Latest / Bloomberg Law / Bloomberg Law Weekend: UAW, Texas AG, Pronouns
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: You're listening to Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: Welcome to the weekend edition of Bloomberg Law. Here's a
- 0:12Speaker 2: look at some of the top stories this week. The
- 0:15Speaker 2: United Auto Workers strike expands. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
- 0:20Speaker 2: may have been acquitted on impeachment charges, but he's now
- 0:24Speaker 2: facing a trial for securities fraud. Should schools tell parents
- 0:28Speaker 2: their children are using new pronouns? And the class action
- 0:32Speaker 2: lawsuits start over ineffective decongestants.
- 0:36Speaker 3: It's exciting but very scary because the unknown. You don't
- 0:40Speaker 3: know when you're going to get that full paycheck again.
- 0:41Speaker 3: You don't know when you're going to get back in there.
- 0:43Speaker 4: To work again.
- 0:44Speaker 2: Tonia Sullivan is a third generation auto worker walking the
- 0:48Speaker 2: picket line as the United Auto Workers' Union expanded its
- 0:52Speaker 2: target strikes against the Big three carmakers. More than five
- 0:55Speaker 2: thousand workers walked out of thirty eight General Motors and
- 0:59Speaker 2: Stalls facilities on Friday, joining the thirteen thousand auto workers
- 1:04Speaker 2: who walked off the job last week. Union President Shawn
- 1:08Speaker 2: Fain announced the stepped up pressure, pointing once again to
- 1:12Speaker 2: CEO pay raises and profits. The three companies have raked
- 1:15Speaker 2: in in recent.
- 1:16Speaker 5: Years across the country.
- 1:18Speaker 1: People are going to know that the UAW is ready
- 1:22Speaker 1: to stand up for our communities and ready to stand
- 1:25Speaker 1: up against corporate greed.
- 1:27Speaker 2: Ford with spared additional strikes because the company has met
- 1:30Speaker 2: some of the union's demands during negotiations over the past week.
- 1:34Speaker 2: Joining me is labor law expert Michael Duff, a professor
- 1:37Speaker 2: at the Saint Louis University School of Law. Let's talk
- 1:40Speaker 2: about the way Sean Fain has framed these negotiations as
- 1:45Speaker 2: a broader struggle. He said, it's the battle of the
- 1:47Speaker 2: working class against the rich, the haves versus the have nots,
- 1:51Speaker 2: the billionaire class against everyone else.
- 1:54Speaker 5: So I come from a blue collar background and a
- 1:57Speaker 5: prior life. I was a blue collar worker in the
- 2:00Speaker 5: airline industry. I didn't go to law school until my thirties.
- 2:03Speaker 5: I was a teamster shop star for a number of years.
- 2:06Speaker 5: And that rhetoric resonates with me as somebody from that
- 2:12Speaker 5: class and somebody who has gone through on a personal
- 2:15Speaker 5: level labor structure. To be honest, we have to look
- 2:18Speaker 5: at that and say, well, there's a generation of people,
- 2:21Speaker 5: people of roughly my age or a little bit younger
- 2:24Speaker 5: who would be very put off by that language that
- 2:27Speaker 5: would seem extremely corrosive, not tending to lead to agreements
- 2:32Speaker 5: and so forth. Now we have younger people coming up
- 2:37Speaker 5: through the ranks of organized labor, and the sort of
- 2:40Speaker 5: precariousness that a lot of them are facing, I think
- 2:43Speaker 5: makes the rhetoric almost suddenly appropriate, almost unbelievably to those
- 2:48Speaker 5: of us who have been involved studying the labor movement
- 2:52Speaker 5: for the last few decades. So what I think of
- 2:55Speaker 5: it is that it matches the enormity of some of
- 2:58Speaker 5: the structural change that we see going on in the
- 3:02Speaker 5: economy for workers.
- 3:04Speaker 2: What about this so called stand up strike targeting work
- 3:09Speaker 2: stoppages at plants.
- 3:11Speaker 5: Well, I think to the outside observer, a lot of
- 3:14Speaker 5: this sounds are pretty esoteric and strange, But actually from
- 3:18Speaker 5: a legal perspective, it makes sense because unions strike at
- 3:23Speaker 5: their peril, and the reason they strike at their peril
- 3:26Speaker 5: is that if employees are striking over economic subjects of bargaining,
- 3:30Speaker 5: that's the phrase of art. So you're not paying me enough,
- 3:33Speaker 5: I need more contribution to healthcare from you, mister m
- 3:37Speaker 5: his employer. If they are economic subjects that are sort
- 3:41Speaker 5: of fomenting the conflict between the union and the player.
- 3:44Speaker 5: Employees go on and strike, they can be permanently replaced,
- 3:48Speaker 5: and that's sort of the animating principle behind a lot
- 3:51Speaker 5: of what's going on here. What permanent replacement means is
- 3:54Speaker 5: that you go out on strike over an economic subject.
- 3:58Speaker 5: You can't be fired, but we have to be able
- 4:01Speaker 5: to attract people to do the job that you're no
- 4:04Speaker 5: longer doing because you're on strike, and we can't very
- 4:08Speaker 5: well go to this prospective employee that we want to
- 4:11Speaker 5: take your place and say, well, we're only going to
- 4:14Speaker 5: temporarily hire you. Why because we're not going to get
- 4:18Speaker 5: a lot of people that are going to like that deal.
