Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E005: BlackRock ETF and the Future of Retirement Plans with Matt Dines
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about stuff and we're
- 0:04going to be left, holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of down test. 1974 1987 1297 2000
- 0:18and whatever we're going to call this.
- 0:19It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell Gentlemen,
- 0:32the signals are going off. BlackRock is here.
- 0:35Matt dines is joining us for episode 5 of The Last raid.
- 0:39Matt, welcome. Started off.
- 0:42Let's start it off at the signals or say I'm saying, right
- 0:45before we hit record, I've got an investment banker in the
- 0:48family, A cousin-in-law, if you will, when things are happening
- 0:55and that side of the industry of the, the finance side of the
- 1:00world, I usually get a text from him.
- 1:03I got a text from him yesterday. I think Black Rock has sent a
- 1:06signal out there and you have all Wall Street trying to figure
- 1:09out. All right, what is our Bitcoin
- 1:11strategy? What are we doing?
- 1:14I won't get into the specifics of what have reached out about,
- 1:16but Wall Street seems to be interested in what Bitcoin
- 1:21companies are doing these days. I had a signal to Stanford
- 1:27friend of mine who has been bullish on.
- 1:30Crypto, broadly, reached out yesterday, a little bit little
- 1:35bit in despair about the future of crypto, because it suddenly
- 1:41seems a lot darker with SEC coming in and making its
- 1:46actions. And, you know, I think that's
- 1:51part of the journey towards bit. A coin is realizing that
- 1:55everything else is is doesn't have staying power and it's
- 2:00feels like that is a little indicator for me that my network
- 2:04is just a little bit closer to seeing the Bit Coin and crypto
- 2:07are different and Bitcoin has real real value of real legs and
- 2:12and should be a part of everybody's portfolio.
- 2:15Yeah, I think it's very interesting times.
- 2:19When you know, you know, we have a directional idea what's going
- 2:21to happen over the course of this year, next year.
- 2:23And as we started kind of the cells motion with on-ramp and
- 2:27Outreach and inbound in credit to Jesse and his piece this
- 2:32week, with the Black Rock, Trust in on-ramp and, you know, one's
- 2:36a bicycle and can run properly. And one stuck in mud or is
- 2:40inevitably going to be fucking mud, had some conversations with
- 2:43unions that have allocated and small.
- 2:45Mounts. But what was interesting is that
- 2:48they said now other unions are looking at them.
- 2:50Asking them look at what the Playbook is, how they could
- 2:52evaluate in today. I had a really good conversation
- 2:55with a pension fund in early stages that are asking all the
- 2:58right questions on the fundamentals.
- 3:00They realize it's been the best performing asset for 10 years,
- 3:02but also, at the same time, they haven't figured out how do they
- 3:04hold it long term. And so we think we're onto
- 3:06something and being able to help them, but it's just early days,
- 3:09right? So it's gonna be very
- 3:11interesting. Next, let's call 18 to 24
- 3:12months. Yeah, you get he signals out
- 3:16there so if you just look at the week in review there wasn't that
- 3:22much news from what you call like that just the broader
- 3:25Capital markets abroad, a finance, it was really you know
- 3:28that the lines have been hitting the ticker that I reveal, the
- 3:35big ones were obviously the SEC enforcement the things going on
- 3:40with what would you say like the the prime trust situation?
- 3:45The The finance situation, the true USD situation.
- 3:50Everything there seems like the action is happening and then on
- 3:54top of that you had just the cover smoke signal of the
- 3:58BlackRock Bitcoin ETF. But on top of that, you saw
- 4:02other just kind of infrastructure news that the the
- 4:07capital markets players are showing up to Big headlines.
- 4:10I think that I saw that showed up on my radar so there's the
- 4:14firm edx markets have been Kind of building up.
- 4:17But these are the big boys showing up.
- 4:20So, backed by want to say Fidelity Schwab and Citadel
- 4:26their CEO is the former Global head of Business Development at
- 4:29the spot trading firm for Miss a Bitcoin but they're not
- 4:32exclusively listing Bitcoin as their sole Focus, they list, you
- 4:37know the other day just crypto assets if you want to like these
- 4:41terms. But the the other stuff they do
- 4:45include that on what they're offering on.
- 4:47Auto trading vests but you know, from from that angle, you know,
- 4:51to show up with that degree of a caliber of a person launching
- 4:54this project. Just like, it's telling you,
- 4:56like they're mobilizing the troops for The Invasion into
- 5:00Carthage. I think it's coming another one.
- 5:03I saw Elwood Technologies, the sperm is backed by Alan Howard
- 5:10like billionaire. Co-founder of a massive hedge
- 5:13fund brevan Howard. They're basically creating Ting,
- 5:17you know, portfolio management order management system for
- 5:20institutional clients. So our firm build, we use for
- 5:24our order management system. I can explain what that tool
- 5:26does a little bit but basically Bloomberg part announced a
- 5:31partnership and this has been a few months in the making and all
- 5:34this is public intuitive, so I'm not sharing anything that's, you
- 5:38know, not on the news wire if you're looking for it but they
- 5:42announced, you know, portfolio trading for Bitcoin, but Also
- 5:47lists, those others, obviously, they're not showing up with an
- 5:51exclusive Bitcoin Focus but that's where we believe the
- 5:53action is. But yeah, the order management
- 5:55system for institutional players, it's part of like the
- 5:59table Stakes that you need for tools and infrastructure for
- 6:04this to show up and be like a reliable asset class for Capital
- 6:07markets and scale players if you will.
- 6:10So, when I say that, you know, that that acronym order
- 6:13management system or OMS, it just means like when you're
- 6:17Trading for a client account. Like, let's say build.
- 6:20We manage multiple clients funds when you need to buy or sell,
- 6:24you know, a holding in their portfolio.
- 6:26You need to show like a ticket. If you would like an order to
- 6:29get same way, if you go, you know, order food at Cooper's
- 6:32barbecue or something like that. Yeah, you'll get your ticket
- 6:34back and shout out to my awesome friends.
- 6:36Want to make sure I put this in, you know, the terms you guys
- 6:39like to see but you get it, you get a ticketing and like a
- 6:42timestamp price that your trade was struck.
- 6:47Lawyer. And then your counterparty for
- 6:49that. So you see this system, you
- 6:52know, build out, going on. And then also, like the spot
- 6:56Market development, where you don't have movies.
- 7:00You're just like the bucket shops the by Nance that, you
- 7:03know, all of these exchanges that are just, you know, Fly by
- 7:07Night. They come, they go.
- 7:09It seems like you're seeing right now.
- 7:11The infrastructure getting built at the base layer for the for
- 7:15the scale players to show up. And yeah, you know, where the
- 7:19long time frame, it's it's not just going to be a quick copy
- 7:22paste of the old system onto the new.
- 7:23I think this will. This will change everything.
- 7:26Yeah, yeah. Feels like it's happening.
- 7:30Yeah, it does feel like, it feels, it feels like Wall.
- 7:34Street wants to run this industry.
- 7:37The crypto industry in particular, I found it
- 7:40interesting that like edx the Schwab Citadel.
- 7:45And who else was it? Is it?
- 7:47Fidelity also. Oh yeah, you know, they're not
- 7:51just going to do Bitcoin which means that They believe that the
- 7:56SEC is not going to like, completely clamp down on crypto
- 8:01or at least for the foreseeable future, which then kind of cast
- 8:05into into Dale choir, why is that she going after crypto and
- 8:10crypto companies, like Finance, but they're going to allow edx
- 8:14to set up shop and do the same sort of thing in a more
- 8:17professional more Wall Street way.
- 8:20It does seem like Regulators, it kind of clearing the slate in
- 8:24order to Make room for the big boys who have decided they can't
- 8:28miss out on any more. So I would say about be good to
- 8:33have a lawyer on to bring the perspective on this because
- 8:35there's, you know, just demarcation lines that can be
- 8:40drawn. So obviously they coin with the
- 8:41Immaculate Conception, you know, it's UT exocet that's, you know,
- 8:45treated as not a security or it's, you know, on one end of
- 8:47the spectrum like put it as further to the left on as
- 8:51decentralized as you can be as clear as you can be.
- 8:54This is You know, a commodity Ledger money, then you go to the
- 8:59right the full end of the spectrum would be like the a 16z
- 9:02coins, you know, just just spending up projects, get the
- 9:07wash right and going and pump-and-dump type of Securities
- 9:11and there's some demarcation, you know, along the middle and
- 9:15if you're using something like you guys know the space better
- 9:19than I do. But something that forked over
- 9:21the UT exocet from Bitcoin at one point or another If it was
- 9:26just like a hard for the technology, those are the things
- 9:28that are kind of grandfathered in or treated us differently
- 9:31than these. Just start up Silicon Valley,
- 9:36funded tokenization, pump-and-dump type of thing.
- 9:39So it's somewhere in there and you don't, you're not going to
- 9:42see any of these at this point. I'm just coming in as Bitcoin
- 9:48only his kind of what I'm reading as I go through these
- 9:52news announcements. Yeah.
- 9:53They the institutions have to learn their Instead they're
- 9:56going to get wrecked. They're going to get rid of
- 9:58that. Oh yeah.
- 9:59But yeah. And, and BlackRock might be a
- 10:02big part of that for some of these people because of the
- 10:05paper Bitcoin claims that will be created out of out of their
- 10:08product. Well, I think it's a good
- 10:11opportunity to jump into this. Obviously news of the week is
- 10:14Blackrock are filing for the ETF.
- 10:17The trust will just call it an ETF just run with that even
- 10:20though it's probably not Jesse will let you elaborate on that
- 10:23but I think it's great that we have.
- 10:25Mad on today during this week during this Newsweek to set the
- 10:30stage for this conversation. We met we booked you a few weeks
- 10:33ago before any of this was news and it's a bit prescient that
- 10:36you're with us this week particularly because all right
- 10:41Black Rock filed for the trust which essentially will operate
- 10:46like GLD which people refer to as an ETF, Jesse you dove into
- 10:51the filing and wrote a piece and a nice thread on it.
- 10:55Really what the truss structure is, what individual clients or
- 11:00people buying into that? Trust going to be able to do in
- 11:02terms of taking the Bitcoin and kind of eventually or not being
- 11:05able to as it is seen, as it seems, the paper Bitcoin that
- 11:11can leak into that structure. And I think having Matt here to
- 11:16build on that conversation BlackRock.
- 11:18Obviously the largest asset manager in the world.
- 11:21A lot of people have tied up their retirement funds with the
- 11:25Black Rock. Ox and vanguard's of the world.
- 11:27And that is something that Matt is very passionate about the the
- 11:31situation of retirement accounts in the US.
- 11:35And so let's start with jumping into the structure of black
- 11:40rocks, trust how it works. And then I think we can dive
- 11:44into the landscape of retirement accounts in the US.
- 11:49How Black Rock plays into that and how Bitcoin We Believe can
- 11:53can really help retirees as Are retirement accounts.
- 11:57Begin to fall under water. Awesome.
- 12:00Yeah, I'm looking forward to this one.
- 12:03So I spent last weekend kind of digging into the BlackRock
- 12:07product and pouring through there, there s one filing, but
- 12:10they intend to do with this product.
- 12:12It's a trust, it's a grantor trust model, which is a great
- 12:17model. And is in fact, what what
- 12:19on-ramp what honorariums Bitcoin trust is structured, as that is
- 12:26an excellent model for Bitcoin specifically because Because as
- 12:30a single commodity investment vehicle, a grantor trust allows
- 12:36the tax status to live with the with the investor.
- 12:40So it's, you know, for tax purposes owning a share of
- 12:45BlackRock Bitcoin trust since it's a grantor trust is
- 12:49equivalent to owning that underlying Bitcoin, from a tax
- 12:52perspective, which means that when that investor wants to
- 12:56withdraw in kind that. Bitcoin, it isn't a taxable
- 13:01event and That's essential for delivering that that desirable
- 13:07attribute of this truss structure.
- 13:10No taxable event on in-kind Redemption, which is great.
- 13:15And that's how it should be. That's better than gbtc gbtc is
- 13:19not structured that way because to get out of gbtc you can't
- 13:23with withdrawing kind, you have to sell your shares in two
- 13:27dollars. Then use those dollars to go buy
- 13:30Bitcoin. So that's a taxable event and
- 13:33so, you know, in that transaction, you could take a
- 13:36thirty percent hit on the value of your Holdings because you
- 13:39have to go pay the tax man. So the grantor trust side of
- 13:43what black rock is doing is great.
- 13:45It's, it's a good design and the other benefit of what is
- 13:51happening here. Is that because this is a spot
- 13:54product, not a Futures based product.
- 13:58It means that Black Rock has to actually buy Bitcoin.
- 14:01So any allocation that they make towards Bitcoin via this fund
- 14:07from the the 10 trillion dollars of a um that they have.
- 14:12That means buying Bitcoins. So if they had a one percent
- 14:15allocation of their 10 trillion under under management, that's a
- 14:19hundred billion dollars worth of demand, that would be spread out
- 14:23over some time, but that seems reasonable over the next few
- 14:27years and 100 In dollars of inflowing demand, you know for
- 14:31an asset that's 500 billion dollars in total valuation.
- 14:35But most of it is not available for sale means that you're a
- 14:39hundred billion dollars of demand is bidding for a tiny
- 14:41pool of what is available for sale which will and since prices
- 14:46so the margin you're going to string out a series of Trades
- 14:50that amount to a hundred billion dollars of in flowing, demand
- 14:53bidding up the price of Bitcoin dramatically in order to find
- 14:57Supply willing to Sold massively bullish for Bitcoin in that
- 15:03sense. So that's the good of what
- 15:05BlackRock is doing. The bad of it is that it's Black
- 15:10Rock and they are bringing BlackRock Norms of governance
- 15:17and custody to an asset that doesn't play nicely with that
- 15:22type of expectation. So a few, the three, Me in my
- 15:29mind. Biggest problems with this.
- 15:31As first of all, we hypothec ation.
- 15:34There's no, there's nothing that prohibits BlackRock from lending
- 15:39out the Bitcoin that ends up in their trust.
- 15:42As a result, they will do that. So they will get a little extra
- 15:46yield by lending the Bitcoin that they're holding two to the
- 15:51three arrows capitals types. The maybe the block five types,
- 15:55who are going to go further out on the risk curve and do
- 15:59something with that Bitcoin and maybe it works out or maybe it
- 16:02doesn't, you know. So they're going to generate a
- 16:06little, a little extra yield that way but in doing.
- 16:08So they're creating paper Bitcoin claims because they're
- 16:11taking the Bitcoin in the And that the investors in the fund,
- 16:15think they own and they're giving that Bitcoin their
- 16:20lending it out to somebody else. And then now there's two claims
- 16:25on that Bitcoin. There's the the big that Bitcoin
- 16:29lives with somebody who's borrowing it but the original
- 16:32investor in the in the trust thinks that they own it.
- 16:35And actually they have a paper claim on it now.
- 16:39So in that way, you're going to be creating paper Bitcoin.
- 16:43Messing with the supply of Bitcoin in the process and
- 16:48ultimately that, you know, that loan either has to be resolved,
- 16:53get closed. And in order to restore the,
- 16:56there's one Bitcoin for one claim, or if it goes sideways,
- 17:03somebody's stuck without Bitcoin because there's two claims and
- 17:06only one coin. So that's a big problem with the
- 17:09rehypothecation side side. Things there.
- 17:16Gosh. That's such a deeper hole that I
- 17:18did last night. Yeah.
- 17:20God, is it explicit that they're able to rehypothecation?
