO and Chairman since 2014.
- 9:16He gets a lot of credit for the cloud transformation and the AI
- 9:18focus. He absolutely does and working
- 9:20closely with him. Amy Hood, the CFO since 2013.
- 9:24She's widely respected for discipline, capital allocation,
- 9:26managing huge acquisitions like LinkedIn and Activision,
- 9:29overseeing massive share buybacks.
- 9:31And Brad Smith, the vice chair and president, handles the
- 9:33critical legal, regulatory and public affairs side, a very
- 9:37important role given the scrutiny we just talked about.
- 9:39What you notice is that it's largely a team of Microsoft
- 9:41veterans. There's deep institutional
- 9:43knowledge, continuity and their track record speaks for itself.
- 9:47Strong execution, meeting or beating goals on things like
- 9:50Azure growth, the Office 365 transition.
- 9:53And they seem pretty transparent to acknowledging challenges,
- 9:56which is good. And importantly, no major
- 9:59scandals or integrity issues under Nadella.
- 10:02That transparency builds credibility, yeah, and the
- 10:05stability in Adela and Hood in their roles for over a decade,
- 10:09that's a real asset. It translates into that
- 10:11shareholder alignment to management definitely has skin
- 10:14in the game. Satya Nadella's own stake is
- 10:17worth what, over $700 million? That certainly aligns his
- 10:20interest with other shareholders and their pay packages are
- 10:23heavily weighted towards stock and tied to specific performance
- 10:26metrics. It incentivizes long term
- 10:29thinking, not just hitting quarterly numbers.
- 10:31And what about the broader ownership?
- 10:32It's not like one person controls it.
- 10:34No, it's very widely held institutional investors.
- 10:37Big funds like Vanguard, BlackRock, State Street owned
- 10:40over 70% of the company. Interestingly, former CEO Steve
- 10:43Ballmer is still the largest individual shareholders, and
- 10:46Bill Gates still holds a sizable stake, too.
- 10:48So those big institutions hold the voting power mostly.
- 10:51How does that play out? Generally yes, and they tend to
- 10:53support management on routine matters.
- 10:55For instance, at the 2024 shareholder meeting, all the
- 10:58board nominees were reelected with like 9499% approval.
- 11:02There are a few shareholder proposals, things that Bitcoin,
- 11:05AI, ethics, but they were all defeated with the big
- 11:07institutions siding with the board's recommendation against
- 11:10them. So right now it looks like a
- 11:11supportive, not activist shareholder base.
- 11:14They seem confident in the current strategy.
- 11:16OK, let's dive into the numbers themselves then.
- 11:18How healthy is Microsoft financially?
- 11:20We touched on margins, but looking over the last decade and
- 11:23what did the latest earnings report really tell?
- 11:25Us, if this is where you ask that key question, can a company
- 11:28this huge keep delivering these kinds of results?
- 11:32And while sure, they're not totally immune to economic
- 11:34cycles, the overall financial story is just, well, remarkably
- 11:36strong. Even with pouring billions into
- 11:38AI. Looking back, say 2015 to 2024,
- 11:42the financial trajectory is impressive.
- 11:44Very impressive. Revenue growth has been robust
- 11:46right from about $94 billion to $245 billion.
- 11:50That's nearly a triple, roughly an 11% compound annual growth
- 11:53rate and it really accelerated after 2017 with the cloud boom.
- 11:57Exactly. And the profitability story is
- 11:59even better. Operating margins climb from the
- 12:01high teens around 19% up to 45%. Net margins more than doubled,
- 12:0513% up to 36%. Metrics like return on equity
- 12:09consistently 3045%, return on invested capital often 2530%.
- 12:13These are numbers that scream cash generating machine with
- 12:16wide economic moats. Those are the durable
- 12:18competitive advantages protecting its profits.
- 12:20And the balance sheet, our sources called it fortress like
- 12:23assets nearly tripled to over half a trillion dollars and they
- 12:25basically have net cash, way more cash than total debt.
- 12:28Debt to equity plummeted, plenty of liquidity.
- 12:30They're financially rock solid. Absolutely rock solid and very
- 12:33friendly to shareholders. Over that period, dividends
- 12:36steadily increased, huge share buybacks over $120 billion
- 12:40cumulatively, which reduce the share count by about 11%.
- 12:43That boosts earnings per share, but there's always a but in
- 12:47investing. All the success and optimism
- 12:50means the valuation multiples expanded significantly.
- 12:52The price earnings ratio went from maybe the mid 20s up to the
- 12:553035 range. Investors are paying a lot more
- 12:57for each dollar of earnings now. Which neatly brings us to the
- 13:00latest quarter, Q3 fiscal 25. It was a beat, right?
