Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Mapping Military Power" with Michael Hilliard
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Mapping
- 0:07Military Power. This week we were joined by geopolitical
- 0:11and defence analyst Michael Hilliard from the
- 0:14Oxus Society. Michael spoke about their recent
- 0:17mapping exercise collecting years of data to
- 0:20pinpoint the scale of military power per region
- 0:22in Central Asia. My call was also joined shortly
- 0:26on stage during the talk by Mitchell Pullman,
- 0:29an OSINT researcher who helped with the mapping
- 0:31project. Within the talk, we discussed all sorts,
- 0:34from drones to Chinese influence. You can find
- 0:37links to all the resources mentioned in the talk
- 0:40in the podcast description. This talk was hosted
- 0:42by me, Charlotte Mar, on Thursday the 6th of
- 0:45November, 2025, in the Bellingcat Discord server.
- 0:53Let's get started. Okay, welcome to another stage
- 0:59talk. Today, we're talking about military forces.
- 1:02We'll be looking at the central question. How
- 1:04do you map an army and its resources? What features
- 1:08represent military power? Here to enlighten us
- 1:12is Michael Hilliard. Michael is a Director of
- 1:15Defence and Security Analysis at the Oxford Society
- 1:17for Central Asian Affairs. where he leads the
- 1:20new and expansive Armed Forces of Central Asia
- 1:23project. Drawing on his experiences as a policy
- 1:26advisor and defence analyst, a former conflict
- 1:28journalist and the host of the geopolitical podcast
- 1:30The Red Line and Spotlight on Central Asia, by
- 1:33the way, you must listen to them and I'll pop
- 1:36the links to those in the chat later, Michael
- 1:39can answer complex security questions using data.
- 1:42Today he's going to unpack their latest report
- 1:44on the military force of Uzbekistan. a region
- 1:47known as a leading military power in Central
- 1:50Asia, as well as highlight the useful military
- 1:53units and map tracker created as part of the
- 1:55larger armed forces of Central Asia project.
- 1:58By the end of the talk, we should have a better
- 2:00understanding of the military might of Central
- 2:02Asia and the power dynamics at play there, as
- 2:05well as how we could develop a similar mapping
- 2:07exercise in other regions of the world. As we
- 2:11talk, please make sure to add your questions
- 2:13in the chat box via the message bubble icon.
- 2:15in the top right corner of your screen, as I
- 2:17just mentioned. And please note, within your
- 2:19question, if you do not want me to read your
- 2:22username out, as this is going on podcast platforms.
- 2:26Okay. Over to you, Michael. I'm going to mute
- 2:29and give you the floor. You're far too kind to
- 2:33me, Charlie. It's great to be here again. I absolutely
- 2:36love the last time I was here and I am here today.
- 2:39I'm going to share my screens with you a bit,
- 2:40but obviously we're here for the podcast. Let's
- 2:42talk a bit about the project. I've been heading
- 2:44up and effectively talk about what Becca's done
- 2:46a bit. Obviously we have our second chapter of
- 2:49the Armed Forces of Central Asia report, effectively
- 2:51giving what is probably the most comprehensive
- 2:54analysis of the five Central Asian republics.
- 2:57We're releasing each chapter alongside a bunch
- 3:00of maps. So this is the second chapter or the
- 3:03public version of that chapter. And so far we've
- 3:05located about 5 ,400 military and security locations
- 3:08across Central Asia. So quite a lot of work on
- 3:13that one. Now, part of the re -prompt we got
- 3:16here today is effectively looking at how to measure
- 3:21military and security power. I think that's an
- 3:23interesting question. So there are a lot of outlets
- 3:26online who do, and for lack of a better word,
- 3:29try and put a number on firepower. And I think
- 3:31it's very difficult to do that most of the time.
- 3:36militaries really aren't easily to quantify on
- 3:39how good they are at what they do. I'm not going
- 3:40to throw a GPF under the bus. I'm just, you know,
- 3:42this is kind of the one I see quoted the most
- 3:44in public studies. I want to take a look and
- 3:47kind of talk about the problem with trying to
- 3:49quantify things on a really solid number. Looking
- 3:55at three militaries. And effectively here we
- 3:57have Australia, Indonesia, and Uzbekistan. And
- 3:59you can see here the national GDP, Australia
- 4:01is much larger. But so is the military budget.
- 4:04Most countries do tend to kind of go to that
- 4:06way, where the military budget goes up and down
- 4:09depending on how rich the country is. Bigger
- 4:10budget, more money to play with, understandable.
- 4:13But when you dive into sort of more military
- 4:16analysis, you start to see things like this.
- 4:18You'll start to see effectively, if you're not
- 4:20looking at my screen, where Indonesia, even though
- 4:23it's got a much smaller military budget, has
- 4:25like 400 ,000 personnel in its active service.
- 4:28Whereas Australia's only got about 58 and Uzbekistan's
- 4:30only got about 48 and then it gets bigger once
- 4:32you put paramilitary in. But that doesn't make
- 4:36sense comparing what we just talked about, which
- 4:38is military budgets being, you know, Australia
- 4:40being the much largest one. And then again, it
- 4:43changes again when you start looking at things
- 4:45like tanks per person, you know, as an example,
- 4:49Uzbekistan actually has effectively 73 personnel
- 4:52for every tank, whereas Australia has about 481
- 4:55and Indonesia's got about 2 ,900 people per tank,
- 4:59which is a little off on the ratios. So even
- 5:03when you look at military budgets, it's hard
- 5:05to quantify how much that translates to, I guess,
- 5:10the ability of that military and what it needs
- 5:12to do. There's quite a lot of reasons for that.
- 5:15We're also, if we look at the percentage of the
- 5:19active force in each military, whilst Uzbekistan
- 5:23and Indonesia have most of their military, 75
- 5:25% nearly, put towards, let's call it the active
- 5:30ground forces. I'm only talking about the actual
- 5:31military here. The Indonesians have very little
- 5:35within their air force and the Uzbeks, understandably,
- 5:38have much less within their navy or naval forces.
- 5:41Again, because militaries are kind of made for
- 5:43purpose. And this is why it's really difficult
- 5:45to quantify exact numbers on what a military
- 5:48is capable of. Australia, it's built its entire
- 5:52military around doing a few really quite niche
- 5:55tasks. We are pretty good at going out and putting
- 5:58a battalion somewhere in the South Pacific or
- 6:00in the South China Sea, holding that ground.
- 6:03When we insert places, we're pretty good and
- 6:05we have a lot of equipment and technology with
- 6:07us. But if you were to ask Australia to plonk
- 6:10on a field or you were to ask Australia to run
- 6:13a long mountain warfare campaign, we might not
- 6:16be very good in that. Indonesia, if you look
- 6:18at that as a military effectively is much, you
- 6:21know, it doesn't have the kind of air force that
- 6:23a lot of other countries have. It doesn't have
- 6:25the massive, uh, tank forces, you know, that
- 6:29less even as Bekistan has, which is a much smaller
- 6:31GDP and budget. But again, it's designed as a
- 6:34military that can quickly respond anywhere around
- 6:36the country. And again, because it's an archipelago,
- 6:38anywhere across that massive archipelago, very
- 6:41quickly, you know, whether it's crushing riots
- 6:43or responding to a threat. knowing that it will
- 6:46probably be a while before they get resupplied.
- 6:48People design their militaries to deal with the
- 6:51situation they're in. And it's why I really do
- 6:53enjoy looking at militaries because you do get
- 6:55a good look at long -term planning and long -term
- 6:56thinking. For Uzbekistan, I think that is the
- 7:00most obvious out of them. And what I've got on
- 7:02screen for people who are watching, but you can
- 7:05also check it out in the report, is where the
- 7:07major brigade level stuff is in Uzbekistan. What
- 7:09you can see pretty quickly is the Most of your
- 7:12tank units, your kind of real heavy, I'm thinking
- 7:15old kind of Soviet style stuff is right there
- 7:17down the south, right near the border with Afghanistan.
- 7:20They view that as the conventional threat. It's
- 7:23also the approaches that you'd use to go toward
- 7:26Tajikistan, we'll talk a bit about that later.
