Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Car Longevity: When to Keep It
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Dee Dive. Today we are tackling probably
- 0:13the biggest question for anyone looking at electric cars.
- 0:16What's the real story long term with owning an EV?
- 0:19Yeah, thinking beyond just the sticker price, it's all about
- 0:23that total cost of ownership, the TCO.
- 0:25Right. How long do they really last?
- 0:27How do the batteries hold up? Do those maintenance savings
- 0:30actually, you know, happen? Exactly.
- 0:32It's complicate. I mean, the tech is still
- 0:34evolving, but thankfully we've got some actual concrete data
- 0:38now, not just guesses. And this isn't just like stories
- 0:41from a few owners. You pulled together some serious
- 0:43sources. We're talking academic studies,
- 0:45UK roadworthiness tests, MOT tests, right?
- 0:49Covering over 300 million records.
- 0:50That's the one, a massive data set.
- 0:53It helps us see when cars actually drop off the road.
- 0:56We're trying to cut through the noise here.
- 0:57OK. So our mission today for you
- 0:59listening is to break this down into three key parts.
- 1:02First, maintenance costs are the savings real?
- 1:05Second, EV batteries. What's the secret sauce that
- 1:09makes them last so much longer than, say, your phone battery?
- 1:12We'll talk about Gray's capacity.
- 1:14Right, that's crucial. And finally, lifespan.
- 1:17Using that huge data set, what's the actual projected life in
- 1:21years and miles for EVs compared to petrol or diesel cars?
- 1:26Let's dig in. Right, maintenance first.
- 1:28This is where EVs are supposed to shine, right?
- 1:30Fewer moving parts, fewer problems.
- 1:31That's the pitch, yeah. But you hear the counter
- 1:33arguments. People worry about tires wearing
- 1:35out faster because the cars are heavy or complex electronics,
- 1:41liquid cooling systems. Is the saving really that big a
- 1:44deal? Well, the data points pretty
- 1:46strongly in One Direction. Yes, it's significant.
- 1:49Consumer Reports, for example, found EV owners spent about half
- 1:52as much on maintenance and repairs.
- 1:54Half. Compared to regular combustion
- 1:55engine cars. Half as much on average, yeah.
- 1:58Wow. OK.
- 1:58That's, that's pretty substantial.
- 2:00And it gets even better if you look at commercial use, like
- 2:02fleets. That's where the economics
- 2:04really pop. Battery electric trucks, their
- 2:07maintenance is costing around .1766 per mile.
- 2:12Compare that to diesel trucks at .246 per mile.
- 2:15And for electric buses, they're seeing something like a 43% drop
- 2:19in maintenance costs versus diesel. 43% OK, hold on.
- 2:23If the savings are that clear that immediate, especially for
- 2:26businesses running vehicles all day, why isn't everyone
- 2:30switching tomorrow? What's the hold up?
- 2:33That's a great question. And it usually comes down to the
- 2:36upfront cost, the purchase price of the vehicle itself and
- 2:40critically, the charging infrastructure.
- 2:43It's not usually the maintenance cost that's the barrier once
- 2:46you're up and running. OK.
- 2:47So once you have the car, the savings kick in because it's
- 2:50just. Simpler.
- 2:52Fundamentally simpler. An EV powertrain might have,
- 2:54what, maybe 20 moving parts? Give or take. 20 Yeah, compared
- 2:58to an internal combustion engine system which has like 2000 parts
- 3:02or even more sometimes. 2000 that OK, that explains a lot.
- 3:05Right. So you just eliminate entire
- 3:07categories of maintenance, No more oil changes, obviously no
- 3:10spark plugs, no exhaust systems failing, no timing belt
- 3:13snapping. The whole service schedule looks
- 3:15different and. Regenerative braking plays a big
- 3:17part too, doesn't it, For keeping brake costs down.
- 3:20Oh absolutely, Region is key. When you lift off the
- 3:23accelerator the motor slows the car down and puts energy back in
- 3:27the battery, so the actual friction breaks the pads and
- 3:31rotors. You only really use them for
- 3:33like hard stops are the last few feet.
- 3:34So they last longer. Way longer, often two to three
- 3:37times longer than on a regular car.
- 3:39We've seen reports pretty reliably of owners getting
- 3:42100,000 miles, sometimes more, on their original set of brakes.
