Latest / From the Coach's Mouth / Episode 59: Steve Hendershot
Transcript
- 0:00Now we get kind of get into the world of what I think should
- 0:03happen. And so a question of the show
- 0:05is, you know, or this investigation that I'm
- 0:08undertaking this season is like, all right, So baseball at least,
- 0:11has historically been especially important in all the sports.
- 0:15And it totally has boxed out women.
- 0:18Is it worth fixing? At the field, in your car or on
- 0:22the couch, get your basket from the coach's mouth.
- 0:41Welcome to the From the Coach's Mouth podcast with your host Jay
- 0:46Bolden and Ken Krause. Yes, hello everyone.
- 1:04We are back again with the From the Coach's Mouth podcast.
- 1:08This is Ken, of course here with my good buddy Jay Bolden.
- 1:12Jay, the pride of Indiana, how are you doing today?
- 1:16I'm doing well, Ken. How?
- 1:17How about yourself, buddy? I'm doing all right, you know,
- 1:21healthy, healthy, moving around, staying on the right side of the
- 1:24grass. So that's always good.
- 1:26That's always a positive. Yes, absolutely.
- 1:28No, it's things are good. And Speaking of Indiana, our
- 1:31conference tournament is currently going on.
- 1:33We're down there playing at the Crown Point Sports Complex.
- 1:36We are still on the winter side, which is awesome and hopefully
- 1:40we stay there all the way through it.
- 1:41But weather has been a little iffy.
- 1:43It was real feel of 39° last night and tonight looks like
- 1:47it's going to be a little bit chillier with possible rain.
- 1:49I'm just wondering when the the good weather is actually going
- 1:53to get here and and stay here. Well, it's probably going to be
- 1:56right after you get done with the conference tournament and
- 1:58when you're done playing, it'll get nice.
- 2:00Yeah, it usually works like that.
- 2:02Yeah. You know, it's actually hard for
- 2:03me to believe that we're already up to the conference tournament.
- 2:06I mean, it seems like just a couple of weeks ago we were
- 2:09talking about being excited for the opening of the season.
- 2:12Yeah, it's it. Every year it just seems to go
- 2:15faster and faster. It's like, don't blink because
- 2:18it's over really quick. Yeah, for sure.
- 2:20Hey, I want to mention something to you.
- 2:22I've I've been seeing some of these videos lately and I don't
- 2:24know if you've seen them, but it's the thing where I guess
- 2:28some coaches are teaching this to catchers.
- 2:30They have runners on 2nd and 3rd, there's two outs or maybe
- 2:33bases loaded, 2 outs, and the catcher deliberately throwing
- 2:37the ball into the batter to try to get the umpire to call the
- 2:40batter out for interference. I mean, it's so bad that I
- 2:44actually saw one that looked like the kid ran after the
- 2:47hitter, got right next to her and then just chucked the ball
- 2:50into her helmet. Yeah, I have seen, I have seen
- 2:54some of those, Ken, and I say it all the time.
- 2:56I think if it's intentional, you're just trying to hurt
- 2:59somebody and that's just, that's not the way to play this game,
- 3:01right? Those things do happen.
- 3:04I I don't expect the batter to give up the box that I don't.
- 3:07But if you're doing that on purpose just to get somebody
- 3:09out, I think, you know, that's just intentional.
- 3:12It's not a good thing at all. Yeah, To me, they shouldn't be
- 3:15calling that as interference. I think that the umpiring
- 3:18organizations or the, you know, the sanctioning organizations
- 3:21have to make sure they're getting the word out to these
- 3:23umpires that don't just assume because the batter got hit with
- 3:27a throw that it was interference or that it should be called
- 3:30interference. To me, especially one of the
- 3:32ones I saw, that shouldn't be interference, that should be an
- 3:35ejection of the catcher and maybe the coach because it was
- 3:39clear the coach taught it. Yeah, yeah.
- 3:41If it's being taught, that's just, that's absolutely wrong.
- 3:44That's absolutely wrong. Yeah, it's just not the way the
- 3:46game is meant to be played. So agreed.
- 3:49All righty. Well, should we get into our our
- 3:52guest? 100% Ken, Let's introduce this
- 3:55awesome guest we have today. This is going to be a great
- 3:57episode. Cannot wait to dig in and and
- 3:59see what our guest has to say. Well, our guest today doesn't
- 4:02come from the channels we usually draw from.
- 4:05He's not as far as we know, nor has he ever been a fast pitched
- 4:09softball coach, player or a umpire.
- 4:11In fact, until recently he has had no connection to softball
- 4:14whatsoever, although he has coached youth baseball, so he's
- 4:18not a total stranger to bat and ball sports.
- 4:21What he is instead is an award-winning journalist and
- 4:24multimedia creator whose latest project delves deep into our
- 4:27world. More on that in a bit.
- 4:30As a journalist, his work has been featured on many high level
- 4:32media outlets including WBEZWGN and WLS Radio in Chicago,
- 4:39WTTWTV, Chicago's Public TV station, Chicago Access
- 4:44Television Network, and Crane Chicago Business Magazine, among
- 4:48other outlets. As many accolades include the
- 4:51Peter J Lissiger Award, the Jesse H Neil Award, the
- 4:54Editorial Excellence Gold Award, the W3 Gold Award, and Content
- 5:00Marketing Association Awards, his content spans a wide variety
- 5:04of areas from Chicago politics to craft brewing to homelessness
- 5:08to technology to academia and education.
- 5:12He is also the author of the best selling book, Undisputed
- 5:15Street Fighter, the art and innovation behind the game
- 5:18changing series, which was named one of the best video game books
- 5:21of all time by Nintendo. Life magazine.
- 5:24Pretty sure that's a magazine my kids read his.
- 5:27His latest project is a documentary style podcast called
- 5:31UN Ingrained, which looks at ideas that are deeply ingrained
- 5:34into society and examines whether it is worth pulling them
- 5:38out. The first season takes a deep
- 5:40dive into the question of why boys are generally directed
- 5:43toward baseball while girls are directed towards softball, and
- 5:47whether that should change. Ladies and gentlemen, please
- 5:50welcome the founder of Cedar Cathedral, Steve Hendershott, to
- 5:54the From the Coach's Mouth podcast.
- 5:57Penny, Jay, good day. Good to be with you.
- 5:59Good to be with you. Welcome.
- 6:00Welcome. Thank you.
- 6:02We're glad to have you here. You know, when we first got in
- 6:05touch with you through our mutual friend Matt Bath, you
- 6:08know, looked at it and, you know, wasn't really sure what we
- 6:11were going to do or how we were looking at it.
- 6:13But, you know, the more we looked at the topic, it seemed
- 6:15like this would be a good one. Kind of goes against the grain,
- 6:19obviously, the onion grain, but, you know, against the grain of
- 6:21what Jay and I normally talk about.
- 6:23But I think there's a lot of mutual ground in there there
- 6:26that that we can explore. I'm looking forward to the to
- 6:28the conversation and to learn more about your world.
- 6:32So I know that you're a baseball coach.
- 6:34So the thing we were mentioning before, have you been seeing
- 6:36that in baseball too, with the catchers kind of hunting the
- 6:39hitters and trying to get the outs, you know, the cheap outs?
- 6:43I have not. I did have a game the other day
- 6:46that ended. It was like a massive comeback
- 6:48from 11:00 to 3:00 and 11:00 to 11:00 and then the game ended in
- 6:50the most anti climactic way on runners interference where the
- 6:54kid on 2nd plot into the shortstop.
- 6:55But I think that was the old fashioned legitimate sort of
- 6:57interference. Not the not the type you were
- 6:59just talking about, but I do. I mean, look, name your sports
- 7:03when there's a coaching technique.
- 7:07And this is the kind of thing to the point about the umpires
- 7:09associations, if that happens once or twice and it feels
- 7:13anecdotal and one off and you let it go.
- 7:14But the minute you start to discern that that's a tactic
- 7:18that's just so far out of bounds and outside the spirit of what
- 7:21this is supposed to be about, you've got to like, you know,
- 7:24squish it out not from not only from a like calls perspective by
- 7:28the, but that's just not where you want your program to be,
- 7:31right? Or even better, if you're
- 7:33teaching that, then what are you doing right?
- 7:35Like you shouldn't be, you should not be coaching then like
- 7:38again, I think, like I said there, I I don't want the batter
- 7:40to give up the box. I understand that part of it.
- 7:42But however, if you're teaching that, just throw it in the back
- 7:45of her helmet. I mean, that's just that's,
- 7:47that's wrong, wrong on every level.
- 7:49And, and as a coach, you, I mean, I always say like, respect
- 7:54the game, respect the players, win with class, lose with class.
- 7:57If you can't do that, then get out of the game.
- 7:58You don't belong in it. Well, and here's the other
- 8:00thing, who adapts fastest to the, you know, the the rules and
- 8:05the umpires are not always the fastest.
- 8:06The players are going to start noticing.
- 8:08So all of a sudden the batter in the box, you're going to start
- 8:11cheating that helmet back toward the catcher to anticipate that
- 8:14play so you can get out of the way.