- 7:28Whereas your rapid response units are often out
- 7:31near the capital, Tashkent, or in the Fagana
- 7:33Valley, partly to do with the fact and when we
- 7:35interviewed lots of Uzbek military officers and
- 7:38personnel. They kept bringing up events in 2005
- 7:41in an incident called Andijan. Effectively, what
- 7:43happened is there was an uprising, a very small
- 7:46uprising at the beginning, who actually managed
- 7:48to take a military base by surprise because they
- 7:50were just not very well coordinated at the time.
- 7:53The success there gave them a bit of a boost.
- 7:56They went on and took a MIA outpost. They went
- 7:58on and took more and more outposts in the town.
- 8:00Eventually, they had taken most of the administrative
- 8:02block in the city and then eventually the military
- 8:05comes back and roars back into town a few days
- 8:07later and thousands will die afterwards. There
- 8:11is a huge reaction to that following the 2005
- 8:14events that Uzbekistan has decided that one of
- 8:16its major priorities right now is to make sure
- 8:19it can quickly respond to things. And it's something
- 8:21that doesn't matter how high or low through the
- 8:24military, you keep hearing this, had we been
- 8:26able to respond quickly while there's 30 people,
- 8:29well, less people would have died, which I see
- 8:31the... very morbid logic behind it, but it's
- 8:33interesting. Again, this is a military that's
- 8:36built for quickly responding to crises. The conventional
- 8:39stuff's down toward the border with Afghanistan,
- 8:42because it's obviously a slight conventional
- 8:43threat. And most of your rocket or heavy artillery
- 8:47stuff is actually near the center of the country,
- 8:49which means you can effectively pivot at where
- 8:51it needs to go. And again, these are logical
- 8:53decisions that kind of make sense. When we look
- 8:55at kind of Uzbekistan, I guess, in the context
- 8:58of the five Central Asian republics, that being
- 8:59Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan,
- 9:01Turkmenistan, almost every graph you are going
- 9:04to look like, you know, is effectively going
- 9:06to look a little bit like this, but on screen,
- 9:08imagine you're at a one to 10, 10 being the best,
- 9:11one being the worst, Kazakhstan is always going
- 9:13to be kind of a 10, Uzbekistan is usually going
- 9:15to be, let's call it an eight or a nine, Turkmenistan
- 9:18would be about a four or a five, and then Kyrgyzstan,
- 9:21Tajikistan are going to be down in the ones and
- 9:22twos. Not saying they're bad, but just I'm trying
- 9:25to make it as easy as possible. This here is
- 9:28military spending. And again, that tracks. We
- 9:30saw that GDP matches military spending, except
- 9:33in Central Asia's case where, whilst Uzbekistan
- 9:36tends to spend much more than you'd expect as
- 9:39a share of regional military spending, Kazakhstan
- 9:42tends to spend much less. But it's also because
- 9:44Kazakhstan is so much richer than the other states
- 9:46that it can effectively afford to spend 1 % of
- 9:49GDP or a bit above. and still be the dominant
- 9:52player effectively. Whereas Uzbekistan is traditionally
- 9:56spent toward the 4 % mark and starts to dip back
- 9:59down toward two as things start to stabilize.
- 10:01But again, I think military, even if we're looking
- 10:03for a way of quantifying things, military spending
- 10:06doesn't even do that either. Because not only
- 10:08does it get a bit wonky when you start getting
- 10:11to purchasing power, it's obviously cheaper to
- 10:13keep the Russians armed and sort of in the field
- 10:16because they spend less per soldier than it would
- 10:18be, let's say, compared to the Americans. But
- 10:21at the same time, you also have what gets included
- 10:23in that. Military research, for instance, gets
- 10:26included quite often within the US DOD budget,
- 10:29but in China that often doesn't. It's a separate
- 10:31budget. And that starts to make things really
- 10:33wonky. Again, we have what was Bekistan with
- 10:36quite a large military and is the largest by
- 10:40numbers, but does that mean they actually have
- 10:42the best military? I'd argue probably not, particularly
- 10:45when we start to look at things like paramilitary.
- 10:47So these are... If people who really know what
- 10:51they're looking at, let's call MIA forces. Effectively,
- 10:53they're not going to have the heavy artillery,
- 10:55they're not going to have the heavy tanks. They're
- 10:57mostly designed for internal operations. They're
- 10:59better trained at riot control, better shields,
- 11:02that kind of stuff compared to your standard
- 11:06military. And Uzbekistan actually has the lowest
- 11:09out of the five Central Asian Republics ratio
- 11:11of paramilitary to military. In other words,
- 11:13if you combine that number together, 63 % sit
- 11:17within the conventional military. with 36 % sitting
- 11:20within border forces, MIA forces, emergency services
- 11:23forces, which means they have quite a heavy,
- 11:28still somewhat Soviet military sitting at the
- 11:30core of this. And that's a big problem because
- 11:32when you have a massive numbers military, it
- 11:35does help with unemployment. It does help with
- 11:39a whole bunch of other factors, but it also really
- 11:41hurts your ability to... So if you spend money,
- 11:46because you're spending way too much money on
- 11:48wages and pensions. If we go back to nominal
- 11:50GDP, this is what I was talking about, where
- 11:52even though Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan are somewhat
- 11:55similar military power wise, the GDP by Kazakhstan
- 12:00is just so much higher in the region and growing
- 12:01at a much higher rate. And there's a whole bunch
- 12:03of reasons for that. Even if we look at, as you
- 12:06can see from the pie chart, but for people, Kazakhstan
- 12:08alone makes up about 60 % or 57%. of the entire
- 12:13region's GDP. So it's not unusual to expect that
- 12:15they would be the core military power, even though
- 12:18they haven't got the largest military in the
- 12:20region and have got less tanks or whatnot. Part
- 12:24of the other thing you want to look at when assessing
- 12:26military capabilities is who their suppliers
- 12:28are and how over -reliant they are. And I guess
- 12:31you'd almost on a scale of things, look to someone
- 12:35like Uzbekistan on nearly one end of the scale
- 12:37where Russia or the USSR supplied let's call
- 12:40it 85 -ish percent of all of their equipment.
- 12:44And I guess this is an interesting one for me,
- 12:46I guess. It's almost a drinking game for Central
- 12:48Asia analysts. We see all these headlines coming
- 12:50out of Turkey selling this or China selling this.
- 12:54And that's true, but it still doesn't make up
- 12:57anyone near the maturity of what they use. And
- 13:00part of this is just simple economics. For Uzbekistan,
- 13:04if let's say you're the defense commander and
- 13:05you went, hey, what are we going to do about
- 13:06tanks? And they go, well, we could buy an American
- 13:08tank for $8 million, but we need new mechanics.
- 13:12It's going to cost $8 million. We need new manuals.
- 13:14We're going to train the guys and we could get
- 13:16sanctioned. If we have problems with Americans,
- 13:19we need to buy new gearboxes and yada yada. If
- 13:22you go with the Russians though, you can probably
- 13:23spend 20, $30 ,000 on a modernization kit, slap
- 13:26it in and call it a day. So you do find that
- 13:29if they don't need to spend the capital, they
- 13:31tend to just slap modernization kits and new
- 13:33coats of paint on Russian equipment, which is
- 13:35why Russia is still pretty dominant for the kind
- 13:37of basics and consumables. That changed a little
- 13:39bit over 2020 through 2023, as Russia effectively
- 13:43diverted more of its industry toward the war
- 13:45effort and, you know, what was left for the export
- 13:47market was competed for by India and whatnot.
- 13:50But, you know, it was back in time really just
- 13:52starting to roll back and Russia is taking a
- 13:53bigger part in their procurement as we speak.
- 13:56I guess what the interesting thing though is
- 13:59when it isn't a decision between new tank and
- 14:02modernization kit and, you know, equipment versus
- 14:04equipment. that's where the really interesting
- 14:08part is happening. And that's where you ask them
- 14:09to see China and Turkey and a few other places.
- 14:12Because when it comes down to, well, I need to
- 14:13buy a Russian drone or a Turkish drone, they
- 14:17tend to go and not with Russia. They do have
- 14:19some Russian drones. They do have some Russian
- 14:21bits and pieces, but yeah, it is a testament
- 14:23to, we think Russia is pretty good for basic
- 14:27consumer. It's, you know, basic bullets, basic
- 14:30gearboxes. They're not so good for the high tech
- 14:32stuff at the moment. I think they're slightly
- 14:34distracted elsewhere. The other part you want
- 14:37to look at, and I get a lot of people don't include
- 14:39this when they start to look at military power,
- 14:42is the ability to be self -sustainable. If you're
- 14:45Australia, we can kind of keep some of it going
- 14:48ourselves. We're not great for that, but we can.
