Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D Classics-Volko Ruhnke
Transcript
- 0:02So five g for d has been going for nearly five years now, and
- 0:06I'm sure many of you will have missed some of the early interviews because you
- 0:10weren't there at the beginning. I mean, why would you have been.
- 0:13So what I'm gonna do is I'm going to release some classic episodes from some
- 0:18legends of the industry that you might have missed. And so I hope you
- 0:22enjoy these shows, and I hope you enjoy the brand new ones that come
- 0:26out every two weeks. So thank you for listening and enjoy. Out of
- 0:36the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:40waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:44at you, the sirens, the hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:48of the city. And you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:52that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:55still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 0:59shelf of game You only have room for five Five Games for Doomsday. Five
- 1:08Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust into a
- 1:12cabin in the woods, to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only take
- 1:17five of their games with them. But which will they choose? My guest
- 1:23this week is a legend of the wargaming world, but also used his skills
- 1:26in game design to help train the CIA. He's a retired CIA analyst and
- 1:30instructor at the CIA's own training facility, the Sherman Kent School for Intelligence Analysis.
- 1:37In the board game world, he's probably best well known for being the
- 1:40inventor of the Coin series of games, which try and unravel the puzzle of
- 1:44Internisian conflict. My guest this week is Volco Runker. Volco Welcome to the
- 1:49cabin. So to begin with, then, my first question is how difficult
- 1:53was it for you to choose the five games to take to the cabin.
- 1:57It is difficult, and you know, you have so many things you love
- 2:02and everything has its place. So trying to choose the top four or five
- 2:07games for that I might you know, be interested in playing or projects I
- 2:12might be interested in working on in the future is very much. I think
- 2:15comes down actually to time. If you ask me that question a year ago
- 2:20or a year from now would probably be a different answer. Do you think
- 2:24in a sense. For the war gamer, this task is a little bit
- 2:30easier because it seems to me that war games have the notion of playability built
- 2:37into them in a way that more conventional games don't. Well, that's interesting.
- 2:42That hadn't occurred to me about wargames having more replayability built in. However,
- 2:50even if that is true, if I have to pick what are the
- 2:54five most interesting or the five most replayable, I'm still probably in the most
- 3:00part comparing one war game to another. So it still leaves the choice a
- 3:04difficult one. And sort of what criteria did you use for taking the games
- 3:08to the cabin? Was it sentimentality? Was it? Was it pure utility?
- 3:13I am going to get the most value out of this game? Or
- 3:15was it something else? I suppose it is utility. It was what am
- 3:19I going to find most engrossing and entertaining over an extended period of time.
- 3:28I don't have too much sentimentality about about old games, I sell, I
- 3:32suppose, But I didn't bring it to the cabin to look at it on
- 3:38the shelf and say, oh, those were the days, but rather,
- 3:40you know, here's something I can I can play a lot and still have
- 3:44be interested in playing more or in my case, here's a game that I'm
- 3:47working on right now that I'm looking forward to spending time developing, refining,
- 3:53finishing the design. And so you're going to have to forgive me here because
- 3:58I'm I'm something of a well, a neo fight would be over selling it,
- 4:01I think when it comes to wargames myself, but it seems that wargames
- 4:06have a sort of an esthetic that sort of goes across the genre, in
- 4:15the way when I look at more conventional board games, you have very different
- 4:18styles and there is an ever more present leaning towards miniatures and components. Do
- 4:30you think you yourself and wargamers in general, do you think they have an
- 4:35attachment to the object of the game, not just the mechanics, or do
- 4:43you think wargamers are much more about focusing on the rules rather than the bling
- 4:47that goes with it. It's interesting. The starting point I would always have
- 4:54thought was the simulation, right the you know, what is the model in
- 4:59there? It's going to help show me how this battle or this war worked
- 5:03in history. But I've found over time, in fact, I think war
- 5:08gamers, like other gamers, do have a lot of attachment to the form
- 5:13of the thing. Art nowadays is as important to war games as other board
- 5:18games in transporting you to that time and history in that place, and war
- 5:26gamers, I think, like any hobbyists, can become attached to the forms
- 5:32that they're used to and what what what has worked for them in the past
- 5:36and consider that beautiful and something new, undesirable or enathma. And I've certainly
- 5:42run into that in terms of reactions to my own designs and questions like why
- 5:46does this have wooden cubes and not little cardboard chits with numbers on them?
- 5:50That's that's some somehow a detriment to the experience if what you're used to is
- 5:58chits with numbers, and sort of I've noticed within you know, board games
- 6:02have sort of niches that are away from the sort of the mainstream of the
- 6:08hobby game, if you like. And so, but I've noticed there has
- 6:13been a sort of upping in production for things like eighteen xx games and train
- 6:18games, and you know, I was always very surprised when I got into
- 6:21games that in a war game amounted board was a was a special thing.
- 6:28Do you think wargames are going away from that sort of feeling of being made
- 6:32by guys in their garages to a more sort of conventional professional mode of production.
- 6:40Well, absolutely, in terms of the you know, the leading companies
- 6:46quality, physical quality has come up, as it has in the in the
- 6:54rest of the hobby, and maybe with wargames it started at a lower level,
- 6:59so that that's even more noticeable. Uh, And and questions like is
- 7:04the is the board mounted? And how cleanly are the counters cut? And
- 7:10doesn't have woodbits? And are the woodbits and boss? And what is the
- 7:13quality of the playing cards? All of that comes in in reactions of players
- 7:17and viewers to war games. Absolutely. I will say, however, at
- 7:21the same time that that's not to imply that this cottage industry desktop published in
- 7:30print to play and less pricey publisher games. It's not to say that those
- 7:38aren't thriving as well. We really have a thousand flowers blooming. And so
- 7:45is there a sort of indie side to wall gaming, as there's an indie
- 7:48side to everything? There absolutely is. And in the past, you know,
- 7:54there were there were micro games, little little pocket one and two dollars
- 7:59games you could buy, and little Baggie, and there are all kinds of
- 8:03designers experimenting putting out their own designs for free print and play, publishing games
- 8:11through game Crafter home publishing them. There are publishers that specialize in lower,
- 8:18lower cost components and ones that specialize in very you know, very ritzy productions
- 8:24at the other end of the scale. So so yeah, it's quite a
- 8:30variety, and India is a good word for for segments of it. So
- 8:33let's go back to the beginning then. So you you told me that you
- 8:37were born to a you know, a German father and a mother brought up
- 8:41in a German family in in Argentina. How did your parents end up in
- 8:46America. Well, my my father had emigrated from you know, post war
- 8:54Germany in the late fifties to the United States with you know, founded employer
- 8:58to help bring him over. His older brother had essentially done the same thing
- 9:05from Germany to Uruguay and Argentina, and he ended up my father's older brother
- 9:09ended up marrying there in Argentina and Uruguay, and my father went down from
- 9:20the United States to visit his brother and meet the new bride, meet his
- 9:24sister in law, and ended up getting engaged to her younger sister and they
- 9:28got married there and both my parents came up to the United States. And
- 9:31what was it like to be a German in America so close to the Second
- 9:37World War? You do you think your parents found it difficult or were they
- 9:41there at a time when sort of things are blown over? Oh? By
- 9:46that time it was the early sixties, And yes, I would say,
- 9:48I would say things have blown over. And of course for my mother,
- 9:54I mean she was she was in at Montevideo as a as a as a
- 9:58toddler when the Lashbee was scuttle there. But she was, you know,
- 10:03she was young, so they were growing up in the nineteen fifties really.
- 10:07But my father as had been a young teenager in World War Two already.
- 10:13Obviously my grandparents on his side had vivid recollections of the war. So I
- 10:18did grow up on stories of World War Two from the point of view of
- 10:26the German civilian and sort of do you think that gave you a unique perspective
- 10:31into sort of people's attitudes to war in that I remember I saw the movie
- 10:37when I was sort of sixteen seventeen, I saw the movie Styliningrad, which
- 10:41is a German Second World War film, and I was quite shocked at German
- 10:50soldiers being portrayed as human beings because I'd grown up on where eagles there and
- 10:54the Great Escape and things like this, you know, very much films that
- 10:58portrayed the Germans as the villains. Do you think you have a more sort
- 11:03of rounded view of that period simply by the house in which you grew up?
- 11:07I think it did? You know? We all, I mean,
- 11:13it's a good example that you give how we all look at that life and
- 11:16history and humanity through through the experiences and the information we have, and it's
- 11:22always a particular perspective and a partial set of information. So in my case,
- 11:26it was different, I think than many of my boyhood friends in terms
- 11:30of what I had consumed, which was stories like like my you know father
- 11:37having a schoolhouse, you know, bombed by the Russians and being happy about
- 11:41it because he was failing some of his classes and the records were all destroyed,
- 11:46and then the family just barely escaping being overrun by the Red Army as
- 11:50it was escaped. They lived in East Prussia and they were crossing Poland and
- 11:54arriving as refugees in Dresden and being bombed there by the Americans and seeing you
- 12:00know, my father as a as a boy, seeing you know, civilians
- 12:05with you know, burning phosphorus on their skin and so forth from the American
- 12:07bombs and my grandfather, who'd been a conscript soldier at the end of the
- 12:16war, being in a French pow camp for another two years and baking asthma
- 12:20just to be able to go home at that point, and then you know,
- 12:24a sort of a starvation time afterwards. My family always sent my father
- 12:28to go collect the food coupons because he was a very thin boy, and
- 12:31it made it look like the family needed more coupons, and so I you
- 12:37know, So it wasn't you know that where Eagles dare or Kelly's heroes were
- 12:43a view of World War Two that I was growing up on. But I
- 12:46do think that made me, if anything, more interested in war as a
- 12:52phenomenon and what is it like for human beings to experience that? And did
- 12:58that manage to give you a view of Germans attitudes towards Hitler, because you
- 13:03know, when you're brought up, I was brought up in Britain on sort
- 13:07of British history, and you assume all the Germans and Nazis until you get
- 13:09a bit older and there's a nuance something did you you know? Was their
- 13:13talk of how people felt towards the Third Reich, discussed over the dinner table
- 13:20or in the living room. Yes, and I mean, I'll say at
- 13:24the beginning, of course, I have no way of verifying you know,
- 13:26what I heard. But here here's what I heard, and that was,
- 13:31you know, my father's father was, as I said, conscripted right in
- 13:33the beginning, didn't have any you know, interest in war, but but
- 13:39really had no choice he and he was a construction engineer and built bunkers and
- 13:46things like that, and did get into a situation once in the Russian Front,
- 13:50confronted while on guard duty by a couple of individual Russian soldiers, and
- 13:54he managed to capture them and win a an iron cross, but it was
- 14:00much just you know, by by accident, really, and he never he
- 14:03went through six years of war and was never wounded. So the kind of
- 14:05story was he kept his head down and tried to survive. And my father's
- 14:11mother was never, at least as what I was being told, was really
- 14:16never very supportive of the regime and was not enthusiastic about the war. She
- 14:22had gone through World War One and actually the Russian Revolution because she had been
- 14:28taken by the Russian army and internally displaced within Russia and then afterwards had to
- 14:33as a girl with her family get back home to Germany, going across Russia's
- 14:37within revolution. So she was not very enthusiastic about war in the regime.