- 17:24Is it something that's just like, not mention that they
- 17:26can't and therefore it's implicit?
- 17:29Maybe that they could probably will do with it.
- 17:33And it's the norm in with, with, with ETFs in general that this
- 17:38is just how Wall Street, does things like you're allowed to
- 17:42lend out. Out the Assets in the ETF.
- 17:45And so people do and and there's nothing in the S one that says
- 17:49they can't do it. Which means that they're going
- 17:51to do it. Yeah.
- 17:54And Michael whether America. Sorry Michael.
- 17:58If you have something go ahead I have another angle to.
- 18:01Yeah problem creation Redemption.
- 18:02Yeah, I think there's a couple components to this.
- 18:07That would be interesting. One is I'm really excited to
- 18:10have Matt joined because I feel like he's our Resident like
- 18:14Bitcoin her inside. We saw you like look to your
- 18:18your right or left, whatever Direction.
- 18:20Where I'm treated like a Bloomberg screen and you're
- 18:23talking the lingo, and you know what's happening in that world.
- 18:25And one of the things that came up when we started thinking
- 18:28about on-ramp was finding out from folks between Black Rock,
- 18:33consider Bell, that black rock had institutional demand, but
- 18:37they did not want to face quote-unquote like web to web
- 18:41three companies and Owen base fell into that.
- 18:43This is even before FTX blew up. And so part of that was the edx
- 18:49formation which came from again, Fidelity, Citadel and Charles
- 18:53Schwab. And so that all sounds good
- 18:56until you realize like the backend engine of that was paxos
- 19:01and I think they were even going to leverage them for custody.
- 19:04I don't I guess that's kind of changed.
- 19:06Now these are marketing themselves as like a
- 19:07decentralized exchange and they're going to have like the
- 19:09settlement somewhere else. Maybe it is packed so still But
- 19:13regardless of means practice or not.
- 19:15The reality is all these custodians are the same thing.
- 19:18It's just there's no difference between coinbase.
- 19:20FTX custody or paxos and the reality is that like looking at
- 19:27this and see what happened the past few years.
- 19:29Had this realization that we're going to see this orders of
- 19:32magnitude larger. Whether it's the rehypothecation
- 19:34from BlackRock, or someone else or the centralization of the
- 19:38assets and just the similarly just destruction of chemical
- 19:43Capital that happened. And so one of the things that
- 19:45I'm just curious on your side. Mat is, what do you think has
- 19:47changed with that? Because you talked about the
- 19:50dance with the SEC. And, you know, now they're
- 19:53letting, you know, the firm's come in and it's like, there's
- 19:56feels like there's something with coinbase, like, bending the
- 19:59knee, that is happening in the background of like, okay Block
- 20:03rock. You know, we're here, we're
- 20:05going to use coinbase, they have the infrastructure but like we
- 20:10almost we own you at this point because at the other side, Talk
- 20:13about fees, the structure and he's completely kneecap
- 20:15exchanges when it comes to the compression of these within an
- 20:18ETF. And so, there was corn base, you
- 20:21know, liquidity and feed trading fees when it comes to that,
- 20:24along with a bunch of other exchanges.
- 20:26So I'm curious if you thinking things to change or what's
- 20:28happened in the course of the past six months will coin basis.
- 20:30Now, looked at as a counterparty that institutional investors are
- 20:33going to be willing to trust with their Bitcoin.
- 20:36So I think over the last race, a 15 months, right?
- 20:39Last spring it was a point in time where you had a lot of
- 20:44filings going out but they were getting pulled and you know this
- 20:48is pretty well known. I was looking to you know find
- 20:52some Solution on top like build around Bitcoin.
- 20:56Like this is you know how we got to this point where we are today
- 20:59with this with this private placement offering or private
- 21:01placement that we have talked about with the Unchained Bitcoin
- 21:04back loans. But we were looking at
- 21:07evaluating, you know, how do you how do you go through this
- 21:10process? What could we bring to Market?
- 21:11And in that process you talk to lawyers and you see what
- 21:15everybody else is doing. And we were told I think it was
- 21:17last March or April, it's like don'ti don't file here, we had
- 21:20another asset manager who just, you know, submitted a filing and
- 21:24they were told to pull it back. Like the, they were asked by the
- 21:27SEC to withdraw. It's not a rejection or just
- 21:30like, just don't do this right now.
- 21:32So, it was kind of known at least from what we were told.
- 21:35By our lawyers who are plugged in with the capital markets.
- 21:39This is what they do. You know, big law firms.
- 21:41They said just just pull back. This is, this is just, you know,
- 21:44hot stove, do not touch this right now and then as of this
- 21:47week, right? It's like oh, we're back.
- 21:49We're game on. So I don't know if it's, you
- 21:53know, tied to certain shoes dropping over the last 15 months
- 21:56where we've seen certain players like The Leverage build up in
- 22:00the system. You know people doing things on
- 22:02a building on top of on sound practices, those going wrong.
- 22:06And getting exposed or if it's just kind of learning where
- 22:10within the, you know, the X's and O's or the just the black
- 22:18text on the white paper. How do you how do you map this
- 22:22offering? Right if we have this goal, like
- 22:23everybody is known about this prize that's sitting there for
- 22:26someone to go get to have an exchange-traded offering with
- 22:32actual you txo like spot Bitcoin.
- 22:34I guess is the term People use, who is the first one who can
- 22:40take that Hill, like you're sitting on, you know, a revenue
- 22:43stream of fees and commissions. And this is the way Wall Street
- 22:46is kind of viewed it and known about for a while.
- 22:49But is it an element of like the right things had to happen?
- 22:53The right regulatory actions were taken the right back room.
- 22:56You know, meetings were made, I don't know that or is it just
- 23:00they figured out how to, how to submit the filing to increase
- 23:03their prospects of? Hey, We think we can get this
- 23:06thing through the door and make this happen.
- 23:09I don't know. It could be, could be a bit of
- 23:10both. We don't know as as the outside
- 23:12observers. But you know it could be
- 23:15somewhere in between, but it went from, I would say like the
- 23:19the temperature went from, do not touch this thing 15 months
- 23:22ago to now you see what happened?
- 23:24One black rock way and then now you had a land rush.
- 23:26I don't know exactly the number of came out with follow-on
- 23:31filings and I know Wisdom Tree and that's great.
- 23:35Six. Yeah, so it's back on again.
- 23:37They're going for the land rush and, you know, this isn't going
- 23:39to change that. Like, I don't know if we're
- 23:42still in a bear Market, I would assume we are until till we hit
- 23:46another all-time high. But you know, it's getting ready
- 23:49for the land. Grab you can see, you know,
- 23:51they're positioning for the next bull market.
- 23:55Yeah, it's really interesting. And because I tweeted this out
- 23:58earlier today in Jesse, I mean, you alluded to it with the
- 24:01rehypothecation and on-ramp is obviously created the custody of
- 24:05the Bitcoin held in the on-ramp trust in a very specific way to
- 24:09leverage Bitcoins, native properties, particularly
- 24:12multisig, and that's what's going to be incredibly
- 24:15fascinating to watch, play out over the next three to five
- 24:18years is Wall, Street, getting acquainted with the technology
- 24:21side of Bitcoin. Like, how do you custody to this
- 24:23custody? This We do use a third-party,
- 24:26you use multiple third parties and it's going to be fun.
- 24:31Watching Wall Street, learn these lessons because as we know
- 24:35Bitcoin as he's native properties, that make it very
- 24:38easy to build. Sound and secure Financial
- 24:42products on chain. Particularly with multisig, that
- 24:46Wall Street, doesn't seem to grok yet.
- 24:48Obviously, with blocks York, see me BlackRock not block stream,
- 24:53using Queen basis, custody that is a signal that they sort of
- 24:56don't get it yet as they probably should.
- 25:00And that's like another aspect that's thrown into it.
- 25:03Like, we are so early. Bitcoin has these native
- 25:06properties that really don't map to the And financial and banking
- 25:12system. And we're so far ahead of the
- 25:16curve on ramp particularly, unchain companies that are
- 25:19leveraging. Multisig, river, shrike are so
- 25:22far ahead, the chain the trend in terms of native security of
- 25:27Bitcoin. And so let's just touch on that
- 25:30like why on-ramp and of explained in the past but I
- 25:34think juxtaposing it to the Black Rock filing and they're
- 25:38offering if it gets approved is Is is really important for
- 25:41people to understand and intuitively grasp because their
- 25:44decision allocate to one trust with a certain security model
- 25:48versus another is a pretty big one.
- 25:51Yeah, so well I'll cover off a little bit, a little bit more on
- 25:56the BlackRock side of we touched on rehypothecation.
- 25:59There are two other problems that come up with how they're
- 26:02approaching custody and governance, one is who's allowed
- 26:07to do in kind redemptions. What's that Redemption process?
- 26:09Like the other is what happens in the event of forks and
- 26:17together, those three problems are Attic of how Wall Street has
- 26:23yet to appreciate the Bitcoin has these properties that
- 26:28protect client rights and by minimizing counterparty risk or
- 26:37you know, making making it easier to audit and and and Ctrl
- 26:44+ C and limit the ability to re hypothecated this asset.
- 26:51Because it can live on chain, it can live in a multisig vault,
- 26:54where three different parties control that Vault into are
- 26:58necessary to effect control. And, and then that prohibits the
- 27:04ability to do any funny business, any be hypothec ation
- 27:07because you can't lend it. Unless you have the agreement of
- 27:12of multiple institutions involved, which is how on-ramp
- 27:16is built, but it is not how black Because doing things,
- 27:21because as a custom, their custodian model is they're
- 27:25handing it to coinbase. So, now you've got two
- 27:28counterparties stacked up here, you've got black rock in the
- 27:33risks, there with them as a counterparty and then you've got
- 27:37coinbase as your custodian, the counterparty risk there.
- 27:43And and that is not as good as diversifying your counterparty
- 27:50risk by Splitting it into three different keys that in the
- 27:53multisig Quorum. So yeah, the in-kind redemptions
- 27:59problem with black rocks model is that The, you're only allowed
- 28:04to withdraw in kind your Bitcoin, if you are an
- 28:09authorized participant, which means a registered broker-dealer
- 28:14firm that has entered a separate contract with black rock and
- 28:21with and is in the good graces of BlackRock at that point in
- 28:25time. So that obviously is a, is a
- 28:27list of of firms with that, right?
- 28:30That can shift and can go to Well depending on what BlackRock
- 28:34wants to do and that's that reduces the rights of the end
- 28:41client to access their Bitcoin versus what's possible.
- 28:46The other problem here is the forks situation where there's a
- 28:50kind of a large section in black rocks, filing that specifies,
- 28:54that in the event of a Bitcoin Fork, BlackRock asserts the
- 28:58right to determine which Fork is the real one in which And they
- 29:02will honor. And the one that's not real in
- 29:06their mind, they can ignore or sell off the those assets
- 29:11depending on what they want to do, which is problematic because
- 29:15this is Black Rock and their the originator of the ESG score
- 29:19concept, it's them, that's that's their thing.
- 29:24And you know, it CSG the issue score is effectively a
- 29:29capitalist social credit system. Charlie capitalists pretty
- 29:34caught. Well, it's it's a so social
- 29:37credit system for wrapped in capitalism, you know, my party's
- 29:42a big fan a ESG so good. Let's see why shit-eating grin.
- 29:47Here is a, yeah, it's so you play that forward.
- 29:52You can obviously see a scenario where BlackRock would, you know,
- 29:57the black, right? Let's say black rocks.
- 29:58Trust end up becoming a very large holder of Bitcoin.
- 30:02Then they get some pressure from the government to, you know,
- 30:07impose a change on bitcoin to Fork it and create an ESG,
- 30:13friendly Bitcoin it or call it green, Bitcoin, whatever.
- 30:19And now you're looking at a Bitcoin cash scenario where
- 30:23there's corporate interests pushing for a fork but now it's
- 30:27not like small-time players, this is Black, Rock in the US.
- 30:32Pushing this fork and they're holding hostage.
- 30:36A lot of the institutions that have gotten Bitcoin exposure
- 30:39through this trust and that becomes a scarier fight then
- 30:44then Bitcoin cash was. And that's all because in this
- 30:48document BlackRock asserts that right and it's just in Legally
- 30:51sand hard to really see the threat there.
- 30:54But it's there and it doesn't need to be that way.
- 30:58And so, you know, on-ramp on-ramps model is to Is that
- 31:03grantor trust model, which is excellent.
- 31:05But to leverage Bitcoins properties of custody and
- 31:10governance to deliver best-in-class.
- 31:13Custody through the multi-party custody solution that we have
- 31:18where we have three institutions holding a key to our vaults.
- 31:25Two of those institutions are qualified custodians And it
- 31:29should all be about the rights of the client to access and
- 31:35control their Bitcoin and not about a permission system where
- 31:39you have to be in the good graces of of BlackRock, who can
- 31:44change the rules at any time and can impose their politicized
- 31:48desires. So, petition for change with a
- 31:54fork and declines code, Yeah, in just like expand on that I think
- 31:59Marty's thread was or tweet earlier was a little inspired
- 32:04from conversations. We have in the sense of like
- 32:06there's two parts and this is like one of the funnest times to
- 32:08just be involved in all of this stuff because we're basically,
- 32:11if you somebody's been workin, in space, you're looking at it.
- 32:13They've seen the stuff play out. We know how this How This Ends.
- 32:17So, Jesse to game out with Jesse.
- 32:19Just alluded to the closest, at least in my mind parallel was
- 32:24blocked Phi. And And the lending model that
- 32:27they had experienced this, I don't chain capital on the
- 32:31lending desk. Where in nominal terms, it was
- 32:35more expensive to go and take a loan from unchain versus block
- 32:39by and what we experience as you having those conversations and
- 32:44we explained that normally it costs a little more to take a
- 32:47loan, but risk adjusted, the lot more expensive to take the block
- 32:50file own, who's we understood? And people that, you know, it's
- 32:54just an asymmetry and information would Jesse just To
- 32:57it's the market not fully understanding.
- 32:59One that this is a different kind of asset or no bailouts and
- 33:02Bitcoin you can't print more Bitcoin.
- 33:04If the Bitcoin is lost, stolen hacked, or your rehypothecation.
- 33:09And you know, the tide goes out in your college store but in the
- 33:12same situation, block Phi over the course of years, we would
- 33:15start to see more individuals realized as that information,
- 33:19was disseminated the market. Oh, this isn't the right way.
- 33:22I want to know my Bitcoins on chain.
- 33:24I want to know. I'm willing to pay that
- 33:25additional The extra bits to know that the Bitcoin sits
- 33:30there. It's not being real and out and
- 33:32it was really fascinating because during the conversations
- 33:35over the course of years. It we would say the differential
- 33:38I would personally saying I felt it was a bold statement but I
- 33:41believed it. I didn't know what happened.
- 33:43So quick is that the difference between block line and change
- 33:46market cap was simply? And the Delta between
- 33:48information similar is like Bitcoin, becoming money is just
- 33:51understanding of all the things that individuals have spent.
- 33:54The time looking at And, you know, little we know like 12
- 33:58months later, whatever the time frame was that block fight
- 34:01basically Enterprise Value, 0, or negative.
