Latest / Adventures Through The Mind / MICRO:12 - Mushroom Santa Confusion, Tom Hatsis
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, this is going to be a micro from Adventures of the Mind. A micro is a smaller clip from
- 0:07a longer episode, the longer episodes being our default here at Adventures of the Mind.
- 0:13And normally I do these little extras on the backside of the micro. Starts with the clip
- 0:20and then I say, "Thanks for listening to this micro," and so on and so forth.
- 0:24This time I'm going to do it a little bit different and I'm going to let you know in
- 0:27advance what you're about to hear.
- 0:29This is a clip from episode 89 with Tom Hatsis called Debunking the Mushroom Santa Hypothesis.
- 0:37This episode was released quite a long time ago, actually all the way back in 2018 and
- 0:42chances are you're going to be able to recognize the significant difference in audio quality
- 0:47between what you're likely used to now and what you're about to hear.
- 0:51It's a nice reminder because I often get maybe a little too wrapped up in what I perceive
- 0:55as the audio quality not being good enough.
- 0:58And then I look back and think, well, it's certainly better than it used to be.
- 1:02That said, I'm not going to offer much more ado here before getting into this clip with
- 1:08Tom Hatsis.
- 1:09But what I will say is this is the last thing that I'll be releasing through the podcast
- 1:14here for 2025.
- 1:16And I wanted to wish you happy holidays if that is what you're up to, marry insert cultural
- 1:24or religious tradition for this time of year here to you, and a happy turning over of the
- 1:31Gregorian calendar into 2026. And I'll see you then. Thanks for listening, and I hope you enjoy
- 1:37this little clip from episode 89 of Adventures of the Mind with Tom Hatsis.
- 1:45Okay, there's a story coming up over the last few years, but I saw it reach a real height last year around around Christmas time around the holiday season, which is the story that Santa Claus, the legend of Santa Claus has its roots in Siberian shamanism and the Fly Agaric or Amanita Muscaria mushroom that the famous red and white cabs is, is, you know, connected to his red and white outfit.
- 2:14Why don't you just maybe start by presenting to us what that theory is and why you believe
- 2:20it is patently false?
- 2:23Sure.
- 2:24First, I would just say it's not a theory, it's a hypothesis because it doesn't even
- 2:28register as a theory.
- 2:31I mean, it barely registers as a hypothesis.
- 2:34So the idea is...
- 2:36Ever since John Marco Allegro's sacred mushroom in the cross came out, people have been trying to throw
- 2:43Amonita, Muscaria traditions onto all things Christian. So, geez, this was really a mushroom.
- 2:48John the Baptist was really a mushroom. The whole Christian drama is really just about mushrooms.
- 2:53And when that didn't play out so well, at least among academics circles, because there's no evidence for it at all,
- 3:01Um
- 3:02People move the target away to something easy like Santa Claus and I mean it's unfortunately
- 3:08I hate to use this term, but it's a product of just lazy thinking
- 3:12They see the red and white of Santa's outfit and the red and white of an Amanita Muscaria and oh that must be it and
- 3:18the what they don't know and it's interesting because all people who believe the let's call it holy mushroom conspiracy
- 3:26One thing they all have in common is they all aren't even aware of how little they know about this topic that they prize so much
- 3:34What many don't realize is that as far as the whole Amonida Santa Claus thing is,
- 3:40they're really talking about four different lines of evidence and four different historical lines,
- 3:45excuse me, I should say, one of which doesn't even exist. They had to make it up.
- 3:49So the one that they had to make up was the idea of
- 3:52um... shaman reindeer herders as i'm sure you've heard of this okay there is no such thing as a reindeer herding shaman in all of
- 4:00cyber that is a made up character in american society not even american society
- 4:07just these conspiracy theorists who believe this kind of am i allowed to curse you can say anything you want
- 4:12that believe this kind of horseshit.
- 4:15So you have the made up idea of Siberian reindeer shaman,
- 4:20or excuse me, reindeer herding shamans.
- 4:23So that we can X out right away because that is an even, that's a made up,
- 4:27they might as well talk about the historical line of the smurfs
- 4:32if you're going to talk about
- 4:33Siberian reindeer shaman herders that are you know that's not a real thing so there's there's there's there's no there's no actual anthropological evidence that suggests that in Siberia there's shamanic traditions that connect with.
- 4:48Reindeer herding and with the reindeer eating the aminus aminida and drinking the year like the shamans drinking the year
- 4:55Sure, but those are different. We'll get into all that. Okay, what you're talking about is that that that is correlation equal in causation
- 5:03And so there are some I'm not saying that people weren't eating Amanita muskariya in you know certain Siberian shamans
- 5:09That's not what I'm saying at all
- 5:10I'm saying the idea that Santa Claus is derived from that is total nonsense. Okay, so you have the made-up
- 5:16character of the Siberian shaman reindeer her as one line of as of history which doesn't even exist
- 5:23that you have the line of
- 5:26saint Nicholas then you have the line
- 5:30of Santa Claus or center class
- 5:33And then you have the line of winter festivals.