- 4:20Speaker 5: So what we say to the replacement worker is you
- 4:23Speaker 5: come in and you can hold the job as long
- 4:25Speaker 5: as you want. And so, as a matter of law,
- 4:28Speaker 5: the employer is not required to fire that person at
- 4:32Speaker 5: the end of the strike. And so if you're the
- 4:35Speaker 5: average worker, you go out on strike and you're permanently replaced,
- 4:40Speaker 5: it's kind of a lawyer's distinction, the distinction between being
- 4:43Speaker 5: fired from being permanently replaced. If it means no employment,
- 4:47Speaker 5: then you're out of work either way, right, there's no
- 4:50Speaker 5: money coming in, you don't have food on the table.
- 4:52Speaker 5: Once you understand that this is the background rule, you
- 4:56Speaker 5: begin to understand why unions are very leer come more
- 5:00Speaker 5: lear over the decades of just going out on strike,
- 5:03Speaker 5: Because if you go out on strike and the job
- 5:06Speaker 5: is the kind of job that somebody coming in off
- 5:08Speaker 5: the street could do, and then what's going to happen
- 5:11Speaker 5: is the employer is simply going to replace all or
- 5:13Speaker 5: most of the bargaining unit, and it's a very difficult
- 5:16Speaker 5: situation for unions.
- 5:18Speaker 2: Thousands of workers have been laid off. All three of
- 5:21Speaker 2: the automakers have laid off workers, and they say it's
- 5:24Speaker 2: because of internal supply chain issues, a lack of parts
- 5:27Speaker 2: needed for certain assembly workers to do their jobs. Why
- 5:31Speaker 2: are they citing that? Do they need a reason for
- 5:34Speaker 2: laying off workers during a strike?
- 5:36Speaker 5: That's a very good question. So when you lay off
- 5:40Speaker 5: workers because you don't have enough materials to continue production,
- 5:46Speaker 5: arguably that's not even a lockout, right, You're not laying
- 5:50Speaker 5: the workers off, at least on the surface. You're not
- 5:53Speaker 5: laying them off to pressure the union to accept a
- 5:57Speaker 5: bargaining position that you have. You're laying workers off because
- 6:01Speaker 5: you can't continue production. In the old days, we used
- 6:04Speaker 5: to talk about lockouts, and just give you a sense
- 6:07Speaker 5: of how far back this line of law goes. It
- 6:09Speaker 5: used to be that we would say that defensive lockouts
- 6:13Speaker 5: were lawful, but offensive lockouts were unlawful. The distinction was
- 6:18Speaker 5: a defensive lockouts you had a good business reason for
- 6:22Speaker 5: doing what you were doing, right, There was no way
- 6:24Speaker 5: that you were doing it to pressure the union. You
- 6:27Speaker 5: had a business justification for locking employees out. I think
- 6:31Speaker 5: the strategy of the automakers here is the position themselves
- 6:36Speaker 5: in such a way that it's much harder to say
- 6:38Speaker 5: that they're doing what they're doing for discriminatory reasons. Probably
- 6:42Speaker 5: they're allowed to do it anyhow. They're probably allowed to
- 6:45Speaker 5: do it to pressure the union to accept their bargaining position.
- 6:48Speaker 5: They arguably could do that. But here they actually have
- 6:52Speaker 5: a business justification, which is, we can't make cars if
- 6:56Speaker 5: we don't have.
- 6:56Speaker 2: Park It sounds like management has all the cars. What
- 6:59Speaker 2: cars does the union hold?
- 7:02Speaker 5: Well, the sort of gamesmanship, that's what it is. It's
- 7:04Speaker 5: a high safe game. But this idea of the stand
- 7:08Speaker 5: up strike is that by moving around all right, so
- 7:13Speaker 5: you know, a boxer doesn't stand in one place and
- 7:16Speaker 5: allow himself to be punched. You sort of move around,
- 7:19Speaker 5: so you're not on strike at a number of facilities,
- 7:24Speaker 5: but you are at one key facility, right, And so
- 7:27Speaker 5: what you're doing is you're setting up a situation where
- 7:30Speaker 5: the employer could permanently replace in that particular location or
- 7:34Speaker 5: lock out, but then you have other facilities where nothing's
- 7:37Speaker 5: going on. It's a variant of something that labor insiders
- 7:41Speaker 5: called whipsaw strike. This actually goes back a number of decades, right,
- 7:46Speaker 5: and typically it was a union bargaining with different employers
- 7:50Speaker 5: than what was called a multi employer bargaining unit. But
- 7:53Speaker 5: the idea was very similar that what you did was,
- 7:56Speaker 5: as the employer, you see that the union is striking,
- 8:00Speaker 5: employers say over there, So what you do is you
- 8:04Speaker 5: lock out your employees to prevent the union from being
- 8:08Speaker 5: able to strike according to its own timetable. And the
- 8:11Speaker 5: idea is that that pressures the union in unforeseen ways.
- 8:15Speaker 5: But what the union can do is to engage in
- 8:19Speaker 5: work stoppages in unpredictable ways, it will run into various
- 8:24Speaker 5: legal doctrines that have been designed over the decades to
- 8:28Speaker 5: frustrate that kind of maneuver, but I do think that
- 8:30Speaker 5: that's the union's best opportunity to wind up with a
- 8:34Speaker 5: positive outcome.