- 8:15And then all of a sudden you're going to catch that thing and
- 8:17you're, you know, in the mask, not the back of the helmet.
- 8:20And you know so before that starts happening.
- 8:23Yeah, it just doesn't seem like if you can't win without doing
- 8:25stuff like that, then you really don't belong.
- 8:27Coaching. Yep.
- 8:29Couldn't agree more. All right, so let's get into the
- 8:33topic of the day though. So you've got the On Ingrained
- 8:36podcast. Can you give us an idea what
- 8:38that documentary series is all about and how it's going to
- 8:41work? Yeah.
- 8:42So this is essentially, I mean, you mentioned the The Street
- 8:45Fighter book earlier. This is a podcast, you know,
- 8:48that we'll every year we'll look at a or as often as I've managed
- 8:51to put maybe it'll be less often than a year.
- 8:53But the plan is to do these ten episode deep dives into a topic
- 8:57and each one of those looks at an idea, a cultural idea that's
- 9:00so ingrained, so invisible, you know, based on some hidden
- 9:04assumption that we didn't notice it.
- 9:05So I think for a lot of people, you know, the the question of
- 9:08like, Oh yeah, why don't girls and women play base?
- 9:10But you didn't even think to ask.
- 9:12In fact, the genesis for this particular topic happened when a
- 9:16fellow baseball coach friend of mine said, I want to start an
- 9:20all girls fall Baseball League. And I interrupted her and I
- 9:24said, you mean softball, right? And she didn't.
- 9:27That was when I realized, Oh, I I, you know, had this idea so
- 9:31close, so ingrained in my own brain that I somehow thought it
- 9:35was the right idea to just correct this person who would
- 9:37send something else. So, you know, a different story
- 9:39like that. And there are lots of those in
- 9:41society and we'll we'll unpack one of them, figure out, you
- 9:44know, a how we got here. But then also, and this is
- 9:47really relevant to baseball and softball because to tip my hand
- 9:51a little bit, I you know, I think they're different sports.
- 9:53And I don't think there's any reason why men's fast pitch
- 9:55shouldn't be a big deal. And I don't think there's any
- 9:56reason why girls women's baseball shouldn't be a big
- 9:59deal. But they're, you know, then is
- 10:01the question of like, well, now this is the state of affairs.
- 10:03Is it worth fixing or have where we landed?
- 10:05Does this make sense or is it OK even if it you know it wasn't
- 10:09the most logical path? So was it your friend that
- 10:13having that conversation that got you interested into this
- 10:16concept of going against the, the norm generally, or did you
- 10:20kind of have this already in your, in your mind a little bit?
- 10:22Was it the friend that made this like, wow, that's that would be
- 10:25a great topic to to to really dig into.
- 10:27The topic, yes, a combination of her starting the league and then
- 10:31also, you know, so I coach, I have two kids, a daughter and a
- 10:34son. My daughter is older.
- 10:36She had played Coed baseball, in part inspired by this friend,
- 10:39you know, before she started the all girls league.
- 10:41Just, you know, hey, girls should play baseball.
- 10:43Jade got excited about it. And I watched the difference in
- 10:46social dynamics between her being the girl on the team or
- 10:49the one of two or three girls on the team in the Coed situation.
- 10:52It just the coaching she got, how she responded to it, how she
- 10:55got along with other members of the team compared to when she
- 10:58finally got into a dugout on a girls team or, you know, playing
- 11:01girls basketball or whatever it may be.
- 11:02And it was just like, yeah, this is it.
- 11:04This is an odd world. If you convince a girl to love
- 11:07baseball, as my friend did, then we've put her into a bit of an
- 11:10odd situation. And how did we get here?
- 11:12And you know what, what what are the other possible paths to the
- 11:14show more broadly? That's just my personality.
- 11:17I never just want to like give the right answer to the
- 11:19question, I want to come up with an answer that nobody else in
- 11:22the class thought of. Awesome.
- 11:27You seem more like a business writer than a sports writer, at
- 11:30least from your background. How did you choose?
- 11:32Well, you kind of talked about how you got baseball, softball
- 11:35in the beginning as the topic. You know, how deep are you into
- 11:38the whole baseball area and did you get it into the softball
- 11:43part of it as well? Actually started out I went to
- 11:46college to do sports journalism specifically.
- 11:48I mean, that was my dream coming out of high school.
- 11:51I was partly why I, you know, I didn't end up being that great
- 11:54at baseball. I was better at basketball, but
- 11:55nowhere near a college athletes. So I went to college so I could
- 11:58I went, I went to Drake where I could be AD one athlete thinking
- 12:01that was going to be the thing that helped to make my bona
- 12:03fides as a sports journalist. And then quickly realized over
- 12:06the, you know, I did play by play for all the college teams
- 12:09and went back and did TV sports in my hometown and things like
- 12:11that. And realized that though I love
- 12:14sports, I didn't love sports journalism because of the number
- 12:17of times in everything I just said a second ago about like in
- 12:19the the wacky thing you've never heard before.
- 12:22I realized that, you know, the post game interview where you're
- 12:24just essentially asking a variation of, hey, that big play
- 12:28in the 7th inning, how huge was that?
- 12:32It's a boring way to live life as a journalist, even though I
- 12:34love the thing. So I decided to mostly leave
- 12:36sports in the in the fandom domain, though, you know, I've,
- 12:39I've come back and covered sports occasionally and did a
- 12:42story about the National Pro fast pitch league back in the
- 12:46late 2000s. I think when the cat and Jenny
- 12:49Finch and, you know, they like the Chicago and Rockford, you
- 12:51know, an earlier era in which that league was going on and had
- 12:53some some star power. But mostly.
- 12:55Yeah, I I found with business, for example, I was covering
- 12:58specifically a lot of tech startups for a while.
- 13:01And I just really loved interviewing those founders
- 13:03because those were people who were, again, trying to come up
- 13:06with a different answer to the test than anyone else had come
- 13:09up with. And I just really like telling
- 13:10those stories that has kind of broadened over the years to
- 13:14going deep on whatever. So, you know, you you mentioned
- 13:18earlier that the breadth of stuff and like, yeah, sure.
- 13:20Homelessness, that's another thorny issue that nobody knows
- 13:23the answer to. So let's talk about that.
- 13:24Or, you know, public safety, craft beer, take your pick.
- 13:27Yeah. Yeah, I think things like
- 13:30homelessness, people are always looking for that simple answer.
- 13:34And yet if there was a simple answer, we'd have already solved
- 13:36it. So it's, you know, it's not as
- 13:38simple as saying just do this, that and the other and
- 13:40everything is good. Yes, exactly.
- 13:42So the bad news then is if if I pick a topic, that probably
- 13:44means there's no solution. But yeah.
- 13:47Except for craft beer, there's plenty of solutions for craft.
- 13:50There you go. An abundance of solutions.
- 13:53Is that still going strong, by the way?
- 13:55I know that that was a big thing for a while.
- 13:57And then, you know, I live in Mundelein and there are, I
- 14:00think, a couple of craft breweries here.
- 14:02I mean, that's one of those like for a while it was going
- 14:04gangbusters to such an extent that all you needed to do was
- 14:07have some ability to make a beer and a neon sign to put out
- 14:10front. And you were you were doing
- 14:12fantastically. I don't think it's, you know
- 14:14that the industry is like consolidating, but I don't think
- 14:18it's going to vanish. It's going to going to right
- 14:20size. So you talked about like the
- 14:22whatever that you're going to, you know, what meaning topics,
- 14:26what are, what are some future things that you're looking to,
- 14:28to cover in the future? If you can give us a little hint
- 14:30about some of the things coming up for you.
- 14:33Yeah, this is a tricky 1. I so I've thought about this
- 14:35live. It's very important because, you
- 14:36know, it's not like every episode is a different topic.
- 14:38Every year is a different topic. So the first season in
- 14:41particular, I have to remember that this is not a show for
- 14:43baseball and softball geeks to, you know, like I have to really
- 14:46care about the general interest audience that just wants to like
- 14:50check into this topic. And so I had to kind of map out
- 14:53other seasons. I am still a little conflicted
- 14:57on how much to give the game away because partly the, you
- 14:59know, the fun of the show is that I'm going to tell some
- 15:01story that nobody else has has told.
- 15:03So I don't want to to road map it.
- 15:05But, you know, I do think it's always going to be important and
- 15:07I think it's always going to be fun.
- 15:08It's going to be close enough to some.
- 15:09You know, I think this season is perfect from the perspective of
- 15:12like, hey, I think there are some social importance issues to
- 15:16have. We boxed girls and women out of
- 15:18baseball, but enough of us are also just baseball and softball
- 15:22fans that it's fun to tell the story and it, you know, connects
- 15:25to things that are past times for us and stuff like that.
- 15:28So seasons will always do that to give you it to like come
- 15:33sideways to a place that I may or may not go in season 2.
- 15:36Let me ask you a question. Prospect rankings, like you
- 15:39know, how important are those and to what extent do families,
- 15:45kids going to change their schedules, the programs they
- 15:48participate in, things like that to try to maximize their ranking
- 15:55and prospects visibility and profile as opposed to making the
- 15:59choices that are just best for improving their game?
