Latest / Logistics at a Crossroads / S2 🎙️Episode 8 — Diesel Doesn't Care About Your Freight Budget
Transcript
- 1:14Speaker: Hey hey hey and welcome back to holding the line it's your girl Gia and today we need to have a little talk about Diesel because Diesel does not care about your transportation budget.
- 1:32Speaker: Diesel does not care what your customer was quoted quoted three months ago, and I hate to break it to you.
- 1:40Speaker: Diesel doesn't care that finance already approved the annual plan.
- 1:47Speaker: Because it absolutely does not care that somebody promised the customer shipping would remain the same price all year.
- 1:57Speaker: I'm gonna break it to you gently.
- 2:00Speaker: Fuel prices go up.
- 2:03Speaker: Somebody has to pay.
- 2:05Speaker: The only question is who?
- 2:08Speaker: And right now, diesel prices are squeezing transportation rates again.
- 2:17Speaker: And whenever fuel spikes like this, I always hear the same conversation over and over again.
- 2:25Speaker: Um, when did the rate go up?
- 2:28Speaker: See, what happened was is normally the answer.
- 2:33Speaker: Because the trucks, they don't run on hope, dreams, or positive energy.
- 2:41Speaker: Let's take a second.
- 2:42Speaker: Let's just sit back and talk about what actually happens.
- 2:47Speaker: So, a carrier gives you a quote on a lane, and that quote is constructed with assumptions like fuel, the driver wages, the insurance, the equipment, yada yada yada, maybe even deadhead miles, tolls, all of that, and enough margin left over so they don't go out of business.
- 3:11Speaker: But what's been happening lately is one of those variables suddenly increase, raise your rate.
- 3:22Speaker: That's the only option they really have, or adjust a fuel surcharge, or the worst part they like doing is absorb it, or basically stop taking freight that no longer makes financial sense to haul.
- 3:38Speaker: And the last one is the part people forget all the time.
- 3:44Speaker: Freight doesn't always become unavailable because there aren't trucks available.
- 3:50Speaker: Sometimes, oh, those trucks are available, they just won't run your freight.
- 3:57Speaker: The rate you need is not there.
- 4:01Speaker: And those two are very different capacity issues.
- 4:06Speaker: Now, this is where it starts getting really ugly for the small carriers.
- 4:12Speaker: The bigger the company, the more likely they have a fuel purchasing program, bigger network, a little bit more negotiating power.
- 4:21Speaker: That owner operator over there, they may fuel up their truck today and hope that the settlement check they get next month covers their cost.
- 4:31Speaker: A few cents don't matter.
- 4:35Speaker: A dollar, and now we're having another conversation.
- 4:41Speaker: Because if that driver is burning through several hundred gallons of fuel a week, that price increase is cutting into their bottom line.
- 4:51Speaker: Literally.
- 4:53Speaker: Well, then somebody says, Well, there is a fuel surge.
- 4:56Speaker: Fuel surcharge.
- 4:58Speaker: Sometimes, but you got to think about it.
- 5:02Speaker: Those fuel surcharges, the formulas that people use vary due to contracts or timing, and gasoline at the pump can increase far more quickly than someone's contract can account for.
- 5:19Speaker: So that may mean the carrier will decide to eat part of that fuel increase.
- 5:25Speaker: And if they can't absorb all of it into their margins, somebody else will.
- 5:31Speaker: And you know who that ends up being?
- 5:35Speaker: It'll go down the line.
- 5:37Speaker: The shipper, the customer, the consumer will eventually eat it too, because little by little it trickles.
- 5:47Speaker: This is how transportation costs bleed into economy.
- 5:52Speaker: Not immediately, eventually.
- 5:56Speaker: Here's where I tend to get frustrated because people in logistics act like buying transportation is just it's got to be the cheapest, or who gave who gives me the cheapest rate.
- 6:12Speaker: Guess what?
- 6:13Speaker: The lowest cost is not always the lowest risk.
- 6:18Speaker: I feel bad when I tell people that.
- 6:21Speaker: Okay, I don't feel bad.
- 6:22Speaker: I try to make it sound like I feel bad, but I don't.
- 6:25Speaker: But if you structure your transportation program around squeezing every last dollar out of your carrier base, what happens when something changes?
- 6:37Speaker: What happens when that capacity gets tight or when a carrier can literally choose between hauling your freight and someone else's?
- 6:47Speaker: And all of a sudden, that commodity freight that you were treating like crap because hey, there's a truck becomes valuable again.
- 6:58Speaker: That is why dependable carrier relationships matter.
- 7:03Speaker: If I call you when I need the cheapest truck in town, but I don't talk to you any other time, why should I expect you to bail me out when the market turns sideways?
- 7:14Speaker: I shouldn't.
- 7:16Speaker: And this is why I say relationships matter when capacity gets tight.
- 7:23Speaker: Forecasting, communication, lead times.
- 7:28Speaker: And yes, price matters.
- 7:32Speaker: I'm not saying we should just start throwing money at freight, but I am saying we should understand what we're buying.