- 8:35Speaker 2: Here, Sean Fain expanded the strike on Friday, is he
- 8:39Speaker 2: using a pretty aggressive strategy?
- 8:42Speaker 5: Well, it is aggressive, And you know what this reminds
- 8:45Speaker 5: me of. You know, at the end of World War Two,
- 8:48Speaker 5: aggressive union activity was obviously curtailed during the war and
- 8:53Speaker 5: there was a lot of hint up labor activity that
- 8:56Speaker 5: all of a sudden was released at the conclusion of
- 8:59Speaker 5: the war, and you had a lot of strikes occur,
- 9:02Speaker 5: and that became the impetus for creation of the Task
- 9:06Speaker 5: Partly Act, which is a part of the National Labor
- 9:09Speaker 5: Relations Act as it's been amended. And I almost feel like,
- 9:12Speaker 5: you know, as a result of just everything that's been
- 9:16Speaker 5: going on with respect to the gig economy and the
- 9:19Speaker 5: precariousness of employment, couples with the pandemic and some of
- 9:23Speaker 5: the labor conflicts that emerged because of the pandemic, a
- 9:26Speaker 5: lot of it centered on healthcare and perceived dangerous workplaces.
- 9:30Speaker 5: All of that kind of culminates over this summer. You
- 9:34Speaker 5: have a situation where workers maybe have had enough, they're
- 9:38Speaker 5: willing to take risk and I think Sean Fatis is
- 9:41Speaker 5: tapping into that. He realizes almost viscerally that he has
- 9:45Speaker 5: a rank and file employee group that's ready to hear
- 9:49Speaker 5: that message. If that message had been attempted in other eras,
- 9:53Speaker 5: it might not have been successful. But I think he
- 9:56Speaker 5: is mirroring some of the emotions that are percolating up
- 10:00Speaker 5: from the ranked file. And of course he is a
- 10:03Speaker 5: rank and file memory. He has deep roots in the
- 10:05Speaker 5: Auto union itself.
- 10:06Speaker 2: Well, it seems to be working as far as Ford
- 10:09Speaker 2: is concerned. Let's see what happens next week. Thanks so much, Michael.
- 10:13Speaker 2: That's Professor Michael Duff of the Saint Louis University School
- 10:16Speaker 2: of Law. Coming up next. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton
- 10:20Speaker 2: was acquitted at his impeachment trial, but now he's facing
- 10:24Speaker 2: a trial on felony securities fraud charges and is in
- 10:28Speaker 2: danger of losing his license to practice law. I'm June
- 10:31Speaker 2: Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 10:36Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 10:43Speaker 6: All Rise. The Court of Impeachment of the Texas Senate
- 10:46Speaker 6: is now in session.
- 10:47Speaker 2: Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton's eight year tenure as the
- 10:51Speaker 2: state's top law enforcement officer has been marked by public
- 10:55Speaker 2: scandals and criminal charges. The toughest test of his political
- 11:00Speaker 2: resilience came when he was impeached by fellow Republicans in
- 11:03Speaker 2: the House over allegations including bribery and corruption. Paxton denied
- 11:09Speaker 2: any wrongdoing and said the impeachment was a political sham
- 11:13Speaker 2: orchestrated by his opponents, and after a ten day trial
- 11:17Speaker 2: in the Republican led state Senate.
- 11:20Speaker 6: Living fourteen yas sixteen nays, a finding of acquittal is
- 11:26Speaker 6: entered as to Article one.
- 11:28Speaker 2: And that was the vote on all sixteen charges, a
- 11:32Speaker 2: resounding acquittal that puts back into office an attorney general
- 11:36Speaker 2: who's facing trial on felony securities fraud charges. Remains under
- 11:41Speaker 2: a separate FBI investigation and could be disbarred in an
- 11:45Speaker 2: ethics case brought by the Texas State Bar. Despite all
- 11:49Speaker 2: those legal challenges, in his first post trial interviews, a
- 11:53Speaker 2: newly embold in Paxton took aim at a number of
- 11:56Speaker 2: high profile fellow Republicans he believes betrayed him, including Texas
- 12:01Speaker 2: Senator John Cornyn, even telling Tucker Carlson he's not ruling
- 12:05Speaker 2: out a run for Cornyn's seat.
- 12:07Speaker 1: You know what, I don't.
- 12:08Speaker 6: I think he's never really had competition.
- 12:11Speaker 1: Why do you run against him?
- 12:12Speaker 6: Hey, look, everything's on the table for me.
- 12:14Speaker 2: Joining me is Madlin Meckelberg Bloomberg Texas Legal reporter. Madlin
- 12:18Speaker 2: start by telling us about the articles of impeachment, broadly,
- 12:23Speaker 2: what was he accused of.
- 12:24Speaker 7: So Ken Paxton was impeached by the Republican dominated House
- 12:29Speaker 7: in May of this year on twenty charges that spanned
- 12:34Speaker 7: the various allegations raised thence he took office as Attorney
- 12:38Speaker 7: General in twenty fifteen. They talked specifically about allegations raised
- 12:44Speaker 7: by top staffers in the Attorney General's office who reported
- 12:48Speaker 7: Paxton to the FBI for alleged bribery. They all really
- 12:52Speaker 7: center on Paxton's relationship with a friend and political donor
- 12:57Speaker 7: named Nate Paul, who's a real estate developer in Austin,
- 13:01Speaker 7: and he's been accused of using his office to aid Paul,
- 13:05Speaker 7: both in terms of turning over potentially confidential law enforcement
- 13:09Speaker 7: investigation information to Paul, who was under an FBI probe
- 13:14Speaker 7: at the time, and issuing opinions that would favor Paul
- 13:18Speaker 7: in some of his proceedings and so there's twenty different
- 13:21Speaker 7: articles that go into different facets, but this relationship is
- 13:25Speaker 7: really what's at the heart of them.