- 16:03Jay, you want to take that one or you're the college coach.
- 16:06Well, I'll go first, but you should chime in on this as well
- 16:09too. I think kids are always chasing
- 16:11that recognition. I don't know how important those
- 16:14rankings are because I've seen several kids who have been
- 16:18ranked on this these lists that when they get to the next level,
- 16:23don't show up like that. And then I've seen other kids on
- 16:26that list that do get ranked that do that do at the next
- 16:28level show up like that. And I think it's one of those
- 16:31things where there's just so many kids and there's so many
- 16:35tournaments and there's so many things going on, There's no real
- 16:40way to actually rank these kids out properly, right?
- 16:44Because, and I always say this to to the kids that I work with
- 16:47in my lessons, you know, my clients is that beauty is in the
- 16:51eye of the beholder. So 1 coach may see you as this
- 16:55high level prospect where another coach will look at you
- 16:58and say that high level, but doesn't fit my program.
- 17:02And I think so a lot of those rankings, and again, let's don't
- 17:05get me wrong, I think some of them are valid, But when we're
- 17:09ranking 6th graders, 7th graders and 8th graders, that's
- 17:13absolutely ridiculous because nobody knows how good these kids
- 17:18are going to be or not be right at that level.
- 17:21And then you also have the kids that are late bloomers.
- 17:23I mean, so to me, the ranking system is really great for some
- 17:27travel organizations and some pitching coaches and some
- 17:32parents to beat their chest and bang a drum at look at my kid,
- 17:35look at my kid. But then when they get to the
- 17:37college level and everybody's like that and they just kind of
- 17:40just average. So I think I'm not a fan of the
- 17:43of the ranking systems. I've had plenty of kids that
- 17:45have gone on to pitch it at the Division One level that were
- 17:48never ranked right. And, and some are really, really
- 17:51good. And, and, and the point of that
- 17:52is I just, I, I don't think that there is a, there's not enough
- 17:56resources, at least in the softball realm to be able to
- 17:59rank all of these kids validly. And I think that's kind of where
- 18:03I stand with it. So I don't put a lot of weight
- 18:05into that. And again, coaches know who's
- 18:08good or or not good know how do they do that?
- 18:10They do that by evaluating, which means you go to the
- 18:12tournament, you hear the hype of this kid, you go watch them
- 18:15play, you watch how they act, you watch those things, you make
- 18:18your evaluation. And then you know, if that kid
- 18:21really is what people are talking about and if they're
- 18:24going to fit in your program. And if not, then you're like,
- 18:26well, that's great that she's ranked, but unfortunately that's
- 18:30not the right fit and that's not what I'm looking for.
- 18:32That's just my take on that. Ken, what about you?
- 18:35Well, my take, yeah, I love seeing my kids get ranked.
- 18:38I love seeing, you know, nice high rankings.
- 18:40I feel good for them. I'm proud of them.
- 18:42I like to, you know, share that information when it comes out.
- 18:45But at the end of the day, a lot of the rankings are this is the
- 18:49best of who we've seen rather than these are the best kids
- 18:52that are out there. There may be kids that give it's
- 18:55from a particular organization. All right, so they did some
- 18:59showcases for them, pay their money, went to those things.
- 19:03And then now, you know, those are the kids that are being
- 19:05evaluated. But there are other kids who
- 19:07didn't go, didn't participate in any of that, who may be better
- 19:10players and they're getting left out of it.
- 19:13So, you know, it's, it's a funny ego thing.
- 19:15It's, you know, nice to see. But again, I also have that
- 19:19problem, especially at the younger ages, you never know
- 19:23who's going to be great by the time they're 16.
- 19:25And it really matters. So ranking an eighth grader or
- 19:297th grader, that puts a lot of pressure on those kids too.
- 19:33How about we just play some ball, have a good time, try to
- 19:36develop our skills, and then from there we'll see what
- 19:39happens? So somewhere in there is the
- 19:41idea. I think you guys were both right
- 19:43on the list. A number of ranking.
- 19:46It feels data-driven, it feels objective.
- 19:50And somewhere is the somewhere in there is the ingrained
- 19:52thought that I think we buy into as a society.
- 19:54Hey, if there's a, somebody's made a list, it's got to be
- 19:57objective and then A to both of your points.
- 20:00It's not always and then B, sometimes the tail starts
- 20:03wagging the dog. You start, you know, changing
- 20:06the way you approach things in order to gamify where you appear
- 20:09on the list, which you know shouldn't rationally be your,
- 20:12you know, your aim, right? Right.
- 20:14Well, I was looking. It's like Hotshots part do
- 20:16right, You're the best of what's left.
- 20:21Yeah. So all right, let's let's dig
- 20:23into you a little bit. Did you play baseball growing up
- 20:26and and if and if you did, did you have girls on the team that
- 20:29you played on? I did play baseball.
- 20:32I, you know, maybe in t-ball slash, very young.
- 20:36I remember a girl on the team. But you know, definitely by the
- 20:39time I got to anywhere near double digits, I think that was
- 20:43not the case anymore. I played basketball, ran cross
- 20:45country and track. You know, those they were, they
- 20:48were parallel teams. There were girls teams, but they
- 20:51it wasn't this Coed situation. And I think that's kind of what
- 20:53makes baseball weird. In fact, that I didn't think
- 20:56about this going into the season, but I have reflected
- 20:58since I dated in high school and Allstate basketball player.
- 21:02And you know, I was also on the the guys team and she was better
- 21:05than me and she ended up playing D1.
- 21:07Her kid played for the University of Michigan a couple
- 21:10years ago. That was one of those things
- 21:12where I started thinking about this world in baseball where an
- 21:17elite girls and women's baseball player right now can make the
- 21:22guy's team in a fringy way and have a look at a certainly made
- 21:27our team. But instead she was Allstate
- 21:32scholarship caliber in this other category because it
- 21:34existed of women's basketball. And so I you know, I as I have
- 21:37interviewed these Unicorn women's baseball players.
- 21:40It's hard not to think it what could you have done if this
- 21:42other sport existed? And you know what, a lot of them
- 21:44actually, you know, I, I think baseball and softball are
- 21:48different sports with shared DNA and we can get into that, except
- 21:51I'm sure you probably believe it and don't need the convincing.
- 21:54So, you know, it's, it's not so far a field that you can't make
- 21:57the transition unless you're a pitcher.
- 21:59That's the one where I feel like the, that, that that's a tough
- 22:01go. If you become a pitcher in one
- 22:03thing or another, it's hard to just crossover.
- 22:06If you are a hitter or a fielder, you are in for a year's
- 22:10worth of hard transitional work. But I think you can, you can do
- 22:13it. But, you know, that's the that's
- 22:15the trade off you have to make. If you started in baseball and
- 22:17then suddenly decide you really want that scholarship.
- 22:20And I say that knowing, you know, there are somewhere
- 22:22between 6:00 and 10:00, you know, women playing on men's
- 22:26college baseball teams right now across the country.
- 22:27But you know that's not the easiest path, right?
- 22:30Right, right. You know, and one of the things
- 22:33that makes it complicated, too, is that the opportunities for
- 22:36women in the bat and the ball sports are definitely in
- 22:39softball. That's where the scholarships
- 22:41are. That's where the visibility is.
- 22:44The Women's College World Series outdraws the men's College World
- 22:47Series on television so that you have a lot of those things going
- 22:51on. But once you get past college,
- 22:53yeah, there's the AUSL, but it doesn't pay very well versus
- 22:57Major League Baseball. If you can make it to that
- 22:59level, you know you're doing pretty well.
- 23:01Yeah, that's it. And you know what, I I will
- 23:04feature the AUSL and I think it's the best shot that softball
- 23:08has had to sort of create that Halo effect pro opportunity.
- 23:11But one of the things, especially if we get into the
- 23:13history here of how we came to this state of being, you know,
- 23:17like what softball did that was really special.
- 23:21That has absolutely no analog in baseball is welcome women in and
- 23:26at the time the first ASA tournament, the predecessor
- 23:30organization to USA softball. You know, there was AI think
- 23:34Chicago had the World's Fair, the equivalent of the World's
- 23:37Fair in 1933. It was a big softball tournament
- 23:41to showcase this game that had, you know, that was absolutely on
- 23:44fire and that had been invented locally in Chicago.
- 23:48And it was primarily a women's, excuse me, a men's tournament.
- 23:51But the crazy thing is that the organizers, I don't think, with
- 23:54any huge sense of social purpose, maybe just trying to
- 23:57boost their numbers, also invited women's teams.
- 23:59And they showed up. And that opened the door to this
- 24:02national tournament that happened annually and to the
- 24:05creation of the industrial leagues.
- 24:07And then boom, there was infrastructure.
- 24:10But what's interesting is in those days it was entirely
- 24:13possible to have a 20 plus year career as a semi pro or quasi
- 24:20pro. It was one of the, you know, the
- 24:21industrial league jobs. You weren't necessarily getting
- 24:22a softball salary, but you had a job that paid you to play.
- 24:29You had a job that made sure you could get to all your games.
- 24:31And we're taken care of. You know, one of those lucky.