- 34:04And I think of the it sounds like Blossom and it's crazy and
- 34:08say but I feel like very similar to any structure that goes
- 34:11against the principles that we're talking about here with
- 34:15Bitcoin in the centralization. Like this is an asset, it
- 34:17doesn't have to be held in the old way we don't the map the old
- 34:20world to it and part of murders tweet earlier was talking about
- 34:25you know, qualified Doing and I don't know, I don't know ever
- 34:27made. Um it was basically referring to
- 34:28like there are legal confines and Regulatory structures that
- 34:34we have to adhere to or were US citizens and there's things to
- 34:39offer Financial products but at the same time there's a way to
- 34:42offer those with also staying close as close to Bitcoins
- 34:45principles that allow for the longevity of the custody and
- 34:50just being able to hold that asset, right?
- 34:52Very easy to buy Bitcoins. Her to hold it long term to the
- 34:55volatility Exchange tax and everything that we know.
- 34:57And so I think that's very important because there's plenty
- 34:59of people out there that will tout Au because it's in a trust
- 35:02structure because it's in a qualified custodian, or because
- 35:05it's Black Rock. But the end of the day, like,
- 35:07Bitcoin is show number 13 years that it doesn't matter, who's
- 35:11holding it, unless you do it in the right way.
- 35:15Your Bitcoin is at risk of being gone and being gone forever.
- 35:17We can't make more of it. And I think that's the
- 35:19fundamental thing that we see with BlackRock as people that
- 35:22have looked at Bitcoin long enough that there's no world,
- 35:24where Black Rock The lot of Bitcoin call it hundreds of
- 35:27thousands, not millions that it ends up good for the people that
- 35:30are putting their dollars in and thinking they have Bitcoin.
- 35:34Yeah. My tweet earlier you can check
- 35:36all the legal boxes. You me qualify custodian.
- 35:39You can read out meet all the fcc's regulations.
- 35:41All the banking regulations but if you don't Croc Bitcoin
- 35:45security and build your product around Bitcoins, native
- 35:48properties, there's no legal checkbox in the world that can
- 35:51save you from losing people's Bitcoins security, That key
- 35:56Point like, is a, the liabilities and athletic
- 35:59mismatch, like the common thought that came up about block
- 36:02by eat it. I know I was part of it was
- 36:04like, look like fiber has a hole or a zero.
- 36:07What Peter teal? Do back them up, they'll fill it
- 36:10in that common thought happens. Now with Fidelity or black rock
- 36:13that if something happens if they're hacked, if you know
- 36:17there's a mismatch in you know the rehypothecation lending,
- 36:21whatever might happen. There's such large institutions
- 36:23that they will backfill but if you think about Got it.
- 36:26The idea is, if somebody's holding that asset, then they're
- 36:29looking at the price to get 10x, 100x, whatever the number is,
- 36:32and at some threshold, it's, they're upside down and what
- 36:35they're holding versus the Enterprise Value.
- 36:37And at that point, that's where the question happens one.
- 36:41If they're, if they're haploid, or something happens to the
- 36:43funds, it's, it's more than likely a zero.
- 36:46But then also, in this ties in, I was having this conversation
- 36:49earlier to be able to take redemptions.
- 36:52Because if that price appreciates, then there's this
- 36:55Like dancing Bitcoin, you shows, think about your MDK talents, I
- 36:59don't know exactly where it came from, but it's just the thought
- 37:01that, you know, you always want to think about your security
- 37:03model as if the price of Bitcoin is 10x what it is today because
- 37:06of the never will. And then you're going to, you
- 37:09don't want to be scrambling when it does that.
- 37:11And similarly, with having with black Iraq, you can imagine
- 37:14institution endowment that allocates a billion dollars,
- 37:17whatever the number is. And now at 10 billion and black
- 37:19rocks falling trillions. And you're thinking, wait, this
- 37:21doesn't make much sense, but you're stuck because you can't
- 37:24take it and we seen Thousands of people stuck with GGC a cell
- 37:27like Jesse's piece was great because it really laid out the
- 37:30the fundamental things that we thought about with on-ramp and
- 37:33in the difference between what Black Rock God and the visual of
- 37:36the bike with one wheel, will it stuck with a square whatever?
- 37:40The square thing was a rock maybe was very apt and
- 37:44explaining, you know how or vehicle moved.
- 37:47Yeah. A map, did I catch it correctly?
- 37:51Earlier, were you about to go into the potential duration
- 37:53mismatches that could arise if they do?
- 37:55A hypothec it hours of talk about the creation of
- 37:58redemption. That's just to cut just an echo
- 38:01on with Michael saying, like, the the risk, right?
- 38:04Yeah. You're on the back end of a fun
- 38:08Financial product, Etc. Like, your your weakest links in
- 38:13the entire process, right? They're going to take you out.
- 38:18Financial industry is built on wrist, like it is a risky
- 38:21business period. And any point that you do not
- 38:28understand where the risk is it will build up and when things go
- 38:33wrong, that's that's when the stretchers and and body Max get
- 38:37built out. So to some degree you're playing
- 38:40with fire here, right? And it's not just Bitcoin, you
- 38:44know, wrapping it in these layers in the industry and
- 38:46applying just in a lever leverage Capital Market System.
- 38:52Michael mentioned, do you come in?
- 38:53Just fill in the hole as soon as you run into a situation where
- 38:57hey, your company took on rested, didn't understand or
- 39:00wasn't aware of now you're in a situation where you need to go
- 39:02out and raise more Capital. Oh yeah.
- 39:04Yeah. Ask Peter thiel's, maybe he'll
- 39:05fill it in but in a system where you're running it 12 to 1 or 15
- 39:09to 1 leverage on average. If you don't understand the
- 39:14uranium that you're playing with or polka, not like you got to be
- 39:17careful and I don't think we've fully thought thought through
- 39:21all of the things that could go wrong.
- 39:23Wrong with putting actual UT EXO's into an ETF ETL like fully
- 39:32liquid 24/7 with elastic. Create redeem you mentioned the
- 39:37authorized participants as like a point of failure, Jesse in
- 39:41terms of kind of like a exclusionary, right?
- 39:47Like, I get to choose who's in here but I think it goes beyond
- 39:50that. It's mechanical, right?
- 39:52If you're looking at how the Creation Redemption mechanism
- 39:55works right when I say those words like that's what makes the
- 39:58ATF special is that you can be perpetually, like open as a as a
- 40:04pooled fund and traded on an exchange because you assume
- 40:08these authorized participants. And tandem with the market
- 40:12makers, who do the actual trading against your, your
- 40:18retail or institutional clients right?
- 40:20Who were moving in and out and trading shares in your fund, the
- 40:23author. Guys participant is the one firm
- 40:25who can create or redeem baskets of shares his way.
- 40:29It works. So the way our firm has an 80s,
- 40:31I had to learn about all of this.
- 40:33There's people who do this for their living, 20, 30 years of
- 40:37experience, like, they know this inside and out way better than I
- 40:40do. But I understand like the kind
- 40:42of like the Practical elements of this.
- 40:44Like, I've actually sat at the keyboard and process these these
- 40:47strategies, creating redeems, what happens with the with the
- 40:50AP, as like, they'll get an order from the market makers
- 40:53there. They understand supply and
- 40:55demand, they do like the share count need to go up or down and
- 40:57then they'll create a new basket.
- 40:59So one basket will be, I think, for the, for the filing of said,
- 41:0340,000 shares. Yeah, they it starts at at the
- 41:06share price of 25 that's a million dollars in assets per
- 41:10basket. So let's say an authorized
- 41:11participant like we're starting at zero share so you got to
- 41:13create baskets, you'll say we need a million dollars worth of
- 41:18you Texas. There's no other asset that you
- 41:20can get to put it in this basket, right?
- 41:22You have to deliver Ever Bitcoin utx.
- 41:25I was right and there's some degree like if we ever get into
- 41:28a kind of a bar fight. What is the chain?
- 41:32What am I CU? T XL.
- 41:33Well it's also Black Box decision.
- 41:35What makes it in there, right? What goes in the back seat
- 41:37basket. If it's a fork, you've got to go
- 41:39get those you got to show them and you know, these weights and
- 41:42measures like here's the price forty, forty thousand shares
- 41:46worth 10, 20 50 million dollars worth of worth of UT EXO's.
- 41:51You put those in the basket. Now you can you check this
- 41:54against a market? Where if you look at the
- 41:56Dynamics you look at like the the really good kind of analysts
- 42:01we have in this space is something that's like unique to
- 42:03bitcoin that other assets. Don't have like you have an open
- 42:07source community of analysts like you've got dealing with
- 42:10Claire out there and rational room people putting together,
- 42:12good work and know this industry I think better than then.
- 42:18You know, the entry-level analyst and Senior along this,
- 42:20that better even on the street. But you look at a market where
- 42:23the available supply for trade. Probably peaked and and q1 of
- 42:28like 20, 20 or 20 21. And the last cycle, your
- 42:31declining, what happens in your creation basket.
- 42:35When now you need to go create shares and you go into a spot
- 42:38Market where available Supply to trade is dwindling, right?
- 42:44You got to go get those. And at some point this market,
- 42:47like if you just, Follow the logic like where this looks like
- 42:51it's going. Like it looks like 5 to 10 years
- 42:54from now. Could you know, give or take?
- 42:56Who knows when that day comes with.
- 42:57It looks like this is a market with a reasonable probability of
- 43:01you know that the market going no offer and then what do you
- 43:04do? Like you're in this situation
- 43:07like day to duel in shares out like we can't create any more,
- 43:10we can't go get UT EXO's. I mean I don't think we've
- 43:14really thought about all these things and there's so many
- 43:16different ways for this to go wrong from Product standpoint.
- 43:21If you're looking in the rearview mirror, you've just
- 43:23seen You know, each cycle starts with Mount gox and then
- 43:27everybody there's always a body bag.
- 43:30Yeah. A lot of risk here.
- 43:32I think I think you nailed it there, where like Wall Street is
- 43:35going to burn their hand on the stove and it's a question of do
- 43:39they do that sooner like sooner or later if they do it soon
- 43:43enough where the holes that they create from, you know, not
- 43:49treating Bitcoin with the appropriate level of respect is
- 43:52fillable. If they can fill that, Whole the
- 43:56then maybe they'll learn their lesson and not rehypothecation,
- 43:59for example, but you could end up in a scenario where even
- 44:03these giants, like Black Rock, could let there's a very
- 44:08plausible scenario of BlackRock manages to ingest a million
- 44:15Bitcoin and to this fund and 10 years from now, the price of
- 44:20Bitcoin is a million dollars per Bitcoin.
- 44:22That's so that that's a trillion.
- 44:24Our fund. And if they if in some crash
- 44:29happens then and they've been rehypothecation and they're
- 44:34caught swimming without any clothes on that hole is bigger
- 44:40than the Enterprise Value. What Michael is getting it
- 44:42earlier of that, entire business, the biggest Behemoth
- 44:46on Wall Street and, you know, the Bitcoin has the potential to
- 44:51take out every institution on wall.
- 44:54Eat that doesn't learn to respect it soon enough.
- 44:58Yeah, I think another thing going back to the custody model
- 45:02depending on coinbase. A single custodian and that you
- 45:06brought up like individual UT EXO's.
- 45:08And that's the thing with allocating your Custody of
- 45:13coinbase like the coinbase is not going to like be registering
- 45:18those you tx's and I can be able to go to like the filings of the
- 45:21BlackRock fund and find the individually.
- 45:24T, UT X OS where the shares are held.
- 45:27I find it very hard to believe. I don't think coinbase does that
- 45:30for grayscale right now or gbtc. And so, it's bad for two
- 45:36reasons. Number one, in the event of a
- 45:37fork, like Black Rock can number one.
- 45:40Choose what they deem to be. Bitcoin, the true Bitcoin.
- 45:45And then since you don't have visibility into the individual
- 45:49utx, oh, is that the fun actually owns?
- 45:52They could say. All right, we're just going to
- 45:55run with this. This Fork as Bitcoin, we're not
- 45:58going to do anything with the other fork and they could market
- 46:01sell that and not tell their customers, and just just recall
- 46:05that in, in a way, we'll know that like, yes.
- 46:08Stop getting a bid. And once that, like, know this,
- 46:11this this BlackRock chain, like, we've Got them.
- 46:13These These are good utx. Us know, it'll show up in the
- 46:16market price. Yes.
- 46:18Yeah, you know what, you just made me think of Marty.
- 46:21So there's something interesting, without going too
- 46:23far, like down the rabbit hole coinbase basically being blessed
- 46:27with this because it is a blessing like that.
- 46:28They are going to hold this. They're going to get these.
- 46:30There's a lot happening from that.
- 46:32And we've always had these thoughts or discussions, like
- 46:34the government really can't like build custody solution in the
- 46:37same way they can actually build whatever currency that is going
- 46:39to be digital. So, there'd be like this,
- 46:41public-private partnership. That's what coinbase feels like
- 46:44in this world and similar Circle.
- 46:46And if you could take that further, it's like Black Rock,
- 46:49basically on Circle and coinbase.
- 46:51Now, the problem with that is coinbase outside of the fund and
- 46:56it amassing a million PTC. Coinbase hold, what's the number
- 47:01right now? A Bitcoin outside and just in
- 47:03general, like between Zappo gbtc and coin basis, you like 2.2
- 47:07million or something that's above 2 million.
- 47:11Yeah so So, there's a big problem here.
- 47:18Yeah. Alan Farrington included that in
- 47:20his excellent piece about the BlackRock product.
- 47:23He enumerates eight reasons to be worried about this and one of
- 47:29them is, is that black rock is, you know, so interconnected with
- 47:35the US government that using coinbase, as their custody
- 47:40provider effectively is going to like Bring coinbase into the
- 47:47government's control in terms of what what they're doing.
- 47:51If they weren't already one of four, one of eight facets and to
- 47:57be worried about with regard to back, rocks product.
- 48:02Yeah. On top of the three that I
- 48:04enumerated, which which weren't actually called out in his
- 48:08weren't fully called out in his excellent piece that called
- 48:14Trust me bro. Excellent name for an article.
- 48:19I mean it's a very interesting 5 to 10 business days.
- 48:21When you think about coinbase sued, you know, whatever by
- 48:25Nancy will, it's not even count that and then BlackRock ETF
- 48:29blessing coinbase with it like that doesn't, you know, they're
- 48:31all talking to the same people, the icc's involved in all of
- 48:33this, the government, you know, it doesn't.
- 48:36There's just it's a very interesting Dynamic to now think
- 48:39that Block rock is working with Is that holds 2.2 million btcd?
- 48:46Yeah. So do you think upstarts like
- 48:49on-ramp compete with Wall Street?
- 48:52You think this is a move to sort of box out the the startup
- 48:56culture in Bitcoin and let the adults in the room come in?
- 48:58Or are they going to be forced to let us compete, you know,
- 49:02we're an ant to to Black Rock where nothing, but from the
- 49:09perspective of a client, You can still choose you know whether
- 49:14you want to have a bike that has this good wheel.
- 49:17This good normal wheel the grantor trust model, it's a good
- 49:20fit for Bitcoin and then a square wheel which is the
- 49:27custody and governance. The black rock is bringing in.
- 49:30You can choose that that you, that can be your option.
- 49:33If you're if you're if you don't want to take on self custody and
- 49:36you want to get direct exposure to bitcoin while leaving
- 49:39yourself open to Actually taking self custody without a taxable
- 49:43event. Your options are that BlackRock
- 49:46vehicle one, good wheel. One square wheel or a Bitcoin
- 49:51native investment vehicle like on ramp where we've got the good
- 49:56wheel. Same thing.
- 49:57But you also have Bitcoin native custody through multisig through
- 50:02multi-party, vaults. And that is genuinely a better
- 50:10investment. You're called for preserving you
- 50:13as the client your rights, and minimizing your risks in that
- 50:18process because BlackRock is introducing a lot of risks in
- 50:23how they're going to govern this fund.