- 13:26Speaker 2: And we should note that Nate Paul has been federally
- 13:29Speaker 2: indicted on charges of making false statements to financial institutions.
- 13:34Speaker 2: Going back to the trial, what evidence stood out to you?
- 13:37Speaker 7: I think something that really stood out was consistent testimony
- 13:41Speaker 7: from top employees in his office who said they told
- 13:44Speaker 7: him time and time again that they were concerned about
- 13:48Speaker 7: his actions. We heard from people who said that they
- 13:51Speaker 7: had private conversations with him, who called meetings with him
- 13:55Speaker 7: to tell him that they were concerned that what he
- 13:57Speaker 7: was doing was stepping over the line. Something that's really
- 14:00Speaker 7: key in the case here that gets into this bribery
- 14:03Speaker 7: allegation is his alleged extramarital affair. One of the accusations
- 14:09Speaker 7: is that Nate Paul hired the woman with whom he
- 14:12Speaker 7: was allegedly having an affair and kept her on his payroll,
- 14:15Speaker 7: and in turn, Paxton was performing these acts in his
- 14:18Speaker 7: office to benefit Paul. We heard from his former chief
- 14:22Speaker 7: of staff in the office who talked about how this
- 14:24Speaker 7: relationship affected the staff and how people were uncomfortable fielding
- 14:29Speaker 7: phone calls from Paxton's wife and having to make certain
- 14:32Speaker 7: accommodations for him and this relationship. I think that was
- 14:36Speaker 7: a really compelling piece of.
- 14:37Speaker 3: Testimony that we heard.
- 14:38Speaker 2: Paxton didn't testify in his own defense. He only made
- 14:43Speaker 2: appearances at the trial at the beginning, in the very end,
- 14:46Speaker 2: what was his defense.
- 14:47Speaker 7: The goal for his defense was clear here, and that
- 14:50Speaker 7: was to cast this as a mutiny by some staffers
- 14:54Speaker 7: in his office who wanted to take over as attorney
- 14:57Speaker 7: general potentially. They said, this is is a politically targeted
- 15:01Speaker 7: attack at Ken Paxton. They say none of the actions
- 15:04Speaker 7: he took violated the law. All of the things were
- 15:07Speaker 7: things that he was allowed to do within his power
- 15:10Speaker 7: as attorney general.
- 15:12Speaker 2: So Paxton is back in office as the state's top
- 15:15Speaker 2: law enforcement officer, but he's facing other legal problems.
- 15:20Speaker 7: That's right, he's been reinstated as attorney general. I think
- 15:23Speaker 7: there's a lot of eyes now on what happens next.
- 15:26Speaker 7: How do you go back to that office after going
- 15:28Speaker 7: through this like really public ordeal where a lot of
- 15:31Speaker 7: details were shared about your alleged conduct. And then he's
- 15:35Speaker 7: got other legal battles regarding his conduct that he still
- 15:39Speaker 7: has to fight, like I mentioned he's been under indictment
- 15:42Speaker 7: since twenty fifteen or securities fraud in a case that
- 15:45Speaker 7: is yet to go to trial. It's been delayed significantly
- 15:49Speaker 7: by these different pre trial squabbles, and he's also tied
- 15:53Speaker 7: up in some disciplinary proceedings involving the state bar of
- 15:56Speaker 7: Texas who accused him of professional conduct for his efforts
- 16:01Speaker 7: to try to overturn the twenty twenty presidential election results.
- 16:05Speaker 7: And there's an ongoing federal probe into his conduct that
- 16:09Speaker 7: was prompted by the whistleblowers who are behind some of
- 16:12Speaker 7: these impeachment plans, So we could still see charges them
- 16:15Speaker 7: from that. So while this was a significant step, it's
- 16:18Speaker 7: not the final word on Paxton's legal saga.
- 16:22Speaker 2: Those two state securities fraud charges, he was indicted on
- 16:26Speaker 2: those just months after he took office in twenty fifteen,
- 16:30Speaker 2: and it's always surprised me that that hasn't gone to
- 16:33Speaker 2: trial yet. How has he managed to avoid trial for eight.
- 16:37Speaker 7: Years, That's a great question. There's been quite a few
- 16:41Speaker 7: skirmishes ahead of this trial date. I think a key
- 16:44Speaker 7: one was venue where the case should be tried, either
- 16:48Speaker 7: in Houston or in his home county of Colin County.
- 16:52Speaker 7: There have been objections raised to the prosecutor bringing the case,
- 16:56Speaker 7: and all of these disputes have gone through a full
- 16:58Speaker 7: appeals process on their own, going up to the top
- 17:01Speaker 7: state appeals court in Texas, and they caused significant delays.