- 14:43However, when the family started to experience the American and I presume British bombing
- 14:52of the cities, I was told as a kid, she, like a
- 14:58lot of other Germans, for the you know, she for the first time
- 15:01started contributing, you know, don't making donations to the war effort and in
- 15:07effect the regime because because what the what the bombing did was hardened the civilians
- 15:16against an enemy in a way that perhaps they had not been before. That
- 15:20that was the kind of story that I heard growing up. And so do
- 15:24you think that it was It was you know, those kind of conversations around
- 15:30the dinner table, the atmosphere room which you were growing up that drew you
- 15:35towards wargames. Were they the games you were always into when games entered your
- 15:41life. Yeah, I mean it's interesting because it's hard for me to know
- 15:46for sure why what you know, why a certain thing looked interesting to me
- 15:50as a ten year old. But it was about when I was ten years
- 15:54old that I saw, in this case, Avalon hill war games and they
- 15:58did very often have you know, German troops on them, or German equipment,
- 16:03and and you know, in the in the in the game store,
- 16:07in the toy store, saying oh, that looks cool, I'd like to
- 16:10try that out, and and eventually you know, being able to afford to
- 16:14buy one. Now, whether that came directly from my family heritage and the
- 16:19kind I don't know. I actually haven't myself from part of that. It's
- 16:22it's possible that that played a role, and it's it's very interesting. I
- 16:26do this. I've done this a lot, and I sort of always ask
- 16:29the origin story of people as gamers, and I get usually one of three
- 16:34answers. It's either red Box, D and d Qatan or Avalon Hill wargames.
- 16:41How important do you think those Avalon Hill wargames have been to the development
- 16:48of gaming culture. Well, I think they're in a critical part of the
- 16:56early pathway. So when I look at what the board gaming tribes are today,
- 17:03and we talked about wargamers and eurogamers and the train games and all that.
- 17:07A great deal of it comes from from tradition, and tradition is to
- 17:11some degree happenstance, and it happenstance in wargaming is Charles S. Roberts and
- 17:22Avalon Hill, and in the fifties and sixties the first set of serious board
- 17:29games having to do with topics like the Battle of Waterloo or the Battle of
- 17:33Gettysburg, or Midway and so forth, and that happened to be the topic
- 17:38for these games, and that began a tradition in Avalon Hill was the central
- 17:45pillar of that tradition that became what was called a Golden Age of board wargaming
- 17:55in the nineteen seventies, SPI following on that and other companies. And those
- 18:03were the games that my friends had, Those are the games I saw in
- 18:07the stores. Those are the games I started playing, and began that self
- 18:12reinforcing interest in history, in which I'd play a game and it'd makes me
- 18:18want to read about that history some more, and then want to go on
- 18:22to explore something similar from another time in history, or another part of the
- 18:27same war, or something like that, and all that builds and branches out.
- 18:33And so when we look at games about history, games that are making
- 18:38that the part of the fun is the simulation, and what you're simulating is
- 18:42some aspect of human history. A great deal of those games are board war
- 18:49games are about happened to be about military history rather than political history, economic
- 18:53history, cultural history, and so forth. And that's not because board games
- 18:57are not very powerful at exploring any kind of human affair, any kind of
- 19:03human history. It's just that it happens that the serious games that were designed,
- 19:10marketed and became popular in the nineteen fifties to the nineteen seventies in the
- 19:14United States were war games. And so Avalon Hill, you know, Avalon
- 19:22Hill doing what it did successfully, I think has a great deal to do
- 19:29with who hobbyists like myself are and what they play today and what they have
- 19:34available to them today. And do you think so? You know, I
- 19:40live in Germany, and the Eurogame came out of Germany as a sort of
- 19:44response to the Second World War in many ways, in the Germans obviously didn't
- 19:51want to remind themselves of war, and so wargames weren't an option, so
- 19:55they developed the Eurogame as a way of gaming on the table without dealing with
- 20:00subjects they didn't want to face. Do you think there was a sense of
- 20:04triumphalism in those Avalon Hill games or were they attempting neutral reconstruction of those events?
- 20:15Well both may be true. Again, the demeanor of those games,
- 20:26and of most war games today is one of seriousness, of a serious examination.
- 20:33We are doing research and we're going to show you in this game of
- 20:40how the Battle of France in nineteen forty occurred, and what was important,
- 20:45and what might plausibly have gone differently, what the French ship, what the
- 20:48Allies might have done that they didn't do, and so forth. We're going
- 20:51to try to illuminate how it was that the Germans pulled off this victory.
- 20:56So that's from a posture of the historian going to try to examine it and
- 21:00give you a simulation. And the reason this is fun for you is because
- 21:06it's a simulation. It's going to, you know, put you in the
- 21:08realistic roles of these things. Now. At the same time, it can
- 21:15be true that certain roles or certain aspects are celebrated and that Okay, this
- 21:22is a cool looking tank, and that's why we're going to put this tank
- 21:26on the cover, you know, to help sell the game and to make
- 21:30it exciting and not just clinical. There might be some celebration of triumphs by
- 21:37one side or the other. So I don't, I don't. I don't
- 21:41think those are exclusive. And so when did you start to design games?
- 21:45And is it? Is it the the inevitable destiny of the war gamer that
- 21:51you inevitably rewrite rules and create variants for the games that you're playing. I
- 21:56don't think it's inevitable, and for me, it took some time. I
- 22:02there was a moment. I was about a decade into the hobby, and
- 22:04I had been playing these games as entirely as received wisdom, that is to
- 22:10say, some professionals, you know, research this and design this, and
- 22:14they know it and it's correct, you know, and I'm going to and
- 22:15I'm going to play it and get a correct view of history. And it
- 22:21was actually an occasion I was visiting. I was touring Europe and got a
- 22:26chance to visit some of the market Gardens battlefield and I'd been playing a game
- 22:32set there, and when I actually went there, I saw that the terrain
- 22:34on the battlefield was nothing like what it was in my game boards, and
- 22:37it was a kind of a shock, like whoa, I mean, why
- 22:41what's going on here? And from then on I think I started a period
- 22:45of another, oh, probably fifteen years or so of just tinkering of Okay,
- 22:51I think this rule could be better, or I think I can expand
- 22:56this in a certain way to bring out the hit street more effectively. And
- 23:03I went from that from tinkering. Which is a great advantage of board games
- 23:07is you don't have to you know, reprogram software as with a computer game.
- 23:11You can just use a pencil to change the game to your taste.
- 23:14I mean, it's really a wonderful aspect of the medium. And eventually I'm
- 23:18going to you know, scenarios and expansions and things like that, and some
- 23:22of those also published, being involved in play testing and of designers games.
- 23:29And it's not until I'm you know, decades in that it occurred to me
- 23:33that if I don't think there's a good enough game on a topic that I'm
- 23:38very interested in, why don't I just design it myself? And I thought,
- 23:42which I finally did in the you know, the year two thousand and
- 23:45I'd been gaming since the early nineteen seventies, So so that was a path.
- 23:49And there are I think war gamers who might come to tinkering and designing
- 23:56much quicker than I did. At the same time, there are others who
- 24:00might not be so interested in that. They're interested in sampling different games,
- 24:07or they're interested in the competition of it, or they're interested in reviewing and
- 24:11critiquing games, or discussing the evolution of the art form. So there are
- 24:15various, if you will, let's say, specializations within the hobby, because
- 24:21they're just our various ways to enjoy the meeting. So your first game then
- 24:25is Combat Commander Pacific. So firstly, why do we find the Second World
- 24:30War so fascinating? Do you think it's because we have goodies and baddies in
- 24:38a way that real life rarely offers us. Yeah, I'm not sure.
- 24:45I don't really know. I think I could think of other wars that might
- 24:51be that way as well, that aren't as well represented. And I wonder
- 24:53if I would go first back to where did the proliferation of World War two
- 25:00games come from? And how did it start? And I go back to
- 25:03Charles Roberts and Avalon Hill and the first games that made this kind of thing
- 25:10a thing, made this kind of thing a hobby, And that was in
- 25:15the nineteen fifties and nineteen sixties that that path was set. Well, the
- 25:22recent big event that would be the subject of most war movies and documentaries and
- 25:29books was World War Two, and so there certainly were games on American Civil
- 25:34War and Napoleonic Wars and other things. But I think in that period it's
- 25:38almost inevitable that a lot of the volume is going to be taken up,
- 25:45taken up by looking back on the last generation's really big war, and it
- 25:52is a world war, and the biggest world war that the world has seen.