- 50:28And it doesn't need to be that way, and it shouldn't be that
- 50:30way and bitcoiners like us at on-ramp want to make one to
- 50:37bring people into Bitcoin the right way.
- 50:40And Empower them to take self custody when they want and help
- 50:45them preserve their rights. And access to this this asset
- 50:51and not try to dupe anybody into ESG coin.
- 50:55And sorry, this is what you get because you got exposure to
- 51:00bitcoin through BlackRock. Now you're holding BlackRock
- 51:03ESG, Bitcoin doesn't need to be that way and it's ultimately up
- 51:08to the individual and the Institution to decide what they
- 51:12value. Do you want to go with the big
- 51:14name of BlackRock? And frankly, most institutions
- 51:16will do that because, you know, black rocks clients will
- 51:21probably get exposure to bitcoin through BlackRock rather than
- 51:25upstart on-ramp. But every individual and every
- 51:29institution can make that choice for themselves, I'm Jesse little
- 51:33more bearish on honoring than I am.
- 51:36I, I tend where I've been having a lot of fun as again, this is
- 51:41like pattern, recognition of what we just, you know, did
- 51:43we've seen this. Whether it's an unchanged or
- 51:46river when you think about all this stuff from first
- 51:49principles, it's very darwinistic in the sense of like
- 51:52whether you choose the right money or the wrong money, you
- 51:56know, as we really to Parker's, you know, greatest asymmetry,
- 51:58it's not only to the upside of the downsides if you make the
- 52:00wrong decision, can insulate yourself from it?
- 52:02It and the same way from the product.
- 52:04So you know, the idea is like, we need two keys to be
- 52:07distributed Bitcoin for it to work.
- 52:10It's pathetic is going to have to happen it.
- 52:13Let's say we game out. Pick one successful, then your
- 52:15decision on where you secure. The Bitcoin is going to be the
- 52:18difference between you holding back when long term and not, and
- 52:21we just seen this play out with the past five years, whether
- 52:23it's a lending example with block fine and chain or, you
- 52:26know, custody and thinking about building your own infrastructure
- 52:29like River or whatever tapping out crying.
- 52:30Trust like, it's This is the where I'm bullish just like on
- 52:34the education because that's what this games going to be.
- 52:36For the next ten years, were dealing with alien technology, a
- 52:39new asset and it's up to us to be able to disseminate and
- 52:43explain that. And, you know, credit to Jesse
- 52:46Parker individuals that are able to pull from their traditional
- 52:50Finance backgrounds, along with understanding deep understanding
- 52:53of Bitcoin and monetary Theory and all the things that go along
- 52:56with it and articulating that two individuals and you couple
- 52:59that with a product that's native and that it's inherently
- 53:02native, when You look at it it's like do you want a single
- 53:04institution hole in it? There's no difference at the end
- 53:06of the day, whether it's Block rock, coinbase, FTX block fire,
- 53:08any institution of single, or do you want to use a native
- 53:11properties, that reduce that counterparty risk?
- 53:13And from a game theoretical perspective, especially if you
- 53:15do it from your stick tional perspective, you're not adherent
- 53:19to a single institution or somebody rugged you from that
- 53:22key over time, the best products going to win.
- 53:25It's a free market. And so again, having lived this
- 53:29the past few years in previous roles in the space.
- 53:31I don't I see. That it's just education that it
- 53:35all comes down to, and then the market takes care of, well,
- 53:38that's why we're here filming to educate.
- 53:40That's why the last trade exist. I completely agree with you
- 53:43Michael. I think that's the I want to say
- 53:47maybe Wall Street, may have an innovators Dilemma on their
- 53:50hand. Where there are two massive and
- 53:53due to the regulatory environment or not able to move
- 53:56as quickly with these unique, custody models that exist with
- 54:00multi-institution multi-city. Who knows, maybe The Regulators
- 54:03will get smart and they'll be able to move more nimbly, but
- 54:06I'm not going to hold my breath for that, and I think that's the
- 54:11beauty of the time. We live in right now.
- 54:14The inflection point. We live in.
- 54:15There's a grab going on wall, Street's going for their grab
- 54:18right now. We would argue on the show that
- 54:21they're they're approaching it the wrong way and because
- 54:25they're doing that we view it as a massive opportunity to do it
- 54:27the right way and show people do it the right way.
- 54:29Educate people on what the right way is, which is why we're here,
- 54:34is there anything with the black rock filing?
- 54:38We want to want to tie the knot on here because I think we
- 54:41should one thing I do want to add, is we've been doing like,
- 54:45forget about like the funder were you talking to folks
- 54:49whether on the union side or people that are managing,
- 54:51something like the everybody, these funds that are allocating
- 54:54capital or made of real people, maybe this ties in the
- 54:56transition to what Matt's working on.
- 54:59And also, just his understanding of the mismatch with, you know,
- 55:03Social Security pensions endowments that when it comes to
- 55:07the conversation, it is people's money.
- 55:09They're they're managing. And that they need to think your
- 55:12Russia area. And so, as the education
- 55:14happens, that's part of it, is that there's a real people that
- 55:18they have returns that they have to, they're responsible for.
- 55:22And if they don't have to take that counterparty risk, given
- 55:25all the things we just talked about definitionally, they
- 55:27shouldn't if they care. And so there's a lot here that
- 55:30we're going to be able to do to help a lot of these funds and
- 55:34then we all know like that it's in your, in the better for, you
- 55:37know, the return. So that's really weird as I've
- 55:41been going about the bath a couple weeks.
- 55:42It's like there's a real duty to help educate these large pools
- 55:46of capital because somebody on the other end of it is depending
- 55:48on it for the retirement among Social Security and other things
- 55:53that are associated That was I was just going to close on this,
- 55:58this one out I think. I don't think there's ever been
- 56:04kind of a situation, like this. Maybe there is a case study, we
- 56:06can find in history, where the playing field on this new
- 56:11paradigm tilt towards the individual, not the scale
- 56:14player, not the, you know, large pool fund.
- 56:17This is hard to do to map Bitcoin onto the Legacy system,
- 56:21like the Legacy infrastructure, like you're going to keep seeing
- 56:24it. There are going to be problems.
- 56:26You know, you rep of the floorboards.
- 56:27I didn't think about that, but for an individual, it's super
- 56:31easy. To onboard figure this out.
- 56:35It does take homework, you do have to put the time in, but you
- 56:39know, there's never been more. I would say just Alpha on the
- 56:42table for you. If you do buy any, you're going
- 56:43to your. You make that choice to on board
- 56:46on to bitcoin. Learn.
- 56:49Learn learn how to do seed words.
- 56:51You know, learn how to use a sign device, like a cool card.
- 56:54Go to one of these on-site events, do a workshop and take
- 56:58personal responsibility. So I'd say that's that's the
- 57:01huge lie. Foolish thing is you as an
- 57:03individual. Have a have a table set up in
- 57:08front of you. Where personal responsibility
- 57:10has never been more rewarded. I'd say in this framework, as
- 57:14opposed to, you know, so many other facets and life right now
- 57:19where you can take as much personal responsibility as you
- 57:22want like I can, you know, diet exercise.
- 57:25Get enough sleep at night try to stay healthy.
- 57:28My health insurance premiums are going to go up just like
- 57:30everybody else's 10 to 15 percent a year, right?
- 57:34I can't do anything about that. It's Just a complete change in
- 57:39Paradigm, one system versus the others.
- 57:41I think that's the extremely bullish thing here is, if you do
- 57:44choose to opt out of, you know, your existing option, your
- 57:50existing Financial investment choices will talk about this,
- 57:53what people are invested in and saving.
- 57:55And for retirement, if you choose to come play in this game
- 57:58over here, game is not the right word there.
- 58:00This this new system, this emergent system personal
- 58:05responsibility carries He's 10 minutes, it's free office, the
- 58:08complete opposite of what you're used to.
- 58:11Yeah, absolutely. And I'd go so far as to say that
- 58:17the people who do that, who take on that, you know, the scary
- 58:23elements of the new and in and learn about Bitcoin, do their
- 58:26homework and take on personal responsibility here.
- 58:31I think that could be the deciding factor between whether
- 58:35middle class individuals get to a retire.
- 58:40Ever or not and and it's I see that as we're all of this is
- 58:47moving towards and I think we can dig into Matt your work on
- 58:53this about asset classes and and individual Networks.
- 59:01Marty. Did you die?
- 59:01You'll know. Good.
- 59:02Want to throw up the slides. We went over.
- 59:04Did you want to recent rehash? Any of those or just open in
- 59:06discussion? I think we'll start with
- 59:09open-end discussion. Just how bad is the retirement
- 59:12situation? Private retirement account?
- 59:15Yeah. Well Jesse I've heard you talk
- 59:17about this to on other podcast you but I'll maybe the Citadel
- 59:20best dispatch episode with Mana W, talked about the same, the
- 59:24same things where does the middle class like where they've
- 59:29been trained, just Two accumulations and preserve
- 59:32purchasing power for retirement. And it's two things it's their
- 59:35homes. It's a primary residence and
- 59:37that's the big one we can talk at talk about the housing market
- 59:40at a bit and then it's retirement accounts, right?
- 59:42So you've seen this, this whole infrastructure belt out, you
- 59:47know, since Orissa government acronym but an Act passed by
- 59:54Congress and I think the 70s up to put an oversight layer over.
- 1:00:00Plants. And then after that like the 80s
- 1:00:03they the IRS, the tax code was the Revenue code was implemented
- 1:00:09to make these like tax favored treatment accounts where you
- 1:00:12could either get a benefit and a kind of a traditional standpoint
- 1:00:16like a regular 401 k versus or II reverses like the Roth and
- 1:00:21it's all amounts to do. You either pay the tax today in
- 1:00:24a Roth and then save, you know, over your working years into
- 1:00:27retirement and then presumably, you won't have To pay tax when
- 1:00:30you turn 65. Or, you know, whenever you hit
- 1:00:33that retirement of and distribution age, it's a move.
- 1:00:35It's a, you know, moving goalposts on when that comes
- 1:00:39home or is it you get a tax benefit each paycheck where you
- 1:00:43can contribute it to this account, you know, every
- 1:00:47bi-weekly or monthly paycheck and not take a text hit on like
- 1:00:53right away, you get a tax deduction, then you save it then
- 1:00:56you pay the tax at the end but It was it's really been a system
- 1:00:59that's built out and in the incentive since the early 80s to
- 1:01:03get people to save in this vehicle and financial assets,
- 1:01:08build up a nest egg and then, you know, ideally if everything
- 1:01:12works, you hit 65 or you know that number just keeps going up,
- 1:01:15seven and a half now. Maybe 72 the next time we hit a
- 1:01:19new secure act. Do you have that Nest?
- 1:01:22A built-up? And that's presumably.
- 1:01:24What's going to make up the bulk of your, you know, consumption
- 1:01:27needs In retirement, right? You have no more income other
- 1:01:31than you have your financial assets producing income, but you
- 1:01:34have no labor income. And that's a model that over
- 1:01:37like a 40-year bull market and financial assets.
- 1:01:39We're kind of you were, you were leaning into growth for most of
- 1:01:44it, right? The 80's 90's Boomers finally
- 1:01:48work their way fully under the work, the work force.
- 1:01:51So you got a lot of earners, a lot of a lot of you know
- 1:01:55paychecks. If you throw me, the aggregate
- 1:01:57aggregate, your work. Force is rising.
- 1:01:59You got a lot of income coming in and then every month there's
- 1:02:01just a bid and in the stock market and a bid for bonds and
- 1:02:06rates are coming lower. So everything's just going up
- 1:02:08for 40 years, that model worked and then what what happens, you
- 1:02:14know, once you're on the other side of that mountain and all of
- 1:02:16those fundamental drivers start going into reverse and that's,
- 1:02:20you know, that's really concerning problem.
- 1:02:24If you're looking on a like a forward Horizon, when you see,
- 1:02:26you know, the waves. Baby Boomers.
- 1:02:29Like we heard about this like we knew it was coming 10,000
- 1:02:32retirees per day and it's here and you're looking at the
- 1:02:38metrics, I have this pulled up. I won't screenshare can if you
- 1:02:43want to okay? Yeah I do love that.
- 1:02:48I love that point of like didn't know there's a lack of bid.
- 1:02:51There's been a bid every paycheck for 40 years and now
- 1:02:56that it is kind of diminishing, huh?
- 1:02:58Huh. Yep.
- 1:03:00Can you guys see this? Yeah, Logan's going to pull it
- 1:03:02up now. He's got it.
- 1:03:03Oh cool. Let me not feel me.
- 1:03:06It's it change the dimensions. And, and for everybody out there
- 1:03:09to like this is all in the context of interest rates like
- 1:03:131981, interest rates for 15%, you know, mortgage rate was 17%.
- 1:03:20So the value of homes couldn't be that much and we've had a
- 1:03:26pretty straight more or less straight line decline for 30
- 1:03:30years of interest rates going from 15% to 0 and then stayed
- 1:03:35there. For 10 years and only in the
- 1:03:37last year. Have have we seen actual
- 1:03:40interest rates back again, but that decline is fuel for
- 1:03:46financial assets to get bid up because the discounted cash
- 1:03:51flow. Valuation models that underpin,
- 1:03:53all these asset valuations, they benefit when the discount rate
- 1:03:59is dropping in because the future cash flows from that
- 1:04:03asset. Whether that's a company or Or a
- 1:04:06rental property, you have to discount them less as the
- 1:04:10interest rates are dropping over time.
- 1:04:13So that structural Force for 30 years. 40 years, really helped
- 1:04:21bid up Financial assets to the sky.
- 1:04:25So sorry, Matt, you can take it back now.
- 1:04:27Yeah, it's exactly, right. And then once you see is like,
- 1:04:30are we through it, right? Are we on that other side of the
- 1:04:32mountain? You can't call it while you're
- 1:04:34in real time. This is not how anybody does it,
- 1:04:37you can't call it top called bottom.
- 1:04:39You don't know for sure until three years, five years, ten
- 1:04:42years have passed maybe. But if you're looking at this
- 1:04:45data and what's happened since you know, we got that that covid
- 1:04:49deceleration, right? This this credit bubble wanted
- 1:04:53to deflate upon itself and then we had to take the monetary
- 1:04:56policy and fiscal policy actions that took place, right?
- 1:04:59You look at what's happened and the the main asset classes that
- 1:05:03make up a retirement account. All right, it's just stocks and
- 1:05:06bonds. That's all you can buy in there
- 1:05:08and you look at kind of the mother of all fiscal and
- 1:05:14monetary stimulus. And that only put these markets
- 1:05:19or at least the bond market into kind of like a preservation
- 1:05:23mode. For I'm say, like four months,
- 1:05:26like they pull out the Bazooka as late March, bond market
- 1:05:31topped, and early August, so at they pull pull four months
- 1:05:34basically, Kind of like a rally there, holding up bond prices
- 1:05:41and then, it's just been leakage ever since the bond market has
- 1:05:43been selling off. I know everybody's kind of like,
- 1:05:45we're going to hear recession Bond markets will / or yields
- 1:05:48will come in, you know, maybe that's, maybe that's in front of
- 1:05:51us somewhere with six months, 12 months. 18, lets you know, what
- 1:05:55have you? This is the most highly called
- 1:05:57for recession in history. I think.