- 17:06Speaker 7: I think. Finally the state appeals court said that the
- 17:09Speaker 7: case can proceed in Harris County. There was a date
- 17:13Speaker 7: here in state for Paxton in the case just before
- 17:16Speaker 7: the impeachment proceedings began, and the judge said, once those
- 17:20Speaker 7: proceedings wrapped, she's ready to get this case moving again
- 17:23Speaker 7: in Harris County.
- 17:25Speaker 2: And as you said, there is an investigation by the
- 17:30Speaker 2: FBI and the Justice Department's Public Integrity Section. Is that
- 17:34Speaker 2: on the same allegations that were testified to in the
- 17:39Speaker 2: impeachment trial.
- 17:40Speaker 7: That's right. So these top employees in Paxton's office, who
- 17:45Speaker 7: we call the whistleblowers, they reported Paxton's conduct to the
- 17:49Speaker 7: FBI as it relates to advancing causes on behalf of
- 17:53Speaker 7: his friend and political donor Nate Paul, and the FBI
- 17:57Speaker 7: and the DOJ they've been investigating. We have seen the
- 18:00Speaker 7: result of that investigation up to this point, but those
- 18:04Speaker 7: cases are ongoing.
- 18:05Speaker 2: And just to be clear, he was re elected last
- 18:09Speaker 2: year to a third term despite all these criminal and
- 18:12Speaker 2: ethical allegations.
- 18:14Speaker 7: That's exactly right, and that was a point that we
- 18:16Speaker 7: heard from Paxton's defense council throughout the proceedings. They said,
- 18:20Speaker 7: Texas voters knew about these allegations and made it a
- 18:23Speaker 7: care they elected him anyway, and so why should the
- 18:26Speaker 7: state Senate overturn that? Why should they overturn the will
- 18:30Speaker 7: of the voters.
- 18:30Speaker 2: And Paxton seems newly emboldened by his acquittal. Some political
- 18:36Speaker 2: experts think that he could gain prominence on the national stage.
- 18:40Speaker 7: I think that's totally fair. I mean, from the beginning,
- 18:43Speaker 7: Paxton's reputation has been built on being a conservative agitator
- 18:48Speaker 7: who does the Biden administration over everything that they do,
- 18:53Speaker 7: and he's worked to align himself with former President Donald Trump,
- 18:57Speaker 7: who we saw go through a similar thing during his presidency,
- 19:01Speaker 7: being acquitted in impeachment cases and only serving to boost
- 19:05Speaker 7: his reputation. And I think that that's exactly what we're
- 19:08Speaker 7: going to see happen here with Paxton, who's going to
- 19:11Speaker 7: certainly be emboldened by this outcome. I think we're still
- 19:15Speaker 7: waiting kind of with bated breast to see what his
- 19:17Speaker 7: first moves are going to be now that he's been
- 19:19Speaker 7: reinstated to the office. But I think it's certainly fair
- 19:22Speaker 7: to say that this has only helped to bolster his
- 19:25Speaker 7: reputation within his own party.
- 19:26Speaker 2: A lot more to come in the legal sagas of
- 19:30Speaker 2: Ken Paxton, and I know you'll be following that Forrest Madeline.
- 19:33Speaker 2: Thanks so much. That's Bloomberg Texas Legal reporter and Madelin
- 19:37Speaker 2: Mecklberg coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show. A
- 19:41Speaker 2: new legal battle is emerging over whether schools should tell
- 19:44Speaker 2: parents that their children are using new preferred pronouns. I'm
- 19:49Speaker 2: June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 19:54Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 20:00Speaker 8: When children say they identify as something other than their
- 20:03Speaker 8: sex at school, do they become mere creatures of the state,
- 20:07Speaker 8: or do their fit parents still have the fundamental right
- 20:10Speaker 8: to make decisions regarding their care.
- 20:14Speaker 2: The emerging legal battle over pronoun protocol in public schools
- 20:18Speaker 2: has nothing to do with grammar and everything to do
- 20:21Speaker 2: with gender identity. Some parents are suing schools that keep
- 20:26Speaker 2: their children's use of new pronouns secret, claiming it's a
- 20:29Speaker 2: violation of their constitutional right to direct the upbringing of
- 20:33Speaker 2: their children. The Ludlow, Massachusetts School Committee is being sued
- 20:37Speaker 2: over a teacher's failure to notify parents that their eleven
- 20:41Speaker 2: year old began using different preferred pronouns. A federal judge
- 20:45Speaker 2: dismissed the parent's complaint, but the First Circuit Court of
- 20:49Speaker 2: Appeals could revive it, and at oral arguments, the judges
- 20:52Speaker 2: seem to be wrestling with the issues. Here are judges
- 20:56Speaker 2: Julie Reichlemann and Kermit Leipez.
- 20:58Speaker 9: I think gender identify is clearly very important to everyone,
- 21:02Speaker 9: and there are many things that happen in school every
- 21:04Speaker 9: day that would qualify is less important than that. So
- 21:08Speaker 9: do you really see no limiting principle between something like
- 21:12Speaker 9: the gender identity of your child and who your child
- 21:15Speaker 9: may have played with during recess that day. Are you
- 21:18Speaker 9: really saying there's no difference there?
- 21:20Speaker 6: But you seem to be assert bottom line that the
- 21:24Speaker 6: rights of the student to preclude disclosure of this request
- 21:31Speaker 6: to use pronouns trump's the right of the parents to
- 21:35Speaker 6: know what's going on with respect to the child's gender identity.