- 24:33I want to make sure I, you know, walk the right side of that
- 24:35line, but you could continue to essentially develop your
- 24:40softball gifts over the course of your career.
- 24:42Now you Fast forward, the advent of college softball was not the
- 24:47reason that the industrial leagues declined solely.
- 24:50There were, you know, the the factory jobs that were, you
- 24:53know, that the companies that were supporting those leagues
- 24:55were also having their own issues and they were different
- 24:56trends, But essentially those things happened at the same
- 24:59time. You know that those industrial
- 25:01league I played until I was 40 or you know, 50 in a couple
- 25:04cases, those opportunities declined.
- 25:07The college softball and high school.
- 25:09I mean, all the stuff spun up at like the same time, right in
- 25:12the, you know, around 1970 when those, when that architecture
- 25:15got built, it led to the college championship.
- 25:19I'll say that, you know, not just the College World Series,
- 25:22because there was the AIAW and a bunch of, you know, things
- 25:24happening in women's sports in those early years, but
- 25:26essentially you got this new marquee event and you Max out at
- 25:30age 22. And then what do you do?
- 25:32So the scholarship is this huge goal.
- 25:35And then so is having success with your college team.
- 25:38But then it's a shame that before we had women that were
- 25:41able to play until they were 40 and see what they could do.
- 25:44And it's like, who's the best of the best in a in a quasi pro
- 25:48realm? And then softball has been
- 25:50looking for that since then. And, and I hope we have it with
- 25:54the AUSL. Yeah, I hope so, too.
- 25:56You know, it'd be nice to have those opportunities.
- 25:59When we spoke to Sarah Polly, you know, she mentioned that she
- 26:03didn't really hit her peak speed until she was, what, about 27?
- 26:07So she would have never seen that.
- 26:09She did never gotten close to that if her career would have
- 26:12been done when her college days were done.
- 26:15Yeah, yeah. You know, and that's just one of
- 26:17many. Based on what you've learned so
- 26:19far, why do you think baseball's never really embraced attracting
- 26:23girls to the sport? Why is it, you know, just kind
- 26:26of been left alone? On purpose is the answer if you
- 26:31go way, way back to the founding of baseball.
- 26:34I mean, let's go back to, you know, 18 something there to, you
- 26:37know, the the sports that were popular were, you know, sports
- 26:42of questionable repute that mostly you could bet on, you
- 26:46know, boxing and horse racing, things like that.
- 26:48So, you know, not that there's not a huge athleticism and
- 26:53training and skill in boxing, but you know, since it was a
- 26:55sort of gambling driven thing. And then obviously when you move
- 26:57over into horse racing or, you know, cock fighting or what have
- 26:59you, you know, you've like left the realm of human athleticism
- 27:03entirely at that point. So baseball comes around.
- 27:05It's huge, you know, starting mid 19th century, but it's not
- 27:09organized yet. And when it finally starts to
- 27:12coalesce into a big box office draw professional, I mean, this,
- 27:16this again is based here in Chicago, AG Spalding of Spalding
- 27:20Sporting Goods. He was a star pitcher.
- 27:23Then he's in charge of the National League, of one of the
- 27:25teams. And he starts to build this
- 27:28mythology around baseball, but also really manages successfully
- 27:33to put forth this idea that it's not just an entertainment, but
- 27:37it is of social value. That, you know, like when we
- 27:40play baseball as kids, as pros, you know, we are building
- 27:43character. All this.
- 27:45I'm just all the stuff that we as coaches tell ourselves every
- 27:48day. This is why our work is
- 27:49important, that we're not just out there having a blast.
- 27:51Kind of like CW post saying that the most important meal of the
- 27:54day is breakfast because that's when he's trying to sell you.
- 27:58Yes, exactly. So you know what I actually do
- 28:00buy into all these things. I I think these like arguments
- 28:03have valid or the validity that sports generally, you know, can,
- 28:08you know, build character and all of that stuff.
- 28:10But for Spalding in particular, in this moment, I'm going to
- 28:13read this quote. Baseball is too strenuous for
- 28:16womankind, except that she may take part in the grandstand with
- 28:19applause to the brilliant play with a waving kerchief to the
- 28:21hero. It's not just men and women.
- 28:25It, it's also, I mean, the, this guy's obsessed with the
- 28:28Americanness of bait. I mean, it like obviously has
- 28:31roots in cricket and rounders and all these British sports.
- 28:34And one of the early, you know, it's a British guy, an American
- 28:37named Henry Chadwick, who's kind of paying attention.
- 28:39And he's like, no, actually, I recognize these sports.
- 28:41And Spalding is like, you absolutely do not shut up.
- 28:44It is, it is 1000% American. It would actually be impossible
- 28:48for a British member of the British Gentry who can barely be
- 28:52moved from his country house to put on his cricket whites to go
- 28:55play for six days, which, you know, obviously doesn't include
- 28:57the working man because he's off at the factory.
- 28:59That sport is, you know, like, that is everything about why we
- 29:03are cooler than the British and therefore this game that we have
- 29:06could not have descended from. And in fact, I'm pretty sure an
- 29:08American invented, in fact, I'm pretty sure a Civil War hero
- 29:11invented it. And that, you know, This is why
- 29:13you get Abner Doubleday in Cooperstown, even though that's
- 29:16pretty plainly not where baseball came from.
- 29:19So it's this idea that like America's special, it is more
- 29:24special than all the other places.
- 29:25And baseball. We play baseball and no other
- 29:29country can play it or could have thought of it.
- 29:31And but also it's like America. I mean, this is a lot of like
- 29:33this American manhood idea. And so you are literally boxing
- 29:37women outs, not even necessarily because of well, I mean,
- 29:40whenever we can talk about misogynist that is, or whatever,
- 29:42but like you're, you're trying to elevate the American man and
- 29:45that means edging out people that don't fit both halves of
- 29:49that description. Time Blue.
- 29:54Hey Jay, on a scale of 1 to 10, how important do you think brush
- 29:57contact is for pictures? It's pretty high up there Ken
- 30:01probably attend since it's hard to get maximum speed and or
- 30:05accuracy without it. Yeah I agree, but have you ever
- 30:08had a student who struggled to get good light brush contact?
- 30:12Sure, all the time, in fact. Especially when they've been
- 30:16taught hello elbow and are trying to throw around their
- 30:18hips or they're sliding their hips out of the way doing that
- 30:21crazy ninja move. So what do you do when you run
- 30:24into this situation? Keep railing on them until they
- 30:27get it right. I used to do that a lot, but
- 30:30then I learned about a product called Pitch Squeak Ken.
- 30:33Pitch squeak. What's that?
- 30:35It's a cool little armband with a squeaker inside of it.
- 30:38Like a dog toy. Yeah, kinda.
- 30:41So how does it work? Well, you slip the armband onto
- 30:45the pitcher's forearm and you set it so the squeaker is where
- 30:48the brush contact should happen. Then when the pitcher goes into
- 30:52release, she tries to get it to squeak like this.
- 30:56If she makes it happen, she got brush.
- 30:59If there's no sound, she knows immediately and can make a
- 31:02correction. Wow cool, so she gets immediate
- 31:05audible as well as tactile feedback.
- 31:08Oh, there you go again, showing off with those big and technical
- 31:12words again. But yeah, she can feel it and
- 31:15hear it. Does it really work?
- 31:17You bet it does. I use it with my students all
- 31:20the time and it helps them learn how to get brush contact pretty
- 31:23quickly if they practice with it.
- 31:26Sounds neat. Where can I get one?
- 31:28Oh, it's easy, Ken. Just e-mail
- 31:30support@pitchsqueak.com and Jason, the inventor of it and a
- 31:36Poly Girl certified pitching coach himself, will ask you how
- 31:39many you want and send them right out.
- 31:41I'll do that today. Thanks, Jay.
- 31:44What's that address again? Oh, you bet, Ken.
- 31:47It's support@pitchsqueak.com one more time for those of you who
- 31:52are listening, support@pitchsqueak.com.
- 31:56And don't forget to mention in the e-mail that you heard about
- 32:00it right here on From the Coach's Mouth podcast and you'll
- 32:03receive 10% off play ball. I want to ask you because we
- 32:10have seen a few girls, most notably Monet Davis, you know,
- 32:14gain some notoriety playing baseball in the Little League
- 32:17World Series. Do you think that those players
- 32:20have had an effect on the number of girls playing baseball?
- 32:22Like in in your opinion? Yeah, so this is an interesting
- 32:261 and it goes back to the infrastructure.
- 32:29So girls baseball has had a number of individual
- 32:33breakthrough players, you know, like Monet.
- 32:35I mean, and she's an interesting one 'cause I mean, she, yeah,
- 32:37tons of exposure. I mean, that was as a 12 UI
- 32:40think pitcher in the Little League World Series.
- 32:42So, you know, like very young in her athletic journey, but
- 32:45obviously it's like a breakthrough star.
- 32:47You know, now you have several women in that Savannah Bananas
- 32:52and associated leagues. You know, Kelsey Whitmore as the
- 32:54the most prominent of those. Over time, you've had those
- 32:58individual breakthrough stars from Jackie Mitchell striking
- 33:01out Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig back in the 30s and a few women
- 33:05played in the Negro Leagues in the 90s.