- 1:06:01But you still see bonds selling off like I'm, you know, Ferrara
- 1:06:05Existing funds accounts, like what we're trying to do is solve
- 1:06:08the this looming problem hitting hitting fixed-income,
- 1:06:10allocations, and I trade these things every day and you just
- 1:06:14keep seeing yields come up like bids are backing off on, it's
- 1:06:19not just you know the treasury curve.
- 1:06:21Its front end corporate issuers, right?
- 1:06:24You might see names that seemed rock-solid like at the beginning
- 1:06:27of this year, United Healthcare, I could just throw out names.
- 1:06:30It's like these yields wouldn't budge it seemed like.
- 1:06:33And then all the sudden they do so it's like the The levees just
- 1:06:36keep breaking and I don't like no one knows how this how this
- 1:06:40plays out over the cycle. But it just at this point from
- 1:06:43my perspective, having the hands on the keyboard with like just
- 1:06:48watching these things all day. It's not slowing down, right?
- 1:06:55So it with a thing, I wanted to share on these these asset
- 1:06:57classes. What I did is I took the total
- 1:06:59repair and indices for the Bloomberg, I as a pay 500, total
- 1:07:04returns, go include dividends. And then Bitcoin.
- 1:07:07And then you take that ratio Total return and then you divide
- 1:07:12it by the CPI Index, right? Not that not the you know, hey,
- 1:07:17it's nine percent year-over-year.
- 1:07:18Know it's the actual index, like they charted, and it just goes
- 1:07:22up and to the right. And that's that's kind of your
- 1:07:24proxy for what's your purchasing power of your say, dollar asset
- 1:07:30Savings in that investment class.
- 1:07:32So we can choose like, any any And when you want, like just
- 1:07:36roll it back forward before, you know, we even knew covid-19 Aang
- 1:07:40December 31st 2019. You're going to get a similar
- 1:07:43similar result, but I chose this when the bond market started to
- 1:07:47sell off in August of 2020, we've been tipped.
- 1:07:50It hasn't kind of bounced since and your bond purchasing power
- 1:07:57is down. It says 24.4 a percent.
- 1:08:01So you're you've lost almost a quarter of your purchasing power
- 1:08:04in that alley. Location to investment grade.
- 1:08:07Bonds, I say investment grade. That's the category of bonds,
- 1:08:13that kind of the street analyst. The consensus is, these are, you
- 1:08:18know, they're investable, they shouldn't be a significant
- 1:08:22credit risk, right? So that that stack sauce to 25%
- 1:08:26as a whole, what that's made up of it's made up of US,
- 1:08:29government and agency debt, it's made up of investment grade,
- 1:08:32corporate Sandman investment-grade securitize.
- 1:08:34So think about like, Mortgage-backed security holding
- 1:08:36just pulled and securitize into a bond fund.
- 1:08:39That's what goes in there down, 25%.
- 1:08:41Since since August 20 20, it's August 20 2008.
- 1:08:45So since that stimuli that is like it could work through at
- 1:08:48least the financial markets and then things just of course from
- 1:08:52there while Bitcoins up 200% in that same time period, dollar
- 1:08:57price? Yeah, we'll go.
- 1:08:59So, that's something 500, I'll get to bitcoin third SMP 500,
- 1:09:02it's up six point six, four percent Total.
- 1:09:05So about it says two point three seven percent annually.
- 1:09:08So once your haircut for purchasing power preservation,
- 1:09:11growing your purchasing power saving and the S&P 500 since
- 1:09:14August twenty, twenty two point three, seven percent and Bitcoin
- 1:09:18even after, you know, a massive draw down.
- 1:09:21Like where did it get to from November 20?
- 1:09:2321. 22, November 22. Like the P that was Peak and
- 1:09:26trough is a 85%. Drawdown, write something like
- 1:09:31something pretty significant psych after believe.
- 1:09:34Yes. okay, even after that, you got Bitcoin up 98.6% Real
- 1:09:42purchasing power preservation. Like, in that time frame, Twenty
- 1:09:46Eight percent twenty Point, 36 percent annualized.
- 1:09:48So it's like, yeah, everybody. Look things as what happened
- 1:09:51this week or this month or, you know, in the last year.
- 1:09:55But it's, you know, numbers, don't lie, even though it is, go
- 1:10:02ahead. Sorry, I didn't see maybe to
- 1:10:05take a step back on. There's the chart on the
- 1:10:09allocations that I think you had previously.
- 1:10:11SLI went over with Marty. I think helps contextualize like
- 1:10:16taking a step back because if it was you mentioned 2020 but 08
- 1:10:19was really where everything started and the allocations
- 1:10:21leading up to that on the retirement and homes from
- 1:10:25individuals and how most got pushed there and then basically
- 1:10:27everything's gone downhill from there.
- 1:10:29Do you have that chart to show where we can pull it up?
- 1:10:31They think that sets the stage for like the precarious
- 1:10:34situation from individuals, right?
- 1:10:38And what they're basically like their personal balance Sheet is
- 1:10:42and then where it pulls into institutions and their
- 1:10:45investment in these different asset classes.
- 1:10:47And how they're all basically, Not producing any return.
- 1:10:53So the the sighs I'm Marty and I covered where an Institutional,
- 1:10:57it was like American household balance sheets where they say,
- 1:11:01institutional allocations would be a different set.
- 1:11:07I don't know if you if you want me to put these up Marty and
- 1:11:10Logan I can I can I can put them on your docket if you want to if
- 1:11:13you want to play these guys. Yeah, it's okay.
- 1:11:18This one. Yeah, you get to the main one
- 1:11:21yet, this guy. Yeah.
- 1:11:23This this gets to what we were talking about Jesse and I
- 1:11:25earlier like, yeah, but this is restoring.
- 1:11:29Its those are most broadly owned assets and the only ones that
- 1:11:34have gained value for your kind of your middle class, its
- 1:11:37primary residence and your retirement accounts or saying
- 1:11:41those other three three buckets if we're working from left to
- 1:11:44right? There's a class that's, you
- 1:11:47know, really limited ownership and Gain value, think of these
- 1:11:51as just like you own Financial assets.
- 1:11:55Whether it's like you own share, you know, you're an LP and a
- 1:11:58hedge fund, you own the bond Holdings, like you own cue
- 1:12:03steps. Directly give other pooled
- 1:12:05investment funds or you have other residential, real estate.
- 1:12:08So your second home. Third home, etc.
- 1:12:09Those those did extremely well. There's a there's a slug.
- 1:12:15Then next kind of life. It's like an orange circle.
- 1:12:19These are declining ownership and not gaining any value for
- 1:12:22the typical or the median American holds them.
- 1:12:26So number one of your CDs, cash value life, insurance savings,
- 1:12:31bonds directly held stocks, that one's actually surprising.
- 1:12:34I'll walk through that a little bit.
- 1:12:37Retail Traders are like it's known.
- 1:12:40They're terrible Traders, right? We kind of have this idea that
- 1:12:43thing to do is you buy low sell high.
- 1:12:47This is this is shocking. Being actually in the like the
- 1:12:50mother of all bull markets for an equity Market.
- 1:12:53Any country in history ever to retail, investor doesn't do
- 1:12:58well, like they in this, this comes into Bitcoin to write.
- 1:13:02We have this like This, I guess we call just like a fatal fall
- 1:13:08as humans. We, when we're trying to invest
- 1:13:11or speculate right on on an asset, but we do is we go and
- 1:13:16rush to buy to it. When we hear the news then we
- 1:13:19sell it once, it's downright. And when we hear the news, or we
- 1:13:22hear like, hey bitcoin price like this week, for example,
- 1:13:24it's it's rallied from 24K to 30k, see it in the news and you
- 1:13:30rush to your brokerage and or you know, whatever coinbase or
- 1:13:34whatever, you know, most Most Americans are and how they
- 1:13:36acquire Bitcoin they'll go by then right you're buying on a
- 1:13:40distribution typically it's it's it's a really hard and rare
- 1:13:45mindset to do otherwise like not many people actually buy low in
- 1:13:49an accumulation phase and then sell high or or buy low and Holt
- 1:13:53right which which works well in Bitcoin to.
- 1:13:56But in stocks this this data point here number it's on the
- 1:14:01fourth line. It's a cyst.
- 1:14:02Tiny little arrow. Here, they get barely any games.
- 1:14:05And it doesn't even really create wealth for most Americans
- 1:14:10when they're buying just equities and in their brokerage
- 1:14:15accounts. So it's kind of shocking.
- 1:14:17And then other than that group is other Financial assets and
- 1:14:20other non-financial. They're just catch all's in this
- 1:14:22like Bill the pool in for financial assets like any other
- 1:14:26credit claims or you know, there's oil and gas rights in
- 1:14:30some of these and then other non-financial assets will be
- 1:14:32things like like a commodity. You hold precious metals or, you
- 1:14:38know, something else, something like anything.
- 1:14:41Physical, like any investment you would say, that's not a, not
- 1:14:45a financial security or claim if you will.
- 1:14:48So I think, when I look at that buck and I see things like CDs,
- 1:14:52cash value, life insurance is savings bonds.
- 1:14:55Like what I see in this or how I interpret this.
- 1:14:59These are kind of reflective of a a Mark or a product marketing.
- 1:15:05Or product space Financial assets.
- 1:15:07That may be used to work for people but they're no longer
- 1:15:11working right at build building and accumulating wealth Through
- 1:15:17Time, right? So Marty and I talked when I was
- 1:15:21on TC a few weeks ago about what our grandmothers would give us
- 1:15:25for Christmas. And my grandmother gave me
- 1:15:26savings bonds and Marty's gave him CDs.
- 1:15:29It's like right that anymore. Like this is This little it be
- 1:15:34system, that's no longer working and I think in the cash value
- 1:15:38life insurance, you see this to and the and the equities, right?
- 1:15:40Go look up Ellen see, you know Lincoln but you look at the
- 1:15:44insurers, like it's it's it's not a good picture, right?
- 1:15:48If you if you think about these things in terms of businesses
- 1:15:51and markets and and where the customers are, what what I love
- 1:15:54about that and that chart in particular is how it kind of
- 1:16:00connects to what we as As a society and a culture propagate
- 1:16:06as investment advice to the Next Generation you know us
- 1:16:10Millennials we've received the wisdom.
- 1:16:13That what all you got to do is go out there.
- 1:16:15Get a job max out your 401 k, get a mortgage, you're going to
- 1:16:20do great because that's what worked for our parents.
- 1:16:24That was the winning model. That's what that that's slide
- 1:16:26shows is that's all you had to do.
- 1:16:28Just max out your 401 k and pay down your mortgage and Those are
- 1:16:33the two assets that were the real winners in that whole
- 1:16:36landscape over the last 40 years.
- 1:16:40What's funny about your anecdote about Grandparents is that for
- 1:16:45that generation CDs, made more sense.
- 1:16:50Those might have been the winners for them and so that's
- 1:16:53what they are propagating was like, oh, this is a good thing
- 1:16:56to own because it will provide security and stability in a
- 1:17:01world where you can't trust You can't trust the stock market or,
- 1:17:06or equities are or home values to go up.
- 1:17:09So I and then I can't help but look forward with regard to that
- 1:17:16like we've received this wisdom, max out, your 401 k, get a
- 1:17:19mortgage but as we've talked about like this is a 40-year
- 1:17:24bull market, where the conditions that allowed for that
- 1:17:27to happen. Our over like they can't
- 1:17:31continue. The wind has reversed.
- 1:17:33And now it's headwinds. There were massive Tailwind for
- 1:17:36last 40 years and now those asset classes in particular
- 1:17:40face, headwinds. And and so then the question
- 1:17:45becomes what does when and what can deliver?
- 1:17:48The kind of performance that housing and retirement accounts
- 1:17:53did over the last 40 years, in the next 40 years.
- 1:17:56The question. Then remains is like our the
- 1:17:59headwinds actually stronger than the Tailwind that that got you
- 1:18:02to this way. Is because with the retirement
- 1:18:03accounts particularly you have like the demographic thing that
- 1:18:06mentioned it earlier the 10,000 retirees a day.
- 1:18:09And so that's like for selling you have all the money printing
- 1:18:12going on. So met indexed those charts that
- 1:18:15we showed earlier to CPI, like you're fighting inflation as
- 1:18:19well as a fall, in the value of the assets at the same time.
- 1:18:25And then Those two alone like that like was the last 30 years
- 1:18:33of Boomers investing in their 401K is investing in their
- 1:18:37housing. Maybe the housing market is like
- 1:18:38the last Bastion of savings for the retirement accounts.
- 1:18:42But when it comes to the financial assets outside of real
- 1:18:45estate like there was it all a mirage?
- 1:18:48They had this false sense of security for four decades
- 1:18:52leading up to retirement. Let's talk about housing and
- 1:18:55just, let's, let's go Common Sense.
- 1:18:56Here, the house. Um, stock the American housing
- 1:18:58stock, it's old, its aging like the medium house like you can go
- 1:19:04with this up. It's like 1980 half of the homes
- 1:19:07are built before, 1980. I think the exactly might be
- 1:19:10like 1978, so it's an aging housing stock.
- 1:19:16Odds are, if you're a new entry buyer, you know, you're in your
- 1:19:21You know, 25 to 40 type of age group, right now you're going to
- 1:19:26you're looking to buy your first home, get your down payment,
- 1:19:28whatever you're probably buying something from the existing
- 1:19:32housing stock, you know, if you're really lucky you're just
- 1:19:34not going out of the park. Maybe you can hear you get a new
- 1:19:36build right existing housing stock.
- 1:19:39You're buying an old home like it's 20, 30, 40 years old, maybe
- 1:19:44older and then right now, you know with the rate sell-off
- 1:19:50bonds are Not holding their value yields going up.
- 1:19:54You've got the 30-year mortgage rate at 7% now, like it's just
- 1:20:01his seven percent again. Back to the same level, you
- 1:20:07know, they haven't been at a seven handles since December
- 1:20:112000. So right at the end of the.com
- 1:20:14bubble. So now you're paying us seven
- 1:20:16handle. Again, you're signing up to
- 1:20:18finance his house 30 years and seven percent your sign up for
- 1:20:21all that, you know, that payment stream for, you know, most of
- 1:20:26the time it's probably gonna be a house that, you know, it's
- 1:20:27been through a few mortgages already, you're getting the same
- 1:20:30house. It's just depreciated.
- 1:20:32Another twenty twenty twenty, three years now, right, Right.
- 1:20:37What's happened since price or what's happened in that
- 1:20:39timeframe of price, the median existing home sale price.
- 1:20:46In December 2000 was about 150 K.
- 1:20:50Now it's 396 case over 100k to 400k.
- 1:20:53Like you've gone up 175 percent The new interest.
- 1:20:57Now in this system, what it's asking you to this financial
- 1:21:00system, what is asking you to do to buy your new house such as
- 1:21:05and on credit, with 30 years of payment, stream is asking by the
- 1:21:09same house at a 2.7 x 2.75. X value is older.
- 1:21:16Now it's, you know, it's got to take more input, more costs, you
- 1:21:21no more Replacements, replace, the AC unit to replace the, you
- 1:21:24know, just you name it. There's cost involved.
- 1:21:27It's a depreciating asset - A 2.75% on the same 30 years and
- 1:21:32seven percent. It's, it's it's truly
- 1:21:35mind-boggling, right? That asking this system that
- 1:21:39says, you know, hey what's that the American dream of
- 1:21:41homeownership like, you too? Young couple, you know, man, you
- 1:21:45know, you can have a garage for yourself, it's just absurd.
- 1:21:50It truly is like, we couldn't even hand it down, like that
- 1:21:52same set of opportunities for like one generation.