- 25:56So in the immediate decades after the biggest war that the world has seen,
- 26:04you'd expect a lot of games to cover that, right, And that
- 26:10tradition builds on itself that you go into a store or a catalog or to
- 26:17your friend's house and what you see there's a lot of different titles, but
- 26:21an awful lot of them are about World War Two, And you're familiar with
- 26:25that story from other media, and so you know you're interested in it,
- 26:30and so that's what you're going to try and get into. So again,
- 26:33I wonder if it doesn't have more to do with the happenstance of the pathway
- 26:37and when the Hobby first emerged than inherent I don't know moral aspects of that
- 26:45war, and so I've been listening recently to the episode just dropped of Dan
- 26:52Carling's Hardcore History and he's talking about the Pacific Theater specifically in that and IM,
- 27:00while far from being an expert, I enjoy history, and I realize
- 27:03I know almost nothing about the Pacific Theater. Do you think there is a
- 27:10deficit of knowledge on the Pacific Theater or or is it just my British European
- 27:15blinkers? I think there is so European World War two is at the top
- 27:22of it is at the top of the heap in terms of coverage in the
- 27:26Hobby, and World War two itself is larger, is on the top of
- 27:32heap compared to other wars. But the Pacific Theater is it's not undergained because
- 27:37there are tremendous amount of Pacific Theater games compared to other episodes in history,
- 27:42but relative to European theory, yes, absolutely, and that might be a
- 27:47part of the reason why. It's not the only reason, but a part
- 27:51of the reason why I would choose to grab Combat Commander Pacific from Chad Jensen
- 27:56rather than Combat Command or Europe. Even if you allowed me with Combat Commander
- 28:02Europe to include the Mediterranean box and all the scenario, there's a lot more
- 28:06it's been done for Europe than Pacific. But even so, I just find
- 28:11the Pacific volume more alluring, in part because it's more. It is more,
- 28:18it's more interesting, it's more exotic, it's more fresh. I you
- 28:22know, I, oh, yeah, another European World War two game.
- 28:26Well, okay, what is it offered? It's different, and Pacific is
- 28:30still a little bit a little bit less thoroughly tried. And how does this
- 28:38game tell us about the conflict? How is the design reflecting what is specific
- 28:45about the Pacific theater of war? Well, a part of that answer is
- 28:49to realize what the scope is. So wargames are are divided broadly into tactical,
- 28:56operational, and strategic scale. And in this case, we're talking very
- 29:00tactical. We've got individual squads. You know, a piece might be ten
- 29:04soldiers or even a single leader, and you're you're covering you know, maybe
- 29:11a stretch of of of less than a mile on a side of of the
- 29:17map, So it's not going to be telling you too much about great power
- 29:23issues such as, you know, why did Japan launch its attacks? And
- 29:30what were the strengths and weaknesses of us overall strategy, and and what was
- 29:34the nature of the the human suffering that resulted and so forth. It's really
- 29:41coming down to very you know, nitty gritty, how are these small units
- 29:48maneuvering over terrain? What kind of weapons do they have, what kind of
- 29:51tactical how does their tactical doctrine affect the options that a company or a battalion
- 29:57commander might have in a a you know, a conflict spanning of you know,
- 30:02a clash that might take just an hour or something like that. So
- 30:04we're really zoomed in so in terms of what the expectations are of what it
- 30:07might tell us. But what it does, to me do very well is
- 30:12transport us into that theater, because we get through the construction of the game
- 30:22a great look at the strengths and weaknesses of the different nationalities that we're fighting
- 30:27and the impact of the often very harsh terrain. In fact, one of
- 30:33my favorite scenarios is set on Eora creek in New Guinea. So the Australians
- 30:38against the Japanese and it's these steep, jungly slopes and a rushing river at
- 30:45the bottom and a little, you know, a rickety little bridge that the
- 30:48Australians have to get across to come on to the Japanese positions. And to
- 30:55me, when I play that scenario, I mean it's it's like I just
- 31:00I feel like I can feel the New Guinea jungle around me. So Chad
- 31:04Jedson, who desired this game recently passed away. What contribution do you think
- 31:10he made to the world of games and specifically the world of wargames. So
- 31:14he has been he was a very successful designer of eurogames. The dominant species
- 31:21stands out, But for me, the Combat Commander series, I mean it
- 31:27is alone enough to put him into the pantheon. For me, that was
- 31:38probably the highest expression of the card driven game genre within war games, but
- 31:48articulated in a very very original way, making the most I think possible use
- 31:53of deck of cards for many different functions, all design decisions being being being
- 32:02the right ones, a tremendous accessibility at the same time that there's tremendous detail
- 32:13at the same time that there's tremendous immersion in the particulars and a scope for
- 32:17a great variety of settings. As I was just describing about Combat Commander Pacific
- 32:24and New Guinea and it was it's almost like when you have that his whole
- 32:29series in your game room, it's sort of you know, where in the
- 32:31world do I want to go today? Where in the world of World War
- 32:36two infantry combat? And it's all different. So to me, it's just
- 32:39a monumental achievement of of of Chad Jensen's and that, like any great series,
- 32:50led to additional work by other designers and developers, and a lot of
- 32:57that orchestrated by his wife, Kai developed a great developer and designer, John
- 33:02Bowley, and more recently we now have and I'm just adoring and getting into
- 33:08a great War Commander, which takes the whole system and sets it in World
- 33:14War One, so you can go to the trenches and no man's land and
- 33:16gas attacks and tanks even of the Western Front in the Great War, and
- 33:23all of that, of course building on Chad Jensen's craft. So I want
- 33:29to go on there and talk about your professional life as far as we can
- 33:32talk about it, and so you worked for the Central Intelligence Agency. And
- 33:38how does a person get a job at the CIA? I always imagine that
- 33:43you're stood in a bar drinking in Manhattan and someone comes up to you and
- 33:46slides a card over and says, do you want to work for the good
- 33:50guys? Is it anything like that? Or is it? Do you apply
- 33:52for it like any normal job. So it's not like that, and for
- 33:59me it was. It was of course back before the internet, so there
- 34:04were brochures and uh things like that to advertise and contact, and you could
- 34:08you sent in an application by mail as you as you would for any government
- 34:14job. And nowadays it's just go to www. Dot c I A dot
- 34:19DOV. I think there's probably a career's tab or something like that, and
- 34:22you can get more information and make contact. But it's it's a it's a
- 34:27it's a government agency, and the recruiting and the staffing is actually very similar
- 34:32to any other government agency. So why did you want to work at the
- 34:38CIA? Well? I had It's certainly wrapped up in my gaming hobby because
- 34:45as I mentioned before, you know, I start as a child. I'm
- 34:49seeing the cool box covers or whatever. Maybe I'm recollecting family memories of our
- 34:53family stories of of of life during during the war. I like the game.
- 35:00I'm enjoying the game that gets me interested in the in the the subject.
- 35:05I even I wrote up you know, sixth grade, I wrote essentially
- 35:07a book report, but it was more done again, so I'm researching the
- 35:12battles, I'm reading more and all of that built a hit in interest not
- 35:15only in history, but in foreign affairs as well, and I ended up
- 35:22I majored in history and international relations in college, again, you know,
- 35:28feeding off of that interest that was originally stimulated by avalon Hill games, I
- 35:31think, and then studied the same thing international affairs in graduate school. And
- 35:38the question was, then do I want to go into into government? Because
- 35:45in government I realized, in the US government, you're going to be a
- 35:50very very small cog and a big machine, but it's a very important machine.
- 35:52And I thought, I'm all right with that. I don't need to,
- 35:57you know, be my own boss or anything like that. I'd like
- 35:59to contribute to resolving large questions, even if my particular contribution is a small
- 36:06one within the larger enterprise. So US government was fine. And then a
- 36:08question is is it going to be diplomacy or something else. And when I
- 36:14was in graduate school, and this was the time I was really shopping around
- 36:16for a career, the two things happened. One was I was exposed to
- 36:21a different set of ideas at my graduate university than I had been as an
- 36:27undergraduate, different set of ideas in terms of right, left, center,
- 36:31that kind of thing, and it made me a little bit uneasy that if
- 36:36I went into a diplomacy or policy kind of role, that I would be
- 36:40pushing a policy that I might later on might find out was wrong or misguided.
- 36:49And I thought, maybe that's not right for me. But instead,
- 36:52the other thing that happened was there were two of my professors who ran a
- 36:57particularly interesting course at my university, a seminar course. They were both agency
- 37:06careersts at high levels, and they didn't exactly recruit us, but about a
- 37:13half dozen of us from that course ended up working there, so maybe they
- 37:15did. And I came to understand the role of intelligence in policy as being
- 37:24to as has been put by others, being to elevate the debate right.
- 37:30The intelligence analyst is not taking a policy position, is not making value judgments,
- 37:37is trying to examine a system, not a historical system, but a
- 37:44current system out there somewhere in the world in foreign affairs, and understand those
- 37:50dynamics in such a way as to support others who are making policy decisions or
- 37:57operational decisions or trying to advance a country's interests. And that seemed like a
- 38:05really attractive role to me, and it kind of you can maybe hear the
- 38:08echoes in that to the posture of a war game, which is, you
- 38:15know, to present a model of how something worked. And in a way,
- 38:20that's what with regard to complex human affairs, that's what intelligence analytic work
- 38:23is trying to do. It's trying to develop a more insightful model of how
- 38:29something works so that it can inform policy through opportunity analysis to saying, okay,
- 38:37here's how this works. You know, we think, dear policymaker,
- 38:40if you were to push here or pull there, you're likely to get this
- 38:45or that result, or here's how we think this works. If we see
- 38:50this or that indicator, we think there might be a danger emerging, and
- 38:53we're going to try and let you know of that danger, mister and missus
- 38:59policymaker, sooner than you otherwise would find out about it. That's our role,
- 39:04and then it's not up to me as the intelligence analyst to you know,
- 39:08push US policy in one direction or another. Really that that's somebody else's
- 39:15job, and that that appealed to me. And you know, there's always
- 39:17the assumption with something like the CIA that you know, you're dealing with powers
- 39:24that are hostile to American interests? But is there an element? Was there
- 39:30an element without obviously getting too specific, was there an element within the CIA
- 39:35that you're also dealing with powers that are friendly to the USA and plotting a
- 39:42direction with how to interface with them. Well, I I think it's even
- 39:47broader than that, to be honest with you. It's it's trying to understand
- 39:53and address whatever it may be happening out there that can affect the nation's interests.
- 40:00So that might be something like, you know, what is the direction
- 40:04that this alliance is taking. What is it that is important to our allies
- 40:10that you know, we need to be ready to make sure we can still
- 40:16provide for example, that would be a relevant question for a policymaker to put
- 40:24to intelligence. Right, Really, anything that has to that is that is
- 40:30relevant to policy where you know, information and analysis can be brought to bear.
- 40:37It's really really very it's really very broad. Now, certainly when it
- 40:39comes to threats, certainly when it comes to warning of bad things that might
- 40:45happen, well, that's going to be a big area that intelligence plays.