- 33:07You know, Isla Borders made it into fairly high, you know,
- 33:11men's independent League Baseball, 1 games as a starting
- 33:14pitcher. And then really I would point to
- 33:16A league of their own as like the, you know, the the thing
- 33:18that fixed women's baseball. Oh, that that is possible.
- 33:21So you've always had at the high level this Halo effect and
- 33:24especially after League of their own.
- 33:25This is where I'm going to go with the the first episode of on
- 33:27ingrained. You know, that then leads people
- 33:29to say, oh, cool, so where are these people?
- 33:32And then they turn around and look for the thousands of
- 33:35women's baseball players. And those haven't necessarily
- 33:37existed because there isn't the developmental architecture and
- 33:42infrastructure that softball has.
- 33:44So yes, to your to your question, like, you know, did
- 33:47that inspire? Sure.
- 33:48But like, does a solar flare of inspiration immediately create
- 33:54youth house and travel programs? It does not.
- 33:56Well, that's interesting too. And I guess, yeah, when you talk
- 33:58about the infrastructure, you had some wealthy people, you
- 34:02know, you had William Wrigley in particular supporting women's
- 34:05baseball when it was convenient for him.
- 34:08And then once men's baseball came back and was in full force,
- 34:12he kind of lost interest in it. But it's unfortunate that there
- 34:17wasn't somebody else to pick up that mantle.
- 34:19Yeah, that era is interesting. I mean, it did going back to the
- 34:22industrial league we talked about before, I mean in the
- 34:25first years, I think it was like 19501943 to 54.
- 34:29That league existed in the first days.
- 34:32They were pitching underhand. It was essentially softball,
- 34:34though it was called baseball. They were drawing all of their
- 34:37players from the industrial league softball programs, or at
- 34:40least most of them. And then gradually they
- 34:42converted them over to baseball. They were to your point about
- 34:45Wrigley paying them well. But you know, the ASA played
- 34:50hardball in the same way that they did when there was an
- 34:52attempt at pro softball in that era.
- 34:55Essentially, you know, if you go over, you're ineligible for like
- 34:57the next thousand years or you know, it was it was a long time.
- 34:59You were basically saying goodbye to your quasi pro
- 35:03softball career if you went and played.
- 35:05So that was, you know, that always Hanford, that league of
- 35:08their own league, the all American girls professional
- 35:11baseball leagues attempt to get going.
- 35:13But to this point about the architecture and like was there
- 35:17a corresponding youth program? So that's 1943 to 54 if I've got
- 35:24it right. I think it was 19.
- 35:27It was 1950 that, you know, a, a girl played Little League by
- 35:31tucking her hair in her hat. But then, like, word made its
- 35:34way up to Little League HQ and they codified the rule that had,
- 35:38you know, previously been implicit, no girls allowed.
- 35:41So even in this moment, you're like, oh, yeah, that would have
- 35:43been a great time for girls to start playing baseball.
- 35:45Actually, the minute one tried Little League, like put the
- 35:48kibosh on it formally. I mean it, you know?
- 35:50In other words, we're not talking about a lack of a
- 35:52groundswell of girls gravitating to baseball.
- 35:54We're talking about like when when one tried, they dropped the
- 35:57hammer. And yet nobody else picked it up
- 36:00and kind of gave them an alternative either.
- 36:02So I, I guess it's kind of one of those things when I look back
- 36:06on baseball and how it developed for a long time, the players
- 36:11weren't paid very well. They had to have jobs in the
- 36:14offseason. There were a lot of other things
- 36:16going on. And yet just it took enough time
- 36:19and they were given enough time to develop it.
- 36:22It seems like the same thing hasn't gone on either for
- 36:24baseball or for professional softball.
- 36:27It's like it comes around for a few years, it starts to draw an
- 36:30audience, but then for whatever reason, it doesn't get
- 36:34sustainable. So if you were going to say are
- 36:38you looking for baseball as a girls Baseball League to develop
- 36:44or are you thinking more girls playing in men's baseball?
- 36:48And there is this fall that, you know, the Women's Pro Baseball
- 36:52League is launching with its first season.
- 36:54And it's also worth seeing on your podcast, especially that at
- 36:59this point, if you look around either the pro baseball with the
- 37:02Women's Pro Baseball League or the USA, women's USA Baseball,
- 37:05there's a lot of softball in there.
- 37:06Like, you know, it's, it's very hard to ascend to a national or
- 37:10pro team level. As a baseball player, though, I
- 37:14am impressed at the, you know, what baseball for all has built.
- 37:17And the, you know, there are certainly opportunities for
- 37:19girls to play baseball. But if if you want to get to
- 37:21that level, you probably ought to have touched softball pretty
- 37:25significantly just in order to get the coaching and the
- 37:27opportunities to get to that level by the time you're 18 to
- 37:3125. And I've lost my train of
- 37:33thought that that was the high level and I was going to I was
- 37:35going to come back to the to the lower level.
- 37:37That what was your question, though, is essentially about,
- 37:39you know, how many Oh yeah, yeah.
- 37:40They just Co Ed versus women's baseball.
- 37:43Now we get kind of get into the the world of what I think should
- 37:47happen. And so, you know, a question of
- 37:50the show is, you know, or this investigation that I'm
- 37:53undertaking this season is like, all right, so baseball at least
- 37:56has historically been especially important in all the sports.
- 38:00And it totally has boxed out women.
- 38:03Is it worth fixing? You know, there's this moment,
- 38:061970, you know, finally their lawsuits like girls are trying
- 38:10to play Little League and they managed to fight their way
- 38:12through. And then even in that moment
- 38:14when the rest of girls and women's sports are getting built
- 38:17up rapidly, you know what happens instead, even though
- 38:19they do allow for Coed play, but Little League immediately spins
- 38:23up Little League softball. So it's going to go do this
- 38:25thing instead. Here we've we've solved this
- 38:27legal problem by pushing you out of the way into this other
- 38:30opportunity, which happens to be an awesome sport.
- 38:32And you know, off everyone goes. And so, you know, we can debate
- 38:35that, but the question is there's not much debating that
- 38:38baseball has boxed out women, that it occupies a special place
- 38:42in American Society. And is it worth creating some
- 38:46sort of concerted efforts to open that up or have we landed
- 38:50in an OK place? But I go back to your question
- 38:53about, you know, the Coed thing now exists, but A, it's hard.
- 38:58It's socially hard, as I have observed.
- 39:00It's, you know, it's not that like you're necessarily exiled
- 39:04or insulted or, you know, told hard no, like you might have
- 39:07been Once Upon a time. But you, you know, like
- 39:08whatever, especially once you get into your teens, not even
- 39:12like the dynamic of being one girl on a boys team is different
- 39:15than getting with your friends on a softball team.
- 39:18And I appreciate the women who are willing to do that, who are,
- 39:24you know, so hardcore that they want to thrive in that
- 39:26environment. I think creating the other one
- 39:29has some value. And I also see that it has value
- 39:32lower. I mean, I know again, pre
- 39:34puberty, I think the skills are pretty similar.
- 39:37It's not that a girl's, you know, if she's not hacking it in
- 39:40practice, she's probably just not hacking it.
- 39:41But I did watch the way that my daughter got coached
- 39:43differently, responded to coaching differently.
- 39:46So in other words, she had a Co Ed league experience where
- 39:50she's, you know, bottom of the roster and getting coached like
- 39:52it then has this like fall ball experience in a girls league and
- 39:55then comes back and Co Ed the next year is is competing at a
- 39:58completely different level. And obviously that all girls
- 40:01experience in between where she was coached, like the clean up
- 40:03hitter changed how she thought of herself in the diamond and
- 40:07what she was able to do. So I for those reasons, I don't
- 40:11love the Co Ed world. And then also like we talked
- 40:13about before, I think for Co Ed players.
- 40:16If you're a transcendent woman player, you're just kind of on
- 40:20the team. I mean, another woman that we're
- 40:22going to feature in Episode 1 eventually chose college
- 40:25basketball. And she makes this comment like,
- 40:27I was a really good baseball player, but I was a transcendent
- 40:30basketball player. And to me that was like an
- 40:33apples and oranges comment. What you what you just said is
- 40:35you were a transcendent women's basketball player, but you were
- 40:39throwing 88 is a lefty. You were a transcendent women's
- 40:43baseball player. You just didn't know it because
- 40:44you were playing high level California men's baseball or
- 40:47boys baseball. Yeah.
- 40:49And, you know, and I think that this goes back into some of the
- 40:51societal stuff to where you look at, you know, not to get too
- 40:55controversial here, but when they start talking about, you
- 40:58know, men playing women's sports, if it's OK for girls to
- 41:01play boys sports, why can't boys play girls sports?
- 41:04Why can't we just make it 1 sport?
- 41:06Well, there are some size and strength differences that come
- 41:08up up once puberty hits and, you know, that makes it difficult.
- 41:14But I think there's another thing that goes into it too.
- 41:17And I don't know how you feel about how much you have the
- 41:19softball you've watched. But you, like you said earlier,
- 41:22softball is a different game. It's a faster game.