- 7:42Speaker: So let's say you get two quotes on a load: carrier A and carrier B, Jimbo and Jim Bob.
- 7:51Speaker: Carrier Jimbo gives you a quote for $2,000.
- 7:56Speaker: Jim Bob quotes you $2,150.
- 7:59Speaker: How many of you automatically went to Jimbo?
- 8:03Speaker: Okay, fair enough.
- 8:06Speaker: But what if Jim Bob has a significantly better service industry, service history than Jimbo?
- 8:16Speaker: What if they know your facility so well that they never book inefficient appointments?
- 8:24Speaker: What if they consistently meet appointments?
- 8:29Speaker: What if they always have equipment where you need it?
- 8:34Speaker: And what happens if old Jimbo over here instead of Jim Bob, who knows your stuff inside and out, but Jimbo takes your load, drives it to your facility, and drops it because it just doesn't make sense for them to come back.
- 8:49Speaker: Uh, and I'm gonna be honest, it happens a little bit more than anybody wants to admit.
- 8:58Speaker: So, what did you actually save?
- 9:01Speaker: Nothing.
- 9:02Speaker: Because when that freight suddenly becomes urgent, you'll wish you paid that 150.
- 9:08Speaker: And you'll wish Jim Bob over here has capacity because now you need his service.
- 9:17Speaker: And I'm gonna tell you right now that emergency transportation costs money.
- 9:24Speaker: Detention, money, misproduction, late customer orders, paying your employees overtime because your freight showed up six hours after your receiving window opened.
- 9:37Speaker: Money.
- 9:39Speaker: Rates don't exist in a vacuum.
- 9:42Speaker: You've got to look at the total cost of doing business.
- 9:45Speaker: The cool thing is, planners kind of understand this instinctively.
- 9:51Speaker: Cheap freight that causes you five other problems downstream isn't cheap.
- 9:58Speaker: Fuel parts, fuel, fuel, fuel is just one of those little reminders that logistics is a physical business.
- 10:08Speaker: It's not just numbers and data.
- 10:11Speaker: Look, we love to talk about AI, we love to talk about automation, we love to bring up digital supply chains.
- 10:21Speaker: But at the end of the day, a semi still has to drive somewhere.
- 10:27Speaker: A ship still burns fuel.
- 10:30Speaker: Oh, so does an airplane.
- 10:34Speaker: Equipment still costs money to run, and we still need drivers to drive them.
- 10:41Speaker: So basically, somebody still has to pay for that fuel to move your freight from point A to point B.
- 10:49Speaker: I mean, you can digitize a ton of paperwork, you cannot digitize diesel, at least not yet.
- 10:57Speaker: Let's not talk about you know the plug-in battery situation.
- 11:04Speaker: So look, the next time fuel increases, people start freaking out.
- 11:11Speaker: But don't just ask your carrier, why is transportation costing us more money?
- 11:17Speaker: Stop.
- 11:18Speaker: Ask yourself some questions.
- 11:21Speaker: What changed?
- 11:23Speaker: How long do we think this will last?
- 11:25Speaker: What does our contract say we will do?
- 11:28Speaker: Which lanes are most susceptible to this increase?
- 11:33Speaker: Can we consolidate our freight?
- 11:35Speaker: What about if we shift some truck freight?
- 11:40Speaker: Shift some truck freight, let me get that outright, to the rail.
- 11:46Speaker: Can we actually improve those lead times?
- 11:49Speaker: What can we reduce empty miles?
- 11:51Speaker: That's a big one.
- 11:53Speaker: What about scheduling smarter?
- 11:55Speaker: Can we give our carriers a more accurate forecast?
- 11:59Speaker: And where are we paying extra because of our inefficiency?
- 12:06Speaker: Because here's another thing about fuel.
- 12:08Speaker: It gets wasted too.
- 12:10Speaker: Trucks got to sit for four hours, fuel.
- 12:13Speaker: Driver has to come back and tomorrow to deliver because nobody was ready for it.
- 12:18Speaker: A bad appointment planning, empty mile repositioning, and decide you need something right now because Amazon Prime wasn't wants it yesterday.
- 12:28Speaker: What does all of that have in common?
- 12:31Speaker: Fuel.
- 12:32Speaker: We can't control the price of diesel.
- 12:35Speaker: What we can control is how much extra transportation costs we are creating through our own inefficiencies.
- 12:45Speaker: That's where the conversation about sudden fuel increases should start.
- 12:51Speaker: So this week, my question for you is this.
- 12:55Speaker: If fuel increased a dollar tomorrow, does your transportation strategy still work?
- 13:03Speaker: Is your budget built around everything staying exactly the same?
- 13:10Speaker: Because Diesel does not care about your budget.
- 13:15Speaker: And neither does disruption.
- 13:18Speaker: Thank you for tuning in to Holding the Line Logistics at a Crossroads.
- 13:24Speaker: I'm your host Gia, and until next time, I'll be right here, navigating the crossroads, right along with you.