- 14:50When you're, let's say, the central agents here,
- 14:54almost everything they have is imported in. For
- 14:57Uzbekistan, as a classic example, when they have
- 15:00their planes, which are getting quite old, needing
- 15:03repairs, they can't do anything by basic repairs
- 15:06in their own facilities. They end up sending
- 15:07them off to Belarus or Russia to get that done.
- 15:10Which if you can imagine, let's say you're in
- 15:12a conflict with Tajikistan or one of your other
- 15:15regional players. Do you think Belarus is going
- 15:19to be hop, skip and jump to want to fix your
- 15:21planes? Not really. And you kind of have to take
- 15:23that into account when you're starting to plan
- 15:25and war game out a number of these scenarios.
- 15:28Even you know, something like here, which is
- 15:30the Churchill aircraft repair plant just north
- 15:33of the Capitol, north east of the Capitol. This
- 15:37has been pretty under repaired for a while and
- 15:39is suffering quite badly. And frankly, you know,
- 15:42even though a lot of these States would probably
- 15:44benefit from, you know, combining their money
- 15:46and getting this back up and running like it
- 15:48was during the USSR times, kind of doesn't get
- 15:51that because no state trusts each other enough
- 15:53to do that. Now, and this is again, we'll weigh
- 15:56into military calculations here. And again, this
- 15:58is one of the reasons that I think it's difficult
- 16:00to kind of put a number on, you know, exact number
- 16:03of how powerful a military is. Now, when you're
- 16:06looking at mapping bases, there are a few things
- 16:09you can look for. So actually, I want to kind
- 16:11of, before I get into the mapping stuff, let's
- 16:13go right through this and I'll come back to that.
- 16:15The two things I found really interesting in
- 16:17this study is effectively, no, lots of things
- 16:20I found interesting, but one of the most interesting
- 16:22things is looking at purpose -built. So as part
- 16:25of this, we ran a bunch of war games, getting
- 16:28a bunch of military and security experts in and
- 16:29sat down and worked out how each guy would respond,
- 16:32what the situation is, what they're capable of,
- 16:34and effectively what the outcomes are likely
- 16:36to be. Now, the two we ran for the Uzbek chapter,
- 16:40where one was an ISKP, so Islamic State Khorasan
- 16:43Province, effectively gathering up on the Afghan
- 16:46side of the river and launching a, using kind
- 16:49of rubber boats and dinghies, an attack into
- 16:50the southern city of Termez where the Uzbek -Afghan
- 16:53friendship bridges. Now, this was so difficult
- 16:57for the ISKP team that we actually need to give
- 17:01them an absurd amount of concessions to even
- 17:04get them off the ground. We need to say that
- 17:07there was no riverine patrols that night. There
- 17:09were no surveillance that night. People were
- 17:12asleep when they weren't watching at the watchtowers.
- 17:15They took the massive base just over the bridge
- 17:18here. by surprise and pretty much everyone surrendered
- 17:22immediately. All stuff that even in the start
- 17:24of the chat we get is absurd and not going to
- 17:26happen because every other time we didn't give
- 17:28these concessions, the enemy forces would kind
- 17:31of build up on the other side of the river and
- 17:32be immediately eliminated. And it just shows
- 17:35you that if Bekazdan has thought about this,
- 17:37Bekazdan knows this is a threat and has built
- 17:39up so much in the way of defensive materials
- 17:43and force down here that it's really good at
- 17:46doing that. They pretty quickly pushed the ISKP
- 17:50forces back. And even in this absurd scenario
- 17:53where they get a lot further than they would
- 17:55in reality, the whole thing ends in, I think
- 17:58it's about 24 or 36 hours. They're meant to do
- 18:01that. Then we ran another scenario. And this
- 18:04is what I think surprised a lot more people is
- 18:06an Uzbek invasion of Tajikistan. Now, Uzbekistan
- 18:09being the largest military in Central Asia, Tajikistan
- 18:11being the smallest. Particularly with the fact
- 18:13that the Tajik capital is only 40km away from
- 18:16the Uzbek border, you'd think, well, this is
- 18:18an easy fight, Uzbekistan should win this, not
- 18:20a problem. And we're modeling off effectively
- 18:25water disputes. They decide that they want to
- 18:28go for an invasion and take the northern capital
- 18:31of Khujand and Dushanbe at once. Again, they've
- 18:35got a massive military, it is in the realm of
- 18:37possibility. But immediately logistics becomes
- 18:39just so much of a problem. You are effectively
- 18:43marching your troops over long distances with
- 18:46very little in the way of ability to keep them
- 18:48supplied. And whilst we kind of had to give them
- 18:52an artificial parameter as well, saying that
- 18:54the Russians wouldn't fire on them if their Russians
- 18:56weren't fired on first. And the Uzbeks were able
- 18:59to build up prior to the invasion completely
- 19:04by surprise, which again, I think is not possible.
- 19:08Day one goes fairly well as expected, Uzbekistan
- 19:11can pack a real punch on day one. They can even
- 19:14get in the north in better punch and they can
- 19:17really kind of get right to the outskirts of
- 19:18the major city. On the southern front, Dushanbe,
- 19:21the capital of Tajikistan, they can get right
- 19:23to the edge. But once you start getting into
- 19:26your day seven -ish of the scenario, things really
- 19:30go badly. Where A, the Uzbeks aren't trained
- 19:33to do urban warfare very much anymore. It's not
- 19:37really what they're aiming to do. B, the logistics
- 19:40are just not there. They don't have the mobile
- 19:41refueling stations. They don't have the logistics
- 19:43trucks. They don't have the communications staff
- 19:47and the dedicated communications and logistics
- 19:49units. Their stuff is still coming from hundreds
- 19:52of kilometers away in Termez at this point. They
- 19:54don't have the suitable railway units to get
- 19:57this all up and running. And you end up having
- 20:00this situation where they just end up losing
- 20:03way too many men. trying to fight this urban
- 20:06campaign without trying to maneuver themselves
- 20:10away from the Russians as well. So the end result
- 20:14is effectively that the Uzbeks almost inevitably,
- 20:16because their top priority will be to make sure
- 20:18the administration remains stable, is they pull
- 20:20back. They go, it's not worth our time. Let's
- 20:24pull back. And that's a pretty bad scenario.
- 20:26If you've gone in, you lost 20 ,000, you're probably
- 20:29less than that. You've lost, I think it's about
- 20:308 ,000 personnel. And you've gained effectively
- 20:33little to nothing. So it ends up being a pretty
- 20:37disastrous scenario for the Uzbeks. And again,
- 20:39a lot of people would take that away and say,
- 20:41well, obviously the Uzbek military is a weak
- 20:43military and on paper, their score is higher
- 20:46than the Tajiks. They should have won this. But
- 20:48it's just because they're not really designed
- 20:49to do that. You know, this is a military that
- 20:52is mostly designed to respond quickly to internal
- 20:55uprisings or pressures, respond to border skirmishes
- 20:58where the Olympics are really good. If it's a
- 21:00short, sharp campaign, they're really good at
- 21:02that. But if it's a prolonged logistics heavy
- 21:05campaign, not really. And again, it comes down
- 21:09to that kind of what we talked about earlier
- 21:10with the tanks. If you're a defense commander
- 21:11and you say, you know, sir, what should we buy?
- 21:13Should we buy all the stuff we need to go invade
- 21:15Tajikistan? Well, probably not. If you're not
- 21:18thinking you're going to be doing that, you put
- 21:20that money towards communications equipment and
- 21:22pensions and everything else you need to. And
- 21:25again, that can give me a bit more easy sleep
- 21:29at night knowing that none of these militaries
- 21:31are really preparing or even halfway prepared
- 21:33to launch massive invasions of the other. So
- 21:37if you're trying to measure military power, I
- 21:39guess, which was the kind of prompt here. I don't
- 21:41know if you can, you can kind of rank things
- 21:45first to fifth in this region, but only because
- 21:47it's so blindingly obvious in order they're going
- 21:51to go in on almost every single metric. But that
- 21:54doesn't mean you can actually expect easy victories
- 21:58because their numbers are higher. Tajikistan,
- 22:01when we wargamed their invasion of Kyrgyzstan
- 22:03went really badly and they ended up pulling back
- 22:05on I think day 10 or something. Kyrgyzstan and
- 22:09Venetian Tajikistan, higher number, still can't
- 22:11get past even the first, you know, can get past
- 22:13the first major city, but can't make it further.
