Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / CLA Electric and Mild-Hybrid Technical Specifications
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to The Deep Dive, the show that cuts through the noise
- 0:12and gives you the hard data you need to make smarter decisions.
- 0:16Today we are getting to the bottom of a huge debate in the
- 0:19luxury car world. It's the internal combustion
- 0:22engine versus the pure electric and we're doing it with two cars
- 0:26that are on the surface almost identical, the brand new
- 0:30Mercedes CLA 250 plus EQ, that's the electric one versus its
- 0:34sibling, the CLA 200, which has a pretty advanced mild hybrid
- 0:38system. Right, and this is the perfect
- 0:40comparison because they share the same DNA, same body, same
- 0:43look. Exactly.
- 0:44Our mission today is pretty straightforward.
- 0:46We've got all the specs, but more importantly we have a full
- 0:486 year cost analysis. We're talking 120,000 kilometers
- 0:52of driving. And that initial price gap is
- 0:55significant. We're talking almost €10,000
- 0:57more for the EV. So the big question is, can the
- 1:00EV's running costs actually save you money in the long run?
- 1:03The answer might surprise you. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:06These cars as you said, they share so much.
- 1:08They're both that sleek 4.72m long 5 seat coupe a style.
- 1:12The dimensions are basically identical.
- 1:14But the philosophy behind them couldn't be more different.
- 1:16Exactly. 1 is the evolution of what we know, and the other is,
- 1:20well, it's the future. Let's start with what you feel
- 1:24when you actually press the accelerator, the power.
- 1:27Yeah, the power differences, it's not subtle.
- 1:30The pure electric CLA 250 plus EQ has this massive immediate
- 1:35advantage. OK, so break that down for us.
- 1:37What are the numbers you're? Looking at a rear electric motor
- 1:40that puts out 200 kilowatts, that's about 272 horsepower and
- 1:45crucially, 335 Newton meters of instant.
- 1:48Torque Instant is the keyword there.
- 1:50Absolutely. Now compare that to the mild
- 1:52hybrid. The CLA 200 has a really clever
- 1:551.5 liter turbo engine and it's helped by a 48 Volt system.
- 1:59Sort of fills in the gaps. Right, it does, but the total
- 2:01output is still 140 kilowatts, so about 185 horsepower and the
- 2:06torque is around 300 Newton meters, so.
- 2:08It's a big horsepower difference.
- 2:09How does that translate to, you know, zero to 100?
- 2:12It's a huge difference in feel. The electric sprints from zero
- 2:15to 100 kilometers per hour in just 6.7 seconds.
- 2:18Wow, the mild hybrid. It's respectable, but it takes
- 2:21about 8.0 seconds. That's a second and a half you
- 2:25feel that every single time you pull away from a stoplight.
- 2:28Every time. But there is a little twist if
- 2:30you're someone who cares about top speed.
- 2:32OK, the old Autobahn argument. Right.
- 2:34The mild hybrid with its traditional engine can still
- 2:37push up to around 230 kilometers per hour.
- 2:40The electric CLA is capped a bit lower at 2:10.
- 2:44It's built for acceleration, not necessarily for ultimate top end
- 2:47speed. OK, that makes sense.
- 2:49Let's talk about the architecture, because this is
- 2:51where that big price difference for the EV starts to make a bit
- 2:54more sense. This is the real story.
- 2:55The electric CLA is running on an 85 kWh battery, which is a
- 2:59good size, but the secret sauce is the 800 Volt architecture.
- 3:03So why should I as a driver care if it's 400 volts or 800 Volt?
- 3:07It changes everything. It's about efficiency.
- 3:09Higher voltage means you need less current to get the same
- 3:12amount of power, and that means less heat, which is the enemy of
- 3:16batteries and charging It lets them use lighter wiring and it
- 3:19just makes the whole system more efficient.
- 3:21And that efficiency is why it gets a ridiculous 792 kilometer
- 3:26WLTP range. Wait, almost 800 kilometers of
- 3:29range on a standard test? Yep.
- 3:32For a car in this class, that's phenomenal.
- 3:34It basically kills range anxiety for most people.
- 3:36And what about charging? The 800 Volt system must help
- 3:39there too. Oh massively.
- 3:40It can handle up to 320 kilowatts of DC fast charging.
- 3:45In real world terms, you can go from 10 to 80% charge in just 22
- 3:49minutes. 22 minutes. That's a coffee break.
- 3:51Exactly. It makes Rd. trips in an EV
- 3:53suddenly seem very, very feasible.