- 21:39Speaker 6: Bottom line you are asserting.
- 21:41Speaker 2: That, aren't you joining me? Is Audrey Anderson, head of
- 21:44Speaker 2: the higher education practice at Bassbari and Simms. Audrey explain
- 21:48Speaker 2: why the parents are suing here.
- 21:51Speaker 3: The school where their children middle school are attended, have
- 21:56Speaker 3: a policy that's not an unusual policy that says, if
- 22:01Speaker 3: the students come to personnel in the school and say
- 22:04Speaker 3: that they want to change their name, change their pronoun
- 22:09Speaker 3: to the opposite gender that they were born into, the
- 22:13Speaker 3: school will work with them to do that, and also
- 22:17Speaker 3: we'll keep that information from the student's parents if the
- 22:21Speaker 3: students ask for it to be kept from their parents.
- 22:25Speaker 3: So the parents here were aware that one of their
- 22:28Speaker 3: children was experiencing some questions about their gender and actually
- 22:33Speaker 3: reached out to the school proactively to say, we don't
- 22:36Speaker 3: want you to talk to our child about this, and
- 22:39Speaker 3: the school, nevertheless, behind the parents' backs, talk to the child,
- 22:44Speaker 3: started calling the child by a different name, use different pronouns,
- 22:49Speaker 3: and the parents, understandably were very upset about this.
- 22:53Speaker 2: What surprises me about this is that at that age,
- 22:58Speaker 2: if your kid seems aggressed, gets into a fight with someone,
- 23:02Speaker 2: the teachers are on the phone, are calling you in
- 23:04Speaker 2: and yet they don't want to tell them about this
- 23:07Speaker 2: very important aspect of their kid's life.
- 23:10Speaker 3: The countervailing policy decision here, and I think one reason
- 23:14Speaker 3: why the parents are going to have a particularly hard
- 23:17Speaker 3: time winning this case is if there's a Massachusetts law
- 23:21Speaker 3: that requires schools to not discriminate against students because of
- 23:27Speaker 3: their gender identity. And so this school has decided that
- 23:33Speaker 3: in order to carry out that duty, they need to
- 23:37Speaker 3: keep that information about the student private if the student
- 23:41Speaker 3: asks for it to be private. So the school district
- 23:45Speaker 3: here says, well, we have this date law that says
- 23:48Speaker 3: we are not allowed to discriminate on the basis of
- 23:52Speaker 3: gender identity. And there are some students for which it
- 23:56Speaker 3: won't be safe for them at home. If their parents
- 24:00Speaker 3: to know that they are going by a different gender identity,
- 24:05Speaker 3: it may become psychologically unsafe for them at home. So
- 24:10Speaker 3: that's the countervailing thing and why this is different in
- 24:14Speaker 3: the school's mind from your child god in a fight,
- 24:18Speaker 3: or your child through up at school, or all the
- 24:21Speaker 3: other things that happened to kids at school that the
- 24:24Speaker 3: school does tell parents about.
- 24:26Speaker 2: Did the school just call the child by preferred pronouns
- 24:30Speaker 2: or did the school do more than that?
- 24:33Speaker 3: They also had somebody at the school meet with the
- 24:36Speaker 3: child regularly to talk to them about how they were
- 24:40Speaker 3: feeling and be a resource person for them. And the
- 24:43Speaker 3: parents here alleged that in that way they were actually
- 24:47Speaker 3: giving mental health treatment to their child without the parent's consent. Now,
- 24:53Speaker 3: the district court found that they hadn't adequately alleged facts
- 24:58Speaker 3: to support a concl inclusion that the child was receiving
- 25:03Speaker 3: mental health treatment, though the district court kind of threw
- 25:07Speaker 3: that out based on the factual allegation.
- 25:10Speaker 2: The district court used a standard, a very tough standard,
- 25:15Speaker 2: shocking the conscience. Tell us what that standard is and
- 25:18Speaker 2: is it appropriate in this case? Is it the correct
- 25:21Speaker 2: standard in this case?
- 25:23Speaker 5: Well?
- 25:23Speaker 3: Yes, the parents here are alleging that their substantive due
- 25:27Speaker 3: process rights were violated, and the court I think used
- 25:31Speaker 3: the right standard to figure that out. You know, the
- 25:36Speaker 3: parents in the Court of Appeals have said that the
- 25:39Speaker 3: district court kind of made that standard extra tough. But
- 25:43Speaker 3: the cases I've looked at deemed to require that the
- 25:46Speaker 3: facts alleged really have to shock the conscience, and they're
- 25:50Speaker 3: usually looking for something where the state actor has intentionally
- 25:57Speaker 3: inflicted harm on the person who is suing. So, you know,
- 26:02Speaker 3: one of the cases I saw where there actually was
- 26:05Speaker 3: substantive due process adequately alleged was where a school coach
- 26:10Speaker 3: had intentionally used a hard object to hit a student
- 26:15Speaker 3: in the face. That shocked the conscience. But there's lots
- 26:20Speaker 3: of things where students are hurt where it might be upsetting,
- 26:25Speaker 3: but it doesn't reach that shock the conscience standard, and
- 26:28Speaker 3: substantive due process is a very tricky legal standard that
- 26:33Speaker 3: lots of judges think should be circumscribed, that there should
- 26:38Speaker 3: be very few things that we find are protected by
- 26:41Speaker 3: substantive due process. So what's established is the right to marry,
- 26:47Speaker 3: the right to have children. So they want to keep
- 26:50Speaker 3: the range of things that are within substantive due process
- 26:54Speaker 3: really small. Now, these parents say that, well, what's within
- 26:58Speaker 3: substantive due process is the right to raise your children
- 27:02Speaker 3: as you see fit. The thing they run into there
- 27:06Speaker 3: is that there are Supreme Court cases that support that.