- 22:16You know, this is the trouble we're trying to
- 22:18rank military power, I guess. So I'm going to
- 22:21obviously turn it back to Charlie and she's going
- 22:24to have some questions. But yeah, to, I guess,
- 22:27be an overall summary is it's very, very difficult
- 22:30to put hard numbers on things. Yeah. And I haven't
- 22:33mentioned railroads yet. I'm sure someone will
- 22:35point that out, but Lots to talk about with the
- 22:37Uzbek chapter here. Yeah. Someone has just mentioned
- 22:42railroads, as you said it. Perhaps we can dive
- 22:45into that in a second. But to start with, I wanted
- 22:47to ask, and maybe this is an obvious question,
- 22:51but this is a lot of research, a lot of data.
- 22:55It's fascinating to see the practicalities of
- 22:58it through your war game scenarios. What were
- 23:01your main sources of data for? this particular
- 23:05Uzbekistan report and how long and how many resources
- 23:09does it take to build a report like this as part
- 23:12of the Armed Forces of Central Asia project?
- 23:15This has effectively been a two year project.
- 23:17It's been massive to put together. And it's been
- 23:21combing through everything from, you know, government
- 23:24reports, you know, through NGO reports, through
- 23:27to weapons inspection reports, through to social
- 23:29media posts. You know, the wonders of social
- 23:32media have made it not only very easy to find
- 23:34certain bases, but also how to gain a lot of
- 23:37context clues on what's there and what's not.
- 23:41When you're trying to find a unit, the amount
- 23:42of units we can't pin to a certain location,
- 23:46all of a sudden we'll find a local primary school
- 23:49did a excursion out to the base and took a bunch
- 23:53of photos from within the base. a random Facebook
- 23:57or Telegram group is just insane. So it's effectively
- 24:01talking with lots and lots of experts, people
- 24:02who know this region quite well, talking with
- 24:05a lot or reading a lot of these reports and piecing
- 24:07together thousands and thousands of points of
- 24:10data to effectively try and have a pretty good
- 24:12data set to run with. And then once you get that,
- 24:14you can start to piece together other pieces.
- 24:16And the fortunate thing is that a lot of these
- 24:18militaries are still somewhat similarly structured
- 24:22and based as what they were during the Soviet
- 24:24era, which does give you a baseline to start
- 24:26with. But generally, yes, it's just been, it's
- 24:28been two years of an entire research team kind
- 24:31of putting, pulling together a huge amount of
- 24:33data points. And how difficult is it to map kind
- 24:37of independent power? Like how much influence,
- 24:40for example, do foreign allies have on military
- 24:43power in central Asia? You mentioned some of
- 24:46Russia's influence. Yeah. How does that come
- 24:51into play when you're looking at writing a report
- 24:54on an individual country's power? This is some
- 24:59of the most difficult and I think, you know,
- 25:00it happens to everyone all the time where I think
- 25:03everyone has different, you know, we all do our
- 25:06math and everyone will do different scores and
- 25:07everyone will kind of have a different approach
- 25:09on this, but it's what we weight differently
- 25:11I think that has, is where people tend to differ.
- 25:14you know, I found particularly working with different
- 25:16members of the team is that whilst I tend to
- 25:18put a lot more weight on logistics and economics
- 25:20to drive things, then other team members tend
- 25:22to think more about cultural dynamics and tend
- 25:25to think more about, you know, how the industry
- 25:28will work or various different factors that do
- 25:31drive their kind of what is important and what's
- 25:32not. When it comes to, I guess, the Russia question,
- 25:36Russia is definitely the kind of the military
- 25:40power in the region. And I think it's weird to
- 25:43say, because when you go to the region, Russia
- 25:45is culturally losing a bit of a step. You know,
- 25:49it's only been in the last couple of years, I've
- 25:50gone, you know, flown into these countries and
- 25:52I've spoken Russian to them. And I get back,
- 25:55hey, we speak Uzbek here. I go, yeah, well, I'm
- 25:57sorry. You know, my bad. This is the cultural
- 26:03shift. But when it comes to the military and
- 26:04security services, a lot of those guys were trained
- 26:06in Russia. They're still very friendly with Russia.
- 26:09All their manuals are often in Russian, particularly
- 26:12with the very Zinni command. Their primary language
- 26:15might even be Russian. It's also a interesting
- 26:20kind of tidbit is when you do a lot of training
- 26:22exercises that as much as China is starting to
- 26:24come back in and do a little bit more, the soldiers
- 26:27distrust the Chinese a fair bit and they don't
- 26:30drink with them. They don't have as much fraternization
- 26:32with them, particularly at the sort of NCO level
- 26:34and above. So Russia is... Yeah, still very much
- 26:39the supply power and the guy supplying the majority
- 26:41of the military equipment here, but also is still
- 26:44kind of the influencer when it comes to the higher
- 26:46ends of security and military forces and probably
- 26:49will be for at least the next 20 years or until
- 26:51that generation of the guys that are kind of
- 26:53coming into the service now reach the top levels
- 26:56of power, which again, it's a bit of a delay.
- 26:59Yeah. So the other one you're talking about is
- 27:00how you can measure what power is in a base.
- 27:03So I got a few examples and obviously I have
- 27:05to describe the people listening, but you know,
- 27:08when you look at bigger basis, you, this, you
- 27:10know, it's a kind of a concept of when you have
- 27:13a really small business to give an example, a
- 27:15bit of an analogy here, if it's just you and
- 27:17one of the guy, that's what you need. But the
- 27:19moment you get to kind of 10 people, well, now
- 27:20you're kind of need an accountant. And then once
- 27:22you get to 50 people, you probably need a HR
- 27:24person. You need an office manager and, you know,
- 27:27you just kind of need all these extra supplementary
- 27:28things. The bigger the base gets or bigger the
- 27:31company gets in our analogy. You know, I'm looking
- 27:33at a screen here, but this is quite a large base.
- 27:35This is out in Samui in Kazakhstan. And once
- 27:38you get to a base of this size, you start to
- 27:40need additional motor pools. You start to need
- 27:43probably dedicated communications units. You
- 27:45start to need a dedicated explosive storage warehouse.
- 27:48It's just outside of town. Those are kind of
- 27:51things that you don't need for the smaller basis.
- 27:53So, you know, if we go to these, some of the
- 27:56smaller ones, let's call a brigade size. Yes,
- 27:59they do have large motor pools because they have
- 28:01to keep the vehicles somewhere. They do have
- 28:03dedicated barracks because of the people living
- 28:04there and you can get a good idea on how many
- 28:06people tend to live there. They do have usually
- 28:08the parade grounds, which are quite common across
- 28:10these guys, but they don't have the kind of massive
- 28:14fuel and explosives dumps that you see in much
- 28:17of the larger base. So, it's probably going to
- 28:19be smaller and less capable. If we look at, let's
- 28:22say, going down another rung to border outposts,
- 28:27you know, the one on the right for people who
- 28:29have the visual here is actually the Chinese
- 28:31base in Tajikistan. And as much as people have
- 28:34made a massive deal about it over the years,
- 28:36when you actually look at particularly the construction
- 28:38photos when it was originally built, you know,
- 28:41there's not a massive supplies of fuel here.
- 28:45There's not massive supplies of vehicles here
- 28:46either, even on the surface. And it just shows
- 28:50that whilst yes, it's a, you know, an important
- 28:53data point to take into account. This is not
- 28:55a base you'd launch a massive invasion with.
- 28:57This is effectively a base you use to long -term
- 29:00guard a road. And so if they don't have the ability
- 29:03to kind of sustain operations by themselves in
- 29:06a good way for a long time, it gives you an idea
- 29:08on what their base's purpose is probably going
- 29:10to be. But yeah, I'll take another question before
- 29:12I ramble too much. I guess this is a good point
- 29:17as well to mention, re -mention the map that
- 29:21you have got going that tracks kind of military
- 29:24vases. Please do have a check that out. I have
- 29:28put it in the chat, but it will also be in the
- 29:33podcast description as well as all of these links.