- 40:50But that's because those are the things that policymakers worry about and want want to
- 40:53have support in terms of warning, right and in terms of mitigation as well.
- 41:00But it's also, as I said, the phrase, the common phrase
- 41:02is opportunity analysis. Opportunity analysis can be about good things or bad things.
- 41:07It's it's not just hey, this bomb is going to go off, it's
- 41:10also what could we do here to make good things happen? You know,
- 41:15I'm just an average schlub who's sort of going through my life and my connection
- 41:22to world events is through the newspaper, through the through the TV, through
- 41:25the internet. When you're working at the CIA, do you feel like you're
- 41:31in the middle of history and do you feel like you're making history? Well?
- 41:40I would I would say for myself. I mean, I'm I was
- 41:45a working level Okay, so I wasn't any great you know, leader of
- 41:50massive you know, uh, commanding massive resources or anything like that, and
- 41:57I was certain I certainly had history being made around me, and you do
- 42:01feel responsible to do whatever is in front of you to fulfill your mission as
- 42:08effectively as you can. But you also, I think, see in a
- 42:14way that is incorrectly fictionalized in most dramatic representations. You see how large the
- 42:23enterprise is, and that is to say, not just one agency, but
- 42:29the entire intelligence community, and then it's partnership with an even more gargantuan defense
- 42:36community and multiple other policy and operational communities in a large national security infrastructure.
- 42:45That is just one country in a constellation of countries that might be working together
- 42:51for common purpose. So you know, yes, you feel that you are
- 42:58a part of history. But I think I always retained what I suspected I
- 43:01was going to feel that realization that I'm a very small piece of a very
- 43:08large history. Now in Britain, when we talk about the civil service,
- 43:15the people who work at Westminster in the government, the idea is that they
- 43:20are politically neutral, that their job remains their job regardless of the ministers they're
- 43:27helping, regardless of the party that's in power. Is that the same with
- 43:32the CIA, Are you essentially a politically neutral organization, and is there a
- 43:38shift in working there under different administrations. So that was very much the ethos
- 43:47when I was there, and I think it's the ethos by the way of
- 43:52the US civil Service also generally that if you're a career civil servant, your
- 44:00your you know, your oath is to the United States Constitution. It is
- 44:04not to a particular leader or party. There in fact laws against as a
- 44:08civil servant, there are laws against too much direct political participation by yourself in
- 44:15any partisan campaign. Uh So, as a civil servant under the Hatch Act,
- 44:22I was you know, I was allowed to put a bumper sticker on
- 44:24my car, but I was not allowed to participate in a candidate's you know,
- 44:30campaign to run for office, for example, and uh and down to
- 44:36guidance on you know, Twitter behavior and the like, so that they all
- 44:39to ensure that impartiality that you just described in the UK, which is I
- 44:45think a good thing. Uh And and that's especially the case in terms of
- 44:51the ethos, at least when I was there of the intelligence community again,
- 44:54because the idea was we we bring neutral, objective information, not policy agendas
- 45:07or value judgments to policymakers and it's their Bailey Wick to decide to go this
- 45:15direction or that direction, up, down, left or right. We're just
- 45:17there as guides and sources of information and perhaps that most coach to help them
- 45:25with whatever we can to achieve whatever it is they're trying to achieve. And
- 45:30so, of course that's going to those objectives and those values and those areas
- 45:36of focus are going to change from one administration to the next as elections have
- 45:42their consequences, and then the intelligence community adjusts. So a very expected and
- 45:50valid way for that to proceed. As a new administration comes in, it's
- 45:52a different party, it's a different set of decision makers. They have different
- 45:57policy objectives, and they have different focuses, they have different sets of concern
- 46:00and the intelligence community moves its resources in response. It's not supposed to mean
- 46:05that the intelligence community gives you different answers, but it may mean that we're
- 46:08going to put more resources looking at this problem than that problem, this opportunity
- 46:14than that opportunity, this threat and that threat. A lot of that,
- 46:15of course, also is not just in response to elections and administrations, but
- 46:20in response to events and what the nature is of the world. And so
- 46:22you designed games. Whilst working at the CI, I was reading a very
- 46:27interesting article about you the other day in preparation for this, talking about training
- 46:31games you've designed for CIA operatives. What is the difference between those games and
- 46:38the commercial games that you make. Yeah, that's right. The difference is
- 46:45you're starting with a purpose, You're starting with a certain goal. If you're
- 46:50designing a course and you're designing up a training course, let's say in the
- 46:54government, you're going to have an overall course goal. What is you're trying
- 46:59to achieve by having people will learn these skills or whatever, and then you
- 47:01have individual learning objectives that we're going to spend two hours with students doing this
- 47:07activity and at the end of the two hours, students will be able to
- 47:12blank. And so it's very it should be if it's designed properly, very
- 47:16very purpose driven. And if we use a game as a teaching method the
- 47:22way we might use a lecture or hands on exercise or a role play,
- 47:30we're going to instead use a tabletop game. It needs to be designed or
- 47:35at least adapted from something else very much with that learning objective in mind.
- 47:39And that's not the case, I would say with a commercial hobby game,
- 47:45it might have a similar topic, let's say, but the first point of
- 47:50a hobby game is to be fun, and so it might be that the
- 47:55fun of playing the game is that you're learning something about history. Let's say.
- 48:00So both cases, you might have conveying real life dynamics as being part
- 48:07of what you're doing. But as you balance different, you know, competing
- 48:16goods in a game, such as accessibility and versus detail, let's say you're
- 48:22going to be guided in those decisions, in weighing those choices as a designer
- 48:28by that overarching goal. So if it's a classroom game and the situation is
- 48:32that we have a learning objective, these students are being paid to do this,
- 48:38uh, and we're only successful if these students will do their job better
- 48:43at the end than they would have before. We're not going to be as
- 48:46concerned with fun or replay value. They're probably only going to play it when
- 48:51that one class they take. Right. If it's we want to sell this
- 48:55game to players to you know, for them to pay money to spend their
- 49:00spare time doing this with their friends, well then it better be better be
- 49:04entertaining. It has to be fun. Maybe it'll also be educational. That's
- 49:08great, but that's probably not the reason that that game will sell and actually
- 49:14get played. So your next game, then, is a game. It's
- 49:16actually a game that I've played quite extensively, and it's I never really even
- 49:24though that the word war is in the title, I never really thought of
- 49:27it as a war game. But this is War of the Ring. So
- 49:30to what extent does this game conform to the tropes of sort of standard war
- 49:35games and in which ways does it differ? Yes, that's a great question.
- 49:38Can you give me what's it? Give me example, what is a
- 49:40what is a standard trope of wargames? Well, you're asking someone who's not
- 49:45an expertise, but you know, if you look at card driven games,
- 49:50the well, I well, I guess the cleaving to historical necessity and you
- 50:00know, very granular sort of terrain elements, that that sort of thing.
- 50:05Yeah, I think it does. It leaves two details that we have of
- 50:14this world. And of course it's a fictional world, it's not real history.
- 50:20But what makes that world so engrossing for us, and what made The
- 50:28Lord of the Rings such a success was the detail. Was the detail that
- 50:36the Tolkien put into it, and it was coherent detail. It fit together,
- 50:40and it had its history, and it had its terrain, and it
- 50:44had its cultures, and it was it transported you there for that reason.
- 50:50It was like reading the you know, information that we really had about some
- 50:53other time and place that really had happened, right, And so that that's
- 50:57what makes the immense. So the game does all that too. It leads
- 51:00to the history of the that's in the books. As far as I know
- 51:06anyway, I'm no Tolkien expert. I know some I'm not one myself,
- 51:09but certainly to the degree that it transports me there and in detail, maybe
- 51:19the terrain is not as detailed as a hex encounter, you know, monster
- 51:24game or something like that, but I would say that the detail of the
- 51:32area movement system and the troops and the siege and battle mechanics and recruiting and
- 51:37all that is comparable to games I've designed, for example, where I might
- 51:43have just a couple types of terrain and a simple area movement system and a
- 51:49couple types of units and simple, very simple, even deterministic combat resolution in
- 51:54some of my games. So yeah, I think We're the Ring to me
- 52:00is a war game that gets for me, derives a lot of it's fun,
- 52:05not just from clever mechanics gameplay or or beautiful heart, but from its
- 52:12model of a complex system, in this case, the war that takes place
- 52:19in the Lord of the Rings books. And you said you're not a Tolkien
- 52:24expert. But were you've drawn to War of the Ring because of Tolkien or
- 52:30was it just a case of someone said, I think you should play this
- 52:32game. It's brilliant, and you played it and thought it was brilliant.
- 52:36Well, I had been a fan. I read I read the books as
- 52:39a as a as a high schooler, so I was already into I was
- 52:46already into this story. I guess I came to the game because I saw
- 52:51it at a friend's house and he had he had painted the miniatures, and
- 52:57it just looked fantastic. And you know, I had two young boys.
- 53:02He had a young boy that he had done that for and they played the
- 53:07game. And I had two young boys, so I was I had my
- 53:08eye open for things that they might like, and so so that inspired me
- 53:13to get the game. And we you know about the project was that the
- 53:15boys and I would paint all the two hundred and four little miniatures together,
- 53:20which we did they painted some of them, but I painted most of them,
- 53:22I would say, but it turns out to be an absolutely masterful design.
