Latest / The So What? / COP27 and South Africa
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za.
- 0:21I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio.
- 0:35Hello and a very warm welcome to another recording to go with JP's newsletter.
- 0:42This one is dated the 23rd of November 2022 and the heading COP27 and South Africa, a
- 0:49basic introduction.
- 0:52I think we need to, as you do in your first paragraph, sort out some background, some
- 0:58jargon.
- 0:59Why is it called COP?
- 1:01Why is it 27?
- 1:04Why is Paris important in the history and how does South Africa fit in?
- 1:10Yeah, now indeed, those are the starting points.
- 1:14COP is simply the convention of the parties.
- 1:16The full title is the Convention of the Parties of the United Nations Climate Change Conference.
- 1:21This is a conference that has been held every year now for 27 years.
- 1:26The first one, COP1, was in 1993 and as I say, it's been going on every year.
- 1:33South Africa has got a long political commitment to the COP process.
- 1:36We were involved from the very first one.
- 1:39We also hosted COP17 in Durban in South Africa and the whole COP process actually came out
- 1:48of the Johannesburg Sustainable Development Conference, which was held way back before
- 1:54that time.
- 1:55Paris is important because over the 27 years, the parties to the United Nations Conference
- 2:02on Climate Change have struggled to reach meaningful consensus on what can be done about
- 2:08climate change.
- 2:10An agreement was reached at Kyoto, but George Bush, previous US president, would draw the
- 2:17United States from that agreement.
- 2:19So it collapsed.
- 2:20Then the parties had to start all over again.
- 2:23And then in 2015, an agreement was made at Paris.
- 2:26And the Paris Agreement essentially said that the nations of the world commit themselves
- 2:31to take steps to reduce carbon emissions to a level sustainable with an increase in global
- 2:38temperatures of not more than one and a half to 2%.
- 2:42South Africa was part of that agreement.
- 2:45When Zuma was then the president of the country, he was in Paris, he agreed to it.
- 2:49And the following year in April 2016, Edna Muleva, who is late minister in the cabinet
- 2:55of Zuma, signed the agreement, the physical document on behalf of South Africa.
- 3:01So yeah, we've had a long commitment to this convention of the parties.
- 3:04It's about climate change.
- 3:07And the commitment that South Africa has made, like so many things in the Zuma government,
- 3:13the ideas were articulated, but they were not in them.
- 3:16Two years ago in 2021, South Africa actually set a target for a number for the reduction
- 3:24in carbon emissions from the country to be sustainable or to be on a level of climate
- 3:30change of 1.5 degrees Celsius.
- 3:33And the government determined that to be 350 to 375 tons per annum, the maximum number
- 3:40of tons that can be emitted.
- 3:42Now at that stage, we were admitting as a country about 450 tons.
- 3:48It has come down to 420, but from 420 to 350 to 375, it's still a 17% reduction.
- 3:57And that is what the Just Economic Transition Plan is about.
- 4:01It sets out the practical steps that need to be taken to achieve that 17% reduction,
- 4:07but it also sets out the money side.
- 4:09How are you going to pay for it and fund this reduction?
- 4:13Where do we fit into the global picture?
- 4:16Are we a big emitter?
- 4:18It does this matter?
- 4:19Yes, we are a big emitter.
- 4:20We are really just look at the number of tons of carbon emissions, carbon equivalent emissions,
- 4:26then we are the 13th largest in the world.
- 4:29Now if you think that our economy is about 28 to 29th in size, if you think that the
- 4:35companies like the US, like China, India, much, much bigger companies and much bigger
- 4:40economies than ours, for us to be number 13, nonetheless, is quite high.
- 4:46If you adjust for population and you look at emissions per capita, then we're coming
- 4:51at about number 15 in the world, still high.
- 4:55So our per capita emissions are sitting at about 7.5 tons per person per year, and the
- 5:01global average is about 4.8.
- 5:03So we are a really big emitter in all terms.
- 5:07Why is that the case?
- 5:09Why are we such a big emitter?
- 5:11I suppose the short answer is history catching up with us.
- 5:14It's coal.
- 5:15South Africa generates, at least used to generate almost 100% of its electricity from coal.
- 5:21Plus we have a simple fuel industry, which is a very successful industry and it serves
- 5:26South Africa very well, but it has had enormous negative consequences around coal.
- 5:32So what are those negative consequences?
- 5:35Well, carbon emissions is number one, but there's also environmental and a health dimension.
- 5:40You're going to Mopulanga, where most of the coal activities are concentrated.