- 29:36And it's on screen for those in the audience
- 29:38now. Michael, quickly, do you want to just quickly
- 29:42do an overview of this? I've also got somebody
- 29:46who worked on the project who would like to jump
- 29:48in, Mitchell Polman. They've asked if they could
- 29:51join the stage as well to help. So perhaps while
- 29:53you're talking through the map, I can invite
- 29:55them on and they can chat a little bit as well,
- 29:59if that's okay with you. Sure, go ahead. Yeah,
- 30:03obviously the map I'm looking at at the moment
- 30:05is got a little more data than the public versions
- 30:09of these maps that we sell. But the map here,
- 30:12you can see that Uzbekistan I think has got about
- 30:151400 pins by itself. Effectively, what we've
- 30:19done is tried to sort it into different categories
- 30:21so you get a bit of a snapshot. As you can probably
- 30:23see here, let's take it down to the larger units,
- 30:27which are brigade and above. Again, for anyone
- 30:29military and security oriented in the audience,
- 30:33I'm going to use brigade and massive air quotes
- 30:35for this region of the world. Effectively, the
- 30:40idea of the map is that you have this central
- 30:42resource that you can effectively go... Oh, I
- 30:44wonder what's in, actually, let's go to Termez
- 30:46because we were talking about Termez as an example
- 30:48earlier on. And I can just turn on a bunch of
- 30:50pins and I have a really good idea of what is
- 30:53in the city and where everything is. Because
- 30:57for playing our war games, it's really useful
- 30:59to know where everything is, but also generally
- 31:01it's just good to know the capabilities of each
- 31:04garrison. For instance, here, you can see up
- 31:06here in the north of the city is where the air
- 31:08defense batteries are and all the radar batteries
- 31:11that are effectively monitoring the south here.
- 31:14You know, here's the naval port. You can see
- 31:16there was a green pin. It's part of the riverine
- 31:19flotillas. And it's just, it's just pouring together
- 31:23oodles and oodles and oodles of data. I mean,
- 31:25Mitch, you were working on this project as well.
- 31:27I mean, you can attest on just the sheer quantity
- 31:31of data you have to kind of pull together for
- 31:33a map like this. Oh yes. Can you hear me? Loud
- 31:36and clear, far away. Okay. Yeah. You've pretty
- 31:42much got it covered, Michael. I just wanted to
- 31:44say that it was actually surprisingly easy to
- 31:50track down some of this information. It wasn't
- 31:55all that long ago that Uzbekistan was being referred
- 31:58to as the North Korea of Central Asia, and I
- 32:02was a little surprised. You could actually even
- 32:05find addresses and street addresses and telephone
- 32:09numbers of military units in the equivalent of
- 32:14an Uzbekistan phone book. It's right there online.
- 32:18It's all in Uzbek, of course, but it's there.
- 32:22Sometimes they even list, you know, the individual
- 32:26units that are at a military base. So it was
- 32:32kind of surprisingly easy. I'd say that it was
- 32:35easy for some of them. In the early stage of
- 32:37the project, there was the low hanging fruits,
- 32:40other guys in the phone books. But when it comes
- 32:42to more sensitive areas, particularly when it
- 32:45comes to things like air defense batteries, that's
- 32:47where things get much more difficult. Unlike
- 32:50the Russians tend to be a little more consistent
- 32:52with their military unit numbering, the Central
- 32:55Asians are really scattershot with it. Yeah,
- 32:58I was going to say that was sort of the bigger
- 32:59challenge was the numbers. And names of units
- 33:04changed all the time and keeping track of who
- 33:08was where and what was who was a bit of a challenge
- 33:11for us, I think. Yeah. I mean, this is part of
- 33:15the project is obviously putting together massive
- 33:18data piles, which is far beyond what goes in
- 33:21the public version of these, of effectively everything
- 33:24we know about, let's say, you know, 11506. And
- 33:26it will be, hey, here's three reports we have
- 33:29that talk about it. Here is, you know, photos
- 33:31of the base that have been taken from a couple
- 33:33of YouTube videos that we've got. And, you know,
- 33:36here's the size of the motor pools, which should
- 33:38indicate that there's this many things here,
- 33:40you know, putting all that together and effectively
- 33:43trying to build a bit of a concept of what's
- 33:46there and what they have capable. Again, I also
- 33:49used, really odd at times. Sorry. I also used,
- 33:55there were online, Uzbek military journals, newspapers
- 33:59that are online and going through them, you could
- 34:03oftentimes find, you know, good information or
- 34:07at least clues. You know, even photos sometimes
- 34:11of, you know, that went to unit locations and
- 34:15things of that nature. And again, a lot of the
- 34:18time you have to just build these massive data
- 34:20piles and dumps because you're trying to piece
- 34:22together multiple different parts of information.
- 34:24You know, you know, There's a commander who is
- 34:26from this base. You know, he's done a news interview
- 34:29at this facility, which you can geolocate to
- 34:31here. You don't know what branch he's on, but
- 34:33then you find a different report, you know, which
- 34:36effectively shows that commander not at that
- 34:40base, but the patch he's wearing would indicate
- 34:41he's from this unit. And you just have to have
- 34:43all these links together to kind of combine a
- 34:45little data later on. You know, sometimes it
- 34:46can be that difficult. Other times it can be
- 34:48even more difficult. Other times I remember looking
- 34:51at some drone footage coming out of, I think
- 34:53it was Uzbekistan. It was Uzbekistan. I'm trying
- 34:55to figure out where is this drone footage from
- 34:57and you're sitting down with a cup of tea thinking
- 34:58you have to geolocate it and then pull down the
- 35:00file name and it had Fagana Airport written in
- 35:02it. So sometimes it does get a little easier
- 35:07than others. But I think we'll take more questions
- 35:09because we've got quite a lot of questions coming
- 35:11through. Yes, thank you. ever be professional.
- 35:15Michael, thank you. And thank you, Mitch, for
- 35:17jumping on and giving us some insight into the
- 35:20open source research that you were doing there.
- 35:22Just a little PSA, obviously, this is the Bellingcat
- 35:25community, so we have to be careful. If you are
- 35:28working with personal data, please be careful,
- 35:31particularly when it involves militaries and
- 35:34make sure you follow procedures. But thank you
- 35:36so much, Mitch, for coming on and chatting. I've
- 35:40got a bunch more questions to throw at Michael,
- 35:42though, if that's all right. So, so many. I wanted
- 35:45to start at the top because some people have
- 35:48been waiting a while. Fade asks, how do you see
- 35:52the advent of commercial drones, which you've
- 35:54just mentioned, in warfare improving slash hindering
- 35:57logistics in the future? Could hex copters be
- 36:00used to supply at the unit level? So that's a
- 36:04really great question and it's the million dollar
- 36:06question I get asked more than anything else
- 36:07about this region. Drones can hinder and hurt
- 36:11and it really depends on what kind of a drone
- 36:13it is and what it can do. Again, people kind
- 36:15of think drones and I think they tend to think
- 36:19of the kind of bi -racked RTB -2 stuff when a
- 36:22lot of drones are mostly just there to either
- 36:24be a exploding munition or they're there just
- 36:27to do reconnaissance. And if let's say, I am,
- 36:31you know, pull up and barb talk, I'm going to
- 36:33pull up and move up to Dushan, but if I'm, let's
- 36:36say monitoring that single road we have to go
- 36:39on to kind of approach the capital, you know,
- 36:41having drones Uh, monitoring that area is going
- 36:43to be great. It means I can effectively keep
- 36:45a close eye on what's coming through. And I know
- 36:48that, Hey, you know, there's three tanks that
- 36:50have just come through this area, but also there's
- 36:52eight fuel trucks and you can attack much more
- 36:55easily into the, in this, the soft targets. And
- 36:57again, it comes down to that classic problem
- 36:59of a tank without fuel is just a really weird
- 37:01car. Um, you know, If you, if you can attack
- 37:06the logistics and the soft points, it makes any
- 37:08war scenario much more difficult. And this is
- 37:10in our war gaming of sort of a Tajik invasion.