- 3:56But there's a trade off for that huge battery, and that's weight.
- 3:59Right, it is. The EV is heavy.
- 4:01It's 2055 kilograms and its rear wheel drive.
- 4:04And the mild hybrid? It's a lightweight by
- 4:06comparison, around 1550 kilos, so a 500 kilogram difference,
- 4:11and it's a more traditional front wheel drive setup with an
- 4:138 speed dual clutch gearbox. So does the EV feel heavy and
- 4:17clumsy in the corners? You know, the engineers have
- 4:19done an amazing job of hiding it.
- 4:20The rear wheel drive platform gives it this great agility and
- 4:23the instant torque management is incredible.
- 4:25But yeah, physics is physics. You can't just erase 500 kilos.
- 4:29And I heard there's some unusual tech in the E VS gearbox to help
- 4:32with. Yes, very unusual for an EV.
- 4:35It has a 2 speed gearbox. A second gear.
- 4:37Why? It's all about optimization.
- 4:40First gear gives you that insane punchy acceleration off the
- 4:44line. Then at higher speeds, it shifts
- 4:47into second gear to improve efficiency on the highway,
- 4:50helping it achieve that amazing range.
- 4:52That's really clever. It's a compromise for both city
- 4:54driving and long hauls. Exactly.
- 4:56OK, let's step inside the car now.
- 4:57Because no matter which one you buy, you're still buying a
- 5:00Mercedes. What do they share?
- 5:02This is where you see the brand's consistency.
- 5:05Both come in high end trims like Advanced or Premium.
- 5:07You get the same core luxury features.
- 5:10Like the headlights and the safety tech?
- 5:11Yep, the fantastic multi beam LED headlights are standard.
- 5:15You also get all the ADS, the advanced driver assistance
- 5:18systems. So automatic braking, adaptive
- 5:21cruise control, all that good. Stuff And inside the cockpit
- 5:24experience, yeah, you still get that signature Mercedes look
- 5:27with the big screens. You do the dual 10.25 inch
- 5:31screen setup is there in both. It looks beautiful, although the
- 5:35EV does give you the option to upgrade to the massive MBUX
- 5:39Hyperscreen. OK, so that's an EV only party
- 5:42trick. Correct, but even without it you
- 5:45get dual zone climate. Nice 18 or 19 inch wheels.
- 5:49It feels premium in both cars. What about the little functional
- 5:52things that are different because of the powertrain?
- 5:54Well, the EV has a heat pump which is really important.
- 5:57It efficiently heats the cabin in winter without destroying
- 6:00your battery range. Got it.
- 6:01And the mild hybrid? The MHEV has a cool feature in
- 6:05its MB UX system where it can go into a brief EV mode.
- 6:08It shuts the engine off and just glides silently up to 100
- 6:12kilometers per hour to save a little bit of fuel.
- 6:14Interesting and practicality luggage space.
- 6:17It's almost a dead heat, about 400 liters for both.
- 6:20The EV actually has slightly more 405 liters.
- 6:23But the real game changer is for the people in the back.
- 6:26How so? Because the EV doesn't have a
- 6:28transmission tunnel running down the middle of the car.
- 6:30Right for the drive shaft. Exactly.
- 6:32The floor in the back back is completely flat.
- 6:34Oh that makes a huge difference for the middle seat passenger.
- 6:37A massive difference. It's way more comfortable for
- 6:39three people in the back. It's a huge win for the EV if
- 6:42you're carrying passengers often.
- 6:43OK, so we've set the stage. The EV is quicker, has way more
- 6:46range and is even more comfortable for passengers, but
- 6:49it costs, what, almost €10,000 upfront?
- 6:52The exact number is 9369 more. The EV starts at 56,665 while
- 6:59the mild hybrid is 47,296. That's the mountain the EV has
- 7:04to climb. All right, this is the main
- 7:05event the financial deep does in six years 120,000 kilometers.
- 7:09Let's break down the running cost, starting with the mild
- 7:11hybrid. OK.
- 7:12So for the MHV driving 20,000 kilometers a year, the biggest
- 7:16cost, no surprise is fuel. Of course, we're assuming a real
- 7:19world consumption of about 6.5 liters per 100 kilometers and a
- 7:24gas price of 1.75 per liter. That sounds pretty realistic.
- 7:27And that alone comes out to 2280 years every single year, just on
- 7:31fuel. Wow.
- 7:32Over 2 grand a year and that's before taxes and maintenance.