- 1:21:56And it's I don't know, just just common sense.
- 1:22:02It's also almost like guys some got rubbed, I was part of this.
- 1:22:06Like in 2021, you know, you're hearing.
- 1:22:09It's the common thing that Jesse was referring to is the in-laws
- 1:22:11or whoever is telling you the wise, the wisdom, you know, buy
- 1:22:16a home, diversify hold it. And you bought it two percent or
- 1:22:20whatever interest rate in the market falls out in most cities,
- 1:22:24it has, unless you're in, you know, in Austin and Asheville
- 1:22:27these markets. Now you're upside down and the
- 1:22:29recession hits. And so now you're out of a job
- 1:22:31and you're upset. Yeah, I'm in your, you know,
- 1:22:34inflation's running. So now your cost of living is
- 1:22:37going up. It's just, it's a, it's a
- 1:22:39complete vas. Every, every cycle you put
- 1:22:43through this, like it gets harder.
- 1:22:45But even still, I guess we're time.
- 1:22:47I like that. Does it work, right?
- 1:22:48When does it stop working if you had bought your house in 2018?
- 1:22:53Right now you've seen real estate prices go up now.
- 1:22:56You finance, like you got a chance like your purchase
- 1:22:59mortgage and then you got your rate cut there.
- 1:23:01Like you're going to Two and a half percent or three now for 30
- 1:23:05years, you know, like wow, these new buyers coming in or pushing
- 1:23:08my house up and they're signing up for this, you know,
- 1:23:10indentured servitude for 30 years as I will really, really
- 1:23:14hard on them. But from your perspective, as
- 1:23:18you know, someone who was in the trade even like 35 years ago, he
- 1:23:22looks like you're in the money. So it's just, it just takes time
- 1:23:26to get past that Tipping Point, but when you frame it like we
- 1:23:30just did. And you see that At this new
- 1:23:33engine, like your new home, everybody's going to be happy
- 1:23:36once they get a pair of keys and approved for a mortgage and
- 1:23:39close on their house. But you look at it in reality,
- 1:23:41it's like no you just signed up for 30 years at 7% on the same
- 1:23:46house. That was financed at that, 25
- 1:23:49years ago and now you just did it for two point seven, five, x,
- 1:23:52the price. It's like, all right.
- 1:23:54It's at what point does this? Stop working no one knows like
- 1:23:57when your You know, working through the credit bubble and I
- 1:24:03count the mortgages as a big part of that, right more, the
- 1:24:07home prices like Banks, lend against them at Scrabble
- 1:24:10collateral. It's, it's writing that same
- 1:24:13Trend up. So, at some point, like, your
- 1:24:16prior entrance of the market, well maybe I felt like in 2022,
- 1:24:19it wasn't going so well for your buyers and 2020 and 2021.
- 1:24:23But oh wait, this next batch, will will push the tab on them
- 1:24:27and I think that just push Is to the.
- 1:24:31So, the lack of fairness and the Dynamics of the system, right?
- 1:24:34We're asking the youth to sign up for that.
- 1:24:37It's just, it's it boggles. My mind that we are offering
- 1:24:42away. It's like, basically, we're
- 1:24:43choosing to eat our young and that's what that existing kind
- 1:24:47of framework that Financial that could be, the credit based
- 1:24:50Financial system is willing to do.
- 1:24:54And then if you go over here and play in Bitcoin, it's the, you
- 1:24:58know, those same set of rules and circumstances like you will
- 1:25:01Don't they don't expect that. That's not, you know, part of
- 1:25:05the part of the tape table Stakes of adopting onto under
- 1:25:08that system. Yeah, anyone need to earn
- 1:25:10talking about like, a long-term store value that coin your utx
- 1:25:15is don't depreciate. You don't have any maintenance
- 1:25:17fees on them. If you're cussing at yourself,
- 1:25:21you can it's extremely liquid. You know what to worry about the
- 1:25:24interest rate environment, and whether or not, you'll be able
- 1:25:26to offload your Bitcoin on the somebody else, there's always
- 1:25:28gonna be a buyer on the other side of the market there.
- 1:25:31You can take it wherever you want, it's not location
- 1:25:34dependent, Like Houses obviously has a state where it is.
- 1:25:38There's a few houses outside of RVs and mobile homes that you
- 1:25:42can, you can take with you. But yeah.
- 1:25:45Well, I'm going to comes to housing to.
- 1:25:46It does feel like we're at, like, the Wily coyote moment,
- 1:25:50where I think that's been the big theme the last couple weeks
- 1:25:52of the home builder. Stocks been ripping, because
- 1:25:55people are realizing that nobody wants to sell their house.
- 1:25:59And then go get a seven percent. Baggage if they have these two
- 1:26:02and a half three percent mortgages locked in.
- 1:26:05So people are literally being forced to go build new homes
- 1:26:08that they can then move into. Yeah I keep thinking about the
- 1:26:14book when money dies and that's a about all these little
- 1:26:19vignettes and stories from why my Germany of like what what
- 1:26:24that investment landscape and environment and climate looked
- 1:26:28like and how that evolved and just stories from And hard
- 1:26:33assets did so well and speculators on hard assets did
- 1:26:37well on the surface because it looked like they were doing
- 1:26:41well. But really, what was happening
- 1:26:42is the money was losing its value and and I am starting to
- 1:26:48wonder if we're kind of seeing that with housing in our current
- 1:26:55ERA where there's a flight to hard assets and for our Culture.
- 1:27:01That means a house and it's the only thing you can trust because
- 1:27:07they're printing more and more of the, of the currency and when
- 1:27:12money dies, in our current ERA is translating into, like, okay,
- 1:27:17just you just, you're going to be fine.
- 1:27:18If you have a house, you just get your house, you pay,
- 1:27:22whatever arm and a leg and ironically or paradoxically that
- 1:27:28can work out as a as Investment because as the money is dying,
- 1:27:34in their printing more and more of it, the inflation causes the
- 1:27:38value that home to shoot upwards.
- 1:27:40So like if the covid stimulus was the reason for the real
- 1:27:47estate, boom, that happened in the two years following, which I
- 1:27:50think it was, you know, house prices went up 30% in two years
- 1:27:56and during a pandemic and I think it was because the He was
- 1:28:01dying a little bit more, right then.
- 1:28:04And what's wild about that is that people who were sitting on
- 1:28:08a mortgage saw the equity of their home or the market Equity
- 1:28:15that they could realize increase because they were holding this
- 1:28:22debt, contract that they had to pay out in nominal dollars from
- 1:28:25the past. So the loser there in that
- 1:28:28situation is the bank. Which is kind of a surprising.
- 1:28:36And in rare feeling, if that is what's happening here.
- 1:28:39If if real estate continues to Boom, as the money dies, the
- 1:28:44dollar dies, the dollar has to be inflated away because we have
- 1:28:48to inflate away the national debt.
- 1:28:52Real estate could be one of those things that on paper works
- 1:28:57out well because it's sort of retaining, its purchasing power
- 1:29:01Power. Even if it is losing in real
- 1:29:04terms, it can still do well in nominal terms and and people
- 1:29:09will think that there are geniuses for investing in real
- 1:29:12estate. So I wonder if like a starter
- 1:29:16home here and Allah I went from before the pandemic starter home
- 1:29:19was like seven hundred thousand dollars in l.a.
- 1:29:22It's an expensive housing market.
- 1:29:24Now it's a million and it's not going down from or maybe it will
- 1:29:29but it hasn't gone down from the a pandemic rally.
- 1:29:33So now a starter home is million dollars, seven percent mortgage.
- 1:29:39Good luck thing, you're seventy thousand dollars of interest you
- 1:29:45know on an annualized. But and we could see another if
- 1:29:51we have another crisis that necessitates massive stimulus,
- 1:29:54which I think is what we're heading towards we have another
- 1:29:59covid style stimulus and they print you know they have to
- 1:30:03print a bunch more the housing market could see the same sort
- 1:30:06of 30-40 percent. Bump happen again.
- 1:30:10And then a starter home is is suddenly 1.3 1.4 million and
- 1:30:16whoever got in at this level looks like they're a winner, a
- 1:30:20nominal terms but it's the money dying.
- 1:30:24Ultimately there's a corridor here imagining right?
- 1:30:30There's there's the Melt up, right?
- 1:30:31They prices continue to go up or is there's the deflationary bust
- 1:30:37when you know we Lies in this game of musical chairs, right?
- 1:30:41There's not enough economic activity out there for everybody
- 1:30:43to service their debt. And then what the banks have to
- 1:30:46foreclose on everybody, you're saying end up with an angry
- 1:30:50populace, you know, one way or the other like you're leaving
- 1:30:54out the new general, the new entrance, you know, gets harder
- 1:30:58and harder for them to achieve the same things, you know, with
- 1:31:02each Progressive generation or it just ends in pain for, for
- 1:31:07everybody. It's It's an unstable kind of
- 1:31:11type your trying to very unstable to operate.
- 1:31:15So Jesse that's really a, there's something really.
- 1:31:18They're like when you said about because the common, there's
- 1:31:21something like Insidious about, the common monitor narrative is
- 1:31:25where do you put, you can't eat your, you can eat your balls,
- 1:31:27you're getting your say your stock, but you need a house, you
- 1:31:30can limit it. And so the thought is, you just
- 1:31:32buy you, buy your home. And that's where you put the
- 1:31:34money, and this I was Remember, like so Fannie Mae and the
- 1:31:41government subsidized for homes was happen after the Great
- 1:31:43Depression? And there's after this big craft
- 1:31:46and there's something to like this fact of?
- 1:31:49Well you don't know if the money stays in these other places but
- 1:31:52you can live in the home, we can put our dollars if the way for
- 1:31:55Capital to flow and it's not until you have the opportunity
- 1:31:58cost we talked about, I think on the first episode when you did I
- 1:32:02was part of this before finding Bitcoin is like you saved
- 1:32:06capital and what do you do with it?
- 1:32:07You don't really know about this dog.
- 1:32:09Ox and you remember something happen to know a and that it's
- 1:32:12not necessarily the safest place is your thing about where does
- 1:32:15it go and look well I guess you're supposed to buy a home
- 1:32:17and it appreciates and you see and Market but then that
- 1:32:21completely changes when you think about the opportunity
- 1:32:24cost. So you have the down payment
- 1:32:25then we talked about and then what's the current person BTC
- 1:32:29and the liquidity profile and and all the things that go along
- 1:32:32with that assessment that just doesn't exist.
- 1:32:34When you're looking at it from the traditional lens of what
- 1:32:37Matt was showing on. Traditionally balance sheet of
- 1:32:40an individual and I think, that's exactly, right.
- 1:32:44It's like when the money dies, when you don't have anywhere
- 1:32:46else to put it, you're putting in the place that at least if
- 1:32:48everything else do you have a place to like, live in a place
- 1:32:51to, you know, shelter, your family.
- 1:32:53It's a very, very sad and scary thing because when you're
- 1:32:57whenever the thing does fall out Maris point about the Wily
- 1:33:01coyote, like it's not gonna be good for anybody.
- 1:33:04And then just leave be holding these bags and mortgages at a
- 1:33:07talk about the price just ran them.
- 1:33:09Talking last night about the in-laws.
- 1:33:12Penthouse, that was 18,000 dollars.
- 1:33:14When they first bought it, I've been, I mean, this is like, you
- 1:33:16know, a small town or whatever, but it's still point that every
- 1:33:22year, your 20, 30 years depreciating, so the assets not
- 1:33:26getting better in the prices, basically, 10 to 20 x, that
- 1:33:29there's something very wrong with that system.
- 1:33:32Yeah. When the Wily coyote, Reality
- 1:33:37sets in and gravity takes over, I guess like the the historical
- 1:33:43parallel that pops out is Luke. Roman has been talking about
- 1:33:48Israel in the 80s and what they had to do to get out from under
- 1:33:51their debt situation, which was in massive inflation to inflate
- 1:33:56away, the debt. And the bondholders are the
- 1:33:59losers. So that's who gets robbed in
- 1:34:03order to get out from under a crushing debt.
- 1:34:06It's the bond holders and and you can think like that's the
- 1:34:10banks, but it's ultimately the people who have 60/40 portfolios
- 1:34:15in the 40% gets just just evaporated and in a way that's
- 1:34:22sort of happening. I mean what Matt was walking
- 1:34:24through, 25% purchasing power destruction, in three years,
- 1:34:30that's that process in action. Of course, it can go a lot
- 1:34:35further. And that's your debt Jubilee
- 1:34:41which is a funny thing where, you know, you could have
- 1:34:44homeowners who have this nominal debt contract suddenly find that
- 1:34:51it's much easier to pay that off but their 401K that includes it
- 1:34:57a large Bond. Allocation is also robbed from.
- 1:35:03So you know they depends on Your allocated, then, right?
- 1:35:07If you're overweight your house, then you come out ahead.
- 1:35:12If you know of torture 40% Bond portfolio on allocation well.
- 1:35:18So yeah, It ultimately, this could really hurt pensions is
- 1:35:22kind of the long and short of it like and retirees in particular,
- 1:35:26who shift? So greater percentages, they
- 1:35:29serve on allocations based off the charts that match just
- 1:35:33showed like it, it is. Unlike back to the Don't, you
- 1:35:36know, when to the, when money dies point that you make, like,
- 1:35:38people feel like they're Wealthy on paper because asset values
- 1:35:42are going like is that are like that.
- 1:35:44That was the point of trying to make earlier like has last 30
- 1:35:46years of these Boomers building up to retire.
- 1:35:49It's just been the Mirage that they think it's their.
- 1:35:52So like if you mentioned a 60/40 stock Bond split but like
- 1:35:57towards like Matt and I went over it like the target date
- 1:35:59funds. Like they shift you to 80/20
- 1:36:01bonds Stocks by the end and if you have a 25 percent fall Fall
- 1:36:06in person, power of those bonds of that.
- 1:36:08That's 20% of your overall portfolio as you're heading into
- 1:36:11retirement right now. Over the last three years, which
- 1:36:14is insane. I think.
- 1:36:16Yeah, what it amounts to is like, all that exists are the
- 1:36:19goods and services in the economy.
- 1:36:20Everything else is just claims on those, right?
- 1:36:22If you look at what we stacked the system, what it's done.
- 1:36:25Like just By, you know, trying to manage the business cycle,
- 1:36:32like with the fiscal policy, monetary policy and stimulus to
- 1:36:38try to smooth that out over, you know, basically the entire time
- 1:36:41since World War Two seventy years, what you've ended up
- 1:36:46doing is creating more claims on the goods and services that
- 1:36:50exist in the economy didn't than exists, right?
- 1:36:52Because we think like, oh you create more credit, that'll
- 1:36:55increase the amount of good. And services account.
- 1:36:57That'll that'll increase growth, right?
- 1:36:59That's the framework. It's like he just got the money.
- 1:37:01The money multiplier from just policy and fiscal stimulus, it
- 1:37:06will work whatever. And it clearly doesn't write you
- 1:37:09look at the charts, it's like the amount of credit creation
- 1:37:11versus the amount of economic growth and they it doesn't keep
- 1:37:13up. So at some point he has to make
- 1:37:16right now. What's the amount of dollar
- 1:37:17credit claims outstanding? Iif says, it's 300 trillion
- 1:37:22dollars. You don't really know how much
- 1:37:24credit of the out there and then you let the GDP just On the
- 1:37:28order of like 25 million dollars.
