Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Lessons - The Influence of Women's Speech on Language Evolution | Valerie Fridland, Sociolinguist, and Author
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Lessons episodes of Success Story, part of the HubSpot podcast network.
- 0:14These lessons episodes will be shorter conversations with past guests, valued members of the success
- 0:21story community, and myself.
- 0:23They'll be focused on teaching you actionable, insightful takeaways that you can use to
- 0:28upscale your personal and professional life.
- 0:31Historically, women's voices were suppressed.
- 0:35How was it so that even though they were suppressed, the items in their speech were actually
- 0:43setting like the precedent for how men speak in the future.
- 0:48In the next couple of years, or the next ten years, men will sort of adopt.
- 0:58Some of these speaking patterns.
- 1:00How did that happen?
- 1:01Well, I mean, of course the big answers women are just cooler, so of course everybody goes
- 1:06after what they say.
- 1:07But the real answer, and we are cool, but the real answer is, what is a role of a woman
- 1:13historically?
- 1:14So they are often the home makers.
- 1:16They raise the children.
- 1:18They are talking to their husbands when they get home.
- 1:21So we have this really interesting thing called intimate diversification, which is a big
- 1:25fancy word to say that unlike other subcultures, that tend to be segregated.
- 1:30So if you look in a lot of cities, you'll find segregated ethnic enclaves so that you
- 1:35have these different sort of backgrounds and different language choices, perhaps.
- 1:39But they tend to be relegated to very distinct enclaves, a lot of times because of historical
- 1:44power differences and socioeconomic differences, but whatever the reasons, there's separate.
- 1:49So there's not as much borrowing across ethnic groups for features, except of course now
- 1:55there's a huge amount of borrowing of African-American features from like black Twitter and hip-hop
- 2:00into white male speech.
- 2:02So that's a totally different thing, but women raise the children.
- 2:06So children tend to adopt initially at least until they go undergo vernacular reorganization
- 2:11in school.
- 2:12They adopt the features of guest who, their mom, their mom.
- 2:17So you know, unless that changes drastically and of course it has changed somewhat, it's
- 2:21still the case that that happens.
- 2:22So what we find is women are usually a generation ahead of men in picking up a speech feature.
- 2:28Now this is not all features, this is when you ask that question about what is our language
- 2:32say about us.
- 2:33It says a lot so much, it's hard to get to it all.
- 2:36We could talk for hours, but essentially in the majority of speech features that have
- 2:41become standard over time gone from being sort of less standard or just not noticed to
- 2:46being standard, it is women that have led in those changes.
- 2:49They lead by usually at least one generation, because when they have children, those children
- 2:54inherit their speech.
- 2:56So boys and girls inherit the system of the mother first and foremost.
- 3:00And then they go to school and they start reorganizing their speech.
- 3:04We call it vernacular reorganization to be more like their peers.
- 3:07And then they pick up new forms and fashions in speech.
- 3:10And that is what we dislike as adults, right?
- 3:12This difference in our speech and the children's speech because it says something like this
- 3:16is youth culture and this is adult culture, it makes us feel old.
- 3:20And we tend to label what they do as sort of novel and undesirable.
- 3:25But in fact, a lot of it does end up staying around and becoming the norms of the next generation.
- 3:30But it's women more than men that in the teen years push language forward.
- 3:35So then we have this relief frog where, okay, women were a generation ahead.
- 3:39They had children, the kids inherited their generation.
- 3:42They go to school or their speech.
- 3:43They go to school with the same system, but then girls forge ahead another generation.
- 3:48If a change is going to continue, the girls will push it forward and then they give it
- 3:54to their children.
- 3:55So you have this kind of leap frog pattern that men stay a generation behind until that
- 3:59change has moved to completion, meaning that it's sort of what everybody says.
- 4:04And it's so, so widespread that there's no more leap frogging and that's only find that
- 4:08men catch up.
- 4:09And that's when a new norm gets established over time.
- 4:13So a great example historically would be, because sometimes it's easier if you have an
- 4:17example, when you say, you know, he does instead of he doff, that was actually a change led
- 4:23by women.
- 4:24So we find in letters, of course, we don't have recordings back from back then, but in
- 4:28the early modern period, which was about 1500 to 1700, we find letters written by women.
- 4:35And we also tend to find letters written by less educated people as well, but sort of also
- 4:40gives us the sense that these weren't really standard features.