- 5:45There are a range of indicators indicating that the people living there are suffering
- 5:49severe health consequences, self disadvantages.
- 5:53You look at the pollution of soil, you look at the pollution of water.
- 5:58These things are all the downside of coal.
- 6:00So coal on the one hand was very good for us, but coal on the other hand has been very
- 6:04bad for us.
- 6:05It has certainly been bad for our relationships.
- 6:08And that's why we need to do something about it.
- 6:11So do we have a plan?
- 6:12Yes, that is the whole point of the so-called JET, Just Energy Transition.
- 6:17It's a plan for how we can move from where we are to where we want to go.
- 6:22But it's also a plan for trying to manage the negative consequences of this transition.
- 6:30A lot of people will lose their jobs.
- 6:31A lot of small towns will close down.
- 6:34A lot of businesses will close down, use their business models.
- 6:38So you have to try and manage these things as well as you can.
- 6:42And that is what is called JET, or Just Energy Transition.
- 6:46It's a 216 page document, government has published.
- 6:49This note is merely the briefest of summaries, but it's a very comprehensive plan of where
- 6:54we want to go.
- 6:56And essentially, it talks about the three priorities, electricity, new energy vehicles
- 7:02and hydrogen.
- 7:03Now the plan will cost about in round terms, 1.5 trillion rand over five years, 1.48 actually
- 7:12over five years.
- 7:1370% of that money will be spent on electricity.
- 7:17Can I just put that in perspective?
- 7:19What is South Africa's national budget for the year?
- 7:23Well, our GDP this year will be about 6 trillion rand.
- 7:27So 1.5 is an enormous chunk.
- 7:30But that's of course, it's 1.5 spread over five years, but it's still a lot.
- 7:36And if you bring into consideration that most of that 1.5 trillion over 1.3 trillion will
- 7:43be capital expenditure, infrastructure expenditure, then you can see that it's going to have a
- 7:49huge impact on the country.
- 7:53So as I've said, 70% of the money will go to electricity.
- 7:57Whatever that be used for, it'll be used for the first, the biggest item will be to build
- 8:02more and new capacity.
- 8:04About 46% of that money will be spent on building new wind farms and new solar farms.
- 8:13So it's clear which way the wind is blowing, so to speak.
- 8:16The second biggest project, about 130 billion rand will be spent on upgrading the South
- 8:22African transmission grid, so then you could accommodate all these renewables.
- 8:27It's no good having wind farms and some solar farms, and you can't get the electricity generated
- 8:32there spread over the country to where it is needed.
- 8:35To do that, we've got to upgrade the grid.
- 8:37And that'll be about 131 billion.
- 8:41And then the third element of electricity is the distribution systems, i.e. electricity
- 8:47inside municipalities.
- 8:49Now we all know how that infrastructure has been neglected and depleted in those cases,
- 8:55if not all.
- 8:57And you will have to spend a lot of money to upgrade that and bring that to the level
- 9:01that is needed.
- 9:02And the money it visits for that is about 200 billion.
- 9:07Now in the context of emissions, which is where this whole thing starts, ESCOM is going
- 9:13to close down nine of its 15 coal-fired power stations.
- 9:18Basically it is now eight of 14 because commodity closed down on 31 October.
- 9:23They switched the last unit off according to 12 on the 36th.
- 9:28So there are now 14 coal-fired power stations, eight of them will be closed down, and you
- 9:33have to replace that with something else.
- 9:36And the replacement will be largely new, but also a bit of gas and probably a bit of nuclear.
- 9:42In the context of emissions, the closing down of those nine or now eight power stations
- 9:50will cut the coal consumption for electricity production by 50%.
- 9:54It will cut it from 113 million tonnes per year to about 55, 56 million tonnes.
- 10:02So it's a huge cut in coal consumption, and that will help to bring down our emissions.
- 10:08They're aiming to do that, Bonnie, what did you say?
- 10:11The date for closing down the power stations, the last date is 2034.
- 10:17It'll happen in phases, but the last one will be out by 2034.
- 10:20Now you think that is now, that's only about, it's up in 2022, it's only 12 years away.
- 10:25It's actually not at one time.
- 10:29So you have to really move to get renewables and other sources of power generation into
- 10:35the system before you close down the last of those power stations.
- 10:39The second element is the new energy vehicles.
- 10:43That's not something that's so much on our radar.
- 10:46Now that all and note the category, the category is new energy vehicles, not just electric
- 10:51vehicles, although that is where the attention is.