- 13:04What stood out? Yes, a strong beat versus
- 13:05expectations. Revenue hit almost $62 billion,
- 13:08up 16% year over year, solid growth.
- 13:11The engine was clearly intelligent Cloud, up about 20%
- 13:14and within that Azure revenue specifically was up a very
- 13:16strong 33%. That re acceleration was key.
- 13:1933% for Azure, yeah. Productivity and business
- 13:21processes grew 12% more personal computing was up 17%, helped by
- 13:25some PC market recovery. And Xbox and gaming overall
- 13:28jumped 39%, really showing the impact of that Activision
- 13:31Blizzard deal closing. And earnings kept pace.
- 13:33They did earnings per share $3.46, up about 14% year over
- 13:37year, nicely beating the consensus.
- 13:39Operating margin for the quarter was very strong, almost 52%. 52%
- 13:43margin, yeah. And they kept returning cash to
- 13:45shareholders, about $9 billion in that quarter alone between
- 13:48buybacks and dividends. So strong results all around,
- 13:51but did they stick to that cautious tone in the outlook
- 13:54despite the beat? They did, yes.
- 13:56Despite the strong Q3, the guidance for Q4 FY25 was still
- 14:00around that 10% year over year revenue growth Mark.
- 14:03They can mention that cloud optimization digestion phase by
- 14:06some clients and the consumer PC market still being a bit soft.
- 14:10But, and this is important, they were very clear about being
- 14:12extremely bullish on AI opportunities long term.
- 14:15And how did the market react to that mix?
- 14:17Positively, actually the stock jumped about 7% after hours.
- 14:20It seems investors focused on the Azure strength and the AI
- 14:23leadership narrative, viewing it as a relatively safe haven, a
- 14:26defensive growth stock even with a slightly cautious near term
- 14:29guidance. OK.
- 14:30So putting it all together, what does this mean for you, the
- 14:33listener maybe thinking about investing?
- 14:35How would a legendary value investor like Warren Buffett
- 14:38potentially view Microsoft today?
- 14:40Right. And this really gets to the
- 14:41heart of value investing dilemma, doesn't it?
- 14:43When does a truly great company become an overpriced opportunity
- 14:46cost? Microsoft's quality, its Moat,
- 14:49its management, it's all pretty undeniable.
- 14:51But from that discipline value perspective, the current stock
- 14:54price seems to imply future returns that might not clear the
- 14:58typical hurdle rate. That minimum acceptable return
- 15:00that deep value investors often look for?
- 15:02It reflects the market's perception of Sapien dominance,
- 15:04Absolutely, but maybe not cheapness in the traditional
- 15:07sense. Our source material actually
- 15:09touched on some notable value investors in Microsoft Value Act
- 15:12Capital had that famous activist stint back in 2013, right, And
- 15:15got in around $30. Exactly, they bought in cheap,
- 15:18influenced the Nadella CEO succession and then sold most of
- 15:21their stake around $8090.00 by 2018.
- 15:24A home run for them. Classic value play by low
- 15:26influence, positive change sell higher.
- 15:28And then there's Warren Buffett famously didn't invest heavily
- 15:31in Microsoft despite his friendship with Bill Gates.
- 15:33Yeah, it's a fascinating story. Buffett himself has called it a
- 15:36mistake, admitting he missed a huge opportunity when it was
- 15:39much cheaper, maybe in the $2550 range, a decade or more ago.
- 15:43His reason? He felt his friendship with
- 15:45Gates might give him an edge or be perceived as such, so he
- 15:48avoided it to maintain impeccable Essex an interesting
- 15:51insight into his principles. And Terry Smith.
- 15:54Fun Smith often compared to Buffett, he is a big holder,
- 15:57isn't he? Yes, Microsoft is a top holding
- 15:59for Fundsmith. He bought in during the 20
- 16:01tense, likely in the $5100 range, and sees it as a long
- 16:04term compounder, a quality focused investor happy to hold
- 16:08great businesses for the long haul.
- 16:09And you see others like Bill Miller, Ken Fisher, Pat Dorsey,
- 16:12you've held it for a long time recognizing that quality.
- 16:15But then some classic deep value folks like Seth Klarman's
- 16:18bowpost apparently sold out more recently, presumably because the
- 16:22valuation got too rich for their strict criteria.
- 16:24Which brings us is squarely to that intrinsic value question.
- 16:27If we try to estimate it, say using a discounted cash flow or
- 16:30DCF analysis like Buffett might, how does it look today?
- 16:34OK, So using the methodology outlined in our source, we start
- 16:37with Microsoft's free cash flow. Think of it as owner earnings,
- 16:40which is around $74 billion for FY20 24.