- 5:36And all four of those things never actually overlapped in history until the modern day.
- 5:42So people today look at all of this and it's just kind of easy, it's very...
- 5:47It's just easy to just throw it all together into something.
- 5:50But when you go back and actually look at the evidence, there's nothing there.
- 5:54Like there are no Siberian reindeer herding shamans. That's not a real thing.
- 5:59Not to belabor the point, but I just think it's interesting that in order for these conspiracy theorists to have their fantasy
- 6:06They literally have to make up a character in history to get there right and so that's a good history
- 6:11No, I agree. I mean one of the big things for me when I first heard about I was like well, that's cute
- 6:16but
- 6:16I mean, just the, even the idea that, oh, the red and white of Santa Claus' outfit connects
- 6:22to the red and white of the mushroom seems ridiculous, because it's like, well, Santa
- 6:26Claus wasn't red and white until Coca-Cola, I knew this, until Coca-Cola made him red
- 6:31and white so that they could basically create the allure of the Santa Claus we know now
- 6:37as a marketing gimmick to their brand, which was already red and white.
- 6:41Absolutely. The only thing I would disagree with is that there wasn't an image of Santa in red and white before Coca-Cola.
- 6:49So the red and white, and I go over this in the book, the red and white from Santa's outfit originally comes from the red, white and blue of the American flag.
- 6:57as illustrated by Thomas Nast on the cover of Harper's Weekly in I think 1862 or 3.
- 7:04I forget the year, but it's one of those two.
- 7:06And what he shows is, not even Santa Claus, it's still St. Nicholas, dressed in, you know, his coat and his knickerbockers.
- 7:17and the coat has stars on it and the knickers have stripes on it and above Santa in this piece you have the American flag waiting as
- 7:25Or excuse me not Santa St. Nicholas as he's giving
- 7:29Provisions to Union soldiers
- 7:31See I let me just point out that even I fall for this sometimes our idea of a historical Santa Claus and a historical St. Nick
- 7:39Being one in the same is so ingrained in our culture that I'm messing it up right now even as I'm talking against
- 7:46That's how ingrained this this error is
- 7:51So I'm sorry, where will we go? You're talking about the red white and blue of the outfit that was represented on the cover
- 7:58Yes, sorry sorry
- 8:00I get a lot of my thoughts sometimes.
- 8:01So you have the red, white, and blue.
- 8:04And now between the 1930s when Coca-Cola adopted Santa Claus
- 8:09as their spokes health and the 1860s when the Civil War was
- 8:13going on, Santa Claus went through a variety of costume
- 8:16and outfit changes.
- 8:17Sometimes he appears in all brown.
- 8:19Sometimes he appears in black and red.
- 8:21Sometimes it's red, white, blue, and green.
- 8:25You know, so if this were really an Amanita Muscaria secret, wouldn't it have been uniform from the beginning?
- 8:32Like with the outfit it just so happened that Coca-Cola, and I agree with you was advertising using red and white and
- 8:40So that's the colors they chose chose for Santa Claus
- 8:42And there was already a cultural betting there of red and white and blue and Santa's outfit because of the American flag
- 8:49So it was an easy transition for the American public
- 8:53I think the chapter in your book is the true history of the psychedelic Santa Claus.
- 8:59I think that's the name of the chapter.
- 9:02Yeah, the sub-chapter.
- 9:03Yeah. And you went pretty deeply into all of this. I'm wondering if you could just comment
- 9:07on a couple different historical lines there. What is the difference then between St. Nicholas
- 9:12and what we know of today as Santa Claus?
- 9:15So that's a great question. It's interesting because Saint Nicholas actually did have what we would call shamanic powers.
- 9:23At least in one episode written about him, whereas Santa Claus never actually did.
- 9:28The idea of the whole flying reindeer thing and reindeer drinking, you know, or eating Amanita Muscaria, that's a correlation, equal in causation thing
- 9:37because when Santa Claus first came over here, or...
- 9:39Again, excuse me, when St. Nick first came over here and merged with Santa Claus, reindeer
- 9:44weren't even part of the story.
- 9:46Santa would either just walk places or in some case he had a boat.
- 9:50Other times he was on a bicycle.
- 9:52Sometimes it was a car.
- 9:53I mean, are we supposed to believe that he was filling up this car engine with Omni-Nata
- 9:57mascara and mushroom?
- 9:58I mean, it's ridiculous.