- 41:25It's, you know, the field is shorter.
- 41:27There's, you know, a whole lot of other things going on.
- 41:30There's some strategic differences to it.
- 41:32And it's an exciting game. And I know, you know, several
- 41:36men who coach softball came from a baseball background and said,
- 41:40yeah, I would never go back. So, you know, there's a place
- 41:43for all of that, I guess. There's an argument.
- 41:45So one of the interesting things to look at in this show is, you
- 41:48know, Once Upon a time, a lot of women's sports look different
- 41:52from the men's version. I'm going to spend a whole
- 41:53episode on basketball because Once Upon a time women's
- 41:56basketball had like different rules.
- 41:57You can cross or one, maybe only one player can cross half court.
- 42:00It was a fundamentally different game than that is high school
- 42:04girls basketball than high school boys basketball.
- 42:06And then eventually those rules fell away and the games aligned.
- 42:10And I think you can make a case that there are similarities
- 42:13between baseball and softball. But in this case, we have stuck
- 42:16with both versions. And you know what, like
- 42:18softball, I mean, softball has evolved past really modest
- 42:22beginnings where it was literally, you know, touted as
- 42:24like this. This is the, you know, indoor.
- 42:28Yeah, well, or for guys, but it was like indoor if you're not as
- 42:32good or whatever, you know, and then like.
- 42:34But hey, it was given, you know, back to our conversation about
- 42:36what you. What you might discover at age
- 42:3827 is when you, you know, finally are able to tap into
- 42:41your. So softball had the the leash to
- 42:44evolve into this fundamentally different but elite game that it
- 42:49became. And I think, yeah, I think
- 42:51there's, you know, there's room to hold those things up next to
- 42:55each other. So I would love to see girls
- 42:58baseball. And again, I'm I'm going to
- 42:59deliberately. And it not gets to like your
- 43:03point about the, you know, there's difference in bodies and
- 43:05like, hey, if we managed to spin up girls baseball, I don't know
- 43:09how much need we have for the Coed opportunity.
- 43:12Cuz, you know, I don't think we see a ton of elite women's
- 43:15basketball players pushing for their shot to play in the NBA
- 43:17right now, for example. But in the world that we do live
- 43:20in right now, I, you know, only respect for the, the women
- 43:23pursuing Coed ball, you know, all the way through.
- 43:25I want to talk about men's fast pitch for a bit.
- 43:28You know, back in the day it used to be popular.
- 43:31I mean, everybody would go watch.
- 43:34It was just what you kind of did on the weekend.
- 43:36What do you think caused the game the the decline in the
- 43:39game? And that's something I'll say,
- 43:42there are things we're talking about right now where I'm like
- 43:4420 interviews in and you're in my wheelhouse.
- 43:46This is one that is we will, we'll be covering it.
- 43:49And I am like a couple hours of, of thought into this, but I, I
- 43:51think there's two things. So first of all, I would point
- 43:53out that internationally, like you go to Australia and New
- 43:57Zealand and these men's fast pitch is still a thing.
- 44:00And it certainly has continued to be a, a huge deal well past
- 44:04when it's tapered off in the US. So then the question is why, You
- 44:08know, one of the hypotheses is that that was, you know, slow
- 44:12pitch became such a thing and, you know, drew enough fast pitch
- 44:16players away. And I mean, this to me is a
- 44:19whole like, you know, we're talking about the potential
- 44:22equivalency of baseball and fast pitch softball.
- 44:26You can put baseball in the middle, fast pitch softball with
- 44:30this emphasis on, you know, quickness and speed is over
- 44:33here. And then this other sport that's
- 44:34also called softball, slow pitch softball belongs on the other
- 44:37side of baseball where it's like, you know, like the premium
- 44:40on pitching vanishes, basically doesn't exist and it's all about
- 44:44power. It's like an unrecognizable
- 44:45game. But I think, you know, softball
- 44:46obviously in the 80s, nineties had this huge moment and drew
- 44:50enough players away that I think that's part of the story.
- 44:52And then somewhere in there too, I think is dislike gender is a
- 44:56it's the flip side of what we're talking about.
- 44:58If softball is baseball for girls, then it starts to feel
- 45:02wrong for a boy to play softball.
- 45:05So, you know, that dynamic did not exist.
- 45:07Softball was softball was baseball for girls in the early
- 45:10days, in the industrial league days only because it let them
- 45:12in. But that did not diminish from
- 45:14the popularity or enthusiasm around the men's game.
- 45:18But then somewhere in the same era, like, you know, 70s, like
- 45:21we really build up softball and it becomes the hey, where is
- 45:24girls base that doesn't exist that softball.
- 45:26Well, then all of a sudden a new generation of guys starts to,
- 45:30you know, a generation that did not know Shifty Gears isn't
- 45:34jumping in. Well, and don't you think
- 45:36there's also some element of it? Again, follow the money like
- 45:39anything else is, you know, USA Softball certainly saw an
- 45:43opportunity there to make money off of it and they saw the
- 45:46growth of the girls game. It was new ground.
- 45:49And and I I think that a lot of times that's what ends up
- 45:52happening is that somebody sees a business opportunity there,
- 45:55another area maybe gets ignored a little bit and then it starts
- 45:59to fall away and then, you know, locate.
- 46:02So here's our profit opportunity.
- 46:04So we're going to put more resources and more resources
- 46:06into it. Yeah, well, and you know, think
- 46:08about like I'm in a watershed moment for softball was the
- 46:11inclusion in the 96 Olympics. But it's somewhat rare to add a
- 46:17sport and not add the equivalent sport and the other gender, you
- 46:22know, so that that's like a moment when you when you say
- 46:23that we recognize women's softball as a thing, but not
- 46:27women's fast pitch softball, but not men's fast pitch.
- 46:30You've kind of said this. 1/2 of this matters more than the
- 46:33other. Yeah, good point.
- 46:34What do you think would be the biggest argument in favor of
- 46:36steering more girls toward baseball?
- 46:40Well, first of all, not to siphon them away from softball.
- 46:43This whole, you know, awakening for me around the Oh yeah, why
- 46:46did why have I never noticed the absence of girls baseball?
- 46:49To some extent it owes to the awesomeness of softball.
- 46:52And no part of, you know, trying to address that should be
- 46:57diminishing, you know, that awesomeness and what the what
- 47:00softball has built and is. And to me that should be pretty
- 47:03self-evident and not this like tug of war because they're
- 47:07different sports and you can do it.
- 47:08And Rachel Gansner, who started that fall league in Chicago,
- 47:11very specifically made it a fall league, not only so that girls
- 47:15from our Coed spring Baseball League could have this all girls
- 47:19experience, but also so softball players could try baseball and
- 47:24consider developing them together.
- 47:26And I know that, you know, you guys come from the high level
- 47:29travel world college where hey, baseball and softball have
- 47:32developed into this highly specialized 365 days a year
- 47:36situation, as have a lot of other sports.
- 47:39That's not how I come up and it's not really, I don't have
- 47:41that much conviction that that's the right way to train yourself
- 47:43as an athlete. I think basketball was very good
- 47:46for me as a runner, etcetera, etcetera.
- 47:48You know, we're not wired that way, but I don't, I think you
- 47:50could argue that, you know, trying out baseball might be
- 47:53good for you, you know, one fall, things like that or being
- 47:56able to bounce back and forth. So we, you know, we can have
- 47:57that conversation too. But that's the, you know, I I
- 48:02would like the the why goes back to, hey, this didn't just happen
- 48:08accidentally. I don't think this was like a,
- 48:10you know, free market choice And all the girls of the world
- 48:12decided to play softball instead of baseball.
- 48:14I don't think that's how we got here.
- 48:16I also think that, well, softball is great.
- 48:19Baseball is special. It's been, you know, for all the
- 48:21reasons I just said. I mean, it's been like a part of
- 48:23the national identity. The president's always there to
- 48:26throw out opening day. I mean, the baseball, whatever.
- 48:28I don't need to read the Mark Twain quotes.
- 48:29I'm sure you all know so is like, so it's the national
- 48:35pastime. It's never been open.
- 48:37Should we just try to open it and see what happens?
- 48:40You know, create this developmental pipeline, you
- 48:42know, so that without harming softball, I think it's my dream.
- 48:45So do you think a sort of hybrid world could exist where males
- 48:50and females go back and forth between both sports at at
- 48:52younger ages? You think that's a possibility?
- 48:55I do. And I think I mean like,
- 48:56especially at younger ages, I mean, I think it's going to be
- 48:59harder to convince the people who are more advanced to, to not
- 49:02pick a sport to begin to specialize in.
- 49:04But you know, you're figuring it out at that point.
- 49:06You know, what if you, I mean, if someone who love, hey, if a
- 49:10girl falls in love with baseball, my daughter discovered
- 49:12she's an awesome softball pitcher.