- 1:37:30Alright, even if you don't spend any are, you know, you put in no
- 1:37:35you know maintenance or who ate everything that goes into
- 1:37:38maintaining that GDP. The next 12 years is already
- 1:37:42spoken for like the claims already exists.
- 1:37:44So now if we just keep getting more credit, it got more claims.
- 1:37:47You got more claims built up on the same amount of goods and
- 1:37:50services essentially. Like you're not going to get
- 1:37:52real growth and we've known that like the book Has been written.
- 1:37:57That real growth is not coming out of this system, like we've
- 1:38:00known that. Since at least 2008, if you're a
- 1:38:02policy maker, it should be, you know, written written in stone,
- 1:38:07not in pencil anymore. Like it's known this system.
- 1:38:09The credit creation model is not creating and criminal growth.
- 1:38:13Yeah so not the Google. Yeah go ahead Jeff Booth in
- 1:38:18price of Tomorrow. Lays out how its incremental
- 1:38:22four dollars of debt to drive one dollar of GDP growth.
- 1:38:26Point just not a winning bargain and then if you keep doing that,
- 1:38:31right, like essentially get to a point where it just.
- 1:38:33It just keeps putting you further and further behind and I
- 1:38:35think yep so policymakers have realized this now and there is a
- 1:38:40hesitant so you're saying like there's going to be another
- 1:38:43deflationary crisis, something like 2008 something like 20 20
- 1:38:47but at this point we know like the the Lessons Learned after
- 1:38:502020. I've shown you like the that is
- 1:38:52not, you know, an infinite trick.
- 1:38:55You just can't keep doing that. Expect this to get get better
- 1:38:58like for example like China stimulus, right there.
- 1:39:01They see the writing on the wall like the global economy is
- 1:39:04slowing their exports are slowing etcetera and they're
- 1:39:08only just starting to apply you know the The most like just a
- 1:39:14couple pinches of salt worth of stimulus and I will cut the
- 1:39:17policy rates by 10 bets or something.
- 1:39:19They're not coming in with Bazookas, you know, like they
- 1:39:22did in q1 of 2020 because they know that what they thought was
- 1:39:26a steroid. It's it's actually you know,
- 1:39:29more likely a poison and you just keep putting yourself more
- 1:39:32and more behind. And I think at this point,
- 1:39:33everybody is realize that. And now we're in the mode where
- 1:39:38it's like we like as policymakers, like if you're
- 1:39:40setting monetary policy, it's like oh no, we have to We have
- 1:39:43to earn her to the downside risks and try to over tighten,
- 1:39:47as you know, be stronger. You know, don't be so he like
- 1:39:51easy, don't be doves, be Hawks and you see that around the
- 1:39:54world like you saw to Central bank's today.
- 1:39:57Like Norway was one of the increasing rates.
- 1:39:59So they they're they're swinging the pendulum back, the other
- 1:40:04direction, almost. And then that goes banging back
- 1:40:07up to the point of, when money dies, their Lepard, you know,
- 1:40:11highlights Sorry for the that apologies highlights, the mermen
- 1:40:18and chartright the gold price in the Weimar inflation and if you
- 1:40:23just look at the average of, it's just like, oh that's a
- 1:40:25smooth edges by gold and hold it.
- 1:40:26And it's like, no, you realize like, it's it's a system that
- 1:40:31wants to toggle from like inflationary melt up to
- 1:40:36deflationary bus and just going to swing in between.
- 1:40:39And it's a, it's a really, and messy chaotic.
- 1:40:42Process. And I think we're, I
- 1:40:46collectively only just starting to awaken up to that fact.
- 1:40:50I think the bells went off in 2020 and that's the world we're
- 1:40:53living in now. Yeah, I get the sense that we
- 1:40:55are on track for a deflationary crunch that will then move
- 1:41:02around and has brought up this phrase that isn't from him, but
- 1:41:07I heard it from him. So I credit him that deflation
- 1:41:11is the Midwife of hyperinflation and and you know, you're the
- 1:41:17deflationary crunch causes the crisis that necessitates, the
- 1:41:20stimulus that causes the inflation and and that's what
- 1:41:24the trajectory. Why Marv was was increasing
- 1:41:28volatility in inflation. So not the average inflation
- 1:41:32rate went up over time, but it was actually just an increasing
- 1:41:35whipsaw between High inflation and negative inflation.
- 1:41:40Deflation that ultimately led to that to money dying.
- 1:41:44There Exciting times General. I like it all.
- 1:41:51I could think about was thinking about you know, chasing from a
- 1:41:56personal or institution perspective BlackRock ETF and
- 1:42:01trying to get a Bitcoin allocation over time to you
- 1:42:05know, be able to sustain the living that people will honor
- 1:42:09the average guns but then it ended up and I was thinking
- 1:42:12halfway through, this is oh there's very bullish and the
- 1:42:14other side was like, oh, but come with Bitcoin sets of
- 1:42:16coinbase. Right.
- 1:42:22It's a I mean, it's yeah. It is a call for us to build
- 1:42:27people out there to build products that are able for
- 1:42:31others to adopt that are have more principles that are, you
- 1:42:33know what we know about it. Just kind of help it go through
- 1:42:36that progression of. Okay, well, they're going to go,
- 1:42:38they're going to be a gradual. And, and Liam are going to
- 1:42:40recognize Bitcoin as a NASA, and black rocks, and the inability
- 1:42:44for that to happen. It's going to be helpful.
- 1:42:46But then, over time, that Simply put them in this position to
- 1:42:49hold a lot if they're in the majority of be PC via KOIN
- 1:42:53videos you can you can get it right here.
- 1:42:56You can you can have the right conclusion and have the right
- 1:43:00allocation and still pick the wrong investment vehicle that
- 1:43:04ends up becoming a goose egg because of some unknown risk.
- 1:43:08On some hidden risk in the governance or custody model of
- 1:43:12that vehicle. And I'm afraid that that's going
- 1:43:15to happen. It's happened in do with block
- 1:43:19five, people who put in there, their hard-earned money into
- 1:43:23Celsius because they thought that they could live off of the
- 1:43:26interest, you know? And that's going to be a winning
- 1:43:29model and I can retire early. Nope.
- 1:43:31That's a goose egg. Same with block, fi people who
- 1:43:37had lots of assets on FTX and wall Street's going to do that,
- 1:43:42too. In some different ways that
- 1:43:46outcome is going to happen. For Wall Street, firms, who are
- 1:43:51going to go through the learning curve of how to correctly,
- 1:43:53engage with this asset, this asset class in general, and it's
- 1:43:59a real shame because there's going to be a lot of people
- 1:44:01whose pensions they're going to have the bond portion of their
- 1:44:06pension go up in smoke, and they're going to be thrilled
- 1:44:12that they got some Bitcoin, you know, as part of their
- 1:44:17allocation. You and that part's going to do
- 1:44:19well. And some of those people are
- 1:44:21still going to get a goose egg because they had it with the
- 1:44:25wrong custodian or the wrong governance model.
- 1:44:29And that's why Bitcoin education is so important here.
- 1:44:33Yeah, and I think it's important like this is part of this
- 1:44:37podcast but also anchoring it to real-world practicality, Jesse,
- 1:44:41with Jesse just referenced we saw happen with Ira accounts
- 1:44:46with Gemini, So there's a firm and remember the name, but if
- 1:44:50you Google Gemini are a, it'll come up that you use Gemini at
- 1:44:55and there's actually two in both had Gemini involved.
- 1:44:57One was the firm used Gemini as the custodian and these are
- 1:45:02boomers so they have an allocation, they got fish.
- 1:45:04And so there was I think 50 to 75 million dollars and if you
- 1:45:07think about the one amount like the one allocation of funds is
- 1:45:10your retirement should just be offline Cold Storage, you don't
- 1:45:12need it they lost they got the trade completely right and They
- 1:45:17were drugged because of the custodian and like just the
- 1:45:21intermediary and in the other side of it, which Gemini also
- 1:45:24had involved in a different relation is they had a
- 1:45:27partnership with eagle Borough which is kind of a quasi.
- 1:45:32I'll get it a little wrong, but attack platform for a phase in
- 1:45:35our is that are supposed to be super prudent risk averse, but
- 1:45:38they love the yield in. So, between the FAA is looking
- 1:45:42at that and also, you know, Gemini having right next to
- 1:45:45their do the building to get that.
- 1:45:47Whatever Genesis was promising that these FAS and clients were
- 1:45:51like oh I see three percent. I can get this on there and now
- 1:45:54there's a close to a billion dollar hole that sitting between
- 1:45:57that from people. Oh and there's you still found
- 1:45:59the trade but because the vehicle wasn't correct because
- 1:46:02the assets different than just the dollars and whatever
- 1:46:05happened to Robin Hood, you click a button you revert.
- 1:46:07It doesn't work that way in this asset.
- 1:46:09And so that's a big part of all this is like we're not just
- 1:46:11saying these things because we're thinking about a possibly
- 1:46:13could like we see this happen time and time.
- 1:46:15Again, it's important to like talk about it.
- 1:46:17Then share so that it doesn't happen to the individuals were
- 1:46:20involved with and so you need to know what your belly, do.
- 1:46:24Some do your research, anytime you put Bitcoin or, you know,
- 1:46:28you were talking about dollars and yielding products and
- 1:46:31putting them in a rapper, right, history.
- 1:46:35You know, the young history of you know the Bitcoin experiment
- 1:46:38has made one thing. Clear?
- 1:46:40And that's ultimately those things that you thought were
- 1:46:42Bitcoin will turn into like once it's in the court of law it's a
- 1:46:46credit. You just bought a credit.
- 1:46:48And you took credit risk with no upside.
- 1:46:51Like, there's no positive upside in this for you, and it goes
- 1:46:54back to what I talked about. Like there's there's Alpha on
- 1:46:57the table here for the person, the individual or Partnerships
- 1:47:02who want to learn an exercise personal responsibility.
- 1:47:06Like this is, this is a tool but it's on you to learn how to, you
- 1:47:13know, understand it and kind of map.
- 1:47:17A path. Like the ownership structure
- 1:47:19that works on this and this new paradigm we had don't buy a what
- 1:47:23you thought was an equity that's the opposite of a convertible
- 1:47:26Bond, right? You think you have a bond with
- 1:47:27some upside like a turned into the good thing.
- 1:47:30If things went well you're very like when you buy products like
- 1:47:33that, it's you're doing the opposite, you're you're buying
- 1:47:36thumb, something you thought was like an equity like or risk like
- 1:47:39product, like with a return profile and turned out.
- 1:47:41You, you bought a credit, then it turned into the credit.
- 1:47:43When things ultimately went went bad for you, if you You want,
- 1:47:49you want Susan, his yard? Yeah, exactly.
- 1:47:53The yeah, I mean, and when you put it like in this context to,
- 1:47:56that would be one of the saddest things that could ever happen
- 1:48:00is, you're riding the wave. Bitcoin is the six figures,
- 1:48:03seven figures, maybe you're like, yes, I made it and you get
- 1:48:07to the end and you get robbed because, you know, who you know,
- 1:48:11who loves this, the lawyers, the lawyers, love it, like Isis long
- 1:48:17drawn-out. Out of court battles, Etc.
- 1:48:19And it just you know that's who you're your allocation is is
- 1:48:23ultimately going to go to like a big chunk of it will go to as
- 1:48:26the. Yeah, let me see.
- 1:48:27Now box is going on 10 years now of that, that whole case.
- 1:48:33So well that and that just remind me of it's in, may not
- 1:48:36even be the rugged, may be self-inflicted, in the sense of,
- 1:48:40not only the wrong decision, but the wrong philosophy.
- 1:48:42These, we talked about ESG, whatever the narrative is going
- 1:48:45to be. People may fall into that trap.
- 1:48:47Rap of like oh of course the proof of work is bad and what
- 1:48:50Block rock has it under or over the large entity is like oh
- 1:48:54that's that's that's not mine coin.
- 1:48:57Whatever, they know wrong decision there and they hold
- 1:49:00zero going, don't let Fink think for you, okay?
- 1:49:04It's an original thoughts. DSG is an ephemeral Trend That
- 1:49:07Dying. You do not want to get on the
- 1:49:10ESG Bitcoin train. You're going to get.
- 1:49:13You're ready. At present the coin bag isn't
- 1:49:15Bitcoin bad for the environment, Freddie, Prinze Bitcoin.
- 1:49:19Honestly, earnestly believe this Bitcoin is the Catalyst for The
- 1:49:28environmentalist future that like we want to see like we're
- 1:49:30going to be extremely efficient from an energy perspective.
- 1:49:35I mean, it can beat the dead horse on how Bitcoin mining
- 1:49:38makes us extremely energy-efficient off-grid and
- 1:49:41on-grid miners are economically, incentivize the find the lowest
- 1:49:46cost energy that is energy is wasted or stranded
- 1:49:50underutilized. So just by going and taking that
- 1:49:54electricity is being wasted and utilizing it to produce.
- 1:49:56Pick one. Efficiency, gain stranded
- 1:49:59energy. Same thing, you're tapping into
- 1:50:01something that is out in the wild and cannot be brought to
- 1:50:05Market. You bring the market to that
- 1:50:06thing and you might have ties a beautiful thing.
- 1:50:09That's the first-order effect of the energy.
- 1:50:11Second order effect is the monetary policy which actually
- 1:50:13brings opportunity cost back to markets.
- 1:50:16They have to weigh Capital, allocation decisions.
- 1:50:18You're not just able to print money and throat, willy-nilly at
- 1:50:22stuff that probably should have be invested or have Capital
- 1:50:26allocated it too. So yeah, Bitcoin is incredibly
- 1:50:31good for the environment directly and indirectly first
- 1:50:34order and second order effect. Again, most is the thing out
- 1:50:41there. Actually, if it was, if you sp
- 1:50:43was actually about environmental social governance, this is that
- 1:50:51because it's the greatest Tailwind for, for renewable
- 1:50:55energy and it brings like equity and property rights to everyone
- 1:51:05in the world whose unbanked And prevents those people from being
- 1:51:09robbed via inflation. And so it empowers the
- 1:51:16individual and a way that nothing on Earth, Currently
- 1:51:20does. And yet it is smeared as this
- 1:51:24thing that is bad for the world or bad for the environment when
- 1:51:28the opposite is true. But maybe, maybe Martin Larry
- 1:51:33know. Even with that being said, I was
- 1:51:34just about to say, I know what you're going to say when I was
- 1:51:37Jesse don't even fall into their framework.
- 1:51:38Yes G is a oh yeah is it dog wasn't for control like they
- 1:51:42just they don't care about the environment.
- 1:51:43They don't care about social justice.
- 1:51:44They don't care about go. That's right.
- 1:51:46They don't care if it was actually about that.
- 1:51:50Then then Would be in in the good graces of BlackRock, but
- 1:51:54it's not about e/s orgy. It's about what we deem to be,
- 1:52:03you know, a good corporate citizen based on what's good for
- 1:52:06BlackRock and the US government. Yeah, well to bring that this
- 1:52:11back in a long time, the energy and with the with the BlackRock
- 1:52:14ETF. I think as this plays out over
- 1:52:17time and we're talking like years, you see?
- 1:52:21I didn't ETF. We'll bring Capital into into
- 1:52:26Bitcoin, will go through layers, but it has to get there.
- 1:52:31And then you see how the mechanisms of how kind of the
- 1:52:37financialization kind of engine is now going to have to plug in
- 1:52:41and play in this new space, right?
- 1:52:42You see a market that has to go has to go by UT EXO's into it
- 1:52:46and do a into a no offer market. Now energy is kind of back.