- 7:35Exactly. You add on the annual Rd.
- 7:37Tax the BOLO, which is about €220 and then maintenance, you
- 7:41know, oil changes, spark plugs, we're estimating that averages
- 7:46out to €208 per year. So what's the grand total per
- 7:50year for the gasoline car? If you Add all that up, you're
- 7:52looking at a total annual operating cost of about 2708.
- 7:57So over the full six years, that's more than €16,000 just to
- 8:00keep it on the road. 16,248 euros to be precise.
- 8:05It's a huge number. OK.
- 8:07Now for the electric car, this should be interesting.
- 8:09What are the costs here? And let's be clear, we're
- 8:11assuming you can charge at home, right?
- 8:13That is the key assumption. This whole model works best with
- 8:15home charging. So let's assume a decent
- 8:17electricity rate, say EUR .25 per kWh.
- 8:21OK, the car is very efficient, about 12 kilowatt hours per 100
- 8:24kilometers. For those same 20,000
- 8:26kilometers, your annual energy cost is just 600.
- 8:29Wait, wait, say that again, €600. 600.
- 8:32So the mild hybrid owner is spending almost €2000 more per
- 8:36year just on fuel than the EV owner is on electricity.
- 8:40That's the monumental difference right there, and it gets better
- 8:43in many places. The road tax for the EV is 0,
- 8:46and maintenance is cheaper too. Fewer moving parts, less wear on
- 8:50the brakes because of regenerative braking.
- 8:52We estimate about €160 a year. So the total annual cost for the
- 8:56EV. Is just €760. €760 compared to
- 9:00over 2700 for the hybrid, the annual saving is enormous.
- 9:04It's 1948 per year, every year, and that saving adds up to
- 9:0911,688 over the six. Years.
- 9:12OK, let's do the math here. The initial price difference was
- 9:14about 9300 year and you're saving almost €2000 a year.
- 9:18Which means. The Ed pays for itself.
- 9:20It recovers that initial higher cost in what, about 4.8 years?
- 9:25Just under five years. Exactly.
- 9:26The payback is there, which brings us to the final total
- 9:29cost of ownership after the full six years are up.
- 9:31Let's hear it. The final verdict.
- 9:32OK. For the Mild Hybrid CLA 200, you
- 9:35take the purchase price of 47,296 strays and add the 16,248
- 9:41in running costs. The total cost over six years is
- 9:4463,544. 63 1/2 thousand and the EV.
- 9:48For the electric CLA 250 plus EQ, the higher purchase price of
- 9:5356,665 plus the very low running cost of 4562.
- 9:59In world the total is 61,225. So it's cheaper.
- 10:03The EV is actually cheaper in the long run.
- 10:05It is after six years, despite costing almost 10,000 more to
- 10:09buy, the electric CLA provides a net saving of about 2319 over
- 10:14the mild hybrid. That is a fascinating
- 10:15conclusion. The numbers don't lie.
- 10:17For a driver who can charge at home, the EV wins the financial
- 10:21argument. It wins decisively.
- 10:23And remember, you're getting the better car in many ways.
- 10:25The quicker acceleration, the futuristic tech, the silent
- 10:28ride. So who is the mild hybrid for
- 10:30then to still have a place? It does for a niche user if you
- 10:33do a lot of extremely long journeys in areas where fast
- 10:36charging is still unreliable, or if for some reason you just
- 10:38really need that extra 20 kilometers per hour of top
- 10:41speed. But for the vast majority
- 10:42drivers, especially for urban and suburban driving.
- 10:45The conclusion is unavoidable. The EV is the smarter buy.
- 10:48So to sum it all up, yes, the electric CLA has a big sticker
- 10:52price, but it pays you back in under five years and it ends up
- 10:55saving you money, all while giving you a better driving
- 10:58experience and more comfort. It's a powerful combination.
- 11:01And it leaves you with a really important question to think
- 11:04about for the future. If this 800 Volt architecture
- 11:08and nearly 800 kilometers of range is becoming the new
- 11:13standard in this segment, what does that mean for the long term
- 11:16value of a mild hybrid? I think the economic case for
- 11:20gasoline engines, at least in this class of car, is starting
- 11:23to crumble fast. That is definitely something to
- 11:26Mull over. A big thank you for joining us
- 11:28on this deep dive. We really hope this breakdown
- 11:30helps you put the data into perspective.
- 11:32Be sure to follow the channel so you never miss another analysis
- 11:35that gives you the insights you need.
- 11:37We'll get you on the next deep dive.