- 10:55It's also using hydrogen as an energy source for particularly heavy transport.
- 11:01Now and your platinum, for example, is running those huge trucks that they use for mining
- 11:07at the mine in Mokolakwina using now hydrogen trucks.
- 11:13It's quite an astonishing thing.
- 11:15So the idea is that you slowly expand the frontier and go from those big trucks to other
- 11:22trucks running on the highways, to buses if possible, to trains and of course, airplanes.
- 11:28Those are your big energy emitters.
- 11:30And if you can deal with them by way of electricity and hydrogen, it will make a big contribution
- 11:37to the reduction in emissions.
- 11:39The nice thing about new energy vehicles, as in the case of platinum, the private sector
- 11:45can do the investment.
- 11:46They will make the money out of it, out of selling electric vehicles as they're currently
- 11:51doing.
- 11:52They'll make the money out of new infrastructure, which is put out to accommodate the vehicles.
- 11:57So one can expect them to do the bulk of the investment in this category of new electric
- 12:03vehicles, just as private companies are doing almost all the investment in renewable energy
- 12:10up to date.
- 12:11It's a typical private sector activity.
- 12:14And then the third element, green hydrogen, what does that mean?
- 12:18Yeah, hydrogen, you're seeing hydrogen in terms of colors, hydrogen is being manufactured
- 12:23to the moment in the world and it's called gray hydrogen, white gray, because fossil
- 12:28fuels are used to produce that hydrogen.
- 12:31When you switch from fossil fuels in the production to renewables, then the resultant hydrogen
- 12:38is called green hydrogen.
- 12:40It is called pink hydrogen if you use neoclear power and it is called blue if you use fossil
- 12:46fuels, but you do capturing of the carbon emissions.
- 12:50So these colors tell us about different processes.
- 12:53And essentially the point is to switch the worlds to do two things.
- 12:58First of all, switch hydrogen production from carbon gray that is using fossil fuels to
- 13:04green, which is using renewables.
- 13:07But secondly, also to expand the fields and the areas of natural life where hydrogen can
- 13:13be used.
- 13:14Hydrogen has got three problems.
- 13:15Basically there's a price problem and there is a safety problem.
- 13:21If hydrogen interacts with oxygen, it can lead to a huge blow up.
- 13:26And thirdly, storage.
- 13:28It's not that easy to restore and transport hydrogen.
- 13:32But a lot of people are investing a lot of time and money into pushing the technology
- 13:37frontiers of all these areas as India Platinum is doing at their mine.
- 13:43So I would expect huge probabilities to come in the next couple of years.
- 13:47The war that Russia has launched on Ukraine will also help.
- 13:52At the moment we see some regressions that's inevitable because it's an emergency situation.
- 13:59But what the war has done is to illustrate how vulnerable the world is to fossil fuel
- 14:03supplies and that is spurring particularly the Germans on to look at alternatives.
- 14:10And the German chancellor has been here to South Africa on a state visit.
- 14:14And as I've said to people, the visit only lasted about 20 hours.
- 14:19The Luftwaffe couldn't fly from Berlin to Johannesburg and back in 20 hours.
- 14:25You flew more than the time you spent on the ground here.
- 14:28Why did the chancellor do it?
- 14:29Well, he's done it to come and sign agreements with the government, but also with SASL around
- 14:35developing hydrogen technologies for use in Germany, for use in the world, but essentially
- 14:41sponsored by the German government.
- 14:43So hydrogen is the next big thing where a lot of energy and money and the search for
- 14:50new technology will go on.
- 14:52You and I have been to the West coast of South Africa, to Wohel Bay, which is 60 kilometers
- 14:57north of Port Mollusk, between Port Mollusk and the mouth of the Orange River, the border
- 15:01with Namibia.
- 15:02There's nothing there as you will recall, but the idea is to, the feasibility studies
- 15:07are going on now to build a deep sea harbor there.
- 15:11And not just a deep sea harbor, but also a railway line and to use that as a point for
- 15:16exporting hydrogen to Europe.
- 15:19So I would expect over the next 10 years for hydrogen in South Africa to become a major
- 15:25economic activity and exporting it to world markets.
- 15:30You have touched on this, but all of this is going to cost enormous amounts of money.
- 15:36Well, what does the funding plan look like?
- 15:38Yeah, that is in the sense that most, not the most interesting, but it is an interesting
- 15:43part of the basic jet plan.
- 15:46As we discussed earlier, it'll cost about 1.5 trillion over the first five years and
- 15:51of course much more thereafter.