- 53:25It's just a tremendous asymmetric balancing act pulled off with a plumb. So
- 53:35I want to go on now and talk about what, certainly, certainly in
- 53:39my sort of circle of game of friends, that you're most famous for,
- 53:44and this is the Coin series. So how did you come up with the
- 53:47idea of a series of games based on counterinsurgency. Well, I had done
- 53:53LABYRINTHO War on Terror for GMT Games, and that was essentially a commissioned design
- 54:00suggested to me by GMPT Games president Gene Billingsley. And I had done Labyrinth
- 54:04Huan Terror as a two player game about global jihadism and it had done well,
- 54:12and based on that success, I thought I could come back to Gene
- 54:15and say, well, you know, I'd like you to take my next
- 54:17game and here's what it is, and which he did, and that was
- 54:23to zero in a little bit on the national level. So I talked earlier
- 54:29about the scope tactical, operational, strategic, and so forth. Well,
- 54:31Labyrinth is grand strategic. I mean it's sort of a global conflict it's a
- 54:37very rough level of resolution, if you will, and with only two players,
- 54:43even though there are many different nations and many different jihadist movements loosely aligned
- 54:51that I tried to stimulate as best I could with just two players, and
- 54:54I thought I'd like to zero in on what seems like so back in the
- 55:01way. The premise of that game, Labyrinth, is that the war on
- 55:06Terror is a global or was a global counter insurgency. Well Kaida was trying
- 55:10to do was overthrow governments across the Muslim world, and to do so using
- 55:20classic tools of insurgents, including terror, and so I was already interested in
- 55:28terrorism, in insurgency and counter insurgency from my day job. I was interested
- 55:35in modeling it. I'd done what I could in the format of Labyrinth,
- 55:37and I wanted to zero in on a single country and its insurgency and counterinsurgency
- 55:44and expand the model to include multiple players because insurgencies, experts tell us,
- 55:50are always almost always multi factional affairs, and the story of Columbia was fascinating
- 55:58to me because it was a case of a successful counter insurgency in which the
- 56:04government based down simultaneously three different insurgencies left wings, right wing extremists, and
- 56:13narco you know, commercial insurgency that are Narco terrorists, and succeeded to a
- 56:22great degree in expanding the government's writ across its own territory after decades of having
- 56:28essentially given up about half the geography of the country. And the more I
- 56:32looked at Columbia, the more interested I became in the way that these different
- 56:39factions in there with, each with its own vision for what the future of
- 56:44the country should look like, all had different relationships with each other, wheeled
- 56:50and dealed in remarkable ways. And I thought this would be the perfect setting
- 56:57for the first in the series, because insurgency is an internal war in general,
- 57:04much more common than the big conventional wars that tradition, the tradition of
- 57:10war gaming had tended to focus on World War Two, poleonic wars, American
- 57:15Civil War, that kind of thing. Well, there were so many stories
- 57:20of internal wars that had not been touched or only lightly touched. In fact,
- 57:24Columbia was a setting for only one previous wargame could incidentally published out of
- 57:30my own town, and it had been published in nineteen ninety, which is
- 57:35predated the period of Columbia that I wanted to do in my own game,
- 57:37so it was completely virgin territory as well for simulation, and I knew that
- 57:43there were settings like that to be modeled across the globe and across history,
- 57:47so I was able to propose it as the first volume in a series.
- 57:52And how did these conflicts differ from the grand conflicts that we instantly think of
- 58:00when someone says the word war. Well, one way I think that they
- 58:05differ is that something that's true about all military conflicts but is vividly presented in
- 58:13these internal conflicts, and that they all have aspects that are not purely military.
- 58:20They all have aspects that include politics and economics and culture and so forth.
- 58:24But in internal wars, these aspects I think come more to the foe
- 58:30because it becomes more clear as you're trying to change You're not just trying to
- 58:37conquer a chunk of land with boots, right, You're trying to change the
- 58:40nature of governance. You're trying to change the loyalty of people and populations,
- 58:47and so political tools and political effects remain front and center, even as shooting
- 58:58and bombing and marching and the like still matter, and those that's you know
- 59:07these effects politics and economics and culture and so forth. Social effects. These
- 59:13are important in conventional warfare as well, but it's easier for a simple game,
- 59:19a simple model, to set those aside and focus exclusively on the movement
- 59:22of divisions, if you will. And I was interested. I'm interested in
- 59:30this sort of multidisciplinary look because the world is multidisciplinary. All these different aspects
- 59:36of life are interwoven and so and so that I think makes insurgencies that's I
- 59:42mean, it's one of many ways that differ, but makes them fascinating to
- 59:46me because then we have to somehow take let's say, political factors into account.
- 59:55Otherwise there's no way we can really gain and understanding of what's important in
- 1:00:01a guerrilla war. And so it's it's been really interesting being a gamer in
- 1:00:07the last couple of years because I've found that listening to podcasts and speaking to
- 1:00:14friends and even myself sitting down to a game of Quba Believery that that the
- 1:00:19coin series are branching over to gamers that wouldn't traditionally play war games. Do
- 1:00:27you have any idea why this is? Yeah, I am. I am
- 1:00:30very happy to hear that, and it's part it's a part of my intent,
- 1:00:38so hopefully because because the series has succeeded in that way. But I
- 1:00:45have as as some of my earlier comments might might portray, I actually have
- 1:00:50some frustration about how tribal the board gaming hobby in general is. That there
- 1:00:57are you know, it's not that people shouldn't have tastes and games. I
- 1:01:01have taste in games, and there are certain kinds of games I'm more likely
- 1:01:04to play than others. It's not so much that, but it is that
- 1:01:07we seem to adhere so fiercely to the categories, and that there are gulfs
- 1:01:14between this flavor of game and that flavor of game, when one could imagine
- 1:01:20a fusion of those flavors might be quite tasty. And if we look at
- 1:01:23culture in general, I mean, when you get fusion and music and food
- 1:01:28and the arts, you know, very often it's something great because it's a
- 1:01:31fusion. In fact, all innovation is actually the combination of previous different ideas
- 1:01:37in new ways, right, And so I am fulfilling in those gaps as
- 1:01:43much as possible, and that broadens everybody's enjoyment. If I'm a war gamer,
- 1:01:47and out of tradition, I just don't like anything with wooden cubes.
- 1:01:52You know, well, I'm missing out on a lot of fun and exploration
- 1:01:57and knowledge and social life. Should that be so with the coin series,
- 1:02:02my attempt was to bring tribes together and then we could use maybe you know,
- 1:02:09unfair phrases, but they're the panzer pushers and the cabbage growers, you
- 1:02:13know, and I'm hoping to kind of bring them both to the table together.
- 1:02:16And for the for the traditional wargamers, the message is, you know,
- 1:02:23this is a war game. It's a historical simulation, it's a it's
- 1:02:28a competent one, it's a serious one. It happens not to be about
- 1:02:31the kind of war that you've studied in other games in the past, but
- 1:02:36it's still a war game. It's still about military history. It has something
- 1:02:38to tell you, and it happens not to look like maybe most of the
- 1:02:44games you've played, but when you play it, you'll see that that too
- 1:02:46is purposeful and it actually even can be attractive. Try it out right.
- 1:02:52And at the same time, I'm trying to lure gamers who might not be
- 1:03:00interested in something about a serious topic, a consequential topic, because you know,
- 1:03:06I'm not playing these fun these games to be for serious, consequential learning.
- 1:03:10That's not why, you know, that's not why I'm here for fun,
- 1:03:14you know. I mean, I've been working all day, you know,
- 1:03:15I want something that's going to be light and lighthearted. But to say,
- 1:03:20you know what, look at this, it's it looks like other things
- 1:03:23that you found to be fun. Give it a try, and maybe you'll
- 1:03:30find as you're trying it out that this topic is actually more interesting than you
- 1:03:34might have thought it was. And that has happened, That's happened to me
- 1:03:37with games, right, And so if the games have that power to lure
- 1:03:42me to explore topics that I otherwise would not have known were interesting, I'm
- 1:03:46hoping to do the same with different subcultures within the game and hobby, if
- 1:03:52that makes sense. And so there are lots of coin games. Now,
- 1:03:57which one do you think gets closed sys to fulfilling that aim? Well,
- 1:04:02I don't know. I don't know on basis what basis I might make that
- 1:04:11judgment. I suppose. I mean, I could say I think the biggest
- 1:04:16seller has been Firing the Lake, which is the one about Vietnam, and
- 1:04:21Vietnam of course is a very serious, even grim topic, and it is
- 1:04:29not one of the most accessible. It's one of the larger, perhaps slightly
- 1:04:34more complicated games in the series, and yet it has the largest following,
- 1:04:41at least based on sales numbers. So that seems to me to be a
- 1:04:45success in that it also is a topic. It is probably the most gained
- 1:04:51topic in the series. I mean, it's not certainly not the first game,
- 1:04:56normal would be the last on the Vietnam War, and and yet it's
- 1:05:02that game Fire and the Lake has reached, has reached a broader audience,
- 1:05:06So perhaps it's the one that is, you know, it's most wargame like
- 1:05:11and yet also has has reached the broadest, broadest part of the market.
- 1:05:17So your next game then is Steal Infernover Done nineteen sixteen. Firstly, can
- 1:05:24we conceive of the kind of hell that the Battle of the Done was?
- 1:05:30Yeah, it's a it's a great question and a fitting question because one of
- 1:05:35the things that fascinates me about the Western Front of World War One is it
- 1:05:42is how it's trying to imagine what that would have been like and how somebody
- 1:05:46could go at that week after week and year after year. And so can
- 1:05:58we probably not, I would say, however, I mean, I've never
- 1:06:02been in well, I mean, I've never been in infantry combat, Okay,
- 1:06:09So can I really imagine what that would be like? I don't know.
- 1:06:13I mean I try from different media I'm consuming. But I suspect whatever
- 1:06:18I might imagine is going to be a pale and maybe even misguided shadow of
- 1:06:25the real thing. So that's probably true of all wars. So I think
- 1:06:28the answer is probably no. However, I would say that through the games,
- 1:06:33I do feel we can get a much better understanding again of the dynamics,
- 1:06:42because the kind of the simplified, unexamined view is you have two armies
- 1:06:51that are dug in, whichever army goes over the top gets slaughtered, and
- 1:06:57it's just you know, stupidity that these were stupid people to even do that.
- 1:07:00Why would you just order your troops forward to just be slaughtered? Right?
- 1:07:04And then the other side does the same thing and there's blood letting and
- 1:07:08nothing changes in four years. And that turns out to be a rather misleading
- 1:07:14view of what was actually a rather strategically dynamic back and forth in which chunks
- 1:07:26of terrain were taken hopes of breakthrough. We were often present for plausible reasons,
- 1:07:35where breakthroughs were achieved, but then counter attacks reversed them, and so
- 1:07:44on and so on and so on. There's a fascinating literature and now game
- 1:07:48repertoire that represents this, and this design from twenty twenty from Walter Vedowski in
- 1:07:57France, Steele Inferno in a very beautiful, accessible way shows us those kinds
- 1:08:08of dynamics of of of trench warfare, offensives and counter offensives at the operational
- 1:08:15level. And that's why I love it. And I'm sort of building on
- 1:08:20from this. You know, you read Wilfred Owen, you watch documentaries,
- 1:08:27you read books, and it seems that the First World War, as opposed
- 1:08:31to the Second World War, where it was felt that there's a you know,
- 1:08:34a worldwide threat, the First World War seemed to be a war of
- 1:08:41brinksmanship, a war of essentially wanton, futile slaughter. Do you agree with
- 1:08:50this? And even though you know, for done as you said, was
- 1:08:58strategically dynamic, is there a sense of, yeah, the futility of the
- 1:09:04First World War baked into this game? Yeah? Uh well, let me
- 1:09:11let me separate discuss separately. Two words you used wanton and futile. Wanton.