- 37:13The Uzbek team had massive problems with effectively
- 37:15the Tajiks just sitting in the foothills launching,
- 37:18you know, lots of small kind of needling drone
- 37:21attacks in the logistics line because it is a
- 37:25really narrow choke point to get toward the capital.
- 37:29When sort of hex copters, hex copters are great
- 37:31for reconnaissance. They're good for munitions,
- 37:33but when you're trying to supply a front, you
- 37:38were talking massive quantities between tonnage
- 37:41most of the time, because soldiers just burn
- 37:43through lots and lots and lots of equipment.
- 37:45And particularly once you start to get the bigger
- 37:47unit levels, you know, whether it be everything
- 37:48from medical supplies to blood, to ammunition,
- 37:51to fuel, to food, to, you know, whatever you
- 37:54need, that's probably too difficult to try and
- 37:56do by Higgs Copter at the moment. So at this
- 37:59point, it's making it much more difficult and
- 38:02you have to spend a lot more of your resources
- 38:03and troops protecting your rear areas. But drones
- 38:08are evolving at a pretty rapid pace. So I'm never
- 38:10going to say never. Okay, coming in quick and
- 38:14fast. Silverknife, one of our lovely moderators,
- 38:18asked earlier about significant shifts. You mentioned
- 38:22at the beginning, I mentioned at the beginning
- 38:25as well, that Uzbekistan was seen as this big
- 38:28military power, but Kazakhstan on paper, to a
- 38:32point, has kind of overtaken that. Have you seen
- 38:35any significant shifts in structure, deployment
- 38:38and composition as you've been going through
- 38:40these reports? Absolutely. And I think this is
- 38:43the really fascinating part of these militaries
- 38:44is whilst they all kind of imagine you're looking
- 38:48at a bunch of cakes. everyone's kind of got the
- 38:51same sponge cake. They're all somewhat similar
- 38:53inheritance from the Soviet Union, but where
- 38:56they've changed the flavoring tells you a massive
- 38:58amount about what their priorities are and how
- 39:00they want to structure things. Uzbekistan has,
- 39:03let's say, its ground forces and its air and
- 39:05air defense forces under the ministry of defense,
- 39:07very standard to everyone else. Its internal
- 39:10troops under the MIA, pretty much like everyone
- 39:11else, and its emergency services get a separate
- 39:14department, which is like everyone else except
- 39:16Turkmenistan. But then you have things like the
- 39:19the National Guard and the Presidential Security
- 39:22Service, which are fairly new. It was under the
- 39:25previous leader, Kareemov, who effectively ran
- 39:28the country almost as close as North Korea, who
- 39:32had so much power concentrated in what would
- 39:35have been the KGB back in the day, the State
- 39:38Security Service or SGB back then. The State
- 39:42Security Service at that point controlled the
- 39:44Frontier Service, which is the border guards,
- 39:46the internal troops, a big chunk of the Special
- 39:49Forces, the National Guard and the Presidential
- 39:51Security Service. But now that Karimov has died
- 39:55and the head of the SGB at the time, Ian Lotov
- 39:57has been moved on. A lot of the powers have been
- 40:01ripped out from that agency and distributed to
- 40:03other agencies. And I think watching which agencies
- 40:07get extra resources and which ones don't give
- 40:09you a really good insight into the kind of the
- 40:11internal power dynamics going on. That as an
- 40:14example, the National Guard, which was originally
- 40:17part of the security agencies, originally was
- 40:20kind of, was going to go to the Ministry of Defense.
- 40:23And then it was a bit, do I trust the Ministry
- 40:24of Defense? So it became a separate unit and
- 40:27was given, you know, would protect the president
- 40:29at one point. And then all of a sudden, had the
- 40:32president ripped out the president's security
- 40:34service from the national guard and made an own
- 40:36separate unit that can investigate anyone as
- 40:39well. So it's those kinds of changes that seem
- 40:42quite subtle and an administrative on paper,
- 40:44but you know, actually tell you quite a lot of
- 40:45what's going on behind the scenes. Yeah, let's
- 40:49go to the next question. Yeah, that answers your
- 40:51question. Absolutely. Just with that in mind,
- 40:55have you tried to address the temporal? dimension
- 40:59with these projects, because obviously the reports
- 41:02themselves are PDF documents, which kind of sets
- 41:05it in tone. Is that kind of where the military
- 41:08unit map comes into play? Where is that going
- 41:10to be updated live? Have you thought about the
- 41:14kind of time sensitive nature of a lot of this
- 41:17information? Yeah, so for our paid version of
- 41:22this effectively, you know, when a event happens.
- 41:26So like, for instance, there was just a shootout
- 41:28on the border between Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan.
- 41:32We can identify that pin quickly and kind of
- 41:34pin the story there and say, Hey, look, this
- 41:35is what happened. This is the pin you're looking
- 41:36for. This is the result of that. But at the same
- 41:39time, I also wanted a version, a public version
- 41:42of this, which doesn't give everything, but does
- 41:44allow, particularly for the OSING community,
- 41:47rather than spending a million years like I have
- 41:49and just staring at mountains of bitumen. um,
- 41:53you know, you can quickly identify which bases,
- 41:55which, and know where the pinch points are going
- 41:57to be. Uh, so yeah, we will be updating, uh,
- 42:01as we learn new locations, as things change,
- 42:02as things open up, I'll keep adding them to the
- 42:05both map, both the public and private. Uh, but
- 42:07also, you know, right now, obviously we've done
- 42:09all the mapping for all five countries, but as
- 42:11each chapter comes out, we will be releasing
- 42:13that country's pins as well. So the next one
- 42:15out is Kyrgyzstan. So that should be exciting.
- 42:20Amazing. And I think someone's in the chat already
- 42:22put the purchase link in there, which is awesome.
- 42:26Thank you for sharing that. We've had quite a
- 42:29few questions on how you overcome deceptions
- 42:34and what are the key characteristics of deceptions
- 42:38usually seen in Central Asia. We also had a follow
- 42:43up question on that in terms of have we seen
- 42:45any interesting evidence of these powers making
- 42:47efforts to insulate themselves against Chinese
- 42:49espionage as well as we're talking about hidden
- 42:52details. I mean, Chinese espionage is a great
- 42:56question. And I think Tajikistan is the one you
- 42:58probably talk about more for China. There was
- 43:01a few years ago, about almost a decade ago now,
- 43:03I'll show you the whole thing. China effectively
- 43:07announced this base out here, the PAP facility,
- 43:09which is technically not a military because people
- 43:12are on police, but we're going to get into that
- 43:14another time. And everyone thought that was kind
- 43:16of going to be China's first step into the region
- 43:18to be a military player in the same way the Russians
- 43:21have, because Russia has quite large military
- 43:24deployments out here. In fact, the largest military
- 43:26base outside of Russia is in Tajikistan, apart
- 43:30from what's in Ukraine at the moment, but that's
- 43:32a whole other thing. The Chinese though, At the
- 43:35same time, we're dealing with problems in Gwadar
- 43:37in the south of Pakistan, where effectively what
- 43:39was happening is they put more personnel in to
- 43:41run the port. Those personnel would come under
- 43:43attack because the locals would take jobs or
- 43:45for a whole myriad of reasons. And then they
- 43:47put more security personnel in to protect those
- 43:49personnel to which that would just exacerbate
- 43:51the problem and you end up having a terrible
- 43:52cycle. So what's happened is the Chinese have
- 43:55looked at the headaches they've got in Pakistan
- 43:57and then looked at Tajikistan and said, I don't
- 43:59want any of that. I'm just going to throw money
- 44:00at you. I will pay you Tajikistan to just put
- 44:04on extra border outposts, build extra border
- 44:06facilities, put on extra border guards because
- 44:08I don't want to deal with this headache. And
- 44:11whilst that has somewhat solved a small problem
- 44:13for China, it also creates other problems. So
- 44:15that for instance, Tajikistan has incentives
- 44:19to somewhat exaggerate border problems at times.
- 44:24Where looking at some of these shootouts that
- 44:26we see reported in the media that Tajikistan
- 44:28talks to China and says, look, look what's happening,
- 44:30we need more money. And then we call locals in
- 44:32the area and we find out it's kind of one farmer
- 44:35who was drunk and trying to shoot some goats.