- 27:10Speaker 3: But what they support is the right to raise your
- 27:14Speaker 3: children as you see fit in a private school setting.
- 27:18Speaker 3: So to me, those cases only say that these parents
- 27:21Speaker 3: have a right to send their children to a school
- 27:24Speaker 3: that would not have a policy like this. I think
- 27:27Speaker 3: it's much harder to say that within the public schools
- 27:30Speaker 3: they get to have a right to say what the
- 27:33Speaker 3: policy is on something like this. Here's my caveat. I'm
- 27:37Speaker 3: surprised that they haven't raised a religious argument. I think
- 27:41Speaker 3: that they'd have a stronger argument if they were also
- 27:44Speaker 3: raising some kind of a free exercise argument, that our
- 27:49Speaker 3: religion also supports the idea that you are the gender
- 27:54Speaker 3: that you're born into, and so for you to be
- 27:56Speaker 3: teaching our child something other than that and sporting them
- 28:00Speaker 3: transitioning when we've told you not to violate our religious rights.
- 28:05Speaker 3: But they haven't argued that in this case.
- 28:07Speaker 2: So this First Circuit decision will be the highest court
- 28:11Speaker 2: ruling on the merits of this argument. There's a case
- 28:16Speaker 2: before the Eleventh Circuit which is very conservative, so there
- 28:19Speaker 2: might end up being some kind of split in the circuits.
- 28:23Speaker 3: Yeah, I definitely agree with that. I think that this
- 28:25Speaker 3: is an issue that some conservative court will find that
- 28:30Speaker 3: at least a complaint can go forward, and then the
- 28:33Speaker 3: question will be whether the Supreme Court gets interested enough
- 28:36Speaker 3: at that point or whether they want a case with
- 28:39Speaker 3: a little bit more factual development, something that goes to
- 28:44Speaker 3: a summary judgment motion at least or maybe even a
- 28:47Speaker 3: trial before they decide to weigh in on this. You
- 28:52Speaker 3: know when the Supreme Court. If when the Supreme Court
- 28:55Speaker 3: weighs into this, I think that some of the justices
- 28:57Speaker 3: will have a hard time because the concern servative side
- 29:00Speaker 3: of the Supreme Court wants very much to have a
- 29:04Speaker 3: very very narrow set of circumstances where substantive process protects
- 29:09Speaker 3: rights and justice. Thomas doesn't think that there is such
- 29:12Speaker 3: a thing as substantivety process. On the other hand, I
- 29:16Speaker 3: would believe them to be very concerned about these kinds
- 29:20Speaker 3: of school policies. So how they will thread that needle,
- 29:24Speaker 3: I think will be very interesting.
- 29:27Speaker 2: Well, certainly this case is being watched nationally. There were
- 29:31Speaker 2: more than one hundred amkas briefs filed, including from nineteen
- 29:35Speaker 2: states that supported the parents' position and fifteen states that
- 29:40Speaker 2: supported the school's position. So we'll see other first circuit rules.
- 29:43Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Audrey. That's Audrey Anderson, head of the
- 29:47Speaker 2: higher education practice at bess Berry and Simms. Coming up next,
- 29:52Speaker 2: the lawsuits start over ineffective decongestins. This is Bloomberg.
- 30:00Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg radio.
- 30:05Speaker 2: We're approaching cold and flu season, and advisors to the
- 30:09Speaker 2: Food and Drug Administration say the key drug and the
- 30:12Speaker 2: leading over the counter decongestants used by millions of Americans
- 30:17Speaker 2: is no better than a placebo. Allergists like doctor Purvy
- 30:21Speaker 2: Perik say consumers should read the labels of coal medications.
- 30:25Speaker 2: This ingredient panel affron is in so many different cold medicines.
- 30:30Speaker 2: That's why it is important to kind of educate yourself
- 30:33Speaker 2: on what to.
- 30:34Speaker 7: Look for and just avoid that ingredient.
- 30:37Speaker 2: It was predictable that shortly after the FDA's announcement, class
- 30:41Speaker 2: action lawsuits were filed against pharmaceutical companies and retailers on
- 30:45Speaker 2: behalf of consumers joining me is healthcare attorney Harry Nelson
- 30:49Speaker 2: of Nelson Hardiman. Class action lawsuits were filed within days
- 30:55Speaker 2: of the FDA's announcement.