- 1:09:17Yes, when we think about the casualties that were deemed acceptable in the
- 1:09:27pursuit of the goals of the war, it seems incomprehensible or idiotic or monstrous
- 1:09:36to us today, right we you know, we certainly have had terrible losses,
- 1:09:45for example in the long conflict in Afghanistan, but if you put the
- 1:09:50numbers of those losses relative to our populations and compare that to the world warsh
- 1:10:00it just pales. Right. So, there wasn't an idea at that time
- 1:10:05in the Great War that we could suffer these types of losses and still come
- 1:10:14out as winners. That decides did not, I mean nobody until the whole
- 1:10:20thing cracked socially through revolution. Nobody said, you know what, another year
- 1:10:27like the last year, and it doesn't matter what we achieve in this war,
- 1:10:30it's not going to be worth it. Let's just make peace, right.
- 1:10:31Nobody said that that's wanting. Okay, Now, we have to understand
- 1:10:36the view of the time and the view of you know, what nationalism was
- 1:10:41in the time, and what had already been experienced, and what their fears
- 1:10:44were and so forth. It's not irrational, it's just a different value system
- 1:10:47than the one we know. Okay, Now, futile is a little more
- 1:10:51difficult, I think, because first of all, we have retrospect and we
- 1:11:01know not only what the end of the war was and what it cost,
- 1:11:06we also know what came but a generation later with the Second World War,
- 1:11:13and we know the difficulties for many of the countries of the inter war period
- 1:11:16as well. And one could say, well, what did World War One
- 1:11:19really achieve, right, because then we had the Cold War, and we
- 1:11:24had World War Two, then we had the Cold War and so forth and
- 1:11:26so on. But of course that's not really fair to judge the decisions and
- 1:11:31actions of people who were living in nineteen fourteen, nineteen fifteen, nineteen sixteen,
- 1:11:36nineteen seventeen. And I think I can forgive them for seeing once I
- 1:11:47get over the want and willingness to accept horrendous losses to achieve these national goals
- 1:11:54which I have a hard time identifying with that. But once I get past
- 1:11:57that and I accept that, I can say I can understand the expectation and
- 1:12:04the hope that if we crack the code on this, if we make this
- 1:12:10big push and we use this new tactic of this new technology, we can
- 1:12:14achieve our national aims, and among our national aims is making sure that there'll
- 1:12:18never be another catastrophe like this in the future, and that that is achievable
- 1:12:23because of the extreme nature of this catastrophe. Of course, we're not ever
- 1:12:27going to do this again, right, we just need to make this big
- 1:12:31push now. And so what is the purpose of a game like Steel Inferno?
- 1:12:40Is it to teach us about all? And is it okay to be
- 1:12:45entertained by these things? Yes to a degree, and yes, that would
- 1:12:51be my answers. So it's a commercial game and therefore its purposes is to
- 1:12:58entertain, is to have one. But because it is a war game,
- 1:13:00even though it it it is very accessible, it is not a super detailed
- 1:13:05game. And it is a I mean, it's it's it's i think,
- 1:13:10a physically beautiful game. The art in particular is unusual for games, and
- 1:13:16uh uh it's it's it's very vivid. But it does have a teaching as
- 1:13:26a component of the fund because it's it's a it is a serious simulation of
- 1:13:29that battle, and it answers questions like how how was it that you know,
- 1:13:36overwhelming uh force, especially artillery on a trench line could still fail to
- 1:13:43produce a breakthrough. How was it that the Germans could set out to fight
- 1:13:47a battle of attrition with the idea of bleeding the French army white, and
- 1:13:50then end up bleeding itself just as much. How was it and why was
- 1:13:56it that the French felt that, after having barely held at Verdun, they
- 1:14:01would commit yet more hundreds of thousands of bodies to taking back you know,
- 1:14:09the the acres of mud that they had lost and so forth. Right,
- 1:14:13So you play the game and you do learn not only the dynamics, but
- 1:14:19I think the mindset of that battle. And it's a tremendously it's a fascinating,
- 1:14:26mysterious and very important battle. It's perhaps the longest battle in history,
- 1:14:30lasting almost all of the year nineteen sixteen, and was iconic of the Western
- 1:14:39Front. Was a remarkable idea on the German side that we can we will
- 1:14:48attack where the enemy will not allow us to pass through because our objective is
- 1:14:54actually just to kill enemy soldiers rather than actually taking ground. It's it's a
- 1:15:00phenomenon, I mean, it is a It is a remarkable battle that poses
- 1:15:09a number of mysteries that the game indeed does help us address. So I
- 1:15:15want to talk now about the CIA in general and sort of the history of
- 1:15:23the organization. And so you were at the CIA on September the eleventh,
- 1:15:28two thousand and one. What was that like? Well, for me personally,
- 1:15:34not a very exciting stormy afraid. I happened on that morning to be
- 1:15:41at an outbuilding taking a language exam. They and so I was in isolation,
- 1:15:47as you know, to be able to you know, be complete the
- 1:15:51exam on my own reowner, on my own resources. And they didn't pull
- 1:15:56us out, and they when we got out, I was simply quickly told
- 1:16:01to not to go to headquarters and to go home. And and I didn't.
- 1:16:09I didn't know anything. So I got into my car, I turned
- 1:16:11on the radio, and the radio said something like the south tower has collapsed.
- 1:16:15Well, the the headquarters building has has two sections that that we called
- 1:16:23towers. And I was like, oh my god, they's somebody's attack headquarters.
- 1:16:27But of course they were talking about Manhattan. What it was. What
- 1:16:30it was was was like was I was not at that time on anything to
- 1:16:38do with terrorism, Al Kaido or the Middle East. I was, you
- 1:16:41know, following a different part of the world. And uh so it was
- 1:16:46in a way like feeling a little bit useless in terms of being on the
- 1:16:51on the sidelines and not being not being directly involved in the momentous events and
- 1:17:03what was going to be coming soon. But that changed fairly quickly, because
- 1:17:08what of course happened very quickly and in a sustained way, was a redirection
- 1:17:14of effort. There had already been a growing effort on counter terrorism, certainly,
- 1:17:18but with nine to eleven, the resources, understandably to deal with that
- 1:17:29threat flowed, and many, many of us who had been doing other issues
- 1:17:34sooner or later ended up in some aspect of counter terrorism, as I did
- 1:17:39myself. And so the CIA has been around, if my history is corrected,
- 1:17:45maybe since it's basically after the Second World War. How effective as an
- 1:17:49organization in its stated purpose do you think it's been since it started? Well,
- 1:17:56I do think it's been very, very effective, and I would hasten
- 1:18:00to say it's again it's perhaps the most glamorized, but it's one of many
- 1:18:03different intelligence agencies, and I think the US intelligence community has, you know,
- 1:18:11many great achievements to its name, not all of which are of course
- 1:18:16known, and and we can say, since the CIA was a creature creation
- 1:18:25of the Cold War, it was part of the constellation of capabilities that helped
- 1:18:32the Cold War avoid develop it into a much greater tragedy than parts of it
- 1:18:45certainly were, and that contributed to a successful conclusion of that, you know,
- 1:18:51forty some year crisis for the world. So I think I think we
- 1:18:57can we can give the agency the credit for achieving it's part of that,
- 1:19:02and for remaining quite relevant and effective in what followed, which was not the
- 1:19:11end of history after the Cold War, but a continuation of some threats,
- 1:19:16development of new ones, and another international sort of a defining international conflict,
- 1:19:26and that was the requirement to defend against and disrupt and ultimately overcome ideologically al
- 1:19:36Qaeda and jihadism and the like. And so do you think the CIA has
- 1:19:42sort of universally been a force for good or have there been examples of overreach
- 1:19:48or simply wrong decisions in its history? Well, I can't imagine that it
- 1:19:54would be universally a force for good. Actually, when, especially when what's
- 1:20:01good is a matter of perspective. Uh, you know who you are and
- 1:20:05where your interests lie. But if I look at any any organization over a
- 1:20:15period of decades, Is there any that has only been a force for good?
- 1:20:19I mean, uh, Christopher Hitchins, I think did a a sort
- 1:20:27of an expose Marie Theresa and the terrible things that had had had resulted from
- 1:20:33her activities. You know, well, I mean, so you know,
- 1:20:39we can we I think in the complexity of life, there's there, there
- 1:20:43are There is bound to be errors, of course, no, no,
- 1:20:46no human enterprises is without flaws. And when you're engaging in conflict like the
- 1:20:57Cold War, there's going to be over reach as well. And so you
- 1:21:02had asked earlier a question about World War Two and is it attractive because they're
- 1:21:08sort of clear goodies and baddies, And that's you know, there's something to
- 1:21:12that that that question that you ask. And we can look back on World
- 1:21:15War Two and have a pretty pretty clear bifurcation of of of good or evil.
- 1:21:21But but it's it makes the point by being exception to the rule.