- 15:53We just remember South Africa has not only made a goal now for reducing carbon emissions,
- 15:59it also set the goal of being carbon neutral by 2050.
- 16:03So it's an ongoing process.
- 16:04It's not something that can stop after five years.
- 16:07But the first five years will cost 1.5 trillion.
- 16:10Now a group of countries and the European Union and the World Bank, basically the UK,
- 16:16the US, France, Germany, those four companies, the EU and the climate change funds, which
- 16:23are administered by the World Bank, so it's all in all six players, have contributed $8.5
- 16:30billion US dollars to this just economic transition of South Africa.
- 16:35You work at an exchange rate of 15 to one, which is perhaps conservative, you're looking
- 16:40at 128 billion rare that will come into the country.
- 16:44Most of that money, the first phase, not all of it, but most of it will probably be used
- 16:48to upgrade the grid.
- 16:50The first monies have already coming, France and Germany have signed agreements with the
- 16:57National Treasury in South Africa for 600 million euros, euros, not dollars, of concessional
- 17:05cheap funding.
- 17:0620 years, five year growth period, interest rate about three and a quarter cent.
- 17:14So that money will flow into Treasury and Treasury can then allocate the two programs
- 17:18around just transition.
- 17:20Then we had 495 million US dollars, that's about 9 billion grand, which has been linked
- 17:27by the World Bank, ISCOM, again on really favorable terms, for ISCOM to do the repurposing
- 17:33of the commodity power structure.
- 17:35Now there's a difference between closing something down and repurposing.
- 17:39The repurposing will cost money and the idea is to help ISCOM to achieve that and change
- 17:47what is there now from coal to renewables.
- 17:50So that money has also come in.
- 17:53Then an interesting development is the third channel of the money so far are from international
- 17:59charity organizations.
- 18:00There's a very interesting list of them.
- 18:03There's a Bezos Foundation, for example.
- 18:05Clearly while Mr. Bezos is busy trying to fight with the moon or whatever, he also has
- 18:10a charity that's looking after, wants to look after this environment here on the planet.
- 18:15And they are sponsoring mainly training and research activities, things for which there's
- 18:21no commercial return.
- 18:22$10 million in one case and 180 million rand in another case to do training and in general
- 18:31help with just transition at Comarty and now also at Switzerland, which will be another
- 18:37tower stage metal closed down.
- 18:39So you've got these, you've got governments, you've got international institutions, multilateral
- 18:45banks and you've got international charities, those three.
- 18:49And then of course, South Africa itself would have to invest and the way it will come is
- 18:53by way of biosector investment, as we've discussed.
- 18:57The private sector have both the solar industry and the wheat industry so far in South Africa.
- 19:01I foresee that they will build the electric vehicle industry in South Africa.
- 19:06I foresee that they will build the hydrogen industry.
- 19:08Those are all classic biosector investments because there's no return.
- 19:13CEC is really an example of how this can play out and it makes the just transition much
- 19:22more tangible.
- 19:23Yeah, absolutely.
- 19:25So what's happening at Comarty, as I've already said, they closed it down and switched the
- 19:29last unit off on 31 October.
- 19:32And what they're doing there is they're putting up 150 megawatts solar plant, a 70 megawatt
- 19:37wind farm so that'll produce about 220 megawatts between those two technologies, as well as
- 19:44150 megawatts of batteries.
- 19:47So you produce the power that goes into the battery and that can help you to extend the
- 19:51supply of electricity.
- 19:53The transmission lines are right there so you don't have to build anything.
- 19:57You just feed it into the grid and goes to wherever the power is needed.
- 20:01Now, of course, the building of the new plants and so on and the batteries will cost money.
- 20:06And that's part of what ISCOM got the money from.
- 20:08But ISCOM has also signed an agreement with the Cape University of Technology because
- 20:14at the Cape University of Technology, they've developed curricula and a program around retraining
- 20:21people to switch from coal into solar industry or to go into the wind industry.
- 20:26And those curricula programs have now been accepted by CEC for use...
- 20:32At ISCOM?
- 20:33At ISCOM, sorry, by ISCOM, and then I keep on saying CEC for use at Kumati.
- 20:38And they will also use it at the third flight and the other stations.
- 20:42So there you retraining people.
- 20:43A third aspect which is taking place at the moment in Kumati is that you use the land,
- 20:50which is available around the power station, for agricultural purposes.
- 20:54So you establish small farmers there and enable them to grow food for the local area and so
- 21:00on.