- 30:58Speaker 4: I mean, it's almost reflective. There are planet of law
- 31:01Speaker 4: firms around the countries that are basically built to take
- 31:04Speaker 4: on harm related to different drugs, and so as soon
- 31:08Speaker 4: as the FDA said the drug was ineffective, it's not
- 31:10Speaker 4: a surprise that we saw the first class action filed
- 31:13Speaker 4: down in Florida. The real question is other than the
- 31:16Speaker 4: harm to people's wallets from spending one point seventy five
- 31:19Speaker 4: billion on the drug, what actual harm? You know, whether
- 31:22Speaker 4: there were any side effects that actually hurt anybody from
- 31:25Speaker 4: fenel effronts. There are a lot of reports of like
- 31:27Speaker 4: minor problems like swelling or in rashes and itching, but
- 31:31Speaker 4: I'm not aware of any severe harm, and it's not
- 31:34Speaker 4: clear what kind of damages they are going to be
- 31:36Speaker 4: beyond just the fact that these companies were selling an
- 31:38Speaker 4: ineffect or drug.
- 31:40Speaker 2: Some of the complaints charged that the defendants violated consumer
- 31:44Speaker 2: protection statutes and alleged a breach of implied warranty of
- 31:49Speaker 2: merchant ability and they committed fraud.
- 31:51Speaker 8: But if the.
- 31:52Speaker 2: FDA approved this, what were the manufacturers supposed to do? Say, no,
- 31:57Speaker 2: the FDA is wrong.
- 31:59Speaker 4: You know, there's been a lot of industry studies going on,
- 32:02Speaker 4: so we know that, for example, competitors of some of
- 32:05Speaker 4: the mls and products, like the folks that sharing Plot
- 32:07Speaker 4: who were making Clereson, were doing a lot of research
- 32:10Speaker 4: to show that and arguing that these drugs were ineffective.
- 32:12Speaker 4: It's an interesting question whether internally whether the manufacturers were
- 32:17Speaker 4: doing their own research and had reason to know that
- 32:20Speaker 4: these drugs were not effective, and whether they turned a
- 32:23Speaker 4: blind eye to it. I think it's an interesting question,
- 32:25Speaker 4: and hopefully we'll learn about some of the internal process
- 32:28Speaker 4: within the pharmaceuticals and how much they were aware of
- 32:31Speaker 4: this and taking it seriously and concerned about it. But
- 32:33Speaker 4: you know, I think that still remains ahead of us.
- 32:36Speaker 2: You mentioned harm to consumers and that there's probably very
- 32:39Speaker 2: little of that, so it would be limited to economic damages, right.
- 32:44Speaker 4: I think what's likely to happen. I mean, I don't
- 32:46Speaker 4: mean to sound cynical, but when this case gets prosecuted,
- 32:49Speaker 4: what's likely to happen is that the lawyers who brought
- 32:51Speaker 4: these cases will have a multimillion dollar payday and attorneys fees,
- 32:56Speaker 4: and they'll be coupons, you know, for people who can
- 32:58Speaker 4: prove that they bought the drugs, But those coupons will
- 33:01Speaker 4: be for insignificant amounts. The big winners in this class
- 33:04Speaker 4: action are likely to be the lawyers who get tens
- 33:06Speaker 4: of millions of dollars for filing it.
- 33:08Speaker 2: As an example, Johnson and Johnson's consumer unit settle claims
- 33:13Speaker 2: alleging aerosol products contained benzene for one point seventy five
- 33:18Speaker 2: million dollars plus two point five million in attorneys fees,
- 33:23Speaker 2: so more an attorney's fees than in the settlement for consumers.
- 33:27Speaker 6: Yeah.
- 33:28Speaker 4: So a lot of people and including me, think it
- 33:30Speaker 4: is a defect in our class action systems that, you know,
- 33:32Speaker 4: the plane of class action lawyers are motivated to bring
- 33:36Speaker 4: cases that really don't do much to advance the public interest,
- 33:39Speaker 4: but to produce profitable work for them. Kind of a
- 33:43Speaker 4: sort of bug in our class action system that anytime
- 33:47Speaker 4: there's a drug even if the harm to the public
- 33:48Speaker 4: is really miniscule, the plane of class action lawyers have
- 33:51Speaker 4: a big opportunity.
- 33:52Speaker 2: Are those kinds of suits mostly settled? Do any of
- 33:55Speaker 2: them ever go to trial?
- 33:57Speaker 4: This is certainly not a case that's going to trial.
- 34:00Speaker 4: You know, if there were big damages and significant amounts
- 34:03Speaker 4: that would be you know, at risk, like if the
- 34:06Speaker 4: harm caused by a final effron was so significant, then
- 34:09Speaker 4: there would be something to fight over and a lot
- 34:12Speaker 4: at stakes. But you know, the money that the drug
- 34:14Speaker 4: companies are likely to pay for this is going to
- 34:17Speaker 4: be something like a rounding error for them. This is
- 34:19Speaker 4: not going to be one of those multi billion dollar settlements.
- 34:22Speaker 4: It's likely that the plans class ection layers will kind
- 34:24Speaker 4: of have a get in quick, you know, reach the settlements,
- 34:27Speaker 4: and the drug companies will be offered numbers that will
- 34:30Speaker 4: motivate them to do so. I think it's a pretty
- 34:32Speaker 4: safe bet that we're never going to see a trial
- 34:34Speaker 4: on the marketing of a penel efron.
- 34:36Speaker 2: Thanks Harry. That's Harry Nelson of Nelson Hardiman, and that's
- 34:39Speaker 2: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember
- 34:42Speaker 2: you can always get the latest legal news on our
- 34:44Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 34:48Speaker 2: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law,
- 34:54Speaker 2: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 34:57Speaker 2: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 35:01Speaker 2: and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 35:03Speaker 4: Mhm.