- 4:43In fact, it was a northern feature, a northern British feature, and it was finally adopted
- 4:47into London speech, which is when it became the standard, but we find does, starting to
- 4:51appear instead of doff, first in women's and less educated speakers letters.
- 4:58And then about, you know, another generation skips forward and we start to see it in men's
- 5:03speech.
- 5:04So that's sort of what incrementally pushes change forward.
- 5:08Now sometimes, of course, a feature gets very gendered, so little boys go to school and
- 5:13then they hear girls say it and it takes on this very feminine tone.
- 5:17They get a very gendered association with that, sort of like totally as an intensifier.
- 5:23And so they retreat and that's where you find that changes tend not to progress or they
- 5:27become very gendered, changes over time where only women do them to a high degree and
- 5:32men don't.
- 5:33And we find the opposite is true as well.
- 5:35Sometimes, features become gendered towards men and women don't do it as much.
- 5:39What would cause that?
- 5:40What would cause the totally to be a more gendered feature?
- 5:43Well, a lot of times it's the different types of sociocultural attractiveness that features
- 5:48carry.
- 5:49So what makes a boy popular in school, you know, you were a boy, right?
- 5:54Traditionally sports.
- 5:55Okay.
- 5:56Yeah.
- 5:57Like, like, sports having friends, you know, being kind of tough in macho, right, sort
- 6:00of having fun on that kind of thing.
- 6:03And is that the same kind of thing that happens for women when a girl, I mean, they can play
- 6:07sports, but it's sort of masculine, bravado, very good for her.
- 6:11No, traditionally no.
- 6:12No, it's really not feminine, nudity, and more so totally 180 from that.
- 6:15Right.
- 6:16So think about the types of features that boys tend to use, you know, like man and bro
- 6:21and dude are good example of that, that it sort of is a masculine solidarity, tough kind
- 6:27of guy or just the appropriation of hip hop language, you know, that type of thing, saying
- 6:33things like ain't generally women as young girls get vilified for their speech much more
- 6:40than boys do.
- 6:41So if a girl comes home and says, I ain't doing that, that have parents that have an expectation
- 6:46about what that girl should sound like, she's going to get ridiculed for it much more than
- 6:51a boy would because for a boy, we kind of had this expectation of rough, tough kind of
- 6:56behavior.
- 6:57And the features that embody that kind of roughness, that toughness, that masculine kind
- 7:02of quality, those are the types that boys tend to pick up, which is why they tend to be
- 7:06very attracted to non-standard features because we have these stereotypes about what those
- 7:12speakers are like, even though they're completely cultural artifacts, like the idea that young
- 7:18black men are dangerous and rebellious and non-conformist, well, that's our interpretation
- 7:24of a speech feature that has nothing to do with the reality of why a young black man
- 7:28uses it, right?
- 7:30Because what young black man might use a speech feature like thing or ain't, or ain't
- 7:34or acts because he's trying for solidarity with a group of other speakers who have faced
- 7:40the same sort of social cultural prejudice as he has and he has to have that, that's
- 7:45part of what bonds them is having a shared language and it's actually acts is an older
- 7:50feature than ask and that's what ask came from.
- 7:53Which is another thing, right?
- 7:55That's wild, so you're saying like people, no, I just wanted to understand, so that means
- 7:59that one group of individuals have completely adopted a language, I'm going to just very,
- 8:06very simplify this so I understand it.
- 8:08One group of individuals have adopted certain things in their language because of a certain
- 8:12social cultural norm and then another group has misinterpreted that social cultural norm
- 8:18and then adopted things because of that misinterpretation and then that's been brought
- 8:21up.
- 8:22That's exactly what's happening.
- 8:23That's exactly what happens.
- 8:24That's exactly what happens and the reason that ethnic features tend to be so popular
- 8:29among young men, so if you go to high school, I have a teenage son and so I'm and he plays
- 8:35a lot of sports, so I'm around a lot of boys a lot of times and sometimes it makes me
- 8:39laugh the way they talk because I want to say do you realize what you're doing, you know,
- 8:43but they would totally ignore me and my son would never invite me to another game, so
- 8:47not going to do it.
- 8:49What they don't understand is the reason those features are attractive to them is because
- 8:53they're completely misinterpreting why they're used in the first place.