- 21:01And it's all part and parcel of learning how to live with this transition.
- 21:05And one can only learn as one goes along.
- 21:09I think that's what ISCOM is doing.
- 21:12It's interesting that you say that under the debate they've raised 180 million for a training
- 21:17center through its lay and observed that there are 16,000 vacancies right now in solar and
- 21:23wind industry.
- 21:24So people are going to do these jobs, but there will also be new opportunities.
- 21:29Oh, absolutely.
- 21:30You know, if you think about it, 60,000 vacancies in an industry which is really flourishing.
- 21:36I mean, a lot of wind farms have been built, a lot of solar farms have been built.
- 21:40So the people skills, they don't have enough skills, 60,000 vacancies and we have millions
- 21:47of people unemployed.
- 21:48It is just such a logical fit.
- 21:50Now, not everybody who will be the trench from a power station will necessarily get
- 21:54a job at a wind farm.
- 21:56We must just be realistic about that.
- 21:58But you are creating new jobs in a new industry and you are helping people, training people
- 22:04to get into those industries.
- 22:05So that's the upside of the transition.
- 22:08That's also the just element of the transition.
- 22:12Such huge changes will not come without resistance.
- 22:16Absolutely.
- 22:17What's happening politically?
- 22:18Well, politically, you basically have two groups out of service to go to the one group
- 22:24which is jokingly known as the Green Taliban.
- 22:27They are absolutely against anything except wind and solar and of course, batteries.
- 22:33Now that's a nice pure position to have, but that's not how it's going to be for like
- 22:39a while.
- 22:40So actually, we'll still use coal for a long time and we will probably have to look at
- 22:44nuclear for base power as well.
- 22:46And you cannot have renewables if you don't have gas.
- 22:49The big thing about gas, as you know from your house or you know from a gas stove, it's
- 22:55dispatchable.
- 22:56You can switch it on and off.
- 22:57You cannot switch a coal-fired power station on and off.
- 23:00You also cannot switch a nuclear power station on and off.
- 23:04So you need dispatchable power.
- 23:07It's part of your mix.
- 23:08So the idea that only wind, only solar, nothing else will serve so much energy needs is very
- 23:16pure but it's a bit extreme.
- 23:19And the people that are really far on that side have now gone so far as to lobby international
- 23:26governments and the national philanthropists not to give any money to South Africa because
- 23:32South Africa is not closing down coal completely.
- 23:35So that's the one side of the political spectrum.
- 23:37On the other side of the political spectrum, you have people with an interest in the coal
- 23:41industry or just people with a political interest in coal.
- 23:45And they're saying that people will lose their jobs, which is quite right.
- 23:49Towns will die, which is quite right.
- 23:51And they have much more validity in their argument than the other side, I dare say.
- 23:57But industries decline.
- 23:59This country, the coal mining industry, declined and it's a shadow of what it was.
- 24:05Agriculture has shed hundreds of thousands of jobs after the deregulation of agriculture
- 24:10in 1996.
- 24:11Telecom is a shadow of what it was.
- 24:15Many people have lost their jobs because technology has driven change.
- 24:19So industries change, that is how life is.
- 24:22It's like the sun rising and setting.
- 24:25You can't stop that.
- 24:26What you can do is to try and manage to fall out as well as possible.
- 24:30Now if you compare the Just Energy Transition Plan now with training centers of commodity
- 24:36and retraining people and creating new economic activity, you compare that to the way that
- 24:42we handled or not handled the decline of the coal mining industry or how we've not handled
- 24:49the decline of employment and agriculture or not handled the decline at the SOEs like
- 24:55telecom and trans-state and others, then this is much, much better than anything that we've
- 25:00done in the past.
- 25:02In the past, we've never really paid any attention.
- 25:04We spoke about the social contract and social upliftment, but also all was said and done
- 25:10much more than was actually said and done.
- 25:13Compared with energy, there is a chance of managing the negative fallouts from the process
- 25:19more effectively.
- 25:20There will still be bodies in the street, might not mistake, but at least you can try
- 25:23and minimize the bodies.
- 25:26I'm going to just lift out three of your so-whats.
- 25:31The first one, you say the catastrophe of load shedding is actually galvanizing the
- 25:36transition to green energy.
- 25:38Expand in a minute.
- 25:39Yeah, look, all of us who read history, people who are interested in large, must be struck
- 25:46by the irony of what's going on here.
- 25:49We're having really a catastrophe with load shedding.