- 1:21:27And I think the rule is that life is ambiguous. Human lives, uh
- 1:21:32are are conflicted, and we can for the in the case of the agency,
- 1:21:39for example, in the Cold War, certainly there were cases where the
- 1:21:44Agency was the arm of an intervention in a foreign government that may have been
- 1:21:51seen at the time through the lens of the Soviet yet threat during the Cold
- 1:21:58War, as a beneficial intervention on behalf of democracy. But as we look
- 1:22:02back on it, we have to say, well, over the long run,
- 1:22:06the effect was perhaps anti democratic because because we end up with you know,
- 1:22:14authoritarian governments that happened to be you know, allied with the United States,
- 1:22:18but we're nevertheless not representative of their people. So your next game,
- 1:22:27then you're a first among designers actually who've been on this show who willingly taking
- 1:22:33work with them to the cabin. So your next game is Inferno, and
- 1:22:39this is an unpublished game. What is your design process? Do you have
- 1:22:44a fixed sort of I get to the desk at nine and I work until
- 1:22:46twelve or is it more scattergun than that. I do have a process,
- 1:22:55like a daily process like that now that I'm retired. I think before when
- 1:22:58I had a day job and young children, of course it was catches,
- 1:23:01catch Canon. When I had the spare time and energy, I would do
- 1:23:04it. But now I have the luxury in retirement that I do more or
- 1:23:09less wake up, have my coffee and start, you know, working on
- 1:23:14something, and very often to something is a game design, and so it's
- 1:23:19for me, it would not be taking work to the cabin. It would
- 1:23:23be taking my joy because, as I talked about earlier in our hobby,
- 1:23:29there are many ways to enjoy it, playing games with friends, playing games
- 1:23:33alone, reviewing and studying games, modifying games, tinkering with games, and
- 1:23:40designing new games. I mean, it's all in the same medium, but
- 1:23:43they're different kinds of joys. And so for me, of course I see
- 1:23:51game design. It's not work, you know, it's my hobby. I
- 1:23:55do it for me, it's a joy, and so I would not want
- 1:23:58to leave that behind if I had get to this cabin my And yeah,
- 1:24:03so my routine is most of most of the work I'm doing is in the
- 1:24:08first half of the day. I happen to be I like to get up
- 1:24:11at the same time in the morning, and I'm productive about until midday and
- 1:24:16and uh, and then I become I become less less able to effectively compose.
- 1:24:24Let's say, and so, how do you find a topic to build
- 1:24:28a game around? And how long is the research process before you can get
- 1:24:31down to the nuts and bolts of creating the game. Well, let me
- 1:24:35talk about it. It's maybe different in different cases, and it usually revolves
- 1:24:41around here is a topic that I find a very engaging story, a system
- 1:24:45that I want to understand better. There's something, there's a dynamic there that's
- 1:24:49interesting, and it's not yet adequately covered in the medium. So that was
- 1:24:56the case with my first game, which is about the French and Indian War.
- 1:24:58It was the case with Labyrinth, the War on Terror, was the
- 1:25:00case with the Insurgency Counterinsurgency Coin series, as I talked about, and Inferno
- 1:25:06is a similar case. So Inferno is going to be volume three in a
- 1:25:13series of games that I'm working on right now that focus on military operations in
- 1:25:19medieval times. So the first volume was Nevsky, which looks at thirteenth century
- 1:25:25Russia Alexander Nevski versus the German Teutonic Knights, just like in Nevsky the movie
- 1:25:32that campaign, and I went in that direction because I thought there was a
- 1:25:40dearth interesting of games in general that looked at that intermediate operational level of warfare.
- 1:25:47There was a reasonable number of battlefield games about big medieval battles. There
- 1:25:53was a reasonable number of strategic or grand strategic games that would look at entire
- 1:26:00wars or all of Europe, even in the Middle Ages, but not a
- 1:26:03lot that looked effectively. I thought at the raising and moving of individual armies
- 1:26:13and how the feudal system generated and supported troops in the field, and so
- 1:26:21I wanted to I wanted to come up with a new game system that would
- 1:26:26cover that. So Nevski was the first one. The second one, which
- 1:26:29is currently an art with Gimt, is Almavid, which is set in eleventh
- 1:26:33century Spain, So Reconquista Christians against Muslims, and volume three will be set
- 1:26:42in thirteenth century Italy in Tuscany in the conflict there between the Guelfs and the
- 1:26:46Gibilings. So Inferno as in Dante's Inferno. And it's Inferno that I selected
- 1:26:51to bring the cabin because it is a design that has already been has been
- 1:27:03put together in its content and structure, but that I am going to be
- 1:27:08refining. It's a co design, as many of my games are, and
- 1:27:11in this case Enrico Cherby, and a veteran wargame designer in Italy, got
- 1:27:18into conversation with me in the aftermath of Nevsky and I asked him if he
- 1:27:23would design a game with me and he could pick the setting and the period,
- 1:27:27and he did. And so I have ahead of me doing the kind
- 1:27:31of refinement work to take Enrico's original design and melt it into my series and
- 1:27:39hash it out. And so that's what I would be doing in the cabin.
- 1:27:43So I want to go on there and talk about the future. So
- 1:27:45you have Inferno coming, is there? What do you have coming out in
- 1:27:49the short to medium term that wargamers can enjoy? So the next two things
- 1:27:56knew that I'm directly involved in, because I have a lot of indirect involvement
- 1:28:02in the rest of the Coin series. But two things that are coming in
- 1:28:05the near future. One is Fall of Saigon, which is an expansion within
- 1:28:12the Coin series to Fire and the Lake, the Vietnam game that I mentioned
- 1:28:15before. The second it's the second game in the series that's gotten an expansion,
- 1:28:19the first one being Falling Sky, which is Caesar and gaulf And in
- 1:28:25Firing the Lake, we and I say we because my code designer is the
- 1:28:30great Mark Herman. Mark and I focused Fire in the Lake on the main
- 1:28:34period of us involvement in the guerrilla war in Vietnam nineteen sixty four to nineteen
- 1:28:43seventy two, but of course the war was longer than that on either side.
- 1:28:46And what Fall of Saigon will do is it will be the sequel to
- 1:28:50complete the story and take the war through the mainly South Vietnamese ARBON versus North
- 1:29:00Vietnamese NVA part of the conflict that ends with the fall of Saigon in South
- 1:29:05Vietnam and April nineteen seventy five, So that is now in art. There
- 1:29:12will be a separate Soltaire system by Bruce Manfield. An intense amount of development
- 1:29:18and testing work has been led by Jason Carr, and so Fall of Saigon
- 1:29:26is I'd say many weeks to a few months away, depending on how quickly
- 1:29:30the art proceeds. So that's the one. The other is the volume two
- 1:29:34of loving campaign series that mentioned has also just beginning art. So if anybody's
- 1:29:42who's had a look at my game Nevsky about the Russian theater in medieval times,
- 1:29:48this is the same system, but in the much bigger, more populated,
- 1:29:54richer and more fortified Iberia of the eleventh century. So it's Muslim Taifa
- 1:30:00kingdoms and North African army, a Berber led force called the Almravids intervening to
- 1:30:10hold back the Christians of Leon, Castilla and Aragon attempting to push back the
- 1:30:16Muslims in the Raylandquista. So El sid Alfonso the sixth and Yusuf Sultan Alma
- 1:30:26Ravin all duking it out in Spain, and that is in art. So
- 1:30:30the first thing folks are going to see probably is some early looks at early
- 1:30:34bits of art. Checchinetto is doing the game board as he has for most
- 1:30:40of my games, and then other Spanish artists are involved in the cards and
- 1:30:45other materials. So as soon as we have some things to show, that
- 1:30:47will be the next thing that fans will see. So I had Mark Herman
- 1:30:54on this show, and when I spoke to my wargame of friends and said
- 1:30:57I'm interviewing Mark Herman for a show, the sort of eyes glazed over and
- 1:31:01they sort of looked at me in wonderment. How how important is Mark Herman
- 1:31:06to the to the hobby of wargames. Yeah, it's it's funny that you
- 1:31:12should should ask that, because they've just had a question on Twitter. Somebody
- 1:31:15was putting on it, you know, Mount Rushmore, which has four US
- 1:31:17presidents on it. If you had a Mount Rushmore for war game designers,
- 1:31:21who would the four b and I mentioned for me it was Charles S.
- 1:31:25Roberts, who I mentioned as the founder of Avalon Hill in that whole tradition.
- 1:31:29Really the founder of the hobby, James Dunnagan who brought in SPI the
- 1:31:33second big giant war game maker in the nineteen seventies, Mark Herman and chat
- 1:31:40Chad Jensen. So so clearly I think Mark is a fundament of what we
- 1:31:49have achieved in the in the hobby and in this state of the art.
- 1:31:54He you know, he began on the inside in SPI in nineteen seventies.
- 1:31:58I mean I was in I was in high school, and he was already
- 1:32:00designing and publishing games in one of the two great companies of the day.
- 1:32:06His company, Victory Games, was in my eyes, the leading quality producer
- 1:32:13of wargames in the nineteen eighties and into the nineteen nineties, in a period
- 1:32:16when the thinking was the whole hobby might die out and just be replaced by
- 1:32:20computers. Well, that didn't happen. And among the reasons that didn't happen
- 1:32:25was Mark Herman, and I would point to especially his absolute breakthrough design in
- 1:32:31the nineties called We the People, which invented the card driven game subgenre of
- 1:32:40wargames. And it's a genre within which I mean all of my designs,
- 1:32:45all of my designs are built upon Mark Herman's We the People as the basis.
- 1:32:50So, yes, I don't know about I don't know about eyes dizing
- 1:32:56over. But if you are into board wargames and you don't or you're not
- 1:33:01familiar with what Mark Herman has brought to your table, then yes, I
- 1:33:06can help you open your eyes. So when you think about so, the
- 1:33:12reason we're talking today is that I put out a tweet saying, because I
- 1:33:17feel I neglect wargame and wargame designers on this show. So I put a
- 1:33:21tweet out saying which wargame designers would you like to see on the show?
- 1:33:27And you were by far the most popular request to that. When you look
- 1:33:34back at your contribution to wargames, what do you think your contribution has been
- 1:33:44and where do you think you stand? Well, first, I appreciate that
- 1:33:48compliment from your listeners. If I'm going to be generous to myself, I
- 1:33:54guess what I would like to think is that brought the state of the art
- 1:34:01forward. That is, I've added new innovations to systems or put things together
- 1:34:09in new ways that give us a bigger and perhaps better toolbox in terms of
- 1:34:15mechanics to simulate history and military and military political affairs especially, But more importantly,
- 1:34:26I would like to think that I succeeded in broadening the appeal of games
- 1:34:38that take a serious look at serious topics, a consequential topics. And you
- 1:34:43know, war is not a delightful topic. It is a consequential topic.