- 16:43Now you have to make assumptions about future growth.
- 16:45Let's run a conservative scenario.
- 16:47FCF grows 6% a year for five years, then slows to 3% for the
- 16:50next 5, then a long term 2.5% terminal growth discount that
- 16:54back at a 10% rate above its typical hurdle.
- 16:57That conservative calculation spits out an intrinsic value of
- 17:00roughly $160 per share. A. $160, OK, that's a
- 17:03conservative view. What about a more sort of
- 17:05baseline or average growth case? All right.
- 17:07Let's assume a bit faster growth, 10% FCF growth for five
- 17:10years than 5% for the next 5, same 2.5% terminal rate.
- 17:14Still using that 10% discount rate.
- 17:16Under those assumptions, the intrinsic value comes out closer
- 17:18to $200 per. Share, right.
- 17:19So $160 conservative, $200 baseline, but the market price
- 17:24as we speak mid 2025 is way up around $490.00 per share.
- 17:29That's a huge gap, more than double even the baseline.
- 17:31Estimate. It is a huge gap and it tells
- 17:33you the market is baking in very optimistic assumptions about
- 17:36future growth, future dominance, maybe lower discount rates due
- 17:39to perceived safety or for another way, if you buy at
- 17:42$490.00 today, based on our DCF assumptions, the implied annual
- 17:46return you might expect is only around 5 to 6%. 5 to 6%, that's
- 17:50well, it's not bad, but it's maybe closer to what you'd
- 17:52expect from a on, not typically what equity investors seek for
- 17:55taking on stock market risk. And if a value investor demands
- 17:58a margin of safety, say buying at a 30% or even 50% discount to
- 18:01that estimated intrinsic value just to be safe, where would the
- 18:04buy price need to be? To get that kind of margin of
- 18:06safety on our $200 baseline estimate, your buy target would
- 18:09need to be somewhere between 100 and $140 per share.
- 18:12And on $160 conservative estimate, it'd be even lower,
- 18:15like 80 to $110. Miles away from 490 dollars.
- 18:19Miles away. So the conclusion from a strict
- 18:21classic value investing viewpoint based on this analysis
- 18:25is that Microsoft looks like a wonderful company, no doubt, but
- 18:27potentially at A2 wonderful price.
- 18:30Investors are clearly paying a hefty premium for its quality,
- 18:32its stability, its AI leadership position.
- 18:35That doesn't automatically make it a bad and testament,
- 18:37especially for long term holders focused on quality, but it
- 18:39suggests future returns from this price point might be more
- 18:42modest compared to history or compared to what a deep value
- 18:44investor targets. And let's just reiterate that
- 18:47important disclaimer for you, our listener.
- 18:49These DCF calculations, these intrinsic value numbers, they're
- 18:52purely illustrative. They depend heavily on the
- 18:55assumptions made about growth and discount rates.
- 18:58They are not guarantees. Investing involves risk.
- 19:01This analysis is for education, helping you understand the
- 19:03framework, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold.
- 19:06Microsoft, always do your own research.
- 19:08So wrapping up today's deep dive, we looked at Microsoft's
- 19:11sprawling business empire, the very real risks and headwinds it
- 19:14navigates, the strong Align management team, and it's truly
- 19:16impressive financial track record.
- 19:18We also applied that value investor lens, revealing this
- 19:20interesting paradox. Fantastic company, but perhaps a
- 19:23very demanding market price right now.
- 19:25And maybe a final thought to leave you with Microsoft is
- 19:28betting the farm almost literally on AI.
- 19:32That projected $80 billion in CapEx for FY25 is just
- 19:36unprecedented now, given their history of turning huge fixed
- 19:39costs into higher margins eventually and their fortress
- 19:42balance sheet, could their ability to innovate and dominate
- 19:45the AI era actually reshape how we even define value for a tech
- 19:49Titan like this? Or is it simply that at today's
- 19:52price, even for the best companies, future returns might
- 19:55just be destined to be, well, more normal?
- 19:57Something to ponder. We really hope this deep dive
- 20:00gave you a clearer, more informed view of Microsoft and
- 20:02maybe some tools for analyzing other complex companies.
- 20:05What stood out most to you from its story?
- 20:07We hope you'll consider these insights in your own learning.
- 20:09And a if you found this valuable, please do like and
- 20:11subscribe. You can find us on Apple
- 20:12Podcasts, Spotify, or our YouTube channel.
- 20:14Deep value investing. Oh, and one more thing.
- 20:17If you're keen to learn more about value investing
- 20:18principles, check out the episode description.
- 20:20We've put together a list of recommended books there for you.
- 20:22Thanks for diving depth with us.