- 3:47100,000 miles. Think of the savings just on
- 3:49brake jobs alone. Exactly.
- 3:51Time and money. But let's be fair, EVs aren't 0
- 3:54maintenance. You mentioned tires earlier
- 3:56because of the weight. Correct, that's a real factor.
- 3:59The battery packs are heavy so yes tires can wear out quicker.
- 4:02You need to be diligent about rotation and honestly investing
- 4:04in EV specific tires helps. They're built for the extra
- 4:08weight and that instant torque. OK, tires.
- 4:11What else? The cooling system.
- 4:12That's the other main one. It's not like an old radiator.
- 4:14It's a pretty complex liquid cooling loop, usually to keep
- 4:17the battery happy. Right around 25 Celsius, 77
- 4:22Fahrenheit. That needs checking.
- 4:24Yeah, you need to monitor coolant levels, make sure the
- 4:26pumps are working well. It's vital for the battery's
- 4:29health and long life. So, you know, instead of an oil
- 4:32change, you've got this sophisticated cooling system.
- 4:34Check. It's a different kind of
- 4:36maintenance. OK, so that brings us nicely to
- 4:39the battery itself. This is usually the biggest
- 4:42source of anxiety for people considering an EV.
- 4:44Right, the classic question. My phone battery is rubbish
- 4:48after three years. How can this car battery last 8
- 4:51or 10? And the answer really lies in
- 4:53smart engineering and maybe more importantly, software control.
- 4:57Two key things, oversizing and what we call grace capacity.
- 5:01Grace capacity. I like that term.
- 5:03Explain that. Is it like a hidden fuel tank
- 5:04the car only uses later? That's a perfect analogy
- 5:07actually. It's spare capacity built in
- 5:09from day one that you, the driver, don't directly access
- 5:12initially. How does that work?
- 5:14Well, say a car is advertised with A100 kWh battery, the
- 5:17battery management system, the BMS, it puts virtual fences
- 5:20around that. So when it's new, IT might only
- 5:23let you use, say, 60% of the actual total physical capacity.
- 5:27So my dashboard says 100% charged.
- 5:29The physical cells might only be at maybe 80% of their maximum
- 5:33charge, and when the dash hits zero, they might still
- 5:36physically be at 20%. So it keeps the battery
- 5:39operating in its happiest, least stressful zone.
- 5:42Exactly. It avoids the extremes top and
- 5:45bottom, which is where most degradation happens faster.
- 5:48Then as the battery naturally ages and loses some capacity
- 5:52over the years, which happens slowly, the BMS quietly starts
- 5:56using that hidden buffer that grace capacity.
- 5:58So it keeps the usable range feeling consistent for longer.
- 6:01Precisely. You often won't notice
- 6:03significant range loss until that built in buffer has been
- 6:06used up, which takes years. OK, that makes sense.
- 6:09What about the actual numbers, warranties and real world
- 6:11degradation? Warranties are pretty standard
- 6:13now, usually eight years or 100,000 miles.
- 6:16They guarantee the battery will keep at least say 7075% of its
- 6:20original capacity. Some places, like California,
- 6:23mandate even longer. 10 years 150,000.
- 6:26Miles and what is the real world data show?
- 6:28How fast do they actually degrade?
- 6:30It's generally pretty slow. The average seems to be around
- 6:331.8% capacity loss per year. So you know, after 50,000 miles
- 6:39you might have only lost about 5% of your initial range, which
- 6:42isn't too bad at all. So for you listening, if you
- 6:45want to really maximize that battery life, what are the
- 6:48simple rules based on the science?
- 6:50It mostly comes down to managing temperature and how much you
- 6:53charge. First, try to limit using ultra
- 6:56fast DC chargers all the time, especially if the battery is
- 6:59very cold or very hot. Level 2 AC charging at home or
- 7:03work is generally gentler. OK, use fast charging when
- 7:06needed, but not necessarily every single day, right?
- 7:09Second, don't always charge to 100% if you don't need that much
- 7:12range for your daily driving. Consistently charging above 80%
- 7:15puts a bit more stress on the chemistry.
- 7:17May be charged to 80 or 90% for daily use and only go to 100%
- 7:21for long trips. And the other end, don't run it
- 7:23completely flat. Yeah, that's the Third Point.
- 7:26Try to avoid regularly dipping below 20% state of charge.