- 49:13Well, hey, there's no real equivalent in this other thing
- 49:16that would be a great lane for you to go ahead and get into,
- 49:19but also vice versa. Or you know what, I've really
- 49:22discovered that I am never going to get on top of that rise ball,
- 49:25but I can handle a curve. You know, like there's just
- 49:27opportunities to discover who you are as an athlete, even in
- 49:31these two more related sports. And like, why not have the
- 49:35exposure and if nothing else, playing on fields with different
- 49:38dimensions or you know, like related to, I mean, these are
- 49:40like similar experiences that cannot do worse than having
- 49:44relevance as a drill. You know, that kind of like, oh,
- 49:46this is speed up. I'm now I just learned what
- 49:49ready position means because I played third base in the
- 49:51softball game or or vice versa that I I think you know, why not
- 49:55expose yourself? Yeah, well, I think one of the
- 49:57other things too that comes into it.
- 49:59You know, we've talked a lot in the past about how when girls
- 50:04get started, you know, there's the thing about throwing like a
- 50:06girl. And that a lot of times comes
- 50:09from the fact that, you know, you have a boy who's got a
- 50:12little 9 inch ball that weighs 3 oz and then you have a girl
- 50:16who's got an 11 inch ball that weighs, you know, close to 6 oz.
- 50:22You know, so it's twice as heavy, it's twice as big.
- 50:25There may be a little bit smaller in a lot of cases.
- 50:27So they just can't lift the arm in the same way naturally to
- 50:32make that throw. So it would seem like maybe, you
- 50:35know, opening more opportunities for baseball might help
- 50:38fundamentals. Even if girls decide ultimately
- 50:41to go into softball, they could establish those fundamentals
- 50:44early a little bit better. Yeah, this is something I've
- 50:47encountered a lot reporting this with just telling the story to
- 50:50people who do not come from either of our worlds.
- 50:53So, you know, they, it's like when when someone who is not a
- 50:57baseball or softball person thinks about why they think it's
- 51:00appropriate that softball is baseball for girls, often it
- 51:04seems one of the first places they go is, well, they can't
- 51:07throw, right. There's a reason why they, they
- 51:09do that underhand pitch because they can't do the overhand
- 51:11pitch. And it's, I mean, I just that
- 51:13aggravates every girls baseball, but also softball player.
- 51:17Like, have you seen any of the other positions?
- 51:18Did you know, did the shortstop throw underhand?
- 51:21They did not and so it like that, but there's but there is
- 51:25that cultural idea and obviously you can coach through that with
- 51:29a softball and you can coach through that with a baseball and
- 51:32you're going to get there. But that is one of those like
- 51:34that. You know, there's that latent
- 51:35idea in the public imagination and it's easily enough
- 51:39destroyed. But you're right, you know, like
- 51:41the size of the thing you're throwing and the weight of the
- 51:44thing you're throwing. Does, you know, especially when
- 51:46you're talking about little girls matter.
- 51:49Yeah, You know, it's funny because I remember, and I'm sure
- 51:52Jay had the same experience. I don't see this much anymore,
- 51:55but I would have a dad catching for his, say, his 10 year old
- 51:59daughter in softball pitching lessons.
- 52:03And the girl would throw the ball.
- 52:04She'd be trying to throw it pretty hard.
- 52:06And the dad would just be lobbing that ball back as soft
- 52:09as he could to her, you know, as if she was this fragile little
- 52:12thing that couldn't handle it. And I would go down by the dad
- 52:15and when he was catching and say here, can I have that ball for a
- 52:18second? He'd give me the ball and I just
- 52:20taken that, toss it. You know, I'd Chuck it at the
- 52:21girl and she catch the ball just fine.
- 52:23And I'd say don't lob it at her. Don't you know, don't lollipop
- 52:27that ball to her. She can catch it.
- 52:29She's going to have to catch it if he gets hit back, you know,
- 52:31let her develop those skills. But I think that that again,
- 52:34it's a society thing of, oh, we have to protect these girls from
- 52:38it. And that, you know, if you're
- 52:40talking about the younger ages, I think that crosses the gender
- 52:43lines. You know what?
- 52:43When do I start challenging this kid versus making sure that they
- 52:47don't, you know, catch a ball in the nose that makes them want to
- 52:50never play again? Yeah, I mean, you don't want to
- 52:52throw it as hard as you can, but you can certainly throw it at
- 52:55them on a line instead of a rainbow.
- 52:58Yes, and you know, we all wish the rainbow came at you in the
- 53:01game a little bit more often. Than yes.
- 53:06So from the people you've spoken to then, Steve, how ingrained is
- 53:10this really? Is this something that's pretty
- 53:12deep? And what would it take to kind
- 53:15of breakthrough that? That's an interesting question
- 53:17because I think it's really ingrained, but I don't think
- 53:20there's like conviction behind it in the same way that there
- 53:22was, right? I mean, you know, like the back
- 53:25to that AG Spalding quote. Once Upon a time it will even
- 53:28through 1950 through 1970. It was like inappropriate.
- 53:32Do not let girls into this game. I just don't think that many
- 53:36people feel that way now. They're just used to it.
- 53:38And this gets back to the question of well, we're used to
- 53:41it and we now have this high level, awesome bat and ball
- 53:44sport for girls and women. Do we just let it go or are they
- 53:49different enough? And by setting this dichotomy
- 53:53up, or this would to me is a false equivalency between
- 53:57softball and baseball. We say they're the same, but
- 53:58they're not. And yet the girls can't quite
- 54:00play the one and the guys don't play the other.
- 54:02It's it's a weird situation. We killed men's fast pitch
- 54:05softball for no, you know, for, for out of this idea.
- 54:08And we never really created an opportunity for girls and women
- 54:10to play baseball out of this idea.
- 54:12Is it, is it worth doing something?
- 54:14I mean, hey, you guys are coaches.
- 54:17You can also think through this logistically, like I can't like
- 54:19what are the fields that would be required to do this?
- 54:22How much coaching infrastructure, you know, like
- 54:24you don't want to just take a bunch of boys baseball coaches
- 54:28like the Physiology a little different.
- 54:30You know, there there are a bunch of things in place that
- 54:31you would need to create in order to like rapidly expand
- 54:35opportunities for girls in baseball.
- 54:37Probably not at the youth level. I think you know, like there's
- 54:39there are more similarities and you could pull this up to, you
- 54:41know, 10/11/12 you without breaking the world.
- 54:44But you know, beyond that, you would need to figure out what,
- 54:47you know, again, women's basketball, for example, changed
- 54:51from the version that, you know, nobody could pass half court.
- 54:55It was this like fundamentally different game.
- 54:57The game that we have now is 97% like men's bad.
- 55:00But the ball, the size of the ball is different.
- 55:03The size, the distance to the three-point line is different.
- 55:05That might be it. That might be the only two
- 55:06things. But like, you know, what are the
- 55:07accommodations and what would be the needs to like the
- 55:10infrastructure of the parks of America to accommodate that?
- 55:13I know I'm not saying it's nothing.
- 55:15You can think through that then and it's there.
- 55:17But to me, I'd love to see that. And I bet you anything like,
- 55:21hey, if the AUSL does take off and the College World Series
- 55:24continues to build on the ratings, like people are going
- 55:28to discover softball, they're going to notice that it is a
- 55:30different game and guys are going to want to play it too,
- 55:32right? I mean, like, to me, these
- 55:33things are going to naturally follow and we're going to want
- 55:36to figure out how to accommodate them.
- 55:37Yeah, well, I think too that there's some things that have
- 55:40been going on recently in the softball world where used to be,
- 55:43if you were on a team that had a mix of 13 and 14 year olds, so
- 55:468th graders and freshmen, the freshmen went off to play
- 55:49freshman softball in high school and the 8th graders sat around
- 55:55and waited for them to get done playing freshman softball.
- 55:57Now you have combined teams, you know that you have little
- 56:01leagues that have popped up so that the 8th graders can
- 56:03continue to play. You know, I think that there are
- 56:06other things going on like that as well.
- 56:08So maybe it's just kind of a need or just having the will to
- 56:13say, you know what, here's an opportunity, here's something
- 56:17that maybe makes sense to try, and let's see if we can put a
- 56:21structure together. Yeah.
- 56:22Well, and back to, I mean, the fundamental ingrained idea that
- 56:26we say softball is baseball for girls.
- 56:28Well, a lot of where my narrative is going is that that
- 56:32costs girls baseball opportunities, but it also hides
- 56:35what softball is. You know, we just pretend that
- 56:38it's girls baseball with a but with like all kinds of rules
- 56:41changes. You know, like I said, so many
- 56:44that it's a different game and so like nobody really sees that
- 56:48sport or do you know, not not enough people see that sport.
- 56:50So I I think the more you like tease these two things apart,
- 56:53you create visibility and opportunity all over the place.
- 56:56Steve, if you can tell us where and when what, where can people
- 57:00find this on ingrained and when will this be out?
- 57:03Jay, I can do that. Thank you so on ingrained
- 57:09ingrained, but with on in front of it.
- 57:11That's a.com with the website. It's right now there is a
- 57:14trailer and I don't know how long we have between this
- 57:17conversation and when this thing goes live, but.
- 57:19About a week. About a week, OK, that so that
- 57:21right around then is when the first proper episode will go up
- 57:24as well. So if you head to your podcast
- 57:26player to wherever you're listening to this thing on
- 57:28Ingrained, you can search and subscribe to that.