- 1:34:47And what makes me so happy about the ri activeness of players to many of
- 1:35:02my designs is that is that they are they are willing to spend their spare
- 1:35:14time exploring strange, potentially strange, off the beaten track settings from history that
- 1:35:28they would not have thought an attractive place to go in their free time until
- 1:35:38picking up and playing a design I did. So that that that to me,
- 1:35:43to to attract people to think about consequential human history that they would not
- 1:35:51have otherwise been tempted to spend their energy on. My games have helped do
- 1:36:00that for more people. That that, that, to me, is the
- 1:36:03is the greatest success. So your last game is another one of yours that
- 1:36:06isn't finished yests, and this is Hunt for Blackbeard. And I was reading
- 1:36:12up on this to prepare for this interview, and is this a hidden movement
- 1:36:15game? It is. It's a it's a hunt game that with two players
- 1:36:20would be played with stand up blocks that would show Blackbeard's activities only to the
- 1:36:27black Beard player, and the hunters playing the Royal Navy principally would just be
- 1:36:33you know, occasionally able to look at the other side of the block to
- 1:36:36try to find the pirate. And then each player would also have a screen
- 1:36:41with some tiles and ponds and things happening behind in secret. And so how
- 1:36:47much fun was it to research the Golden Age of pirates? Well, it's
- 1:36:51it's it's great fun. And in uh, like with some other of my
- 1:36:57designs, there's some there's some personal attachment to it as well. My first
- 1:37:01published war game, Wilderness War, was about the French and Indian War,
- 1:37:04and that came in part from my interest in the Virginia Frontier and George Washington
- 1:37:11during the French and Indian War and all of that. I live in Virginia
- 1:37:14and so it was kind of local local history. In a way, I
- 1:37:16could go out and drive to many of these places. And for Labyrinth,
- 1:37:21the War on Terror, it was really, you know, what I had
- 1:37:27been dealing with in my day job for some some years, so it was
- 1:37:30already personal in a way. Nevsky, which I just mentioned, it's really
- 1:37:36about it's from the Middle Ages, but it's about a part of the world
- 1:37:40that my father and his family are from. So it's it's a place I'm
- 1:37:43not some in some cases I've not had a chance to visit, but but
- 1:37:47hope to. But I traveled there instead by doing the game design in a
- 1:37:50way. And for Hunter, for Blackbeard's it's Blackbeard's Last Days, not in
- 1:37:57the Caribbean, the Caribbean being so famous for Golden Asi piracy, but in
- 1:38:00North Carolina, North Carolina in seventeen eighteen, and Blackbeard had essentially arrived in
- 1:38:08North Carolina for sanctuary. He'd been more or less put under too much pressure
- 1:38:13in the Caribbean by the authorities. But North Carolina seemed to have a governor
- 1:38:18who was either tolerant or simply did not have the capacity to effectively object to
- 1:38:24Blackbeard's presence there, and so North Carolina neighboring state to Virginia, and in
- 1:38:30particular the drama plays itself out in North Carolina's Outer Banks Islands and Sounds,
- 1:38:38which has been a regular vacation spot for my family over the last couple of
- 1:38:43decades. So I also am tied to Williamsburg. I went to college there
- 1:38:49and the frequently in Williamsburg even to this day. Williamsburg, Virginia and Williamsburg
- 1:38:55at that time was the capital of Virginia, and it was the Virginia from
- 1:39:00Williamsburg who supported the expedition to hunt Blackbeard down in seventeen eighteen. So all
- 1:39:08of these places that are rather gear to my heart get to appear on the
- 1:39:12game board. And do you have any tidbits of information about the sort of
- 1:39:17the age of Pirates that most people wouldn't know that you found particularly interesting.
- 1:39:24Well, there's so many interesting aspects that I'm hoping to bring people in this.
- 1:39:30Even though it's a little game, I think people will find it's kind
- 1:39:32of chock full of history and historical kidbits. One example is in the Battle
- 1:39:40of Okracoke, this is the in which Blackbeard was caught and lost his life
- 1:39:45and his surviving crew was captured by the Royal Navy sent by Virginia. So
- 1:39:49in that battle it wasn't regular. It was like it's almost the iconic pirate
- 1:39:54boarding battle, because Blackbeard, after shooting up the Navy's sloops, boarded one
- 1:40:00of them with his crew and was fought off by the brave Royal Navy Lieutenant
- 1:40:06Maynard successfully well in that battle. The ships that the ships are quite small,
- 1:40:14they're sloops, and in fact the Navy, the Royal Navy, had
- 1:40:17two larger warships frigates up in Virginia on station there, but they didn't use
- 1:40:21those for this hunt. They commandeered civilian single mass ships sloops and put Navy
- 1:40:30crews on them and sailed. And the reason was because in these sounds of
- 1:40:32the outer banks, the shallows, the shoals are a tremendous difficulty. And
- 1:40:40in fact, during the course of the battle, and this had happened in
- 1:40:42other pirate battles in the area in the Carolinas, the ships occasionally ran aground
- 1:40:48uh and where Blackbeard was hiding out was an area that you could only kind
- 1:40:53of sail in and out through a little channel in the shoals and so forth.
- 1:40:56So these shallow more shallow bottomed ships, and they were civilian ships on
- 1:41:00the Royal Navy side that weren't even equipped with cannon. So, if you
- 1:41:02can imagine this, they're sailing to catch black Beard. Black Beard has a
- 1:41:06sloop with about eight or nine cannon and swable guns on it, and the
- 1:41:11Royal Navy's endeavoring to hunt him down and bring him to heal and they have
- 1:41:17no cannon at all. They're only shooting with their muskets. It's you know,
- 1:41:21it's you wouldn't expect it from the classic movie scene of the broadsides firing
- 1:41:28at each other before the boarding action. And so when can people Because I
- 1:41:31was reading this and the minute I started reading it, because I I love
- 1:41:33the Golden Nach Pirates, I thought, I really, I really want to
- 1:41:38get hold of this. When can people get this game to the table.
- 1:41:41Well, there are really two answers to that. In terms of the finished
- 1:41:45production game. That's going to be some time yet. Because with GMT Games,
- 1:41:50my publisher, we go through a pre order process. A game has
- 1:41:54to make at least five hundred orders, and then it goes into a queue
- 1:41:58for art and and so forth. As you can imagine, with the with
- 1:42:04the pandemic this year, I think everything has slowed down to some degree and
- 1:42:10we are now we have underway an effort to do something that I had not
- 1:42:16intended to do before, but that is with this double blind game. We
- 1:42:20are going to design solitaire systems for both sides, so in a way,
- 1:42:26it'll be like three games in the box. You can have two players Hunters
- 1:42:29versus Pirates in that double blind hidden movement game that I described, but we're
- 1:42:34going to see if we can't also deliver a very similar experience, either playing
- 1:42:41Blackbeard against an automated Royal Navy or playing the Hunters against an automated pirate crew.
- 1:42:48So we'll see. So that design work is underway now and so I
- 1:42:54don't know it will I hope. My ambition is to have the game out
- 1:42:57for pre order next calendar year, but even then it will be some time
- 1:43:01beyond that. However, however, for those who are really interested and willing
- 1:43:09to try something out that is not necessarily the final version, and if you
- 1:43:15are on vassal, which is it's in a way like tabletop simulator, which
- 1:43:21I think folks will be very familiar with, but is an older, more
- 1:43:27two dimensional system that has a lot of free war games available on it,
- 1:43:32and it's available at Vassal engine dot org and I highly recommend it. I
- 1:43:34do almost all my social gaming now on Vassal. Well, there's a module
- 1:43:42for Hunt for black Beard on Vassal, and all that you need besides the
- 1:43:46Vassal module itself is the rule set, is the draft of the rule book,
- 1:43:54and I'm happy to share that with anybody who would be be interested to
- 1:43:58try the game out, because for me, I'm always looking for feedback while
- 1:44:01we're still in development of the game. So one last question. Man,
- 1:44:05you're heading out in Fleeing the Apocalypse eighty eight miles an hour. You go
- 1:44:13around the corner, the back seat of the car flies open. Four of
- 1:44:17the games, fly down a ravine, into a river, and a swept
- 1:44:23away to posterity. Which game do you hope is sitting in the backseat to
- 1:44:28the car Hunt for Blackbeard? And yeah, and the reason because it's what
- 1:44:35I'm on right now, you know, So I think that would be my
- 1:44:38first thought, because I mean, I was working on it this morning,
- 1:44:45so I want to work on it tomorrow morning. So you know, again,
- 1:44:48ask me in a few months and it'll be a different answer, but
- 1:44:51that is the project that I have right in front of me, and I
- 1:44:55have to say, I have to confess. If I had to give up
- 1:44:58either playing games that I love or designing games, I would give up playing
- 1:45:03games first. So it would be one of the designs in progress. And
- 1:45:08I know that's true because before I retired, when I really didn't have the
- 1:45:12luxury to do much of either, I for many, many years, practically
- 1:45:17speaking, was only playing my own stuff in design and development and testing almost
- 1:45:24all the time. And I hated that, you know, I hated that
- 1:45:27that I didn't have time to do both. But designing games is time consuming,
- 1:45:32so that was the choice I made for years. I think that would
- 1:45:34be the choice I would make today. So if people want to get hold
- 1:45:38of you, if they want to find out what you're up to all of
- 1:45:41that sort of stuff, how can they go about it? Best way is
- 1:45:43on Twitter. I'm at Volco two six, and I'm not there necessarily every
- 1:45:47single day, but I'm there a lot, and so that's really the best
- 1:45:51way. Fantastic, Well, Volco Rumka, thank you very much. Well
- 1:45:56thanks for having me along on your apocalypse Ben. This was very enjoyable.
- 1:46:00Support the show in many ways. You can tell your friends, you can
- 1:46:02talk about it on social media, you can talk about it in your own
- 1:46:06blog, podcast, or video. Or you can support it directly by going
- 1:46:11to Patreon dot com, forward slash five GFD for a rolling donation, or
- 1:46:15for a one off donation, hitting the papal link at the bottom of the
- 1:46:17website five Games for Doomsday dot com. It's these donations that keep the show
- 1:46:23going. Also, if you want to say something nice about the show,
- 1:46:27or if you want to say something horrible about the show, you can contact
- 1:46:29me on Twitter at five Games for Doomsday or send me an email at five
- 1:46:33Games for Doomsday at gmail dot com. And if I've managed to roll away
- 1:46:39from the grabbing hands and the large amounts, I'll see you in two weeks
- 1:46:43for another five Games for Doomsday