- 7:29Very low charge levels increase internal resistance, which isn't
- 7:32ideal. And finally, temperature.
- 7:35Keep it moderate. We mentioned that 25 Celsius, 77
- 7:38Fahrenheit sweet spot. Extreme heat is bad, but very
- 7:42cool temperatures also affect performance and charging.
- 7:46The car's thermal management system does most of the work,
- 7:48but parking in the shade on hot days, or maybe preconditioning
- 7:52the battery before driving in winter can help.
- 7:54Now, there was a really interesting kind of unexpected
- 7:57detail in the source material about reversing some capacity
- 8:01loss. Yes, the recovery effect.
- 8:03This is fascinating. It relates to something called
- 8:06lithium plating. Lithium plating?
- 8:08What's that? It's basically tiny deposits of
- 8:11metallic lithium forming on the anode.
- 8:13Often happens if you fast charge when the battery is cold.
- 8:16It makes that lithium inactive so you lose capacity.
- 8:18OK. And this can be reversed.
- 8:20Sometimes, yes. The science suggests that if the
- 8:23battery cell rests for an extended period, like days,
- 8:26weeks, maybe even months, at a relatively low to medium state
- 8:29of charge, say between 30% and 50%, what happened that plated
- 8:32lithium can gradually dissolve back into the electrolyte and
- 8:35become active again. So you can actually recover some
- 8:37of that lost capacity. It sounds a bit like the old
- 8:40memory effect people used to talk about with older battery
- 8:43types, but it's a totally different chemical process.
- 8:45Completely different chemistry, yes, but the practical outcome
- 8:48is similar in a way. A period of rest can actually
- 8:51help rejuvenate the battery a bit.
- 8:53It's another built in mechanism that can help prolong its useful
- 8:56life. All right, so we've covered
- 8:58maintenance and batteries. Now let's zoom out to the big
- 9:01picture. How long does the whole vehicle
- 9:04last? This is where that huge UKMOT
- 9:07data set comes in. Yeah, because knowing the
- 9:09realistic lifespan is fundamental for calculating the
- 9:12total cost of ownership. If the car lasts longer, each
- 9:16year costs less, basically. Exactly.
- 9:18So what are those 300 million records tell us about
- 9:20traditional cars, petrol and diesel?
- 9:22What's the baseline? The average lifespan for a
- 9:25typical internal combustion engine vehicle combining petrol,
- 9:27Vin Diesel came out at 17.9 years and around 138,000 miles
- 9:31driven before it's typically retired.
- 9:33OK, 17.9 years, 138,000 miles. Got it.
- 9:37Now, were there any surprises? Yes, the real longevity
- 9:41champions according to this massive study were actually the
- 9:44plug in hybrids, the PHEVS hybrids.
- 9:47Really, how much longer did they last?
- 9:48Significantly longer. They were projected to survive
- 9:51on average 25 years and cover over 209,000 miles. 25 years?
- 9:56Wow. That's almost seven years longer
- 9:58than the average ICE car. Why?
- 10:00It probably goes back to what we discussed with maintenance.
- 10:03The hybrid system allows the petrol engine to operate much
- 10:05more gently. It often avoids cold starts,
- 10:08avoids high revving acceleration, and generally runs
- 10:11in its most efficient, least stressful range because the
- 10:14electric motor helps out. So less wear and tear on the
- 10:17engine itself. Drastically less potentially,
- 10:20which seems to extend its mechanical life quite a bit.
- 10:23OK, that makes sense for hybrids.
- 10:25Now what about the pure electrics, the Bevs?
- 10:27How did they stack up against that 17.9 year average for
- 10:31petrol and diesel? Well, the study looked at how
- 10:33quickly the failure rate increases overtime.
- 10:35They used a statistical thing called the Ribull shape
- 10:37parameter. Basically, it showed that the
- 10:40aging process for Bev's is less aggressive.
- 10:42Meaning they wear out slower. Yeah, the failure rate climbs
- 10:46more slowly over the years compared to petrol or diesel
- 10:49cars. It supports the idea of less
- 10:51mechanical wear and tear. And the final numbers for Bev
- 10:54lifespan. The latest average Bev's
- 10:56included in that study were projected to last 18.4 years.
- 11:00OK, 18.4 years, so slightly longer than the combined ICE
- 11:05average, basically matching petrol cars.