- 57:30There's also the website. I also want to there there's on
- 57:34ingrained.substack.com and I want to specifically call that
- 57:38out and the UN ingrained YouTube because as I mentioned earlier,
- 57:42these are like, you know, half an hour documentary style
- 57:44episodes where I'm just pulling in a quote.
- 57:46A lot of it's scripted. Each story is going in in a
- 57:48specific way for a general interest audience that, you
- 57:50know, I I think certainly baseball and softball fans will
- 57:53enjoy. But on the sub stack, I'm doing
- 57:56things more like the conversation that the three of
- 57:58us are having right now where I'm going to go back to that.
- 58:00You know, it's a little more edited like like the maybe there
- 58:03was an hour, hour and 15 minute interview and I'm going to crush
- 58:06that down to, you know, the best 30 or 45 minutes or something
- 58:09like that. But I just have talked to too
- 58:12many from Lori Ramsey from the mid century industrial league.
- 58:16First the Caterpillar D silhouettes and then the pecan.
- 58:19Let's I mean, like, you know, I just heard about her career for
- 58:21a long time and it brings up this way to do quasi pro
- 58:25softball that, you know, we're not going to stop and spend 45
- 58:28minutes talking about that. But it's so fascinating to tell
- 58:31that story and learn about it. You know, we've got a 96
- 58:35Olympian, we've got AOSL star as lots of, you know, people from
- 58:39the softball world, and we're not going to quite go into the
- 58:42depth on the main show. So yes, please listen to the
- 58:44main show, but I also just want to plug that sub stack because
- 58:47especially if you are a baseball or softball dork, I think there
- 58:50are, you know, there, there's goodness in those expanded
- 58:53episodes too. So I have one more question for
- 58:56you, and that's just kind of after all the talk and, you
- 58:59know, the people from different parts of softball, baseball and
- 59:02all that. Have you received a lot of
- 59:04pushback from either side on the idea of baseball for girls, or
- 59:10has that been something that people have been open to?
- 59:13I have not I have heard, you know, like the compared to all
- 59:16of the very obvious pushback that has happened to different
- 59:18areas. Now the Max pushback here is
- 59:20like, do we need it? You know, as opposed to this
- 59:23should not be. I mean, I'm interested.
- 59:26What's what's the two of your reaction?
- 59:29I've now kind of made the case. I've tried to, you know, put it
- 59:32next to softball in a in a world in which everything can coexist,
- 59:35does this seem plausible? Have I moved you?
- 59:38You're like, this is an interesting way to spend an
- 59:39hour, but we're good go. Ahead, Ken, you first.
- 59:42Oh, OK. I was looking at you.
- 59:44I thought maybe you'd want to go.
- 59:45It's an interesting thought. I mean, I'm, I'm very ingrained
- 59:49into the softball area and I have two boys as well who played
- 59:52baseball. I don't have a personal
- 59:55objection to it. So I think the more
- 59:58opportunities there are for girls to play sports in general
- 1:00:01or do whatever else they want to do.
- 1:00:03I think the better. So it's it again, it's, you
- 1:00:07know, from the softball standpoint, I think their best
- 1:00:09opportunities right now are softball, their best path.
- 1:00:14They want to go to college. There's probably not a lot of
- 1:00:16baseball scholarships. There's more softball
- 1:00:20scholarships available. So that's a thought.
- 1:00:22But not everybody that plays softball wants to go to college
- 1:00:25to play either. So I think that from that
- 1:00:28standpoint, you know, why not? If there are people who want to
- 1:00:32play, if there's enough people who want to coach it, there's
- 1:00:34people who want to support it, you know, I'm all for it.
- 1:00:37The more opportunities for kids in general to play, the better.
- 1:00:41Yeah, I will. I'll only just say this.
- 1:00:43I feel that we live in a world where you should be able to be
- 1:00:47what you want to be and do what you want to do, and nobody
- 1:00:50should tell you. No.
- 1:00:52That's what I firmly believe. You know, I you know, I have
- 1:00:55three daughters myself. They want to play baseball, go
- 1:00:58do it. You want to be the best.
- 1:00:59You want to play the piano, go do it.
- 1:01:02Don't let others dictate what you want to do, right?
- 1:01:05And again, I think that's the biggest thing.
- 1:01:07I want to live in a world where people don't tell you what you
- 1:01:10have to do. You go and do what you want to
- 1:01:12do. And, and I firmly believe in
- 1:01:14that. And I and I live by that every
- 1:01:16day. As an educator for a long time,
- 1:01:19I couldn't imagine that when kids walk into my classroom that
- 1:01:24I'm going to say, well, you can't be a doctor and you can't
- 1:01:26be a mechanic and you can't be this.
- 1:01:28That's the wrong profession for me then, you know, And so I, I
- 1:01:32firmly believe that you, if you have a dream, you go chase your
- 1:01:36dreams, regardless of what it is.
- 1:01:38Well, and to that, the last question, then it's just like,
- 1:01:41you know, the last objection because who can listen to that
- 1:01:44and not be like, Amen. It's just yeah.
- 1:01:46But does anybody are do enough people feel this way to create
- 1:01:50the opportunity? And we went last year to the
- 1:01:52Baseball for All tournament. It was a high level, very
- 1:01:54competitive travel tournament. It was in suburban Reno last
- 1:01:58year, more than 500 kids. And I have no idea how many of
- 1:02:02them are. You know, again, lots of those
- 1:02:05kids were crossing over from softball.
- 1:02:06And in fact, our team got to sign the, you know, like some
- 1:02:09amazing 12 you softball player from Reno, just like read about
- 1:02:12the tournament in the paper and came out and jumped in was
- 1:02:14immediately awesome. But 500 kids, and that's today
- 1:02:19as we know this landscape, you know, where most people don't
- 1:02:21even think about this as an opportunity or as a, you know,
- 1:02:24sport that exists. There are still, you know, that
- 1:02:26many serious players. And I'm, you know, that's the
- 1:02:29number who are willing to fly to Reno and plan a travel
- 1:02:31tournament, not just the number who might otherwise care.
- 1:02:34So I do think there are enough people out there who might
- 1:02:36wander into your classroom and want to do it.
- 1:02:38Definitely, if that's something you want to do, don't restrict
- 1:02:41the opportunities. Get out there.
- 1:02:44Give everybody the opportunity to do whatever it is that that
- 1:02:46floats the boat. Yeah, right.
- 1:02:48This been awesome. Thank you.
- 1:02:49Thanks for letting me make the case and hopefully all of these
- 1:02:53sports go on to to grow and thrive.
- 1:02:55Well, yeah. Well, we're definitely looking
- 1:02:56forward to seeing that. Again, it's unengrained.
- 1:02:59It should be out in the beginning of May.
- 1:03:01So about the time this podcast hits, you should be able to go
- 1:03:04out and find it. So after you're done with us, go
- 1:03:06out and give that a listen wherever you get your podcast.
- 1:03:09Thanks again guys. Thank you, Steve.
- 1:03:11Jay, you want to talk about the T-shirts?
- 1:03:13Yeah, just have a few more left, Ken, and I think I'm going to
- 1:03:16have to make another order here. Like we always say, if you'd
- 1:03:19like a free T-shirt, we'd be happy to mail you one.
- 1:03:21All you've got to do is go to Spotify, Apple Podcast or
- 1:03:24wherever you listen, click give us a follow and then also share
- 1:03:28an episode out. Just introducing somebody out.
- 1:03:30This would be a great episode to share out there.
- 1:03:33Let people do that. Just let us know that you've
- 1:03:35done that. Send Ken or IA message and we
- 1:03:38will happily get you out a free T-shirt.
- 1:03:40Mail it out to you. Yeah, thanks to everybody who's
- 1:03:42been listening and and sharing. We appreciate it.
- 1:03:44And again, we've got a few left. We might do another run of
- 1:03:47T-shirts. So if you're interested in
- 1:03:49getting a free one, go ahead and do that.
- 1:03:51Yeah, and I just want to add that I had somebody send me a
- 1:03:54message the other day was talking about it and said that
- 1:03:56we are the only podcast that he and his wife can agree on to
- 1:03:59listen to. So, you know, definitely worth
- 1:04:02sharing. Absolutely.
- 1:04:03I'm stealing this. I'm stealing this free T-shirt
- 1:04:06idea. It's great.
- 1:04:07That's all Jay, but yeah, we're we're happy to do it.
- 1:04:11Get the word out there. The more the people that know
- 1:04:14about it, the more we can share great content like this.
- 1:04:16All righty. So that's it for us this week.
- 1:04:18Thanks to all of you for listening and the kind words
- 1:04:21you've been sharing with us. If you like what you're hearing,
- 1:04:23please give us a like leave a comment and share this podcast
- 1:04:26on your social media channels. Make sure you never miss an
- 1:04:29episode by following us on your favorite podcast platform.
- 1:04:33If you're so inclined, you can also leave us a great review on
- 1:04:36Apple Podcast to help more people find us.
- 1:04:39On behalf of the From the Coaches Mouth podcast, have a
- 1:04:42great rest of your week and weekend.