- 25:51I don't think anybody will disagree with that statement, but this catastrophe is also spurring
- 25:56the country along to alternatives.
- 26:00We had 100% electricity supply all the time coming from coal-fired power stations.
- 26:06We would not have started the just transition.
- 26:09We would have kept pumping out those 435 tons of carbon equivalent emissions every year,
- 26:15and we would have had no commercial or political incentive to change.
- 26:20Load shedding paradoxically, and what must be one of the biggest ironies in our history,
- 26:26is actually pushing the country towards an energy transition.
- 26:30The fact that we now have a democracy and an open political society is also forcing
- 26:36that transition to look at the just element.
- 26:39Something that we didn't do in the decline of gold mining, we didn't do in agriculture.
- 26:43The other examples I've mentioned.
- 26:46I think we are in that sense quite lucky that we have to do the transition.
- 26:50We forced to do it, but the fact that we have a democracy is helping us to do it in a more
- 26:55just way.
- 26:57I also want to make the point lead to that.
- 27:00You've got that, so Patrick has got a long political commitment to climate, to the whole
- 27:05climate change process.
- 27:07The World Summit on Sustainable Development was held here in Johannesburg.
- 27:12One of the COP meetings were held in Durban.
- 27:16We've agreed to do originally to the Kyoto Protocol.
- 27:19When that collapsed after the US were drawn, we agreed to Paris, Trump took the US out
- 27:25of Paris.
- 27:26We stayed, and we were committed to the process all the way through.
- 27:32It is not true or not correct that we've now suddenly woken up and signed onto this.
- 27:38I think that's an important perspective to bring.
- 27:40One of the so what's is the long political commitment.
- 27:43This is merely a practical outflow of that commitment.
- 27:48The other point you make that I think is really important for people to note is that this
- 27:53is not simple and it's not going to happen overnight.
- 27:56Absolutely.
- 27:57This Just Energy Plan covers only the first five years of a process that will run the
- 28:042050.
- 28:05There will be a multiple transition.
- 28:08It's not just one.
- 28:09Kumati will transition, Kharutphule will transition, ISKCON will transition, but the whole country
- 28:15over time will transition.
- 28:16The auto industry will transition.
- 28:18The logistics industry will transition with hydrogen and so on.
- 28:22It's several transitions.
- 28:25It will come over a multitude of years.
- 28:27It's not going to be an overnight story.
- 28:29It will cost many, many multi-families to pay for all this.
- 28:36It's an old new ballgame.
- 28:37It's a country we will have to learn and we will learn to adjust to it and to play according
- 28:43to a new set of new set of roles.
- 28:46The run of ISKCON?
- 28:49One can be provocative and say ISKCON will decline and you can say it's finished in
- 28:54Tlar, that's not necessarily the case, but it certainly will have a much diminished hope.
- 29:00That is the whole purpose of the changes going on.
- 29:03That's the whole outcome.
- 29:04Where we had five years ago, 10 years ago, a monopoly supplier of electricity that belonged
- 29:10to the state, you will move to a competitive market in electricity belonging to private
- 29:16sector players, certainly on the generation side.
- 29:19If you take Transmission out of ISKCON as well, then it will not be left with very much
- 29:24it to become a shadow of its former self.
- 29:27But I think what is important here, I've written about this and we've covered it, that what's
- 29:31important here is that we must distinguish between ISKCON and electricity.
- 29:37Even if we say for purposes of the argument that ISKCON is kaput, it's finished in Tlar,
- 29:44that doesn't mean that electricity is finished in Tlar, in spite of the kind of load shifting.
- 29:49Especially because so much more money is going into new generating capacity in new technologies.
- 29:55And that's where the future of electricity will come from.
- 29:57So draw a distinction between ISKCON and electricity.
- 30:01They are increasingly not the same.
- 30:04Thank you very much.
- 30:06This draws a picture of a quite different future.
- 30:11Sounds almost like the Industrial Revolution, where steam came into the picture and changed
- 30:17everything.
- 30:18I think that's a very fair comparison.
- 30:21We like to talk about the Fourth Industrial Revolution as technology and digital and so
- 30:26on, and that's of course correct.
- 30:28But the Green Revolution is certainly also going to be an Industrial Revolution of enormous
- 30:34magnitude.
- 30:36And technology of course will help with that.
- 30:42Thank you for listening to the So What Podcast.
- 30:45If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating, and please
- 30:50consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 30:54Also tell your friends.
- 30:56Remember you can find a written version of all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.