- 44:38At the same time, you also have problems like
- 44:40what we've seen just in the last couple of weeks
- 44:41in particular, is out in kind of an area called
- 44:44Satagor, which I've put up on the map for people
- 44:47who are watching live. You know, you have effectively
- 44:50a gold mine on the Afghan side, which is funded
- 44:53by China and a gold mine on the Tajik side, which
- 44:56is also funded by China. And because the water
- 44:59keeps getting diverted and other water problems,
- 45:02the two sides are now shooting at each other.
- 45:04But China is also funding security services on
- 45:06both sides. At the same time, China has just
- 45:08built massive border guard training facilities
- 45:11just north of here as well. So China is somewhat,
- 45:16simultaneously, I guess, very involved in almost
- 45:18every angle of the border problems. not in a
- 45:21kind of boots on the ground way that I think
- 45:23people were anticipating or looking for when
- 45:25this issue first came up. So it is a super interesting
- 45:28dynamic when it comes to China trying to deceive
- 45:31them. I mean, they will exchange some information,
- 45:34but depends what they will exchange will depend
- 45:36on what sort of information it is. But there's
- 45:39also just a You know, again, it comes down to
- 45:42that security services problem of, you know,
- 45:43a lot of these spies and a lot of the mid -level
- 45:45officers don't trust the Chinese very much. The
- 45:48whole bunch of reasons, and I do find it interesting
- 45:50when you talk to particularly Tajiks, you know,
- 45:52you kind of ask them questions like, hey, China
- 45:54just built this massive highway for you. That's
- 45:57pretty great. I mean, this is effectively, you
- 45:59know, people were dying on this fire all the
- 46:00time. This has cut your commute time by an hour.
- 46:03How do you feel about it? And the response will
- 46:05often be something like, well, they built a big
- 46:07enough tanks, didn't they? which is just absurd.
- 46:09China's not going to do that, but it just shows
- 46:11you this kind of underlying dynamic that quite
- 46:14often comes up in the region. All of that in
- 46:17mind. And there's some funny comments in the
- 46:20chat right now about China playing both sides.
- 46:25Is there any concern when you're doing these
- 46:29military infrastructure mapping that the information
- 46:33could be misused? How do you deal with... the
- 46:37problem of malicious actors when you're working
- 46:40on these, particularly when you're doing war
- 46:42games and exercises like that. We're very careful
- 46:47in what we do put public and what we don't as
- 46:50well as who we do contract with. It's why you
- 46:52can't just buy the data. You effectively have
- 46:54to be kind of vetted before we, you know, what
- 46:57level of data we see. I mean, if it's just kind
- 46:58of mapping stuff, we're a bit more open about
- 47:00that. But if it's coming down to like how many
- 47:02tanks for each base, that's a much more thorough
- 47:06process. Most of this stuff is going to be particularly
- 47:10in the public realm, not knowing, but it will
- 47:12be fairly easy. It's not going to make a massive
- 47:15difference to any actor. It will for Osinter
- 47:19in keeping tabs on what's going on. And we've
- 47:22also made a decision to keep black sides off
- 47:24this, mostly for my... I have to go to the region
- 47:27every now and again, and I prefer not to spend
- 47:29the rest of my life in this big prism. But yes,
- 47:31we've had obviously lots of conversations about
- 47:34what does get included and what doesn't. And
- 47:36it's why we had to glaze over a bunch of very,
- 47:40very specific details. We had a question earlier
- 47:44about concern saying, should we worry? Do you
- 47:49believe a real invasion is imminent? Dushanbi,
- 47:54for example, that you mentioned earlier. When
- 47:57you're doing these war games scenarios, have
- 47:59you come across any that have been likely or
- 48:04have caused concern? No. So this is an, it's
- 48:08an interesting question. We start pretty much
- 48:10most of the scenarios saying we do not think
- 48:11this is going to happen, but there's two problems.
- 48:15One, when you brief quite often diplomats or
- 48:17non -military people, they often might not understand
- 48:20what you're trying to tell them unless they've
- 48:21got lines on the map, which, you know, having
- 48:23the war games to kind of put them in front of
- 48:24them and go, hey, look, here's what the likely
- 48:26scenario plays out, makes everyone easier to
- 48:28understand. But two, it's also a way of, you
- 48:31know, I feel actually much more comfortable and
- 48:33confident that, you know, this region is relatively
- 48:36stable because of these wargaming. Because A,
- 48:38it just shows that none of these guys are really
- 48:40prepared to fight a long campaign. None of these
- 48:43guys are gearing up for a long campaign and none
- 48:45of them have shown really any interest in preparing
- 48:48for a long -term campaign. And that's probably
- 48:51a good sign. I think almost all these militaries
- 48:54are, you know, imagining that they may end up
- 48:56in a border skirmish or they may end up in a
- 48:57kind of three -day, you know, you go 10 Ks back
- 49:01from the border and I don't think you'd notice,
- 49:03but generally it's been fairly, particularly
- 49:06on a conventional point, you know, campaign averse,
- 49:10which is good to see. That doesn't mean that
- 49:12there is no chance of things going wrong, particularly
- 49:15when it comes to Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan or
- 49:18Afghanistan, Tajikistan, but at least on a sort
- 49:21of massive conventional scale. No, I think that's
- 49:23a lot of things would have to go wrong before
- 49:25we get to that point. So no need to panic everyone.
- 49:30We can all have a deep sigh of relief. I've just
- 49:33put the... Sorry, the other point I will add
- 49:37quickly is they're also all incentivized to not
- 49:41go to war. And this is one of the interesting
- 49:43things that I've seen from both sides is that
- 49:46everyone wants to seem like they're stable because
- 49:47there's more tourism, there's more added advantages.
- 49:50But when I do consulting for particularly energy
- 49:52companies and mineral companies that are looking
- 49:54at Central Asia as an option, the classic story
- 49:57I continue to see is, hey, we're currently mining
- 50:00X or Y in Sahel or in Central Africa. We're looking
- 50:03to diversify. We're looking to move our operations
- 50:05somewhere else. And we're looking at Central
- 50:07Asia because we know that they are more stable,
- 50:10more reasonable. They don't tend to go to war
- 50:12and that I could build a mine. And because of
- 50:16the way that mining works, that quite often you
- 50:17lose money for the first 10 years, but you make
- 50:19a bunch on the back 20, long -term Central Asia
- 50:23looks a lot more stable. And this is where the
- 50:25money is coming from. It is coming into the region.
- 50:27image of stability. So everyone is driven not
- 50:31only in themselves to keep things stable, but
- 50:33also even if let's say when Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan
- 50:35have their border skirmishes, you can guarantee
- 50:39everyone in the region is calling them saying,
- 50:40please shut up. We're trying to be stable here.
- 50:43Can we all just knock it off a bit? So everyone
- 50:46is making significant efforts to try and make
- 50:48sure this region doesn't break out into a war.
- 50:51And Mitchell just backed that up in the chat
- 50:53saying all the nations are very much integrating
- 50:55their economies and settling their border disputes
- 50:58now. All five presidents are now here in Washington
- 51:00together today. Thank you for that little addition
- 51:05there. We have so many questions in the chat
- 51:08about, there's a lot of people wanting access
- 51:11to your resources now and asking whether you
- 51:15have special accommodations for independent contractors
- 51:20working with academic or CIVSOC institutions,
- 51:23for example. Do you have any? That is possible.
- 51:29I would obviously suggest you can email me and
- 51:33my details are all on those websites and we can
- 51:36have a chat about it then. That'd be the best
- 51:38way to get in contact. Fabulous. So you heard
- 51:40it here first. Please email the dedicated email
- 51:43with your application. to get access to the paid
- 51:48version. But it's great to see so many people
- 51:50interested in really delving into the data here.
- 51:53I was just going to say, it's been fascinating
- 51:55to watch all the Central Asia people come out
- 51:59of the woodwork and see more interest in the
- 52:01region as time goes on. I think this is part
- 52:04of the reason I got into this project in the
- 52:05first place is that every other one of my friends
- 52:07who works on the Africa desks or in Europe or
- 52:10whatever, particularly in the South China Sea
- 52:12areas, they all have all of very similar resources
- 52:15they can go to, to look up where things are and
- 52:18understand very quickly what bases exist. Central
- 52:23Asia just doesn't have anything. So it's finally
- 52:25good to have kind of a central resource I can
- 52:27put in the third screen, remember where each
- 52:28base is. Yes. And if you are in the Discord server
- 52:32and you're interested in this particular region,
- 52:35we do have a space for you to chat about it.