- 11:07Exactly. And in terms of mileage, they
- 11:09projected an average lifetime mileage of 124,000 miles.
- 11:14I noticed that's a bit less than 138,000 miles for the average
- 11:18ICE vehicle. Why the difference there if the
- 11:21years are similar? That probably reflects how EVs
- 11:24have been used historically. Maybe you shorter average trips
- 11:26in the specific data set they analyzed from the UK.
- 11:29But here's the really crucial bit.
- 11:32It's not just about the average mileage, it's about how well
- 11:34they handle intense use. What do you mean?
- 11:37They looked at how much the risk of retirement the hazard rate
- 11:39increases for every extra mile driven per day.
- 11:42For Bev's, that risk only went up by 2.5% per extra daily mile.
- 11:46OK, for petrol cars, the risk jumped by 8.4% for each extra
- 11:50daily mile. Whoa, so driving an EV hard,
- 11:53like lots of commuting or fleet use, ages it much more slowly
- 11:57than doing the same at a petrol car?
- 11:58Roughly 3 times more slowly. According to this data, the
- 12:02mechanical robustness under high usage seems significantly
- 12:05better. That's why fleet managers are so
- 12:07interested. It really strengthens the TCO
- 12:09argument for high mileage scenarios.
- 12:11Right. So pulling this all together for
- 12:13you listening, the idea that EVs don't last long and mechanically
- 12:17just doesn't seem to hold up against this large scale data.
- 12:20They appear to last as long or potentially even longer than
- 12:24traditional cars, especially when you factor in how they
- 12:27handle intensive use and when you combine that longevity with
- 12:30the lower maintenance costs we talked about.
- 12:32It makes the long term economic case much stronger than maybe
- 12:36people initially thought. The total cost of ownership
- 12:38looks increasingly favorable over, say, a 15 or 20 year
- 12:41lifespan. Hashtag #outro.
- 12:44OK, so this has been a really illuminating deep dive.
- 12:46Let's quickly recap the key takeaways for everyone.
- 12:49First, those maintenance savings for EVs.
- 12:51They look pretty real and significant, mainly due to that
- 12:53mechanical simplicity. Definitely, and regenerative
- 12:56braking is a big part of that too. 2nd, EV batteries aren't
- 13:00like your phone battery. They're engineered for longevity
- 13:03with things like grace capacity, and you can help them last even
- 13:08longer with smart charging habits.
- 13:10There's even that potential for chemical recovery.
- 13:12Right, the engineering is quite sophisticated.
- 13:15And finally, the big picture. The mechanical lifespan of EVs
- 13:18is looking solid now, matching or even beating traditional cars
- 13:22in years, especially hybrids leading the pack and pure EV
- 13:26showing better durability under heavy use.
- 13:29Which leads us to one final kind of provocative thought from the
- 13:32sources. While the cars themselves seem
- 13:34built to last, realizing that full long lifespan economically
- 13:38hinges on something else entirely.
- 13:39What's that? It's the need for a really
- 13:41robust and crucially affordable circular economy for battery
- 13:45replacement and recycling. Why is that the potential
- 13:49stumbling block? Well, think about it, If your EV
- 13:51reaches say you're 15 and the body is fine, the motors fine,
- 13:56everything works, but the battery has naturally degraded,
- 14:00That extended mechanical life is kind of pointless if getting a
- 14:04replacement battery costs almost as much as the car is worth at
- 14:08that point. Right, you end up scrapping a
- 14:09perfectly good car just because the battery fix is too
- 14:12expensive. Exactly.
- 14:14We've unfortunately seen examples of this already, like
- 14:17those EV graveyards in some places where business models for
- 14:20battery refurbishment or replacement just didn't work
- 14:23out. So having affordable second life
- 14:26battery options and efficient recycling is absolutely key to
- 14:30actually unlocking the full TCO benefit of that longer
- 14:34mechanical lifespan. That's a really important point.
- 14:36It's not just about the car, it's a whole ecosystem around
- 14:39it. Well, thank you for guiding us
- 14:40through all that complex data on EV longevity and ownership
- 14:44costs. It was a pleasure, lots to think
- 14:45about. Absolutely.
- 14:46And for everyone listening, thank you for joining us.
- 14:48Make sure you subscribe or follow the deep dive so you
- 14:51don't miss our next exploration. We'll see you then.