- 1:52:52Instead of taking a back seat for the last 15 years and
- 1:52:57policy. I mean, and and every table that
- 1:53:01matters, now, now energy as backup, you know, at the front
- 1:53:07of the, the wedding reception at those tables, close to the, to
- 1:53:10the decision-making. So I think it gets energy back
- 1:53:12involved as a stakeholder and then I think it's just part of
- 1:53:17this broader process of financialization suppressing.
- 1:53:22Input costs throughout the economy, right?
- 1:53:25You can you see this everywhere? Like it's the WTF happened in
- 1:53:291971 charge, right? You see, labor costs like just
- 1:53:33flatlining, you can see it in Commodities.
- 1:53:36Charts you go go. Look at the Copper chart like
- 1:53:38long-term. You see it break right about
- 1:53:42between the.com bubble in 2008, see these cost inputs just going
- 1:53:47up, you see, iron, ore, Etc. And it's like, I think it's just
- 1:53:51a part of Everything breaking the kind of the engine of
- 1:53:56financialization that was, you know, keeping things.
- 1:54:01Stable prices low for 40 years and now you slowly see,
- 1:54:06everything, like just one rivet at a time.
- 1:54:09You know, people look at the oil markets, you saw pressure
- 1:54:13buildup in 2008, you saw the technology of fracking, you
- 1:54:18know, kind of alleviate some of that pressure, right?
- 1:54:21And provide a deflation in oil, but the thing about the credit
- 1:54:23system is, it has to fill any deflationary whole, any
- 1:54:29technological advancement You know, any a me, anything,
- 1:54:34anything new, it has to gobble it up and you know, just create
- 1:54:40more credit. You know.
- 1:54:41It will just abhor all of that vacuum.
- 1:54:45So I'll just continue to suck out here in space.
- 1:54:48I think if there's one positive coming out of this week, I think
- 1:54:50this is, you know, as as kind of Bitcoin and then the Legacy
- 1:54:58Financial system, the credit money You know, the credit
- 1:55:01dollar standard go head-to-head, you start see these two binary
- 1:55:05Stars orbiting and there can only be one winner coming out of
- 1:55:08this room over the long run, you know, that will be a messy
- 1:55:12process in between. But I think those linkages are
- 1:55:14there over time. The, the economics win at the
- 1:55:19end of the day. It's undefeated, and we're
- 1:55:23going, we're going to find out. This is the exciting thing.
- 1:55:26So you know what? What is on maintainable will not
- 1:55:30be maintained over the long run? Which then means what Marty
- 1:55:35what's that phrase that you like to say?
- 1:55:38We're going to throw a grenade at the Fiat system.
- 1:55:40Okay? Which phrase we're going to win.
- 1:55:45Oh we are going to with yeah cause we got the mechatronics
- 1:55:48wins. We got a binary star problem
- 1:55:51here. One doesn't have the economics
- 1:55:54to support it yet. Other does that mean I win?
- 1:55:58And I think as much as we've been doing our grading BlackRock
- 1:56:05and their particular fun structure and the custody model,
- 1:56:08I do think it is a signal like me, eat you compound that
- 1:56:14announcement with Jerome Powell to house sir Financial Services
- 1:56:18committee meeting saying. Yeah, I think crypto staying
- 1:56:20power with like Fidelity Schwab. Citadel, I think the incumbent
- 1:56:28Financial system does understand the gravity of the problem to a
- 1:56:32certain extent. And they at the very least view
- 1:56:36Bitcoin is something like, alright, if these guys are,
- 1:56:38right, we should at least have some exposure to this and, and
- 1:56:43lead in at least a little bit as a hedge, which yeah, yeah, yeah,
- 1:56:48reality is, you have to take what the market gives you.
- 1:56:50There's a lot of opining on. Is it?
- 1:56:52Good or bad for bigger ones like it's happening?
- 1:56:55And so you have to build products and services that the
- 1:56:57market wants that fit to the model of it.
- 1:56:59It's going to happen to well. Yeah exactly that's something
- 1:57:02mvk says all the time if she tweeted earlier this week it's
- 1:57:06we can have our critiques on particular ways.
- 1:57:12Bitcoin products are structured by certain companies.
- 1:57:17That's also the beauty bit more Bitcoins and open permission
- 1:57:19list system if people want to interact with the protocol
- 1:57:24there. There's nobody to stop them from
- 1:57:26doing something. Download the software, if they
- 1:57:28can get access to private, public key Pairs, and put UT
- 1:57:31x's, and then they can begin building.
- 1:57:33Structured Products around that. If you want to Michael's point,
- 1:57:37you can sit here and cry about it and whine about it and say,
- 1:57:40oh, this is the way to do it or you can go out and out-compete,
- 1:57:43build better products that the market will recognize over time.
- 1:57:50Which we're coming up on two hours.
- 1:57:52And before we we wrap up here, speaking of products and things
- 1:57:56that people are building in the space, I think is a good time to
- 1:58:00sort of wrap up on a good note on a white pill note on how
- 1:58:03Bitcoin fitting into traditional credit portfolios can sort of
- 1:58:08help ease the pain of the transition as we go with what
- 1:58:11you guys are building a bill bet.
- 1:58:14Awesome. Yeah, so I think I've been
- 1:58:17pretty public about this, but we're working on a project with
- 1:58:19unchain for a long time. Marty, you've talked a lot about
- 1:58:22Auntie FTC and our HR over time about their lending model and
- 1:58:27their best practices built around their, their multisig
- 1:58:30vaults. And then a lot like the, the
- 1:58:35on-ramp custody model where you bring in Key Management with
- 1:58:39multiple stakeholders on challenging works the same way.
- 1:58:43So, Unchained is really. If you think about it, we've
- 1:58:45talked about earlier about all these blow-ups block, feis
- 1:58:49Celsius, and they don't need to be named, they don't, they they
- 1:58:52shouldn't be remembered, just put them in the, you know, just
- 1:58:55tombstones of the body count of mistakes that have been made and
- 1:58:59lessons hard learned, as people try to figure out how to build
- 1:59:03upon the the resilience and soundness of Bitcoin
- 1:59:06infrastructure. But on chains, lending model is
- 1:59:10something that really stuck out to me.
- 1:59:12As I was Considering and 2020 and 2021 as we were watching
- 1:59:18that bond market, sell-off get underway and I realized this
- 1:59:21isn't going to work for our clients and this is a mission
- 1:59:23that I've kind of been going after four.
- 1:59:26I'd say 10 years, the last 10 years of my life.
- 1:59:29Just knowing that something was coming with these Bond
- 1:59:32allocations and that something had to be done to save our, you
- 1:59:37know, our parents friends families Etc.
- 1:59:39Are, you know, the workers aren't communities.
- 1:59:41You guys talked about municipal, As firefighters police officers
- 1:59:46Etc. Our communities need saving
- 1:59:48here. So this is where you know we got
- 1:59:52we need to build solutions to solve that and that means not
- 1:59:55just, you know, getting people to understand Bitcoin if they do
- 2:00:01choose to adopt teaching them, you know, the ways to do it
- 2:00:06soundly Key Management Center, that Marty and Matt do such a
- 2:00:09great job week in and week out, but it means like finding other
- 2:00:13ways. As well.
- 2:00:16And that's where the over the last.
- 2:00:19It's all it's coming up on almost two years since you know,
- 2:00:21I first met Parker and we were trying to figure out how we
- 2:00:25could get Bitcoin Incorporated to save the bond market problem
- 2:00:29that has materialized into launching billed.
- 2:00:33As a, my firm, I manage this my day job build Asset Management,
- 2:00:39we launched a private placement pooled fund, which exclusively
- 2:00:43back Invest in there in unchanged Bitcoin back loans.
- 2:00:46So if you look at the profile of how we could see a credit
- 2:00:49allocation having a fighting chance, to keep its head above
- 2:00:52water and preserve purchasing power in this environment.
- 2:00:55What are you looking for? While one minimize duration?
- 2:00:59Whereas the, you know, we Jesse part about the last 40 years,
- 2:01:02duration was your friend as raised, just kind of cycled down
- 2:01:07lower lows, lower highs for 40 years in the biggest credit bull
- 2:01:12market, you know, on the way up on that.
- 2:01:14What if things look like, on the other side this is where you
- 2:01:17have to really be clever and design solutions that you know
- 2:01:22hopefully protect your clients and allow them to preserve some
- 2:01:24purchasing power in this dollar system dollar credit system.
- 2:01:29So high nominal, you low duration and then also secured
- 2:01:36with a lot of value behind it. So 40% LTD loans, or
- 2:01:39equivalently 2.5 x over collateralized and then most
- 2:01:43importantly to Is perfecting the security interest as a lender in
- 2:01:47that in that collateral. And that's what I think as
- 2:01:51partners Unchained does a better job at or has done a better job
- 2:01:55of building, you know, very conservatively over the it's
- 2:01:59almost eight years now that they've been in existence.
- 2:02:02So shout out to Joe and the team there.
- 2:02:05We think they're onto something, I think they stood out, you
- 2:02:09know, in our due diligence as really pure 'less in.
- 2:02:14In this emergent space. So that's my day job, that's
- 2:02:18what we're doing. And then on top of that there's
- 2:02:20some other projects I'm working on.
- 2:02:22So my hometown is Jefferson City Missouri.
- 2:02:25I've been you know just shooting this idea with Marty for it's
- 2:02:29been a while but we're making it happen.
- 2:02:32We're going to hold an event in Jefferson City.
- 2:02:34Missouri, on October 26th and 27th, I'm going to call it the
- 2:02:38Bitcoin Expedition, find a good title, that's where the Lewis
- 2:02:42and Clark expedition, you know, close to a launch.
- 2:02:44It off and Jesse you've written about that to the you know, you
- 2:02:48got to go out and explore the the West, right?
- 2:02:50And that's what this this new opportunity, this new space is
- 2:02:54really exploring and educating how Bitcoin in this opportunity.
- 2:02:58I'm proud of us can really tap growth.
- 2:03:03It's that it's the next level, you know, the the next field to
- 2:03:08explore if you will. So we'll be doing that.
- 2:03:11There'll be an investor day, we're planning an education day.
- 2:03:14We were going to try to line it up with a Mizzou football game,
- 2:03:18so SEC football, hold there. Hold the tailgate other Bitcoin
- 2:03:22companies coming in and sponsor, and just meet and greet Q&A.
- 2:03:25Have a great time with your fans.
- 2:03:27Unfortunately, that's not going to work.
- 2:03:29We couldn't get a date that lined up on the schedule for
- 2:03:32just bitcoiners and in the audience as well with.
- 2:03:35There's a couple Marquee events going on around that time frame
- 2:03:38to. But hopefully, we put on a good
- 2:03:40one this year and we'll get that football game.
- 2:03:44On the calendar for next year but this is an event where you
- 2:03:49know if you're a Bitcoin or in Kansas City st.
- 2:03:51Louis Des Moines Springfield Omaha.
- 2:03:54Even go as far as like Memphis Nashville and you know, expand
- 2:03:58but it's a close drive for four to five hours and I think we're
- 2:04:01going to make a lot of Headway. Not just kind of the Marty last
- 2:04:07week on our HR. You and Matt were talking about
- 2:04:09it's the same people over and over.
- 2:04:12It's not going to be that I think will get A lot of your
- 2:04:15favorite friends and, you know, people your you've already met
- 2:04:21relationships built in the Bitcoin Community, but there's
- 2:04:23gonna be a lot of new blood here.
- 2:04:25We're making to make some some Headway Open Hearts and Minds to
- 2:04:30to learning about this new opportunity and what it can do
- 2:04:33for the region. So we're excited to announce
- 2:04:35that the website is going to be Bitcoin.
- 2:04:38Dash Expedition.com. We spun it up today, so we've
- 2:04:43got tickets available. For Friday, investor day will be
- 2:04:46on a invite basis. So just because everybody has to
- 2:04:50be an accredited investor or financial advisor and
- 2:04:54institutionalize our work in the industry.
- 2:04:55We do need to make sure that everybody coming in is just an
- 2:05:03appropriate audience by the nature.
- 2:05:05But Friday is going to be g a day.
- 2:05:07It's going to be a great time. We've got great venues book so
- 2:05:11bringing a kind of a Bitcoin, only Bitcoin focused event To
- 2:05:14hopefully somewhere that there's a lot of passionate that
- 2:05:17cleaners out there. Marty, you've probably learned
- 2:05:20this over and over again. People just reaching out to you
- 2:05:21on TFT CC episodes, but after our episode, I had people from
- 2:05:27our hometown career placement at my at where I went to graduate
- 2:05:35school at Washington. So the st.
- 2:05:36Louis, it sounded like he, they're out there, they just
- 2:05:39need that Gathering point and I think this will be submitting an
- 2:05:43event to help make that happen. Um, so that's that's something
- 2:05:46else were building. And looking to put on, I'm very
- 2:05:50much looking forward to it. That's something that has
- 2:05:53astonish me and Michael, and I talk about it every once in a
- 2:05:56while. The freaks are everywhere.
- 2:05:57It's crazy here. When you get people reaching out
- 2:06:02the across the Spectrum from your, from your plumber, to some
- 2:06:06of the wealthiest asset managers on the world, it's a special
- 2:06:11thing because we're like some special here.
- 2:06:15That's a good time to give a shout out.
- 2:06:18So there's another frequent says hi and thanks to says, hi.
- 2:06:22Thanks for Marty for helping one is Bitcoin journey and also hide
- 2:06:26in the team. He put together the audio that
- 2:06:29is going to be the new audio for the last trade he wanted.
- 2:06:33It is he goes by Johnny, hey little one on Twitter and he
- 2:06:37does musical services in Canada so he said he's available if he
- 2:06:41wants to reach out for weddings and bar mitzvahs.
- 2:06:44Well Johnny You did an incredible job.
- 2:06:46I love the intro. Should we play it now?
- 2:06:48Do you have it? Upload It should be in the
- 2:06:51slack. You should be able to is not
- 2:06:53possible when we If you can't, I'll give a little note on.
- 2:06:58If anybody seen the the Entourage when he goes on and
- 2:07:01you get the free speakers and it puts the Hat on.
- 2:07:03That's what I told him. That it feel very much like the
- 2:07:06putting on the hat to get the sneakers, but we would give them
- 2:07:08a shout out. The people have already heard.
- 2:07:10It's at the top of this episode. Matt hasn't heard it yet.
- 2:07:14What if a fast-forward? Yeah, well Matt, I think Matt
- 2:07:17Matt's gonna do it. You can well.
- 2:07:19Oh yeah, you're right. Everybody else.
- 2:07:20Let's do it twice. You guys hear that?
- 2:07:24Now, they wouldn't have heard that many whatever.
- 2:07:26All right. Well, you guys heard at the
- 2:07:27beginning of the episode for dragging on here?
- 2:07:31Matt, thank you for joining us this week.
- 2:07:34Anybody listening? Then once you learn more about
- 2:07:38the intricacies of the retirement fund landscape, go
- 2:07:43follow that. On Twitter is always tweeting.
- 2:07:45And go check out build. What's the website for build
- 2:07:49builds website is get building.com.
- 2:07:52If you'd like to learn more about this project I talked
- 2:07:55about with unchanging Go to build Bitcoin.com.
- 2:07:58And then my Twitter handle is at build CIO.
- 2:08:02Go check it out. Episode 5.
- 2:08:05The last trade in the books. Go forth and enjoy your weekend,
- 2:08:09freaks. Thanks guys.
- 2:08:12Thanks Matt. Thanks Johnnie hottel.
- 2:08:16Shut up jobs.