- 9:59Right, right, you know, so it's they don't these conspiracy theorists do not realize the larger
- 10:05Larger cultural contexts that were happening at this time they focus in on the one little narrow piece of
- 10:12Hypothesis let's say because it's not really evidence
- 10:15and they just, they build their entire case around that.
- 10:18And it's like, well, why don't we unpack that
- 10:20and see if there's anything there to start with.
- 10:22And if your listeners are kind enough
- 10:24to pick up a copy of my book and get really deep in,
- 10:27they'll see there's absolutely no connection
- 10:29between Santa Claus and the Amanita Muscaria whatsoever.
- 10:32None.
- 10:32But what about the pictures from old cards with elves Christmas cards with those are Christmas cards that one of the one of the big
- 10:42Fallacies of this entire hypothesis or conspiracy I should say
- 10:47perpetrated by even smart guys like Jerry Brown
- 10:51Joe Rogan Jonathan Ott all I'm sure Paul Stamets as well like all very smart guys, but
- 10:57what they are and they're not historians.
- 10:59So what they do is they just see a card
- 11:01and they all look Amanita Muscaria and snow.
- 11:03This must be a Christmas card.
- 11:05But if you actually look at the cards,
- 11:06they all say Gluckig Necher, which is Happy New Year.
- 11:10There's not a single Christmas card among them.
- 11:11In fact, there is no such thing as one of these earlier cards
- 11:16in the Germanic areas.
- 11:17There is no such thing as one that features Christmas themes
- 11:21and the Amanita Muscaria.
- 11:22Now, when those cards eventually made their way
- 11:25to the United States.
- 11:27people were just attracted to them because Christmas was now becoming
- 11:31centered around children and so were Amonita Mascarias and that's why they
- 11:35turn up in fairy tales and things like that and there's a whole back history
- 11:39we could get into about that but you know that would take a lot of time but
- 11:44I'm happy to answer it. So
- 11:46They, um, the cards themselves were never meant to be Christmas cards until they came to America.
- 11:53And I found this great quote from a guy named Francis Hamilton, who was speaking to Congress,
- 12:00and they were talking about tax issues, and he talked about these cards.
- 12:03And it was like, oh my goodness, I finally like there's a direct guy from that time and place. I think this is like 1912 1913
- 12:11Actually discussing what these were and he said, you know, we didn't know anything about these cards
- 12:15We didn't know what they meant, but people just started digging them. They just they liked the way they looked
- 12:20and what happened was manufacturers in america started to add symbols of the
- 12:26of luck as excuse me um started to add american symbols of luck to these cards
- 12:31if you look at the earliest of these of these new year cards they show things like pigs and
- 12:38omni muscaria mushroom and they were called in german um the the glux pigs and uh the pills and
- 12:45bomb. The lucky pig in the fly, a Garg.
- 12:49Those are symbols of luck in the dramatic lands in Europe.
- 12:53Now, why they're symbols of luck has been lost to history.
- 12:55I hypothesized in the book that, well, if you're on your way to a New Year party and
- 12:58you stumble across Amanita Muscaria, it's going to be a way better party.
- 13:02So maybe that's where it comes from.
- 13:04No doubt people were definitely experimenting with these things, but that's not where the
- 13:08motif comes from.
- 13:11So when they finally came to America, they were only seen as symbols of luck.
- 13:16And manufacturers in America said, "Well, these aren't our symbols of luck, so let's add ours."
- 13:22So in later cards, you have the Omnidomuscaria mushroom, you have the pigs, and then you have
- 13:27decisively American symbols of luck, like four-leaf clovers and horseshoes.
- 13:31So if you look at the early dramatic cards, the horseshoes and the floor leaf clovers are absent because those do not pertain to the dramatic lands.
- 13:40So you can actually trace the development of these cards, the history of them, based on what appears on them.
- 13:46And I do that in the book and show that there's nothing here to suggest anything that they had anything to do with Christmas.
- 13:51Now, let me just say when they do eventually come to America,
- 13:55You'll get cards that say Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year that'll have Amanita
- 13:59Muscaria mushrooms.
- 14:00But again, this is just a holdover from the Germanic original.
- 14:03There are no known American cards that say Merry Christmas that have an Omni Muscaria,
- 14:09Santa Claus or both Omnum.
- 14:11Not one. So until somebody shows me one of those, I'm going to say that this is all horseshit.
- 14:17A card with like a Santa Claus holding a mushroom saying "Merry Christmas, let's all get high."
- 14:24Or just a card that says "Merry Christmas alone with a mushroom."
- 14:28Like I'll take that as well. They don't exist. There have been some recently if you would have Google
- 14:34Omnidomuscarium Santa Claus that people have doctored today and you know made their own but they're you know from a few years ago
- 14:39Like you said this is like it's kind of become a craze now