- 52:38It's called Crocuses Central Asia, and I've just
- 52:43linked it in the chat now and I'll put it in
- 52:45the Discord. I'll put it in this stage talk description
- 52:48as well on the podcast. So please do hop in there
- 52:52and continue the conversation from today within
- 52:55there. That is the space for you. I know your
- 52:58expertise is in Central Asia, but you mentioned
- 53:01that your team also works across lots of different
- 53:04regions. And at the very beginning, In your speech,
- 53:07you were talking about how it's quite unique
- 53:10in Central Asia that you're able to kind of rank
- 53:13the militaries. How difficult is it to kind of
- 53:17take this model and look at other regions of
- 53:19the world in regards to military force? What
- 53:22would be your advice if somebody is looking to
- 53:25do this in a different region? And what were
- 53:29the kind of key factors that you had to think
- 53:33about when approaching this particular project?
- 53:37I think the reason that it's a little easier
- 53:39to do here is because of the geography, because
- 53:42they are very similar economic stylings, they're
- 53:45very similar geographic realities. If you're
- 53:48trying to, let's say, rank Australia versus Indonesia,
- 53:52and you were to say, you could either rank it
- 53:54as, hey, what are they capable of if we put them
- 53:56in a giant flat field with no terrain and just
- 53:59plopped all their military resources on either
- 54:01end of the field and said, go boys. And yeah,
- 54:04you could probably work out something of that
- 54:06variety, but I think that's a little unrealistic.
- 54:08You know, if you're looking at something like
- 54:11Australia versus Indonesia, Australia could absolutely
- 54:13take some of the small islands, no problem. The
- 54:15Australian Navy is really, really capable, but
- 54:17the Australian ground forces are quite small
- 54:19because we don't anticipate that we're going
- 54:21to be fighting massive land wars anytime soon.
- 54:23So again, it just gets, you know, unless you're
- 54:25dealing with specific cases or you're trying
- 54:28to, you know, rank countries on their ability
- 54:31to do a specific task. So let's say, if I was
- 54:35to try and figure out if Uzbekistan invaded Kazakhstan
- 54:38or Kazakhstan invaded Uzbekistan, who could get
- 54:41further? That would probably be Kazakhstan. But
- 54:45does that mean there are better military? It's
- 54:48tough to say. And again, because there's also
- 54:51going to be geographic realities that ruin a
- 54:54lot of this. Again, you put them in a plain field,
- 54:57Uzbekistan wins against Tajikistan every day
- 54:59of the week. But because of the fact that there's
- 55:01such a narrow choke point approaching Dushanbe,
- 55:03that logistics aren't built up for this, that
- 55:05a lot of the, you have to cross certain river
- 55:09points that are quickly going to be occupied.
- 55:11It just makes it much more costly for Uzbekistan
- 55:14to go on the offensive and gives massive advantages
- 55:16that you wouldn't get if you were Tajikistan,
- 55:19if it was just kind of a plain map. I either
- 55:21recommend you try and rank things on a specific
- 55:23metric. If you're looking at Air Force projection
- 55:26capabilities or supply capabilities, or how many
- 55:30tons a day can you put into the field? That's
- 55:33something you could try and measure. Overall,
- 55:36it gets a bit difficult. And again, I think another
- 55:38example of this is everyone, when they try and
- 55:40measure tanks, looks at the stats on the chart
- 55:43and says, oh, well, this tank can fire further
- 55:45than this tank. And I think it's a little bit
- 55:47deceptive. When you look at the American tanks,
- 55:50everyone points to them and goes, oh, they're
- 55:52so fuel intensive. And that's correct. They are.
- 55:54But if you're the Americans and you have the
- 55:56American logistical capabilities, you're allowed
- 55:58to be fuel intensive. They built the tanks around
- 56:02doing that. You look at a South Korean tank and
- 56:03you go, oh, it's so slow. But then you realize
- 56:06that the tanks in South Korea are mostly built
- 56:08to kind of hunker down and take on waves of advancing
- 56:13Paul Hyam and North Koreans, which that tank
- 56:16is kind of perfect to do that. Again, militaries
- 56:19build things for purposes and that will obviously
- 56:22change your rankings and how capable things are.
- 56:24And trying to match a, you know, take the American
- 56:27tank, for instance, and give it to Uzbekistan
- 56:30where they have a pretty average logistical capability.
- 56:33It's going to effectively drain Uzbek fuel reserves
- 56:36very, very quickly because it's just not made
- 56:39for their purpose. Absolutely. And a really good
- 56:41example there. Obviously you spoke to us previously
- 56:44too. I've just put the link to your previous
- 56:46talk in there. So people can also listen back
- 56:49to that on researching Central Asia. We've only
- 56:52got a couple minutes. I want to ask you one last
- 56:55question. And this is based on the fact that
- 56:56we've had quite a few stage talks recently on
- 56:59paramilitaries. And you mentioned the, you had
- 57:02that amazing graph earlier about the disproportionate
- 57:06percentage of paramilitaries in the different
- 57:08regions. Is it more difficult to map paramilitary
- 57:13power than traditional military power? And how
- 57:17do you kind of go about doing that? Well, I think
- 57:20it is more difficult to try and map paramilitary
- 57:23stuff because it's much softer capabilities.
- 57:26You know, it's easy to map, try to look at the
- 57:28amount of tanks or look at the amount of vehicles
- 57:30or look at the amount of logistical capabilities
- 57:33someone has because a lot of it's, you know,
- 57:36things you can point to. Whereas with paramilitaries
- 57:38quite often, how good they are at cracking down
- 57:41on a population or how quick they are at, you
- 57:45know, riot control, that kind of stuff is much
- 57:48softer and you really have to spend more time
- 57:50watching military exercises or watching, you
- 57:53know, trying to get your hands on video of these
- 57:55guys doing training exercises or interview people
- 57:56at how quick it took them to do that. Or, you
- 57:59know, smuggled out videos of, you know, let's
- 58:02say Turkmenistan of the internal security services
- 58:05cracking down on a city, how quickly they can
- 58:07shut down the internet, that kind of stuff. it
- 58:10becomes a lot harder to measure and you're usually
- 58:12running off much smaller data sets, which will
- 58:15obviously complicate things going forward. But
- 58:19there are things you can piece together. It just
- 58:22becomes a bit harder, I guess, particularly if
- 58:24you're trying to put a score on things. Thank
- 58:26you, Michael, for your amazing insight once again.
- 58:30As I mentioned, we have had previous talks on
- 58:34paramilitaries very recently. We had the New
- 58:37America group come in and talk about mapping
- 58:40militia networks. Recently, it's a fascinating
- 58:43discussion. Do listen back to that if you're
- 58:45interested in these kinds of conflict networks.
- 58:49I tell you, you would have had Candace and Ben
- 58:51on for that one. We did. Yes, exactly. They are
- 58:55fantastic. I can't recommend particularly Candace's
- 58:58work more heavily. It's amazing. But in the meantime,
- 59:01please do check out these fantastic resources
- 59:05that we've shared today on Central Asia, particularly
- 59:08the new Uzbekistan report. And thank you so much
- 59:12for joining us. Michael, thanks for coming in
- 59:15and talking about your work. And we'll be back
- 59:18in two weeks time with another stage talk. Thank
- 59:20you all. Thanks again for having me. And if anyone
- 59:22has any questions, feel free to email me and
- 59:25I'm always happy to try and answer any questions
- 59:28people have. But it's been an absolute pleasure
- 59:29to be here. and hopefully I'll be back when we
- 59:32release the next chapter of this thing in a while's
- 59:34time with Kyrgyzstan. Absolutely, we'll be itching
- 59:38at the bit to have you back on. Thank you for
- 59:42listening to the stage talk. If you'd like to
- 59:44catch a stage talk live where you can ask the
- 59:47guest questions, join the Bellingcat Discord
- 59:50server by visiting www .discord .gg slash Bellingcat.
- 59:57The music you've heard is titled Dawn by Newer
- 1:00:00Self and is courtesy of Artlist.